,*APT] #h 

#ahigahig 

,PEOPLE 3 

,AU?OR 3 ,LEO ,TOL/OY 

,TRANSLATOR 3 ,AYLM] ,MAUDE 

,TEXT 3 

,BUT IF >T IS A HUMAN ACTIVITY HAV+ = ITS PURPOSE ! 
TRANSMISSION TO O!RS ( ! HI<E/ & BE/ FEEL+S TO 
:I* M5 HAVE RIS51 H[ C\LD IT BE ?AT HUMANITY 
= A C]TA9 RA!R CONSID]ABLE P]IOD ( ITS EXI/5CE 
7FROM ! TIME PEOPLE CEAS$ TO BELIEVE 9 ,*UR* DOCTR9E 
D[N TO ! PRES5T DAY7 %\LD EXI/ )\T ?IS IMPORTANT 
ACTIVITY1 &1 9/EAD ( IT1 %\LD PUT UP ) AN 
9SIGNIFICANT >TI/IC ACTIVITY ONLY AF=D+ PLEASURE8 

,9 ORD] TO ANSW] ?IS QUE/ION1 IT IS NECESS>Y1 FIR/ ( 
ALL1 TO CORRECT ! CURR5T ]ROR PEOPLE MAKE 9 ATTRIBUT+ 
TO \R >T ! SIGNIFICANCE ( TRUE1 UNIV]SAL >T4 ,WE >E 
SO ACCU/OM$1 NOT ONLY NAIVELY TO CONSID] ! ,CIRCASSIAN 
FAMILY ! BE/ /OCK ( PEOPLE1 BUT ALSO ! ,ANGLO-,SAXON 
RACE ! BE/ RACE IF WE >E ,5GLI%M5 OR ,AM]ICANS1 OR 
! ,TEUTONIC IF WE >E ,G]MANS1 OR ! ,GALLO-,LAT9 IF WE >E 
,FR5*1 OR ! ,SLAVONIC IF WE >E ,RUSSIANS1 ?AT :5 
SPEAK+ ( \R [N >T WE FEEL FULLY CONV9C$1 NOT ONLY 
?AT \R >T IS TRUE >T1 BUT EV5 ?AT IT IS ! BE/ & ONLY 
TRUE >T4 ,BUT 9 REALITY \R >T IS NOT ONLY NOT ! ONLY >T 
7AS ! ,BIBLE ONCE WAS HELD TO BE ! ONLY BOOK71 BUT IT IS 
NOT EV5 ! >T ( ! :OLE ( ,*RI/5DOM1--ONLY ( A 
SMALL SECTION ( ?AT P>T ( HUMANITY4 ,IT WAS CORRECT TO 
SPEAK ( A NATIONAL ,JEWI%1 ,GRECIAN1 OR ,EGYPTIAN >T1 & ONE 
MAY SPEAK ( A N[-EXI/+ ,*9ESE1 ,JAPANESE1 OR ,9DIAN >T 
%>$ 9 BY A :OLE PEOPLE4 ,SU* >T1 COMMON TO A :OLE 
NATION1 EXI/$ 9 ,RUSSIA TILL ,PET] ! ,FIR/'S TIME1 & EXI/$ 
9 ! RE/ ( ,EUROPE UNTIL ! ?IRTE5? OR F\RTE5? 
#f#hC5TURY2 BUT S9CE ! UPP] CLASSES ( ,EUROPEAN SOCIETY1 
HAV+ LO/ FAI? 9 ! ,*UR* TEA*+1 DID NOT ACCEPT REAL 
,*RI/IANITY BUT REMA9$ )\T ANY FAI?1 ONE CAN NO 
LONG] SPEAK ( AN >T ( ! ,*RI/IAN NATIONS 9 ! S5SE 
( ! :OLE ( >T4 ,S9CE ! UPP] CLASSES ( ! ,*RI/IAN 
NATIONS LO/ FAI? 9 ,*UR* ,*RI/IANITY1 ! >T ( ?OSE 
UPP] CLASSES HAS SEP>AT$ ITSELF FROM ! >T ( ! RE/ ( 
! PEOPLE1 & !RE HAVE BE5 TWO >TS--! >T ( ! 
PEOPLE & G5TEEL >T4 ,& !RE=E ! ANSW] TO ! 
QUE/ION H[ IT C\LD OCCUR ?AT HUMANITY LIV$ = A 
C]TA9 P]IOD )\T REAL >T1 REPLAC+ IT BY >T :I* 
S]V$ 5JOYM5T ONLY1 IS1 ?AT NOT ALL HUMANITY1 NOR EV5 
ANY CONSID]ABLE PORTION ( IT1 LIV$ )\T REAL >T1 BUT 
ONLY ! HI<E/ CLASSES ( ,EUROPEAN ,*RI/IAN SOCIETY1 & 
EV5 !Y ONLY = A COMP>ATIVELY %ORT TIME--FROM ! 
COMM5CEM5T ( ! ,R5AISSANCE D[N TO \R [N DAY4 

