,*APT] #ab ,( ! ,LIB]TY ( ,HUMAN ,ACTIONS #ahcaahca ,PEOPLE 3 ,AU?OR 3 ,WILLIAM ,GODW9 ,TEXT 3 ,E,S,S,A,Y ,X,I,I ,( ,! ,L,I,B,],T,Y ,( ,H,U,M,A,N ,A,C,T,I,O,N,S4 ,! QUE/ION1 :I* HAS BE5 ATT5D$ ) SO LONG & OB/9ATE DEBATES1 CONC]N+ ! METAPHYSICAL DOCTR9ES ( LIB]TY & NECESSITY1 & ! FRE$OM ( HUMAN ACTIONS1 IS NOT EV5 YET F9ALLY & SATISFACTORILY SETTL$4 ,! NEGATIVE IS MADE \T BY AN >GUM5T :I* SEEMS TO AM\NT TO DEMON/RATION1 ?AT EV]Y EV5T REQUIRES A CAUSE1 A CAUSE :Y IT IS AS IT IS & NOT O!RWISE1 ?AT ! HUMAN WILL IS GUID$ BY MOTIVES1 & IS CONSEQU5TLY ALWAYS RUL$ BY ! /RONGE/ MOTIVE1 & ?AT WE CAN NEV] *OOSE ANY ?+1 EI!R )\T A MOTIVE ( PREF]5CE1 OR 9 ! WAY ( FOLL[+ ! WEAK]1 & DES]T+ ! /RONG] MOTIVE#a4 ,:Y IS IT !N ?AT DISBELIEF OR D\BT %\LD /ILL SUBSI/ 9 A QUE/ION SO FULLY DECID$8 ,= ! SAME REASON ?AT COMPELS US TO REJECT MANY O!R DEMON/RATIONS4 ,! HUMAN M9D IS SO CON/ITUT$ AS TO OBLIGE US1 IF NOT !ORETICALLY1 AT LEA/ PRACTICALLY1 TO REJECT DEMON/RATION1 & ADH]E TO \R S5SES4 ,! CASE IS ?US 9 ! GREAT QUE/ION ( ! NONEXI/5CE ( AN EXT]NAL WORLD1 OR ( MATT]4 ,H[ EV] MU* ! UND]/&+ MAY BE SATISFI$ ( ! TRU? ( ! PROPOSITION BY ! >GUM5TS ( ,B]KELEY & O!RS1 WE NO SOON] GO \T 9TO ACTUAL LIFE1 ?AN WE BECOME CONV9C$1 9 SPITE ( \R PREVI\S SKEPTICISM OR UNBELIEF1 ( ! REAL EXI/5CE ( ! TABLE1 ! *AIR1 & ! OBJECTS >\ND US1 & ( ! P]MAN5CE & REALITY ( ! P]SONS1 BO? BODY & M9D1 ) :OM WE HAVE 9T]C\RSE4 ,IF WE W]E NOT1 WE %\LD SOON BECOME 9DIFF]5T TO !IR PLEASURE & PA91 & 9 NO LONG TIME REASON \RSELVES 9TO ! OP9ION ?AT ! ONE WAS NOT MORE DESIRABLE ?AN ! O!R1 & CONDUCT \RSELVES ACCORD+LY4 ,BUT !RE IS A GREAT DIFF]5CE BETWE5 ! QUE/ION ( A MAT]IAL WORLD1 & ! QUE/ION ( LIB]TY & NECESSITY4 ,! MO/ /R5U\S ,B]KLEIAN CAN NEV] SAY1 ?AT !RE IS ANY CONTRADICTION OR IMPOSSIBILITY 9 ! EXI/5CE ( MATT]4 ,ALL ?AT HE CAN CONSI/5TLY & SOB]LY MA9TA9 IS1 ?AT1 IF ! MAT]IAL WORLD EXI/S1 WE CAN NEV] P]CEIVE IT1 & ?AT \R S5SATIONS1 & TRA9S ( IMPRESSIONS & ?9K+ GO ON :OLLY 9DEP5D5T ( ?AT EXI/5CE4 ,BUT ! QUE/ION ( ! FRE$OM ( HUMAN ACTIONS IS TOTALLY ( ANO!R CLASS4 ,TO SAY ?AT 9 \R *OICE WE REJECT ! /RONG] MOTIVE1 & ?AT WE *OOSE A ?