,P>T #b1 ,*APT] #b1 ,SECTION #a 
,MY ,P[] 

#ahddahdd 

,PEOPLE 3 

,AU?OR 3 ,MAX ,/IRN] 

,TEXT 3 

,MY ,P[] 

,RI<T.<#a.> IS ! SPIRIT ( SOCIETY4 ,IF SOCIETY HAS A WILL ?IS WILL IS SIMPLY RI<T3 SOCIETY EXI/S ONLY ?R\< RI<T4 ,BUT1 AS IT 5DURES ONLY EX]CIS+ A SOV]EIGNTY OV] 9DIVIDUALS1 RI<T IS ITS SOV]EIGN WILL 4 ,>I/OTLE SAYS JU/ICE IS ! ADVANTAGE ( SOCIETY4 

,ALL EXI/+ RI<T IS - =EIGN LAW.<#b.>2 SOME ONE MAKES ME \T TO BE 9 ! RI<T1 0DOES RI<T BY ME40 ,BUT %\LD ,I !RE=E BE 9 ! RI<T IF ALL ! WORLD MADE ME \T SO8 ,& YET :AT ELSE IS ! RI<T ?AT ,I OBTA9 9 ! /ATE1 9 SOCIETY1 BUT A RI<T ( ?OSE =EIGN TO ME8 ,:5 A BLOCKHEAD MAKES ME \T 9 ! RI<T1 ,I GR[ DI/RU/FUL ( MY RI<TNESS2 ,I DON'T LIKE TO RECEIVE IT FROM HIM4 ,BUT1 EV5 :5 A WISE MAN MAKES ME \T 9 ! RI<T1 ,I NEV]!LESS AM NOT 9 ! RI<T ON ?AT ACC\NT4 ,:E!R ,I AM 9 ! RI<T IS COMPLETELY 9DEP5D5T ( ! FOOL'S MAK+ \T & ( ! WISE MAN'S4 

,ALL ! SAME1 WE HAVE COVET$ ?IS RI<T UNTIL N[4 ,WE SEEK = RI<T1 & TURN TO ! C\RT = ?AT PURPOSE4 ,TO :AT8 ,TO A ROYAL1 A PAPAL1 A POPUL> C\RT1 ETC4 ,CAN A SULTANIC C\RT DECL>E ANO!R RI<T ?AN ?AT :I* ! SULTAN HAS ORDA9$ TO BE RI<T8 ,CAN IT MAKE ME \T 9 ! RI<T IF ,I SEEK = A RI<T ?AT DOES NOT AGREE ) ! SULTAN'S LAW8 ,CAN IT1 = 9/ANCE1 CONC$E TO ME HI< TREASON AS A RI<T1 S9CE IT IS ASSUR$LY NOT A RI<T ACCORD+ TO ! SULTAN'S M9D8 ,CAN IT AS A C\RT ( C5SOR%IP ALL[ ME ! FREE UTT]ANCE ( OP9ION AS A RI<T1 S9CE ! SULTAN WILL HE> NO?+ ( ?IS MY RI<T8 ,:AT AM ,I SEEK+ = 9 ?IS C\RT1 !N8 ,I AM SEEK+ = SULTANIC RI<T1 NOT MY RI<T2 ,I AM SEEK+ = - =EIGN RI<T4 ,AS LONG AS ?IS =EIGN RI<T H>MONIZES ) M9E1 TO BE SURE1 ,I %ALL F9D 9 IT ! LATT] TOO4 

,! /ATE DOES NOT P]MIT PIT*+ 9TO EA* O!R MAN TO MAN2 IT OPPOSES ! DUEL4 ,EV5 EV]Y ORD9>Y APPEAL TO BL[S1 NOT)/&+ ?AT NEI!R ( ! FI<T]S CALLS ! POLICE TO IT1 IS PUNI%$2 EXCEPT :5 IT IS NOT AN ,I :ACK+ AWAY AT A Y\1 BUT1 SAY1 ! HEAD ( A FAMILY AT ! *ILD4 ,! FAMILY IS 5TITL$ TO ?IS1 & 9 ITS NAME ! FA!R2 ,I AS ,EGO AM NOT4 

,! ,VOSSIS*E ,ZEITUNG.<#c.> PRES5TS TO US ! 0COMMONWEAL? ( RI<T.<#d.>40 ,!RE EV]Y?+ IS TO BE DECID$ BY ! JUDGE & A C\RT4 ,IT RANKS ! SUPREME C\RT ( C5SOR%IP AS A 0C\RT0 :]E 0RI<T IS DECL>$40 ,:AT SORT ( A RI<T8 ,! RI<T ( ! C5SOR%IP4 ,TO RECOGNIZE ! S5T5CES ( ?AT C\RT AS RI<T ONE MU/ REG>D ! C5SOR%IP AS RI<T4 ,BUT IT IS ?\<T NEV]!LESS ?AT ?IS C\RT (F]S A PROTECTION4 ,YES1 PROTECTION AGA9/ AN 9DIVIDUAL C5SOR'S ]ROR3 IT PROTECTS ONLY ! C5SOR%IP-LEGISLATOR AGA9/ FALSE 9T]PRETATION ( HIS WILL1 AT ! SAME TIME MAK+ HIS /ATUTE1 BY ! 0SACR$ P[] ( RI<T10 ALL ! FIRM] AGA9/ WRIT]S4 

,:E!R ,I AM 9 ! RI<T OR NOT !RE IS NO JUDGE BUT MYSELF4 ,O!RS CAN JUDGE ONLY :E!R !Y 5DORSE MY RI<T1 & :E!R IT EXI/S AS RI<T = !M TOO4 

,9 ! MEANTIME LET US TAKE ! MATT] YET ANO!R WAY4 ,I AM TO REV]5CE SULTANIC LAW 9 ! SULTANATE1 POPUL> LAW 9 REPUBLICS1 CANON LAW 9 ,CA?OLIC COMMUNITIES4 ,TO !SE LAWS ,I AM TO SUBORD9ATE MYSELF2 ,I AM TO REG>D !M AS SACR$4 ,A 0S5SE ( RI<T0 & 0LAW-ABID+ M9D0 ( SU* A SORT IS SO FIRMLY PLANT$ 9 PEOPLE'S HEADS ?AT ! MO/ REVOLUTION>Y P]SONS ( \R DAYS WANT TO SUBJECT US TO A NEW 0SACR$ LAW10 ! 0LAW ( SOCIETY10 ! LAW ( MANK9D1 ! 0RI<T ( ALL10 1& ! LIKE4 ,! RI<T ( 0ALL0 IS TO GO BE=E MY RI<T4 ,AS A RI<T ( ALL IT W\LD 9DE$ BE MY RI<T AMONG ! RE/1 S9CE ,I1 ) ! RE/1 AM 9CLUD$ 9 ALL2 BUT ?AT IT IS AT ! SAME TIME A RI<T ( O!RS1 OR EV5 ( ALL O!RS1 DOES NOT MOVE ME TO ITS UPHOLD+4 ,NOT AS A RI<T ( ALL WILL ,I DEF5D IT1 BUT AS MY RI<T2 & !N EV]Y O!R MAY SEE TO IT H[ HE %ALL LIKEWISE MA9TA9 IT = HIMSELF4 ,! RI<T ( ALL 7= EXAMPLE1 TO EAT7 IS A RI<T ( EV]Y 9DIVIDUAL4 ,LET EA* KEEP ?IS RI<T UNABRIDG$ = HIMSELF1 !N ALL EX]CISE IT SPONTANE\SLY2 LET HIM NOT TAKE C>E = ALL ?\< - LET HIM NOT GR[ ZEAL\S = IT AS = A RI<T ( ALL4 

,BUT ! SOCIAL RE=M]S PREA* TO US A 0LAW ( SOCIETY04 ,!RE ! 9DIVIDUAL BECOMES SOCIETY'S SLAVE1 & IS 9 ! RI<T ONLY :5 SOCIETY MAKES HIM \T 9 ! RI<T1 :5 HE LIVES ACCORD+ TO SOCIETY'S /ATUTES & SO IS - LOYAL4 ,:E!R ,I AM LOYAL UND] A DESPOTISM OR 9 A 0SOCIETY0 A LA ,WEITL+.<#e.>1 IT IS ! SAME ABS5CE ( RI<T 9 SO F> AS 9 BO? CASES ,I HAVE NOT MY RI<T BUT =EIGN RI<T4 

,9 CONSID]ATION ( RI<T ! QUE/ION IS ALWAYS ASK$1 0,:AT OR :O GIVES ME ! RI<T TO IT80 ,ANSW]3 ,GOD1 LOVE1 REASON1 NATURE1 HUMANITY1 ETC4 ,NO1 ONLY Y\R MI<T1 Y\R P[] GIVES Y\ ! RI<T 7Y\R REASON1 !RE=E1 MAY GIVE IT TO Y\74 

,COMMUNISM1 :I* ASSUMES ?AT M5 0HAVE EQUAL RI<TS BY NATURE10 CONTRADICTS ITS [N PROPOSITION UNTIL IT COMES TO ?IS1 ?AT M5 HAVE NO RI<T AT ALL BY NATURE4 ,= IT IS NOT WILL+ TO RECOGNIZE1 = 9/ANCE1 ?AT P>5TS HAVE 0BY NATURE0 RI<TS AS AGA9/ !IR *ILDR51 OR ! *ILDR5 AS AGA9/ ! P>5TS3 IT ABOLI%ES ! FAMILY4 ,NATURE GIVES P>5TS1 BRO!RS1 & SO ON1 NO RI<T AT ALL4 ,ALTOGE!R1 ?IS 5TIRE REVOLUTION>Y OR ,BAB\VI/ PR9CIPLE.<#f.> RE/S ON A RELIGI\S1 ?AT IS1 FALSE1 VIEW ( ?+S4 ,:O CAN ASK AFT] 0RI<T0 IF HE DOES NOT OCCUPY ! RELIGI\S /&-PO9T HIMSELF8 ,IS NOT 0RI<T0 A RELIGI\S CONCEPT1 SOME?+ SACR$8 ,:Y1 0EQUALITY ( RI<TS01 AS ! ,REVOLUTION PROP\ND$ IT1 IS ONLY ANO!R NAME = 0,*RI/IAN EQUALITY10 ! 0EQUALITY ( ! BRE?R510 0( ,GOD'S *ILDR510 0( ,*RI/IANS02 9 %ORT1 FRAT]NITE4 ,EA* & EV]Y 9QUIRY AFT] RI<T DES]VES TO BE LA%$ ) ,S*ILL]'S WORDS3 

,MANY A YE> ,I'VE US$ MY NOSE ,TO SMELL ! ONION & ! ROSE2 ,IS !RE ANY PRO( :I* %[S ,?AT ,I'VE A RI<T TO ?AT SAME NOSE8 

,:5 ! ,REVOLUTION /AMP$ EQUALITY AS A 0RI<T10 IT TOOK FLI<T 9TO ! RELIGI\S DOMA91 9TO ! REGION ( ! SACR$1 ( ! IDEAL4 ,H5CE1 S9CE !N1 ! FI<T = ! 0SACR$1 9ALI5ABLE RI<TS ( MAN40 ,AGA9/ ! 0ET]NAL RI<TS ( MAN0 ! 0WELL-E>N$ RI<TS ( ! E/ABLI%$ ORD]0 >E QUITE NATURALLY1 & ) EQUAL RI<T1 BR\<T TO BE>3 RI<T AGA9/ RI<T1 :]E ( C\RSE ONE IS DECRI$ BY ! O!R AS 0WRONG40 ,?IS HAS BE5 ! CONTE/ ( RI<TS.<#g.> S9CE ! ,REVOLUTION4 

