,*APT] #bg #aidaid ,PEOPLE 3 ,AU?OR 3 ,LEO ,TOL/OY ,TEXT 3 ,! !ORY BY :I* M5 :O HAVE FRE$ !MSELVES FROM P]SONAL LABOR JU/IFY !MSELVES1 IS1 9 ITS SIMPLE/ & MO/ EXACT =M1 ?IS3 0,WE M51 HAV+ FRE$ \RSELVES FROM WORK1 & HAV+ BY VIOL5CE APPROPRIAT$ ! LABOR ( O!RS1 WE F9D \RSELVES BETT] ABLE TO B5EFIT !M40 ,9 O!R WORDS1 C]TA9 M51 = DO+ ! PEOPLE A PALPABLE & COMPREH5SIBLE H>M1--UTILIZ+ !IR LABOR BY VIOL5CE1 & !REBY 9CREAS+ ! DIFFICULTY ( !IR /RUGGLES ) NATURE1--DO TO !M AN IMPALPABLE & 9COMPREH5SIBLE GOOD4 ,?IS IS A V]Y /RANGE PROPOSITION2 BUT ! M51 BO? ( =M] AS WELL ( MOD]N TIMES1 :O HAVE LIV$ ON ! LABOR ( WORKM51 BELIEVE IT1 & CALM !IR CONSCI5CE BY IT4 ,LET US SEE 9 :AT WAY IT IS JU/IFI$1 9 DIFF]5T CLASSES ( M5 :O HAVE FRE$ !MSELVES FROM LABOR 9 \R [N DAYS4 0,I S]VE M5 BY MY ACTIVITY 9 *UR* OR /ATE1--AS K+1 M9I/]1 >*BI%OP2 ,I S]VE M5 BY MY TRAD+ OR BY 9DU/RY2 ,I S]VE M5 BY MY ACTIVITY 9 ! DEP>TM5TS ( SCI5CE OR >T4 ,BY \R ACTIVITIES WE >E ALL AS NECESS>Y TO ! PEOPLE AS !Y >E TO US40 ,SO SAY V>I\S M5 ( TO-DAY :O HAVE FRE$ !MSELVES FROM LABOR4 ,LET US CONSID] S]IATIM ! PR9CIPLES UPON :I* !Y BASE ! USEFULNESS ( !IR ACTIVITY4 ,!RE >E ONLY TWO 9DICATIONS ( ! USEFULNESS ( ANY ACTIVITY ( ONE MAN = ANO!R3 7#a7 AN EXT]IOR 9DICATION1--! ACKN[L$GM5T ( ! UTILITY ( ! ACTIVITY BY ?OSE TO :OM IT IS APPLI$2 & 7#b7 AN 9T]IOR 9DICATION1--! DESIRE TO BE ( USE TO O!RS LY+ AT ! ROOT ( ! ACTIVITY ( ! ONE :O IS TRY+ TO BE ( USE4 ,/ATESM5 7,I 9CLUDE ! ,*UR* DIGNIT>IES APPO9T$ BY ! GOV]NM5T 9 ! CATEGORY ( /ATESM57 >E1 IT IS SAID1 ( USE TO ?OSE :OM !Y GOV]N4 ,! EMP]OR1 ! K+1 ! PRESID5T ( A REPUBLIC1 ! PRIME M9I/]1 ! M9I/] ( JU/ICE1 ! M9I/] ( W>1 ! M9I/] ( PUBLIC 9/RUCTION1 ! BI%OP1 & ALL UND] !M :O S]VE ! /ATE1 ALL LIVE FREE FROM ! /RUGGLE ( MANK9D = EXI/5CE1 HAV+ LAID ALL ! BURD5 ( ?IS /RUGGLE ON SOMEONE ELSE1 ON ! GR\ND ?AT !IR NON-ACTIVITY COMP5SATES = ?IS4 ,LET US APPLY ! FIR/ 9DICATION TO ?OSE = :OSE WELF>E ! ACTIVITY ( /ATESM5 IS BE/[$4 ,DO !Y1 ,I ASK1 RECOGNIZE ! USEFULNESS ( ?IS ACTIVITY8 ,YES1 IT IS RECOGNIZ$4 ,MO/ M5 CONSID] /ATESMAN%IP NECESS>Y TO !M4 ,! MAJORITY RECOGNIZE ! USEFULNESS ( ?IS ACTIVITY 9 PR9CIPLE2 BUT 9 ALL ITS MANIFE/ATIONS KN[N TO US1 9 ALL P>TICUL> CASES KN[N TO US1 ! USEFULNESS ( EA* ( ! 