,DEMAGOGU]Y ,NOT ,AN>*ISM 

,PEOPLE 3 

,AU?OR 3 ,WILLIAM ,GILLIS 

,TEXT 3 

,Y\ KN[ :AT ,I LOVE MO/ AB\T ! MILIEU8 ,! LEVEL ( \R DISC\RSE4 

,MAGPIE ,KILLJOY'S LOBB$ A %ORT TROLLI% BROADSIDE AT ,M>KETS ,NOT ,CAPITALISM CALL+ IT 0RACI/0 & 0DISGU/+40 ,( C\RSE HE'S C\*$ HIS HODGEPODGE ASSEMBLY ( EMOTIONALLY-*>G$ MISREADS ) A FEW NOTES AB\T H[ HE HAS NO FUNDAM5TAL OBJECTION TO M>KET AN>*ISM P] SE & ?AT MANY ( ! VIEWS 9SIDE ,M>KETS ,NOT ,CAPITALISM >E LEGITIMATELY AN>*I/1 BUT NUANCE DOESN'T BR+ ! PAGEVIEWS & RALLY+ ! TROOPS AGA9/ TEH ANCAP SC\RGE-T5DRILS TO BE F\ND 9 Y\R V]Y COLLECTIVE6-DOES4 

,!RE'S NOT MU* TO WORK ) H]E BUT ,I'LL ?R[ D[N = ! HECK ( IT1 IF ONLY BECAUSE !RE'S A ?READ ( REASONABL5ESS TO HIS OBJECTIONS1 H[EV] 9ACCURATELY !Y FIT HIS T>GET4 

,WE CAN ALL AGREE ?AT ANY SOCIETY ?AT ALL[S C5TRALIZ$ P[] IS NOT AN>*I/4 ,BUT MORE ?AN ?AT ANY SOCIETY ?AT ALL[S P[] RELATIONS 9 ANY =M1 DEC5TRALIZ$ OR NOT1 IS NOT AN>*I/4 ,TRUE AN>*I/S DO NOT EV5 C\NT5ANCE DIFFUSE OR 9T]P]SONAL L9ES ( CONTROL1 ABUSE1 & CON/RA9T4 ,H]E'S ! DEAL ?\<1 ! ECONOMIC REALM IS BUT ONE FACET ( A SOCIETY2 NOT EV]Y PROBLEM CAN OR %\LD BE SOLV$ )9 IT4 ,WE DRAW SU* DI/9CTIONS IMP]FECTLY1 BUT !Y CAN BE AN EXTRAORD9>ILY GOOD RULE ( ?UMB4 ,IF SOMEONE SPITES Y\ AT A P>TY WE'D HOPEFULLY FR[N ON GETT+ Y\R FRI5DS TOGE!R & BURN+ D[N !IR F>M4 ,! PO9T IS IT CAN BE A GOOD IDEA TO HAVE SOCIAL NORMS ?AT PLACE LIMITS ON ! COMMUNITY'S PURVIEW & DEL9EATE APPROPRIATE REALMS ( REACTION & CONFLICT4 ,SAD TO SAY BUT IF SOMEONE SAYS SOME?+ A SMIDG5 RACI/ WE %\LDN'T NECESS>ILY GO BREAK+ !IR KNEECAPS 9 RESPONSE4 ,9 FACT1 NOT TO POLICE ANYONE'S RAGE1 BUT ?AT'S ALMO/ C]TA9LY AN OV]REACTION ?AT CAN LEAD D>K PLACES4 ,I BY NO MEANS MEAN TO EQUIVOCATE ) SOME?+ AS 9/ITUTIONAL AS ,JIM ,CR[ OR SUGGE/ ?AT WE %\LDN'T DO \R BE/ TO NAVIGATE !SE ISSUES1 BUT IT IS WOR? NOT+ EXCLUSION FROM SPACES CAN & FREQU5TLY DOES BECOME CONT5TI\S )9 \R COMMUNITY4 ,:AT CON/ITUTES LEGIT GR\NDS = EXCLUSION1 :O GETS TO DECIDE TO EXPEL SOMEONE FROM A SPACE & H[ ?AT EXPULSION WILL GO D[N444 !SE >E ISSUES \R COMMUNITIES DEAL ) CON/ANTLY4 ,= ALL ! GOOD ?AT WE DO1 CATT9ESS & MESS$ UP /UFF DOES HAPP54 ,P>T ( :AT M9IMIZES IT IS ?AT WE DO G5]ALLY DEFAULT ON RESPECT+ C]TA9 DIVISIONS ( PROP]TY & CATEGORIES ( BEHAVIOR4 