,Y\ WANT TO BE 09 ! RI<T0 AS AGA9/ ! RE/4 ,?AT Y\ CANNOT2 AS AGA9/ !M Y\ REMA9 =EV] 09 ! WRONG02 = !Y SURELY W\LD NOT BE Y\R OPPON5TS IF !Y W]E NOT 9 0!IR RI<T0 TOO2 !Y WILL ALWAYS MAKE Y\ \T 09 ! WRONG40 ,BUT1 AS AGA9/ ! RI<T ( ! RE/1 Y\RS IS A HI<]1 GREAT]1 MORE P[]FUL RI<T1 IS IT NOT8 ,NO SU* ?+6 ,Y\R RI<T IS NOT MORE P[]FUL IF Y\ >E NOT MORE P[]FUL4 ,HAVE ,*9ESE SUBJECTS A RI<T TO FRE$OM8 ,JU/ BE/[ IT ON !M1 & !N LOOK H[ F> Y\ HAVE GONE WRONG 9 Y\R ATTEMPT3 BECAUSE !Y DO NOT KN[ H[ TO USE FRE$OM !Y HAVE NO RI<T TO IT1 OR1 9 CLE>] T]MS1 BECAUSE !Y HAVE NOT FRE$OM !Y HAVE NOT ! RI<T TO IT4 ,*ILDR5 HAVE NO RI<T TO ! CONDITION ( MAJORITY BECAUSE !Y >E NOT ( AGE1 BECAUSE !Y >E *ILDR54 ,PEOPLES ?AT LET !MSELVES BE KEPT 9 NONAGE HAVE NO RI<TS TO ! CONDITION ( MAJORITY2 IF !Y CEAS$ TO BE 9 NONAGE1 !N ONLY W\LD !Y HAVE ! RI<T TO BE ( AGE4 ,?IS MEANS NO?+ ELSE ?AN 0,:AT Y\ HAVE ! P[] TO BE Y\ HAVE ! RI<T TO40 ,I D]IVE ALL RI<T & ALL W>RANT FROM ME2 ,I AM 5TITL$ TO EV]Y?+ ?AT ,I HAVE 9 MY P[]4 ,I AM 5TITL$ TO OV]?R[ ,ZEUS1 ,JEHOVAH1 ,GOD1 IF ,I CAN2 IF ,I CANNOT1 !N !SE GODS WILL ALWAYS REMA9 9 ! RI<T & 9 P[] AS AGA9/ ME1 & :AT ,I DO WILL BE TO FE> !IR RI<T & !IR P[] 9 IMPOT5T 0GOD-FE>+NESS10 TO KEEP !IR COMM&M5TS & BELIEVE ?AT ,I DO RI<T 9 EV]Y?+ ?AT ,I DO ACCORD+ TO !IR RI<T1 AB\T AS ! ,RUSSIAN B\ND>Y-S5T9ELS ?9K !MSELVES RI<TFULLY 5TITL$ TO %OOT DEAD ! SUSPICI\S P]SONS :O >E ESCAP+1 S9CE !Y MURD] 0BY SUP]IOR AU?ORITY10 0) RI<T40.<#h.> ,BUT ,I AM 5TITL$ BY MYSELF TO MURD] IF ,I MYSELF DO NOT =BID IT TO MYSELF1 IF ,I MYSELF DO NOT FE> MURD] AS A 0WRONG40 ,?IS VIEW ( ?+S LIES AT ! F\NDATION ( ,*AMISSO'S POEM1 0,DAS ,MORDTAL10 :]E ! GRAY-HAIR$ ,9DIAN MURD]] COMPELS REV]5CE FROM ! :ITE MAN :OSE BRE?R5 HE HAS MURD]$4 ,! ONLY ?+ ,I AM NOT 5TITL$ TO IS :AT ,I DO NOT DO ) A FREE *E]1 ?AT IS1 :AT ,I DO NOT 5TITLE MYSELF TO4 

,I DECIDE :E!R IT IS ! RI<T ?+ 9 ME2 !RE IS NO RI<T \TSIDE ME4 ,IF IT IS RI<T = ME.<#i.>1 IT IS RI<T4 ,POSSIBLY ?IS MAY NOT SUFFICE TO MAKE IT RI<T = ! RE/2 ?AT IS !IR C>E1 NOT M9E3 LET !M DEF5D !MSELVES4 ,& IF = ! :OLE WORLD SOME?+ W]E NOT RI<T1 BUT IT W]E RI<T = ME1 ?AT IS1 ,I WANT$ IT1 !N ,I W\LD ASK NO?+ AB\T ! :OLE WORLD4 ,SO EV]Y ONE DOES :O KN[S H[ TO VALUE HIMSELF1 EV]Y ONE 9 ! DEGREE ?AT HE IS AN EGOI/2 = MI<T GOES BE=E RI<T1 & ?AT - ) P]FECT RI<T4 

,BECAUSE ,I AM 0BY NATURE0 A MAN ,I HAVE AN EQUAL RI<T TO ! 5JOYM5T ( ALL GOODS1 SAYS ,BABEUF4 ,MU/ HE NOT ALSO SAY3 BECAUSE ,I AM 0BY NATURE0 A FIR/-BORN PR9CE ,I HAVE A RI<T TO ! ?RONE8 ,! RI<TS ( MAN & ! 0WELL-E>N$ RI<TS0 COME TO ! SAME ?+ 9 ! 5D1 NAMELY1 TO NATURE1 :I* GIVES ME A RI<T1 ?AT IS1 TO BIR? 7&1 FUR!R1 9H]ITANCE74 0,I AM BORN AS A MAN0 IS EQUAL TO 0,I AM BORN AS A K+'S SON40 ,! NATURAL MAN HAS ONLY A NATURAL RI<T 7BECAUSE HE HAS ONLY A NATURAL P[]7 & NATURAL CLAIMS3 HE HAS RI<T ( BIR? & CLAIMS ( BIR?4 ,BUT NATURE CANNOT 5TITLE ME1 GIVE ME CAPACITY OR MI<T1 TO ?AT TO :I* ONLY MY ACT 5TITLES ME4 ,?AT ! K+'S *ILD SETS HIMSELF ABOVE O!R *ILDR51 EV5 ?IS IS HIS ACT1 :I* SECURES TO HIM ! PREC$5CE2 & ?AT ! O!R *ILDR5 APPROVE & RECOGNIZE ?IS ACT IS !IR ACT1 :I* MAKES !M WOR?Y TO BE - SUBJECTS4 

,:E!R NATURE GIVES ME A RI<T1 OR :E!R ,GOD1 ! PEOPLE'S *OICE1 ETC41 DOES SO1 ALL ( ?AT IS ! SAME =EIGN RI<T1 A RI<T ?AT ,I DO NOT GIVE OR TAKE TO MYSELF4 

,?US ! ,COMMUNI/S SAY1 EQUAL LABOR 5TITLES MAN TO EQUAL 5JOYM5T4 ,=M]LY ! QUE/ION WAS RAIS$ :E!R ! 0VIRTU\S0 MAN MU/ NOT BE 0HAPPY0 ON E>?4 ,! ,JEWS ACTUALLY DREW ?IS 9F]5CE3 0,?AT IT MAY GO WELL ) !E ON E>?40 ,NO1 EQUAL LABOR DOES NOT 5TITLE Y\ TO IT1 BUT EQUAL 5JOYM5T ALONE 5TITLES Y\ TO EQUAL 5JOYM5T4 ,5JOY1 !N Y\ >E 5TITL$ TO 5JOYM5T4 ,BUT1 IF Y\ HAVE LABOR$ & LET ! 5JOYM5T BE TAK5 FROM Y\1 !N - 0IT S]VES Y\ RI<T40 

,IF Y\ TAKE ! 5JOYM5T1 IT IS Y\R RI<T2 IF1 ON ! CONTR>Y1 Y\ ONLY P9E = IT )\T LAY+ H&S ON IT1 IT REMA9S AS BE=E1 A 10WELL-E>N$ RI<T0 ( ?OSE :O >E PRIVILEG$ = 5JOYM5T4 ,IT IS !IR RI<T1 AS BY LAY+ H&S ON IT W\LD BECOME Y\R RI<T4 

,! CONFLICT OV] ! 0RI<T ( PROP]TY0 WAV]S 9 VEHEM5T COMMOTION4 ,! ,COMMUNI/S AFFIRM.<#a.> ?AT 0! E>? BELONGS RI<TFULLY TO HIM :O TILLS IT1 & ITS PRODUCTS TO ?OSE :O BR+ !M \T40 ,I ?9K IT BELONGS TO HIM :O KN[S H[ TO TAKE IT1 OR :O DOES NOT LET IT BE TAK5 FROM HIM1 DOES NOT LET HIMSELF BE DEPRIV$ ( IT4 ,IF HE APPROPRIATES IT1 !N NOT ONLY ! E>?1 BUT ! RI<T TO IT TOO1 BELONGS TO HIM4 ,?IS IS EGOI/IC RI<T3 IT IS RI<T = ME1 !RE=E IT IS RI<T4 

,ASIDE FROM ?IS1 RI<T DOES HAVE 0A WAX NOSE40 ,! TIG] ?AT ASSAILS ME IS 9 ! RI<T1 & ,I :O /RIKE HIM D[N AM ALSO 9 ! RI<T4 ,I DEF5D AGA9/ HIM NOT MY RI<T1 BUT MYSELF4 

,AS HUMAN RI<T IS ALWAYS SOME?+ GIV51 IT ALWAYS 9 REALITY R$UCES TO ! RI<T :I* M5 GIVE1 0CONC$E10 TO EA* O!R4 ,IF ! RI<T TO EXI/5CE IS CONC$$ TO NEW-BORN *ILDR51 !N !Y HAVE ! RI<T2 IF IT IS NOT CONC$$ TO !M1 AS WAS ! CASE AMONG ! ,SP>TANS & ANCI5T ,ROMANS1 !N !Y DO NOT HAVE IT4 ,= ONLY SOCIETY CAN GIVE OR CONC$E IT TO !M2 !Y !MSELVES CANNOT TAKE IT1 OR GIVE IT TO !MSELVES4 ,IT WILL BE OBJECT$1 ! *ILDR5 HAD NEV]!LESS 0BY NATURE0 ! RI<T TO EXI/2 ONLY ! ,SP>TANS REFUS$ RECOGNITION TO ?IS RI<T4 ,BUT !N !Y SIMPLY HAD NO RI<T TO ?IS RECOGNITION - NO MORE ?AN !Y HAD TO RECOGNITION ( !IR LIFE BY ! WILD BEA/S TO :I* !Y W]E ?R[N4 

,PEOPLE TALK SO MU* AB\T BIR?RI<T1 & COMPLA93 ,!RE IS ALAS6 - NO M5TION ( ! RI<TS ,?AT W]E BORN ) US4.<#a#a.> 

,:AT SORT ( RI<T1 !N1 IS !RE ?AT WAS BORN ) ME8 ,! RI<T TO RECEIVE AN 5TAIL$ E/ATE1 TO 9H]IT A ?RONE1 TO 5JOY A PR9CELY OR NOBLE $UCATION2 OR1 AGA91 BECAUSE POOR P>5TS BEGOT ME1 TO - GET FREE S*OOL+1 BE CLO!D \T ( CONTRIBUTIONS ( ALMS1 & AT LA/ E>N MY BREAD & MY H]R+ 9 ! COAL-M9ES OR AT ! LOOM8 ,>E !SE NOT BIR?RI<TS1 RI<TS ?AT HAVE COME D[N TO ME FROM MY P>5TS ?R\< BIR?8 ,Y\ ?9K - NO2 Y\ ?9K !SE >E ONLY RI<TS IMPROP]LY SO CALL$1 IT IS JU/ !SE RI<TS ?AT Y\ AIM TO ABOLI% ?R\< ! REAL BIR?RI<T4 ,TO GIVE A BASIS = ?IS Y\ GO BACK TO ! SIMPLE/ ?+ & AFFIRM ?AT EV]Y ONE IS BY BIR? EQUAL TO ANO!R - NAMELY1 A MAN4 ,I WILL GRANT Y\ ?AT EV]Y ONE IS BORN AS MAN1 H5CE ! NEW-BORN >E !RE9 EQUAL TO EA* O!R4 ,:Y >E !Y8 ,ONLY BECAUSE !Y DO NOT YET %[ & EX]T !MSELVES AS ANY?+ BUT B>E - *ILDR5 ( M51 NAK$ LITTLE HUMAN BE+S4 ,BUT !REBY !Y >E AT ONCE DIFF]5T FROM ?OSE :O HAVE ALREADY MADE SOME?+ \T ( !MSELVES1 :O ?US >E NO LONG] B>E 0*ILDR5 ( MAN10 BUT - *ILDR5 ( !IR [N CREATION4 ,! LATT] POSSESSES MORE ?AN B>E BIR?RI<TS3 !Y HAVE E>N$ RI<TS4 ,:AT AN ANTI!SIS1 :AT A FIELD ( COMBAT6 ,! OLD COMBAT ( ! BIR?RI<TS ( MAN & WELL-E>N$ RI<TS4 ,GO RI<T ON APPEAL+ TO Y\R BIR?RI<TS2 PEOPLE WILL NOT FAIL TO OPPOSE TO Y\ ! WELL-E>N$4 ,BO? /& ON ! 0GR\ND ( RI<T02 = EA* ( ! TWO HAS A 0RI<T0 AGA9/ ! O!R1 ! ONE ! BIR?RI<T ( NATURAL RI<T1 ! O!R ! E>N$ OR 0WELL-E>N$0 RI<T4 