+ M]ELY BECAUSE WE *OOSE IT1 IS %E] NONS5SE & ABSURDITY2 & :OEV] ) A S\ND UND]/&+ WILL FIX HIS M9D UPON ! /ATE ( ! QUE/ION WILL P]CEIVE ITS IMPOSSIBILITY4 ,9 ! MEAN TIME IT IS NOT LESS TRUE1 ?AT EV]Y MAN1 ! NECESS>IAN AS WELL AS HIS OPPON5T1 ACTS ON ! ASSUMPTION ( HUMAN LIB]TY1 & CAN NEV] = A MOM5T1 :5 HE 5T]S 9TO ! SC5ES ( REAL LIFE1 DIVE/ HIMSELF ( ?IS P]SUASION4 ,LET US TAKE SEP>ATELY 9TO \R CONSID]ATION ! LAWS ( MATT] & ( M9D4 ,WE ACKN[L$GE G5]ALLY 9 BO? AN E/ABLI%$ ORD] ( ANTEC$5TS & CONSEQU5TS1 OR ( CAUSES & EFFECTS4 ,?IS IS ! SOLE F\NDATION ( HUMAN PRUD5CE & ( ALL MORALITY4 ,IT IS BECAUSE WE =ESEE ?AT C]TA9 EFFECTS WILL FOLL[ FROM A C]TA9 MODE ( CONDUCT1 ?AT WE ACT 9 ONE WAY RA!R ?AN ANO!R4 ,IT IS BECAUSE WE =ESEE ?AT1 IF ! SOIL IS PREP>$ 9 A C]TA9 WAY1 & IF SE$ IS PROP]LY SCATT]$ & COV]$ UP 9 ! SOIL ?US PREP>$1 A CROP WILL FOLL[1 ?AT WE 5GAGE 9 ! LABORS ( AGRICULTURE4 ,9 ! SAME MANN]1 IT IS BECAUSE WE =ESEE ?AT1 IF LESSONS >E PROP]LY GIV51 & A Y\NG P]SON HAS !M CLE>LY EXPLA9$ TO HIM1 C]TA9 B5EFITS WILL RESULT1 & BECAUSE WE >E APPRIZ$ ( ! OP]ATION ( P]SUASION1 ADMONITION1 REMON/RANCE1 M5ACE1 PUNI%M5T & REW>D1 ?AT WE 5GAGE 9 ! LABORS ( $UCATION4 ,ALL ! /UDIES ( ! NATURAL PHILOSOPH] & ! *EMI/1 ALL \R J\RNEYS BY L& & \R VOYAGES BY SEA1 & ALL ! SY/EMS & SCI5CE ( GOV]NM5T1 >E BUILT UPON ?IS PR9CIPLE1 ?AT FROM A C]TA9 ME?OD ( PROCE$+1 REGULAT$ BY ! PRECEPTS ( WISDOM & EXP]I5CE1 C]TA9 EFFECTS MAY BE EXPECT$ TO FOLL[4 ,YET1 AT ! SAME TIME ?AT WE ADMIT ( A REGUL> S]IES ( CAUSE & EFFECT 9 ! OP]ATIONS BO? ( MATT] & M9D1 WE NEV] FAIL1 9 \R REFLECTIONS UPON EA*1 TO ASCRIBE TO !M AN ESS5TIAL DIFF]5CE4 ,9 ! LAWS BY :I* A FALL+ BODY DESC5DS TO ! E>?1 & BY :I* ! PLANETS >E RETA9$ 9 !IR ORBITS1 9 A WORD1 9 ALL ?AT RELATES TO 9ANIMATE NATURE1 WE READILY ASS5T TO ! EXI/5CE ( ABSOLUTE LAWS1 SO ?AT1 :5 WE HAVE ONCE ASC]TA9$ ! FUNDAM5TAL PR9CIPLES ( A/RONOMY & PHYSICS1 WE RELY ) P]FECT ASSURANCE UPON ! 9V>IABLE OP]ATION ( !SE LAWS1 YE/]DAY1 TO-DAY1 & = EV]4 ,AS LONG AS ! SY/EM ( ?+S1 ( :I* WE >E SPECTATORS1 & 9 :I* WE ACT \R SEV]AL P>TS1 %ALL REMA91 SO LONG HAVE ! G5]AL PH5OM5A ( NATURE GONE ON UN*ANG$ = MORE YE>S ( PA/ AGES ?AN WE CAN DEF9E1 & WILL 9 ALL PROBABILITY CONT9UE TO OP]ATE = AS MANY AGES TO COME4 ,WE ADMIT ( NO V>IATION1 BUT FIRMLY BELIEVE ?AT1 IF WE W]E P]FECTLY ACQUA9T$ ) ALL ! CAUSES1 WE C\LD1 )\T DANG] ( ]ROR1 PR$ICT ALL ! EFFECTS4 ,WE >E SATISFI$ ?AT1 S9CE FIR/ ! MA*9E ( ! UNIV]SE WAS SET GO+1 EV]Y ?+ 9 9ANIMATE NATURE HAS TAK5 PLACE 9 A REGUL> C\RSE1 & NO?