,*APT] #d - ,SOCIAL ,PROTE/ & A ,NEW ,CLASS 

#aigaig 

,PEOPLE 3 

,AU?OR 3 ,ALB]T ,MELTZ] 

,AU?OR 3 ,/U>T ,*RI/IE 

,TEXT 3 

#d ,SOCIAL ,PROTE/ & A ,NEW ,CLASS 

  

,! APPALL+ PROGRESS & PROSPECTS ( ! ,DE/RUCTION ,/ATE1 ! 9CREAS$ P[]LESSNESS ( ! 9DIVIDUAL1 & ! 9CREAS$ MEAN+LESSNESS ( P>TY OR E/ABLI%$ BELIEFS HELD ALL OV] ! WORLD1 GAVE AN 5ORM\S IMPETUS TO SOCIAL PROTE/4 ,IT WAS A SECUL> REVOLUTION AGA9/ ! NEO-,*UR*ES4 ,IT BEGAN ON WELL-WORN ANTI-MILIT>I/ L9ES1 IF ) SOME IMAG9ATIVE OV]TONES1 BUT NEV]!LESS T5D$ TO FOLL[ C]TA9 PATT]NS ( ! CLASS /RUGGLE4 ,?IS WAS AGA9/ ! EXPECTATIONS ( SOME ( ?OSE :O1 LIKE MANY RADICAL LEAD]S1 ?9K ?AT TO RUN A LITTLE AHEAD ( ! CR[D IS TO LEAD IT4 

,! G5]AL CLIMATE ( SOCIAL PROTE/ WAS A REVIVAL ( MILITANT LIB]ALISM4 ,POLITICAL LIB]ALISM WAS 9/ITUTIONALIZ$ & DEAD1 & 9 ! NEW =M ! OLD RADICALISM WALK$ AGA9 ON E>?4 ,IT DEVELOP$ IDEAS & GIMMICKS ANTICIPAT$ EV5 BY ! ,SUFFRAGETTES1 BUT MOV$ FUR!R ON 9 FACE ( ! ACCEPT$ IRRELEVANCE ( PROTE/ AS SU*4 ,PROTE/ HAD BECOME A RITUAL P>T ( ! SC5E1 (FICIALLY TOL]AT$ & EV5 5C\RAG$ )9 LIMITS4 ,BUT :5 IT HAD GONE BEYOND ?OSE LIMITS1 POLICE DEF5SE ( ! /ATUS QUO1 9 SOME C\NTRIES REA*+ ! PO9T ( BRUTAL SOCIAL CONQUE/1 :I* IS ! NATURE ( ! ,/ATE1 HAD %>P5$ ! TEE? ( PROTE/4 ,! ,DUT* ,PROVOS1 P]CEIV+ ?IS1 HAD ! IDEA ( DELIB]ATELY PROVOK+ ! ,/ATE TO DO SO1 & %[ ITS TRUE NATURE4 

,IT WAS NATURAL ?AT AN>*I/S W\LD BE AMONG ?OSE MILITANT 9 ! PROTE/ MOVEM5T1 S9CE DEMON/RATIONS ON ! /REETS AGA9/ ! ,/ATE1 LIKE /RIKE ACTION1 MU/ WEAK5 ! SEQU5CE ( COMM&-&-OBEY4 ,IT W\LD NOT HAVE BE5 ILLOGICAL = ! REVOLUTION>Y AN>*I/ O!RWISE TO HAVE TAK5 ! /& ( A FEW SECT>IAN ,M>XI/S :O /AT$ ?AT SU* A MOVEM5T WAS IRRELEVANT TO SOCIAL *ANGE & %\LD BE IGNOR$4 ,AS IT HAPP5$1 ! AN>*I/S W]E USUALLY ! MA9 T>GETS = POLICE ATTACK BECAUSE !Y 9CLUD$ ! MO/ MILITANT PROTE/]S1 & CONV]SELY1 ! AN>*I/ BANN]S RALLI$ ! MO/ MILITANT PROTE/]S BECAUSE !RE ! POLICE ATTACK W\LD BE /RONGE/4 ,SO AN>*ISM HAS APPE>$ TO MANY1 SOLELY ON ! /REET LEVEL )\T CONSID]ATION ( O!R FACTORS1 ! MO/ AGGRESSIVE =M ( DISS5SION4 ,?IS MI<T BE SO1 BUT ! CONCLUSION1 ?AT ! MO/ AGGRESSIVE =M ( DISS5SION MU/ !RE=E BE AN>*ISM1 WAS QUITE FALSE1 ?\< IT WAS ASSUM$ TO BE TRUE BY MANY GO+ =W>D FROM ,C,N,D 7XXXI74 

,H5CE ! CONFUSION1 AMUS+ OR IRRITAT+ TO ! REVOLUTION>Y AN>*I/ ACCORD+ TO TEMP]AM5T1 ?AT MILITANT LIB]ALISM & AN>*ISM >E ! SAME ?+4 ,! =M] SOMETIMES ASSUMES ! NAME ( AN>*ISM1 AT LEA/ ) ! DILUTIVE HYPH5ATION PACIFI/-AN>*ISM4 ,?AT IS NOT TO SAY ?AT A P]SON PR(ESS+ ! PACIFI/ CRE$ C\LD NOT BE AN AN>*I/1 OR VISE V]SA2.<#a#a.> BUT ! HYBRID1 PACIFI/-AN>*ISM1 C]TA9LY AS EXP\ND$ BY ! FAKIRS ( ,PEACE ,NEWS1 IS SO PAT5TLY MILITANT LIB]ALISM AS TO MAKE IT DIFFICULT = ,Y\NG ,LIB]ALS TO TELL ! DIFF]5CE4 

,P]HAPS MILITANT LIB]ALISM MAY BE 9CLUD$ UND] ! UMBRELLA ( ! LIB]T>IAN MOVEM5T4 ,! DEF9ITION HAS BECOME SOME:AT WIDE 9 ! LA/ FEW YE>S4 ,IT IS AN ABUSE ( WORDS1 H[EV]1 TO CALL IT AN>*I/1 H[EV] IT MAY LABEL ITSELF4 ,IT CANNOT COMPREH5D A MEANS ( SOCIAL *ANGE1 %ORT ( AN APPEAL TO ! RI* TO GIVE UP !IR POSSESSIONS1 AS ADVOCAT$ BY ,V9OBA ,BHAVE & ! ,GRAMDAN MOVEM5T 9 ,9DIA & LAUD$ BY ! OR?ODOX PEACE MOVEM5T4 ,EV5 ?OSE :O BELIEVE 9 MANY-H&$ GODS & >E AFRAID :5 ! LIZ>D CROAKS1 F9D IT H>D TO BELIEVE ?IS IS POSSIBLE4 

