,BOOK #g1 ,*APT] #b ,G5]AL ,DISADVANTAGES ( ,PUNI%M5T #agicagic ,PEOPLE 3 ,AU?OR 3 ,WILLIAM ,GODW9 ,TEXT 3 ,B,O,O,K ,V,I,I ,( ,C,R,I,M,E,S ,& ,P,U,N,I,%,M,5,T,S ,*,A,P,T,] ,I,I ,G5]AL ,DISADVANTAGES ( ,PUNI%M5T ,CONSCI5CE 9 MATT]S ( RELIGION CONSID]$ - ! CONDUCT ( LIFE4 - ,BE/ PRACTICABLE CRIT]ION ( DUTY - NOT ! DECISION ( O!R M51 BUT ( \R [N UND]/&+4 - ,T5 D5CY ( CO]CION4 - ,ITS V>I\S CLASSES CON- SID]$4 ,H,A,V,+ ?US 5DEAVOR$ TO %[ :AT D5OM9ATIONS ( PUNI%M5T JU/ICE1 & A S\ND IDEA ( ! NATURE ( MAN1 W\LD 9V>IABLY PROSCRIBE1 IT BELONGS TO US1 9 ! FUR!R PROSECUTION ( ! SUBJECT1 TO CONSID] M]ELY ?AT CO]CION1 :I* IT HAS BE5 SUPPOS$ RII\S REASONS BY :I* IT IS RECOMM5D$4 ,IT WILL NOT BE POSSIBLE TO AVOID ! REPETITION ( SOME ( ! REASONS :I* OCCURR$ 9 ! PRELIM9>Y DISCUSSION ( ! EX]CISE ( PRIVATE JUDGM5T4#a ,BUT ?OSE REASON+S WILL N[ BE EXT5D$1 & WILL P]HAPS D]IVE ADDITIONAL ADVANTAGE FROM A FULL] >RANGEM5T4 ,IT IS COMMONLY SAID '?AT NO MAN \Y TO ! DICTATES ( HIS CONSCI5CE4 ,RELIGION IS A PR9CIPLE :I* ! PRACTICE ( ALL AGES HAS DEEPLY IMPRESS$ UPON ! HUMAN M9D4 ,HE ?AT DIS*>GES :AT HIS APPREH5SIONS PRESCRIBE TO HIM ON ! SUBJECT /&S APPROV$ TO ! TRIBUNAL ( HIS [N M9D1 &1 CONSCI\S ( RECTITUDE 9 HIS 9T]C\RSE ) ! AU?OR ( NATURE1 CANNOT FAIL TO OBTA9 ! GREATE/ ( ?OSE ADVANTAGES1 :ATEV] MAY BE !IR AM\NT1 :I* RELIGION HAS TO BE/[4 ,IT IS 9 VA9 ?AT ,I 5DEAVOR1 BY P]SECUT+ /ATUTES1 TO COMPEL HIM TO RESIGN A FALSE RELIGION = A TRUE4 ,>GUM5TS MAY CONV9CE1 BUT P]SECUTION CANNOT4 ,! NEW RELIGION1 :I* ,I OBLIGE HIM TO PR(ESS CONTR>Y TO HIS [N CONVICTION1 H[EV] PURE & HOLY IT MAY BE 9 ITS [N NATURE1 HAS NO B5EFITS 9 /ORE = HIM4 ,! SUBLIME/ WOR%IP BECOMES TRANS=M$ 9TO A S\RCE ( DEPRAVITY :5 IT IS NOT CONSECRAT$ BY ! TE/IMONY ( A PURE CONSCI5CE4 ,TRU? IS ! SECOND OBJECT 9 ?IS RESPECT1 9TEGRITY ( HE>T IS ! FIR/3 OR RA!R1 A PROPOSITION ?AT1 9 ITS AB/RACT NATURE1 IS TRU? ITSELF CONV]TS 9TO RANK FALSEHOOD & MORTAL POISON1 IF IT BE PR(ESS$ ) ! LIPS ONLY1 & ABJUR$ BY ! UND]/&+4 ,IT IS !N ! F\L G>B ( HYPOCRISY4 ,9/EAD ( ELEVAT+ ! M9D ABOVE SORDID TEMPTATIONS1 IT P]PETUALLY REM9DS ! WOR%IP] ( ! DEGRAD+ SUBJECTION TO :I* HE HAS YIELD$4 ,9/EAD ( FILL+ HIM ) SACR$ CONFID5CE1 IT OV]:ELMS HIM ) CONFUSION & REMORSE4' ,! 