,P>T #c1 ,*APT] #ab ,PROTECTION1 & ITS ,RELATION TO ,R5T #ahigahig ,PEOPLE 3 ,AU?OR 3 ,B5JAM9 ,R4 ,TUCK] ,TEXT 3 ,PROTECTION1 & ITS ,RELATION TO ,R5T4 .<,LIB]TY1 ,OCTOB] #b#g1 #a#h#h#h4.> ,TO ! ,$ITOR ( ,LIB]TY37#a#a 8 #a7 ,REF]R+ TO Y\R FAVOR$ REPLY ( ,OCTOB] #a#c1 ,I FAIL TO F9D AN ANSW] TO ! QUE/ION AS TO ! RESULT ( ! ATTEMPT ( TWO RIVAL PROTECTORS TO SECURE TO DIFF]5T P]SONS ! SAME T]RITORY4 ,I CANNOT SEE H[1 UND] SU* CONDITIONS1 A PHYSICAL CONFLICT CAN BE AVOID$1 7#a7 NOR IS IT CLE> :Y ! BE/ & *EAPE/ PROTECTOR WILL BE ! MO/ PATRONIZ$ IF HE IS NOT AT ! SAME TIME ! /RONGE/4 ,IT W\LD BE ! P[] RA!R ?AN ! QUALITY ( PROTECTION ?AT W\LD SECURE PATRONAGE4 7#b7 ,BUT IF ! TYRANT BY SOPHI/RY C\LD CONV9CE ! MASSES1 AS HE N[ DOES1 ?AT HIS POLICY IS TO !IR B5EFIT & C\LD OBTA9 !IR SUPPORT1 ,AN>*Y W\LD 9EVITABLY LEAD TO DESPOTISM4 7#c7 ,! PRES5T ,/ATE1 TO MY M9D1 IS 9DE$ ! NATURAL \TGR[? ( ,AN>*Y1 ITS ABSURD *>ACT]1 BE+ DUE TO %ORTSIKS AB\T EQUITY DO C]TA9LY NOT REF] TO :AT IS N[ T]M$ EQUITY1 BUT TO ! G5U9E >TICLE47#a#a 8 #c7 ,! /ATEM5T ?AT ! VALUE ( ! PROTECTION 9 ! POSSESSION ( L& EQUALS ITS ECONOMIC R5T ,I CONSID] TRUE1 EV5 IF !RE IS NO DIRECT LABOR ( PROTECTION 9VOLV$47#a#a 8 #d7 ,BY R5T ,I MEAN1 ( C\RSE1 ?AT :I* ,RIC>DO T]MS R5T1--I4E41 ! DIFF]5CE BETWE5 ! PRODUCTIVITY ( A P>TICUL> PIECE ( L& & ! M>G9AL PRODUCTIVITY2 ! EXCESS ( ! VALUE ( A PRODUCT OV] ! VALUE ( ! LABOR PRODUC+ IT47#a#a 8 #e7 ,! OBS]VATION REG>D+ ! S5TIM5TAL VALUE ( PROTECTION IS C]TA9LY \T ( PLACE1 S9CE 9 ECONOMIC DISCUSSION NONE O!R ?AN EX*ANGE VALUE CAN BE CONSID]$4 7#e7 ,EV5 9 A SOCIETY 9 :I* ! POLICEMAN IS SUP]FLU\S1 ! VALUE ( PROTECTION 9 ! POSSESSION ( L& CAN BE %[N TO BE EQUAL TO ITS ECONOMIC R5T4 ,! RI'S LABOR 7SAY ?REE HUNDR$ DAYS7 WILL EX*ANGE = FIVE HUNDR$ DAYS' ( O!R M5'S LABOR :O MU/ WORK )\T SU* SPECIAL ADVANTAGES1 IT WILL BE DIFFICULT TO %[ ?AT ! OCCUPI] ( ?AT L& IS EQUITABLY 5TITL$ TO ?IS EX*ANGE VALUE4 7#g7 ,?OSE :O BUY HIS