,! LIMITATIONS ( ! PROTE/ MOVEM5T1 & ( ALL MILITANT LIB]ALISM H[EV] RADICAL & LIB]T>IAN IT MI<T BECOME & H[EV] ADVANC$ IT HAS DEVELOP$ 9 ! ,UNIT$ ,/ATES1 RE/ ON ITS 9ABILITY TO COMPREH5D ! CLASS /RUGGLE1 )\T ! RECOGNITION ( :I* SOCIAL *ANGE IS NOT POSSIBLE4 ,IT MAY TRY TO JU/IFY ITSELF BY CRITICIZ+ 0\TMOD$ CONCEPTIONS0 :I* W]E NEV] 9 MODE EXCEPT BY WAY ( HYP]BOLE RA!R ?AN ANALYSIS 7= 9/ANCE1 BY D5\NC+ ! ,K+SLEYAN-TYPE MESSIANISM & ATTRIBUT+ IT TO 0,M>X & ,BAKUN9074 

,?IS ADVANC$ LIB]AL !SIS1 MASQU]AD+ AS PACIFI/-AN>*ISM1 HAS ATTRACT$ A SUB/ANTIAL SECTION ( A G5]ATION ( RADICALS4 ,& FUR!R1 9 ,HEGELIAN T]MS1 ?IS !SIS PUT =W>D BY ?OSE COM+ FROM A MIDDLE-CLASS BACKGR\ND1 HAS CONFRONT$ ITS ANTI!SIS1 ! 0FASCISM0 ( !IR P>5TS :I* SPR+S FROM A P>ANOIAC FE> ( /ATE COMMUNISM4 ,?IS BASIC FASCISM1 ( ! PRIMITIVE ,MUSSOL9IAN TYPE1 IS A SORT ( HOMEOPA?IC REM$Y = /ATE COMMUNISM1 :I* LEADS !M TO ADVOCATE ITS MEASURES4 

,!SIS & ANTI!SIS CALL 9TO BE+ A SYN!SIS :I* IS SE5 9 ! 0SITUATIONI/0 MOVEM5T 9 P>TICUL>1 & 9 ! HIPPIE MOVEM5T & V>IATIONS UPON ITS !ME4 ,UND]/&+ ?IS 5ABLES US TO DISP5SE ) RELIANCE ON ! 0G5]ATION GAP0 BELOV$ BY J\RNALI/S4 ,9 ! V>I\S SPLITS & C\NT]-SPLITS (1 ! SITUATIONI/S1 9 ! ,AM]ICAN-9SPIR$ HIPPIE MOVEM5T1 ! OLD JAZZ-'N'-DRUGS SC5E1 ! ,9T]NATIONAL ,TIMES & ITS ESOT]IC SUCCESSORS & COMPETITORS1 ! ANTI!SIS IS WORK$ \T4 ,!RE IS A CONTEMPT = ! 0MASSES0 -- 0,ALFS0 IS ! WORD GIV5 BY ! MAGAZ9E 0,OZ0 -- = ! SQU>ES1 PROLLIES1 LUMPS -- M+L$ ) PEACE-MOVEM5T GIMMICKS TO WAKE UP ! B\RGEOISIE 7BUT DIRECT$ AT !M ALL ! SAME74 ,! VANGU>D ( SOCIAL PROGRESS BECOMES $UCAT$ Y\?1 ! /UD5TS1 ! 0PROVOT>IAT04 ,! NATURAL ELITE ( SOCIETY IS 0! BEAUTIFUL PEOPLE04 ,SOCIETY IS DESPIS$ = ITSELF & NOT = ITS ACCEPT$ VALUES4 ,!RE IS A CULT ( DEA?1 MANIFE/ 9 AN ADDICTION = ! H>D /UFF & 9 ! WAY SU* MOVEM5TS MOVE ON TO ,EA/]N MY/ICISM & ! CULTS ?AT PRODUCE ,BOOKS ( ! ,DEAD4 ,! WAY TO *ANGE SOCIETY IS TO GO (F ON TRIPS TO ! A/RAL PLANE BY WAY ( N>COTICS1 SO ?AT EV]Y?+ BECOMES IDEAL :ILE REMA9+ EXACTLY ! SAME 7LIB]AL RE=MISM 9 A NEW GUISE874 

,ALT]NATIVELY1 ?\< 9 ESS5CE SIMIL>LY1 !RE IS ! IDEA ( SELF-RESPONSIBILITY1 ! PRET5SIONS TO CURB 9DIVIDUAL AGGRESSIV5ESS1 OR ! CREATION ( \TLETS = FRU/RAT$ Y\? TO 5ABLE IT TO ADJU/ TO SOCIETY4 ,VOLUNT>Y SOCIAL WELF>E IS TAK5 TO BE SOCIAL REVOLUTION4 ,DO-GOODISM ADOPTS A SW++ IMAGE -- FIR/-AID = JUNKIES1 ME?-DR9K]S & VAGRANTS -- & 9SPIRES1 = 9/ANCE1 ! 0,CA?OLIC ,WORK]0 MOVEM5T ) ITS ,ROMANI/ *>ITY OBSESSION 7?AT WAS GUY$ 9 ,BUNUEL'S ,VIRIDIANA71 ) ! TRAMP-GLORIFICATION ( ,AM]ICAN 9DIVIDUALISM 70,HALLELUJAH1 ,I'M A BUM607 & ?IS HAS GONE R\ND ! SC5E 9 V>I\S GUISES4 

,NEV]!LESS1 ?IS IS NOT TO CRITICIZE ANY OR ALL ( !SE TOO SEV]ELY1 AT LEA/ NOT AS LONG AS !Y UND]/& !IR UNIMPORTANCE 7:I* SO FEW ( US DO74 ,IT IS C]TA9LY NOT TO JO9 9 ! PETTY B\RGEOIS DISAPPROVAL ( !M = !IR %OCK VALUE4 ,ANY?+ WILL %OCK ! PETTY-M9D$1 FROM A V>IATION 9 HAIR-/YLES TO ! USE ( N>COTICS NOT HALL[$ BY COMM]CIAL EXPLOITATION NOR LEGAL SANCTION4 

0,DROPP+ \T01 ! SLOGAN ( ! HIPPIE MOVEM5T1 IS F9E1 :E!R ONE ?9KS ( IT AS IGNOR+ ! RAT RACE1 OR 9 T]MS ( A COMMUNITY ( NEO-,DIGG]S1 ,UTOPIAN SOCIALI/S1 OR SA9TS 9 A COOP]ATIVE F>M2 OR1 = A SUFFICI5TLY WELL-HEEL$ ,?OREAU 7XXXIII71 9 ! RU/IC DELI<TS ( A COTTAGE BY ! SEA4 ,! WEEK-5D HIPPIE1 :O DROPS \T :5 HE IS NOT WORK+ 9 ! BANK1 IS NO MORE TO BE D]ID$ ?AN ! VACATION YA*TSMAN1 A SON ( ! SEA :5 HE IS NOT CALCULAT+ ACTU>IAL /ATI/ICS ON LIFE EXPECTANCY4 