9F]5CE ?AT HAS BE5 MADE FROM !SE REASON+S IS '?AT CRIM9AL LAW IS EM95TLY MISAPPLI$ 9 AFFAIRS ( RELIGION1 & ?AT ITS TRUE PROV9CE IS CIVIL MISDEMEANORS'4 ,BUT ?IS DI/9CTION IS BY NO MEANS SO SATISFACTORY & WELL F\ND$ AS AT FIR/ SI4#b ,IS IT NOT /RANGE ?AT M5 %\LD HAVE AFFIRM$ RELIGION TO BE ! SACR$ PROV9CE ( CONSCI5CE1 :ILE MORAL DUTY IS TO BE LEFT UNDEF9$ TO ! DECISION ( ! MAGI/RATE8 ,IS IT ( NO CONSEQU5CE :E!R ,I BE ! B5EFACTOR ( MY SPECIES1 OR !IR BITT]E/ 5EMY8 :E!R ,I BE AN 9=M]1 A ROBB]1 OR A MURD]]8 :E!R ,I BE EMPLOY$1 AS A SOLDI]1 TO EXTIRPATE MY FELL[ BE+S1 OR1 AS A CITIZ51 CONTRIBUTE MY PROP]TY TO !IR EXTIRPATION8 :E!R ,I DECL>E ! TRU?1 ) ?AT FIRMNESS & UNRES]VE :I* AN >D5T PHILAN?ROPY WILL NOT FAIL TO 9SPIRE1 OR SUPPRESS SCI5CE1 LE/ ,I BE CONVICT$ ( BLASPHEMY1 & FACT1 LE/ ,I BE CONVICT$ ( A LIBEL8 :E!R ,I CONTRIBUTE MY EF=TS = ! FUR!RANCE ( POLITICAL IMPROVEM5T1 OR QUIETLY SUBMIT TO ! EXILE ( A PR9CE ( :OSE CLAIMS ,I AM AN ADVOCATE1 OR TO ! SUBV]SION ( LIB]TY1 ! MO/ VALUABLE ( ALL HUMAN POSSESSIONS8 ,NO?+ CAN BE MORE CLE> ?AN ?AT ! VALUE ( RELIGION1 OR ( ANY O!R SPECIES ( OP9ION1 LIES 9 ITS MORAL T5D5CY4 ,IF ,I AM TO HOLD AS ( NO ACC\NT ! CIVIL P[]1 = ! SAKE ( ?AT :I* IS ! MEANS1 H[ MU* MORE :5 IT RISES 9 CONTRADICTION TO ! 5D8 ,( ALL HUMAN CONC]NS MORALITY IS ! MO/ 9T]E/+4 ,IT IS ! CON/ANT ASSOCIATE ( ALL \R TRANSACTIONS3 !RE IS NO SITUATION 9 :I* WE CAN BE PLAC$1 NO ALT]NATIVE ?AT CAN BE PRES5T$ TO \R *OICE1 RESPECT+ :I* DUTY IS SIL5T4 ',:AT IS ! /&>D ( MORALITY & DUTY8' ,JU/ICE4 ,NOT ! >BITR>Y DECREES ?AT >E 9 =CE 9 A P>TICUL> CLIMATE2 BUT ?OSE LAWS ( REASON ?AT >E EQUALLY OBLIGATORY :]EV] MAN IS TO BE F\ND4 ,!RE IS AN OBVI\S DI/9CTION BETWE5 ?OSE P>TICUL>S 9 EA* 9/ANCE :I* CON/ITUTE ! P]MAN5T