PRODUCTS REALLY PRODUCE & ACTUALLY PAY ! EXCESS ( TWO HUNDR$ DAYS' LABOR4 ,>E !Y NOT 5TITL$ TO A DI/RIBUTION ( ?IS R5T :I* !Y1 9 ! C\RSE ( EX*ANGE1 HAVE PAID TO HIM8 ,IF ! PEOPLE ( A COMMUNITY >E 5D[$ ) 9TELLIG5T EGOISM1 !Y CANNOT GIVE ?AT PROTECTION TO ANY ONE :O IS NOT WILL+ TO PAY ! R5T2 &1 IF ! OCCUPI] REFUSES TO DO SO1 ! RIGA94 7#i7 ,:AT RIE WILL+ TO PAY ! FULL VALUE ( ! ADVANTAGES (F]$1 :]EBY EQUITY IS E/ABLI%$8 ,I CAN CONCEIVE ( NO O!R 9DIVIDUALI/IC MEASURE 7#a#a7 BY :I* ! CO/ PR9CIPLE ( VALUE CAN BE REALIZ$ 9 ?OSE CASES 9 :I* ! CO/ ( PRODUC+ EQUAL QUANTITIES IS DIFF]5T ON ACC\NT ( A V>IATION ( LOCAL OPPORTUNITIES ?AN TO ADD R5T TO ! CO/ :]E ! IMM$IATE CO/ IS NATURALLY LESS ?AN ! VALUE ( ! PRODUCT4 ,ALL M5 >E !N UPON AN EQUITABLE PLANE REG>D+ ! GIFTS ( NATURE2 & NONE CAN1 AS NONE %\LD 9 ?IS RESPECT1 HAVE AN ADVANTAGE ?AT IS NOT SIMIL>LY 5JOY$ BY ALL4 7#a#b77#a#a 8 #f7 ,EGOI/4 7#a7 ,A PHYSICAL CONFLICT MAY OR MAY NOT OCCUR4 ,! PROBABILITY ( IT IS 9V]SELY PROPORTIONAL TO ! AM\NT ( $UCATION 9 ECONOMICS & SOCIAL SCI5CE ACQUIR$ BY ! PEOPLE PRIOR TO ! 9AUGURATION ( ! CONDITIONS SUPPOS$4 ,IF GOV]NM5T %\LD BE ABRUPTLY & 5TIRELY ABOLI%$ TO-MORR[1 !RE W\LD PROBABLY 5SUE A S]IES ( PHYSICAL CONFLICTS AB\T L& & MANY O!R ?+S1 5D+ 9 REACTION & A REVIVAL ( ! OLD TYRANNY4 ,BUT IF ! ABOLITION ( GOV]NM5T %ALL TAKE PLACE GRADUALLY1 BEG9N+ ) ! D[NFALL ( ! MONEY & L& MONOPOLIES & EXT5D+ !NCE 9TO ONE FIELD AFT] ANO!R1 IT WILL BE ACCOMPANI$ BY SU* A CON/ANT ACQUISITION & /EADY SPREAD+ ( SOCIAL TRU? ?AT1 :5 ! TIME %ALL COME TO APPLY ! VOLUNT>Y PR9CIPLE 9 ! SUPPLY ( POLICE PROTECTION1 ! PEOPLE WILL RALLY AS PROMPTLY & UNIV]SALLY TO ! SUPPORT ( ! PROTECTOR :O ACTS MO/ NE>LY 9 ACCORDANCE ) ! PR9CIPLES ( SOCIAL SCI5CE AS !Y N[ RALLY TO ! SIDE ( ! ASSAULT$ MAN AGA9/ HIS W\LD-BE MURD]]4 ,9 ?AT CASE NO S]I\S CONFLICT CAN >ISE47#a#a 8 #g7 7#b7 ,EGOI/ NEGLECTS TO CONSID] MY /ATEM5T 9 REPLY TO HIM 9 ! LA/ ISSUE ( ,LIB]TY1 TO ! EFFECT ?AT ! S\RCE ( ! PROTECTOR'S P[] LIES PRECISELY 9 ! PATRONAGE4 ,! PROTECTOR :O IS MO/ PATRONIZ$ WILL1 !RE=E1 BE ! /RONGE/2 & ! PEOPLE WILL 5D[ ) !IR P[] ! PROTECTOR :O IS BE/ FITT$ TO USE IT 9 ! ADM9I/RATION ( JU/ICE47#a#a 8 #h7 7#c7 ,?AT IS TO SAY1 IF ! MASSES1 OR ANY L>GE SECTION ( !M1 AFT] HAV+ COME TO AN UND]/&+ & ACCEPTANCE ( ,AN>*ISM1 %\LD !N BE 9DUC$ BY ! SOPHI/RY ( TYRANTS TO REJECT IT AGA91 DESPOTISM W\LD RESULT4 ,?IS IS P]FECTLY TRUE4 ,NO ,AN>*I/ EV] DREAM$ ( D5Y+ IT4 ,9DE$1 ! ,AN>*I/'S ONLY HOPE LIES 9 HIS CONFID5CE ?AT PEOPLE :O HAVE ONCE 9TELLIG5TLY ACCEPT$ HIS PR9CIPLE WILL /AY PUT47#a#a 8 #i7 7#d7 ,! PRES5T ,/ATE CANNOT BE AN \TGR[? ( ,AN>*Y1 BECAUSE ,AN>*Y1 9 ! PHILOSOPHICAL S5SE ( ! WORD1 HAS NEV] EXI/$4 ,= ,AN>*Y1 AFT] ALL1 MEANS SOME?+ MORE ?AN ! POSSESSION ( LIB]TY4 ,JU/ AS ,RUSK9 DEF9ES WEAL? AS ! POSSESSION ( ! VALUABLE BY ! VALIANT1 SO ,AN>*Y MAY BE DEF9$ AS ! POSSESSION ( LIB]TY BY LIB]T>IANS1--?AT IS1 BY ?OSE :O KN[ :AT LIB]TY MEANS4 ,! B>B>IC LIB]TY \T ( :I* ! PRES5T ,/ATE DEVELOP$ WAS NOT ,AN>*Y 9 ?IS S5SE AT ALL1 = ?OSE :O POSSESS$ IT HAD NOT ! SLIY1 IT RE/S1 9 AN EV]-RIS+ DEGREE & AMONG AN EV]-9CREAS+ PROPORTION ( ! PEOPLE1 UPON ! LOVE ( SECURITY & PEACE1 ! LOVE ( HOME1 ! LOVE ( BEAUTIFUL SC5]Y1 & MANY O!R :OLLY S5TIM5TAL MOTIVES4 ,9ASMU*1 !N1 AS ! /R5G? ( SOME ( ! MOTIVES = ! DEM& ( PROTECTION BE>S (T5 NO RELATION TO ECONOMIC R5T1 ! VALUE ( SU* PROTECTION IS NOT NECESS>ILY EQUAL TO ECONOMIC R5T4 ,:I* IS ! CONTR>Y ( ,EGOI/'S PROPOSITION47#a#a 8 #a#a7 7#f7 ,ALL ?IS LEGITIMATELY FOLL[S1 ONCE HAV+ ADMITT$ ,EGOI/'S DEF9ITION ( ! RI*I/S D5Y1--NAMELY1 ?AT !RE IS AN 5TITY KN[N AS ! COMMUNITY :I* IS ! RIGUM5T :I* ,EGOI/ USES 9 BEHALF ( ! COMMUNITY ?IS \TSIDE 9DIVIDUAL1 IF HE BUT HAD ! /R5G? TO BACK IT UP1 MIT TO =EGO ! SPECIAL ADVANTAGES :I* ! USE ( SU* L& AF=DS TO AN UNDI/URB$ POSSESSOR4 ,IT REPRES5TS A GIV+-UP1 BY ME1 ( ?AT :I* ,I C\LD OBTA9 = MYSELF1--! CO/ TO ME BE+ C]TA9LY ?AT :I* ,I