,!RE HAVE BE5 SOME WELL-9T5TION$ RADICALS :O HAVE TOLD US ?AT IF WE WI% NEI!R TO BE EXPLOIT$ NOR TO EXPLOIT O!RS1 WE %\LD BE W9D[-CLEAN]S OR SELL HOT DOGS4 ,! PO9T ( VIEW IS A VOCATIONAL HAZ>D ( 9DIVIDUALISM4 ,IT IS AN IDEALIZATION1 SU* AS IT IS1 ( :AT HAPP5S TO ! =M]LY 9DEP5D5T CRAFTSMAN4 ,PEOPLE ) ! CA% AVAILABILITY MAY EQUALLY ?9K 9 T]MS ( [N+ !IR [N DES]T ISL& & GETT+ AWAY FROM ! WICK$ WORLD4 ,IT IS ALL V]Y TRUE1 BUT HAS NO?+ TO DO ) SOCIAL *ANGE :I* IS DEP5D5T UPON ECONOMIC LIB]ATION4 

,IF NATIONAL LIB]ATION HAS BE5 SAID TO BE A GOOD BREAKFA/ BUT A POOR1 SUPP]1 MILITANT LIB]ALISM IS A GOOD MID-MORN+ SNACK1 & MAY EV51 IF WE >E NOT TOO DEM&+1 S]VE AS ! MID-DAY MEAL ITSELF2 IT CANNOT LA/ US UNTIL EV5+4 

,! NEW LIB]ALISM HAS NOT REMA9$ /ILL4 ,A L>GE P>T ( ! 0ELITE0 DISSATISFI$ ) ITS 9ADEQUACIES1 HAS ADAPT$ IT TO GREAT] MILITANCY4 ,9 SOME CASES !Y HAVE GONE ON TO REVIVE ! !ORIES ( ,BLANQUI OR MAKE A CULT ( ,*E ,GUEV>A4 ,IT IS1 H[EV]1 ONLY ! PRESS1 9V>IABLY LESS 9=M$ ?AN ! PUBLIC IT S]VES1 :I* SEES ! PROTE/ MOVEM5T SOLELY COMPRIS$ ( /UD5TS1 & ! UNIV]SITY COMPOS$ ( ! 0,NEW ,LEFT04 ,! 9DU/RIAL WORK] LAGS 9 HIS SUPPORT ( ?IS ,NEW ,LEFT BECAUSE HE SEES IT 9 T]MS ( ! OLD LIB]ALISM WRIT L>GE4 ,IT IS NOT UNTRUE ?AT HE IS MORE 9CL9$ TO BE CONS]VATIVE 9 HIS MANN] ( ?9K+ :5 HE IS NOT DIRECTLY RELAT+ IT TO HIS [N EXP]I5CES4 ,! NEW RADICAL /UD5T MAY GET 9FURIAT$ :5 ! 9DU/RIAL WORK] DI/RU/S HIM1 RECALL+ ! /UD5T ( #a#i#b#f1 AS IF ! /UD5TS :O HELP$ TO BREAK ! /RIKE !N W]E NOT N[ NE>+ RETIREM5T AGE1 & W]E !N1 9 ANY CASE1 V]Y DIFF]5T 9 SOCIAL ORIG9 & \TLOOK FROM ?OSE ( ! PRES5T TIME4 ,BUT UNIV]SITY RADICALISM1 LIKE >TI/ BOHEMIANISM1 MAY = SOME BE FA%IONABLE & H>MLESS1 EV5 POSSIBLY USEFUL TO A FUTURE C>E]4 ,IT IS ANO!R MATT] TO BE BLACKLI/$ 9 ! ONLY TRADE TO :I* ONE'S APPR5TICE%IP APPLIES4 

,IT IS = ?IS REASON ?AT ?OSE MO/ ACTIVE 9 DEFIANCE ( ! ,/ATE HAVE BECOME1 EXCEPT ON PURELY 9DU/RIAL ISSUES1 ?OSE MO/ DIVORC$ FROM PRODUCTIVE WORK1 YET REMA9+ SOCIALLY ( ! L[] CLASS RA!R ?AN ! UPP] & C]TA9LY HAV+ NO RESPONSIBILITY = ! DOM9ATION ( SOCIETY4 ,!Y MAY BE WORK+ 9 DRIV+ JOBS1 (FICES1 %OPS OR O!R P]IPH]AL TRADES4 ,!Y MAY HAVE COME ?R\< ! UNIV]SITIES4 ,!Y >E (T5 ! 5D-PRODUCT ( SAUSAGE-FACTORY GRAMM>-S*OOL $UCATION4 ,!Y HAVE 9 COMMON ! FACT ?AT !Y CAN *OP & *ANGE >\ND SO F> AS EMPLOYM5T IS CONC]N$1 ADMITT$LY NOT ALWAYS TO !IR F9ANCIAL B5EFIT4 ,!Y CAN1 H[EV]1 BE REASONABLY 9DEP5D5T ( 9DUC$ PUBLIC OP9ION1 C]TA9LY UNTIL FAMILY RESPONSIBILITIES OV]TAKE SOCIAL COMMITM5TS & =CE A SURR5D] TO ! CON=MITY ( ! PETTY-M9D$4 

,H]E WE SEE A NEW CLASS 9 ! MAK+4 ,9 ONE S5SE IT IS 9DEP5D5T1 & ?\< 9 TIMES ( DEPRESSION IT IS DISA/R\S TO LOSE JOBS1 YET AT O!R TIMES IT DOES NOT REALLY MATT] TWO HOOTS TO PEOPLE 9 ?IS CLASS :E!R !Y HAVE ONE JOB OR ANO!R4 ,A CL]K1 = EXAMPLE1 MAY JUMP FROM ! W9E TRADE TO ! ,PO/ ,(FICE & F9I% UP EXPORT+ DRY GOODS1 ) ALL ! C>ELESS AB&ON ( A CAB9ET M9I/] SWAPP+ PORTFOLIOS4 

,! NOT UNNATURAL1 IF COMM]CIALLY UNJU/IFIABLE1 DESIRE ( BUS9ESS EXECUTIVES TO HAVE PRETTY GIRLS %[+ !IR LEGS >\ND ! (FICE HAS L$ TO HI<] WAGES 7:I* ! 0C\LD NEV] AF=D0 = A NURSE OR FACTORY GIRL7 BE+ (F]$ TO Y\NG] %OR?&-TYPI/S & SECRET>IES4 ,?IS HAS BE5 5HANC$ BY ! FREE USE ( ! 9DIVIDUAL /RIKE1 FLITT+ FROM JOB TO JOB1 :I* HAS PUT UP SAL>IES /ILL MORE1 ?\< MANY ( ! GIRLS CONC]N$ MI<T %AKE !IR HEADS SADLY AT ! ?\<T ( O!R PEOPLES /RIKE ACTION1 :I* EV]YBODY KN[S IS ! REASON 0! C\NTRY0 IS GO+ TO ! DOGS4 