NATURE ( ! CASE BE=E US1 & ?OSE 9T]POSITIONS ( A P]EMPTORY AU?ORITY TO :I* IT MAY BE PRUD5T TO SUBMIT1 BUT :I* CANNOT ALT] \R IDEAS ( ! CONDUCT TO :I* 9DEP5D5T MAN \E ! CONSEQU5CES ?AT WILL RESULT FROM ! OB$I5CE ( COMPULSION1 & NOT ( ! UND]/&+8 ,NO PR9CIPLE ( MORAL SCI5CE CAN BE MORE OBVI\S & FUNDAM5TAL ?AN ?AT ! MOTIVE BY :I* WE >E 9DUC$ TO AN ACTION CON/ITUTES AN ESS5TIAL P>T ( ITS *>ACT]4 ,?IS IDEA HAS P]HAPS SOMETIMES BE5 C>RI$ TOO F>4 ,A GOOD MOTIVE IS ( LITTLE VALUE :5 IT IS NOT JO9$ TO A SALUT>Y EX]TION4 ,BUT1 )\T A GOOD MOTIVE1 ! MO/ EXT5SIVELY USEFUL ACTION ?AT EV] WAS P]=M$ CAN CONTRIBUTE LITTLE TO ! IMPROVEM5T OR HONOR ( HIM ?AT P]=MS IT4 ,WE [E HIM NO RESPECT IF HE HAS BE5 9DUC$ TO P]=M IT BY IDEAS ( P]SONAL ADVANTAGE1 OR ! 9FLU5CE ( A BRIBE4 ,IT IS1 9 SOME RESPECTS1 WORSE1 IF ! MOTIVE ?AT GOV]N$ HIM W]E ! S5TIM5T ( FE>4 ,IF WE HOLD 9 ANY E/IMATION ! ATTRIBUTES ( MAN1 IF WE DESIRE ! IMPROVEM5T ( \R SPECIES1 WE \TICUL>LY TO DESIRE ?AT !Y %\LD BE L$ 9 ! PA? ( USEFULNESS BY G5]\S & LIB]AL CONSID]ATIONS1 ?AT !IR OB$I5CE %\LD BE ! OB$I5CE ( ! HE>T1 & NOT ?AT ( A SLAVE4 ,NO?+ CAN BE ( HI<] IMPORTANCE TO ! IMPROVEM5T ( ! HUMAN M9D ?AN ?AT1 :ATEV] BE ! CONDUCT WE MAY BE COMPELL$ TO PURSUE1 WE %\LD HAVE DI/9CT & ACCURATE NOTIONS ( ! M]ITS ( EV]Y MORAL QUE/ION 9 :I* WE MAY BE CONC]N$4 ,9 ALL D\BTFUL QUE/IONS1 !RE >E BUT TWO CRIT]IA POSSIBLE1 ! DECISIONS ( O!R M5'S WISDOM1 & ! DECISIONS ( \R [N UND]/&+4 ,:I* ( !SE IS CON=MABLE TO ! NATURE ( MAN8 ,CAN WE SURR5D] \R [N UND]/&+8 ,H[EV] WE MAY /RA9 AFT] IMPLICIT FAI?1 WILL NOT CONSCI5CE 9 SPITE ( \RSELVES :ISP] US1 ',! DECREE IS EQUITABLE1 & ?IS IS F\ND$ 9 MI/AKE8' ,WILL !RE NOT BE 9 ! M9DS ( ! VOT>IES ( SUP]/ITION A P]PETUAL DISSATISFACTION1 A DESIRE TO BELIEVE :AT IS DICTAT$ TO !M1 ACCOMPANI$ ) A WANT ( ?AT 9 :I* BELIEF CONSI/S1 EVID5CE & CONVICTION8 ,IF WE C\LD SURR5D] \R UND]/&+1 :AT SORT ( BE+S %\LD WE BECOME8 ,! DIRECT T5D5CY ( CO]CION IS TO SET \R UND]/&+ & \R FE>S1 \R DUTY & \R WEAKNESS1 