,( C\RSE :ILE !Y'RE (T5 USEFUL IT W\LD BE A PR(\ND MI/AKE TO MAKE TOO MU* ( !SE DI/9CTIONS4 ,AS ) ?AT OLD SELF-DESCRIB$ 0CAPITALI/0 ,VOLTAIR9E DE ,CLEYRE ,I'VE ALWAYS /OOD ON ! 0IF Y\'RE />V+ TAKE BREAD0 SIDE ( ?+S4 ,ALL GOOD AN>*I/S >E UTILIT>IANS4 ,WE CANNOT AF=D TO RULE \T ANY TACTIC OR APPROA* :OLESALE4 ,9 ?IS MANN] ,I PROBABLY DIFF] TO SOME DEGREE ) A FEW ( ! O!R AU?ORS PUBLI%$ 9 ,M>KETS ,NOT ,CAPITALISM :O DEFAULT ON :AT ,I CONSID] ! NAIVE LANGUAGE ( 0RI<TS0 & SPEAK /RONGLY ON ! LIMITS TO \R APPROA*ES4 ,I D\BT !Y'RE AS ABSOLUTI/ 9 PRACTICE AS !IR RHETORIC WAXES1 BUT IT IS SOME:AT REGRETTABLE4 ,?AT SAID1 IT MU/ BE NOT$ ?AT SIMIL> DEONTOLOGICAL /ANCES ON TACTICS LIKE NONVIOL5CE & VEGANISM C>RY WIDE CURR5CY )9 ! SOCIAL AN>*I/ MILIEU4 ,AS IMPLICITLY ABSOLUTI/ POSITIONS ON TACTICS & BEHAVIOR !Y MU/ BE CALL$ \T & C\NT]$1 BUT !Y DO ALSO DES]VE READ+ 9 A *>ITABLE LI<T4 ,= JU/ AS !RE IS S]I\S CONT5T TO ! >GUM5TS = VEGANISM & NONVIOL5CE SO TOO IS !RE S]I\S CONT5T TO ! >GUM5T ?AT SEGREGATION CAN BE C\NT]$ )\T REC\RSE TO /ATE VIOL5CE OR EV5 /RONG VIOLATIONS ( P]SONAL PROP]TY4 

,9 ONE SMALL >TICLE 7LIT]ALLY LESS ?AN F\R PAGES7 REPR9T$ )9 ,M>KETS ,NOT ,CAPITALISM ONE AU?OR TALK$ AB\T ! SUCCESSES ( ! SIT-9 MOVEM5T AGA9/ SEGREGATION 9 ! ,JIM ,CR[ ,S\?1 EXPLICITLY ATTEMPT+ TO P]SUADE A RI<T-LIB]T>IAN AUDI5CE ?AT ! O/5SIBLY 0NON-CO]CIVE0 RACISM !Y MI<T POO-POO DOES 9 FACT AT ! V]Y LEA/ JU/IFY ACTIONS 9VOLV+ TRESPASS+ 9TO SOMEONE ELSE'S SPACE_/PROP]TY4 ,?IS >TICLE 9TRODUC$ ITSELF AS AN AUDI5CE-SPECIFIC FOLL[-UP TO ANO!R PIECE BY $ITOR ,*>LES ,JOHNSON SPEAK+ AB\T ! COOPTION ( ! CIVIL RI<TS MOVEM5T BY ! /ATE1 

,WOOLWOR?'S LUN* C\NT]S W]5'T DESEGREGAT$ BY ,TITLE ,I,I4 ,! SIT-9 MOVEM5T DID ?AT4 ,FROM ! ,MONTGOM]Y ,BUS ,BOYCOTT ONW>D1 ! ,FRE$OM ,MOVEM5T HAD WON VICTORIES1 T[N BY T[N1 BUILD+ MOVEM5TS1 HOLD+ RACI/ 9/ITUTIONS SOCIALLY & ECONOMICALLY ACC\NTABLE4 ,! SIT-9S PROV$ ! REAL-WORLD P[] ( ! /RATEGY3 ,9 ,GRE5SBORO1 ,N4,C41 NONVIOL5T SIT-9 PROTE/S DROVE ,WOOLWOR?'S TO AB&ON ITS :ITES-ONLY POLICY BY ,JULY #a#i#f4 ,! ,NA%VILLE ,/UD5T ,MOVEM5T1 ?R\< ?REE MON?S ( SIT-9S & BOYCOTTS1 CONV9C$ M]*ANTS TO OP5 ALL D[NT[N LUN* C\NT]S 9 ,MAY ! SAME YE>4 ,CREATIVE PROTE/S & GRASSROOTS PRESSURE CAMPAIGNS ACROSS ! ,S\? *ANG$ LOCAL CULTURES & DISMANTL$ PRIVATE SEGREGATION )\T LEGAL BACK+4 