+ HAS HAPP5$ & CAN HAPP51 O!RWISE ?AN AS IT ACTUALLY HAS BE5 & WILL BE4 ,BUT WE BELIEVE1 OR1 MORE ACCURATELY SPEAK+1 WE FEEL1 ?AT IT IS O!RWISE 9 ! UNIV]SE ( M9D4 ,:OEV] ATT5TIVELY OBS]VES ! PH5OM5A ( ?9K+ & S5TI5T BE+S1 WILL BE CONV9C$1 ?AT M5 & ANIMALS >E UND] ! 9FLU5CE ( MOTIVES1 ?AT WE >E SUBJECT TO ! PR$OM9ANCE ( ! PASSIONS1 ( LOVE & HATR$1 ( DESIRE & AV]SION1 ( SORR[ & JOY1 & ?AT ! ELECTIONS WE MAKE >E REGULAT$ BY IMPRESSIONS SUPPLI$ TO US BY !SE PASSIONS4 ,BUT WE >E FULLY P5ETRAT$ ) ! NOTION1 ?AT M9D IS AN >BIT]1 ?AT IT SITS ON ITS ?RONE1 & DECIDES1 AS AN ABSOLUTE PR9CE1 ?IS MAY OR ?AT2 9 %ORT1 ?AT1 :ILE 9ANIMATE NATURE PROCE$S PASSIVELY 9 AN ET]NAL *A9 ( CAUSE & EFFECT1 M9D IS 5D[$ ) AN 9ITIAT+ P[]1 & =MS ITS DET]M9ATIONS BY AN 9H]5T & 9DEFEASIBLE PR]OGATIVE4 ,H5CE >ISES ! IDEA ( CONT+5CY RELATIVE TO ! ACTS ( LIV+ & S5TI5T BE+S1 & ! OP9ION ?AT1 :ILE1 9 ! UNIV]SE ( MATT]1 EV]Y ?+ PROCE$S 9 REGUL> C\RSE1 & NO?+ HAS HAPP5$ OR CAN HAPP51 O!RWISE ?AN AS IT ACTUALLY HAS BE5 OR WILL BE1 9 ! DET]M9ATIONS & ACTS ( LIV+ BE+S EA* OCCURR5CE MAY BE OR NOT BE1 & WAITS ! MA/]Y ( M9D TO DECIDE :E!R ! EV5T %ALL BE ONE WAY OR ! O!R1 BO? ISSUES BE+ EQUALLY POSSIBLE TILL ?AT DECISION HAS BE5 MADE4 ,?US1 AS WAS SAID 9 ! BEG9N+1 WE HAVE DEMON/RATION1 ALL ! P[]S ( \R REASON+ FACULTY1 ON ONE SIDE1 & ! FEEL+1 ( \R M9DS1 AN 9W>D P]SUASION ( :I* ) ALL \R EF=TS WE CAN NEV] DIVE/ \RSELVES1 ON ! O!R4 ,?IS PH5OM5ON 9 ! HI/ORY ( EV]Y HUMAN CREATURE1 HAD APTLY 5\< BE5 D5OM9AT$1 ! 0DELUSIVE S5SE ( LIB]TY#b40 ,&1 ?\< ! PHILOSOPH] 9 HIS CLOSET WILL = ! MO/ P>T FULLY ASS5T TO ! DOCTR9E ( ! NECESSITY ( HUMAN ACTIONS1 YET ?IS 9DE/RUCTIBLE FEEL+ ( LIB]TY1 :I* ACCOMPANIES US FROM ! CRADLE TO ! GRAVE1 IS 5TITL$ TO \R S]I\S ATT5TION1 & HAS NEV] OBTA9$ ?AT CONSID]ATION FROM ! SPECULATIVE P>T ( MANK9D1 :I* MU/ BY NO MEANS BE )HELD1 IF WE W\LD PROP]LY 5T] 9TO ! MY/]IES ( \R NATURE4 ,! NECESS>IAN HAS PAID IT V]Y IMP]FECT ATT5TION TO ! IMPULSES :I* =M ! *>ACT] ( MAN1 IF HE OMITS ?IS *APT] 9 ! HI/ORY ( M9D1 :ILE ON ! O!R H& ! ADVOCATE ( FREE WILL1 IF HE W\LD FOLL[ UP HIS DOCTR9E RIGOR\SLY 9TO ALL ITS CONSEQU5CES1 W\LD R5D] ALL SPECULATIONS ON HUMAN *>ACT] & CONDUCT SUP]FLU\S1 PUT AN 5D TO ! SY/EM ( P]SUASION1 ADMONITION1 REMON/RANCE1 M5ACE1 PUNI%M5T & REW>D1 ANNIHILATE ! V]Y ESS5CE ( CIVIL GOV]NM5T1 & BR+ TO A CLOSE ALL DI/9CTION BETWE5 ! SANE P]SON & ! MANIAC4 ,) ! DISCIPLES ( ! LATT] ( !SE DOCTR9ES ,I AM BY NO MEANS SPECIALLY CONC]N$4 ,I AM FULLY P]SUAD$1 AS F> AS ! P[]S ( MY UND]/&+ CAN C>RY ME1 ?AT ! PH5OM5A ( M9D >E GOV]N$ BY LAWS ALTOGE!R AS 9EVITABLE AS ! PH5OM5A ( MATT]1 & ?AT ! DECISIONS ( \R WILL >E ALWAYS 9 OB$I5CE TO ! IMPULSE ( ! /RONGE/ MOTIVE4 ,! CONSEQU5CES ( ! PR9CIPLE IMPLANT$ 9 \R NATURE1 BY :I* M5 ( EV]Y CRE$1 :5 !Y DESC5D 9TO ! SC5E ( BUSY LIFE1 PRON\NCE !MSELVES & !IR FELL[-MORTALS TO BE FREE AG5TS1 >E SUFFICI5TLY MEMORABLE4 ,FROM H5CE !RE SPR+S :AT WE CALL CONSCI5CE 9 MAN1 & A S5SE ( PRAISE OR BLAME DUE TO \RSELVES & O!RS = ! ACTIONS WE P]=M4 ,H[ POOR1 LI/LESS & UN5]GETIC W\LD ALL \R P]=MANCES BE1 BUT = ?IS S5TIM5T6 ,IT IS 9 VA9 ?AT ,I %\LD TALK TO MYSELF OR O!RS1 ( ! NECESSITY ( HUMAN ACTIONS1 ( ! CONNECTION BETWE5 CAUSE & EFFECT1 ?AT ALL 9DU/RY1 /UDY & M5TAL DISCIPL9E WILL TURN TO ACC\NT1 & ?IS ) 9F9ITELY MORE SECURITY ON ! PR9CIPLE ( NECESSITY1 ?AN ON ! OPPOSITE DOCTR9E1 EV]Y ?+ ,I DID W\LD BE )\T A S\L4 ,I %\LD /ILL SAY1 ,:ATEV] ,I MAY DO1 :E!R IT BE RIGEM5T ( ! HE>T1 ! GLORY SP>KL+ 9 ! EYE1 & ! BLOOD FLU%+ 9TO ! *EEK1 ?AT SU/A9S ME 9 ALL MY LABORS4 ,?IS TURNS ! MAN 9TO :AT WE CONCEIVE ( A ,GOD1 >MS HIM ) PR[ESS1 GIVES HIM A MORE ?AN HUMAN C\RAGE1 & 9SPIRES HIM ) A RESOLUTION & P]SEV]ANCE ?AT NO?+ CAN SUBDUE4 ,9 ! SAME MANN] ! LOVE OR HATR$1 AFFECTION OR ALI5ATION1 WE 5T]TA9 = \R FELL[-M51 IS MA9LY REF]ABLE = ITS F\NDATION TO ! 0DELUSIVE S5SE ( LIB]TY40 0,WE APPROVE ( A %>P KNIFE RA!R ?AN A BLUNT ONE1 BECAUSE ITS CAPACITY IS GREAT]4 ,WE APPROVE ( ITS BE+ EMPLOY$ 9 C>V+ FOOD1 RA!R ?AN 9 MAIM+ M5 OR O!R ANIMALS1 BECAUSE ?AT APPLICATION ( ITS CAPACITY IS PREF]ABLE4 ,BUT ALL APPROBATION OR PREF]5CE IS RELATIVE TO UTILITY OR G5]AL GOOD4 ,A KNIFE IS AS CAPABLE AS A MAN1 ( BE+ EMPLOY$ 9 PURPOSES ( UTILITY2 & ! ONE IS NO MORE FREE ?AN ! O!R AS TO ITS EMPLOYM5T4 ,! MODE 9 :I* A KNIFE IS MADE SUBS]VI5T TO !SE PURPOSES1 IS BY MAT]IAL IMPULSE4 ,! MODE 9 :I* A MAN IS MADE SUBS]VI5T1 IS BY 9DUCEM5T & P]SUASION4 ,BUT BO? >E EQUALLY ! AFFAIR ( NECESSITY#c40 ,!SE >E ! S5TIM5TS DICTAT$ TO US BY ! DOCTR9E ( ! NECESSITY ( HUMAN ACTIONS4 ,BUT H[ DIFF]5T >E ! FEEL+S ?AT >ISE )9 US1 AS SOON AS WE 5T] 9TO ! SOCIETY ( \R FELL[-CREATURES6 0,! 