,! ,REACTION 9 ,G]MANY #ahdb ,PEOPLE 3 ,AU?OR 3 ,MIKHAIL ,BAKUN9 ,TEXT 3 ,PHOTO BY ,L5N]T ,ONKEL9X1,C,C ,B,Y ,LIC5SE ,FRE$OM1 ! REALIZATION ( FRE$OM3 :O CAN D5Y ?AT ?IS EXPRESSION TODAY /&S AT ! HEAD ( ! AG5DA ( HI/ORY8 ,FRI5D & FOE MU/ ADMIT IT2 9DE$1 NO ONE D>ES OP5LY & FE>LESSLY TO PR(ESS ?AT HE IS AN 5EMY ( FRE$OM4 ,BUT ! EXPRESSION1 ! PR(ESSION1 DOES NOT MAKE ! REALITY1 AS ! ,GOSPEL WELL KN[S4 ,UN=TUNATELY1 !RE IS /ILL A MULTITUDE ( PEOPLE :O 9 FACT1 9 !IR 9N]MO/ HE>TS1 DO NOT BELIEVE 9 FRE$OM4 ,& SO1 = FRE$OM'S SAKE1 IT IS WOR? \R :ILE TO CONC]N \RSELVES ) !SE PEOPLE4 ,!Y >E ( V]Y DIFF]5T K9DS4 ,FIR/ ( ALL WE 5C\NT] HI<-PLAC$1 AG$ & EXP]I5C$ PEOPLE :O 9 !IR Y\? W]E !MSELVES DILETTANTES 9 POLITICAL FRE$OM -- A DI/+UI%$ & RI* MAN TAKES A PIQUANT PLEASURE 9 SPEAK+ AB\T FRE$OM & EQUALITY1 & 9 DO+ MAKES HIM TWICE AS 9T]E/+ 9 BUS9ESS4 ,!SE M5 N[ TRY TO HIDE !IR PHYSICAL & SPIRITUAL LAXITY UND] ! SEAL ( ?AT MU* ABUS$ WORD1 'EXP]I5CE'1 N[ ?AT !IR =M] 9T]E/ HAS LEFT !M ALONG ) !IR CAPACITY = Y\?FUL VITALITY4 ,!RE IS NO PR(IT 9 SPEAK+ ) !SE PEOPLE3 !Y W]E NEV] S]I\S AB\T FRE$OM & FRE$OM = !M A RELIGION :I* (F]S ! GREATE/ PLEASURE & ! HIE OLD & >E GO+ TO DIE SOON BON GRE MAL GRE4 ,!RE >E ALSO1 UN=TUNATELY1 MANY Y\NG PEOPLE :O %>E ! SAME CONVICTIONS OR1 RA!R1 LACK ( ANY CONVICTION4 ,!SE BELONG EI!R1 & = ! MO/ P>T1 TO ! >I/OCRACY :I* 9 ITS ESS5CE HAS LONG BE5 POLITICALLY DEAD 9 ,G]MANY1 OR TO ! BUR<]1 COMM]CIAL & (FIC] CLASSES4 ,!RE IS NO?+ Y\ CAN DO ) !SE EI!R1 &1 9DE$1 EV5 LESS ?AN ) ! FIR/ CATEGORY ( PRUD5T & AG$ PEOPLE :OSE DEA? IS ALREADY SO NE>4 ,?OSE HAD AT LEA/ A GLIMM] ( LIFE1 BUT ! LATT] >E LIFELESS & DEAD M5 FROM ! V]Y BEG9N+4 ,COMPLETELY 9VOLV$ 9 !IR PALTRY1 VA91 OR MONET>Y 9T]E/S1 & COMPLETELY OCCUPI$ BY !IR COMMONPLACE CONC]NS1 !Y HAVE NOT EV5 ! SLI\ND !M4 ,HAD !Y NOT HE>D SOME?+ ( HI/ORY & ( ! DEVELOPM5T ( ! SPIRIT 9 S*OOL1 !Y W\LD APP>5TLY BELIEVE ?AT NO?+ 9 ! WORLD HAD EV] BE5 DIFF]5T FROM ! WAY IT IS N[4 ,!Y >E COLORLESS1 FROM !M1 = ONLY ?AT :I* IS ALIVE CAN BE EFFECTIVE1 &1 S9CE IT IS NO LONG] FA%IONABLE TO ASSOCIATE ) IES ( ! PR9CIPLE ( REVOLUTION3 ?AT IS ! ,REACTION>Y P>TY :I* EM]G$ ALL OV] ,EUROPE SOON AFT] ! ,RE/ORATION4 ,9 POLITICS IT IS CALL$ ,CONS]VATISM1 9 JURISPRUD5CE ! ,HI/ORICAL ,S*OOL1 & 9 ! SCI5CE ( SPECULATION1 ,POSITIVE ,PHILOSOPHY4 ,) !SE WE WANT TO SPEAK4 ,IT W\LD BE POOR TA/E 9 \R P>T IF WE IGNOR$ !IR EXI/5CE & ACT$ AS IF WE CONSID]$ !M 9SIGNIFICANT4 ,ON ! CONTR>Y1 WE %ALL HONE/LY ADMIT ?AT !Y >E N[ EV]Y:]E ! RUL+ P>TY4 ,& MORE /ILL3 WE WANT TO CONC$E ?AT !IR PRES5T P[] IS NOT DUE TO A PLAY ( *ANCE BUT HAS ITS DEEP GR\ND 9 ! DEVELOPM5T ( ! MOD]N ,SPIRIT4 ,ANYH[1 ,I CONC$E NO TRUE P[] TO *ANCE 9 HI/ORY -- HI/ORY IS FREE1 BUT CONSEQU5TLY NECESS>Y1 DEVELOPM5T ( ! FREE ,SPIRIT1 SO ?AT IF ,I WANT$ TO CALL ! PRES5T SUPREMACY ( ! ,REACTION>Y ,P>TY A *ANCE EV5T ,I W\LD1 9 SO DO+1 R5D] ! WOR/ POSSIBLE S]VICE TO ! DEMOCRATIC CRE$ :I* UNIQUELY & ALONE IS F\ND$ ON ! UNCONDITIONAL FRE$OM ( ,SPIRIT4 ,SU* AN EVIL1 DECEITFUL S$ATIVE W\LD BE MU* MORE DANG]\S = US3 UN=TUNATELY WE >E AS YET /ILL F> FROM UND]/&+ \R POSITION &1 9 ! ONLY TOO FREQU5T MISUND]/&+ ( ! TRUE S\RCE ( \R P[] & ( ! NATURE ( \R 5EMY1 WE MU/ EI!R :OLLY LOSE \R C\RAGE1 DEPRESS$ BY ! DE>Y PICTURE ( DAILY DRUDG]Y OR -- & ?IS IS P]HAPS WORSE1 S9CE A VITAL HUMAN BE+ CANNOT LONG TOL]ATE DESPAIR1 !RE COMES UPON US A GR\NDLESS1 BOYI%1 & FRUITLESS EXUB]ANCE4 ,NO?+ CAN BE MORE USEFUL TO ! ,DEMOCRATIC P>TY ?AN ! RECOGNITION ( ITS WEAKNESS & ( ! RELATIVE /R5G? ( ITS ADV]S>Y AT ?IS /AGE4 ,?R\< ?IS RECOGNITION ! ,DEMOCRATIC P>TY FIR/ /EPS \T ( ! UNC]TA9TY ( FANTASY & 9TO ! REALITY :I* IT MU/ LIVE1 SUFF]1 &1 9 ! 5D1 CONQU]4 ,?R\< ?IS RECOGNITION ITS 5?USIASM BECOMES DISCREET & HUMBLE4 ,ONLY IF IT FIR/ COMES TO AN AW>5ESS ( ITS HOLY1 PRIE/LY (FICE ?R\< ?IS PA9FUL CONTACT ) REALITY2 ONLY IF IT RECOGNIZES ?R\< ! 5DLESS DIFFICULTIES :I* /& EV]Y:]E 9 ITS WAY & :I* FL[ NOT ONLY FROM ! OBSCURANTISM ( ITS ADV]S>IES1 & IT (T5 SEEMS TO IMPLY1 BUT ALSO & RA!R FROM ! FULLNESS & TOTALITY ( HUMAN NATURE :I* CANNOT BE EXHAU/$ 9 AB/RACT !ORETICAL PROPOSITIONS -- ONLY IF IT FIR/ RECOGNIZES ?R\< !SE DIFFICULTIES ! 9ADEQUACY ( ITS :OLE PRES5T EXI/5CE & ?US COMES TO UND]/& ?AT ITS 5EMY IS AT H& NOT ONLY EXT]NALLY BUT ALSO & MU* MORE 9T]NALLY1 & ?AT IT MU/ !RE=E BEG9 BY CONQU]+ ITS 9T]NAL 5EMY2 ONLY IF IT FIR/ CONV9CES ITSELF ?AT ,DEMOCRACY NOT ONLY /&S 9 OPPOSITION TO ! GOV]NM5T & IS NOT ONLY A P>TICUL> CON/ITUTIONAL OR POLITICO-ECONOMIC *ANGE1 BUT A TOTAL TRANS=MATION ( ?AT WORLD CONDITION & A H]ALD ( AN ORIG9AL1 NEW LIFE :I* HAS NOT YET EXI/$ 9 HI/ORY2 ESPECIALLY ONLY IF IT FIR/ COMES TO UND]/& ?AT ,DEMOCRACY IS A RELIGION1 IF IT ?US ?R\< ?IS AW>5ESS ITSELF BECOMES RELIGI\S1 ?AT IS1 P]MEAT$ BY ITS PR9CIPLE NOT ONLY 9 ?\TY REALLY CONQU] ! WORLD4 ,CONSEQU5TLY1 WE WANT TO ADMIT C&IDLY ?AT ! PRES5T P[] ( ! ,REACTION>Y P>TY IS NOT CONT+5T BUT NECESS>Y4 ,IT HAS ITS GR\ND NOT 9 ! 