,BOOK #b1 ,*APT] #ba 

#ahiiahii 

,PEOPLE 3 

,AU?OR 3 ,LEO ,TOL/OY 

,TEXT 3 

0,WELL1 H[ >E ! *ILDR580 ,NEKHLUD(F ASK$ HIS SI/]1 
HAV+ CALM$ D[N4 

,?US ! UNPLEASANT CONV]SATION WAS *ANG$4 ,NATALIE 
BECAME CALM & TALK$ AB\T H] *ILDR54 ,%E 
W\LD NOT SPEAK1 H[EV]1 AB\T ?OSE ?+S :I* ONLY 
H] BRO!R UND]/OOD 9 ! PRES5CE ( H] HUSB&1 
& 9 ORD] TO CONT9UE ! CONV]SATION %E BEGAN TO TALK 
( ! LATE/ NEWS1 ! KILL+ ( ,KANESKY 9 ! DUEL4 

,IGNATIUS ,NIKI=OVIT* EXPRESS$ HIS DISAPPROVAL ( ! 
CONDITION ( ?+S :I* EXCLUD$ ! KILL+ 9 A DUEL 
FROM ! CATEGORY ( CRIMES4 

,HIS REM>K CALL$ =? ,NEKHLUD(F'S REPLY1 & A HOT 
DISCUSSION FOLL[$ ON ! SAME SUBJECT1 NEI!R EXPRESS+ 
FULLY HIS OP9ION1 & 9 ! 5D !Y W]E AGA9 AT 
LOGG]HEADS4 

,IGNATIUS ,NIKI=OVIT* FELT ?AT ,NEKHLUD(F CONDEMN$ 
HIM1 HAT+ ALL HIS ACTIVITY1 & HE WI%$ TO PROVE ! 9JU/ICE 
( HIS REASON+4 ,NEKHLUD(F1 ON ! O!R H&1 
TO SAY NO?+ ( ! VEXATION CAUS$ HIM BY HIS BRO!R-9-LAW'S 
9T]F]5CE 9 HIS AFFAIRS 79 ! DEP? ( HIS S\L 
HE FELT ?AT HIS BRO!R-9-LAW1 HIS SI/] & !IR *ILDR51 
AS HEIRS1 HAD ! RI<T TO DO SO71 WAS 9DIGNANT AT ! CALM 
& CONFID5T MANN] ( ?AT N>R[-M9D$ MAN :O 
CONT9U$ TO CONSID] LEGAL & JU/ ?AT :I* TO ,NEKHLUD(F 
WAS UND\BT$LY FOOLI%4 ,?IS SELF-CONFID5CE IRRITAT$ 
HIM4 

0,:AT %\LD ! C\RT DO80 ASK$ ,NEKHLUD(F4 

0,S5T5CE ONE ( ! DUELI/S1 AS IT W\LD A COMMON 
MURD]]1 TO H>D LABOR40 

,NEKHLUD(F'S H&S AGA9 TURN$ COLD1 & HE CONT9U$ 
) W>M?3 

0,WELL1 :AT W\LD BE !N80 

0,JU/ICE W\LD BE DONE40 

0,AS IF ! AIM ( C\RTS WAS TO DO JU/ICE60 SAID ,NEKHLUD(F4 

0,:AT ELSE80 

0,!IR AIM IS TO SUPPORT CLASS 9T]E/S4 ,C\RTS1 ACCORD+ 
TO MY IDEA1 >E ONLY 9/RUM5TS = ! P]PETUATION 
( CONDITIONS PR(ITABLE TO \R CLASS40 

0,?AT IS AN 5TIRELY NEW VIEW10 SAID ,IGNATIUS ,NIKI=OVIT*1 
SMIL+ CALMLY4 0,USUALLY SOME:AT DIFF]5T AIMS 
>E ASCRIB$ TO C\RTS40 

0,9 !ORY1 BUT NOT 9 PRACTICE1 AS ,I HAVE LE>N$4 ,! 
ONLY AIM ( ! C\RTS IS TO PRES]VE ! EXI/+ /ATE ( 
?+S1 & = ?IS REASON !Y P]SECUTE & KILL ALL ?OSE 
:O >E ABOVE ! COMMON LEVEL & :O WI% TO RAISE IT 
AS WELL AS ?OSE :O >E BEL[ IT40 

