,! ,T>NAC ,V]DICTS3 ,UNRAVEL+ ! ,LOGIC ( ,ANTI-,T]RORISM 

,PEOPLE 3 

,AU?OR 3 ,CRIME?,9C4 

,TEXT 3 

,9 #b#h1 ! /ATE ( ,FRANCE ACCUS$ ! ,T>NAC ,T5 ( T]RORISM1 *>G+ ?AT !Y HAD =M$ 0A GR\P ( ! ULTRALEFT1 ( ! AUTONOM\S TYPE1 MA9TA9+ L9KS ) 9T]NATIONAL EXTREMI/ MOVEM5TS40.<#a.> ,AFT] A DECADE-LONG ORDEAL1 ! REMA9+ DEF5DANTS RECEIV$ !IR F9AL V]DICT ON ,APRIL #a#b1 #b#a#h4 

,ALL ( ! DEF5DANTS W]E F\ND NOT GUILTY ( ! *>GES ( SABOTAGE1 RIOT+1 & CONSPIRACY2 ! T]RORISM *>GES HAD BE5 DROPP$ MU* E>LI]4 ,*RI/OPHE ,BECK] WAS S5T5C$ TO SIX MON?S ( PROBATION = POSSESSION ( FAKE ,I,DS & A F9E ( #e EUROS = REFUSAL TO GIVE A ,D,N,A SAMPLE TO ! AU?ORITIES4 ,JULI5 ,C\PAT & ,YILDUNE ,LEVY W]E ALSO F\ND GUILTY ( REFUS+ TO GIVE ,D,N,A1 BUT FACE NO S5T5CE ON ACC\NT ( ! AM\NT ( TIME ?AT HAS PASS$4 ,CONSID]+ H[ MANY RES\RCES ! ,FR5* /ATE HAD 9VE/$ 9 ?IS C\RT CASE1 ?IS REPRES5T$ A MASSIVE VICTORY = ! DEF5DANTS4 

,:AT CAN WE LE>N FROM ?IS PASSAGE ( A FEW PEOPLE ?R\< A RA!R LONG TRIAL = T]RORISM8 ,LET'S REVIEW ! BACKGR\ND ( ?IS /ORY1 ! DETAILS ( ! CASE1 & ITS IMPLICATIONS = ! FUTURE4 

,ALL ! ,UNSETTL$ ,DEBTS ( ,HI/ORY 

  

,AS POPUL> MOVEM5TS >\ND ,EUROPE COLLAPS$ 9 ! #a#i#gS1 ANTI-IMP]IALI/ >M$ /RUGGLE GR\PS =M$--9CLUD+ ,ACTION ,DIRECTE 9 ,FRANCE & ! 9FAM\S ,R$ ,>MY ,FACTION 9 ,G]MANY4 ,TAK+ ON ! /ATE 9 SYMMETRICAL W>F>E PROV$ A DOOM$ V5TURE2 BY ! E>LY #a#i#iS1 ALL ?AT REMA9$ ( !SE GR\PS WAS ! REPRESSIVE APP>ATUS ?AT ! /ATE HAD G5]AT$ 9 ! C\RSE ( DE/ROY+ !M4 ,CAPITALISM APPE>$ TO HAVE P]MAN5TLY TRIUMPH$1 ) FEW SIGNS ( REVOLT VISIBLE )9 ! CORE C\NTRIES4 ,NONE!LESS1 9 ! ,UNIT$ ,/ATES & 9 ,FRANCE1 A FEW /RANGE Y\NG PEOPLE BEGAN READ+ ! ,SITUATIONI/S & PLOTT+ !IR ESCAPE FROM ! #b? C5TURY4 

,9 ! ,UNIT$ ,/ATES1 ! MID-#a#i#iS SAW ! EM]G5CE ( ! ,CRIME?,9C EX-,WORK]S ,COLLECTIVE1 A DEC5TRALIZ$ NETWORK ( ASPIR+ REVOLUTION>Y DROP\TS1 :OSE PUBLICATION ( ,DAYS ( ,W>1 ,NI<TS ( ,LOVE UPTURN$ TRADITIONAL REVOLUTION>Y DOGMA4 ,ACROSS ! OCEAN1 A MY/]I\S REVIEW ( 0CRITICAL METAPHYSICS0 CALL$ ,TIQQUN APPE>$1 ADVOCAT+ = ! =MATION ( A ,SOCIETY = ! ,ADVANCEM5T ( ,CRIM9AL ,SCI5CE1 REPURPOS+ ! CONCEPTS ( ?9K]S LIKE ,DELEUZE & ,F\CAULT :O HAD LONG BE5 NEUTRALIZ$ BY ACADEMIA4 

,%ORTLY !REAFT]1 TO EV]YONE'S SURPRISE1 ! SO-CALL$ ANTI-GLOBALIZATION MOVEM5T PRECIPITAT$ ! FI]CE/ CLA%ES ,EUROPE HAD SE5 9 DECADES4 ,9 ,FRANCE1 9 ! WAKE ( ! PROTE/S AGA9/ ! ,G#h SUMMIT 9 #b#a1 A MY/]I\S ANONYM\S TEXT 5TITL$ ,! ,CALL APPE>$1 DEM&+ 0A NEW K9D ( 9T]NATIONAL ?AT WILL NOT MAKE ! SAME MI/AKES AS ! OLD40 

,9 FALL #b#e1 AHEAD ( ! GLOBAL WAVE ( UPRIS+S ?AT W]E TO BEG9 ) ! ,GREEK 9SURRECTION1 ,FRANCE EXP]I5C$ AN \TBREAK ( RIOTS 9 ! BANLIEUES FOLL[$ BY A P[]FUL /UD5T MOVEM5T AGA9/ ! ,CONTRAT PREMI]E EMBAU*E 7,C,P,E74 ,9 #b#g1 ! ,9VISIBLE ,COMMITTEE'S ,L'9SURRECTION QUI VI5T TOOK ! ,FR5* RADICAL MILIEU BY /ORM MU* AS ,DAYS ( ,W>1 ,NI<TS ( ,LOVE HAD TAK5 ! ,NOR? ,AM]ICAN MILIEU4 ,9 ! SEV5 YE>S ?AT SEP>AT$ !SE TWO BOOKS1 REBELLION HAD ACQUIR$ A %>P] $GE3 TO GO 9TO EXODUS NO LONG] MEANT SIMPLY )DRAW+ FROM ! FE$BACK LOOPS ?AT REPRODUCE 9DU/RIAL CAPITALISM1 BUT 5T]+ 9TO OP5 BATTLE4 

,:5 REVOLUTION>Y IDEAS SPREAD RAPIDLY ?R\<\T SOCIETY1 ?OSE :OSE TASK IT IS TO PRES]VE ! PREVAIL+ ORD] GET N]V\S4 ,IT APPE>S ?AT ! ,FR5* /ATE DECID$ TO EMPLOY ! SAME /RATEGY ( REPRESSION ?AT HAD BE5 SO EFFECTIVE AGA9/ >M$ /RUGGLE GR\PS 9 ! #a#i#gS AGA9/ !SE NEW AN>*I/-9SPIR$ MOVEM5TS4 ,! MORE FLUID /RUCTURE ( AN>*I/IC NETWORKS MADE IT MORE DIFFICULT = ! /ATE TO DET]M9E ! PRECISE MEMB]%IP & LEAD]%IP ( !SE GR\PS1 BUT NO?+ IS IMPOSSIBLE = ! AU?ORITIES IF !Y >E PREP>$ TO BE DI%ONE/ 5\<4 ,9 #b#h1 POLICE & 9TELLIG5CE S]VICES C>RI$ \T ONE ( ! L>GE/ ANTI-T]RORISM OP]ATIONS EV] COORD9AT$ ON ,FR5* SOIL4 ,! ,FR5* ANTI-T]RORI/ POLICE 7,S,D,A,T7 >RE/$ N9E Y\NG PEOPLE1 !N ADD$ ANO!R = GOOD MEASURE4 ,9T]IOR ,M9I/] ,MI*ELE ,ALLIOT-,M>IE DECL>$ VICTORY1 PROCLAIM+ ?AT ! 09N] CIRCLE0 ( ! ,9VISIBLE ,COMMITTEE WAS N[ >RE/$ & !IR HEAD1 ,JULI5 ,C\PAT 7A =M] ASSOCIATE ( ,TIQQUN71 HAD BE5 CUT (F ! BODY4 ,IF ONLY IT W]E SO EASY TO SUPPRESS REVOLT6 

,T5 YE>S LAT]1 :AT SEEM$ IMPOSSIBLE HAS ALREADY COME TO PASS4 ,IT IS WIDELY AGRE$ ?AT CAPITALISM IS 9 A /ATE ( T]M9AL COLLAPSE2 PROPOSITIONS ?AT SEEM$ \TRAGE\S 9 ! LATE #a#i#iS >E N[ REG>D$ AS SELF-EVID5T4 ,ON ,APRIL #a#b1 #b#a#h1 ! NO-LONG]-QUITE-SO-Y\NG PEOPLE ACCUS$ ( =M+ A CONSPIRACY TO OV]?R[ CAPITALISM HE>D !IR F9AL V]DICT = BE+1 LIT]ALLY1 0AN ASSOCIATION ( WRONGDO]S40.<#b.> 

,! ,BRITI% ,UND]COV] ,9SIDE ! ,ANTI-,GLOBALIZATION ,MOVEM5T 

  

,:5 WE ORGANIZE DEMON/RATIONS1 DISCUSS AN>*I/ !ORY1 & COMMIT \RSELVES TO DIRECT ACTION1 IT CAN BE EASY TO FEEL ?AT \R 9DIVIDUAL EF=TS HAVE LITTLE EFFECT4 ,BUT ! ,T>NAC CASE CONFIRMS ?AT ! HEADMA/]S ( GLOBAL CAPITALISM TAKE V]Y S]I\SLY ! POSSIBILITY ?AT \R ACTIONS--& EV5 \R WORDS--CAN *ANGE ! WORLD4 

,AT ! ,G#h C\NT]-SUMMIT 9 #b#a1 ! CONFRONTATIONS 9 ! /REETS ( ,G5OA REA*$ SU* A PIT* ?AT ! ,ITALIAN POLICE OP5LY MURD]$ A P>TICIPANT 9 ! BLACK BLOC1 ,C>LIO ,GIULIANI4 ,9 ORD] TO PREV5T SU* REVOLTS FROM OCCURR+ AGA91 ,EUROPEAN GOV]NM5TS E/ABLI%$ NEW AGREEM5TS AB\T %>+ 9TELLIG5CE & DEPLOY$ LONG-T]M UND]COV] AG5TS 9TO ! AN>*I/ MOVEM5T ) ! GOAL ( DISABL+ 9T]NATIONAL ANTI-CAPITALI/ PROTE/S4 

