,P>T #e 
,?\<T AT ! ,M]IDIAN 

,PEOPLE 3 

,AU?OR 3 ,ALB]T ,CAMUS 

,TEXT 3 

,P>T ,FIVE3 ,?\<T AT ! ,M]IDIAN 

,REBELLION & ,MURD] 

,F> FROM ?IS S\RCE ( LIFE1 H[EV]1 ,EUROPE & ! REVOLUTION >E BE+ %AK5 TO ! CORE BY A 
SPECTACUL> CONVULSION4 ,DUR+ ! LA/ C5TURY1 MAN CA/ (F ! FETT]S ( RELIGION4 ,H>DLY WAS HE FREE1 
H[EV]1 :5 HE CREAT$ NEW & UTT]LY 9TOL]ABLE *A9S4 ,VIRTUE DIES BUT IS BORN AGA91 MORE EXACT+ 
?AN EV]4 ,IT PREA*ES AN E>-SPLITT+ S]MON ON *>ITY TO ALL COM]S & A K9D ( LOVE = ! FUTURE 
:I* MAKES A MOCK]Y ( CONTEMPOR>Y HUMANISM4 ,:5 IT HAS REA*$ ?IS PO9T ( /ABILITY1 IT CAN 
ONLY WREAK HAVOC4 ,A DAY >RIVES :5 IT BECOMES BITT]1 IMM$IATELY ADOPTS POLICE ME?ODS1 &1 = ! 
SALVATION ( MANK9D1 ASSUMES ! IGNOBLE ASPECT ( AN 9QUISITION4 ,AT ! CLIMAX ( CONTEMPOR>Y 
TRAG$Y1 WE !RE=E BECOME 9TIMATES ( CRIME4 ,! S\RCES ( LIFE & ( CREATION SEEM EXHAU/$4 ,FE> 
P>ALYZES A ,EUROPE PEOPL$ ) PHANTOMS & MA*9ES4 ,BETWE5 TWO HOLOCAU/S1 SCAFFOLDS >E 9/ALL$ 
9 UND]GR\ND CAV]NS :]E HUMANI/ EXECUTION]S CELEBRATE !IR NEW CULT 9 SIL5CE4 ,:AT CRY W\LD 
EV] TR\BLE !M8 ,! POETS !MSELVES1 CONFRONT$ ) ! MURD] ( !IR FELL[ M51 PR\DLY DECL>E 
?AT !IR H&S >E CLEAN4 ,! :OLE WORLD ABS5T-M9D$LY TURNS ITS BACK ON !SE CRIMES2 ! VICTIMS 
HAVE REA*$ ! EXTREMITY ( !IR DISGRACE3 !Y >E A BORE4 ,9 ANCI5T TIMES ! BLOOD ( MURD] AT LEA/ 
PRODUC$ A RELIGI\S HORROR & 9 ?IS WAY SANCTIFI$ ! VALUE ( LIFE4 ,! REAL CONDEMNATION ( ! 
P]IOD WE LIVE 9 IS1 ON ! CONTR>Y1 ?AT IT LEADS US TO ?9K ?AT IT IS NOT BLOOD-?IR/Y 5\<4 ,BLOOD IS NO LONG] VISIBLE2 IT DOES NOT BESPATT] ! FACES ( \R PH>ISEES VISIBLY 5\<4 

,?IS IS ! EXTREME ( NIHILISM2 BL9D & SAVAGE MURD] BECOMES AN OASIS1 & ! IMBECILE CRIM9AL 
SEEMS POSITIVELY REFRE%+ 9 COMP>ISON ) \R HI<LY 9TELLIG5T EXECUTION]S4 

,HAV+ BELIEV$ = A LONG TIME ?AT IT C\LD FI<T AGA9/ ,GOD ) ALL HUMANITY AS ITS ALLY1 ! ,EUROPEAN 
M9D !N P]CEIV$ ?AT IT MU/ ALSO1 IF IT DID NOT WANT TO DIE1 FI<T AGA9/ M54 ,! REBELS :O1 UNIT$ 
AGA9/ DEA?1 WANT$ TO CON/RUCT1 ON ! F\NDATION ( ! HUMAN SPECIES1 A SAVAGE IMMORTALITY >E 
T]RIFI$ AT ! PROSPECT ( BE+ OBLIG$ TO KILL 9 !IR TURN4 ,NEV]!LESS1 IF !Y RETREAT !Y MU/ ACCEPT 
DEA?2 IF !Y ADVANCE !Y MU/ ACCEPT MURD]4 ,REBELLION1 CUT (F FROM ITS ORIG9S & CYNICALLY 
TRAVE/I$1 OSCILLATES1 ON ALL LEVELS1 BETWE5 SACRIFICE & MURD]4 ,! =M ( JU/ICE ?AT IT ADVOCAT$ & 
?AT IT HOP$ WAS IMP>TIAL HAS TURN$ \T TO BE SUMM>Y4 ,! K+DOM ( GRACE HAS BE5 CONQU]$1 BUT 
! K+DOM ( JU/ICE IS CRUMBL+ TOO4 ,EUROPE IS DY+ ( ?IS DISAPPO9T+ REALIZATION4 ,REBELLION 
PLEAD$ = ! 9NOC5CE ( MANK9D1 & N[ IT HAS H>D5$ ITS HE>T AGA9/ ITS [N CULPABILITY4 

,H>DLY DOES IT />T (F 9 SE>* ( TOTALITY :5 IT RECEIVES AS ITS PORTION ! MO/ DESP]ATE S5SATIONS ( 
SOLITUDE4 ,IT WANT$ TO 5T] 9TO COMMUNION ) MANK9D & N[ IT HAS NO O!R HOPE BUT TO ASSEMBLE1 
ONE BY ONE1 ?R\<\T ! YE>S1 ! SOLIT>Y M5 :O FI<T !IR WAY T[>D UNITY4 

,MU/ WE !RE=E R5\NCE EV]Y K9D ( REBELLION1 :E!R WE ACCEPT1 ) ALL ITS 9JU/ICES1 A SOCIETY 
?AT \TLIVES ITS USEFULNESS1 OR :E!R WE DECIDE1 CYNICALLY1 TO S]VE1 AGA9/ ! 9T]E/ ( MAN1 ! 
9EXORABLE ADVANCE ( HI/ORY8 ,AFT] ALL1 IF ! LOGIC ( \R REFLECTION %\LD LEAD TO A C[>DLY 
CON=MISM IT W\LD HAVE TO BE ACCEPT$ AS C]TA9 FAMILIES SOMETIMES ACCEPT 9EVITABLE DI%ONOR4 ,IF IT 
MU/ ALSO JU/IFY ALL ! V>IETIES ( ATTEMPTS AGA9/ MAN1 & EV5 HIS SY/EMATIC DE/RUCTION1 IT W\LD BE 
NECESS>Y TO CONS5T TO ?IS SUICIDE4 ,! DESIRE = JU/ICE W\LD F9ALLY REALIZE ITS AMBITION3 ! 
DISAPPE>ANCE ( A WORLD ( TRADESM5 & POLICE4 

,BUT >E WE /ILL LIV+ 9 A REBELLI\S WORLD8 ,HAS NOT REBELLION BECOME1 ON ! CONTR>Y1 ! EXCUSE ( A NEW V>IETY ( TYRANT8 ,CAN ! 0,WE >E0 CONTA9$ 9 ! MOVEM5T ( REBELLION1 )\T %AME & )\T 
SUBT]FUGE1 BE RECONCIL$ ) MURD]8 ,9 ASSIGN+ OPPRESSION A LIMIT )9 :I* BEG9S ! DIGNITY 
COMMON TO ALL M51 REBELLION DEF9$ A PRIM>Y VALUE4 ,IT PUT 9 ! FIR/ RANK ( ITS FRAME ( REF]5CE AN 
OBVI\S COMPLICITY AMONG M51 A COMMON TEXTURE1 ! SOLID>ITY ( *A9S1 A COMMUNICATION BETWE5 
HUMAN BE+ & HUMAN BE+ :I* MAKES M5 BO? SIMIL> & UNIT$4 ,9 ?IS WAY1 IT COMPELL$ ! 
M9D TO TAKE A FIR/ /EP 9 DEFIANCE ( AN ABSURD WORLD4 ,BY ?IS PROGRESS IT R5D]$ /ILL MORE ACUTE ! 
PROBLEM ?AT IT MU/ N[ SOLVE 9 REG>D TO MURD]4 ,ON ! LEVEL ( ! ABSURD1 9 FACT1 MURD] W\LD ONLY 
GIVE RISE TO LOGICAL CONTRADICTIONS2 ON ! LEVEL ( REBELLION IT IS M5TAL LAC]ATION4 ,= IT IS N[ A QUE/ION 
( DECID+ IF IT IS POSSIBLE TO KILL SOMEONE :OSE RESEMBLANCE TO \RSELVES WE HAVE AT LA/ RECOGNIZ$ 
& :OSE ID5TITY WE HAVE JU/ SANCTIFI$4 ,:5 WE HAVE ONLY JU/ CONQU]$ SOLITUDE1 MU/ WE !N RE- 
E/ABLI% IT DEF9ITIVELY BY LEGITIMIZ+ ! ACT ?AT ISOLATES EV]Y?+8 ,TO =CE SOLITUDE ON A MAN :O 
HAS JU/ COME TO UND]/& ?AT HE IS NOT ALONE1 IS ?AT NOT ! DEF9ITIVE CRIME AGA9/ MAN8 

,LOGICALLY1 ONE %\LD REPLY ?AT MURD] & REBELLION >E CONTRADICTORY4 ,IF A S+LE MA/] %\LD1 9 FACT1 
BE KILL$1 ! REBEL1 9 A C]TA9 WAY1 IS NO LONG] JU/IFI$ 9 US+ ! T]M COMMUNITY ( M5 FROM :I* 
HE D]IV$ HIS JU/IFICATION4 ,IF ?IS WORLD HAS NO HI<] MEAN+1 IF MAN IS ONLY RESPONSIBLE TO MAN1 IT 
SUFFICES = A MAN TO REMOVE ONE S+LE HUMAN BE+ FROM ! SOCIETY ( ! LIV+ TO AUTOMATICALLY 
EXCLUDE HIMSELF FROM IT4 ,:5 ,CA9 KILLS ,ABEL1 HE FLEES TO ! DES]T4 ,& IF MURD]]S >E LEGION1 !N 
?IS LEGION LIVES 9 ! DES]T & 9 ?AT O!R K9D ( SOLITUDE CALL$ PROMISCUITY4 

,FROM ! MOM5T ?AT HE /RIKES1 ! REBEL CUTS ! WORLD 9 TWO4 ,HE REBELL$ 9 ! NAME ( ! ID5TITY 
( MAN ) MAN & HE SACRIFICES ?IS ID5TITY BY CONSECRAT+ ! DIFF]5CE 9 BLOOD4 ,HIS ONLY 
EXI/5CE1 9 ! MID/ ( SUFF]+ & OPPRESSION1 WAS CONTA9$ 9 ?IS ID5TITY4 ,! SAME MOVEM5T1 
:I* 9T5D$ TO AFFIRM HIM1 ?US BR+S AN 5D TO HIS EXI/5CE4 ,HE CAN CLAIM ?AT SOME1 OR EV5 ALMO/ 
ALL1 >E ) HIM4 ,BUT IF ONE 
S+LE HUMAN BE+ IS MISS+ 9 ! IRREPLACEABLE WORLD ( FRAT]NITY1 !N ?IS WORLD IS IMM$IATELY 
DEPOPULAT$4 ,IF WE >E NOT1 !N ,I AM NOT & ?IS EXPLA9S ! 9F9ITE SADNESS ( ,KALIAYEV & ! SIL5CE 
( ,SA9T-,JU/4 ,! REBELS1 :O HAVE DECID$ TO GA9 !IR 5DS ?R\< VIOL5CE & MURD]1 HAVE 9 VA9 
REPLAC$1 9 ORD] TO PRES]VE ! HOPE ( EXI/+1 0,WE >E0 BY ! 0,WE %ALL BE40 ,:5 ! MURD]] & 
! VICTIM HAVE DISAPPE>$1 ! COMMUNITY WILL PROVIDE ITS [N JU/IFICATION )\T !M4 ,! 
EXCEPTION HAV+ LA/$ ITS APPO9T$ TIME1 ! RULE WILL ONCE MORE BECOME POSSIBLE4 ,ON ! LEVEL ( 
HI/ORY1 AS 9 9DIVIDUAL LIFE1 MURD] IS ?US A DESP]ATE EXCEPTION OR IT IS NO?+4 ,! DI/URBANCE ?AT IT 
BR+S TO ! ORD] ( ?+S (F]S NO HOPE ( A FUTURE2 IT IS AN EXCEPTION & !RE=E IT CAN BE NEI!R 
UTILIT>IAN NOR SY/EMATIC AS ! PURELY HI/ORICAL ATTITUDE W\LD HAVE IT4 ,IT IS ! LIMIT ?AT CAN BE REA*$ 
BUT ONCE1 AFT] :I* ONE MU/ DIE4 ,! REBEL HAS ONLY ONE WAY ( RECONCIL+ HIMSELF ) HIS ACT ( 
MURD] IF HE ALL[S HIMSELF TO BE L$ 9TO P]=M+ IT3 TO ACCEPT HIS [N DEA? & SACRIFICE4 ,HE KILLS 
& DIES SO ?AT IT %ALL BE CLE> ?AT MURD] IS IMPOSSIBLE4 ,HE DEMON/RATES ?AT1 9 REALITY1 HE PREF]S ! 
0,WE >E0 TO ! 0,WE %ALL BE40 ,! CALM HAPP9ESS ( ,KALIAYEV 9 HIS PRISON1 ! S]5ITY ( ,SA9T-,JU/ 
:5 HE WALKS T[>D ! SCAFFOLD1 >E EXPLA9$ 9 !IR TURN4 ,BEYOND ?AT F>!/ FRONTI]1 CON-TRADITION & NIHILISM BEG94 