,%\LD LUN* C\NT]S HAVE BE5 ALL[$ TO /AY SEGREGAT$8 ,NO--BUT ! QUE/ION IS H[ TO DISALL[ IT4 ,BIGOT$ BUS9ESSES %\LDN'T FACE ?REATS ( LEGAL =CE = !IR RACISM4 ,!Y %\LD FACE A =CE MU* FI]C] & MORE MEAN+FUL--! FULL =CE ( VOLUNT>Y SOCIAL ORGANIZATION & A CULTURE ( EQUALITY4 ,:AT'S TO /OP RESEGREGATION 9 A LIB]T>IAN SOCIETY8 ,WE >E4 ,US+ ! SAME SOCIAL P[] ?AT WAS DISMANTL+ ,JIM ,CR[ YE>S BE=E LEGAL DESEGREGATION4 .<EMPHASIS M9E.> 

,LET'S BE CLE> H]E3 ,W\LD !SE SORT ( NONVIOL5T SIT-9S BE 5\< TO CRACK EV]Y CONCEIVABLE RACI/ SOCIETY OR SITUATION8 ,OBVI\SLY NOT4 ,& ANY DISCUSSION ( ,JIM ,CR[ ?AT FAILS TO TAKE 9TO CONSID]ATION ! DIFFUSE BUT SY/EMIC EFFECTS ( PRIVATE VIOL5CE 7! ,K,K,K AS WELL AS A BROAD] CULTURE ( :ITE SUPREMACY7 & C5TURIES ( /ATE 9T]F]5CE 9 SOCIETY BY GUN & DOLL> ?AT CREAT$ ! 5TIRE SOCIAL CONTEXT ( SEGREGATION W\LD BE A WA/E4 ,EV5 IF WE W]E TO POSIT A MORE RI<T-LIB]T>IAN DEONTOLOGICAL E?ICS1 !RE'S A /RONG >GUM5T TO BE HAD ?AT ! EFFECT ( HI/ORICAL 9JU/ICE & CO]CION COMPLETELY 9VALIDATES ANY EXI/+ TITLE TO PROP]TY & WEAL? 9 \R SOCIETY4 

,BUT ,*>LES & ,%ELDON /ILL HAVE AN EXTREMELY LEGIT PO9T H]E ?AT %\LDN'T BE LO/3 ,:ILE !RE'S ROOM TO >GUE AB\T :E!R SOME?+ ELSE W\LD BE MORE EFFECTIVE & JU/ :AT ! RAMIFICATIONS MI<T BE ( VIOL5CE OR MORE AGGRESSIVE DISREG>D = PROP]TY1 WE CAN AT LEA/ TAKE COM=T ?AT HI/ORY HAS PROV$ ?AT SIT-9S WORK QUITE WELL -- EV5 AGA9/ FREAK+ ,JIM ,CR[ LEVEL SEGREGATION4 ,!IR MA9 PO9T IS ?AT WE DON'T NE$ /ATE VIOL5CE TO FI<T GRASSROOTS RACISM1 & ?AT'S A PO9T EV]Y AN>*I/ %\LD 5C\RAGE4 ,MAGPIE'S 0CRITIQUE0 IS ?AT :ILE ,%ELDON H]OICALLY TAKES RI<T-LIB]T>IANS HEAD-ON1 >GU+ ?AT TRESPASS IS JU/IFI$ EV5 ON !IR [N T]MS1 HE %IES AWAY FROM OP5+ ! CAN ( WORMS ( MORE AGGRESSIVE VIOL5CE OR PROP]TY VIOLATIONS ON ! SCALE ( SAY DE/ROY+ SPACES OR =CIBLY 9VAD+ P]SONAL HOMES4 ,BUT SU* HESITANCY %\LD BE UND]/&ABLE AT ! V]Y LEA/4 ,SOCIAL AN>*I/S RECOGNIZE !SE K9D ( DI/9CTIONS ALL ! TIME 9 PRACTICE4 ,:5 FOLKS =M$ A BLOC & CONFRONT$ SOMEONE ) A HI/ORY ( ABUSE AT !IR HOME !Y /ILL DELIB]ATELY AVOID$ 9VAD+ ?AT HOME4 ,IT'S TOTALLY VALID = SOMEONE TO F9D 0WE HAVE PROBLEMS ) Y\R SPACE'S EXCLUSION POLICY SO WE'RE GO+ TO BURN Y\ TO ! GR\ND0 TO BE AN E?ICALLY TR\BLESOME ESCALATION & A WORRY+ PREC$5T4 