HAVE REL9QUI%$1 & EQUALS 9 VALUE ! SPECIAL ADVANTAGE :I* IS ! CAUSE ( R5T4 ,9 VIEW ( ?IS1 IT SEEMS TO ME ?AT AF=D+ ?IS PROTECTION IS TO ME AN EXP5SE EQUAL TO ! R5T4 ,& !REUPON HE MIY TO 5=CE SU* AN >GUM5T AS ?IS4 ,! COMMUNITY1 OR COMB9ATION ( 9DIVIDUALS1 HAS ?IS /R5G?4 ,ITS ONLY SUP]IORITY TO ! S+LE 9DIVIDUAL1 !N1 9 RELATION TO ! L&1 CONSI/S 9 ! RIE NECESSITIES ( LIFE8 ,:Y RECOGNIZE HIM AT ALL1 9 ANY WAY1 EXCEPT AS A TOOL TO BE US$ 9 ! 9T]E/ ( ! COMMUNITY8 ,9 A WORD1 :Y NOT DO PRECISELY :AT CAPITALISM IS DO+ N[1 OR ELSE :AT ,/ATE ,SOCIALISM PROPOSES TO DO :5 IT GETS CONTROL ( AFFAIRS8 ,BUT IF ! COMMUNITY DOES NOT PROPOSE TO GO TO ?IS EXTREME2 IF IT PROPOSES TO RECOGNIZE ! 9DIVIDUAL & TREAT ) HIM1--!N IT MU/ =EGO 5TIRELY ITS RI SAY TO ! H\SEHOLD]3 ,H]E1 ,I CAN1 IF ,I *OOSE1 5T] Y\R H\SE ONE ( !SE F9E NIRY (F Y\R VALUABLES2 ,I !RE=E DEM& ?AT Y\ IMM$IATELY H& !M OV] TO ME AS COMP5SATION = ! SACRIFICE :I* ,I MAKE & ! PROTECTION :I* ,I AF=D Y\ 9 NOT DO+ SO47#a#a 8 #a#b7 7#g7 ,PRECISELY AS DIFFICULT AS IT W\LD BE TO %[ ?AT ! MAN ( SUP]IOR SKILL 7NATIVE1 NOT ACQUIR$7 :O PRODUCES 9 ! RATIO ( FIVE HUNDR$ TO ANO!R'S ?REE HUNDR$ IS EQUITABLY 5TITL$ TO ?IS SURPLUS EX*ANGE VALUE4 ,!RE IS NO MORE REASON :Y WE %\LD POOL ! RESULTS ( \R L&S ?AN ! RESULTS ( \R H&S4 ,& TO COMPEL SU* POOL+ IS AS M$DLESOME & TYRANNICAL 9 ONE CASE AS 9 ! O!R4 ,?AT S*OOL ( ,SOCIALI/IC ECONOMI/S :I* C>RIES ,H5RY ,GEORGE'S IDEA TO ITS CONCLUSIONS1 CONFISCAT+ NOT ONLY R5T BUT 9T]E/ & PR(IT & EQUALIZ+ WAGES1--A S*OOL ( :I* ,G4 ,B]N>D ,%AW MAY BE TAK5 AS A TYPICAL REPRES5TATIVE1--IS MORE LOGICAL ?AN ! S*OOL TO :I* ,MR4 ,GEORGE & ,EGOI/ BELONG1 BECAUSE IT COMPLETES ! APPLICATION ( ! TYRANNICAL PR9CIPLE47#a#a 8 #a#c7 7#h7 ,H]E AGA9 WE HAVE ! ASSUMPTION ( ! COMMUNITY'S SUP]IOR TITLE TO ! L&47#a#a 8 #a#d7 7#i7 ,YES1 ! B>GA9 ( ! HIILY4 ,BUT 9 ! MEAN TIME ,I %ALL TEA* ! PR9CIPLE ( LIB]TY TO ! 