9ADEQUACY ( ! ,DEMOCRATIC PR9CIPLE -- ?IS IS 9DE$ ?AT ( ! EQUALITY ( MAN REALIZ+ ITSELF 9 FRE$OM & ?US ALSO IS ! MO/ 9TR9SIC1 UNIV]SAL1 & ALL-EMBRAC+1 9 A WORD ! UNIQUE ESS5CE ( ! ,SPIRIT SELF-OP]AT+ 9 HI/ORY4 ,! PRES5T P[] ( ! ,REACTION>Y P>TY IS DUE1 RA!R1 TO ! 9ADEQUACY ( ! ,DEMOCRATIC P>TY :I* HAS NOT YET REA*$ AN AFFIRMATIVE CONSCI\SNESS ( ITS PR9CIPLE & !RE=E EXI/S ONLY AS ! NEGATION ( ! PREVAIL+ REALITY4 ,AS SU*1 AS M]E NEGATION1 ! :OLE FULLNESS ( LIFE IS NECESS>ILY EXT]NAL TO IT2 IT CANNOT YET DEVELOP ?IS FULLNESS \T ( ITS PR9CIPLE :I* IT CONCEIVES ALMO/ :OLLY NEGATIVELY4 ,CONSEQU5TLY1 IT HAS UP TO N[ BE5 ONLY A P>TY & NOT YET ! LIV+ REALITY2 IT HAS BE5 ! FUTURE1 NOT ! PRES5T4 ,?IS FACT1 ?AT ! DEMOCRATS CON/ITUTE ONLY A P>TY -- &1 9DE$1 A WEAK P>TY SO F> AS ITS EXT]NAL EXI/5CE IS CONC]N$ -- & ?AT !IR BE+ ONLY A P>TY PRESUPPOSES ! EXI/5CE ( ANO!R1 OPPOS$1 /RONG P>TY -- ?IS FACT ALONE %\LD ALREADY GIVE !M AN EXPLANATION ( !IR TRUE1 ESS5TIAL1 9H]5T DEFICI5CY4 ,) RESPECT TO ITS ESS5CE1 ITS PR9CIPLE1 ! ,DEMOCRATIC P>TY IS ! UNIV]SAL1 ALL-EMBRAC+ ONE1 BUT1 ) RESPECT TO ITS EXI/5CE1 IT IS ONLY A P>TICUL> ONE1 ! ,NEGATIVE1 AGA9/ :I* /&S ANO!R P>TICUL> ONE1 ! ,POSITIVE4 ,! :OLE SIGNIFICANCE & ! IRREPRESSIBLE P[] ( ! ,NEGATIVE IS ! ANNIHILATION ( ! ,POSITIVE2 BUT ALONG ) ! ,POSITIVE IT LEADS ITSELF TO DE/RUCTION AS ?IS EVIL1 P>TICUL> EXI/5CE :I* IS 9ADEQUATE TO ITS ESS5CE4 ,DEMOCRACY DOES NOT YET EXI/ 9DEP5D5TLY 9 ITS AFFIRMATIVE ABUNDANCE1 BUT ONLY AS ! D5IAL ( ! ,POSITIVE1 & !RE=E1 9 ?IS EVIL /ATE1 IT TOO MU/ BE DE/ROY$ ALONG ) ! ,POSITIVE1 SO ?AT FROM ITS FREE GR\ND IT MAY SPR+ =? AGA9 9 A NEWBORN /ATE1 AS ITS [N LIV+ FULLNESS4 ,& ?IS SELF-*ANGE ( ! ,DEMOCRATIC P>TY WILL NOT BE M]ELY A QUANTITATIVE *ANGE1 I4E41 A BROAD5+ ( ITS PRES5T P>TICUL> & H5CE EVIL EXI/5CE3 ,GOD SAVE US1 SU* A BROAD5+ W\LD BE ! LEVEL+ ( ! :OLE WORLD & ! 5D RESULT ( ALL ( HI/ORY W\LD BE ABSOLUTE NO?+NESS -- BUT A QUALITATIVE TRANS=MATION1 A NEW1 VITAL1 & LIFE-CREAT+ REVELATION1 A NEW HEAV5 & A NEW E>?1 A Y\NG & MAGNIFIC5T WORLD 9 :I* ALL PRES5T DISCORDS WILL RESOLVE !MSELVES 9TO H>MONI\S UNITY4 ,! 9ADEQUACY ( ! ,DEMOCRATIC P>TY CAN /ILL LESS BE MITIGAT$ BY TRANSC5D+ ! ONE-SID$NESS ( ITS EXI/5CE AS A P>TY ?R\< AN ET]NAL M$IATION ) ! ,POSITIVE -- ?IS W\LD BE A VA9 5DEAVOR1 = ! ,POSITIVE & ! ,NEGATIVE >E ONCE & = ALL 9COMPATIBLE4 ,9S(> AS IT IS ISOLAT$ 9 ITS CONTRADICTION TO ! ,POSITIVE & IS TAK5 = ITSELF1 ! ,NEGATIVE APPE>S AT FIR/ TO BE EMPTY & LIFELESS2 & ?IS APP>5T EMPT9ESS IS ALSO ! PR9CIPAL REPROA* :I* ! ,POSITIVES MAKE TO ! ,DEMOCRATS -- A REPROA* :I*1 H[EV]1 RE/S ONLY ON A MISUND]/&+4 ,9 FACT1 AS A ?+ 9 ISOLATION1 ! ,NEGATIVE IS NOT AT ALL2 AS SU* IT W\LD BE NO?+4 ,IT EXI/S ONLY 9 CONTRADICTION TO ! ,POSITIVE4 ,ITS :OLE BE+1 ITS CONT5T & ITS VITALITY >E SIMPLY ! DE/RUCTION ( ! ,POSITIVE4 ',REVOLUTION>Y PROPAG&A1' SAYS ! ,P5T>*I/1 'IS1 9 ITS DEEPE/ ESS5CE1 ! NEGATION ( ! EXI/+ CONDITIONS ( ! /ATE2 =1 ) RESPECT TO ITS 9N]MO/ NATURE1 IT HAS NO O!R PROGRAM ?AN ! DE/RUCTION ( :ATEV] ORD] PREVAILS AT ! TIME4' ,BUT IS IT POSSIBLE ?AT ?AT :OSE :OLE LIFE IS ONLY TO DE/ROY %\LD EXT]NALLY BE RECONCIL$ ) ?AT :I*1 ACCORD+ TO ITS 9N]MO/ NATURE1 IT MU/ DE/ROY8 ,ONLY HALF-M5 :O S]I\SLY TAKE SIDES NEI!R ) ! ,POSITIVE NOR ) ! ,NEGATIVE CAN >GUE 9 SU* A FA%ION4 ,!RE >E TWO MAJOR DIVISIONS )9 ! ,REACTION>Y P>TY TODAY3 TO ! ONE BELONG ! PURE ,CONSI/5T REACTION>IES1 & TO O!R ! 9CONSI/5T1 ,COMPROMIS+ REACTION>IES4 ,! FIR/ 9T]PRET ! CONTRADICTION 9 ITS PURE =M2 !Y FEEL 9DE$ ?AT ! ,POSITIVE & ! ,NEGATIVE GET ALONG NO MORE ?AN FIRE & WAT]2 &1 S9CE !Y DO NOT SEE 9 ! ,NEGATIVE ITS AFFIRMATIVE ASPECT & SO CANNOT BELIEVE 9 ! ,NEGATIVE1 !Y QUITE RI AS ! ,NEGATIVE OPPOSES IT1 & ?AT CONSEQU5TLY1 9 ! EV5T ( A COMPLETE VICTORY OV] ! ,NEGATIVE1 IT W\LD NO LONG] BE ! ,POSITIVE BUT RA!R ITS CONTRADICTORY1 ! COMPLETION ( ! ,NEGATIVE -- ?AT !Y DO NOT P]CEIVE ?IS MU/ BE =GIV5 !M1 S9CE BL9DNESS IS ! MA9 *>ACT]I/IC ( ALL ?AT IS POSITIVE & 9SIDICE TO CONCEAL FROM !MSELVES ! /RICT CONSEQU5CES ( !IR [N PR9CIPLES 9 ORD] ?US TO ESCAPE ! DANG] ( BECOM+ DI/URB$ 9 ! >TIFICIAL & WEAK SY/EM ( !IR PRET5D$ CONVICTIONS4 ,!SE G5TLEM5 >E S9C]E1 HONE/2 !Y WANT TO BE :OLE M54 ,ONE CANNOT TALK MU* ) !M1 = !Y NEV] WANT TO 5T] 9TO A S5SIBLE CONV]SATION4 ,IT IS SO DIFFICULT = !M N[1 S9CE ! DISSOLV+ POISON ( ! ,NEGATIVE HAS SPREAD EV]Y:]E2 IT IS SO DIFFICULT1 9DE$ ALMO/ IMPOSSIBLE1 = !M TO MA9TA9 !MSELVES 9 PURE ,POSITIVITY ?AT !Y )DRAW FROM !IR [N REASON & MU/ BE AFRAID ( !MSELVES1 ( ! SLIE HONE/ & :OLE M51 OR1 MORE CORRECTLY1 !Y WANT TO BE HONE/ & :OLE M54 ,JU/ LIKE US1 !Y HATE EV]Y?+ ?AT IS HALFHE>T$ = !Y KN[ ?AT ONLY A :OLE MAN CAN BE GOOD & ?AT HALFHE>T$NESS IS ! PUTRID S\RCE ( ALL EVIL4 ,!SE FANATICAL REACTION>IES ACCUSE US ( H]ESY4 ,IF IT W]E POSSIBLE !Y W\LD P]HAPS EV5 CALL \T ( ! >S5AL ( HI/ORY ! SUBT]RANEAN P[] ( ! ,9QUISITION 9 ORD] TO USE IT AGA9/ US4 ,!Y D5Y US ALL ?AT IS GOOD1 ALL ?AT IS HUMAN4 ,!Y SEE 9 US NO?+ O!R ?AN EMBODI$ ,ANTI*RI/S1 AGA9/ :OM EV]Y MEANS IS P]MITT$4 ,%ALL WE REPAY !M ) ! SAME CO98 ,NO2 IT W\LD BE UNWOR?Y ( US & ( ! GREAT CAUSE :OSE AG5TS WE >E4 ,! GREAT PR9CIPLE 9 :OSE S]VICE WE HAVE PL$G$ \RSELVES GIVES US1 AMONG MANY O!R ADVANTAGES1 ! F9E PRIVILEGE ( BE+ JU/ & IMP>TIAL )\T1 BY SO BE+1 H>M+ \R CAUSE4 ,NO?