,*APT] #d 

#ahiahi 

,PEOPLE 3 

,AU?OR 3 ,LEO ,TOL/OY 

,TRANSLATOR 3 ,NA?AN ,HASKELL ,DOLE 

,TEXT 3 

0,BUT10 IT IS FREQU5TLY SAID1 0MAY NOT A SLI<T BRIEF *ANGE1 LIKE ! MILD EXHIL>ATION PRODUC$ BY A MOD]ATE USE ( W9E & TOBACCO1 BR+ AB\T SOME SIGNIFICANT RESULTS8 ,IT IS COMPREH5SIBLE ?AT IF A MAN SMOKES OPIUM1 HA%I%1 OR DR9KS SO MU* W9E AS TO FALL & LOSE HIS S5SES1 ! CONSEQU5CES ( SU* A /UPEFY+ ( HIMSELF MAY BE V]Y GRAVE2 BUT ?AT A MAN %\LD COME UND] ! EXCE$+LY MILD EFFECTS ( ALCOHOLIC EXHIL>ATION OR TOBACCO C\LD NEV] HAVE ANY S]I\S CONSEQU5CES40  

,IT SEEMS TO PEOPLE ?AT A SLI<T 9TOXICATION1 A SLI<T D>K5+ ( CONSCI\SNESS1 CAN NEV] PRODUCE A S]I\S EFFECT4 ,BUT TO ?9K SO IS ! SAME AS TO ?9K ?AT IT MAY BE 9JURI\S TO A WAT* TO /RIKE IT AGA9/ A /ONE1 BUT ?AT TO PUT AN OB/ACLE 9 ITS WORKS CANNOT H>M IT4  

,Y\ SEE ! *IEF WORK :I* MOVES ! :OLE LIFE ( A MAN PROCE$S NOT 9 ! MOTION ( >MS & LEGS1 ! PHYSICAL P[]S1 BUT 9 ! CONSCI\SNESS4 ,9 ORD] = A MAN TO ACCOMPLI% SOME?+ ) HIS >MS & LEGS1 HE MU/ FIR/ UND]GO A C]TA9 *ANGE 9 HIS CONSCI\SNESS4 ,& ?IS *ANGE DET]M9ES ALL ! MAN'S SUBSEQU5T ACTS4 ,!SE *ANGES >E ALWAYS BRIEF1 ALMO/ UNNOTICEABLE4 ,BRULL( WAS CORRECT+ AN ETUDE  
= A PUPIL4 ,! PUPIL1 GLANC+ AT ! *ANGES ?AT HAD BE5 MADE1 SAID3--  

0,H]E Y\ HAVE SC>CELY T\*$ ! ETUDE1 BUT IT IS 5TIRELY *ANG$40  

,BRULL( ANSW]$3--  

0,>T BEG9S :]E SC>CELY BEG9S40  

,?IS OBS]VATION IS /RIK+LY TRUE1 NOT 9 RELATION TO >T ALONE1 BUT TO ALL ( LIFE4 ,IT MAY BE SAID ?AT A TRUE LIFE BEG9S :]E 0SC>CELY0 BEG9S1 :]E ! SC>CELY P]CEPTIBLE1 ALMO/ 9F9ITELY SMALL1 *ANGES TAKE PLACE4 ,! TRUE LIFE IS PRODUC$1 NOT :]E ! GREAT EXT]NALS  
>E EFFECTUAT$1 :]E M5 MOVE AB\T1 JO/LE ONE ANO!R1 /RUGGLE1 & FI<T1 BUT IT IS PRODUC$ :]E ! SC>CELY DIFF]5TIAT$ *ANGES >E ACCOMPLI%$4  

,! TRUE LIFE ( ,RASKOLNIK(.<#b.> WAS NOT ACCOMPLI%$ :5 HE KILL$ ! OLD MONEY-L5D] & H] SI/]4 ,:ILE HE WAS KILL+ ! OLD WOMAN1 & ESPECIALLY H] SI/]1 HE WAS NOT LIV+ HIS TRUE LIFE1 BUT WAS ACT+ LIKE A MA*9E1 DO+ :AT HE C\LD NOT HELP DO+1 DIS*>G+ ! C>TRIDGE ) :I* HE HAD LONG AGO BE5 LOAD$4 ,ONE OLD WOMAN LAY KILL$1 ! O!R WAS BE=E HIM !RE2 ! AX WAS 9 HIS H&4  