,! ,BRITI% 9TELLIG5CE S]VICE HAD BE5 9FILTRAT+ RADICAL CIRCLES S9CE AT LEA/ ! #a#i#fS1 BUT ! 9FLUX ( PEOPLE NEWLY CURI\S AB\T RESI/ANCE GAVE !M A NEW OPPORTUNITY4 ,A LON<AIR$ & TATTOO$ RADICAL CALL+ HIMSELF 0,M>K ,/ONE0 %[$ UP AT ! #bc ,E,U ,SUMMIT PROTE/S 9 ,DUBL91 TAK+ ! FRONT L9ES AGA9/ ! POLICE4 ,HIS REAL NAME WAS ,M>K ,K5N$Y2 HE WAS AN UND]COV] POLICE (FIC] FROM ! ,NATIONAL ,PUBLIC ,ORD] ,9TELLIG5CE ,UNIT S5T TO 9FILTRATE ! AN>*I/ W+ ( ! ANTI-GLOBALIZATION & ECOLOGICAL MOVEM5TS4 

,A COMP>ATIVE AN?ROPOLOGICAL /UDY ( ! POLICE ( DIFF]5T NATIONS W\LD BE REVEAL+4 ,POLICE 9FILTRATORS 9 ! ,UNIT$ ,/ATES SET \T TO GET IMM$IATE RESULTS BY 5TRAPP+ PROTE/]S & *>G+ PROTE/ ORGANIZ]S SU* AS ! ,R,N,C #h ( 0,CONSPIRACY TO ,RIOT 9 ,FUR!RANCE ( ,T]RORISM40 ,BY CONTRA/1 ,BRITI% 9TELLIG5CE1 DRAW+ ON !IR EXP]I5CES ) ! ,IRI% ,REPUBLICAN ,>MY 7,I,R,A71 US$ UND]COV] POLICE (FIC]S OV] A LONG P]IOD ( TIME TO MAP ! SOCIAL NETWORKS ?AT MOBILIZ$ ! ANTI-GLOBALIZATION & ECOLOGICAL PROTE/S >\ND ,E>? ,FIR/6 9 ! ,U,K4 

,ALL ! UND]COV] COPS 9 ! WORLD CANNOT /OP A PROTE/ :OSE TIME HAS COME3 ,M>K ,K5N$Y & HIS H&L]S FAIL$ TO PREV5T ! ,G#h PROTE/S 9 ,GREAT ,BRITA91 AS WE DESCRIB$ 9 0,CAN'T ,/OP ! ,*AOS40 ,:ILE ,M>K ,K5N$Y FOCUS$ ! ATT5TION ( ! ,LONDON ,METROPOLITAN ,POLICE ON >RE/+ ! ,W,O,M,B,L,E,S AT A PUB 9 ,GLASG[1 HE COMPLETELY MISS$ ! PRIM>ILY ,G]MAN BLACK BLOC ?AT EM]G$ TO WRECK HAVOC FROM A SEEM+LY ECO-HIPPIE CAMP \TSIDE ,/IRL+4 ,TO PREV5T ?IS FROM RECURR+ 9 ! FUTURE1 HE WAS ORD]$ TO 9FILTRATE ! 9FAM\S 0,G]MAN ,AUTONOM50 ?AT W]E TO BE KEY 9 ! #bg ,G#h 9 ,HEILIGDAMM1 ,G]MANY4 ,AFT] GA9+ ! TRU/ ( ! NOTORI\SLY SECURITY-CONSCI\S ,G]MAN AN>*I/S BY BURN+ A C>1 HIS ATT5TION TURN$ TO A GR\P ( ,FR5* REVOLUTION>IES1 9CLUD+ ,JULI5 ,C\PAT1 A P>TICIPANT 9 ,TIQQUN4 

,9 ,JANU>Y #b#h1 ,M>K ,K5N$Y %[$ UP 9 ,NEW ,YORK ,CITY AT AN 9T]NATIONAL DISCUSSION ON ! FUTURE ( SOCIAL MOVEM5TS4 ,HIS T>GETS W]E ,JULI5 ,C\PAT & ,YILDUNE ,LEVY4 ,!SE DISCUSSIONS FOCUS$ PRIM>ILY ON H[ TO GO AB\T OCCUPY+ SOCIAL SPACE1 AN OBVI\S NECESSITY 9 ,NEW ,YORK ,CITY ?AT PREFIGUR$ _?OCCUPY4 ,AT ! SAME TIME1 ,JAPANESE 9TELLECTUALS >RIV$ 9 ,NEW ,YORK ,CITY :O W]E 9T]E/$ 9 ORGANIZ+ AN ANTI-GLOBALIZATION PROTE/ AT ! ,G#h 9 ,JAPAN4 ,M>K ,K5N$Y 5ROLL$ ! ,F,B,I TO HELP HIM KEEP TABS ON ,JULI5 & ,YILDUNE4 

,BAS$ ON A TELEVIS$ /ATEM5T FROM ! ,NEW ,YORK ,CITY ,*IEF ( ,POLICE1 IT APPE>S ?AT POLICE ?\<T ?AT ,JULI5 & ,YILDUNE MI<T HAVE BE5 CONNECT$ TO ! 0,TIMES ,SQU>E ,BICYCLE ,BOMB+10 BUT AS IT TURN$ \T1 NEI!R ( !M W]E 9 ! ,U,S AT ! TIME ( ! ATTACK4 ,! FOLL[+ YE>1 RAIDS ON A H\SE BELONG+ TO ,NEW ,YORK ,CITY AN>*I/S TURN$ UP NO USEFUL EVID5CE4 ,EV5 ! ,F,B,I EV5TUALLY LO/ 9T]E/4 

,MEAN:ILE1 ! ,FR5* POLICE1 TOO1 W]E DESC5D+ 9TO A /ATE ( P>ANOIA1 AS ! #baa ,G#h WAS SLAT$ = ,DEAUVILLE1 ,FRANCE & ! AU?ORITIES W]E T]RIFI$ ( A MASSIVE BLACK BLOC TAK+ ! /REETS4 ,! ,FR5* POLICE SET !IR SI<TS ON A GR\P ( Y\NG PEOPLE :O HAD E/ABLI%$ A COMMUNE 9 ! REMOTE VILLAGE ( ,T>NAC.<#c.> AS ! LOCUS ( A SUBV]SIVE VIRUS ?AT HAD ! POT5TIAL TO SPREAD ?R\<\T ALL ( ,FRANCE4 

,! ,ANTI-,T]RORI/ ,POLICE ,/RIKE 

  

,LIKE AN OLD K+ 9 A ,%AKESPE>E PLAY1 ! /ATE WAS T]RIFI$ ( ITS [N DOOM4 ,ALA9 ,BAU]1 =EMO/ !ORETICIAN ( ! SECURITY APP>ATUS1 DISCOV]$ ,! ,COM+ ,9SURRECTION & MAIL$ #d COPIES ( IT TO POLICE =CES1 CLAIM+ ?AT ! BOOK REPRES5T$ ! REEM]G5CE ( ! LEFT-W+ >M$ /RUGGLE GR\PS ?AT ! POLICE ?\<T !Y HAD DEFEAT$ 9 #a#i#gS4 ,PRESID5T ,S>KOZY HAD COMB9$ ! =EIGN-FAC+ ANTI-T]RORI/ GR\P1 ! ,D,/ 7,DIRECTION DE LA ,SURVEILLANCE DU ,T]RITOIRE71 & ! 9T]NAL ,R5SEIGNEM5TS G5]AUX TOGE!R 9TO A S+LE NEW 9TELLIG5CE AG5CY1 ,D,C,R,I 7,DIRECTION C5TRALE DU R5SEIGNEM5T 9T]IEUR74 ,9SIDE ?IS NEW WORD SALAD1 ! TWO AG5CIES DETE/$ EA* O!R & BEGAN JOCKEY+ = P[]4 ,9 ORD] = ,R5SEIGNEM5TS G5]AUX TO BE TAK5 S]I\SLY1 !Y HAD TO PROVE ?AT !RE WAS 9DE$ A S]I\S ?REAT TO ! 9T]NAL /ABILITY ( ,FRANCE4 

,! ,FR5* /ATE DECID$ ?AT ! DEBUT P>TY ( ! NEW ,FR5* ,F,B,I1 ! ,D,C,R,I1 W\LD BE TO ELIM9ATE !IR NEW 0AN>*O-AUTONOM\S0 T]ROR CELL4 ,! ,D,C,R,I PREP>$ = ! ,S,D,A,T 7,S\S-DIRECTION ANTI-T]RORI/E7 TO C>RY \T >RE/S ?R\<\T ,FRANCE ON ,NOVEMB] #a#a1 #b#h4 

,! EXCUSE ! /ATE PUT =W>D WAS ?AT CO-ORD9AT$ SABOTAGE HAD TAK5 PLACE ALONG F\R L9ES ( ! ,FR5* NATIONAL ,S,N,C,F TRA9 SY/EM ON ! EV5+ ( ,NOVEMB] #g1 UTILIZ+ A TE*NIQUE FROM ! ,G]MAN AUTONOM\S MOVEM5T 9 :I* ! SABOTEUR PLACES AN IRON CLAW ON ! ELECTRICAL L9ES ( ! RAILWAY SO ?AT ! CLAW 0UNPLUGS0 ! ELECTRICITY ( ! TRA94 ,! PURPORT$ SABOTAGE OCCURR$ ON ! DAY ?AT ! 9FAM\S ,CA/] NUCLE> TRA9S C>RI$ NUCLE> WA/E FROM ,FRANCE TO BE DUMP$ 9 ,WE/]N ,G]MANY4 ,LOCAL F>M]S & V>I\S ,G]MAN MOVEM5TS HAVE PROTE/$ !SE NUCLE> WA/E TRANSPORTS = DECADES4 ,! SAME EV5+ ?AT ! TRA9 L9ES 9 ,FRANCE W]E %UT D[N1 A COMMUNIQUE 9 ,G]MAN WAS S5T TO NEWSPAP]S CLAIM+ ! ANTI-NUCLE> ACTION4 

,! ,FR5* POLICE CLAIM ?AT !Y HAD #ah POLICE (FIC]S FOLL[+ ,JULI5 ,C\PAT & ,YILDUNE ,LEVY ON ,NOVEMB] #g1 />T+ AT #a AM4 ,! SURVEILLANCE WAS HEAVY-H&$2 FRU/RAT$ AT ! OPPRESSIVE ATMOSPH]E CREAT$ BY !IR POLICE ESCORTS1 ! TWO LEFT ,P>IS 9 HOPES ( GETT+ SOME TIME TO !MSELVES4 ,!RE FOLL[$ A CAT & M\SE GAME AS ! Y\NG C\PLE TRI$ TO LOSE ! POLICE :O W]E TAIL+ !M4 ,!Y /OPP$ TO EAT A PIZZA1 !N TRI$ TO F9D A HOTEL ROOM1 BUT ALL ! HOTELS W]E FULL4 ,!Y DECID$ TO SLEEP 9 !IR C> = A LITTLE :ILE1 !N DROVE BACK TO ,P>IS4 

