,P>T #b1 ,*APT] #b1 ,SECTION #b 
,MY ,9T]C\RSE 

#ahddahdd 

,PEOPLE 3 

,AU?OR 3 ,MAX ,/IRN] 

,TEXT 3 

,MY ,9T]C\RSE 

,9 SOCIETY ! HUMAN DEM& AT MO/ CAN BE SATISFI$1 :ILE ! EGOI/IC MU/ ALWAYS COME %ORT4 

,BECAUSE IT CAN H>DLY ESCAPE ANYBODY ?AT ! PRES5T %[S NO SU* LIV+ 9T]E/ 9 ANY QUE/ION AS 9 ! 0SOCIAL10 ONE HAS TO DIRECT HIS GAZE ESPECIALLY TO SOCIETY4 ,9DE$1 IF ! 9T]E/ FELT 9 IT W]E LESS PASSIONATE & DAZZL$1 PEOPLE W\LD NOT SO MU*1 9 LOOK+ AT SOCIETY1 LOSE SI<T ( ! 9DIVIDUALS 9 IT1 & W\LD RECOGNIZE ?AT A SOCIETY CANNOT BECOME NEW SO LONG AS ?OSE :O =M & CON/ITUTE IT REMA9 ! OLD ONES4 ,IF1 = EXAMPLE1 !RE WAS TO >ISE 9 ! ,JEWI% PEOPLE A SOCIETY :I* %\LD SPREAD A NEW FAI? OV] ! E>?1 !SE APO/LES C\LD 9 NO CASE REMA9 ,PH>ISEES4 

,AS Y\ >E1 SO Y\ PRES5T Y\RSELF1 SO Y\ BEHAVE T[>D M53 A HYPOCRITE AS A HYPOCRITE1 A ,*RI/IAN AS A ,*RI/IAN4 ,!RE=E ! *>ACT] ( A SOCIETY IS DET]M9$ BY ! *>ACT] ( ITS MEMB]S3 !Y >E ITS CREATORS4 ,SO MU* AT LEA/ ONE MU/ P]CEIVE EV5 IF ONE W]E NOT WILL+ TO PUT TO ! TE/ ! CONCEPT 0SOCIETY0 ITSELF4 

,EV] F> FROM LETT+ !MSELVES COME TO !IR FULL DEVELOPM5T & CONSEQU5CE1 M5 HAVE HI!RTO NOT BE5 ABLE TO F\ND !IR SOCIETIES ON !MSELVES2 OR RA!R1 !Y HAVE BE5 ABLE ONLY TO F\ND 0SOCIETIES0 & TO LIVE 9 SOCIETIES4 ,! SOCIETIES W]E ALWAYS P]SONS1 P[]FUL P]SONS1 SO-CALL$ 0MORAL P]SONS10 <O/S1 BE=E :I* ! 9DIVIDUAL HAD ! APPROPRIATE :EEL 9 HIS HEAD1 ! FE> ( <O/S4 ,AS SU* <O/S !Y MAY MO/ SUITABLY BE DESIGNAT$ BY ! RESPECTIVE NAMES 0PEOPLE0 & 0PEOPLET03 ! PEOPLE ( ! PATRI>*S1 ! PEOPLE ( ! ,HELL5ES1 ETC41 AT LA/ ! - PEOPLE ( M51 ,MANK9D 7,ANA*>SIS ,CLOOTS WAS 5?USIA/IC = ! 0NATION0 ( MANK9D72 !N EV]Y SUBDIVISION ( ?IS 0PEOPLE10 :I* C\LD & MU/ HAVE ITS SPECIAL SOCIETIES1 ! ,SPANI%1 ,FR5* PEOPLE1 ETC42 )9 IT AGA9 CLASSES1 CITIES1 9 %ORT ALL K9DS ( CORPORATIONS2 LA/LY1 TAP]+ TO ! F9E/ PO9T1 ! LITTLE PEOPLET ( ! - FAMILY4 ,H5CE1 9/EAD ( SAY+ ?AT ! P]SON ?AT WALK$ AS <O/ 9 ALL SOCIETIES HI!RTO HAS BE5 ! PEOPLE1 !RE MI<T ALSO HAVE BE5 NAM$ ! TWO EXTREMES - NAMELY1 EI!R 0MANK9D0 OR ! 0FAMILY10 BO? ! MO/ 0NATURAL-BORN UNITS40 ,WE *OOSE ! WORD 0PEOPLE0 BECAUSE ITS D]IVATION HAS BE5 BR\<T 9TO CONNECTION ) ! ,GREEK POLLOI1 ! 0MANY0 OR 0! MASSES10 BUT /ILL MORE BECAUSE 0NATIONAL EF=TS0 >E AT PRES5T ! ORD] ( ! DAY1 & BECAUSE EV5 ! NEWE/ MUT9E]S HAVE NOT YET %AK5 (F ?IS DECEPTIVE P]SON1 AL?\< ON ! O!R H& ! LATT] CONSID]ATION MU/ GIVE ! PREF]5CE TO ! EXPRESSION 0MANK9D10 S9CE ON ALL SIDES !Y >E GO+ 9 = 5?USIASM OV] 0MANK9D40 

,! PEOPLE1 !N - MANK9D OR ! FAMILY - HAVE HI!RTO1 AS IT SEEMS1 PLAY$ HI/ORY3 NO EGOI/IC 9T]E/ WAS TO COME UP 9 !SE SOCIETIES1 BUT SOLELY G5]AL ONES1 NATIONAL OR POPUL> 9T]E/S1 CLASS 9T]E/S1 FAMILY 9T]E/S1 & 0G5]AL HUMAN 9T]E/S40 ,BUT :O HAS BR\<T TO !IR FALL ! PEOPLES :OSE DECL9E HI/ORY RELATES8 ,:O BUT ! EGOI/1 :O WAS SEEK+ HIS SATISFACTION6 ,IF ONCE AN EGOI/IC 9T]E/ CREPT 91 ! SOCIETY WAS 0CORRUPT$0 & MOV$ T[>D ITS DISSOLUTION1 AS ,ROME PROVES ) ITS HI<LY DEVELOP$ SY/EM ( PRIVATE RI<TS1 OR ,*RI/IANITY ) ! 9CESSANTLY-BREAK+-9 0RATIONAL SELF-DET]M9ATION10 0SELF-CONSCI\SNESS10 ! 0AUTONOMY ( ! SPIRIT10 & SO ON4 

,! ,*RI/IAN PEOPLE HAS PRODUC$ TWO SOCIETIES :OSE DURATION WILL KEEP EQUAL MEASURE ) ! P]MAN5CE ( ?AT PEOPLE3 !SE >E ! SOCIETIES /ATE & ,*UR*4 ,CAN !Y BE CALL$ A UNION ( EGOI/S8 ,DO WE 9 !M PURSUE AN EGOI/IC1 P]SONAL1 [N 9T]E/1 OR DO WE PURSUE A POPUL>1 AN 9T]E/ ( ! ,*RI/IAN PEOPLE1 NAMELY1 A /ATE1 & ,*UR* 9T]E/8 ,CAN ,I & MAY ,I BE MYSELF 9 !M8 ,MAY ,I ?9K & ACT AS ,I WILL1 MAY ,I REVEAL MYSELF1 LIVE MYSELF \T1 BUSY MYSELF8 ,MU/ ,I NOT LEAVE UNT\*$ ! MAJE/Y ( ! /ATE1 ! SANCTITY ( ! ,*UR*8 

,WELL1 ,I MAY NOT DO SO AS ,I WILL4 ,BUT %ALL ,I F9D 9 ANY SOCIETY SU* AN UNMEASUR$ FRE$OM ( MAY+8 ,C]TA9LY NO6 ,ACCORD+LY WE MI<T BE CONT5T8 ,NOT A BIT6 ,IT IS A DIFF]5T ?+ :E!R ,I REB\ND FROM AN EGO OR FROM A PEOPLE1 A G5]ALIZATION4 ,!RE ,I AM MY OPPON5T'S OPPON5T1 BORN HIS EQUAL2 H]E ,I AM A DESPIS$ OPPON5T1 B\ND & UND] A GU>DIAN3 !RE ,I /& MAN TO MAN2 H]E ,I AM A S*OOLBOY :O CAN ACCOMPLI% NO?+ AGA9/ HIS COMRADE BECAUSE ! LATT] HAS CALL$ FA!R & MO!R TO AID & HAS CREPT UND] ! APRON1 :ILE ,I AM WELL SCOLD$ AS AN ILL-BR$ BRAT1 & ,I MU/ NOT 0>GUE03 !RE ,I FI<T AGA9/ A BODILY 5EMY2 H]E AGA9/ MANK9D1 AGA9/ A G5]ALIZATION1 AGA9/ A 0MAJE/Y10 AGA9/ A SPOOK4 ,BUT TO ME NO MAJE/Y1 NO?+ SACR$1 IS A LIMIT2 NO?+ ?AT ,I KN[ H[ TO OV]P[]4 ,ONLY ?AT :I* ,I CANNOT OV]P[] /ILL LIMITS MY MI<T2 & ,I ( LIMIT$ MI<T AM TEMPOR>ILY A LIMIT$ ,I1 NOT LIMIT$ BY ! MI<T \TSIDE ME1 BUT LIMIT$ BY MY [N /ILL DEFICI5T MI<T1 BY MY [N IMPOT5CE4 ,H[EV]1 0! ,GU>D DIES1 BUT DOES NOT SURR5D]60 ,ABOVE ALL1 ONLY A BODILY OPPON5T6 

,I D>E MEET EV]Y FOEMAN ,:OM ,I CAN SEE & MEASURE ) MY EYE1 ,:OSE METTLE FIRES MY METTLE = ! FI<T - ETC4 

,MANY PRIVILEGES HAVE 9DE$ BE5 CANCEL$ ) TIME1 BUT SOLELY = ! SAKE ( ! COMMON WEAL1 ( ! /ATE & ! /ATE'S WEAL1 BY NO MEANS = ! /R5G!N+ ( ME4 ,VASSALAGE WAS ABROGAT$ ONLY ?AT A S+LE LIEGE LORD1 ! LORD ( ! PEOPLE1 ! MON>*ICAL P[]1 MI<T BE /R5G!N$3 VASSALAGE UND] ! ONE BECAME YET MORE RIGOR\S !REBY4 ,ONLY 9 FAVOR ( ! MON>*1 BE HE CALL$ 0PR9CE0 OR 0LAW10 HAVE PRIVILEGES FALL54 ,9 ,FRANCE ! CITIZ5S >E NOT1 9DE$1 VASSALS ( ! K+1 BUT >E 9/EAD VASSALS ( ! 0LAW0 7! ,*>T]74 ,SUBORD9ATION WAS RETA9$1 ONLY ! ,*RI/IAN /ATE RECOGNIZ$ ?AT MAN CANNOT S]VE TWO MA/]S 7! LORD ( ! MANOR & ! PR9CE72 !RE=E ONE OBTA9$ ALL ! PR]OGATIVES2 N[ HE CAN AGA9 PLACE ONE ABOVE ANO!R1 HE CAN MAKE 0M5 9 HI< PLACE40 

,BUT ( :AT CONC]N TO ME IS ! COMMON WEAL8 ,! COMMON WEAL AS SU* IS NOT MY WEAL1 BUT ONLY ! FUR!/ EXTREMITY ( SELF-R5UNCIATION4 ,! COMMON WEAL MAY *E] AL\D :ILE ,I MU/ 0D[N02 ! /ATE MAY %9E :ILE ,I />VE4 ,9 :AT LIES ! FOLLY ( ! POLITICAL LIB]ALS BUT 9 !IR OPPOS+ ! PEOPLE TO ! GOV]NM5T & TALK+ ( PEOPLE'S RI<TS8 ,SO !RE IS ! PEOPLE GO+ TO BE ( AGE1 ETC4 ,AS IF ONE :O HAS NO M\? .<,MUND.> C\LD BE ( AGE .<MUNDIG.>6 ,ONLY ! 9DIVIDUAL IS ABLE TO BE ( AGE4 ,?US ! :OLE QUE/ION ( ! LIB]TY ( ! PRESS IS TURN$ UPSIDE D[N :5 IT IS LAID CLAIM TO AS A 0RI<T ( ! PEOPLE40 ,IT IS ONLY A RI<T1 OR BETT] ! MI<T1 ( ! 9DIVIDUAL4 ,IF A PEOPLE HAS LIB]TY ( ! PRESS1 !N ,I1 AL?\< 9 ! MID/ ( ?IS PEOPLE1 HAVE IT NOT2 A LIB]TY ( ! PEOPLE IS NOT MY LIB]TY1 & ! LIB]TY ( ! PRESS AS A LIB]TY ( ! PEOPLE MU/ HAVE AT ITS SIDE A PRESS LAW DIRECT$ AGA9/ ME4 

,?IS MU/ BE 9SI/$ ON ALL >\ND AGA9/ ! PRES5T-DAY EF=TS = LIB]TY3 

,LIB]TY ( ! PEOPLE IS NOT MY LIB]TY6 

,LET US ADMIT !SE CATEGORIES1 LIB]TY ( ! PEOPLE & RI<T ( ! PEOPLE3 = EXAMPLE1 ! RI<T ( ! PEOPLE ?AT EV]YBODY MAY BE> >MS4 ,DOES ONE NOT =FEIT SU* A RI<T8 ,ONE CANNOT =FEIT HIS [N RI<T1 BUT MAY WELL =FEIT A RI<T ?AT BELONGS NOT TO ME BUT TO ! PEOPLE4 ,I MAY BE LOCK$ UP = ! SAKE ( ! LIB]TY ( ! PEOPLE2 ,I MAY1 UND] S5T5CE1 9CUR ! LOSS ( ! RI<T TO BE> >MS4 

,LIB]ALISM APPE>S AS ! LA/ ATTEMPT AT A CREATION ( ! LIB]TY ( ! PEOPLE1 A LIB]TY ( ! COMMUNE1 ( 0SOCIETY10 ( ! G5]AL1 ( MANK9D2 ! DREAM ( A HUMANITY1 A PEOPLE1 A COMMUNE1 A 0SOCIETY10 ?AT %ALL BE ( AGE4 

,A PEOPLE CANNOT BE FREE O!RWISE ?AN AT ! 9DIVIDUAL'S EXP5SE2 = IT IS NOT ! 9DIVIDUAL ?AT IS ! MA9 PO9T 9 ?IS LIB]TY1 BUT ! PEOPLE4 ,! FRE] ! PEOPLE1 ! MORE B\ND ! 9DIVIDUAL2 ! ,A!NIAN PEOPLE1 PRECISELY AT ITS FREE/ TIME1 CREAT$ O/RACISM1 BANI%$ ! A!I/S1 POISON$ ! MO/ HONE/ ?9K]4 

,H[ !Y DO PRAISE ,SOCRATES = HIS CONSCI5TI\SNESS1 :I* MAKES HIM RESI/ ! ADVICE TO GET AWAY FROM ! DUNGEON6 ,HE IS A FOOL ?AT HE CONC$ES TO ! ,A!NIANS A RI<T TO CONDEMN HIM4 ,!RE=E IT C]TA9LY S]VES HIM RI<T2 :Y !N DOES HE REMA9 /&+ ON AN EQUAL FOOT+ ) ! ,A!NIANS8 ,:Y DOES HE NOT BREAK ) !M8 ,HAD HE KN[N1 & BE5 ABLE TO KN[1 :AT HE WAS1 HE W\LD HAVE CONC$$ TO SU* JUDGES NO CLAIM1 NO RI<T4 ,?AT HE DID NOT ESCAPE WAS JU/ HIS WEAKNESS1 HIS DELUSION ( /ILL HAV+ SOME?+ 9 COMMON ) ! ,A!NIANS1 OR ! OP9ION ?AT HE WAS A MEMB]1 A M]E MEMB] ( ?IS PEOPLE4 ,BUT HE WAS RA!R ?IS PEOPLE ITSELF 9 P]SON1 & C\LD ONLY BE HIS [N JUDGE4 ,!RE WAS NO JUDGE OV] HIM1 AS HE HIMSELF HAD REALLY PRON\NC$ A PUBLIC S5T5CE ON HIMSELF & RAT$ HIMSELF WOR?Y ( ! ,PRYTANEUM4 ,HE %\LD HAVE /UCK TO ?AT1 &1 AS HE HAD UTT]$ NO S5T5CE ( DEA? AGA9/ HIMSELF1 %\LD HAVE DESPIS$ ?AT ( ! ,A!NIANS TOO & ESCAP$4 ,BUT HE SUBORD9AT$ HIMSELF & RECOGNIZ$ 9 ! PEOPLE HIS JUDGE2 HE SEEM$ LITTLE TO HIMSELF BE=E ! MAJE/Y ( ! PEOPLE4 ,?AT HE SUBJECT$ HIMSELF TO MI<T 7TO :I* ALONE HE C\LD SUCCUMB7 AS TO A 0RI<T0 WAS TREASON AGA9/ HIMSELF3 IT WAS VIRTUE4 ,TO ,*RI/1 :O1 IT IS ALLEG$1 REFRA9$ FROM US+ ! P[] OV] HIS HEAV5LY LEGIONS1 ! SAME SCRUPUL\SNESS IS !REBY ASCRIB$ BY ! N>RATORS4 ,LU!R DID V]Y WELL & WISELY TO HAVE ! SAFETY ( HIS J\RNEY TO ,WORMS W>RANT$ TO HIM 9 BLACK & :ITE1 & ,SOCRATES %\LD HAVE KN[N ?AT ! ,A!NIANS W]E HIS 5EMIES1 HE ALONE HIS JUDGE4 ,! SELF-DECEPTION ( A 0REIGN ( LAW10 ETC41 %\LD HAVE GIV5 WAY TO ! P]CEPTION ?AT ! RELATION WAS A RELATION ( MI<T4 

,IT WAS ) HAIRSPLITT+ & 9TRIGUES ?AT ,GREEK LIB]TY 5D$4 ,:Y8 ,BECAUSE ! ORD9>Y ,GREEKS C\LD /ILL LESS ATTA9 ?AT LOGICAL CONCLUSION :I* NOT EV5 !IR H]O ( ?\<T1 ,SOCRATES1 WAS ABLE TO DRAW4 ,:AT !N IS HAIRSPLITT+ BUT A WAY ( UTILIZ+ SOME?+ E/ABLI%$ )\T DO+ AWAY ) IT8 ,I MI<T ADD 0= ONE'S [N ADVANTAGE10 BUT1 Y\ SEE1 ?AT LIES 9 0UTILIZ+40 ,SU* PETTIFOGG]S >E ! !OLOGIANS :O 0WRE/0 & 0=CE0 ,GOD'S WORD2 :AT W\LD !Y HAVE TO WRE/ IF IT W]E NOT = ! 0E/ABLI%$0 ,WORD ( ,GOD8 ,SO ?OSE LIB]ALS :O ONLY %AKE & WRE/ ! 0E/ABLI%$ ORD]40 ,!Y >E ALL P]V]T]S1 LIKE ?OSE P]V]T]S ( ! LAW4 ,SOCRATES RECOGNIZ$ LAW1 RI<T2 ! ,GREEKS CON/ANTLY RETA9$ ! AU?ORITY ( RI<T & LAW4 ,IF ) ?IS RECOGNITION !Y WANT$ NEV]!LESS TO ASS]T !IR ADVANTAGE1 EV]Y ONE HIS [N1 !N !Y HAD TO SEEK IT 9 P]V]SION ( ! LAW1 OR 9TRIGUE4 ,ALCIBIADES1 AN 9TRIGU] ( G5IUS1 9TRODUCES ! P]IOD ( ,A!NIAN 0DECAY02 ! ,SP>TAN ,LYS&] & O!RS %[ ?AT 9TRIGUE HAD BECOME UNIV]SALLY ,GREEK4 ,GREEK LAW1 ON :I* ! ,GREEK /ATES RE/$1 HAD TO BE P]V]T$ & UND]M9$ BY ! EGOI/S )9 !SE /ATES1 & ! /ATES W5T D[N ?AT ! 9DIVIDUALS MI<T BECOME FREE1 ! ,GREEK PEOPLE FELL BECAUSE ! 9DIVIDUALS C>$ LESS = ?IS PEOPLE ?AN = !MSELVES4 ,9 G5]AL1 ALL /ATES1 CON/ITUTIONS1 *UR*ES1 HAVE SUNK BY ! SECESSION ( 9DIVIDUALS2 = ! 9DIVIDUAL IS ! IRRECONCILABLE 5EMY ( EV]Y G5]ALITY1 EV]Y TIE1 EV]Y FETT]4 ,YET PEOPLE FANCY TO ?IS DAY ?AT MAN NE$S 0SACR$ TIES03 HE1 ! DEADLY 5EMY ( EV]Y 0TIE40 ,! HI/ORY ( ! WORLD %[S ?AT NO TIE HAS YET REMA9$ UNR5T1 %[S ?AT MAN TIRELESSLY DEF5DS HIMSELF AGA9/ TIES ( EV]Y SORT2 & YET1 BL9D$1 PEOPLE ?9K UP NEW TIES AGA9 & AGA91 & ?9K ?AT !Y HAVE >RIV$ AT ! RI<T ONE IF ONE PUTS UPON !M ! TIE ( A SO-CALL$ FREE CON/ITUTION1 A BEAUTIFUL1 CON/ITUTIONAL TIE2 DECORATION RIBBONS1 ! TIES ( CONFID5CE BETWE5 0 - - - 10 DO SEEM GRADUALLY TO HAVE BECOME SOME:AT 9FIRM1 BUT PEOPLE HAVE MADE NO FUR!R PROGRESS ?AN FROM APRON-/R+S TO G>T]S & COLL>S4 

,EV]Y?+ SACR$ IS A TIE1 A FETT]4 

,EV]Y?+ SACR$ IS & MU/ BE P]V]T$ BY P]V]T]S ( ! LAW2 !RE=E \R PRES5T TIME HAS MULTITUDES ( SU* P]V]T]S 9 ALL SPH]ES4 ,!Y >E PREP>+ ! WAY = ! BREAKUP ( LAW1 = LAWLESSNESS4 

,POOR ,A!NIANS :O >E ACCUS$ ( HAIRSPLITT+ & SOPHI/RY6 POOR ,ALCIBIADES1 ( 9TRIGUE6 ,:Y1 ?AT WAS JU/ Y\R BE/ PO9T1 Y\R FIR/ /EP 9 FRE$OM4 ,Y\R ,AES*YLUS1 ,H]ODOTUS1 ETC41 ONLY WANT$ TO HAVE A FREE ,GREEK PEOPLE2 Y\ W]E ! FIR/ TO SURMISE SOME?+ ( Y\R FRE$OM4 

,A PEOPLE REPRESSES ?OSE :O T[] ABOVE ITS MAJE/Y1 BY O/RACISM AGA9/ TOO-P[]FUL CITIZ5S1 BY ! ,9QUISITION AGA9/ ! H]ETICS ( ! ,*UR*1 BY ! - ,9QUISITION AGA9/ TRAITORS 9 ! /ATE4 

,= ! PEOPLE IS CONC]N$ ONLY ) ITS SELF-ASS]TION2 IT DEM&S 0PATRIOTIC SELF-SACRIFICE0 FROM EV]YBODY4 ,TO IT1 ACCORD+LY1 EV]Y ONE 9 HIMSELF IS 9DIFF]5T1 A NO?+1 & IT CANNOT DO1 NOT EV5 SUFF]1 :AT ! 9DIVIDUAL & HE ALONE MU/ DO - NAMELY1 TURN HIM TO ACC\NT4 ,EV]Y PEOPLE1 EV]Y /ATE1 IS UNJU/ T[>D ! EGOI/4 

,AS LONG AS !RE /ILL EXI/S EV5 ONE 9/ITUTION :I* ! 9DIVIDUAL MAY NOT DISSOLVE1 ! [NNESS & SELF-APPURT5ANCE ( ,ME IS /ILL V]Y REMOTE4 ,H[ CAN ,I BE FREE :5 ,I MU/ B9D MYSELF BY OA? TO A CON/ITUTION1 A *>T]1 A LAW1 0V[ BODY & S\L0 TO MY PEOPLE8 ,H[ CAN ,I BE MY [N :5 MY FACULTIES MAY DEVELOP ONLY SO F> AS !Y 0DO NOT DI/URB ! H>MONY ( SOCIETY0 7,WEITL+78 

,! FALL ( PEOPLES & MANK9D WILL 9VITE ME TO MY RISE4 

,LI/51 EV5 AS ,I AM WRIT+ ?IS1 ! BELLS BEG9 TO S\ND1 ?AT !Y MAY J+LE 9 = TOMORR[ ! FE/IVAL ( ! ?\S& YE>S' EXI/5CE ( \R DE> ,G]MANY4 ,S\ND1 S\ND ITS KNELL6 ,Y\ DO S\ND SOLEMN 5\<1 AS IF Y\R TONGUE WAS MOV$ BY ! PRES5TIM5T ?AT IT IS GIV+ CONVOY TO A CORPSE4 ,! ,G]MAN PEOPLE & ,G]MAN PEOPLES HAVE BEH9D !M A HI/ORY ( A ?\S& YE>S3 :AT A LONG LIFE6 ,O1 GO TO RE/1 NEV] TO RISE AGA9 - ?AT ALL MAY BECOME FREE :OM Y\ SO LONG HAVE HELD 9 FETT]S4 - ,! PEOPLE IS DEAD4 - ,UP ) ME 6 

,O ?\ MY MU*-TORM5T$ ,G]MAN PEOPLE - :AT WAS ?Y TORM5T8 ,IT WAS ! TORM5T ( A ?\<T ?AT CANNOT CREATE ITSELF A BODY1 ! TORM5T ( A WALK+ SPIRIT ?AT DISSOLVES 9TO NO?+ AT EV]Y COCK-CR[ & YET P9ES = DELIV]ANCE & FULFILLM5T4 ,9 ME TOO ?\ HA/ LIV$ LONG1 ?\ DE> - ?\<T1 ?\ DE> - SPOOK4 ,ALREADY ,I ALMO/ FANCI$ ,I HAD F\ND ! WORD ( ?Y DELIV]ANCE1 DISCOV]$ FLE% & BONES = ! W&]+ SPIRIT2 !N ,I HE> !M S\ND1 ! BELLS ?AT U%] !E 9TO ET]NAL RE/2 !N ! LA/ HOPE FADES \T1 !N ! NOTES ( ! LA/ LOVE DIE AWAY1 !N ,I DEP>T FROM ! DESOLATE H\SE ( ?OSE :O N[ >E DEAD & 5T] AT ! DOOR ( ! - LIV+ ONE3 

,= ONLY HE :O IS ALIVE IS 9 ! RI<T4 

,F>EWELL1 ?\ DREAM ( SO MANY MILLIONS2 F>EWELL1 ?\ :O HA/ TYRANNIZ$ OV] ?Y *ILDR5 = A ?\S& YE>S6 

,TOMORR[ !Y C>RY !E TO ! GRAVE2 SOON ?Y SI/]S1 ! PEOPLES1 WILL FOLL[ !E4 ,BUT1 :5 !Y HAVE ALL FOLL[$1 !N - - MANK9D IS BURI$1 & ,I AM MY [N1 ,I AM ! LAU<+ HEIR6 

,! WORD SOCIETY .<,GESELLS*AFT.> HAS ITS ORIG9 9 ! WORD HALL .<,SAAL.>4 ,IF ONE HALL 5CLOSES MANY P]SONS1 !N ! HALL CAUSES !SE P]SONS TO BE 9 SOCIETY4 ,!Y >E 9 SOCIETY1 & AT MO/ CON/ITUTE A DRAW+-ROOM SOCIETY BY TALK+ 9 ! TRADITIONAL =MS ( DRAW+-ROOM SPEE*4 ,:5 IT COMES TO REAL 9T]C\RSE1 ?IS IS TO BE REG>D$ AS 9DEP5D5T ( SOCIETY3 IT MAY OCCUR OR BE LACK+1 )\T ALT]+ ! NATURE ( :AT IS NAM$ SOCIETY4 ,?OSE :O >E 9 ! HALL >E A SOCIETY EV5 AS MUTE P]SONS1 OR :5 !Y PUT EA* O!R (F SOLELY ) EMPTY PHRASES ( C\RTESY4 ,9T]C\RSE IS MUTUALITY1 IT IS ! ACTION1 ! COMM]CIUM1 ( 9DIVIDUALS2 SOCIETY IS ONLY COMMUNITY ( ! HALL1 & EV5 ! /ATUES ( A MUSEUM-HALL >E 9 SOCIETY1 !Y >E 0GR\P$40 ,PEOPLE >E ACCU/OM$ TO SAY 0!Y OCCUPY .<HAB5 9NE.> ?IS HALL 9 COMMON10 BUT ! CASE IS RA!R ?AT ! HALL HAS US )9 .<HAT UNS 9NE.> OR 9 IT4 ,SO F> ! NATURAL SIGNIFICATION ( ! WORD SOCIETY4 ,9 ?IS IT COMES \T ?AT SOCIETY IS NOT G5]AT$ BY ME & Y\1 BUT BY A ?IRD FACTOR :I* MAKES ASSOCIATES \T ( US TWO1 & ?AT IT IS JU/ ?IS ?IRD FACTOR ?AT IS ! CREATIVE ONE1 ?AT :I* CREATES SOCIETY4 

,JU/ SO A PRISON SOCIETY OR PRISON COMPANION%IP .<,G5OSS5S*AFT.> 7?OSE :O 5JOY .<G5IESS5.> ! SAME PRISON74 ,H]E WE ALREADY HIT UPON A ?IRD FACTOR FULL] ( SIGNIFICANCE ?AN WAS ?AT M]ELY LOCAL ONE1 ! HALL4 ,PRISON NO LONG] MEANS A SPACE ONLY1 BUT A SPACE ) EXPRESS REF]5CE TO ITS 9HABITANTS3 = IT IS A PRISON ONLY ?R\< BE+ DE/9$ = PRISON]S1 )\T :OM IT W\LD BE A M]E BUILD+4 ,:AT GIVES A COMMON /AMP TO ?OSE :O >E GA!R$ 9 IT8 ,EVID5TLY ! PRISON1 S9CE IT IS ONLY BY MEANS ( ! PRISON ?AT !Y >E PRISON]S4 ,:AT1 !N1 DET]M9ES ! MANN] ( LIFE ( ! PRISON SOCIETY8 ,! PRISON6 ,:AT DET]M9ES !IR 9T]C\RSE8 ,! PRISON TOO1 P]HAPS8 ,C]TA9LY !Y CAN 5T] UPON 9T]C\RSE ONLY AS PRISON]S1 ONLY SO F> AS ! PRISON LAWS ALL[ IT2 BUT ?AT !Y !MSELVES HOLD 9T]C\RSE1 ,I ) Y\1 ?IS ! PRISON CANNOT BR+ TO PASS2 ON ! CONTR>Y1 IT MU/ HAVE AN EYE TO GU>D+ AGA9/ SU* EGOI/IC1 PURELY P]SONAL 9T]C\RSE 7& ONLY AS SU* IS IT REALLY 9T]C\RSE BETWE5 ME & Y\74 ,?AT WE JO9TLY EXECUTE A JOB1 RUN A MA*9E1 EFFECTUATE ANY?+ 9 G5]AL - = ?IS A PRISON WILL 9DE$ PROVIDE2 BUT ?AT ,I =GET ?AT ,I AM A PRISON]1 & 5GAGE 9 9T]C\RSE ) Y\ :O LIKEWISE DISREG>D IT1 BR+S DANG] TO ! PRISON1 & NOT ONLY CANNOT BE CAUS$ BY IT1 BUT MU/ NOT EV5 BE P]MITT$4 ,= ?IS REASON ! SA9TLY & MORAL-M9D$ ,FR5* *AMB] DECIDES TO 9TRODUCE SOLIT>Y CONF9EM5T1 & O!R SA9TS WILL DO ! LIKE 9 ORD] TO CUT (F 0DEMORALIZ+ 9T]C\RSE40 ,IMPRISONM5T IS ! E/ABLI%$ & - SACR$ CONDITION1 TO 9JURE :I* NO ATTEMPT MU/ BE MADE4 ,! SLI<TE/ PU% ( ?AT K9D IS PUNI%ABLE1 AS IS EV]Y UPRIS+ AGA9/ A SACR$ ?+ BY :I* MAN IS TO BE *>M$ .<BEFANG5.> & *A9$ .<GEFANG5.>4 

,LIKE ! HALL1 ! PRISON .<,GEFANGNIS.> DOES =M A SOCIETY1 A COMPANION%IP1 A COMMUNION 7AS 9 A COMMUNION ( LABOR71 BUT NO 9T]C\RSE1 NO RECIPROCITY1 NO UNION4 ,ON ! CONTR>Y1 EV]Y UNION 9 ! PRISON BE>S )9 IT ! DANG]\S SE$ ( A 0PLOT10 :I* UND] FAVORABLE CIRCUM/ANCES MI<T SPR+ UP & BE> FRUIT4 

,YET ONE DOES NOT USUALLY 5T] ! PRISON VOLUNT>ILY1 & SELDOM REMA9S 9 IT VOLUNT>ILY EI!R1 BUT *]I%ES ! EGOI/IC DESIRE = LIB]TY4 ,H]E1 !RE=E1 IT SOON] BECOMES MANIFE/ ?AT P]SONAL 9T]C\RSE IS 9 HO/ILE RELATIONS TO ! PRISON SOCIETY & T5DS TO ! DISSOLUTION ( ?IS V]Y SOCIETY1 ?IS JO9T 9C>C]ATION4 

,LET US !RE=E LOOK AB\T = SU* COMMUNIONS AS1 IT SEEMS1 WE REMA9 9 GLADLY & VOLUNT>ILY1 )\T WANT+ TO 5DANG] !M BY \R EGOI/IC IMPULSES4 

,AS A COMMUNION ( ! REQUIR$ SORT ! FAMILY (F]S ITSELF 9 ! FIR/ PLACE4 ,P>5TS1 HUSB&S & WIFE1 *ILDR51 BRO!RS & SI/]S1 REPRES5T A :OLE OR =M A FAMILY1 = ! FUR!R WID5+ ( :I* ! COLLAT]AL RELATIVES ALSO MAY BE MADE TO S]VE IF TAK5 9TO ACC\NT4 ,! FAMILY IS A TRUE COMMUNION ONLY :5 ! LAW ( ! FAMILY1 PIETY OR FAMILY LOVE1 IS OBS]V$ BY ITS MEMB]S4 ,A SON TO :OM P>5TS1 BRO!RS1 & SI/]S HAVE BECOME 9DIFF]5T HAS BE5 A SON2 =1 AS ! SON%IP NO LONG] %[S ITSELF EFFICACI\S1 IT HAS NO GREAT] SIGNIFICANCE ?AN ! LONG-PA/ CONNECTION ( MO!R & *ILD BY ! NAVEL-/R+4 ,?AT ONE HAS ONCE LIV$ 9 ?IS BODILY JUNCTURE CANNOT AS A FACT BE UNDONE2 & SO F> ONE REMA9S IRREVOCABLY ?IS MO!R'S SON & ! BRO!R ( ! RE/ ( H] *ILDR52 BUT IT W\LD COME TO A LA/+ CONNECTION ONLY BY LA/+ PIETY1 ?IS SPIRIT ( ! FAMILY4 ,9DIVIDUALS >E MEMB]S ( A FAMILY 9 ! FULL S5SE ONLY :5 !Y MAKE ! P]SI/5CE ( ! FAMILY !IR TASK2 ONLY AS CONS]VATIVE DO !Y KEEP ALO( FROM D\BT+ !IR BASIS1 ! FAMILY4 ,TO EV]Y MEMB] ( ! FAMILY ONE ?+ MU/ BE FIX$ & SACR$ - NAMELY1 ! FAMILY ITSELF1 OR1 MORE EXPRESSIVELY1 PIETY4 ,?AT ! FAMILY IS TO P]SI/ REMA9S TO ITS MEMB]1 SO LONG AS HE KEEPS HIMSELF FREE FROM ?AT EGOISM :I* IS HO/ILE TO ! FAMILY1 AN UNASSAILABLE TRU?4 ,9 A WORD3 - ,IF ! FAMILY IS SACR$1 !N NOBODY :O BELONGS TO IT MAY SEC$E FROM IT2 ELSE HE BECOMES A 0CRIM9AL0 AGA9/ ! FAMILY3 HE MAY NEV] PURSUE AN 9T]E/ HO/ILE TO ! FAMILY1 =M A MISALLIANCE4 ,HE :O DOES ?IS HAS 0DI%ONOR$ ! FAMILY10 0PUT IT TO %AME10 ETC4 

,N[1 IF 9 AN 9DIVIDUAL ! EGOI/IC IMPULSE HAS NOT =CE 5\<1 HE COMPLIES & MAKES A M>RIAGE :I* SUITS ! CLAIMS ( ! FAMILY1 TAKES A RANK :I* H>MONIZES ) ITS POSITION1 & ! LIKE2 9 %ORT1 HE 0DOES HONOR TO ! FAMILY40 

,IF1 ON ! CONTR>Y1 ! EGOI/IC BLOOD FL[S FI]ILY 5\< 9 HIS VE9S1 HE PREF]S TO BECOME A 0CRIM9AL0 AGA9/ ! FAMILY & TO ?R[ (F ITS LAWS4 

,:I* ( ! TWO LIES NE>] MY HE>T1 ! GOOD ( ! FAMILY OR MY GOOD8 ,9 9NUM]ABLE CASES BO? GO PEACEFULLY TOGE!R2 ! ADVANTAGE ( ! FAMILY IS AT ! SAME TIME M9E1 & VISE V]SA4 ,!N IT IS H>D TO DECIDE :E!R ,I AM ?9K+ SELFI%LY .<EIG5NUTZIG.> OR = ! COMMON B5EFIT .<GEME9NUTZIG.>1 & P]HAPS ,I COMPLAC5TLY FLATT] MYSELF ) MY UNSELFI%NESS4 ,BUT !RE COMES ! DAY :5 A NECESSITY ( *OICE MAKES ME TREMBLE1 :5 ,I HAVE IT 9 M9D TO DI%ONOR MY FAMILY TREE1 TO AFFRONT P>5TS1 BRO!RS1 & K9DR$4 ,:AT !N8 ,N[ IT WILL APPE> H[ ,I AM DISPOS$ AT ! BOTTOM ( MY HE>T2 N[ IT WILL BE REVEAL$ :E!R PIETY EV] /OOD ABOVE EGOISM = ME1 N[ ! SELFI% ONE CAN NO LONG] SKULK BEH9D ! SEMBLANCE ( UNSELFI%NESS4 ,A WI% RISES 9 MY S\L1 &1 GR[+ FROM H\R TO H\R1 BECOMES A PASSION4 ,TO :OM DOES IT OCCUR AT FIR/ BLU% ?AT ! SLI<TE/ ?\<T :I* MAY RESULT ADV]SELY TO ! SPIRIT ( ! FAMILY 7PIETY7 BE>S )9 IT A TRANSGRESSION AGA9/ ?IS8 ,9DE$1 :O AT ONCE1 9 ! FIR/ MOM5T1 BECOMES COMPLETELY CONSCI\S ( ! MATT]8 ,IT HAPP5S SO ) ,JULIET 9 0,ROMEO & ,JULIET40 ,! UNRULY PASSION CAN AT LA/ NO LONG] BE TAM$1 & UND]M9ES ! BUILD+ ( PIETY4 ,Y\ WILL SAY1 9DE$1 IT IS FROM SELF-WILL ?AT ! FAMILY CA/S \T ( ITS BOSOM ?OSE WILLFUL ONES ?AT GRANT MORE ( A HE>+ TO !IR PASSION ?AN TO PIETY2 ! GOOD ,PROTE/ANTS US$ ! SAME EXCUSE ) MU* SUCCESS AGA9/ ! ,CA?OLICS1 & BELIEV$ 9 IT !MSELVES4 ,BUT IT IS JU/ A SUBT]FUGE TO ROLL ! FAULT (F ONESELF1 NO?+ MORE4 ,! ,CA?OLICS HAD REG>D = ! COMMON BOND ( ! *UR*1 & ?RU/ ?OSE H]ETICS FROM !M ONLY BECAUSE !SE DID NOT HAVE SO MU* REG>D = ! BOND ( ! *UR* AS TO SACRIFICE !IR CONVICTIONS TO IT2 ! =M]1 !RE=E1 HELD ! BOND FA/1 BECAUSE ! BOND1 ! ,CA?OLIC 7COMMON & UNIT$7 *UR*1 WAS SACR$ TO !M2 ! LATT]1 ON ! CONTR>Y1 DISREG>D$ ! BOND4 ,JU/ SO ?OSE :O LACK PIETY4 ,!Y >E NOT ?RU/ \T1 BUT ?RU/ !MSELVES \T1 PRIZ+ !IR PASSION1 !IR WILLFULNESS1 HI<] ?AN ! BOND ( ! FAMILY4 

,BUT N[ SOMETIMES A WI% GLIMM]S 9 A LESS PASSIONATE & WILLFUL HE>T ?AN ,JULIET'S4 ,! PLIABLE GIRL BR+S H]SELF AS A SACRIFICE TO ! PEACE ( ! FAMILY4 ,ONE MI<T SAY ?AT H]E TOO SELFI%NESS PREVAIL$1 = ! DECISION CAME FROM ! FEEL+ ?AT ! PLIABLE GIRL FELT H]SELF MORE SATISFI$ BY ! UNITY ( ! FAMILY ?AN BY ! FULFILLM5T ( H] WI%4 ,?AT MI<T BE2 BUT :AT IF !RE REMA9$ A SURE SIGN ?AT EGOISM HAD BE5 SACRIFIC$ TO PIETY8 ,:AT IF1 EV5 AFT] ! WI% ?AT HAD BE5 DIRECT$ AGA9/ ! PEACE ( ! FAMILY WAS SACRIFIC$1 IT REMA9$ AT LEA/ AS A RECOLLECTION ( A 0SACRIFICE0 BR\<T TO A SACR$ TIE8 ,:AT IF ! PLIABLE GIRL W]E CONSCI\S ( HAV+ LEFT H] SELF-WILL UNSATISFI$ & HUMBLY SUBJECT$ H]SELF TO A HI<] P[]8 ,SUBJECT$ & SACRIFIC$1 BECAUSE ! SUP]/ITION ( PIETY EX]CIS$ ITS DOM9ION OV] H]6 

,!RE EGOISM WON1 H]E PIETY W9S & ! EGOI/IC HE>T BLE$S2 !RE EGOISM WAS /RONG1 H]E IT WAS - WEAK4 ,BUT ! WEAK1 AS WE HAVE LONG KN[N1 >E ! - UNSELFI%4 ,= !M1 = !SE ITS WEAK MEMB]S1 ! FAMILY C>ES1 BECAUSE !Y BELONG TO ! FAMILY1 DO NOT BELONG TO !MSELVES & C>E = !MSELVES4 ,?IS WEAKNESS ,HEGEL PRAISES :5 HE WANTS TO HAVE MAT*-MAK+ LEFT TO ! *OICE ( ! P>5TS4 

,AS A SACR$ COMMUNION TO :I*1 AMONG ! RE/1 ! 9DIVIDUAL [ES OB$I5CE1 ! FAMILY HAS ! JUDICIAL FUNCTION TOO VE/$ 9 IT2 SU* A 0FAMILY C\RT0 IS DESCRIB$ 9 ! ,CABANIS ( ,WILLIBALD ,ALEXIS4 ,!RE ! FA!R1 9 ! NAME ( ! 0FAMILY C\NCIL10 PUTS ! 9TRACTABLE SON AMONG ! SOLDI]S & ?RU/S HIM \T ( ! FAMILY1 9 ORD] TO CLEANSE ! SMIR*$ FAMILY AGA9 BY MEANS ( ?IS ACT ( PUNI%M5T4 - ,! MO/ CONSI/5T DEVELOPM5T ( FAMILY RESPONSIBILITY IS CONTA9$ 9 ,*9ESE LAW1 ACCORD+ TO :I* ! :OLE FAMILY HAS TO EXPIATE ! 9DIVIDUAL'S FAULT4 

,TODAY1 H[EV]1 ! >M ( FAMILY P[] SELDOM REA*ES F> 5\< TO TAKE S]I\SLY 9 H& ! PUNI%M5T ( APO/ATES 79 MO/ CASES ! /ATE PROTECTS EV5 AGA9/ DIS9H]ITANCE74 ,! CRIM9AL AGA9/ ! FAMILY 7FAMILY-CRIM9AL7 FLEES 9TO ! DOMA9 ( ! /ATE & IS FREE1 AS ! /ATE-CRIM9AL :O GETS AWAY TO ,AM]ICA IS NO LONG] REA*$ BY ! PUNI%M5TS ( HIS /ATE4 ,HE :O HAS %AM$ HIS FAMILY1 ! GRACELESS SON1 IS PROTECT$ AGA9/ ! FAMILY'S PUNI%M5T BECAUSE ! /ATE1 ?IS PROTECT+ LORD1 TAKES AWAY FROM FAMILY PUNI%M5T ITS 0SACR$NESS0 & PR(ANES IT1 DECREE+ ?AT IT IS ONLY - 0REV5GE03 IT RE/RA9S PUNI%M5T1 ?IS SACR$ FAMILY RI<T1 BECAUSE BE=E ITS1 ! /ATE'S1 0SACR$NESS0 ! SUBORD9ATE SACR$NESS ( ! FAMILY ALWAYS PALES & LOSES ITS SANCTITY AS SOON AS IT COMES 9 CONFLICT ) ?IS HI<] SACR$NESS4 ,)\T ! CONFLICT1 ! /ATE LETS PASS ! LESS] SACR$NESS ( ! FAMILY2 BUT 9 ! OPPOSITE CASE IT EV5 COMM&S CRIME AGA9/ ! FAMILY1 *>G+1 = EXAMPLE1 ! SON TO REFUSE OB$I5CE TO HIS P>5TS AS SOON AS !Y WANT TO BEGUILE HIM TO A CRIME AGA9/ ! /ATE4 

,WELL1 ! EGOI/ HAS BROK5 ! TIES ( ! FAMILY & F\ND 9 ! /ATE A LORD TO %ELT] HIM AGA9/ ! GRIEV\SLY AFFRONT$ SPIRIT ( ! FAMILY4 ,BUT :]E HAS HE RUN N[8 ,/RAI<T 9TO A NEW SOCIETY1 9 :I* HIS EGOISM IS AWAIT$ BY ! SAME SN>ES & NETS ?AT IT HAS JU/ ESCAP$4 ,= ! /ATE IS LIKEWISE A SOCIETY1 NOT A UNION2 IT IS ! BROAD5$ FAMILY 70SOV]EIGN LORD - SOV]EIGN LADY - SOV]EIGN *ILDR5074 

,:AT IS CALL$ A /ATE IS A TISSUE & PLEXUS ( DEP5D5CE & ADH]5CE2 IT IS A BELONG+ TOGE!R1 A HOLD+ TOGE!R1 9 :I* ?OSE :O >E PLAC$ TOGE!R FIT !MSELVES TO EA* O!R1 OR1 9 %ORT1 MUTUALLY DEP5D ON EA* O!R3 IT IS ! ORD] ( ?IS DEP5D5CE4 ,SUPPOSE ! K+1 :OSE AU?ORITY L5DS AU?ORITY TO ALL D[N TO ! BEADLE1 %\LD VANI%3 /ILL ALL 9 :OM ! WILL = ORD] WAS AWAKE W\LD KEEP ORD] ]ECT AGA9/ ! DISORD]S ( BE/IALITY4 ,IF DISORD] W]E VICTORI\S1 ! /ATE W\LD BE AT AN 5D4 

,BUT IS ?IS ?\<T ( LOVE1 TO FIT \RSELVES TO EA* O!R1 TO ADH]E TO EA* O!R & DEP5D ON EA* O!R1 REALLY CAPABLE ( W9N+ US8 ,ACCORD+ TO ?IS ! /ATE %\LD BE LOVE REALIZ$1 ! BE+ = EA* O!R & LIV+ = EA* O!R ( ALL4 ,IS NOT SELF-WILL BE+ LO/ :ILE WE ATT5D TO ! WILL = ORD]8 ,WILL PEOPLE NOT BE SATISFI$ :5 ORD] IS C>$ = BY AU?ORITY1 :5 AU?ORITY SEES TO IT ?AT NO ONE 0GETS 9 ! WAY (0 ANO!R2 :51 !N1 ! H]D IS JUDICI\SLY DI/RIBUT$ OR ORD]$8 ,:Y1 !N EV]Y?+ IS 9 0! BE/ ORD]10 & IT IS ?IS BE/ ORD] ?AT IS CALL$ - /ATE6 

,\R SOCIETIES & /ATES >E )\T \R MAK+ !M1 >E UNIT$ )\T \R UNIT+1 >E PR$E/9$ & E/ABLI%$1 OR HAVE AN 9DEP5D5T /&+ .<,BE/&.> ( !IR [N1 >E ! 9DISSOLUBLY E/ABLI%$ AGA9/ US EGOI/S4 ,! FI<T ( ! WORLD TODAY IS1 AS IT IS SAID1 DIRECT$ AGA9/ ! 0E/ABLI%$ .<DAS ,BE/EH5DE.>40 ,YET PEOPLE >E WONT TO MISUND]/& ?IS AS IF IT W]E ONLY ?AT :AT IS N[ E/ABLI%$ WAS TO BE EX*ANG$ = ANO!R1 A BETT]1 E/ABLI%$ SY/EM4 ,BUT W> MI<T RA!R BE DECL>$ AGA9/ E/ABLI%M5T ITSELF1 ! /ATE1 NOT A P>TICUL> /ATE1 NOT ANY SU* ?+ AS ! M]E CONDITION ( ! /ATE AT ! TIME2 IT IS NOT ANO!R /ATE 7SU* AS A 0PEOPLE'S /ATE07 ?AT M5 AIM AT1 BUT !IR UNION1 UNIT+1 ?IS EV]-FLUID UNIT+ ( EV]Y?+ /&+4 - ,A /ATE EXI/S EV5 )\T MY COOP]ATION3 ,I AM BORN 9 IT1 BR\<T UP 9 IT1 UND] OBLIGATIONS TO IT1 & MU/ 0DO IT HOMAGE .<HULDIG5.>40 ,IT TAKES ME UP 9TO ITS 0FAVOR .<,HULD.>10 & ,I LIVE BY ITS 0GRACE40 ,?US ! 9DEP5D5T E/ABLI%M5T ( ! /ATE F\NDS MY LACK ( 9DEP5D5CE2 ITS CONDITION AS A 0NATURAL GR[?10 ITS ORGANISM1 DEM&S ?AT MY NATURE DO NOT GR[ FREELY1 BUT BE CUT TO FIT IT4 ,?AT IT MAY BE ABLE TO UNFOLD 9 NATURAL GR[?1 IT APPLIES TO ME ! %E>S ( 0CIVILIZATION02 IT GIVES ME AN $UCATION & CULTURE ADAPT$ TO IT1 NOT TO ME1 & TEA*ES ME TO RESPECT ! LAWS1 TO REFRA9 FROM 9JURY TO /ATE PROP]TY 7?AT IS1 PRIVATE PROP]TY71 TO REV]5CE DIV9E & E>?LY HI<NESS1 ETC42 9 %ORT1 IT TEA*ES ME TO BE - UNPUNI%ABLE1 0SACRIFIC+0 MY [NNESS TO 0SACR$NESS0 7EV]Y?+ POSSIBLE IS SACR$2 PROP]TY1 O!RS' LIFE1 ETC474 ,9 ?IS CONSI/S ! SORT ( CIVILIZATION & CULTURE ?AT ! /ATE IS ABLE TO GIVE ME3 IT BR+S ME UP TO BE A 0S]VICEABLE 9/RUM5T10 A 0S]VICEABLE MEMB] ( SOCIETY40 