,IF Y\ REMA9 ON ! GR\ND ( RI<T.<#a#b.>1 Y\ REMA9 9 - SELF-OP9IONAT$NESS .<#a#c.>4 ,! O!R CANNOT GIVE Y\ Y\R RI<T2 HE CANNOT 0METE \T RI<T0 TO Y\4 ,HE :O HAS MI<T HAS - RI<T2 IF Y\ HAVE NOT ! =M]1 NEI!R HAVE Y\ ! LATT]4 ,IS ?IS WISDOM SO H>D TO ATTA98 ,JU/ LOOK AT ! MI<TY & !IR DO+S6 ,WE >E TALK+ H]E ONLY ( ,*9A & ,JAPAN1 ( C\RSE4 ,JU/ TRY IT ONCE1 Y\ ,*9ESE & ,JAPANESE1 TO MAKE !M \T 9 ! WRONG1 & LE>N BY EXP]I5CE H[ !Y ?R[ Y\ 9TO JAIL4 7,ONLY DO NOT CONFUSE ) ?IS ! 0WELL-MEAN+ C\NSELS0 :I* - 9 ,*9A & ,JAPAN - >E P]MITT$1 BECAUSE !Y DO NOT H9D] ! MI<TY ONE1 BUT POSSIBLY HELP HIM ON 47 ,= HIM :O %\LD WANT TO MAKE !M \T 9 ! WRONG !RE W\LD /& OP5 ONLY ONE WAY !RETO1 ?AT ( MI<T4 ,IF HE DEPRIVES !M ( !IR MI<T1 !N HE HAS REALLY MADE !M \T 9 ! WRONG1 DEPRIV$ !M ( !IR RI<T2 9 ANY O!R CASE HE CAN DO NO?+ BUT CL5* HIS LITTLE FI/ 9 HIS POCKET1 OR FALL A VICTIM AS AN OBTRUSIVE FOOL4 

,9 %ORT1 IF Y\ ,*9ESE OR ,JAPANESE DID NOT ASK AFT] RI<T1 & 9 P>TICUL> IF Y\ DID NOT ASK AFT] ! RI<TS 0?AT W]E BORN ) Y\10 !N Y\ W\LD NOT NE$ TO ASK AT ALL AFT] ! WELL-E>N$ RI<TS EI!R4 

,Y\ />T BACK 9 FRI<T BE=E O!RS1 BECAUSE Y\ ?9K Y\ SEE BESIDE !M ! <O/ ( RI<T 1 :I*1 AS 9 ! ,HOM]IC COMBATS1 SEEMS TO FI<T AS A GODDESS AT !IR SIDE1 HELP+ !M4 ,:AT DO Y\ DO8 ,DO Y\ ?R[ ! SPE>8 ,NO1 Y\ CREEP >\ND TO GA9 ! SPOOK OV] TO Y\RSELVES1 ?AT IT MAY FI<T ON Y\R SIDE3 Y\ WOO = ! <O/'S FAVOR4 ,ANO!R W\LD SIMPLY ASK ?US3 ,DO ,I WILL :AT MY OPPON5T WILLS8 0,NO60 ,N[ !N1 !RE MAY FI<T = HIM A ?\S& DEVILS OR GODS1 ,I GO AT HIM ALL ! SAME6 

,! 0COMMONWEAL? ( RI<T10 AS ! ,VOSSIS*E ,ZEITUNG AMONG O!RS /&S = IT1 ASKS ?AT (FICE-HOLD]S BE REMOVABLE ONLY BY ! JUDGE1 NOT BY ! ADM9I/RATION4 ,VA9 ILLUSION6 ,IF IT W]E SETTL$ BY LAW ?AT AN (FICE-HOLD] :O IS ONCE SE5 DRUNK5 %ALL LOSE HIS (FICE1 !N ! JUDGES W\LD HAVE TO CONDEMN HIM ON ! WORD ( ! WITNESSES4 ,9 %ORT1 ! LAW-GIV] W\LD ONLY HAVE TO /ATE PRECISELY ALL ! POSSIBLE GR\NDS :I* 5TAIL ! LOSS ( (FICE1 H[EV] LAU<ABLE !Y MI<T BE 7?AT IS1 HE :O LAU<S 9 HIS SUP]IORS' FACES1 :O DOES NOT GO TO *UR* EV]Y ,SUNDAY1 :O DOES NOT TAKE ! COMMUNION EV]Y F\R WEEKS1 :O RUNS 9 DEBT1 :O HAS DISREPUTABLE ASSOCIATES1 :O %[S NO DET]M9ATION1 ETC41 %ALL BE REMOV$4 ,!SE ?+S ! LAW-GIV] MI<T TAKE IT 9TO HIS HEAD TO PRESCRIBE = A C\RT ( HONOR72 !N ! JUDGE W\LD SOLELY HAVE TO 9VE/IGATE :E!R ! ACCUS$ HAD 0BECOME GUILTY0 ( ?OSE 0(F5SES10 &1 ON PRES5TATION ( ! PRO(1 PRON\NCE S5T5CE ( REMOVAL AGA9/ HIM 09 ! NAME ( ! LAW40 

,! JUDGE IS LO/ :5 HE CEASES TO BE ME*ANICAL1 :5 HE 0IS =SAK5 BY ! RULES ( EVID5CE40 ,!N HE NO LONG] HAS ANY?+ BUT AN OP9ION LIKE EV]YBODY ELSE2 &1 IF HE DECIDES ACCORD+ TO ?IS OP9ION1 HIS ACTION IS NO LONG] AN (FICIAL ACTION4 ,AS JUDGE HE MU/ DECIDE ONLY ACCORD+ TO ! LAW4 ,COMM5D ME RA!R TO ! OLD ,FR5* P>LIAM5TS1 :I* WANT$ TO EXAM9E = !MSELVES :AT WAS TO BE MATT]S ( RI<T1 & TO REGI/] IT ONLY AFT] !IR [N APPROVAL4 ,!Y AT LEA/ JUDG$ ACCORD+ TO A RI<T ( !IR [N1 & W]E NOT WILL+ TO GIVE !MSELVES UP TO BE MA*9ES ( ! LAW-GIV]1 AL?\< AS JUDGES !Y MU/1 TO BE SURE1 BECOME !IR [N MA*9ES4 

,IT IS SAID ?AT PUNI%M5T IS ! CRIM9AL'S RI<T4 ,BUT IMPUNITY IS JU/ AS MU* HIS RI<T4 ,IF HIS UND]TAK+ SUCCE$S1 IT S]VES HIM RI<T1 &1 IF IT DOES NOT SUCCE$1 IT LIKEWISE S]VES HIM RI<T4 ,Y\ MAKE Y\R B$ & LIE 9 IT4 ,IF SOME ONE GOES FOOLH>DILY 9TO DANG]S & P]I%ES 9 !M1 WE >E APT TO SAY1 0,IT S]VES HIM RI<T2 HE W\LD HAVE IT SO40 ,BUT1 IF HE CONQU]$ ! DANG]S1 IF HIS MI<T WAS VICTORI\S1 !N HE W\LD BE 9 ! RI<T TOO4 ,IF A *ILD PLAYS ) ! KNIFE & GETS CUT1 IT IS S]V$ RI<T2 BUT1 IF IT DOESN'T GET CUT1 IT IS S]V$ RI<T TOO4 ,H5CE RI<T BEFALLS ! CRIM9AL1 D\BTLESS1 :5 HE SUFF]S :AT HE RISK$2 :Y1 :AT DID HE RISK IT =1 S9CE HE KNEW ! POSSIBLE CONSEQU5CES8 ,BUT ! PUNI%M5T ?AT WE DECREE AGA9/ HIM IS ONLY \R RI<T1 NOT HIS4 ,\R RI<T REACTS AGA9/ HIS1 & HE IS - 09 ! WRONG AT LA/0 BECAUSE - WE GET ! UPP] H&4 

,BUT :AT IS RI<T1 :AT IS MATT] ( RI<T 9 A SOCIETY1 IS VOIC$ TOO - 9 ! LAW.<#a#d.>4 

,:ATEV] ! LAW MAY BE1 IT MU/ BE RESPECT$ BY ! - LOYAL CITIZ54 ,?US ! LAW-ABID+ M9D ( ,OLD ,5GL& IS EULOGIZ$4 ,TO ?IS ?AT ,EURIPIDEAN S5TIM5T 7,ORE/ES1 #d#a#b7 5TIRELY CORRESPONDS3 0,WE S]VE ! GODS1 :ATEV] ! GODS >E40 ,LAW AS SU*1 ,GOD AS SU*1 ?US F> WE >E TODAY4 

,PEOPLE >E AT PA9S TO DI/+UI% LAW FROM >BITR>Y ORD]S1 FROM AN ORD9ANCE3 ! =M] COMES FROM A DULY 5TITL$ AU?ORITY 4 ,BUT A LAW OV] HUMAN ACTION 7E?ICAL LAW1 /ATE LAW1 ETC47 IS ALWAYS A DECL>ATION ( WILL1 & SO AN ORD]4 ,YES1 EV5 IF ,I MYSELF GAVE MYSELF ! LAW1 IT W\LD YET BE ONLY MY ORD]1 TO :I* 9 ! NEXT MOM5T ,I CAN REFUSE OB$I5CE4 ,ONE MAY WELL 5\< DECL>E :AT HE WILL PUT UP )1 & SO DEPRECATE ! OPPOSITE ( ! LAW1 MAK+ KN[N ?AT 9 ! CONTR>Y CASE HE WILL TREAT ! TRANSGRESSOR AS HIS 5EMY2 BUT NO ONE HAS ANY BUS9ESS TO COMM& MY ACTIONS1 TO SAY :AT C\RSE ,I %ALL PURSUE & SET UP A CODE TO GOV]N IT4 ,I MU/ PUT UP ) IT ?AT HE TREATS ME AS HIS 5EMY1 BUT NEV] ?AT HE MAKES FREE ) ME AS HIS CREATURE1 & ?AT HE MAKES HIS REASON1 OR EV5 UNREASON1 MY PLUMB-L9E4 

,/ATES LA/ ONLY SO LONG AS !RE IS A RUL+ WILL & ?IS RUL+ WILL IS LOOK$ UPON AS TANTAM\NT TO ! [N WILL4 ,! LORD'S WILL IS - LAW4 ,:AT DO Y\R LAWS AM\NT TO IF NO ONE OBEYS !M8 ,:AT Y\R ORD]S1 IF NOBODY LETS HIMSELF BE ORD]$8 ,! /ATE CANNOT =BE> ! CLAIM TO DET]M9E ! 9DIVIDUAL'S WILL1 TO SPECULATE & C\NT ON ?IS4 ,= ! /ATE IT IS 9DISP5SABLE ?AT NOBODY HAVE AN [N WILL2 IF ONE HAD1 ! /ATE W\LD HAVE TO EXCLUDE 7LOCK UP1 BANI%1 ETC47 ?IS ONE2 IF ALL HAD1 !Y W\LD DO AWAY ) ! /ATE4 ,! /ATE IS NOT ?9KABLE )\T LORD%IP .<,H]RS*AFT.> & S]VITUDE .<,KNE*TS*AFT.> 7SUBJECTION72 = ! /ATE MU/ WILL TO BE ! LORD ( ALL ?AT IT EMBRACES1 & ?IS WILL IS CALL$ ! 0WILL ( ! /ATE40 

,HE :O1 TO HOLD HIS [N1 MU/ C\NT ON ! ABS5CE ( WILL 9 O!RS IS A ?+ MADE BY !SE O!RS1 AS ! MA/] IS A ?+ MADE BY ! S]VANT4 ,IF SUBMISSIV5ESS CEAS$1 IT W\LD BE OV] ) ALL LORD%IP4 