,9 ,R\51 9 ! REGION ( ,NORM&Y1 ! POLICE W]E MONITOR+ WELL-KN[N COLLECTIVE H\SES & NOTIC$ ?AT ,MAT?IEU ,BURNEL1 ,>IA ,?OMAS1 ,B]TR& ,DEVEAUX1 & ,ELSA ,HAUCK HAD MY/]I\SLY LEFT !IR H\SE ON ! EV5+ ( ,NOVEMB] #g AS WELL4 ,B5JAM9 ,ROS\X1 ,MANON ,GLIB]T1 & ,GABRIELLE ,HALLEZ W]E ALSO HASSL$ BY ! POLICE :ILE SLEEP+ 9 !IR C> ON ,NOVEMB] #g4 

,?REE DAYS LAT]1 ON ,NOVEMB] #a#a1 ANTI-T]RORI/ POLICE /ORM$ ,T>NAC 9 AN OP]ATION 9VOLV+ HELICOPT]S & HUNDR$S ( POLICE4 ,!Y >RE/$ ,JULI51 ,MANON1 ,GABRIELLE1 & ,B5JAM92 A SIMIL> OP]ATION SEIZ$ ,MAT?IEU1 ,>IA1 ,ELSA1 & ,B]TR& 9 !IR COLLECTIVE H\SES 9 ,R\54 ,YILDUNE WAS >RE/$ 9 ,P>IS4 ,M9I/] ( ! ,9T]IOR ,MI*ELE ,ALLIOT-,M>IE TOOK ! /AGE TO DECL>E VICTORY TO ! M$IA1 ANN\NC+ ?AT ! POLICE HAD /OPP$ A T]RORI/ CELL ?AT WAS PREP>+ TO VIOL5TLY OV]?R[ ! /ATE4 

,! ,T>NAC ,N9E W]E ACCUS$ ( BE+ P>T ( AN ASSOCIATION ( WRONGDO]S 9 RELATION%IP ) A T]RORI/ 5T]PRISE 7ASSOCATION DE MALFAITEURS 5 RELATION%IP AVEC UN 5T]PRISE T]RORI/E74 ,! EQUIVAL5T 9 ,AM]ICAN OR ,BRITI% LAW W\LD BE A CONSPIRACY *>GE ) T]RORI/ 5HANCEM5TS4 ,! NUMB] ( DEF5DANTS WAS EXP&$ TO T5 AFT] ! >RE/ ( ,*RI/OPHE ,BECK] 9 ,T>NAC = CREAT+ DOCUM5TS F\ND ON ,MANON ,GLIB]T'S COMPUT]1 :I* HAD BE5 SEIZ$ 9 A H\SE RAID4 

,! /ATE ?\<T IT WAS F9ALLY SAFE1 & YET NO AM\NT ( UND]COV] POLICE & PREEMPTIVE >RE/S CAN UPHOLD A DY+ ORD] = LONG4 

,! ,9SURRECTION ,>RIVES 

  

0,EV]YBODY KN[S IT'S AB\T TO EXPLODE60 *ANT$ OCCUPI]S AT AN IMPROMPTU RELEASE P>TY 9 ,B>NES & ,NOBLE = ! ,5GLI% TRANSLATION ( ,! ,COM+ ,9SURRECTION 9 ,NEW ,YORK ,CITY4.<#d.> ,& EXPLODE IT DID4 ,AS ! ANTI-T]RORI/ OP]ATION WAS R\ND+ UP ! SUPPOS$ MA/]M9DS ( A NEW T]RORI/ NETWORK ?R\<\T ,FRANCE1 ! F9ANCIAL CRISIS ( #bh PIT*$ ! WORLD 9TO GLOBAL CRISIS1 UND]SCOR+ ?AT ! GREATE/ RISK TO HUMANITY IS NOT ?OSE :O ?REAT5 ! SY/EM1 BUT ! SY/EM ITSELF4 ,AS HATR$ ( ! BANK+ SY/EM 9CREAS$1 RIOTS SPREAD ?R\<\T ,EUROPE LIKE FLAMES FROM A ,MOLOTOV COCKTAIL4 ,AL?\< !RE WAS NO 9T]NATIONAL B>B>IAN HORDE TO TE> D[N ! GATES ( ! ,G#h AT ,DEAUVILLE1 IT WAS BECAUSE NO ONE BESIDES ! POLICE EV5 C>$3 ! ,G#h WAS CLE>LY IMPOT5T 9 ! FACE ( G5]ALIZ$ F9ANCIAL MELTD[N & 9CREAS+LY DEC5TRALIZ$ UNRE/4 

,MEAN:ILE1 ! ,T>NAC DEF5DANTS W]E IMPRISON$ AS POLITICAL CRIM9ALS & T]RORI/S4 ,SOME >RE/EES W]E RELEAS$ QUICKLY1 :ILE O!RS W]E JAIL$ = MON?S4 ,! ACCUS$ 0*IEF ( ! T]RORI/ 5T]PRISE10 ,JULI5 ,C\PAT1 WAS HELD ! LONGE/1 SP5D+ OV] SIX MON?S 9 JAIL BE=E PUBLIC \TCRY OV] ! EM]G+ WEAKNESS ( ! CASE F9ALLY =C$ ! AU?ORITIES TO RELEASE HIM4 ,?IS REFLECT$ ! *ALL5GES ( BR++ T]RORISM *>GES AGA9/ Y\NG :ITE PEOPLE3 IT IS LIKELY ?AT A ,MUSLIM *>G$ ) T]RORISM 9 ?OSE DAYS W\LD HAVE REMA9$ 9 JAIL = MU* LONG]4 

,UNEXPECT$ FRI5D%IPS BLOSSOM$ DUR+ ! DEF5DANTS' IMPRISONM5T2 ,B5JAM9 ,ROS\X BEFRI5D$ ,MAKA ,KANTE FROM ! BANLIEUE ( ,VILLI]S-LE-,BEL1 :O WAS ACCUS$ ( %OOT+ AT ! POLICE DUR+ ! CLA%ES ( ,NOVEMB] #b#e-#b#f1 #b#g4 ,VILLI]S-LE-,BEL HAD ]UPT$ 9TO OP5 9SURRECTION AGA9/ ! POLICE AFT] (FIC]S MURD]$ TWO Y\NG LOCALS4 ,DESPITE !IR DIFF]5CES1 ! 0AN>*O-AUTONOM\S0 >RE/EE FROM A MIDDLE-CLASS FAMILY 9 ,BRITTANY & ! SECOND-G5]ATION ,AFRICAN IMMIGRANT F\ND COMMON CAUSE3 0,N\S SAVONS QUE N\S SOMMES T\J\RS PLUS NOMBREUX1 DE T\S HORIZONS1 DET]M9ES A NE PAS LES LAISS] M>*] SUR NOS TETES40.<#e.> 

,ACROSS ! WORLD1 SOLID>ITY GR\PS W]E LAUN*$ FROM ,RUSSIA TO ! ,UNIT$ ,/ATES4 ,9 ,GREECE1 BESIDE AN (FICIAL ,FR5* ADM9I/RATIVE BUILD+ ?AT HAD BE5 ATTACK$ ) ,MOLOTOVS1 GRAFFITI APPE>$ READ+ 0,FROM ,T>NAC TO ,A!NS1 ! 9SURRECTION HAS >RIV$40 ,SALES ( ,! ,COM+ ,9SURRECTION SKYROCKET$ TO #h11 ) ! ,5GLI% TRANSLATION PROMPT+ RI<T-W+ RADIO-HO/ ,GL5N ,BECK TO /ATE ?AT IT WAS AN 0EVIL BOOK0 BUT 0IT'S IMPORTANT Y\ READ ?IS40 

,9 RESPONSE1 ! /ATE DID EV]Y?+ POSSIBLE TO ISOLATE ! ,T>NAC ,T5 FROM EA* O!R EV5 AFT] !Y W]E RELEAS$ FROM PRISON1 9/ITUT+ /RICT RULES ( NON-ASSOCIATION4 ,?IS CONTROLE JUDICI>E RE/RICT$ !IR MOVEM5TS TO A SMALL GEOGRAPHICAL >EA4 ,9 SOME WAYS1 IT IS MORE HUMILIAT+ & BOR+ TO BE KEPT UND] H\SE >RE/ AT Y\R P>5TS' ISOLAT$ RESID5CE ?AN TO BE KEPT 9 JAIL :]E Y\ CAN FRAT]NIZE ) O!R VICTIMS ( ! /ATE4 ,SOMEH[1 H[EV]1 ! IDEA ( ,T>NAC AS A COLLECTIVE POLITICAL PROJECT SURVIV$1 AS COMRADES FROM PLACES AS DI/ANT AS ,SWITZ]L& & ,ITALY MOV$ TO ! T9Y T[N TO KEEP ! ,MAGAS9 ,G5]AL OP54 .<#f.> 

,9 ,DECEMB] #b#i1 ! ,T>NAC ,T5 DECID$ TO WILLFULLY BREAK !IR NON-ASSOCIATION RULES1 ANN\NC+ 9 ,LE ,MONDE ?AT !Y W\LD NO LONG] ABIDE BY !M4 ,A LAWY] REPRES5T+ !M HAD (FICIALLY ASK$ ! ,C\RT ( ,APPEALS TO DROP ! *>GES RE/RICTIONS1 BUT !Y BOLDLY PO/$ !IR /ATEM5T TWO DAYS 9 ADVANCE4  
  

0,BUT :AT WE DES]T FIR/ IS ! ROLE ( PUBLIC 5EMY1 ?AT IS TO SAY1 BASICALLY1 ( VICTIM1 ?AT !Y WANT$ TO MAKE US PLAY4 ,&1 IF WE DES]T IT1 IT IS TO BE ABLE TO RESUME ! FI<T4 ',= ! FEEL+ ( HUNT$ GAME1 WE MU/ SUB/ITUTE ! 9ITIATIVE ( ! COMBATANT1' SAID ,GEORGES ,GU+\91 9 QUITE SIMIL> CIRCUM/ANCES40 