,?IS EV]Y /ATE MU/ DO1 ! PEOPLE'S /ATE AS WELL AS ! ABSOLUTE OR CON/ITUTIONAL ONE4 ,IT MU/ DO SO AS LONG AS WE RE/ 9 ! ]ROR ?AT IT IS AN ,I1 AS :I* IT !N APPLIES TO ITSELF ! NAME ( A 0MORAL1 MY/ICAL1 OR POLITICAL P]SON40 ,I1 :O REALLY AM ,I1 MU/ PULL (F ?IS LION-SK9 ( ! ,I FROM ! /ALK+ ?I/LE-EAT]4 ,:AT MANIFOLD ROBB]Y HAVE ,I NOT PUT UP ) 9 ! HI/ORY ( ! WORLD6 ,!RE ,I LET SUN1 MOON1 & />S1 CATS & CROCODILES1 RECEIVE ! HONOR ( RANK+ AS ,I2 !RE ,JEHOVAH1 ,ALLAH1 & ,\R ,FA!R CAME & W]E 9VE/$ ) ! ,I2 !RE FAMILIES1 TRIBES1 PEOPLES1 & AT LA/ ACTUALLY MANK9D1 CAME & W]E HONOR$ AS ,I'S2 !RE ! ,*UR*1 ! /ATE1 CAME ) ! PRET5SION TO BE ,I - & ,I GAZ$ CALMLY ON ALL4 ,:AT WOND] IF !N !RE WAS ALWAYS A REAL ,I TOO ?AT JO9$ ! COMPANY & AFFIRM$ 9 MY FACE ?AT IT WAS NOT MY Y\ BUT MY REAL ,I4 ,:Y1 ! ,SON ( ,MAN P> EXCELL5CE HAD DONE ! LIKE2 :Y %\LD NOT A SON ( MAN DO IT TOO8 ,SO ,I SAW MY ,I ALWAYS ABOVE ME & \TSIDE ME1 & C\LD NEV] REALLY COME TO MYSELF4 

,I NEV] BELIEV$ 9 MYSELF2 ,I NEV] BELIEV$ 9 MY PRES5T1 ,I SAW MYSELF ONLY 9 ! FUTURE4 ,! BOY BELIEVES HE WILL BE A PROP] ,I1 A PROP] FELL[1 ONLY :5 HE HAS BECOME A MAN2 ! MAN ?9KS1 ONLY 9 ! O!R WORLD WILL HE BE SOME?+ PROP]4 ,&1 TO 5T] MORE CLOSELY UPON REALITY AT ONCE1 EV5 ! BE/ >E TODAY /ILL P]SUAD+ EA* O!R ?AT ONE MU/ HAVE RECEIV$ 9TO HIMSELF ! /ATE1 HIS PEOPLE1 MANK9D1 & :AT NOT1 9 ORD] TO BE A REAL ,I1 A 0FREE BUR<]10 A 0CITIZ510 A 0FREE OR TRUE MAN02 !Y TOO SEE ! TRU? & REALITY ( ME 9 ! RECEPTION ( AN ALI5 ,I & DEVOTION TO IT4 ,& :AT SORT ( AN ,I8 ,AN ,I ?AT IS NEI!R AN ,I NOR A Y\1 A FANCI$ ,I1 A SPOOK4 

,:ILE 9 ! ,MIDDLE ,AGES ! *UR* C\LD WELL BROOK MANY /ATES LIV+ UNIT$ 9 IT1 ! /ATES LE>N$ AFT] ! ,RE=MATION1 ESPECIALLY AFT] ! ,?IRTY ,YE>S' ,W>1 TO TOL]ATE MANY *UR*ES 7CONFESSIONS7 GA!R+ UND] ONE CR[N4 ,BUT ALL /ATES >E RELIGI\S &1 AS ! CASE MAY BE1 0,*RI/IAN /ATES10 & MAKE IT !IR TASK TO =CE ! 9TRACTABLE1 ! 0EGOI/S10 UND] ! BOND ( ! UNNATURAL1 ?AT IS1 ,*RI/IANIZE !M4 ,ALL >RANGEM5TS ( ! ,*RI/IAN /ATE HAVE ! OBJECT ( ,*RI/IANIZ+ ! PEOPLE4 ,?US ! C\RT HAS ! OBJECT ( =C+ PEOPLE TO JU/ICE1 ! S*OOL ?AT ( =C+ !M TO M5TAL CULTURE - 9 %ORT1 ! OBJECT ( PROTECT+ ?OSE :O ACT ,*RI/IANLY AGA9/ ?OSE :O ACT UN-,*RI/IANLY1 ( BR++ ,*RI/IAN ACTION TO DOM9ION1 ( MAK+ IT P[]FUL4 ,AMONG !SE MEANS ( =CE ! /ATE C\NT$ ! ,*UR* TOO1 IT DEM&$ A - P>TICUL> RELIGION FROM EV]YBODY4 ,DUP9 SAID LATELY AGA9/ ! CL]GY1 0,9/RUCTION & $UCATION BELONG TO ! /ATE40 

,C]TA9LY EV]Y?+ ?AT REG>DS ! PR9CIPLE ( MORALITY IS A /ATE AFFAIR4 ,H5CE IT IS ?AT ! ,*9ESE /ATE M$DLES SO MU* 9 FAMILY CONC]NS1 & ONE IS NO?+ !RE IF ONE IS NOT FIR/ ( ALL A GOOD *ILD TO HIS P>5TS4 ,FAMILY CONC]NS >E ALTOGE!R /ATE CONC]NS ) US TOO1 ONLY ?AT \R /ATE - PUTS CONFID5CE 9 ! FAMILIES )\T PA9FUL OV]SI<T2 IT HOLDS ! FAMILY B\ND BY ! M>RIAGE TIE1 & ?IS TIE CANNOT BE BROK5 )\T IT4 

,BUT ?AT ! /ATE MAKES ME RESPONSIBLE = MY PR9CIPLES1 & DEM&S C]TA9 ONES FROM ME1 MI<T MAKE ME ASK1 :AT CONC]N HAS IT ) ! 0:EEL 9 MY HEAD0 7PR9CIPLE78 ,V]Y MU*1 = ! /ATE IS ! - RUL+ PR9CIPLE4 ,IT IS SUPPOS$ ?AT 9 DIVORCE MATT]S1 9 M>RIAGE LAW 9 G5]AL1 ! QUE/ION IS ( ! PROPORTION ( RI<TS BETWE5 ,*UR* & /ATES4 ,RA!R1 ! QUE/ION IS ( :E!R ANY?+ SACR$ IS TO RULE OV] MAN1 BE IT CALL$ FAI? OR E?ICAL LAW 7MORALITY74 ,! /ATE BEHAVES AS ! SAME RUL] ?AT ! ,*UR* WAS4 ,! LATT] RE/S ON GODL9ESS1 ! =M] ON MORALITY4 

,PEOPLE TALK ( ! TOL]ANCE1 ! LEAV+ OPPOSITE T5D5CIES FREE1 & ! LIKE1 BY :I* CIVILIZ$ /ATES >E DI/+UI%$4 ,C]TA9LY SOME >E /RONG 5\< TO LOOK ) COMPLAC5CY ON EV5 ! MO/ UNRE/RA9$ MEET+S1 :ILE O!RS *>GE !IR CAT*POLE TO GO HUNT+ = TOBACCO-PIPES4 ,YET = ONE /ATE AS = ANO!R ! PLAY ( 9DIVIDUALS AMONG !MSELVES1 !IR BUZZ+ TO & FRO1 !IR DAILY LIFE1 IS AN 9CID5T :I* IT MU/ BE CONT5T TO LEAVE TO !MSELVES BECAUSE IT CAN DO NO?+ ) ?IS4 ,MANY1 9DE$1 /ILL /RA9 \T GNATS & SWALL[ CAMELS1 :ILE O!RS >E %REWD]4 ,9DIVIDUALS >E 0FRE]0 9 ! LATT]1 BECAUSE LESS PE/]$4 ,BUT ,I AM FREE 9 NO /ATE4 ,! LAUD$ TOL]ANCE ( /ATES IS SIMPLY A TOL]AT+ ( ! 0H>MLESS10 ! 0NOT DANG]\S02 IT IS ONLY ELEVATION ABOVE PETTYM9D$NESS1 ONLY A MORE E/IMABLE1 GR&]1 PR\D] - DESPOTISM4 ,A C]TA9 /ATE SEEM$ = A :ILE TO MEAN TO BE PRETTY WELL ELEVAT$ ABOVE LIT]>Y COMBATS1 :I* MI<T BE C>RI$ ON ) ALL HEAT2 ,5GL& IS ELEVAT$ ABOVE POPUL> TURMOIL & - TOBACCO-SMOK+4 ,BUT WOE TO ! LIT]ATURE ?AT DEALS BL[S AT ! /ATE ITSELF1 WOE TO ! MOBS ?AT 05DANG]0 ! /ATE4 ,9 ?AT C]TA9 /ATE !Y DREAM ( A 0FREE SCI5CE10 9 ,5GL& ( A 0FREE POPUL> LIFE40 

,! /ATE DOES LET 9DIVIDUALS PLAY AS FREELY AS POSSIBLE1 ONLY !Y MU/ NOT BE 9 E>NE/1 MU/ NOT =GET IT4 ,MAN MU/ NOT C>RY ON 9T]C\RSE ) MAN UNCONC]N$LY1 NOT )\T 0SUP]IOR OV]SI<T & M$IATION40 ,I MU/ NOT EXECUTE ALL ?AT ,I AM ABLE TO1 BUT ONLY SO MU* AS ! /ATE ALL[S2 ,I MU/ NOT TURN TO ACC\NT MY ?\<TS1 NOR MY WORK1 NOR1 9 G5]AL1 ANY?+ ( M9E4 

,! /ATE ALWAYS HAS ! SOLE PURPOSE TO LIMIT1 TAME1 SUBORD9ATE1 ! 9DIVIDUAL - TO MAKE HIM SUBJECT TO SOME G5]ALITY OR O!R2 IT LA/S ONLY SO LONG AS ! 9DIVIDUAL IS NOT ALL 9 ALL1 & IT IS ONLY ! CLE>LY-M>K$ RE/RICTION ( ME1 MY LIMITATION1 MY SLAV]Y4 ,NEV] DOES A /ATE AIM TO BR+ 9 ! FREE ACTIVITY ( 9DIVIDUALS1 BUT ALWAYS ?AT :I* IS B\ND TO ! PURPOSE ( ! /ATE4 ,?R\< ! /ATE NO?+ 9 COMMON COMES TO PASS EI!R1 AS LITTLE AS ONE CAN CALL A PIECE ( CLO? ! COMMON WORK ( ALL ! 9DIVIDUAL P>TS ( A MA*9E2 IT IS RA!R ! WORK ( ! :OLE MA*9E AS A UNIT1 MA*9E WORK4 ,9 ! SAME /YLE EV]Y?+ IS DONE BY ! /ATE MA*9E TOO2 = IT MOVES ! CLOCKWORK ( ! 9DIVIDUAL M9DS1 NONE ( :I* FOLL[ !IR [N IMPULSE4 ,! /ATE SEEKS TO H9D] EV]Y FREE ACTIVITY BY ITS C5SOR%IP1 ITS SUP]VISION1 ITS POLICE1 & HOLDS ?IS H9D]+ TO BE ITS DUTY1 BECAUSE IT IS 9 TRU? A DUTY ( SELF-PRES]VATION4 ,! /ATE WANTS TO MAKE SOME?+ \T ( MAN1 !RE=E !RE LIVE 9 IT ONLY MADE M52 EV]Y ONE :O WANTS TO BE HIS [N SELF IS ITS OPPON5T & IS NO?+4 0,HE IS NO?+0 MEANS AS MU* AS1 ! /ATE DOES NOT MAKE USE ( HIM1 GRANTS HIM NO POSITION1 NO (FICE1 NO TRADE1 & ! LIKE4 

,$G> ,BAU]1 9 ,DIE ,LIB]AL5 ,BE/REBUNG5 7VOL4 ,I,I1 P4 #e71 IS /ILL DREAM+ ( A 0GOV]NM5T :I*1 PROCE$+ \T ( ! PEOPLE1 CAN NEV] /& 9 OPPOSITION TO IT40 ,HE DOES 9DE$ 7P4 #f#i7 HIMSELF TAKE BACK ! WORD 0GOV]NM5T03 

0,9 ! REPUBLIC NO GOV]NM5T AT ALL OBTA9S1 BUT ONLY AN EXECUTIVE AU?ORITY4 ,AN AU?ORITY :I* PROCE$S PURELY & ALONE \T ( ! PEOPLE2 :I* HAS NOT AN 9DEP5D5T P[]1 9DEP5D5T PR9CIPLES1 9DEP5D5T (FIC]S1 OV] AGA9/ ! PEOPLE2 BUT :I* HAS ITS F\NDATION1 ! F\NTA9 ( ITS P[] & ( ITS PR9CIPLES1 9 ! SOLE1 SUPREME AU?ORITY ( ! /ATE1 9 ! PEOPLE4 ,! CONCEPT GOV]NM5T1 !RE=E1 IS NOT AT ALL SUITABLE 9 ! PEOPLE'S /ATE40 

,BUT ! ?+ REMA9S ! SAME4 ,?AT :I* HAS 0PROCE$$1 BE5 F\ND$1 SPRUNG FROM ! F\NTA90 BECOMES SOME?+ 09DEP5D5T0 &1 LIKE A *ILD DELIV]$ FROM ! WOMB1 5T]S UPON OPPOSITION AT ONCE4 ,! GOV]NM5T1 IF IT W]E NO?+ 9DEP5D5T & OPPOS+1 W\LD BE NO?+ AT ALL4 

0,9 ! FREE /ATE !RE IS NO GOV]NM5T10 ETC4 7P4#i#d74 ,?IS SURELY MEANS ?AT ! PEOPLE1 :5 IT IS ! SOV]EIGN1 DOES NOT LET ITSELF BE CONDUCT$ BY A SUP]IOR AU?ORITY4 ,IS IT P]*ANCE DIFF]5T 9 ABSOLUTE MON>*Y8 ,IS !RE !RE = ! SOV]EIGN1 P]*ANCE1 A GOV]NM5T /&+ OV] HIM8 ,OV] ! SOV]EIGN1 BE HE CALL$ PR9CE OR PEOPLE1 !RE NEV] /&S A GOV]NM5T3 ?AT IS UND]/OOD ( ITSELF4 ,BUT OV] ME !RE WILL /& A GOV]NM5T 9 EV]Y 0/ATE10 9 ! ABSOLUTE AS WELL AS 9 ! REPUBLICAN OR 0FREE40 ,I AM AS BADLY (F 9 ONE AS 9 ! O!R4 

,! REPUBLIC IS NO?+ :ATEV] BUT - ABSOLUTE MON>*Y2 = IT MAKES NO DIFF]5CE :E!R ! MON>* IS CALL$ PR9CE OR PEOPLE1 BO? BE+ A 0MAJE/Y40 ,CON/ITUTIONALISM ITSELF PROVES ?AT NOBODY IS ABLE & WILL+ TO BE ONLY AN 9/RUM5T4 ,! M9I/]S DOM9E] OV] !IR MA/] ! PR9CE1 ! DEPUTIES OV] !IR MA/] ! PEOPLE4 ,H]E1 !N1 ! P>TIES AT LEA/ >E ALREADY FREE - VIDELICET1 ! (FICE-HOLD]S' P>TY 7SO-CALL$ PEOPLE'S P>TY74 ,! PR9CE MU/ CON=M TO ! WILL ( ! M9I/]S1 ! PEOPLE DANCE TO ! PIPE ( ! *AMB]S4 ,CON/ITUTIONALISM IS FUR!R ?AN ! REPUBLIC1 BECAUSE IT IS ! /ATE 9 9CIPI5T DISSOLUTION4 

,$G> ,BAU] D5IES 7P4#e#f7 ?AT ! PEOPLE IS A 0P]SONALITY0 9 ! CON/ITUTIONAL /ATE2 P] CONTRA1 !N1 9 ! REPUBLIC8 ,WELL1 9 ! CON/ITUTIONAL /ATE ! PEOPLE IS - A P>TY1 & A P>TY IS SURELY A 0P]SONALITY0 IF ONE IS ONCE RESOLV$ TO TALK ( A 0POLITICAL0 7P4#g#f7 MORAL P]SON ANYH[4 ,! FACT IS ?AT A MORAL P]SON1 BE IT CALL$ PEOPLE'S P>TY OR PEOPLE OR EV5 0! ,LORD10 IS 9 NO WISE A P]SON1 BUT A SPOOK4 

,FUR!R1 ,$G> ,BAU] GOES ON 7P4 #fi 73 0GU>DIAN%IP IS ! *>ACT]I/IC ( A GOV]NM5T40 ,TRULY1 /ILL MORE ?AT ( A PEOPLE & 0PEOPLE'S /ATE02 IT IS ! *>ACT]I/IC ( ALL DOM9ION4 ,A PEOPLE'S /ATE1 :I* 0UNITES 9 ITSELF ALL COMPLET5ESS ( P[]10 ! 0ABSOLUTE MA/]10 CANNOT LET ME BECOME P[]FUL4 ,& :AT A *IM]A1 TO BE NO LONG] WILL+ TO CALL ! 0PEOPLE'S (FICIALS0 0S]VANTS1 9/RUM5TS10 BECAUSE !Y 0EXECUTE ! FREE1 RATIONAL LAW-WILL ( ! PEOPLE60 7P4 #g#c74 ,HE ?9KS 7P4 #g#d73 0,ONLY BY ALL (FICIAL CIRCLES SUBORD9AT+ !MSELVES TO ! GOV]NM5T'S VIEWS CAN UNITY BE BR\<T 9TO ! /ATE02 BUT HIS 0PEOPLE'S /ATE0 IS TO HAVE 0UNITY0 TOO2 H[ WILL A LACK ( SUBORD9ATION BE ALL[$ !RE8 SUBORD9ATION TO ! - PEOPLE'S WILL4 

0,9 ! CON/ITUTIONAL /ATE IT IS ! REG5T & HIS DISPOSITION ?AT ! :OLE /RUCTURE ( GOV]NM5T RE/S ON 9 ! 5D40 7P4 #a#c47 ,H[ W\LD ?AT BE O!RWISE 9 ! 0PEOPLE'S /ATE08 ,%ALL ,I NOT !RE BE GOV]N$ BY ! PEOPLE'S DISPOSITION TOO1 & DOES IT MAKE A DIFF]5CE = ME :E!R ,I SEE MYSELF KEPT 9 DEP5D5CE BY ! PR9CE'S DISPOSITION OR BY ! PEOPLE'S DISPOSITION1 SO-CALL$ 0PUBLIC OP9ION08 ,IF DEP5D5CE MEANS AS MU* AS 0RELIGI\S RELATION10 AS ,$G> ,BAU] RI<TLY ALLEGES1 !N 9 ! PEOPLE'S /ATE ! PEOPLE REMA9S = ME ! SUP]IOR P[]1 ! 0MAJE/Y0 7= ,GOD & PR9CE HAVE !IR PROP] ESS5CE 9 0MAJE/Y07 TO :I* ,I /& 9 RELIGI\S RELATIONS4 - ,LIKE ! SOV]EIGN REG5T1 ! SOV]EIGN PEOPLE TOO W\LD BE REA*$ BY NO LAW4 ,$G> ,BAU]'S :OLE ATTEMPT COMES TO A *ANGE ( MA/]S4 ,9/EAD ( WANT+ TO MAKE ! PEOPLE FREE1 HE %\LD HAVE HAD HIS M9D ON ! SOLE REALIZABLE FRE$OM1 HIS [N4 

,9 ! CON/ITUTIONAL /ATE ABSOLUTISM ITSELF HAS AT LA/ COME 9 CONFLICT ) ITSELF1 AS IT HAS BE5 %ATT]$ 9TO A DUALITY2 ! GOV]NM5T WANTS TO BE ABSOLUTE1 & ! PEOPLE WANTS TO BE ABSOLUTE4 ,!SE TWO ABSOLUTES WILL WE> \T AGA9/ EA* O!R4 

,$G> ,BAU] 9VEI<S AGA9/ ! DET]M9ATION ( ! REG5T BY BIR?1 BY *ANCE4 ,BUT1 :5 0! PEOPLE0 HAVE BECOME 0! SOLE P[] 9 ! /ATE0 7P4 #a#c#b71 HAVE WE NOT !N 9 IT A MA/] FROM *ANCE8 ,:Y1 :AT IS ! PEOPLE8 ,! PEOPLE HAS ALWAYS BE5 ONLY ! BODY ( ! GOV]NM5T3 IT IS MANY UND] ONE HAT 7A PR9CE'S HAT7 OR MANY UND] ONE CON/ITUTION4 ,& ! CON/ITUTION IS ! - PR9CE4 ,PR9CES & PEOPLES WILL P]SI/ SO LONG AS BO? DO NOT COLLAPSE1 ?AT IS1 FALL TOGE!R4 ,IF UND] ONE CON/ITUTION !RE >E MANY 0PEOPLES0 - AS 9 ! ANCI5T ,P]SIAN MON>*Y & TODAY - !N !SE 0PEOPLES0 RANK ONLY AS 0PROV9CES40 ,= ME ! PEOPLE IS 9 ANY CASE AN - ACCID5TAL P[]1 A =CE ( NATURE1 AN 5EMY ?AT ,I MU/ OV]COME4 

,:AT IS ONE TO ?9K ( UND] ! NAME ( AN 0ORGANIZ$0 PEOPLE 7P4 #a#c#b78 ,A PEOPLE 0?AT NO LONG] HAS A GOV]NM5T10 ?AT GOV]NS ITSELF4 ,9 :I*1 !RE=E1 NO EGO /&S \T PROM95TLY2 A PEOPLE ORGANIZ$ BY O/RACISM4 ,! BANI%M5T ( EGOS1 O/RACISM1 MAKES ! PEOPLE AUTOCRAT4 

,IF Y\ SPEAK ( ! PEOPLE1 Y\ MU/ SPEAK ( ! PR9CE2 = ! PEOPLE1 IF IT IS TO BE A SUBJECT & MAKE HI/ORY1 MU/1 LIKE EV]Y?+ ?AT ACTS1 HAVE A HEAD1 ITS 0SUPREME HEAD40 ,WEITL+ SETS ?IS =? 9 HIS 0,TRIO01 & ,PR\DHON DECL>ES1 0UNE SOCIETE1 P\R A9SI DIRE ACEPHALE1 NE PEUT VIV]40 

,! VOX POPULI IS N[ ALWAYS HELD UP TO US1 & 0PUBLIC OP9ION0 IS TO RULE \R PR9CES4 ,C]TA9LY ! VOX POPULI IS AT ! SAME TIME VOX DEI2 BUT IS EI!R ( ANY USE1 & IS NOT ! VOX PR9CIPIS ALSO VOX DEI 8 

,AT ?IS PO9T ! 0,NATIONALS0 MAY BE BR\<T TO M9D4 ,TO DEM& ( ! ?IRTY-EI<T /ATES ( ,G]MANY ?AT !Y %ALL ACT AS ONE NATION CAN ONLY BE PUT ALONGSIDE ! S5SELESS DESIRE ?AT ?IRTY-EI<T SW>MS ( BEES1 L$ BY ?IRTY-EI<T QUE5-BEES1 %ALL UNITE !MSELVES 9TO ONE SW>M4 ,BEES !Y ALL REMA92 BUT IT IS NOT ! BEES AS BEES ?AT BELONG TOGE!R & CAN JO9 !MSELVES TOGE!R1 IT IS ONLY ?AT ! SUBJECT BEES >E CONNECT$ ) ! RUL+ QUE5S4 ,BEES & PEOPLES >E DE/ITUTE ( WILL1 & ! 9/9CT ( !IR QUE5S LEADS !M4 

,IF ONE W]E TO PO9T ! BEES TO !IR BEEHOOD1 9 :I* AT ANY RATE !Y >E ALL EQUAL TO EA* O!R1 ONE W\LD BE DO+ ! SAME ?+ ?AT !Y >E N[ DO+ SO /ORMILY 9 PO9T+ ! ,G]MANS TO !IR ,G]MANHOOD4 ,:Y1 ,G]MANHOOD IS JU/ LIKE BEEHOOD 9 ?IS V]Y ?+1 ?AT IT BE>S 9 ITSELF ! NECESSITY ( CLEAVAGES & SEP>ATIONS1 YET )\T PU%+ ON TO ! LA/ SEP>ATION1 :]E1 ) ! COMPLETE C>RY+ ?R\< ( ! PROCESS ( SEP>AT+1 ITS 5D APPE>S3 ,I MEAN1 TO ! SEP>ATION ( MAN FROM MAN4 ,G]MANHOOD DOES 9DE$ DIVIDE ITSELF 9TO DIFF]5T PEOPLES & TRIBES1 BEEHIVES2 BUT ! 9DIVIDUAL :O HAS ! QUALITY ( BE+ A ,G]MAN IS /ILL AS P[]LESS AS ! ISOLAT$ BEE4 ,& YET ONLY 9DIVIDUALS CAN 5T] 9TO UNION ) EA* O!R1 & ALL ALLIANCES & LEAGUES ( PEOPLES >E & REMA9 ME*ANICAL COMP\ND+S1 BECAUSE ?OSE :O COME TOGE!R1 AT LEA/ SO F> AS ! 0PEOPLES0 >E REG>D$ AS ! ONES ?AT HAVE COME TOGE!R1 >E DE/ITUTE ( WILL4 ,ONLY ) ! LA/ SEP>ATION DOES SEP>ATION ITSELF 5D & *ANGE TO UNIFICATION4 

,N[ ! ,NATIONALS >E EX]T+ !MSELVES TO SET UP ! AB/RACT1 LIFELESS UNITY ( BEEHOOD2 BUT ! SELF-[N$ >E GO+ TO FI<T = ! UNITY WILL$ BY !IR [N WILL1 = UNION4 ,?IS IS ! TOK5 ( ALL REACTION>Y WI%ES1 ?AT !Y WANT TO SET UP SOME?+ G5]AL1 AB/RACT1 AN EMPTY1 LIFELESS CONCEPT1 9 DI/9CTION FROM :I* ! SELF-[N$ ASPIRE TO RELIEVE ! ROBU/1 LIVELY P>TICUL> FROM ! TRA%Y BURD5 ( G5]ALITIES4 ,! REACTION>IES W\LD BE GLAD TO SMITE A PEOPLE1 A NATION1 =? FROM ! E>?2 ! SELF-[N$ HAVE BE=E !IR EYES ONLY !MSELVES4 ,9 ESS5TIALS ! TWO EF=TS ?AT >E JU/ N[ ! ORD] ( ! DAY - NAMELY1 ! RE/ORATION ( PROV9CIAL RI<TS & ( ! OLD TRIBAL DIVISIONS 7,FRANKS1 ,BAV>IANS1 ,LAUSITZ1 ETC471 & ! RE/ORATION ( ! 5TIRE NATIONALITY - CO9CIDE 9 ONE4 ,BUT ! ,G]MANS WILL COME 9TO UNISON1 UNITE !MSELVES1 ONLY :5 !Y KNOCK OV] !IR BEEHOOD AS WELL AS ALL ! BEEHIVES2 9 O!R WORDS1 :5 !Y >E MORE ?AN - ,G]MANS3 ONLY !N CAN !Y =M A 0,G]MAN ,UNION40 ,!Y MU/ NOT WANT TO TURN BACK 9TO !IR NATIONALITY1 9TO ! WOMB1 9 ORD] TO BE BORN AGA91 BUT LET EV]Y ONE TURN 9 TO HIMSELF4 ,H[ RIDICUL\SLY S5TIM5TAL :5 ONE ,G]MAN GRASPS ANO!R'S H& & PRESSES IT ) SACR$ AWE BECAUSE 0HE TOO IS A ,G]MAN60 ,) ?AT HE IS SOME?+ GREAT6 ,BUT ?IS WILL C]TA9LY /ILL BE ?\<T T\*+ AS LONG AS PEOPLE >E 5?USIA/IC = 0BRO!RL9ESS10 AS LONG AS !Y HAVE A 0FAMILY DISPOSITION04 ,FROM ! SUP]/ITION ( 0PIETY10 FROM 0BRO!RL9ESS0 OR 0*ILDLIK5ESS0 OR H[EV] ELSE ! S(T-HE>T$ PIETY-PHRASES RUN - FROM ! FAMILY SPIRIT - ! ,NATIONALS1 :O WANT TO HAVE A GREAT FAMILY ( ,G]MANS1 CANNOT LIB]ATE !MSELVES4 

,ASIDE FROM ?IS1 ! SO-CALL$ ,NATIONALS W\LD ONLY HAVE TO UND]/& !MSELVES RI<TLY 9 ORD] TO LIFT !MSELVES \T ( !IR JUNCTURE ) ! GOOD-NATUR$ ,TEUTOMANIACS4 ,= ! UNIT+ = MAT]IAL 5DS & 9T]E/S1 :I* !Y DEM& ( ! ,G]MANS1 COMES TO NO?+ ELSE ?AN A VOLUNT>Y UNION4 ,C>RI]E1 9SPIR$1 CRIES \T1 0,RAILROADS >E TO ! MORE P5ETRAT+ EYE ! WAY TO A LIFE ( ! PEOPLE SU* AS HAS NOT YET ANY:]E APPE>$ 9 SU* SIGNIFICANCE40 ,QUITE RI<T1 IT WILL BE A LIFE ( ! PEOPLE ?AT HAS NO:]E APPE>$1 BECAUSE IT IS NOT A - LIFE ( ! PEOPLE4 - ,SO ,C>RI]E !N COMBATS HIMSELF 7P4 #a73 0,PURE HUMANITY OR MANHOOD CANNOT BE BETT] REPRES5T$ ?AN BY A PEOPLE FULFILL+ ITS MISSION40 ,:Y1 BY ?IS NATIONALITY ONLY IS REPRES5T$4 0,WA%$-\T G5]ALITY IS L[] ?AN ! =M COMPLETE 9 ITSELF1 :I* IS ITSELF A :OLE1 & LIVES AS A LIV+ MEMB] ( ! TRULY G5]AL1 ! ORGANIZ$40 ,:Y1 ! PEOPLE IS ?IS V]Y 0WA%$-\T G5]ALITY10 & IT IS ONLY A MAN ?AT IS ! 0=M COMPLETE 9 ITSELF40 

,! IMP]SONALITY ( :AT !Y CALL 0PEOPLE1 NATION10 IS CLE> ALSO FROM ?IS3 ?AT A PEOPLE :I* WANTS TO BR+ ITS ,I 9TO VIEW TO ! BE/ ( ITS P[] PUTS AT ITS HEAD ! RUL] )\T WILL4 ,IT F9DS ITSELF 9 ! ALT]NATIVE EI!R TO BE SUBJECT$ TO A PR9CE :O REALIZES ONLY HIMSELF1 HIS 9DIVIDUAL PLEASURE - !N IT DOES NOT RECOGNIZE 9 ! 0ABSOLUTE MA/]0 ITS [N WILL1 ! SO-CALL$ WILL ( ! PEOPLE - OR TO SEAT ON ! ?RONE A PR9CE :O GIVES EFFECT TO NO WILL ( HIS [N - !N IT HAS A PR9CE )\T WILL1 :OSE PLACE SOME +5I\S CLOCKWORK W\LD P]HAPS FILL JU/ AS WELL4 - ,!RE=E 9SI<T NE$ GO ONLY A /EP F>!R2 !N IT BECOMES CLE> ( ITSELF ?AT ! ,I ( ! PEOPLE IS AN IMP]SONAL1 0SPIRITUAL0 P[]1 ! - LAW4 ,! PEOPLE'S ,I1 !RE=E1 IS A - SPOOK1 NOT AN ,I4 ,I AM ,I ONLY BY ?IS1 ?AT ,I MAKE MYSELF2 ?AT IT IS NOT ANO!R :O MAKES ME1 BUT ,I MU/ BE MY [N WORK4 ,BUT H[ IS IT ) ?IS ,I ( ! PEOPLE8 ,*ANCE PLAYS IT 9TO ! PEOPLE'S H&1 *ANCE GIVES IT ?IS OR ?AT BORN LORD1 ACCID5TS PROCURE IT ! *OS5 ONE2 HE IS NOT ITS 7! 0SOV]EIGN0 PEOPLE'S7 PRODUCT1 AS ,I AM MY PRODUCT4 ,CONCEIVE ( ONE WANT+ TO TALK Y\ 9TO BELIEV+ ?AT Y\ W]E NOT Y\R ,I1 BUT ,HANS OR ,KUNZ WAS Y\R ,I6 ,BUT SO IT IS ) ! PEOPLE1 & RI<TLY4 ,= ! PEOPLE HAS AN ,I AS LITTLE AS ! ELEV5 PLANETS C\NT$ TOGE!R HAVE AN ,I1 ?\< !Y REVOLVE >\ND A COMMON C5T]4 

,BAILLY'S UTT]ANCE IS REPRES5TATIVE ( ! SLAVE-DISPOSITION ?AT FOLKS MANIFE/ BE=E ! SOV]EIGN PEOPLE1 AS BE=E ! PR9CE4 0,I HAVE10 SAYS HE1 0NO LONG] ANY EXTRA REASON :5 ! G5]AL REASON HAS PRON\NC$ ITSELF4 ,MY FIR/ LAW WAS ! NATION'S WILL2 AS SOON AS IT HAD ASSEMBL$ ,I KNEW NO?+ BEYOND ITS SOV]EIGN WILL40 ,HE W\LD HAVE NO 0EXTRA REASON10 & YET ?IS EXTRA REASON ALONE ACCOMPLI%ES EV]Y?+4 ,JU/ SO ,MIRABEAU 9VEI<S 9 ! WORDS1 0,NO P[] ON E>? HAS ! RI<T TO SAY TO ! NATION'S REPRES5TATIVES1 ,IT IS MY WILL60 

,AS ) ! ,GREEKS1 !RE IS N[ A WI% TO MAKE MAN A ZOON POLITICON1 A CITIZ5 ( ! /ATE OR POLITICAL MAN4 ,SO HE RANK$ = A LONG TIME AS A 0CITIZ5 ( HEAV540 ,BUT ! ,GREEK FELL 9TO IGNOM9Y ALONG ) HIS /ATE1 ! CITIZ5 ( HEAV5 LIKEWISE FALLS ) HEAV52 WE1 ON ! O!R H&1 >E NOT WILL+ TO GO D[N ALONG ) ! PEOPLE1 ! NATION & NATIONALITY1 NOT WILL+ TO BE M]ELY POLITICAL M5 OR POLITICIANS4 ,S9CE ! ,REVOLUTION !Y HAVE /RIV5 TO 0MAKE ! PEOPLE HAPPY10 & 9 MAK+ ! PEOPLE HAPPY1 GREAT1 & ! LIKE1 !Y MAKE US UNHAPPY3 ! PEOPLE'S GOOD HAP IS - MY MI%AP4 

,:AT EMPTY TALK ! POLITICAL LIB]ALS UTT] ) EMPHATIC DECORUM IS WELL SE5 AGA9 9 ,NAUW]CK'S ,UB] DIE ,TEILNAHME AM ,/AATE4 ,!RE COMPLA9T IS MADE ( ?OSE :O >E 9DIFF]5T & DO NOT TAKE P>T1 :O >E NOT 9 ! FULL S5SE CITIZ5S1 & ! AU?OR SPEAKS AS IF ONE C\LD NOT BE MAN AT ALL IF ONE W]E NOT A POLITICIAN4 ,9 ?IS HE IS RI<T2 =1 IF ! /ATE RANKS AS ! W>D] ( EV]Y?+ 0HUMAN10 WE CAN HAVE NO?+ HUMAN )\T TAK+ P>T 9 IT4 ,BUT :AT DOES ?IS MAKE \T AGA9/ ! EGOI/8 ,NO?+ AT ALL1 BECAUSE ! EGOI/ IS TO HIMSELF ! W>D] ( ! HUMAN1 & HAS NO?+ TO SAY TO ! /ATE EXCEPT 0,GET \T ( MY SUN%9E40 ,ONLY :5 ! /ATE COMES 9 CONTACT ) HIS [NNESS DOES ! EGOI/ TAKE AN ACTIVE 9T]E/ 9 IT4 ,IF ! CONDITION ( ! /ATE DOES NOT BE> H>D ON ! CLOSET-PHILOSOPH]1 IS HE TO OCCUPY HIMSELF ) IT BECAUSE IT IS HIS 0MO/ SACR$ DUTY80 ,SO LONG AS ! /ATE DOES ACCORD+ TO HIS WI%1 :AT NE$ HAS HE TO LOOK UP FROM HIS /UDIES8 ,LET ?OSE :O FROM AN 9T]E/ ( !IR [N WANT TO HAVE CONDITIONS O!RWISE BUSY !MSELVES ) !M4 ,NOT N[1 NOR EV]MORE1 WILL 0SACR$ DUTY0 BR+ FOLKS TO REFLECT AB\T ! /ATE - AS LITTLE AS !Y BECOME DISCIPLES ( SCI5CE1 >TI/S1 ETC41 FROM 0SACR$ DUTY40 ,EGOISM ALONE CAN IMPEL !M TO IT1 & WILL AS SOON AS ?+S HAVE BECOME MU* WORSE4 ,IF Y\ %[$ FOLKS ?AT !IR EGOISM DEM&$ ?AT !Y BUSY !MSELVES ) /ATE AFFAIRS1 Y\ W\LD NOT HAVE TO CALL ON !M LONG2 IF1 ON ! O!R H&1 Y\ APPEAL TO !IR LOVE ( FA!RL& & ! LIKE1 Y\ WILL LONG PREA* TO DEAF HE>TS 9 BEHALF ( ?IS 0S]VICE ( LOVE40 ,C]TA9LY1 9 Y\R S5SE ! EGOI/S WILL NOT P>TICIPATE 9 /ATE AFFAIRS AT ALL4 

,NAUW]CK UTT]S A G5U9E LIB]AL PHRASE ON P4#a#f3 0,MAN COMPLETELY FULFILLS HIS CALL+ ONLY 9 FEEL+ & KN[+ HIMSELF AS A MEMB] ( HUMANITY1 & BE+ ACTIVE AS SU*4 ,! 9DIVIDUAL CANNOT REALIZE ! IDEA ( MANHOOD IF HE DOES NOT /AY HIMSELF UPON ALL HUMANITY1 IF HE DOES NOT DRAW HIS P[]S FROM IT LIKE ,ANTAEUS40 

,9 ! SAME PLACE IT IS SAID3 0,MAN'S RELATION TO ! RES PUBLICA IS DEGRAD$ TO A PURELY PRIVATE MATT] BY ! !OLOGICAL VIEW2 IS1 ACCORD+LY1 MADE AWAY ) BY D5IAL40 ,AS IF ! POLITICAL VIEW DID O!RWISE ) RELIGION6 ,!RE RELIGION IS A 0PRIVATE MATT]40 

,IF1 9/EAD ( 0SACR$ DUTY10 0MAN'S DE/9Y10 ! 0CALL+ TO FULL MANHOOD10 & SIMIL> COMM&M5TS1 IT W]E HELD UP TO PEOPLE ?AT !IR SELF-9T]E/ WAS 9FR+$ ON :5 !Y LET EV]Y?+ 9 ! /ATE GO AS IT GOES1 !N1 )\T DECLAMATIONS1 !Y W\LD BE ADDRESS$ AS ONE WILL HAVE TO ADDRESS !M AT ! DECISIVE MOM5T IF HE WANTS TO ATTA9 HIS 5D4 ,9/EAD ( ?IS1 ! !OLOGY-HAT+ AU?OR SAYS1 0,IF !RE HAS EV] BE5 A TIME :5 ! /ATE LAID CLAIM TO ALL ?AT >E H]S1 SU* A TIME IS \RS4 - ,! ?9K+ MAN SEES 9 P>TICIPATION 9 ! !ORY & PRACTICE ( ! /ATE A DUTY1 ONE ( ! MO/ SACR$ DUTIES ?AT RE/ UPON HIM0 - & !N TAKES UND] CLOS] CONSID]ATION ! 0UNCONDITIONAL NECESSITY ?AT EV]YBODY P>TICIPATE 9 ! /ATE40 

,HE 9 :OSE HEAD OR HE>T OR BO? ! /ATE IS SEAT$1 HE :O IS POSSESS$ BY ! /ATE1 OR ! BELIEV] 9 ! /ATE1 IS A POLITICIAN1 & REMA9S SU* TO ALL ET]NITY4 

0,! /ATE IS ! MO/ NECESS>Y MEANS = ! COMPLETE DEVELOPM5T ( MANK9D40 ,IT ASSUR$LY HAS BE5 SO AS LONG AS WE WANT$ TO DEVELOP MANK9D2 BUT1 IF WE WANT TO DEVELOP \RSELVES1 IT CAN BE TO US ONLY A MEANS ( H9DRANCE4 

,CAN /ATE & PEOPLE /ILL BE RE=M$ & BETT]$ N[8 ,AS LITTLE AS ! NOBILITY1 ! CL]GY1 ! *UR*1 ETC43 !Y CAN BE ABROGAT$1 ANNIHILAT$1 DONE AWAY )1 NOT RE=M$4 ,CAN ,I *ANGE A PIECE ( NONS5SE 9TO S5SE BY RE=M+ IT1 OR MU/ ,I DROP IT \TRI<T8 

,H5CE=? :AT IS TO BE DONE IS NO LONG] AB\T ! /ATE 7! =M ( ! /ATE1 ETC471 BUT AB\T ME4 ,) ?IS ALL QUE/IONS AB\T ! PR9CE'S P[]1 ! CON/ITUTION1 & SO ON1 S9K 9TO !IR TRUE ABYSS & !IR TRUE NO?+NESS4 ,I1 ?IS NO?+1 %ALL PUT =? MY CREATIONS FROM MYSELF4 

,TO ! *APT] ( SOCIETY BELONGS ALSO 0! P>TY10 :OSE PRAISE HAS ( LATE BE5 SUNG4 

,9 ! /ATE ! P>TY IS CURR5T4 0,P>TY1 P>TY1 :O %\LD NOT JO9 ONE60 ,BUT ! 9DIVIDUAL IS UNIQUE1 NOT A MEMB] ( ! P>TY4 ,HE UNITES FREELY1 & SEP>ATES FREELY AGA94 ,! P>TY IS NO?+ BUT A /ATE 9 ! /ATE1 & 9 ?IS SMALL] BEE-/ATE 0PEACE0 IS ALSO TO RULE JU/ AS 9 ! GREAT]4 ,! V]Y PEOPLE :O CRY L\DE/ ?AT !RE MU/ BE AN OPPOSITION 9 ! /ATE 9VEI< AGA9/ EV]Y DISCORD 9 ! P>TY4 ,A PRO( ?AT !Y TOO WANT ONLY A - /ATE4 ,ALL P>TIES >E %ATT]$ NOT AGA9/ ! /ATE1 BUT AGA9/ ! EGO4 

,ONE HE>S NO?+ (T5] N[ ?AN ! ADMONITION TO REMA9 TRUE TO HIS P>TY2 P>TY M5 DESPISE NO?+ SO MU* AS A MUGWUMP4 ,ONE MU/ RUN ) HIS P>TY ?R\< ?ICK & ?91 & UNCONDITIONALLY APPROVE & REPRES5T ITS *IEF PR9CIPLES4 ,IT DOES NOT 9DE$ GO QUITE SO BADLY H]E AS ) CLOS$ SOCIETIES1 BECAUSE !SE B9D !IR MEMB]S TO FIX$ LAWS OR /ATUTES 7SU* AS ! ORD]S1 ! ,SOCIETY ( ,JESUS1 ETC474 ,BUT YET ! P>TY CEASES TO BE A UNION AT ! SAME MOM5T AT :I* IT MAKES C]TA9 PR9CIPLES B9D+ & WANTS TO HAVE !M ASSUR$ AGA9/ ATTACKS2 BUT ?IS MOM5T IS ! V]Y BIR?-ACT ( ! P>TY4 ,AS P>TY IT IS ALREADY A BORN SOCIETY1 A DEAD UNION1 AN IDEA ?AT HAS BECOME FIX$4 ,AS P>TY ( ABSOLUTISM IT CANNOT WILL ?AT ITS MEMB]S %\LD D\BT ! IRREFRAGABLE TRU? ( ?IS PR9CIPLE2 !Y C\LD *]I% ?IS D\BT ONLY IF !Y W]E EGOI/IC 5\< TO WANT /ILL TO BE SOME?+ \TSIDE !IR P>TY1 NONP>TIZANS4 ,NONP>TIZANS !Y CANNOT BE AS P>TY-M51 BUT ONLY AS EGOI/S4 ,IF Y\ >E A ,PROTE/ANT & BELONG TO ?AT P>TY1 Y\ MU/ ONLY JU/IFY ,PROTE/ANTISM1 AT MO/ 0PURGE0 IT1 NOT REJECT IT2 IF Y\ >E A ,*RI/IAN & BELONG AMONG M5 TO ! ,*RI/IAN P>TY1 Y\ CANNOT BE BEYOND ?IS AS A MEMB] ( ?IS P>TY1 BUT ONLY :5 Y\R EGOISM1 NONP>TIZAN%IP1 IMPELS Y\ TO IT4 ,:AT EX]TIONS ! ,*RI/IANS1 D[N TO ,HEGEL & ! ,COMMUNI/S1 HAVE PUT =? TO MAKE !IR P>TY /RONG6 ,!Y /UCK TO IT ?AT ,*RI/IANITY MU/ CONTA9 ! ET]NAL TRU?1 & ?AT ONE NE$S ONLY TO GET AT IT1 MAKE SURE ( IT1 & JU/IFY IT4 

,9 %ORT1 ! P>TY CANNOT BE> NONP>TIZAN%IP1 & IT IS 9 ?IS ?AT EGOISM APPE>S4 ,:AT MATT]S ! P>TY TO ME8 ,I %ALL F9D 5\< ANYH[ :O UNITE ) ME )\T SWE>+ ALLEGIANCE TO MY FLAG4 

,HE :O PASSES OV] FROM ONE P>TY TO ANO!R IS AT ONCE ABUS$ AS A 0TURNCOAT40 ,C]TA9LY MORALITY DEM&S ?AT ONE /& BY HIS P>TY1 & TO BECOME APO/ATE FROM IT IS TO SPOT ONESELF ) ! /A9 ( 0FAI?LESSNESS02 BUT [NNESS KN[S NO COMM&M5T ( 0FAI?LESSNESS02 ADHESION1 & ! LIKE1 [NNESS P]MITS EV]Y?+1 EV5 APO/ASY1 DEFECTION4 ,UNCONSCI\SLY EV5 ! MORAL !MSELVES LET !MSELVES BE L$ BY ?IS PR9CIPLE :5 !Y HAVE TO JUDGE ONE :O PASSES OV] TO !IR P>TY - 9DE$1 !Y >E LIKELY TO BE MAK+ PROSELYTES2 !Y %\LD ONLY AT ! SAME TIME ACQUIRE A CONSCI\SNESS ( ! FACT ?AT ONE MU/ COMMIT IMMORAL ACTIONS 9 ORD] TO COMMIT HIS [N - H]E1 ?AT ONE MU/ BREAK FAI?1 YES1 EV5 HIS OA?1 9 ORD] TO DET]M9E HIMSELF 9/EAD ( BE+ DET]M9$ BY MORAL CONSID]ATIONS4 ,9 ! EYES ( PEOPLE ( /RICT MORAL JUDGM5T AN APO/ATE ALWAYS %IMM]S 9 EQUIVOCAL COLORS1 & WILL NOT EASILY OBTA9 !IR CONFID5CE2 = !RE /ICKS TO HIM ! TA9T ( 0FAI?LESSNESS10 ( AN IMMORALITY4 ,9 ! L[] MAN ?IS VIEW IS F\ND ALMO/ G5]ALLY2 ADVANC$ ?9K]S FALL H]E TOO1 AS ALWAYS1 9TO AN UNC]TA9TY & BEWILD]M5T1 & ! CONTRADICTION NECESS>ILY F\ND$ 9 ! PR9CIPLE ( MORALITY DOES NOT1 ON ACC\NT ( ! CONFUSION ( !IR CONCEPTS1 COME CLE>LY TO !IR CONSCI\SNESS4 ,!Y DO NOT V5TURE TO CALL ! APO/ATE IMMORAL D[NRI<T1 BECAUSE !Y !MSELVES 5TICE TO APO/ASY1 TO DEFECTION FROM ONE RELIGION TO ANO!R2 /ILL1 !Y CANNOT GIVE UP ! /&-PO9T ( MORALITY EI!R4 ,& YET H]E ! OCCASION WAS TO BE SEIZ$ TO /EP \TSIDE ( MORALITY4 

,>E ! [N OR UNIQUE P]*ANCE A P>TY8 ,H[ C\LD !Y BE [N IF !Y W]E SU* AS BELONG$ TO A P>TY8 

,OR IS ONE TO HOLD ) NO P>TY8 ,9 ! V]Y ACT ( JO9+ !M & 5T]+ !IR CIRCLE ONE =MS A UNION ) !M ?AT LA/S AS LONG AS P>TY & ,I PURSUE ONE & ! SAME GOAL4 ,BUT TODAY ,I /ILL %>E ! P>TY'S T5D5CY1 AS BY TOMORR[ ,I CAN DO SO NO LONG] & ,I BECOME 0UNTRUE0 TO IT4 ,! P>TY HAS NO?+ B9D+ 7OBLIGATORY7 = ME1 & ,I DO NOT HAVE RESPECT = IT2 IF IT NO LONG] PLEASES ME1 ,I BECOME ITS FOE4 

,9 EV]Y P>TY ?AT C>ES = ITSELF & ITS P]SI/5CE1 ! MEMB]S >E UNFREE 7OR BETT]1 UN[N7 9 ?AT DEGREE1 !Y LACK EGOISM 9 ?AT DEGREE1 9 :I* !Y S]VE ?IS DESIRE ( ! P>TY4 ,! 9DEP5D5CE ( ! P>TY CONDITIONS ! LACK ( 9DEP5D5CE 9 ! P>TY-MEMB]S4 

,A P>TY1 ( :ATEV] K9D IT MAY BE1 CAN NEV] DO )\T A CONFESSION ( FAI?4 ,= ?OSE :O BELONG TO ! P>TY MU/ BELIEVE 9 ITS PR9CIPLE1 IT MU/ NOT BE BR\<T 9 D\BT OR PUT 9 QUE/ION BY !M1 IT MU/ BE ! C]TA91 9DUBITABLE ?+ = ! P>TY-MEMB]4 ,?AT IS3 ,ONE MU/ BELONG TO A P>TY BODY & S\L1 ELSE ONE IS NOT TRULY A P>TY-MAN1 BUT MORE OR LESS - AN EGOI/4 ,H>BOR A D\BT ( ,*RI/IANITY1 & Y\ >E ALREADY NO LONG] A TRUE ,*RI/IAN1 Y\ HAVE LIFT$ Y\RSELF TO ! 0EFFRONT]Y0 ( PUTT+ A QUE/ION BEYOND IT & HAL+ ,*RI/IANITY BE=E Y\R EGOI/IC JUDGM5T-SEAT4 ,Y\ HAVE - S9N$ AGA9/ ,*RI/IANITY1 ?IS P>TY CAUSE 7= IT IS SURELY NOT = EXAMPLE A CAUSE = ! ,JEWS1 ANO!R P>TY47 ,BUT WELL = Y\ IF Y\ DO NOT LET Y\RSELF BE AFFRI<T$3 Y\R EFFRONT]Y HELPS Y\ TO [NNESS4 