,IT'S TRUE ?AT ,%ELDON DRIVES HOME ! EMPHATICALLY NONVIOL5T *>ACT] ( SU* SIT-9S 7TO HIS >TICLE'S ORIG9AL RI<T-LIB]T>IAN AUDI5CE71 TO HELP E/ABLI% H[ UNASSAILABLY E?ICALLY JU/IFI$ SU* ACTIONS >E4 ,!RE'S A DANG] H]E ( IMPLY+ ?AT VIOLATION ( PROP]TY CAN BE JU/IFI$ ONLY ?R\< ITS NONVIOL5T *>ACT]4 ,%ELDON IMM$IATELY PUBLICLY REPUDIAT$ ?IS MISREAD ( ,MAGPIE'S 9 NO UNC]TA9 T]MS & HAS ALSO ACKN[L$G$ H[ PROBLEMATIC IT CAN BE TO SPEAK EV5 AB/RACTLY AB\T ! MO/ IDEAL TACTICS A SUBJUGAT$ GR\P MI<T *OOSE1 0IT'S TOO EASY = ME TO SIT SAFELY 9 ,CONWAY1 ,>1 & TELL PEOPLE 9 BAD SITUATIONS :AT IT IS RI<T OR WRONG = !M TO DO ) RESPECT TO AN OPPRESSIVE SITUATION40 ,?AT %\LD REALLY BE ! 5D ( IT4 

,I'M ( ! OP9ION ?AT IDEOLOGICAL PACIFISM CAN BE RACI/ 9 EFFECT1 YET EV5 IF ?AT *>ACT]IZ$ ,%ELDON'S PIECE !RE >E DIFF]+ USES ( ! T]M 0RACISM0 & ,I DON'T KN[ AB\T Y\ BUT ,I'M NOT GO+ TO GO >\ND CALL+ PACIFI/ AN>*I/S LIKE ,TOL/OY & ,UTAH ,PHILLIPS DISGU/+ RACI/S & L\DLY DECRY ANY 9T5TIONALLY DIV]SE COMPILATION ( ,AN>*I/ MAT]IAL ?AT HAPP5S TO 9CLUDE !IR WRIT+S AS 0RACI/0 & 0DESPICABLE0 AS A RESULT4 ,I MEAN1 PROPS TO ANY TROLL ?AT DOES ?AT ,I SUPPOSE1 BUT PLEASE1 A LITTLE CONSI/5CY4 