AT V>IANCE ) EA* O!R4 ,CO]CION FIR/ ANNIHILATES ! UND]/&+ ( ! SUBJECT UPON :OM IT IS EX]CIS$1 & !N ( HIM :O EMPLOYS IT4 ,DRESS$ 9 ! SUP9E PR]OGATIVES ( A MA/]1 HE IS EXCUS$ FROM CULTIVAT+ ! FACILITIES ( A MAN4 ,:AT W\LD NOT MAN HAVE BE51 LONG BE=E ?IS1 IF ! PR\DE/ ( US HAD NO HOPES BUT 9 >GUM5T1 IF HE KNEW ( NO RESORT BEYOND1 IF HE W]E OBLIG$ TO %>P5 HIS FACULTIES1 & COLLECT HIS P[]S1 AS ! ONLY MEANS ( EFFECT+ HIS PURPOSES8 ,LET US REFLECT A LITTLE UPON ! SPECIES ( 9FLU5CE ?AT CO]CION EMPLOYS4 ,IT AV]S TO ITS VICTIM ?AT HE MU/ NECESS>ILY BE 9 ! WRONG1 BECAUSE ,I AM MORE VIGOR\S OR MORE CUNN+ ?AN HE4 ,WILL VIGOR & CUNN+ BE ALWAYS ON ! SIDE ( TRU?8 ,IT APPEALS TO =CE1 & REPRES5TS SUP]IOR /R5G? AS ! /&>D ( JU/ICE4 ,EV]Y SU* EX]TION IMPLIES 9 ITS NATURE A SPECIES ( CONTE/4 ,! CONTE/ IS (T5 DECID$ BE=E IT IS BR\TIES4 ,! >DOR & P>OXYSM ( PASSION BE+ OV]1 ! (F5D] SURR5D]S HIMSELF 9TO ! H&S ( HIS SUP]IORS1 & CALMLY AWAITS ! DECL>ATION ( !IR PLEASURE4 ,BUT IT IS NOT ALWAYS SO4 ,! DEPR$ATOR ?AT BY MA9 =CE SURM\NTS ! /R5G? ( HIS PURSU]S1 OR BY /RATAGEM & +5UITY ESCAPES !IR TOILS1 SO F> AS ?IS >GUM5T IS VALID1 PROVES ! JU/ICE ( HIS CAUSE4 ,:O CAN REFRA9 FROM 9DIGNATION :5 HE SEES JU/ICE ?US MIS]ABLY PRO/ITUT$8 ,:O DOES NOT FEEL1 ! MOM5T ! CONTE/ BEG9S1 ! FULL EXT5T ( ! ABSURDITY ?AT ! APPEAL 9CLUDES8 ,! MAGI/RACY1 ! REPRES5TATIVE ( ! SOCIAL SY/EM1 ?AT DECL>ES W> AGA9/ ONE ( ITS MEMB]S1 9 BEHALF ( JU/ICE1 OR 9 BEHALF ( OPPRESSION1 APPE>S ALMO/ EQUALLY1 9 BO? CASES1 5TITL$ TO \R C5SURE4 ,9 ! FIR/ CASE1 WE SEE TRU? ?R[+ ASIDE H] NATIVE >MS & H] 9TR9SIC ADVANTAGE1 & PUTT+ H]SELF UPON A LEVEL ) FALSEHOOD4 ,9 ! SECOND1 WE SEE FALSEHOOD CONFID5T 9 ! CASUAL ADVANTAGE %E POSSESSES1 >TFULLY EXT+UI%+ ! NEW BORN LITIES TO AN IMP>TIAL HE>+4 ,OBS]VE ! CONSI/5CY ( ?IS REASON+6 ,WE FIR/ V9DICATE POLITICAL CO]CION1 BECAUSE ! CRIM9AL HAS COMMITT$ AN (F5SE AGA9/ ! COMMUNITY AT L>GE1 & !N PRET5D1 :ILE WE BR+ HIM TO ! B> ( ! COMMUNITY1 ! (F5D$ P>TY1 ?AT WE BR+ HIM BE=E AN