+ P>TIAL CAN USE TRU? ITSELF AS A WEAPON1 = TRU? IS ! REFUTATION ( ALL ONE-SID$NESS2 :]EAS ALL ONE-SID$NESS MU/ BE P>TIAL & FANATICAL 9 ITS UTT]ANCE1 & HATE IS ITS NECESS>Y EXPRESSION1 = IT CAN MA9TA9 ITSELF 9 NO O!R WAY ?AN BY OPPOS+1 ?R\< A VIOL5T REPULSION1 ALL O!R ONE-SID$NESS1 EV5 IF AS LEGITIMATE AS ITSELF4 ,ONE-SID$NESS BY ITS V]Y PRES5CE PRESUPPOSES ! PRES5CE ( O!R ONE-SID$NESSES1 & YET1 AS A CONSEQU5CE ( ITS ESS5TIAL NATURE1 IT MU/ EXCLUDE !SE 9 ORD] TO MA9TA9 ITSELF4 ,?IS CONFLICT IS ! CURSE :I* HANGS OV] ONE-SID$NESS1 A CURSE 9NATE TO IT1 A CURSE :I* TRANS=MS 9TO HATR$ 9 !IR V]Y UTT]ANCE ALL ! GOOD S5TIM5TS ?AT >E 9NATE 9 EV]Y MAN AS MAN4 ,WE >E 9F9ITELY MORE =TUNATE 9 ?IS RESPECT4 ,AS A P>TY WE 9DE$ /& 9 OPPOSITION TO ! ,POSITIVES & FIE AWAK5$ ALSO 9 US ?R\< ?IS FI AS WE \RSELVES BELONG TO A P>TY1 WE >E ALSO V]Y (T5 P>TIAL & UNJU/4 ,BUT WE >E NOT ONLY ?IS ,NEGATIVE P>TY SET 9 OPPOSITION TO ! ,POSITIVE3 WE HAVE \R LIV+ S\RCE 9 ! ALL-EMBRAC+ PR9CIPLE ( UNCONDITIONAL FRE$OM1 9 A PR9CIPLE :I* CONTA9S 9 ITSELF ALL ! GOOD ?AT IS CONTA9$ ONLY 9 ! ,POSITIVE & :I* IS EXALT$ ABOVE ! ,POSITIVE JU/ AS OV] \RSELVES AS A P>TY4 ,AS A P>TY WE PURSUE ONLY POLITICS1 BUT AS A P>TY WE >E JU/IFI$ ONLY ?R\< \R PR9CIPLE2 O!RWISE WE W\LD HAVE NO BETT] GR\ND ?AN ! ,POSITIVE4 ,H5CE1 WE MU/ REMA9 TRUE1 EV5 CONTR>Y TO \R SELF-PRES]VATION1 TO \R PR9CIPLE AS ! ONLY GR\ND ( \R P[] & ( \R LIFE2 I4E41 WE MU/ ET]NALLY TRANSC5D \RSELVES AS ?IS ONE-SID$1 M]ELY POLITICAL EXI/5CE 9 ! RELIGION ( \R ALL-EMBRAC+ & ALL-SID$ PR9CIPLE4 ,WE MU/ NOT ONLY ACT POLITICALLY1 BUT 9 \R POLITICS ALSO ACT RELIGI\SLY1 RELIGI\SLY 9 ! S5SE ( FRE$OM ( :I* ! ONE TRUE EXPRESSION IS JU/ICE & LOVE4 ,9DE$1 = US ALONE1 :O >E CALL$ ! 5EMIES ( ! ,*RI/IAN RELIGION1 = US ALONE IS IT RES]V$1 & EV5 MADE ! HID5T ( FIE /RIV+ REALLY TO WANT ! GOOD1 ?AT 9DE$ 9 !IR NATURE !Y >E CALL$ TO ! GOOD1 TO A VITAL LIFE1 & ?AT !Y HAVE DEVIAT$ FROM !IR TRUE DE/9Y ONLY [+ TO AN 9COMPREH5SIBLE MIS=TUNE4 ,WE >E NOT SPEAK+ ( ?OSE :O HAVE JO9$ !IR P>TY ONLY 9 ORD] TO BE ABLE TO GIVE V5T TO !IR EVIL PASSIONS4 ,!RE >E1 UN=TUNATELY1 MANY ,T>TUFFES 9 EV]Y P>TY2 WE >E SPEAK+ ONLY ( ! S9C]E DEF5D]S ( ,CONSI/5T ,POSITIVISM4 ,!SE /RIVE AFT] ! GOOD1 BUT !Y CANNOT EFFECTIVELY WILL IT2 ?IS IS !IR GREAT MIS=TUNE1 !Y >E DIVID$ 9 !MSELVES4 ,9 ! PR9CIPLE ( FRE$OM !Y SEE ONLY A COLD & PROSAIC AB/RACTION -- TO :I* MANY PROSAIC & DRY DEF5D]S ( FRE$OM HAVE GREATLY CONTRIBUT$4 ,!Y SEE ONLY AN AB/RACTION :I* EXCLUDES ALL ?AT IS VITAL1 ALL ?AT IS BEAUTIFUL & HOLY4 ,!Y DO NOT P]CEIVE ?AT ?IS PR9CIPLE IS BY NO MEANS TO BE CONFUS$ ) ITS CURR5T EVIL & M]ELY NEGATIVE EXI/5CE1 & ?AT IT IS ONLY AS A LIV+ SELF-AFFIRMATION :I* HAS TRANSC5D$ ! ,NEGATIVE AS WELL AS ! ,POSITIVE ?AT IT CAN CONQU] & ?AT IT WILL REALIZE ITSELF4 ,!Y BELIEVE -- & ?IS BELIEF IS UN=TUNATELY /ILL %>$ BY MANY ADH]5TS ( ! ,NEGATIVE P>TY ITSELF -- ?AT ! ,NEGATIVE TRIES TO DIFFUSE ITSELF AS SU*1 & !Y ?9K1 JU/ AS WE DO1 ?AT ! DIFFUSION W\LD BE ! LEVEL+ ( ! :OLE SPIRITUAL WORLD4 ,AT ! SAME TIME1 9 ! DIRECTNESS ( !IR FEEL+1 !Y HAVE A :OLLY JU/IFI$ 5DEAVOR T[>D A VITAL FULL LIFE1 &1 S9CE !Y F9D 9 ! ,NEGATIVE ONLY ITS LEVEL+1 !Y TURN BACK TO ! PA/1 TO ! PA/ AS IT WAS BE=E ! BIR? ( ! CONTRADICTION BETWE5 ! ,NEGATIVE & ! ,POSITIVE4 ,!Y >E RI AS ?IS PA/ REALLY WAS 9 ITSELF A LIV+ :OLE & AS SU* APPE>S MU* MORE VITAL & MU* RI*] ?AN ! DIVID$ PRES5T4 ,!IR GREAT MI/AKE1 H[EV]1 CONSI/S 9 ?IS1 ?AT !Y ?9K ?AT !Y CAN RECREATE IT 9 ITS PA/ VITALITY2 !Y =GET ?AT ! PA/ TOTALITY CAN BY N[ APPE> ONLY 9 ! AMORPH\S & CRACK$ REFLECTION ( ! PRES5T 9EVITABLE CONTRADICTION :I* ?AT TOTALITY 5TAILS1 & ?AT ! TOTALITY1 AS POSITIVE1 IS ONLY ITS [N CORPSE1 ) ITS S\L TORN FROM IT1 I4E41 ! CORPSE AS DELIV]$ UP TO ! ME*ANICAL & *EMICAL PROCESSES ( ?\E ,POSITIVE !Y HAVE ! ,NEGATIVE )9 !M1 !Y ?R[ ONTO ! ,NEGATIVE ! :OLE BLAME = ?IS DEFICI5CY1 & ! :OLE WEIY 9N] PROCESS 9 EV]Y ,CONSI/5T ,POSITIVI/1 & !RE=E ,I SAY ALSO ?AT !Y >E REALLY TO BE PITI$1 S9CE ! S\RCE ( !IR 5DEAVOR IS YET ALMO/ ALWAYS HONE/4 ,! ,COMPROMIS+ ,POSITIVI/S HOLD AN 5TIRELY DIFF]5T POSITION4 ,!Y DI/+UI% !MSELVES FROM ! ,CONSI/5T ,POSITIVI/S 9 ! FIR/ PLACE 9 ?AT1 MORE ROTT$ ?AN !SE BY SPECULATIVE DISEASE ( ! TIME1 !Y NOT ONLY DO NOT CONDEMN ! ,NEGATIVE UNCONDITIONALLY AS AN ABSOLUTE EVIL BUT CONC$E TO IT A RELATIVE1 TRANSITORY JU/IFICATION2 &1 9 ! SECOND PLACE1 9 ?AT !Y DO NOT POSSESS ! SAME 5]GETIC PURITY1 A PURITY = :I* ! ,CONSI/5T1 RU?LESS ,POSITIVI/S AT LEA/ /RIVE & :I* WE HAVE DESIGNAT$ AS ! *>ACT]I/IC ( A FULL1 COMPLETE1 & HONE/ NATURE4 ,! /&PO9T ( ! ,COMPROMIS]S WE MAY 9 CONTRA/ DESIGNATE AS ?AT ( !ORETICAL DI%ONE/Y1 ,I SAY !ORETICAL BECAUSE ,I W\LD RA!R AVOID ANY PRACTICAL1 P]SONAL ACCUSATION & BECAUSE ,I DO NOT BELIEVE ?AT A P]SONALLY EVIL WILL C\LD REALLY 9T]V5E OB/RUCTIVELY 9 ! DEVELOPM5T ( ,SPIRIT2 AL?