-,! ,T>NAC DEF5DANTS1 WRIT+ 9 ,LE ,MONDE  
  

,:ILE ,JULI51 ,B5JAM91 ,MANON1 & ,GABRIELLE RETURN$ TO ,T>NAC1 ! =CES ?AT HAD SET ! OP]ATION 9 MOTION W]E BEG9N+ TO FALL AP>T4 ,9 ,5GL&1 ,M>K ,K5N$Y'S ID5TITY AS AN UND]COV] POLICE (FIC] WAS REVEAL$ 9 #baa :5 HIS ACTIVI/ P>TN] DISCOV]$ HIS REAL PASSPORT & LAT] F\ND A BIR? C]TIFICATE ) ! FA!R'S PR(ESSION LI/$ AS 0POLICE (FIC]40 ,CONFRONT$ BY HIS OLD FRI5DS1 ,M>K ,K5N$Y CLAIM$ TO REP5T & EV5 (F]$ TO HELP ROLL BACK ! *>GES = PREVI\S C\RT CASES HE HAD BE5 9VOLV$ 94 ,!RE FOLL[$ A UNIQUELY ,5GLI% SEX SC&AL ?AT 5GULF$ ! ,LONDON ,METROPOLITAN POLICE & DISRUPT$ AN UND]COV] OP]ATION TO 9FILTRATE SOCIAL MOVEM5TS ?AT DAT$ BACK TO #a#i#f#h4 ,H[EV]1 ,M>K ,K5N$Y WAS NO FRI5D ( ! ,T>NAC ,T54 ,HE 9S9UAT$ ?AT /OPP+ !M JU/IFI$ HIS O!R LESS GLORI\S UND]COV] ACTIVITIES1 SU* AS SLEEP+ ) ACTIVI/S UND] HIS FALSE ID5TITY4 

,AS ! ,>AB ,SPR+ KICK$ (F 9 ! =M] ,FR5* COLONY ( ,TUNISIA1 ,M9I/] ,MI*ELE ,ALLIOT-,M>IE PROPOS$ ?AT ! SAME ANTI-9SURG5CY EXP]TIZE RESPONSIBLE = ! ,T>NAC >RE/S C\LD BE EXPORT$ TO ,TUNISIA--ALONG ) A LITTLE TE> GAS--TO HELP QUELL ! UNRE/4 ,:5 PUBLIC SYMPA?Y TURN$ 9 FAVOR ( ,>AB ,SPR+1 %E WAS =C$ TO RESIGN2 ,S>KOZY LO/ ! ,FR5* ELECTION 9 #bab TO ! ,SOCIALI/ ,FRANCOIS ,HOLL&E1 A DEPUTY FROM ,CORREZE1 ! ADM9I/RATIVE DIVISION ( ,FRANCE ?AT 9CLUDES ,T>NAC4 ,9 A /ATEM5T 5TITL$ 0,P>IS1 ,TEXAS10 ! ,T>NAC ,T5 WROTE ?AT ,S>KOZY %\LD RETURN TO HIS PAYMA/]S 9 ! ,UNIT$ ,/ATES 9 ! SAME MANN] ,MUB>AK DID :5 HE FL$ = ,SAUDI ,>ABIA DUR+ ! ,>AB ,SPR+3 0,MR4 ,PRESID5T1 !RE >E RAN*ES = SALE 9 ,TEXAS1 & Y\R PLANE IS WAIT+ = Y\ AT ! ,VILLAC\BLAY AIRPORT40 

,POLICE (FIC]S WORK$ !MSELVES 9TO A /ATE ( COMPLETE P>ANOIA4 ,*RI/IAN ,BI*ET1 ONE ( ! (FIC]S :O HAD BE5 SURVEILL+ ! ,T>NAC ,T5 S9CE AT LEA/ #b#g1 OP5$ NO LESS ?AN SEV5 DIFF]5T BLOGS P]SONALLY ATTACK+ !M4 ,! ATTACKS ( ?IS P>TICUL> DISAPPO9T$ 9TELLECTUAL-TURN$-POLICE (FIC] W]E SO V5OM\S ?AT !Y APPE>$ TO COME FROM DISAPPO9T$ EX-COMRADES FROM ! AN>*I/ MILIEU4 ,?IS POLICE (FIC] =M$ FAKE SUPPORT GR\PS 9 ORD] TO OBTA9 ! NAMES ( SUPPORT]S1 WROTE LETT]S ( SUPPORT TO ! REAL SUPPORT COMMITTEES1 & />T$ LEAK+ EVID5CE ( A GLOBAL CONSPIRACY TO NEWSPAP]S4 ,:5 HE WAS REVEAL$1 ,BI*ET WAS REMOV$ FROM HIS POSITION & DEMOT$ TO T5D ! POLICE >*IVES4 

,ONE ( ! *IEF WITNESSES = ! PROSECUTION1 A LOCAL F>M] :O HAD ACCUS$ ! DEF5DANTS ( BURN+ D[N UNEMPLOYM5T BUILD+S & TRA9+ = >M$ /RUGGLE1 NOT ONLY ADMITT$ TO HAV+ SIGN$ ! DEPOSITION ?AT 9CLUD$ !SE ALLEGATIONS UND] POLICE PRESSURE )\T READ+ IT1 BUT HE ALSO APPE>$ TO HAVE LO/ HIS SANITY4 ,9 AN UNRELAT$ CASE1 HE WAS *>G$ ) FABRICAT+ DEA? ?REATS AGA9/ HIMSELF1 AMONG O!R ?+S4 ,SO MU* = ?AT EVID5CE6 ,H[EV] D]ANG$ ! AU?ORITIES MAY MAKE REBELS \T TO BE1 Y\ CAN C\NT ON ORD9>Y PEOPLE TO BE /RANG]4 

,! 09VE/IGAT+ MAGI/RATE0.<#g.> ,?I]RY ,FRAGNOLI BEHAV$ LIKE A JILT$ LOV]4 ,AFT] ANN\NC+ TO A J\RNALI/ ?AT HE WANT$ TO BE PLAY$ BY ,BRAD ,PITT 9 A MOVIE AB\T ,T>NAC1 HE ORD]$ MORE H\SE RAIDS & >RE/S 9 ,R\5 9 HOPES ( TURN+ UP ACTUAL EVID5CE ( T]RORISM4 ,FRAGNOLI IMAG9$ ?AT ,*>LES ,TORRES1 A BLACKSMI? & ! GR&SON ( A ,SPANI% AN>*I/ VET]AN1 HAD MANUFACTUR$ ! IRON CLAW US$ TO %UT D[N ! TRA9 L9ES4 ,H[EV]1 DUR+ A H\SE RAID1 ! BLUND]+ ,FR5* POLICE ACCID5TALLY LEFT A DOSSI] CONTA9+ FILES ON EV]YONE !Y W]E SURVEILL+ 9 ,R\5 ON ! TABLE--ALONG ) ONE ( !IR POLICE PHONES1 :I* !Y HAD TO MEEKLY RETURN TO PICK UP6 ,:5 ! DOSSI] & P]SONAL EMAILS EXPRESS+ HIS VIRUL5T HATR$ ( ! DEF5DANTS W]E LEAK$ TO ! ,FR5* PRESS1 ,FRAGNOLI S5T A P>ANOID LETT] CLAIM+ ?AT A CONSPIRACY EXI/$ BETWE5 ! ,FR5* M$IA & ,JULI5'S ,JEWI% LAWY]1 ,J]EMIE ,ASS\S4 ,?IS LETT] WAS DULY PUBLI%$ 9 ! M$IA4 ,9 RESPONSE TO SUBSEQU5T PRESSURE1 ,FRAGNOLI QUIT ! CASE & WAS EFFECTIVELY ,LIMOG$#c TO A ,FR5* COLONY 9 ! ,PACIFIC1 ,PETITE-,ILE4 

,:ILE POLITICIANS1 POLICE (FIC]S1 WITNESSES1 & JUDGES /RUGGL$ ) 9COMPET5CE & DELUSIONS1 ! VILLAG]S ( ,T>NAC W]E AT FIR/ DIVID$ ON H[ TO RESPOND TO ! >RE/S4 ,ON ONE H&1 !IR QUIET RURAL LIVES HAD BE5 DISRUPT$ BY ! T]RORI/ RAIDS2 ON ! O!R H&1 ! Y\NG PEOPLE ?AT ! /ATE WAS T>GET+ W]E CLE>LY BR++ LIFE BACK TO ! LITTLE VILLAGE4 ,! T]RORISM TRIAL REVIV$ ! HI/ORICAL MEMORY ( ! OLD COMMUNI/ M\NTA9 F>M]S ( ,T>NAC1 :O HAD RESI/$ ! ,NAZI OCCUPATION & BORE MORE ?AN A PASS+ RESEMBLANCE TO ,JULI5 ,C\PAT4 ,AT ! LOCAL G5]AL /ORE1 ! CONV]SATION TURN$ TO ! TOPIC ( 0COLLABORATION0 AS ! VILLAG]S RECOGNIZ$ ! LAT5T FASCISM HID+ UND] 0ANTI-T]RORISM40 ,! V]Y EV5+ ( ! >RE/S1 A SOLID>ITY COMMITTEE =M$ 9 ,T>NAC1 E*O$ %ORTLY !REAFT] BY DOZ5S MORE SOLID>ITY GR\PS ACROSS ,FRANCE4 ,TOGE!R1 !Y BEGAN RAIS+ FUNDS & PUBLICLY SPEAK+ ON BEHALF ( ! >RE/EES4 

,BY & L>GE1 AN>*I/S &--MORE SURPRIS+LY--! BROAD] ,LEFT UNIT$ >\ND ,T>NAC4 ,BY #b#a#a1 ?IS SOLID>ITY HAD GIV5 ! DEF5DANTS SU* C\RAGE ?AT MANY ( !M PUBLICLY P>TICIPAT$ 9 A MASSIVE PUBLIC DIRECT ACTION TO /OP ! V]Y SAME ,CA/] NUCLE>-WA/E C>RY+ TRA9S ?AT !Y HAD BE5 ACCUS$ ( SABOTAG+ 9 #b#h4 ,SU* PUBLIC SUPPORT = AN ACTION ?AT HAD BE5 LABEL$ AS T]RORISM ONLY A FEW YE>S E>LI] HI<LI<T$ H[ ! CONTEXT 9 ,FRANCE HAD *ANG$ S9CE ! >RE/S4 ,:5 ! ,HOLL&E GOV]NM5T ATTEMPT$ TO PU% ?R\< ! CON/RUCTION ( AN AIRPORT NE> ,NANTES1 ECO-AN>*I/S SET UP ! AUTONOM\S ,Z,A,D 7,ZONE ,A ,DEF5DRE7 OCCUPY+ ! PROPOS$ SITE4 ,:5 ! ,FR5* /ATE S5T OV] TWO ?\S& POLICE TO EVICT !M 9 ! HIL>I\SLY MISNAM$ 0,OP]ATION ,CES>10 MORE ?AN =TY ?\S& PEOPLE %[$ UP FROM ALL WALKS ( LIFE 9 SUPPORT ( ! NEW B>B>IANS4 