,SO !N AN EGOI/ C\LD NEV] EMBRACE A P>TY OR TAKE UP ) A P>TY8 ,OH1 YES1 ONLY HE CANNOT LET HIMSELF BE EMBRAC$ & TAK5 UP BY ! P>TY4 ,= HIM ! P>TY REMA9S ALL ! TIME NO?+ BUT A GA!R+3 HE IS ONE ( ! P>TY1 HE TAKES P>T4 

,! BE/ /ATE WILL CLE>LY BE ?AT :I* HAS ! MO/ LOYAL CITIZ5S1 & ! MORE ! DEVOT$ M9D = LEGALITY IS LO/1 SO MU* ! MORE WILL ! /ATE1 ?IS SY/EM ( MORALITY1 ?IS MORAL LIFE ITSELF1 BE DIM9I%$ 9 =CE & QUALITY4 ,) ! 0GOOD CITIZ5S0 ! GOOD /ATE TOO P]I%ES & DISSOLVES 9TO AN>*Y & LAWLESSNESS4 0,RESPECT = ! LAW60 ,BY ?IS CEM5T ! TOTAL ( ! /ATE IS HELD TOGE!R4 0,! LAW IS SACR$1 & HE :O AFFRONTS IT A CRIM9AL04 ,)\T CRIME NO /ATE3 ! MORAL WORLD - & ?IS ! /ATE IS - IS CRAMM$ FULL ( SCAMPS1 *EATS1 LI>S1 ?IEVES4 ,S9CE ! /ATE IS ! 0LORD%IP ( LAW10 ITS HI]>*Y1 IT FOLL[S ?AT ! EGOI/1 9 ALL CASES :]E HIS ADVANTAGE RUNS AGA9/ ! /ATE'S1 CAN SATISFY HIMSELF ONLY BY CRIME4 

,! /ATE CANNOT GIVE UP ! CLAIM ?AT ITS LAWS & ORD9ANCES >E SACR$ .<HEILIG.>4 ,AT ?IS ! 9DIVIDUAL RANKS AS ! UNHOLY .<UNHEILIG.> 7B>B>IAN1 NATURAL MAN1 0EGOI/07 OV] AGA9/ ! /ATE1 EXACTLY AS HE WAS ONCE REG>D$ BY ! ,*UR*2 BE=E ! 9DIVIDUAL ! /ATE TAKES ON ! NIMBUS ( A SA9T .<,HEILIG].>4 ,?US IT ISSUES A LAW AGA9/ DUEL+4 ,TWO M5 :O >E BO? AT ONE 9 ?IS1 ?AT !Y >E WILL+ TO /AKE !IR LIFE = A CAUSE 7NO MATT] :AT71 >E NOT TO BE ALL[$ ?IS1 BECAUSE ! /ATE WILL NOT HAVE IT3 IT IMPOSES A P5ALTY ON IT4 ,:]E IS ! LIB]TY ( SELF-DET]M9ATION !N8 ,IT IS AT ONCE QUITE ANO!R SITUATION IF1 AS 9 ,NOR? ,AM]ICA1 SOCIETY DET]M9ES TO LET ! DUELI/S BE> C]TA9 EVIL CONSEQU5CES ( !IR ACT1 SU* AS )DRAWAL ( ! CR$IT HI!RTO 5JOY$4 ,TO REFUSE CR$IT IS EV]YBODY'S AFFAIR1 &1 IF A SOCIETY WANTS NAMELYHDRAW IT = ?IS OR ?AT REASON1 ! MAN :O IS HIT CANNOT !RE=E COMPLA9 ( 5CROA*M5T ON HIS LIB]TY3 ! SOCIETY IS SIMPLY AVAIL+ ITSELF ( ITS [N LIB]TY4 ,?AT IS NO P5ALTY = S91 NO P5ALTY = A CRIME4 ,! DUEL IS NO CRIME !RE1 BUT ONLY AN ACT AGA9/ :I* ! SOCIETY ADOPTS C\NT]-MEASURES1 RESOLVES ON A DEF5SE4 ,! /ATE1 ON ! CONTR>Y1 /AMPS ! DUEL AS A CRIME1 AS AN 9JURY TO ITS SACR$ LAW3 IT MAKES IT A CRIM9AL CASE4 ,! SOCIETY LEAVES IT TO ! 9DIVIDUAL'S DECISION :E!R HE WILL DRAW UPON HIMSELF EVIL CONSEQU5CES & 9CONV5I5CES BY HIS MODE ( ACTION1 & H]EBY RECOGNIZES HIS FREE DECISION2 ! /ATE BEHAVES 9 EXACTLY ! REV]SE WAY1 D5Y+ ALL RI<T TO ! 9DIVIDUAL'S DECISION &1 9/EAD1 ASCRIB+ ! SOLE RI<T TO ITS [N DECISION1 ! LAW ( ! /ATE1 SO ?AT HE :O TRANSGRESSES ! /ATE'S COMM&M5T IS LOOK$ UPON AS IF HE W]E ACT+ AGA9/ ,GOD'S COMM&M5T - A VIEW :I* LIKEWISE WAS ONCE MA9TA9$ BY ! ,*UR*4 ,H]E ,GOD IS ! ,HOLY 9 & ( HIMSELF1 & ! COMM&M5TS ( ! ,*UR*1 AS ( ! /ATE1 >E ! COMM&M5TS ( ?IS ,HOLY ,ONE1 :I* HE TRANSMITS TO ! WORLD ?R\< HIS ANO9T$ & ,LORDS-BY-!-,GRACE-(-,GOD4 ,IF ! ,*UR* HAD DEADLY S9S1 ! /ATE HAS CAPITAL CRIMES2 IF ! ONE HAD H]ETICS1 ! O!R HAS TRAITORS2 ! ONE ECCLESIA/ICAL P5ALTIES1 ! O!R CRIM9AL P5ALTIES2 ! ONE 9QUISITORIAL PROCESSES1 ! O!R FISCAL2 9 %ORT1 !RE S9S1 H]E CRIMES1 !RE 9QUISITION & H]E - 9QUISITION4 ,WILL ! SANCTITY ( ! /ATE NOT FALL LIKE ! ,*UR*'S8 ,! AWE ( ITS LAWS1 ! REV]5CE = ITS HI<NESS1 ! HUMILITY ( ITS 0SUBJECTS10 WILL ?IS REMA98 ,WILL ! 0SA9T'S0 FACE NOT BE /RIPP$ ( ITS ADORNM5T8 

,:AT A FOLLY1 TO ASK ( ! /ATE'S AU?ORITY ?AT IT %\LD 5T] 9TO AN HONORABLE FI<T ) ! 9DIVIDUAL1 &1 AS !Y EXPRESS !MSELVES 9 ! MATT] ( FRE$OM ( ! PRESS1 %>E SUN & W9D EQUALLY6 ,IF ! /ATE1 ?IS ?\<T1 IS TO BE A DE FACTO P[]1 IT SIMPLY MU/ BE A SUP]IOR P[] AGA9/ ! 9DIVIDUAL4 ,! /ATE IS 0SACR$0 & MU/ NOT EXPOSE ITSELF TO ! 0IMPUD5T ATTACKS0 ( 9DIVIDUALS4 ,IF ! /ATE IS SACR$1 !RE MU/ BE C5SOR%IP4 ,! POLITICAL LIB]ALS ADMIT ! =M] & DISPUTE ! 9F]5CE4 ,BUT 9 ANY CASE !Y CONC$E REPRESSIVE MEASURES TO IT1 = - !Y /ICK TO ?IS1 ?AT /ATE IS MORE ?AN ! 9DIVIDUAL & EX]CISES A JU/IFI$ REV5GE1 CALL$ PUNI%M5T4 

,PUNI%M5T HAS A MEAN+ ONLY :5 IT IS TO AF=D EXPIATION = ! 9JUR+ ( A SACR$ ?+4 ,IF SOME?+ IS SACR$ TO ANY ONE1 HE C]TA9LY DES]VES PUNI%M5T :5 HE ACTS AS ITS 5EMY4 ,A MAN :O LETS A MAN'S LIFE CONT9UE 9 EXI/5CE BECAUSE TO HIM IT IS SACR$ & HE HAS A DREAD ( T\*+ IT IS SIMPLY A - RELIGI\S MAN4 

,WEITL+ LAYS CRIME AT ! DOOR ( 0SOCIAL DISORD]10 & LIVES 9 ! EXPECTATION ?AT UND] ,COMMUNI/IC >RANGEM5TS CRIMES WILL BECOME IMPOSSIBLE1 BECAUSE ! TEMPTATIONS TO !M1 SU* AS MONEY1 FALL AWAY4 ,AS1 H[EV]1 HIS ORGANIZ$ SOCIETY IS ALSO EXALT$ 9TO A SACR$ & 9VIOLABLE ONE1 HE MISCALCULATES 9 ?AT GOOD-HE>T$ OP9ION4 ,SU* AS ) !IR M\? PR(ESS$ ALLEGIANCE TO ! ,COMMUNI/IC SOCIETY1 BUT WORK$ UND]H& = ITS RU91 W\LD NOT BE LACK+4 ,BESIDES1 ,WEITL+ HAS TO KEEP ON ) 0CURATIVE MEANS AGA9/ ! NATURAL REMA9D] ( HUMAN DISEASES & WEAKNESSES10 & 0CURATIVE MEANS0 ALWAYS ANN\NCE TO BEG9 ) ?AT 9DIVIDUALS WILL BE LOOK$ UPON AS 0CALL$0 TO A P>TICUL> 0SALVATION0 & H5CE TREAT$ ACCORD+ TO ! REQUIREM5TS ( ?IS 0HUMAN CALL+40 ,CURATIVE MEANS OR HEAL+ IS ONLY ! REV]SE SIDE ( PUNI%M5T1 ! !ORY ( CURE RUNS P>ALLEL ) ! !ORY ( PUNI%M5T2 IF ! LATT] SEES 9 AN ACTION A S9 AGA9/ RI<T1 ! =M] TAKES IT = A S9 ( ! MAN AGA9/ HIMSELF1 AS A DECAD5CE FROM HIS HEAL?4 ,BUT ! CORRECT ?+ IS ?AT ,I REG>D IT EI!R AS AN ACTION ?AT SUITS ME OR AS ONE ?AT DOES NOT SUIT ME1 AS HO/ILE OR FRI5DLY TO ME1 ?AT ,I TREAT IT AS MY PROP]TY1 :I* ,I *]I% OR DEMOLI%4 0,CRIME0 OR 0DISEASE0 >E NOT EI!R ( !M AN EGOI/IC VIEW ( ! MATT]1 A JUDGM5T />T+ FROM ME1 BUT />T+ FROM ANO!R - NAMELY1 :E!R IT 9JURES RI<T1 G5]AL RI<T1 OR ! HEAL? P>TLY ( ! 9DIVIDUAL 7! SICK ONE71 P>TLY ( ! G5]ALITY 7SOCIETY 74 0,CRIME0 IS TREAT$ 9EXORABLY1 0DISEASE0 ) 0LOV+ G5TL5ESS1 COMPASSION10 & ! LIKE4 

,PUNI%M5T FOLL[S CRIME4 ,IF CRIME FALLS BECAUSE ! SACR$ VANI%ES1 PUNI%M5T MU/ NOT LESS BE DRAWN 9TO ITS FALL2 = IT TOO HAS SIGNIFICANCE ONLY OV] AGA9/ SOME?+ SACR$4 ,ECCLESIA/ICAL PUNI%M5TS HAVE BE5 ABOLI%$4 ,:Y8 ,BECAUSE H[ ONE BEHAVES T[>D ! 0HOLY ,GOD0 IS HIS [N AFFAIR4 ,BUT1 AS ?IS ONE PUNI%M5T1 ECCLESIA/ICAL PUNI%M5T1 HAS FALL51 SO ALL PUNI%M5TS MU/ FALL4 ,AS S9 AGA9/ ! SO-CALL$ ,GOD IS A MAN'S [N AFFAIR1 SO IS ?AT AGA9/ EV]Y K9D ( ! SO-CALL$ SACR$4 ,ACCORD+ TO \R !ORIES ( P5AL LAW1 ) :OSE 0IMPROVEM5T 9 CON=MITY TO ! TIMES0 PEOPLE >E TORM5T+ !MSELVES 9 VA91 !Y WANT TO PUNI% M5 = ?IS OR ?AT 09HUMANITY02 & !RE9 !Y MAKE ! SILL9ESS ( !SE !ORIES ESPECIALLY PLA9 BY !IR CONSI/5CY1 HANG+ ! LITTLE ?IEVES & LETT+ ! BIG ONES RUN4 ,= 9JURY TO PROP]TY !Y HAVE ! H\SE ( CORRECTION1 & = 0VIOL5CE TO ?\<T10 SUPPRESSION ( 0NATURAL RI<TS ( MAN10 ONLY - REPRES5TATIONS & PETITIONS4 

,! CRIM9AL CODE HAS CONT9U$ EXI/5CE ONLY ?R\< ! SACR$1 & P]I%ES ( ITSELF IF PUNI%M5T IS GIV5 UP4 ,N[ !Y WANT TO CREATE EV]Y:]E A NEW P5AL LAW1 )\T 9DULG+ 9 A MISGIV+ AB\T PUNI%M5T ITSELF4 ,BUT IT IS EXACTLY PUNI%M5T ?AT MU/ MAKE ROOM = SATISFACTION1 :I*1 AGA91 CANNOT AIM AT SATISFY+ RI<T OR JU/ICE1 BUT AT PROCUR+ US A SATISFACTORY \TCOME4 ,IF ONE DOES TO US :AT WE WILL NOT PUT UP )1 WE BREAK HIS P[] & BR+ \R [N TO BE>3 WE SATISFY \RSELVES ON HIM1 & DO NOT FALL 9TO ! FOLLY ( WANT+ TO SATISFY RI<T 7! SPOOK74 ,IT IS NOT ! SACR$ ?AT IS TO DEF5D ITSELF AGA9/ MAN1 BUT MAN AGA9/ MAN2 AS ,GOD TOO1 Y\ KN[1 NO LONG] DEF5DS HIMSELF AGA9/ MAN1 ,GOD TO :OM =M]LY 7& 9 P>T1 9DE$1 EV5 N[7 ALL ! 0S]VANTS ( ,GOD0 (F]$ !IR H&S TO PUNI% ! BLASPHEM]1 AS !Y /ILL AT ?IS V]Y DAY L5D !IR H&S TO ! SACR$4 ,?IS DEVOTION TO ! SACR$ BR+S IT TO PASS ALSO ?AT1 )\T LIVELY P>TICIPATION ( ONE'S [N1 ONE ONLY DELIV]S MISDO]S 9TO ! H&S ( ! POLICE & C\RTS3 A NONP>TICIPAT+ MAK+ OV] TO ! AU?ORITIES1 0:O1 ( C\RSE1 WILL BE/ ADM9I/] SACR$ MATT]S40 ,! PEOPLE IS QUITE CRAZY = H\ND+ ! POLICE ON AGA9/ EV]Y?+ ?AT SEEMS TO IT TO BE IMMORAL1 (T5 ONLY UNSEEMLY1 & ?IS POPUL> RAGE = ! MORAL PROTECTS ! POLICE 9/ITUTION MORE ?AN ! GOV]NM5T C\LD 9 ANY WAY PROTECT IT4 

,9 CRIME ! EGOI/ HAS HI!RTO ASS]T$ HIMSELF & MOCK$ AT ! SACR$2 ! BREAK ) ! SACR$1 OR RA!R ( ! SACR$1 MAY BECOME G5]AL4 ,A REVOLUTION NEV] RETURNS1 BUT A MI<TY1 RECKLESS1 %AMELESS1 CONSCI5CELESS4 PR\D - CRIME1 DOES IT NOT RUMBLE 9 DI/ANT ?UND]S1 & DO Y\ NOT SEE H[ ! SKY GR[S PRESCI5TLY SIL5T & GLOOMY8 

,HE :O REFUSES TO SP5D HIS P[]S = SU* LIMIT$ SOCIETIES AS FAMILY1 P>TY1 NATION1 IS /ILL ALWAYS LONG+ = A WOR?I] SOCIETY1 & ?9KS HE HAS F\ND ! TRUE OBJECT ( LOVE1 P]HAPS1 9 0HUMAN SOCIETY0 OR 0MANK9D10 TO SACRIFICE HIMSELF TO :I* CON/ITUTES HIS HONOR2 FROM N[ ON HE 0LIVES = & S]VES MANK9D40 

,PEOPLE IS ! NAME ( ! BODY1 /ATE ( ! SPIRIT1 ( ?AT RUL+ P]SON ?AT HAS HI!RTO SUPPRESS$ ME4 ,SOME HAVE WANT$ TO TRANSFIGURE PEOPLES & /ATES BY BROAD5+ !M \T TO 0MANK9D0 & 0G5]AL REASON02 BUT S]VITUDE W\LD ONLY BECOME /ILL MORE 9T5SE ) ?IS WID5+1 & PHILAN?ROPI/S & HUMANIT>IANS >E AS ABSOLUTE MA/]S AS POLITICIANS & DIPLOMATS4 

,MOD]N CRITICS 9VEI< AGA9/ RELIGION BECAUSE IT SETS ,GOD1 ! DIV9E1 MORAL1 ETC41 \TSIDE ( MAN1 OR MAKES !M SOME?+ OBJECTIVE1 9 OPPOSITION TO :I* ! CRITICS RA!R TRANSF] !SE V]Y SUBJECTS 9TO MAN4 ,BUT ?OSE CRITICS NONE ! LESS FALL 9TO ! PROP] ]ROR ( RELIGION1 TO GIVE MAN A 0DE/9Y10 9 ?AT !Y TOO WANT TO HAVE HIM DIV9E1 HUMAN1 & ! LIKE3 MORALITY1 FRE$OM & HUMANITY1 ETC41 >E HIS ESS5CE4 ,&1 LIKE RELIGION POLITICS TOO WANT$ TO 0$UCATE0 MAN1 TO BR+ HIM TO ! REALIZATION ( HIS 0ESS5CE10 HIS 0DE/9Y10 TO MAKE SOME?+ \T ( HIM - NAMELY1 A 0TRUE MAN10 ! ONE 9 ! =M ( ! 0TRUE BELIEV]10 ! O!R 9 ?AT ( ! 0TRUE CITIZ5 OR SUBJECT40 ,9 FACT1 IT COMES TO ! SAME :E!R ONE CALLS ! DE/9Y ! DIV9E OR HUMAN4 

,UND] RELIGION & POLITICS MAN F9DS HIMSELF AT ! /&-PO9T ( %\LD3 HE %\LD BECOME ?IS & ?AT1 %\LD BE SO & SO4 ,) ?IS PO/ULATE1 ?IS COMM&M5T1 EV]Y ONE /EPS NOT ONLY 9 FRONT ( ANO!R BUT ALSO 9 FRONT ( HIMSELF4 ,?OSE CRITICS SAY3 ,Y\ %\LD BE A :OLE1 FREE MAN4 ,?US !Y TOO /& 9 ! TEMPTATION TO PROCLAIM A NEW RELIGION1 TO SET UP A NEW ABSOLUTE1 AN IDEAL - NAMELY1 FRE$OM4 ,M5 %\LD BE FREE4 ,!N !RE MI<T EV5 >ISE MISSION>IES ( FRE$OM 1 AS ,*RI/IANITY1 9 ! CONVICTION ?AT ALL W]E PROP]LY DE/9$ TO BECOME ,*RI/IANS1 S5T \T MISSION>IES ( ! FAI?4 ,FRE$OM W\LD !N 7AS HAVE HI!RTO FAI? AS ,*UR*1 MORALITY AS /ATE7 CON/ITUTE ITSELF AS A NEW COMMUNITY & C>RY ON A LIKE 0PROPAG&A0 !REFROM4 ,C]TA9LY NO OBJECTION CAN BE RAIS$ AGA9/ A GETT+ TOGE!R2 BUT SO MU* ! MORE MU/ ONE OPPOSE EV]Y R5EWAL ( ! OLD C>E = US1 ( CULTURE DIRECT$ T[>D AN 5D - 9 %ORT1 ! PR9CIPLE ( MAK+ SOME?+ \T ( US1 NO MATT] :E!R ,*RI/IANS1 SUBJECTS1 OR FREEM5 & M54 

,ONE MAY WELL SAY ) ,FEU]BA* & O!RS ?AT RELIGION HAS DISPLAC$ ! HUMAN FROM MAN1 & HAS TRANSF]R$ IT SO 9TO ANO!R WORLD ?AT1 UNATTA9ABLE1 IT W5T ON ) ITS [N EXI/5CE !RE AS SOME?+ P]SONAL 9 ITSELF1 AS A 0,GOD03 BUT ! ]ROR ( RELIGION IS BY NO MEANS EXHAU/$ ) ?IS4 ,ONE MI<T V]Y WELL LET FALL ! P]SONALITY ( ! DISPLAC$ HUMAN1 MI<T TRANS=M ,GOD 9TO ! DIV9E1 & /ILL REMA9 RELIGI\S4 ,= ! RELIGI\S CONSI/S 9 DISCONT5T ) ! PRES5T M51 9 ! SETT+ UP ( A 0P]FECTION0 TO BE /RIV5 =1 9 0MAN WRE/L+ = HIS COMPLETION40 70,YE !RE=E %\LD BE P]FECT AS Y\R FA!R 9 HEAV5 IS P]FECT40 ,MATT4 #e1 #d#h73 IT CONSI/S 9 ! FIXATION ( AN IDEAL1 AN ABSOLUTE4 ,P]FECTION IS ! 0SUPREME GOOD10 ! F9IS BONORUM2 EV]Y ONE'S IDEAL IS ! P]FECT MAN1 ! TRUE1 ! FREE MAN1 ETC4 

,! EF=TS ( MOD]N TIMES AIM TO SET UP ! IDEAL ( ! 0FREE MAN40 ,IF ONE C\LD F9D IT1 !RE W\LD BE A NEW - RELIGION1 BECAUSE A NEW IDEAL2 !RE W\LD BE A NEW LONG+1 A NEW TORM5T1 A NEW DEVOTION1 A NEW DEITY1 A NEW CONTRITION4 

,) ! IDEAL ( 0ABSOLUTE LIB]TY10 ! SAME TURMOIL IS MADE AS ) EV]Y?+ ABSOLUTE1 & ACCORD+ TO ,HESS1 IT IS SAID TO 0BE REALIZABLE 9 ABSOLUTE HUMAN SOCIETY4 ,9DE$1 ?IS REALIZATION IS IMM$IATELY AFT]W>DS /YL$ A 0VOCATION02 JU/ SO HE !N DEF9ES LIB]TY AS 0MORALITY03 ! K+DOM ( 0JU/ICE0 7EQUALITY7 & 0MORALITY0 7LIB]TY7 IS TO BEG91 ETC4 

,RIDICUL\S IS HE :O1 :ILE FELL[S ( HIS TRIBE1 FAMILY1 NATION1 RANK HI<1 IS - NO?+ BUT 0PUFF$ UP0 OV] ! M]IT ( HIS FELL[S2 BUT BL9D$ TOO IS HE :O WANTS ONLY TO BE 0MAN40 ,NEI!R ( !M PUTS HIS WOR? 9 EXCLUSIV5ESS1 BUT 9 CONNECT$NESS1 OR 9 ! 0TIE0 ?AT CONJO9S HIM ) O!RS1 9 ! TIES ( BLOOD1 ( NATIONALITY1 ( HUMANITY4 

,?R\< ! 0,NATIONALS0 ( TODAY ! CONFLICT HAS AGA9 BE5 /IRR$ UP BETWE5 ?OSE :O ?9K !MSELVES TO HAVE M]ELY HUMAN BLOOD & HUMAN TIES ( BLOOD1 & ! O!RS :O BRAG ( !IR SPECIAL BLOOD & ! SPECIAL TIES ( BLOOD4 

,IF WE DISREG>D ! FACT ?AT PRIDE MAY MEAN CONCEIT1 & TAKE IT = CONSCI\SNESS ALONE1 !RE IS F\ND TO BE A VA/ DIFF]5CE BETWE5 PRIDE 9 0BELONG+ TO0 A NATION & !RE=E BE+ ITS PROP]TY1 & ?AT 9 CALL+ A NATIONALITY ONE'S PROP]TY4 ,NATIONALITY IS MY QUALITY1 BUT ! NATION MY [N] & MI/RESS4 ,IF Y\ HAVE BODILY /R5G?1 Y\ CAN APPLY IT AT A SUITABLE PLACE & HAVE A SELF-CONSCI\SNESS OR PRIDE ( IT2 IF1 ON ! CONTR>Y1 Y\R /RONG BODY HAS Y\1 !N IT PRICKS Y\ EV]Y:]E1 & AT ! MO/ UNSUITABLE PLACE1 TO %[ ITS /R5G?3 Y\ CAN GIVE NOBODY Y\R H& )\T SQUEEZ+ HIS4 

,! P]CEPTION ?AT ONE IS MORE ?AN A MEMB] ( ! FAMILY1 MORE ?AN A FELL[ ( ! TRIBE1 MORE ?AN AN 9DIVIDUAL ( ! PEOPLE1 HAS F9ALLY L$ TO SAY+1 ONE IS MORE ?AN ALL ?IS BECAUSE ONE IS MAN1 OR1 ! MAN IS MORE ?AN ! ,JEW1 ,G]MAN1 ETC4 0,!RE=E BE EV]Y ONE :OLLY & SOLELY - MAN40 ,C\LD ONE NOT RA!R SAY3 ,BECAUSE WE >E MORE ?AN :AT HAS BE5 /AT$1 !RE=E WE WILL BE ?IS1 AS WELL AS ?AT 0MORE0 ALSO8 ,MAN & ,G]MANS1 !N1 MAN & ,GUELPH8 ,! ,NATIONALS >E 9 ! RI<T2 ONE CANNOT D5Y HIS NATIONALITY3 & ! HUMANIT>IANS >E 9 ! RI<T2 ONE MU/ NOT REMA9 9 ! N>R[NESS ( ! NATIONAL4 ,9 UNIQU5ESS ! CONTRADICTION IS SOLV$2 ! NATIONAL IS MY QUALITY4 ,BUT ,I AM NOT SWALL[$ UP 9 MY QUALITY - AS ! HUMAN TOO IS MY QUALITY1 BUT ,I GIVE TO MAN HIS EXI/5CE FIR/ ?R\< MY UNIQU5ESS4 

,HI/ORY SEEKS = ,MAN3 BUT HE IS ,I1 Y\1 WE4 ,S\<T AS A MY/]I\S ESS5CE1 AS ! DIV9E1 FIR/ AS ,GOD1 !N AS ,MAN 7HUMANITY1 HUMAN5ESS1 & MANK9D71 HE IS F\ND AS ! 9DIVIDUAL1 ! F9ITE1 ! UNIQUE ONE4 

,I AM [N] ( HUMANITY1 AM HUMANITY1 & DO NO?+ = ! GOOD ( ANO!R HUMANITY4 ,FOOL1 Y\ :O >E A UNIQUE HUMANITY1 ?AT Y\ MAKE A M]IT ( WANT+ TO LIVE = ANO!R ?AN Y\ >E4 

,! HI!RTO-CONSID]$ RELATION ( ME TO ! WORLD ( M5 (F]S SU* A WEAL? ( PH5OM5A ?AT IT WILL HAVE TO BE TAK5 UP AGA9 & AGA9 ON O!R OCCASIONS1 BUT H]E1 :]E IT WAS ONLY TO HAVE ITS *IEF \TL9ES MADE CLE> TO ! EYE1 IT MU/ BE BROK5 (F TO MAKE PLACE = AN APPREH5SION ( TWO O!R SIDES T[>D :I* IT RADIATES4 ,=1 AS ,I F9D MYSELF 9 RELATION NOT M]ELY TO M5 SO F> AS !Y PRES5T 9 !MSELVES ! CONCEPT 0MAN0 OR >E *ILDR5 ( M5 7*ILDR5 ( ,MAN1 AS *ILDR5 ( ,GOD >E SPOK5 (71 BUT ALSO TO ?AT :I* !Y HAVE ( MAN & CALL !IR [N1 & AS !RE=E ,I RELATE MYSELF NOT ONLY TO ?AT :I* !Y >E ?R\< MAN1 BUT ALSO TO !IR HUMAN POSSESSIONS3 SO1 BESIDES ! WORLD ( M51 ! WORLD ( ! S5SES & ( IDEAS WILL HAVE TO BE 9CLUD$ 9 \R SURVEY1 & SOME:AT SAID ( :AT M5 CALL !IR [N ( S5SU\S GOODS1 & ( SPIRITUAL AS WELL4 

,ACCORD+ AS ONE HAD DEVELOP$ & CLE>LY GRASP$ ! CONCEPT ( MAN1 HE GAVE IT TO US TO RESPECT AS ?IS OR ?AT P]SON ( RESPECT1 & FROM ! BROADE/ UND]/&+ ( ?IS CONCEPT !RE PROCE$$ AT LA/ ! COMM& 0TO RESPECT ,MAN 9 EV]Y ONE40 ,BUT IF ,I RESPECT ,MAN1 MY RESPECT MU/ LIKEWISE EXT5D TO ! HUMAN1 OR :AT IS ,MAN'S4 

,M5 HAVE SOME:AT ( !IR [N1 & ,I AM TO RECOGNIZE ?IS [N & HOLD IT SACR$4 ,!IR [N CONSI/S P>TLY 9 \TW>D1 P>TLY 9 9W>D POSSESSIONS4 ,! =M] >E ?+S1 ! LATT] SPIRITUALITIES1 ?\<TS1 CONVICTIONS1 NOBLE FEEL+S4 ,BUT ,I AM ALWAYS TO RESPECT ONLY RI<TFUL OR HUMAN POSSESSIONS3 ! WRONGFUL & UNHUMAN ,I NE$ NOT SP>E1 = ONLY ,MAN'S [N IS M5'S REAL [N4 ,AN 9W>D POSSESSION ( ?IS SORT IS1 = EXAMPLE1 RELIGION2 BECAUSE RELIGION IS FREE1 ?AT IS1 IS ,MAN'S1 ,I MU/ NOT /RIKE AT IT4 ,JU/ SO HONOR IS AN 9W>D POSSESSION2 IT IS FREE & MU/ NOT BE /RUCK AT MY ME4 7,ACTION = 9SULT1 C>ICATURES1 ETC47 ,RELIGION & HONOR >E 0SPIRITUAL PROP]TY40 ,9 TANGIBLE PROP]TY ! P]SON /&S =EMO/3 MY P]SON IS MY FIR/ PROP]TY4 ,H5CE FRE$OM ( ! P]SON2 BUT ONLY ! RI<TFUL OR HUMAN P]SON IS FREE1 ! O!R IS LOCK$ UP4 ,Y\R LIFE IS Y\R PROP]TY2 BUT IT IS SACR$ = M5 ONLY IF IT IS NOT ?AT ( AN 9HUMAN MON/]4 

,:AT A MAN AS SU* CANNOT DEF5D ( BODILY GOODS1 WE MAY TAKE FROM HIM3 ?IS IS ! MEAN+ ( COMPETITION1 ( FRE$OM ( OCCUPATION4 ,:AT HE CANNOT DEF5D ( SPIRITUAL GOODS FALLS A PREY TO US LIKEWISE3 SO F> GOES ! LIB]TY ( DISCUSSION1 ( SCI5CE1 ( CRITICISM4 

,BUT CONSECRAT$ GOODS >E 9VIOLABLE4 ,CONSECRAT$ & GU>ANTI$ BY :OM8 ,PROXIMATELY BY ! /ATE1 SOCIETY1 BUT PROP]LY BY MAN OR ! 0CONCEPT10 ! 0CONCEPT ( ! ?+02 = ! CONCEPT ( CONSECRAT$ GOODS IS ?IS1 ?AT !Y >E TRULY HUMAN1 OR RA!R ?AT ! HOLD] POSSESSES !M AS MAN & NOT AS UN-MAN4 

,ON ! SPIRITUAL SIDE MAN'S FAI? IS SU* GOODS1 HIS HONOR1 HIS MORAL FEEL+ - YES1 HIS FEEL+ ( DEC5CY1 MODE/Y1 ETC4 ,ACTIONS 7SPEE*ES1 WRIT+S7 ?AT T\* HONOR >E PUNI%ABLE2 ATTACKS ON 0! F\NDATIONS ( ALL RELIGION02 ATTACKS ON POLITICAL FAI?2 9 %ORT1 ATTACKS ON EV]Y?+ ?AT A MAN 0RI<TLY0 HAS4 

,H[ F> CRITICAL LIB]ALISM W\LD EXT5D ! SANCTITY ( GOODS - ON ?IS PO9T IT HAS NOT YET MADE ANY PRON\NCEM5T1 & D\BTLESS FANCIES ITSELF TO BE ILL-DISPOS$ T[>D ALL SANCTITY2 BUT1 AS IT COMBATS EGOISM1 IT MU/ SET LIMITS TO IT1 & MU/ NOT LET ! UN-MAN P\NCE ON ! HUMAN4 ,TO ITS !ORETICAL CONTEMPT = ! 0MASSES0 !RE MU/ CORRESPOND A PRACTICAL SNUB IF IT %\LD GET 9TO P[]4 

,:AT EXT5SION ! CONCEPT 0MAN0 RECEIVES1 & :AT COMES TO ! 9DIVIDUAL MAN ?R\< IT - :AT1 !RE=E1 MAN & ! HUMAN >E - ON ?IS PO9T ! V>I\S GRADES ( LIB]ALISM DIFF]1 & ! POLITICAL1 ! SOCIAL1 ! HUMANE MAN >E EA* ALWAYS CLAIM+ MORE ?AN ! O!R = 0MAN40 ,HE :O HAS BE/ GRASP$ ?IS CONCEPT KN[S BE/ :AT IS 0MAN'S40 ,! /ATE /ILL GRASPS ?IS CONCEPT 9 POLITICAL RE/RICTION1 SOCIETY 9 SOCIAL2 MANK9D1 SO IT IS SAID1 IS ! FIR/ TO COMPREH5D IT 5TIRELY1 OR 0! HI/ORY ( MANK9D DEVELOPS IT40 ,BUT1 IF 0MAN IS DISCOV]$10 !N WE KN[ ALSO :AT P]TA9S TO MAN AS HIS [N1 MAN'S PROP]TY1 ! HUMAN4 

,BUT LET ! 9DIVIDUAL MAN LAY CLAIM TO EV] SO MANY RI<TS BECAUSE ,MAN OR ! CONCEPT MAN 05TITLES0 HIM TO !M1 BECAUSE HIS BE+ MAN DOES IT3 :AT DO ,I C>E = HIS RI<T & HIS CLAIM8 ,IF HE HAS HIS RI<T ONLY FROM ,MAN & DOES NOT HAVE IT FROM ME1 !N = ME HE HAS NO RI<T4 ,HIS LIFE1 = EXAMPLE1 C\NTS TO ME ONLY = :AT IT IS WOR? TO ME4 ,I RESPECT NEI!R A SO-CALL$ RI<T ( PROP]TY 7OR HIS CLAIM TO TANGIBLE GOODS7 NOR YET HIS RI<T TO ! 0SANCTU>Y ( HIS 9N] NATURE0 7OR HIS RI<T TO HAVE ! SPIRITUAL GOODS & DIV9ITIES1 HIS GODS1 REMA9 UN-AGGRIEV$74 ,HIS GOODS1 ! S5SU\S AS WELL AS ! SPIRITUAL1 >E M9E1 & ,I DISPOSE ( !M AS PROPRIETOR1 9 ! MEASURE ( MY - MI<T4 

,9 ! PROP]TY QUE/ION LIES A BROAD] MEAN+ ?AN ! LIMIT$ /ATEM5T ( ! QUE/ION ALL[S TO BE BR\<T \T4 ,REF]R$ SOLELY TO :AT M5 CALL \R POSSESSIONS1 IT IS CAPABLE ( NO SOLUTION2 ! DECISION IS TO BE F\ND 9 HIM 0FROM :OM WE HAVE EV]Y?+40 ,PROP]TY DEP5DS ON ! [N]4 

,! ,REVOLUTION DIRECT$ ITS WEAPONS AGA9/ EV]Y?+ :I* CAME 0FROM ! GRACE ( ,GOD10 AGA9/ DIV9E RI<T1 9 :OSE PLACE ! HUMAN WAS CONFIRM$4 ,TO ?AT :I* IS GRANT$ BY ! GRACE ( ,GOD1 !RE IS OPPOS$ ?AT :I* IS D]IV$ 0FROM ! ESS5CE ( MAN40 

,N[1 AS M5'S RELATION TO EA* O!R1 9 OPPOSITION TO ! RELIGI\S DOGMA :I* COMM&S A 0,LOVE ONE ANO!R = ,GOD'S SAKE10 HAD TO RECEIVE ITS HUMAN POSITION BY A 0,LOVE EA* O!R = MAN'S SAKE10 SO ! REVOLUTION>Y TEA*+ C\LD NOT DO O!RWISE ?AN1 FIR/1 AS TO :AT CONC]NS ! RELATION ( M5 TO ! ?+S ( ?IS WORLD1 SETTLE IT ?AT ! WORLD1 :I* HI!RTO WAS >RANG$ ACCORD+ TO ,GOD'S ORD9ANCE1 H5CE=? BELONGS TO 0,MAN40 

,! WORLD BELONGS TO 0,MAN10 & IS TO BE RESPECT$ BY ME AS HIS PROP]TY4 

,PROP]TY IS :AT IS M9E6 

,PROP]TY 9 ! CIVIC S5SE MEANS SACR$ PROP]TY1 SU* ?AT ,I MU/ RESPECT Y\R PROP]TY4 0,RESPECT = PROP]TY60 ,H5CE ! POLITICIANS W\LD LIKE TO HAVE EV]Y ONE POSSESS HIS LITTLE BIT ( PROP]TY1 & !Y HAVE 9 P>T BR\<T AB\T AN 9CR$IBLE P>CELLATION BY ?IS EF=T4 ,EA* MU/ HAVE HIS BONE ON :I* HE MAY F9D SOME?+ TO BITE4 

,! POSITION ( AFFAIRS IS DIFF]5T 9 ! EGOI/IC S5SE4 ,I DO NOT /EP %YLY BACK FROM Y\R PROP]TY1 BUT LOOK UPON IT ALWAYS AS MY PROP]TY1 9 :I* ,I NE$ TO 0RESPECT0 NO?+4 ,PRAY DO ! LIKE ) :AT Y\ CALL MY PROP]TY6 

,) ?IS VIEW WE %ALL MO/ EASILY COME TO AN UND]/&+ ) EA* O!R4 

,! POLITICAL LIB]ALS >E ANXI\S ?AT1 IF POSSIBLE1 ALL S]VITUDES BE DISSOLV$1 & EV]Y ONE BE FREE LORD ON HIS GR\ND1 EV5 IF ?IS GR\ND HAS ONLY SO MU* >EA AS CAN HAVE ITS REQUIREM5TS ADEQUATELY FILL$ BY ! MANURE ( ONE P]SON4 7,! F>M] 9 ! /ORY M>RI$ EV5 9 HIS OLD AGE 0?AT HE MI<T PR(IT BY HIS WIFE'S DUNG .<,KOT.>407 ,BE IT EV] SO LITTLE1 IF ONE ONLY HAS SOME:AT ( HIS [N - NAMELY1 A RESPECT$ PROP]TY6 ,! MORE SU* [N]S1 SU* COTT>S .<,KOTSASS5.>1 ! MORE 0FREE PEOPLE & GOOD PATRIOTS0 HAS ! /ATE4 

,POLITICAL LIB]ALISM1 LIKE EV]Y?+ RELIGI\S1 C\NTS ON RESPECT1 HUMAN5ESS1 ! VIRTUES ( LOVE4 ,!RE=E DOES IT LIVE 9 9CESSANT VEXATION4 ,= 9 PRACTICE PEOPLE RESPECT NO?+1 & EV]Y DAY ! SMALL POSSESSIONS >E B\<T UP AGA9 BY GREAT] PROPRIETORS1 & ! 0FREE PEOPLE0 *ANGE 9TO DAY-LABOR]S4 

,IF1 ON ! CONTR>Y1 ! 0SMALL PROPRIETORS0 HAD REFLECT$ ?AT ! GREAT PROP]TY WAS ALSO !IRS1 !Y W\LD NOT HAVE RESPECTFULLY %UT !MSELVES \T FROM IT1 & W\LD NOT HAVE BE5 %UT \T4 

,PROP]TY AS ! CIVIC LIB]ALS UND]/& IT DES]VES ! ATTACKS ( ! ,COMMUNI/S & ,PR\DHON3 IT IS UNT5ABLE1 BECAUSE ! CIVIC PROPRIETOR IS 9 TRU? NO?+ BUT A PROP]TY-LESS MAN1 ONE :O IS EV]Y:]E %UT \T4 ,9/EAD ( [N+ ! WORLD1 AS HE MI<T1 HE DOES NOT [N EV5 ! PALTRY PO9T ON :I* HE TURNS >\ND4 

,PR\DHON WANTS NOT ! PROPRIETAIRE BUT ! POSSESSEUR OR USUFRUITI]4 ,:AT DOES ?AT MEAN8 ,HE WANTS NO ONE TO [N ! L&2 BUT ! B5EFIT ( IT - EV5 ?\< ONE W]E ALL[$ ONLY ! HUNDR$? P>T ( ?IS B5EFIT1 ?IS FRUIT - IS AT ANY RATE ONE'S PROP]TY1 :I* HE CAN DISPOSE ( AT WILL4 ,HE :O HAS ONLY ! B5EFIT ( A FIELD IS ASSUR$LY NOT ! PROPRIETOR ( IT2 /ILL LESS HE :O1 AS ,PR\DHON W\LD HAVE IT1 MU/ GIVE UP SO MU* ( ?IS B5EFIT AS IS NOT REQUIR$ = HIS WANTS2 BUT HE IS ! PROPRIETOR ( ! %>E ?AT IS LEFT HIM4 ,PR\DHON1 !RE=E1 D5IES ONLY SU* & SU* PROP]TY1 NOT PROP]TY ITSELF4 ,IF WE WANT NO LONG] TO LEAVE ! L& TO ! L&$ PROPRIETORS1 BUT TO APPROPRIATE IT TO \RSELVES1 WE UNITE \RSELVES TO ?IS 5D1 =M A UNION1 A SOCIETE1 ?AT MAKES ITSELF PROPRIETOR2 IF WE HAVE GOOD LUCK 9 ?IS1 !N ?OSE P]SONS CEASE TO BE L&$ PROPRIETORS4 ,&1 AS FROM ! L&1 SO WE CAN DRIVE !M \T ( MANY ANO!R PROP]TY YET1 9 ORD] TO MAKE IT \R PROP]TY1 ! PROP]TY ( ! - CONQU]ORS4 ,! CONQU]ORS =M A SOCIETY :I* ONE MAY IMAG9E SO GREAT ?AT IT BY DEGREES EMBRACES ALL HUMANITY2 BUT SO-CALL$ HUMANITY TOO IS AS SU* ONLY A ?\<T 7SPOOK72 ! 9DIVIDUALS >E ITS REALITY4 ,& !SE 9DIVIDUALS AS A COLLECTIVE 7MASS WILL TREAT L& & E>? NOT LESS >BITR>ILY ?AN AN ISOLAT$ 9DIVIDUAL OR SO-CALL$ PROPRIETAIRE4 ,EV5 SO1 !RE=E1 PROP]TY REMA9S /&+1 & ?AT AS EXCLUSIVE0 TOO1 9 ?AT HUMANITY1 ?IS GREAT SOCIETY1 EXCLUDES ! 9DIVIDUAL FROM ITS PROP]TY 7P]HAPS ONLY LEASES TO HIM1 GIVES HIS AS A FIEF1 A PIECE ( IT7 AS IT BESIDES EXCLUDES EV]Y?+ ?AT IS NOT HUMANITY1 DOES NOT ALL[ ANIMALS TO HAVE PROP]TY4 - ,SO TOO IT WILL REMA91 & WILL GR[ TO BE4 ,?AT 9 :I* ALL WANT TO HAVE A %>E WILL BE )DRAWN FROM ?AT 9DIVIDUAL :O WANTS TO HAVE IT = HIMSELF ALONE3 IT IS MADE A COMMON E/ATE4 ,AS A COMMON E/ATE EV]Y ONE HAS HIS %>E 9 IT1 & ?IS %>E IS HIS PROP]TY4 ,:Y1 SO 9 \R OLD RELATIONS A H\SE :I* BELONGS TO FIVE HEIRS IS !IR COMMON E/ATE2 BUT ! FIF? P>T ( ! REV5UE IS1 EA* ONE'S PROP]TY4 ,PR\DHON MI<T SP>E HIS PROLIX PA?OS IF HE SAID3 0,!RE >E SOME ?+S ?AT BELONG ONLY TO A FEW1 & TO :I* WE O!RS WILL FROM N[ ON LAY CLAIM OR - SIEGE4 ,LET US TAKE !M1 BECAUSE ONE COMES TO PROP]TY BY TAK+1 & ! PROP]TY ( :I* = ! PRES5T WE >E /ILL DEPRIV$ CAME TO ! PROPRIETORS LIKEWISE ONLY BY TAK+4 ,IT CAN BE UTILIZ$ BETT] IF IT IS 9 ! H&S ( US ALL ?AN IF ! FEW CONTROL IT4 ,LET US !RE=E ASSOCIATE \RSELVES = ! PURPOSE ( ?IS ROBB]Y 7VOL 740 - ,9/EAD ( ?IS1 HE TRIES TO GET US TO BELIEVE ?AT SOCIETY IS ! ORIG9AL POSSESSOR & ! SOLE PROPRIETOR1 ( IMP]SCRIPTIBLE RI<T2 AGA9/ IT ! SO-CALL$ PROPRIETORS HAVE BECOME ?IEVES 7,LA PROPRIETE C'E/ LE VOL72 IF IT N[ DEPRIVES ( HIS PROP]TY ! PRES5T PROPRIETOR1 IT ROBS HIM ( NO?+1 AS IT IS ONLY AVAIL+ ITSELF ( ITS IMP]SCRIPTIBLE RI<T4 - ,SO F> ONE COMES ) ! SPOOK ( SOCIETY AS A MORAL P]SON4 ,ON ! CONTR>Y1 :AT MAN CAN OBTA9 BELONGS TO HIM3 ! WORLD BELONGS TO ME4 ,DO Y\ SAY ANY?+ ELSE BY Y\R OPPOSITE PROPOSITION8 0,! WORLD BELONGS TO ALL0 8 ,ALL >E ,I & AGA9 ,I1 ETC4 ,BUT Y\ MAKE \T ( ! 0ALL0 A SPOOK1 & MAKE IT SACR$1 SO ?AT !N ! 0ALL0 BECOME ! 9DIVIDUAL'S FE>FUL MA/]4 ,!N ! <O/ ( 0RI<T0 PLACES ITSELF ON !IR SIDE4 

,PR\DHON1 LIKE ! ,COMMUNI/S1 FI<TS AGA9/ EGOISM4 ,!RE=E !Y >E CONT9UATIONS & CONSI/5T C>RY+S-\T ( ! ,*RI/IAN PR9CIPLE1 ! PR9CIPLE ( LOVE1 ( SACRIFICE = SOME?+ G5]AL1 SOME?+ ALI54 ,!Y COMPLETE 9 PROP]TY1 ONLY :AT HAS LONG BE5 EXTANT AS A MATT] ( FACT - NAMELY1 ! PROP]TYLESSNESS ( ! 9DIVIDUAL4 ,:5 ! LAWS SAYS1 ,AD REGES POTE/AS OMNIUM P]T9ET1 AD S+ULOS PROPRIETAS2 OMNIA REX IMP]IO POSSIDET1 S+ULI DOM9IO1 ?IS MEANS3 ,! K+ IS PROPRIETOR1 = HE ALONE CAN CONTROL & DISPOSE ( 0EV]Y?+10 HE HAS POTE/A & IMP]IUM OV] IT4 ,! ,COMMUNI/S MAKE ?IS CLE>]1 TRANSF]R+ ?AT IMP]IUM TO ! 0SOCIETY ( ALL40 ,!RE=E3 ,BECAUSE 5EMIES ( EGOISM1 !Y >E ON ?AT ACC\NT - ,*RI/IANS1 OR1 MORE G5]ALLY SPEAK+1 RELIGI\S M51 BELIEV]S 9 <O/S1 DEP5D5TS1 S]VANTS ( SOME G5]ALITY 7,GOD1 SOCIETY1 ETC474 ,9 ?IS TOO ,PR\DHON IS LIKE ! ,*RI/IANS1 ?AT HE ASCRIBES TO ,GOD ?AT :I* HE D5IES TO M54 ,HE NAMES HIM 7ON PAGE #i7 ! ,PROPRIETAIRE ( ! E>?4 ,H]E) HE PROVES ?AT HE CANNOT ?9K AWAY ! PROPRIETOR AS SU*2 HE COMES TO A PROPRIETOR AT LA/1 BUT REMOVES HIM TO ! O!R WORLD4 

,NEI!R ,GOD NOR ,MAN 70HUMAN SOCIETY07 IS PROPRIETOR1 BUT ! 9DIVIDUAL4 

,PR\DHON 7,WEITL+ TOO7 ?9KS HE IS TELL+ ! WOR/ AB\T PROP]TY :5 HE CALLS IT !FT 7VOL 74 ,PASS+ QUITE OV] ! EMB>RASS+ QUE/ION1 :AT WELL-F\ND$ OBJECTION C\LD BE MADE AGA9/ !FT1 WE ONLY ASK3 ,IS ! CONCEPT 0!FT0 AT ALL POSSIBLE UNLESS ONE ALL[S VALIDITY TO ! CONCEPT 0PROP]TY08 ,H[ CAN ONE /EAL IF PROP]TY IS NOT ALREADY EXTANT8 ,:AT BELONGS TO NO ONE CANNOT BE /OL52 ! WAT] ?AT ONE DRAWS \T ( ! SEA HE DOES NOT /EAL4 ,ACCORD+LY PROP]TY IS NOT !FT1 BUT A !FT BECOMES POSSIBLE ONLY ?R\< PROP]TY4 ,WEITL+ HAS TO COME TO ?IS TOO1 AS HE DOES REG>D EV]Y?+ AS ! PROP]TY ( ALL3 IF SOME?+ IS 0! PROP]TY ( ALL10 !N 9DE$ ! 9DIVIDUAL :O APPROPRIATES IT TO HIMSELF /EALS4 

,PRIVATE PROP]TY LIVES BY GRACE ( ! LAW4 ,ONLY 9 ! LAW HAS IT ITS W>RANT - = POSSESSION IS NOT YET PROP]TY1 IT BECOMES 0M9E0 ONLY BY ASS5T ( ! LAW2 IT IS NOT A FACT1 NOT UN FAIT AS ,PR\DHON ?9KS1 BUT A FICTION1 A ?\<T4 ,?IS IS LEGAL PROP]TY1 LEGITIMATE PROP]TY1 GU>ANTI$ PROP]TY4 ,IT IS M9E NOT ?R\< ME BUT ?R\< ! - LAW4 