,& ! CONSEQU5CE ( ?IS ABS5CE ( TRUE >T %[$ 
ITSELF1 9EVITABLY1 9 ! CORRUPTION ( ?AT CLASS :I* 
N\RI%$ ITSELF ON ! FALSE >T4 ,ALL ! CONFUS$1 UN9TELLIGIBLE 
!ORIES ( >T1 ALL ! FALSE & CONTRADICTORY 
JUDGM5TS ON >T1 & P>TICUL>LY ! SELF-CONFID5T /AGNATION 
( \R >T 9 ITS FALSE PA?1 ALL >ISE FROM ! ASS]TION1 
:I* HAS COME 9TO COMMON USE & IS ACCEPT$ AS AN 
UNQUE/ION$ TRU?1 BUT IS YET AMAZ+LY & PALPABLY FALSE1 
! ASS]TION1 NAMELY1 ?AT ! >T ( \R UPP] CLASSES.<#f#e.> IS 
! :OLE ( >T1 ! TRUE1 ! ONLY1 ! UNIV]SAL >T4 ,& 
AL?\< ?IS ASS]TION 7:I* IS PRECISELY SIMIL> TO ! 
ASS]TION MADE BY RELIGI\S PEOPLE ( ! V>I\S ,*UR*ES 
:O CONSID] ?AT !IRS IS ! ONLY TRUE RELIGION7 IS QUITE 
>BITR>Y & OBVI\SLY UNJU/1 YET IT IS CALMLY REPEAT$ BY 
ALL ! PEOPLE ( \R CIRCLE ) FULL FAI? 9 ITS 9FALLIBILITY4 

#f#i,! >T WE HAVE IS ! :OLE ( >T1 ! REAL1 ! ONLY 
>T1 & YET TWO-?IRDS ( ! HUMAN RACE 7ALL ! PEOPLES 
( ,ASIA & ,AFRICA7 LIVE & DIE KN[+ NO?+ ( ?IS 
SOLE & SUPREME >T4 ,& EV5 9 \R ,*RI/IAN SOCIETY 
H>DLY ONE P] C5T4 ( ! PEOPLE MAKE USE ( ?IS >T :I* 
WE SPEAK ( AS BE+ ! :OLE ( >T2 ! REMA9+ N9ETY-N9E 
P] C5T4 LIVE & DIE1 G5]ATION AFT] G5]ATION1 
CRU%$ BY TOIL & NEV] TA/+ ?IS >T1 :I* MOREOV] 
IS ( SU* A NATURE ?AT1 IF !Y C\LD GET IT1 !Y W\LD NOT 
UND]/& ANY?+ ( IT4 ,WE1 ACCORD+ TO ! CURR5T 
AES!TIC !ORY1 ACKN[L$GE >T EI!R AS ONE ( ! HI<E/ 
MANIFE/ATIONS ( ! ,IDEA1 ,GOD1 ,BEAUTY1 OR AS ! HI<E/ 
SPIRITUAL 5JOYM5T2 FUR!RMORE1 WE HOLD ?AT ALL PEOPLE 
HAVE EQUAL RI<TS1 IF NOT TO MAT]IAL1 AT ANY RATE TO SPIRITUAL 
WELL-BE+2 & YET N9ETY-N9E P] C5T4 ( \R ,EUROPEAN 
POPULATION LIVE & DIE1 G5]ATION AFT] G5]ATION1 CRU%$ 
BY TOIL1 MU* ( :I* TOIL IS NECESS>Y = ! PRODUCTION ( 
\R >T :I* !Y NEV] USE1 & WE1 NEV]!LESS1 CALMLY 
ASS]T ?AT ! >T :I* WE PRODUCE IS ! REAL1 TRUE1 ONLY 
>T--ALL ( >T6 