,NIHILI/IC ,MURD] 

,IRRATIONAL CRIME & RATIONAL CRIME1 9 FACT1 BO? EQUALLY BETRAY ! VALUE BR\<T TO LI<T BY ! 
MOVEM5T ( REBELLION4 ,LET US FIR/ CONSID] ! =M]4 ,HE :O D5IES EV]Y?+ & ASSUMES ! 
AU?ORITY TO KILL--,SADE1 ! HOMICIDAL D&Y1 ! PITILESS ,UNIQUE1 ,K>AMAZOV1 ! ZEAL\S SUPPORT]S ( 
! UNLEA%$ B&IT--LAY CLAIM TO NO?+ %ORT ( TOTAL FRE$OM & ! UNLIMIT$ DISPLAY ( HUMAN 
PRIDE4 ,NIHILISM CONF\NDS CREATOR & CREAT$ 9 ! SAME BL9D FURY4 ,SUPPRESS+ EV]Y PR9CIPLE ( HOPE1 
IT REJECTS ! IDEA ( ANY LIMIT1 & 9 BL9D 9DIGNATION1 :I* NO LONG] IS EV5 AW>E ( ITS REASONS1 5DS 
) ! 
CONCLUSION ?AT IT IS A MATT] ( 9DIFF]5CE TO KILL :5 ! VICTIM IS ALREADY CONDEMN$ TO DEA?4 

,BUT ITS REASONS--! MUTUAL RECOGNITION ( A COMMON DE/9Y & ! COMMUNICATION ( M5 BETWE5 
!MSELVES-->E ALWAYS VALID4 ,REBELLION PROCLAIM$ !M & UND]TOOK TO S]VE !M4 ,9 ! SAME WAY 
IT DEF9$1 9 CONTRADICTION TO NIHILISM1 A RULE ( CONDUCT ?AT HAS NO NE$ TO AWAIT ! 5D ( HI/ORY TO 
EXPLA9 ITS ACTIONS & :I* IS1 NEV]!LESS1 NOT =MAL4 ,CONTR>Y TO ,JACOB9 MORALITY1 IT MADE 
ALL[ANCES = EV]Y?+ ?AT ESCAPES FROM RULES & LAWS4 ,IT OP5$ ! WAY TO A MORALITY :I*1 F> 
FROM OBEY+ AB/RACT PR9CIPLES1 DISCOV]S !M ONLY 9 ! HEAT ( BATTLE & 9 ! 9CESSANT MOVEM5T 
( CONTRADICTION4 ,NO?+ JU/IFIES ! ASS]TION ?AT !SE PR9CIPLES HAVE EXI/$ EXT]NALLY2 IT IS ( NO USE 
TO DECL>E ?AT !Y WILL ONE DAY EXI/4 ,BUT !Y DO EXI/1 9 ! V]Y P]IOD 9 :I* WE EXI/4 ,) US1 
& ?R\<\T ALL HI/ORY1 !Y D5Y S]VITUDE1 FALSEHOOD1 & T]ROR4 

,!RE IS1 9 FACT1 NO?+ 9 COMMON BETWE5 A MA/] & A SLAVE2 IT IS IMPOSSIBLE TO SPEAK & 
COMMUNICATE ) A P]SON :O HAS BE5 R$UC$ TO S]VITUDE4 ,9/EAD ( ! IMPLICIT & UNTRAMMEL$ 
DIALOGUE ?R\< :I* WE COME TO RECOGNIZE \R SIMIL>ITY & CONSECRATE \R DE/9Y1 S]VITUDE GIVES 
SWAY TO ! MO/ T]RIBLE ( SIL5CES4 ,IF 9JU/ICE IS BAD = ! REBEL1 IT IS NOT BECAUSE IT CONTRADICTS AN 
ET]NAL IDEA ( JU/ICE1 BUT BECAUSE IT P]PETUATES ! SIL5T HO/ILITY ?AT SEP>ATES ! OPPRESSOR FROM ! 
OPPRESS$4 ,IT KILLS ! SMALL P>T ( EXI/5CE ?AT CAN BE REALIZ$ ON ?IS E>? ?R\< ! MUTUAL 
UND]/&+ ( M54 ,9 ! SAME WAY1 S9CE ! MAN :O LIES %UTS HIMSELF (F FROM O!R M51 
FALSEHOOD IS !RE=E PROSCRIB$ &1 ON A SLI<TLY L[] LEVEL1 MURD] & VIOL5CE1 :I* IMPOSE 
DEF9ITIVE SIL5CE4 ,! MUTUAL UND]/&+ & COMMUNICATION DISCOV]$ BY REBELLION CAN SURVIVE ONLY 
9 ! FREE EX*ANGE ( CONV]SATION4 ,EV]Y AMBIGUITY1 EV]Y MISUND]/&+1 LEADS TO DEA?2 CLE> 
LANGUAGE & SIMPLE WORDS >E ! ONLY SALVATION FROM ?IS DEA?4.<#h#d.> ,! CLIMAX ( EV]Y TRAG$Y LIES 9 ! 
DEAFNESS ( ITS H]OES4 ,PLATO IS RI<T & NOT ,MOSES & ,NIETZS*E4 ,DIALOGUE ON ! LEVEL ( MANK9D IS 
LESS CO/LY 
?AN ! GOSPEL PREA*$ BY TOTALIT>IAN REGIMES 9 ! =M ( A MONOLOGUE DICTAT$ FROM ! TOP ( A 
LONELY M\NTA94 ,ON ! /AGE AS 9 REALITY1 ! MONOLOGUE PREC$ES DEA?4 ,EV]Y REBEL1 SOLELY BY ! 
MOVEM5T ?AT SETS HIM 9 OPPOSITION TO ! OPPRESSOR1 !RE=E PLEADS = LIFE1 UND]TAKES TO /RUGGLE 
AGA9/ S]VITUDE1 FALSEHOOD1 & T]ROR1 & AFFIRMS1 9 A FLA%1 ?AT !SE ?REE AFFLICTIONS >E ! CAUSE ( 
SIL5CE BETWE5 M51 ?AT !Y OBSCURE !M FROM ONE ANO!R & PREV5T !M FROM R$ISCOV]+ 
!MSELVES 9 ! ONLY VALUE ?AT CAN SAVE !M FROM NIHILISM--! LONG COMPLICITY ( M5 AT GRIPS ) !IR DE/9Y4 

,9 A FLA%--BUT ?AT IS TIME 5\< TO SAY1 PROVISIONALLY1 ?AT ! MO/ EXTREME =M ( FRE$OM1 ! 
FRE$OM TO KILL1 IS NOT COMPATIBLE ) ! S5SE ( REBELLION4 ,REBELLION IS 9 NO WAY ! DEM& = TOTAL 
FRE$OM4 ,ON ! CONTR>Y1 REBELLION PUTS TOTAL FRE$OM UP = TRIAL4 ,IT SPECIFICALLY ATTACKS ! UNLIMIT$ 
P[] ?AT AU?ORIZES A SUP]IOR TO VIOLATE ! =BIDD5 FRONTI]4 ,F> FROM DEM&+ G5]AL 
9DEP5D5CE1 ! REBEL WANTS IT TO BE RECOGNIZ$ ?AT FRE$OM HAS ITS LIMITS EV]Y:]E ?AT A HUMAN 
BE+ IS TO BE F\ND--! LIMIT BE+ PRECISELY ?AT HUMAN BE+'S P[] TO REBEL4 ,! MO/ PR(\ND 
REASON = REBELLI\S 9TRANSIG5CE IS TO BE F\ND H]E4 ,! MORE AW>E REBELLION IS ( DEM&+ A JU/ 
LIMIT1 ! MORE 9FLEXIBLE IT BECOMES4 ,! REBEL UND\BT$LY DEM&S A C]TA9 DEGREE ( FRE$OM = 
HIMSELF2 BUT 9 NO CASE1 IF HE IS CONSI/5T1 DOES HE DEM& ! RI<T TO DE/ROY ! EXI/5CE & ! 
FRE$OM ( O!RS4 ,HE HUMILIATES NO ONE4 ,! FRE$OM HE CLAIMS1 HE CLAIMS = ALL2 ! FRE$OM HE 
REFUSES1 HE =BIDS EV]YONE TO 5JOY4 ,HE IS NOT ONLY ! SLAVE AGA9/ ! MA/]1 BUT ALSO MAN AGA9/ ! 
WORLD ( MA/] & SLAVE4 ,!RE=E1 ?ANKS TO REBELLION1 !RE IS SOME?+ MORE 9 HI/ORY ?AN ! 
RELATION BETWE5 MA/]Y & S]VITUDE4 ,UNLIMIT$ P[] IS NOT ! ONLY LAW4 ,IT IS 9 ! NAME ( ANO!R 
VALUE ?AT ! REBEL AFFIRMS ! IMPOSSIBILITY ( TOTAL FRE$OM :ILE HE CLAIMS = HIMSELF ! RELATIVE 
FRE$OM NECESS>Y TO RECOGNIZE ?IS IMPOSSIBILITY4 ,EV]Y HUMAN FRE$OM1 AT ITS V]Y ROOTS1 IS !RE=E 
RELATIVE4 ,ABSOLUTE FRE$OM1 :I* IS ! FRE$OM TO KILL1 IS ! ONLY ONE :I* DOES NOT CLAIM1 AT ! SAME 
TIME AS ITSELF1 ! ?+S ?AT LIMIT 
& OBLIT]ATE IT4 ,?US IT CUTS ITSELF (F FROM ITS ROOTS & --AB/RACT & MALEVOL5T %ADE--W&]S 
HAPHAZ>DLY UNTIL SU* TIME AS IT IMAG9ES ?AT IT HAS F\ND SUB/ANCE 9 SOME IDEOLOGY4 

,IT IS !N POSSIBLE TO SAY ?AT REBELLION1 :5 IT DEVELOPS 9TO DE/RUCTION1 IS ILLOGICAL4 ,CLAIM+ ! UNITY 
( ! HUMAN CONDITION1 IT IS A =CE ( LIFE1 NOT ( DEA?4 ,ITS MO/ PR(\ND LOGIC IS NOT ! LOGIC ( 
DE/RUCTION2 IT IS ! LOGIC ( CREATION4 ,ITS MOVEM5T1 9 ORD] TO REMA9 AU!NTIC1 MU/ NEV] AB&ON ANY 
( ! T]MS ( ! CONTRADICTION ?AT SU/A9S IT4 ,IT MU/ BE FAI?FUL TO ! YES ?AT IT CONTA9S AS WELL AS TO 
! NO ?AT NIHILI/IC 9T]PRETATIONS ISOLATE 9 REBELLION4 ,! LOGIC ( ! REBEL IS TO WANT TO S]VE JU/ICE SO 
AS NOT TO ADD TO ! 9JU/ICE ( ! HUMAN CONDITION1 TO 9SI/ ON PLA9 LANGUAGE SO AS NOT TO 9CREASE ! 
UNIV]SAL FALSEHOOD1 & TO WAG]1 9 SPITE ( HUMAN MIS]Y1 = HAPP9ESS4 ,NIHILI/IC PASSION1 ADD+ TO 
FALSEHOOD & 9JU/ICE1 DE/ROYS 9 ITS FURY ITS ORIG9AL DEM&S & ?US DEPRIVES REBELLION ( ITS MO/ 
COG5T REASONS4 ,IT KILLS 9 ! FOND CONVICTION ?AT ?IS WORLD IS D$ICAT$ TO DEA?4 ,! CONSEQU5CE ( 
REBELLION1 ON ! CONTR>Y1 IS TO REFUSE TO LEGITIMIZE MURD] BECAUSE REBELLION1 9 PR9CIPLE1 IS A PROTE/ AGA9/ DEA?4 

,BUT IF MAN W]E CAPABLE ( 9TRODUC+ UNITY 9TO ! WORLD 5TIRELY ON HIS [N1 IF HE C\LD E/ABLI% ! 
REIGN1 BY HIS [N DECREE1 ( S9C]ITY1 9NOC5CE1 & JU/ICE1 HE W\LD BE ,GOD ,HIMSELF4 ,EQUALLY1 IF HE 
C\LD ACCOMPLI% ALL ?IS1 !RE W\LD BE NO MORE REASONS = REBELLION4 ,IF REBELLION EXI/S1 IT IS BECAUSE 
FALSEHOOD1 9JU/ICE1 & VIOL5CE >E P>T ( ! REBEL'S CONDITION4 ,HE CANNOT1 !RE=E1 ABSOLUTELY CLAIM 
NOT TO KILL OR LIE1 )\T R5\NC+ HIS REBELLION & ACCEPT+1 ONCE & = ALL1 EVIL & MURD]4 ,BUT NO 
MORE CAN HE AGREE TO KILL & LIE1 S9CE ! 9V]SE REASON+ :I* W\LD JU/IFY MURD] & VIOL5CE 
W\LD ALSO DE/ROY ! REASONS = HIS 9SURRECTION4 ,?US ! REBEL CAN NEV] F9D PEACE4 ,HE KN[S :AT IS 
GOOD &1 DESPITE HIMSELF1 DOES EVIL4 ,! VALUE ?AT SUPPORTS HIM IS NEV] GIV5 TO HIM ONCE & = ALL2 
HE MU/ FI<T TO UPHOLD IT1 UNCEAS+LY4 ,AGA9 ! EXI/5CE HE A*IEVES COLLAPSES IF REBELLION DOES NOT 
SUPPORT IT4 ,9 ANY CASE1 IF HE IS NOT ALWAYS ABLE NOT TO KILL1 EI!R DIRECTLY OR 9DIRECTLY1 HE CAN PUT HIS 
CONVICTION & PASSION TO 
WORK AT DIM9I%+ ! *ANCES ( MURD] >\ND HIM4 ,HIS ONLY VIRTUE WILL LIE 9 NEV] YIELD+ TO ! 
IMPULSE TO ALL[ HIMSELF TO BE 5GULF$ 9 ! %AD[S ?AT SURR\ND HIM & 9 OB/9ATELY DRAGG+ ! 
*A9S ( EVIL1 ) :I* HE IS B\ND1 T[>D ! LI<T ( GOOD4 ,IF HE F9ALLY KILLS HIMSELF1 HE WILL ACCEPT 
DEA?4 ,FAI?FUL TO HIS ORIG9S1 ! REBEL DEMON/RATES BY SACRIFICE ?AT HIS REAL FRE$OM IS NOT FRE$OM FROM 
MURD] BUT FRE$OM FROM HIS [N DEA?4 ,AT ! SAME TIME1 HE A*IEVES HONOR 9 METAPHYSICAL T]MS4 ,?US 
,KALIAYEV CLIMBS ! GALL[S & VISIBLY DESIGNATES TO ALL HIS FELL[ M5 ! EXACT LIMIT :]E MAN'S HONOR BEG9S & 5DS4 