,! ,T>NAC ,T5 CONT9U$ !IR PROCESS ( COLLECTIVE !ORIZATION1 REPAIR+ !IR RAID$ F>M AT ,G\TAILL\X 9 ORD] TO HO/ SEM9>S ON EV]Y?+ FROM FEM9ISM TO CYB]NETICS4 ,?IS HELP$ TO RE9VIGORATE ! ,FR5* AUTONOM\S MOVEM5T1 EV5TUALLY RESULT+ 9 ! FIR/ NEW BOOK FROM ! ,9VISIBLE ,COMMITTEE S9CE ! >RE/S1 ,TO ,\R ,FRI5DS1 :I* HAZ>D$ AN ANALYSIS ( ! 9SURRECTION>Y PROCESS AFT] #b#a#a4 ,IT WAS PUBLI%$ 9 #b#a#d1 NOT A MOM5T TOO LATE2 _?OCCUPY F9ALLY HIT ,FRANCE 9 ! =M ( ! ,NUIT ,DEB\T PROTE/S1 FOLL[$ BY MASSIVE BLACK BLOCS AT ! ANTI-AU/]ITY PROTE/S AGA9/ ! ,LOI DE ,TRAVAIL 9 #b#a#f4 ,!SE PROTE/S UND]M9$ :ATEV] REMA9+ CR$IBILITY ,PRESID5T ,HOLL&E POSSESS$1 LEAD+ TO ! HI/ORIC COLLAPSE ( BO? ! ,FR5* ,SOCIALI/ ,P>TY & ! RI<T-W+ ,LES ,REPUBLICA9S4 ,9 ! WAKE ( ?IS F9AL WAVE ( PROTE/S ?AT %OOK ,FRANCE TO ITS V]Y F\NDATIONS1 ! ,9VISIBLE ,COMMITTEE PUBLI%$ A NEW BOOK 9 #b#a#g1 ,MA9T5ANT4 ,F9ALLY 5T]+ ! 9T]NET ]A1 ASSOCIATES BEGAN PRODUC+ ON ONL9E NEWSPAP]1 LUNDI4AM4 

,AS ! ,FR5* /ATE CONT9U$ TO FACE ONE POPUL> UPRIS+ AFT] ANO!R1 ! *>GES ( 0T]RORISM0 SEEM$ 9CREAS+LY QUA9T4 ,SC&AL AFT] SC&AL HAD SAPP$ ! POLICE ( LEGITIMACY2 ! ILLEGAL 9VOLVEM5T ( ! ,BRITI% UND]COV] ,M>K ,K5N$Y C\LD NOT BE D5I$ :5 NOTES DETAIL+ HIS SURVEILLANCE ( ,JULI5 9 HIS H&WRIT+ W]E REVEAL$1 BY ACCID5T1 VIA C\RT DISCLOSURES 9 ! ,UNIT$ ,K+DOM4 ,AT ! SAME TIME1 ,FRANCE WAS ROCK$ BY ATTACKS C>RI$ \T BY FUNDAM5TALI/S AFFILIAT$ ) ! ,ISLAMIC ,/ATE4 ,?IS MADE ! TREM5D\S AM\NT ( RES\RCES ! /ATE HAD P\R$ 9TO TRY+ TO MAKE A 0T]RORI/0 M5ACE \T ( ! ULTRA-LEFT APPE> RIDICUL\S4 ,! NEW 9VE/IGAT+ MAGI/RATE1 NOT+ ! FATE ( H] PR$ECESSOR ,FRAGNOLI & ! POPUL>ITY ( ! ,T>NAC ,T51 DECID$ ?AT ! T]RORI/ *>GES W]E TO BE DROPP$4 

,! ORIG9AL *>GE WAS ESS5TIALLY T]RORI/ CONSPIRACY--SEEK+ 0TO SEV]ELY DI/URB PUBLIC ORD] ?R\< 9TIMIDATION OR T]ROR40 ,! ALLEG$ CRIME CONSI/$ ( TAK+ P>T 9 9T]NATIONAL MEET+S 9 ,G]MANY1 ! ,U,S1 & ,GREECE1 9CIT+ VIOL5CE AGA9/ POLICE (FIC]S & DE/RUCTION ( PROP]TY1 & DE/ROY+ TRA9 P[] L9ES4 ,! ANTI-T]RORI/ PROSECUTOR WAS DET]M9$ NOT TO LET ! N>RATIVE ( T]RORISM COLLAPSE1 & PRES5T$ APPEAL AFT] APPEAL AGA9/ ! DROPP+ ( ! T]ROR *>GES4 ,EV5TUALLY1 ! PROSECUTION TOOK ! ACCUSATION ( 0T]RORISM0 TO ! HI<E/ C\RT ( ,FRANCE1 ! C\RT DE CASSATION4 ,9 #b#a#e1 ! C\RT RUL$ ?AT ! *>GE ( A 0T]RORI/ 5T]PRISE0 WAS TO BE DROPP$1 BUT ?AT A CRIM9AL TRIAL )\T ! *>GE ( 0T]RORI/ 5HANCEM5T0 W\LD CONT9UE4 

,! ACCUS$ ( ,T>NAC W]E D[NGRAD$ FROM T]RORISM DEF5DANTS TO AN ASSOCIATION DE MALFAITEURS1 A *>GE 9TRODUC$ 9 #ahid = ! EXPRESS PURPOSE ( S5D+ AN>*I/S TO JAIL 9 ,FRANCE = SUPPORT+ DIRECT ACTION 9 NEWSPAP]S SU* AS L',AN>*IE EV5 IF NO O!R *>GES C\LD BE BR\<T AGA9/ !M4 ,)\T ! T]RORISM *>GE1 ! CASE WAS HELD TOGE!R BY ! B>E/ ( ?READS4 ,GABRIELLE ,HALLEZ & ,>IA ,?OMAS SAW !IR *>GES COMPLETELY DROPP$1 R$UC+ ! ,T>NAC ,T5 TO ! ,T>NAC ,EI<T4 

,MAT?IEU ,BURNEL & ,B5JAM9 ,ROS\X W]E *>G$ ) REFUS+ TO GIVE !IR ,D,N,A TO ! POLICE4 ,MANON ,GLIB]T & ,*RI/OPHE ,BECK] FAC$ *>GES = FAK+ DOCUM5TS4 ,B]TR& ,DEVEAUX & ,ELSA ,HAUCK REMA9$ *>G$ ) ASSOCIATION DE MALFAITEURS1 BUT NOT ON ACC\NT ( ! SABOTAGE1 :I* EV]YONE MA9TA9$ !Y HAD NO?+ TO DO )4 ,RA!R1 !Y W]E ACCUS$ ( P>TICIPAT+ 9 AN ANTI-FASCI/ DEMON/RATION AGA9/ AN ,E,U SUMMIT ON BLOCK+ IMMIGRATION ?AT WAS ORGANIZ$ 9 ,VI*Y--IRONICALLY1 DUR+ ! OCCUPATION1 ! SEAT ( ! COLLABORATIONI/ GOV]NM5T ?AT DEPORT$ ,JEWS & COMMUNI/S TO ,NAZI DEA? CAMPS4 ,ONLY ,YILDUNE ,LEVY & ,JULI5 ,C\PAT RETA9$ ! SABOTAGE *>GES & ! *>GES ( BE+ P>T ( AN ASSOCIATION DE MALFAITEURS4 ,JULI5 HAD BE5 DEMOT$ FROM BE+ ! *IEF ( A T]RORI/ CONSPIRACY TO A M]E ANIMATEUR1 DOVETAIL+ ) HIS CURR5T JOB AS P>T ( A !AT] GR\P4 

,! ATTEMPT TO 9TRODUCE ! LOGIC ( ANTI-T]RORISM HAD FAIL$4 ,! ,FR5* /ATE HAD TRI$ TO USE A MASSIVE M$IA OP]ATION TO CONV9CE ! PUBLIC ?AT ! 0AN>*O-AUTONOM\S0 MOVEM5T WAS A 0PRE-T]RORI/ ORGANIZATION0 9 #b#a#a1 BUT !Y W]E DEFEAT$ ON !IR [N T]RITORY4 ,! ,T>NAC ,T5 )/OOD ! PRESSURE & MANAG$ TO CONV9CE ! VA/ MAJORITY ( ! ,FR5* POPULATION ?AT AUTONOMY WAS NOT SYNONYM\S ) T]RORISM4 

,AT ! SAME TIME1 9 ! 5D1 ! PROSECUTION WAS ABLE TO AVAIL !MSELVES ( ALL ! SPECIAL RES\RCES RES]V$ = PURSU+ T]RORISM CASES TO T>GET :AT TURN$ \T TO BE A H&FUL ( P]FECTLY ORD9>Y ACTIVI/S4 ,ALL ! EVID5CE GA!R$ UND] ! AUSPICES ( 0FI<T+ T]RORISM0 WAS /ILL ADMISSIBLE 9 ! TRIAL4 ,! LEAD ANTI-T]RORI/ PROSECUTOR WAS /ILL PROSECUT+ ! CASE1 DESPITE ! M]ELY CRIM9AL NATURE ( ! TRIAL4 ,ABOVE ALL1 ! TREM5D\S1 DEBILITAT+ REPRESSION RES]V$ = T]RORISM CASES WAS DIRECT$ AT P>ALYZ+ ! DEF5DANTS & !IR COMMUNITIES4 ,?IS GIVES US A =ETA/E ( :AT WE CAN EXPECT FROM ! SECURITY APP>ATUS 9 ! FUTURE4 ,WE CAN SEE ?IS PROCESS SOME:AT FUR!R ALONG 9 ,RUSSIA & ,BRAZIL4 

,! 0,T>NAC ,PROCESS0 

  
  

0,BE=E ! JUDGES ( ! B\RGEOIS CLASS1 ! REVOLUTION>Y DOES NOT HAVE TO ACC\NT = HIS ACTS NOR DOES HE HAVE TO RESPECT ANY SO-CALL$ TRU? ( !IRS40 

-,VICTOR ,S]GE  
  

,9 EV]Y C\RT CASE1 !RE >E C]TA9 ROLES3 ! SOLEMN JUDGES1 ! DEF5DANTS PLEAD+ GUILTY OR 9NOC5T 7BUT ABOVE ALL1 PLEAD+71 & A WELL-PAID SUPPORT+ CA/ ( P>ASITES1 FROM LAWY]S TO J\RNALI/S1 :O /& TO PR(IT FROM ! CASE4 ,! 5TIRE PROC$URE REQUIRES EV]YONE TO PLAY BY ! RULES4 ,EV5 D5\NC+ ! 5TIRE JURIDICAL PROC$URE1 AS POPUL>IZ$ BY ,ALG]IAN REVOLUTION>IES & ILLEGALI/ AN>*I/S1.<#h.> HAS BECOME A =MALIZ$ P>T ( ! PROC$URE4 ,BUT :5 ! C\RT CASE OP5$ ON ,M>* #a#c1 #b#a#h1 IT BECAME CLE> ?AT ! DEF5DANTS W]E NOT PLAY+ ! GAME4 