,! [N WILL ( ,ME IS ! /ATE'S DE/ROY]2 IT IS !RE=E BR&$ BY ! /ATE AS 0SELF-WILL40 ,[N WILL & ! /ATE >E P[]S 9 DEADLY HO/ILITY1 BETWE5 :I* NO 0ET]NAL PEACE0 IS POSSIBLE4 ,AS LONG AS ! /ATE ASS]TS ITSELF1 IT REPRES5TS [N WILL1 ITS EV]-HO/ILE OPPON5T1 AS UNREASONABLE1 EVIL2 & ! LATT] LETS ITSELF BE TALK$ 9TO BELIEV+ ?IS - 9DE$1 IT REALLY IS SU*1 = NO MORE REASON ?AN ?IS1 ?AT IT /ILL LETS ITSELF BE TALK$ 9TO SU* BELIEF3 IT HAS NOT YET COME TO ITSELF & TO ! CONSCI\SNESS ( ITS DIGNITY2 H5CE IT IS /ILL 9COMPLETE1 /ILL AM5ABLE TO F9E WORDS4 

,EV]Y /ATE IS A DESPOTISM1 BE ! DESPOT ONE OR MANY1 OR 7AS ONE IS LIKELY TO IMAG9E AB\T A REPUBLIC7 IF ALL BE LORDS1 ?AT IS1 DESPOTIZE ONE OV] ANO!R4 ,= ?IS IS ! CASE :5 ! LAW GIV5 AT ANY TIME1 ! EXPRESS$ VOLITION ( 7IT MAY BE7 A POPUL> ASSEMBLY1 IS !NCE=? TO BE LAW = ! 9DIVIDUAL1 TO :I* OB$I5CE IS DUE FROM HIM OR T[>D :I* HE HAS ! DUTY ( OB$I5CE4 ,IF ONE W]E EV5 TO CONCEIVE ! CASE ?AT EV]Y 9DIVIDUAL 9 ! PEOPLE HAD EXPRESS$ ! SAME WILL1 & H]EBY A COMPLETE 0COLLECTIVE WILL0 HAD COME 9TO BE+1 ! MATT] W\LD /ILL REMA9 ! SAME4 ,W\LD ,I NOT BE B\ND TODAY & H5CE=? TO MY WILL ( YE/]DAY8 ,MY WILL W\LD 9 ?IS CASE BE FROZ54 ,WRET*$ /ABILITY6 ,MY CREATURE - NAMELY1 A P>TICUL> EXPRESSION ( WILL - W\LD HAVE BECOME MY COMM&]4 ,BUT ,I 9 MY WILL1 ,I ! CREATOR1 %\LD BE H9D]$ 9 MY FL[ & MY DISSOLUTION4 ,BECAUSE ,I WAS A FOOL YE/]DAY ,I MU/ REMA9 SU* MY LIFE LONG4 ,SO 9 ! /ATE-LIFE ,I AM AT BE/ - ,I MI<T JU/ AS WELL SAY1 AT WOR/ - A BONDMAN ( MYSELF4 ,BECAUSE ,I WAS A WILL] YE/]DAY1 ,I AM TODAY )\T WILL3 YE/]DAY VOLUNT>Y1 TODAY 9VOLUNT>Y4 

,H[ *ANGE IT8 ,ONLY BE RECOGNIZ+ NO DUTY1 NOT B9D+ MYSELF NOR LETT+ MYSELF BE B\ND4 ,IF ,I HAVE NO DUTY1 !N ,I KN[ NO LAW EI!R4 

0,BUT !Y WILL B9D ME60 ,MY WILL NOBODY CAN B9D1 & MY DIS9CL9ATION REMA9S FREE4 

0,:Y1 EV]Y?+ MU/ GO TOPSY-TURVY IF EV]Y ONE C\LD DO :AT HE W\LD60 ,WELL1 :O SAYS ?AT EV]Y ONE CAN DO EV]Y?+8 ,:AT >E Y\ !RE =1 PRAY1 Y\ :O DO NOT NE$ TO PUT UP ) EV]Y?+8 ,DEF5D Y\RSELF1 & NO ONE WILL DO ANY?+ TO Y\6 ,HE :O W\LD BREAK Y\R WILL HAS TO DO ) Y\1 & IS Y\R 5EMY4 ,DEAL ) HIM AS SU*4 ,IF !RE /& BEH9D Y\ = Y\R PROTECTION SOME MILLIONS MORE1 !N Y\ >E AN IMPOS+ P[] & WILL HAVE AN EASY VICTORY4 ,BUT1 EV5 IF AS A P[] Y\ OV]AWE Y\R OPPON5T1 /ILL Y\ >E NOT ON ?AT ACC\NT A HALL[$ AU?ORITY TO HIM1 UNLESS HE BE A SIMPLETON4 ,HE DOES NOT [E Y\ RESPECT & REG>D1 EV5 ?\< HE WILL HAVE TO CONSID] Y\R MI<T4 

,WE >E ACCU/OM$ TO CLASSIFY /ATES ACCORD+ TO ! DIFF]5T WAYS 9 :I* 0! SUPREME MI<T0 IS DI/RIBUT$4 ,IF AN 9DIVIDUAL HAS IT - MON>*Y2 IF ALL HAVE IT - DEMOCRACY2 ETC4 ,SUPREME MI<T !N6 ,MI<T AGA9/ :OM8 ,AGA9/ ! 9DIVIDUAL & HIS 0SELF-WILL40 ,! /ATE PRACTICES 0VIOL5CE10 ! 9DIVIDUAL MU/ NOT DO SO4 ,! /ATE'S BEHAVIOR IS VIOL5CE1 & IT CALLS ITS VIOL5CE 0LAW02 ?AT ( ! 9DIVIDUAL1 0CRIME.<#a#e.>40 ,CRIME1 !N - SO ! 9DIVIDUAL'S VIOL5CE IS CALL$2 & ONLY BY CRIME DOES HE OV]COME.<#a#f.> ! /ATE'S VIOL5CE :5 HE ?9KS ?AT ! /ATE IS NOT ABOVE HIM1 BUT HE IS ABOVE ! /ATE4 

,N[1 IF ,I WANT$ TO ACT RIDICUL\SLY1 ,I MI<T1 AS A WELL-MEAN+ P]SON1 ADMONI% Y\ NOT TO MAKE LAWS :I* IMPAIR MY SELF-DEVELOPM5T1 SELF-ACTIVITY1 SELF-CREATION4 ,I DO NOT GIVE ?IS ADVICE4 ,=1 IF Y\ %\LD FOLL[ IT1 Y\ W\LD BE UNWISE1 & ,I %\LD HAVE BE5 *EAT$ ( MY 5TIRE PR(IT4 ,I REQUE/ NO?+ AT ALL FROM Y\2 =1 :ATEV] ,I MI<T DEM&1 Y\ W\LD /ILL BE DICTATORIAL LAW-GIV]S1 & MU/ BE SO1 BECAUSE A RAV5 CANNOT S+1 NOR A ROBB] LIVE )\T ROBB]Y4 ,RA!R DO ,I ASK ?OSE :O W\LD BE EGOI/S :AT !Y ?9K ! MORE EGOI/IC - TO LET LAWS BE GIV5 !M BY Y\1 & TO RESPECT ?OSE ?AT >E GIV51 OR TO PRACTICE REFRACTOR9ESS1 YES1 COMPLETE DISOB$I5CE4 ,GOOD-HE>T$ PEOPLE ?9K ! LAWS \<T TO PRESCRIBE ONLY :AT IS ACCEPT$ 9 ! PEOPLE'S FEEL+ AS RI<T & PROP]4 ,BUT :AT CONC]N IS IT ( M9E :AT IS ACCEPT$ 9 ! NATION & BY ! NATION8 ,! NATION WILL P]HAPS BE AGA9/ ! BLASPHEM]2 !RE=E A LAW AGA9/ BLASPHEMY4 ,AM ,I NOT TO BLASPHEME ON ?AT ACC\NT8 ,IS ?IS LAW TO BE MORE ?AN AN 0ORD]0 TO ME8 ,I PUT ! QUE/ION4 

,SOLELY FROM ! PR9CIPLE ?AT ALL RI<T & ALL AU?ORITY BELONG TO ! COLLECTIVITY ( ! PEOPLE DO ALL =MS ( GOV]NM5T >ISE4 ,= NONE ( !M LACKS ?IS APPEAL TO ! COLLECTIVITY1 & ! DESPOT1 AS WELL AS ! PRESID5T OR ANY >I/OCRACY1 ACTS & COMM&S 09 ! NAME ( ! /ATE40 ,!Y >E 9 POSSESSION ( ! 0AU?ORITY ( ! /ATE10 & IT IS P]FECTLY 9DIFF]5T :E!R1 W]E ?IS POSSIBLE1 ! PEOPLE AS A COLLECTIVITY 7ALL 9DIVIDUALS7 EX]CISE ?IS /ATE - AU?ORITY1 OR :E!R IT IS ONLY ! REPRES5TATIVES ( ?IS COLLECTIVITY1 BE !RE MANY ( !M AS 9 >I/OCRACIES OR ONE AS 9 MON>*IES4 ,ALWAYS ! COLLECTIVITY IS ABOVE ! 9DIVIDUAL1 & HAS A P[] :I* IS CALL$ LEGITIMATE1 :I* IS LAW4 

,OV] AGA9/ ! SACR$NESS ( ! /ATE1 ! 9DIVIDUAL IS ONLY A VESSEL ( DI%ONOR1 9 :I* 0EXUB]ANCE1 MALEVOL5CE1 MANIA = RIDICULE & SL&]1 FRIVOLITY10 >E LEFT AS SOON AS HE DOES NOT DEEM ?AT OBJECT ( V5]ATION1 ! /ATE1 TO BE WOR?Y ( RECOGNITION4 ,! SPIRITUAL HAU<T9ESS ( ! S]VANTS & SUBJECTS ( ! /ATE HAS F9E P5ALTIES AGA9/ UNSPIRITUAL 0EXUB]ANCE40 

,:5 ! GOV]NM5T DESIGNATES AS PUNI%ABLE ALL PLAY ( M9D AGA9/ ! /ATE1 ! MOD]ATE LIB]ALS COME & OP9E ?AT FUN1 SATIRE1 WIT1 HUMOR1 MU/ HAVE FREE PLAY ANYH[1 & G5IUS MU/ 5JOY FRE$OM4 ,SO NOT ! 9DIVIDUAL MAN 9DE$1 BUT /ILL G5IUS1 IS TO BE FREE4 ,H]E ! /ATE1 OR 9 ITS NAME ! GOV]NM5T1 SAYS ) P]FECT RI<T3 ,HE :O IS NOT = ME IS AGA9/ ME24 ,FUN1 WIT1 ETC4 - 9 %ORT1 ! TURN+ ( /ATE AFFAIRS 9TO A COM$Y - HAVE UND]M9$ /ATES FROM ( OLD3 !Y >E NOT 09NOC5T40 ,&1 FUR!R1 :AT B\ND>IES >E TO BE DRAWN BETWE5 GUILTY & 9NOC5T WIT8 ,AT ?IS QUE/ION ! MOD]ATES FALL 9TO GREAT P]PLEXITY1 & EV]Y?+ R$UCES ITSELF TO ! PRAY] ?AT ! /ATE 7GOV]NM5T7 W\LD PLEASE NOT BE SO S5SITIVE1 SO TICKLI%2 ?AT IT W\LD NOT IMM$IATELY SC5T MALEVOL5CE 9 0H>MLESS' ?+S1 & W\LD 9 G5]AL BE A LITTLE 0MORE TOL]ANT40 ,EXAGG]AT$ S5SITIV5ESS IS C]TA9LY A WEAKNESS1 ITS AVOIDANCE MAY BE PRAISEWOR?Y VIRTUE2 BUT 9 TIME ( W> ONE CANNOT BE SP>+1 & :AT MAY BE ALL[$ UND] PEACEABLE CIRCUM/ANCES CEASES TO BE P]MITT$ AS SOON AS A /ATE ( SIEGE IS DECL>$4 ,BECAUSE ! WELL-MEAN+ LIB]ALS FEEL ?IS PLA9LY1 !Y HA/5 TO DECL>E ?AT1 CONSID]+ 0! DEVOTION ( ! PEOPLE10 !RE IS ASSUR$LY NO DANG] TO BE FE>$4 ,BUT ! GOV]NM5T WILL BE WIS]1 & NOT LET ITSELF BE TALK$ 9TO BELIEV+ ANY?+ ( ?AT SORT4 ,IT KN[S TOO WELL H[ PEOPLE /UFF ONE ) F9E WORDS1 & WILL NOT LET ITSELF BE SATISFI$ ) ! ,B>MECIDE DI%4.<#a#g.> 