,HI/ORICAL ,MURD] 

,REBELLION ALSO DEPLOYS ITSELF 9 HI/ORY1 :I* DEM&S NOT ONLY EXEMPL>Y *OICES1 BUT ALSO EFFICACI\S 
ATTITUDES4 ,RATIONAL MURD] RUNS ! RISK ( F9D+ ITSELF JU/IFI$ BY HI/ORY4 ,! CONTRADICTION ( 
REBELLION1 !N1 IS REFLECT$ 9 AN APP>5TLY 9SOLUBLE CONTRADICTION1 ( :I* ! TWO C\NT]P>TS 9 
POLITICS >E ON ! ONE H& ! OPPOSITION BETWE5 VIOL5CE & NONVIOL5CE1 & ON ! O!R H& ! 
OPPOSITION BETWE5 JU/ICE & FRE$OM4 ,LET US TRY TO DEF9E !M 9 ! T]MS ( !IR P>ADOX4 

,! POSITIVE VALUE CONTA9$ 9 ! 9ITIAL MOVEM5T ( REBELLION SUPPOSES ! R5UNCIATION ( VIOL5CE 

COMMITT$ ON PR9CIPLE4 ,IT CONSEQU5TLY 5TAILS ! IMPOSSIBILITY ( /ABILIZ+ A REVOLUTION4 ,REBELLION IS1 
9CESSANTLY1 PREY TO ?IS CONTRADICTION4 ,ON ! LEVEL ( HI/ORY IT BECOMES EV5 MORE 9SOLUBLE4 ,IF ,I 
R5\NCE ! PROJECT ( MAK+ HUMAN ID5TITY RESPECT$1 ,I ABDICATE 9 FAVOR ( OPPRESSION1 ,I R5\NCE 
REBELLION & FALL BACK ON AN ATTITUDE ( NIHILI/IC CONS5T4 ,!N NIHILISM BECOMES CONS]VATIVE4 ,IF ,I 9SI/ 
?AT HUMAN ID5TITY %\LD BE RECOGNIZ$ AS EXI/+1 !N ,I 5GAGE 9 AN ACTION :I*1 TO SUCCE$1 
SUPPOSES A CYNICAL ATTITUDE T[>D VIOL5CE & D5IES ?IS ID5TITY & REBELLION ITSELF4 ,TO EXT5D ! 
CONTRADICTION /ILL F>!R1 IF ! UNITY ( ! WORLD CANNOT COME FROM ON HI<1 MAN MU/ CON/RUCT IT ON 
HIS [N LEVEL1 9 
HI/ORY4 ,HI/ORY )\T A VALUE TO TRANSFIGURE IT1 IS CONTROLL$ BY ! LAW ( EXP$I5CY4 ,HI/ORICAL 
MAT]IALISM1 DET]M9ISM1 VIOL5CE1 NEGATION ( EV]Y =M ( FRE$OM :I* DOES NOT CO9CIDE ) 
EXP$I5CY & ! WORLD ( C\RAGE & ( SIL5CE1 >E ! HI<LY LEGITIMATE CONSEQU5CES ( A PURE 
PHILOSOPHY ( HI/ORY4 ,9 ! WORLD TODAY1 ONLY A PHILOSOPHY ( ET]NITY C\LD JU/IFY NONVIOL5CE4 ,TO 
ABSOLUTE WOR%IP ( HI/ORY IT W\LD MAKE ! OBJECTION ( ! CREATION ( HI/ORY & ( ! HI/ORICAL 
SITUATION IT W\LD ASK :5CE IT HAD SPRUNG4 ,F9ALLY1 IT W\LD PUT ! RESPONSIBILITY = JU/ICE 9 ,GOD'S 
H&S1 ?US CONSECRAT+ 9JU/ICE4 ,EQUALLY1 ITS ANSW]S1 9 !IR TURN1 W\LD 9SI/ ON FAI?4 ,! OBJECTION 
WILL BE RAIS$ ( EVIL1 & ( ! P>ADOX ( AN ALL-P[]FUL & MALEVOL5T1 OR B5EVOL5T & /]ILE1 
,GOD4 ,! *OICE WILL REMA9 OP5 BETWE5 GRACE & HI/ORY1 ,GOD OR ! SWORD4 
,:AT1 !N1 %\LD BE ! ATTITUDE ( ! REBEL8 ,HE CANNOT TURN AWAY FROM ! WORLD & FROM HI/ORY 
)\T D5Y+ ! V]Y PR9CIPLE ( HIS REBELLION1 NOR CAN HE *OOSE ET]NAL LIFE )\T RESIGN+ 
HIMSELF1 9 ONE S5SE1 TO EVIL4 ,IF1 = EXAMPLE1 HE IS NOT A ,*RI/IAN1 HE %\LD GO TO ! BITT] 5D4 ,BUT TO 
! BITT] 5D MEANS TO *OOSE HI/ORY ABSOLUTELY & ) IT MURD]1 IF MURD] IS ESS5TIAL TO HI/ORY3 TO 
ACCEPT ! JU/IFICATION ( MURD] IS AGA9 TO D5Y HIS ORIG9S4 ,IF ! REBEL MAKES NO *OICE1 HE *OOSES ! 
SIL5CE & SLAV]Y ( O!RS4 ,IF1 9 A MOM5T ( DESPAIR1 HE DECL>ES ?AT HE OPTS BO? AGA9/ ,GOD & 
AGA9/ HI/ORY1 HE IS ! WITNESS ( PURE FRE$OM2 9 O!R WORDS1 ( NO?+4 ,9 \R P]IOD ( HI/ORY & 
9 ! IMPOSSIBLE CONDITION 9 :I* HE F9DS HIMSELF1 ( BE+ UNABLE TO AFFIRM A SUP]IOR MOTIVE ?AT 
DOES NOT HAVE ITS LIMITS 9 EVIL1 HIS APP>5T DILEMMA IS SIL5CE OR MURD]--9 EI!R CASE1 A SURR5D]4 

,& IT IS ! SAME AGA9 ) JU/ICE & FRE$OM4 ,!SE TWO DEM&S >E ALREADY TO BE F\ND AT ! 
BEG9N+ ( ! MOVEM5T ( REBELLION & >E TO BE F\ND AGA9 9 ! FIR/ IMPETUS ( REVOLUTION4 ,! 
HI/ORY ( REVOLUTIONS DEMON/RATES1 H[EV]1 ?AT !Y ALMO/ ALWAYS CONFLICT AS ?\< !IR MUTUAL 
DEM&S W]E IRRECONCILABLE4 ,ABSOLUTE FRE$OM IS ! RI<T ( ! /RONGE/ TO DOM9ATE4 ,!RE=E IT 
PROLONGS ! CONFLICTS ?AT PR(IT BY 
9JU/ICE4 ,ABSOLUTE JU/ICE IS A*IEV$ BY ! SUPPRESSION ( ALL CONTRADICTION3 !RE=E IT DE/ROYS FRE$OM4.<#h#e.> ,! 
REVOLUTION TO A*IEVE JU/ICE1 ?R\< FRE$OM1 5DS BY ALIGN+ !M AGA9/ EA* O!R4 ,?US !RE EXI/S 9 EV]Y 
REVOLUTION1 ONCE ! CLASS ?AT DOM9AT$ UP TO !N HAS BE5 LIQUIDAT$1 A /AGE 9 :I* IT GIVES BIR?1 ITSELF1 TO A 
MOVEM5T ( REBELLION :I* 9DICATES ITS LIMITS & ANN\NCES ITS *ANCES ( FAILURE4 ,! REVOLUTION1 FIR/ ( ALL1 
PROPOSES TO SATISFY ! SPIRIT ( REBELLION :I* HAS GIV5 RISE TO IT2 !N IT IS COMPELL$ TO D5Y IT1 ! BETT] TO 
AFFIRM ITSELF4 ,!RE IS1 IT W\LD SEEM1 AN 9]ADICABLE OPPOSITION BETWE5 ! MOVEM5T ( REBELLION & ! 
ATTA9M5TS ( REVOLUTION4 

,BUT !SE CONTRADICTIONS ONLY EXI/ 9 ! ABSOLUTE4 ,!Y SUPPOSE A WORLD & A ME?OD ( ?\<T )\T 
M$ITATION4 ,!RE IS1 9 FACT1 NO CONCILIATION POSSIBLE BETWE5 A GOD :O IS TOTALLY SEP>AT$ FROM HI/ORY & A 
HI/ORY PURG$ ( ALL TRANSC5D5CE4 ,!IR REPRES5TATIVES ON E>? >E1 9DE$1 ! YOGI & ! COMMISS>4 ,BUT ! 
DIFF]5CE BETWE5 !SE TWO TYPES ( M5 IS NOT1 AS HAS BE5 /AT$1 ! DIFF]5CE BETWE5 9EFFECTUAL PURITY & 
EXP$I5CY4 ,! =M] *OOSES ONLY ! 9EFFECTIV5ESS ( AB/5TION & ! SECOND ! 9EFFECTIV5ESS ( 
DE/RUCTION4 ,BECAUSE BO? REJECT ! CONCILIATORY VALUE ?AT REBELLION1 ON ! CONTR>Y1 REVEALS1 !Y (F] US ONLY TWO 
K9DS ( IMPOT5CE1 BO? EQUALLY REMOV$ FROM REALITY1 ?AT ( GOOD & ?AT ( EVIL4 

,IF1 9 FACT1 TO IGNORE HI/ORY COMES TO ! SAME AS D5Y+ REALITY1 IT IS /ILL ALI5AT+ ONESELF FROM REALITY TO CONSID] 
HI/ORY AS A COMPLETELY SELF-SUFFICI5T ABSOLUTE4 ,! REVOLUTION ( ! TW5TIE? C5TURY BELIEVES ?AT IT CAN AVOID 
NIHILISM & REMA9 FAI?FUL TO TRUE REBELLION1 BY REPLAC+ ,GOD BY HI/ORY4 ,9 REALITY1 IT =TIFIES ! =M] & 
BETRAYS ! LATT]4 ,HI/ORY 9 ITS PURE =M FURNI%ES NO VALUE BY ITSELF4 ,!RE=E ONE MU/ LIVE BY ! PR9CIPLES ( 
IMM$IATE EXP$I5CY & KEEP SIL5T 
OR TELL LIES4 ,SY/EMATIC VIOL5CE1 OR IMPOS$ SIL5CE1 CALCULATION OR CONC]T$ FALSEHOOD BECOME ! 9EVITABLE RULE4 

,PURELY HI/ORICAL ?\<T IS !RE=E NIHILI/IC3 IT :OLEHE>T$LY ACCEPTS ! EVIL ( HI/ORY & 9 ?IS WAY IS 
OPPOS$ TO REBELLION4 ,IT IS USELESS = IT TO AFFIRM1 9 COMP5SATION1 ! ABSOLUTE RATIONALITY ( HI/ORY1 = HI/ORICAL 
REASON WILL NEV] BEY FULFILL$ & WILL NEV] HAVE ITS FULL MEAN+ OR VALUE UNTIL ! 5D ( HI/ORY4 ,9 ! 
MEAN:ILE1 IT IS NECESS>Y TO ACT1 & TO ACT )\T A MORAL RULE 9 ORD] ?AT ! DEF9ITIVE RULE %\LD ONE DAY BE 
REALIZ$4 ,CYNICISM AS A POLITICAL ATTITUDE IS ONLY LOGICAL AS A FUNCTION ( ABSOLUTI/ ?\<T2 9 O!R WORDS1 ABSOLUTE 
NIHILISM ON ! ONE H&1 ABSOLUTE RATIONALISM ON ! O!R4.<#h#f.> ,AS = ! CONSEQU5CES1 !RE IS NO DIFF]5CE BETWE5 
! TWO ATTITUDES4 ,FROM ! MOM5T ?AT !Y >E ACCEPT$1 ! E>? BECOMES A DES]T4 