\< IT MU/ BE ADMITT$ ?AT !ORETICAL DI%ONE/Y BY ITS V]Y NATURE ALMO/ ALWAYS REV]TS 9TO A PRACTICAL ONE4 ,! ,COMPROMIS+ ,POSITIVI/S >E CLEV]] & HAVE MORE 9SIE ! CLEV] M51 ! !ORI/S P> EXCELL5CE1 & TO ?AT EXT5T !Y >E ALSO ! *IEF REPRES5TATIVES ( ! PRES5T TIME4 ,WE CAN APPLY TO !M :AT WAS SAID 9 A ,FR5* J\RNAL AT ! BEG9N+ ( ! ,JULY ,REVOLUTION AB\T ! ,JU/E-MILIEU3 ,! ,LEFT SAYS1 #b TIMES #b >E #d2 ! ,RIE #f2 & ! ,JU/E-MILIEU SAYS1 #b TIMES #b >E #e4 ,BUT !Y W\LD TAKE ?IS AMISS4 ,H5CE WE WANT TO TRY TO 9VE/IGATE !IR UNCLE> & DIFFICULT ESS5CE 9 ALL E>NE/NESS & ) ! DEEPE/ RESPECT = !IR WISDOM4 ,IT IS MU* MORE DIFFICULT TO DEAL ) !M ?AN ) ! ,CONSI/5T ONES3 ! LATT] HAVE ! PRACTICAL 5]GY ( !IR CONVICTIONS2 !Y KN[ & !Y SPEAK 9 CLE> WORDS & SAY :AT !Y MEAN TO SAY2 !Y HATE1 JU/ AS WE DO1 ALL UNC]TA9TY1 ALL CONFUSION1 = AS PRACTICALLY 5]GETIC BE+S !Y CAN BREA! ONLY 9 A PURE & CLE> AIR4 ,) ! ,COMPROMIS]S1 H[EV]1 IT IS A CURI\S MATT]4 ,!Y >E WILY2 OH1 !Y >E CLEV] & WISE6 ,!Y NEV] P]MIT ! PRACTICAL IMPULSE T[>D TRU? TO DE/ROY ! METICUL\SLY PAT*WORK$ $IFICE ( !IR !ORY4 ,!Y >E TOO EXP]I5C$1 TOO CLEV]1 TO GRANT A GRACI\S HE>+ TO ! BESEE*+ VOICE ( SIMPLE1 PRACTICAL CONSCI5CE4 ,FROM ! HEIACT]I/IC BY :I* ONE CAN DI/+UI% !M1 ! CLEV] PEOPLE1 FROM ! /UPID & UN$UCAT$ MOB4 ,CONSEQU5TLY IT IS V]Y DIFFICULT TO DEAL ) !M1 BECAUSE ALL IS KN[N TO !M2 BECAUSE1 AS WORLDLY-WISE PEOPLE1 !Y CONSID] IT AN UN=GIVABLE WEAKNESS TO LET !MSELVES BE A/ONI%$ BY ANY?+2 BECAUSE !Y HAVE BY !IR ?9K+ P5ETRAT$ EV]Y CORN] ( ! NATURAL & SPIRITUAL UNIV]SE1 & BECAUSE1 AFT] ?IS LONG & LABORI\S SPECULATIVE J\RNEY1 !Y HAVE REA*$ ! CONVICTION ?AT IT IS NOT WOR? ! BO!R TO 5T] 9TO REAL1 VITAL CONTACT ) ! REAL WORLD4 ,IT IS DIFFICULT TO COME TO AN UND]/&+ ) !SE PEOPLE1 S9CE1 JU/ LIKE ! ,G]MAN CON/ITUTIONS1 !Y TAKE BACK ) ! RIE RITY ( ! ,COMPROMIS]S1 DESPITE ITS 9N] LACK ( PR9CIPLE & ITS 9ABILITY TO EFFECT ANY?+ ON ITS [N1 IS TODAY A P[]FUL1 9DE$ ! MO/ P[]FUL P>TY -- NUM]ICALLY1 ( C\RSE1 NOT ) RESPECT TO ITS CONT5T4 ,IT IS ONE ( ! MO/ IMPORTANT SIGNS ( ! TIMES1 & SO WE D>E NOT IGNORE IT & BYPASS IT4 ,! :OLE WISDOM ( ! ,COMPROMIS]S CONSI/S 9 ?IS1 ?AT !Y MA9TA9 ?AT TWO OPPOS+ TR5DS >E AS SU* ONE-SID$ & !RE=E UNTRUE2 BUT1 !Y >GUE1 IF ! TWO MEMB]S ( ! CONTRADICTION >E UNTRUE :5 TAK5 AB/RACTLY 9 !MSELVES1 !N ! TRU? MU/ LIE 9 !IR MIDDLE1 & SO ONE MU/ 9T]-CORRELATE !M TO >RIVE AT ! TRU?4 ,?IS REASON+ AT FIR/ APPE>S IRREFUTABLE3 9DE$1 WE HAVE \RSELVES ADMITT$ ?AT ! ,NEGATIVE1 9S(> AS IT IS OPPOS$ TO ! ,POSITIVE & IS SELF-ORI5T$ 9 ?IS OPPOSITION1 IS ONE-SID$4 ,!N DOES IT NOT NECESS>ILY FOLL[ FROM ?IS ?AT ! ,NEGATIVE IS ESS5TIALLY FULFILL$ & COMPLET$ BY ! ,POSITIVE8 ,& >E NOT ! ,COMPROMIS]S RIE AS SU* MUTUALLY DEP5D5T1 !N !Y MU/ ACCEPT & RECOGNIZE EA* NATURE TO ITS FULL EXT5T2 !Y MU/ DO ?IS = ! SAKE ( CONSI/5CY1 9 ORD] !MSELVES TO REMA9 TRUE TO !IR [N POSITION4 ,= ! SIDE ( ! CONTRADICTION :I* IS FAVORABLE TO !M IS 9SEP>ABLE FROM ITS UNFAVORABLE SIDE2 BUT ?IS UNFAVORABLE SIDE CONSI/S 9 ?IS1 ?AT IT IS NOT POSITIVE BUT NEGATIVE1 DE/RUCTIVE1 TO GIVE PRIORITY TO ONE MEMB] OV] ! O!R4 ,! G5TLEM5 >E TO BE REF]R$ TO ,HEGEL'S LOGIC1 :]E ! CATEGORY ( CONTRADICTION IS SO BEAUTIFULLY TREAT$4 ,CONTRADICTION & ITS IMMAN5T DEVELOPM5T CON/ITUTE A KEYNOTE ( ! :OLE ,HEGELIAN SY/EM1 & S9CE ?IS CATEGORY IS ! *IEF CATEGORY ( ! GOV]N+ SPIRIT ( \R TIMES1 ,HEGEL IS UNCONDITIONALLY ! GREATE/ PHILOSOPH] ( ! PRES5T TIME1 ! HIY SELF-RESOLUTION ( MOD]N CULTURAL =MATION3 AS ?IS SUMMIT HE HAS ALREADY GONE ABOVE !ORY -- GRANT$ ?AT AT ! SAME TIME HE IS /ILL )9 !ORY -- & HAS PO/ULAT$ A NEW1 PRACTICAL WORLD :I* WILL BR+ ITSELF TO COMPLETION BY NO MEANS ?R\< A =MAL APPLICATION & DIFFUSION ( !ORIES ALREADY WORK$ \T1 BUT ONLY ?R\< AN ORIG9AL ACT ( ! PRACTICAL AUTONOM\S ,SPIRIT4 ,CONTRADICTION IS ! ESS5CE NOT ONLY ( EV]Y SPECIFIC1 P>TICUL> !ORY1 BUT ALSO ( !ORY 9 G5]AL1 & SO ! DIALECTICAL PHASE ( ITS COMPREH5SION IS SIMULTANE\SLY ! PHASE ( ! FULFILLM5T ( !ORY2 BUT ITS FULFILLM5T IS ITS SELF-RESOLUTION 9TO AN ORIG9AL & NEW1 PRACTICAL WORLD1 9TO ! REAL PRES5CE ( FRE$OM4 ,BUT ?IS IS NOT YET ! PLACE TO DEVELOP ?IS FUR!R1 & WE WANT TO TURN AGA9 TO ! DISCUSSION ( ! LOGICAL !ORY ( CONTRADICTION4 ,CONTRADICTION ITSELF1 AS ! EMBRAC+ ( ITS TWO ONE-SID$ MEMB]S1 IS TOTAL1 ABSOLUTE1 TRUE4 ,ONE CANNOT REPROA* IT ) ONE-SID$NESS OR ) ! SUP]FICIALITY & POV]TY :I* >E NECESS>ILY B\ND UP ) ONE-SID$NESS1 S9CE IT IS NOT ONLY ! ,NEGATIVE1 BUT ALSO ! ,POSITIVE1 & S9CE1 AS ?IS ALL-EMBRAC+ ?+1 IT IS TOTAL1 ABSOLUTE1 ALL-9CLUSIVE FULLNESS4 ,?IS 5TITLES ! ,COMPROMIS]S TO =BID ?AT ONE ( ! TWO ONE-SID$ MEMB]S BE TAK5 9 ! AB/RACT1 & TO REQUIRE ?AT !Y BE COMPREH5D$ AS A TOTALITY 9 !IR NECESS>Y UNION1 9 !IR 9SEP>ABILITY4 ,ONLY ! CONTRADICTION IS TRUE1 !Y SAY1 & EI!R ( ITS OPPOS$ MEMB]S1 TAK5 BY ITSELF1 IS ONE-SID$ & ?US UNTRUE2 H5CE WE HAVE TO GRASP ! CONTRADICTION 9 ITS TOTALITY 9 ORD] TO HAVE TRU?4 ,BUT ?IS IS JU/ :]E ! DIFFICULTY BEG9S4 ,CONTRADICTION IS 9DE$ TRU?1 BUT IT DOES NOT EXI/ AS SU*1 IT IS NOT !RE AS ?IS TOTALITY2 IT IS ONLY A SELF-SUBSI/+1 HIDD5 TOTALITY1 & ITS EXI/5CE IS JU/ ! CONFLICT+ CLEAVAGE ( ITS TWO MEMB]S1 ! ,POSITIVE & ! ,NEGATIVE4 ,CONTRADICTION AS ! TOTAL TRU? IS ! 