9DIVIDUALS ( :I* Y\ >E COMPOS$1 & BY & BY1 :5 !Y SEE ?AT Y\ >E OPPRESS+ ME1 !Y WILL ESP\SE MY CAUSE1 & Y\R TYRANNICAL YOKE WILL SPE$ILY BE LIFT$ FROM MY NECK47#a#a 8 #a#f7 7#a#a7 ,NO O!R6 ,IS ,EGOI/'S MEASURE 9DIVIDUALI/IC1 !N8 ,I HAVE ALREADY PO9T$ \T ITS COMMUNI/IC & AU?ORIT>IAN *>ACT]47#a#a 8 #a#g7 7#a#b7 ,IF ! CO/ PR9CIPLE ( VALUE CANNOT BE REALIZ$ O!RWISE ?AN BY COMPULSION1 !N IT HAD BETT] NOT BE REALIZ$4 ,= MY P>T1 ,I DO NOT BELIEVE ?AT IT IS POSSIBLE OR HITIAL ABOLITION ( COMPULSION1--& SO MU* WILL BE SUFFICI5T4 ,BY F> ! L>G] P>T ( ! VIOLATIONS ( ! CO/ PR9CIPLE--PROBABLY N9E-T5?S--RESULT FROM >TIFICIAL1 LAW-MADE 9EQUALITIES2 ONLY A SMALL PORTION >ISE FROM NATURAL 9EQUALITIES4 ,ABOLI% ! >TIFICIAL MONOPOLIES ( MONEY & L&1 & 9T]E/1 PR(IT1 & ! R5T ( BUILD+S WILL ALMO/ 5TIRELY DISAPPE>2 GR\ND R5TS WILL NO LONG] FL[ 9TO A FEW H&S2 & PRACTICALLY ! ONLY 9EQUALITY REMA9+ WILL BE ! SLIITY ( PRODUCTS DUE TO SUP]IORITY ( SOIL & SKILL4 ,EV5 ?IS DISP>ITY WILL SOON DEVELOP A T5D5CY TO DECREASE4 ,UND] ! NEW ECONOMIC CONDITIONS & 5L>G$ OPPORTUNITIES RESULT+ FROM FRE$OM ( CR$IT & L& CLASSES WILL T5D TO DISAPPE>2 GREAT CAPACITIES WILL NOT BE DEVELOP$ 9 A FEW AT ! EXP5SE ( /UNT+ ?OSE ( ! MANY2 TAL5TS WILL APPROXIMATE T[>DS EQUALITY1 ?\< !IR V>IETY WILL BE GREAT] ?AN EV]2 FRE$OM ( LOCOMOTION WILL BE VA/LY 9CREAS$2 ! TOIL]S WILL NO LONG] BE AN*OR$ 9 SU* L>GE NUMB]S 9 ! PRES5T COMM]CIAL C5T]S1 & ?US MADE SUBS]VI5T TO ! CITY L&LORDS2 T]RITORIES & RES\RCES NEV] BE=E UTILIZ$ WILL BECOME EASY ( ACCESS & DEVELOPM5T2 & UND] ALL !SE 9FLU5CES ! DISP>ITY ABOVE M5TION$ WILL DECREASE TO A M9IMUM4 ,PROBABLY IT WILL NEV] DISAPPE> 5TIRELY2 ON ! O!R H&1 IT CAN NEV] BECOME 9TOL]ABLE4 ,IT MU/ ALWAYS REMA9 A COMP>ATIVELY TRIVIAL CONSID]ATION1 C]TA9LY NEV] TO BE WEI<$ = A MOM5T 9 ! SAME SCALE ) LIB]TY47#a#a 8 #a#h7 ,FROM 3 FAIR-USE4ORG4 ,*RONOLOGY 3 ,NOVEMB] #c1 #ahif 3 ,P>T #c1 ,*APT] #ab -- ,PUBLICATION4 ,FEBRU>Y #b#a1 #bag 3 ,P>T #c1 ,*APT] #ab -- ,ADD$4 FILE G5]AT$ FROM 3 HTTP3_/_/REVOLTLIB4COM_/