,TO ! REM>K ?AT IF \R >T IS ! TRUE >T EV]YONE 
%\LD HAVE ! B5EFIT ( IT1 ! USUAL REPLY IS ?AT IF NOT 
EV]YBODY AT PRES5T MAKES USE ( EXI/+ >T1 ! FAULT 
LIES1 NOT 9 ! >T1 BUT 9 ! FALSE ORGANIZATION ( SOCIETY2 
?AT ONE CAN IMAG9E TO ONESELF1 9 ! FUTURE1 A /ATE ( 
?+S 9 :I* PHYSICAL LABOR WILL BE P>TLY SUP]S$$ 
BY MA*9]Y1 P>TLY LI<T5$ BY ITS JU/ DI/RIBUTION1 & 
?AT LABOR = ! PRODUCTION ( >T WILL BE TAK5 9 TURNS2 
?AT !RE IS NO NE$ = SOME PEOPLE ALWAYS TO SIT BEL[ ! 
/AGE MOV+ ! DECORATIONS1 W9D+ UP ! MA*9]Y1 
WORK+ AT ! PIANO OR ,FR5* HORN1 & SETT+ TYPE & 
PR9T+ BOOKS1 BUT ?AT ! PEOPLE :O DO ALL ?IS WORK 
MI<T BE 5GAG$ ONLY A FEW H\RS P] DAY1 & 9 !IR 
LEISURE TIME MI<T 5JOY ALL ! BLESS+S ( >T4 

,?AT IS :AT ! DEF5D]S ( \R EXCLUSIVE >T SAY4 ,BUT 
#g,I ?9K !Y DO NOT !MSELVES BELIEVE IT4 ,!Y CANNOT 
HELP KN[+ ?AT F9E >T CAN >ISE ONLY ON ! SLAV]Y ( 
! MASSES ( ! PEOPLE1 & CAN CONT9UE ONLY AS LONG AS 
?AT SLAV]Y LA/S1 & !Y CANNOT HELP KN[+ ?AT ONLY 
UND] CONDITIONS ( 9T5SE LABOR = ! WORK]S1 CAN 
SPECIALI/S--WRIT]S1 MUSICIANS1 DANC]S1 & ACTORS-->RIVE 
AT ?AT F9E DEGREE ( P]FECTION TO :I* !Y DO ATTA91 
OR PRODUCE !IR REF9$ WORKS ( >T2 & ONLY UND] ! 
SAME CONDITIONS CAN !RE BE A F9E PUBLIC TO E/EEM SU* 
PRODUCTIONS4 ,FREE ! SLAVES ( CAPITAL1 & IT WILL BE 
IMPOSSIBLE TO PRODUCE SU* REF9$ >T4 

,BUT EV5 W]E WE TO ADMIT ! 9ADMISSIBLE1 & SAY ?AT 
MEANS MAY BE F\ND BY :I* >T 7?AT >T :I* AMONG US 
IS CONSID]$ TO BE >T7 MAY BE ACCESSIBLE TO ! :OLE 
PEOPLE1 ANO!R CONSID]ATION PRES5TS ITSELF %[+ ?AT 
FA%IONABLE >T CANNOT BE ! :OLE ( >T1 VIZ4 ! FACT 
?AT IT IS COMPLETELY UN9TELLIGIBLE TO ! PEOPLE4 ,=M]LY 
M5 WROTE POEMS 9 ,LAT91 BUT N[ !IR >TI/IC PRODUCTIONS 
>E AS UN9TELLIGIBLE TO ! COMMON FOLK AS IF !Y W]E 
WRITT5 9 ,SANSKRIT4 ,! USUAL REPLY TO ?IS IS1 ?AT IF ! 
PEOPLE DO NOT N[ UND]/& ?IS >T ( \RS1 IT ONLY PROVES 
?AT !Y >E UNDEVELOP$1 & ?AT ?IS HAS BE5 SO AT EA* 
FRE% /EP =W>D MADE BY >T4 ,FIR/ IT WAS NOT UND]/OOD1 
BUT AFT]W>DS PEOPLE GOT ACCU/OM$ TO IT4 