9/ITUTIONS & ( EA* ( ! MANIFE/ATIONS ( ?IS ACTIVITY IS NOT ONLY D5I$ BY ?OSE = :OSE ADVANTAGE IT IS P]=M$1 BUT !Y ASS]T ?AT IT IS EV5 P]NICI\S & HURTFUL4 ,!RE IS NO /ATE FUNCTION OR SOCIAL ACTIVITY :I* IS NOT CONSID]$ BY MANY M5 TO BE HURTFUL3 !RE IS NO 9/ITUTION :I* IS NOT CONSID]$ P]NICI\S1--C\RTS ( JU/ICE1 BANKS1 LOCAL SELF-GOV]NM5T1 POLICE1 CL]GY4 ,EV]Y /ATE ACTIVITY1 FROM ! M9I/] D[N TO ! POLICEMAN1 FROM ! BI%OP TO ! SEXTON1 IS CONSID]$ BY SOME M5 TO BE USEFUL & BY O!RS TO BE P]NICI\S4 ,& ?IS IS ! CASE NOT ONLY 9 ,RUSSIA BUT ?R\<\T ! WORLD2 9 ,FRANCE AS WELL AS 9 ,AM]ICA4 ,! ACTIVITY ( ! REPUBLICAN P>TY IS CONSID]$ P]NICI\S BY ! RADICAL P>TY1 & VISE V]SA3 ! ACTIVITY ( ! RADICAL P>TY1 IF ! P[] IS 9 !IR H&S1 IS CONSID]$ BAD BY ! REPUBLICAN & O!R P>TIES4 ,BUT NOT ONLY IS IT A FACT ?AT ! ACTIVITY ( /ATESM5 IS NEV] CONSID]$ BY ALL M5 TO BE USEFUL1 ?IS ACTIVITY HAS1 BESIDES1 ?IS PECULI>ITY1 ?AT IT MU/ ALWAYS BE C>RI$ \T BY VIOL5CE1 & ?AT1 TO ATTA9 ITS 5D1 MURD]S1 EXECUTIONS1 PRISONS1 TAXES RAIS$ BY =CE1 & SO ON1 BECAME NECESS>Y4 ,IT APPE>S !RE=E ?AT BESIDES ! FACT ?AT ! USEFULNESS ( /ATE ACTIVITY IS NOT RECOGNIZ$ BY ALL M51 & IS ALWAYS D5I$ BY ONE PORTION ( M51 ?IS USEFULNESS HAS ! PECULI>ITY ( V9DICAT+ ITSELF ALWAYS BY VIOL5CE4 ,!RE=E ! USEFULNESS ( /ATE ACTIVITY CANNOT BE CONFIRM$ BY ! FIR/ 9DICATION1--I4E41 ! FACT ?AT IT IS RECOGNIZ$ BY ?OSE M5 = :OM IT IS SAID TO BE P]=M$4 ,LET US APPLY ! SECOND TE/4 ,LET US ASK /ATESM5 !MSELVES1 FROM ! ,CZ> D[N TO ! POLICEMAN1 FROM ! PRESID5T TO ! SECRET>Y1 FROM ! PATRI>* TO ! SEXTON1 BEGG+ = A S9C]E ANSW]1 :E!R1 9 OCCUPY+ !IR RESPECTIVE POSITIONS !Y HAVE 9 VIEW ! GOOD :I* !Y WI% TO DO = M5 OR SOME?