,9 REALITY1 ! PURELY HI/ORICAL ABSOLUTE IS NOT EV5 CONCEIVABLE4 ,JASP]S'S ?\<T1 = EXAMPLE1 9 ITS ESS5TIALS1 
UND]L9ES ! IMPOSSIBILITY ( MAN'S GRASP+ TOTALITY1 S9CE HE LIVES 9 ! MID/ ( ?IS TOTALITY4 ,HI/ORY1 AS AN 
5TIRETY1 C\LD EXI/ ONLY 9 ! EYES ( AN OBS]V] \TSIDE IT & \TSIDE ! WORLD4 ,HI/ORY ONLY EXI/S1 9 ! F9AL 
ANALYSIS1 = ,GOD4 ,?US IT IS IMPOSSIBLE TO ACT ACCORD+ TO PLANS EMBRAC+ ! TOTALITY ( UNIV]SAL HI/ORY4 ,ANY 
HI/ORICAL 5T]PRISE CAN !RE=E ONLY BE A MORE OR LESS REASONABLE OR JU/IFIABLE ADV5TURE4 ,IT IS PRIM>ILY A RISK4 ,9 
SO F> AS IT IS A RISK IT CANNOT BE US$ TO JU/IFY ANY EXCESS OR ANY RU?LESS & ABSOLUTI/ POSITION4 

,IF1 ON ! O!R H&1 REBELLION C\LD F\ND A PHILOSOPHY IT W\LD BE A PHILOSOPHY ( LIMITS1 ( CALCULAT$ IGNORANCE1 
& ( RISK4 ,HE :O DOES NOT KN[ EV]Y?+ CANNOT KILL EV]Y?+4 ,! REBEL1 F> FROM MAK+ AN ABSOLUTE ( 
HI/ORY1 REJECTS & DISPUTES IT1 9 ! NAME ( A CONCEPT ?AT HE HAS ( HIS [N NATURE4 ,HE REFUSES HIS CONDITION1 & 
HIS CONDITION TO A L>GE EXT5T IS HI/ORICAL4 ,9JU/ICE1 ! TRANSCI5CE ( TIME1 DEA?--ALL >E MANIFE/ 9 HI/ORY4 ,9 SPURN+ !M1 HI/ORY ITSELF IS SPURN$4 ,MO/ C]TA9LY ! REBEL DOES NOT D5Y ! HI/ORY ?AT SURR\NDS HIM2 IT IS 9 T]MS ( ?IS ?AT HE ATTEMPTS TO AFFIRM HIMSELF4 ,BUT CONFRONT$ ) IT1 
HE FEELS LIKE ! >TI/ CONFRONT$ ) REALITY2 HE SPURNS IT )\T ESCAP+ FROM IT4 ,HE HAS NEV] SUCCE$$ 9 CREAT+ AN ABSOLUTE HI/ORY4 ,EV5 ?\< HE CAN P>TICIPATE1 BY ! =CE ( EV5TS1 9 ! 
CRIME ( HI/ORY1 HE CANNOT NECESS>ILY LEGITIMATE IT4 ,RATIONAL CRIME NOT ONLY CANNOT BE ADMITT$ ON ! 
LEVEL ( REBELLION1 BUT ALSO SIGNIFIES ! DEA? ( REBELLION4 ,TO MAKE ?IS EVID5CE MORE CONV9C+1 
RATIONAL CRIME EX]CISES ITSELF1 9 ! FIR/ PLACE1 ON REBELS :OSE 9SURRECTION CONTE/S A HI/ORY ?AT IS 
H5CE=? DEIFI$4 

,! MY/IFICATION PECULI> TO ! M9D :I* CLAIMS TO BE REVOLUTION>Y TODAY SUMS UP & 9CREASES 
B\RGEOIS MY/IFICATION4 ,IT CONTRIVES1 BY ! PROMISE ( ABSOLUTE JU/ICE1 ! ACCEPTANCE ( P]PETUAL 
9JU/ICE1 ( UNLIMIT$ COMPROMISE1 & ( 9DIGNITY4 ,REBELLION ITSELF ONLY ASPIRES TO ! RELATIVE & CAN 
ONLY PROMISE AN ASSUR$ DIGNITY C\PL$ ) RELATIVE JU/ICE4 ,IT SUPPOSES A LIMIT AT :I* ! COMMUNITY 
( MAN IS E/ABLI%$4 ,ITS UNIV]SE IS ! UNIV]SE ( RELATIVE VALUES4 ,9/EAD ( SAY+1 ) ,HEGEL & 
,M>X1 ?AT ALL IS NECESS>Y1 IT ONLY REPEATS ?AT ALL IS POSSIBLE & ?AT1 AT A C]TA9 PO9T ON ! F>!/ 
FRONTI]1 IT IS WOR? MAK+ ! SUPREME SACRIFICE = ! SAKE ( ! POSSIBLE4 ,BETWE5 ,GOD & HI/ORY1 
! YOGI & ! COMMISS>1 IT OP5S A DIFFICULT PA? :]E CONTRADICTIONS MAY EXI/ & ?RIVE4 ,LET US 
CONSID] ! TWO CONTRADICTIONS GIV5 AS AN EXAMPLE 9 ?IS WAY4 

,A REVOLUTION>Y ACTION :I* WI%ES TO BE COH]5T 9 T]MS ( ITS ORIG9S %\LD BE EMBODI$ 9 AN 
ACTIVE CONS5T TO ! RELATIVE4 ,IT W\LD EXPRESS FIDELITY TO ! HUMAN CONDITION4 ,UNCOMPROMIS+ AS TO ITS 
MEANS1 IT W\LD ACCEPT AN APPROXIMATION AS F> AS ITS 5DS >E CONC]N$ &1 SO ?AT ! APPROXIMATION 
%\LD BECOME MORE & MORE ACCURATELY DEF9$1 IT W\LD ALL[ ABSOLUTE FRE$OM ( SPEE*4 ,?US IT 
W\LD PRES]VE ! COMMON EXI/5CE ?AT JU/IFIES ITS 9SURRECTION4 ,9 P>TICUL>1 IT W\LD PRES]VE AS AN 
ABSOLUTE LAW ! P]MAN5T POSSIBILITY ( SELF-EXPRESSION4 ,?IS DEF9ES A P>TICUL> L9E ( CONDUCT 9 
REG>D TO JU/ICE & FRE$OM4 ,!RE IS NO JU/ICE 9 SOCIETY )\T NATURAL OR CIVIL RI<TS AS ITS BASIS4 

,!RE 
>E NO RI<TS )\T EXPRESSION ( ?OSE RI<TS4 ,IF ! RI<TS >E EXPRESS$ )\T HESITATION IT IS MORE 
?AN PROBABLE ?AT1 SOON] OR LAT]1 ! JU/ICE !Y PO/ULATE WILL COME TO ! WORLD4 ,TO CONQU] EXI/5CE1 
WE MU/ />T FROM ! SMALL AM\NT ( EXI/5CE WE F9D 9 \RSELVES & NOT D5Y IT FROM_/! V]Y 
BEG9N+4 ,TO SIL5CE ! LAW UNTIL JU/ICE IS E/ABLI%$ IS TO SIL5CE IT =EV] S9CE IT WILL HAVE NO MORE 
OCCASION TO SPEAK IF JU/ICE REIGNS =EV]4 ,ONCE MORE1 WE ?US CONFIDE JU/ICE 9TO ! KEEP+ ( ?OSE 
:O ALONE HAVE ! ABILITY TO MAKE !MSELVES HE>D--?OSE 9 P[]4 ,= C5TURIES1 JU/ICE & 
EXI/5CE AS DISP5S$ BY ?OSE 9 P[] HAVE BE5 CONSID]$ A FAVOR4 ,TO KILL FRE$OM 9 ORD] TO 
E/ABLI% ! REIGN ( JU/ICE COMES TO ! SAME AS RESUSCITAT+ ! IDEA ( GRACE )\T DIV9E 
9T]CESSION & ( RE/OR+ BY A MY/IFY+ REACTION ! MY/IC BODY 9 ITS BASE/ ELEM5TS4 ,EV5 :5 
JU/ICE IS NOT REALIZ$1 FRE$OM PRES]VES ! P[] TO PROTE/ & GU>ANTEES HUMAN COMMUNICATION4 

,JU/ICE 9 A SIL5T WORLD1 JU/ICE 5SLAV$ & MUTE1 DE/ROYS MUTUAL COMPLICITY & F9ALLY CAN NO LONG] 
BE JU/ICE4 ,! REVOLUTION ( ! TW5TIE? C5TURY HAS >BITR>ILY SEP>AT$1 = OV]AMBITI\S 5DS ( 
CONQUE/1 TWO 9SEP>ABLE IDEAS4 ,ABSOLUTE FRE$OM MOCKS AT JU/ICE4 ,ABSOLUTE JU/ICE D5IES FRE$OM4 ,TO 
BE FRUITFUL1 ! TWO IDEAS MU/ F9D !IR LIMITS 9 EA* O!R4 ,NO MAN CONSID]S ?AT HIS CONDITION IS FREE IF 
IT IS NOT AT ! SAME TIME JU/1 NOR JU/ UNLESS IT IS FREE4 ,FRE$OM1 PRECISELY1 CANNOT EV5 BE IMAG9$ 
)\T ! P[] ( SAY+ CLE>LY :AT IS JU/ & :AT IS UNJU/1 ( CLAIM+ ALL EXI/5CE 9 ! NAME 
( A SMALL P>T ( EXI/5CE :I* REFUSES TO DIE4 ,F9ALLY !RE IS A JU/ICE1 ?\< A V]Y DIFF]5T K9D ( 
JU/ICE1 9 RE/OR+ FRE$OM1 :I* IS ! ONLY IMP]I%ABLE VALUE ( HI/ORY4 ,M5 >E NEV] REALLY WILL+ 
TO DIE EXCEPT = ! SAKE ( FRE$OM3 !RE=E !Y DO NOT BELIEVE 9 DY+ COMPLETELY4 

,! SAME REASON+ CAN BE APPLI$ TO VIOL5CE4 ,ABSOLUTE NONVIOL5CE IS ! NEGATIVE BASIS ( SLAV]Y & 
ITS ACTS ( VIOL5CE2 SY/EMATIC VIOL5CE POSITIVELY DE/ROYS ! LIV+ COMMUNITY & ! EXI/5CE WE 
RECEIVE FROM IT4 ,TO BE FRUITFUL1 !SE TWO IDEAS MU/ E/ABLI% F9AL LIMITS4 ,9 HI/ORY1 CONSID]$ AS AN 
ABSOLUTE1 VIOL5CE F9DS ITSELF LEGITIMIZ$2 AS A RELATIVE RISK1 IT IS ! CAUSE ( A RUPTURE 
9 COMMUNICATION4 ,IT MU/ !RE=E PRES]VE1 = ! REBEL1 ITS PROVISIONAL *>ACT] ( EFFRACTION & 
MU/ ALWAYS BE B\ND1 IF IT CANNOT BE AVOID$1 TO A P]SONAL RESPONSIBILITY & TO AN IMM$IATE RISK4 

,SY/EMATIC VIOL5CE IS P>T ( ! ORD] ( ?+S2 9 A C]TA9 S5SE1 ?IS IS CONSOLATORY4 ,FUHR]PR9ZIP OR 
HI/ORICAL ,REASON1 :ATEV] ORD] MAY E/ABLI% IT1 IT REIGNS OV] ! UNIV]SE ( ?+S1 NOT ! UNIV]SE 
( M54 ,JU/ AS ! REBEL CONSID]S MURD] AS ! LIMIT ?AT HE MU/1 IF HE IS SO 9CL9$1 CONSECRATE BY HIS 
[N DEA?1 SO VIOL5CE CAN ONLY BE AN EXTREME LIMIT :I* COMBATS ANO!R =M ( VIOL5CE1 AS1 = 
EXAMPLE1 9 ! CASE ( AN 9SURRECTION4 ,IF AN EXCESS ( 9JU/ICE R5D]S ! LATT] 9EVITABLE1 ! REBEL 
REJECTS VIOL5CE 9 ADVANCE1 9 ! S]VICE ( A DOCTR9E OR ( A REASON ( ,/ATE4 ,EV]Y HI/ORICAL CRISIS1 = 
EXAMPLE1 T]M9ATES 9 9/ITUTIONS4 ,IF WE HAVE NO CONTROL OV] ! CRISIS ITSELF1 :I* IS PURE HAZ>D1 WE 
DO HAVE CONTROL OV] ! 9/ITUTIONS1 S9CE WE CAN DEF9E !M1 *OOSE ! ONES = :I* WE WILL FI<T1 
& ?US B5D \R EF=TS T[>D !IR E/ABLI%M5T4 ,AU!NTIC >TS ( REBELLION WILL ONLY CONS5T TO TAKE 
UP >MS = 9/ITUTIONS ?AT LIMIT VIOL5CE1 NOT = ?OSE :I* CODIFY IT4 ,A REVOLUTION IS NOT WOR? DY+ 
= UNLESS IT ASSURES ! IMM$IATE SUPPRESSION ( ! DEA? P5ALTY2 NOT WOR? GO+ TO PRISON = UNLESS 
IT REFUSES 9 ADVANCE TO PASS S5T5CE )\T FIX$ T]MS4 ,IF REBEL VIOL5CE EMPLOYS ITSELF 9 ! 
E/ABLI%M5T ( !SE 9/ITUTIONS1 ANN\NC+ ITS AIMS AS (T5 AS IT CAN1 IT IS ! ONLY WAY 9 :I* IT 
CAN BE REALLY PROVISIONAL4 ,:5 ! 5D IS ABSOLUTE1 HI/ORICALLY SPEAK+1 & :5 IT IS BELIEV$ C]TA9 
( REALIZATION1 IT IS POSSIBLE TO GO SO F> AS TO SACRIFICE O!RS4 ,:5 IT IS NOT1 ONLY ONESELF CAN BE 
SACRIFIC$1 9 ! HAZ>DS ( A /RUGGLE = ! COMMON DIGNITY ( MAN4 ,DOES ! 5D JU/IFY ! MEANS8 