,H[ MI<T ! ACCUS$ AVOID PLAY+ ! GAME ( ! /ATE8 ,P]HAPS1 FIR/1 BY TREAT+ ALL ! MEMB]S ( ! TRIAL1 9CLUD+ ! PROSECUTOR & ! JUDGE1 AS EV]YDAY PEOPLE3 LAU<+ :5 !Y SAY SOME?+ /UPID1 *ID+ !M :5 !Y =GET A KEY PO9T1 REFUS+ TO PUT !M ON A P$E/AL4 ,! JUDGE1 IRRITAT$1 DEM&$ ?AT ! DEF5DANTS EI!R D5\NCE ! C\RT OR CONT9UE 9 A RESPECTFUL MANN]3 0,Y\ >E FREE TO ADOPT A DEF5SE ( RUPTURE10 %E RAIL$1 0IT'S Y\R RI<T4 ,BUT IF Y\ DON'T WANT ?IS1 Y\ NE$ TO RESPECT ! C\RT40 ,! ,T>NAC DEF5DANTS REFUS$ EI!R APPROA*1 DISCUSS+ ! FACTS ( ! CASE 9 DETAIL BUT ACCORD+ ! POMP & CIRCUM/ANCE ( ! JUDICIAL SPH]E NO RESPECT4 ,! PROCE$+S RESEMBL$ A DECID$LY MORE PHILOSOPHICAL V]SION ( ! ,*ICAGO ,SEV5 TRIAL1 ) ! DEF5DANTS CON/ANTLY 9T]RUPT+ ! JUDGE1 ! POLICE1 ! LAWY]S1 & EA* O!R4 

,ANO!R WAY ! DEF5DANTS SUBV]T$ ! JU/ICE SY/EM WAS BY NEI!R D5Y+ ! *>GES NOR VALIDAT+ !M4 ,:ILE ! ACT ( SABOTAGE ITSELF WAS CLE>LY DEF5SIBLE AS AN ANTI-NUCLE> ECOLOGICAL MEASURE & ! ,FR5* C\RT ATTEMPT$ TO SUPPRESS ! FACT ?AT POLICE HAD RECEIV$ A COMMUNIQUE FROM ,G]MAN GR\PS CLAIM+ RESPONSIBILITY = IT1 ! DEF5DANTS NEV] D5\NC$ ! ACTION4 ,LIKEWISE1 ! PROSECUTOR %[$ PICTURE AFT] PICTURE ( ! ACCUS$ AT A DEMON/RATION 9 ,VI*Y AGA9/ ! OPPON5TS ( IMMIGRATION1 AT :I* !Y W]E ALLEG$ TO HAVE BR\<T ROPES TO PULL D[N ! F5C+ >\ND ! MEET+4 ,F9ALLY1 ,*RI/OPHE EM]G$ & NOT$ ?AT IT WAS RIDICUL\S TO QUE/ION ! DEF5DANTS AB\T A DEMON/RATION ?AT HAD TAK5 PLACE T5 YE>S E>LI]1 BUT ASS]T$ ?AT HE WAS PR\D TO HAVE P>TICIPAT$ 9 A DEMON/RATION = IMMIGRATION4 ,! 5TIRE C\RT BROKE 9TO APPLAUSE4 ,! DEF5DANTS NEV] RECANT$ ANY ( !IR ACTIONS BUT1 ONE BY ONE1 GAVE REASONS = !M4 ,JULI51 = EXAMPLE1 JU/IFI$ HIS ILLEGAL BORD] CROSS+ 9TO ! ,UNIT$ ,/ATES FROM ,CANADA AS A REFUSAL ( A FASCI/ BIOMETRIC SY/EM4 

,MORE IMPORTANTLY1 ! DEF5DANTS NEV] REFUS$ !IR CAUSE4 ,:ILE ! DEF5DANTS PROCLAIM$ !IR SUPPORT ( ! AUTONOM\S PROJECT ( ,T>NAC 9 PUBLIC1 ! POLICE & 9TELLIG5CE (FIC]S HID !IR ID5TITIES BEH9D MASKS1 REF]R$ TO BY NUMB]S RA!R ?AN NAMES4 

,! JUDGE ATTEMPT$ TO GO ?R\< ! FILE 9 *RONOLOGICAL ORD]4 ,%E HA/ILY PU%$ ?R\< ! FILES ON ,M>K ,K5N$Y & ! 9FAM\S TRIP ( ,JULI5 & ,YILDUNE ,LEVY TO ,NEW ,YORK ,CITY AFT] ,JULI5 OP5LY MOCK$ ,F,B,I REPORTS AB\T A ,NETWORK ( ,WORLDWIDE ,AN>*I/S 7,N,W,A74 ,EV5 9 ,FRANCE1 ,N,W,A S\NDS LIKE AN ACRONYM = A HIP-HOP B& OR WRE/+ F$]ATION2 ! DEF5DANTS TOOK ! OPPORTUNITY TO HOLD =? ON ! HI/ORY ( HIP HOP 9 ! ,U,S,A4 ,/ILL1 ! JUDGE REFUS$ TO ACKN[L$GE ! CRUCIAL ROLE PLAY$ BY ! 9TELLIG5CE ( ,M>K ,K5N$Y1 SEEK+ TO AVOID BLAM+ ! ,5GLI% SPY = ! 9ITIAL FRAME ( ANTI-T]RORISM4 

,AS ! TRIAL CONT9U$1 ! QUE/ION ( ! AU?OR%IP ( ,! ,COM+ ,9SURRECTION CAME UP AGA9 & AGA94 ,! BOOK /ATES ?AT1  
  

0,TO SABOTAGE ! SOCIAL MA*9E ) SOME CONSEQU5CE TODAY MEANS RECONQU]+ & RE9V5T+ ! MEANS ( 9T]RUPT+ ITS NETWORKS4 ,H[ C\LD A ,T,G,V .<HI< SPE$ TRA9.> L9E OR AN ELECTRICAL NETWORK BE R5D]$ USELESS80  
  

,?IS QUOTE WAS US$ AS EVID5CE TO DEMON/RATE CONCLUSIVELY ?AT !RE WAS A PLAN TO 0P>ALYZE0 ! CITY4 ,:ILE EXPRESS+ AGREEM5T ) ! CONT5TS ( ! BOOK1 ! DEF5DANTS NEV] ADMITT$ TO AU?OR+ ! TEXT4 ,/RANGELY1 ! *>GE ( ?\<TCRIME PREMIS$ ON AU?OR%IP ( ,! ,COM+ ,9SURRECTION HAD BE5 ! RAISON D'ETRE = ! T]RORI/ *>GES4 ,9 ! TIME S9CE ! *>GES HAD FIR/ BE5 PRESS$1 IT HAD BECOME ONE ( ! BE/-SELL+ POLITICAL BOOKS 9 ,FRANCE2 LEGIONS ( 9TELLECTUALS1 P>ANOID POLICE (FIC]S1 & J\RNALI/S HAD AGRE$ ?AT ! BOOK WAS ( HI< QUALITY4 ,! T]RORISM *>GES CREAT$ A P>ADOX = ?OSE :O WI%$ TO SEE !MSELVES AS ! DEF5D]S ( SOCIETY3 IF ! AU?ORS W]E T]RORI/S1 WAS ! POPUL>ITY ( ! BOOK A SIGN ( POPUL> SUPPORT = T]RORISM8 

,! C\RT EMB>K$ ON \TRI<T ,DADAISM :5 IT WAS DECID$ ?AT BO? ! POLICE & ! DEF5DANTS HAD TO RE5ACT ! ORIG9AL SABOTAGE4 ,AS IF ON A S*OOL FIELD TRIP1 ! JUDGE1 ! PROSECUTOR1 & ! DEF5DANTS RODE TOGE!R TO ,DHUISY 9 A BUS TO RE5ACT ! PURPORT$ SABOTAGE4 ,FIVE ANTI-T]RORI/ POLICE (FIC]S :O P>TICIPAT$ 9 ! TRIAL AS MASK$ ANONYM\S WITNESSES RODE ALONG 9 ONE ( ! #c POLICE C>S ?AT ESCORT$ ! BUS2 A POLICE HELICOPT] FLEW ALONG OV]HEAD ! :OLE DAY4 ,! POLICE & 9TELLIG5CE AG5CY WITNESSES HAD TO KEEP !IR MASKS ON ! 5TIRE TIME4 ,AS ! C\RT HAD TO V]IFY ELEM5TS ( ! POLICE TE/IMONY BO? 9 DAYLI<T & AT NI<T1 ! C\RT & ! DEF5DANTS HAD TO WAIT 9 A FE/IVAL HALL SURR\ND$ BY DOZ5S ( G5D>MES4 ,! DEF5DANTS ATE & DRANK W9E 9 ?IS SURREAL SITUATION :ILE ! ANTIT]RORI/ WITNESSES HAD TO /AY \TSIDE TO MA9TA9 !IR ANONYMITY4 ,:5 ! POLICE REAPPE>$ = ! LA/ V]IFICATION ( ! NI<T1 !Y COMPLA9$ TO ! JUDGE ?AT !Y C\LDN'T EAT4 ,! DEF5DANTS' LAWY]S ANSW]$ ?AT !RE MI<T BE SOME CRUMBS LEFT OV]1 H9T+ ?AT--9 A REV]SAL ( ! ORD9>Y RELATION BETWE5 REBELS & ! LACKEYS ( ! /ATE--!Y %\LD EAT ! DEF5DANTS' TRA%4 ,( C\RSE1 ! POLICE REFUS$ !IR JU/ DESS]TS4 

,AS ! TRIAL CLOS$1 ! JUDGE /RUGGL$ TO MA9TA9 ORD]4 ,MA?IEU ,BURNEL1 9 HIS F9AL /ATEM5T1 US$ ! C\RT AS A PLAT=M TO 9DICT ! /ATE APP>ATUS ITSELF RA!R ?AN SUBMIT TO ! JUDGM5T ( ! /ATE4 ,JULI5 TOOK ! /& & NOT$ ?AT IT WAS 9DE$ !IR PRIVILEG$ ROLES AS 9TELLECTUALS ?AT SAV$ !M3 0,! PECULI>ITY ( ?IS TRIAL IS ?AT ! JUDICIAL APP>ATUS HAS COME UP AGA9/ PEOPLE :O >E PREP>$ TO DEF5D !MSELVES & DET]M9$ NOT TO LET !MSELVES BE CRU%$4 ,WE >E CONSCI\S ( HAV+ HAD ! *ANCE TO DEF5D \RSELVES1 ( BE+ ABLE TO SPEAK1 ( HAV+ ?REE WEEKS 9 :I* TO DO SO4 ,S9CE WE'VE F\<T1 WE HAVE B5EFIT$ FROM C]TA9 PRIVILEGES4 ,HAV+ SP5T A LITTLE TIME 9 PRISON1 ,I W\LD LIKE TO D$ICATE ?IS TRIAL TO ALL ?OSE :O HAV5'T HAD ! MEANS TO DEF5D !MSELVES1 :O >E NOT LI/5$ TO & :O >E CONVICT$ 9 SIL5CE40 ,! C\RT BROKE 9TO A F9AL APPLAUSE = ! ALLEG$ T]RORI/S4 

