Theory & Practice

Part 1 : Kautsky’s poor handling of Mas...

Published: Gesammelte Werke, Vol. 2 (Berlin: Dietz Verlag, 1972, 1974), pp. 344–77, 378–420; they have also been checked against the manner in which they were printed in Die Neue Zeit. Source: News & Letters, April 1980. Translated: (from the German) David Wolff. Transcription/Markup: Ted Crawford/Brian Baggins. Copyright: © 1980 News & Letters. Printed with Permission from News & Letters. The first question which the interest of party circles demands in our present dispute is this: whether discussion of the mass strike was obstructed in the party press, namely in Vorwärts and the Neue Zeit. Comrade Kautsky denies this, asserting that it would “naturally never have occurred to him to wish to &lsquo... (From: Marxists.org.)

Part 2 : Kautsky disdains Russian revol...

And now to the mass strike. To explain his unexpected stand against the slogan of the mass strike in the latest Prussian voting rights campaign, Comrade Kautsky created a whole theory of two strategies: the “strategy of overthrow” and the “strategy of attrition.” Now Comrade Kautsky goes a step farther, and constructs ad hoc yet another whole new theory of the conditions for political mass strikes in Russia and in Germany. He begins with general reflections on the deceptiveness of historical examples, and how plausibly one can, with insufficient caution, find appropriate justification in history for all strategies, methods, aims, institutions, and earthly things in general. These observations, of a harmless nature... (From: Marxists.org.)

Part 3 : Kautsky: the mass strike is in...

Part 3 We have briefly examined the factual basis of Comrade Kautsky’s newest theory on Russia and Western Europe. But the most important thing about this latest creation is its general tendency, which runs on to construct an absolute contradiction between revolutionary Russia and parliamentary “Western Europe,” and sets down the prominent role played by the political mass strike in the Russian Revolution as a product of Russia’s economic and political backwardness. But here Comrade Kautsky finds himself in the disagreeable position of having proved much too much. In this case, somewhat less would have been decidedly more. Above all, Comrade Kautsky has not noticed that his current theory destroys his earli... (From: Marxists.org.)

Part 4 : Russian development created th...

In light of the conclusions which follow from Comrade Kautsky’s newest theory, it now becomes clear -how very false, from the ground up, this theory is. To derive the mass strike action of the Russian proletariat, unparalleled in the history of modern class struggle, from Russia’s social backwardness – in other words, to explain the outstanding importance and leading role of the urban industrial proletariat in the Russian Revolution as Russian “backwardness” – is to stand things right on their heads. It was not economic retardation, but precisely the high development of capitalism, modern industry, and commerce in Russia which made that grandiose mass strike action possible, and which caused it. It was... (From: Marxists.org.)

Part 5 : Kautsky’s theory: mass strike ...

What actually remains of Comrade Kautsky’s mass strike theory, after he has pointed out all the “impossibilities”? The one, “final,” pure political mass strike, disengaged from economic strikes: which once only, but with absolute conclusiveness, smashes down like thunder out of the clear blue sky. Says Comrade Kautsky: Here, in this conception, lies the deepest ground of the differences between my friends and me over the mass strike. They anticipate a period of mass strikes. Under the existing conditions in Germany, I can imagine a political mass strike only as a one-time event into which the entire proletariat of the Reich enters with its entire strength; as a struggle to the death; as a struggle which eith... (From: Marxists.org.)

Part 6 : Prussia: the mass strike arise...

Let us return to Prussia. At the beginning of March, in view of the voting rights campaign which had begun and the mounting demonstration movement, I declared that if the party wished to lead the movement farther forward it must make the slogan of the mass strike the order of the day, and that a demonstration mass strike would be the first step toward this in the present situation. I considered that the party faced a dilemmas it would either raise the voting rights movement to sharper forms or, as in 1908, the movement would go back to sleep after a short time. Indeed, this was what summoned Comrade Kautsky to the field of battle against me. And what do we see? Comrade Kautsky points out that, me to the contrary, we have certainly not... (From: Marxists.org.)

Postscript : An Attrition or Collision

In conclusion, a little historical reminiscence – yet one which is not without agreeable parallels to the present. Comrade Kautsky rejects, for Prussia, the examples of other lands where the mass strike has recently been used. Russia counts for nothing as an example, neither does Belgium or even Austria. For it is “out of the question to appeal to the examples of other lands in the present situation in Prussia.” [Kautsky, What Now?, p.36.] But in search of the fitting model for our tactic, Comrade Kautsky himself goes back to the old Romans and Hannibal. Here he finds an example for the edification of the German proletariat in Fabius the Procrastinator, with his allegedly victorious “strategy of attrition.” ... (From: Marxists.org.)

<< Last Entry in Anarchism Thailand, Buddha, the King & I	Current Entry in Anarchism Theory & Practice	Next Entry in Anarchism >> The Wage System
All Nearby Items in Anarchism Thailand, Buddha, the King & I, by Anonymous That 19th July in Spain in 1936, by Federazione Dei Comunisti Anarchici That Aside, A Valuable Service, by Lawrence Jarach That Teaching is Impossible, by Alejandro De Acosta Thatcher: Putting the fun back into funeral, by Iain McKay Their Morality and Ours, by Anarchist Federation Their Peace, by Victor Serge Theming of the countryside, The, by Anonymous Theorization Of Historical Experiences, The, by Agustín Guillamón A Word, The, by Anonymous Theory & Practice “Electoral Pursuits Have Veered Us Away”, by Adam Weaver “Dear Citizens, This Is Your Police”, by CrimethInc. “Each Crueler Than the Last”, by CrimethInc. “The Barricades Must Be Torn Down.” Moscow-Fascism in Spain, by Paul Mattick “Ceasefire” Is a Deadly Fraud, The, by CrimethInc. “Anti-Government Ideologues” and Coronavirus, by Iain McKay “Anarchism … is a living force within our life …” Anarchism, Education and Alternative Possibilities, by Abraham P. DeLeon Words of a Rebel, by Peter Kropotkin War!, by Peter Kropotkin Wage System, The, by Peter Kropotkin

Theory & Practice

By Rosa Luxemburg

Entry 9568

Public

Author : Rosa Luxemburg

Chapters