,DESPITE ALL ?IS APP>5T 9DEP5D5CE1 ! CLASS TO :I* WE >E REF]R+ IS /ILL HELPLESS AS F> AS SOCIAL A AFFAIRS >E CONC]N$1 & ALI5AT$ FROM ANY VOICE 9 POLITICAL MATT]S OR ECONOMIC BETT]M5T4 ,IT CAN ONLY 0TRU/ ! GOV]NM5T01 & ! CL]K T5DS TO BLAME HIS PROBLEMS UPON :ATEV] POLITICIAN HAPP5S TO BE 9 (FICE AT ! MOM5T1 IF NOT UPON ! TRADE UNIONS OR ! F9ANCI]S ACCORD+ TO IDEOLOGY4 ,! P>K KEEP] & MET] READ]1 :O DO NOT USUALLY ID5TIFY !MSELVES ) ! MIDDLE CLASS1 \T ( SOCIAL PREJUDICE1 >E 9 A SIMIL> POSITION4 ,!Y DO NOT HAVE ! PRODUCTIVE P[] ( ! AIRPLANE 5G9E]1 = 9/ANCE1 AL?\< !IR DEGREE ( SOCIAL USEFULNESS MI<T BE HI<] OR MI<T BE L[]4 

,UNLESS SU* WORK]S HAPP5 TO WORK 9 L>GE NUMB]S 7DU/M5 OR PO/M5 = EXAMPLE71 !IR P[] TO /RIKE IS DIM9I%$1 & ! CONCEPTION ( ! /RUGGLE BECOMES MORE NEBUL\S = !M ?AN IT DOES = ?OSE ON ! FACTORY FLOOR4 ,9DE$1 IT (T5 APPE>S ?AT ! MORE SOCIALLY USEFUL A JOB IS1 ! MORE DIFFICULT IT IS TO P]CEIVE ?AT !RE IS 9 FACT A CLASS /RUGGLE4 ,IT IS EASY TO SEE ?AT !RE >E TWO SIDES 9 A C> PLANT1 LESS EASY TO SEE A DIVISION ( 9T]E/ ON A F>M1 & ALMO/ IMPOSSIBLE TO UND]/& IT WORK+ 9 A HOSPITAL4 ,BECAUSE ( ?IS1 ! CONCEPTION ( WORK]S' CONTROL BECOMES LESS CLE>LY UND]/OOD :]E !RE IS AT A GIV5 MOM5T A %>$ 9T]E/ 9 A JOB4 ,A COMM]CIAL TRAVEL]1 WORK+ UPON COMMISSION1 C\LD ONLY DISCOV] ! NATURE ( ! /RUGGLE BY HIS READ+ OR UND]/&+1 & MI<T CONCLUDE IT WAS AN ACADEMIC CONCEPTION4 

,:AT DI/+UI%ES ?IS CLASS1 CONSI/+ ( V>I$ OCCUPATIONS & DEGREES ( PROSP]ITY1 :I* GETS BIGG] :ILE ! 9DU/RIAL CLASS GETS SMALL]8 ,IT IS ! FACT ( DISPOSSESSION ( A CLASS FROM ALL PRODUCTIVE WORK ?AT IS NOT M>G9AL TO ! ECONOMY4 

,IS !RE A PREC$5T8 ,N9ETE5?-C5TURY CAPITALISM DEVELOP$ A CLASS ?AT CONSI/$ ( ! P]MAN5TLY UNEMPLOY$1 & ( ! 0ROGUES & VAGABONDS0 ( FEUDALISM1 AS WELL AS ( ?OSE EVICT$ FROM ! L&4 ,IT WAS SWELL$ BY WORK]S DISPOSSESS$ BY MA*9]Y1 BY UNMONEY$ IDL]S1 LAZY \T ( !IR APPROPRIATE CLASS1 &1 BY ?OSE :O /RUGGL$ = G5]AL LABOR+ JOBS AT ! BOTTOM ( ! SOCIAL LADD]4 ,IT 9CLUD$ ! P$DL]1 ! BEGG>1 ! PETTY CRIM9AL4 ,M>X LABEL$ ?IS CLASS1 SOME:AT CONDESC5D+LY1 ! 0LUMP5PROLET>IAT01 ! ROGUE-WORK]S4 ,IT WAS ! SUB/RATUM1 SE5 9 ! 0*ILDR5 ( ! ,JAGO01 ! ,LONDON ( ,DICK5S & ,MAYHEW1 ! 0SUBM]G$ T5?01 ! 0PEOPLE ( ! ABYSS01 ?OSE 9 0D>KE/ ,5GL&04 ,P]HAPS IT IS SE5 9 ! WORSE ,AM]ICAN ,NEGRO 0<ETTOS0 ( TODAY4 

,IT IS A PRODUCTIVE CLASS DELIB]ATELY MADE UNPRODUCTIVE = ! MO/ P>T1 & PRODUCTIVE ONLY BY ACCID5T4 ,IT HAS BE5 REF]R$ TO BY SOME SOCIOLOGI/S AS ! ,LAZ>US CLASS4 

,BY A SIMIL> EXEGESIS WE MAY REF] TO ! O!R1 NEW] CLASS DEPRIV$ ( ITS PRODUCTIVE ABILITY1 ?\< NOT 9 ?IS CASE ITS CAPACITY TO WORK1 AS ! ,NABO? CLASS4 ,! V9EY>D ( :I* IT HAS BE5 DISPOSSESS$ IS ?AT ( 9DEP5D5T PRODUCTIV5ESS4 ,UNLIKE ! ,LAZ>US CLASS1 IT IS NOT DEP5D5T ON ! RI* MAN'S 79 PRACTICE1 MORE (T5 ! POOR MAN'S7 TABLE = CRUMBS4 ,ON ! CONTR>Y1 EV5 )\T ! V9EY>D IT REMA9S A USEFUL P>T ( SOCIETY1 ?\< ! LEA/ USEFUL ! TASKS IT UND]TAKES1 ! MORE COMM]CIALLY REW>D+ !Y APPE> TO BE4 

,9 ! MI<TY (FICE BLOCKS T[]+ TO ! GLORY ( \R MOD]N *ECKBOOK ,CAES>S1 TRIBUTE TO ! MI<TY IS C\NT$ NOT BY ! C5TURIONS AT !IR COMM& BUT BY ! NUMB] ( /AFF B5EA? !M4 ,H[EV] POKY OR 9ADEQUATE ! FACTORY MI<T BE ?AT PRODUCES ! WEAL? ON :I* ! (FICE BLOCK SUBSI/S1 IF 9DE$ ! :OLE $IFICE DOES NOT DEAL 9 9VISIBILITY1 ! PRE/IGE (FICE SO>S TO ! HEAV5S & ?OSE :O PRODUCE ITS MEMOS >E BETT] PAID ?AN ?OSE :O PRODUCE ITS WEAL?4 

