,*APT] #bd ,YOSSIF ! ,EMIGRANT #aibeaibe ,PEOPLE 3 ,AU?OR 3 ,ALEX&] ,B]KMAN ,TEXT 3 ,A %ORT1 SL5D] MAN ( ?IRTY1 ) LU/R\S D>K EYES SET WIDE AP>T1 & A FACE ( PECULI> SADNESS4 ,! EXPRESSION ( HIS EYES /ILL HAUNTS ME3 N[ M\RNFUL1 N[ IRATE1 !Y REFLECT ALL ! TRAG$Y ( HIS ,JEWI% DESC5T4 ,HIS SMILE SPEAKS ! K9DL9ESS ( A HE>T ?AT HAS SUFF]$ & LE>N$ TO UND]/&4 ,! ?\S BE5 ACTIVE 9 ! RADICAL MOVEM5T 9 ! ,UNIT$ ,/ATES1 BUT ! CALL ( ! ,REVOLUTION BR\K$ SORR[FULLY4 ,BUT SOON ! ,COMMUNI/S BEGAN TO SUPPRESS ! O!R REVOLUTION>Y P>TIES1 & ,YOSSIF W5T ) ,LEA TO ! ,UKRA9A1 :]E !Y AID$ 9 ORGANIZ+ ! ,S\!RN ,CONF$]ATION ( ,AN>*I/ ,GR\PS UND] ! NAME ( ! ,NABAT 7,AL>M74 ,AS ! 0,EMIGRANT10 HIS P5 NAME 9 ! 0,NABAT10 ! ORGAN ( ! ,CONF$]ATION1 ,YOSSIF IS WIDELY KN[N 9 ! ,S\? & IS MU* LOV$ = HIS IDEALISM & SUNNY DISPOSITION4 ,5]GETIC & ACTIVE1 HE IS TIRELESS 9 HIS LABORS AMONG ! ,UKRA9IAN PEASANTRY1 & EV]Y:]E HE IS ! S\L & 9SPIRATION ( PROLET>IAN CIRCLES4 ,I HAVE REPEAT$LY VISIT$ HIM & HIS FRI5DS 9 ! ,AN>*I/ BOOK/ORE ,VOLNOYE ,BRAT/VO 7,FREE ,BRO!RHOOD74 ,!Y HAVE WITNESS$ ! NUM]\S POLITICAL *ANGES 9 ! ,UKRA9A1 HAVE SUFF]$ IMPRISONM5T BY ! ,:ITES1 & HAVE BE5 MALTREAT$ BY ,D5IK9 SOLDI]S4 0,WE >E H\ND$ NO LESS BY ! ,BOL%EVIKI10 ! ,EMIGRANT SAID2 0WE NEV] KN[ :AT !Y WILL DO TO US4 ,ONE DAY !Y >RE/ US1 & CLOSE \R CLUB & BOOK/ORE2 AT O!R TIMES !Y LEAVE US ALONE4 ,WE NEV] FEEL SAFE2 !Y KEEP US UND] CON/ANT SURVEILLANCE4 ,9 ?IS !Y HAVE A GREAT ADVANTAGE OV] ! ,:ITES2 UND] ! LATT] WE C\LD WORK UND]GR\ND1 BUT ! ,COMMUNI/S KN[ ALMO/ EV]YONE ( US P]SONALLY1 = WE ALWAYS /OOD %\LD] TO %\LD] ) !M AGA9/ C\NT]-REVOLUTION40 ,! ,EMIGRANT1 :OM ,I HAD =M]LY KN[N AS A MO/ PEACE-LOV+ MAN1 SURPRIS$ ME BY HIS MILITANT 5?USIASM REG>D+ ,MAKHNO1 :OM HE FAMILI>LY CALLS ,NE/OR4 ,HE SP5T MU* TIME ) ! LATT]1 & HE REG>DS HIM AS A ?OR\< ,AN>*I/1 :O IS FI$ ! DAILY LIFE ( ! POV/ANTSI1 & ACCOMPANI$ !M AS A NONCOMBATANT ON !IR CAMPAIGNS4 ,HE IS DEEPLY CONV9C$ ?AT ! ,BOL%EVIKI HAVE BETRAY$ ! PEOPLE4 0,AS LONG AS !Y W]E REVOLUTION>Y WE COOP]AT$ ) !M10 HE SAID2 0! FACT IS1 WE ,AN>*I/S DID SOME ( ! MO/ RESPONSIBLE & DANG]\S WORK ALL ?R\< ! ,REVOLUTION4 ,9 ,KRON/ADT1 ON ! ,BLACK ,SEA1 9 ! ,URAL & ,SIB]IA1 EV]Y:]E WE GAVE A GOOD ACC\NT ( \RSELVES4 ,BUT AS SOON AS ! ,COMMUNI/S GA9$ P[]1 !Y BEGAN ELIM9AT+ ALL ! O!R REVOLUTION>Y ELEM5TS1 & N[ WE >E 5TIRELY \TLAW$4 ,YES1 ! ,BOL%EVIKI1 ?OSE >*-REVOLUTIONI/S1 HAVE \TLAW$ US10 HE REPEAT$ BITT]LY4 0,C\LD NOT SOME WAY ( REAPPROA*M5T BE F\ND80 ,I SUGGE/$1 REF]R+ TO MY 9T5TION ( BROA*+ ! MATT] TO ,RAKOVSKY1 ! ,L59 ( ! ,UKRA9A4 0,NO1 IT'S TOO LATE10 ,YOSSIF REPLI$ POSITIVELY4 0,WE'VE TRI$ IT REPEAT$LY1 BUT EV]Y TIME ! ,BOL%EVIKI BROKE !IR PROMISES & EXPLOIT$ \R AGREEM5TS ONLY TO DEMORALIZE \R RANKS4 ,Y\ MU/ UND]/& ?AT ! ,COMMUNI/ ,P>TY HAS N[ BECOME A FULLFL$G$ GOV]NM5T1 SEEK+ TO IMPOSE ITS RULE UPON ! PEOPLE & DO+ IT BY ! MO/ DRA/IC ME?ODS4 ,!RE IS NO MORE HOPE ( TURN+ ! ,BOL%EVIKI 9TO REVOLUTION>Y *ANNELS4 ,TODAY !Y >E ! WOR/ 5EMIES ( ! ,REVOLUTION1 F> MORE DANG]\S ?AN ! ,D5IK9S & ,WRANGELS1 :OM ! PEASANTRY KN[ AS SU*4 ,! ONLY HOPE ( ,RUSSIA N[ IS 9 ! =CIBLE OV]?R[ ( ! ,COMMUNI/S BY A NEW UPRIS+ ( ! PEOPLE40 0,I SEE NO EVID5CE ( SU* A POSSIBILITY10 ,I OBJECT$4 0,! :OLE PEASANTRY ( ! ,S\? IS BITT]LY OPPOS$ TO !M10 ,YOSSIF REPLI$1 0BUT1 ( C\RSE1 WE MU/ TURN !IR BL9D HATR$ 9TO CONSCI\S REBELLION4 ,9 ?IS REG>D ,I CONSID] ,MAKHNO'S POV/ANISI MOVEM5T AS A MO/ PROMIS+ BEG9N+ ( A GREAT POPUL> UPHEAVAL AGA9/ ! NEW TYRANNY40 0,I HAVE HE>D MANY CONFLICT+ /ORIES AB\T ,MAKHNO10 ,I REM>K$4 0,HE IS PA9T$ EI!R AS A DEVIL OR AS A SA9T40 ,YOSSIF SMIL$4 0,EV] S9CE ,I LE>N$ ?AT Y\ >E 9 ,RUSSIA10 HE SAID E>NE/LY1 0,I HAVE BE5 HOP+ Y\ W\LD COME H]E40 ,9 A L[]$ VOICE HE ADD$3 0,! BE/ WAY TO F9D \T ! TRU? AB\T ,MAKHNO W\LD BE TO 9VE/IGATE = Y\RSELF40 ,I LOOK$ AT HIM QUE/ION+LY4 ,WE W]E ALONE 9 ! BOOK/ORE1 SAVE = A Y\NG WOMAN :O WAS BUSY+ H]SELF AT ! %ELVES4 ,YOSSIF'S EYES W&]$ TO ! /REET1 & HIS LOOK RE/$ ON TWO M5 CONV]S+ ON ! SIDEWALK4 0,T*EKA10 HE DECL>$ LACONICALLY1 0ALWAYS SNEAK+ >\ND H]E40 0,I HAVE SOME?+ TO PROPOSE TO Y\10 HE CONT9U$1 0BUT WE MU/ F9D A SAF] PLACE4 ,TOMORR[ EV5+ ,I %ALL HAVE SEV]AL COMRADES MEET Y\4 ,COME TO ! DAT*A---10 HE NAM$ A SUMM] H\SE OCCUPI$ BY A FRI5D1 0BUT BE C>EFUL Y\ >E NOT FOLL[$40 ,AT ! DAT*A1 SITUAT$ 9 A P>K 9 ! 