9SEP>ABLE UNITY ( ! SIMPLICITY & CLEAVAGE ( ITSELF 9 ONE2 ?IS IS ITS IMPLICIT1 HIDD51 BUT ?US ALSO AT FIR/ 9COMPREH5SIBLE NATURE1 & JU/ BECAUSE ?IS UNITY IS A HIDD5 ONE1 CONTRADICTION EXI/S ALSO ONE-SID$LY AS ! M]E CLEAVAGE ( ITS MEMB]S4 ,IT IS PRES5T ONLY AS ,POSITIVE & ,NEGATIVE1 & !SE MUTUALLY EXCLUDE EA* O!R TO SU* AN EXT5T ?AT ?IS MUTUAL EXCLUSION CON/ITUTES !IR :OLE NATURE4 ,BUT !N H[ >E WE TO COMPREH5D ! TOTALITY ( CONTRADICTION8 ,H]E !RE APPE> TO REMA9 TWO WAYS \T3 EI!R WE MU/ >BITR>ILY AB/RACT FROM ! CLEAVAGE & FLEE TO ! SIMPLE TOTALITY ( ! CONTRADICTION1 :I* TOTALITY IS PRIOR TO ! CLEAVAGE -- BUT ?IS IS IMPOSSIBLE1 BECAUSE ! 9COMPREH5SIBLE IS SIMPLY 9COMPREH5SIBLE1 & BECAUSE CONTRADICTION 9 ITSELF EXI/S IMM$IATELY ONLY AS CLEAVAGE1 )\T ?IS IT IS NOT AT ALL2 OR WE MU/ 9 A MAT]NAL WAY TRY TO RECONCILE ! OPPOS$ MEMB]S4 ,& 9 ?IS CONSI/S ! :OLE EF=T ( ! ,COMPROMIS] ,S*OOL4 ,LET US SEE :E!R !Y REALLY SUCCE$4 ,! POSITIVE APPE>S AT FIR/ TO BE ! RE/FUL1 ! IMMOBILE4 ,IT IS ,POSITIVE 9DE$ ONLY BECAUSE IT RE/S 9 ITSELF )\T DI/URBANCE & BECAUSE IT CONTA9S NO?+ ?AT IT C\LD NEGATE2.<#a.> ONLY BECAUSE IT CONTA9S NO MOVEM5T1 S9CE EV]Y MOVEM5T IS A NEGATION4 ,! ,POSITIVE IS JU/ ! SORT ( ?+ 9 :I* IMMOBILITY AS SU* REPOSES1 ! SORT ( ?+ :I* IS REFLECT$ 9 ITSELF AS ! ABSOLUTELY IMMOBILE4 ,BUT REFLECTION ON IMMOBILITY IS 9SEP>ABLE FROM REFLECTION ON MOBILITY2 OR RA!R !Y >E ONE & ! SAME REFLECTION1 & SO ! ,POSITIVE1 ABSOLUTE RE/1 IS POSITIVE ONLY 9 CONTRA/ TO ! ,NEGATIVE1 ABSOLUTE UNRE/4 ,! ,POSITIVE IS 9T]NALLY RELAT$ TO ! ,NEGATIVE AS ITS [N VITAL DET]M9ATION4 ,?US ! ,POSITIVE HAS A D\BLE PLACE 9 RELATION TO ! ,NEGATIVE3 ON ! ONE H& IT RE/S 9 ITSELF & 9 ?IS APA!TIC SELF-SUFFICI5CY CONTA9S NO?+ ( ! ,NEGATIVE2 ON ! O!R1 H[EV]1 & JU/ BECAUSE ( ?IS RE/1 AS SOME?+ 9 ITSELF OPPOS$ TO ! ,NEGATIVE1 IT ACTIVELY EXCLUDES ! ,NEGATIVE2 BUT ?IS ACTIVITY ( EXCLUSION IS A MOTION & SO ! ,POSITIVE1 JU/ BECAUSE ( ITS POSITIVITY1 IS 9 ITSELF NO LONG] ! ,POSITIVE1 BUT ! ,NEGATIVE2 9 ?AT IT EXCLUDES ! ,NEGATIVE FROM ITSELF1 IT EXCLUDES ITSELF FROM ITSELF & DRIVES ITSELF TO DE/RUCTION4 ,CONSEQU5TLY1 ! ,POSITIVE & ! ,NEGATIVE DO NOT1 AS ! ,COMPROMIS]S ?9K1 HAVE EQUAL JU/IFICATION4 ,CONTRADICTION IS NOT AN EQUILIBRIUM BUT A PREPOND]ANCE ( ! ,NEGATIVE1 :I* IS ITS 5CROA*+ DIALECTICAL PHASE4 ,! ,NEGATIVE1 AS DET]M9+ ! LIFE ( ! ,POSITIVE ITSELF1 ALONE 9CLUDES )9 ITSELF ! TOTALITY ( ! CONTRADICTION1 & SO IT ALONE ALSO HAS ABSOLUTE JU/IFICATION4 ,:AT1 SOMEONE WILL P]HAPS ASK ME2 HAVE Y\ NOT Y\RSELF ADMITT$ TO US ?AT ! ,NEGATIVE1 TAK5 9 ITSELF AB/RACTLY1 IS JU/ AS ONE-SID$ AS ! ,POSITIVE1 & ?AT ! DIFFUSION ( ITS EVIL EXI/5CE W\LD BE A LEVEL+ ( ! :OLE WORLD8 ,YES1 BUT ,I WAS SPEAK+ ONLY ( ! PRES5T EXI/5CE ( ! ,NEGATIVE1 ( ! ,NEGATIVE 9S(> AS1 EXCLUD$ FROM ! ,POSITIVE1 IT IS PEACEFULLY SELF-ORI5T$ & SO IS POSITIVE2 AS SU* IT IS ALSO NEGAT$ BY ! ,POSITIVE1 & ! ,CONSI/5T ,POSITIVI/S1 9 D5Y+ ! EXI/5CE ( ! ,NEGATIVE1 ITS PEACEFUL SELF-ORI5TATION1 >E P]=M+ BO? A LOGICAL & A HOLY S]VICE -- AL?\< !Y DO NOT KN[ :AT !Y DO4 ,!Y BELIEVE ?AT !Y >E NEGAT+ ! ,NEGATIVE :ILE1 ON ! CONTR>Y1 !Y >E NEGAT+ ! ,NEGATIVE ONLY 9S(> AS IT IS MAK+ ITSELF ,POSITIVE2 !Y AWAK5 ! ,NEGATIVE FROM ITS ,PHILI/9E REPOSE1 TO :I* IT IS NOT FITT$1 & !Y LEAD IT BACK TO ITS GREAT CALL+1 TO ! RE/LESS & RU?LESS ANNIHILATION ( EV]Y POSITIVELY EXI/+ ?+4 ,WE %ALL GRANT ?AT ! ,POSITIVE & ! ,NEGATIVE1 IF ! LATT] IS PEACEFULLY & EGOI/ICALLY SELF-ORI5T$ & SO UNTRUE TO ITSELF1 HAVE EQUAL JU/IFICATION4 ,BUT ! ,NEGATIVE %\LD NOT BE EGOI/IC2 IT %\LD LOV+LY SURR5D] TO ! ,POSITIVE 9 ORD] TO CONSUME IT &1 9 ?IS RELIGI\S1 FAI?FUL1 & VITAL ACT ( D5IAL1 TO REVEAL ITS 9EXHAU/IBLE & PREGNANT NATURE4 ,! ,POSITIVE IS NEGAT$ BY ! ,NEGATIVE & ! ,NEGATIVE 9 TURN IS NEGAT$ BY ! ,POSITIVE3 :AT1 !N1 IS COMMON TO BO? & OV]LAPS BO?8 ,D5IAL1 DE/RUCTION1 PASSIONATE CONSUMPTION ( ! ,POSITIVE1 EV5 IF ?IS LATT] SEEKS SLYLY TO HIDE ITSELF 9 ! GUISE ( ! ,NEGATIVE4 ,! ,NEGATIVE IS JU/IFI$ ONLY AS ?IS RU?LESS NEGATION1 BUT AS SU* IT IS ABSOLUTELY JU/IFI$1 = AS SU* IT IS ! ACTION ( ! PRACTICAL ,SPIRIT 9VISIBLY PRES5T 9 ! CONTRADICTION ITSELF1 ! ,SPIRIT :I*1 ?R\< ?IS /ORM ( DE/RUCTION1 P[]FULLY URGES S9FUL1 COMPROMIS+ S\LS TO REP5TANCE & ANN\NCES ITS IMM95T COM+1 ITS IMM95T REVELATION 9 A REALLY DEMOCRATIC & UNIV]SALLY HUMAN RELIGION ( FRE$OM4 ,?IS SELF-RESOLUTION ( ! ,POSITIVE IS ! ONLY POSSIBLE RECONCILIATION ( ! ,POSITIVE ) ! ,NEGATIVE1 = IT IS ! IMMAN5T1 TOTAL MOTION & 5]GY ( ! CONTRADICTION ITSELF1 & ?US ANY O!R MEANS ( RECONCIL+ !M IS >BITR>Y1 & EV]YONE :O 9T5DS ANO!R RECONCILIATION M]ELY PROVES 9 SO DO+ ?AT HE IS NOT P]MEAT$ ) ! ,SPIRIT ( ! TIMES & ?US IS EI!R /UPID OR UNPR9CIPL$2 = A MAN IS REALLY 9TELLIG5T & MORAL ONLY IF HE SURR5D]S HIMSELF :OLEHE>T$LY TO ?IS ,SPIRIT & IS P]MEAT$ BY IT4 ,CONTRADICTION IS TOTAL & TRUE --- ! ,COMPROMIS]S !MSELVES GRANT ?IS --- BUT AS TOTAL IT IS :OLLY VITAL & ! 