,!RE'S ,NO ,JU/ICE--,IT'S ,JU/ ,US 

  

,SO :AT CAN WE LE>N FROM ! ,T>NAC CASE8 ,FIR/1 ?AT ) A LITTLE LUCK & P]SEV]ANCE1 IT CAN BE POSSIBLE TO FACE D[N ! FULL =CE ( ! /ATE4 ,! ,T>NAC CASE C\LD HAVE TURN$ \T MU* WORSE HAD ! DEF5DANTS NOT /OOD TOGE!R UNCOMPROMIS+LY4 ,AT ! BEG9N+1 ! SITUATION MU/ HAVE LOOK$ GRIM 9DE$4 

,AFT] ! ,T>NAC >RE/S1 AT PREVI\SLY TAME ,FR5* DEMON/RATIONS1 MORE & MORE Y\NG MASK$ PEOPLE ATTACK$ ! POLICE4 ,! POLICE HAVE ALSO LE>N$ FROM ! ,T>NAC AFFAIR1 CONT9U+ TO REPRESS REVOLUTION>IES ) ABSURD *>GES1 AL?\< SOME:AT MORE DISCREETLY4 ,WE CANNOT SAY ?AT EI!R P>TY HAS REALLY COME \T AHEAD 9 ?IS CONFLICT4 ,:AT WE HAVE SE5 OV] ! PA/ T5 YE>S IS A P>ALLEL DEVELOPM5T ( BO? =CES4 ,ON ONE H&1 ! IDEA ( A FEW REVOLUTION>IES BE+ REALLY DANG]\S AS A SMALL SELF-CONTA9$ GR\P HAS BE5 DISPELL$1 YET EV]Y?+ ?AT ! POLICE T>GET$ SPREAD ?R\<\T ,FR5* SOCIETY3 ANONYMITY1 RIOTS1 ! REFUSAL ( ALL 9/ITUTIONAL POLITICS4 ,AT ! SAME TIME1 IF ! ,T>NAC PROSECUTIONS DID NOT 5TIRELY SUCCE$1 ! POLICE >E RAPIDLY LE>N+ H[ TO EMPLOY !IR 9TELLIG5CE GA!R+ MORE EFFECTIVELY4 ,CONSPIRACY CASES >E MORE & MORE COMMON2 SURVEILLANCE & POLICE VIOL5CE >E 9T5SIFY+ BY ! DAY4 ,! 5D ( ?IS /ORY HAS YET TO BE WRITT54 

,ANTI-T]RORISM IS A PECULI> K9D ( LOGIC4 ,AS ! 5EMY IS POT5TIALLY ANYONE1 ALL IT TAKES TO LABEL SOMEONE A T]RORI/ IS TO FRAME ! ACTIONS ( ! ACCUS$ 9 SU* A WAY ?AT !Y POT5TIALLY UND]M9E ! /ABILITY ( ! /ATE4 ,AS ! /ATE $GES CLOS] TO DISSOLUTION1 !RE >E MORE & MORE EXCUSES TO ACCUSE PEOPLE ( UND]M9+ ITS /ABILITY4 ,! SECURITY APP>ATUS IS ON ! LOOK\T = ANYONE :O REFUSES ! LOGIC ( CAPITALI/ 9DIVIDUALISM--A CATEGORY ?AT CAN 9CLUDE ANYONE FROM ,ISLAMIC FUNDAM5TALI/S TO AN>*I/S :O WANT TO LIVE 9 A COMMUNE4 ,B5JAM9 ,ROS\X OBS]V$ ?IS IRONY 9 C\RT :5 HE NOT$ ?AT LIFE 9 ,T>NAC WAS BAS$ ON OP5NESS & %>+1 :ILE ! POLICE W]E HID+ 9 ! =E/ TAK+ PHOTOS ( !IR H\SES4 

,:AT IS T]RORISM8 ,T]RORISM IS ! PANIC PUT 9TO ! /ATE APP>ATUS BY ! FE> ( ITS [N DEMISE4 ,T]RORISM1 DEF9$ BY ! /ATE1 IS NOT A MATT] ( HUMAN ANGUI% BUT ( 9/ITUTIONAL LOSS ( CONTROL4 ,! ,T>NAC ,T5 /RUCK A *ORD ( T]ROR 9 ! /ATE--NOT BECAUSE ( ! =CE !Y C\LD MU/]1 BUT BECAUSE ( ! UNCONTROLLABLE POT5TIAL !Y REPRES5T4 ,! SPECT] ( 9SURRECTION ?AT HAD DISAPPE>$ 9 ! #a#i#hS RETURN$1 AS NEW GR\PS ( Y\NG PEOPLE APPE>$ :O W]E PREP>$ TO DEFY ! EXI/+ ORD]4 

,ONE %\LD NEV] UND]E/IMATE ! P[] ( SMALL GR\PS4 ,! ,P>IS ,COMMUNE WAS NOT BR\<T AB\T BY A GREAT ORGANIZATION OR ,P>TY1 BUT BY MYRIAD SMALL CONSPIRACIES3 ! ,VIGILANCE ,COMMITTEES ?AT MET 9 EA* >RONDISSEM5T1 ! NETWORKS ( FRI5DS & NEI<BORS ON EA* /REET 9 ! FAUB\RGS4 ,:5 ! />S ALIGN1 LITTLE CONSPIRACIES LIKE !SE CAN SPREAD LIKE WILDFIRE UNTIL !Y >E 9NUM]ABLE2 ?AT IS :AT CREATES ! CONDITIONS = UNCONTROLLABLE 9SURRECTION4 ,?IS IS :Y ! /ATE APP>ATUS ALWAYS ATTEMPTS TO NIP !SE CONSPIRACIES 9 ! BUD2 IT IS :Y !Y T>GET$ ! ,T>NAC DEF5DANTS 9 HOPES ( =E/ALL+ ! WAVE ( UNRE/ ?AT SURG$ 9 ,DECEMB] #b#h2 & IT IS :Y NO AM\NT ( REPRESSION CAN ULTIMATELY /EM ! TIDE ( 9SURRECTION1 = IT CAN SPR+ ANEW FROM ANY ( ! C\NTLESS NODES 9 ! VA/ WEB ( RELATIONS ?AT MAKES UP ?IS SOCIETY4 

,IT IS ! 9T5SITY ( FEEL+ ?AT WE CAN %>E ?AT ! /ATE FE>S ABOVE ALL1 ! CAPACITY TO G5]ATE NEW DREAMS & AMBITIONS TOGE!R4 ,?IS IS ! V]Y /UFF ( LIFE4 ,= ?OSE :O CAN F9D IT TOGE!R1 IT IS WOR? ANY ORDEAL1 ANY DEGREE ( REPRESSION4 

,SOME HAVE CRITICIZ$ ! WAY ! ,T>NAC ,T5 5GAG$ ) ! M$IA & ) ! PUBLIC NOTIONS ( LEGITIMACY REPRES5T$ BY ! 9TELLECTUALS :O CAME =W>D TO SPEAK 9 !IR FAVOR4 ,WE %\LD NEV] MAKE ! MI/AKE ( BELIEV+ ?AT M$IA EXPOSURE OR SOCIAL LEGITIMACY >E TOOLS ?AT CAN 9 !MSELVES S]VE TO ADVANCE ! CAUSE ( LIB]ATION2 BUT NOR CAN WE ALWAYS AF=D TO DO )\T !M 5TIRELY :5 ! =CES ( REPRESSION USE ?OSE TOOLS TO SET ! /AGE TO DE/ROY US4 ,AS AN>*I/S1 WE >E ALWAYS FI<T+ AGA9/ ! T]RA9 ITSELF AS WELL AS AGA9/ \R ADV]S>IES4 ,?IS IS NOT A REASON NOT TO FI<T ON ! T]RA9 ( M$IA OR P]CEIV$ LEGITIMACY2 IT SIMPLY MEANS ?AT WE MU/ F9D A WAY TO OP]ATE 9 ?AT T]RITORY ?AT 5ABLES US TO \TFLANK ! AU?ORITIES )\T ABSORB+ !IR LOGIC4 ,EV]Y BL[ !Y /RIKE AGA9/ US MU/ CO/ !M D\BLE3 9 ?IS REG>D1 ! EXPLOSION ( 9T]E/ ?AT ! ,T>NAC >RE/S PRODUC$ 9 ,! ,COM+ ,9SURRECTION SETS A GOOD EXAMPLE = H[ REVOLUTION>IES CAN PREP>E TO MAKE ! PHASE ( REPRESSION JU/ ANO!R /EP 9 \R PLANS--A PHASE 9 :I* WE CAN CONT9UE TO ADVANCE4 

,AT ! SAME TIME1 SPECTACUL> FAME IS DANG]\S1 ABOVE ALL BECAUSE IT 5ABLES ! SPECTATOR TO SIT BACK & LET ANO!R PROTAGONI/ /& 9 = HIS OR H] [N AG5CY4 ,WE MU/ NOT LOOK TO ANY P>TICUL> CADRE ( H]OES = ! NEXT BRILLIANT !ORY OR C\RAGE\S ACTION4 ,IF ! PROMISE ( ! ,9VISIBLE ,COMMITTEE IS ?AT P]HAPS1 9 A WORLD ( ,MAOI/ ACADEMICS & HIP/]S SP\T+ EMPTY WORDS1 SOMEONE SOME:]E MI<T BE PUTT+ !IR ?\<TS 9TO ACTION1 ?AT SOMEONE MU/ BE US4 

,!RE >E /ILL MANY BATTLES TO BE F\<T1 & MANY ?\<TS YET UN?\<T1 & MANY ACTS = :I* ONE MU/ TRY NOT TO GET CAU<T4 ,! FE> ( IMPRISONM5T %\LD NOT PREV5T US FROM UNIFY+ \R ?\<TS ) \R ACTIONS4 ,9DE$1 ! POSSIBILITY ?AT WE MI<T DO SO IS ! LA/1 BE/ HOPE ( A DY+ WORLD4 

,APP5DIX3 ,EXTRACTS FROM ,MA?IEU ,BURNEL'S ,CLOS+ ,/ATEM5T 

  