,BUT !Y >E B\ND TO HAVE !IR PLAY-GR\ND1 = !Y >E *ILDR51 Y\ KN[1 & CANNOT BE SO /AID AS OLD FOLKS2 BOYS WILL BE BOYS4 ,ONLY = ?IS PLAY-GR\ND1 ONLY = A FEW H\RS ( JOLLY RUNN+ AB\T1 !Y B>GA94 ,!Y ASK ONLY ?AT ! /ATE %\LD NOT1 LIKE A SPL5ETIC PAPA1 BE TOO CROSS4 ,IT %\LD P]MIT SOME ,PROCESSIONS ( ! ,ASS & PLAYS ( FOOLS1 AS ! *UR* ALL[$ !M 9 ! ,MIDDLE ,AGES4 ,BUT ! TIMES :5 IT C\LD GRANT ?IS )\T DANG] >E PA/4 ,*ILDR5 ?AT N[ ONCE COME 9TO ! OP51 & LIVE ?R\< AN H\R )\T ! ROD ( DISCIPL9E1 >E NO LONG] WILL+ TO GO 9TO ! CELL4 ,= ! OP5 IS N[ NO LONG] A SUPPLEM5T TO ! CELL1 NO LONG] A REFRE%+ RECREATION1 BUT ITS OPPOSITE1 AN AUT-AUT4 ,9 %ORT1 ! /ATE MU/ EI!R NO LONG] PUT UP ) ANY?+1 OR PUT UP ) EV]Y?+ & P]I%2 IT MU/ BE EI!R S5SITIVE ?R\< & ?R\<1 OR1 LIKE A DEAD MAN1 9S5SITIVE4 ,TOL]ANCE IS DONE )4 ,IF ! /ATE BUT GIVES A F+]1 !Y TAKE ! :OLE H& AT ONCE4 ,!RE CAN BE NO MORE 0JE/+10 & ALL JE/1 SU* AS FUN1 WIT1 HUMOR1 BECOMES BITT] E>NE/4 

,! CLAMOR ( ! ,LIB]ALS .<,FREIS9NIGE.> = FRE$OM ( ! PRESS RUNS C\NT] TO !IR [N PR9CIPLE1 !IR PROP] WILL4 ,!Y WILL :AT !Y DO NOT WILL2 !Y WI%1 !Y W\LD LIKE4 ,H5CE IT IS TOO ?AT !Y FALL AWAY SO EASILY :5 ONCE SO-CALL$ FRE$OM ( ! PRESS APPE>S2 !N !Y W\LD LIKE C5SOR%IP4 ,QUITE NATURALLY4 ,! /ATE IS SACR$ EV5 TO !M2 LIKEWISE MORALS4 ,!Y BEHAVE T[>D IT ONLY AS ILL-BR$ BRATS1 AS TRICKY *ILDR5 :O SEEK TO UTILIZE ! WEAKNESSES ( !IR P>5TS4 ,PAPA /ATE IS TO P]MIT !M TO SAY MANY ?+S ?AT DO NOT PLEASE HIM1 BUT PAPA HAS ! RI<T1 BY A /]N LOOK1 TO BLUE-P5CIL !IR IMP]T95T GABBLE4 ,IF !Y RECOGNIZE 9 HIM !IR PAPA1 !Y MU/ 9 HIS PRES5CE PUT UP ) ! C5SOR%IP ( SPEE*1 LIKE EV]Y *ILD4 

,IF Y\ LET Y\RSELF BE MADE \T 9 ! RI<T BY ANO!R1 Y\ MU/ NO LESS LET Y\RSELF BE MADE \T 9 ! WRONG BY HIM2 IF JU/IFICATION & REW>D COME TO Y\ FROM HIM1 EXPECT ALSO HIS >RAIGNM5T & PUNI%M5T4 ,ALONGSIDE RI<T GOES WRONG1 ALONGSIDE LEGALITY CRIME4 ,:AT >E Y\8 - ,Y\ >E A - CRIM9AL6 

0,! CRIM9AL IS 9 ! UTMO/ DEGREE ! /ATE'S [N CRIME60.<#a#h.> SAYS ,BETT9A4 ,ONE MAY LET ?IS S5TIM5T PASS1 EV5 IF ,BETT9A H]SELF DOES NOT UND]/& IT EXACTLY SO4 ,= 9 ! /ATE ! UNBRIDL$ ,I - ,I1 AS ,I BELONG TO MYSELF ALONE - CANNOT COME TO MY FULFILLM5T & REALIZATION4 ,EV]Y EGO IS FROM BIR? A CRIM9AL TO BEG9 ) AGA9/ ! PEOPLE1 ! /ATE4 ,H5CE IT IS ?AT IT DOES REALLY KEEP WAT* OV] ALL2 IT SEES 9 EA* ONE AN - EGOI/1 & IT IS AFRAID ( ! EGOI/4 ,IT PRESUMES ! WOR/ AB\T EA* ONE1 & TAKES C>E1 POLICE-C>E1 ?AT 0NO H>M HAPP5S TO ! /ATE10 NE QUID RESPUBLICA DETRIM5TI CAPIAT4 ,! UNBRIDL$ EGO - & ?IS WE ORIG9ALLY >E1 & 9 \R SECRET 9W>D P>TS WE REMA9 SO ALWAYS - IS ! NEV]-CEAS+ CRIM9AL 9 ! /ATE4 ,! MAN :OM HIS BOLDNESS1 HIS WILL1 HIS 9CONSID]AT5ESS & FE>LESSNESS LEAD IS SURR\ND$ ) SPIES BY ! /ATE1 BY ! PEOPLE4 ,I SAY1 BY ! PEOPLE6 ,! PEOPLE 7?9K IT SOME?+ WOND]FUL1 Y\ GOOD-HE>T$ FOLKS1 :AT Y\ HAVE 9 ! PEOPLE7 - ! PEOPLE IS FULL ( POLICE S5TIM5TS ?R\< & ?R\<4 - ,ONLY HE :O R5\NCES HIS EGO1 :O PRACTICES 0SELF-R5UNCIATION10 IS ACCEPTABLE TO ! PEOPLE4 

,9 ! BOOK CIT$ ,BETT9A IS ?R\<\T GOOD-NATUR$ 5\< TO REG>D ! /ATE AS ONLY SICK1 & TO HOPE = ITS RECOV]Y1 A RECOV]Y :I* %E W\LD BR+ AB\T ?R\< ! 0DEMAGOGUES0.<#a#i.>2 BUT IT IS NOT SICK2 RA!R IS IT 9 ITS FULL /R5G?1 :5 IT PUTS FROM IT ! DEMAGOGUES :O WANT TO ACQUIRE SOME?+ = ! 9DIVIDUALS1 = 0ALL40 ,9 ITS BELIEV]S IT IS PROVID$ ) ! BE/ DEMAGOGUES 7LEAD]S ( ! PEOPLE74 ,ACCORD+ TO ,BETT9A1 ! /ATE IS TO.<#b.> 0DEVELOP MANK9D'S G]M ( FRE$OM2 O!RWISE IT IS A RAV5-MO!R.<#b#a.> & C>+ = RAV5-FODD]60 ,IT CANNOT DO O!RWISE1 = 9 ITS V]Y C>+ = 0MANK9D0 7:I*1 BESIDES1 W\LD HAVE TO BE ! 0HUMANE0 OR 0FREE0 /ATE TO BEG9 )7 ! 09DIVIDUAL0 IS RAV5-FODD] = IT4 ,H[ RI<TLY SPEAKS ! BURGOMA/]1 ON ! O!R H&3.<#b#b.> 

0,:AT8 ! /ATE HAS NO O!R DUTY ?AN TO BE M]ELY ! ATT5DANT ( 9CURABLE 9VALIDS8 - ,?AT ISN'T TO ! PO9T4 ,FROM ( OLD ! HEAL?Y /ATE HAS RELIEV$ ITSELF ( ! DISEAS$ MATT]1 & NOT MIX$ ITSELF ) IT4 ,IT DOES NOT NE$ TO BE SO ECONOMICAL ) ITS JUICES4 ,CUT (F ! ROBB]-BRAN*ES )\T HESITATION1 ?AT ! O!RS MAY BLOOM4 - ,DO NOT %IV] AT ! /ATE'S H>%NESS2 ITS MORALITY1 ITS POLICY & RELIGION1 PO9T IT TO ?AT4 ,ACCUSE IT ( NO WANT ( FEEL+2 ITS SYMPA?Y REVOLTS AGA9/ ?IS1 BUT ITS EXP]I5CE F9DS SAFETY ONLY 9 ?IS SEV]ITY6 ,!RE >E DISEASES 9 :I* ONLY DRA/IC REM$IES WILL HELP4 ,! PHYSICIAN :O RECOGNIZES ! DISEASE AS SU*1 BUT TIMIDLY TURNS TO PALLIATIVES1 WILL NEV] REMOVE ! DISEASE1 BUT MAY WELL CAUSE ! PATI5T TO SUCCUMB AFT] A %ORT] OR LONG] SICKNESS40 

,FRAU ,RAT'S QUE/ION1 0,IF Y\ APPLY DEA? AS A DRA/IC REM$Y1 H[ IS ! CURE TO BE WR\<T !N80 ISN'T TO ! PO9T4 ,:Y1 ! /ATE DOES NOT APPLY DEA? AGA9/ ITSELF1 BUT AGA9/ AN (F5SIVE MEMB]2 IT TE>S \T AN EYE ?AT (F5DS IT1 ETC40 

0,= ! 9VALID /ATE ! ONLY WAY ( SALVATION IS TO MAKE MAN FL\RI% 9 IT40.<#b#c.> ,IF ONE H]E1 LIKE ,BETT9A1 UND]/& BY MAN ! CONCEPT 0,MAN10 %E IS RI<T2 ! 09VALID0 /ATE WILL RECOV] BY ! FL\RI%+ ( 0,MAN10 =1 ! MORE 9FATUAT$ ! 9DIVIDUALS >E ) 0,MAN10 ! BETT] IT S]VES ! /ATE'S TURN4 ,BUT1 IF ONE REF]R$ IT TO ! 9DIVIDUALS1 TO 0ALL0 7& ! AU?ORESS HALF-DOES ?IS TOO1 BECAUSE AB\T 0,MAN0 %E IS /ILL 9VOLV$ 9 VAGU5ESS71 !N IT W\LD S\ND SOME:AT LIKE ! FOLL[+3 ,= AN 9VALID B& ( ROBB]S ! ONLY WAY ( SALVATION IS TO MAKE ! LOYAL CITIZ5 N\RI% 9 IT6 ,:Y1 !REBY ! B& ( ROBB]S W\LD SIMPLY GO TO RU9 AS A B& ( ROBB]S2 &1 BECAUSE IT P]CEIVES ?IS1 IT PREF]S TO %OOT EV]Y ONE :O HAS A LEAN+ T[>D BECOM+ A 0/EADY MAN40 

,9 ?IS BOOK ,BETT9A IS A PATRIOT1 OR1 :AT IS LITTLE MORE1 A PHILAN?ROPI/1 A WORK] = HUMAN HAPP9ESS4 ,%E IS DISCONT5T$ ) ! EXI/+ ORD] 9 QUITE ! SAME WAY AS IS ! TITLE-<O/ ( H] BOOK1 ALONG ) ALL :O W\LD LIKE TO BR+ BACK ! GOOD OLD FAI? & :AT GOES ) IT4 ,ONLY %E ?9KS1 CONTR>IWISE1 ?AT ! POLITICIANS1 PLACE-HOLD]S1 & DIPLOMATS RU9$ ! /ATE1 :ILE ?OSE LAY IT AT ! DOOR ( ! MALEVOL5T1 ! 0S$UC]S ( ! PEOPLE40 