,A SECOND T9Y >TICLE 9 ,M>KETS ,NOT ,CAPITALISM FOCUSES ON EXPLA9+ H[ WE DON'T NECESS>ILY NE$ TO USE ! /ATE TO W9 5VIRONM5TAL VICTORIES & ?AT ILLEGAL DIRECT ACTION CAN GET ! GOODS4 ,?AT !RE >E D[NSIDES TO LEGISLATIVE APPROA*ES & FEASIBLE BOTTOM-UP ALT]NATIVES IS A PRETTY ELEM5T>Y AN>*I/ PO9T4 ,MAGPIE ( C\RSE NONS5SICALLY *>ACT]IZES ?IS AS >GU+ ?AT ! =EMO/ 5EMY ( AN 5VIRONM5TALI/ 9 \R PRES5T CONTEXT %\LD BE 5VIRONM5TAL LAW & \R EF=TS %\LD BE FOCUS$ ON REPEAL+ IT4 ,BEYOND BE+ AN 9SANELY WILLFUL MISREAD IT %\LD GO )\T SAY+ ?AT ?IS W\LD1 ( C\RSE1 USUALLY BE A T]RIBLE PRESCRIPTION4 ,AL?\< :5 VIEW$ AS A ONE-L9] 9 ! PR\D AN>*I/ TRADITION ( TROLL /ATEM5TS ) S]I\S SUB/ANCE BEL[ ! SURFACE 70PROP]TY IS LIB]TY0_/0PROP]TY IS !FT01 0AN>*Y IS ORD]01 ETC7 IT W\LD ALSO BE K9DA ADMIRABLE4 ,RE=MI/ TACTICS OCCASIONALLY HAVE !IR PLACE2 :5 A TREE-SIT IMPLICITLY WORKS TO PRESSURE ! PASSAGE ( 5VIRONM5TAL LEGISLATION ONE WAY OR ! O!R ?AT CAN BE /RATEGICALLY VALID4 ,:ILE ,I HAVE NO PATI5CE = ,SOCIAL ,DEMOCRATS LIKE ,*OMSKY TELL+ US TO WAIT ANO!R C5TURY & VOTE ,DEMOCRAT1 ,I'VE LONG >GU$ ! /RATEGIC UTILITY ( ?+S LIKE ,FOOD ,/AMPS :ILE ! /ATE CONT9UES TO EXI/4 ,MANY M>KET AN>*I/S AGREE4 ,& EV5 :5 WE FULLY OPPOSE SOME?+ WE %\LD /ILL BE SANE AB\T \R PRIORITIES4 ,H[EV] SU* CALCULATIONS >E COMPLEX TO SAY ! LEA/ & !RE %\LD OBVI\SLY /ILL BE SPACE = CRITIQUES ( /ATI/ MEANS4 ,IT'S MORE ?AN A LITTLE RIDICUL\S = ,MAGPIE TO LOB *>GES ( 0RE=MISM0 AT SOMEONE COM+ AT ! ISSUE BY CRITIQU+ /ATI/ MEANS4 ,I DO NOT ?9K ?AT WORD MEANS :AT Y\ ?9K IT MEANS4 

,ONE MI<T BE TEMPT$ TO LAU< IF ! :OLE AFFAIR WASN'T SO TRANSP>5TLY 9 BAD FAI?4 

,KEV9 ,C>SON HAS BE5 WRIT+ ! CLE>E/ & MO/ SUB/ANTIVE ECONOMIC & SY/EMS ANALYSIS ! AN>*I/ MOVEM5T HAS SE5 9 POSSIBLY A C5TURY4 ,HIS WORK IS ! BACKBONE TO MU* ( ,IA9 ,MC,KAY'S ,A,F,A,Q4 ,HE'S BUILT A GLOBAL REPUTATION OV] A DECADE BY PA9/AK+LY REVEAL+ ! V>I\S ME*ANISMS ( /ATE CO]CION UND]P9N+ EV]Y FACET ( CAPITALISM FROM WORKPLACE HI]>*IES TO ! CLASS SY/EM & ATTACK+ ! MULTITUDE ( PRIVATE =CES COMPLICIT 9 IT EV5 9 ! MO/ 9TANGIBLE ( WAYS4 444,MAGPIE APP>5TLY SP5DS HALF A M9UTE SKIMM+ ,KEV9'S SITE & DECIDES ?AT ! >GUM5T ?AT CAPITALISM IS BUILT ON HI/ORICAL VIOL5CE & W\LDN'T BE SU/A9ABLE )\T CON/ANT GOV]NM5T VIOL5CE DISRUPT+ & MANIPULAT+ PEOPLE'S FREE ASSOCIATION IS A R$EF9ITION ( 0CAPITALISM0 TO MEAN M]ELY ANY =M ( GOV]NM5T 9T]F]5CE4 ,WELL OKAY4 ,IF Y\'RE LOOK+ = ANY?+ TO CONFIRM Y\R F]V5T HOPE ?AT WE'RE ALL CAPITALI/ APOLOGI/S 7MAYBE TO AVOID HAV+ TO ACTUALLY CONSID] ! BASIC MA!MATICAL REALITIES ( ECONOMICS71 ,I'M SURE Y\'LL BE ABLE TO DRUM SOME?+ UP4 ,EV5 IF IT'S *ORTL+ AB\T A CONTRIBUTOR'S LA/ NAME4 