5D ( ! COMM&M5T IS LOVE40 ,IT IS ! GO+ =? ( ! HE>T T[>DS ?OSE TO :OM WE >E B\ND BY ! TIES ( A COMMON NATURE1 AFF9ITY1 SYMPA?Y OR WOR?1 ?AT IS ! LUM9>Y ( ! MORAL WORLD4 ,)\T IT !RE W\LD HAVE BE5 0A HUGE ECLIPSE ( SUN & MOON20 OR AT BE/1 AS A WELL-KN[N WRIT]#d EXPRESSES IT 9 REF]5CE TO ANO!R SUBJECT1 WE %\LD HAVE LIV$ 9 0A SIL5T & DRAB-COLOR$ CREATION40 ,WE >E PREP>$ BY ! P[] ?AT MADE US = FEEL+S & EMOTIONS2 &1 UNLESS !SE COME TO DIV]SIFY & ELEVATE \R EXI/5CE1 WE %\LD WA/E \R DAYS 9 MELAN*OLY1 & SC>CELY BE ABLE TO SU/A9 \RSELVES4 ,! AFFECTION WE 5T]TA9 = ?OSE T[>DS :OM \R P>TIALITY & K9DNESS >E EXCIT$1 IS ! LIFE ( \R LIFE4 ,IT IS TO ?IS WE >E 9DEBT$ = ALL \R REF9EM5T1 &1 9 ! NOBLE/ S5SE ( ! WORD1 = ALL \R HUMANITY4 ,)\T IT WE %\LD HAVE HAD NO S5TIM5T 7A WORD1 H[EV] ABUS$1 :I*1 :5 PROP]LY DEF9$1 COMPRISES EV]Y ?+ ?AT IS ! CR[N ( \R NATURE71 & NO POETRY4--,LOVE & HATR$1 AS !Y REG>D \R FELL[-CREATURES1 9 CONTRADI/9CTION TO ! COMPLAC5CY1 OR ! FEEL+ ( AN OPPOSITE NATURE1 :I* IS EXCIT$ 9 US T[>DS 9ANIMATE OBJECTS1 >C 5TIRELY ! (FSPR+ ( ! DELUSIVE S5SE ( LIB]TY4 ,! T]MS1 PRAISE & BLAME1 EXPRESS TO A GREAT DEGREE ! SAME S5TIM5TS AS ?OSE ( LOVE & HATR$1 ) ?IS DIFF]5CE1 ?AT PRAISE & BLAME 9 !IR SIMPLE/ S5SE APPLY TO S+LE ACTIONS1 :]EAS LOVE & HATR$ >E PRODUC$ 9 US BY ! SUM ( ?OSE ACTIONS OR T5D5CIES1 :I* CON/ITUTE :AT WE CALL *>ACT]4 ,!RE IS ALSO ANO!R DIFF]5CE1 ?AT LOVE & HATR$ >E 5G5D]$ 9 US BY O!R CAUSES AS WELL AS MORAL QUALITIES2 BUT PRAISE & BLAME1 9 ! S5SE 9 :I* !Y >E PECULI>LY APPLI$ TO \R FELL[-MORTALS1 >E F\ND$ ON MORAL QUALITIES ONLY4 ,9 LOVE & HATR$ H[EV]1 :5 !Y >E 9T5SE OR >E LA/+1 SOME REF]5CE TO MORAL QUALITIES IS P]HAPS NECESS>ILY IMPLI$4 ,! LOVE BETWE5 ! SEXES1 UNLESS 9 CASES :]E IT IS ( A PECULI>LY TRANSI5T NATURE1 ALWAYS COMPRISES 9 IT A BELIEF ?AT ! P>TY :O IS ! OBJECT ( \R LOVE1 IS DI/+UI%$ BY T5D5CIES ( AN AMIABLE NATURE1 :I* WE EXPECT TO SEE MANIFE/+ !MSELVES 9 AFFECTIONATE ATT5TIONS & ACTS ( K9DNESS4 ,EV5 ! ADMIRATION WE 5T]TA9 = ! FEATURES1 ! FIGURE1 & P]SONAL GRACES ( ! OBJECT ( \R REG>D1 IS MIX$ ) & HEIE IMPELL$ BY ! CONSID]ATION1 0,HE ALSO IS A MAN AS WELL AS ,I10 ! EXCITEM5T WILL C>RY US BUT A LITTLE WAY1 UNLESS WE DISCOV] 9 ! BE+ T[>DS :OM WE >E MOV$ SOME PECULI>ITIES :I* MAY BEGET A MORAL P>TIALITY & REG>D4 ,&1 AS T[>DS \R FELL[-CREATURES1 SO 9 RELATION TO \RSELVES1 \R MORAL S5TIM5TS >E ALL 9VOLV$ )1 & TAKE !IR RISE 91 ! DELUSIVE S5SE ( LIB]TY4 ,IT IS 9 ?IS ?AT IS CONTA9$ ! PECULI> =CE ( ! T]MS VIRTUE1 DUTY1 GUILT & DES]T4 ,WE NEV] PRON\NCE !SE WORDS )\T ?9K+ ( ! ACTION TO :I* !Y REF]1 AS ?AT :I* MIE L$ TO OBS]VE UPON ?OSE QUALITIES1 & ! EXHIBITION ( ?OSE QUALITIES 9 ACTUAL LIFE1 :I* CON/ITUTE \R NATURE1 IS A MAN :O1 BE+ 9 FULL POSSESSION ( ! FRE$OM ( HUMAN ACTION1 IS 5GAG$ 9 DO+ ?OSE ?