,:AT IS ! ORD9>Y CRIM9AL BUT ONE :O HAS COMMITT$ ! FATAL MI/AKE ( 5DEAVOR+ AFT] :AT IS ! PEOPLE'S 9/EAD ( SEEK+ = :AT IS HIS8 ,HE HAS S\<T DESPICABLE ALI5 GOODS1 HAS DONE :AT BELIEV]S DO :O SEEK AFT] :AT IS ,GOD'S4 ,:AT DOES ! PRIE/ :O ADMONI%ES ! CRIM9AL DO8 ,HE SETS BE=E HIM ! GREAT WRONG ( HAV+ DESECRAT$ BY HIS ACT :AT WAS HALL[$ BY ! /ATE1 ITS PROP]TY 79 :I*1 ( C\RSE1 MU/ BE 9CLUD$ EV5 ! LIFE ( ?OSE :O BELONG TO ! /ATE72 9/EAD ( ?IS1 HE MI<T RA!R HOLD UP TO HIM ! FACT ?AT HE HAS BEF\L$ HIMSELF 9 NOT DESPIS+ ! ALI5 ?+1 BUT ?9K+ IT WOR? /EAL+2 HE C\LD1 IF HE W]E NOT A P>SON4 ,TALK ) ! SO-CALL$ CRIM9AL AS ) AN EGOI/1 & HE WILL BE A%AM$1 NOT ?AT HE TRANSGRESS$ AGA9/ Y\R LAWS & GOODS1 BUT ?AT HE CONSID]$ Y\R LAWS WOR? EVAD+1 Y\R GOODS WOR? DESIR+2 HE WILL BE A%AM$ ?AT HE DID NOT - DESPISE Y\ & Y\RS TOGE!R1 ?AT HE WAS TOO LITTLE AN EGOI/4 ,BUT Y\ CANNOT TALK EGOI/ICALLY ) HIM1 = Y\ >E NOT SO GREAT AS A CRIM9AL1 Y\ - COMMIT NO CRIME6 ,Y\ DO NOT KN[ ?AT AN EGO :O IS HIS [N CANNOT DESI/ FROM BE+ A CRIM9AL1 ?AT CRIME IS HIS LIFE4 ,& YET Y\ %\LD KN[ IT1 S9CE Y\ BELIEVE ?AT 0WE >E ALL MIS]ABLE S9N]S02 BUT Y\ ?9K SURREPTITI\SLY TO GET BEYOND S91 Y\ DO NOT COMPREH5D - = Y\ >E DEVIL-FE>+ - ?AT GUILT IS ! VALUE ( A MAN4 ,OH1 IF Y\ W]E GUILTY6 ,BUT N[ Y\ >E 0RI<TE\S.<#b#d.>40 ,WELL - JU/ PUT EV]Y ?+ NICELY TO RI<TS.<#b#e.> = Y\R MA/]6 

,:5 ! ,*RI/IAN CONSCI\SNESS1 OR ! ,*RI/IAN MAN1 DRAWS UP A CRIM9AL CODE1 :AT CAN ! CONCEPT ( CRIME BE !RE BUT SIMPLY - HE>TLESSNESS8 ,EA* SEV]+ & W\ND+ ( A HE>T RELATION1 EA* HE>TLESS BEHAVIOR T[>D A SACR$ BE+1 IS CRIME4 ,! MORE HE>TFELT ! RELATION IS SUPPOS$ TO BE1 ! MORE SC&AL\S IS ! D]ID+ ( IT1 & ! MORE WOR?Y ( PUNI%M5T ! CRIME4 ,EV]YONE :O IS SUBJECT TO ! LORD %\LD LOVE HIM2 TO D5Y ?IS LOVE IS A HI< TREASON WOR?Y ( DEA?4 ,ADULT]Y IS A HE>TLESSNESS WOR?Y ( PUNI%M5T2 ONE HAS NO HE>T1 NO 5?USIASM1 NO PA!TIC FEEL+ = ! SACR$NESS ( M>RIAGE4 ,SO LONG AS ! HE>T OR S\L DICTATES LAWS1 ONLY ! HE>TFUL OR S\LFUL MAN 5JOYS ! PROTECTION ( ! LAWS4 ,?AT ! MAN ( S\L MAKES LAWS MEANS PROP]LY ?AT ! MORAL MAN MAKES !M3 :AT CONTRADICTS !SE M5'S 0MORAL FEEL+10 ?IS !Y P5ALIZE4 ,H[ %\LD DISLOYALTY1 SECESSION1 BREA* ( OA?S - 9 %ORT1 ALL RADICAL BREAK+ (F1 ALL TE>+ ASUND] ( V5]ABLE TIES - NOT BE FLAGITI\S & CRIM9AL 9 !IR EYES8 ,HE :O BREAKS ) !SE DEM&S ( ! S\L HAS = 5EMIES ALL ! MORAL1 ALL ! M5 ( S\L4 ,ONLY ,KRUMMA*] & HIS MATES >E ! RI<T PEOPLE TO SET UP CONSI/5TLY A P5AL CODE ( ! HE>T1 AS A C]TA9 BILL SUFFICI5TLY PROVES4 ,! CONSI/5T LEGISLATION ( ! ,*RI/IAN /ATE MU/ BE PLAC$ :OLLY 9 ! H&S ( ! - P>SONS1 & WILL NOT BECOME PURE & COH]5T SO LONG AS IT IS WORK$ \T ONLY BY - ! P>SON-RIDD51 :O >E ALWAYS ONLY HALF-P>SONS4 ,ONLY !N WILL EV]Y LACK ( S\LFULNESS1 EV]Y HE>TLESSNESS1 BE C]TIFI$ AS AN UNP>DONABLE CRIME1 ONLY !N WILL EV]Y AGITATION ( ! S\L BECOME CONDEMNABLE1 EV]Y OBJECTION ( CRITICISM & D\BT BE ANA!MATIZ$2 ONLY !N IS ! [N MAN1 BE=E ! ,*RI/IAN CONSCI\SNESS1 A CONVICT$ - CRIM9AL TO BEG9 )4 

,! M5 ( ! ,REVOLUTION (T5 TALK$ ( ! PEOPLE'S 0JU/ REV5GE0 AS ITS 0RI<T40 ,REV5GE & RI<T CO9CIDE H]E4 ,IS ?IS AN ATTITUDE ( AN EGO TO AN EGO8 ,! PEOPLE CRIES ?AT ! OPPOSITE P>TY HAS COMMITT$ 0CRIMES0 AGA9/ IT4 ,CAN ,I ASSUME ?AT ONE COMMITS A CRIME AGA9/ ME1 )\T ASSUM+ ?AT HE HAS TO ACT AS ,I SEE FIT8 ,& ?IS ACTION ,I CALL ! RI<T1 ! GOOD1 ETC42 ! DIV]G5T ACTION1 A CRIME4 ,SO ,I ?9K ?AT ! O!RS MU/ AIM AT ! SAME GOAL ) ME2 ,I DO NOT TREAT !M AS UNIQUE BE+S :O BE> !IR LAW 9 !MSELVES & LIVE ACCORD+ TO IT1 BUT AS BE+S :O >E TO OBEY SOME 0RATIONAL0 LAW4 ,I SET UP :AT 0,MAN0 IS & :AT ACT+ 9 A 0TRULY HUMAN0 WAY IS1 & ,I DEM& ( EV]Y ONE ?AT ?IS LAW BECOME NORM & IDEAL TO HIM2 O!RWISE HE WILL EXPOSE HIMSELF AS A 0S9N] & CRIM9AL40 ,BUT UPON ! 0GUILTY0 FALLS ! 0P5ALTY ( ! LAW06 

,ONE SEES H]E H[ IT IS 0,MAN0 AGA9 :O SETS ON FOOT EV5 ! CONCEPT ( CRIME1 ( S91 & !RE) ?AT ( RI<T4 ,A MAN 9 :OM ,I DO NOT RECOGNIZE 0MAN0 IS 0S9N]1 A GUILTY ONE40 

,ONLY AGA9/ A SACR$ ?+ >E !RE CRIM9ALS2 Y\ AGA9/ ME CAN NEV] BE A CRIM9AL1 BUT ONLY AN OPPON5T4 ,BUT NOT TO HATE HIM :O 9JURES A SACR$ ?+ IS 9 ITSELF A CRIME1 AS ,/4 ,JU/ CRIES \T AGA9/ ,DANTON3.<#b#f.> 0,>E Y\ NOT A CRIM9AL & RESPONSIBLE = NOT HAV+ HAT$ ! 5EMIES ( ! FA!RL&80 

,IF1 AS 9 ! ,REVOLUTION1 :AT 0,MAN0 IS IS APPREH5D$ AS 0GOOD CITIZ510 !N FROM ?IS CONCEPT ( 0,MAN0 WE HAVE ! WELL-KN[N 0POLITICAL (F5SES & CRIMES40 

,9 ALL ?IS ! 9DIVIDUAL1 ! 9DIVIDUAL MAN1 IS REG>D$ AS REFUSE1 & ON ! O!R H& ! G5]AL MAN1 0,MAN10 IS HONOR$4 ,N[1 ACCORD+ TO H[ ?IS <O/ IS NAM$ - AS ,*RI/IAN1 ,JEW1 ,MUSSULMAN1 GOOD CITIZ51 LOYAL SUBJECT1 FREEMAN1 PATRIOT1 ETC4 - JU/ SO DO ?OSE :O W\LD LIKE TO C>RY ?R\< A DIV]G5T CONCEPT ( MAN1 AS WELL AS ?OSE :O WANT TO PUT !MSELVES ?R\<1 FALL BE=E VICTORI\S 0,MAN40 

,& ) :AT UNCTION ! BUT*]Y GOES ON H]E 9 ! NAME ( ! LAW1 ( ! SOV]EIGN PEOPLE1 ( ,GOD1 ETC46 

,N[1 IF ! P]SECUT$ TRICKILY CONCEAL & PROTECT !MSELVES FROM ! /]N P>SONICAL JUDGES1 PEOPLE /IGMATIZE !M AS ,/4 ,JU/ DOES ?OSE :OM HE ACCUSES 9 ! SPEE* AGA9/ ,DANTON4 ,ONE IS TO BE A FOOL1 & DELIV] HIMSELF UP TO !IR ,MOLO*4 

,CRIMES SPR+ FROM FIX$ IDEAS4 ,! SACR$NESS ( M>RIAGE IS A FIX$ IDEA4 ,FROM ! SACR$NESS IT FOLL[S ?AT 9FIDELITY IS A CRIME1 & !RE=E A C]TA9 M>RIAGE LAW IMPOSES UPON IT A %ORT] OR LONG] P5ALTY4 ,BUT BY ?OSE :O PROCLAIM 0FRE$OM AS SACR$0 ?IS P5ALTY MU/ BE REG>D$ AS A CRIME AGA9/ FRE$OM1 & ONLY 9 ?IS S5SE HAS PUBLIC OP9ION 9 FACT BR&$ ! M>RIAGE LAW4 

,SOCIETY W\LD HAVE EV]Y ONE COME TO HIS RI<T 9DE$1 BUT YET ONLY TO ?AT :I* IS SANCTION$ BY SOCIETY1 TO ! SOCIETY-RI<T1 NOT REALLY TO HIS RI<T4 ,BUT ,I GIVE OR TAKE TO MYSELF ! RI<T \T ( MY [N PL5ITUDE ( P[]1 & AGA9/ EV]Y SUP]IOR P[] ,I AM ! MO/ IMP5IT5T CRIM9AL4 ,[N] & CREATOR ( MY RI<T1 ,I RECOGNIZE NO O!R S\RCE ( RI<T ?AN - ME1 NEI!R ,GOD NOR ! /ATE NOR NATURE NOR EV5 MAN HIMSELF ) HIS 0ET]NAL RI<TS ( MAN10 NEI!R DIV9E NOR HUMAN RI<T4 

,RI<T 09 & = ITSELF40 ,)\T RELATION TO ME1 !RE=E6 0,ABSOLUTE RI<T40 ,SEP>AT$ FROM ME1 !RE=E6 ,A ?+ ?AT EXI/S 9 & = ITSELF6 ,AN ABSOLUTE6 ,AN ET]NAL RI<T1 LIKE AN ET]NAL TRU?6 

,ACCORD+ TO ! LIB]AL WAY ( ?9K+1 RI<T IS TO BE OBLIGATORY = ME BECAUSE IT IS ?US E/ABLI%$ BY HUMAN REASON1 AGA9/ :I* MY REASON IS 0UNREASON40 ,=M]LY PEOPLE 9VEI<$ 9 ! NAME ( DIV9E REASON AGA9/ WEAK HUMAN REASON2 N[1 9 ! NAME ( /RONG HUMAN REASON1 AGA9/ EGOI/IC REASON1 :I* IS REJECT$ AS 0UNREASON40 ,& YET NONE IS REAL BUT ?IS V]Y 0UNREASON40 ,NEI!R DIV9E NOR HUMAN REASON1 BUT ONLY Y\R & MY REASON EXI/+ AT ANY GIV5 TIME1 IS REAL1 AS & BECAUSE Y\ & ,I >E REAL4 