,NEV]!LESS1 PROP]TY IS ! EXPRESSION = UNLIMIT$ DOM9ION OV] SOME:AT 7?+1 BEA/1 MAN7 :I* 0,I CAN JUDGE & DISPOSE ( AS SEEMS GOOD TO ME40 ,ACCORD+ TO ,ROMAN LAW1 9DE$1 JUS UT5DI ET ABUT5DI RE SUA1 QUAT5US JURIS RATIO PATITUR1 AN EXCLUSIVE & UNLIMIT$ RI<T2 BUT PROP]TY IS CONDITION$ BY MI<T4 ,:AT ,I HAVE 9 MY P[]1 ?AT IS MY [N4 ,SO LONG AS ,I ASS]T MYSELF AS HOLD]1 ,I AM ! PROPRIETOR ( ! ?+2 IF IT GETS AWAY FROM ME AGA91 NO MATT] BY :AT P[]1 AS ?R\< MY RECOGNITION ( A TITLE ( O!RS TO ! ?+ - !N ! PROP]TY IS EXT9CT4 ,?US PROP]TY & POSSESSION CO9CIDE4 ,IT IS NOT A RI<T LY+ \TSIDE MY MI<T ?AT LEGITIMIZES ME1 BUT SOLELY MY MI<T3 IF ,I NO LONG] HAVE ?IS1 ! ?+ VANI%ES AWAY FROM ME4 ,:5 ! ,ROMANS NO LONG] HAD ANY MI<T AGA9/ ! ,G]MANS1 ! WORLD-EMPIRE ( ,ROME BELONG$ TO ! LATT]1 & IT W\LD S\ND RIDICUL\S TO 9SI/ ?AT ! ,ROMANS HAD NEV]!LESS REMA9$ PROP]LY ! PROPRIETORS4 ,:OEV] KN[S H[ TO TAKE & TO DEF5D ! ?+1 TO HIM IT BELONGS UNTIL IT IS AGA9 TAK5 FROM HIM1 AS LIB]TY BELONGS TO HIM :O TAKES IT4 

,ONLY MI<T DECIDES AB\T PROP]TY1 &1 AS ! /ATE 7NO MATT] :E!R /ATE OR WELL-TO-DO CITIZ5S OR ( RAGAMUFF9S OR ( M5 9 ! ABSOLUTE7 IS ! SOLE MI<TY ONE1 IT ALONE IS PROPRIETOR2 ,I1 ! UNIQUE1 HAVE NO?+1 & AM ONLY 5FE(F$1 AM VASSAL & AS SU*1 S]VITOR4 ,UND] ! DOM9ION ( ! /ATE !RE IS NO PROP]TY ( M9E4 

,I WANT TO RAISE ! VALUE ( MYSELF1 ! VALUE ( [NNESS1 & %\LD ,I *EAP5 PROP]TY8 ,NO1 AS ,I WAS NOT RESPECT$ HI!RTO BECAUSE PEOPLE1 MANK9D1 & A ?\S& O!R G5]ALITIES W]E PUT HI<]1 SO PROP]TY TOO HAS TO ?IS DAY NOT YET BE5 RECOGNIZ$ 9 ITS FULL VALUE4 ,PROP]TY TOO WAS ONLY ! PROP]TY ( A <O/1 ! PEOPLE'S PROP]TY2 MY :OLE EXI/5CE 0BELONG$ TO ! FA!RL&02 ,I BELONG$ TO ! FA!RL&1 ! PEOPLE1 ! /ATE1 & !RE=E ALSO EV]Y?+ ?AT ,I CALL$ MY [N4 ,IT IS DEM&$ ( /ATES ?AT !Y MAKE AWAY ) PAUP]ISM4 ,IT SEEMS TO ME ?IS IS ASK+ ?AT ! /ATE %\LD CUT (F ITS [N HEAD & LAY IT AT ITS FEET2 = SO LONG AS ! /ATE IS ! EGO ! 9DIVIDUAL EGO MU/ REMA9 A POOR DEVIL1 A NON-EGO4 ,! /ATE HAS AN 9T]E/ ONLY 9 BE+ ITSELF RI*2 :E!R ,MI*AEL IS RI* & ,PET] POOR IS ALIKE TO IT2 ,PET] MI<T ALSO BE RI* & ,MI*AEL POOR4 ,IT LOOKS ON 9DIFF]5TLY AS ONE GR[S POOR & ! O!R RI*1 UNRUFFL$ BY ?IS ALT]NATION4 ,AS 9DIVIDUALS !Y >E REALLY EQUAL BE=E ITS FACE2 9 ?IS IT IS JU/3 BE=E IT BO? ( !M >E - NO?+1 AS WE 0>E ALTOGE!R S9N]S BE=E ,GOD02 ON ! O!R H&1 IT HAS A V]Y GREAT 9T]E/ 9 ?IS1 ?AT ?OSE 9DIVIDUALS :O MAKE IT !IR EGO %\LD HAVE A P>T 9 ITS WEAL?2 IT MAKES !M P>TAK]S 9 ITS PROP]TY4 ,?R\< PROP]TY1 ) :I* IT REW>DS ! 9DIVIDUALS1 IT TAMES !M2 BUT ?IS REMA9S ITS PROP]TY1 & EV]Y ONE HAS ! USUFRUCT ( IT ONLY SO LONG AS HE BE>S 9 HIMSELF ! EGO ( ! /ATE1 OR IS A 0LOYAL MEMB] ( SOCIETY02 9 ! OPPOSITE CASE ! PROP]TY IS CONFISCAT$1 OR MADE TO MELT AWAY BY VEXATI\S LAWSUITS4 ,! PROP]TY1 !N1 IS & REMA9S /ATE PROP]TY1 NOT PROP]TY ( ! EGO4 ,?AT ! /ATE DOES NOT >BITR>ILY DEPRIVE ! 9DIVIDUAL ( :AT HE HAS FROM ! /ATE MEANS SIMPLY ?AT ! /ATE DOES NOT ROB ITSELF4 ,HE :O IS /ATE-EGO1 A GOOD CITIZ5 OR SUBJECT1 HOLDS HIS FIEF UNDI/URB$ AS SU* AN EGO1 NOT AS BE+ AN EGO ( HIS [N4 ,ACCORD+ TO ! CODE1 PROP]TY IS :AT ,I CALL M9E 0BY VIRTUE ( ,GOD & LAW40 ,BUT IT IS M9E BY VIRTUE ( ,GOD & LAW ONLY SO LONG AS - ! /ATE HAS NO?+ AGA9/ IT4 

,9 EXPROPRIATIONS1 DIS>MAM5TS1 & ! LIKE 7AS1 :5 ! EX*EQU] CONFISCATES 9H]ITANCES IF ! HEIRS DO NOT PUT 9 AN APPE>ANCE E>LY 5\<7 H[ PLA9LY ! ELSE-VEIL$ PR9CIPLE ?AT ONLY ! PEOPLE1 0! /ATE10 IS PROPRIETOR1 :ILE ! 9DIVIDUAL IS FE(FEE1 /RIKES ! EYE6 

,! /ATE1 ,I MEAN TO SAY1 CANNOT 9T5D ?AT ANYBODY %\LD = HIS [N SAKE HAVE PROP]TY OR ACTUALLY BE RI*1 9DE$1 EV5 WELL-TO-DO2 IT CAN ACKN[L$GE NO?+1 YIELD NO?+1 GRANT NO?+ TO ME AS ME4 ,! /ATE CANNOT *ECK PAUP]ISM1 BECAUSE ! POV]TY ( POSSESSION IS A POV]TY ( ME4 ,HE :O IS NO?+ BUT :AT *ANCE OR ANO!R - NAMELY1 ! /ATE - MAKES \T ( HIM ALSO HAS QUITE RI<TLY NO?+ BUT :AT ANO!R GIVES HIM4 ,& ?IS O!R WILL GIVE HIM ONLY :AT HE DES]VES1 :AT HE IS WOR? BY S]VICE4 ,IT IS NOT HE ?AT REALIZES A VALUE FROM HIMSELF2 ! /ATE REALIZES A VALUE FROM HIM4 

,POLITICAL ECONOMY .<,NATIONALOKONOMIE.> BUSIES ITSELF MU* ) ?IS SUBJECT4 ,IT LIES F> \T BEYOND ! 0NATIONAL10 H[EV]1 & GOES BEYOND ! CONCEPTS & HORIZON ( ! /ATE1 :I* KN[S ONLY /ATE PROP]TY & CAN DI/RIBUTE NO?+ ELSE4 ,= ?IS REASON IT B9DS ! POSSESSIONS ( PROP]TY TO CONDITIONS - AS IT B9DS EV]Y?+ TO !M1 AS 9 M>RIAGE1 ALL[+ VALIDITY ONLY TO ! M>RIAGE SANCTION$ BY IT1 & WRE/+ ?IS \T ( MY P[]4 ,BUT PROP]TY IS MY PROP]TY ONLY :5 ,I HOLD IT UNCONDITIONALLY 3 ONLY ,I1 AN UNCONDITIONAL EGO1 HAVE PROP]TY1 5T] A RELATION ( LOVE1 C>RY ON FREE TRADE4 

,! /ATE HAS NO ANXIETY AB\T ME & M9E1 BUT AB\T ITSELF & ITS3 ,I C\NT = SOME?+ TO IT ONLY AS ITS *ILD1 AS 0A SON ( ! C\NTRY02 AS EGO ,I AM NO?+ AT ALL = IT4 ,= ! /ATE'S UND]/&+1 :AT BEFALLS ME AS EGO IS SOME?+ ACCID5TAL1 MY WEAL? AS WELL AS MY IMPOV]I%M5T4 ,BUT1 IF ,I ) ALL ?AT IS M9E AM AN ACCID5T 9 ! /ATE'S EYES1 ?IS PROVES ?AT IT CANNOT COMPREH5D ME3 ,I GO BEYOND ITS CONCEPTS1 OR1 ITS UND]/&+ IS TOO LIMIT$ TO COMPREH5D ME4 ,!RE=E IT CANNOT DO ANY?+ = ME EI!R4 

,PAUP]ISM IS ! VALUELESSNESS ( ME1 ! PH5OM5ON ?AT ,I CANNOT REALIZE VALUE FROM MYSELF4 ,= ?IS REASON /ATE & PAUP]ISM >E ONE & ! SAME4 ,! /ATE DOES NOT LET ME COME TO MY VALUE1 & CONT9UES 9 EXI/5CE ONLY ?R\< MY VALUELESSNESS3 IT IS =EV] 9T5T ON GETT+ B5EFIT FROM ME1 EXPLOIT+ ME1 TURN+ ME TO ACC\NT1 US+ ME UP1 EV5 IF ! USE IT GETS FROM ME CONSI/S ONLY 9 MY SUPPLY+ A PROLES 7PROLET>IAT 72 IT WANTS ME TO BE 0ITS CREATURE40 

,PAUP]ISM CAN BE REMOV$ ONLY :5 ,I AS EGO REALIZE VALUE FROM MYSELF1 :5 ,I GIVE MY [N SELF VALUE1 & MAKE MY PRICE MYSELF4 ,I MU/ RISE 9 REVOLT TO RISE 9 ! WORLD4 

,:AT ,I PRODUCE1 FL\R1 L951 OR IRON & COAL1 :I* ,I TOILSOMELY W9 FROM ! E>?1 IS MY WORK ?AT ,I WANT TO REALIZE VALUE FROM4 ,BUT !N ,I MAY LONG COMPLA9 ?AT ,I AM NOT PAID = MY WORK ACCORD+ TO ITS VALUE3 ! PAY] WILL NOT LI/5 TO ME1 & ! /ATE LIKEWISE WILL MA9TA9 AN APA!TIC ATTITUDE SO LONG AS IT DOES NOT ?9K IT MU/ 0APPEASE0 ME ?AT ,I MAY NOT BREAK \T ) MY DREAD$ MI<T4 ,BUT ?IS 0APPEAS+0 WILL BE ALL1 &1 IF IT COMES 9TO MY HEAD TO ASK = MORE1 ! /ATE TURNS AGA9/ ME ) ALL ! =CE ( ITS LION-PAWS & EAGLE-CLAWS3 = IT IS ! K+ ( BEA/S1 IT IS LION & EAGLE4 ,IF ,I REFUSE TO BE CONT5T ) ! PRICE ?AT IT FIXES = MY W>E & LABOR1 IF ,I RA!R ASPIRE TO DET]M9E ! PRICE ( MY W>E MYSELF1 ?AT IS1 0TO PAY MYSELF10 9 ! FIR/ PLACE ,I COME 9TO A CONFLICT ) ! BUY]S ( ! W>E4 ,IF ?IS W]E /ILL$ BY A MUTUAL UND]/&+1 ! /ATE W\LD NOT READILY MAKE OBJECTIONS2 = H[ 9DIVIDUALS GET ALONG ) EA* O!R TR\BLES IT LITTLE1 SO LONG AS !RE9 !Y DO NOT GET 9 ITS WAY4 ,ITS DAMAGE & ITS DANG] BEG9 ONLY :5 !Y DO NOT AGREE1 BUT1 9 ! ABS5CE ( A SETTLEM5T1 TAKE EA* O!R BY ! HAIR4 ,! /ATE CANNOT 5DURE ?AT MAN /& 9 A DIRECT RELATION TO MAN2 IT MU/ /EP BETWE5 AS - M$IATOR1 MU/ - 9T]V5E4 ,:AT ,*RI/ WAS1 :AT ! SA9TS1 ! ,*UR* W]E1 ! /ATE HAS BECOME - NAMELY1 0M$IATOR40 ,IT TE>S MAN FROM MAN TO PUT ITSELF BETWE5 !M AS 0SPIRIT40 ,! LABOR]S :O ASK = HI<] PAY >E TREAT$ AS CRIM9ALS AS SOON AS !Y WANT TO COMPEL IT4 ,:AT >E !Y TO DO8 ,)\T COMPULSION !Y DON'T GET IT1 & 9 COMPULSION ! /ATE SEES A SELF-HELP1 A DET]M9ATION ( PRICE BY ! EGO1 A G5U9E1 FREE REALIZATION ( VALUE FROM HIS PROP]TY1 :I* IT CANNOT ADMIT (4 ,:AT !N >E ! LABOR]S TO DO8 ,LOOK TO !MSELVES & ASK NO?+ AB\T ! /ATE8 

,BUT1 AS IS ! SITUATION ) REG>D TO MY MAT]IAL WORK1 SO IT IS ) MY 9TELLECTUAL TOO4 ,! /ATE ALL[S ME TO REALIZE VALUE FROM ALL MY ?\<TS & TO F9D CU/OM]S = !M 7,I DO REALIZE VALUE FROM !M1 9 ! V]Y FACT ?AT !Y BR+ ME HONOR FROM ! LI/5]S1 & ! LIKE72 BUT ONLY SO LONG AS MY ?\<TS >E - ITS ?\<TS4 ,IF1 ON ! O!R H&1 ,I H>BOR ?\<TS ?AT IT CANNOT APPROVE 7MAKE ITS [N71 !N IT DOES NOT ALL[ ME AT ALL TO REALIZE VALUE FROM !M1 TO BR+ !M 9TO EX*ANGE 9TO COMM]CE4 ,MY ?\<TS >E FREE ONLY IF !Y >E GRANT$ TO ME BY ! /ATE'S GRACE1 IF !Y >E ! /ATE'S ?\<TS4 ,IT LETS ME PHILOSOPHIZE FREELY ONLY SO F> AS ,I APPROVE MYSELF A 0PHILOSOPH] ( /ATE02 AGA9/ ! /ATE ,I MU/ NOT PHILOSOPHIZE1 GLADLY AS IT TOL]ATES MY HELP+ IT \T ( ITS 0DEFICI5CIES10 0FUR!R+0 IT4 - ,!RE=E1 AS ,I MAY BEHAVE ONLY AS AN EGO MO/ GRACI\SLY P]MITT$ BY ! /ATE1 PROVID$ ) ITS TE/IMONIAL ( LEGITIMACY & POLICE PASS1 SO TOO IT IS NOT GRANT$ ME TO REALIZE VALUE FROM :AT IS M9E1 UNLESS ?IS PROVES TO BE ITS1 :I* ,I HOLD AS FIEF FROM IT4 ,MY WAYS MU/ BE ITS WAYS1 ELSE IT DI/RA9S ME2 MY ?\<TS ITS ?\<TS1 ELSE IT /OPS MY M\?4 

,! /ATE HAS NO?+ TO BE MORE AFRAID ( ?AN ! VALUE ( ME1 & NO?+ MU/ IT MORE C>EFULLY GU>D AGA9/ ?AN EV]Y OCCASION ?AT (F]S ITSELF TO ME = REALIZ+ VALUE FROM MYSELF4 ,I AM ! DEADLY 5EMY ( ! /ATE1 :I* ALWAYS HOV]S BETWE5 ! ALT]NATIVES1 IT OR ,I4 ,!RE=E IT /RICTLY 9SI/S NOT ONLY ON NOT LETT+ ME HAVE A /&+1 BUT ALSO ON KEEP+ D[N :AT IS M9E4 ,9 ! /ATE !RE IS NO PROP]TY1 NO PROP]TY ( ! 9DIVIDUAL1 BUT ONLY /ATE PROP]TY4 ,ONLY ?R\< ! /ATE HAVE ,I :AT ,I HAVE1 AS ,I AM ONLY ?R\< IT :AT ,I AM4 ,MY PRIVATE PROP]TY IS ONLY ?AT :I* ! /ATE LEAVES TO ME ( ITS1 CUTT+ (F O!RS FROM IT 7MAK+ IT PRIVATE72 IT IS /ATE PROP]TY4 

,BUT1 9 OPPOSITION TO ! /ATE1 ,I FEEL MORE & MORE CLE>LY ?AT !RE IS /ILL LEFT ME A GREAT MI<T1 ! MI<T OV] MYSELF1 OV] EV]Y?+ ?AT P]TA9S ONLY TO ME & ?AT EXI/S ONLY 9 BE+ MY [N4 

,:AT DO ,I DO IF MY WAYS >E NO LONG] ITS WAYS1 MY ?\<TS NO LONG] ITS ?\<TS8 ,I LOOK TO MYSELF1 & ASK NO?+ AB\T IT6 ,9 MY ?\<TS1 :I* ,I GET SANCTION$ BY NO ASS5T1 GRANT1 OR GRACE1 ,I HAVE MY REAL PROP]TY1 A PROP]TY ) :I* ,I CAN TRADE4 ,= AS M9E !Y >E MY CREATURES1 & ,I AM 9 A POSITION TO GIVE !M AWAY 9 RETURN = O!R ?\<TS3 ,I GIVE !M UP & TAKE 9 EX*ANGE = !M O!RS1 :I* !N >E MY NEW PUR*AS$ PROP]TY4 

,:AT !N IS MY PROP]TY8 ,NO?+ BUT :AT IS 9 MY P[]6 ,TO :AT PROP]TY AM ,I 5TITL$8 ,TO EV]Y PROP]TY TO :I* ,I - EMP[] MYSELF4 ,I GIVE MYSELF ! RI<T ( PROP]TY 9 TAK+ PROP]TY TO MYSELF1 OR GIV+ MYSELF ! PROPRIETOR'S P[]1 FULL P[]1 EMP[]M5T4 

,EV]Y?+ OV] :I* ,I HAVE MI<T ?AT CANNOT BE TORN FROM ME REMA9S MY PROP]TY2 WELL1 !N LET MI<T DECIDE AB\T PROP]TY1 & ,I WILL EXPECT EV]Y?+ FROM MY MI<T6 ,ALI5 MI<T1 MI<T ?AT ,I LEAVE TO ANO!R1 MAKES ME AN [N$ SLAVE3 !N LET MY [N MI<T MAKE ME AN [N]4 ,LET ME !N )DRAW ! MI<T ?AT ,I HAVE CONC$$ TO O!RS \T ( IGNORANCE REG>D+ ! /R5G? ( MY [N MI<T6 ,LET ME SAY TO MYSELF1 :AT MY MI<T REA*ES TO IS MY PROP]TY2 & LET ME CLAIM AS PROP]TY EV]Y?+ ?AT ,I FEEL MYSELF /RONG 5\< TO ATTA91 & LET ME EXT5D MY ACTUAL PROP]TY AS F> AS ,I 5TITLE1 ?AT IS1 EMP[]1 MYSELF TO TAKE4 

,H]E EGOISM1 SELFI%NESS1 MU/ DECIDE2 NOT ! PR9CIPLE ( LOVE1 NOT LOVE-MOTIVES LIKE M]CY1 G5TL5ESS1 GOOD-NATURE1 OR EV5 JU/ICE & EQUITY 7= JU/ITIA TOO IS A PH5OM5ON ( - LOVE1 A PRODUCT ( LOVE73 LOVE KN[S ONLY SACRIFICES & DEM&S 0SELF-SACRIFICE40 

,EGOISM DOES NOT ?9K ( SACRIFIC+ ANY?+1 GIV+ AWAY ANY?+ ?AT IT WANTS2 IT SIMPLY DECIDES1 :AT ,I WANT ,I MU/ HAVE & WILL PROCURE4 

,ALL ATTEMPTS TO 5ACT RATIONAL LAWS AB\T PROP]TY HAVE PUT \T FROM ! BAY ( LOVE 9TO A DESOLATE SEA ( REGULATIONS4 ,EV5 ,SOCIALISM & ,COMMUNISM CANNOT BE EXCEPT$ FROM ?IS4 ,EV]Y ONE IS TO BE PROVID$ ) ADEQUATE MEANS1 = :I* IT IS LITTLE TO ! PO9T :E!R ONE SOCIALI/ICALLY F9DS !M /ILL 9 A P]SONAL PROP]TY1 OR COMMUNI/ICALLY DRAWS !M FROM ! COMMUNITY ( GOODS4 ,! 9DIVIDUAL'S M9D 9 ?IS REMA9S ! SAME2 IT REMA9S A M9D ( DEP5D5CE4 ,! DI/RIBUT+ BO>D ( EQUITY LETS ME HAVE ONLY :AT ! S5SE ( EQUITY1 ITS LOV+ C>E = ALL1 PRESCRIBES4 ,= ME1 ! 9DIVIDUAL1 !RE LIES NO LESS ( A *ECK 9 COLLECTIVE WEAL? ?AN 9 ?AT ( 9DIVIDUAL O!RS2 NEI!R ?AT IS M9E1 NOR ?IS3 :E!R ! WEAL? BELONGS TO ! COLLECTIVITY1 :I* CONF]S P>T ( IT ON ME1 OR TO 9DIVIDUAL POSSESSORS1 IS = ME ! SAME CON/RA9T1 AS ,I CANNOT DECIDE AB\T EI!R ( ! TWO4 ,ON ! CONTR>Y1 ,COMMUNISM1 BY ! ABOLITION ( ALL P]SONAL PROP]TY1 ONLY PRESSES ME BACK /ILL MORE 9TO DEP5D5CE ON ANO!R1 NAMELY1 ON ! G5]ALITY OR COLLECTIVITY2 &1 L\DLY AS IT ALWAYS ATTACKS ! 0/ATE10 :AT IT 9T5DS IS ITSELF AGA9 A /ATE1 A /ATUS1 A CONDITION H9D]+ MY FREE MOVEM5T1 A SOV]EIGN P[] OV] ME4 ,COMMUNISM RI<TLY REVOLTS AGA9/ ! PRESSURE ?AT ,I EXP]I5CE FROM 9DIVIDUAL PROPRIETORS2 BUT /ILL MORE HORRIBLE IS ! MI<T ?AT IT PUTS 9 ! H&S ( ! COLLECTIVITY4 

,EGOISM TAKES ANO!R WAY TO ROOT \T ! NON-POSSESS+ RABBLE4 ,IT DOES NOT SAY3 ,WAIT = :AT ! BO>D ( EQUITY WILL - BE/[ ON Y\ 9 ! NAME ( ! COLLECTIVITY 7= SU* BE/[AL TOOK PLACE 9 0/ATES0 FROM ! MO/ ANCI5T TIMES1 EA* RECEIV+ 0ACCORD+ TO HIS DES]T10 & !RE=E ACCORD+ TO ! MEASURE 9 :I* EA* WAS ABLE TO DES]VE .<V]DI55.> IT1 TO ACQUIRE IT BY S]VICE .<]DI55.>71 BUT3 ,TAKE HOLD1 & TAKE :AT Y\ REQUIRE6 ,) ?IS ! W> ( ALL AGA9/ ALL IS DECL>$4 ,I ALONE DECIDE :AT ,I WILL HAVE4 

0,N[1 ?AT IS TRULY NO NEW WISDOM1 = SELF-SEEK]S HAVE ACT$ SO AT ALL TIMES60 ,NOT AT ALL NECESS>Y EI!R ?AT ! ?+ BE NEW1 IF ONLY CONSCI\SNESS ( IT IS PRES5T4 ,BUT ?IS LATT] WILL NOT BE ABLE TO CLAIM GREAT AGE1 UNLESS P]HAPS ONE C\NTS 9 ! ,EGYPTIAN & ,SP>TAN LAW2 = H[ LITTLE CURR5T IT IS APPE>S EV5 FROM ! /RICTURE ABOVE1 :I* SPEAKS ) CONTEMPT ( 0SELF-SEEK]S40 ,ONE IS TO KN[ JU/ ?IS1 ?AT ! PROC$URE ( TAK+ HOLD IS NOT CONTEMPTIBLE1 BUT MANIFE/S ! PURE DE$ ( ! EGOI/ AT ONE ) HIMSELF4 

,ONLY :5 ,I EXPECT NEI!R FROM 9DIVIDUALS NOR FROM A COLLECTIVITY :AT ,I CAN GIVE TO MYSELF1 ONLY !N DO ,I SLIP \T ( ! SN>ES ( - LOVE2 ! RABBLE CEASES TO BE RABBLE ONLY :5 IT TAKES HOLD4 ,ONLY ! DREAD ( TAK+ HOLD1 & ! CORRESPOND+ PUNI%M5T !RE(1 MAKES IT A RABBLE4 ,ONLY ?AT TAK+ HOLD IS S91 CRIME - ONLY ?IS DOGMA CREATES A RABBLE4 ,= ! FACT ?AT ! RABBLE REMA9S :AT IT IS1 IT 7BECAUSE IT ALL[S VALIDITY TO ?AT DOGMA7 IS TO BLAME AS WELL AS1 MORE ESPECIALLY1 ?OSE :O 0SELF-SEEK+LY0 7TO GIVE !M BACK !IR FAVORITE WORD7 DEM& ?AT ! DOGMA BE RESPECT$4 ,9 %ORT1 ! LACK ( CONSCI\SNESS ( ?AT 0NEW WISDOM10 ! OLD CONSCI\SNESS ( S91 ALONE BE>S ! BLAME4 

,IF M5 REA* ! PO9T ( LOS+ RESPECT = PROP]TY1 EV]Y ONE WILL HAVE PROP]TY1 AS ALL SLAVES BECOME FREE M5 AS SOON AS !Y NO LONG] RESPECT ! MA/] AS MA/]4 ,UNIONS WILL !N1 9 ?IS MATT] TOO1 MULTIPLY ! 9DIVIDUAL'S MEANS & SECURE HIS ASSAIL$ PROP]TY4 

,ACCORD+ TO ! ,COMMUNI/S' OP9ION ! COMMUNE %\LD BE PROPRIETOR4 ,ON ! CONTR>Y1 ,I AM PROPRIETOR1 & ,I ONLY COME TO AN UND]/&+ ) O!RS AB\T MY PROP]TY4 ,IF ! COMMUNE DOES NOT DO :AT SUITS ME1 ,I RISE AGA9/ IT & DEF5D MY PROP]TY4 ,I AM PROPRIETOR1 BUT PROP]TY IS NOT SACR$4 ,I %\LD BE M]ELY POSSESSOR8 ,NO1 HI!RTO ONE WAS ONLY POSSESSOR1 SECUR$ 9 ! POSSESSION ( A P>CEL BY LEAV+ O!RS ALSO 9 POSSESSION ( A P>CEL2 BUT N[ EV]Y?+ BELONGS TO ME1 ,I AM PROPRIETOR ( EV]Y?+ ?AT ,I REQUIRE & CAN GET POSSESSION (4 ,IF IT IS SAID SOCIALI/ICALLY1 SOCIETY GIVES ME :AT ,I REQUIRE - !N ! EGOI/ SAYS1 ,I TAKE :AT ,I REQUIRE4 ,IF ! ,COMMUNI/S CONDUCT !MSELVES AS RAGAMUFF9S1 ! EGOI/ BEHAVES AS PROPRIETOR4 

,ALL SWAN-FRAT]NITIES1 & ATTEMPTS AT MAK+ ! RABBLE HAPPY1 ?AT SPR+ FROM ! PR9CIPLE ( LOVE1 MU/ MISC>RY4 ,ONLY FROM EGOISM CAN ! RABBLE GET HELP1 & ?IS HELP IT MU/ GIVE TO ITSELF & - WILL GIVE TO ITSELF4 ,IF IT DOES NOT LET ITSELF BE CO]C$ 9TO FE>1 IT IS A P[]4 0,PEOPLE W\LD LOSE ALL RESPECT IF ONE DID NOT CO]CE !M 9TO FE>10 SAYS BUGBE> ,LAW 9 ,D] GE/IEFELTE ,KAT]4 

,PROP]TY1 !RE=E1 %\LD NOT & CANNOT BE ABOLI%$2 IT MU/ RA!R BE TORN FROM <O/LY H&S & BECOME MY PROP]TY2 !N ! ]RONE\S CONSCI\SNESS1 ?AT ,I CANNOT 5TITLE MYSELF TO AS MU* AS ,I REQUIRE1 WILL VANI%4 

0,BUT :AT CANNOT MAN REQUIRE60 ,WELL1 :OEV] REQUIRES MU*1 & UND]/&S H[ TO GET IT1 HAS AT ALL TIMES HELP$ HIMSELF TO IT1 AS ,NAPOLEON DID ) ! ,CONT95T & ,FRANCE ) ,ALGI]S4 ,H5CE ! EXACT PO9T IS ?AT ! RESPECTFUL 0RABBLE0 %\LD LE>N AT LA/ TO HELP ITSELF TO :AT IT REQUIRES4 ,IF IT REA*ES \T TOO F> = Y\1 :Y1 !N DEF5D Y\RSELVES4 ,Y\ HAVE NO NE$ AT ALL TO GOOD-HE>T$LY - BE/[ ANY?+ ON IT2 &1 :5 IT LE>NS TO KN[ ITSELF1 IT - OR RA!R3 :OEV] ( ! RABBLE LE>NS TO KN[ HIMSELF1 HE - CA/S (F ! RABBLE-QUALITY 9 REFUS+ Y\R ALMS ) ?ANKS4 ,BUT IT REMA9S RIDICUL\S ?AT Y\ DECL>E ! RABBLE 0S9FUL & CRIM9AL0 IF IT IS NOT PLEAS$ TO LIVE FROM Y\R FAVORS BECAUSE IT CAN DO SOME?+ 9 ITS [N FAVOR4 ,Y\R BE/[ALS *EAT IT & PUT IT (F4 ,DEF5D Y\R PROP]TY1 !N Y\ WILL BE /RONG2 IF1 ON ! O!R H&1 Y\ WANT TO RETA9 Y\R ABILITY TO BE/[1 & P]HAPS ACTUALLY HAVE ! MORE POLITICAL RI<TS ! MORE ALMS 7POOR-RATES7 Y\ CAN GIVE1 ?IS WILL WORK JU/ AS LONG AS ! RECIPI5TS LET Y\ WORK IT4 

,9 %ORT1 ! PROP]TY QUE/ION CANNOT BE SOLV$ SO AMICABLY AS ! ,SOCIALI/S1 YES1 EV5 ! ,COMMUNI/S1 DREAM4 ,IT IS SOLV$ ONLY BY ! W> ( ALL AGA9/ ALL4 ,! POOR BECOME FREE & PROPRIETORS ONLY :5 !Y - RISE4 ,BE/[ EV] SO MU* ON !M1 !Y WILL /ILL ALWAYS WANT MORE2 = !Y WANT NO?+ LESS ?AN ?AT AT LA/ - NO?+ MORE BE BE/[$4 

,IT WILL BE ASK$1 BUT H[ !N WILL IT BE :5 ! HAVE-NOTS TAKE HE>T8 ,( :AT SORT IS ! SETTLEM5T TO BE8 ,ONE MI<T AS WELL ASK ?AT ,I CA/ A *ILD'S NATIVITY4 ,:AT A SLAVE WILL DO AS SOON AS HE HAS BROK5 HIS FETT]S1 ONE MU/ - AWAIT4 

,9 ,KAIS]'S PAMPHLET 7,DIE ,P]SONLI*KEIT DES ,EIG5TUM]S44471 WOR?LESS = LACK ( =M AS WELL AS SUB/ANCE1 HE HOPES FROM ! /ATE ?AT IT WILL BR+ AB\T A LEVEL+ ( PROP]TY4 ,ALWAYS ! /ATE6 ,H]R ,PAPA6 ,AS ! ,*UR* WAS PROCLAIM$ & LOOK$ UPON AS ! 0MO!R0 ( BELIEV]S1 SO ! /ATE HAS ALTOGE!R ! FACE ( ! PROVID5T FA!R4 

,COMPETITION %[S ITSELF MO/ /RICTLY CONNECT$ ) ! PR9CIPLE ( CIVISM4 ,IS IT ANY?+ ELSE ?AN EQUALITY 7EGALITE78 ,& IS NOT EQUALITY A PRODUCT ( ?AT SAME ,REVOLUTION :I* WAS BR\<T ON BY ! COMMONALTY1 ! MIDDLE CLASSES8 ,AS NO ONE IS B>R$ FROM COMPET+ ) ALL 9 ! /ATE 7EXCEPT ! PR9CE1 BECAUSE HE REPRES5TS ! /ATE ITSELF7 & WORK+ HIMSELF UP TO !IR HEI<T1 YES1 OV]?R[+ OR EXPLOIT+ !M = HIS [N ADVANTAGE1 SO>+ ABOVE !M & BY /RONG] EX]TION DEPRIV+ !M ( !IR FAVORABLE CIRCUM/ANCES - ?IS S]VES AS A CLE> PRO( ?AT BE=E ! /ATE'S JUDGM5T-SEAT EV]Y ONE HAS ONLY ! VALUE ( A 0SIMPLE 9DIVIDUAL0 & MAY NOT C\NT ON ANY FAVORITISM4 ,\TRUN & \TBID EA* O!R AS MU* AS Y\ LIKE & CAN2 ?AT %ALL NOT TR\BLE ME1 ! /ATE6 ,AMONG Y\RSELVES Y\ >E FREE 9 COMPET+1 Y\ >E COMPETITORS2 ?AT IS Y\R SOCIAL POSITION4 ,BUT BE=E ME1 ! /ATE1 Y\ >E NO?+ BUT 0SIMPLE 9DIVIDUALS06 

,:AT 9 ! =M ( PR9CIPLE OR !ORY WAS PROP\ND$ AS ! EQUALITY ( ALL HAS F\ND H]E 9 COMPETITION ITS REALIZATION & PRACTICAL C>RY+ \T2 = EGALITE IS - FREE COMPETITION4 ,ALL >E1 BE=E ! /ATE - SIMPLE 9DIVIDUALS2 9 SOCIETY1 OR 9 RELATION TO EA* O!R - COMPETITORS4 

,I NE$ BE NO?+ FUR!R ?AN A SIMPLE 9DIVIDUAL TO BE ABLE TO COMPETE ) ALL O!RS ASIDE FROM ! PR9CE & HIS FAMILY3 A FRE$OM :I* =M]LY WAS MADE IMPOSSIBLE BY ! FACT ?AT ONLY BY MEANS ( ONE'S CORPORATION1 & )9 IT1 DID ONE 5JOY ANY FRE$OM ( EF=T4 

,9 ! GUILD & FEUDALITY ! /ATE IS 9 AN 9TOL]ANT & FA/IDI\S ATTITUDE1 GRANT+ PRIVILEGES2 9 COMPETITION & LIB]ALISM IT IS 9 A TOL]ANT & 9DULG5T ATTITUDE1 GRANT+ ONLY PAT5TS 7LETT]S ASSUR+ ! APPLICANT ?AT ! BUS9ESS /&S OP5 7PAT5T7 TO HIM7 OR 0CONCESSIONS40 ,N[1 AS ! /ATE HAS ?US LEFT EV]Y?+ TO ! APPLICANTS1 IT MU/ COME 9 CONFLICT ) ALL1 BECAUSE EA* & ALL >E 5TITL$ TO MAKE APPLICATION4 ,IT WILL BE 0/ORM$10 & WILL GO D[N 9 ?IS /ORM4 

,IS 0FREE COMPETITION0 !N REALLY 0FREE80 9DE$1 IS IT REALLY A 0COMPETITION0 - NAMELY1 ONE ( P]SONS - AS IT GIVES ITSELF \T TO BE BECAUSE ON ?IS TITLE IT BASES ITS RI<T8 ,IT ORIG9AT$1 Y\ KN[1 9 P]SONS BECOM+ FREE ( ALL P]SONAL RULE4 ,IS A COMPETITION 0FREE0 :I* ! /ATE1 ?IS RUL] 9 ! CIVIC PR9CIPLE1 HEMS 9 BY A ?\S& B>RI]S8 ,!RE IS A RI* MANUFACTUR] DO+ A BRILLIANT BUS9ESS1 & ,I %\LD LIKE TO COMPETE ) HIM4 0,GO AHEAD10 SAYS ! /ATE1 0,I HAVE NO OBJECTION TO MAKE TO Y\R P]SON AS COMPETITOR40 ,YES1 ,I REPLY1 BUT = ?AT ,I NE$ A SPACE = BUILD+S1 ,I NE$ MONEY6 0,?AT'S BAD2 BUT1 IF Y\ HAVE NO MONEY1 Y\ CANNOT COMPETE4 ,Y\ MU/ NOT TAKE ANY?+ FROM ANYBODY1 = ,I PROTECT PROP]TY & GRANT IT PRIVILEGES40 ,FREE COMPETITION IS NOT 0FREE10 BECAUSE ,I LACK ! ?+S = COMPETITION4 ,AGA9/ MY P]SON NO OBJECTION CAN BE MADE1 BUT BECAUSE ,I HAVE NOT ! ?+S MY P]SON TOO MU/ /EP TO ! RE>4 ,& :O HAS ! NECESS>Y ?+S8 ,P]HAPS ?AT MANUFACTUR]8 ,:Y1 FROM HIM ,I C\LD TAKE !M AWAY6 ,NO1 ! /ATE HAS !M AS PROP]TY1 ! MANUFACTUR] ONLY AS FIEF1 AS POSSESSION4 

,BUT1 S9CE IT IS NO USE TRY+ IT ) ! MANUFACTUR]1 ,I WILL COMPETE ) ?AT PR(ESSOR ( JURISPRUD5CE2 ! MAN IS A BOOBY1 & ,I1 :O KN[ A HUNDR$ TIMES MORE ?AN HE1 %ALL MAKE HIS CLASS-ROOM EMPTY4 0,HAVE Y\ /UDI$ & GRADUAT$1 FRI5D80 ,NO1 BUT :AT ( ?AT8 ,I UND]/& ABUNDANTLY :AT IS NECESS>Y = 9/RUCTION 9 ?AT DEP>TM5T4 0,SORRY1 BUT COMPETITION IS NOT 'FREE' H]E4 ,AGA9/ Y\R P]SON !RE IS NO?+ TO BE SAID1 BUT ! ?+1 ! DOCTOR'S DIPLOMA1 IS LACK+4 ,& ?IS DIPLOMA ,I1 ! /ATE1 DEM&4 ,ASK ME = IT RESPECTFULLY FIR/2 !N WE WILL SEE :AT IS TO BE DONE40 

,?IS1 !RE=E1 IS ! 0FRE$OM0 ( COMPETITION4 ,! /ATE1 MY LORD1 FIR/ QUALIFIES ME TO COMPETE4 

,BUT DO P]SONS REALLY COMPETE8 ,NO1 AGA9 ?+S ONLY6 ,MONEYS 9 ! FIR/ PLACE1 ETC4 

,9 ! RIVALRY ONE WILL ALWAYS BE LEFT BEH9D ANO!R 7AS1 A POETA/] BEH9D A POET74 ,BUT IT MAKES A DIFF]5CE :E!R ! MEANS ?AT ! UNLUCKY COMPETITOR LACKS >E P]SONAL OR MAT]IAL1 & LIKEWISE :E!R ! MAT]IAL MEANS CAN BE WON BY P]SONAL 5]GY OR >E TO BE OBTA9$ ONLY BY GRACE1 ONLY AS A PRES5T2 AS :5 ! POOR] MAN MU/ LEAVE1 ?AT IS1 PRES5T1 TO ! RI* MAN HIS RI*ES4 ,BUT1 IF ,I MU/ ALL ALONG WAIT = ! /ATE'S APPROVAL TO OBTA9 OR TO USE 7AS 9 ! CASE ( GRADUATION7 ! MEANS1 ,I HAVE ! MEANS BY ! GRACE ( ! /ATE4 

,FREE COMPETITION1 !RE=E1 HAS ONLY ! FOLL[+ MEAN+3 ,TO ! /ATE ALL RANK AS ITS EQUAL *ILDR51 & EV]Y ONE CAN SCUD & RUN TO E>N ! /ATE'S GOODS & L>GESSE4 ,!RE=E ALL DO *ASE AFT] HAV+S1 HOLD+S1 POSSESSIONS 7BE IT ( MONEY OR (FICES1 TITLES ( HONOR1 ETC471 AFT] ! ?+S4 

,9 ! M9D ( ! COMMONALTY EV]Y ONE IS POSSESSOR OR 0[N]40 ,N[1 :5CE COMES IT ?AT ! MO/ HAVE 9 FACT NEXT TO NO?+8 ,FROM ?IS1 ?AT ! MO/ >E ALREADY JOYFUL OV] BE+ POSSESSORS AT ALL1 EV5 ?\< IT BE ( SOME RAGS1 AS *ILDR5 >E JOYFUL 9 !IR FIR/ TR\S]S OR EV5 ! FIR/ P5NY ?AT IS PRES5T$ TO !M4 ,MORE PRECISELY1 H[EV]1 ! MATT] IS TO BE TAK5 AS FOLL[S4 ,LIB]ALISM CAME =W>D AT ONCE ) ! DECL>ATION ?AT IT BELONG$ TO MAN'S ESS5CE NOT TO BE PROP]TY1 BUT PROPRIETOR4 ,AS ! CONSID]ATION H]E WAS AB\T 0MAN10 NOT AB\T ! 9DIVIDUAL1 ! H[-MU* 7:I* =M$ EXACTLY ! PO9T ( ! 9DIVIDUAL'S SPECIAL 9T]E/7 WAS LEFT TO HIM4 ,H5CE ! 9DIVIDUAL'S EGOISM RETA9$ ROOM = ! FREE/ PLAY 9 ?IS H[-MU*1 & C>RI$ ON AN 9DEFATIGABLE COMPETITION4 

,H[EV]1 ! LUCKY EGOISM HAD TO BECOME A SNAG 9 ! WAY ( ! LESS =TUNATE1 & ! LATT]1 /ILL KEEP+ ITS FEET PLANT$ ON ! PR9CIPLE ( HUMANITY1 PUT =W>D ! QUE/ION AS TO H[-MU* ( POSSESSION1 & ANSW]$ IT TO ! EFFECT ?AT 0MAN MU/ HAVE AS MU* AS HE REQUIRES40 

,WILL IT BE POSSIBLE = MY EGOISM TO LET ITSELF BE SATISFI$ ) ?AT8 ,:AT 0MAN0 REQUIRES FURNI%ES BY NO MEANS A SCALE = MEASUR+ ME & MY NE$S2 = ,I MAY HAVE USE = LESS OR MORE4 ,I MU/ RA!R HAVE SO MU* AS ,I AM COMPET5T TO APPROPRIATE4 

,COMPETITION SUFF]S FROM ! UNFAVORABLE CIRCUM/ANCE ?AT ! MEANS = COMPET+ >E NOT AT EV]Y ONE'S COMM&1 BECAUSE !Y >E NOT TAK5 FROM P]SONALITY1 BUT FROM ACCID5T4 ,MO/ >E )\T MEANS1 & = ?IS REASON )\T GOODS4 

,H5CE ! ,SOCIALI/S DEM& ! MEANS = ALL1 & AIM AT A SOCIETY ?AT %ALL (F] MEANS4 ,Y\R MONEY VALUE1 SAY !Y1 WE NO LONG] RECOGNIZE AS Y\R 0COMPET5CE02 Y\ MU/ %[ ANO!R COMPET5CE - NAMELY1 Y\R WORK+ =CE4 ,9 ! POSSESSION ( A PROP]TY1 OR AS 0POSSESSOR10 MAN DOES C]TA9LY %[ HIMSELF AS MAN2 IT WAS = ?IS REASON ?AT WE LET ! POSSESSOR1 :OM WE CALL$ 0PROPRIETOR10 KEEP HIS /&+ SO LONG4 ,YET Y\ POSSESS ! ?+S ONLY SO LONG AS Y\ >E NOT 0PUT \T ( ?IS PROP]TY40 

,! POSSESSOR IS COMPET5T1 BUT ONLY SO F> AS ! O!RS >E 9COMPET5T4 ,S9CE Y\R W>E =MS Y\R COMPET5CE ONLY SO LONG AS Y\ >E COMPET5T TO DEF5D IT 7AS WE >E NOT COMPET5T TO DO ANY?+ ) IT71 LOOK AB\T Y\ = ANO!R COMPET5CE2 = WE N[1 BY \R MI<T1 SURPASS Y\R ALLEG$ COMPET5CE4 

,IT WAS AN EXTRAORD9>ILY L>GE GA9 MADE1 :5 ! PO9T ( BE+ REG>D$ AS POSSESSORS WAS PUT ?R\<4 ,!RE9 BONDS]VICE WAS ABOLI%$1 & EV]Y ONE :O UNTIL !N HAD BE5 B\ND TO ! LORD'S S]VICE1 & MORE OR LESS HAD BE5 HIS PROP]TY1 N[ BECAME A 0LORD40 ,BUT H5CE=? Y\R HAV+1 & :AT Y\ HAVE1 >E NO LONG] ADEQUATE & NO LONG] RECOGNIZ$2 P] CONTRA1 Y\R WORK+ & Y\R WORK RISE 9 VALUE4 ,WE N[ RESPECT Y\R SUBDU+ ?+S1 AS WE =M]LY DID Y\R POSSESS+ !M4 ,Y\R WORK IS Y\R COMPET5CE6 ,Y\ >E LORD OR POSSESSOR ONLY ( :AT COMES BY WORK1 NOT BY 9H]ITANCE4 ,BUT AS AT ! TIME EV]Y?+ HAS COME BY 9H]ITANCE1 & EV]Y COPP] ?AT Y\ POSSESS BE>S NOT A LABOR-/AMP BUT AN 9H]ITANCE-/AMP1 EV]Y?+ MU/ BE MELT$ OV]4 

,BUT IS MY WORK !N REALLY1 AS ! ,COMMUNI/S SUPPOSE1 MY SOLE COMPET5CE8 OR DOES NOT ?IS CONSI/ RA!R 9 EV]Y?+ ?AT ,I AM COMPET5T =8 ,& DOES NOT ! WORK]S' SOCIETY ITSELF HAVE TO CONC$E ?IS1 9 SUPPORT+ ALSO ! SICK1 *ILDR51 OLD M5 - 9 %ORT1 ?OSE :O >E 9CAPABLE ( WORK8 ,!SE >E /ILL COMPET5T = A GOOD DEAL1 = 9/ANCE1 TO PRES]VE !IR LIFE 9/EAD ( TAK+ IT4 ,IF !Y >E COMPET5T TO CAUSE Y\ TO DESIRE !IR CONT9U$ EXI/5CE1 !Y HAVE A P[] OV] Y\4 ,TO HIM :O EX]CIS$ UTT]LY NO P[] OV] Y\1 Y\ W\LD V\*SAFE NO?+2 HE MI<T P]I%4 

,!RE=E1 :AT Y\ >E COMPET5T = IS Y\R COMPET5CE6 ,IF Y\ >E COMPET5T TO FURNI% PLEASURE TO ?\S&S1 !N ?\S&S WILL PAY Y\ AN HONOR>IUM = IT2 = IT W\LD /& 9 Y\R P[] TO =BE> DO+ IT1 H5CE !Y MU/ PUR*ASE Y\R DE$4 ,IF Y\ >E NOT COMPET5T TO CAPTIVATE ANY ONE1 Y\ MAY SIMPLY />VE4 

,N[ AM ,I1 :O AM COMPET5T = MU*1 P]*ANCE TO HAVE NO ADVANTAGE OV] ! LESS COMPET5T8 

,WE >E ALL 9 ! MID/ ( ABUNDANCE2 N[ %ALL ,I NOT HELP MYSELF AS WELL AS ,I CAN1 BUT ONLY WAIT & SEE H[ MU* IS LEFT ME 9 AN EQUAL DIVISION8 

,AGA9/ COMPETITION !RE RISES UP ! PR9CIPLE ( RAGAMUFF9 SOCIETY - P>TITION4 

,TO BE LOOK$ UPON AS A M]E P>T1 P>T ( SOCIETY1 ! 9DIVIDUAL CANNOT BE> - BECAUSE HE IS MORE2 HIS UNIQU5ESS PUTS FROM IT ?IS LIMIT$ CONCEPTION4 

,H5CE HE DOES NOT AWAIT HIS COMPET5CE FROM ! %>+ ( O!RS1 & EV5 9 ! WORK]S' SOCIETY !RE >ISES ! MISGIV+ ?AT 9 AN EQUAL P>TITION ! /RONG WILL BE EXPLOIT$ BY ! WEAK2 HE AWAITS HIS COMPET5CE RA!R FROM HIMSELF1 & SAYS N[1 :AT ,I AM COMPET5T TO HAVE1 ?AT IS MY COMPET5CE4 

,:AT COMPET5CE DOES NOT ! *ILD POSSESS 9 ITS SMIL+1 ITS PLAY+1 ITS SCREAM+6 9 %ORT1 9 ITS M]E EXI/5CE6 ,>E Y\ CAPABLE ( RESI/+ ITS DESIRE8 ,OR DO Y\ NOT HOLD \T TO IT1 AS MO!R1 Y\R BREA/2 AS FA!R1 AS MU* ( Y\R POSSESSIONS AS IT NE$S8 ,IT COMPELS Y\1 !RE=E IT POSSESSES :AT Y\ CALL Y\RS4 

,IF Y\R P]SON IS ( CONSEQU5CE TO ME1 Y\ PAY ME ) Y\R V]Y EXI/5CE2 IF ,I AM CONC]N$ ONLY ) ONE ( Y\R QUALITIES1 !N Y\R COMPLIANCE1 P]HAPS1 OR Y\R AID1 HAS A VALUE 7A MONEY VALUE7 = ME1 & ,I PUR*ASE IT4 