,I BEGAN ?IS RESPONSE BY TALK+ AB\T C5TRALIZ$ P[]4 ,! DANG] ( PROCESSES BY :I* ?OSE ) SOME?+ GET MORE & ?OSE )\T >E =C$ TO CONT9UE GO+ )\T IS ALWAYS A LEGIT ISSUE4 ,FE$BACK LOOPS >E IMPORTANT4 ,F]RET+ !M \T1 UND]/&+ !M & ADDRESS+ !M IS C5TRAL TO ! AN>*I/ PROJECT4 ,EV5 ?+S LIKE MAK+ CONTACTS MORE EASILY BECAUSE Y\ ALREADY HAVE CONTACTS FALL )9 \R PURVIEW4 ,ECONOMIES ( SCALE1 LOGJAMS 9 COMMUNICATION & B>RI]S TO 5TRY >E BASIC BUILD+ BLOCKS ( P[] & OPPRESSION & LEFT M>KET AN>*I/S HAVE BE5 PRACTICALLY ! ONLY ONES WRIT+ AB\T !SE ME*ANISMS1 MU* LESS CON/RUCT+ OR DISCOV]+ VIABLE C\NT]-ME*ANISMS4 ,FOLKS LIKE ,KEV9 ,C>SON HAVE DONE F> MORE TO EXPLORE & SOLIDLY FLE% \T ! AN>*I/ ANALYSIS ?AN ANYONE 9 ! SOCIAL MILIEU4 ,:I* IS A %AME BECAUSE !RE >E IMPORTANT 9T]P]SONAL & CULTURAL ISSUES ?AT SOCIAL AN>*I/S W]E HI/ORICALLY MORE S5SITIVE TO1 YET HAVE DONE V]Y LITTLE TO MAP \T4 

,FUR!R1 AS ) ANY?+ ! PRECISE ME*ANISMS ( 5=CEM5T 7OR 5C\RAGEM5T OR DISC\RAGEM5T7 ALWAYS MATT]4 ,NO ONE %\LD BE ABLE TO GET AWAY ) M]ELY SAY+ 0MY ECONOMIC SY/EM IS NO MAK+ MONEY ) MONEY0 OR 0NO RUNAWAY ACCUMULATION ( P[]0 BECAUSE ?AT DOESN'T SPEAK ONE :IT TO H[ PRECISELY Y\ MEAN TO /OP SU*4 0,WE'LL HAVE T[NHALL MEET+S & VOTE ON :O WE DON'T LIKE0 OR 0WE'LL JU/ BEAT UP & TAKE ! /UFF ( ANYONE :O DOES SOME?+ LIKE LET A FRI5D R5T !IR C> = A WEEK 9 EX*ANGE = KOMBU*A04 ,! ANTI-M>KET PEANUT GALL]Y HAS (F]$ NEXT TO NO SUB/ANTIVE ?\<T ON ?IS FRONT1 :ILE M>KET AN>*I/S HAVE WRITT5 VOLUMES ON ! P>TICUL>S ( ! P>TICUL>S4 

,POSSESSIONS1 EX*ANGE & ?US M>KETS CAN BE BR\<T 9TO EXI/5CE BY A RANGE ( POSSIBLE DEL9EATIONS AB\T :AT TO 5=CE ) :AT MEANS4 ,RESPECT = PROP]TY_/POSSESSION TITLES DOES NOT NECESS>ILY DEP5D ON CO]CIVE MEANS1 AS REPUTATION_/GOODWILL ME*ANISMS >E ALSO VIABLE4 ,?IS IS DISCUSS$ AT L5G? 9 SEV]AL PIECES 9 ,M>KETS ,NOT ,CAPITALISM4 ,HECK ,J]EMY ,WEIL&'S GOT A BIT ESS5TIALLY *E]+ ON PROLE SABOTAGE ( & !FT FROM ! WEAL?Y AS A CORE & VITAL FREE M>KET ME*ANISM4 