+ ELSE4 ,9 !IR DESIRE TO FILL ! SITUATION ( A ,CZ>1 A PRESID5T1 A M9I/]1 A POLICE-S]GEANT1 A SEXTON1 A TEA*]1 >E !Y MOV$ BY ! DESIRE ( BE+ USEFUL TO M5 OR = !IR [N P]SONAL ADVANTAGE8 ,& ! ANSW] ( S9C]E M5 W\LD BE ?AT !IR *IEF MOTIVE IS !IR [N P]SONAL ADVANTAGE4 ,SO IT APPE>S ?AT ONE CLASS ( M51 :O LIVE BY ! LABOR ( SOME O!RS :O >E P]I%+ BY !SE LABORS1 COMP5SATE = ?IS 9DUBITABLE EVIL BY AN ACTIVITY :I* IS ALWAYS CONSID]$ BY A GREAT MANY M5 TO BE NOT ONLY USELESS1 BUT P]NICI\S2 :I* CANNOT BE ACCEPT$ VOLUNT>ILY1 BUT TO :I* M5 MU/ ALWAYS BE COMPELL$1 & ! AIM ( :I* IS NOT ! B5EFIT ( O!RS BUT ! P]SONAL ADVANTAGE ( ! M5 :O P]=M IT4 ,:AT IS IT1 !N1 ?AT CONFIRMS ! !ORY ?AT /ATE ACTIVITY IS USEFUL = HUMANITY8 ,ONLY ! FACT ?AT ! M5 :O P]=M IT FIRMLY PR(ESS TO BELIEVE IT TO BE USEFUL1 & ?AT IT HAS BE5 ALWAYS 9 EXI/5CE4 ,BUT SO SOME NOT ONLY USELESS1 BUT V]Y P]NICI\S 9/ITUTIONS1 LIKE SLAV]Y1 PRO/ITUTION1 & W>S1 HAVE ALWAYS BE5 9 EXI/5CE4 ,BUS9ESS PEOPLE 7M]*ANTS1 MANUFACTUR]S1 RAILWAY PROPRIETORS1 BANK]S1 L&-[N]S7 BELIEVE ?AT !Y DO A GOOD :I* COMP5SATES = ! H>M UND\BT$LY DONE BY !M4 ,ON :AT GR\NDS DO !Y BELIEVE ?IS8 ,TO ! QUE/ION1 ,BY :OM IS ! USEFULNESS ( !IR ACTIVITY RECOGNIZ$8 M5 9 *UR* & 9 /ATE >E ABLE TO PO9T TO ! ?\S&S & MILLIONS ( WORK+-PEOPLE :O 9 PR9CIPLE RECOGNIZE ! USEFULNESS ( /ATE & *UR* ACTIVITY4 ,BUT TO :OM WILL BANK]S1 DI/ILL]S1 MANUFACTUR]S ( VELVET1 ( BRONZES1 ( LOOK+-GLASSES1 TO SAY NO?+ ( GUNS1--TO :OM WILL !Y PO9T :5 WE ASK !M1 ,IS !IR USEFULNESS RECOGNIZ$ BY PUBLIC OP9ION8 ,IF M5 CAN BE F\ND :O RECOGNIZE ! USEFULNESS ( MANUFACTUR+ *9TZES1 RAILS1 BE]1 & SU* LIKE ?+S1 !RE WILL BE F\ND ALSO A /ILL GREAT] NUMB] ( M5 :O CONSID] ! MANUFACTURE ( !SE >TICLES P]NICI\S4 ,AS = ! M]*ANTS :OSE ACTIVITY IS CONF9$ TO PRICES1 & L&-[N]S1 NOBODY W\LD EV5 ATTEMPT TO JU/IFY !M4 ,BESIDES1 ?IS ACTIVITY IS ALWAYS ASSOCIAT$ ) H>M TO WORK+-PEOPLE1 & ) VIOL5CE1 :I*1 IF LESS DIRECT ?AN ?AT ( ! /ATE1 IS YET JU/ AS CRUEL 9 ITS CONSEQU5CES4 ,= ! ACTIVITIES DISPLAY$ 9 9DU/RY & 9 TRADE >E 5TIRELY BAS$ ON TAK+ ADVANTAGE ( ! WANTS ( WORK+-PEOPLE 9 EV]Y =M 9 ORD] TO COMPEL !M TO H>D & HAT$ LABOR2 TO BUY+ *EAP1 & TO SELL+ NECESS>IES