,?AT IS POSSIBLE4 ,BUT :AT WILL JU/IFY ! 5D8 ,TO ?AT QUE/ION1 :I* HI/ORICAL ?\<T LEAVES P5D+1 
REBELLION REPLIES3 ! MEANS4 

,:AT DOES SU* AN ATTITUDE SIGNIFY 9 POLITICS8 ,&1 FIR/ ( ALL1 IS IT EFFICACI\S8 ,WE MU/ ANSW] )\T 
HESITATION ?AT IT IS ! ONLY ATTITUDE ?AT IS EFFICACI\S TODAY4 ,!RE >E TWO SORTS ( EFFICACITY3 ?AT ( 
TYPHOONS & ?AT ( SAP4 ,HI/ORICAL ABSOLUTISM IS NOT EFFICACI\S1 IT IS EFFICI5T2 IT HAS SEIZ$ & KEPT 
P[]4 ,ONCE IT IS 9 POSSESSION 
( P[]1 IT DE/ROYS ! ONLY CREATIVE REALITY4 ,UNCOMPROMIS+ & LIMIT$ ACTION1 SPR++ FROM 
REBELLION1 UPHOLDS ?IS REALITY & ONLY TRIES TO EXT5D IT F>!R & F>!R4 ,IT IS NOT SAID ?AT ?IS ACTION 
CANNOT CONQU]4 ,IT IS SAID ?AT IT RUNS ! RISK ( NOT CONQU]+ & ( DY+4 ,BUT EI!R REVOLUTION WILL 
TAKE ?IS RISK OR IT WILL CONFESS ?AT IT IS ONLY ! UND]TAK+ ( A NEW SET ( MA/]S1 PUNI%ABLE BY ! 
SAME SCORN4 ,A REVOLUTION ?AT IS SEP>AT$ FROM HONOR BETRAYS ITS ORIG9S ?AT BELONG TO ! REIGN ( HONOR4 

,ITS *OICE1 9 ANY CASE1 IS LIMIT$ TO MAT]IAL EXP$I5CY & F9AL ANNIHILATION1 OR TO RISKS & H5CE TO 
CREATION4 ,! REVOLUTION>IES ( ! PA/ W5T AHEAD AS FA/ AS !Y C\LD & !IR OPTIMISM WAS 
COMPLETE4 ,BUT TODAY ! REVOLUTION>Y SPIRIT HAS GR[N 9 KN[L$GE & CLE>-SI<T$NESS2 IT HAS BEH9D 
IT A HUNDR$ & FIFTY YE>S ( EXP]I5CE4 ,MOREOV]1 ! REVOLUTION HAS LO/ ITS ILLUSIONS ( BE+ A PUBLIC 
HOLIDAY4 ,IT IS1 5TIRELY ON ITS [N1 A PRODIGI\S & CALCULAT$ 5T]PRISE1 :I* EMBRACES ! 5TIRE 
UNIV]SE4 ,IT KN[S1 EV5 ?\< IT DOES NOT ALWAYS SAY SO1 ?AT IT WILL BE WORLD-WIDE OR ?AT IT WILL NOT BE 
AT ALL4 ,ITS *ANCES >E BALANC$ AGA9/ ! RISK ( A UNIV]SAL W>1 :I*1 EV5 9 ! EV5T ( VICTORY1 WILL 
ONLY PRES5T IT ) AN ,EMPIRE ( RU9S4 ,IT CAN REMA9 FAI?FUL TO ITS NIHILISM1 & 9C>NATE 9 ! *>NEL 
H\SES ! ULTIMATE REASON ( HI/ORY4 ,!N IT WILL BE NECESS>Y TO R5\NCE EV]Y?+ EXCEPT ! SIL5T 
MUSIC ?AT WILL AGA9 TRANSFIGURE ! T]RE/RIAL HELL4 ,BUT ! REVOLUTION>Y SPIRIT 9 ,EUROPE CAN ALSO1 = ! 
FIR/ & LA/ TIME1 REFLECT UPON ITS PR9CIPLES1 ASK ITSELF :AT ! DEVIATION IS :I* LEADS IT 9TO T]ROR & 
9TO W>1 & R$ISCOV] ) ! REASONS = ITS REBELLION1 ITS FAI? 9 ITSELF4 

,MOD]ATION & ,EXCESS 

,! ]RORS ( CONTEMPOR>Y REVOLUTION >E FIR/ ( ALL EXPLA9$ BY ! IGNORANCE OR SY/EMATIC 
MISCONCEPTION ( ?AT LIMIT :I* SEEMS 9SEP>ABLE FROM HUMAN NATURE & :I* REBELLION REVEALS4 

,NIHILI/ ?\<T1 BECAUSE IT NEGLECTS ?IS FRONTI]1 5DS BY PRECIPITAT+ ITSELF 9TO A UNI=MLY ACCEL]AT$ 
MOVEM5T4 ,NO?+ ANY LONG] *ECKS IT 9 ITS C\RSE & IT REA*ES ! PO9T ( JU/IFY+ TOTAL 
DE/RUCTION OR UNLIMIT$ CONQUE/4 ,WE N[ KN[1 AT ! 5D ( ?IS LONG 9QUIRY 9TO REBELLION & 
NIHILISM1 ?AT REBELLION ) NO O!R LIMITS BUT HI/ORICAL EXP$I5CY SIGNIFIES UNLIMIT$ SLAV]Y4 ,TO 
ESCAPE ?IS FATE1 ! REVOLUTION>Y M9D1 IF IT WANTS TO REMA9 ALIVE1 MU/ !RE=E RETURN AGA9 TO ! 
S\RCES ( REBELLION & DRAW ITS 9SPIRATION FROM ! ONLY SY/EM ( ?\<T :I* IS FAI?FUL TO ITS 
ORIG9S3 ?\<T ?AT RECOGNIZES LIMITS4 ,IF ! LIMIT DISCOV]$ BY REBELLION TRANSFIGURES EV]Y?+1 IF 
EV]Y ?\<T1 EV]Y ACTION ?AT GOES BEYOND A C]TA9 PO9T NEGATES ITSELF1 !RE IS1 9 FACT1 A MEASURE BY 
:I* TO JUDGE EV5TS & M54 ,9 HI/ORY1 AS 9 PSY*OLOGY1 REBELLION IS AN IRREGUL> P5DULUM1 :I* 
SW+S 9 AN ]RATIC >C BECAUSE IT IS LOOK+ = ITS MO/ P]FECT & PR(\ND RHY?M4 ,BUT ITS IRREGUL>ITY 
IS NOT TOTAL3 IT FUNCTIONS >\ND A PIVOT4 ,REBELLION1 AT ! SAME TIME ?AT IT SUGGE/S A NATURE COMMON TO ALL 
M51 BR+S TO LI<T ! MEASURE & ! LIMIT :I* >E ! V]Y PR9CIPLE ( ?IS NATURE4 

,EV]Y REFLECTION TODAY1 :E!R NIHILI/ OR POSITIVI/1 GIVES BIR?1 SOMETIMES )\T KN[+ IT1 TO 
/&>DS ?AT SCI5CE ITSELF CONFIRMS4 ,! QUANTUM !ORY1 RELATIVITY1 ! UNC]TA9TY ( 9T]RELATION%IPS1 
DEF9E A WORLD ?AT HAS NO DEF9ABLE REALITY EXCEPT ON ! SCALE ( AV]AGE 
GREATNESS1 :I* IS \R [N4 ,! IDEOLOGIES :I* GUIDE \R WORLD W]E BORN 9 ! TIME ( ABSOLUTE 
SCI5TIFIC DISCOV]IES4 ,\R REAL KN[L$GE1 ON_/! O!R H&1 ONLY JU/IFIES A SY/EM ( ?\<T BAS$ ON 
RELATIVE DISCOV]IES4 0,9TELLIG5CE10 SAYS ,LAZ>E ,BICKEL1 0IS \R FACULTY = NOT DEVELOP+ :AT WE ?9K 
TO ! V]Y 5D1 SO ?AT WE CAN /ILL BELIEVE 9 REALITY40 ,APPROXIMATIVE ?\<T IS ! ONLY CREATOR ( 
REALITY4.<#h#g.> 

,! V]Y =CES ( MATT]1 9 !IR BL9D ADVANCE1 IMPOSE !IR [N LIMITS4 ,?AT IS :Y IT IS USELESS TO 
WANT TO REV]SE ! ADVANCE ( TE*NOLOGY4 ,! AGE ( ! SP9N+-:EEL IS OV] & ! DREAM ( A 
CIVILIZATION ( >TISANS IS VA94 ,! MA*9E IS BAD ONLY 9 ! WAY ?AT IT IS N[ EMPLOY$4 ,ITS B5EFITS 
MU/ BE ACCEPT$ EV5 IF ITS RAVAGES >E REJECT$4 ,! TRUCK1 DRIV5 DAY & NI<T1 DOES NOT HUMILIATE ITS 
DRIV]1 :O KN[S IT 9SIDE \T & TREATS IT ) AFFECTION & EFFICI5CY4 ,! REAL & 9HUMAN EXCESS 
LIES 9 ! DIVISION ( LABOR4 ,BUT BY D9T ( ?IS EXCESS1 A DAY COMES :5 A MA*9E CAPABLE ( A HUNDR$ 
OP]ATIONS1 OP]AT$ BY ONE MAN1 CREATES ONE SOLE OBJECT4 ,?IS MAN1 ON A DIFF]5T SCALE1 WILL HAVE 
P>TIALLY R$ISCOV]$ ! P[] ( CREATION :I* HE POSSESS$ 9 ! DAYS ( ! >TISAN4 ,! ANONYM\S 
PRODUC] !N MORE NE>LY APPROA*ES ! CREATOR4 ,IT IS NOT C]TA91 NATURALLY1 ?AT 9DU/RIAL EXCESS WILL 
IMM$IATELY EMB>K ON ?IS PA?4 ,BUT IT ALREADY DEMON/RATES1 BY ! WAY IT FUNCTIONS1 ! NECESSITY = 
MOD]ATION & GIVES RISE TO REFLECTIONS ON ! PROP] WAY TO ORGANIZE ?IS MOD]ATION4 ,EI!R ?IS VALUE 
( LIMITATION WILL BE REALIZ$1 OR CONTEMPOR>Y EXCESSES WILL ONLY F9D !IR PR9CIPLE & PEACE 9 UNIV]SAL DE/RUCTION4 

,?IS LAW ( MOD]ATION EQUALLY WELL EXT5DS TO ALL ! CONTRADICTIONS ( REBELLI\S ?\<T4 ,! REAL IS NOT 
5TIRELY RATIONAL1 NOR IS ! RATIONAL 5TIRELY REAL4 ,AS WE HAVE SE5 9 REG>D TO SURREALISM1 ! DESIRE = 
UNITY NOT ONLY DEM&S ?AT EV]Y?+ %\LD BE RATIONAL4 ,IT ALSO WI%ES ?AT ! IRRATIONAL %\LD NOT BE SACRIFIC$4 

,ONE CANNOT SAY ?AT NO?+ HAS ANY MEAN+1 BECAUSE 9 DO+ SO ONE AFFIRMS A VALUE SANCTIFI$ BY AN 
OP9ION2 NOR ?AT EV]Y?+ HAS A MEAN+1 BECAUSE ! WORD EV]Y?+ HAS NO MEAN+ = US4 ,! 
IRRATIONAL IMPOSES LIMITS ON ! RATIONAL1 :I*1 9 ITS TURN1 GIVES IT ITS MOD]ATION4 ,SOME?+ HAS A 
MEAN+1 F9ALLY1 :I* WE MU/ OBTA9 FROM MEAN+LESSNESS4 ,9 ! SAME WAY1 IT CANNOT BE SAID ?AT 
EXI/5CE TAKES PLACE ONLY ON ! LEVEL ( ESS5CE4 ,:]E C\LD ONE P]CEIVE ESS5CE EXCEPT ON ! LEVEL 
( EXI/5CE & EVOLUTION8 ,BUT NOR CAN IT BE SAID ?AT BE+ IS ONLY EXI/5CE4 ,SOME?+ ?AT IS ALWAYS 9 
! PROCESS ( DEVELOPM5T C\LD NOT EXI/--!RE MU/ BE A BEG9N+4 ,BE+ CAN ONLY PROVE ITSELF 9 
DEVELOPM5T1 & DEVELOPM5T IS NO?+ )\T BE+4 ,! WORLD IS NOT 9 A CONDITION ( PURE /ABILITY2 
NOR IS IT ONLY MOVEM5T4 ,IT IS BO? MOVEM5T & /ABILITY4 ,! HI/ORICAL DIALECTIC1 = EXAMPLE1 IS NOT 9 
CONT9U\S PURSUIT ( AN UNKN[N VALUE4 ,IT REVOLVES >\ND ! LIMIT1 :I* IS ITS PRIME VALUE4 ,H]ACLITUS1 
! DISCOV]] ( ! CON/ANT *ANGE ( ?+S1 NEV]!LESS SET A LIMIT TO ?IS P]PETUAL PROCESS4 ,?IS 
LIMIT WAS SYMBOLIZ$ BY ,NEMESIS1 ! GODDESS ( MOD]ATION & ! IMPLACABLE 5EMY ( ! 
IMMOD]ATE4 ,A PROCESS ( ?\<T :I* WANT$ TO TAKE 9TO ACC\NT ! CONTEMPOR>Y CONTRADICTIONS ( REBELLION %\LD SEEK ITS 9SPIRATION FROM ?IS GODDESS4 