5]GY ( ITS ALL-EMBRAC+ VITALITY CONSI/S1 AS WE HAVE ALREADY SE51 JU/ 9 ?IS 9CESSANT SELF-COMBU/ION ( ! ,POSITIVE 9 ! PURE FIRE ( ! ,NEGATIVE4 ,:AT DO ! ,COMPROMIS]S DO N[8 ,!Y GRANT US ?IS :OLE ?+2 !Y ACKN[L$GE ! TOTALITY ( CONTRADICTION JU/ AS WE DO1 EXCEPT ?AT !Y ROB IT1 OR RA!R WANT TO ROB IT1 ( ITS MOTION1 ( ITS VITALITY1 ( ITS :OLE S\L1 = ! VITALITY ( CONTRADICTION IS A PRACTICAL P[] 9COMPATIBLE ) !IR IMPOT5T HALF-S\LS1 BUT BY ?IS FACT SUP]IOR TO !IR EV]Y ATTEMPT TO /IFLE IT4 ,! ,POSITIVE1 AS WE HAVE SAID & DEMON/RAT$1 HAS NO JU/IFICATION IF TAK5 9 ITSELF2 IT IS JU/IFI$ ONLY 9S(> AS IT NEGATES ! RE/1 ! SELF-ORI5TATION ( ! ,NEGATIVE2 9S(> AS IT UNCONDITIONALLY & DET]M9ATELY EXCLUDES ! ,NEGATIVE & ?US MA9TA9S IT 9 ITS ACTIVITY -- ?US F> IT BECOMES ACTIVELY NEGATIVE4 ,?IS ACTIVITY ( NEGATION TO :I* ! ,POSITIVI/S >E RAIS$ ?R\< ! UNSURM\NTABLE P[] ( CONTRADICTION 9VISIBLY PRES5T 9 EV]Y LIV+ BE+ & :I* CON/ITUTES !IR ONLY JU/IFICATION & ! ONLY *>ACT]I/IC ( !IR VITALITY -- IT IS JU/ ?IS ACTIVITY ( NEGATION :I* ! ,COMPROMIS]S WANT TO PROHIBIT !M4 ,AS A CONSEQU5CE ( A S+UL> 9COMPREH5SIBLE MIS=TUNE1 OR RA!R FROM ! :OLE COMPREH5SIBLE MIS=TUNE ( !IR PRACTICAL LACK ( PR9CIPLE1 !IR PRACTICAL IMPOT5CE1 !Y ACKN[L$GE 9 ! ,POSITIVE JU/ ?AT :I* IS DEAD )9 !MSELVES1 ROTT51 & WOR?Y ONLY ( DE/RUCTION -- & !Y REJECT ?AT :I* CON/ITUTES !IR :OLE VITALITY3 ! VITAL FIE RIN IS = CONSUMPTIVE BODIES4 ,SO F> AS WE >E CONC]N$1 WE W\LD HAVE SETTL$ \RSELVES 9 Y\R WORLD ) ! GREATE/ PLEASURE1 A WORLD :]E NOT REASON & ! REASONABLE DET]M9ATION ( ! HUMAN WILL1 BUT LONG EXI/5CE & IMMOBILITY >E ! MEASURE ( ! TRUE & ! HOLY1 & :]E CONSEQU5TLY ,*9A1 ) ITS M&>9S & ITS BAMBOO /ICKS1 MU/ OBTA9 AS ABSOLUTE TRU?4 ,BUT :AT CAN WE DO1 ,G5TLEM58 ,! TIMES >E BAD2 \R COMMON 5EMIES1 ! ,NEGATIVES1 HAVE WON MU* GR\ND4 ,WE HATE !M AS MU* AS & P]HAPS EV5 MORE ?AN Y\ DO Y\RSELVES1 S9CE1 9 !IR LACK ( RE/RA9T1 !Y P]MIT !MSELVES TO SCORN US2 BUT !Y HAVE BECOME P[]FUL & ONE MU/ WILLY-NILLY BE M9DFUL ( !M 9 ORD] NOT TO BE :OLLY DE/ROY$ BY !M4 ,SO DON'T BE SO FANATICAL1 ,G5TLEM52 GRANT !M A LITTLE SPACE 9 Y\R SOCIETY4 ,:AT MATT]S IT TO Y\ IF !Y SUCCE$ 9 Y\R.<#b.> HI/ORICAL MUSEUM TO SOME RU9S :I*1 ?\< V]Y V5]ABLE1 YET >E :OLLY FALL5 9TO DECAY8 ,BELIEVE US1 5TIRELY PLEAS$ BY ! HONOR :I* Y\ ?US R5D] !M1 !Y WILL CONDUCT !MSELVES V]Y QUIETLY & DISCREETLY 9 Y\R HONORABLE SOCIETY1 =1 9 ! 5D1 !Y >E BUT Y\NG PEOPLE :O1 'EMBITT]$ BY POV]TY & A LACK ( C>EFREE CONDITIONS1' %\T & MAKE SO MU* NOISE ONLY BECAUSE !Y HOPE ?US TO OBTA9 A C]TA9 IMPORTANCE & A COM=TABLE PLACE 9 SOCIETY4 ,!N !Y TURN TO ! ,NEGATIVES & SAY TO !M3 Y\R 5DEAVOR IS HONORABLE1 ,G5TLEM54 ,WE UND]/& Y\R Y\?FUL 5?USIASM = PURE PR9CIPLES & WE HAVE ! GREATE/ SYMPA?Y = Y\1 BUT1 BELIEVE US1 PURE PR9CIPLES 9 !IR PURITY >E NOT APPLICABLE TO LIFE2 LIFE REQUIRES A C]TA9 DOSE ( ECLECTICISM1 ! WORLD CANNOT BE CONQU]$ AS Y\ WI% TO DO IT1 Y\ MU/ YIELD SOME?+ 9 ORD] TO BE ABLE TO MOLD IT2 O!RWISE Y\ WILL :OLLY DAMAGE Y\R POSITION 9 IT4 ,&1 AS ONE TELLS ( ! ,POLI% ,JEWS1 ?AT 9 ! LA/ ,POLI% W> !Y WANT$ AT ! SAME TIME TO S]VE BO? W>R+ P>TIES1 ! ,POLES AS WELL AS ! ,RUSSIANS1 & W]E HANG$ BY BO?1 SO !SE POOR S\LS VEX !MSELVES ) ! IMPOSSIBLE BUS9ESS ( EXT]NAL RECONCILIATION1 & = ?ANKS >E DESPIS$ BY BO? P>TIES4 ,IT IS TOO BAD ?AT PRES5T TIMES >E TOO WEAK & TOO LI/LESS TO APPLY ! ,LAW ( ,SOLON TO !M6 ,PEOPLE WILL REPLY3 !SE >E M]E PHRASES4 ,! ,COMPROMIS]S >E MO/LY HONE/ & SCI5TIFICALLY $UCAT$ PEOPLE4 ,!RE >E A GREAT MANY UNIV]SALLY E/EEM$ & HIY1 SOME?+ 9COMM5SURABLE1 ON :I* ,I %ALL NEV] P]MIT MYSELF A JUDGM5T2 ?IS 9N] CORE CAN HAVE 9F9ITE WOR? = ! 9DIVIDUAL HIMSELF1 BUT = ! WORLD IT IS REAL ONLY 9S(> AS IT EXPRESSES ITSELF & IT IS ONLY ?AT :I* DOES EXPRESS ITSELF4 ,EV]Y MAN IS REALLY ONLY :AT HE IS 9 ! REAL WORLD1 & Y\ SURELY DON'T EXPECT ME TO SAY ?AT BLACK IS :ITE4 ,YES1 PEOPLE WILL RETORT1 !IR 5DEAVOR SEEMS TO BE BLACK TO Y\1 OR RA!R GRAY2 BUT 9 FACT ! ,COMPROMIS]S WANT & AIM ONLY AT PROGRESS & !Y FUR!R IT F> MORE ?AN Y\ DO Y\RSELF1 = !Y GO TO WORK PRUD5TLY & NOT EXCESSIVELY AS DO ! ,DEMOCRATS :O WANT TO BLA/ ! :OLE WORLD TO PIECES4 ,BUT WE HAVE SE5 :AT SU* PEOPLE IMAG9E ! PROGRESS 9T5D$ BY ! ,COMPROMIS]S TO BE2 WE HAVE SE5 ?AT ! ,COMPROMIS]S WANT NO?+ ELSE BUT ! /IFL+ ( ! ONLY VITAL PR9CIPLE ( \R PRES5T TIME1 O!RWISE SO POOR3 ! /IFL+ ( ! CREATIVE & PREGNANT PR9CIPLE ( RESOLV+ MOTION4 ,!Y P]CEIVE JU/ AS WE DO ?AT \R TIME IS A TIME ( CONTRADICTION4 ,!Y GRANT US ?AT ?IS IS AN EVIL1 9T]NALLY TORN CONDITION1 BUT1 9/EAD ( LETT+ IT TURN OV] 9TO A NEW1 AFFIRMATIVE1 & ORGANIC REALITY ?R\< ! COMPLETION ( ! CONTRADICTION1 !Y WANT1 BY MEANS ( AN 5DLESS GRADATION1 TO PRES]VE IT ET]NALLY 9 ITS PRES5T %ABBY & CONSUMPTIVE /ATE4 ,IS ?AT PROGRESS8 ,!Y SAY TO ! ,POSITIVES3 ',HANG ON TO ! OLD1 BUT P]MIT ! ,NEGATIVES AT ! SAME TIME TO RESOLVE IT GRADUALLY4' ,& TO ! ,NEGATIVES3 ',DE/ROY ! OLD1 BUT NOT ALL AT ONCE & COMPLETELY1 SO ?AT Y\ WILL ALWAYS HAVE SOME?