,:AT PO9T IS !RE 9 SAY+ ?AT MO/ PEOPLE PROBABLY 5T] ! S]VITUDE ( ?IS CLASS VOLUNT>ILY8 ,?AT APPLIES TO EV]Y CLASS FROM ! MO/ SUBM]G$ TO ! MO/ OPPRESSIVE EXCEPT ?AT MO/ PEOPLE PREF] TO GO UPW>DS RA!R ?AN D[NW>D4 ,= YE>S ! GRAMM> S*OOLS HAVE *URN$ \T PUPILS 9 ! SAUSAGE-MA*9E ( $UCATION1 DIVORC+ !M FROM !IR SOCIAL CLASS BUT FAIL+ TO GIVE !M ! OPPORTUNITY TO ESCAPE FROM IT ECONOMICALLY4 ,!Y LEFT ! HUMANI/IC CULTURES ( ! SIX? =M TO FILL UP 9KWELLS & WRITE 9 L$G]S1 OR 9 ! CASE ( GIRLS TO LE>N %OR?& AT #a WORDS P] M9UTE TO TAKE DICTATION FROM BOSSES :O ?9K AT #b WORDS P] M9UTE4 ,ONLY 9 ! LA/ FEW YE>S HAS ! WA/AGE BECOME APP>5T1 & HI<] $UCATION OP5 = LESS OBVI\SLY TIME-FILL+ JOBS4 ,! SEP>ATION FROM SOCIAL ORIG9S1 H[EV]1 REMA9S ! SAME4 

,9 !SE CIRCUM/ANCES SOME HAVE COME TO ?9K ( !MSELVES1 CONTR>Y TO ALL REASON1 AS 0MIDDLE-CLASS01 OR AT ANY RATE 0L[] MIDDLE-CLASS01 :5 !Y >E NO?+ ( ! SORT4 ,9 ! 9T]-W> P]IOD1 FASCISM MADE ! MO/ ( ITS APPEAL TO ?OSE :O1 ?9K+ ( !MSELVES AS 0L[] MIDDLE-CLASS0 -- L[] CLASS ECONOMICALLY1 MIDDLE-CLASS 9 ASPIRATION1 !RE=E FELT A K9%IP TO ! DOM9ANT CLASS ?AT WAS NOT RECIPROCAT$ EXCEPT BY WAY ( IDEALIZATION 7EX-S]VICE1 COMRADE%IP1 OR FELL[-MEMB]%IP ( 0! NATION0 74 ,REACTION DIRECT$ !IR S5SE ( FRU/RATION AT ! NE>E/ AVAILABLE SCAPEGOAT4 ,!Y FELT A VAGUE RES5TM5T AT BE+ ?\<T ( AS PETTY B\RGEOIS1 9 ! NEW 9SULT+ S5SE1 BY ! SOCIALI/ MOVEM5T1 & ! FACE-SAV+ DEF9ITION ( 0WORK]S BY H& & BRA90 MADE NO IMPRESSION4 7,ONE MAY SPECULATE ON ! 9T]E/+ POSSIBILITY ( WORK+ )\T EI!R OR BO?1 EXCEPT 9 A GOV]NM5T DEP>TM5T OR A FACTORY = ! H&ICAPP$47 

,BUT :ILE FASCISM \T ( P[] TRI$ TO MAKE A BID TO RALLY ?IS EM]G+ CLASS1 TO GIVE A L>G] BASE TO AN ELITI/ MOVEM5T1 IT HAD NO ROLE BUT DEMO-FODD] = ANYONE NOT ( ! ELITE4 ,IT EXT5D$ ITS BID1 ONCE 9 P[]1 TO 9CLUDE ! 9DU/RIAL WORK]S1 & US$ ! PEOPLE AS A :OLE AS CANNON-FODD]4 ,! NAZI PHILOSOPHY EMBRAC$ ! NOTION ( A CIVIL W> AGA9/ ! L[] ORD]S 9 ORD] ?AT A PREORDA9$ RUL+ CLASS MI<T TAKE P[] 9 ! ,/ATE4 ,! MA/]-RACE WAS SE5 AS A RUL+ CLASS )9 ! NATION4 ,ONLY DUR+ ! BID = POPUL> SUPPORT WAS ! !ORY RE-PHRAS$ 9 SU* A WAY ?AT IT MI<T APPE> ?AT ! NATION WAS REG>D$ AS BE+ P>T ( ! MA/]-RACE4.<#a#b.> 

,ONCE FASCISM GOT OV] ! 9ITIAL %OCK ( PUTT+ ! BULLY-BOYS ( OPPOSITION 9TO ! HALLS ( ! MI<TY1 IT FITT$ COM=TABLY 9TO AN ADM9I/RATIVE BUREAUCRACY1 EXACTLY ! FEATURE ( /ATE COMMUNISM ?AT MO/ REPELL$ ?OSE TO :OM ! FASCI/ APPEAL$4 ,EV5 ! MASS-MURD] CAMPS ( ,HITL]'S ,G]MANY W]E RUN BY AN E/ABLI%$ CIVIL S]VICE ?AT SETTL$ 9TO A R\T9E :I*1 GIV5 TIME1 MI<T HAVE 9TRODUC$ COMPETITIVE EXAM9ATIONS & BIR?DAY HONORS4 

,IT WAS REG>D$ AS ! MAJOR RE=M ( FASCISM TO 0PROBLEM ( UNEMPLOYM5T0 BY TAK+ WORK]S EVICT$ BY ! PROCESSES ( CAPITALISM FROM !IR CAPABILITY ( PRODUCTIV5ESS1 & PLAC+ !M AT ! S]VICE ( ! ,/ATE4 ,9/EAD ( LETT+ !M FILT] 9TO LI<T OR NON-ESS5TIAL 9DU/RY1 :I* WAS ! ONLY ALT]NATIVE 9 A CAPITALI/ SOCIETY TO MASS UNEMPLOYM5T1 IT DILUT$ PRIVATE CAPITALISM ) /ATE S]FDOM & MADE !M S]VE ! W> MA*9E OR 5GAGE 9 PYRAMID-TYPE A*IEVEM5TS SU* AS ! AUTOBAHN4 

,SE5 9 ?IS LI<T1 ! CONC5TRATION CAMPS W]E NOT DIV]G5CE FROM FASCI/ IDEAS1 AS ,B]N>D ,%AW ?\<T AT ! TIME & ! APOLOGI/S = NAZISM HAVE S9CE PROCLAIM$4 ,!Y W]E PRIM>ILY1 ( C\RSE1 ! MEANS ( 9FLICT+ T]ROR1 S9CE ! P>TY1 EV5 BE=E ITS ACCESSION TO P[]1 HAD PICK$ ON A SCAPEGOAT & ISOLAT$ IT AS A SMALL]1 DI/9CT SECTION4 ,ITS DISPLAY ( /R5G? UPON ?AT M9ORITY1 :I* FELL BACK ON CON/ITUTIONAL PROTE/S & EV5 APPEALS TO CONSCI5CE1 NEV] HE$$ 9 P[] POLITICS1 MEANT ?AT IT C\LD ISOLATE O!R SECTIONS & T]RORIZE EA* ( !M 9 TURN1 TOO4 ,?IS IS NORMAL /REET GANG OR POLICE TACTICS & P>T ( ! TE*NIQUE ( DIVIDE-&-CONQU] :I* LEADS TO COMM&-&-OBEY4 ,9 ADDITION1 H[EV]1 ! CONC5TRATION CAMPS W]E AN ESS5TIAL P>T ( ! SWIT* FROM CAPITALISM TO ,/ATE-CONTROL4 ,F9ALLY1 EV5 ! GREAT 9DU/RIALI/S :O HAD F9ANC$ ,HITL] F\ND !MSELVES SUBORD9ATE TO ! GOV]NM5TAL COMPLEX1 & ! POSSESSION ( WEAL? BECAME LESS IMPORTANT ?AN ! RI<T CONNECTIONS 9 A M9I/RY4 ,! EXI/5CE ( A T]ROR MA*9E WAS A GUN PO9T$ AT ! CAPITALI/ & ! >MY (FIC] NO LESS ?AN AT ! WORK]4 ,NATURALLY IT WAS POSSIBLE TO SOLVE ! UNEMPLOYM5T PROBLEM IF EV]YONE HAD TO WORK :]E !Y W]E TOLD1 AT DICTAT$ CONDITIONS & WAGES4 

