,! ,AN>*I/ ,E?IC 9 ! ,AGE ( ! ,ANTI-,GLOBALIZATION ,MOVEM5T ,PEOPLE 3 ,AU?OR 3 ,ANONYM\S ,TEXT 3 ,P>T ,I ,! QUE/ION ALWAYS BE=E AN>*I/S IS H[ TO ACT 9 ! PRES5T MOM5T ( /RUGGLE AGA9/ CAPITALISM & ! /ATE4 ,AS NEW =MS ( SOCIAL /RUGGLES >E BECOM+ MORE CLE>LY UND]/OOD1 ?IS QUE/ION BECOMES EV5 MORE IMPORTANT4 ,9 ORD] TO ANSW] !SE QUE/IONS WE HAVE TO CL>IFY ! RELATION%IP BETWE5 AN>*I/S & ! WID] SOCIAL MOVEM5T ( ! EXPLOIT$ & ! NATURE ( ?AT MOVEM5T ITSELF4 ,FIR/ ( ALL1 WE NE$ TO NOTE ?AT ! MOVEM5T ( ! EXPLOIT$ IS ALWAYS 9 C\RSE4 ,!RE IS NO USE 9 AN>*I/S1 :O WI% TO DE/ROY CAPITALISM & ! /ATE 9 !IR 5TIRETY1 WAIT+ TO ACT ON SOME FUTURE DATE1 AS PR$ICT$ BY AN OBJECTIVI/ READ+ ( CAPITALISM OR A DET]M9I/ UND]/&+ ( HI/ORY AS IF ONE W]E READ+ ! />S4 ,?IS IS ! MO/ SECURE WAY ( KEEP+ US LOCK$ 9 ! PRES5T =EV]4 ,! REVOLUTION>Y MOVEM5T ( ! EXPLOIT$ MULTITUDE NEV] TOTALLY DISAPPE>S1 NO MATT] H[ HIDD5 IT IS4 ,ABOVE ALL ?IS IS A MOVEM5T TO DE/ROY ! SEP>ATION BETWE5 US1 ! EXPLOIT$1 & \R CONDITIONS ( EXI/5CE1 ?AT :I* WE NE$ TO LIVE4 ,IT IS A MOVEM5T ( SOCIETY AGA9/ ! /ATE4 ,WE CAN SEE ?IS MOVEM5T1 H[EV] 9COH]5T OR UNCONSCI\S1 9 ! ACTIONS ( ,BRAZIL'S PEASANTS :O TAKE ! L& !Y NE$ TO SURVIVE1 :5 ! POOR /EAL1 OR :5 SOMEONE ATTACKS ! /ATE ?AT MA9TA9S ! SY/EM ( EXCLUSION & EXPLOITATION4 ,WE CAN SEE ?IS MOVEM5T 9 ! ACTIONS ( ?OSE :O ATTACK ! MA*9]Y ?AT DE/ROYS \R V]Y LIFE-GIV+ 5VIRONM5T4 ,)9 ?IS CURR5T1 AN>*I/S >E A M9ORITY4 ,&1 AS CONSCI\S AN>*I/S1 WE DON'T /& \TSIDE ! MOVEM5T1 PROPAG&IZ+ & ORGANIZ+ IT2 WE ACT ) ?IS CURR5T1 HELP+ TO REANIMATE & %>P5 ITS /RUGGLES4 ,IT IS 9/RUCTIVE TO LOOK BACK AT ! REC5T HI/ORY ( ?IS CURR5T4 ,9 ! ,U4,S41 BEG9N+ 9 ! #a#i#gS1 SOCIAL MOVEM5TS BEGAN TO FRACTURE 9TO S+LE-ISSUE /RUGGLES ?AT LEFT ! TOTALITY ( SOCIAL RELATIONS UN*ALL5G$4 ,9 MANY WAYS1 ?IS WAS REFLECT$ 9 A %IFT 9 ! =M ( IMPOS$ SOCIAL RELATIONS1 :I* OCCURR$ 9 RESPONSE TO ! /RUGGLES ( ! #a#i#fS & E>LY #a#i#g1 & IS M>K$ BY A %IFT FROM A ,=DI/ REGIME ( ACCUMULATION 7DOM9AT$ BY L>GE FACTORIES & A M$IAT$ TRUCE ) UNIONS7 TO A REGIME ( FLEXIBLE ACCUMULATION 7:I* BEGAN TO BREAK UNIONS1 DISMANTLE ! WELF>E /ATE1 & OP5 BORD]S TO ! FREE FL[ ( CAPITAL74 ,?IS %IFT IS ALSO MIRROR$ BY ! ACADEMIC %IFT TO PO/MOD]NI/ !ORY1 :I* PRIVILEGES ! FRACTUR$1 ! FLOAT+1 & ! FLEXIBLE4 ,:ILE ! GR[? ( S+LE-ISSUE GR\PS SIGNALS ! DEFEAT ( ! ANTI-CAPITALI/ /RUGGLES ( ! #a#i#fS1 OV] ! #a#i#iS WE HAVE WITNESS$ A RECONV]G5CE ( /RUGGLES ?AT >E BEG9N+ TO *ALL5GE CAPITALISM AS A TOTALITY4 ,?US ! REVOLUTION>Y CURR5T ( ! EXPLOIT$ & EXCLUD$ HAS REC5TLY REEM]G$ 9 A CYCLE ( CONFRONTATIONS ?AT BEGAN 9 ! ?IRD WORLD & HAVE SPREAD TO ! FIR/ WORLD ( ,LONDON1 ,SEATTLE1 & ,PRAGUE1 & 9 ! DIRECT ACTION MOVEM5T ?AT HAS1 = ! MO/ P>T1 GR[N \T ( ! RADICAL 5VIRONM5TAL MILIEU4 ,9 ! SPECTACUL> CONFRONTATIONS ( ! GLOBAL DAYS ( ACTION1 !SE /REAMS HAVE BE5 CONV]G+ 9TO A P[]FUL SOCIAL =CE4 ,! KEY TO ?IS RECONV]G5CE IS ?AT ! NEW /RUGGLES ( ! #a#i#iS >E CREAT+ WAYS TO COMMUNICATE & L9K LOCAL & P>TICUL> /RUGGLES )\T BUILD+ /IFL+ ORGANIZATIONS ?AT ATTEMPT TO SYN!SIZE ALL /RUGGLE UND] !IR COMM&4 ,FUNDAM5TAL TO ?IS MOVEM5T IS AN E?IC ?AT /&S AGA9/ ALL ?AT SEP>ATES US FROM \R CONDITIONS ( EXI/5CE & ALL ?AT SEP>ATES US FROM \R P[] TO TRANS=M ! WORLD & TO CREATE SOCIAL RELATIONS BEYOND MEASURE -- A MEASURE IMPOS$ FROM ABOVE4 ,?IS E?IC IS A CALL = ! SELF-ORGANIZATION ( FRE$OM1 ! SELF-VALORIZATION ( HUMAN ACTIVITY4 ,9 ?IS >TICLE WE WILL \TL9E \R UND]/&+ ( ! E?IC ( ! REVOLUTION>Y AN>*I/ CURR5T ( SOCIETY ?AT GR[S \T ( ! MOVEM5T ( ! EXPLOIT$ 9 G5]AL4 ,!N WE WILL TURN TO ! QUE/ION ( ACTION & ORGANIZATION1 LOOK+ CRITICALLY AT ! =MS ( /RUGGLE ?AT >E APPE>+ 9 ! REC5T CYCLE ( SOCIAL MOVEM5TS & >GU+ ?AT 9=MAL ORGANIZATION IS ! BE/ WAY = AN>*I/S TO ORGANIZE AS A M9ORITY )9 ! WID] SOCIAL MOVEM5T4 ,BY ORGANIZ+ ALONG !SE L9ES1 WE BELIEVE AN>*I/S CAN %>P5 ! LEVEL ( /RUGGLE & DEVELOP SOCIAL RELATIONS 9 PRACTICE ?AT >E BO? ANTAGONI/IC TO CAPITAL & ! /ATE & BEG9 TO CREATE ( NEW WAYS ( LIV+4 ,E?IC & MORALITY ,WE USE ! T]M E?IC 9 A V]Y SPECIFIC S5SE & CONTRA/ IT TO MORALITY4 ,MORALITY /&S \TSIDE :AT IT RULES OV]1 IT SWOOPS D[N FROM ABOVE TO ORGANIZE RELATION%IPS & DISCIPL9E BEHAVIOR4 ,= EXAMPLE1 ! RELATION%IP BETWE5 TWO PEOPLE CAN BE SET MORALLY BY A ?IRD P>TY1 ! *UR*1 ! /ATE1 OR ! S*OOL4 ,?IS ?IRD P>TY IS NOT A P>T ( ! RELATION%IP2 9 O!R WORDS1 IT /&S TRANSC5D5T TO ! RELATION%IP4 ,! RELATION%IP BETWE5 TWO PEOPLE CAN ALSO BE >RANG$ ?R\< AN E?IC4 ,UNLIKE MORALITY1 AN E?IC NEV] COMES FROM ! \TSIDE2 AN E?IC LETS US UND]/& H[ TO RELATE TO O!R PEOPLE OR OBJECTS1 O!R BODIES1 9 A WAY ?AT IS B5EFICIAL TO US4 ,AN E?IC IS ?US A DOCTR9E ( HAPP9ESS1 ONE :I* NEV] COMES =M ! \TSIDE ( ! SITUATION1 :I* NEV] /&S ABOVE A RELATION%IP1 BUT IS ALWAYS DEVELOP$ FROM )92 IT IS ALWAYS IMMAN5T TO ! SITUATION 9/EAD ( TRANSC5D5T TO IT4 ,AN E?IC IS A RELATION%IP ( DESIRE4 ,9 AN E?ICAL RELATION%IP DESIRE IS COMPLEM5T$ BY DESIRE1 EXP&$ BY IT4 ,MORALITY1 ON ! O!R H&1 ALWAYS LIMITS & *ANNELS DESIRE4 ,A TRANSC5D5T MORALITY IS ALI5 TO ! SITUATION AT H&2 ITS LOGIC HAS NO NECESS>Y CONNECTION TO ! DESIRE ( ?OSE 9VOLV$ OR TO 9CREAS+ !IR PLEASURE4 ,IT IS A FIX$ LAW :OSE REASON+ IS ALWAYS 0BECAUSE ,I SAID SO10 0BECAUSE IT IS ! WORD ( GOD10 0BECAUSE IT IS WRONG10 OR 0BECAUSE IT IS ! LAW & :AT W\LD HAPP5 )\T ! LAW40 ,AN E?IC IS A TOOL = ! ACTIVE CREATION ( \R [N LIVES2 IT IS NEV] AN IMPOS$ DECISION1 A B\N 9 ! /RUGGLE AGA9/ IMPOS$ DECISION IS H[ TO ACT1 H[ TO BECOME MORE P[]FUL 9 \R ACTION4 ,AN>*ISM IS AN E?IC 9 ! MO/ BASIC S5SE3 IT IS AN E?IC BECAUSE IT CALLS = DECISIONS TO REMA9 IMMAN5T TO ! SITUATION AT H& 9/EAD ( ALI5AT$ 9TO A TRANSC5D5T 9/ITUTION1 IT MOVES 9 AN ANTAGONI/IC RELATION%IP TO ALL TRANSC5D5T MORALITY & 9/ITUTIONS1 SU* AS ! /ATE1 ! P>TY & ! *UR*4 ,P[] & ! ALI5ATION ( P[] ,HUMAN NATURE HAS BE5 A F\NDATIONAL CONCEPT = MANY AN>*I/S4 ,AS SU*1 ! >GUM5T RUNS1 HUMAN NATURE IS GOOD & P[]1 :I* CON/RICTS & W>PS ?AT NATURE1 IS BAD4 ,AN>*ISM BECOMES A PHILOSOPHY ?AT /&S = GETT+ RID ( P[] & ALL[+ ! GOOD NATURE ( HUMANS TO FL\RI%4 ,9 ?IS SECTION1 WE DEVELOP A DIFF]5T UND]/&+ ( P[]1 AN UND]/&+ ?AT DOESN'T AUTOMATICALLY DEF9E P[] AS BAD4 ,9/EAD ( SETT+ A P>TICUL> CONCEPTION ( HUMAN NATURE AS ! F\NDATION ( AN>*ISM1 !RE=E1 WE SUGGE/ ?AT AN E?IC ( DESIRE IS ! PROP] F\NDATION = AN>*I/ ACTION & ORGANIZATION4 ,P[] IS ! POT5TIAL TO EX]T A =CE1 ! ABILITY TO CREATE & TRANS=M4 ,CAPITALISM ALI5ATES ?AT POT5TIAL FROM US 9 ! PRODUCTION PROCESS4 ,! /ATE ALSO ALI5ATES \R P[]2 9 FACT1 ! /ATE IS A =M ( ALI5AT$ P[] ?AT HAS BE5 9/ITUT$1 ?AT HAS BE5 CON/ITUT$ 9 ! /ATE =M4 ,9 ITS ALI5AT$ =M1 P[] BECOMES ! POT5TIAL & ABILITY TO MAKE O!RS EX]T A =CE1 TO DO WORK1 OR ! ABILITY TO PREV5T US FROM EX]T+ A =CE4 ,IT IS A P[] ?AT HAS BE5 EXTRACT$ FROM ! SOCIAL BODY ?R\< A COMPLEX PROCESS ( =CE & CONS5T4 ,CAPITALISM & ! /ATE SEP>ATE ! MOM5T ( DECISION FROM ! ACT ( ITS REALIZATION 9 BO? SPACE & TIME3 A DECISION IS MADE BE=E ! ACTION HAS BEGUN & IT IS MADE 9 A DIFF]5T PLACE1 9 SOME (FICE ( ! /ATE1 CORPORATE BO>DROOM1 OR ORGANIZ]'S MEET+4 ,A LAW CAN BE MADE YE>S BE=E IT COMES TO CONTROL AN ACT4 ,! =M ( ALI5AT$ P[] T5DS T[>DS FIXIVITY1 ( SETT+ & MA9TA9+ AN ORD] & A SET ( 9/ITUTIONS -- LIKE ! HEAVY-SET GRANITE /RUCTURES ?AT H\SE ! 9/ITUTIONS !MSELVES -- ?AT /& ABOVE SOCIETY2 IT CAN ?US BE CALL$ CON/ITUT$ OR TRANSC5D5T P[]4 ,IF P[] IS ! POT5TIAL TO EX]T A =CE1 ! ABILITY TO ACT 9 A CREATIVE1 TRANS=MATIVE1 PRODUCTIVE1 OR DE/RUCTIVE WAY1 ! /ATE AS A TRANSC5D5T 9/ITUTION IS ?AT :I* CUTS US (F OR SEP>ATES US FROM \R ACTIVE P[]4 ,\R P[] IS ALI5AT$ FROM US1 TAK5 FROM US1 & 9/ITUT$ 9 ! /ATE4 ,WE >E ONLY ALL[$ TO ACT 9 C]TA9 WAYS1 :]EAS ! /ATE CON/ANTLY ACTS & DECIDES = US1 ACTS 9 \R NAME1 OR =CES US TO ACT 9 C]TA9 WAYS4 ,IT CUTS US (F FROM ! CREATIVE 5]GY ( DESIRE ITSELF4 ,:5 P[] HAS NOT BE5 ALI5AT$1 IT REMA9S IMMAN5T )9 9DIVIDUALS & ! SOCIAL BODY AS A :OLE4 ,&1 SO LONG AS IT IS NOT SEP>AT$ FROM ! ACT ITSELF1 IT REMA9S A CREATIVE1 PRODUCTIVE1 & TRANS=MATIVE POT5TIAL1 = IT REFUSES A FIX$ ORD]4 ,AS ,KROPOTK9 /ATES1 0,N[ ALL HI/ORY1 ALL ! EXP]I5CE ( ! HUMAN RACE & ALL SOCIAL PSY*OLOGY1 UNITE 9 %[+ ?AT ! BE/ & FAIRE/ WAY IS TO TRU/ ! DECISION TO ?OSE :OM IT CONC]NS MO/ NE>LY40 ,BUT !RE IS ALWAYS A DANG] ?AT ?IS P[] WILL BE RECUP]AT$ BY GR\PS TO =M 9/ITUTIONS & WILL BECOME A CON/ITUT$1 TRANSC5D5T P[] ?AT /&S ABOVE ! SOCIAL BODY3 ! REVOLUTION>Y P[] ( ?OSE /RUGGL+ AGA9/ CAPITALISM & ! /ATE CAN BE FROZ5 9 ! =M ( '! ,P>TY' &1 F9ALLY1 ! /ATE ITSELF4 ,9 /UDY+ PRIMITIVE SOCIETIES1 ,PI]RE ,CLA/RES DISCOV]$ ?AT SOCIETIES )\T A /ATE W]E REALLY 0SOCIETIES AGA9/ ! /ATE40 ,!Y ORGANIZ$ ! SOCIAL BODY 9 SU* A WAY ?AT W>D$ (F ! CON/ITUTION ( ALI5AT$ P[] 9TO AN 9/ITUTION SEP>ATE FROM SOCIETY4 ,/ABLE1 CONS]V$ P[] IS PREV5T$ FROM