+S :I* A S\ND JUDGM5T ( ! T5D5CIES ( :AT WE DO PRON\NCES TO BE GOOD4 ,DUTY IS A T]M ?AT CAN SC>CELY BE SAID TO HAVE A MEAN+1 EXCEPT ?AT :I* IT D]IVES FROM ! DELUSIVE S5SE ( LIB]TY4 ,ACCORD+ TO ! CRE$ ( ! NECESS>IAN1 IT EXPRESSES ?AT MODE ( ACTION ON ! P>T ( ! 9DIVIDUAL1 :I* CON/ITUTES ! BE/ POSSIBLE APPLICATION ( HIS CAPACITY TO ! G5]AL B5EFIT#e4 ,9 ! MEAN TIME1 IF WE CONF9E \RSELVES TO ?IS DEF9ITION1 IT MAY AS WELL BE TAK5 TO DESCRIBE ! BE/ APPLICATION ( A KNIFE1 OR ANY O!R IMPLEM5T PROCE$+ FROM ! H&S ( ! MANUFACTUR]1 AS ( ! P[]S ( A HUMAN BE+4 ,BUT WE SURELY HAVE A V]Y DIFF]5T IDEA 9 \R M9DS1 :5 WE EMPLOY ! T]M DUTY4 ,IT IS NOT AGREEABLE TO ! USE ( LANGUAGE ?AT WE %\LD USE ?IS T]M1 EXCEPT WE SPEAK ( A BE+ 9 ! EX]CISE ( VOLITION4 ,DUTY !N MEANS ?AT :I* MAY JU/LY BE REQUIR$ ( A HUMAN CREATURE 9 ! POSSESSION ( LIB]TY ( ACTION4 ,IT 9CLUDES 9 ITS PROP] S5SE ! CONCEPTION ( ! EMPIRE ( WILL1 ! NOTION ?AT M9D IS AN >BIT]1 ?AT IT SITS ON ITS ?RONE1 & DECIDES1 AS AN ABSOLUTE PR9CE1 ?IS WAY OR ?AT4 ,DUTY IS ! P]=MANCE ( :AT IS DUE1 ! DIS*>GE ( A DEBT 7DEBITUM74 ,BUT A KNIFE [ES NO?+1 & CAN 9 NO S5SE BE SAID TO BE HELD TO ONE SORT ( APPLICATION RA!R ?AN ANO!R2 ! DEBT CAN ONLY BELONG TO A HUMAN BE+ 9 POSSESSION ( HIS LIB]TY1 BY :OM ! KNIFE MAY BE APPLI$ LAUDABLY OR O!RWISE4 ,A MULTITUDE ( T]MS 9/ANTLY OCCUR TO US1 ! APPLICATION ( :I* IS LIMIT$ 9 ! SAME MANN] AS ! T]M DUTY IS LIMIT$3 SU* >E1 TO [E1 OBLIGATION1 DEBT1 BOND1 RID & PUNI%M5T1 H[EV] !Y MAY BE 9TELLIGIBLE :5 US$ M]ELY 9 ! S5SE ( MOTIVES EMPLOY$1 HAVE 9 G5]AL ACCEPTATION A S5SE PECULI>LY D]IV$ FROM ! SUPPOS$ FRE$OM ( ! HUMAN WILL4 ,! MODE !RE=E 9 :I* ! ADVOCATES ( ! DOCTR9E ( NECESSITY HAVE UNIV]SALLY TALK$ & WRITT51 IS ONE ( ! MO/ MEMORABLE EXAMPLES ( ! HALLUC9ATION ( ! HUMAN 9TELLECT4 ,!Y HAVE AT ALL TIMES RECOMM5D$ ?AT WE %\LD TRANSLATE ! PHRASES 9 :I* WE USUALLY EXPRESS \RSELVES ON ! HYPO!SIS ( LIB]TY1 9TO ! PHRASEOLOGY ( NECESSITY1 ?AT WE %\LD TALK NO O!R LANGUAGE ?AN ?AT :I* IS 9 CORRESPOND5CE ) ! SEV]E/ PHILOSOPHY1 & ?AT WE %\LD EX]T \RSELVES TO EXPEL ALL FALLACI\S NOTIONS & DELUSIONS SO MU* AS FROM \R RECOLLECTION4 ,!Y DID NOT P]CEIVE :AT A WIDE DEVA/ATION & DE/RUCTION !Y W]E PROPOS+ ( ALL ! T]MS & PHRASES ?AT >E 9 USE 9 ! COMMUNICATIONS BETWE5 MAN & MAN 9 ACTUAL LIFE4--,!Y MI 9 M9D ON ! ORD9>Y OCCASIONS ( LIFE1 ?AT !RE IS NO SU* ?