5VIRONS ( ! CITY1 ,I F\ND A NUMB] ( ,YOSSIF'S FRI5DS4 ,!Y FELT SAFE 9 ?AT RETREAT1 !Y AV]R$2 BUT ! HUNT$ LOOK DID NOT LEAVE !M1 & !Y SPOKE 9 L[]$ VOICES4 ,SOMEONE REM>K$ ?AT ! OCCASION REM9D$ HIM ( HIS UNIV]SITY DAYS1 9 ! TIME ( ,NI*OLAS ,I,I1 :5 ! /UD5TS US$ TO GA!R 9 ! WOODS TO DISCUSS =BIDD5 POLITICAL QUE/IONS4 0,?+S HAVE NOT *ANG$ 9 ?AT RESPECT10 HE ADD$ SADLY4 0,9COMP>ABLY WORSE 9 EV]Y REG>D10 A D>K-FEATUR$ ,UKRA9IAN REM>K$ EMPHATICALLY4 0,DON'T TAKE HIM LIT]ALLY10 SMIL$ ,YOSSIF1 0HE IS \R 9VET]ATE PESSIMI/40 0,I DO MEAN IT LIT]ALLY10 ! ,UKRA9IAN P]SI/$4 0,!RE ISN'T 5\< LEFT ( ! ,REVOLUTION TO MAKE A FIGLEAF = ,BOL%EVIK NAK$NESS4 ,RUSSIA HAS NEV] BE=E LIV$ UND] SU* ABSOLUTE DESPOTISM4 ,SOCIALISM1 ,COMMUNISM1 9DE$6 ,NEV] HAD WE LESS LIB]TY & EQUALITY ?AN TODAY4 ,WE HAVE M]ELY EX*ANG$ ,NI*OLAS = ,ILYIT*40 0,Y\ SEE ONLY ! =MS10 PUT 9 A Y\NG MAN 9TRODUC$ AS ! ,POET2 0BUT !RE IS AN ESS5CE 9 ! PRES5T ,RUSSIA ?AT ESCAPES Y\4 ,!RE IS A SPIRITUAL REVOLUTION :I* IS ! SYMBOL & ! G]M ( A NEW ,KULTUR4 ,= EV]Y ,KULTUR10 HE CONT9U$1 0IS AN ORGANIC :OLE ( MANIFOLD REALIZATION2 IT IS ! KN[+ ( SOME?+ 9 CONNECTION ) SOME?+ ELSE4 ,9 O!R WORDS1 CONSCI\SNESS4 ,! HIE O!RS1 9 ALL WALKS ( LIFE1 & !Y >E SICK ( ALL POLITICAL DOGMAS4 ,!RE >E MILLIONS ( CONSCI\SNESSES ?AT >E PA9FULLY /RUGGL+ T[>D NEW CRIT]IA ( REALITY4 ,9 !IR S\LS !Y HAVE LIV$ ?R\< ! TREM5D\S COLLISION ( LIFE & DEA?2 !Y HAVE DI$ & COME TO LIFE AGA94 ,!Y HAVE ATTA9$ TO NEW VALUES4 ,9 !M IS ! COM+ DAWN ( ! NEW ,RUSSIAN ,KULTUR40 0,AH1 ! ,REVOLUTION IS DEAD10 REM>K$ A %ORT1 SMOO?-%AV5 MAN ( MIDDLE AGE1 9 A ,R$ ,>MY UNI=M4 0,:5 ,I ?9K ( ! ,OCTOB] DAYS & ! MIMY WAS 9SPIR$4 ,EA* FELT HIMSELF A FREE MAN DEF5D+ ! ,REVOLUTION ?AT WAS HIS4 ,BUT :5 WE RETURN$ FROM ! FRONT1 WE F\ND ! ,BOL%EVIKI PROCLAIM$ !MSELVES DICTATORS OV] US1 9 ! NAME ( !IR ,P>TY4 ,IT'S DEAD1 \R ,REVOLUTION10 HE CONCLUD$1 ) A DEEP SI<4 0,Y\ >E WRONG1 MY FRI5D10 ,YOSSIF PROTE/$4 0,! ,BOL%EVIKI HAVE 9DE$ RET>D$ ! PROGRESS ( ! ,REVOLUTION & !Y >E TRY+ TO DE/ROY IT ALTOGE!R1 TO SECURE !IR POLITICAL P[]4 ,BUT ! SPIRIT ( ! ,REVOLUTION LIVES1 9 SPITE ( !M4 ,M>*1 #a#i#a#g1 WAS ONLY ! REVOLUTION>Y HONEYMOON1 ! LISP+ ( LOV]S4 ,IT WAS CLEAN & PURE1 BUT IT WAS 9>TICULATE1 IMPOT5T4 ,! REAL PASSION WAS YET TO COME4 ,OCTOB] SPRANG FROM ! WOMB ( ,RUSSIA ITSELF4 ,TRUE1 ! ,BOL%EVIKI HAVE TURN$ ,JESUITS1 BUT ! ,REVOLUTION HAS ACCOMPLI%$ MU* --- IT HAS DE/ROY$ CAPITALISM & UND]M9$ ! PR9CIPLES ( PRIVATE [N]%IP4 ,9 ITS CONCRETE EXPRESSION TODAY ,BOL%EVISM IS A SY/EM ( ! MO/ RU?LESS DESPOTISM4 ,IT HAS ORGANIZ$ A SOCIALI/IC SLAV]Y4 ,YET1 NOT)/&+1 ,I DECL>E ?AT ! ,RUSSIAN ,REVOLUTION LIVES4 ,= ! LEAD]S & ! PRES5T =MS ( ,BOL%EVISM >E A TEMPOR>Y ELEM5T4 ,!Y >E A MORBID SPASM 9 ! G5]AL PROCESS4 ,! P>OXYSM WILL PASS2 ! HEAL?Y REVOLUTION>Y ESS5CE WILL REMA94 ,EV]Y?+ ?AT IS GOOD & VALUABLE 9 HUMAN HI/ORY WAS ALWAYS BORN & DEVELOP$ 9 ! ATMOSPH]E ( EVIL & CORRUPTION1 MIX+ & 9T]WEAV+ ) IT4 ,?AT IS ! FATE ( EV]Y /RUGGLE = LIB]TY4 ,IT ALSO APPLIES TO ,RUSSIA TODAY1 & IT IS \R MISSION TO GIVE AID & /R5G? TO ! F9E & ! TRUE1 ! P]MAN5T1 9 ?AT /RUGGLE40 0,I SUPPOSE ?AT'S :Y Y\ >E SO P>TIAL TO ,MAKHNO10 PUT 9 ! ,R$ ,>MY MAN4 0,MAKHNO REPRES5TS ! REAL SPIRIT ( ,OCTOB]10 ,YOSSIF REPLI$ ) W>M?4 0,9 ! REVOLUTION>Y POV/ANTSI1 :OM HE LEADS1 IS ! SOLE HOPE ( ! C\NTRY4 ,! ,UKRA9IAN PEASANT IS AN 9/9CTIVE ,AN>*I/1 & HIS EXP]I5CE HAS TAUE ESS5TIALLY ALIKE --- TAK+ EV]Y?+ FROM HIM & GIV+ NO?+ 9 RETURN4 ,HE WANTS TO BE RID ( !M2 TO BE LEFT ALONE TO >RANGE HIS [N LIFE & AFFAIRS4 ,HE WILL FIE KULAKI ) PETTY B\RGEOIS IDEAS ( PROP]TY10 RETORT$ ! ,PESSIMI/4 0,!RE IS SU* AN ELEM5T10 ,YOSSIF ADMITT$1 0BUT ! GREAT MAJORITY >E NOT ( ?AT TYPE4 ,AS TO ! ,MAKHNO MOVEM5T1 IT (F]S ! GREATE/ FIELD = PROPAG&A4 ,NE/OR1 HIMSELF AN ,AN>*I/1 AF=DS US ! FULLE/ OPPORTUNITY TO WORK 9 HIS >MY1 EV5 TO ! EXT5T ( SUPPLY+ US ) PR9T$ MAT]IAL & MA*9]Y = ! PUBLICATION ( \R NEWSPAP]S & LEAFLETS4 ,! T]RITORY OCCUPI$ BY ,MAKHNO IS ! ONLY PLACE :]E LIB]TY ( SPEE* & PRESS PREVAILS40 0,BUT NOT = ,COMMUNI/S10 RETORT$ ! SOLDI]4 0,MAKHNO JU/LY CONSID]S ! ,COMMUNI/S AS MU* C\NT]-REVOLUTION>Y AS ! ,:ITES10 REPLI$ ,YOSSIF4 0,BUT = ! REVOLUTIONI/S --- = ,AN>*I/S1 ,MAXIMALI/S1 & ,LEFT ,SOCIAL ,REVOLUTIONI/S --- !RE IS FULL LIB]TY ( ACTION 9 ! POV/ANTSI DI/RICTS40 ,MAKHNO MAY CALL HIMSELF AN ,AN>*I/10 SPOKE UP ,M---1 AN ,9DIVIDUALI/ ,AN>*I/1 0BUT ,I DISAGREE 5TIRELY ) ,YOSSIF AB\T ! SIGNIFICANCE ( HIS MOVEM5T4 ,I CONSID] HIS '>MY' M]ELY AN 5L>G$ B& ( REBEL PEASANTS )\T REVOLUTION>Y PURPOSE OR CONSCI\SNESS40 0,!Y HAVE BE5 GUILTY ( BRUTALITY & POGROMS10 ADD$ ! ,PESSIMI/4 0,!RE HAVE BE5 EXCESSES10 ,YOSSIF REPLI$1 0JU/ AS !Y HAPP5 9 EV]Y >MY1 ! ,COMMUNI/ NOT EXCEPT$4 ,BUT ,NE/OR IS M]CILESS T[>D ?OSE GUILTY ( ,JEW-BAIT+4 ,MO/ ( Y\ HAVE READ HIS NUM]\S PROCLAMATIONS AGA9/ POGROMS1 & Y\ KN[ H[ SEV]ELY HE PUNI%ES SU* ?+S4 ,I REMEMB]1 = 9/ANCE1 ! 9CID5T AT ,V]KHNY ,TAKM>4 ,IT WAS *>ACT]I/IC4 ,IT HAPP5$ AB\T A YE> AGO1 ON ! #d? OR #e? ( ,MAY1 #aiai ,MAKHNO1 ACCOMPANI$ BY SEV]AL MEMB]S ( HIS MILIT>Y /AFF1 WAS ON HIS WAY FROM ! FRONT TO ,GULYAI-,POLE1 HIS HEADQU>T]S1 = A CONF]5CE ) ! SPECIAL ,SOVIET EMISS>IES S5T FROM ,KH>KOV4 ,AT ! /ATION ( ,V]KHNY ,TAKM> ,NE/OR NOTIC$ A L>GE PO/] READ+3 ',KILL ! ,JEWS6 ,SAVE ,RUSSIA6 ,LONG LIVE ,MAKHNO6' ,NE/OR S5T = ! /ATION MA/]4 ',:O PUT UP ?AT PO/]8' HE DEM&$4 ',I DID1' REPLI$ ! (FICIAL1 A PEASANT :O HAD BE5 9 FID MANY /ORIES ( ATROCITIES & POGROMS COMMITT$ BY ,MAKHNO UNITS10 ,I REM>K$4 0,!Y >E LIES WILLFULLY SPREAD BY ! ,BOL%EVIKI10 ,YOSSIF ASS]T$4 0,!Y HATE ,NE/OR WORSE ?AN !Y DO ,WRANGEL4 ,TROTSKY ONCE SAID ?AT IT W]E BETT] ! ,UKRA9A W]E TAK5 BY ,D5IK9 ?AN TO ALL[ ,MAKHNO TO CONT9UE !RE4 ,) REASON3 = ! SAVAGE RULE ( ! ,CZ>I/ G5]ALS W\LD SOON TURN ! PEASANTRY AGA9/ !M & ?US 5ABLE ! ,BOL%EVIKI TO DEFEAT !M1 :ILE ! SPREAD ( ,MAKHNOV/*9A1 AS ! ,MAKHNO MOVEM5T IS KN[N1 ) ITS ,AN>*I/ IDEAS ?REAT5S ! :OLE ,BOL%EVIK SY/EM4 ,! POGROMS ASCRIB$ TO ,MAKHNO UPON 9VE/IGATION ALWAYS PROVE TO HAVE BE5 COMMITT$ BY ! ,GRE5S OR O!R B&ITS4 ,! FACT IS1 ,MAKHNO & HIS /AFF KEEP UP A CONT9U\S AGITATION AGA9/ RELIGI\S & NATIONALI/IC SUP]/ITIONS & PREJUDICES40 ,?\< RADICALLY DIFF]+ CONC]N+ ! *>ACT] & SIGNIFICANCE ( ! ,MAKHNOV/*9A1 ?OSE PRES5T AGRE$ ?AT ,NE/OR HIMSELF IS A UNIQUE FIGURE & ONE ( ! MO/ \T/&+ P]SONALITIES ON ! REVOLUTION>Y HORIZON4 ,TO HIS ADMIR] ,YOSSIF1 H[EV]1 HE TYPIFIES ! SPIRIT ( ,REVOLUTION AS IT EXPRESSES ITSELF 9 ! FEEL+1 ?\*Y ,>*IVES4 ,*RONOLOGY 3 ,NOVEMB] #c1 #aibd 3 ,*APT] #bd -- ,PUBLICATION4 ,FEBRU>Y #b1 #bag 3 ,*APT] #bd -- ,ADD$4 FILE G5]AT$ FROM 3 HTTP3_/_/REVOLTLIB4COM_/