,IF Y\ DO NOT KN[ H[ TO GIVE Y\RSELF ANY O!R ?AN A MONEY VALUE 9 MY E/IMATION1 !RE MAY >ISE ! CASE ( :I* HI/ORY TELLS US1 ?AT ,G]MANS1 SONS ( ! FA!RL&1 W]E SOLD TO ,AM]ICA4 ,%\LD ?OSE :O LET !MSELVES TO BE TRAD$ 9 BE WOR? MORE TO ! SELL]8 ,HE PREF]R$ ! CA% TO ?IS LIV+ W>E ?AT DID NOT UND]/& H[ TO MAKE ITSELF PRECI\S TO HIM4 ,?AT HE DISCOV]$ NO?+ MORE VALUABLE 9 IT WAS ASSUR$LY A DEFECT ( HIS COMPET5CE2 BUT IT TAKES A ROGUE TO GIVE MORE ?AN HE HAS4 ,H[ %\LD HE %[ RESPECT :5 HE DID NOT HAVE IT1 9DE$1 H>DLY C\LD HAVE IT = SU* A PACK6 

,Y\ BEHAVE EGOI/ICALLY :5 Y\ RESPECT EA* O!R NEI!R AS POSSESSORS NOR AS RAGAMUFF9S OR WORK]S1 BUT AS A P>T ( Y\R COMPET5CE1 AS 0USEFUL BODIES04 ,!N Y\ WILL NEI!R GIVE ANY?+ TO ! POSSESSOR 70PROPRIETOR07 = HIS POSSESSIONS1 NOR TO HIM :O WORKS1 BUT ONLY TO HIM :OM Y\ REQUIRE4 ,! ,NOR? ,AM]ICANS ASK !MSELVES1 ,DO WE REQUIRE A K+8 & ANSW]3 ,NOT ONE P5NY >E HE & HIS WORK WOR? TO US4 

,IF IT IS SAID ?AT COMPETITION ?R[S EV]Y ?+ OP5 TO ALL1 ! EXPRESSION IS NOT ACCURATE1 & IT IS BETT] PUT ?US3 COMPETITION MAKES EV]Y?+ PUR*ASABLE4 ,9 AB&ON+ .<PREISGEB5.> IT TO !M1 COMPETITION LEAVES IT TO !IR APPRAISAL .<,PREIS5.> OR !IR E/IMATION1 & DEM&S A PRICE .<,PREIS.> = IT4 

,BUT ! W\LD-BE BUY]S MO/LY LACK ! MEANS TO MAKE !MSELVES BUY]S3 !Y HAVE NO MONEY4 ,= MONEY1 !N1 ! PUR*ASABLE ?+S >E 9DE$ TO BE HAD 70,= MONEY EV]Y?+ IS TO BE HAD6071 BUT IT IS EXACTLY MONEY ?AT IS LACK+4 ,:]E IS ONE TO GET MONEY1 ?IS CURR5T OR CIRCULAT+ PROP]TY8 ,KN[ !N1 Y\ HAVE AS MU* MONEY .<,GELD.> AS Y\ HAVE - MI<T2 = Y\ C\NT = AS MU* AS Y\ MAKE Y\RSELF C\NT = .<,GELTUNG.>4 

,ONE PAYS NOT ) MONEY1 ( :I* !RE MAY COME A LACK1 BUT ) HIS COMPET5CE1 BY :I* ALONE WE >E 0COMPET5T02 = ONE IS PROPRIETOR ONLY SO F> AS ! >M ( \R P[] REA*ES4 

,WEITL+ HAS ?\<T \T A NEW MEANS ( PAYM5T - WORK4 ,BUT ! TRUE MEANS ( PAYM5T REMA9S1 AS ALWAYS1 COMPET5CE4 ,) :AT Y\ HAVE 0)9 Y\R COMPET5CE0 Y\ PAY4 ,!RE=E ?9K ON ! 5L>GEM5T ( Y\R COMPET5CE4 

,?IS BE+ ADMITT$1 !Y >E NEV]!LESS RI<T ON H& AGA9 ) ! MOTTO1 0,TO EA* ACCORD+ TO HIS COMPET5CE60 ,:O IS TO GIVE TO ME ACCORD+ TO MY COMPET5CE8 ,SOCIETY8 ,!N ,I %\LD HAVE TO PUT UP ) ITS E/IMATION4 ,RA!R1 ,I %ALL TAKE ACCORD+ TO MY COMPET5CE4 

0,ALL BELONGS TO ALL60 ,?IS PROPOSITION SPR+S FROM ! SAME UNSUB/ANTIAL !ORY4 ,TO EA* BELONGS ONLY :AT HE IS COMPET5T =4 ,IF ,I SAY1 ,! WORLD BELONGS TO ME1 PROP]LY ?AT TOO IS EMPTY TALK1 :I* HAS A MEAN+ ONLY 9 SO F> AS ,I RESPECT NO ALI5 PROP]TY4 ,BUT TO ME BELONGS ONLY AS MU* AS ,I AM COMPET5T =1 OR HAVE )9 MY COMPET5CE4 

,ONE IS NOT WOR?Y TO HAVE :AT ONE1 ?R\< WEAKNESS1 LETS BE TAK5 FROM HIM2 ONE IS NOT WOR?Y ( IT BECAUSE ONE IS NOT CAPABLE ( IT4 

,!Y RAISE A MI<TY UPRO> OV] ! 0WRONG ( A ?\S& YE>S0 :I* IS BE+ COMMITT$ BY ! RI* AGA9/ ! POOR4 ,AS IF ! RI* W]E TO BLAME = POV]TY1 & ! POOR W]E NOT 9 LIKE MANN] RESPONSIBLE = RI*ES6 ,IS !RE ANO!R DIFF]5CE BETWE5 ! TWO ?AN ?AT ( COMPET5CE & 9COMPET5CE1 ( ! COMPET5T & 9COMPET5T8 ,:]E91 PRAY1 DOES ! CRIME ( ! RI* CONSI/8 0,9 !IR H>DHE>T$NESS40 ,BUT :O !N HAVE MA9TA9$ ! POOR8 ,:O HAVE C>$ = !IR N\RI%M5T8 ,:O HAVE GIV5 ALMS1 ?OSE ALMS ?AT HAVE EV5 !IR NAME FROM M]CY 7ELEEMOSYNE 78 ,HAVE NOT ! RI* BE5 0M]CIFUL0 AT ALL TIMES8 ,>E !Y NOT TO ?IS DAY 0T5D]-HE>T$10 AS POOR-TAXES1 HOSPITALS1 F\NDATIONS ( ALL SORTS1 ETC41 PROVE8 

,BUT ALL ?IS DOES NOT SATISFY Y\6 ,D\BTLESS1 !N1 !Y >E TO %>E ) ! POOR8 ,N[ Y\ >E DEM&+ ?AT !Y %ALL ABOLI% POV]TY4 ,ASIDE FROM ! PO9T ?AT !RE MI<T BE H>DLY ONE AMONG Y\ :O W\LD ACT SO1 & ?AT ?IS ONE W\LD BE A FOOL = IT1 DO ASK Y\RSELVES3 :Y %\LD ! RI* LET GO !IR FLEECES & GIVE UP !MSELVES1 !REBY PURSU+ ! ADVANTAGE ( ! POOR RA!R ?AN !IR [N8 ,Y\1 :O HAVE Y\R ?AL] DAILY1 >E RI* ABOVE ?\S&S :O LIVE ON F\R GROS*54 ,IS IT = Y\R 9T]E/ TO %>E ) ! ?\S&S1 OR IS IT NOT RA!R = !IRS8 -- 

,) COMPETITION IS CONNECT$ LESS ! 9T5TION TO DO ! ?+ BE/ ?AN ! 9T5TION TO MAKE IT AS PR(ITABLE1 AS PRODUCTIVE1 AS POSSIBLE4 ,H5CE PEOPLE /UDY TO GET 9TO ! CIVIL S]VICE 7POT-BOIL+ /UDY71 /UDY CR++ & FLATT]Y1 R\T9E & 0ACQUA9TANCE ) BUS9ESS10 WORK 0= APPE>ANCE40 ,H5CE1 :ILE IT IS APP>5TLY A MATT] ( DO+ 0GOOD S]VICE10 9 TRU? ONLY A 0GOOD BUS9ESS0 & E>N+ ( MONEY >E LOOK$ \T =4 ,! JOB IS DONE ONLY O/5SIBLY = ! JOB'S SAKE1 BUT 9 FACT ON ACC\NT ( ! GA9 ?AT IT YIELDS4 ,ONE W\LD 9DE$ PREF] NOT TO BE C5SOR1 BUT ONE WANTS TO BE - ADVANC$2 ONE W\LD LIKE TO JUDGE1 ADM9I/]1 ETC41 ACCORD+ TO HIS BE/ CONVICTIONS1 BUT ONE IS AFRAID ( TRANSF]5CE OR EV5 DISMISSAL2 ONE MU/1 ABOVE ALL ?+S - LIVE4 

,?US !SE GO+S-ON >E A FI<T = DE> LIFE1 &1 9 GRADATION UPW>D1 = MORE OR LESS ( A 0GOOD LIV+40 

,& YET1 )AL1 !IR :OLE R\ND ( TOIL & C>E BR+S 9 = MO/ ONLY 0BITT] LIFE0 & 0BITT] POV]TY40 ,ALL ! BITT] PA9/AK+ = ?IS6 

,RE/LESS ACQUISITION DOES NOT LET US TAKE BREA?1 TAKE A CALM 5JOYM5T3 WE DO NOT GET ! COM=T ( \R POSSESSIONS4 

,BUT ! ORGANIZATION ( LABOR T\*ES ONLY SU* LABORS AS O!RS CAN DO = US1 SLAU<T]+1 TILLAGE1 & ! LIKE2 ! RE/ REMA9 EGOI/IC1 BECAUSE NO ONE CAN 9 Y\R /EAD ELABORATE Y\R MUSICAL COMPOSITIONS1 C>RY \T Y\R PROJECTS ( PA9T+1 ETC42 NOBODY CAN REPLACE ,RAPHAEL'S LABORS4 ,! LATT] >E LABORS ( A UNIQUE P]SON1 :I* ONLY HE IS COMPET5T TO A*IEVE1 :ILE ! =M] DES]V$ TO BE CALL$ 0HUMAN10 S9CE :AT IS ANYBODY'S [N 9 !M IS ( SLI<T ACC\NT1 & ALMO/ 0ANY MAN0 CAN BE TRA9$ TO IT4 

,N[1 AS SOCIETY CAN REG>D ONLY LABORS = ! COMMON B5EFIT1 HUMAN LABORS1 HE :O DOES ANY?+ UNIQUE REMA9S )\T ITS C>E2 9DE$1 HE MAY F9D HIMSELF DI/URB$ BY ITS 9T]V5TION4 ,! UNIQUE P]SON WILL WORK HIMSELF =? \T ( SOCIETY ALL RI<T1 BUT SOCIETY BR+S =? NO UNIQUE P]SON4 

,H5CE IT IS AT ANY RATE HELPFUL ?AT WE COME TO AN AGREEM5T AB\T HUMAN LABORS1 ?AT !Y MAY NOT1 AS UND] COMPETITION1 CLAIM ALL \R TIME & TOIL4 ,SO F> ,COMMUNISM WILL BE> ITS FRUITS4 ,= BE=E ! DOM9ION ( ! COMMONALTY EV5 ?AT = :I* ALL M5 >E QUALIFI$1 OR CAN BE QUALIFI$1 WAS TI$ UP TO A FEW & )HELD FROM ! RE/3 IT WAS A PRIVILEGE4 ,TO ! COMMONALTY IT LOOK$ EQUITABLE TO LEAVE FREE ALL ?AT SEEM$ TO EXI/ = EV]Y 0MAN40 ,BUT1 BECAUSE LEFT FREE .<FREIGEGEB5.>1 IT WAS YET GIV5 .<GEGEB5.> TO NO ONE1 BUT RA!R LEFT TO EA* TO BE GOT HOLD ( BY HIS HUMAN P[]4 ,BY ?IS ! M9D WAS TURN$ TO ! ACQUISITION ( ! HUMAN1 :I* H5CE=? BECKON$ TO EV]Y ONE2 & !RE >OSE A MOVEM5T :I* ONE HE>S SO L\DLY BEMOAN$ UND] ! NAME ( 0MAT]IALISM40 

,COMMUNISM SEEKS TO *ECK ITS C\RSE1 SPREAD+ ! BELIEF ?AT ! HUMAN IS NOT WOR? SO MU* DISCOM=T1 &1 ) S5SIBLE >RANGEM5TS1 C\LD BE GA9$ )\T ! GREAT EXP5SE ( TIME & P[]S :I* HAS HI!RTO SEEM$ REQUISITE4 

,BUT = :OM IS TIME TO BE GA9$8 ,= :AT DOES MAN REQUIRE MORE TIME ?AN IS NECESS>Y TO REFRE% HIS WE>I$ P[]S ( LABOR8 ,H]E ,COMMUNISM IS SIL5T4 

,= :AT8 ,TO TAKE COM=T 9 HIMSELF AS ! UNIQUE1 AFT] HE HAS DONE HIS P>T AS MAN6 

,9 ! FIR/ JOY OV] BE+ ALL[$ TO /RET* \T !IR H&S T[>D EV]Y?+ HUMAN1 PEOPLE =GOT TO WANT ANY?+ ELSE2 & !Y COMPET$ AWAY VIGOR\SLY1 AS IF ! POSSESSION ( ! HUMAN W]E ! GOAL ( ALL \R WI%ES4 

,BUT !Y HAVE RUN !MSELVES TIR$1 & >E GRADUALLY NOTIC+ ?AT 0POSSESSION DOES NOT GIVE HAPP9ESS40 ,!RE=E !Y >E ?9K+ ( OBTA9+ ! NECESS>Y BY AN EASI] B>GA91 & SP5D+ ON IT ONLY SO MU* TIME & TOIL AS ITS 9DISP5SABL5ESS EXACTS4 ,RI*ES FALL 9 PRICE1 & CONT5T$ POV]TY1 ! C>E-FREE RAGAMUFF91 BECOMES ! S$UCTIVE IDEAL4 

,%\LD SU* HUMAN ACTIVITIES1 ?AT EV]Y ONE IS CONFID5T ( HIS CAPACITY =1 BE HI<LY SAL>I$1 & S\<T = ) TOIL & EXP5DITURE ( ALL LIFE-=CES8 ,EV5 9 ! EV]YDAY =M ( SPEE*1 0,IF ,I W]E M9I/]1 OR EV5 ! 4 4 41 !N IT %\LD GO QUITE O!RWISE10 ?AT CONFID5CE EXPRESSES ITSELF - ?AT ONE HOLDS HIMSELF CAPABLE ( PLAY+ ! P>T ( SU* A DIGNIT>Y2 ONE DOES GET A P]CEPTION ?AT TO ?+S ( ?IS SORT !RE BELONGS NOT UNIQU5ESS1 BUT ONLY A CULTURE :I* IS ATTA9ABLE1 EV5 IF NOT EXACTLY BY ALL1 AT ANY RATE BY MANY2 ?AT = SU* A ?+ ONE NE$ ONLY BE AN ORD9>Y MAN4 

,IF WE ASSUME ?AT1 AS ORD] .<,ORDNUNG.> BELONGS TO ! ESS5CE ( ! /ATE1 SO SUBORD9ATION .<,UNT]ORDNUNG.> TOO IS F\ND$ 9 ITS NATURE1 !N WE SEE ?AT ! SUBORD9ATES1 OR ?OSE :O HAVE RECEIV$ PREF]M5T1 DISPROPORTIONATELY OV]*>GE & OV]REA* ?OSE :O >E PUT 9 ! L[] RANKS4 ,BUT ! LATT] TAKE HE>T 7FIR/ FROM ! ,SOCIALI/ /&-PO9T1 BUT C]TA9LY ) EGOI/IC CONSCI\SNESS LAT]1 ( :I* WE WILL !RE=E AT ONCE GIVE !IR SPEE* SOME COLOR+7 = ! QUE/ION1 ,BY :AT !N IS Y\R PROP]TY SECURE1 Y\ CREATURES ( PREF]M5T8 - & GIVE !MSELVES ! ANSW]1 ,BY \R REFRA9+ FROM 9T]F]5CE6 ,& SO BY \R PROTECTION6 ,& :AT DO Y\ GIVE US = IT8 ,KICKS & DISDA9 Y\ GIVE TO ! 0COMMON PEOPLE02 POLICE SUP]VISION1 & A CATE*ISM ) ! *IEF S5T5CE 0,RESPECT :AT IS NOT Y\RS1 :AT BELONGS TO O!RS6 RESPECT O!RS1 & ESPECIALLY Y\R SUP]IORS60 ,BUT WE REPLY1 0,IF Y\ WANT \R RESPECT1 BUY IT = A PRICE AGREEABLE TO US4 ,WE WILL LEAVE Y\ Y\R PROP]TY1 IF Y\ GIVE A DUE EQUIVAL5T = ?IS LEAV+40 ,REALLY1 :AT EQUIVAL5T DOES ! G5]AL 9 TIME ( PEACE GIVE = ! MANY ?\S&S ( HIS YE>LY 9COME48 - ANO!R = ! %E] HUNDR$-?\S&S & MILLIONS YE>LY8 ,:AT EQUIVAL5T DO Y\ GIVE = \R *EW+ POTATOES & LOOK+ CALMLY ON :ILE Y\ SWALL[ OY/]S8 ,ONLY BUY ! OY/]S ( US AS DE> AS WE HAVE TO BUY ! POTATOES ( Y\1 !N Y\ MAY GO ON EAT+ !M4 ,OR DO Y\ SUPPOSE ! OY/]S DO NOT BELONG TO US AS MU* AS TO Y\8 ,Y\ WILL MAKE AN \TCRY OV] VIOL5CE IF WE REA* \T \R H&S & HELP CONSUME !M1 & Y\ >E RI<T4 ,)\T VIOL5CE WE DO NOT GET !M1 AS Y\ NO LESS HAVE !M BY DO+ VIOL5CE TO US4 

,BUT TAKE ! OY/]S & HAVE DONE ) IT1 & LET US CONSID] \R NE>] PROP]TY1 LABOR2 = ! O!R IS ONLY POSSESSION4 ,WE DI/RESS \RSELVES TWELVE H\RS 9 ! SWEAT ( \R FACE1 & Y\ (F] US A FEW GROS*5 = IT4 ,!N TAKE ! LIKE = Y\R LABOR TOO4 ,>E Y\ NOT WILL+8 ,Y\ FANCY ?AT \R LABOR IS RI*LY REPAID ) ?AT WAGE1 :ILE Y\RS ON ! O!R H&S IS WOR? A WAGE ( MANY ?\S&S4 ,BUT1 IF Y\ DID NOT RATE Y\RS SO HI<1 & GAVE US A BETT] *ANCE TO REALIZE VALUE FROM \RS1 !N WE MI<T WELL1 IF ! CASE DEM&$ IT1 BR+ TO PASS /ILL MORE IMPORTANT ?+S ?AN Y\ DO = ! MANY ?\S& ?AL]S2 &1 IF Y\ GOT ONLY SU* WAGES AS WE1 Y\ W\LD SOON GR[ MORE 9DU/RI\S 9 ORD] TO RECEIVE MORE4 ,BUT1 IF Y\ R5D] ANY S]VICE ?AT SEEMS TO US WOR? T5 & A HUNDR$ TIMES MORE ?AN \R [N LABOR1 :Y1 !N Y\ %ALL GET A HUNDR$ TIMES MORE = IT TOO2 WE1 ON ! O!R H&1 ?9K ALSO TO PRODUCE = Y\ ?+S = :I* Y\ WILL REQUITE US MORE HI<LY ?AN ) ! ORD9>Y DAY'S WAGES4 ,WE %ALL BE WILL+ TO GET ALONG ) EA* O!R ALL RI<T1 IF ONLY WE HAVE FIR/ AGRE$ ON ?IS - ?AT NEI!R ANY LONG] NE$S TO - PRES5T ANY?+ TO ! O!R4 ,!N WE MAY P]HAPS ACTUALLY GO SO F> AS TO PAY EV5 ! CRIPPLES & SICK & OLD AN APPROPRIATE PRICE = NOT P>T+ FROM US BY HUNG] & WANT2 =1 IF WE WANT !M TO LIVE1 IT IS FITT+ ALSO ?AT WE - PUR*ASE ! FULFILLM5T ( \R WILL4 ,I SAY 0PUR*ASE10 & !RE=E DO NOT MEAN A WRET*$ 0ALMS40 ,= !IR LIFE IS ! PROP]TY EV5 ( ?OSE :O CANNOT WORK2 IF WE 7NO MATT] = :AT REASON7 WANT !M NOT NAMELYHDRAW ?IS LIFE FROM US1 WE CAN MEAN TO BR+ ?IS TO PASS ONLY BY PUR*ASE2 9DE$1 WE %ALL P]HAPS 7MAYBE BECAUSE WE LIKE TO HAVE FRI5DLY FACES AB\T US7 EV5 WANT A LIFE ( COM=T = !M4 ,9 %ORT1 WE WANT NO?+ PRES5T$ BY Y\1 BUT NEI!R WILL WE PRES5T Y\ ) ANY?+4 ,= C5TURIES WE HAVE H&$ ALMS TO Y\ FROM GOODHE>T$ - /UPIDITY1 HAVE DOL$ \T ! MITE ( ! POOR & GIV5 TO ! MA/]S ! ?+S ?AT >E - NOT ! MA/]S'2 N[ JU/ OP5 Y\R WALLET1 = H5CE=? \R W>E RISES 9 PRICE QUITE 5ORM\SLY4 ,WE DO NOT WANT TO TAKE FROM Y\ ANY?+1 ANY?+ AT ALL1 ONLY Y\ >E TO PAY BETT] = :AT Y\ WANT TO HAVE4 ,:AT !N HAVE Y\8 0,I HAVE AN E/ATE ( A ?\S& ACRES40 ,& ,I AM Y\R PL[MAN1 & WILL H5CE=? ATT5D TO Y\R FIELDS ONLY = ONE ?AL] A DAY WAGES4 0,!N ,I'LL TAKE ANO!R40 ,Y\ WON'T F9D ANY1 = WE PL[M5 >E NO LONG] DO+ O!RWISE1 &1 IF ONE PUTS 9 AN APPE>ANCE :O TAKES LESS1 !N LET HIM BEW>E ( US4 ,!RE IS ! H\SEMAID1 %E TOO IS N[ DEM&+ AS MU*1 & Y\ WILL NO LONG] F9D ONE BEL[ ?IS PRICE40,:Y1 !N IT IS ALL OV] ) ME40 ,NOT SO FA/6 ,Y\ WILL D\BTLESS TAKE 9 AS MU* AS WE2 &1 IF IT %\LD NOT BE SO1 WE WILL TAKE (F SO MU* ?AT Y\ %ALL HAVE :]E) TO LIVE LIKE US4 0,BUT ,I AM ACCU/OM$ TO LIVE BETT]40 ,WE HAVE NO?+ AGA9/ ?AT1 BUT IT IS NOT \R LOOK-\T2 IF Y\ CAN CLE> MORE1 GO AHEAD4 ,>E WE TO HIRE \T UND] RATES1 ?AT Y\ MAY HAVE A GOOD LIV+8 ,! RI* MAN ALWAYS PUTS (F ! POOR ) ! WORDS1 0,:AT DOES Y\R WANT CONC]N ME8 ,SEE TO IT H[ Y\ MAKE Y\R WAY ?R\< ! WORLD2 ?AT IS Y\R AFFAIR1 NOT M9E40 ,WELL1 LET US LET IT BE \R AFFAIR1 !N1 & LET US NOT LET ! MEANS ?AT WE HAVE TO REALIZE VALUE FROM \RSELVES BE PILF]$ FROM US BY ! RI*4 0,BUT Y\ UNCULTUR$ PEOPLE REALLY DO NOT NE$ SO MU*40 ,WELL1 WE >E TAK+ SOME:AT MORE 9 ORD] ?AT = IT WE MAY PROCURE ! CULTURE ?AT WE P]HAPS NE$4 0,BUT1 IF Y\ ?US BR+ D[N ! RI*1 :O IS !N TO SUPPORT ! >TS & SCI5CES H]EAFT]80 ,OH1 WELL1 WE MU/ MAKE IT UP BY NUMB]S2 WE CLUB TOGE!R1 ?AT GIVES A NICE LITTLE SUM - BESIDES1 Y\ RI* M5 N[ BUY ONLY ! MO/ TA/ELESS BOOKS & ! MO/ LAM5TABLE ,MADONNAS OR A PAIR ( LIVELY DANC]'S LEGS4 0,O ILL-/>R$ EQUALITY60 ,NO1 MY GOOD OLD SIR1 NO?+ ( EQUALITY4 ,WE ONLY WANT TO C\NT = :AT WE >E WOR?1 &1 IF Y\ >E WOR? MORE1 Y\ %ALL C\NT = MORE RI<T ALONG4 ,WE ONLY WANT TO BE WOR? \R PRICE1 & ?9K TO %[ \RSELVES WOR? ! PRICE ?AT Y\ WILL PAY4 

,IS ! /ATE LIKELY TO BE ABLE TO AWAK5 SO SECURE A TEMP] & SO =CEFUL A SELF-CONSCI\SNESS 9 ! M5IAL8 ,CAN IT MAKE MAN FEEL HIMSELF8 ,9DE$1 MAY IT EV5 DO SO MU* AS SET ?IS GOAL = ITSELF8 ,CAN IT WANT ! 9DIVIDUAL TO RECOGNIZE HIS VALUE & REALIZE ?IS VALUE FROM HIMSELF8 ,LET US KEEP ! P>TS ( ! D\BLE QUE/ION SEP>ATE1 & SEE FIR/ :E!R ! /ATE CAN BR+ AB\T SU* A ?+4 ,AS ! UNANIMITY ( ! PL[M5 IS REQUIR$1 ONLY ?IS UNANIMITY CAN BR+ IT TO PASS1 & A /ATE LAW W\LD BE EVAD$ 9 A ?\S& WAYS BY COMPETITION & 9 SECRET4 ,BUT CAN ! /ATE BE> ) IT8 ,! /ATE CANNOT POSSIBLY BE> ) PEOPLE'S SUFF]+ CO]CION FROM ANO!R ?AN IT2 IT C\LD NOT1 !RE=E1 ADMIT ! SELF-HELP ( ! UNANIM\S PL[M5 AGA9/ ?OSE :O WANT TO 5GAGE = L[] WAGES4 ,SUPPOSE1 H[EV]1 ?AT ! /ATE MADE ! LAW1 & ALL ! PL[M5 W]E 9 ACCORD ) IT3 C\LD ! /ATE BE> ) IT !N8 

,9 ! ISOLAT$ CASE - YES2 BUT ! ISOLAT$ CASE IS MORE ?AN ?AT1 IT IS A CASE ( PR9CIPLE4 ,! QUE/ION !RE9 IS ( ! :OLE RANGE ( ! EGO'S SELF-REALIZATION ( VALUE FROM HIMSELF .<,SELB/V]W]TUNG DES ,I*S.>1 & !RE=E ALSO ( HIS SELF-CONSCI\SNESS .<,SELB/GEFUHL.> AGA9/ ! /ATE4 ,SO F> ! ,COMMUNI/S KEEP COMPANY2 BUT1 AS SELF-REALIZATION ( VALUE FROM SELF NECESS>ILY DIRECTS ITSELF AGA9/ ! /ATE1 SO IT DOES AGA9/ SOCIETY TOO1 & !RE) REA*ES \T BEYOND ! COMMUNE & ! COMMUNI/IC - \T ( EGOISM4 

,COMMUNISM MAKES ! MAXIM ( ! COMMONALTY1 ?AT EV]Y ONE IS A POSSESSOR 70PROPRIETOR071 9TO AN IRREFRAGABLE TRU?1 9TO A REALITY1 S9CE ! ANXIETY AB\T OBTA9+ N[ CEASES & EV]Y ONE HAS FROM ! />T :AT HE REQUIRES4 ,9 HIS LABOR-=CE HE HAS HIS COMPET5CE1 &1 IF HE MAKES NO USE ( IT1 ?AT IS HIS FAULT4 ,! GRASP+ & H\ND+ IS AT AN 5D1 & NO COMPETITION IS LEFT 7AS SO (T5 N[7 )\T FRUIT1 BECAUSE ) EV]Y /ROKE ( LABOR AN ADEQUATE SUPPLY ( ! NE$FUL IS BR\<T 9TO ! H\SE4 ,N[ = ! FIR/ TIME ONE IS A REAL POSSESSOR1 BECAUSE :AT ONE HAS 9 HIS LABOR-=CE CAN NO LONG] ESCAPE FROM HIM AS IT WAS CONT9UALLY ?REAT5+ TO DO UND] ! SY/EM ( COMPETITION4 ,ONE IS A C>E-FREE & ASSUR$ POSSESSOR4 ,& ONE IS ?IS PRECISELY BY SEEK+ HIS COMPET5CE NO LONG] 9 A W>E1 BUT 9 HIS [N LABOR1 HIS COMPET5CE = LABOR2 & !RE=E BY BE+ A RAGAMUFF91 A MAN ( ONLY IDEAL WEAL?4 ,I1 H[EV]1 CANNOT CONT5T MYSELF ) ! LITTLE ?AT ,I SCRAPE UP BY MY COMPET5CE = LABOR1 BECAUSE MY COMPET5CE DOES NOT CONSI/ M]ELY 9 MY LABOR4 

,BY LABOR ,I CAN P]=M ! (FICIAL FUNCTIONS ( A PRESID5T1 A M9I/]1 ETC42 !SE (FICES DEM& ONLY A G5]AL CULTURE - NAMELY1 SU* A CULTURE AS IS G5]ALLY ATTA9ABLE 7= G5]AL CULTURE IS NOT M]ELY ?AT :I* EV]Y ONE HAS ATTA9$1 BUT BROADLY ?AT :I* EV]Y ONE CAN ATTA91 & !RE=E EV]Y SPECIAL CULTURE1 M$ICAL1 MILIT>Y1 PHILOLOGICAL1 ( :I* NO 0CULTIVAT$ MAN0 BELIEVES ?AT !Y SURPASS HIS P[]S71 OR1 BROADLY1 ONLY A SKILL POSSIBLE TO ALL4 

,BUT1 EV5 IF !SE (FICES MAY VE/ 9 EV]Y ONE1 YET IT IS ONLY ! 9DIVIDUAL'S UNIQUE =CE1 PECULI> TO HIM ALONE4 ?AT GIVES !M1 SO TO SPEAK1 LIFE & SIGNIFICANCE4 ,?AT HE DOES NOT MANAGE HIS (FICE LIKE AN 0ORD9>Y MAN40 BUT PUTS 9 ! COMPET5CE ( HIS UNIQU5ESS1 ?IS HE IS NOT YET PAID = :5 HE IS PAID ONLY 9 G5]AL AS AN (FICIAL OR A M9I/]4 ,IF HE HAS DONE IT SO AS TO E>N Y\R ?ANKS1 & Y\ WI% TO RETA9 ?IS ?ANK-WOR?Y =CE ( ! UNIQUE ONE1 Y\ MU/ NOT PAY HIM LIKE A M]E MAN :O P]=M$ ONLY :AT WAS HUMAN1 BUT AS ONE :O ACCOMPLI%ES :AT IS UNIQUE4 ,DO ! LIKE ) Y\R LABOR1 DO6 

,!RE CANNOT BE A G5]AL S*$ULE-PRICE FIX$ = MY UNIQU5ESS AS !RE CAN = :AT ,I DO AS MAN4 ,ONLY = ! LATT] CAN A S*$ULE-PRICE BE SET4 

,GO RI<T ON1 !N1 SETT+ UP A G5]AL APPRAISAL = HUMAN LABORS1 BUT DO NOT DEPRIVE Y\R UNIQU5ESS ( ITS DES]T4 

,HUMAN OR G5]AL NE$S CAN BE SATISFI$ ?R\< SOCIETY2 = SATISFACTION ( UNIQUE NE$S Y\ MU/ DO SOME SEEK+4 ,A FRI5D & A FRI5DLY S]VICE1 OR EV5 AN 9DIVIDUAL'S S]VICE1 SOCIETY CANNOT PROCURE Y\4 ,& YET Y\ WILL EV]Y MOM5T BE 9 NE$ ( SU* A S]VICE1 & ON ! SLI<TE/ OCCASIONS REQUIRE SOMEBODY :O IS HELPFUL TO Y\4 ,!RE=E DO NOT RELY ON SOCIETY1 BUT SEE TO IT ?AT Y\ HAVE ! :]E)AL TO - PUR*ASE ! FULFILLM5T ( Y\R WI%ES4 

,:E!R MONEY IS TO BE RETA9$ AMONG EGOI/S8 ,TO ! OLD /AMP AN 9H]IT$ POSSESSION ADH]ES4 ,IF Y\ NO LONG] LET Y\RSELVES BE PAID ) IT1 IT IS RU9$3 IF Y\ DO NO?+ = ?IS MONEY1 IT LOSES ALL P[]4 ,CANCEL ! 9H]ITANCE1 & Y\ HAVE BROK5 (F ! EXECUTOR'S C\RT-SEAL4 ,= N[ EV]Y?+ IS AN 9H]ITANCE1 :E!R IT BE ALREADY 9H]IT$ OR AWAIT ITS HEIR4 ,IF IT IS Y\RS1 :]E=E DO Y\ LET IT BE SEAL$ UP FROM Y\8 ,:Y DO Y\ RESPECT ! SEAL8 

,BUT :Y %\LD Y\ NOT CREATE A NEW MONEY8 ,DO Y\ !N ANNIHILATE ! W>E 9 TAK+ FROM IT ! H]$IT>Y /AMP8 ,N[1 MONEY IS A W>E1 & AN ESS5TIAL MEANS OR COMPET5CE4 ,= IT PROTECTS AGA9/ ! OSSIFICATION ( RES\RCES1 KEEPS !M 9 FLUX & BR+S TO PASS !IR EX*ANGE4 ,IF Y\ KN[ A BETT] M$IUM ( EX*ANGE1 GO AHEAD2 YET IT WILL BE A 0MONEY0 AGA94 ,IT IS NOT ! MONEY ?AT DOES Y\ DAMAGE1 BUT Y\R 9COMPET5CE TO TAKE IT4 ,LET Y\R COMPET5CE TAKE EFFECT1 COLLECT Y\RSELVES1 & !RE WILL BE NO LACK ( MONEY - ( Y\R MONEY1 ! MONEY ( Y\R /AMP4 ,BUT WORK+ ,I DO NOT CALL 0LETT+ Y\R COMPET5CE TAKE EFFECT40 ,?OSE :O >E ONLY 0LOOK+ = WORK0 & 0WILL+ TO WORK H>D0 >E PREP>+ = !IR [N SELVES ! 9FALLIBLE UP%OT - TO BE \T ( WORK4 

,GOOD & BAD LUCK DEP5D ON MONEY4 ,IT IS A P[] 9 ! B\RGEOIS P]IOD = ?IS REASON1 ?AT IT IS ONLY WOO$ ON ALL H&S LIKE A GIRL1 9DISSOLUBLY W$D$ BY NOBODY4 ,ALL ! ROMANCE & *IVALRY ( WOO+ = A DE> OBJECT COME TO LIFE AGA9 9 COMPETITION4 ,MONEY1 AN OBJECT ( LONG+1 IS C>RI$ (F BY ! BOLD 0KNI<TS ( 9DU/RY40 

,HE :O HAS LUCK TAKES HOME ! BRIDE4 ,! RAGAMUFF9 HAS LUCK2 HE TAKES H] 9TO HIS H\SEHOLD1 0SOCIETY10 & DE/ROYS ! VIRG94 ,9 HIS H\SE %E IS NO LONG] BRIDE1 BUT WIFE2 & ) H] VIRG9ITY H] FAMILY NAME IS ALSO LO/4 ,AS H\SEWIFE ! MAID5 ,MONEY IS CALL$ 0,LABOR10 = 0,LABOR0 IS H] HUSB&'S NAME4 ,%E IS A POSSESSION ( H] HUSB&'S4 

,TO BR+ ?IS FIGURE TO AN 5D1 ! *ILD ( ,LABOR & ,MONEY IS AGA9 A GIRL1 AN UNW$D$ ONE & !RE=E ,MONEY BUT ) ! C]TA9 DESC5T FROM ,LABOR1 H] FA!R4 ,! =M ( ! FACE1 ! 0EFFIGY10 BE>S ANO!R /AMP4 

,F9ALLY1 AS REG>DS COMPETITION ONCE MORE1 IT HAS A CONT9U$ EXI/5CE BY ?IS V]Y MEANS1 ?AT ALL DO NOT ATT5D TO !IR AFFAIR & COME TO AN UND]/&+ ) EA* O!R AB\T IT4 ,BREAD IS A NE$ ( ALL ! 9HABITANTS ( A CITY2 !RE=E !Y MI<T EASILY AGREE ON SETT+ UP A PUBLIC BAK]Y4 ,9/EAD ( ?IS1 !Y LEAVE ! FURNI%+ ( ! NE$FUL TO ! COMPET+ BAK]S4 ,JU/ SO MEAT TO ! BUT*]S1 W9E TO W9E-DEAL]S1 ETC4 

,ABOLI%+ COMPETITION IS NOT EQUIVAL5T TO FAVOR+ ! GUILD4 ,! DIFF]5CE IS ?IS3 ,9 ! GUILD BAK+1 ETC41 IS ! AFFAIR ( ! GUILD-BRO!RS2 9 COMPETITION1 ! AFFAIR ( *ANCE COMPETITORS2 9 ! UNION1 ( ?OSE :O REQUIRE BAK$ GOODS1 & !RE=E MY AFFAIR1 Y\RS1 ! AFFAIR ( NEI!R ! GUILDIC NOR ! CONCESSION>Y BAK]1 BUT ! AFFAIR ( ! UNIT$4 

,IF ,I DO NOT TR\BLE MYSELF AB\T MY AFFAIR1 ,I MU/ BE CONT5T ) :AT IT PLEASES O!RS TO V\*SAFE ME4 ,TO HAVE BREAD IS MY AFFAIR1 MY WI% & DESIRE1 & YET PEOPLE LEAVE ?AT TO ! BAK]S & HOPE AT MO/ TO OBTA9 ?R\< !IR WRANGL+1 !IR GETT+ AHEAD ( EA* O!R1 !IR RIVALRY - 9 %ORT1 !IR COMPETITION - AN ADVANTAGE :I* ONE C\LD NOT C\NT ON 9 ! CASE ( ! GUILD-BRO!RS :O W]E LODG$ 5TIRELY & ALONE 9 ! PROPRIETOR%IP ( ! BAK+ FRAN*ISE4 - ,:AT EV]Y ONE REQUIRES1 EV]Y ONE %\LD ALSO TAKE A H& 9 PROCUR+ & PRODUC+2 IT IS HIS AFFAIR1 HIS PROP]TY1 NOT ! PROP]TY ( ! GUILDIC OR CONCESSION>Y MA/]4 

,LET US LOOK BACK ONCE MORE4 ,! WORLD BELONGS TO ! *ILDR5 ( ?IS WORLD1 ! *ILDR5 ( M52 IT IS NO LONG] ,GOD'S WORLD1 BUT MAN'S4 ,AS MU* AS EV]Y MAN CAN PROCURE ( IT1 LET HIM CALL HIS2 ONLY ! TRUE MAN1 ! /ATE1 HUMAN SOCIETY OR MANK9D1 WILL LOOK TO IT ?AT EA* %ALL MAKE NO?+ ELSE HIS [N ?AN :AT HE APPROPRIATES AS MAN1 9 HUMAN FA%ION4 ,UNHUMAN APPROPRIATION IS ?AT :I* IS NOT CONS5T$ TO BY MAN1 ?AT IS1 IT IS A 0CRIM9AL0 APPROPRIATION1 AS ! HUMAN1 VISE V]SA1 IS A 0RI<TFUL0 ONE1 ONE ACQUIR$ 9 ! 0WAY ( LAW40 

,SO !Y TALK S9CE ! ,REVOLUTION4 

,BUT MY PROP]TY IS NOT A ?+1 S9CE ?IS HAS AN EXI/5CE 9DEP5D5T ( ME2 ONLY MY MI<T IS MY [N4 ,NOT ?IS TREE1 BUT MY MI<T OR CONTROL OV] IT1 IS :AT IS M9E4 

,N[1 H[ IS ?IS MI<T P]V]SELY EXPRESS$8 ,!Y SAY ,I HAVE A RI<T TO ?IS TREE1 OR IT IS MY RI<TFUL PROP]TY4 ,SO ,I HAVE E>N$ IT BY MI<T4 ,?AT ! MI<T MU/ LA/ 9 ORD] ?AT ! TREE MAY ALSO BE HELD - OR BETT]1 ?AT ! MI<T IS NOT A ?+ EXI/+ ( ITSELF1 BUT HAS EXI/5CE SOLELY 9 ! MI<TY EGO1 9 ME ! MI<TY - IS =GOTT54 ,MI<T1 LIKE O!R ( MY QUALITIES 7HUMANITY1 MAJE/Y1 ETC471 IS EXALT$ TO SOME?+ EXI/+ ( ITSELF1 SO ?AT IT /ILL EXI/S LONG AFT] IT HAS CEAS$ TO BE MY MI<T4 ,?US TRANS=M$ 9TO A <O/1 MI<T IS - RI<T4 ,?IS ET]NALIZ$ MI<T IS NOT EXT+UI%$ EV5 ) MY DEA?1 BUT IS TRANSF]R$ TO 0BEQUEA!D40 

,?+S N[ REALLY BELONG NOT TO ME1 BUT TO RI<T4 

,ON ! O!R SIDE1 ?IS IS NO?+ BUT A HALLUC9ATION ( VISION4 ,= ! 9DIVIDUAL'S MI<T BECOMES P]MAN5T & A RI<T ONLY BY O!RS JO9+ !IR MI<T ) HIS4 ,! DELUSION CONSI/S 9 !IR BELIEV+ ?AT !Y CANNOT )DRAW !IR MI<T4 ,! SAME PH5OM5ON OV] AGA92 MI<T IS SEP>AT$ FROM ME4 ,I CANNOT TAKE BACK ! MI<T ?AT ,I GAVE TO ! POSSESSOR4 ,ONE HAS 0GRANT$ P[] ( ATTORNEY10 HAS GIV5 AWAY HIS P[]1 HAS R5\NC$ COM+ TO A BETT] M9D4 

,! PROPRIETOR CAN GIVE UP HIS MI<T & HIS RI<T TO A ?+ BY GIV+ ! ?+ AWAY1 SQU&]+ IT1 & ! LIKE4 ,& WE %\LD NOT BE ABLE LIKEWISE TO LET GO ! MI<T ?AT WE L5D TO HIM8 

,! RI<TFUL MAN1 ! JU/1 DESIRES TO CALL NO?+ HIS [N ?AT HE DOES NOT HAVE 0RI<TLY0 OR HAVE ! RI<T TO1 & !RE=E ONLY LEGITIMATE PROP]TY4 

,N[1 :O IS TO BE JUDGE1 & ADJUDGE HIS RI<T TO HIM8 ,AT LA/1 SURELY1 ,MAN1 :O IMP>TS TO HIM ! RI<TS ( MAN3 !N HE CAN SAY1 9 AN 9F9ITELY BROAD] S5SE ?AN ,T]5CE1 HUMANI NIHIL A ME ALI5UM PUTO1 ?AT IS1 ! HUMAN IS MY PROP]TY4 ,H[EV] HE MAY GO AB\T IT1 SO LONG AS HE OCCUPIES ?IS /&-PO9T HE CANNOT GET CLE> ( A JUDGE2 & 9 \R TIME ! MULTIF>I\S JUDGES ?AT HAD BE5 SELECT$ HAVE SET !MSELVES AGA9/ EA* O!R 9 TWO P]SONS AT DEADLY 5MITY - NAMELY1 9 ,GOD & ,MAN4 ,! ONE P>TY APPEAL TO DIV9E RI<T1 ! O!R TO HUMAN RI<T OR ! RI<TS ( MAN4 

,SO MU* IS CLE>1 ?AT 9 NEI!R CASE DOES ! 9DIVIDUAL DO ! 5TITL+ HIMSELF4 

,JU/ PICK ME \T AN ACTION TODAY ?AT W\LD NOT BE A VIOLATION ( RI<T6 ,EV]Y MOM5T ! RI<TS ( MAN >E TRAMPL$ UND] FOOT BY ONE SIDE1 :ILE !IR OPPON5TS CANNOT OP5 !IR M\? )\T UTT]+ A BLASPHEMY AGA9/ DIV9E RI<T4 ,GIVE AN ALMS1 Y\ MOCK AT A RI<T ( MAN1 BECAUSE ! RELATION ( BEGG> & B5EFACTOR IS AN 9HUMAN RELATION2 UTT] A D\BT1 Y\ S9 AGA9/ A DIV9E RI<T4 ,EAT DRY BREAD ) CONT5TM5T1 Y\ VIOLATE ! RI<T ( MAN BY Y\R EQUANIMITY2 EAT IT ) DISCONT5T1 Y\ REVILE DIV9E RI<T BY Y\R REP9+4 ,!RE IS NOT ONE AMONG Y\ :O DOES NOT COMMIT A CRIME AT EV]Y MOM5T2 Y\R SPEE*ES >E CRIMES1 & EV]Y H9DRANCE TO Y\R FRE$OM ( SPEE* IS NO LESS A CRIME4 ,Y\ >E CRIM9ALS ALTOGE!R6 

,YET Y\ >E SO ONLY 9 ?AT Y\ ALL /& ON ! GR\ND ( RI<T1 9 ?AT Y\ DO NOT EV5 KN[1 & UND]/& H[ TO VALUE1 ! FACT ?AT Y\ >E CRIM9ALS4 

,9VIOLABLE OR SACR$ PROP]TY HAS GR[N ON ?IS V]Y GR\ND3 IT IS A JURIDICAL CONCEPT4 

,A DOG SEES ! BONE 9 ANO!R'S P[]1 - & /&S (F ONLY IF IT FEELS ITSELF TOO WEAK4 ,BUT MAN RESPECTS ! O!R'S RI<T TO HIS BONE4 ,! LATT] ACTION1 !RE=E1 RANKS AS HUMAN1 ! =M] AS BRUTAL OR 0EGOI/IC40 

,& AS H]E1 SO 9 G5]AL1 IT IS CALL$ 0HUMAN0 :5 ONE SEES 9 EV]Y?+ SOME?+ SPIRITUAL 7H]E RI<T71 MAKES EV]Y?+ A <O/ & TAKES HIS ATTITUDE T[>D IT AS T[>D A <O/1 :I* ONE CAN 9DE$ SC>E AWAY AT ITS APPE>ANCE1 BUT CANNOT KILL4 ,IT IS HUMAN TO LOOK AT :AT IS 9DIVIDUAL NOT AS 9DIVIDUAL1 BUT AS A G5]ALITY4 

,9 NATURE AS SU* ,I NO LONG] RESPECT ANY?+1 BUT KN[ MYSELF TO BE 5TITL$ TO EV]Y?+ AGA9/ IT2 9 ! TREE 9 ?AT G>D51 ON ! O!R H&1 ,I MU/ RESPECT ALI5NESS 7!Y SAY 9 ONE-SID$ FA%ION 0PROP]TY071 ,I MU/ KEEP MY H& (F IT4 ,?IS COMES TO AN 5D ONLY :5 ,I CAN 9DE$ LEAVE ?AT TREE TO ANO!R AS ,I LEAVE MY /ICK4 ETC41 TO ANO!R1 BUT DO NOT 9 ADVANCE REG>D IT AS ALI5 TO ME1 SACR$4 ,RA!R1 ,I MAKE TO MYSELF NO CRIME ( FELL+ IT IF ,I WILL1 & IT REMA9S MY PROP]TY1 H[EV] LONG AS ,I RESIGN IT TO O!RS3 IT IS & REMA9S M9E4 ,9 ! BANK]'S =TUNE ,I AS LITTLE SEE ANY?+ ALI5 AS ,NAPOLEON DID 9 ! T]RITORIES ( K+S3 WE HAVE NO DREAD ( 0CONQU]+0 IT1 & WE LOOK AB\T US ALSO = ! MEANS !RETO4 ,WE /RIP (F FROM IT1 !RE=E1 ! SPIRIT ( ALI5NESS1 ( :I* WE HAD BE5 AFRAID4 

,!RE=E IT IS NECESS>Y ?AT ,I DO NOT LAY CLAIM TO1 ANY?+ MORE AS MAN1 BUT TO EV]Y?+ AS ,I1 ?IS ,I2 & ACCORD+LY TO NO?+ HUMAN1 BUT TO M9E2 ?AT IS1 NO?+ ?AT P]TA9S TO ME AS MAN1 BUT - :AT ,I WILL & BECAUSE ,I WILL IT4 

,RI<TFUL1 OR LEGITIMATE1 PROP]TY ( ANO!R WILL BE ONLY ?AT :I* Y\ >E CONT5T TO RECOGNIZE AS SU*4 ,IF Y\R CONT5T CEASES1 !N ?IS PROP]TY HAS LO/ LEGITIMACY = Y\1 & Y\ WILL LAU< AT ABSOLUTE RI<T TO IT4 

,BESIDES ! HI!RTO DISCUSS$ PROP]TY 9 ! LIMIT$ S5SE1 !RE IS HELD UP TO \R REV]5T HE>T ANO!R PROP]TY AGA9/ :I* WE >E F> LESS 0TO S940 ,?IS PROP]TY CONSI/S 9 SPIRITUAL GOODS1 9 ! 0SANCTU>Y ( ! 9N] NATURE40 ,:AT A MAN HOLDS SACR$1 NO O!R IS TO GIBE AT2 BECAUSE1 UNTRUE AS IT MAY BE1 & ZEAL\SLY AS ONE MAY 09 LOV+ & MODE/ WISE0 SEEK TO CONV9CE ( A TRUE SANCTITY ! MAN :O ADH]ES TO IT & BELIEVES 9 IT1 YET ! SACR$ ITSELF IS ALWAYS TO BE HONOR$ 9 IT3 ! MI/AK5 MAN DOES BELIEVE 9 ! SACR$1 EV5 ?\< 9 AN 9CORRECT ESS5CE ( IT1 & SO HIS BELIEF 9 ! SACR$ MU/ AT LEA/ BE RESPECT$4 

,9 RUD] TIMES ?AN \RS IT WAS CU/OM>Y TO DEM& A P>TICUL> FAI?1 & DEVOTION TO A P>TICUL> SACR$ ESS5CE1 & !Y DID NOT TAKE ! G5TLE/ WAY ) ?OSE :O BELIEV$ O!RWISE2 S9CE1 H[EV]1 0FRE$OM ( BELIEF0 SPREAD ITSELF MORE & MORE ABROAD1 ! 0JEAL\S ,GOD & SOLE ,LORD0 GRADUALLY MELT$ 9TO A PRETTY G5]AL 0SUPREME BE+10 & IT SATISFI$ HUMANE TOL]ANCE IF ONLY EV]Y ONE REV]$ 0SOME?+ SACR$40 

,R$UC$ TO ! MO/ HUMAN EXPRESSION1 ?IS SACR$ ESS5CE IS 0MAN HIMSELF0 & 0! HUMAN40 ,) ! DECEPTIVE SEMBLANCE AS IF ! HUMAN W]E ALTOGE!R \R [N1 & FREE FROM ALL ! O!RWORLDL9ESS ) :I* ! DIV9E IS TA9T$ - YES1 AS IF ,MAN W]E AS MU* AS ,I OR Y\ - !RE MAY >ISE EV5 ! PR\D FANCY ?AT ! TALK IS NO LONG] ( A 0SACR$ ESS5CE0 & ?AT WE N[ FEEL \RSELVES EV]Y:]E AT HOME .<HEIMIS*.> & NO LONG] 9 ! UNCANNY .<UNHEIMLI*.>1 9 ! SACR$ & 9 SACR$ AWE3 9 ! EC/ASY OV] 0,MAN DISCOV]$ AT LA/0 ! EGOI/IC CRY ( PA9 PASSES UNHE>D1 & ! SPOOK ?AT HAS BECOME SO 9TIMATE IS TAK5 = \R TRUE EGO4 