0,Y\ HAVE ALL CLAIM$ ?AT ?IS TRIAL WAS EXCEPTIONAL4 ,:AT WE'VE SE5 ON ! CONTR>Y IS SOME?+ EXTREMELY BANAL3 DIFF]5T P>TIES DISAGREE+ :O DEBATE1 >GUE1 & TALK4 ,?IS IS :AT HAS BE5 HAPP5+ =EV] 9 ALL HUMAN AGGREGATIONS4 ,IT'S BANAL & NORMAL4 ,:AT Y\ ACTUALLY CONSID] EXCEPTIONAL IS ?AT WE COME 9TO ?IS C\RT )\T LOOK+ D[N & )\T K[T[+4 ,?AT WE DIDN'T SUBMIT TO ALL ?IS1 ?IS LITTLE !ATRICAL RITUAL ( SUBMISSION ?AT MAKES Y\R DAILY LIFE444 

0,WE CAME H]E \T ( CURIOSITY1 BUT TO BE HONE/1 ,MADAME JUDGE1 WE HAV5'T DISCOV]$ MU* 9 ?IS C\RT ?AT WE DIDN'T EXPECT4 ,A RITUAL1 SOME !AT]1 ROBES1 GILD+S1 & ALL ?IS PETTY QUA9T /AG+4 ,EV]YONE PLAY+ HIS ROLE1 PLAY+ HIS LITTLE MUSIC1 HIS LITTLE 9DIGNATION1 HIS LITTLE S]I\SNESS1 HIS LITTLE >TICLES ( LAW & EV5 SOMETIMES HIS 'GREAT & JU/ AU?ORITY4' ,9 REALITY1 :AT ,I BELIEVE1 ,MADAME PRESID5T1 IS ?AT :AT WE OBLIG$ Y\ TO TOL]ATE ?OSE ?REE WEEKS1 :AT Y\ CONDEMN$ YE/]DAY EV5+.<#i.> IS ?AT WE W]E ! ONLY PEOPLE 9 ?IS ROOM TO NOT PLAY A ROLE1 TO NOT PRET5D1 TO NOT PLAY ! PETTY GAME ( JU/ICE444 

0,:AT ACTUALLY HAPP5$ DUR+ ?OSE LONG DAYS ( TRIAL ?AT Y\ CALL 'EXCEPTIONAL'8 ,A SMALL DISPLACEM5T1 A T9Y /EP ASIDE4 ,Y\ CAME H]E ) SOME EXPECTATIONS4 ,Y\ W]E GO+ TO SEE ?IS FAM\S ',T>NAC GR\P4' ,GURUS1 A SECT1 'POLITICAL ACTIVI/S1' 'AN>*O-AUTONOM\S1' PR(ESSIONALS ( RIOTS OR !ORETICIANS ( VIOL5T REVOLUTION1 :AT ELSE8 ,BUT 9 ! 5D1 Y\ 5D$ UP 9 FRONT ( US3 ,MANON ,GLIB]T1 ,JULI5 ,C\PAT1 ,B5JAM9 ,ROS\X1 ,YILDUNE ,LEVY1 ,*RI/OPHE ,BECK]1 ,B]TR& ,DEVEAUD1 ,MA?IEU ,BURNEL4 ,& WE APPE>$ BANAL1 NORMAL4 ,Y\ EV5 ASK$ US SOME REALLY CURI\S QUE/IONS3 ,MANON1 :AT IS ! MUSICAL 9/RUM5T %E'S PLAY+8 ,B5JAM91 HIS POLITICAL SCI5CE DEGREE1 HE RECEIV$ IT 9 ,R5NES OR ,P>IS8 ,& H[ DO Y\ MANAGE TO LIVE ON #ge EUROS A MON?8 

0,?IS T9Y /EP ASIDE1 WE PROBABLY PROVOK$ IT1 BUT IT IS )9 Y\RSELF ?AT IT OP]AT$4 ,Y\'VE GA!R$ 9 ! C\RSE ( !SE ?REE WEEKS ( TRIAL ?AT :AT IS ! MO/ S+UL> AB\T REVOLUTION>IES IS ?AT !Y >E MADE ( :AT IS 9F9ITELY COMMON4 

0,WE DON'T NE$ ANY EMPA?Y1 WE ACTUALLY NEV] COMPLA9$4 ,:AT WE DID DUR+ ?OSE T5 YE>S IS :AT WE KN[ H[ TO DO3 FI<T4 ,?IS IS :AT PEOPLE LIKE US DO3 RESI/1 FI<T BACK4 ,IT WAS AB\T HOLD+ \RSELVES TO A C5TRAL & SOV]EIGN REFUSAL3 NOT TO ACCEPT TO BE CRU%$4 ,! =CES JO9$ AGA9/ US W]E MASSIVE & P[]FUL4 ,WE HAD TO F9D RES\RCES1 TIME1 /R5G?1 & COMPLICITIES4 ,WE HELD \RSELVES TO ?IS T9Y BUT IRR$UCIBLE TRU?3 Y\ WON'T CRU% US4 ,! 'US' H]E NOT BE+ LIMIT$ TO ! EI<T ( US1 ( C\RSE1 BUT TO ALL ?OSE :O W]E 9DIRECTLY T>GET$ BY ?IS POLITICAL1 M$IA1 & JURIDICAL OP]ATION4 ,WE & \R FRI5DS1 :O >E NUM]\S4 ,:ATEV] ! \TCOME ( ?IS TRIAL WILL BE1 WE'LL COME \T ( IT /RONG] ?AN WE 5T]$ IT1 /RONG] ?AN T5 YE>S AGO40 

.<#a.> ,! QUOTATION IS FROM ! 9TELLIG5CE FILES GA!R$ ON ! DEF5DANTS4 ,R\<LY TRANSLAT$1 ! REPORT IS 5TITL$ 0,FROM ! ,C,P,E ,MOVEM5T TO ! CON/ITUTION ( A ,EUROPEAN PRE-T]RORI/ NETWORK0--SUGGE/+ A L9K ) ! /UD5T MOVEM5T ?REE YE>S BE=E ! >RE/S4 

.<#b.> ,! SO-CALL$ ,LOI ,SCEL]ATES 70,SC\NDREL ,LAWS07 ( #ahic & #a#h#i#d1 :I* W]E PASS$ SPECIFICALLY = ! PURPOSE ( REPRESS+ AN>*I/S1 9TRODUC$ ?IS *>GE AS A WAY ( T>GET+ ?OSE :O DID NOT !MSELVES 5GAGE 9 ILLEGAL ACTIVITY1 BUT ASSOCIAT$ ) ?OSE :O MI<T4 

.<#c.> ,TO GIVE A S5SE ( ! REMOT5ESS ( ,T>NAC1 WE NE$ ONLY NOTE ?AT ! NE>E/ T[N ( ANY NOTE IS ,LIMOGES1 ! NAME ( :I* HAS 5T]$ ! ,FR5* LEXICON AS A V]B MEAN+ TO BE FIR$ OR TO BE S5T 9TO EXILE4 ,( A JUDGE :O WAS DEMOT$ FROM A POSITION 9 ,P>IS TO S]VE 9 ONE ( ! \T] COLONIES1 = EXAMPLE1 IT C\LD BE SAID ?AT HE WAS 0,LIMOG$40 ,! EXPRESSION D]IVES FROM ! ,FIR/ ,WORLD ,W>1 :5 ,LIMOGES WAS SO F> FROM ! ACTION ?AT ,G5]AL ,J(FRE S5T S5IOR /AFF !RE ?AT HE CONSID]$ USELESS4 

.<#d.> ,TO ILLU/RATE ! COMMON SOIL FROM :I* E>LY ,CRIME?,9C4 & ,9VISIBLE ,COMMITTEE GREW1 WE NE$ ONLY PO9T \T ?AT ?IS MODEL WAS BORR[$ FROM A SIMIL> UNP]MITT$ RELEASE P>TY AT AN UNSUSPECT+ CORPORATE BOOK/ORE 9 ! YE> #b1 AT :I* A ,CRIME?,9C4 CELL 9 ,CONNECTICUT CELEBRAT$ ! PUBLICATION ( ,DAYS ( ,W>1 ,NI<TS ( ,LOVE4 ,! DIFF]5CE WAS ?AT AT ! E>LI] EV5T1 ! P>TICIPANTS DID NOT 9VITE A REPORT] FROM ! ,NEW ,YORK ,TIMES4 

.<#e.> 0,WE KN[ ?AT WE >E ALWAYS MORE NUM]\S1 FROM ALL WALKS ( LIFE1 DET]M9$ NOT TO LET !M /EP ON \R HEADS40 ,MAKA ,KANTE & ,B5JAM9 ,R\S\X4 

.<#f.> ,! VILLAGE'S 0G5]AL /ORE40 

.<#g.> ,AN 9VE/IGAT+ MAGI/RATE IS A JUDGE1 SUPPOS$ TO BE NEUTRAL1 :O IS *>G$ ) ASSEMBL+ A DOSSI] REPRES5T+ ! 0TRU?0 ( ! C\RT CASE--A RA!R ,5LI<T5M5T TRADITION4 

.<#h.> ,9 ,FRANCE 9 ! #a#i#fS1 DUR+ ! ,ALG]IAN W>1 A LAWY] :O LAT] BECAME FAM\S 09V5T$0 :AT HE CALL$ ! 0DEF5SE ( RUPTURE10 9 :I* ! ACCUS$ DID NOT RECOGNIZE ! LEGITIMACY ( ! TRIAL4 ,9 ! CONTEXT ( FI<T+ COLONIZATION1 IT MEANT ?AT ,F,L,N MEMB]S DID NOT RECOGNIZE ! RI<T ( ,FR5* C\RTS TO JUDGE !M ON ,ALG]IAN SOIL4 ,AFT]W>DS1 SOME EXTREME-LEFT GR\PS US$ ?IS APPROA* UP TO ! #a#i#hS TO D5\NCE 0B\RGEOIS JU/ICE10 AS OPPOS$ TO SOME SORT ( IMAG9$ 0PROLET>IAN0 JU/ICE4 

.<#i.> ,:5 %E SAID ! DEF5DANTS W]E ! MO/ ILL-MANN]$ PEOPLE %E HAD EV] MET4 

7,S\RCE3 ,RETRIEV$ ON #a#f? ,JUNE #bba FROM CRIME?9C4COM47 

,FROM 3 ,!,AN>*I/,LIBR>Y4ORG4 

,*RONOLOGY 3 
,JANU>Y #a#d1 #bbb 3 ,! ,T>NAC ,V]DICTS3 ,UNRAVEL+ ! ,LOGIC ( ,ANTI-,T]RORISM -- ,ADD$4 

 FILE G5]AT$ FROM 3  
HTTP3_/_/REVOLTLIB4COM_/