+ TO DO4 ,I4E41 EA* ( Y\ REMA9 9 Y\R ONE-SID$NESS1 BUT WE1 ! ELECT1 WILL PROVE ! PLEASURE ( TOTALITY = \RSELVES4' ,WRET*$ TOTALITY ) :I* ONLY WRET*$ S\LS CAN BE SATISFI$6 ,!Y ROB CONTRADICTION ( ITS MOV+1 PRACTICAL S\L & REJOICE ?AT !Y CAN COMM& IT >BITR>ILY4 ,! GREAT PRES5T-DAY CONTRADICTION IS NOT = !M ! PRACTICAL P[] TO :I* EV]Y VITAL MAN MU/ RU?LESSLY SURR5D] HIMSELF 9 ORD] TO REMA9 VITAL1 BUT ONLY A !ORETICAL TOY4 ,!Y >E NOT P]MEAT$ BY ! PRACTICAL ,SPIRIT ( ! TIMES1 & H5CE !Y >E ALSO IMMORAL M54 ,YES1 !Y :O SO GLORY 9 !IR MORALITY >E IMMORAL M51 = MORALITY IS IMPOSSIBLE \TSIDE ! RELIGION ( FREE HUMANITY :I* ALONE BR+S HEAV5LY JOY4 ,ONE MU/ REPEAT TO !M :AT ! AU?OR ( ! ,APOCALYPSE SAID TO ! ,COMPROMIS]S ( HIS [N DAY3 ,I KN[ ?Y WORKS1 ?AT ?\ >T NEI!R COLD NOR HOT4 ,I W\LD ?\ W]T COLD OR HOT4 ,BUT BECAUSE ?\ >T LUKEW>M1 & NEI!R COLD NOR HOT1 ,I WILL BEG9 TO VOMIT !E \T ( MY M\?4 ,BECAUSE ?\ SAYE/3 ,I AM RI*1 & MADE WEAL?Y1 & HAVE NE$ ( NO?+3 & KN[E/ NOT1 ?AT ?\ >T WRET*$1 & MIS]ABLE1 & POOR1 & BL9D1 & NAK$4.<#c.> ,BUT1 PEOPLE WILL SAY TO ME1 >E Y\ NOT1 ) Y\R IRRECONCILABLE EXTREMES1 RELAPS+ 9TO ! AB/RACT POSITION LONG AGO REFUT$ BY ,S*ELL+ & ,HEGEL8 ,DID NOT ,HEGEL1 :OM Y\ VALUE SO HIKNESS1 & ?AT ONLY ! CONCRETE UNITY ( ! TWO MAKES VISION POSSIBLE AT ALL8 ,& DOES NOT ,HEGEL'S GREATE/ S]VICE CONSI/ 9 HIS HAV+ DEMON/RAT$ H[ EV]Y VITAL EXI/5CE IS VITAL ONLY BECAUSE IT HAS NEGATION NOT \TSIDE ITSELF BUT )9 ITSELF AS AN IMMAN5T CONDITION NECESS>Y TO ITS VITALITY2 & H[1 IF IT W]E ONLY POSITIVE & HAD ITS NEGATION \TSIDE ITSELF1 IT W\LD BE MOTIONLESS & LIFELESS8 ,I KN[ ?AT V]Y WELL1 ,G5TLEM56 ,I GRANT Y\ ?AT A VITAL ORGANISM1 = 9/ANCE1 IS VITAL ONLY 9 ?AT IT C>RIES ! G]M ( DEA? )9 IT4 ,BUT IF Y\ WANT TO QUOTE ,HEGEL TO ME1 !N Y\ MU/ QUOTE HIM 9 FULL4 ,!N Y\ WILL OBS]VE ?AT ! ,NEGATIVE IS ! CONDITION NECESS>Y = ! LIFE ( ?IS P>TICUL> ORGANISM ONLY SO LONG AS IT IS PRES5T 9 IT M]ELY AS A DIALECTICAL PHASE ASS]T$ 9 ?AT PHASE'S TOTALITY2 ?AT !RE COMES A PO9T1 H[EV]1 :5 ! GRADUAL EFFECT ( ! ,NEGATIVE IS SUDD5LY 9T]RUPT$ 9 SU* A MANN] ?AT ! ,NEGATIVE IS TRANS=M$ 9TO AN 9DEP5D5T PR9CIPLE1 & ?IS MOM5T IS ! DEA? ( ?IS P>TICUL> ORGANISM1 A DIALECTICAL PHASE :I* 9 ,HEGELIAN PHILOSOPHY IS *>ACT]IZ$ AS ! TRANSITION ( NATURE 9TO A QUALITATIVELY NEW WORLD1 9TO ! FREE WORLD ( ,SPIRIT4 ,! SAME IS REPEAT$ 9 HI/ORY4 ,! PR9CIPLE ( !ORETICAL FRE$OM1 = 9/ANCE1 ALREADY MADE ITSELF FELT 9 ! DECEAS$ ,CA?OLIC WORLD FROM ! />T ( ?AT WORLD'S EXI/5CE2 ?IS PR9CIPLE WAS ! S\RCE ( ALL H]ESIES 9 :I* ,CA?OLICISM WAS SO RI*4 ,BUT )\T ?IS PR9CIPLE ,CA?OLICISM W\LD HAVE BE5 MOTIONLESS1 & SO IT WAS AT ! SAME TIME ! PR9CIPLE ( ITS VITALITY1 ?\< ONLY SO LONG AS ! PR9CIPLE WAS MA9TA9$ 9 ITS TOTALITY AS PURE DIALECTICAL PHASE4 ,PROTE/ANTISM ALSO >OSE GRADUALLY3 IT HAD ITS BEG9N+ 9 ! BEG9N+ ( ,CA?OLICISM ITSELF2 BUT ONCE ?IS GRADUALNESS WAS 9T]RUPT$1 ! PR9CIPLE ( !ORETICAL FRE$OM RAIS$ ITSELF TO A SELF-SU/A9+1 9DEP5D5T PR9CIPLE4 ,!N ! CONTRADICTION WAS REVEAL$ 9 ITS PURITY = ! FIR/ TIME1 & Y\ WELL KN[1 ,G5TLEM51 Y\ :O CALL Y\RSELVES ,PROTE/ANTS1 :AT ,LU!R ANSW]$ TO ! ,COMPROMIS]S ( HIS DAY AS !Y (F]$ !IR S]VICES TO HIM4 ,Y\ SEE1 MY VIEW ( ! NATURE ( CONTRADICTION IS SUSCEPTIBLE NOT ONLY ( LOGICAL1 BUT ALSO ( HI/ORICAL CORROBORATION4 ,BUT ,I KN[ ?AT NO PRO( WILL AVAIL S9CE1 9 Y\R LIFELESSNESS1 Y\ UND]TAKE NO OCCUPATION SO WILL+LY AS ! MA/]Y ( HI/ORY4 ,IT IS NOT = NO?+ ?AT Y\ HAVE COME TO BE CALL$ DRY >RANG]S4 ',WE >E NOT YET DEFEAT$1' ! ,COMPROMIS]S WILL PROBABLY REPLY TO ME4 ',ALL ?AT Y\ SAY AB\T CONTRADICTION MAY BE TRUE1 BUT !RE IS JU/ ONE ?+ WE CANNOT GRANT Y\1 NAMELY1 ?AT ?+S >E N[1 9 \R TIME1 SO BAD AS Y\ MA9TA94 ,( C\RSE1 !RE >E CONTRADICTIONS 9 ! PRES5T DAY1 BUT !Y >E NOT SO DANG]\S AS Y\ ASS]T4 ,LOOK1 !RE IS TRANQUILITY EV]Y:]E1 EV]Y:]E MOVEM5T HAS SUBSID$4 ,NO ONE ?9KS ( W>1 & ! MAJORITY ( NATIONS & ( M5 N[ /RA9 EV]Y N]VE TO PRES]VE PEACE1 = !Y WELL KN[ ?AT ! MAT]IAL 9T]E/S :I* TODAY APPE> TO HAVE BECOME ! MA9 CONC]N ( POLITICS & ( UNIV]SAL CULTURE CANNOT BE PROMOT$ )\T PEACE4 ,H[ MANY IMPORTANT 9DUCEM5TS TO W> & TO ! DISSOLUTION ( ! PRES5T ORD] ( ?+S HAVE !RE NOT BE5 S9CE ! ,JULY ,REVOLUTION6 ,9 ! C\RSE ( !SE TWELVE YE>S !RE HAVE BE5 SU* 5TANGLEM5TS ?AT NO ONE C\LD POSSIBLY HAVE EXPECT$ !M TO BE PEACEFULLY UNRAVEL$2 MOM5TS :5 A UNIV]SAL W> SEEM$ ALMO/ 9EVITABLE & :5 ! MO/ FE>FUL /ORMS ?REAT5$ US2 & YET ALL DIFFICULTIES W]E GRADUALLY RESOLV$1 ALL REMA9$ QUIET1 & PEACE SEEMS TO HAVE E/ABLI%$ ITSELF ON E>? = EV]4' ,PEACE1 Y\ SAY4 ,YES1 :AT IS N[ CALL$ PEACE4 ,I MA9TA9 9 REPLY1 H[EV]1 ?AT CONTRADICTIONS HAVE NEV] BE5 SO %>PLY PRES5T$ AS N[1 ?AT ! ET]NAL CONTRADICTION1 :I* IS ! SAME AT ALL TIMES EXCEPT ?AT IT 9CREASES 9 9T5SITY & DEVELOPS ITSELF EV] MORE 9 ! C\RSE ( HI/ORY1 ?AT ?IS CONTRADICTION ( FRE$OM & UNFRE$OM HAS ADVANC$ & SO>$ TO ITS LA/ & HI TO ! P]IOD ( DISSOLUTION ( ! HEA!N WORLD4 ,HAVE Y\ NOT READ ! MY/]I\S & AWESOME WORDS1 ,LIB]TE1 ,EGALITE & ,FRAT]NITE ON ! =EGR\ND ( ! ,TEMPLE ( ,FRE$OM ]ECT$ BY ! ,REVOLUTION8 ,& DO Y\ NOT KN[ & FEEL ?AT !SE WORDS 9TIMATE ! COMPLETE ANNIHILATION ( ! PRES5T POLITICAL & SOCIAL WORLD8 ,HAVE Y\ HE>D NO?