,BUT 0,HUMANUS IS ! SA9T'S NAME0 7SEE ,GOE!71 & ! HUMANE IS ONLY ! MO/ CL>IFI$ SANCTITY4 

,! EGOI/ MAKES ! REV]SE DECL>ATION4 ,= ?IS PRECISE REASON1 BECAUSE Y\ HOLD SOME?+ SACR$1 ,I GIBE AT Y\2 &1 EV5 IF ,I RESPECT$ EV]Y?+ 9 Y\1 Y\R SANCTU>Y IS PRECISELY :AT ,I %\LD NOT RESPECT4 

,) !SE OPPOS$ VIEWS !RE MU/ ALSO BE ASSUM$ A CONTRADICTORY RELATION TO SPIRITUAL GOODS3 ! EGOI/ 9SULTS !M1 ! RELIGI\S MAN 7EV]Y ONE :O PUTS HIS 0ESS5CE0 ABOVE HIMSELF 7 MU/ CONSI/5TLY - PROTECT !M4 ,BUT :AT K9D ( SPIRITUAL GOODS >E TO BE PROTECT$1 & :AT LEFT UNPROTECT$1 DEP5DS 5TIRELY ON ! CONCEPT ?AT ONE =MS ( ! 0SUPREME BE+02 & HE :O FE>S ,GOD1 = EXAMPLE1 HAS MORE TO %ELT] ?AN HE 7! LIB]AL7 :O FE>S ,MAN4 

,9 SPIRITUAL GOODS WE >E 79 DI/9CTION FROM ! S5SU\S7 9JUR$ 9 A SPIRITUAL WAY1 & ! S9 AGA9/ !M CONSI/S 9 A DIRECT DESECRATION1 :ILE AGA9/ ! S5SU\S A PURLO9+ .<,5TW5DUNG.> OR ALI5ATION .<,5TFREMDUNG.> TAKES PLACE2 ! GOODS !MSELVES >E ROBB$ ( VALUE & ( CONSECRATION1 NOT M]ELY TAK5 AWAY2 ! SACR$ IS IMM$IATELY COMPROMIS$4 ,) ! WORD 0IRREV]5CE0 OR 0FLIPPANCY0 IS DESIGNAT$ EV]Y?+ ?AT CAN BE COMMITT$ AS CRIME AGA9/ SPIRITUAL GOODS1 AGA9/ EV]Y?+ ?AT IS SACR$ = US2 & SC(F+1 REVIL+1 CONTEMPT1 D\BT1 & ! LIKE1 >E ONLY DIFF]5T %ADES ( CRIM9AL FLIPPANCY4 

,?AT DESECRATION CAN BE PRACTIC$ 9 ! MO/ MANIFOLD WAY IS H]E TO BE PASS$ OV]1 & ONLY ?AT DESECRATION IS TO BE PREF]5TIALLY M5TION$ :I* ?REAT5S ! SACR$ ) DANG] ?R\< AN UNRE/RICT$ PRESS4 

,AS LONG AS RESPECT IS DEM&$ EV5 = ONE SPIRITUAL ESS5CE1 SPEE* & ! PRESS MU/ BE 5?RALL$ 9 ! NAME ( ?IS ESS5CE2 = JU/ SO LONG ! EGOI/ MI<T 0TRESPASS0 AGA9/ IT BY HIS UTT]ANCES1 FROM :I* ?+ HE MU/ BE H9D]$ BY 0DUE PUNI%M5T0 AT LEA/1 IF ONE DOES NOT PREF] TO TAKE UP ! MORE CORRECT MEANS AGA9/ IT1 ! PREV5TIVE USE ( POLICE AU?ORITY1 SU* AS C5SOR%IP4 

,:AT A SI<+ = LIB]TY ( ! PRESS6 ,:AT !N IS ! PRESS TO BE LIB]AT$ FROM8 ,SURELY FROM A DEP5D5CE1 A BELONG+1 & A LIABILITY TO S]VICE6 ,BUT TO LIB]ATE HIMSELF FROM ?AT IS EV]Y ONE'S AFFAIR1 & IT MAY ) SAFETY BE ASSUM$ ?AT1 :5 Y\ HAVE DELIV]$ Y\RSELF FROM LIABILITY TO S]VICE1 ?AT :I* Y\ COMPOSE & WRITE WILL ALSO BELONG TO Y\ AS Y\R [N 9/EAD ( HAV+ BE5 ?\<T & 9DICT$ 9 ! S]VICE ( SOME P[]4 ,:AT CAN A BELIEV] 9 ,*RI/ SAY & HAVE PR9T$1 ?AT %\LD BE FRE] FROM ?AT BELIEF 9 ,*RI/ ?AN HE HIMSELF IS8 ,IF ,I CANNOT OR MAY NOT WRITE SOME?+1 P]HAPS ! PRIM>Y FAULT LIES ) ME4 ,LITTLE AS ?IS SEEMS TO HIT ! PO9T1 SO NE> IS ! APPLICATION NEV]!LESS TO BE F\ND4 ,BY A PRESS-LAW ,I DRAW A B\ND>Y = MY PUBLICATIONS1 OR LET ONE BE DRAWN1 BEYOND :I* WRONG & ITS PUNI%M5T FOLL[S4 ,I MYSELF LIMIT MYSELF4 

,IF ! PRESS WAS TO BE FREE1 NO?+ W\LD BE SO IMPORTANT AS PRECISELY ITS LIB]ATION FROM EV]Y CO]CION ?AT C\LD BE PUT ON IT 9 ! NAME ( A LAW4 ,&1 ?AT IT MI<T COME TO ?AT1 ,I MY [N SELF %\LD HAVE TO HAVE ABSOLV$ MYSELF FROM OB$I5CE TO ! LAW4 

,C]TA9LY1 ! ABSOLUTE LIB]TY ( ! PRESS IS LIKE EV]Y ABSOLUTE LIB]TY1 A NON5TITY4 ,! PRESS CAN BECOME FREE FROM FULL MANY A ?+1 BUT ALWAYS ONLY FROM :AT ,I TOO AM FREE FROM4 ,IF WE MAKE \RSELVES FREE FROM ! SACR$1 IF WE HAVE BECOME GRACELESS & LAWLESS1 \R WORDS TOO WILL BECOME SO4 

,AS LITTLE AS WE CAN BE DECL>$ CLE> ( EV]Y CO]CION 9 ! WORLD1 SO LITTLE CAN \R WRIT+ BE )DRAWN FROM IT4 ,BUT AS FREE AS WE >E1 SO FREE WE CAN MAKE IT TOO4 

,IT MU/ !RE=E BECOME \R [N1 9/EAD (1 AS HI!RTO1 S]V+ A SPOOK4 

,PEOPLE DO NOT YET KN[ :AT !Y MEAN BY !IR CRY = LIB]TY ( ! PRESS4 ,:AT !Y O/5SIBLY ASK IS ?AT ! /ATE %ALL SET ! PRESS FREE2 BUT :AT !Y >E REALLY AFT]1 )\T KN[+ IT !MSELVES1 IS ?AT ! PRESS BECOME FREE FROM ! /ATE1 OR CLE> ( ! /ATE4 ,! =M] IS A PETITION TO ! /ATE1 ! LATT] AN 9SURRECTION AGA9/ ! /ATE4 ,AS A 0PETITION = RI<T10 EV5 AS A S]I\S DEM&+ ( ! RI<T ( LIB]TY ( ! PRESS1 IT PRESUPPOSES ! /ATE AS ! GIV]1 & CAN HOPE ONLY = A PRES5T1 A P]MISSION1 A *>T]+4 ,POSSIBLE1 NO D\BT1 ?AT A /ATE ACTS SO S5SELESSLY AS TO GRANT ! DEM&$ PRES5T2 BUT Y\ MAY BET EV]Y?+ ?AT ?OSE :O RECEIVE ! PRES5T WILL NOT KN[ H[ TO USE IT SO LONG AS !Y REG>D ! /ATE AS A TRU?3 !Y WILL NOT TRESPASS AGA9/ ?IS 0SACR$ ?+10 & WILL CALL = A P5AL PRESS-LAW AGA9/ EV]Y ONE :O W\LD BE WILL+ TO D>E ?IS4 

,9 A WORD1 ! PRESS DOES NOT BECOME FREE FROM :AT ,I AM NOT FREE FROM4 

,DO ,I P]HAPS H]EBY %[ MYSELF AN OPPON5T ( ! LIB]TY ( ! PRESS8 ,ON ! CONTR>Y1 ,I ONLY ASS]T ?AT ONE WILL NEV] GET IT IF ONE WANTS ONLY IT1 ! LIB]TY ( ! PRESS1 IF ONE SETS \T ONLY = AN UNRE/RICT$ P]MISSION4 ,ONLY BEG RI<T ALONG = ?IS P]MISSION3 Y\ MAY WAIT =EV] = IT1 = !RE IS NO ONE 9 ! WORLD :O C\LD GIVE IT TO Y\4 ,AS LONG AS Y\ WANT TO HAVE Y\RSELVES 05TITL$0 TO ! USE ( ! PRESS BY A P]MISSION1 Y\ LIVE 9 VA9 HOPE & COMPLA9T4 

0,NONS5SE6 ,:Y1 Y\ Y\RSELF1 :O H>BOR SU* ?\<TS AS /& 9 Y\R BOOK1 CAN UN=TUNATELY BR+ !M TO PUBLICITY ONLY ?R\< A LUCKY *ANCE OR BY /EAL?2 NEV]!LESS Y\ WILL 9VEI< AGA9/ ONE'S PRESS+ & IMPORTUN+ HIS [N /ATE UNTIL IT GIVES ! REFUS$ P]MISSION TO PR9T80 ,BUT AN AU?OR ?US ADDRESS$ W\LD P]HAPS - = ! IMPUD5CE ( SU* PEOPLE GOES F> - GIVE ! FOLL[+ REPLY3 0,CONSID] WELL :AT Y\ SAY6 ,:AT !N DO ,I DO TO PROCURE MYSELF LIB]TY ( ! PRESS = MY BOOK8 ,DO ,I ASK = P]MISSION1 OR DO ,I NOT RA!R1 )\T ANY QUE/ION ( LEGALITY1 SEEK A FAVORABLE OCCASION & GRASP IT 9 COMPLETE RECKLESSNESS ( ! /ATE & ITS WI%ES8 ,I - ! T]RIFY+ WORD MU/ BE UTT]$ - ,I *EAT ! /ATE4 ,Y\ UNCONSCI\SLY DO ! SAME4 ,FROM Y\R TRIBUNES Y\ TALK IT 9TO ! IDEA ?AT IT MU/ GIVE UP ITS SANCTITY & 9VIOLABILITY1 IT MU/ LAY ITSELF B>E TO ! ATTACKS ( WRIT]S1 )\T NE$+ ON ?AT ACC\NT TO FE> DANG]4 ,BUT Y\ >E IMPOS+ ON IT2 = ITS EXI/5CE IS DONE = AS SOON AS IT LOSES ITS UNAPPROA*ABL5ESS4 ,TO Y\ 9DE$ IT MI<T WELL ACCORD LIB]TY ( WRIT+1 AS ,5GL& HAS DONE2 Y\ >E BELIEV]S 9 ! /ATE & 9CAPABLE ( WRIT+ AGA9/ ! /ATE1 H[EV] MU* Y\ W\LD LIKE TO RE=M IT & 'REM$Y ITS DEFECTS4' ,BUT :AT IF OPPON5TS ( ! /ATE AVAIL$ !MSELVES ( FREE UTT]ANCE1 & /ORM$ \T AGA9/ ,*UR*1 /ATE1 MORALS1 & EV]Y?+ 'SACR$' ) 9EXORABLE REASONS8 ,Y\ W\LD !N BE ! FIR/1 9 T]RIBLE AGONIES1 TO CALL 9TO LIFE ! ,SEPTEMB] LAWS4 ,TOO LATE W\LD Y\ !N RUE ! /UPIDITY ?AT E>LI] MADE Y\ SO READY TO FOOL & PALAV] 9TO COMPLIANCE ! /ATE1 OR ! GOV]NM5T ( ! /ATE4 - ,BUT1 ,I PROVE BY MY ACT ONLY TWO ?+S4 ,?IS = ONE1 ?AT ! LIB]TY ( ! PRESS IS ALWAYS B\ND TO 'FAVORABLE OPPORTUNITIES1' & ACCORD+LY WILL NEV] BE AN ABSOLUTE LIB]TY2 BUT SECONDLY ?IS1 ?AT HE :O W\LD 5JOY IT MU/ SEEK \T &1 IF POSSIBLE1 CREATE ! FAVORABLE OPPORTUNITY1 AVAIL+ HIMSELF ( HIS [N ADVANTAGE AGA9/ ! /ATE2 & C\NT+ HIMSELF & HIS WILL MORE ?AN ! /ATE & EV]Y 'SUP]IOR' P[]4 ,NOT 9 ! /ATE1 BUT ONLY AGA9/ IT1 CAN ! LIB]TY ( ! PRESS BE C>RI$ ?R\<2 IF IT IS TO BE E/ABLI%$1 IT IS TO BE OBTA9$ NOT AS ! CONSEQU5CE ( A PETITION BUT AS ! WORK ( AN 9SURRECTION4 ,EV]Y PETITION & EV]Y MOTION = LIB]TY ( ! PRESS IS ALREADY AN 9SURRECTION1 BE IT CONSCI\S OR UNCONSCI\S3 A ?+ :I* ,PHILI/9E HALFNESS ALONE WILL NOT & CANNOT CONFESS TO ITSELF UNTIL1 ) A %R9K+ %UDD]1 IT %ALL SEE IT CLE>LY & IRREFUTABLY BY ! \TCOME4 ,= ! REQUE/$ LIB]TY ( ! PRESS HAS 9DE$ A FRI5DLY & WELL-MEAN+ FACE AT ! BEG9N+1 AS IT IS NOT 9 ! LEA/ M9D$ EV] TO LET ! '9SOL5CE ( ! PRESS' COME 9TO VOGUE2 BUT LITTLE BY LITTLE ITS HE>T GR[S MORE H>D5$1 & ! 9F]5CE FLATT]S ITS WAY 9 ?AT REALLY A LIB]TY IS NOT A LIB]TY IF IT /&S 9 ! S]VICE ( ! /ATE1 ( MORALS1 OR ( ! LAW4 ,A LIB]TY 9DE$ FROM ! CO]CION ( C5SOR%IP1 IT IS YET NOT A LIB]TY FROM ! CO]CION ( LAW4 ,! PRESS1 ONCE SEIZ$ BY ! LU/ = LIB]TY1 ALWAYS WANTS TO GR[ FRE]1 UNTIL AT LA/ ! WRIT] SAYS TO HIMSELF1 REALLY ,I AM NOT :OLLY FREE UNTIL ,I ASK AB\T NO?+2 & WRIT+ IS FREE ONLY :5 IT IS MY [N1 DICTAT$ TO ME BY NO P[] OR AU?ORITY1 BY NO FAI?1 NO DREAD2 ! PRESS MU/ NOT BE FREE - ?AT IS TOO LITTLE - IT MU/ BE M9E3 - [NNESS ( ! PRESS OR PROP]TY 9 ! PRESS1 ?AT IS :AT ,I WILL TAKE4 

0,:Y1 LIB]TY ( ! PRESS IS ONLY P]MISSION ( ! PRESS1 & ! /ATE NEV] WILL OR CAN VOLUNT>ILY P]MIT ME TO GR9D IT TO NO?+NESS BY ! PRESS40 

,LET US N[1 9 CONCLUSION1 BETT]+ ! ABOVE LANGUAGE1 :I* IS /ILL VAGUE1 [+ TO ! PHRASE 'LIB]TY ( ! PRESS1' RA!R PUT IT ?US3 0LIB]TY ( ! PRESS1 ! LIB]ALS' L\D DEM&1 IS ASSUR$LY POSSIBLE 9 ! /ATE2 YES1 IT IS POSSIBLE ONLY 9 ! /ATE1 BECAUSE IT IS A P]MISSION1 & CONSEQU5TLY ! P]MITT] 7! /ATE7 MU/ NOT BE LACK+4 ,BUT AS P]MISSION IT HAS ITS LIMIT 9 ?IS V]Y /ATE1 :I* SURELY %\LD NOT 9 REASON P]MIT MORE ?AN IS COMPATIBLE ) ITSELF & ITS WELF>E3 ! /ATE FIXES = IT ?IS LIMIT AS ! LAW ( ITS EXI/5CE & ( ITS EXT5SION4 ,?AT ONE /ATE BROOKS MORE ?AN ANO!R IS ONLY A QUANTITATIVE DI/9CTION1 :I* ALONE1 NEV]!LESS1 LIES AT ! HE>T ( ! POLITICAL LIB]ALS3 !Y WANT 9 ,G]MANY1 = EXAMPLE1 ONLY A 'MORE EXT5D$1 BROAD] ACCORDANCE ( FREE UTT]ANCE4' ,! LIB]TY ( ! PRESS :I* IS S\<T = IS AN AFFAIR ( ! PEOPLE'4S1 & BE=E ! PEOPLE 7! /ATE7 POSSESSES IT ,I MAY MAKE NO USE ( IT4 ,FROM ! /&-PO9T ( PROP]TY 9 ! PRESS1 ! SITUATION IS DIFF]5T4 ,LET MY PEOPLE1 IF !Y WILL1 GO )\T LIB]TY ( FREE PRESS1 ,I WILL MANAGE TO PR9T BY =CE OR RUSE2 ,I GET MY P]MISSION TO PR9T ONLY FROM - MYSELF & MY /R5G?4 

,IF ! PRESS IS MY [N1 ,I AS LITTLE NE$ A P]MISSION ( ! /ATE = EMPLOY+ IT AS ,I SEEK ?AT P]MISSION 9 ORD] TO BL[ MY NOSE4 ,! PRESS IS MY PROP]TY FROM ! MOM5T :5 NO?+ IS MORE TO ME ?AN MYSELF2 = FROM ?IS MOM5T /ATE1 ,*UR*1 PEOPLE1 SOCIETY1 & ! LIKE1 CEASE1 BECAUSE !Y HAVE TO ?ANK = !IR EXI/5CE ONLY ! DISRESPECT ?AT ,I HAVE = MYSELF1 & ) ! VANI%+ ( ?IS UND]VALUATION !Y !MSELVES >E EXT+UI%$3 !Y EXI/ ONLY :5 !Y EXI/ ABOVE ME1 EXI/ ONLY AS P[]S & P[]-HOLD]S4 ,OR CAN Y\ IMAG9E A /ATE :OSE CITIZ5S ONE & ALL ?9K NO?+ ( IT8 ,IT W\LD BE AS C]TA9LY A DREAM1 AN EXI/5CE 9 SEEM+1 AS 'UNIT$ ,G]MANY4' 

,! PRESS IS MY [N AS SOON AS ,I MYSELF AM MY [N1 A SELF-[N$ MAN3 TO ! EGOI/ BELONGS ! WORLD1 BECAUSE HE BELONGS TO NO P[] ( ! WORLD4 

,) ?IS MY PRESS MI<T /ILL BE V]Y UNFREE1 AS AT ?IS MOM5T4 ,BUT ! WORLD IS L>GE1 & ONE HELPS HIMSELF AS WELL AS HE CAN4 ,IF ,I W]E WILL+ TO ABATE FROM ! PROP]TY ( MY PRESS1 ,I C\LD EASILY ATTA9 ! PO9T :]E ,I MI<T EV]Y:]E HAVE AS MU* PR9T$ AS MY F+]S PRODUC$4 ,BUT1 AS ,I WANT TO ASS]T MY PROP]TY1 ,I MU/ NECESS>ILY SW9DLE MY 5EMIES4 ',W\LD Y\ NOT ACCEPT !IR P]MISSION IF IT W]E GIV5 Y\8' ,C]TA9LY1 ) JOY2 = !IR P]MISSION W\LD BE TO ME A PRO( ?AT ,I HAD FOOL$ !M & />T$ !M ON ! ROAD TO RU94 ,I AM NOT CONC]N$ = !IR P]MISSION1 BUT SO MU* ! MORE = !IR FOLLY & !IR OV]?R[4 ,I DO NOT SUE = !IR P]MISSION AS IF ,I FLATT]$ MYSELF 7LIKE ! POLITICAL LIB]ALS7 ?AT WE BO?1 !Y & ,I1 C\LD MAKE \T PEACEABLY ALONGSIDE & ) EA* O!R1 YES1 PROBABLY RAISE & PROP EA* O!R2 BUT ,I SUE = IT 9 ORD] TO MAKE !M BLE$ TO DEA? BY IT1 ?AT ! P]MITT]S !MSELVES MAY CEASE AT LA/4 ,I ACT AS A CONSCI\S 5EMY1 OV]REA*+ !M & UTILIZ+ !IR HE$LESSNESS4 

,! PRESS IS M9E :5 ,I RECOGNIZE \TSIDE MYSELF NO JUDGE :ATEV] OV] ITS UTILIZATION1 :5 MY WRIT+ IS NO LONG] DET]M9$ BY MORALITY OR RELIGION OR RESPECT = ! /ATE LAWS OR ! LIKE1 BUT BY ME & MY EGOISM60 

,N[1 :AT HAVE Y\ TO REPLY TO HIM :O GIVES Y\ SO IMPUD5T AN ANSW]8 - ,WE %ALL P]HAPS PUT ! QUE/ION MO/ /RIK+LY BY PHRAS+ IT AS FOLL[S3 ,:OSE IS ! PRESS1 ! PEOPLE'S 7/ATE'S7 OR M9E8 ,! POLITICALS ON !IR SIDE 9T5D NO?+ FUR!R ?AN TO LIB]ATE ! PRESS FROM P]SONAL & >BITR>Y 9T]F]5CES ( ! POSSESSORS ( P[]1 )\T ?9K+ ( ! PO9T ?AT TO BE REALLY OP5 = EV]YBODY IT W\LD ALSO HAVE TO BE FREE FROM ! LAWS1 FROM ! PEOPLE'S 7/ATE'S7 WILL4 ,!Y WANT TO MAKE A 0PEOPLE'S AFFAIR0 ( IT4 

,BUT1 HAV+ BECOME ! PEOPLE'S PROP]TY1 IT IS /ILL F> FROM BE+ M9E2 RA!R1 IT RETA9S = ME ! SUBORD9ATE SIGNIFICANCE ( A P]MISSION4 ,! PEOPLE PLAYS JUDGE OV] MY ?\<TS2 IT HAS ! RI<T ( CALL+ ME TO ACC\NT = !M1 OR1 ,I AM RESPONSIBLE TO IT = !M4 ,JURORS1 :5 !IR FIX$ IDEAS >E ATTACK$1 HAVE JU/ AS H>D HEADS AS ! /IFFE/ DESPOTS & !IR S]VILE (FICIALS4 

,9 ,DIE ,LIB]AL5 ,BE/REBUNG5 ,$G> ,BAU] ASS]TS ?AT LIB]TY ( ! PRESS IS IMPOSSIBLE 9 ! ABSOLUTI/ & ! CON/ITUTIONAL /ATE1 :]EAS 9 ! 0FREE /ATE0 IT F9DS ITS PLACE4 0,H]E10 ! /ATEM5T IS1 0IT IS RECOGNIZ$ ?AT ! 9DIVIDUAL1 BECAUSE HE IS NO LONG] AN 9DIVIDUAL BUT A MEMB] ( A TRUE & RATIONAL G5]ALITY1 HAS ! RI<T TO UTT] HIS M9D40 ,SO NOT ! 9DIVIDUAL1 BUT ! 0MEMB]10 HAS LIB]TY ( ! PRESS4 ,BUT1 IF = ! PURPOSE ( LIB]TY ( ! PRESS ! 9DIVIDUAL MU/ FIR/ GIVE PRO( ( HIMSELF REG>D+ HIS BELIEF 9 ! G5]ALITY1 ! PEOPLE2 IF HE DOES NOT HAVE ?IS LIB]TY ?R\< MI<T ( HIS [N - !N IT IS A PEOPLE'S LIB]TY1 A LIB]TY ?AT HE IS 9VE/$ ) = ! SAKE ( HIS FAI?1 HIS 0MEMB]%IP40 ,! REV]SE IS ! CASE3 IT IS PRECISELY AS AN 9DIVIDUAL ?AT EV]Y ONE HAS OP5 TO HIM ! LIB]TY TO UTT] HIS M9D4 ,BUT HE HAS NOT ! 0RI<T03 ?AT LIB]TY IS ASSUR$LY NOT HIS 0SACR$ RI<T40 ,HE HAS ONLY ! MI<T2 BUT ! MI<T ALONE MAKES HIM [N]4 ,I NE$ NO CONCESSION = ! LIB]TY ( ! PRESS1 DO NOT NE$ ! PEOPLE'S CONS5T TO IT1 DO NOT NE$ ! 0RI<T0 TO IT1 NOR ANY 0JU/IFICATION40 ,! LIB]TY ( ! PRESS TOO1 LIKE EV]Y LIB]TY1 ,I MU/ 0TAKE02 ! PEOPLE1 0AS BE+ ! SOLE JUDGE10 CANNOT GIVE IT TO ME4 ,IT CAN PUT UP ) ME ! LIB]TY ?AT ,I TAKE1 OR DEF5D ITSELF AGA9/ IT2 GIVE1 BE/[1 GRANT IT1 IT CANNOT4 ,I EX]CISE IT DESPITE ! PEOPLE1 PURELY AS AN 9DIVIDUAL2 ,I GET IT BY FI<T+ ! PEOPLE1 MY - 5EMY1 & OBTA9 IT ONLY :5 ,I REALLY GET IT BY SU* FI<T+1 TAKE IT4 ,BUT ,I TAKE IT BECAUSE IT IS MY PROP]TY4 

,S&]1 AGA9/ :OM ,E4 ,BAU] WRITES1 LAYS CLAIM 7P4 #i#i7 TO ! LIB]TY ( ! PRESS 0AS ! RI<T & ! LIB]TY ( ! CITIZ5S 9 ! /ATE04 ,:AT ELSE DOES ,$G> ,BAU] DO8 ,TO HIM ALSO IT IS ONLY A RI<T ( ! FREE CITIZ54 

,! LIB]TY ( ! PRESS IS ALSO DEM&$ UND] ! NAME ( A 0G5]AL HUMAN RI<T40 ,AGA9/ ?IS ! OBJECTION WAS WELL-F\ND$ ?AT NOT EV]Y MAN KNEW H[ TO USE IT RI<TLY1 = NOT EV]Y 9DIVIDUAL WAS TRULY MAN4 ,NEV] DID A GOV]NM5T REFUSE IT TO ,MAN AS SU*2 BUT ,MAN WRITES NO?+1 = ! REASON ?AT HE IS A <O/4 ,IT ALWAYS REFUS$ IT TO 9DIVIDUALS ONLY1 & GAVE IT TO O!RS1 ITS ORGANS4 ,IF !N ONE W\LD HAVE IT = ALL1 ONE MU/ ASS]T \TRI<T ?AT IT IS DUE TO ! 9DIVIDUAL1 ME1 NOT TO MAN OR TO ! 9DIVIDUAL SO F> AS HE IS MAN4 ,BESIDES1 ANO!R ?AN A MAN 7A BEA/7 CAN MAKE NO USE ( IT4 ,! ,FR5* GOV]NM5T1 = EXAMPLE1 DOES NOT DISPUTE ! LIB]TY ( ! PRESS AS A RI<T ( MAN1 BUT DEM&S FROM ! 9DIVIDUAL A SECURITY = HIS REALLY BE+ MAN2 = IT ASSIGNS LIB]TY ( ! PRESS NOT TO ! 9DIVIDUAL1 BUT TO MAN4 

,UND] ! EXACT PRET5SE ?AT IT WAS NOT HUMAN1 :AT WAS M9E WAS TAK5 FROM ME6 ,:AT WAS HUMAN WAS LEFT TO ME UNDIM9I%$4 

,LIB]TY ( ! PRESS CAN BR+ AB\T ONLY A RESPONSIBLE PRESS2 ! IRRESPONSIBLE PROCE$S SOLELY FROM PROP]TY 9 ! PRESS4 

,= 9T]C\RSE ) M5 AN EXPRESS LAW 7CON=MITY TO :I* ONE MAY V5TURE AT TIMES S9FULLY TO =GET1 BUT ! ABSOLUTE VALUE ( :I* ONE AT NO TIME V5TURES TO D5Y7 IS PLAC$ =EMO/ AMONG ALL :O LIVE RELIGI\SLY3 ?IS IS ! LAW - ( LOVE1 TO :I* NOT EV5 ?OSE :O SEEM TO FI<T AGA9/ ITS PR9CIPLE1 & :O HATE ITS NAME1 HAVE AS YET BECOME UNTRUE2 = !Y ALSO /ILL HAVE LOVE1 YES1 !Y LOVE ) A DEEP] & MORE SUBLIMAT$ LOVE1 !Y LOVE 0MAN & MANK9D40 

,IF WE =MULATE ! S5SE ( ?IS LAW1 IT WILL BE AB\T AS FOLL[S3 ,EV]Y MAN MU/ HAVE A SOME?+ ?AT IS MORE TO HIM ?AN HIMSELF4 ,Y\ >E TO PUT Y\R 0PRIVATE 9T]E/0 9 ! BACKGR\ND :5 IT IS A QUE/ION ( ! WELF>E ( O!RS1 ! WEAL ( ! FA!RL&1 ( SOCIETY1 ! COMMON WEAL1 ! WEAL ( MANK9D1 ! GOOD CAUSE1 & ! LIKE6 ,FA!RL&1 SOCIETY1 MANK9D1 MU/ BE MORE TO Y\ ?AN Y\RSELF1 & AS AGA9/ !IR 9T]E/ Y\R 0PRIVATE 9T]E/0 MU/ /& BACK2 = Y\ MU/ NOT BE AN - EGOI/4 

,LOVE IS A F>-REA*+ RELIGI\S DEM&1 :I* IS NOT1 AS MI<T BE SUPPOS$1 LIMIT$ TO LOVE TO ,GOD & MAN1 BUT /&S =EMO/ 9 EV]Y REG>D4 ,:ATEV] WE DO1 ?9K1 WILL1 ! GR\ND ( IT IS ALWAYS TO BE LOVE4 ,?US WE MAY 9DE$ JUDGE1 BUT ONLY 0) LOVE40 ,! ,BIBLE MAY ASSUR$LY BE CRITICIZ$1 & ?AT V]Y ?OR\<LY1 BUT ! CRITIC MU/ BE=E ALL ?+S LOVE IT & SEE 9 IT ! SACR$ BOOK4 ,IS ?IS ANY?+ ELSE ?AN TO SAY HE MU/ NOT CRITICIZE IT TO DEA?1 HE MU/ LEAVE IT /&+1 & ?AT AS A SACR$ ?+ ?AT CANNOT BE UPSET8 - ,9 \R CRITICISM ON M5 TOO1 LOVE MU/ REMA9 ! UN*ANG$ KEY-NOTE4 ,C]TA9LY JUDGM5TS ?AT HATR$ 9SPIRES >E NOT AT ALL \R [N JUDGM5TS1 BUT JUDGM5TS ( ! HATR$ ?AT RULES US1 0RANCOR\S JUDGM5TS40 ,BUT >E JUDGM5TS ?AT LOVE 9SPIRES 9 US ANY MORE \R [N 8 ,!Y >E JUDGM5TS ( ! LOVE ?AT RULES US1 !Y >E 0LOV+1 L5I5T0 JUDGM5TS1 !Y >E NOT \R [N1 & ACCORD+LY NOT REAL JUDGM5TS AT ALL4 ,HE :O BURNS ) LOVE = JU/ICE CRIES \T1 FIAT JU/ITIA1 P]EAT MUNDUS6 ,HE CAN D\BTLESS ASK & 9VE/IGATE :AT JU/ICE PROP]LY IS OR DEM&S1 & 9 :AT IT CONSI/S1 BUT NOT :E!R IT IS ANY?+4 

,IT IS V]Y TRUE1 0,HE :O ABIDES 9 LOVE ABIDES 9 ,GOD1 & ,GOD 9 HIM40 7#a ,JOHN #d3#a#f47 ,GOD ABIDES 9 HIM1 HE DOES NOT GET RID ( ,GOD1 DOES NOT BECOME GODLESS2 & HE ABIDES 9 ,GOD1 DOES NOT COME TO HIMSELF & 9TO HIS [N HOME1 ABIDES 9 LOVE TO ,GOD & DOES NOT BECOME LOVELESS4 

0,GOD IS LOVE6 ,ALL TIMES & ALL RACES RECOGNIZE 9 ?IS WORD ! C5TRAL PO9T ( ,*RI/IANITY40 ,GOD1 :O IS LOVE1 IS AN (FICI\S ,GOD3 HE CANNOT LEAVE ! WORLD 9 PEACE1 BUT WANTS TO MAKE IT BLESS$4 0,GOD BECAME MAN TO MAKE M5 DIV9E4 ,HE HAS HIS H& 9 ! GAME EV]Y:]E1 & NO?+ HAPP5S )\T IT2 EV]Y:]E HE HAS HIS 0BE/ PURPOSES10 HIS 09COMPREH5SIBLE PLANS & DECREES40 ,REASON1 :I* HE HIMSELF IS1 IS TO BE =W>D$ & REALIZ$ 9 ! :OLE WORLD4 ,HIS FA!RLY C>E DEPRIVES US ( ALL 9DEP5D5CE4 ,WE CAN DO NO?+ S5SIBLE )\T ITS BE+ SAID1 ,GOD DID ?AT1 & CAN BR+ UPON \RSELVES NO MIS=TUNE )\T HE>+1 ,GOD ORDA9$ ?AT2 WE HAVE NO?+ ?AT WE HAVE NOT FROM HIM1 HE 0GAVE0 EV]Y?+4 ,BUT1 AS ,GOD DOES1 SO DOES ,MAN4 ,GOD WANTS P]=CE TO MAKE ! WORLD BLESS$1 & ,MAN WANTS TO MAKE IT HAPPY1 TO MAKE ALL M5 HAPPY4 ,H5CE EV]Y 0MAN0 WANTS TO AWAK5 9 ALL M5 ! REASON :I* HE SUPPOSES HIS [N SELF TO HAVE3 EV]Y?+ IS TO BE RATIONAL ?R\<\T4 ,GOD TORM5TS HIMSELF ) ! DEVIL1 & ! PHILOSOPH] DOES IT ) UNREASON & ! ACCID5TAL4 ,GOD LETS NO BE+ GO ITS [N GAIT1 & ,MAN LIKEWISE WANTS TO MAKE US WALK ONLY 9 HUMAN MANN]4 

,BUT :OSO IS FULL ( SACR$ 7RELIGI\S1 MORAL1 HUMANE7 LOVE LOVES ONLY ! SPOOK1 ! 0TRUE MAN10 & P]SECUTES ) DULL M]CILESSNESS ! 9DIVIDUAL1 ! REAL MAN1 UND] ! PHLEGMATIC LEGAL TITLE ( MEASURES AGA9/ ! 0UN-MAN40 ,HE F9DS IT PRAISEWOR?Y & 9DISP5SABLE TO EX]CISE PITILESSNESS 9 ! H>%E/ MEASURE2 = LOVE TO ! SPOOK OR G5]ALITY COMM&S HIM TO HATE HIM :O IS NOT <O/LY1 ! EGOI/ OR 9DIVIDUAL2 SU* IS ! MEAN+ ( ! R5[N$ LOVE-PH5OM5ON ?AT IS CALL$ 0JU/ICE40 

,! CRIM9ALLY >RAIGN$ MAN CAN EXPECT NO =BE>ANCE1 & NO ONE SPREADS A FRI5DLY VEIL OV] HIS UNHAPPY NAK$NESS4 ,)\T EMOTION ! /]N JUDGE TE>S ! LA/ RAGS ( EXCUSE FROM ! BODY ( ! POOR ACCUS$2 )\T COMPASSION ! JAIL] DRAGS HIM 9TO HIS DAMP ABODE2 )\T PLACABILITY1 :5 ! TIME ( PUNI%M5T HAS EXPIR$1 HE ?RU/S ! BR&$ MAN AGA9 AMONG M51 HIS GOOD1 ,*RI/IAN1 LOYAL BRE?R51 :O CONTEMPTU\SLY SPIT ON HIM4 ,YES1 )\T GRACE A CRIM9AL 0DES]V+ ( DEA?0 IS L$ TO ! SCAFFOLD1 & BE=E ! EYES ( A JUBILAT+ CR[D ! APPEAS$ MORAL LAW CELEBRATES ITS SUBLIME - REV5GE4 ,= ONLY ONE CAN LIVE1 ! MORAL LAW OR ! CRIM9AL4 ,:]E CRIM9ALS LIVE UNPUNI%$1 ! MORAL LAW HAS FALL52 &1 :]E ?IS PREVAILS1 ?OSE MU/ GO D[N4 ,!IR 5MITY IS 9DE/RUCTIBLE4 

,! ,*RI/IAN AGE IS PRECISELY ?AT ( M]CY1 LOVE1 SOLICITUDE TO HAVE M5 RECEIVE :AT IS DUE !M1 YES1 TO BR+ !M TO FULFILL !IR HUMAN 7DIV9E7 CALL+4 ,!RE=E ! PR9CIPLE HAS BE5 PUT =EMO/ = 9T]C\RSE1 ?AT ?IS & ?AT IS MAN'S ESS5CE & CONSEQU5TLY HIS CALL+1 TO :I* EI!R ,GOD HAS CALL$ HIM OR 7ACCORD+ TO ! CONCEPTS ( TODAY7 HIS BE+ MAN 7! SPECIES7 CALLS HIM4 ,H5CE ! ZEAL = CONV]SION4 ,?AT ! ,COMMUNI/S & ! HUMANE EXPECT FROM MAN MORE ?AN ! ,*RI/IANS DO DOES NOT *ANGE ! /&-PO9T 9 ! LEA/4 ,MAN %ALL GET :AT IS HUMAN6 ,IF IT WAS 5\< = ! PI\S ?AT :AT WAS DIV9E BECAME HIS P>T1 ! HUMANE DEM& ?AT HE BE NOT CURTAIL$ ( :AT IS HUMAN4 ,BO? SET !MSELVES AGA9/ :AT IS EGOI/IC4 ,( C\RSE2 = :AT IS EGOI/IC CANNOT BE ACCORD$ TO HIM OR VE/$ 9 HIM 7A FIEF72 HE MU/ PROCURE IT = HIMSELF4 ,LOVE IMP>TS ! =M]1 ! LATT] CAN BE GIV5 TO ME BY MYSELF ALONE4 

,9T]C\RSE HI!RTO HAS RE/$ ON LOVE1 REG>DFUL BEHAVIOR1 DO+ = EA* O!R4 ,AS ONE [$ IT TO HIMSELF TO MAKE HIMSELF BLESS$1 OR [$ HIMSELF ! BLISS ( TAK+ UP 9TO HIMSELF ! SUPREME ESS5CE & BR++ IT TO A V]ITE 7A TRU? & REALITY71 SO ONE [$ IT TO O!RS TO HELP !M REALIZE !IR ESS5CE & !IR CALL+3 9 BO? CASES ONE [$ IT TO ! ESS5CE ( MAN TO CONTRIBUTE TO ITS REALIZATION4 

,BUT ONE [ES IT NEI!R TO HIMSELF TO MAKE ANY?+ \T ( HIMSELF1 NOR TO O!RS TO MAKE ANY?+ \T ( !M2 = ONE [ES NO?+ TO HIS ESS5CE & ?AT ( O!RS4 ,9T]C\RSE RE/+ ON ESS5CE IS AN 9T]C\RSE ) ! SPOOK1 NOT ) ANY?+ REAL4 ,IF ,I HOLD 9T]C\RSE ) ! SUPREME ESS5CE1 ,I AM NOT HOLD+ 9T]C\RSE ) MYSELF1 &1 IF ,I HOLD 9T]C\RSE ) ! ESS5CE ( MAN1 ,I AM NOT HOLD+ 9T]C\RSE ) M54 

,! NATURAL MAN'S LOVE BECOMES ?R\< CULTURE A COMM&M5T4 ,BUT AS COMM&M5T IT BELONGS TO ,MAN AS SU*4 NOT TO ME2 IT IS MY ESS5CE .<,WES5.>1 AB\T :I* MU* FUSS .<,WES5S.> IS MADE4 NOT MY PROP]TY4 ,MAN1 HUMANITY1 PRES5TS ?AT DEM& TO ME2 LOVE IS DEM&$1 IT IS MY DUTY4 ,9/EAD1 !RE=E1 ( BE+ REALLY WON = ME1 IT HAS BE5 WON = ! G5]ALITY1 ,MAN1 AS HIS PROP]TY OR PECULI>ITY3 0IT BECOMES MAN1 EV]Y MAN1 TO LOVE2 LOVE IS ! DUTY & CALL+ ( MAN10 ETC4 

,CONSEQU5TLY ,I MU/ AGA9 V9DICATE LOVE = MYSELF1 & DELIV] IT \T ( ! P[] ( ,MAN ) ! GREAT ,M4 

,:AT WAS ORIG9ALLY M9E1 BUT ACCID5TALLY M9E1 9/9CTIVELY M9E1 ,I WAS 9VE/$ ) AS ! PROP]TY ( ,MAN2 ,I BECAME FE(FEE 9 LOV+1 ,I BECAME ! RETA9] ( MANK9D1 ONLY A SPECIM5 ( ?IS SPECIES1 & ACT$1 LOV+1 NOT AS ,I1 BUT AS MAN1 AS A SPECIM5 ( MAN1 ! HUMANLY4 ,! :OLE CONDITION ( CIVILIZATION IS ! FEUDAL SY/EM1 ! PROP]TY BE+ ,MAN'S OR MANK9D'S1 NOT M9E4 ,A MON/R\S FEUDAL /ATE WAS F\ND$1 ! 9DIVIDUAL ROBB$ ( EV]Y?+1 EV]Y?+ LEFT TO 0MAN40 ,! 9DIVIDUAL HAD TO APPE> AT LA/ AS A 0S9N] ?R\< & ?R\<40 

,AM ,I P]*ANCE TO HAVE NO LIVELY 9T]E/ 9 ! P]SON ( ANO!R1 >E HIS JOY & HIS WEAL NOT TO LIE AT MY HE>T1 IS ! 5JOYM5T ?AT ,I FURNI% HIM NOT TO BE MORE TO ME ?AN O!R 5JOYM5TS ( MY [N8 ,ON ! CONTR>Y1 ,I CAN ) JOY SACRIFICE TO HIM NUMB]LESS 5JOYM5TS1 ,I CAN D5Y MYSELF NUMB]LESS ?+S = ! 5HANCEM5T ( HIS PLEASURE1 & ,I CAN HAZ>D = HIM :AT )\T HIM WAS ! DE>E/ TO ME1 MY LIFE1 MY WELF>E1 MY FRE$OM4 ,:Y1 IT CON/ITUTES MY PLEASURE & MY HAPP9ESS TO REFRE% MYSELF ) HIS HAPP9ESS & HIS PLEASURE4 ,BUT MYSELF1 MY [N SELF1 ,I DO NOT SACRIFICE TO HIM1 BUT REMA9 AN EGOI/ & - 5JOY HIM4 ,IF ,I SACRIFICE TO HIM EV]Y?+ ?AT BUT = MY LOVE TO HIM ,I %\LD KEEP1 ?AT IS V]Y SIMPLE1 & EV5 MORE USUAL 9 LIFE ?AN IT SEEMS TO BE2 BUT IT PROVES NO?+ FUR!R ?AN ?AT ?IS ONE PASSION IS MORE P[]FUL 9 ME ?AN ALL ! RE/4 ,*RI/IANITY TOO TEA*ES US TO SACRIFICE ALL O!R PASSIONS TO ?IS4 ,BUT1 IF TO ONE PASSION ,I SACRIFICE O!RS1 ,I DO NOT ON ?AT ACC\NT GO SO F> AS TO SACRIFICE MYSELF1 NOR SACRIFICE ANY?+ ( ?AT :]EBY ,I TRULY AM MYSELF2 ,I DO NOT SACRIFICE MY PECULI> VALUE1 MY [NNESS4 ,:]E ?IS BAD CASE OCCURS1 LOVE CUTS NO BETT] FIGURE ?AN ANY O!R PASSION ?AT ,I OBEY BL9DLY4 ,! AMBITI\S MAN1 :O IS C>RI$ AWAY BY AMBITION & REMA9S DEAF TO EV]Y W>N+ ?AT A CALM MOM5T BEGETS 9 HIM1 HAS LET ?IS PASSION GR[ UP 9TO A DESPOT AGA9/ :OM HE AB&ONS ALL P[] ( DISSOLUTION3 HE HAS GIV5 UP HIMSELF1 BECAUSE HE CANNOT DISSOLVE HIMSELF1 & CONSEQU5TLY CANNOT ABSOLVE HIMSELF FROM ! PASSION3 HE IS POSSESS$4 

,I LOVE M5 TOO - NOT M]ELY 9DIVIDUALS1 BUT EV]Y ONE4 ,BUT ,I LOVE !M ) ! CONSCI\SNESS ( EGOISM2 ,I LOVE !M BECAUSE LOVE MAKES ME HAPPY1 ,I LOVE BECAUSE LOV+ IS NATURAL TO ME1 BECAUSE IT PLEASES ME4 ,I KN[ NO COMM&M5T ( LOVE40 ,I HAVE A FELL[-FEEL+ ) EV]Y FEEL+ BE+1 & !IR TORM5T TORM5TS1 !IR REFRE%M5T REFRE%ES ME TOO2 ,I CAN KILL !M1 NOT TORTURE !M4 ,P] CONTRA1 ! HI<-S\L$1 VIRTU\S ,PHILI/9E PR9CE ,RUDOLPH 9 .<,EUG5E ,SUE'S.> ,! ,MY/]IES ( ,P>IS1 BECAUSE ! WICK$ PROVOKE HIS 09DIGNATION10 PLANS !IR TORTURE4 ,?AT FELL[-FEEL+ PROVES ONLY ?AT ! FEEL+ ( ?OSE :O FEEL IS M9E TOO1 MY PROP]TY2 9 OPPOSITION TO :I* ! PITILESS DEAL+ ( ! 0RI<TE\S0 MAN 7AS AGA9/ NOT>Y ,F]R&7 IS LIKE ! UNFEEL+NESS ( ?AT ROBB] ,PROCRU/ES :O CUT (F OR /RET*$ HIS PRISON]S' LEGS TO ! MEASURE ( HIS B$/EAD3 ,RUDOLPH'S B$/EAD1 :I* HE CUTS M5 TO FIT1 IS ! CONCEPT ( ! 0GOOD40 ,! = RI<T1 VIRTUE1 ETC41 MAKES PEOPLE H>D-HE>T$ & 9TOL]ANT4 ,RUDOLPH DOES NOT FEEL LIKE ! NOT>Y1 BUT ! REV]SE2 HE FEELS ?AT 0IT S]VES ! RASCAL RI<T02 ?AT IS NO FELL[-FEEL+4 

,Y\ LOVE MAN1 !RE=E Y\ TORTURE ! 9DIVIDUAL MAN1 ! EGOI/2 Y\R PHILAN?ROPY 7LOVE ( M57 IS ! TORM5T+ ( M54 

,IF ,I SEE ! LOV$ ONE SUFF]1 ,I SUFF] ) HIM1 & ,I KN[ NO RE/ UNTIL ,I HAVE TRI$ EV]Y?+ TO COM=T & *E] HIM2 IF ,I SEE HIM GLAD1 ,I TOO BECOME GLAD OV] HIS JOY4 ,FROM ?IS IT DOES NOT FOLL[ ?AT SUFF]+ OR JOY IS CAUS$ 9 ME BY ! SAME ?+ ?AT BR+S \T ?IS EFFECT 9 HIM1 AS IS SUFFICI5TLY PROV$ BY EV]Y BODILY PA9 :I* ,I DO NOT FEEL AS HE DOES2 HIS TOO? PA9S HIM1 BUT HIS PA9 PA9S ME4 

,BUT1 BECAUSE ,I CANNOT BE> ! TR\BL$ CREASE ON ! BELOV$ =EHEAD1 = ?AT REASON1 & !RE=E = MY SAKE1 ,I KISS IT AWAY4 ,IF ,I DID NOT LOVE ?IS P]SON1 HE MI<T GO RI<T ON MAK+ CREASES1 !Y W\LD NOT TR\BLE ME2 ,I AM ONLY DRIV+ AWAY MY TR\BLE4 

,H[ N[1 HAS ANYBODY OR ANY?+1 :OM &4:I* ,I DO NOT LOVE1 A RI<T TO BE LOV$ BY ME8 ,IS MY LOVE FIR/1 OR IS HIS RI<T FIR/8 ,P>5TS1 K9SFOLK1 FA!RL&1 NATION1 NATIVE T[N1 ETC41 F9ALLY FELL[M5 9 G5]AL 70BRO!RS1 FRAT]NITY071 ASS]T ?AT !Y HAVE A RI<T TO MY LOVE1 & LAY CLAIM TO IT )\T FUR!R C]EMONY4 ,!Y LOOK UPON IT AS !IR PROP]TY1 & UPON ME1 IF ,I DO NOT RESPECT ?IS1 AS A ROBB] :O TAKES FROM !M :AT P]TA9S TO !M & IS !IRS4 ,I %\LD LOVE4 ,IF LOVE IS A COMM&M5T & LAW1 !N ,I MU/ BE $UCAT$ 9TO IT1 CULTIVAT$ UP TO IT1 &1 IF ,I TRESPASS AGA9/ IT1 PUNI%$4 ,H5CE PEOPLE WILL EX]CISE AS /RONG A 0MORAL 9FLU5CE0 AS POSSIBLE ON ME TO BR+ ME TO LOVE4 ,& !RE IS NO D\BT ?AT ONE CAN WORK UP & S$UCE M5 TO LOVE AS ONE CAN TO O!R PASSIONS - IF Y\ LIKE1 TO HATE4 ,HATE RUNS ?R\< :OLE RACES M]ELY BECAUSE ! ANCE/ORS ( ! ONE BELONG$ TO ! ,GUELPHS1 ?OSE ( ! O!R TO ! ,<IBELL9ES4 

,BUT LOVE IS NOT A COMM&M5T1 BUT1 LIKE EA* ( MY FEEL+S1 MY PROP]TY4 ,ACQUIRE1 PUR*ASE1 MY PROP]TY1 & !N ,I WILL MAKE IT OV] TO Y\4 ,A *UR*1 A NATION1 A FA!RL&1 A FAMILY1 ETC41 ?AT DOES NOT KN[ H[ TO ACQUIRE MY LOVE1 ,I NE$ NOT LOVE2 & ,I FIX ! PUR*ASE PRICE ( MY LOVE QUITE AT MY PLEASURE4 