+ AS COLOR1 ?AT :I* WE ORD9>Y CALL BY ?AT NAME HAV+ NO EXI/5CE 9 EXT]NAL OBJECTS1 BUT BELONG+ ONLY TO \R WAY ( P]CEIV+ !M4 ,! LANGUAGE :I* IS SUGGE/$ TO US BY ! CONCEPTION ( ! FRE$OM ( HUMAN ACTIONS1 MOLDS ! V]Y FIR/ >TICULATIONS ( A *ILD1 0,I WILL10 & 0,I WILL NOT20 & IS EV5 DI/9CTLY CONVEY$ BY HIS GE/URES1 BE=E HE >RIVES AT ! P[] ( >TICULATION4 ,?IS IS ! EXPLANATION & KEY TO HIS VEHEM5T & UNGOV]NABLE MOVEM5TS1 & HIS REBELLION4 ,! PETULANCE ( ! /RIPL+1 ! F]V5T & 5]GETIC EX]TIONS ( ! W>RIOR1 & ! CALM & UNALT]ABLE RESOLUTION ( ! SAGE1 ALL IMPLY ! SAME ?+4 ,WILL1 & A CONFID5CE 9 ITS EFFICI5CY1 0TRAVEL ?R\<1 NOR QUIT US TILL WE DIE40 ,IT IS ?IS :I* 9SPIRES US ) 9V9CIBLE P]SEV]ANCE1 & H]OIC 5]GIES1 :ILE )\T IT WE %\LD BE ! MO/ 9]T & S\LLESS ( BLOCKS1 ! %AD[S ( :AT HI/ORY RECORDS & POETRY IMMORTALIZES1 & NOT M54 ,FREE WILL IS AN 9TEGRAL P>T ( ! SCI5CE ( MAN1 & MAY BE SAID TO CON/ITUTE ITS MO/ IMPORTANT *APT]4 ,WE MINE/ REFLECTION & EXPOSITION UPON ?AT PR9CIPLE :I* LIES AT ! F\NDATION ( \R MORAL 5]GIES1 FILLS US ) A MORAL 5?USIASM1 PROMPTS ALL \R ANIMAT$ EX]TIONS ON ! !AT] ( ! WORLD1 :E!R UPON A WIDE OR A N>R[ SCALE1 & P5ETRATES US ) ! MO/ LIVELY & F]V5T APPROBATION OR DISAPPROBATION ( ! ACTS ( \RSELVES & O!RS 9 :I* ! =W>D+ OR OB/RUCT+ HUMAN HAPP9ESS IS 9VOLV$4 ,BUT1 ?\< ! LANGUAGE ( ! NECESS>IAN IS AT W> ) ! 9DE/RUCTIBLE FEEL+S ( ! HUMAN M9D1 & ?\< HIS DEMON/RATIONS WILL = EV] CRUMBLE 9TO DU/1 :5 BR\G$ & DISPASSIONATE VIEWS ( ! NATURE ( MAN & ! LAWS ( ! UNIV]SE >E RAPIDLY SPREAD+ 9 ! WORLD4 ,WE CANNOT 9DE$ DIVE/ \RSELVES ( LOVE & HATR$1 ( ! S5TIM5TS ( PRAISE & BLAME1 & ! IDEAS ( VIRTUE1 DUTY1 OBLIGATION1 DEBT1 BOND1 RIG$1 BE BR\D$ AS ! M$IUM ONLY ?R\< ! 9T]V5TION ( :I* PREVI\SLY EXI/+ CAUSES >E 5ABL$ TO PRODUCE C]TA9 EFFECTS4 ,WE %ALL SEE1 ACCORD+ TO AN EXPRESSIVE PHRASE1 ?AT HE 0C\LD NOT HELP IT10 &1 ( CONSEQU5CE1 :ILE WE LOOK D[N FROM ! HI< T[] ( PHILOSOPHY UPON ! SC5E ( HUMAN AFFAIRS1 \R PREVAIL+ EMOTION WILL BE PITY1 EV5 T[>DS ! CRIM9AL1 :O1 FROM ! QUALITIES HE BR\I\S CIRCUM/ANCES :I* ACT UPON HIM FROM 9FANCY1 & =M HIS *>ACT]1 IS IMPELL$ TO BE ! MEANS ( ! EVILS1 :I* WE VIEW ) SO PR(\ND DISAPPROBATION1 & ! EXI/5CE ( :I* WE SO 5TIRELY REGRET4 ,!RE IS AN OLD AXIOM ( PHILOSOPHY1 :I* C\NSELS US TO 0?9K ) ! LE>N$1 & TALK ) ! VULG>20 & ! PRACTICAL APPLICATION ( ?IS AXIOM RUNS ?R\< ! :OLE SC5E ( HUMAN AFFAIRS4 ,?US ! MO/ LE>N$ A/RONOM] TALKS ( ! RIS+ & SETT+ ( ! SUN1 & =GETS 9 HIS ORD9>Y DISC\RSE ?AT ! E>? IS NOT = EV] AT RE/1 & DOES NOT CON/ITUTE ! C5T] ( ! UNIV]SE4 ,?US1 H[EV] WE REASON RESPECT+ ! ATTRIBUTES ( 9ANIMATE MATT] & ! NATURE ( S5SATION1 IT NEV] OCCURS TO US1 :5 OCCUPI$ ) ! AFFAIRS ( ACTUAL LIFE1 ?AT !RE IS NO HEAT 9 FIRE1 & NO COLOR 9 ! RA9B[4 ,9 LIKE MANN]1 :5 WE CONTEMPLATE ! ACTS ( \RSELVES & \R NEI$ 9 ! C\RSE ( ?IS ,ESSAY1 ?AT IT IS NOT DESIRABLE ?AT WE %\LD DO SO4 ,!Y >E !SE IDEAS TO :I* ! WORLD WE LIVE 9 IS 9DEBT$ = ITS CR[N+ GLORY & GREATE/ LU/]4 ,!Y =M ! HIE ! G5U9E BASIS ( SELF-REV]5CE1 & ! CONCEPTIONS ( TRUE NOBILITY & GREATNESS1 & ! REV]SE ( !SE ATTRIBUTES1 9 ! M5 ) :OM WE LIVE1 & ! M5 :OSE DE$S >E RECORD$ 9 ! NEV]-DY+ PAGE ( HI/ORY4 ,BUT1 ?\< ! DOCTR9E ( ! NECESSITY ( HUMAN ACTIONS CAN NEV] =M ! RULE ( \R 9T]C\RSE ) O!RS1 IT WILL /ILL HAVE ITS USE4 ,IT WILL MOD]ATE \R EXCESSES1 & PO9T \T TO US ?AT MIDDLE PA? ( JUDGM5T :I* ! S\NDE/ PHILOSOPHY 9CULCATES4 ,WE %ALL LE>N1 ACCORD+ TO ! APO/OLIC PRECEPT1 TO 0BE ANGRY1 & S9 NOT1 NEI!R LET ! SUN GO D[N UPON \R WRA?40 ,WE %ALL MAKE ( \R FELL[-M5 NEI!R IDOLS TO WOR%IP1 NOR DEMONS TO BE REG>D$ ) HORROR & EXECRATION4 ,WE %ALL ?9K ( !M1 AS ( PLAY]S1 0?AT /RUT & FRET !IR H\R UPON ! /AGE1 & !N >E HE>D NO MORE40 ,WE %ALL 0WEEP1 AS ?\< WE WEPT NOT1 & REJOICE1 AS ?\< WE REJOIC$ NOT1 SEE+ ?AT ! FA%ION ( ?IS WORLD PASSE? AWAY40 ,&1 MO/ ( ALL1 WE %ALL VIEW ) PITY1 EV5 ) SYMPA?Y1 ! M5 :OSE FRAILTIES WE BEHOLD1 OR BY :OM CRIMES >E P]PETRAT$1 SATISFI$ ?AT !Y >E P>TS ( ONE GREAT MA*9E1 &1 LIKE \RSELVES1 >E DRIV5 =W>D BY IMPULSES OV] :I* !Y HAVE NO REAL CONTROL4 ,F,O,O,T,N,O,T,E,S #a,POLITICAL ,JU/ICE1 ,BOOK ,I,V1 ,*AP4 ,V,I,I4 #b ,! FIR/ WRIT]1 BY :OM ?IS PROPOSITION WAS DI/9CTLY 5UNCIAT$1 SEEMS TO HAVE BE5 ,LORD ,KAIMES1 9 HIS ,ESSAYS ON ! ,PR9CIPLES ( ,MORALITY & ,NATURAL ,RELIGION1 PUBLI%$ 9 #a#g#e#a4 ,BUT ?IS +5I\S AU?OR WAS AFT]W>DS FRI*Y ,>*IVES4 ,*RONOLOGY 3 ,NOVEMB] #c1 #ahc 3 ,*APT] #ab -- ,PUBLICATION4 ,JANU>Y #b#h1 #bag 3 ,*APT] #ab -- ,ADD$4 FILE G5]AT$ FROM 3 HTTP3_/_/REVOLTLIB4COM_/