,BUT ( C\RSE JU/ AS ECONOMIC FE$BACK LOOPS >E NOT ! :OLE ( ! PROBLEM ( P[] RELATIONS1 M>KET ME*ANISMS CANNOT BE ! :OLE ( \R SOLUTION4 ,?R\<\T PRETTY MU* EV]Y?+ HE'S WRITT5 ,*>LES ,JOHNSON HAS WORK$ TIRELESSLY TO DRIVE HOME ! REALITY ?AT M>KETS WILL BE ! RESULT ( :AT WE PUT 9TO !M4 ,M>KETS >E AN ORGANIZATIONAL TOOL4 ,& :ILE BUILD+ ! WORLD WE'D LIKE TO SEE MI<T 9VOLVE M>KETS 9 C]TA9 ECONOMIC FACETS ( SOCIETY1 IT WILL /ILL & %\LD 9VOLVE ACTIVISM1 ACTION1 CULTURAL & 9T]P]SONAL /RUGGLES4 ,FRE$ M>KETS >E P>T ( A PLAT=M ON :I* TO BUILD A BETT] WORLD4 ,A NECESS>Y CONDITION P]HAPS1 & NO SMALL /EP1 BUT H>DLY ! 5D ( ! /ORY4 ,?IS REALITY IS /RONGLY & EXPLICITLY /AT$ 9 ,*>LES' & ,G>Y ,*>TI]'S L5G?Y 9TRODUCTION TO ,M>KETS ,NOT ,CAPITALISM & COMES TO BE> IMPLICITLY & EXPLICITLY ?R\<\T4 444,SO ( C\RSE ,MAGPIE DECL>ES ?AT WE MEAN ! OPPOSITE4 

,I MEAN IT'S JU/ /AGG]+4 

,:ILE IT ALWAYS BEHOOVES US TO WORK TO IMPROVE ! PRES5TATION ( \R IDEAS1 ! NATURE ( ANTI-9TELLECTUALISM IS TO DO ABSOLUTELY NO WORK TO EMPA?IZE ) O!RS' >GUM5TS OR *ALL5GE Y\R [N P]SPECTIVES & !N L\NGE BACK 9 ! DEF5SE ?AT !Y HAV5'T P]SUAD$ Y\4 

,IF !RE >E 9 L9ES ,M>KETS ,NOT ,CAPITALISM ON :I* AN EXTREMELY HO/ILE & SUSPICI\S AN>*O-COMMUNI/ MI<T LEAP & TOPICS T\*$ )\T ! 5TIRETY ( 0,! ,OR?ODOX ,LEFT ,M>KET ,AN>*I/ ,POSITION0 DISCUSS$ 9 NUANCE1 ?AT IS NOT SURPRIS+4 ,IT WAS NEV] MEANT AS 0,A ,COMPLETE ,F,A,Q TO ,LEFT ,M>KET ,AN>*ISM = ,SOCIAL ,AN>*I/S ,9 ,!IR ,PREF]R$ ,LANGUAGE ,NEV] ,MAK+ ,COMPLEX ,PO9TS04 ,! BOOK IS A SCATT]%OT COLLECTION ( WRIT+ FROM ! LEFT M>KET AN>*I/ MILIEU4 ,LIKE ,DANIEL ,GU]9'S ,NO ,GODS1 ,NO ,MA/]S1 ,ROB]T ,GRAHAM'S ,A ,DOCUM5T>Y ,HI/ORY ( ,LIB]T>IAN ,?\<T1 & C\NTLESS O!R AN?OLOGIES IT SEEKS TO PROVIDE A WIDE SAMPL+ ( DISCUSSIONS & P>TIAL P]SPECTIVES ON NUM]\S TOPICS RA!R ?AN A COMPLETE MAP4 ,IT GOES )\T SAY+ ?AT COMPLET5ESS IS IMPOSSIBLE4 ,HELL1 ! $ITORS FAC$ ! H]CULEAN TASK ( KEEP+ IT EV5 P>TIALLY ACCESSIBLE TO BO? SOCIAL AN>*I/S & ! RI<T-LIB]T>IANS WE >GUE SO TIRELESSLY TO CONV]T OR AT LEA/ DIFFUSE4 