,SELFI% LOVE IS F> DI/ANT FROM UNSELFI%1 MY/ICAL1 OR ROMANTIC LOVE4 ,ONE CAN LOVE EV]Y?+ POSSIBLE1 NOT M]ELY M51 BUT AN 0OBJECT0 9 G5]AL 7W9E1 ONE'S FA!RL&1 ETC474 ,LOVE BECOMES BL9D & CRAZY BY A MU/ TAK+ IT \T ( MY P[] 79FATUATION71 ROMANTIC BY A %\LD 5T]+ 9TO IT1 BY ! 0OBJECTS0 BECOM+ SACR$ = ME1 OR MY BECOM+ B\ND TO IT BY DUTY1 CONSCI5CE1 OA?4 ,N[ ! OBJECT NO LONG] EXI/S = ME1 BUT ,I = IT4 

,LOVE IS A POSSESS$NESS1 NOT AS MY FEEL+ - AS SU* ,I RA!R KEEP IT 9 MY POSSESSION AS PROP]TY - BUT ?R\< ! ALI5NESS ( ! OBJECT4 ,= RELIGI\S LOVE CONSI/S 9 ! COMM&M5T TO LOVE 9 ! BELOV$ A 0HOLY ONE10 OR TO ADH]E TO A HOLY ONE2 = UNSELFI% LOVE !RE >E OBJECTS ABSOLUTELY LOVABLE = :I* MY HE>T IS TO BEAT1 SU* AS FELL[-M51 OR MY W$D$ MATE1 K9SFOLK1 ETC4 ,HOLY ,LOVE LOVES ! HOLY 9 ! BELOV$1 & !RE=E EX]TS ITSELF ALSO TO MAKE ( ! BELOV$ MORE & MORE A HOLY ONE 7A 0MAN074 

,! BELOV$ IS AN OBJECT ?AT %\LD BE LOV$ BY ME4 ,HE IS NOT AN OBJECT ( MY LOVE ON ACC\NT (1 BECAUSE (1 OR BY1 MY LOV+ HIM1 BUT IS AN OBJECT ( LOVE 9 & ( HIMSELF4 ,NOT ,I MAKE HIM AN OBJECT ( LOVE1 BUT HE IS SU* TO BEG9 )2 = IT IS H]E IRRELEVANT ?AT HE HAS BECOME SO BY MY *OICE1 IF SO IT BE 7AS ) A FIANCEE1 A SP\SE1 & ! LIKE71 S9CE EV5 SO HE HAS 9 ANY CASE1 AS ! P]SON ONCE *OS51 OBTA9$ A 0RI<T ( HIS [N TO MY LOVE10 & ,I1 BECAUSE ,I HAVE LOV$ HIM1 AM UND] OBLIGATION TO LOVE HIM =EV]4 ,HE IS !RE=E NOT AN OBJECT ( MY LOVE1 BUT ( LOVE 9 G5]AL3 AN OBJECT ?AT %\LD BE LOV$4 ,LOVE APP]TA9S TO HIM1 IS DUE TO HIM1 OR IS HIS RI<T1 :ILE ,I AM UND] OBLIGATION TO LOVE HIM4 ,MY LOVE1 ! TOLL ( LOVE ?AT ,I PAY HIM1 IS 9 TRU? HIS LOVE1 :I* HE ONLY COLLECTS FROM ME AS TOLL4 

,EV]Y LOVE TO :I* !RE CL+S BUT ! SMALLE/ SPECK ( OBLIGATION IS AN UNSELFI% LOVE1 &1 SO F> AS ?IS SPECK REA*ES1 A POSSESS$NESS4 ,HE :O BELIEVES ?AT HE [ES ! OBJECT ( HIS LOVE ANY?+ LOVES ROMANTICALLY OR RELIGI\SLY4 

,FAMILY LOVE1 AS IT IS USUALLY UND]/OOD AS 0PIETY10 IS A RELIGI\S LOVE2 LOVE ( FA!RL&1 PREA*$ AS 0PATRIOTISM10 LIKEWISE4 ,ALL \R ROMANTIC LOVES MOVE 9 ! SAME PATT]N3 EV]Y:]E ! HYPOCRISY1 OR RA!R SELF-DECEPTION1 ( AN 0UNSELFI% LOVE10 AN 9T]E/ 9 ! OBJECT = ! OBJECT'S SAKE1 NOT = MY SAKE & M9E ALONE4 

,RELIGI\S OR ROMANTIC LOVE IS DI/+UI%$ FROM S5SUAL LOVE BY ! DIFF]5CE ( ! OBJECT 9DE$1 BUT NOT BY ! DEP5D5CE ( ! RELATION TO IT4 ,9 ! LATT] REG>D BO? >E POSSESS$NESS2 BUT 9 ! =M] ! ONE OBJECT IS PR(ANE1 ! O!R SACR$4 ,! DOM9ION ( ! OBJECT OV] ME IS ! SAME 9 BO? CASES1 ONLY ?AT IT IS ONE TIME A S5SU\S ONE1 ! O!R TIME A SPIRITUAL 7<O/LY7 ONE4 ,MY LOVE IS MY [N ONLY :5 IT CONSI/S ALTOGE!R 9 A SELFI% & EGOI/IC 9T]E/1 & :5 CONSEQU5TLY ! OBJECT ( MY LOVE IS REALLY MY OBJECT OR MY PROP]TY4 ,I [E MY PROP]TY NO?+1 & HAVE NO DUTY TO IT1 AS LITTLE AS ,I MI<T HAVE A DUTY TO MY EYE2 IF NEV]!LESS ,I GU>D IT ) ! GREATE/ C>E1 ,I DO SO ON MY ACC\NT4 

,ANTIQUITY LACK$ LOVE AS LITTLE AS DO ,*RI/IAN TIMES2 ! GOD ( LOVE IS OLD] ?AN ! ,GOD ( ,LOVE4 ,BUT ! MY/ICAL POSSESS$NESS BELONGS TO ! MOD]NS4 

,! POSSESS$NESS ( LOVE LIES 9 ! ALI5ATION ( ! OBJECT1 OR 9 MY P[]LESSNESS AS AGA9/ ITS ALI5NESS & SUP]IOR P[]4 ,TO ! EGOI/ NO?+ IS HI< 5\< = HIM TO HUMBLE HIMSELF BE=E IT1 NO?+ SO 9DEP5D5T ?AT HE W\LD LIVE = LOVE ( IT1 NO?+ SO SACR$ ?AT HE W\LD SACRIFICE HIMSELF TO IT4 ,! EGOI/'S LOVE RISES 9 SELFI%NESS1 FL[S 9 ! B$ ( SELFI%NESS1 & EMPTIES 9TO SELFI%NESS AGA94 

,:E!R ?IS CAN /ILL BE CALL$ LOVE8 ,IF Y\ KN[ ANO!R WORD = IT1 GO AHEAD & *OOSE IT2 !N ! SWEET WORD LOVE MAY WI!R ) ! DEP>T$ WORLD2 = ! PRES5T ,I AT LEA/ F9D NONE 9 \R ,*RI/IAN LANGUAGE1 & H5CE /ICK TO ! OLD S\ND & 0LOVE0 MY OBJECT1 MY - PROP]TY4 

,ONLY AS ONE ( MY FEEL+S DO ,I H>BOR LOVE2 BUT AS A P[] ABOVE ME1 AS A DIV9E P[]1 AS ,FEU]BA* SAYS1 AS A PASSION ?AT ,I AM NOT TO CA/ (F1 AS A RELIGI\S & MORAL DUTY1 ,I - SCORN IT4 ,AS MY FEEL+ IT IS M9E2 AS A PR9CIPLE TO :I* ,I CONSECRATE & 0V[0 MY S\L IT IS A DOM9ATOR & DIV9E1 JU/ AS HATR$ AS A PR9CIPLE IS DIABOLICAL2 ONE NOT BETT] ?AN ! O!R4 ,9 %ORT1 EGOI/IC LOVE1 MY LOVE1 IS NEI!R HOLY NOR UNHOLY1 NEI!R DIV9E NOR DIABOLICAL4 

0,A LOVE ?AT IS LIMIT$ BY FAI? IS AN UNTRUE LOVE4 ,! SOLE LIMITATION ?AT DOES NOT CONTRADICT ! ESS5CE ( LOVE IS ! SELF-LIMITATION ( LOVE BY REASON1 9TELLIG5CE4 ,LOVE ?AT SCORNS ! RIGOR1 ! LAW1 ( 9TELLIG5CE1 IS !ORETICALLY A FALSE LOVE1 PRACTICALLY A RU9\S ONE4 

,SO LOVE IS 9 ITS ESS5CE RATIONAL6 ,SO ?9KS ,FEU]BA*2 ! BELIEV]1 ON ! CONTR>Y1 ?9KS1 ,LOVE IS 9 ITS ESS5CE BELIEV+4 ,! ONE 9VEI<S AGA9/ IRRATIONAL1 ! O!R AGA9/ UNBELIEV+1 LOVE4 ,TO BO? IT CAN AT MO/ RANK AS A SPL5DIDUM VITIUM4 ,DO NOT BO? LEAVE LOVE /&+1 EV5 9 ! =M ( UNREASON & UNBELIEF8 ,!Y DO NOT D>E TO SAY1 IRRATIONAL OR UNBELIEV+ LOVE IS NONS5SE1 IS NOT LOVE2 AS LITTLE AS !Y >E WILL+ TO SAY1 IRRATIONAL OR UNBELIEV+ TE>S >E NOT TE>S4 ,BUT1 IF EV5 IRRATIONAL LOVE1 ETC41 MU/ C\NT AS LOVE1 & IF !Y >E NEV]!LESS TO BE UNWOR?Y ( MAN1 !RE FOLL[S SIMPLY ?IS3 LOVE IS NOT ! HI<E/ ?+1 BUT REASON OR FAI?2 EV5 ! UNREASONABLE & ! UNBELIEV+ CAN LOVE2 BUT LOVE HAS VALUE ONLY :5 IT IS ?AT ( A RATIONAL OR BELIEV+ P]SON4 ,IT IS AN ILLUSION :5 ,FEU]BA* CALLS ! RATIONALITY ( LOVE ITS SELF-LIMITATION2 ! BELIEV] MI<T ) ! SAME RI<T CALL BELIEF ITS 0SELF-LIMITATION40 ,IRRATIONAL LOVE IS NEI!R 0FALSE0 NOR 0RU9\S02 ITS DOES ITS S]VICE AS LOVE4 

,T[>D ! WORLD1 ESPECIALLY T[>D M51 ,I AM TO ASSUME A P>TICUL> FEEL+1 & 0MEET !M ) LOVE10 ) ! FEEL+ ( LOVE1 FROM ! BEG9N+4 ,C]TA9LY1 9 ?IS !RE IS REVEAL$ F> MORE FREE-WILL & SELF-DET]M9ATION ?AN :5 ,I LET MYSELF BE /ORM$1 BY WAY ( ! WORLD1 BY ALL POSSIBLE FEEL+S1 & REMA9 EXPOS$ TO ! MO/ *ECK]$1 MO/ ACCID5TAL IMPRESSIONS4 ,I GO TO ! WORLD RA!R ) A PRECONCEIV$ FEEL+1 AS IF IT W]E A PREJUDICE & A PRECONCEIV$ OP9ION2 ,I HAVE PRESCRIB$ TO MYSELF 9 ADVANCE MY BEHAVIOR T[>D IT1 &1 DESPITE ALL ITS TEMPTATIONS1 FEEL & ?9K AB\T IT ONLY AS ,I HAVE ONCE DET]M9$ TO4 ,AGA9/ ! DOM9ION ( ! WORLD ,I SECURE MYSELF BY ! PR9CIPLE ( LOVE2 =1 :ATEV] MAY COME1 ,I - LOVE4 ,! UGLY1 = EXAMPLE1 MAKES A REPULSIVE IMPRESSION ON ME2 BUT1 DET]M9$ TO LOVE1 ,I MA/] ?IS IMPRESSION AS ,I DO EV]Y ANTIPA?Y4 

,BUT ! FEEL+ TO :I* ,I HAVE DET]M9$ & - CONDEMN$ MYSELF FROM ! />T IS A N>R[ FEEL+1 BECAUSE IT IS A PR$E/9$ ONE1 ( :I* ,I MYSELF AM NOT ABLE TO GET CLE> OR TO DECL>E MYSELF CLE>4 ,BECAUSE PRECONCEIV$1 IT IS A PREJUDICE4 ,I NO LONG] %[ MYSELF 9 FACE ( ! WORLD1 BUT MY LOVE %[S ITSELF4 ,! WORLD 9DE$ DOES NOT RULE ME1 BUT SO MU* ! MORE 9EVITABLY DOES ! SPIRIT ( LOVE RULE ?IS SPIRIT4 

,IF ,I FIR/ SAID1 ,I LOVE ! WORLD1 ,I N[ ADD LIKEWISE3 ,I DO NOT LOVE IT1 = ,I ANNIHILATE IT AS ,I ANNIHILATE MYSELF2 ,I DISSOLVE IT4 ,I DO NOT LIMIT MYSELF TO ONE FEEL+ = M51 BUT GIVE FREE PLAY TO ALL ?AT ,I AM CAPABLE (4 ,:Y %\LD ,I NOT D>E SPEAK IT \T 9 ALL ITS GL>+NESS8 ,YES1 ,I UTILIZE ! WORLD & M56 ,) ?IS ,I CAN KEEP MYSELF OP5 TO EV]Y IMPRESSION )\T BE+ TORN AWAY FROM MYSELF BY ONE ( !M4 ,I CAN LOVE1 LOVE ) A FULL HE>T1 & LET ! MO/ CONSUM+ GL[ ( PASSION BURN 9 MY HE>T1 )\T TAK+ ! BELOV$ ONE = ANY?+ ELSE ?AN ! N\RI%M5T ( MY PASSION1 ON :I* IT EV] REFRE%ES ITSELF ANEW4 ,ALL MY C>E = HIM APPLIES ONLY TO ! OBJECT ( MY LOVE1 ONLY TO HIM :OM MY LOVE REQUIRES1 ONLY TO HIM1 ! 0W>MLY LOV$40 ,H[ 9DIFF]5T W\LD HE BE TO ME )\T ?IS - MY LOVE6 ,I FE$ ONLY MY LOVE ) HIM1 ,I UTILIZE HIM = ?IS ONLY3 ,I 5JOY HIM4 

,LET US *OOSE ANO!R CONV5I5T EXAMPLE4 ,I SEE H[ M5 >E FRETT$ 9 D>K SUP]/ITION BY A SW>M ( <O/S4 ,IF TO ! EXT5T ( MY P[]S ,I LET A BIT ( DAYLI<T FALL 9 ON ! NOCTURNAL SPOOK]Y1 IS IT P]*ANCE BECAUSE LOVE TO Y\ 9SPIRES ?IS 9 ME8 ,DO ,I WRITE \T ( LOVE TO M58 ,NO1 ,I WRITE BECAUSE ,I WANT TO PROCURE = MY ?\<TS AN EXI/5CE 9 ! WORLD2 &1 EV5 IF ,I =ESAW ?AT !SE ?\<TS W\LD DEPRIVE Y\ ( Y\R RE/ & Y\R PEACE1 EV5 IF ,I SAW ! BLOODIE/ W>S & ! FALL ( MANY G5]ATIONS SPR++ UP FROM ?IS SE$ ( ?\<T - ,I W\LD NEV]!LESS SCATT] IT4 ,DO ) IT :AT Y\ WILL & CAN1 ?AT IS Y\R AFFAIR & DOES NOT TR\BLE ME4 ,Y\ WILL P]HAPS HAVE ONLY TR\BLE1 COMBAT1 & DEA? FROM IT1 V]Y FEW WILL DRAW JOY FROM IT4 ,IF Y\R WEAL LAY AT MY HE>T1 ,I %\LD ACT AS ! *UR* DID 9 )HOLD+ ! ,BIBLE FROM ! LAITY1 OR ,*RI/IAN GOV]NM5TS1 :I* MAKE IT A SACR$ DUTY = !MSELVES TO 0PROTECT ! COMMON PEOPLE FROM BAD BOOKS40 

,BUT NOT ONLY NOT = Y\R SAKE1 NOT EV5 = TRU?'S SAKE EI!R DO ,I SPEAK \T :AT ,I ?9K4 ,NO3 ,I S+ AS ! BIRD S+S ,?AT ON ! B\< ALI<TS2 ,! SONG ?AT FROM ME SPR+S ,IS PAY ?AT WELL REQUITES4 

,I S+ BECAUSE - ,I AM A S+]4 ,BUT ,I USE .<GEBRAU*5.> Y\ = IT BECAUSE ,I - NE$ .<BRAU*E.> E>S4 

,:]E ! WORLD COMES 9 MY WAY - & IT COMES 9 MY WAY EV]Y:]E - ,I CONSUME IT TO QUIET ! HUNG] ( MY EGOISM4 ,= ME Y\ >E NO?+ BUT - MY FOOD1 EV5 AS ,I TOO AM F$ UPON & TURN$ TO USE BY Y\4 ,WE HAVE ONLY ONE RELATION TO EA* O!R1 ?AT ( USABL5ESS1 ( UTILITY1 ( USE4 ,WE [E EA* O!R NO?+1 = :AT ,I SEEM TO [E Y\ ,I [E AT MO/ TO MYSELF4 ,IF ,I %[ Y\ A *E]Y AIR 9 ORD] TO *E] Y\ LIKEWISE1 !N Y\R *E]9ESS IS ( CONSEQU5CE TO ME1 & MY AIR S]VES MY WI%2 TO A ?\S& O!RS1 :OM ,I DO NOT AIM TO *E]1 ,I DO NOT %[ IT4 

,ONE HAS TO BE $UCAT$ UP TO ?AT LOVE :I* F\NDS ITSELF ON ! 0ESS5CE ( MAN0 OR1 9 ! ECCLESIA/ICAL & MORAL P]IOD1 LIES UPON US AS A 0COMM&M5T40 ,9 :AT FA%ION MORAL 9FLU5CE1 ! *IEF +R$I5T ( \R $UCATION1 SEEKS TO REGULATE ! 9T]C\RSE ( M5 %ALL H]E BE LOOK$ AT ) EGOI/IC EYES 9 ONE EXAMPLE AT LEA/4 

,?OSE :O $UCATE US MAKE IT !IR CONC]N E>LY TO BREAK US ( LY+ & TO 9CULCATE ! PR9CIPLE ?AT ONE MU/ ALWAYS TELL ! TRU?4 ,IF SELFI%NESS W]E MADE ! BASIS = ?IS RULE1 EV]Y ONE W\LD EASILY UND]/& H[ BY LY+ HE FOOLS AWAY ?AT CONFID5CE 9 HIM :I* HE HOPES TO AWAK5 9 O!RS1 & H[ CORRECT ! MAXIM PROVES1 ,NOBODY BELIEVES A LI> EV5 :5 HE TELLS ! TRU?4 ,YET1 AT ! SAME TIME1 HE W\LD ALSO FEEL ?AT HE HAD TO MEET ) TRU? ONLY HIM :OM HE AU?ORIZ$ TO HE> ! TRU?4 ,IF A SPY WALKS 9 DISGUISE ?R\< ! HO/ILE CAMP1 & IS ASK$ :O HE IS1 ! ASK]S >E ASSUR$LY 5TITL$ TO 9QUIRE AFT] HIS NAME1 BUT ! DISGUIS$ MAN DOES NOT GIVE !M ! RI<T TO LE>N ! TRU? FROM HIM2 HE TELLS !M :AT HE LIKES1 ONLY NOT ! FACT4 ,& YET MORALITY DEM&S1 0,?\ %ALT NOT LIE60 ,BY MORALITY ?OSE P]SONS >E VE/$ ) ! RI<T TO EXPECT ! TRU?2 BUT BY ME !Y >E NOT VE/$ ) ?AT RI<T1 & ,I RECOGNIZE ONLY ! RI<T ?AT ,I IMP>T4 ,9 A GA!R+ ( REVOLUTIONI/S ! POLICE =CE !IR WAY 9 & ASK ! ORATOR = HIS NAME2 EV]YBODY KN[S ?AT ! POLICE HAVE ! RI<T TO DO SO1 BUT !Y DO NOT HAVE IT FROM ! REVOLUTIONI/1 S9CE HE IS !IR 5EMY2 HE TELLS !M A FALSE NAME & - *EATS !M ) A LIE4 ,! POLICE DO NOT ACT SO FOOLI%LY EI!R AS TO C\NT ON !IR 5EMIES' LOVE ( TRU?2 ON ! CONTR>Y1 !Y DO NOT BELIEVE )\T FUR!R C]EMONY1 BUT HAVE ! QUE/ION$ 9DIVIDUAL 0ID5TIFI$0 IF !Y CAN4 ,9DE$1 ! /ATE - EV]Y:]E PROCE$S 9CR$UL\SLY ) 9DIVIDUALS1 BECAUSE 9 !IR EGOISM IT RECOGNIZES ITS NATURAL 5EMY2 IT 9V>IABLY DEM&S A 0V\*]10 & HE :O CANNOT %[ V\*]S FALLS A PREY TO ITS 9VE/IGAT+ 9QUISITION4 ,! /ATE DOES NOT BELIEVE NOR TRU/ ! 9DIVIDUAL1 & SO ( ITSELF PLACES ITSELF ) HIM 9 ! CONV5TION ( LY+2 IT TRU/S ME ONLY :5 IT HAS CONV9C$ ITSELF ( ! TRU? ( MY /ATEM5T1 = :I* !RE (T5 REMA9S TO IT NO O!R MEANS ?AN ! OA?4 ,H[ CLE>LY1 TOO1 ?IS 7! OA?7 PROVES ?AT ! /ATE DOES NOT C\NT ON \R CR$IBILITY & LOVE ( TRU?1 BUT ON \R 9T]E/1 \R SELFI%NESS3 IT RELIES ON \R NOT WANT+ TO FALL F\L ( ,GOD BY A P]JURY4 

,N[1 LET ONE IMAG9E A ,FR5* REVOLUTION>Y 9 ! YE> #a#g#h#h1 :O AMONG FRI5DS LET FALL ! N[ WELL-KN[N PHRASE1 0! WORLD WILL HAVE NO RE/ UNTIL ! LA/ K+ IS HANG$ ) ! GUTS ( ! LA/ PRIE/40 ,! K+ !N /ILL HAD ALL P[]1 &1 :5 ! UTT]ANCE IS BETRAY$ BY AN ACCID5T1 YET )\T ITS BE+ POSSIBLE TO PRODUCE WITNESSES1 CONFESSION IS DEM&$ FROM ! ACCUS$4 ,IS HE TO CONFESS OR NOT8 ,IF HE D5IES1 HE LIES & - REMA9S UNPUNI%$2 IF HE CONFESSES1 HE IS C&ID & - IS BEHEAD$4 ,IF TRU? IS MORE ?AN EV]Y?+ ELSE TO HIM1 ALL RI<T1 LET HIM DIE4 ,ONLY A PALTRY POET C\LD TRY TO MAKE A TRAG$Y \T ( ! 5D ( HIS LIFE2 = :AT 9T]E/ IS !RE 9 SEE+ H[ A MAN SUCCUMBS FROM C[>DICE8 ,BUT1 IF HE HAD ! C\RAGE NOT TO BE A SLAVE ( TRU? & S9C]ITY1 HE W\LD ASK SOME:AT ?US3 ,:Y NE$ ! JUDGES KN[ :AT ,I HAVE SPOK5 AMONG FRI5DS8 ,IF ,I HAD WI%$ !M TO KN[1 ,I %\LD HAVE SAID IT TO !M AS ,I SAID IT TO MY FRI5DS4 ,I WILL NOT HAVE !M KN[ IT4 ,!Y =CE !MSELVES 9TO MY CONFID5CE )\T MY HAV+ CALL$ !M TO IT & MADE !M MY CONFIDANTS2 !Y WILL LE>N :AT ,I WILL KEEP SECRET4 ,COME ON !N1 Y\ :O WI% TO BREAK MY WILL BY Y\R WILL1 & TRY Y\R >TS4 ,Y\ CAN TORTURE ME BY ! RACK1 Y\ CAN ?REAT5 ME ) HELL & ET]NAL DAMNATION1 Y\ CAN MAKE ME SO N]VELESS ?AT ,I SWE> A FALSE OA?1 BUT ! TRU? Y\ %ALL NOT PRESS \T ( ME1 = ,I WILL LIE TO Y\ BECAUSE ,I HAVE GIV5 Y\ NO CLAIM & NO RI<T TO MY S9C]ITY4 ,LET ,GOD1 0:O IS TRU?10 LOOK D[N EV] SO ?REAT5+LY ON ME1 LET LY+ COME EV] SO H>D TO ME1 ,I HAVE NEV]!LESS ! C\RAGE ( A LIE2 &1 EV5 IF ,I W]E WE>Y ( MY LIFE1 EV5 IF NO?+ APPE>$ TO ME MORE WELCOME ?AN Y\R EXECUTION]'S SWORD1 Y\ NEV]!LESS %\LD NOT HAVE ! JOY ( F9D+ 9 ME A SLAVE ( TRU?1 :OM BY Y\R PRIE/LY >TS Y\ MAKE A TRAITOR TO HIS WILL4 ,:5 ,I SPOKE ?OSE TREASONABLE WORDS1 ,I W\LD NOT HAVE HAD Y\ KN[ ANY?+ ( !M2 ,I N[ RETA9 ! SAME WILL1 & DO NOT LET MYSELF BE FRI<T5$ BY ! CURSE ( ! LIE4 

,SIGISMUND IS NOT A MIS]ABLE WRET* BECAUSE HE BROKE HIS PR9CELY WORD1 BUT HE BROKE ! WORD BECAUSE HE WAS A WRET*2 HE MI<T HAVE KEPT HIS WORD & W\LD /ILL HAVE BE5 A WRET*1 A PRIE/-RIDD5 MAN4 ,LU!R1 DRIV5 BY A HI<] P[]1 BECAME UNFAI?FUL TO HIS MONA/IC V[3 HE BECAME SO = ,GOD'S SAKE4 ,BO? BROKE !IR OA? AS POSSESS$ P]SONS3 ,SIGISMUND1 BECAUSE HE WANT$ TO APPE> AS A S9C]E PR(ESSOR ( ! DIV9E TRU?1 ?AT IS1 ( ! TRUE1 G5U9ELY ,CA?OLIC FAI?2 ,LU!R1 9 ORD] TO GIVE TE/IMONY = ! GOSPEL S9C]ELY & ) 5TIRE TRU?4 ) BODY & S\L2 BO? BECAME P]JUR$ 9 ORD] TO BE S9C]E T[>D ! 0HI<] TRU?40 ,ONLY1 ! PRIE/S ABSOLV$ ! ONE1 ! O!R ABSOLV$ HIMSELF4 ,:AT ELSE DID BO? OBS]VE ?AN :AT IS CONTA9$ 9 ?OSE APO/OLIC WORDS1 0,?\ HA/ NOT LI$ TO M51 BUT TO ,GOD80 ,!Y LI$ TO M51 BROKE !IR OA? BE=E ! WORLD'S EYES1 9 ORD] NOT TO LIE TO ,GOD1 BUT TO S]VE HIM4 ,?US !Y %[ US A WAY TO DEAL ) TRU? BE=E M54 ,= ,GOD'S GLORY1 & = ,GOD'S SAKE1 A - BREA* ( OA?1 A LIE1 A PR9CE'S WORD BROK56 

,H[ W\LD IT BE1 N[1 IF WE *ANG$ ! ?+ A LITTLE & WROTE1 ,A P]JURY & LIE = - MY SAKE8 ,W\LD NOT ?AT BE PLEAD+ = EV]Y BAS5ESS8 ,IT SEEMS SO1 ASSUR$LY1 ONLY 9 ?IS IT IS ALTOGE!R LIKE ! 0= ,GOD'S SAKE40 ,= WAS NOT EV]Y BAS5ESS COMMITT$ = ,GOD'S SAKE1 W]E NOT ALL ! SCAFFOLDS FILL$ = HIS SAKE & ALL ! AUTOS-DA-FE HELD = HIS SAKE1 WAS NOT ALL /UPEFACTION 9TRODUC$ = HIS SAKE8 ,& DO !Y NOT TODAY /ILL = ,GOD'S SAKE FETT] ! M9D 9 T5D] *ILDR5 BY RELIGI\S $UCATION8 ,W]E NOT SACR$ V[S BROK5 = HIS SAKE1 & DO NOT MISSION>IES & PRIE/S /ILL GO >\ND EV]Y DAY TO BR+ ,JEWS1 HEA!N1 ,PROTE/ANTS OR ,CA?OLICS1 TO TREASON AGA9/ ! FAI? ( !IR FA!RS - = HIS SAKE8 ,& ?AT %\LD BE WORSE ) ! = MY SAKE8 ,:AT !N DOES ON MY ACC\NT MEAN8 ,!RE PEOPLE IMM$IATELY ?9K ( 0FIL?Y LUCRE04 ,BUT HE :O ACTS FROM LOVE ( FIL?Y LUCRE DOES IT ON HIS [N ACC\NT 9DE$1 AS !RE IS NO?+ ANYH[ ?AT ONE DOES NOT DO = HIS [N SAKE - AMONG O!R ?+S1 EV]Y?+ ?AT IS DONE = ,GOD'S GLORY2 YET HE1 = :OM HE SEEKS ! LUCRE1 IS A SLAVE ( LUCRE1 NOT RAIS$ ABOVE LUCRE2 HE IS ONE :O BELONGS TO LUCRE1 ! MONEY-BAG1 NOT TO HIMSELF2 HE IS NOT HIS [N4 ,MU/ NOT A MAN :OM ! PASSION ( AV>ICE RULES FOLL[ ! COMM&S ( ?IS MA/]8 ,&1 IF A WEAK GOODNATUR$NESS ONCE BEGUILES HIM1 DOES ?IS NOT APPE> AS SIMPLY AN EXCEPTIONAL CASE ( PRECISELY ! SAME SORT AS :5 PI\S BELIEV]S >E SOMETIMES =SAK5 BY !IR ,LORD'S GUIDANCE & 5SN>$ BY ! >TS ( ! 0DEVIL80 ,SO AN AV>ICI\S MAN IS NOT A SELF-[N$ MAN1 BUT A S]VANT2 & HE CAN DO NO?+ = HIS [N SAKE )\T AT ! SAME TIME DO+ IT = HIS LORD'S SAKE - PRECISELY LIKE ! GODLY MAN4 

,FAM\S IS ! BREA* ( OA? :I* ,FRANCIS ,I COMMITT$ AGA9/ ,EMP]OR ,K>L ,V4 ,NOT LAT]1 :5 HE RIPELY WEI<$ HIS PROMISE1 BUT AT ONCE1 :5 HE SWORE ! OA?1 ,K+ ,FRANCIS TOOK IT BACK 9 ?\<T AS WELL AS BY A SECRET PROTE/ATION DOCUM5T>ILY SUBSCRIB$ BE=E HIS C\NCILORS2 HE UTT]$ A P]JURY A=E-?\<T4 ,FRANCIS DID NOT %[ HIMSELF DIS9CL9$ TO BUY HIS RELEASE1 BUT ! PRICE ?AT ,K>L PUT ON IT SEEM$ TO HIM TOO HI< & UNREASONABLE4 ,EV5 ?\< ,K>L BEHAV$ HIMSELF 9 A SORDID FA%ION :5 HE S\<T TO EXTORT AS MU* AS POSSIBLE1 IT WAS YET %ABBY ( ,FRANCIS TO WANT TO PUR*ASE HIS FRE$OM = A L[] RANSOM2 & HIS LAT] DEAL+S1 AMONG :I* !RE OCCURS YET A SECOND BREA* ( HIS WORD1 PROVE SUFFICI5TLY H[ ! HUCK/] SPIRIT HELD HIM 5?RALL$ & MADE HIM A %ABBY SW9DL]4 ,H[EV]1 :AT %ALL WE SAY TO ! REPROA* ( P]JURY AGA9/ HIM8 ,9 ! FIR/ PLACE1 SURELY1 ?IS AGA93 ?AT NOT ! P]JURY1 BUT HIS SORDIDNESS1 %AM$ HIM2 ?AT HE DID NOT DES]VE CONTEMPT = HIS P]JURY1 BUT MADE HIMSELF GUILTY ( P]JURY BECAUSE HE WAS A CONTEMPTIBLE MAN4 ,BUT ,FRANCIS'S P]JURY1 REG>D$ 9 ITSELF1 DEM&S ANO!R JUDGM5T4 ,ONE MI<T SAY ,FRANCIS DID NOT RESPOND TO ! CONFID5CE ?AT ,K>L PUT 9 HIM 9 SETT+ HIM FREE4 ,BUT1 IF ,K>L HAD REALLY FAVOR$ HIM ) CONFID5CE1 HE W\LD HAVE NAM$ TO HIM ! PRICE ?AT HE CONSID]$ ! RELEASE WOR?1 & W\LD !N HAVE SET HIM AT LIB]TY & EXPECT$ ,FRANCIS TO PAY ! R$EMPTION-SUM4 ,K>L H>BOR$ NO SU* TRU/1 BUT ONLY BELIEV$ 9 ,FRANCIS'S IMPOT5CE & CR$ULITY1 :I* W\LD NOT ALL[ HIM TO ACT AGA9/ HIS OA?2 BUT ,FRANCIS DECEIV$ ONLY ?IS - CR$UL\S CALCULATION4 ,:5 ,K>L BELIEV$ HE WAS ASSUR+ HIMSELF ( HIS 5EMY BY AN OA?1 RI<T !RE HE WAS FREE+ HIM FROM EV]Y OBLIGATION4 ,K>L HAD GIV5 ! K+ CR$IT = A PIECE ( /UPIDITY1 A N>R[ CONSCI5CE1 &1 )\T CONFID5CE 9 ,FRANCIS1 C\NT$ ONLY ON ,FRANCIS'S /UPIDITY1 ?AT IS1 CONSCI5TI\SNESS3 HE LET HIM GO FROM ! ,MADRID PRISON ONLY TO HOLD HIM ! MORE SECURELY 9 ! PRISON ( CONSCI5TI\SNESS1 ! GREAT JAIL BUILT AB\T ! M9D ( MAN BY RELIGION3 HE S5T HIM BACK TO ,FRANCE LOCK$ FA/ 9 9VISIBLE *A9S1 :AT WOND] IF ,FRANCIS S\<T TO ESCAPE & SAW$ ! *A9S AP>T8 ,NO MAN W\LD HAVE TAK5 IT AMISS ( HIM IF HE HAD SECRETLY FL$ FROM ,MADRID1 = HE WAS 9 AN 5EMY'S P[]2 BUT EV]Y GOOD ,*RI/IAN CRIES \T UPON HIM1 ?AT HE WANT$ TO LOOSE HIMSELF FROM ,GOD'S BONDS TOO4 7,IT WAS ONLY LAT] ?AT ! POPE ABSOLV$ HIM FROM HIS OA?47 

,IT IS DESPICABLE TO DECEIVE A CONFID5CE ?AT WE VOLUNT>ILY CALL =?2 BUT IT IS NO %AME TO EGOISM TO LET EV]Y ONE :O WANTS TO GET US 9TO HIS P[] BY AN OA? BLE$ TO DEA? BY ! UNSUCCESSFULNESS ( HIS UNTRU/FUL CRAFT4 ,IF Y\ HAVE WANT$ TO B9D ME1 !N LE>N ?AT ,I KN[ H[ TO BUR/ Y\R BONDS4 

,! PO9T IS :E!R ,I GIVE ! CONFID] ! RI<T TO CONFID5CE4 ,IF ! PURSU] ( MY FRI5D ASKS ME :]E HE HAS FL$ TO1 ,I %ALL SURELY PUT HIM ON A FALSE TRAIL4 ,:Y DOES HE ASK PRECISELY ME1 ! PURSU$ MAN'S FRI5D8 ,9 ORD] NOT TO BE A FALSE1 TRAITOR\S FRI5D1 ,I PREF] TO BE FALSE TO ! 5EMY4 ,I MI<T C]TA9LY 9 C\RAGE\S CONSCI5TI\SNESS1 ANSW]1 0,I WILL NOT TELL0 7SO ,FI*TE DECIDES ! CASE72 BY ?AT ,I %\LD SALVE MY LOVE ( TRU? & DO = MY FRI5D AS MU* AS - NO?+1 =1 IF ,I DO NOT MISLEAD ! 5EMY1 HE MAY ACCID5TALLY TAKE ! RI<T /REET1 & MY LOVE ( TRU? W\LD HAVE GIV5 UP MY FRI5D AS A PREY1 BECAUSE IT H9D]$ ME FROM ! - C\RAGE = A LIE4 ,HE :O HAS 9 ! TRU? AN IDOL1 A SACR$ ?+1 MU/ HUMBLE HIMSELF BE=E IT1 MU/ NOT DEFY ITS DEM&S1 NOT RESI/ C\RAGE\SLY2 9 %ORT1 HE MU/ R5\NCE ! H]OISM ( ! LIE4 ,= TO ! LIE BELONGS NOT LESS C\RAGE ?AN TO ! TRU?3 A C\RAGE ?AT Y\NG M5 >E MO/ APT TO BE DEFECTIVE 91 :O W\LD RA!R CONFESS ! TRU? & M\NT ! SCAFFOLD = IT ?AN CONF\ND ! 5EMY'S P[] BY ! IMPUD5CE ( A LIE4 ,TO !M ! TRU? IS 0SACR$10 & ! SACR$ AT ALL TIMES DEM&S BL9D REV]5CE1 SUBMISSION1 & SELF-SACRIFICE4 ,IF Y\ >E NOT IMPUD5T1 NOT MOCK]S ( ! SACR$1 Y\ >E TAME & ITS S]VANTS4 ,LET ONE BUT LAY A GRA9 ( TRU? 9 ! TRAP = Y\1 Y\ PECK AT IT TO A C]TA9TY1 & ! FOOL IS CAU<T4 ,Y\ WILL NOT LIE8 ,WELL1 !N1 FALL AS SACRIFICES TO ! TRU? & BECOME - M>TYRS6 ,M>TYRS6 - = :AT8 ,= Y\RSELVES1 = SELF-[N]%IP8 ,NO1 = Y\R GODDESS - ! TRU?4 ,Y\ KN[ ONLY TWO S]VICES1 ONLY TWO K9DS ( S]VANTS3 S]VANTS ( ! TRU? & S]VANTS ( ! LIE4 ,!N 9 ,GOD'S NAME S]VE ! TRU?6 

,O!RS1 AGA91 S]VE ! TRU? ALSO2 BUT !Y S]VE IT 09 MOD]ATION10 & MAKE A GREAT DI/9CTION BETWE5 A SIMPLE LIE & A LIE SWORN TO4 ,& YET ! :OLE *APT] ( ! OA? CO9CIDES ) ?AT ( ! LIE1 S9CE AN OA?1 EV]YBODY KN[S1 IS ONLY A /RONGLY ASSUR$ /ATEM5T4 ,Y\ CONSID] Y\RSELVES 5TITL$ TO LIE1 IF ONLY Y\ DO NOT SWE> TO IT BESIDES8 ,ONE :O IS P>TICUL> AB\T IT MU/ JUDGE & CONDEMN A LIE AS %>PLY AS A FALSE OA?4 ,BUT N[ !RE HAS BE5 KEPT UP 9 MORALITY AN ANCI5T PO9T ( CONTROV]SY1 :I* IS CU/OM>ILY TREAT$ ( UND] ! NAME ( ! 0LIE ( NECESSITY40 ,NO ONE :O D>ES PLEAD = ?IS CAN CONSI/5TLY PUT FROM HIM AN 0OA? ( NECESSITY40 ,IF ,I JU/IFY MY LIE AS A LIE ( NECESSITY1 ,I %\LD NOT BE SO PUSILLANIM\S AS TO ROB ! JU/IFI$ LIE ( ! /RONGE/ CORROBORATION4 ,:ATEV] ,I DO1 :Y %\LD ,I NOT DO IT 5TIRELY & )\T RES]VATIONS 7RES]VATIO M5TALIS 78 ,IF ,I ONCE LIE1 :Y !N NOT LIE COMPLETELY1 ) 5TIRE CONSCI\SNESS & ALL MY MI<T8 ,AS A SPY ,I %\LD HAVE TO SWE> TO EA* ( MY FALSE /ATEM5TS AT ! 5EMY'S DEM&2 DET]M9$ TO LIE TO HIM1 %\LD ,I SUDD5LY BECOME C[>DLY & UNDECID$ 9 FACE ( AN OA?8 ,!N ,I %\LD HAVE BE5 RU9$ 9 ADVANCE = A LI> & SPY2 =1 Y\ SEE1 ,I %\LD BE VOLUNT>ILY PUTT+ 9TO ! 5EMY'S H&S A MEANS TO CAT* ME4 - ,! /ATE TOO FE>S ! OA? ( NECESSITY1 & = ?IS REASON DOES NOT GIVE ! ACCUS$ A *ANCE TO SWE>4 ,BUT Y\ DO NOT JU/IFY ! /ATE'S FE>2 Y\ LIE1 BUT DO NOT SWE> FALSELY4 ,IF Y\ %[ SOME ONE A K9DNESS1 & HE IS NOT TO KN[ IT1 BUT HE GUESSES IT & TELLS Y\ SO TO Y\R FACE1 Y\ D5Y2 IF HE 9SI/S1 Y\ SAY1 0HONE/LY1 NO60 ,IF IT CAME TO SWE>+1 !N Y\ W\LD REFUSE2 =1 FROM FE> ( ! SACR$1 Y\ ALWAYS /OP HALF WAY4 ,AGA9/ ! SACR$ Y\ HAVE NO WILL ( Y\R [N4 ,Y\ LIE 9 - MOD]ATION1 AS Y\ >E FREE 09 MOD]ATION10 RELIGI\S 09 MOD]ATION0 7! CL]GY >E NOT TO 05CROA*02 OV] ?IS PO9T ! MO/ RAPID ( CONTROV]SIES IS N[ BE+ C>RI$ ON1 ON ! P>T ( ! UNIV]SITY AGA9/ ! *UR*71 MON>*ICALLY DISPOS$ 09 MOD]ATION0 7Y\ WANT A MON>* LIMIT$ BY ! CON/ITUTION1 BY A FUNDAM5TAL LAW ( ! /ATE71 EV]Y?+ NICELY TEMP]$1 LUKEW>M1 HALF ,GOD'S1 HALF ! DEVIL'S4 

,!RE WAS A UNIV]SITY :]E ! USAGE WAS ?AT EV]Y WORD ( HONOR ?AT MU/ BE GIV5 TO ! UNIV]SITY JUDGE WAS LOOK$ UPON BY ! /UD5TS AS NULL & VOID4 ,= ! /UD5TS SAW 9 ! DEM&+ ( IT NO?+ BUT A SN>E1 :I* !Y C\LD NOT ESCAPE O!RWISE ?AN BY TAK+ AWAY ALL ITS SIGNIFICANCE4 ,HE :O AT ?AT SAME UNIV]SITY BROKE HIS WORD ( HONOR TO ONE ( ! FELL[S WAS 9FAM\S2 HE :O GAVE IT TO ! UNIV]SITY JUDGE D]ID$1 9 UNION ) !SE V]Y FELL[S1 ! DUPE :O FANCI$ ?AT A WORD HAD ! SAME VALUE AMONG FRI5DS & AMONG FOES4 ,IT WAS LESS A CORRECT !ORY ?AN ! CON/RA9T ( PRACTICE ?AT HAD !RE TAU<T ! /UD5TS TO ACT SO1 AS1 )\T ?AT MEANS ( GETT+ \T1 !Y W\LD HAVE BE5 PITILESSLY DRIV5 TO TREA*]Y AGA9/ !IR COMRADES4 ,BUT1 AS ! MEANS APPROV$ ITSELF 9 PRACTICE1 SO IT HAS ITS !ORETICAL PROBATION TOO4 ,A WORD ( HONOR1 AN OA?1 IS ONE ONLY = HIM :OM ,I 5TITLE TO RECEIVE IT2 HE :O =CES ME TO IT OBTA9S ONLY A =C$1 A HO/ILE WORD1 ! WORD ( A FOE1 :OM ONE HAS NO RI<T TO TRU/2 = ! FOE DOES NOT GIVE US ! RI<T4 

,ASIDE FROM ?IS1 ! C\RTS ( ! /ATE DO NOT EV5 RECOGNIZE ! 9VIOLABILITY ( AN OA?4 ,=1 IF ,I HAD SWORN TO ONE :O COMES UND] EXAM9ATION ?AT ,I W\LD NOT DECL>E ANY?+ AGA9/ HIM1 ! C\RT W\LD DEM& MY DECL>ATION 9 SPITE ( ! FACT ?AT AN OA? B9DS ME1 &1 9 CASE ( REFUSAL1 W\LD LOCK ME UP UNTIL ,I DECID$ TO BECOME - AN OA?-BREAK]4 ,! C\RT 0ABSOLVES ME FROM MY OA?02 - H[ MAGNANIM\S6 ,IF ANY P[] CAN ABSOLVE ME FROM ! OA?1 ,I MYSELF AM SURELY ! V]Y FIR/ P[] ?AT HAS A CLAIM TO4 

,AS A CURIOSITY1 & TO REM9D US ( CU/OM>Y OA?S ( ALL SORTS1 LET PLACE BE GIV5 H]E TO ?AT :I* ,EMP]OR ,PAUL COMM&$ ! CAPTUR$ ,POLES 7,KOSCIUSZKO1 ,POTOCKI1 ,NIEMCEWICZ1 & O!RS7 TO TAKE :5 HE RELEAS$ !M3 0,WE NOT M]ELY SWE> FIDELITY & OB$I5CE TO ! EMP]OR1 BUT ALSO FUR!R PROMISE TO P\R \T \R BLOOD = HIS GLORY2 WE OBLIGATE \RSELVES TO DISCOV] EV]Y?+ ?REAT5+ TO HIS P]SON OR HIS EMPIRE ?AT WE EV] LE>N2 WE DECL>E F9ALLY ?AT1 9 :ATEV] P>T ( ! E>? WE MAY BE1 A S+LE WORD ( ! EMP]OR %ALL SUFFICE TO MAKE US LEAVE EV]Y?+ & REPAIR TO HIM AT ONCE40 

,9 ONE DOMA9 ! PR9CIPLE ( LOVE SEEMS TO HAVE BE5 LONG \TSO>$ BY EGOISM1 & TO BE /ILL 9 NE$ ONLY ( SURE CONSCI\SNESS1 AS IT W]E ( VICTORY ) A GOOD CONSCI5CE4 ,?IS DOMA9 IS SPECULATION1 9 ITS D\BLE MANIFE/ATION AS ?9K+ & AS TRADE4 ,ONE ?9KS ) A WILL1 :ATEV] MAY COME ( IT2 ONE SPECULATES1 H[EV] MANY MAY SUFF] UND] \R SPECULATIVE UND]TAK+S4 ,BUT1 :5 IT F9ALLY BECOMES S]I\S1 :5 EV5 ! LA/ REMNANT ( RELIGI\SNESS1 ROMANCE1 OR 0HUMANITY0 IS TO BE DONE AWAY1 !N ! PULSE ( RELIGI\S CONSCI5CE BEATS1 & ONE AT LEA/ PR(ESSES HUMANITY4 ,! AV>ICI\S SPECULATOR ?R[S SOME COPP]S 9TO ! POOR-BOX & 0DOES GOOD10 ! BOLD ?9K] CONSOLES HIMSELF ) ! FACT ?AT HE IS WORK+ = ! ADVANCEM5T ( ! HUMAN RACE & ?AT HIS DEVA/ATION 0TURNS TO ! GOOD0 ( MANK9D1 OR1 9 ANO!R CASE1 ?AT HE IS 0S]V+ ! IDEA02 MANK9D1 ! IDEA1 IS TO HIM ?AT SOME?+ ( :I* HE MU/ SAY1 ,IT IS MORE TO ME ?AN MYSELF4 

,TO ?IS DAY ?9K+ & TRAD+ HAVE BE5 DONE = - ,GOD'S SAKE4 ,?OSE :O = SIX DAYS W]E TRAMPL+ D[N EV]Y?+ BY !IR SELFI% AIMS SACRIFIC$ ON ! SEV5? TO ! ,LORD2 & ?OSE :O DE/ROY$ A HUNDR$ 0GOOD CAUSES0 BY !IR RECKLESS ?9K+ /ILL DID ?IS 9 ! S]VICE ( ANO!R 0GOOD CAUSE10 & HAD YET TO ?9K ( ANO!R - BESIDES !MSELVES - TO :OSE GOOD !IR SELF-9DULG5CE %\LD TURN2 ( ! PEOPLE1 MANK9D1 & ! LIKE4 ,BUT ?IS O!R ?+ IS A BE+ ABOVE !M1 A HI<] OR SUPREME BE+2 & !RE=E ,I SAY1 !Y >E TOIL+ = ,GOD'S SAKE4 

,H5CE ,I CAN ALSO SAY ?AT ! ULTIMATE BASIS ( !IR ACTIONS IS - LOVE4 ,NOT A VOLUNT>Y LOVE H[EV]1 NOT !IR [N1 BUT A TRIBUT>Y LOVE1 OR ! HI<] BE+'S [N 7,GOD'S1 :O HIMSELF IS LOVE72 9 %ORT1 NOT ! EGOI/IC1 BUT ! RELIGI\S2 A LOVE ?AT SPR+S FROM !IR FANCY ?AT !Y MU/ DIS*>GE A TRIBUTE ( LOVE1 ?AT !Y MU/ NOT BE 0EGOI/S40 

,IF WE WANT TO DELIV] ! WORLD FROM MANY K9DS ( UNFRE$OM1 WE WANT ?IS NOT ON ITS ACC\NT BUT ON \RS2 =1 AS WE >E NOT WORLD-LIB]ATORS BY PR(ESSION & \T ( 0LOVE10 WE ONLY WANT TO W9 IT AWAY FROM O!RS4 ,WE WANT TO MAKE IT \R [N2 IT IS NOT TO BE ANY LONG] [N$ AS S]F BY ,GOD 7! *UR*7 NOR BY ! LAW 7/ATE71 BUT TO BE \R [N2 !RE=E WE SEEK TO 0W90 IT1 TO 0CAPTIVATE0 IT1 &1 BY MEET+ IT HALFWAY & 0DEVOT+0 \RSELVES TO IT AS TO \RSELVES AS SOON AS IT BELONGS TO US1 TO COMPLETE & MAKE SUP]FLU\S ! =CE ?AT IT TURNS AGA9/ US4 ,IF ! WORLD IS \RS1 IT NO LONG] ATTEMPTS ANY =CE AGA9/ US1 BUT ONLY ) US4 ,MY SELFI%NESS HAS AN 9T]E/ 9 ! LIB]ATION ( ! WORLD1 ?AT IT MAY BECOME - MY PROP]TY4 

,NOT ISOLATION OR BE+ ALONE1 BUT SOCIETY1 IS MAN'S ORIG9AL /ATE4 ,\R EXI/5CE BEG9S ) ! MO/ 9TIMATE CONJUNCTION1 AS WE >E ALREADY LIV+ ) \R MO!R BE=E WE BREA!2 :5 WE SEE ! LI<T ( ! WORLD1 WE AT ONCE LIE ON A HUMAN BE+'S BREA/ AGA91 H] LOVE CRADLES US 9 ! LAP1 LEADS US 9 ! GO-C>T1 & *A9S US TO H] P]SON ) A ?\S& TIES4 ,SOCIETY IS \R /ATE ( NATURE4 ,& ?IS IS :Y1 ! MORE WE LE>N TO FEEL \RSELVES1 ! CONNECTION ?AT WAS =M]LY MO/ 9TIMATE BECOMES EV] LOOS] & ! DISSOLUTION ( ! ORIG9AL SOCIETY MORE UNMI/AKABLE4 ,TO HAVE ONCE AGA9 = H]SELF ! *ILD ?AT ONCE LAY UND] H] HE>T1 ! MO!R MU/ FET* IT FROM ! /REET & FROM ! MID/ ( ITS PLAYMATES4 ,! *ILD PREF]S ! 9T]C\RSE ?AT IT 5T]S 9NAMELYH ITS FELL[S TO ! SOCIETY ?AT IT HAS NOT 5T]$ 9TO1 BUT ONLY BE5 BORN 94 