0,I CANNOT AGREE ) ! VIEW ?AT CRIM9ALS >E EXECUT$ 
BECAUSE !Y >E ABOVE ! LEVEL ( ! AV]AGE4 ,= 
! MO/ P>T !Y >E ! EXCRESC5CE ( SOCIETY1 JU/ AS 
P]V]T$1 ?\< 9 A DIFF]5T MANN]1 AS >E ?OSE 
CRIM9AL TYPES :OM Y\ CONSID] BEL[ ! LEVEL ( ! 
AV]AGE40 

0,& ,I KN[ PEOPLE :O >E F> ABOVE !IR JUDGES40 

,BUT ,IGNATIUS ,NIKI=OVIT*1 NOT ACCU/OM$ TO BE+ 9T]RUPT$ 
:5 SPEAK+1 DID NOT LI/5 TO ,NEKHLUD(F1 
:I* WAS P>TICUL>LY IRRITAT+ TO ! LATT]1 & CONT9U$ 
TO TALK :ILE ,NEKHLUD(F WAS TALK+4 

0,I CANNOT AGREE ) Y\ ?AT ! AIM ( C\RTS IS TO 
SUPPORT ! EXI/+ ORD] ( ?+S4 ,! C\RTS HAVE 
!IR AIMS3 EI!R ! CORRECTION----0 

0,PRISONS >E GREAT PLACES = CORRECTION10 ,NEKHLUD(F 
PUT 94 

0,OR ! REMOVAL10 P]SI/5TLY CONT9U$ ,IGNATIUS ,NIKI=OVIT*1 
0( ?OSE DEPRAV$ & SAVAGE PEOPLE :O 
?REAT5 ! EXI/5CE ( SOCIETY40 

0,?AT IS JU/ :]E ! TR\BLE IS4 ,C\RTS CAN DO 
NEI!R ! ONE NOR ! O!R4 ,SOCIETY HAS NO MEANS ( 
DO+ IT40 

0,H[ IS ?AT8 ,I DON'T UND]/&----0 ASK$ ,IGNATIUS 
,NIKI=OVIT*1 ) A =C$ SMILE4 

0,I MEAN TO SAY ?AT !RE >E ONLY TWO S5SIBLE MODES ( 
PUNI%M5T--?OSE ?AT HAVE BE5 US$ 9 OLD5 TIMES3 
CORPORAL PUNI%M5T & CAPITAL PUNI%M5T4 ,BUT ) 
! ADVANCE ( CIVILIZATION !Y HAVE GONE \T ( EXI/5CE40 

0,?AT IS BO? NEW & SURPRIS+ TO HE> FROM Y\40 

0,YES1 !RE IS S5SE 9 9FLICT+ PA9 ON A MAN ?AT HE 
MI<T NOT REPEAT ?AT = :I* ! PA9 WAS 9FLICT$2 & 
IT IS P]FECTLY S5SIBLE TO CUT ! HEAD (F A H>MFUL & 
DANG]\S MEMB] ( SOCIETY4 ,BUT :AT S5SE IS !RE 9 
IMPRISON+ A MAN1 :O IS DEPRAV$ BY IDL5ESS & BAD 
EXAMPLE1 & KEEP+ HIM 9 SECURE & COMPULSORY IDL5ESS 
9 ! SOCIETY ( ! MO/ DEPRAV$ PEOPLE8 ,OR TO 
TRANSPORT HIM1 = SOME REASON1 AT AN EXP5SE TO ! GOV]NM5T 
( FIVE HUNDR$ RUBLES1 FROM ! ,DI/RICT ( ,TULA 
TO ! ,DI/RICT ( ,IRKUTSK1 OR FROM ,KURSK----0 

0,BUT PEOPLE SEEM TO FE> !SE J\RNEYS AT GOV]NM5T 
EXP5SE4 ,& W]E IT NOT = !SE J\RNEYS1 WE W\LD 
NOT BE SITT+ H]E AS WE >E SITT+ N[40 

0,PRISONS CANNOT SECURE \R SAFETY1 BECAUSE PEOPLE >E 
NOT IMPRISON$ = LIFE1 BUT >E RELEAS$4 ,ON ! CONTR>Y1 
!SE 9/ITUTIONS >E ! GREATE/ BRE$]S ( VISE & CORRUPTION--I4 E41 
!Y 9CREASE ! DANG]40 

0,Y\ MEAN TO SAY ?AT ! P5IT5TI>Y SY/EM \<T TO 
BE P]FECT$80 

0,IT CANNOT BE P]FECT$4 ,P]FECT$ PRISONS W\LD CO/ 
MORE ?AN IS SP5T ON POPUL> $UCATION & W\LD BE A 
NEW BURD5 ON ! POPULACE40 