,! ?\<T ( RI<T IS ORIG9ALLY MY ?\<T2 OR1 IT HAS ITS ORIG9 9 ME4 ,BUT1 :5 IT HAS SPRUNG FROM ME1 :5 ! 0,WORD0 IS \T1 !N IT HAS 0BECOME FLE%10 IT IS A FIX$ IDEA4 ,N[ ,I NO LONG] GET RID ( ! ?\<T2 H[EV] ,I TURN1 IT /&S BE=E ME4 ,?US M5 HAVE NOT BECOME MA/]S AGA9 ( ! ?\<T 0RI<T10 :I* !Y !MSELVES CREAT$2 !IR CREATURE IS RUNN+ AWAY ) !M4 ,?IS IS ABSOLUTE RI<T1 ?AT :I* IS ABSOLV$ OR UNFA/5$ FROM ME4 ,WE1 REV]+ IT AS ABSOLUTE1 CANNOT DEV\R IT AGA91 & IT TAKES FROM US ! CREATIVE P[]3 ! CREATURE IS MORE ?AN ! CREATOR1 IT IS 09 & = ITSELF40 

,ONCE Y\ NO LONG] LET RI<T RUN >\ND FREE1 ONCE Y\ DRAW IT BACK 9TO ITS ORIG91 9TO Y\1 IT IS Y\R RI<T2 & ?AT IS RI<T :I* SUITS Y\ .<UND RE*T I/1 WAS DIR RE*T I/.>4 

,RI<T HAS HAD TO SUFF] AN ATTACK )9 ITSELF1 FROM ! /&-PO9T ( RI<T2 W> BE+ DECL>$ ON ! P>T ( LIB]ALISM AGA9/ 0PRIVILEGE40 

,PRIVILEG$ & 5D[$ ) EQUAL RI<TS - ON !SE TWO CONCEPTS TURNS A /UBBORN FI<T4 ,EXCLUD$ OR ADMITT$ - W\LD MEAN ! SAME4 ,BUT :]E %\LD !RE BE A P[] - BE IT AN IMAG9>Y ONE LIKE ,GOD1 LAW1 OR A REAL ONE LIKE ,I1 Y\ - ( :I* IT %\LD NOT BE TRUE ?AT BE=E IT ALL >E 05D[$ ) EQUAL RI<TS10 ?AT IS1 NO RESPECT ( P]SONS HOLDS8 ,EV]Y ONE IS EQUALLY DE> TO ,GOD IF HE ADORES HIM1 EQUALLY AGREEABLE TO ! LAW IF ONLY HE IS A LAW-ABID+ P]SON2 :E!R ! LOV] ( ,GOD & ! LAW IS HUMPBACK$ & LAME1 :E!R POOR OR RI*1 & ! LIKE1 ?AT AM\NTS TO NO?+ = ,GOD & ! LAW2 JU/ SO1 :5 Y\ >E AT ! PO9T ( DR[N+1 Y\ LIKE A ,NEGRO AS RESCU] AS WELL AS ! MO/ EXCELL5T ,CAUCASIAN - YES1 9 ?IS SITUATION Y\ E/EEM A DOG NOT LESS ?AN A MAN4 ,BUT TO :OM WILL NOT EV]Y ONE BE ALSO1 CONTR>IWISE1 A PREF]R$ OR DISREG>D$ P]SON8 ,GOD PUNI%ES ! WICK$ ) HIS WRA?1 ! LAW *A/ISES ! LAWLESS1 Y\ LET ONE VISIT Y\ EV]Y MOM5T & %[ ! O!R ! DOOR4 

,! 0EQUALITY ( RI<T0 IS A PHANTOM JU/ BECAUSE RI<T IS NO?+ MORE & NO?+ LESS ?AN ADMISSION1 A MATT] ( GRACE1 :I*1 BE IT SAID1 ONE MAY ALSO ACQUIRE BY HIS DES]T2 = DES]T & GRACE >E NOT CONTRADICTORY1 S9CE EV5 GRACE WI%ES TO BE 0DES]V$0 & \R GRACI\S SMILE FALLS ONLY TO HIM :O KN[S H[ TO =CE IT FROM US4 

,SO PEOPLE DREAM ( 0ALL CITIZ5S ( ! /ATE HAV+ TO /& SIDE BY SIDE1 ) EQUAL RI<TS40 ,AS CITIZ5S ( ! /ATE !Y >E C]TA9LY ALL EQUAL = ! /ATE4 ,BUT IT WILL DIVIDE !M1 & ADVANCE !M OR PUT !M 9 ! RE>1 ACCORD+ TO ITS SPECIAL 5DS1 IF ON NO O!R ACC\NT2 & /ILL MORE MU/ IT DI/+UI% !M FROM ONE ANO!R AS GOOD & BAD CITIZ5S4 

,BRUNO ,BAU] DISPOSES ( ! ,JEW QUE/ION FROM ! /&-PO9T ?AT 0PRIVILEGE0 IS NOT JU/IFI$4 ,BECAUSE ,JEW & ,*RI/IAN HAVE EA* SOME PO9T ( ADVANTAGE OV] ! O!R1 & 9 HAV+ ?IS PO9T ( ADVANTAGE >E EXCLUSIVE1 !RE=E BE=E ! CRITIC'S GAZE !Y CRUMBLE 9TO NO?+NESS4 ,) !M ! /ATE LIES UND] ! LIKE BLAME1 S9CE IT JU/IFIES !IR HAV+ ADVANTAGES & /AMPS IT AS A 0PRIVILEGE40 OR PR]OGATIVE1 BUT !REBY D]OGATES FROM ITS CALL+ TO BECOME A 0FREE /ATE40 

,BUT N[ EV]Y ONE HAS SOME?+ ( ADVANTAGE OV] ANO!R - NAMELY1 HIMSELF OR HIS 9DIVIDUALITY .<,E9ZIGKEIT.>2 9 ?IS EV]YBODY REMA9S EXCLUSIVE4 

,&1 AGA91 BE=E A ?IRD P>TY EV]Y ONE MAKES HIS PECULI>ITY .<,EIG5TUMLI*KEIT.> C\NT = AS MU* AS POSSIBLE1 & 7IF HE WANTS TO W9 HIM AT ALL7 TRIES TO MAKE IT APPE> ATTRACTIVE BE=E HIM4 

,N[1 IS ! ?IRD P>TY TO BE 9S5SIBLE TO ! DIFF]5CE ( ! ONE FROM ! O!R8 ,DO !Y ASK ?AT ( ! FREE /ATE OR ( HUMANITY8 ,!N !SE W\LD HAVE TO BE ABSOLUTELY )\T SELF-9T]E/1 & 9CAPABLE ( TAK+ AN 9T]E/ 9 ANY ONE :ATEV]4 ,NEI!R ,GOD 7:O DIVIDES HIS [N FROM ! WICK$7 NOR ! /ATE 7:I* KN[S H[ TO SEP>ATE GOOD CITIZ5S FROM BAD7 WAS ?\<T ( AS SO 9DIFF]5T4 

,BUT !Y >E LOOK+ = ?IS V]Y ?IRD P>TY ?AT BE/[S NO MORE 0PRIVILEGE40 ,!N IT IS CALL$ P]HAPS ! FREE /ATE1 OR HUMANITY1 OR :ATEV] ELSE IT MAY BE4 

,AS ,*RI/IAN & ,JEW >E RANK$ L[ BY ,BRUNO ,BAU] ON ACC\NT ( !IR ASS]T+ PRIVILEGES1 IT MU/ BE ?AT !Y C\LD & %\LD FREE !MSELVES FROM !IR N>R[ /&-PO9T BY SELF-R5UNCIATION OR UNSELFI%NESS4 ,IF !Y ?REW (F !IR 0EGOISM10 ! MUTUAL WRONG W\LD CEASE1 & ) IT ,*RI/IAN & ,JEWI% RELIGI\SNESS 9 G5]AL2 IT W\LD BE NECESS>Y ONLY ?AT NEI!R ( !M %\LD ANY LONG] WANT TO BE ANY?+ PECULI>4 

,BUT1 IF !Y GAVE UP ?IS EXCLUSIV5ESS1 ) ?AT ! GR\ND ON :I* !IR HO/ILITIES W]E WAG$ W\LD 9 TRU? NOT YET BE =SAK54 ,9 CASE ( NE$ !Y W\LD 9DE$ F9D A ?IRD ?+ ON :I* !Y C\LD UNITE1 A 0G5]AL RELIGION10 A 0RELIGION ( HUMANITY10 & ! LIKE2 9 %ORT1 AN EQUALIZATION1 :I* NE$ NOT BE BETT] ?AN ?AT :I* W\LD RESULT IF ALL ,JEWS BECAME ,*RI/IANS1 BY ?IS LIKEWISE ! 0PRIVILEGE0 ( ONE OV] ! O!R W\LD HAVE AN 5D4 ,! T5SION.<#b#g.> W\LD 9DE$ BE DONE AWAY1 BUT 9 ?IS CONSI/$ NOT ! ESS5CE ( ! TWO1 BUT ONLY !IR NEI<BORHOOD4 ,AS BE+ DI/+UI%$ FROM EA* O!R !Y MU/ NECESS>ILY BE MUTUALLY RESI/ANT .<#b#h.>1 & ! DISP>ITY WILL ALWAYS REMA94 ,TRULY IT IS NOT A FAIL+ 9 Y\ ?AT Y\ /IFF5 .<#b#i.> Y\RSELF AGA9/ ME & ASS]T Y\R DI/9CTNESS OR PECULI>ITY3 Y\ NE$ NOT GIVE WAY OR R5\NCE Y\RSELF4 

,PEOPLE CONCEIVE ! SIGNIFICANCE ( ! OPPOSITION TOO =MALLY & WEAKLY :5 !Y WANT ONLY TO 0DISSOLVE0 IT 9 ORD] TO MAKE ROOM = A ?IRD ?+ ?AT %ALL 0UNITE40 ,! OPPOSITION DES]VES RA!R TO BE %>P5$4 ,AS ,JEW & ,*RI/IAN Y\ >E 9 TOO SLI<T AN OPPOSITION1 & >E CONT5D+ ONLY AB\T RELIGION1 AS IT W]E AB\T ! EMP]OR'S BE>D1 AB\T A FIDDLE-/ICK'S 5D4 ,5EMIES 9 RELIGION 9DE$1 9 ! RE/ Y\ /ILL REMA9 GOOD FRI5DS1 & EQUAL TO EA* O!R1 AS M54 ,NEV]!LESS ! RE/ TOO IS UNLIKE 9 EA*2 & ! TIME :5 Y\ NO LONG] M]ELY DISSEMBLE Y\R OPPOSITION WILL BE ONLY :5 Y\ 5TIRELY RECOGNIZE IT1 & EV]YBODY ASS]TS HIMSELF FROM TOP TO TOE AS UNIQUE4 ,!N ! =M] OPPOSITION WILL ASSUR$LY BE DISSOLV$1 BUT ONLY BECAUSE A /RONG] HAS TAK5 IT UP 9TO ITSELF4 

,\R WEAKNESS CONSI/S NOT 9 ?IS1 ?AT WE >E 9 OPPOSITION TO O!RS1 BUT 9 ?IS1 ?AT WE >E NOT COMPLETELY SO2 ?AT WE >E NOT 5TIRELY SEV]$ FROM !M1 OR ?AT WE SEEK A 0COMMUNION .<#c.>10 A 0BOND10 ?AT 9 COMMUNION WE HAVE AN IDEAL4 ,ONE FAI?1 ONE ,GOD1 ONE IDEA1 ONE HAT1 = ALL6 ,IF ALL W]E BR\<T UND] ONE HAT1 C]TA9LY NO ONE W\LD ANY LONG] NE$ TO TAKE (F HIS HAT BE=E ANO!R4 