AT ! HITICUL> CASES2 & BY ! MAJORITY !IR ACTIVITY IS CONSID]$ TO BE DIRECTLY P]NICI\S4 ,IF WE W]E TO APPLY ! SECOND TE/ & TO ASK1 ,:AT IS ! *IEF MOTIVE ( ! ACTIVITY ( BUS9ESS-M58 WE %\LD RECEIVE A /ILL MORE DET]M9ATE ANSW] ?AN ?AT ON ! ACTIVITY ( /ATESM54 ,IF A /ATESMAN SAYS ?AT BESIDES A P]SONAL ADVANTAGE HE HAS 9 VIEW ! COMMON B5EFIT1 WE CANNOT HELP BELIEV+ HIM1 & EA* ( US KN[S SU* M54 ,BUT A BUS9ESS-MAN1 FROM ! V]Y NATURE ( HIS OCCUPATIONS CANNOT HAVE 9 VIEW A COMMON ADVANTAGE1 & W\LD BE RIDICUL\S 9 ! SIE SO ASSUR$ ( !IR [N USEFULNESS ?AT !Y BOLDLY1 = ! SAKE ( !IR IMAG9>Y GOOD1 DO AN UND\BT$1 OBVI\S H>M TO WORKM5 BY EXTRICAT+ !MSELVES FROM LABOR1 & CONSUM+ ! PRODUCE ( ! WORK+-CLASSES4 ,SCI5TI/S & >TI/S HAVE ALSO FRE$ !MSELVES FROM LABOR BY PUTT+ IT ON O!RS1 & LIVE ) A QUIET CONSCI5CE BELIEV+ ?AT !Y BR+ SUFFICI5T ADVANTAGES TO O!R M5 TO COMP5SATE = IT4 ,ON :AT IS ?IS ASSURANCE BAS$8 ,LET US ASK !M AS WE HAVE DONE /ATESM5 & BUS9ESS-M54 ,IS ! UTILITY ( ! >TS & SCI5CES RECOGNIZ$ BY ALL1 OR EV5 BY ! MAJORITY1 ( WORK+-PEOPLE8 ,WE %ALL RECEIVE A V]Y SAD ANSW]4 ,! ACTIVITY ( M5 9 ! ,/ATE ,*UR* & GOV]NM5T (FICES IS RECOGNIZ$ TO BE USEFUL 9 !ORY BY ALMO/ ALL1 & 9 APPLICATION BY ! MAJORITY ( ?OSE = :OM IT IS P]=M$4 ,! ACTIVITY ( BUS9ESS-M5 IS RECOGNIZ$ ONLY BY ?OSE :O >E 5GAG$ 9 IT OR :O DESIRE TO PRACTICE IT4 ,?OSE :O BE> ON !IR %\LD]S ALL ! LABOR ( LIFE & :O FE$ & CLO! ! SCI5TI/S & >TI/S CANNOT RECOGNIZE ! USEFULNESS ( ! ACTIVITY ( !SE M5 BECAUSE !Y CANNOT EV5 =M AN IDEA AB\T AN ACTIVITY :I* ALWAYS APPE>S TO WORKM5 USELESS & EV5 DEPRAV+4 ,?US1 )\T ANY EXCEPTION1 WORK+-PEOPLE ?9K ! SAME AB\T UNIV]SITIES1 LIBR>IES1 CONS]VATORIES1 PICTURE & /ATUE GALL]IES1 & !AT]S1 :I* >E BUILT AT !IR EXP5SE4 ,A WORKMAN CONSID]S ?IS ACTIVITY SO DECID$LY P]NICI\S ?AT HE DOES NOT S5D HIS *ILDR5 TO BE TAUY TO 9TRODUCE A LAW COMPELL+ P>5TS TO S5D ! *ILDR5 TO S*OOL4 ,A WORKMAN ALWAYS LOOKS AT ?IS ACTIVITY ) ILL-WILL1 & ONLY CEASES TO LOOK AT IT SO :5 HE CEASES TO BE A WORKMAN1 & ?R\< GA9 & SO-CALL$ $UCATION