,! TRUE LIFE ( ,RASKOLNIK( WAS NOT PROCE$+ AT ! TIME :5 HE MET ! OLD WOMAN'S SI/]1 BUT AT ! TIME :5 HE HAD NOT AS YET KILL$ EV5 ! OLD WOMAN H]SELF1 HAD NOT YET 5T]$ ANO!R P]SON'S ROOM ) MURD] 9 VIEW1 HAD NOT TAK5 ! AX 9 HIS H&1 HAD NOT ! NOOSE UND] HIS CLOAK ON :I* HE HUNG IT1 BE=E HE HAD EV] ?\<T ( ! OLD WOMAN2 BUT IT WAS :ILE HE WAS LY+ ON ! DIVAN 9 HIS [N ROOM1 NOT EV5 ?9K+ ( ! OLD WOMAN OR EV5 :E!R HE C\LD OR C\LD NOT AT ! WILL ( ANO!R MAN WIPE FROM ! FACE ( ! E>? A USELESS & DANG]\S P]SON1 BUT WAS DECID+ :E!R IT WAS SUITABLE OR NOT = HIM TO LIVE 9 ,PET]SBURG1 :E!R IT WAS SUITABLE OR NOT = HIM TO TAKE MONEY FROM HIS MO!R1 & O!R QUE/IONS NOT AT ALL AFFECT+ ! OLD WOMAN4 ,& H]E AT ?AT TIME1 9 ! ANIMAL K+DOM1 5TIRELY 9DEP5D5T ( !  
REALITY1 W]E DECID$ ! QUE/IONS :E!R HE %\LD OR %\LD NOT KILL ! OLD MONEY-L5D]4 ,!SE QUE/IONS W]E DECID$1 NOT :5 HE1 HAV+ KILL$ ONE OLD WOMAN1 /OOD ) HIS AX BE=E ! SECOND1 BUT AT ! TIME :5 HE HAD NOT YET ACT$1 BUT WAS ONLY ?9K+1 :5 HIS CONSCI5CE ALONE WAS WORK+1 & 9 ?IS CONSCI5CE SC>CELY P]CEPTIBLE *ANGES W]E TAK+ PLACE4  

,N[ !RE IS (T5 NE$$ ! GREATE/ CLE>NESS ( M9D1 ESPECIALLY IMPORTANT = ! REGUL> DECISION ( A QUE/ION1 & A S+LE GLASS ( W9E1 A S+LE CIG>ETTE SMOK$1 MAY PREV5T ! DECISION ( ! QUE/ION1 MAY TURN ?IS QUE/ION1 MAY /IFLE ! VOICE ( CONSCI5CE1 MAY MAKE ! DECISION ( ! QUE/ION1 TO ! PR(IT ( ! L[] ANIMAL NATURE AS WAS ! CASE ) ,RASKOLNIK(4 

,! *ANGES >E IMP]CEPTIBLE1 & FROM !M COME ! MO/ 5ORM\S & AWFUL CONSEQU5CES4 ,FROM :AT HAPP5S :5 A MAN HAS DECID$ & BEGUN TO ACT1 GREAT MAT]IAL *ANGES MAY 5SUE3 H\SES1 PROP]TY1 M5'S BODIES1 MAY BE DE/ROY$1 BUT NO?+ CAN HAPP5 GREAT] ?AN :AT WAS HIDD5 9 ! MAN'S CONSCI5CE4 ,! LIMITS ( :AT MAY COME =? >E GIV5 TO CONSCI5CE4  

,BUT FROM ! SC>CELY P]CEPTIBLE *ANGES :I* TAKE PLACE 9 ! DOMA9 ( ! CONSCI5CE MAY PROCE$ CONSEQU5CES UTT]LY BEYOND ! P[] ( ! IMAG9ATION TO %[ !IR IMPORTANCE1 & :OLLY BEYOND LIMITS4  