IMP>TIAL UMPIRE4 ,?US 9 ,5GL&1 ! K+ BY HIS ATTORNEY IS ! PROSECUTOR1 & ! K+ BY HIS REPRES5TATIVE IS ! JUDGE4 ,H[ LONG %ALL SU* 9CONSI/5CIES IMPOSE ON MANK9D8 ,! PURSUIT COMM5C$ AGA9/ ! SUPPOS$ (F5D] IS ! POSSE COMITATUS1 ! >M$ =CE ( ! :OLE1 DRAWN \T 9 SU* PORTIONS AS MAY BE JUDG$ NECESS>Y2 &1 :5 SEV5 MILLIONS ( M5 HAVE GOT ONE POOR1 UNASSI/$ 9DIVIDUAL 9 !IR P[]1 !Y >E !N AT LEISURE TO TORTURE OR TO KILL HIM1 & TO MAKE HIS AGONIES A SPECTACLE TO GLUT !IR F]OCITY4 ,! >GUM5T AGA9/ POLITICAL CO]CION IS EQUALLY /RONG AGA9/ ! 9FLICTION ( PRIVATE P5ALTIES1 BETWE5 MA/] & SLAVE1 & BETWE5 P>5T & *ILD4 ,!RE WAS1 9 REALITY1 NOT ONLY MORE ( GALLANTRY1 BUT MORE ( REASON 9 ! ,GO?IC SY/EM ( TRIAL BY DUEL ?AN 9 !SE4 ,! TRIAL ( =CE IS OV] 9 !SE1 AS WE HAVE ALREADY SAID1 BE=E ! EX]TION ( =CE IS BEGUN4 ,ALL ?AT REMA9S IS ! LEISURELY 9FLICTION ( TORTURE1 MY P[] TO 9FLICT IT BE+ PLAC$ 9 MY JO9TS & MY S9EWS4 ,?IS :OLE >GUM5T SEEMS LIABLE TO AN IRRESI/IBLE DILEMMA4 ,! RI5T OV] HIS (FSPR+ LIES EI!R 9 HIS SUP]IOR /R5G?1 OR HIS SUP]IOR REASON4 ,IF 9 HIS /R5G?1 WE HAVE ONLY TO APPLY ?IS RIGUM5T ( MY SUP]IOR REASON ?AT ,I AM UNABLE TO MAKE JU/ICE BE APPREH5D$ & FELT1 9 ! MO/ NECESS>Y CASES1 )\T ! 9T]V5TION ( BL[S4 ,LET US CONSID] ! EFFECT ?AT CO]CION PRODUCES UPON ! M9D ( HIM AGA9/ :OM IT IS EMPLOY$4 ,IT CANNOT BEG9 ) CONV9C+2 IT IS NO >GUM5T4 ,IT BEG9S ) PRODUC+ ! S5SATION ( PA91 & ! S5TIM5T ( DI/A/E4 ,IT BEG9S ) VIOL5TLY ALI5AT+ ! M9D FROM ! TRU? ) :I* WE WI% IT TO BE IMPRESS$4 ,IT 9CLUDES 9 IT A TACIT CONFESSION ( IMBECILITY4 ,IF HE :O EMPLOYS CO]CION AGA9/ ME C\LD MOLD ME TO HIS PURPOSES BY >GUM5T1 NO D\BT HE W\LD4 ,HE PRET5DS TO PUNI% ME BECAUSE HIS >GUM5T IS /RONG2 BUT LIE REALLY PUNI%ES ME BECAUSE HIS >GUM5T IS WEAK4 ,FOOTNOTES #a,BOOK ,I,I1 ,*AP4 ,V,I4 #b,BOOK ,I,I1 ,*AP4 ,V,I4 ,FROM 3 ,AN>*Y ,>*IVES4 ,*RONOLOGY 3 ,NOVEMB] #c1 #agib 3 ,BOOK #g1 ,*APT] #b -- ,PUBLICATION4 ,JANU>Y #b#g1 #bag 3 ,BOOK #g1 ,*APT] #b -- ,ADD$4 FILE G5]AT$ FROM 3 HTTP3_/_/REVOLTLIB4COM_/