0,IT WILL BE ! SAME ) \R PRES5T >T2 IT WILL BE 
UND]/OOD :5 EV]YBODY IS AS WELL $UCAT$ AS >E WE--! 
PEOPLE ( ! UPP] CLASSES--:O PRODUCE ?IS >T10 SAY 
! DEF5D]S ( \R >T4 ,BUT ?IS ASS]TION IS EVID5TLY 
EV5 MORE UNJU/ ?AN ! =M]2 = WE KN[ ?AT ! 
MAJORITY ( ! PRODUCTIONS ( ! >T ( ! UPP] CLASSES1 
SU* AS V>I\S ODES1 POEMS1 DRAMAS1 CANTATAS1 PA/ORALS1 
PICTURES1 ETC41 :I* DELI<T$ ! PEOPLE ( ! UPP] 
CLASSES :5 !Y W]E PRODUC$1 NEV] W]E AFT]W>DS 
EI!R UND]/OOD OR VALU$ BY ! GREAT MASSES ( MANK9D1 
BUT HAVE REMA9$1 :AT !Y W]E AT FIR/1 A M]E 
#g#aPA/IME = RI* PEOPLE ( !IR TIME1 = :OM ALONE !Y 
EV] W]E ( ANY IMPORTANCE4 ,IT IS ALSO (T5 URG$ 9 
PRO( ( ! ASS]TION ?AT ! PEOPLE WILL SOME DAY UND]/& 
\R >T1 ?AT SOME PRODUCTIONS ( SO-CALL$ 0CLASSICAL0 
POETRY1 MUSIC1 OR PA9T+1 :I* =M]LY DID NOT PLEASE 
! MASSES1 DO--N[ ?AT !Y HAVE BE5 (F]$ TO !M 
FROM ALL SIDES--BEG9 TO PLEASE !SE SAME MASSES2 BUT ?IS 
ONLY %[S ?AT ! CR[D1 ESPECIALLY ! HALF-SPOIL$ T[N 
CR[D1 CAN EASILY 7ITS TA/E HAV+ BE5 P]V]T$7 BE 
ACCU/OM$ TO ANY SORT ( >T4 ,MOREOV]1 ?IS >T IS NOT 
PRODUC$ BY !SE MASSES1 NOR EV5 *OS5 BY !M1 BUT 
IS 5]GETICALLY ?RU/ UPON !M 9 ?OSE PUBLIC PLACES 9 
:I* >T IS ACCESSIBLE TO ! PEOPLE4 ,= ! GREAT MAJORITY 
( WORK+ PEOPLE1 \R >T1 BESIDES BE+ 9ACCESSIBLE ON 
ACC\NT ( ITS CO/L9ESS1 IS /RANGE 9 ITS V]Y NATURE1 
TRANSMITT+ AS IT DOES ! FEEL+S ( PEOPLE F> REMOV$ 
FROM ?OSE CONDITIONS ( LABORI\S LIFE :I* >E NATURAL TO 
! GREAT BODY ( HUMANITY4 ,?AT :I* IS 5JOYM5T TO 
A MAN ( ! RI* CLASSES1 IS 9COMPREH5SIBLE1 AS A PLEASURE1 
TO A WORK+ MAN1 & EVOKES 9 HIM EI!R NO FEEL+ AT 
ALL1 OR ONLY A FEEL+ QUITE CONTR>Y TO ?AT :I* IT EVOKES 
9 AN IDLE & SATIAT$ MAN4 ,SU* FEEL+S AS =M ! 
*IEF SUBJECTS ( PRES5T-DAY >T--SAY1 = 9/ANCE1 HONOR1.<#f#f.> 
PATRIOTISM & AMOR\SNESS1 EVOKE 9 A WORK+ MAN ONLY 
BEWILD]M5T & CONTEMPT1 OR 9DIGNATION4 ,SO ?AT EV5 
IF A POSSIBILITY W]E GIV5 TO ! LABOR+ CLASSES1 9 !IR 
FREE TIME1 TO SEE1 TO READ1 & TO HE> ALL ?AT =MS ! 
FL[] ( CONTEMPOR>Y >T 7AS IS DONE TO SOME EXT5T 9 
T[NS1 BY MEANS ( PICTURE GALL]IES1 POPUL> CONC]TS1 & 
LIBR>IES71 ! WORK+ MAN 7TO ! EXT5T TO :I* HE IS A 
LABOR]1 & HAS NOT BEGUN TO PASS 9TO ! RANKS ( ?OSE 
P]V]T$ BY IDL5ESS7 W\LD BE ABLE TO MAKE NO?+ ( \R 
F9E >T1 & IF HE DID UND]/& IT1 ?AT :I* HE UND]/OOD 
#g#bW\LD NOT ELEVATE HIS S\L1 BUT W\LD C]TA9LY1 9 
MO/ CASES1 P]V]T IT4 ,TO ?\<TFUL & S9C]E PEOPLE 
!RE CAN !RE=E BE NO D\BT ?AT ! >T ( \R UPP] 
CLASSES NEV] CAN BE ! >T ( ! :OLE PEOPLE4 ,BUT IF >T 
IS AN IMPORTANT MATT]1 A SPIRITUAL BLESS+1 ESS5TIAL = 
ALL M5 70LIKE RELIGION10 AS ! DEVOTEES ( >T >E FOND ( 
SAY+71 !N IT %\LD BE ACCESSIBLE TO EV]YONE4 ,& IF1 AS 
9 \R DAY1 IT IS NOT ACCESSIBLE TO ALL M51 !N ONE ( TWO 
?+S3 EI!R >T IS NOT ! VITAL MATT] IT IS REPRES5T$ 
TO BE1 OR ?AT >T :I* WE CALL >T IS NOT ! REAL ?+4 