,! LA/ & MO/ DECID$ OPPOSITION1 ?AT ( UNIQUE AGA9/ UNIQUE1 IS AT BOTTOM BEYOND :AT IS CALL$ OPPOSITION1 BUT )\T HAV+ SUNK BACK 9TO 0UNITY.<#c#a.>0 & UNISON4 ,AS UNIQUE Y\ HAVE NO?+ 9 COMMON ) ! O!R ANY LONG]1 & !RE=E NO?+ DIVISIVE OR HO/ILE EI!R2 Y\ >E NOT SEEK+ TO BE 9 ! RI<T AGA9/ HIM BE=E A ?IRD P>TY1 & >E /&+ ) HIM NEI!R 0ON ! GR\ND ( RI<T0 NOR ON ANY O!R COMMON GR\ND4 ,! OPPOSITION VANI%ES 9 COMPLETE - SEV]ANCE OR S+L5ESS.<#c#b.>4 ,?IS MI<T 9DE$ BE REG>D$ AS ! NEW PO9T 9 COMMON OR A NEW P>ITY1 BUT H]E ! P>ITY CONSI/S PRECISELY 9 ! DISP>ITY1 & IS ITSELF NO?+ BUT DISP>ITY1 A P> ( DISP>ITY1 & ?AT ONLY = HIM :O 9/ITUTES A 0COMP>ISON40 

,! POLEMIC AGA9/ PRIVILEGE =MS A *>ACT]I/IC FEATURE ( LIB]ALISM1 :I* FUMES AGA9/ 0PRIVILEGE0 BECAUSE IT ITSELF APPEALS TO 0RI<T40 ,FUR!R ?AN TO FUM+ IT CANNOT C>RY ?IS2 = PRIVILEGES DO NOT FALL BE=E RI<T FALLS1 AS !Y >E ONLY =MS ( RI<T4 ,BUT RI<T FALLS AP>T 9TO ITS NO?+NESS :5 IT IS SWALL[$ UP BY MI<T1 :5 ONE UND]/&S :AT IS MEANT BY 0,MI<T GOES BE=E RI<T40 ,ALL RI<T EXPLA9S ITSELF !N AS PRIVILEGE1 & PRIVILEGE ITSELF AS P[]1 AS - SUP]IOR P[]4 

,BUT MU/ NOT ! MI<TY COMBAT AGA9/ SUP]IOR P[] %[ QUITE ANO!R FACE ?AN ! MODE/ COMBAT AGA9/ PRIVILEGE1 :I* IS TO BE F\<T \T BE=E A FIR/ JUDGE1 0,RI<T10 ACCORD+ TO ! JUDGE'S M9D8 

,N[1 9 CONCLUSION1 ,I HAVE /ILL TO TAKE BACK ! HALF-WAY =M ( EXPRESSION ( :I* ,I WAS WILL+ TO MAKE USE ONLY SO LONG AS ,I WAS /ILL ROOT+ AMONG ! 5TRAILS ( RI<T1 & LETT+ ! WORD AT LEA/ /&4 ,BUT1 9 FACT1 ) ! CONCEPT ! WORD TOO LOSES ITS MEAN+4 ,:AT ,I CALL$ 0MY RI<T0 IS NO LONG] 0RI<T0 AT ALL1 BECAUSE RI<T CAN BE BE/[$ ONLY BY A SPIRIT1 BE IT ! SPIRIT ( NATURE OR ?AT ( ! SPECIES1 ( MANK9D1 ! ,SPIRIT ( ,GOD OR ?AT ( ,HIS ,HOL9ESS OR ,HIS ,HI<NESS1 ETC4 ,:AT ,I HAVE )\T AN 5TITL+ SPIRIT ,I HAVE )\T RI<T2 ,I HAVE IT SOLELY & ALONE ?R\< MY P[]4 

,I DO NOT DEM& ANY RI<T1 !RE=E ,I NE$ NOT RECOGNIZE ANY EI!R4 ,:AT ,I CAN GET BY =CE ,I GET BY =CE1 & :AT ,I DO NOT GET BY =CE ,I HAVE NO RI<T TO1 NOR DO ,I GIVE MYSELF AIRS1 OR CONSOLATION1 ) MY IMP]SCRIPTIBLE RI<T4 

,) ABSOLUTE RI<T1 RI<T ITSELF PASSES AWAY2 ! DOM9ION ( ! 0CONCEPT ( RI<T0 IS CANCEL$ AT ! SAME TIME4 ,= IT IS NOT TO BE =GOTT5 ?AT HI!RTO CONCEPTS1 IDEAS1 OR PR9CIPLES RUL$ US1 & ?AT AMONG !SE RUL]S ! CONCEPT ( RI<T1 OR ( JU/ICE1 PLAY$ ONE ( ! MO/ IMPORTANT P>TS4 

,5TITL$ OR UN5TITL$ - ?AT DOES NOT CONC]N ME1 IF ,I AM ONLY P[]FUL1 ,I AM ( MYSELF EMP[]$1 & NE$ NO O!R EMP[]+ OR 5TITL+4 

,RI<T - IS A :EEL 9 ! HEAD1 PUT !RE BY A SPOOK2 P[] - ?AT AM ,I MYSELF1 ,I AM ! P[]FUL ONE & [N] ( P[]4 ,RI<T IS ABOVE ME1 IS ABSOLUTE1 & EXI/S 9 ONE HI<]1 AS :OSE GRACE IT FL[S TO ME3 RI<T IS A GIFT ( GRACE FROM ! JUDGE2 P[] & MI<T EXI/ ONLY 9 ME ! P[]FUL & MI<TY4 

,FOOTNOTES 

8 ,G]MAN3 ,RE*T2 ,?IS WORD HAS ALSO1 9 ,G]MAN1 ! MEAN+ ( 0COMMON LAW10 & WILL SOMETIMES BE TRANSLAT$ 0LAW0 9 ! FOLL[+ P>AGRAPHS4 
8 ,G]MAN3 ,RE*T 
8 ,! OLDE/ & MO/ RESPECT$ NEWSPAP] 9 ,B]L91 F\ND$ 9 ! #a#h? C5TURY4 ,= A TIME IT WAS PUBLI%$ UND] ! TITLE ,KONIGLI* PRIVILEGI]TE ,B]L9] ,ZEITUNG4 
8 ,G]MAN3 ,RE*TS/AAT 
8 ,WILHELM ,*RI/IAN ,WEITL+ 7#a#h#i-#a#h#g#a71 BORN 9 ,MAGDEBURG1 A V]Y ACTIVE P>TICIPANT 9 COMMUNI/ PROPAG&A 9 ,G]MANY BETWE5 #ahdb & #a#h#d#h4 ,HE WAS ONE ( ! RADICALS :O CAME TO ,AM]ICA AFT] ! LATT] DATE1 & ALL HIS ACTIVITIES W]E CONF9$ TO ! ,UNIT$ ,/ATES !REAFT]4 ,WEITL+ WAS A FAVORITE T>GET ( ,/IRN]'S4 
8 ,CF4 ,DIE ,KOMMUNI/5 9 D] ,S*WEIZ1 COMMITTEE REPORT1 P4 #c4 .<,! REF]5CE IS TO ,FRANCOIS-,NOEL ,BABEUF 7#a#g#f#d-#a#g#i#g71 ONE ( ! E>LIE/ !ORI/S ( EQUALIT>IAN COMMUNISM DUR+ ! ,FR5* ,REVOLUTION2 ,BAB\VISM BECAME ! T]M :I* DESCRIB$ ! SUB/ANCE ( HIS OV]ALL VIEWS4 ,! S\RCE CIT$ BY ,/IRN] IS ,DIE ,KOMMUNI/5 9 D] ,S*WEIZ NA* D5 BEI ,WEITL+ VORGEFUND55 ,PAPI]52 ,WORTLI*] ,ABDRUCK DES ,KOMMISSIONALB]I*TES AN DIE ,REGI]UNG DES ,/&ES 7,ZURI*1 #a#h#d#c74 ,IT WAS REPR9T$ 9 ANO!R =M BY 9CLUSION )9 ANO!R PUBLICATION1 PRESUMABLY TO \TWIT ! PRESS C5SORS1 9 ,S*AFFHAUS5 9 ! SAME YE>4 
8 ,G]MAN3 ,RE*TS/REIT1 A WORD :I* USUALLY MEANS 0LAWSUIT40 
8 ,!RE IS AN ELECTRIFY+ CONTEMPOR>Y R+ TO ?IS EXAMPLE ( ,/IRN]'S1 ?\< IT IS PROBABLY SUP]FLU\S TO M5TION ?AT HE IS SPEAK+ ( CIRCUM/ANCES NE>LY A C5TURY & A QU>T] AGO4 
8 ,A COMMON ,G]MAN PHRASE = 0IT SUITS ME40 
8 ,A4 ,BECK]1 ,VOLKSPHILOSOPHIE1 P4 #bb F4 
8 ,MEPHI/OPHELES 9 ,FAU/4 
8 ,G]MAN3 ,RE*TSBOD5 
8 ,G]MAN3 ,RE*?AB]EI4 0,I BEG Y\1 SP>E MY LUNGS6 ,HE :O 9SI/S ON PROV+ HIMSELF RI<T1 IF HE BUT HAS ONE ( !SE ?+S CALL$ TONGUES1 CAN HOLD HIS [N 9 ALL ! WORLD'S DESPITE60 ,FAU/'S WORDS TO ,MEPHI/OPHELES1 SLI<TLY MISQUOT$4 
8 ,G]MAN3 ,GESETZE MEAN+ /ATUTE2 NO LONG] ! SAME ,G]MAN WORD AS 0RI<T40 
8 ,G]MAN3 ,V]BRE*5 
8 ,G]MAN3 BRE*5 
8 ,A FIGURE ( SPEE* = A P>TICUL>LY DISAPPO9T+ ILLUSION1 REF]R+ TO ! /ORY 9 ,! ,>ABIAN ,NI<TS1 :]E9 A MEMB] ( ! ,B>MECIDE FAMILY PRET5D$ TO S]VE A FEA/ TO A BEGG> BUT SET BE=E HIM ONLY A SUCCESSION ( EMPTY DI%ES4 
8 ,?IS ,BOOK ,BELONGS TO ! ,K+1 P4 #c#g#f4 .<,! PSEUDONYM ( ,ELIZABE? ,BR5TANO1 ,C\NTESS VON ,>NIM 7#a#g#h#e-#a#h#e#i71 A WRIT] & BELAT$ SOCIALI/ PROPAG&I/ BE/ REMEMB]$ = H] CORRESPOND5CE ) ,GOE!1 PUBLI%$ 9 #a#h#c#e4 ,DIES ,BU* GEHORT DEM ,KONIG1 CIT$ BY ,/IRN]1 WAS PUBLI%$ 9 ,B]L9 9 #a#h#d#c4 
8 ,BETT9A1 ,?IS ,BOOK1 P4 #c#g#f4 
8 ,BETT9A1 ,?IS ,BOOK1 P4 #c#g#d4 
8 ,AN UNNATURAL MO!R4 
8 ,BETT9A1 ,?IS ,BOOK1 P4 #c#h#a4 
8 ,BETT9A1 ,?IS ,BOOK1 P4 #c#h#e4 
8 ,G]MAN3 ,G]E*TE 
8 G]E*T 
8 ,GEORGES ,JACQUES ,DANTON 7#a#g#e#i-#a#g#i#a71 ALONG ) ,ROBESPI]RE1 ,M>AT & ,/4 ,JU/1 LEAD]S ( ! ,FR5* ,REVOLUTION4 ,DANTON FELL AF\L ( AN 9TRA-REVOLUTION>Y C\P1 *>G$ ) 9SUFFICI5T ZEAL 9 HIS OPPOSITION TO ! C\NTRY'S =EIGN 5EMIES1 & WAS GUILLOT9$ 9 ,APRIL1 #a#g#i#d4 
8 ,G]MAN3 ,SPANNUNG 
8 ,G]MAN3 GESPANNT 
8 ,G]MAN3 SPANN5 
8 ,G]MAN3 ,GEME9S*AFT 
8 ,G]MAN@>,E9HEIT 
8 ,G]MAN3 ,E9ZIGKEIT 

,FROM 3 ,WIKI,S\RCE4 

,*RONOLOGY 3 
,NOVEMB] #c1 #ahdc 3 ,P>T #b1 ,*APT] #b1 ,SECTION #a -- ,PUBLICATION4 
,FEBRU>Y #b1 #bag 3 ,P>T #b1 ,*APT] #b1 ,SECTION #a -- ,ADD$4 

 FILE G5]AT$ FROM 3  
HTTP3_/_/REVOLTLIB4COM_/