,! ,SOVIET =C$ LABOR CAMPS HAD ! SAME POLITICAL & ECONOMIC AIMS4 ,RUSSIA1 BE+ TI$ TO A NONCOMPETITIVE IDEOLOGY1 WAS SL[] TO EVICT WORK]S FROM PRODUCTIVITY & TO R$UCE !M TO ,/ATE-FODD]1 9 ! SAME WAY AS ! CAPITALI/ C\NTRIES DID ) !IR UNEMPLOY$4 ,SC>CITY 9 ANY CASE MEANT ?AT ! C\NTRY NE$$ GOODS & WAS %ORT ( WORK]S RA!R ?AN O!RWISE4 ,BUT = ! ,/ATE TO EX]CISE FULL CONTROL1 IT WAS ESS5TIAL ?AT !RE BE A PIT 9TO :I* ! RECALCITRANT C\LD FALL4 ,S9CE IT WAS NOT ! /AGNATION ( UNEMPLOYM5T AMID DEPRESSION1 IT HAD TO BE TAM+ ! ,SIB]IAN WILDS4 ,!Y DID NOT REQUIRE A TOTALLY NONPRODUCTIVE CLASS4 ,S9CE ! ,/ATE WAS MA/]1 IT MI<T AS WELL KEEP ! 0PEOPLE ( ! ABYSS0 BUILD+ USELESS PYRAMIDS4 ,HAD !RE NOT BE5 POLITICAL (F5D]S1 IT W\LD HAVE BE5 NECESS>Y TO 9V5T !M4 

,TOTALIT>IANISM IS NOT B\ND BY ! NEW ECONOMICS :I* TEA*ES ?AT LABOR IS ! MO/ EXP5SIVE ITEM ON ! %EET1 & ! ,RUSSIAN COMMISS>S >E !RE=E MORE 9CL9$ ?AN O!RWISE TO KEEP ! SOCIALI/ DEF9ITION ?AT LABOR IS ! MEASUREM5T ( EV]Y?+4 ,SO ! ESCAPES BY WAY ( OPT+-\T ( ! SY/EM >E CLOS$1 EXCEPT = A FEW FROM ! VANI%+ LUMP5PROLET>IAT :O CAN C>RY ON /REET TRAD+ = A TIME & A FEW FROM ! 09TELLIG5TSIA0 :O WILL S+ & PA9T ! GLORIES ( ! REGIME4 

,EV5 SO1 ! T5D5CIES T[>DS A 0,NABO? CLASS0 >E NOT 5TIRELY ABS5T FROM ,RUSSIA AS ! BUREAUCRACY 0LIB]ALIZES0 ECONOMICALLY1 I4E4 MOVES FROM /ATE COMMUNISM TO /ATE RULE & SO TO /ATE CAPITALISM4 ,! SAME CONDITIONS AS 9 /ATE CAPITALISM >E BE+ CREAT$4 ,! CIVIL S]VICE NE$S ITS QUOTA ( CL]KS1 C\NT+ ITS GLORY 9 ! NUMB] ( S]FS AT ITS DISPOSAL4 ,! S*OOL CONVEYOR-BELTS TURN \T /UD5TS GE>$ TO S]VE ! DICTAT$ NE$S ( ! BUREAUCRACY4 ,IT IS NOT SURPRIS+ ?AT REBELLION BEG9S TO GR[ AMONG ! Y\NG] G5]ATION1 :I* N[ REALIZES ?AT ?IS PROCESS IS COM+ TO BE REG>D$ AS 9EVITABLE4 

,! CAPITALI/ IS LESS 9HIBIT$ ?AN ! ,SOVIET COMMISS> 9 FEEL+1 OR ?9K+ ?AT HE \<T TO FEEL1 ?AT LABOR IS ! S\RCE ( HIS P[]4 ,ON ! CONTR>Y1 HE RES5TS BE+ DEP5D5T ON ! WORK]1 & ! NEW1 LIT]ATE G5]ATION ( CAPITALI/S IS 9CL9$ TO ?R[ BACK ! *>GE4 0,Y\ >E ! P>ASITES ON US60 IS :AT 9 EFFECT !IR POLITICAL M\?PIECES SAY TO ! PRODUCTIVE WORK]1 & ! PRESS EXP&S ON ! !ME1 SOMETIMES ) MORE TACT & SOMETIMES ) LESS4 ,LABOR IS 0EXP5SIVE01 IT IS CAPABLE ( BECOM+ 0R$UNDANT01 IT \<T TO BE MORE 0MOBILE0 ,IT IS ! 0DE>E/ ITEM ( CO/04 ,ONCE ! BOSS SAID1 0,WE GIVE Y\ WORK04 ,N[ HE IS ABLE TO SAY 0,WE DO NOT NE$ Y\04 ,LABOR 0FAILS TO ADAPT ITSELF TO NEW ME?ODS0 -- SO BR+ 9 ! MA*9]Y1 PU% \T ! M56 ,! ROBOTS >E TAK+ OV]1 ! PRODUCTIVE PROCESSES BR+ 9 -- NOT ,KROPOTK9'S ,UTOPIA1 BECAUSE IT IS NOT WILL$ -- BUT ! ,ANTI-,UTOPIA ( ,ALD\S ,HUXLEY'S 0,BRAVE ,NEW ,WORLD0 & ,GEORGE ,ORWELL'S 0#a#i#h#d04 