,! DILEMMA IS 9EVITABLE1 & !RE=E CLEV] & 
IMMORAL PEOPLE AVOID IT BY D5Y+ ONE SIDE ( IT1 VIZ4 
D5Y+ ?AT ! COMMON PEOPLE HAVE A RI<T TO >T4 ,!SE 
PEOPLE SIMPLY & BOLDLY SPEAK \T 7:AT LIES AT ! HE>T 
( ! MATT]71 & SAY ?AT ! P>TICIPATORS 9 & UTILIZ]S 
( :AT 9 !IR E/EEM IS HI<LY BEAUTIFUL >T1 I4E4 >T 
FURNI%+ ! GREATE/ 5JOYM5T1 CAN ONLY BE 0S*ONE 
,GEI/]10 0! ELECT10 AS ! ROMANTICI/S CALL$ !M1 ! 
0,UEB]M5S*510 AS !Y >E CALL$ BY ! FOLL[]S ( 
,NIETZS*E2 ! REMA9+ VULG> H]D1 9CAPABLE ( EXP]I5C+ 
!SE PLEASURES1 MU/ S]VE ! EXALT$ PLEASURES 
( ?IS SUP]IOR BRE$ ( PEOPLE4 ,! PEOPLE :O EXPRESS 
!SE VIEWS AT LEA/ DO NOT PRET5D & DO NOT TRY TO COMB9E 
! 9COMB9ABLE1 BUT FRANKLY ADMIT1 :AT IS ! CASE1 
?AT \R >T IS AN >T ( ! UPP] CLASSES ONLY4 ,SO1 
ESS5TIALLY1 >T HAS BE51 & IS1 UND]/OOD BY EV]YONE 
5GAG$ ON IT 9 \R SOCIETY4 

,FROM 3 ,GUT5B]G4ORG4 

,*RONOLOGY 3 
,NOVEMB] #c1 #ahif 3 ,*APT] #h -- ,PUBLICATION4 

 FILE G5]AT$ FROM 3  
HTTP3_/_/REVOLTLIB4COM_/