,AS = ! MORAL CONTRADICTIONS1 !Y TOO BEG9 TO BECOME SOLUBLE 9 ! LI<T ( ?IS CONCILIATORY VALUE4 

,VIRTUE CANNOT SEP>ATE ITSELF FROM REALITY )\T BECOM+ A PR9CIPLE ( EVIL4 ,NOR CAN IT ID5TIFY ITSELF 
COMPLETELY ) REALITY )\T D5Y+ ITSELF4 ,! MORAL VALUE BR\<T TO LI<T BY REBELLION1 F9ALLY1 IS NO 
F>!R ABOVE' LIFE & HI/ORY ?AN HI/ORY & LIFE >E ABOVE IT4 ,9 ACTUAL TRU?1 IT ASSUMES NO REALITY 9 
HI/ORY UNTIL MAN GIVES HIS LIFE = IT OR D$ICATES HIMSELF 5TIRELY TO IT4 ,JACOB9 & B\RGEOIS CIVILIZATION 
PRESUMES ?AT VALUES >E ABOVE HI/ORY1 & ITS =MAL VIRTUES !N LAY ! F\NDATION ( A REPUGNANT =M 
( MY/IFICATION4 ,! REVOLUTION ( ! TW5TIE? C5TURY DECREES ?AT VALUES >E 9T]M+L$ ) ! 
MOVEM5T ( HI/ORY & ?AT !IR HI/ORICAL F\NDATIONS JU/IFY A NEW =M ( MY/IFICATION4 ,MOD]ATION1 CONFRONT$ ) ?IS IRREGUL>ITY1 TEA*ES US ?AT AT LEA/ ONE P>T ( REALISM IS NECESS>Y TO EV]Y E?IC3 PURE & UNADULT]AT$ VIRTUE IS HOMICIDAL4 ,& ONE P>T ( E?ICS IS NECESS>Y TO 
ALL REALISM3 CYNICISM IS HOMICIDAL4 ,?AT IS :Y HUMANIT>IAN CANT HAS NO MORE BASIS ?AN CYNICAL PROVOCATION4 ,F9ALLY1 MAN IS NOT 5TIRELY TO BLAME2 IT WAS NOT HE :O />T$ HI/ORY2 NOR IS HE 5TIRELY 
9NOC5T1 S9CE HE CONT9UES IT4 ,?OSE :O GO BEYOND ?IS LIMIT & AFFIRM HIS TOTAL 9NOC5CE 5D 9 ! 9SANITY ( DEF9ITIVE CULPABILITY4 ,REBELLION1 ON ! CONTR>Y1 SETS US ON ! PA? ( CALCULAT$ CULPABILITY4 

,ITS SOLE BUT 9V9CIBLE HOPE IS 9C>NAT$1 9 ! F9AL ANALYSIS1 9 9NOC5T MURD]]S4 

,AT ?IS LIMIT1 ! 0,WE >E0 P>ADOXICALLY DEF9ES A NEW =M ( 9DIVIDUALISM4 0,WE >E0 9 T]MS ( HI/ORY1 & HI/ORY MU/ RECKON ) ?IS 0,WE >E10 :I* MU/ 9 ITS TURN KEEP ITS PLACE 9 HI/ORY4 ,I HAVE 
NE$ ( O!RS :O HAVE NE$ ( ME & ( EA* O!R4 ,EV]Y COLLECTIVE ACTION1 EV]Y =M ( SOCIETY1 
SUPPOSES A DISCIPL9E1 & ! 9DIVIDUAL1 )\T ?IS DISCIPL9E1 IS ONLY A /RANG]1 B[$ D[N UND] 
! WEI<T ( AN 9IMICAL COLLECTIVITY4 ,BUT SOCIETY & DISCIPL9E LOSE !IR DIRECTION IF !Y D5Y ! 0,WE 
>E40 ,I ALONE1 9 ONE S5SE1 SUPPORT ! COMMON DIGNITY ?AT ,I CANNOT ALL[ EI!R MYSELF OR O!RS TO 
DEBASE4 ,?IS 9DIVIDUALISM IS 9 NO S5SE PLEASURE2 IT IS P]PETUAL /RUGGLE1 &1 SOMETIMES1 UNP>ALLEL$ JOY :5 IT REA*ES ! HEI<TS ( PR\D COMPASSION4 

,?\<T AT ! ,M]IDIAN 

,AS = KN[+ IF SU* AN ATTITUDE CAN F9D POLITICAL EXPRESSION 9 ! CONTEMPOR>Y WORLD1 IT IS EASY TO 
EVOKE --& ?IS IS ONLY AN EXAMPLE--:AT IS TRADITIONALLY CALL$ REVOLUTION>Y TRADE-UNIONISM4 ,CANNOT IT 
BE SAID ?AT EV5 ?IS TRADE-UNIONISM IS 9EFFECTUAL8 ,! ANSW] IS SIMPLE3 IT IS ?IS MOVEM5T ALONE ?AT1 
9 ONE C5TURY1 IS RESPONSIBLE = ! 5ORM\SLY IMPROV$ CONDITION ( ! WORK]S FROM ! SIXTE5- 
H\R DAY TO ! =TY-H\R WEEK4 ,! IDEOLOGICAL ,EMPIRE HAS TURN$ SOCIALISM BACK ON ITS TRACKS & 
DE/ROY$ ! GREAT] P>T ( ! CONQUE/S ( TRADE- 
UNIONISM4 ,IT IS BECAUSE TRADE-UNIONISM />T$ FROM A CONCRETE BASIS1 ! BASIS ( PR(ESSIONAL EMPLOYM5T 7:I* IS 
TO ! ECONOMIC ORD] :AT ! COMMUNE IS TO ! POLITICAL ORD]71 ! LIV+ CELL ON :I* ! ORGANISM BUILDS 
ITSELF1 :ILE ! ,CES>EAN REVOLUTION />TS FROM DOCTR9E & =CIBLY 9TRODUCES REALITY 9TO IT4 ,TRADE-UNIONISM1 LIKE 
! COMMUNE1 IS ! NEGATION1 TO ! B5EFIT ( REALITY1 ( BUREAUCRATIC & AB/RACT C5TRALISM4.<#h#h.> ,! REVOLUTION ( ! 
TW5TIE? C5TURY1 ON ! CONTR>Y1 CLAIMS TO BASE ITSELF ON ECONOMICS1 BUT IS PRIM>ILY POLITICAL & IDEOLOGICAL4 ,IT 
CANNOT1 BY ITS V]Y FUNCTION1 AVOID T5OR & VIOL5CE DONE TO ! REAL4 ,DESPITE ITS PRET5SIONS1 IT BEG9S 9 ! 
ABSOLUTE & ATTEMPTS TO MOLD REALITY4 ,REBELLION1 9V]SELY1 RELIES ON REALITY TO ASSI/ IT 9 ITS P]PETUAL /RUGGLE = 
TRU?4 ,! =M] TRIES TO REALIZE ITSELF FROM TOP TO BOTTOM1 ! LATT] FROM BOTTOM TO TOP4 ,F> FROM BE+ A =M ( 
ROMANTICISM1 REBELLION1 ON ! CONTR>Y1 TAKES ! P>T ( TRUE REALISM4 ,IF IT WANTS A REVOLUTION1 IT WANTS IT ON BEHALF ( 
LIFE1 NOT 9 DEFIANCE ( IT4 ,?AT IS :Y IT RELIES PRIM>ILY ON ! MO/ CONCRETE REALITIES--ON OCCUPATION1 ON ! 
VILLAGE1 :]E ! LIV+ HE>T ( ?+S & ( M5 IS TO BE F\ND4 ,POLITICS1 TO SATISFY ! DEM&S ( REBELLION1 MU/ 
SUBMIT TO ! ET]NAL V]ITIES4 ,F9ALLY1 :5 IT CAUSES HI/ORY TO ADVANCE & ALLEVIATES ! SUFF]+S ( MANK9D1 IT 
DOES SO )\T T]ROR1 IF NOT )\T VIOL5CE1 & 9 ! MO/ DISSIMIL> POLITICAL CONDITIONS4.<#h#i.> ,BUT ?IS EXAMPLE GOES 
F>!R ?AN IT SEEMS4 ,ON ! V]Y DAY :5 ! ,CES>EAN REVOLUTION TRIUMPH$ OV] ! SYNDICALI/ & LIB]T>IAN 
SPIRIT1 REVOLUTION>Y ?\<T LO/1 9 ITSELF1 A C\NT]POISE ( :I* IT CANNOT1 )\T DECAY+1 DEPRIVE ITSELF4 ,?IS 
C\NT]POISE1 ?IS SPIRIT :I* TAKES ! MEASURE ( LIFE1 IS ! SAME ?AT ANIMATES ! LONG TRADITION ?AT CAN BE CALL$ SOLIT>Y ?\<T1 9 :I*1 S9CE ! TIME ( ! ,GREEKS1 NATURE HAS ALWAYS 
BE5 WEI<$ AGA9/ EVOLUTION4 ,! HI/ORY ( ! ,FIR/ ,9T]NATIONAL1 :5 ,G]MAN ,SOCIALISM 
CEASELESSLY F\<T AGA9/ ! LIB]T>IAN ?\<T ( ! ,FR5*1 ! ,SPANI%1 & ! ,ITALIANS1 IS ! HI/ORY 
( ! /RUGGLE ( ,G]MAN IDEOLOGY AGA9/ ! ,M$IT]RANEAN M9D4#d ,! COMMUNE AGA9/ ! ,/ATE1 
CONCRETE SOCIETY AGA9/ ABSOLUTI/ SOCIETY1 DELIB]ATE FRE$OM AGA9/ RATIONAL TYRANNY1 F9ALLY ALTRUI/IC 
9DIVIDUALISM AGA9/ ! COLONIZATION ( ! MASSES1 >E1 !N1 ! CONTRADICTIONS ?AT EXPRESS ONCE AGA9 
! 5DLESS OPPOSITION ( MOD]ATION TO EXCESS :I* HAS ANIMAT$ ! HI/ORY ( ! ,OCCID5T S9CE ! 
TIME ( ! ANCI5T WORLD4 ,! PR(\ND CONFLICT ( ?IS C5TURY IS P]HAPS NOT SO MU* BETWE5 ! 
,G]MAN IDEOLOGIES ( HI/ORY & ,*RI/IAN POLITICAL CONCEPTS1 :I* 9 A C]TA9 WAY >E ACCOMPLICES1 AS 
BETWE5 ,G]MAN DREAMS & ,M$IT]RANEAN TRADITIONS1 BETWE5 ! VIOL5CE ( ET]NAL ADOLESC5CE & 
VIRILE /R5G?1 BETWE5 NO/ALGIA1 R5D]$ MORE ACUTE BY KN[L$GE & BY BOOKS & C\RAGE 
RE9=C$ & 5LI<T5$ BY ! EXP]I5CE ( LIFE--9 O!R WORDS1 BETWE5 HI/ORY & NATURE4 ,BUT 
,G]MAN IDEOLOGY1 9 ?IS S5SE1 HAS COME 9TO AN 9H]ITANCE4 ,IT CONSUMMATES TW5TY C5TURIES ( ABORTIVE 
/RUGGLE AGA9/ NATURE1 FIR/ 9 ! NAME ( A HI/ORIC GOD & !N ( A DEIFI$ HI/ORY4 ,*RI/IANITY1 NO 
D\BT1 WAS ONLY ABLE TO CONQU] ITS CA?OLICITY BY ASSIMILAT+ AS MU* AS IT C\LD ( ,GREEK ?\<T4 ,BUT 
:5 ! ,*UR* DISSIPAT$ ITS ,M$IT]RANEAN H]ITAGE1 IT PLAC$ ! EMPHASIS ON HI/ORY TO ! DETRIM5T 
( NATURE1 CAUS$ ! ,GO?IC TO TRIUMPH OV] ! ROMANCE1 &1 DE/ROY+ A LIMIT 9 ITSELF1 HAS MADE 
9CREAS+ CLAIMS TO TEMPORAL P[] & HI/ORICAL DYNAMISM4 ,:5 NATURE CEASES TO BE AN OBJECT ( 
CONTEMPLATION & ADMIRATION1 IT CAN !N BE NO?+ MORE ?AN MAT]IAL = AN ACTION ?AT AIMS AT 
TRANS=M+ IT4 ,!SE T5D5CIES--& NOT ! CONCEPTS ( M$IATION1 :I* W\LD HAVE COMPRIS$ ! 
REAL /R5G? ( ,*RI/IANITY-->E TRIUMPH+ 9 MOD]N TIMES1 TO ! DETRIM5T ( ,*RI/IANITY ITSELF1 BY AN 
9EVITABLE TURN ( EV5TS4 ,?AT ,GOD %\LD1 9 FACT1 BE EXPELL$ FROM ?IS HI/ORICAL UNIV]SE & ,G]MAN IDEOLOGY .<#i.> BE BORN :]E ACTION IS NO LONG] A PROCESS ( P]FECTION BUT PURE CONQUE/1 IS AN EXPRESSION ( TYRANNY4 