,ONCE LABOR CEASES TO BE ! VITAL ELEM5T ( SOCIETY1 !RE REMA9S ! PROBLEM ( :AT TO DO ) ! DISPLAC$4 ,ONE CAN LEAVE ! ECONOMY ALONE & CREATE A VA/ CLASS ( UNEMPLOY$4 ,ONE CAN SET \T TO CREATE A LUMP5PROLET>IAT4 ,ALT]NATIVELY IT IS POSSIBLE TO PUT LABOR 9TO ! SIDE JOBS ( ! ECONOMY4 ,CREAT+ UNEMPLOYM5T1 ! FIR/ ME?OD1 HAS BE5 TRI$ & F\ND DANG]\S TO ! /ABILITY ( ! REGIME4 ,IT IS EV5 N[ ADVANC$1 AT LEA/ 9 M9OR T\*ES1 BY 9FLU5TIAL SECTIONS ( ! ,CONS]VATIVE ,P>TY AS ! BE/ WAY TO FLICK ! :IP1 BUT MO/ MOD]ATE POLITICIANS >E AFRAID ?AT ! BEA/ WILL GET \T ( CONTROL AFT] ! LA%+4 ,CREAT+ A LUMP5PROLET>IAT IS SELDOM DONE DELIB]ATELY BY ! ,/ATE4 ,:5 IT IS DONE IRRESPONSIBLY BY LAISSEZ-FAIRE CAPITALI/S1 IT CAUSES A B\RGEOIS REACTION TO *EAP GOV]NM5T4 ,!Y CALL = /RONG] RULE1 AS 9 P>TS ( ! ,U,S,A TODAY4 ,! MO/ FAVOR$ ME?OD N[ ( DEAL+ ) DISPLAC$ LABOR IS TO TAKE IT FROM BE+ A CLASS ( PRODUC]S & TO MAKE IT A P]IPH]AL CLASS4 ,%IPY>DS >E CLOS$1 BUT !Y CANNOT F9D 5\< DOORM5 = ! VA/ (FICE BLOCKS4 ,UNIV]SITY DEGREES >E GIV5 9 MEANS ( CUTT+ D[N ! NUMB] ( WORK]S EMPLOY$ 9 CREATIVE WORK1 BUT !RE IS AN ACUTE %ORTAGE ( BOOKKEEP]S4 

,! MOM5T ONE BEG9S TO CONSID] /AFF %ORTAGES1 ! :OLE QUE/ION ( EMIGRATION & IMMIGRATION >ISES4 ,*ANGES 9 ! ECONOMY >E ALWAYS ACCOMPANI$ BY ! %IFT+ >\ND ( POPULATIONS4 ,IT IS P>T ( ! NORMAL PATT]N ( SOCIAL CONQUE/4 ,! MILIT>Y SUBJUGATION ( ! ,SCOTTI% ,HI<L&S WAS 9SEP>ABLE FROM ! *ANGE 9 ITS WAY ( LIFE1 & EVICT+ ! CR(T]S WAS AS MU* P>T ( MILIT>Y CONQUE/ AS IT WAS ( ECONOMIC *ANGE4 ,EMIGRATION IS ! PROPHYLACTIC ( REVOLUTION1 AS SE5 CLE>LY 9 ,IREL& EV5 UP TO ! PRES5T DAY4 0,H]E OR NO:]E IS Y\R ,AM]ICA10 SAID ,GOE!4 ,! ,FR5*1 SAID ,HE9E SOME:AT TOO OPTIMI/ICALLY1 DO NOT EMIGRATE3 !Y /AY :]E !Y >E & LET !IR TYRANTS EMIGRATE -- 9 %ORT1 !Y CREATE A REVOLUTION4 

,IT HAS SUIT$ ! CAPITALI/ CLASS TO SEE HUGE NUMB]S ( WORK]S GO \T1 & 9 SOME CASES BE DRIV5 \T1 TO CREATE NEW M>KETS 9 ,AU/RALIA1 ,NEW ,ZEAL& & ,CANADA4 ,IT IS BO? MORE B\RGEOIS & MORE CIVILIZ$ ?AN ,RUSSIA'S COLONIZATION ( ,SIB]IA BY PRISON LABOR1 AT LEA/ S9CE DEPORTATIONS TO ,AU/RALIA BECAME OBSOLETE4 ,NEW M>KETS = EXPANSION >E CREAT$ 9 ?IS WAY1 & ! HOME ECONOMY IS TRANS=M$ BY GETT+ RID ( ?OSE :OM IT IS NO LONG] NECESS>Y TO EXPLOIT4 

,! RUL+ CLASS 9 ! NEW C\NTRIES T5D TO BE MORE DEMOCRATIC 9 !IR HABITS ?AN ?OSE 9 ! OLD] C\NTRIES1 BUT SOON] RA!R ?AN LAT] A NEW MONEY$ >I/OCRACY IS RE-CREAT$1 & ! GAP BETWE5 RUL]S & RUL$ MADE PLA94 

,EMIGRATION FROM ONE C\NTRY MEANS IMMIGRATION 9TO ANO!R1 & NORMALLY IMMIGRATION BR+S PROBLEMS ( ADJU/M5T1 ESPECIALLY :5 ! IMMIGRANT CANNOT HIDE HIS ID5TITY BECAUSE ( LANGUAGE1 RELIGION OR COLOR4 ,ALL ! USUAL ,/ATE IDEOLOGY -- 0\R C\NTRY0 AS OPPOS$ TO !IRS1 MEAN+ WE W]E ! S]FS ( ! GOV]NM5T FIR/ -- REACTS AGA9/ ! IMMIGRANT EV5 :5 NOT AGGRAVAT$ BY LIV+ *EEK-TO-J[L 9 ! SLUMS ) PEOPLE ( DIFF]5T CU/OMS OR COOK]Y4 ,ONLY :5 IMMIGRATION CAN BE SE5 GIV+ DEMON/RABLE B5EFITS1 :E!R REAL OR IMAG9$1 DOES ! E/ABLI%$ WORK+ CLASS ACCEPT IT1 AS 9 ,ISRAEL4 ,! RUL+ CLASS WILL NOT ACCEPT IT UNLESS IT BR+S PRACTICAL B5EFITS TO !M1 *IEFLY BY WAY ( *EAP OR DILUT$ LABOR1 BUT NOT IF IT BR+S LABOR PROBLEMS 9 ITS WAKE4 ,ONE HAS ONLY TO EXAM9E ! PROGRESS ( ! ,U,S IMMIGRATION LAWS4 

,OPPOSITION TO IMMIGRATION TODAY HAS BECOME 9 ,BRITA9 A B&WAGON ON :I* DISCR$IT$ FASCISM HAS JUMP$4 ,IT IS NO ACCID5T ?AT ! SECTION ( ! ,CONS]VATIVE ,P>TY1 EXEMPLIFI$ BY ,5O* ,P[ELL1 :I* ADVOCATES ! T\* ( ! :IP BY UNEMPLOYM5T1 ALSO OPPOSES IMMIGRATION1 AT LEA/ TO ! EXT5T ( CREAT+ FEEL+ AGA9/ IT4 ,BUT !Y DO NOT S]I\SLY 9T5D TO TAKE POSITIVE ACTION S9CE ! SITUATION ( HAV+ DISCONT5T SUITS !M1 & IT W\LD BE FATAL TO DISP5SE ) A SCAPEGOAT4 ,IT IS CONV5I5T = !M TO 5C\RAGE EMIGRATION & TO DISC\RAGE IMMIGRATION ONLY TO ! PO9T ( CREAT+ DISS5SION & SO TO 0*ANGE ! COLOR0 ( ! WORK+ CLASS1 AS IT W]E3 TO HAVE ! 0TR\BLESOME0 LABOR JOBS1 9 TRANSPORT = 9/ANCE1 FILL$ BY ?OSE :O W\LD BE SUBJECT TO DISCRIM9ATION & DISLIKE NOT BECAUSE !Y >E WORK]S1 BUT BECAUSE !Y >E RACIALLY DI/+UI%ABLE4 