PASSES \T ( ! CLASS ( WORK+-PEOPLE 9TO ! CLASS ( M5 :O LIVE ON ! NECK ( O!RS4 ,NOT)/&+ ! FACT ?AT ! USEFULNESS ( ! ACTIVITY ( SCI5TI/S & >TI/S IS NOT RECOGNIZ$ & EV5 CANNOT BE RECOGNIZ$ BY ANY WORKMAN1 !SE M5 >E1 ALL ! SAME1 COMPELL$ TO MAKE SACRIFICES = SU* AN ACTIVITY4 ,A /ATESMAN SIMPLY S5DS ANO!R TO ! GUILLOT9E OR TO PRISON2 A BUS9ESS-MAN1 UTILIZ+ ! LABOR ( SOMEONE ELSE1 TAKES FROM HIM HIS LA/ RES\RCE1 LEAV+ HIM ! ALT]NATIVE ( />VATION OR LABOR DE/RUCTIVE TO HIS HEAL? & LIFE3 BUT A MAN ( SCI5CE OR ( >T SEEM+LY COMPELS NOBODY TO DO ANY?+2 HE M]ELY (F]S ! GOOD HE HAS DONE TO ?OSE :O >E WILL+ TO TAKE IT2 BUT1 TO BE ABLE TO MAKE HIS PRODUCTIONS UNDESIRABLE TO ! WORK+-PEOPLE1 HE TAKES AWAY FROM !M BY VIOL5CE1 ?R\< ! /ATESM51 A GREAT P>T ( !IR LABOR = ! BUILD+ & KEEP+ OP5 ( ACADEMIES1 UNIV]SITIES1 COLLEGES1 S*OOLS1 MUSEUMS1 LIBR>IES1 CONS]VATORIES1 & = ! WAGES = HIMSELF & HIS FELL[S4 ,BUT IF WE W]E TO ASK ! SCI5TI/S & >TI/S ! OBJECT :I* !Y >E PURSU+ 9 !IR ACTIVITY1 WE %\LD RECEIVE ! MO/ A/ONI%+ REPLIES4 ,A /ATESMAN W\LD ANSW] ?AT HIS AIM WAS ! COMMON WELF>E2 & 9 HIS ANSW]1 !RE W\LD BE AN ADMIXTURE ( TRU? CONFIRM$ BY PUBLIC OP9ION4 ,9 ! ANSW] ( ! BUS9ESS-MAN1 !RE W\LD BE LESS PROBABILITY2 BUT WE C\LD ADMIT EV5 ?IS ALSO4 ,BUT ! ANSW] ( ! SCI5TI/S & >TI/S /RIKES ONE AT ONCE BY ITS WANT ( PRO( & BY ITS EFFRONT]Y4 ,SU* M5 SAY1 )\T BR++ ANY PRO(S 7JU/ AS PRIE/S US$ TO DO 9 OLD5 TIMES7 ?AT !IR ACTIVITY IS ! MO/ IMPORTANT ( ALL1 & ?AT )\T IT MANK9D W\LD GO TO RU94 ,!Y ASS]T ?AT IT IS SO1 NOT)/&+ ! FACT ?AT NOBODY EXCEPT !MSELVES EI!R UND]/&S OR ACKN[L$GES !IR ACTIVITY1 & NOT)/&+ ! FACT ?AT1 ACCORD+ TO !IR [N DEF9ITION1 TRUE SCI5CE & TRUE >T %\LD NOT HAVE A UTILIT>IAN AIM4 ,!SE M5 >E OCCUPI$ ) ! MATT] !Y LIKE1 )\T TR\BL+ !MSELVES :AT ADVANTAGE WILL COME \T ( IT TO M52 & !Y >E ALWAYS ASSUR$ ?AT !Y >E DO+ ! MO/ IMPORTANT & ! MO/ NECESS>Y ?