,I'M TOLD ?AT ,MAGPIE WAS (F]$ A *ANCE TO AIR HIS VIEWS ON ,C#d,S,S 9 A FEATURE BE=E A WID] AUDI5CE ) AS MU* SPACE AS HE NE$$ TO BACK UP !SE HAPHAZ>D *>GES & DEF5D !M 9 ! FACE ( LOGIC & EVID5CE4 ,HE ( C\RSE DECL9$4 ,I WI% ?IS W]E SURPRIS+4 ,HIS 0REVIEW0 READS LESS AS AN ATTEMPT$ CRITIQUE ?AN IT DOES A DESP]ATE1 FL\ND]+1 \T-(-DEP? ATTEMPT TO *]RY-PICK TWO BRIEF DISCUSSIONS GLANC+ ON SIDE TOPICS1 DIS+5\SLY PHRASE ?+S 9 ! MO/ UN*>ITABLE WAY POSSIBLE1 TRIUMPHANTLY SL&] ! :OLE ( ! COMPILATION AS A RESULT1 & GET AWAY ) IT BY APPEAL+ TO ! MO/ *URLI% ( J+OI/IC 9/9CTS AMONG ! ANTI-M>KET CR[D4 ,*RI/1 ,I'M SICK ( BE+ EMB>RASS$ ON BEHALF ( AN>*O-COMMUNI/S ,I EXPECT BETT] FROM4 ,S9CE HE'S GONE AHEAD & PUBLICLY LABEL$ ! 5TIRETY ( A COMPILATION ,I WAS P>T ( 0RACI/0 ,I'LL RETURN A B>B3 ,DO+ NO?+ MORE ?AN CONFIRM+ & RE9=C+ Y\R AUDI5CE'S PRECONCEIV$ NOTIONS MAY W9 Y\ SOME POPUL>ITY BUT IT'S PRETTY MU* ! L[E/ =M ( WRIT+ POSSIBLE4 

,AS ! MORTIFY+ PAUCITY ( ECONOMIC ?\<T RAMPANT 9 SOCIAL AN>*I/ CIRCLES COMES UND] ! LI<T 70YAY COMMUNES & %>+ WE'LL JU/ TALK \T :ATEV] PROBLEMS >ISE 9 MEET+S07 SOME HAVE 9CREAS+LY TAK5 TO VICI\S \TBUR/S1 SE>*+ = ANY?+ TO MIS*>ACT]IZE OR POPUL>IZE AGA9/4 ,?IS K9D ( UNFAIR1 BORD]L9E ABUSIVE BEHAVIOR IS :AT FIR/ DROVE ME FROM AN>*O-COMMUNISM & PROMPT$ MY EXPLORATION ( M>KET AN>*I/ ?\<T SO MANY YE>S AGO4 ,& = ALL ! WAYS SU* BEHAVIOR POISONS \R DISC\RSE & CULTURE ,I CAN AT LEA/ TAKE COM=T ?AT IT IS /ILL DRIV+ PEOPLE 9TO LEFT M>KET AN>*ISM ALL >\ND ! WORLD4 

,I'M A %>E-BE> AT HE>T2 ,I ONLY SUPPORT M>KETS BECAUSE ,I SEE !M AS ! BE/ TOOL AVAILABLE TO BUILD AN EGALIT>IAN MASS SOCIETY ( ABUNDANCE4 ,& EV5 ?\< WE >GUE ?AT !Y'RE C\NT]-WEI<$ & ADDRESS$ BY O!R ME*ANISMS !RE >E C]TA9LY DANG]S TO C]TA9 FUNCTIONS )9 M>KET DYNAMICS & ,I W\LD LOVE TO SEE ?OSE SO ABJECTLY AFRAID ( M>KETS S]I\SLY 5GAGE ) US AB\T !M4 ,OR EV5 POSE ALT]NATIVES ?AT DON'T CRUMBLE UND] ! MA!MATICAL LIMITATIONS ( L>GE-SCALE COLLECTIVE DECISION-MAK+ ET AL1 )\T ?R[+ UP !IR H&S & DECL>+ ?AT SITT+ 9 ! MUD _/ LEE*+ FROM FRI5DS IS GOOD 5\<4 ,MAYBE !N ! DIALOGUE WILL HAVE OP5$ TO ! PO9T :]E M>KET AN>*I/S CAN />T PRES5T+ CRITIQUES AB\T ! WAYS ! AMORPH\S COLLECTIVE ME*ANISMS ( AN>*O-COMMUNI/S OP5 ! DOOR TO RUNAWAY 9T]P]SONAL P[] DYNAMICS4 

,FROM 3 ,!,AN>*I/,LIBR>Y4ORG4 

,*RONOLOGY 3 
,JANU>Y #b#a1 #bba 3 ,DEMAGOGU]Y ,NOT ,AN>*ISM -- ,ADD$4 
,JANU>Y #f1 #bbb 3 ,DEMAGOGU]Y ,NOT ,AN>*ISM -- ,UPDAT$4 

 FILE G5]AT$ FROM 3  
HTTP3_/_/REVOLTLIB4COM_/