,IT IS A SOPHI/ICAT$ V]SION ( ! ,H9DU CA/E SY/EM4 ,IT IS NOT FASCISM1 EV5 ?\< ! ADH]5TS ( ! LATT] ADVOCATE IT TO SAVE !MSELVES FROM OBLIVION4 ,! BIG FI/ AGA9/ ! WORK]S IS NOT REQUIR$ BY CAPITALISM1 & M5 LIKE ,P[ELL HAVE LE>N$ ?AT FASCISM IS A TWO-$G$ WEAPON4 ,! ,G]MAN CAPITALI/S F\ND IT WAS AS MU* A BOOM]ANG AS ,LUD5DORFF'S 0SEAL$ TRA90 /RATEGY4 ,9 ANY CASE1 ! ID5TIFICATION ( FASCISM AS SU* ) A DEFEAT$ IMP]IALISM MAKES IT UNABLE ANY MORE1 ( ITSELF1 TO BE A POPUL> RALLY+ PO9T1 :I* WAS ITS ORIG9AL ATTRACTION TO ! CAPITALI/S4 ,! MEASURES ( ! CORPORATE1 /ATE HAVE LONG S9CE BE5 ADAPT$ TO DEMOCRATIC GOV]NM5T BY LIB]ALLY $UCAT$ ECONOMI/S TO :OM ! BRUTALITY ( ,HITL]ISM HAS NO ATTRACTION :5 NOT NECESS>Y4 ,AN >GUM5T OV] IMMIGRATION1 PRO & CON1 MAY SUIT ! POLITICAL BOOK1 BUT FASCISM HAS BECOME A GADFLY4 ,IT HAS NO RELATION TO CLASS ISSUES1 & SO F> AS ANY EFFECTIV5ESS IS CONC]N$1 JO9S ! ANTI-VIVESECTIONI/S OR ! MILITANT TEETOTAL]S OR ! SPIRITUALI/S AS FLIES UPON ! :EEL4 ,SU* MOVEM5TS >E SOCIALLY IRRELEVANT4 ,!Y MAY BE GOOD 7ANTI-ANIMAL CRUELTY72 BAD 7SCI5TOLOGY72 OR DELI<TFULLY 9DIFF]5T 7,JOANNA ,S\?COTT'S BOX74 ,!Y MAY MAKE AN IMPACT UPON PEOPLE'S LIVES 7,JEHOVAH'S ,WITNESSES74 ,IT IS1 = 9/ANCE1 UNPLEASANT TO HAVE A FASCI/ GR\P-IRRESPECTIVE ( ! FACT ?AT IT IS NEV] LIKELY TO GA9 P[]-NAGG+ AWAY AT ONE'S COLOR )\T EV5 (F]+ A HELPFUL SUGGE/ION AS TO H[ TO *ANGE IT4 ,BUT NO SU* GR\P+ CAN MAKE ANY FUNDAM5TAL *ANGE 9 ! COMMUNITY4 ,?IS MU/ HAVE SOME CONNECTION ) ! RELATION ( ONE CLASS TO ANO!R4 ,IF WE ALL JO9$ ! ,LORD'S ,DAY ,OBS]VANCE ,SOCIETY1 WE W\LD BE 9 = SOME DRE>Y ,SCOTTI%-TYPE ,SUNDAYS1 BUT A *ANGE 9 ! /RUCTURE ( ! ECONOMY W\LD NOT BE EFFECT$ BY ,SABBAT>IANISM4 

,IT MAY WELL BE ASK$ IF ! LIB]T>IAN CAN MAKE AN IMPACT UPON SOCIETY1 OR IF HE IS DOOM$ TO BE LUMP$ ) ! ADVOCATES ( FUNNY MONEY OR PURE WAT]4 ,?IS WAS C]TA9LY ! CASE 9 ! 'TW5TIES :5 ! ISSUE ( FREE DEC5TRALIZATION SEEM$ AS IRRELEVANT TO ! *ANG+ PATT]N ( SOCIETY AS ! PRES]VATION ( ! WAT]WAYS4 ,BUT IT CANNOT BE SAID N[4 ,! 9DU/RIAL WORK] HAS TO *OOSE BETWE5 TAK+ OV] SOCIETY OR DISAPPE>+ AS A PRODUCTIVE CLASS4 ,! ,FABIANS W]E RI<T :5 !Y PR$ICT$ ?AT 0! WORK+ CLASS W\LD DISAPPE>04 ,BUT !Y DID NOT IMPLY ?AT WE %\LD ALL BECOME FILM />S OR ADV]TIS+ EXECUTIVES OR *AIRM5 ( COMPANIES4 ,?OSE OCCUPATIONS >E ! WRAPP+S >\ND ! MONOLI?IC ,/ATE4 ,:5 ! 0WORK+ CLASS DISAPPE>S0 IT WILL BE A MAJOR DISA/] LIKE ! DISPOSSESSION ( ! PEASANTRY4 

,IT IS HAPP5+ SL[LY1 BUT IT IS IMPLICIT 9 ! PATT]NS ( TODAY4 ,= ?IS REASON ANY PROTE/ MOVEM5T >IS+ EV5 \T ( A PURELY NEGATIVE *>ACT]1 HO/ILE REACTION TO MASS ANNIHILATION1 COMES TO BE ID5TIFI$ G5]ALLY ) RESI/ANCE TO ! ,DE/RUCTION ,/ATE1 :E!R PASSIVELY OR ACTIVELY4 ,FROM IT HAS COME A MOVEM5T ( SPONTANE\S REVOLUTION ?AT IS SPREAD+ ACROSS ! WORLD4 ,IF MANK9D SURVIVES ! ,/ATE1 ! ACADEMIC & J\RNALI/IC ILLUSION ?AT ?IS MOVEM5T IS ONLY A MANIFE/ATION ( Y\?FUL HI< SPIRITS WILL BE LAU<$ AT BY HI/ORY4 

,FROM 3 ,!,AN>*I/,LIBR>Y4ORG4 

,*RONOLOGY 3 
,NOVEMB] #c1 #aifi 3 ,*APT] #d - ,SOCIAL ,PROTE/ & A ,NEW ,CLASS -- ,PUBLICATION4 
,JULY #a#g1 #bai 3 ,*APT] #d - ,SOCIAL ,PROTE/ & A ,NEW ,CLASS -- ,ADD$4 

 FILE G5]AT$ FROM 3  
HTTP3_/_/REVOLTLIB4COM_/