,BUT HI/ORICAL ABSOLUTISM1 DESPITE ITS TRIUMPHS1 HAS NEV] CEAS$ TO COME 9TO COLLISION ) AN 
IRREPRESSIBLE DEM& ( HUMAN NATURE1 ( :I* ! ,M$IT]RANEAN1 :]E 9TELLIG5CE IS 9TIMATELY 
RELAT$ TO ! BL9D+ LI<T ( ! SUN1 GU>DS ! SECRET4 ,REBELLI\S ?\<T1 ?AT ( ! COMMUNE OR ( 
REVOLUTION>Y TRADE-UNIONISM1 HAS NOT CEAS$ TO D5Y ?IS DEM& 9 ! PRES5CE ( B\RGEOIS NIHILISM AS 
WELL AS ( ,CES>EAN SOCIALISM4 ,AU?ORIT>IAN ?\<T1 BY MEANS ( ?REE W>S & ?ANKS TO ! PHYSICAL 
DE/RUCTION ( A REVOLUTION>Y ELITE1 HAS SUCCE$$ 9 SUBM]G+ ?IS LIB]T>IAN TRADITION4 ,BUT ?IS B>R5 
VICTORY IS ONLY PROVISIONAL2 ! BATTLE /ILL CONT9UES4 ,EUROPE HAS NEV] BE5 FREE ( ?IS /RUGGLE BETWE5 
D>KNESS & LI<T4 ,IT HAS ONLY DEGRAD$ ITSELF BY DES]T+ ! /RUGGLE & ECLIPS+ DAY BY NI<T4 ,! 
DE/RUCTION ( ?IS EQUILIBRIUM IS TODAY BE>+ ITS BITT]E/ FRUITS4 ,DEPRIV$ ( \R MEANS ( M$IATION1 
EXIL$ FROM NATURAL BEAUTY1 WE >E ONCE AGA9 9 ! WORLD ( ! ,OLD ,TE/AM5T1 CRU%$ BETWE5 A CRUEL 
,PH>AOH & AN IMPLACABLE HEAV54 ,9 ! COMMON CONDITION ( MIS]Y1 ! ET]NAL DEM& IS HE>D 
AGA92 NATURE ONCE MORE TAKES UP ! FI<T AGA9/ HI/ORY4 ,NATURALLY1 IT IS NOT A QUE/ION ( DESPIS+ 
ANY?+1 OR ( EXALT+ ONE CIVILIZATION AT ! EXP5SE ( ANO!R1 BUT ( SIMPLY SAY+ ?AT IT IS A ?\<T 
:I* ! WORLD TODAY CANNOT DO )\T = V]Y MU* LONG]4 ,!RE IS1 UND\BT$LY1 9 ! ,RUSSIAN 
PEOPLE SOME?+ TO 9SPIRE ,EUROPE ) ! POT5CY ( SACRIFICE1 & 9 ,AM]ICA A NECESS>Y P[] ( 
CON/RUCTION4 ,BUT ! Y\? ( ! WORLD ALWAYS F9D !MSELVES /&+ ON ! SAME %ORE4 ,?R[N 9TO 
! UNWOR?Y MELT+-POT ( ,EUROPE1 DEPRIV$ ( BEAUTY & FRI5D%IP1 WE ,M$IT]RANEANS1 ! PR\DE/ 
( RACES1 LIVE ALWAYS BY ! SAME LI<T4 ,9 ! DEP?S ( ! ,EUROPEAN NI<T1 SOL> ?\<T1 ! CIVILIZATION 
FAC+ TWO WAYS AWAITS ITS DAWN4 ,BUT IT ALREADY ILLUM9ATES ! PA?S ( REAL MA/]Y4 

,REAL MA/]Y CONSI/S 9 REFUT+ ! PREJUDICES ( ! TIME1 9ITIALLY ! DEEPE/ & MO/ MALIGNANT ( 
!M1 :I* W\LD R$UCE MAN1 AFT] HIS DELIV]ANCE FROM EXCESS1 TO A B>R5 WISDOM4 ,IT IS V]Y TRUE ?AT 
EXCESS CAN BE A =M ( SANCTITY :5 IT IS PAID = BY ! MADNESS ( 
,NIETZS*E4 ,BUT IS ?IS 9TOXICATION ( ! S\L :I* IS EXHIBIT$ ON ! SC5E ( \R CULTURE ALWAYS ! 
MADNESS ( EXCESS1 ! FOLLY ( ATTEMPT+ ! IMPOSSIBLE1 ( :I* ! BR& CAN NEV] BE REMOV$ FROM 
HIM :O HAS1 ONCE AT LEA/1 AB&ON$ HIMSELF TO IT8 ,HAS ,PROME!US EV] HAD ?IS FANATICAL OR ACCUS+ 
ASPECT8 ,NO1 \R CIVILIZATION SURVIVES 9 ! COMPLAC5CY ( C[>DLY OR MALIGNANT M9DS--A SACRIFICE TO 
! VANITY ( AG+ ADOLESC5TS4 ,LUCIF] ALSO HAS DI$ ) ,GOD1 & FROM HIS A%ES HAS >IS5 A SPITEFUL 
DEMON :O DOES NOT EV5 UND]/& ! OBJECT ( HIS V5TURE4 ,9 #a#i#e1 EXCESS IS ALWAYS A COM=T1 & 
SOMETIMES A C>E]4 ,MOD]ATION1 ON ! ONE H&1 IS NO?+ BUT PURE T5SION4 ,IT SMILES1 NO D\BT1 & \R 
,CONVULSIONI/S1 D$ICAT$ TO ELABORATE APOCALYPSES1 DESPISE IT4 ,BUT ITS SMILE %9ES BRI<TLY AT ! CLIMAX 
( AN 9T]M9ABLE EF=T3 IT IS 9 ITSELF A SUPPLEM5T>Y S\RCE ( /R5G?4 ,:Y DO !SE PETTY-M9D$ 
,EUROPEANS :O %[ US AN AV>ICI\S FACE1 IF !Y NO LONG] HAVE ! /R5G? TO SMILE1 CLAIM ?AT !IR 
DESP]ATE CONVULSIONS >E EXAMPLES ( SUP]IORITY8 

,! REAL MADNESS ( EXCESS DIES OR CREATES ITS [N MOD]ATION4 ,IT DOES NOT CAUSE ! DEA? ( O!RS 9 
ORD] TO CREATE AN ALIBI = ITSELF4 ,9 ITS MO/ EXTREME MANIFE/ATIONS1 IT F9DS ITS LIMIT1 ON :I*1 LIKE 
,KALIAYEV1 IT SACRIFICES ITSELF IF NECESS>Y4 ,MOD]ATION IS NOT ! OPPOSITE ( REBELLION4 ,REBELLION 9 ITSELF IS 
MOD]ATION1 & IT DEM&S1 DEF5DS1 & RE-CREATES IT ?R\<\T HI/ORY & ITS ET]NAL DI/URBANCES4 ,! 
V]Y ORIG9 ( ?IS VALUE GU>ANTEES US ?AT IT CAN ONLY BE P>TIALLY DE/ROY$4 ,MOD]ATION1 BORN ( 
REBELLION1 CAN ONLY LIVE BY REBELLION4 ,IT IS A P]PETUAL CONFLICT1 CONT9UALLY CREAT$ & MA/]$ BY ! 
9TELLIG5CE4 ,IT DOES NOT TRIUMPH EI!R 9 ! IMPOSSIBLE OR 9 ! ABYSS4 ,IT F9DS ITS EQUILIBRIUM ?R\< 
!M4 ,:ATEV] WE MAY DO1 EXCESS WILL ALWAYS KEEP ITS PLACE 9 ! HE>T ( MAN1 9 ! PLACE :]E 
SOLITUDE IS F\ND4 ,WE ALL C>RY )9 US \R PLACES ( EXILE1 \R CRIMES & \R RAVAGES4 ,BUT \R TASK IS 
NOT TO UNLEA% !M ON ! WORLD2 IT IS TO FI<T !M 9 \RSELVES & 9 O!RS4 ,REBELLION1 ! SECUL> WILL 
NOT TO SURR5D] ( :I* ,B>RES SPEAKS1 IS /ILL TODAY AT ! BASIS ( ! /RUGGLE4 ,ORIG9 ( =M1 S\RCE 
( REAL LIFE1 IT KEEPS US ALWAYS ]ECT 9 ! SAVAGE1 =MLESS MOVEM5T ( HI/ORY4 

,BEYOND ,NIHILISM 

,!RE DOES EXI/ = MAN1 !RE=E1 A WAY ( ACT+ & ( ?9K+ :I* IS 
POSSIBLE ON ! LEVEL ( MOD]ATION TO :I* HE BELONGS4 ,EV]Y UND]TAK+ ?AT IS MORE AMBITI\S ?AN 
?IS PROVES TO BE CONTRADICTORY4 ,! ABSOLUTE IS NOT ATTA9$ NOR1 ABOVE ALL1 CREAT$ ?R\< HI/ORY4 

,POLITICS IS NOT RELIGION1 OR IF IT IS1 !N IT IS NO?+ BUT ! ,9QUISITION4 ,H[ W\LD SOCIETY DEF9E AN 
ABSOLUTE8 ,P]HAPS EV]YONE IS LOOK+ = ?IS ABSOLUTE ON BEHALF ( ALL4 ,BUT SOCIETY & POLITICS ONLY HAVE 
! RESPONSIBILITY ( >RANG+ EV]YONE'S AFFAIRS SO ?AT EA* WILL HAVE ! LEISURE & ! FRE$OM TO 
PURSUE ?IS COMMON SE>*4 ,HI/ORY CAN !N NO LONG] BE PRES5T$ AS AN OBJECT ( WOR%IP4 ,IT IS ONLY AN 
OPPORTUNITY ?AT MU/ BE R5D]$ FRUITFUL BY A VIGILANT REBELLION4 

0,OBSESSION ) ! H>VE/ & 9DIFF]5CE TO HI/ORY10 WRITES ,R5E ,*> ADMIRABLY1 0>E ! TWO 
EXTREMITIES ( MY B[40 ,IF ! DURATION ( HI/ORY IS NOT SYNONYM\S ) ! DURATION ( ! H>VE/1 !N 
HI/ORY1 9 EFFECT1 IS NO MORE ?AN A FLEET+ & CRUEL %AD[ 9 :I* MAN HAS NO MORE P>T4 ,HE :O 
D$ICATES HIMSELF TO ?IS HI/ORY D$ICATES HIMSELF TO NO?+ &1 9 HIS TURN1 IS NO?+4 ,BUT HE :O 
D$ICATES HIMSELF TO ! DURATION ( HIS LIFE1 TO ! H\SE HE BUILDS1 TO ! DIGNITY ( MANK9D1 D$ICATES 
HIMSELF TO ! E>? & REAPS FROM IT ! H>VE/ ?AT S[S ITS SE$ & SU/A9S ! WORLD AGA9 & 
AGA94 ,F9ALLY1 IT IS ?OSE :O KN[ H[ TO REBEL1 AT ! APPROPRIATE MOM5T1 AGA9/ HI/ORY :O REALLY 
ADVANCE ITS 9T]E/S4 ,TO REBEL AGA9/ IT SUPPOSES AN 9T]M9ABLE T5SION & ! AGONIZ$ S]5ITY ( 
:I* ,R5E ,*> ALSO SPEAKS4 ,BUT ! TRUE LIFE IS PRES5T 9 ! HE>T ( ?IS DI*OTOMY4 ,LIFE IS ?IS 
DI*OTOMY ITSELF1 ! 
M9D SO>+ OV] VOLCANOES ( LI<T1 ! MADNESS ( JU/ICE1 ! EXT5UAT+ 9TRANSIG5CE ( MOD]ATION4 

,! WORDS ?AT REV]B]ATE = US AT ! CONF9ES ( ?IS LONG ADV5TURE ( REBELLION >E NOT =MULAS = 
OPTIMISM1 = :I* WE HAVE NO POSSIBLE USE 9 ! EXTREMITIES ( \R UNHAPP9ESS1 BUT WORDS ( C\RAGE 
& 9TELLIG5CE :I*1 ON ! %ORES ( ! ET]NAL SEAS1 EV5 HAVE ! QUALITIES ( VIRTUE4 

,NO POSSIBLE =M ( WISDOM TODAY CAN CLAIM TO GIVE MORE4 ,REBELLION 9DEFATIGABLY CONFRONTS EVIL1 FROM 
:I* IT CAN ONLY D]IVE A NEW IMPETUS4 ,MAN CAN MA/] 9 HIMSELF EV]Y?+ ?AT %\LD BE MA/]$4 

,HE %\LD RECTIFY 9 CREATION EV]Y?+ ?AT CAN BE RECTIFI$4 ,& AFT] HE HAS DONE SO1 *ILDR5 WILL /ILL 
DIE UNJU/LY EV5 9 A P]FECT SOCIETY4 ,EV5 BY HIS GREATE/ EF=T MAN CAN ONLY PROPOSE TO DIM9I% 
>I?METICALLY ! SUFF]+S ( ! WORLD4 ,BUT ! 9JU/ICE & ! SUFF]+ ( ! WORLD WILL REMA9 &1 
NO MATT] H[ LIMIT$ !Y >E1 !Y WILL NOT CEASE TO BE AN \TRAGE4 ,DIMITRI ,K>AMAZOV'S CRY ( 0,:Y80 
WILL CONT9UE TO RES\ND2 >T & REBELLION WILL DIE ONLY ) ! LA/ MAN4 