+ = ALL MANK9D4 ,SO ?AT :ILE A S9C]E /ATESMAN1 ACKN[L$G+ ?AT ! *IEF MOTIVE ( HIS ACTIVITY IS A P]SONAL ONE1 TRIES TO BE AS USEFUL AS POSSIBLE TO ! WORK+-PEOPLE2 :ILE A BUS9ESS-MAN1 ACKN[L$G+ ! EGOTISM ( HIS ACTIVITY1 TRIES TO GIVE IT AN APPE>ANCE ( BE+ ONE ( UNIV]SAL UTILITY1--M5 ( SCI5CE & >T DO NOT CONSID] IT NECESS>Y EV5 TO SEEM TO %ELT] !MSELVES UND] A PRET5SE ( USEFULNESS1 !Y D5Y EV5 ! OBJECT ( USEFULNESS1 SO SURE >E !Y1 NOT ONLY ( ! USEFULNESS BUT EV5 ( ! SACR$NESS ( !IR [N BUS9ESS4 ,SO IT TURNS \T ?AT ! ?IRD CLASS ( M5 :O HAVE FRE$ !MSELVES FROM LABOR & LAID IT ON O!RS1 >E OCCUPI$ ) ?+S :I* >E TOTALLY 9COMPREH5SIBLE TO ! WORK+-PEOPLE1 & :I* !SE PEOPLE CONSID] TRIFLES & (T5 V]Y P]NICI\S TRIFLES2 & >E OCCUPI$ ) !SE ?+S )\T ANY CONSID]ATION ( !IR USEFULNESS BUT M]ELY = ! GRATIFICATION ( !IR [N PLEASURE3 IT TURNS \T ?AT !SE M5 >E1 FROM SOME REASON OR O!R1 QUITE ASSUR$ ?AT !IR ACTIVITY WILL ALWAYS PRODUCE ?AT )\T :I* ! WORK-PEOPLE W\LD NEV] BE ABLE TO EXI/4 ,M5 HAVE FRE$ !MSELVES FROM LABOR+ = !IR LIV+ & HAVE ?R[N ! WORK UPON O!RS :O P]I% UND] IT3 !Y UTILIZE ?IS LABOR & ASS]T ?AT !IR OCCUPATIONS1 :I* >E 9COMPREH5SIBLE TO ALL O!R M51 & :I* >E NOT DIRECT$ TO USEFUL AIMS1 COMP5SATE = ALL ! EVIL !Y >E DO+ TO M5 BY FREE+ !MSELVES FROM ! TR\BLE ( E>N+ !IR LIVELIHOOD & BY SWALL[+ UP ! LABOR ( O!RS4 ,! /ATESMAN1 TO COMP5SATE = ! UND\BT$ & OBVI\S EVIL :I* HE DOES TO MAN BY FREE+ HIMSELF FROM ! /RUGGLE ) NATURE & BY APPROPRIAT+ ! LABOR ( O!RS1 DOES M5 ANO!R OBVI\S & UND\BT$ H>M BY C\NT5ANC+ ALL SORTS ( VIOL5CE4 ,! BUS9ESS-MAN1 TO COMP5SATE = ! UND\BT$ & OBVI\S H>M :I* HE DOES TO M5 BY US+ UP !IR LABOR1 TRIES TO E>N = HIMSELF AS MU* WEAL? AS POSSIBLE2 ?AT IS1 AS MU* ( O!R M5'S LABOR AS POSSIBLE4 ,! MAN ( SCI5CE & >T1 9 COMP5SAT+ = ! SAME UND\BT$ & OBVI\S H>M :I* HE DOES TO WORK+-PEOPLE1 IS OCCUPI$ ) MATT]S TO :I* HE FEELS ATTRACT$ & :I* >E QUITE 9COMPREH5SIBLE TO WORK-PEOPLE1 & :I*1 ACCORD+ TO HIS [N ASS]TION1 9 ORD] TO BE TRUE1 \E QUITE SURE ?AT !IR RIN+ !IR LIVELIHOOD HAVE NO JU/IFICATION = DO+ SO4 ,BUT1 /RANGE TO SAY1 !SE M5 FIRMLY BELIEVE 9 !IR [N RIY #a#i1 #bag 3 ,*APT] #bg -- ,ADD$4 FILE G5]AT$ FROM 3 HTTP3_/_/REVOLTLIB4COM_/