,LET IT NOT BE ?\<T ?AT :AT ,I SAY HAS ANY?+ 9 COMMON ) QUE/IONS ( FREE WILL OR DET]M9ISM4  

,DISCUSSIONS AB\T !SE SUBJECTS >E SUP]FLU\S = MY PURPOSE OR = ANY O!R4 ,)\T DECID+ ! QUE/ION :E!R A MAN MAY OR MAY NOT ACT AS HE WI%ES--A QUE/ION1 9 MY OP9ION1 WRONGLY /AT$--,I ONLY SAY ?AT1 AS HUMAN ACTIVITY IS DET]M9$ BY SC>CELY P]CEPTIBLE *ANGES 9 ! CONSCI5CE1 !N--IT BE+ ALL ONE1 :E!R Y\ DO OR DO NOT RECOGNIZE ! SO-CALL$ FRE$OM ( ! WILL--ONE MU/ BE ESPECIALLY ATT5TIVE TO ! /ATE 9 :I* !SE ALMO/ IMP]CEPTIBLE *ANGES APPE>1 AS IT IS NECESS>Y TO BE ESPECIALLY ATT5TIVE TO ! CONDITION ( ! WEI<TS BY MEANS ( :I* WE WEI< OBJECTS4  

,WE MU/1 AS F> AS 9 US LIES1 TRY TO PLACE \RSELVES & O!RS 9 SU* CONDITIONS ?AT ! CLE>NESS & DELICACY ( ! ?\<TS NECESS>Y = ! REGUL> WORK ( ! CONSCI5CE MAY NOT BE DI/URB$1 & NOT TO DO ! OPPOSITE BY TRY+ TO MAKE ?IS WORK ( ! CONSCI5CE MORE DIFFICULT & TR\BLESOME BY ! USE ( /UPEFY+ ?+S4  

,A MAN IS BO? A SPIRITUAL & AN ANIMAL BE+4 ,A MAN MAY BE MOV$1 BY 9FLU5C+ ONLY HIS SPIRITUAL NATURE1 & MAY BE MOV$ BY 9FLU5C+ HIS ANIMAL NATURE1 JU/ AS A WAT* MAY BE MOV$ BY A H& & BY A MA9 :EEL4 ,& JU/ AS1 9 A WAT*1 IT IS MORE CONV5I5T TO REGULATE ITS MOVEM5T BY AN 9T]NAL ME*ANISM1 SO A MAN--Y\ Y\RSELF OR ANY ONE ELSE--IS MORE CONV5I5TLY GUID$ BY HIS CONSCI5CE4 ,& AS 9 WAT*ES IT IS NECESS>Y MORE ?AN ALL TO OBS]VE ?AT BY :I* ! C5TRAL ME*ANISM IS MORE CONV5I5TLY MOV$1 SO 9 ! CASE ( A MAN IT IS MORE ?AN ALL NECESS>Y TO OBS]VE PURITY1 CLE>NESS ( CONSCI5CE1 :]EBY IT IS MORE CONV5I5T TO MOVE A MAN4 ,IT IS IMPOSSIBLE TO D\BT ?IS1 & ALL M5 KN[ IT4 ,BUT ! NECESSITY >ISES = M5 TO /UPEFY !MSELVES4 ,M5 >E NOT SO DESIR\S ( !IR CONSCI5CES WORK+ REGUL>LY AS = IT TO SEEM TO !M ?AT :AT !Y >E DO+ IS REGUL>1 & !Y DELIB]ATELY EMPLOY SU* MEANS AS PREV5T ! REGUL> WORK ( ! CONSCI5CE4  

,FROM 3 ,WIKIS\RCE4ORG4 

,*RONOLOGY 3 
,NOVEMB] #c1 #ahhi 3 ,*APT] #d -- ,PUBLICATION4 

 FILE G5]AT$ FROM 3  
HTTP3_/_/REVOLTLIB4COM_/