,!RE IS AN EVIL1 UND\BT$LY1 :I* M5 ACCUMULATE 9 !IR FRANTIC DESIRE = UNITY4 ,BUT YET ANO!R EVIL 
LIES AT ! ROOTS ( ?IS 9ORD9ATE MOVEM5T4 ,CONFRONT$ ) ?IS EVIL1 CONFRONT$ ) DEA?1 MAN FROM 
! V]Y DEP?S ( HIS S\L CRIES \T = JU/ICE4 ,HI/ORICAL ,*RI/IANITY HAS ONLY REPLI$ TO ?IS PROTE/ 
AGA9/ EVIL BY ! ANNUNCIATION ( ! K+DOM & !N ( ET]NAL LIFE1 :I* DEM&S FAI?4 ,BUT 
SUFF]+ EXHAU/S HOPE & FAI? & !N IS LEFT ALONE & UNEXPLA9$4 ,! TOIL+ MASSES1 WORN \T 
) SUFF]+ & DEA?1 >E MASSES )\T ,GOD4 ,\R PLACE IS H5CE=? AT !IR SIDE1 F> FROM TEA*]S1 
OLD OR NEW4 ,HI/ORICAL ,*RI/IANITY PO/PONES TO A PO9T BEYOND ! SPAN ( HI/ORY ! CURE ( EVIL & 
MURD]1 :I* >E NEV]!LESS EXP]I5C$ )9 ! SPAN ( HI/ORY4 ,CONTEMPOR>Y MAT]IALISM ALSO 
BELIEVES ?AT IT CAN ANSW] ALL QUE/IONS4 ,BUT1 AS A SLAVE TO HI/ORY1 IT 9CREASES ! DOMA9 ( HI/ORIC 
MURD] & AT ! SAME TIME LEAVES IT )\T ANY JU/IFICATION1 EXCEPT 9 ! FUTURE--:I* AGA9 
DEM&S FAI?4 ,9 BO? CASES ONE MU/ WAIT1 & MEAN:ILE ! 9NOC5T CONT9UE TO DIE4 ,= TW5TY 
C5TURIES ! SUM TOTAL ( EVIL HAS NOT DIM9I%$ 9 ! WORLD4 ,NO 
P>ADISE1 :E!R DIV9E OR REVOLUTION>Y1 HAS BE5 REALIZ$4 ,AN 9JU/ICE REMA9S 9EXTRICABLY B\ND TO 
ALL SUFF]+1 EV5 ! MO/ DES]V$ 9 ! EYES ( M54 ,! LONG SIL5CE ( ,PROME!US BE=E ! 
P[]S ?AT OV]:ELM$ HIM /ILL CRIES \T 9 PROTE/4 ,BUT ,PROME!US1 MEAN:ILE1 HAS SE5 M5 RAIL & 
TURN AGA9/ HIM4 ,CRU%$ BETWE5 HUMAN EVIL & DE/9Y1 BETWE5 T]ROR & ! >BITR>Y1 ALL ?AT 
REMA9S TO HIM IS HIS P[] TO REBEL 9 ORD] TO SAVE FROM MURD] HIM :O CAN /ILL BE SAV$1 )\T 
SURR5D]+ TO ! >ROGANCE ( BLASPHEMY4 

,!N WE UND]/& ?AT REBELLION CANNOT EXI/ )\T A /RANGE =M ( LOVE4 ,?OSE :O F9D NO RE/ 9 
,GOD OR 9 HI/ORY >E CONDEMN$ TO LIVE = ?OSE :O1 LIKE !MSELVES1 CANNOT LIVE3 9 FACT1 = ! 
HUMILIAT$4 ,! MO/ PURE =M ( ! MOVEM5T ( REBELLION IS ?US CR[N$ ) ! HE>T-R5D+ CRY 
( ,K>AMAZOV3 IF ALL >E NOT SAV$1 :AT GOOD IS ! SALVATION ( ONE ONLY8 ,?US ,CA?OLIC PRISON]S1 9 ! 
PRISON CELLS ( ,SPA91 REFUSE COMMUNION TODAY BECAUSE ! PRIE/S ( ! REGIME HAVE MADE IT OBLIGATORY 
9 C]TA9 PRISONS4 ,!SE LONELY WITNESSES TO ! CRUCIFIXION ( 9NOC5CE ALSO REFUSE SALVATION IF IT MU/ 
BE PAID = BY 9JU/ICE & OPPRESSION4 ,?IS 9SANE G5]OSITY IS ! G5]OSITY ( REBELLION1 :I* 
UNHESITAT+LY GIVES ! /R5G? ( ITS LOVE & )\T A MOM5T'S DELAY REFUSES 9JU/ICE4 ,ITS M]IT LIES 
9 MAK+ NO CALCULATIONS1 DI/RIBUT+ EV]Y?+ IT POSSESSES TO LIFE & TO LIV+ M54 ,IT IS ?US ?AT IT IS 
PRODIGAL 9 ITS GIFTS TO M5 TO COME4 ,REAL G5]OSITY T[>D ! FUTURE LIES 9 GIV+ ALL TO ! PRES5T4 

,REBELLION PROVES 9 ?IS WAY ?AT IT IS ! V]Y MOVEM5T ( LIFE & ?AT IT CANNOT BE D5I$ )\T 
R5\NC+ LIFE4 ,ITS PURE/ \TBUR/1 ON EA* OCCASION1 GIVES BIR? TO EXI/5CE4 ,?US IT IS LOVE & 
FECUNDITY OR IT IS NO?+ AT ALL4 ,REVOLUTION )\T HONOR1 CALCULAT$ REVOLUTION :I*1 9 PREF]R+ AN 
AB/RACT CONCEPT ( MAN TO A MAN ( FLE% & BLOOD1 D5IES EXI/5CE AS MANY TIMES AS IS NECESS>Y1 PUTS 
RES5TM5T 9 ! PLACE ( LOVE4 ,IMM$IATELY REBELLION1 =GETFUL ( ITS G5]\S ORIG9S1 ALL[S ITSELF TO BE 
CONTAM9AT$ BY RES5TM5T2 IT D5IES LIFE1 DA%ES T[>D DE/RUCTION1 & RAISES UP ! GRIMAC+ COHORTS 
( PETTY REBELS1 EMBRYO SLAVES ALL ( !M1 :O 5D BY (F]+ !MSELVES = SALE1 TODAY1 9 ALL ! 
M>KET- 
PLACES ( ,EUROPE1 TO NO MATT] :AT =M ( S]VITUDE4 ,IT IS NO LONG] EI!R REVOLUTION OR REBELLION BUT 
RANCOR1 MALICE1 & TYRANNY4 ,!N1 :5 REVOLUTION 9 ! NAME ( P[] & ( HI/ORY BECOMES A 
MURD]\S & IMMOD]ATE ME*ANISM1 A NEW REBELLION IS CONSECRAT$ 9 ! NAME ( MOD]ATION & ( 
LIFE4 ,WE >E AT ?AT EXTREMITY N[4 ,AT ! 5D ( ?IS TUNNEL ( D>KNESS1 H[EV]1 !RE IS 9EVITABLY A 
LI<T1 :I* WE ALREADY DIV9E & = :I* WE ONLY HAVE TO FI<T TO 5SURE ITS COM+4 ,ALL ( US1 AMONG 
! RU9S1 >E PREP>+ A R5AISSANCE BEYOND ! LIMITS ( NIHILISM4 ,BUT FEW ( US KN[ IT4 

,ALREADY1 9 FACT1 REBELLION1 )\T CLAIM+ TO SOLVE EV]Y?+1 CAN AT LEA/ CONFRONT ITS PROBLEMS4 ,FROM 
?IS MOM5T HI< NOON IS BORNE AWAY ON ! FA/-MOV+ /REAM ( HI/ORY4 ,>\ND ! DEV\R+ FLAMES1 
%AD[S WRI! 9 MORTAL COMBAT = AN 9/ANT ( TIME & !N AS SUDD5LY DISAPPE>1 & ! BL9D1 
F+]+ !IR EYELIDS1 CRY \T ?AT ?IS IS HI/ORY4 ,! M5 ( ,EUROPE1 AB&ON$ TO ! %AD[S1 HAVE 
TURN$ !IR BACKS UPON ! FIX$ & RADIANT PO9T ( ! PRES5T4 ,!Y =GET ! PRES5T = ! FUTURE1 
! FATE ( HUMANITY = ! DELUSION ( P[]1 ! MIS]Y ( ! SLUMS = ! MIRAGE ( ! ET]NAL CITY1 
ORD9>Y JU/ICE = AN EMPTY PROMIS$ L&4 ,!Y DESPAIR ( P]SONAL FRE$OM & DREAM ( A /RANGE 
FRE$OM ( ! SPECIES2 REJECT SOLIT>Y DEA? & GIVE ! NAME ( IMMORTALITY TO A VA/ COLLECTIVE AGONY4 

,!Y NO LONG] BELIEVE 9 ! ?+S ?AT EXI/ 9 ! WORLD & 9 LIV+ MAN2 ! SECRET ( ,EUROPE IS ?AT 
IT NO LONG] LOVES LIFE4 ,ITS BL9D M5 5T]TA9 ! PU]ILE BELIEF ?AT TO LOVE ONE S+LE DAY ( LIFE AM\NTS 
TO JU/IFY+ :OLE C5TURIES ( OPPRESSION4 ,?AT IS :Y !Y WANT$ TO EFFACE JOY FROM ! WORLD & TO 
PO/PONE IT UNTIL A MU* LAT] DATE4 ,IMPATI5CE ) LIMITS1 ! REJECTION ( !IR D\BLE LIFE1 DESPAIR AT 
BE+ A MAN1 HAVE F9ALLY DRIV5 !M TO 9HUMAN EXCESSES4 ,D5Y+ ! REAL GR&EUR ( LIFE1 !Y HAVE 
HAD TO /AKE ALL ON !IR [N EXCELL5CE4 ,= WANT ( SOME?+ BETT] TO DO1 !Y DEIFI$ !MSELVES & 
!IR MIS=TUNES BEGAN2 !SE GODS HAVE HAD !IR EYES PUT \T4 ,KALIAYEV1 & HIS BRO!RS ?R\<\T ! 
5TIRE WORLD1 REFUSE1 ON ! CONTR>Y1 TO BE DEIFI$ 9 ?AT !Y REFUSE ! UNLIMIT$ P[] TO 9FLICT DEA?4 

,!Y *OOSE1 & 
GIVE US AS AN EXAMPLE ! ONLY ORIG9AL RULE ( LIFE TODAY3 TO LE>N TO LIVE & TO DIE1 &1 9 ORD] TO BE A 
MAN1 TO REFUSE TO BE A GOD4 

,AT ?IS M]IDIAN ( ?\<T1 ! REBEL ?US REJECTS DIV9ITY 9 ORD] TO %>E 9 ! /RUGGLES & DE/9Y ( 
ALL M54 ,WE %ALL *OOSE ,I?ACA1 ! FAI?FUL L&1 FRUGAL & AUDACI\S ?\<T1 LUCID ACTION1 & ! 
G5]OSITY ( ! MAN :O UND]/&S4 ,9 ! LI<T1 ! E>? REMA9S \R FIR/ & \R LA/ LOVE4 ,\R 
BRO!RS >E BREA?+ UND] ! SAME SKY AS WE2 JU/ICE IS A LIV+ ?+4 ,N[ IS BORN ?AT /RANGE JOY 
:I* HELPS ONE LIVE & DIE1 & :I* WE %ALL NEV] AGA9 PO/PONE TO A LAT] TIME4 ,ON ! SORR[+ 
E>? IT IS ! UNRE/+ ?ORN1 ! BITT] BREW1 ! H>% W9D (F ! SEA1 ! OLD & ! NEW DAWN4 ,) 
?IS JOY1 ?R\< LONG /RUGGLE1 WE %ALL REMAKE ! S\L ( \R TIME1 & A ,EUROPE :I* WILL EXCLUDE 
NO?+4 ,NOT EV5 ?AT PHANTOM ,NIETZS*E1 :O = TWELVE YE>S AFT] HIS D[NFALL WAS CONT9UALLY 
9VOK$ BY ! ,WE/ AS ! BLA/$ IMAGE ( ITS L(TIE/ KN[L$GE & ITS NIHILISM2 NOR ! PROPHET ( 
JU/ICE )\T M]CY :O LIES1 BY MI/AKE1 9 ! UNBELIEV]S' PLOT AT ,HI<GATE ,CEMET]Y2 NOR ! DEIFI$ 
MUMMY ( ! MAN ( ACTION 9 HIS GLASS C(F92 NOR ANY P>T ( :AT ! 9TELLIG5CE & 5]GY ( 
,EUROPE HAVE CEASELESSLY FURNI%$ TO ! PRIDE ( A CONTEMPTIBLE P]IOD4 ,ALL MAY 9DE$ LIVE AGA91 SIDE 
BY SIDE ) ! M>TYRS ( #a#i#e1 BUT ON CONDITION ?AT IT IS UND]/OOD ?AT !Y CORRECT ONE ANO!R1 & 
?AT A LIMIT1 UND] ! SUN1 %ALL CURB !M ALL4 ,EA* TELLS ! O!R ?AT HE IS NOT ,GOD2 ?IS IS ! 5D ( 
ROMANTICISM4 ,AT ?IS MOM5T1 :5 EA* ( US MU/ FIT AN >R[ TO HIS B[ & 5T] ! LI/S ANEW1 TO 
RECONQU]1 )9 HI/ORY & 9 SPITE ( IT1 ?AT :I* HE [NS ALREADY1 ! ?9 YIELD ( HIS FIELDS1 ! 
BRIEF LOVE ( ?IS E>?1 AT ?IS MOM5T :5 AT LA/ A MAN IS BORN1 IT IS TIME TO =SAKE \R AGE & ITS 
ADOLESC5T FURIES4 ,! B[ B5DS2 ! WOOD COMPLA9S4 ,AT ! MOM5T ( SUPREME T5SION1 !RE WILL LEAP 
9TO FLI<T AN UNSW]V+ >R[1 A %AFT ?AT IS 9FLEXIBLE & FREE4 

,FROM 3 ,!,AN>*I/,LIBR>Y4ORG4 

,*RONOLOGY 3 
,JANU>Y #b#d1 #bba 3 ,P>T #e -- ,ADD$4 

 FILE G5]AT$ FROM 3  
HTTP3_/_/REVOLTLIB4COM_/