,BUT ! DISSOLUTION ( SOCIETY IS 9T]C\RSE OR UNION4 ,A SOCIETY DOES ASSUR$LY >ISE BY UNION TOO1 BUT ONLY AS A FIX$ IDEA >ISES BY A ?\<T - NAMELY1 BY ! VANI%+ ( ! 5]GY ( ! ?\<T 7! ?9K+ ITSELF1 ?IS RE/LESS TAK+ BACK ALL ?\<TS ?AT MAKE !MSELVES FA/7 FROM ! ?\<T4 ,IF A UNION HAS CRY/ALLIZ$ 9TO A SOCIETY1 IT HAS CEAS$ TO BE A COALITION2 = COALITION IS AN 9CESSANT SELF-UNIT+2 IT HAS BECOME A UNIT$NESS1 COME TO A /&/ILL1 DEG5]AT$ 9TO A FIXITY2 IT IS - DEAD AS A UNION1 IT IS ! CORPSE ( ! UNION OR ! COALITION1 IT IS - SOCIETY1 COMMUNITY4 ,A /RIK+ EXAMPLE ( ?IS K9D IS FURNI%$ BY ! P>TY4 

,?AT A SOCIETY 7SU* AS ! SOCIETY ( ! /ATE7 DIM9I%ES MY LIB]TY (F5DS ME LITTLE4 ,:Y1 ,I HAVE TO LET MY LIB]TY BE LIMIT$ BY ALL SORTS ( P[]S & BY EV]Y ONE :O IS /RONG]2 9DE$1 BY EV]Y FELL[-MAN2 &1 W]E ,I ! AUTOCRAT ( ALL ! ,R---1 ,I YET %\LD NOT 5JOY ABSOLUTE LIB]TY4 ,BUT [NNESS ,I WILL NOT HAVE TAK5 FROM ME4 ,& [NNESS IS PRECISELY :AT EV]Y SOCIETY HAS DESIGNS ON1 PRECISELY :AT IS TO SUCCUMB TO ITS P[]4 

,A SOCIETY :I* ,I JO9 DOES 9DE$ TAKE FROM ME MANY LIB]TIES1 BUT 9 RETURN IT AF=DS ME O!R LIB]TIES2 NEI!R DOES IT MATT] IF ,I MYSELF DEPRIVE MYSELF ( ?IS & ?AT LIB]TY 7SU* AS BY ANY CONTRACT74 ,ON ! O!R H&1 ,I WANT TO HOLD JEAL\SLY TO MY [NNESS4 ,EV]Y COMMUNITY HAS ! PROP5SITY1 /RONG] OR WEAK] ACCORD+ TO ! FULLNESS ( ITS P[]1 TO BECOME AN AU?ORITY TO ITS MEMB]S & TO SET LIMITS = !M3 IT ASKS1 & MU/ ASK1 = A 0SUBJECT'S LIMIT$ UND]/&+02 IT ASKS ?AT ?OSE :O BELONG TO IT BE SUBJECT$ TO IT1 BE ITS 0SUBJECTS02 IT EXI/S ONLY BY SUBJECTION4 ,9 ?IS A C]TA9 TOL]ANCE NE$ BY NO MEANS BE EXCLUD$2 ON ! CONTR>Y1 ! SOCIETY WILL WELCOME IMPROVEM5TS1 CORRECTIONS1 & BLAME1 SO F> AS SU* >E CALCULAT$ = ITS GA93 BUT ! BLAME MU/ BE 0WELL-MEAN+10 IT MAY NOT BE 09SOL5T & DISRESPECTFUL0 - 9 O!R WORDS1 ONE MU/ LEAVE UN9JUR$1 & HOLD SACR$1 ! SUB/ANCE ( ! SOCIETY4 ,! SOCIETY DEM&S ?AT ?OSE :O BELONG TO IT %ALL NOT GO BEYOND IT & EXALT !MSELVES1 BUT REMA9 0)9 ! B\NDS ( LEGALITY10 ?AT IS1 ALL[ !MSELVES ONLY SO MU* AS ! SOCIETY & ITS LAW ALL[ !M4 

,!RE IS A DIFF]5CE :E!R MY LIB]TY OR MY [NNESS IS LIMIT$ BY A SOCIETY4 ,IF ! =M] ONLY IS ! CASE1 IT IS A COALITION1 AN AGREEM5T1 A UNION2 BUT1 IF RU9 IS ?REAT5$ TO [NNESS1 IT IS A P[] ( ITSELF1 A P[] ABOVE ME1 A ?+ UNATTA9ABLE BY ME1 :I* ,I CAN 9DE$ ADMIRE1 ADORE1 REV]5CE1 RESPECT1 BUT CANNOT SUBDUE & CONSUME1 & ?AT = ! REASON ?AT ,I AM RESIGN$4 ,IT EXI/S BY MY RESIGNATION1 MY SELF-R5UNCIATION1 MY SPIRITLESSNESS .<,MUTLOSIGKEIT.>1 CALL$ - HUMILITY .<,DEMUT.>4 ,MY HUMILITY MAKES ITS C\RAGE .<,MUT.>1 MY SUBMISSIV5ESS GIVES IT ITS DOM9ION4 

,BUT 9 REF]5CE TO LIB]TY1 /ATE & UNION >E SUBJECT TO NO ESS5TIAL DIFF]5CE4 ,! LATT] CAN JU/ AS LITTLE COME 9TO EXI/5CE1 OR CONT9UE 9 EXI/5CE1 )\T LIB]TY'S BE+ LIMIT$ 9 ALL SORTS ( WAYS1 AS ! /ATE IS COMPATIBLE ) UNMEASUR$ LIB]TY4 ,LIMITATION ( LIB]TY IS 9EVITABLE EV]Y:]E1 = ONE CANNOT GET RID ( EV]Y?+2 ONE CANNOT FLY LIKE A BIRD M]ELY BECAUSE ONE W\LD LIKE TO FLY SO1 = ONE DOES NOT GET FREE FROM HIS [N WEI<T2 ONE CANNOT LIVE UND] WAT] AS LONG AS HE LIKES1 LIKE A FI%1 BECAUSE ONE CANNOT DO )\T AIR & CANNOT GET FREE FROM ?IS 9DISP5SABLE NECESSITY2 & ! LIKE4 ,AS RELIGION1 & MO/ DECID$LY ,*RI/IANITY1 TORM5T$ MAN ) ! DEM& TO REALIZE ! UNNATURAL & SELF-CONTRADICTORY1 SO IT IS TO BE LOOK$ UPON ONLY AS ! TRUE LOGICAL \TCOME ( ?AT RELIGI\S OV]-/RA9+ & OV]WR\<TNESS ?AT F9ALLY LIB]TY ITSELF1 ABSOLUTE LIB]TY1 WAS EXALT$ 9TO AN IDEAL1 & ?US ! NONS5SE ( ! IMPOSSIBLE TO COME GL>+LY TO ! LI<T4 - ,! UNION WILL ASSUR$LY (F] A GREAT] MEASURE ( LIB]TY1 AS WELL AS 7& ESPECIALLY BECAUSE BY IT ONE ESCAPES ALL ! CO]CION PECULI> TO /ATE & SOCIETY LIFE7 ADMIT ( BE+ CONSID]$ AS 0A NEW LIB]TY02 BUT NEV]!LESS IT WILL /ILL CONTA9 5\< ( UNFRE$OM & 9VOLUNT>9ESS4 ,= ITS OBJECT IS NOT ?IS - LIB]TY 7:I* ON ! CONTR>Y IT SACRIFICES TO [NNESS71 BUT ONLY [NNESS4 ,REF]R$ TO ?IS1 ! DIFF]5CE BETWE5 /ATE & UNION IS GREAT 5\<4 ,! =M] IS AN 5EMY & MURD]] ( [NNESS1 ! LATT] A SON & C[ORK] ( IT2 ! =M] A SPIRIT ?AT W\LD BE ADOR$ 9 SPIRIT & 9 TRU?1 ! LATT] MY WORK1 MY PRODUCT 2 ! /ATE IS ! LORD ( MY SPIRIT1 :O DEM&S FAI? & PRESCRIBES TO ME >TICLES ( FAI?1 ! CRE$ ( LEGALITY2 IT EX]TS MORAL 9FLU5CE1 DOM9ATES MY SPIRIT1 DRIVES AWAY MY EGO TO PUT ITSELF 9 ITS PLACE AS 0MY TRUE EGO0 - 9 %ORT1 ! /ATE IS SACR$1 & AS AGA9/ ME1 ! 9DIVIDUAL MAN1 IT IS ! TRUE MAN1 ! SPIRIT1 ! <O/2 BUT ! UNION IS MY [N CREATION1 MY CREATURE1 NOT SACR$1 NOT A SPIRITUAL P[] ABOVE MY SPIRIT1 AS LITTLE AS ANY ASSOCIATION ( :ATEV] SORT4 ,AS ,I AM NOT WILL+ TO BE A SLAVE ( MY MAXIMS1 BUT LAY !M B>E TO MY CONT9UAL CRITICISM )\T ANY W>RANT1 & ADMIT NO BAIL AT ALL = !IR P]SI/5CE1 SO /ILL LESS DO ,I OBLIGATE MYSELF TO ! UNION = MY FUTURE & PL$GE MY S\L TO IT1 AS IS SAID TO BE DONE ) ! DEVIL1 & IS REALLY ! CASE ) ! /ATE & ALL SPIRITUAL AU?ORITY2 BUT ,I AM & REMA9 MORE TO MYSELF ?AN /ATE1 ,*UR*1 ,GOD1 & ! LIKE2 CONSEQU5TLY 9F9ITELY MORE ?AN ! UNION TOO4 

,?AT SOCIETY :I* ,COMMUNISM WANTS TO F\ND SEEMS TO /& NE>E/ TO COALITION4 ,= IT IS TO AIM AT ! 0WELF>E ( ALL10 OH1 YES1 ( ALL1 CRIES ,WEITL+ 9NUM]ABLE TIMES1 ( ALL6 ,?AT DOES REALLY LOOK AS IF 9 IT NO ONE NE$$ TO TAKE A BACK SEAT4 ,BUT :AT !N WILL ?IS WELF>E BE8 ,HAVE ALL ONE & ! SAME WELF>E1 >E ALL EQUALLY WELL (F ) ONE & ! SAME ?+8 ,IF ?AT BE SO1 ! QUE/ION IS ( ! 0TRUE WELF>E40 ,DO WE NOT ) ?IS COME RI<T TO ! PO9T :]E RELIGION BEG9S ITS DOM9ION ( VIOL5CE8 ,*RI/IANITY SAYS1 ,LOOK NOT ON E>?LY TOYS1 BUT SEEK Y\R TRUE WELF>E1 BECOME - PI\S ,*RI/IANS2 BE+ ,*RI/IANS IS ! TRUE WELF>E4 ,IT IS ! TRUE WELF>E ( 0ALL10 BECAUSE IT IS ! WELF>E ( ,MAN AS SU* 7?IS SPOOK74 ,N[1 ! WELF>E ( ALL IS SURELY TO BE Y\R & MY WELF>E TOO8 ,BUT1 IF Y\ & ,I DO NOT LOOK UPON ?AT WELF>E AS \R WELF>E1 WILL C>E !N BE TAK5 = ?AT 9 :I* WE FEEL WELL8 ,ON ! CONTR>Y1 SOCIETY HAS DECRE$ A WELF>E AS ! 0TRUE WELF>E10 IF ?IS WELF>E W]E CALL$ 05JOYM5T HONE/LY WORK$ =02 BUT IF Y\ PREF]R$ 5JOYABLE LAZ9ESS1 5JOYM5T )\T WORK1 !N SOCIETY1 :I* C>ES = ! 0WELF>E ( ALL10 W\LD WISELY AVOID C>+ = ?AT 9 :I* Y\ >E WELL (F4 ,COMMUNISM1 9 PROCLAIM+ ! WELF>E ( ALL1 ANNULS \TRI<T ! WELL-BE+ ( ?OSE :O HI!RTO LIV$ ON !IR 9COME FROM 9VE/M5TS & APP>5TLY FELT BETT] 9 ?AT ?AN 9 ! PROSPECT ( ,WEITL+'S /RICT H\RS ( LABOR4 ,H5CE ! LATT] ASS]TS ?AT ) ! WELF>E ( ?\S&S ! WELF>E ( MILLIONS CANNOT EXI/1 & ! =M] MU/ GIVE UP !IR SPECIAL WELF>E 0= ! SAKE ( ! G5]AL WELF>E40 ,NO1 LET PEOPLE NOT BE SUMMON$ TO SACRIFICE !IR SPECIAL WELF>E = ! G5]AL1 = ?IS ,*RI/IAN ADMONITION WILL NOT C>RY Y\ ?R\<2 !Y WILL BETT] UND]/& ! OPPOSITE ADMONITION1 NOT TO LET !IR [N WELF>E BE SNAT*$ FROM !M BY ANYBODY1 BUT TO PUT IT ON A P]MAN5T F\NDATION4 ,!N !Y >E ( !MSELVES L$ TO ! PO9T ?AT !Y C>E BE/ = !IR WELF>E IF !Y UNITE ) O!RS = ?IS PURPOSE1 ?AT IS1 0SACRIFICE A P>T ( !IR LIB]TY10 YET NOT TO ! WELF>E ( O!RS1 BUT TO !IR [N4 ,AN APPEAL TO M5'S SELF-SACRIFIC+ DISPOSITION 5D SELF-R5\NC+ LOVE \<T AT LEA/ TO HAVE LO/ ITS S$UCTIVE PLAUSIBILITY :51 AFT] AN ACTIVITY ( ?\S&S ( YE>S1 IT HAS LEFT NO?+ BEH9D BUT ! - MIS@&_?#a#d#c2RE ( TODAY4 ,:Y !N /ILL FRUITLESSLY EXPECT SELF-SACRIFICE TO BR+ US BETT] TIME8 ,:Y NOT RA!R HOPE = !M FROM USURPATION8 ,SALVATION COMES NO LONG] FROM ! GIV]1 ! BE/[]1 ! LOV+ ONE1 BUT FROM ! TAK]1 ! APPROPRIATOR 7USURP]71 ! [N]4 ,COMMUNISM1 &1 CONSCI\SLY1 EGOISM-REVIL+ HUMANISM1 /ILL C\NT ON LOVE4 

,IF COMMUNITY IS ONCE A NE$ ( MAN1 & HE F9DS HIMSELF FUR!R$ BY IT 9 HIS AIMS1 !N V]Y SOON1 BECAUSE IT HAS BECOME HIS PR9CIPLE1 IT PRESCRIBES TO HIM ITS LAWS TOO1 ! LAWS ( - SOCIETY4 ,! PR9CIPLE ( M5 EXALTS ITSELF 9TO A SOV]EIGN P[] OV] !M1 BECOMES !IR SUPREME ESS5CE1 !IR ,GOD1 &1 AS SU* - LAWGIV]4 ,COMMUNISM GIVES ?IS PR9CIPLE ! /RICTE/ EFFECT1 & ,*RI/IANITY IS ! RELIGION ( SOCIETY1 =1 AS ,FEU]BA* RI<TLY SAYS1 AL?\< HE DOES NOT MEAN IT RI<TLY1 LOVE IS ! ESS5CE ( MAN2 ?AT IS1 ! ESS5CE ( SOCIETY OR ( SOCIET>Y 7,COMMUNI/IC7 MAN4 ,ALL RELIGION IS A CULT ( SOCIETY1 ?IS PR9CIPLE BY :I* SOCIET>Y 7CULTIVAT$7 MAN IS DOM9AT$2 NEI!R IS ANY GOD AN EGO'S EXCLUSIVE GOD1 BUT ALWAYS A SOCIETY'S OR COMMUNITY'S1 BE IT ( ! SOCIETY1 0FAMILY0 7,L>1 ,P5ATES7 OR ( A 0PEOPLE0 70NATIONAL GOD07 OR ( 0ALL M50 70HE IS A ,FA!R ( ALL M5074 

,CONSEQU5TLY ONE HAS A PROSPECT ( EXTIRPAT+ RELIGION D[N TO ! GR\ND ONLY :5 ONE ANTIQUATES SOCIETY & EV]Y?+ ?AT FL[S FROM ?IS PR9CIPLE4 ,BUT IT IS PRECISELY 9 ,COMMUNISM ?AT ?IS PR9CIPLE SEEKS TO CULM9ATE1 AS 9 IT EV]Y?+ IS TO BECOME COMMON = ! E/ABLI%M5T ( - 0EQUALITY40 ,IF ?IS 0EQUALITY0 IS WON1 0LIB]TY0 TOO IS NOT LACK+4 ,BUT :OSE LIB]TY8 ,SOCIETY'S 6 ,SOCIETY IS !N ALL 9 ALL1 & M5 >E ONLY 0= EA* O!R40 ,IT W\LD BE ! GLORY ( ! - LOVE-/ATE .<,LIEBES/AAT.>4 

,BUT ,I W\LD RA!R BE REF]R$ TO M5'S SELFI%NESS ?AN TO !IR K9DNESSES .<,LIEBESDI5/E.>1 !IR M]CY1 PITY1 ETC4 ,! =M] DEM&S RECIPROCITY 7AS ?\ TO ME1 SO ,I TO !E71 DOES NO?+ 0GRATIS10 & MAY BE WON & - B\<T4 ,BUT ) :AT %ALL ,I OBTA9 ! K9DNESS8 ,IT IS A MATT] ( *ANCE :E!R ,I AM AT ! TIME HAV+ TO DO ) A 0LOV+0 P]SON4 ,! AFFECTIONATE ONE'S S]VICE CAN BE HAD ONLY BY - BEGG+1 BE IT BY MY LAM5TABLE APPE>ANCE1 BY MY NE$ ( HELP1 MY MIS]Y1 MY - SUFF]+4 ,:AT CAN ,I (F] HIM = HIS ASSI/ANCE8 ,NO?+6 ,I MU/ ACCEPT IT AS A - PRES5T4 ,LOVE IS UNPAYABLE1 OR RA!R1 LOVE CAN ASSUR$LY BE PAID =1 BUT ONLY BY C\NT]-LOVE 70,ONE GOOD TURN DES]VES ANO!R074 ,:AT PALTR9ESS & BEGG>L9ESS DOES IT NOT TAKE TO ACCEPT GIFTS YE> 9 & YE> \T )\T S]VICE 9 RETURN1 AS !Y >E REGUL>LY COLLECT$1 = 9/ANCE1 FROM ! POOR DAY-LABOR]8 ,:AT CAN ! RECEIV] DO = HIM & HIS DONAT$ P5NIES1 9 :I* HIS WEAL? CONSI/S8 ,! DAY-LABOR] W\LD REALLY HAVE MORE 5JOYM5T IF ! RECEIV] ) HIS LAWS1 HIS 9/ITUTIONS1 ETC41 ALL ( :I* ! DAY-LABOR] HAS TO PAY = ?\<1 DID NOT EXI/ AT ALL4 ,& YET1 ) IT ALL1 ! POOR WI<T LOVES HIS MA/]4 

,NO1 COMMUNITY1 AS ! 0GOAL0 ( HI/ORY HI!RTO1 IS IMPOSSIBLE4 ,LET US RA!R R5\NCE EV]Y HYPOCRISY ( COMMUNITY1 & RECOGNIZE ?AT1 IF WE >E EQUAL AS M51 WE >E NOT EQUAL = ! V]Y REASON ?AT WE >E NOT M54 ,WE >E EQUAL ONLY 9 ?\<TS1 ONLY :5 0WE0 >E ?\<T1 NOT AS WE REALLY & BODILY >E4 ,I AM EGO1 & Y\ >E EGO3 BUT ,I AM NOT ?IS ?\<T-( EGO2 ?IS EGO 9 :I* WE >E ALL EQUAL IS ONLY MY ?\<T4 ,I AM MAN1 & Y\ >E MAN3 BUT 0MAN0 IS ONLY A ?\<T1 A G5]ALITY2 NEI!R ,I NOR Y\ >E SPEAKABLE1 WE >E UNUTT]ABLE1 BECAUSE ONLY ?\<TS >E SPEAKABLE & CONSI/ 9 SPEAK+4 

,LET US !RE=E NOT ASPIRE TO COMMUNITY1 BUT TO ONE-SID$NESS4 ,LET US NOT SEEK ! MO/ COMPREH5SIVE COMMUNE1 0HUMAN SOCIETY10 BUT LET US SEEK 9 O!RS ONLY MEANS & ORGANS :I* WE MAY USE AS \R PROP]TY6 ,AS WE DO NOT SEE \R EQUALS 9 ! TREE1 ! BEA/1 SO ! PRESUPPOSITION ?AT O!RS >E \R EQUALS SPR+S FROM A HYPOCRISY4 ,NO ONE IS MY EQUAL1 BUT ,I REG>D HIM1 EQUALLY ) ALL O!R BE+S1 AS MY PROP]TY4 ,9 OPPOSITION TO ?IS ,I AM TOLD ?AT ,I %\LD BE A MAN AMONG 0FELL[-M50 7,JUD5FRAGE1 P4 #f72 ,I %\LD 0RESPECT0 ! FELL[-MAN 9 !M4 ,= ME NO ONE IS A P]SON TO BE RESPECT$1 NOT EV5 ! FELL[-MAN1 BUT SOLELY1 LIKE O!R BE+S1 AN OBJECT 9 :I* ,I TAKE AN 9T]E/ OR ELSE DO NOT1 AN 9T]E/+ OR UN9T]E/+ OBJECT1 A USABLE OR UNUSABLE P]SON4 

,&1 IF ,I CAN USE HIM1 ,I D\BTLESS COME TO AN UND]/&+ & MAKE MYSELF AT ONE ) HIM1 9 ORD]1 BY ! AGREEM5T1 TO /R5G!N MY P[]1 & BY COMB9$ =CE TO ACCOMPLI% MORE ?AN 9DIVIDUAL =CE C\LD EFFECT4 ,9 ?IS COMB9ATION ,I SEE NO?+ :ATEV] BUT A MULTIPLICATION ( MY =CE1 & ,I RETA9 IT ONLY SO LONG AS IT IS MY MULTIPLI$ =CE4 ,BUT ?US IT IS A - UNION4 

,NEI!R A NATURAL LIGATURE NOR A SPIRITUAL ONE HOLDS ! UNION TOGE!R1 & IT IS NOT A NATURAL1 NOT A SPIRITUAL LEAGUE4 ,IT IS NOT BR\<T AB\T BY ONE BLOOD1 NOT BY ONE FAI? 7SPIRIT74 ,9 A NATURAL LEAGUE - LIKE A FAMILY1 A TRIBE1 A NATION1 YES1 MANK9D - ! 9DIVIDUALS HAVE ONLY ! VALUE ( SPECIM5S ( ! SAME SPECIES OR G5US2 9 A SPIRITUAL LEAGUE - LIKE A COMMUNE1 A *UR* - ! 9DIVIDUAL SIGNIFIES ONLY A MEMB] ( ! SAME SPIRIT2 :AT Y\ >E 9 BO? CASES AS A UNIQUE P]SON MU/ BE - SUPPRESS$4 ,ONLY 9 ! UNION CAN Y\ ASS]T Y\RSELF AS UNIQUE1 BECAUSE ! UNION DOES NOT POSSESS Y\1 BUT Y\ POSSESS IT OR MAKE IT ( USE TO Y\4 

,PROP]TY IS RECOGNIZ$ 9 ! UNION1 & ONLY 9 ! UNION1 BECAUSE ONE NO LONG] HOLDS :AT IS HIS AS A FIEF FROM ANY BE+4 ,! ,COMMUNI/S >E ONLY CONSI/5TLY C>RY+ FUR!R :AT HAD ALREADY BE5 LONG PRES5T DUR+ RELIGI\S EVOLUTION1 & ESPECIALLY 9 ! /ATE2 NAMELY1 PROP]TYLESSNESS1 ! FEUDAL SY/EM4 

,! /ATE EX]TS ITSELF TO TAME ! DESIR\S MAN2 9 O!R WORDS1 IT SEEKS TO DIRECT HIS DESIRE TO IT ALONE1 & TO CONT5T ?AT DESIRE ) :AT IT (F]S4 ,TO SATE ! DESIRE = ! DESIR\S MAN'S SAKE DOES NOT COME 9TO ! M9D3 ON ! CONTR>Y1 IT /IGMATIZES AS AN 0EGOI/IC MAN0 ! MAN :O BREA!S \T UNBRIDL$ DESIRE1 & ! 0EGOI/IC MAN0 IS ITS 5EMY4 ,HE IS ?IS = IT BECAUSE ! CAPACITY TO AGREE ) HIM IS WANT+ TO ! /ATE2 ! EGOI/ IS PRECISELY :AT IT CANNOT 0COMPREH5D40 ,S9CE ! /ATE 7AS NO?+ ELSE IS POSSIBLE7 HAS TO DO ONLY = ITSELF1 IT DOES NOT TAKE C>E = MY NE$S1 BUT TAKES C>E ONLY ( H[ IT MAKE AWAY ) ME1 MAKE \T ( ME ANO!R EGO1 A GOOD CITIZ54 ,IT TAKES MEASURES = ! 0IMPROVEM5T ( MORALS40 - ,& ) :AT DOES IT W9 9DIVIDUALS = ITSELF8 ,) ITSELF1 ) :AT IS ! /ATE'S1 ) /ATE PROP]TY4 ,IT WILL BE UNREMITT+LY ACTIVE 9 MAK+ ALL P>TICIPANTS 9 ITS 0GOODS10 PROVID+ ALL ) ! 0GOOD ?+S ( CULTURE02 IT PRES5TS !M ITS $UCATION1 OP5S TO !M ! ACCESS TO ITS 9/ITUTIONS ( CULTURE1 CAPACITATES !M TO COME TO PROP]TY 7AS1 TO A FIEF7 9 ! WAY ( 9DU/RY1 ETC4 ,= ALL !SE FIEFS IT DEM&S ONLY ! JU/ R5T ( CONT9UAL ?ANKS4 ,BUT ! 0UN?ANKFUL0 =GET TO PAY !SE ?ANKS4 - ,N[1 NEI!R CAN 0SOCIETY0 DO ESS5TIALLY O!RWISE ?AN ! /ATE4 

,Y\ BR+ 9TO A UNION Y\R :OLE P[]1 Y\R COMPET5CE1 & MAKE Y\RSELF C\NT2 9 A SOCIETY Y\ >E EMPLOY$1 ) Y\R WORK+ P[]2 9 ! =M] Y\ LIVE EGOI/ICALLY1 9 ! LATT] HUMANLY1 ?AT IS1 RELIGI\SLY1 AS A 0MEMB] 9 ! BODY ( ?IS ,LORD02 TO A SOCIETY Y\ [E :AT Y\ HAVE1 & >E 9 DUTY B\ND TO IT1 >E - POSSESS$ BY 0SOCIAL DUTIES02 A UNION Y\ UTILIZE1 & GIVE IT UP UNDUTIFULLY & UNFAI?FULLY :5 Y\ SEE NO WAY TO USE IT FUR!R4 ,IF A SOCIETY IS MORE ?AN Y\1 !N IT IS MORE TO Y\ ?AN Y\RSELF2 A UNION IS ONLY Y\R 9/RUM5T1 OR ! SWORD ) :I* Y\ %>P5 & 9CREASE Y\R NATURAL =CE2 ! UNION EXI/S = Y\ & ?R\< Y\1 ! SOCIETY CONV]SELY LAYS CLAIM TO Y\ = ITSELF & EXI/S EV5 )\T Y\1 9 %ORT1 ! SOCIETY IS SACR$1 ! UNION Y\R [N2 CONSUMES Y\1 Y\ CONSUME ! UNION4 

,NEV]!LESS PEOPLE WILL NOT BE BACKW>D ) ! OBJECTION ?AT ! AGREEM5T :I* HAS BE5 CONCLUD$ MAY AGA9 BECOME BURD5SOME TO US & LIMIT \R FRE$OM2 !Y WILL SAY1 WE TOO W\LD AT LA/ COME TO ?IS1 ?AT 0EV]Y ONE MU/ SACRIFICE A P>T ( HIS FRE$OM = ! SAKE ( ! G5]ALITY40 ,BUT ! SACRIFICE W\LD NOT BE MADE = ! 0G5]ALITY'S0 SAKE A BIT1 AS LITTLE AS ,I CONCLUD$ ! AGREEM5T = ! 0G5]ALITY'S0 OR EV5 = ANY O!R MAN'S SAKE2 RA!R ,I CAME 9TO IT ONLY = ! SAKE ( MY [N B5EFIT1 FROM SELFI%NESS4 ,BUT1 AS REG>DS ! SACRIFIC+1 SURELY ,I 0SACRIFICE0 ONLY ?AT :I* DOES NOT /& 9 MY P[]1 ?AT IS1 ,I 0SACRIFICE0 NO?+ AT ALL4 

,TO COME BACK TO PROP]TY1 ! LORD IS PROPRIETOR4 ,*OOSE !N :E!R Y\ WANT TO BE LORD1 OR :E!R SOCIETY %ALL BE6 ,ON ?IS DEP5DS :E!R Y\ >E TO BE AN [N] OR A RAGAMUFF9 6 ,! EGOI/ IS [N]1 ! ,SOCIALI/ A RAGAMUFF94 ,BUT RAGAMUFF9ISM OR PROP]TYLESSNESS IS ! S5SE ( FEUDALISM1 ( ! FEUDAL SY/EM :I* S9CE ! LA/ C5TURY HAS ONLY *ANG$ ITS OV]LORD1 PUTT+ 0,MAN0 9 ! PLACE ( ,GOD1 & ACCEPT+ AS A FIEF FROM ,MAN :AT HAD BE=E BE5 A FIEF FROM ! GRACE ( ,GOD4 ,?AT ! RAGAMUFF9ISM ( ,COMMUNISM IS C>RI$ \T BY ! HUMANE PR9CIPLE 9TO ! ABSOLUTE OR MO/ RAGAMUFF9LY RAGAMUFF9ISM HAS BE5 %[N ABOVE2 BUT AT ! SAME TIME ALSO1 H[ RAGAMUFF9ISM CAN ONLY ?US SW+ >\ND 9TO [NNESS4 ,! OLD FEUDAL SY/EM WAS SO ?OR\<LY TRAMPL$ 9TO ! GR\ND 9 ! ,REVOLUTION ?AT S9CE !N ALL REACTION>Y CRAFT HAS REMA9$ FRUITLESS1 & WILL ALWAYS REMA9 FRUITLESS1 BECAUSE ! DEAD IS - DEAD2 BUT ! RESURRECTION TOO HAD TO PROVE ITSELF A TRU? 9 ,*RI/IAN HI/ORY1 & HAS SO PROV$ ITSELF3 = 9 ANO!R WORLD FEUDALISM IS RIS5 AGA9 ) A GLORIFI$ BODY1 ! NEW FEUDALISM UND] ! SUZ]A9TY ( 0,MAN40 

,*RI/IANITY IS NOT ANNIHILAT$1 BUT ! FAI?FUL >E RI<T 9 HAV+ HI!RTO TRU/FULLY ASSUM$ ( EV]Y COMBAT AGA9/ IT ?AT ?IS C\LD S]VE ONLY = ! PURGATION & CONFIRMATION ( ,*RI/IANITY2 = IT HAS REALLY ONLY BE5 GLORIFI$1 & 0,*RI/IANITY EXPOS$0 IS ! - HUMAN ,*RI/IANITY4 ,WE >E /ILL LIV+ 5TIRELY 9 ! ,*RI/IAN AGE1 & ! V]Y ONES :O FEEL WOR/ AB\T IT >E ! MO/ ZEAL\SLY CONTRIBUT+ TO 0COMPLETE0 IT4 ,! MORE HUMAN1 ! DE>] HAS FEUDALISM BECOME TO US2 = WE ! LESS BELIEVE ?AT IT /ILL IS FEUDALISM1 WE TAKE IT ! MORE CONFID5TLY = [NNESS & ?9K WE HAVE F\ND :AT IS 0MO/ ABSOLUTELY \R [N0 :5 WE DISCOV] 0! HUMAN40 

,LIB]ALISM WANTS TO GIVE ME :AT IS M9E1 BUT IT ?9KS TO PROCURE IT = ME NOT UND] ! TITLE ( M9E1 BUT UND] ?AT ( ! 0HUMAN40 ,AS IF IT W]E ATTA9ABLE UND] ?IS MASK6 ,! RI<TS ( MAN1 ! PRECI\S WORK ( ! ,REVOLUTION1 HAVE ! MEAN+ ?AT ! ,MAN 9 ME 5TITLES ME TO ?IS & ?AT2 ,I AS 9DIVIDUAL1 AS ?IS MAN1 AM NOT 5TITL$1 BUT ,MAN HAS ! RI<T & 5TITLES ME4 ,H5CE AS MAN ,I MAY WELL BE 5TITL$2 BUT1 AS ,I AM MORE ?AN MAN1 NAMELY1 A SPECIAL MAN1 IT MAY BE REFUS$ TO ?IS V]Y ME1 ! SPECIAL ONE4 ,IF ON ! O!R H& Y\ 9SI/ ON ! VALUE ( Y\R GIFTS1 KEEP UP !IR PRICE1 DO NOT LET Y\RSELVES BE =C$ TO SELL \T BEL[ PRICE1 DO NOT LET Y\RSELVES BE TALK$ 9TO ! IDEA ?AT Y\R W>E IS NOT WOR? ITS PRICE4 DO NOT MAKE Y\RSELF RIDICUL\S BY A 0RIDICUL\S PRICE10 BUT IMITATE ! BRAVE MAN :O SAYS1 ,I WILL SELL MY LIFE 7PROP]TY7 DE>1 ! 5EMY %ALL NOT HAVE IT AT A *EAP B>GA92 !N Y\ HAVE RECOGNIZ$ ! REV]SE ( ,COMMUNISM AS ! CORRECT ?+1 & ! WORD !N IS NOT 0,GIVE UP Y\R PROP]TY60 BUT 0,GET ! VALUE \T ( Y\R PROP]TY60 

,OV] ! PORTAL ( \R TIME /&S NOT ?AT 0,KN[ ?YSELF0 ( ,APOLLO1 BUT A 0,GET ! VALUE \T ( ?YSELF60 

,PR\DHON CALLS PROP]TY 0ROBB]Y0 7LE VOL74 ,BUT ALI5 PROP]TY - & HE IS TALK+ ( ?IS ALONE - IS NOT LESS EXI/5T BY R5UNCIATION1 CESSION1 & HUMILITY2 IT IS A PRES5T4 ,:Y SO S5TIM5TALLY CALL = COMPASSION AS A POOR VICTIM ( ROBB]Y1 :5 ONE IS JU/ A FOOLI%1 C[>DLY GIV] ( PRES5TS8 ,:Y H]E AGA9 PUT ! FAULT ON O!RS AS IF !Y W]E ROBB+ US1 :ILE WE \RSELVES DO BE> ! FAULT 9 LEAV+ ! O!RS UNROBB$8 ,! POOR >E TO BLAME = !RE BE+ RI* M54 

,UNIV]SALLY1 NO ONE GR[S 9DIGNANT AT HIS1 BUT AT ALI5 PROP]TY4 ,!Y DO NOT 9 TRU? ATTACK PROP]TY1 BUT ! ALI5ATION ( PROP]TY4 ,!Y WANT TO BE ABLE TO CALL MORE1 NOT LESS1 !IRS2 !Y WANT TO CALL EV]Y?+ !IRS4 ,!Y >E FI<T+1 !RE=E1 AGA9/ ALI5NESS1 OR1 TO =M A WORD SIMIL> TO PROP]TY1 AGA9/ ALI5TY4 ,& H[ DO !Y HELP !MSELVES !RE98 ,9/EAD ( TRANS=M+ ! ALI5 9TO [N1 !Y PLAY IMP>TIAL & ASK ONLY ?AT ALL PROP]TY BE LEFT TO A ?IRD P>TY1 SU* AS HUMAN SOCIETY4 ,!Y REV9DICATE ! ALI5 NOT 9 !IR [N NAME BUT 9 A ?IRD P>TY'S4 ,N[ ! 0EGOI/IC0 COLOR+ IS WIP$ (F1 & EV]Y?+ IS SO CLEAN & - HUMAN6 

,PROP]TYLESSNESS OR RAGAMUFF9ISM1 ?IS !N IS ! 0ESS5CE ( ,*RI/IANITY10 AS IT IS ESS5CE ( ALL RELIGI\SNESS 7GODL9ESS1 MORALITY1 HUMANITY71 & ONLY ANN\NC$ ITSELF MO/ CLE>LY1 &1 AS GLAD TID+S1 BECAME A GOSPEL CAPABLE ( DEVELOPM5T1 9 ! 0ABSOLUTE RELIGION40 ,WE HAVE BE=E US ! MO/ /RIK+ DEVELOPM5T 9 ! PRES5T FI<T AGA9/ PROP]TY1 A FI<T :I* IS TO BR+ 0,MAN0 TO VICTORY & MAKE PROP]TYLESSNESS COMPLETE3 VICTORI\S HUMANITY IS ! VICTORY ( - ,*RI/IANITY4 ,BUT ! 0,*RI/IANITY EXPOS$0 ?US IS FEUDALISM COMPLET$4 ! MO/ ALL-EMBRAC+ FEUDAL SY/EM1 ?AT IS1 P]FECT RAGAMUFF9ISM4 

,ONCE MORE !N1 D\BTLESS1 A 0REVOLUTION0 AGA9/ ! FEUDAL SY/EM8 

,REVOLUTION & 9SURRECTION .<,EMPORUNG.> MU/ NOT BE LOOK$ UPON AS SYNONYM\S4 ,! =M] CONSI/S 9 AN OV]TURN+ ( CONDITIONS1 ( ! E/ABLI%$ CONDITION OR /ATUS1 ! /ATE OR SOCIETY1 & IS ACCORD+LY A POLITICAL OR SOCIAL ACT2 ! LATT] HAS 9DE$ = ITS UNAVOIDABLE CONSEQU5CE A TRANS=MATION ( CIRCUM/ANCES1 YET DOES NOT />T FROM IT BUT FROM M5'S DISCONT5T ) !MSELVES1 IS NOT AN >M$ RIS+1 BUT A RIS+ ( 9DIVIDUALS1 A GETT+ UP1 )\T REG>D TO ! >RANGEM5TS ?AT SPR+ FROM IT4 ,! ,REVOLUTION AIM$ AT NEW >RANGEM5TS2 9SURRECTION LEADS US NO LONG] TO LET \RSELVES BE >RANG$1 BUT TO >RANGE \RSELVES1 & SETS NO GLITT]+ HOPES ON 09/ITUTIONS40 ,IT IS NOT A FI<T AGA9/ ! E/ABLI%$1 S9CE1 IF IT PROSP]S1 ! E/ABLI%$ COLLAPSES ( ITSELF2 IT IS ONLY A WORK+ =? ( ME \T ( ! E/ABLI%$4 ,IF ,I LEAVE ! E/ABLI%$1 IT IS DEAD & PASSES 9TO DECAY4 ,N[1 AS MY OBJECT IS NOT ! OV]?R[ ( AN E/ABLI%$ ORD] BUT MY ELEVATION ABOVE IT1 MY PURPOSE & DE$ >E NOT A POLITICAL OR SOCIAL BUT 7AS DIRECT$ T[>D MYSELF & MY [NNESS ALONE7 AN EGOI/IC PURPOSE & DE$4 

,! REVOLUTION COMM&S ONE TO MAKE >RANGEM5TS1 ! 9SURRECTION .<,EMPORUNG.> DEM&S ?AT HE RISE OR EXALT HIMSELF .<EMPOR-1 AUFRI*T5.>4 ,:AT CON/ITUTION WAS TO BE *OS51 ?IS QUE/ION BUSI$ ! REVOLUTION>Y HEADS1 & ! :OLE POLITICAL P]IOD FOAMS ) CON/ITUTIONAL FI<TS & CON/ITUTIONAL QUE/IONS1 AS ! SOCIAL TAL5TS TOO W]E UNCOMMONLY 9V5TIVE 9 SOCIET>Y >RANGEM5TS 7PHALAN/]IES & ! LIKE74 ,! 9SURG5T /RIVES TO BECOME CON/ITUTIONLESS4 

,:ILE1 TO GET GREAT] CLE>NESS1 ,I AM ?9K+ UP A COMP>ISON1 ! F\ND+ ( ,*RI/IANITY COMES UNEXPECT$LY 9TO MY M9D4 ,ON ! LIB]AL SIDE IT IS NOT$ AS A BAD PO9T 9 ! FIR/ ,*RI/IANS ?AT !Y PREA*$ OB$I5CE TO ! E/ABLI%$ HEA!N CIVIL ORD]1 5JO9$ RECOGNITION ( ! HEA!N AU?ORITIES1 & CONFID5TLY DELIV]$ A COMM&1 0,GIVE TO ! EMP]OR ?AT :I* IS ! EMP]OR'S40 ,YET H[ MU* DI/URBANCE >OSE AT ! SAME TIME AGA9/ ! ,ROMAN SUPREMACY1 H[ MUT9\S DID ! ,JEWS & EV5 ! ,ROMANS %[ !MSELVES AGA9/ !IR [N TEMPORAL GOV]NM5T6 ,9 %ORT1 H[ POPUL> WAS 0POLITICAL DISCONT5T60 ,?OSE ,*RI/IANS W\LD HE> NO?+ ( IT2 W\LD NOT SIDE ) ! 0LIB]AL T5D5CIES40 ,! TIME WAS POLITICALLY SO AGITAT$ ?AT1 AS IS SAID 9 ! GOSPELS1 PEOPLE ?\<T !Y C\LD NOT ACCUSE ! F\ND] ( ,*RI/IANITY MORE SUCCESSFULLY ?AN IF !Y >RAIGN$ HIM = 0POLITICAL 9TRIGUE10 & YET ! SAME GOSPELS REPORT ?AT HE WAS PRECISELY ! ONE :O TOOK LEA/ P>T 9 !SE POLITICAL DO+S4 ,BUT :Y WAS HE NOT A REVOLUTIONI/1 NOT A DEMAGOGUE1 AS ! ,JEWS W\LD GLADLY HAVE SE5 HIM8 ,:Y WAS HE NOT A LIB]AL8 ,BECAUSE HE EXPECT$ NO SALVATION FROM A *ANGE ( CONDITIONS1 & ?IS :OLE BUS9ESS WAS 9DIFF]5T TO HIM4 ,HE WAS NOT A REVOLUTIONI/1 LIKE ,CES>1 BUT AN 9SURG5T2 NOT A /ATE-OV]TURN]1 BUT ONE :O /RAI<T5$ HIMSELF UP4 ,?AT WAS :Y IT WAS = HIM ONLY A MATT] ( 0,BE YE WISE AS S]P5TS10 :I* EXPRESSES ! SAME S5SE AS1 9 ! SPECIAL CASE1 ?AT 0,GIVE TO ! EMP]OR ?AT :I* IS ! EMP]OR'S02 = HE WAS NOT C>RY+ ON ANY LIB]AL OR POLITICAL FI<T AGA9/ ! E/ABLI%$ AU?ORITIES1 BUT WANT$ TO WALK HIS [N WAY1 UNTR\BL$ AB\T1 & UNDI/URB$ BY1 !SE AU?ORITIES4 ,NOT LESS 9DIFF]5T TO HIM ?AN ! GOV]NM5T W]E ITS 5EMIES1 = NEI!R UND]/OOD :AT HE WANT$1 & HE HAD ONLY TO KEEP !M (F FROM HIM ) ! WISDOM ( ! S]P5T4 ,BUT1 EV5 ?\< NOT A R+LEAD] ( POPUL> MUT9Y1 NOT A DEMAGOGUE OR REVOLUTIONI/1 HE 7& EV]Y ONE ( ! ANCI5T ,*RI/IANS7 WAS SO MU* ! MORE AN 9SURG5T1 :O LIFT$ HIMSELF ABOVE EV]Y?+ ?AT SEEM$ SUBLIME TO ! GOV]NM5T & ITS OPPON5TS1 & ABSOLV$ HIMSELF FROM EV]Y?+ ?AT !Y REMA9$ B\ND TO1 & :O AT ! SAME TIME CUT (F ! S\RCES ( LIFE ( ! :OLE HEA!N WORLD1 ) :I* ! E/ABLI%$ /ATE MU/ WI!R AWAY AS A MATT] ( C\RSE2 PRECISELY BECAUSE HE PUT FROM HIM ! UPSETT+ ( ! E/ABLI%$1 HE WAS ITS DEADLY 5EMY & REAL ANNIHILATOR2 = HE WALL$ IT 91 CONFID5TLY & RECKLESSLY C>RY+ UP ! BUILD+ ( HIS TEMPLE OV] IT1 )\T HE$+ ! PA9S ( ! IMMUR$4 

,N[1 AS IT HAPP5$ TO ! HEA!N ORD] ( ! WORLD1 WILL ! ,*RI/IAN ORD] F>E LIKEWISE8 ,A REVOLUTION C]TA9LY DOES NOT BR+ ON ! 5D IF AN 9SURRECTION IS NOT CONSUMMAT$ FIR/6 

,MY 9T]C\RSE ) ! WORLD1 :AT DOES IT AIM AT8 ,I WANT TO HAVE ! 5JOYM5T ( IT1 !RE=E IT MU/ BE MY PROP]TY1 & !RE=E ,I WANT TO W9 IT4 ,I DO NOT WANT ! LIB]TY ( M51 NOR !IR EQUALITY2 ,I WANT ONLY MY P[] OV] !M1 ,I WANT TO MAKE !M MY PROP]TY1 MAT]IAL = 5JOYM5T4 ,&1 IF ,I DO NOT SUCCE$ 9 ?AT1 WELL1 !N ,I CALL EV5 ! P[] OV] LIFE & DEA?1 :I* ,*UR* & /ATE RES]V$ TO !MSELVES - M9E4 ,BR& ?AT (FIC]'S WID[ :O1 9 ! FLI<T 9 ,RUSSIA1 AFT] H] LEG HAS BE5 %OT AWAY1 TAKES ! G>T] FROM IT1 /RANGLES H] *ILD !RE)1 & !N BLE$S TO DEA? ALONGSIDE ! CORPSE - BR& ! MEMORY ( ! - 9FANTICIDE4 ,:O KN[S1 IF ?IS *ILD HAD REMA9$ ALIVE1 H[ MU* IT MI<T HAVE 0BE5 ( USE TO ! WORLD60 ,! MO!R MURD]$ IT BECAUSE %E WANT$ TO DIE SATISFI$ & AT RE/4 ,P]HAPS ?IS CASE /ILL APPEALS TO Y\R S5TIM5TALITY1 & Y\ DO NOT KN[ H[ TO READ \T ( IT ANY?+ FUR!R4 ,BE IT SO2 ,I ON MY P>T USE IT AS AN EXAMPLE = ?IS1 ?AT MY SATISFACTION DECIDES AB\T MY RELATION TO M51 & ?AT ,I DO NOT R5\NCE1 FROM ANY ACCESS ( HUMILITY1 EV5 ! P[] OV] LIFE & DEA?4 

,AS REG>DS 0SOCIAL DUTIES0 9 G5]AL1 ANO!R DOES NOT GIVE ME MY POSITION T[>D O!RS1 !RE=E NEI!R ,GOD NOR HUMANITY PRESCRIBES TO ME MY RELATION TO M51 BUT ,I GIVE MYSELF ?IS POSITION4 ,?IS IS MORE /RIK+LY SAID ?US3 ,I HAVE NO DUTY TO O!RS1 AS ,I HAVE A DUTY EV5 TO MYSELF 7?AT ( SELF-PRES]VATION1 & !RE=E NOT SUICIDE7 ONLY SO LONG AS ,I DI/+UI% MYSELF FROM MYSELF 7MY IMMORTAL S\L FROM MY E>?LY EXI/5CE1 ETC474 

,I NO LONG] HUMBLE MYSELF BE=E ANY P[]1 & ,I RECOGNIZE ?AT ALL P[]S >E ONLY MY P[]1 :I* ,I HAVE TO SUBJECT AT ONCE :5 !Y ?REAT5 TO BECOME A P[] AGA9/ OR ABOVE ME2 EA* ( !M MU/ BE ONLY ONE ( MY MEANS TO C>RY MY PO9T1 AS A H\ND IS \R P[] AGA9/ GAME1 BUT IS KILL$ BY US IF IT %\LD FALL UPON US \RSELVES4 ,ALL P[]S ?AT DOM9ATE ME ,I !N R$UCE TO S]V+ ME4 ,! IDOLS EXI/ ?R\< ME2 ,I NE$ ONLY REFRA9 FROM CREAT+ !M ANEW1 !N !Y EXI/ NO LONG]3 0HI<] P[]S0 EXI/ ONLY ?R\< MY EXALT+ !M & ABAS+ MYSELF4 

,CONSEQU5TLY MY RELATION TO ! WORLD IS ?IS3 ,I NO LONG] DO ANY?+ = IT 0= ,GOD'S SAKE10 ,I DO NO?+ 0= MAN'S SAKE10 BUT :AT ,I DO ,I DO 0= MY SAKE40 ,?US ALONE DOES ! WORLD SATISFY ME1 :ILE IT IS *>ACT]I/IC ( ! RELIGI\S /&-PO9T1 9 :I* ,I 9CLUDE ! MORAL & HUMANE ALSO1 ?AT FROM IT EV]Y?+ REMA9S A PI\S WI% 7PIUM DESID]IUM 71 AN O!R-WORLD MATT]1 SOME?+ UNATTA9$4 ,?US ! G5]AL SALVATION ( M51 ! MORAL WORLD ( A G5]AL LOVE1 ET]NAL PEACE1 ! CESSATION ( EGOISM1 ETC4 0,NO?+ 9 ?IS WORLD IS P]FECT40 ,) ?IS MIS]ABLE PHRASE ! GOOD P>T FROM IT1 & TAKE FLI<T 9TO !IR CLOSET TO ,GOD1 OR 9TO !IR PR\D 0SELF-CONSCI\SNESS40 ,BUT WE REMA9 9 ?IS 0IMP]FECT0 WORLD1 BECAUSE EV5 SO WE CAN USE IT = \R - SELF-5JOYM5T4 

,MY 9T]C\RSE ) ! WORLD CONSI/S 9 MY 5JOY+ IT1 & SO CONSUM+ IT = MY SELF-5JOYM5T4 ,9T]C\RSE IS ! 5JOYM5T ( ! WORLD1 & BELONGS TO MY - SELF-5JOYM5T4 

,FROM 3 ,WIKI,S\RCE4 

,*RONOLOGY 3 
,NOVEMB] #c1 #ahdc 3 ,P>T #b1 ,*APT] #b1 ,SECTION #b -- ,PUBLICATION4 
,FEBRU>Y #b1 #bag 3 ,P>T #b1 ,*APT] #b1 ,SECTION #b -- ,ADD$4 

 FILE G5]AT$ FROM 3  
HTTP3_/_/REVOLTLIB4COM_/