0,BUT ! DEFICI5CIES ( ! P5IT5TI>Y SY/EM DO NOT 
9VALIDATE ! JUDICIAL SY/EM10 ,IGNATIUS ,NIKI=OVIT* 
AGA9 CONT9U$1 )\T LI/5+ TO HIS BRO!R-9-LAW4 

0,!SE DEFICI5CIES CANNOT BE CORRECT$10 SAID ,NEKHLUD(F1 
RAIS+ HIS VOICE4 

0,:AT !N8 ,W\LD Y\ KILL8 ,OR1 AS A C]TA9 /ATESMAN 
SUGGE/$1 PLUCK \T !IR EYES80 SAID ,IGNATIUS ,NIKI=OVIT*1 
SMIL+ TRIUMPHANTLY4 

0,YES2 ?AT W\LD BE CRUEL1 BUT EXP$I5T4 ,:AT WE >E 
DO+ N[ IS BO? CRUEL & 9EXP$I5T40 

0,& ,I AM TAK+ P>T 9 IT10 SAID ,IGNATIUS ,NIKI=OVIT*1 
PAL+4 

0,?AT IS Y\R BUS9ESS4 ,BUT ,I DO NOT UND]/& IT40 

0,I ?9K !RE >E MANY ?+S Y\ DO NOT UND]/&10 
SAID ,IGNATIUS ,NIKI=OVIT*1 ) A QUIV] 9 HIS VOICE4 

0,I SAW A PUBLIC PROSECUTOR 9 C\RT TRY+ HIS UTMO/ TO 
CONVICT AN UN=TUNATE BOY1 :O C\LD ONLY >\SE COMPASSION 
9 ANY UNP]V]T$ MAN----0 

0,IF ,I ?\<T SO1 ,I %\LD GIVE UP MY POSITION10 SAID 
,IGNATIUS ,NIKI=OVIT*1 RIS+4 

,NEKHLUD(F NOTIC$ A PECULI> GLITT] UND] HIS BRO!R-9-LAW'S 
EYE-GLASSES4 0,CAN IT BE TE>S80 ?\<T ,NEKHLUD(F4 
,!Y REALLY W]E TE>S4 ,IGNATIUS ,NIKI=OVIT* WAS 
(F5D$4 ,GO+ T[>D ! W9D[1 HE DREW A H&K]*IEF 
FROM HIS POCKET1 C\<$1 & BEGAN TO WIPE HIS EYE-GLASSES1 
&1 REMOV+ !M1 HE ALSO WIP$ HIS EYES4 ,RETURN+ 
TO ! C\*1 ,IGNATIUS ,NIKI=OVIT* LIT A CIG> 
& SPOKE NO MORE4 ,NEKHLUD(F WAS PA9$ & A%AM$ 
AT ! GRIEF ?AT HE HAD CAUS$ HIS BRO!R-9-LAW & SI/]1 
ESPECIALLY AS HE WAS LEAV+ ! NEXT DAY & W\LD 
NOT SEE !M AGA94 ,9 GREAT AGITATION HE TOOK LEAVE ( 
!M & DEP>T$4 

0,IT IS QUITE POSSIBLE ?AT :AT ,I SAID WAS TRUE4 ,AT ANY 
RATE1 HE DID NOT REFUTE ME4 ,BUT IT WAS WRONG TO SPEAK ?AT 
WAY4 ,LITTLE HAVE ,I *ANG$ IF ,I C\LD 9SULT HIM & 
GRIEVE POOR ,NATALIE10 HE ?\<T4 

7,S\RCE3 ,! ,AWAK5+ BY GRAF ,LEO ,TOL/OY1 ,TRANSLAT$ BY ,SMI?1 ,WILLIAM ,E41 ,A,K,A3 ,! ,RESURRECTION4 ,TEXT FROM ,GUT5B]G4ORG47 

,FROM 3 ,GUT5B]G4ORG4 

,*RONOLOGY 3 
,NOVEMB] #c1 #ahih 3 ,BOOK #b1 ,*APT] #ba -- ,PUBLICATION4 
,FEBRU>Y #a#c1 #bag 3 ,BOOK #b1 ,*APT] #ba -- ,ADD$4 

 FILE G5]AT$ FROM 3  
HTTP3_/_/REVOLTLIB4COM_/