+ ( ! /ORMS ( ! REVOLUTION1 & DO Y\ NOT KN[ ?AT ,NAPOLEON1 ?IS SO-CALL$ TAM] ( ,DEMOCRACY1 DIFFUS$ ITS LEVEL+ PR9CIPLES OV] ALL ( ,EUROPE1 LIKE A WOR?Y SON ( ! ,REVOLUTION8 ,HAVE Y\ NOT ALSO P]HAPS HE>D SOME?+ ( ,KANT1 ,FI*TE1 ,S*ELL+1 & ,HEGEL1 OR DO Y\ REALLY KN[ NO?+ ( A PHILOSOPHY :I* E/ABLI%$ ! SAME LEVEL+ REVOLUTION>Y PR9CIPLE 9 ! 9TELLECTUAL WORLD --- NAMELY1 ! PR9CIPLE ( ! AUTONOMY ( ,SPIRIT8 ,& DO Y\ NOT COMPREH5D ?AT ?IS PR9CIPLE /&S 9 ! HIE Y\ !N BL9D & DEAF & HAVE Y\ NO EYES OR E>S = :AT GOES ON >\ND Y\8 ,NO1 ,G5TLEM51 ! ,SPIRIT ( REVOLUTION IS NOT SUBDU$1 IT HAS ONLY GONE BACK 9TO ITSELF AGA91 AFT] HAV+ CONVULS$ ! :OLE WORLD 9 ITS F\NDATIONS BY ITS FIR/ APPE>ANCE2 IT HAS ONLY SUNK 9TO ITSELF 9 ORD] SOON TO REVEAL ITSELF AGA9 AS AN AFFIRMATIVE1 CREATIVE PR9CIPLE1 & RI?4 ,& ?AT IT IS NOT WORK+ = NO?+ Y\ CAN SEE FROM ! MANY RU9S ) :I* \R RELIGI\S1 POLITICAL1 & SOCIAL FLOOR+ IS COV]$4 ,Y\ SPEAK ( RESOLUTION1 ( RECONCILIATION6 ,JU/ LOOK >\ND Y\ & TELL ME :AT HAS REMA9$ ALIVE ( ! OLD ,CA?OLIC & ,PROTE/ANT WORLD4 ,Y\ SPEAK ( ! SUBJUGATION ( ! ,NEGATIVE PR9CIPLE6 ,HAVE Y\ READ NO?+ ( ,/RAUSS1 ,FEU]BA* & ,BRUNO ,BAU]1 & DO Y\ NOT KN[ ?AT !IR WORKS >E 9 EV]YONE'S H&S8 ,DO Y\ NOT SEE ?AT ! :OLE ( ,G]MAN LIT]ATURE1 BOOKS1 BRO*URES1 NEWSPAP]S1 9DE$1 ! WORKS ( ! ,POSITIVI/S !MSELVES1 >E UNWITT+LY & UNWILL+LY P]MEAT$ BY ?IS NEGATIVE ,SPIRIT8 ,& Y\ CALL ?IS RECONCILIATION & PEACE6 ,Y\ WELL KN[ ?AT HUMANITY1 [+ TO ITS HI< CALL+1 CAN BE SATISFI$ & PACIFI$ ONLY BY ! ADOPTION ( A UNIV]SALLY PRACTICAL PR9CIPLE1 BY A PR9CIPLE :I* 9T5SELY CONC5TRATES )9 ITSELF ! ?\S& DIFF]5T MANIFE/ATIONS ( SPIRITUAL LIFE4 ,BUT :]E IS ?IS PR9CIPLE1 ,G5TLEM58 ,Y\ MU/ SURELY N[ & !N EXP]I5CE VITAL1 HUMAN MOM5TS DUR+ ! C\RSE ( Y\R EXI/5CE1 O!RWISE SO DISMAL2 MOM5TS :5 Y\ CA/ ASIDE ! PETTY CONC]NS ( Y\R DAILY LIFE & YE>N = ! TRUE1 = ! NOBLE1 = ! HOLY4 ,ANSW] ME HONE/LY1 N[1 Y\R H& ON Y\R HE>T1 HAVE Y\ EV] ANY:]E F\ND SOME?+ VITAL8 ,HAVE Y\ EV] DISCOV]$ UND] ! RU9S :I* SURR\ND US ?IS WORLD Y\ LONG =1 :]E Y\ C\LD :OLLY SURR5D] Y\RSELVES & BE ONCE MORE BORN ANEW 9 ?IS GREAT COMMUNION ) ALL HUMANITY8 ,IS ?IS WORLD P]*ANCE ,PROTE/ANTISM8 ,BUT ,PROTE/ANTISM IS AB&ON$ TO ! MO/ *Y3 9TO H[ MANY DIFF]5T SECTS IS IT NOT R5D]$8 ',)\T GREAT1 UNIV]SAL 5?USIASM !RE >E ONLY SECTS & NO PUBLIC IDIOM1' SAYS ,S*ELL+2 BUT ! CURR5T ,PROTE/ANT WORLD IS AS F> FROM BE+ P]MEAT$ ) A G5]AL 5?USIASM AS HEAV5 IS FROM E>?2 IT IS RA!R ! MO/ PROSAIC WORLD ONE CAN IMAG9E1 ,WELL1 !N1 IS IT P]*ANCE ,CA?OLICISM8 ,BUT :]E IS ,CA?OLICISM'S ANCI5T SPL5DOR8 ,HAS ,CA?OLICISM1 :I* =M]LY RUL$ OV] ! :OLE WORLD1 N[ NOT BECOME AN OB$I5T TOOL ( AN ALI51 IMMORAL POLICY8 ,OR DO Y\ P]HAPS F9D Y\R PEACE ( M9D 9 ! CONTEMPOR>Y /ATE8 ,YES1 ?AT W\LD REALLY BE A F9E PEACE ( M9D6 ,! /ATE IS CURR5TLY 9 ! ?ROES ( ! DEEPE/ 9T]NAL CONFLICT1 = )\T RELIGION1 )\T A P[]FUL UNIV]SAL CONVICTION1 ! /ATE IS IMPOSSIBLE4 ,JU/ LOOK AT ,FRANCE & ,5GL& IF Y\ WANT TO CONV9CE Y\RSELVES ( ?IS2 ,I %ALL NOT SAY ANY?+ AB\T ,G]MANY6 ,F9ALLY1 /UDY Y\RSELVES1 ,G5TLEM51 & TELL ME HONE/LY1 >E Y\ PLEAS$ ) Y\RSELVES1 & CAN Y\ BE PLEAS$ ) Y\RSELVES8 ,>E Y\ NOT1 )\T EXCEPTION1 DISMAL & %ABBY APPE>ANCES ( \R DISMAL & %ABBY TIMES 8 ,>E Y\ NOT FULL ( CONFLICTS8 ,>E Y\ :OLE M58 ,DO Y\ REALLY BELIEVE 9 ANY?+8 ,DO Y\ REALLY KN[ :AT Y\ WANT & CAN Y\ WANT ANY?+ AT ALL8 ,HAS MOD]N SPECULATION1 ! EPIDEMIC ( \R TIME1 LEFT A S+LE S\ND P>T 9 Y\1 & >E Y\ NOT P]MEAT$ BY ?IS DISEASE & P>ALYZ$ & BROK5 BY IT8 ,9 FACT1 ,G5TLEM51 Y\ MU/ CONFESS ?AT \R TIMES >E DISMAL TIMES & ?AT WE >E ALL ITS /ILL MORE DISMAL *ILDR56 ,ON ! O!R H&1 H[EV]1 VISIBLE APPE>ANCES >E /IRR+ >\ND US1 9DICAT+ ?AT ! ,SPIRIT1 ?IS OLD MOLE1 HAS BR\E BE+ =M$1 :OLLY ALI5 TO ! PRES5T POLITICAL WORLD1 SOCIETIES :I* D]IVE !IR LIFE FROM NEW S\RCES QUITE UNKN[N TO US & DEVELOP & DIFFUSE !MSELVES 9 SIL5CE4 ,! PEOPLE1 ! POOR CLASS1 :I* )\T D\BT CON/ITUTES ! GREATE/ P>T ( HUMANITY2 ! CLASS :OSE RI$ TO IT1 & TO DEM& ! ACTUALIZATION ( ! RIE FILL$ ) A K9D ( PREMONITION1 & EV]YONE :OSE VITAL ORGANS >E NOT P>ALYZ$ FACES ) %UDD]+ EXPECTATION ! APPROA*+ FUTURE :I* WILL SPEAK \T ! R$EEM+ WORD4 ,EV5 9 ,RUSSIA1 9 ?IS 5DLESS & SN[-COV]$ K+DOM :I* WE KN[ SO LITTLE & :I* P]HAPS A GREAT FUTURE AWAITS1 EV5 9 ,RUSSIA D>K CL\DS >E GA!R+1 H]ALD+ /ORM4 ,OH1 ! AIR IS SULTRY & FILL$ ) LITS TO TRU?1 TO FREE !MSELVES ( !IR WRET*$ & BL9D WISDOM1 ( !IR 9TELLECTUAL >ROGANCE1 & ( ! S]VILE FE> :I* DRIES UP !IR S\LS & P>ALYZES !IR MOVEM5TS4 ,LET US !RE=E TRU/ ! ET]NAL ,SPIRIT :I* DE/ROYS & ANNIHILATES ONLY BECAUSE IT IS ! UNFA?OMABLE & ET]NALLY CREATIVE S\RCE ( ALL LIFE4 ,! PASSION = DE/RUCTION IS A CREATIVE PASSION1 TOO4 .<#a.> ' 444 9 SI* NI*TS HAT1 WAS ES NEGI]5 KONNTE' -- DOES ,BAKUN9 P]HAPS MEAN '?AT IT C\LD NEGATE IT8 -- ,T,R,A,N,S4 .<#b.> ,READ+ ',IHREM' = 'IHREM' -- ,T,R,A,N,S4 .<#c.> ,REV4 #c3#a#e-#a#g -- ,T,R,A,N,S4 ,FROM 3 ,!,AN>*I/,LIBR>Y4ORG4 ,*RONOLOGY 3 ,NOVEMB] #c1 #ahda 3 ,! ,REACTION 9 ,G]MANY -- ,PUBLICATION4 ,JULY #i1 #bai 3 ,! ,REACTION 9 ,G]MANY -- ,ADD$4 ,JANU>Y #c1 #bbb 3 ,! ,REACTION 9 ,G]MANY -- ,UPDAT$4 FILE G5]AT$ FROM 3 HTTP3_/_/REVOLTLIB4COM_/