CRY/ALLIZ+ 9TO A H>D5$ /ATE =M4 ,AS ,DELUEZE & ,GUATT>I PO9T \T1 ! /ATE 0IS DEF9$ BY ! P]PETUATION OR CONS]VATION ( ORGANS ( P[]4 ,! CONC]N ( ! ,/ATE IS TO CONS]VE40 ,?US ! /ATE IS ! POLITICAL ORGANIZATION ( PASSIVITY4 ,AN?ROPOLOGI/S HAVE NOT$ ! APPE>ANCE ( CONS]V$ ORGANS ( P[] 9 SMALL-SCALE SOCIETIES & HAVE CALL$ SU* E>LY ORGANS 'IMP]SONAL 9/ITUTIONS4' ,IMP]SONAL 9/ITUTIONS >E DI/+UI%$ FROM AN AU?ORITY ?AT IS BAS$ ON P]SONAL ABILITIES OR QUALITIES1 AN AU?ORITY ?AT 5DS :5 EI!R ?AT P]SON DIES1 !Y >E NO LONG] SE5 AS HOLD+ ?OSE P]SONAL ABILITIES1 OR :5 ?OSE ABILITIES >E NO LONG] USEFUL TO SOCIETY4 ,SOMEONE C\LD BECOME KN[N AS A GREAT HUNT] 9 A B& SOCIETY & TRU/$ AS AN AU?ORITY ON HUNT+2 ?AT AU?ORITY IS VE/$ P]SONALLY 9 ! 9DIVIDUAL4 ,A SOCIETY C\LD HAVE SEV]AL 9DIVIDUALS ) SU* AU?ORITY OR IT C\LD HAVE NONE4 ,AS SU*1 AU?ORITY DOES NOT CRY/ALLIZE 9TO AN 9/ITUTION ?AT T5DS T[>DS P]MAN5CE1 9TO IMP]SONAL 9/ITUTIONS4 ,BUT ONCE AU?ORITY COMES TO BE 9/ITUTIONALIZ$ 9TO A P]MAN5T POSITION ?AT IS FILL$ AS AN IMP]SONAL ROLE1 P[] BEG9S TO BE CONS]V$ & SEP>AT$ FROM SOCIETY ITSELF4 ,! ,PRESID5T IS AN IMP]SONAL 9/ITUTION 9 ?AT ! AU?ORITY ( ! ,PRESID5CY CONT9UES AFT] ONE ,PRESID5T LEAVES & ANO!R TAKES !IR PLACE2 ! AU?ORITY RE/S 9 ! 9/ITUTION4 ,SU* IMP]SONAL 9/ITUTIONS >E OP5+S ?AT ALL[ ! /ATE TO SL[LY =M ABOVE SOCIETY4 ,BUT ! SOCIETY AGA9/ ! /ATE1 ?AT ATTEMPTS TO W>D (F OR DE/ROY ! /ATE1 DOES NOT DIE AS ! /ATE GR[S 9TO A H>D5$1 UGLY BODY2 9 FACT1 ! SOCIETY AGA9/ ! /ATE IS CONT9UALLY REEM]G+ & TRANS=M+ ITS ME?ODS AS ! MOVEM5T ( ! EXPLOIT$ & EXCLUD$ TO DECIDE !IR [N FATE4 ,! LONG & TWI/$ HI/ORY ( ! DEVELOPM5T ( ! /ATE & ! CREATIVE MOVEM5T ( ! SOCIETY AGA9/ ! /ATE HAS BE5 WRITT5 & ANALYZ$ ELSE:]E4 ,?IS HI/ORY HAS BR\I$3 :ILE ! P>TY DICTATOR%IP1 A =M ?AT /ILL EXI/S1 IS AN OBVI\S EXAMPLE ( ALI5AT$1 TRANSC5D5T P[]1 ! DEMOCRATIC =M ( ALI5AT$ P[] NO LESS SEP>ATES DECISION FROM ! ACT1 NO LESS SEP>ATES US FROM \R ACTIVE P[]S4 ,AS ) ! SOCIETY AGA9/ ! /ATE1 AN>*I/S MU/ ALWAYS FIIAN4 ,?IS IS NOT ONLY BECAUSE SU* TRANSC5D5T P[] SEP>ATES US FROM \R P[] TO ACT ON \R DESIRES1 BUT ALSO BECAUSE AS SOON AS \R ACTIVE P[] -- \R P[] TO TRANS=M SOCIETY & TO CREATE \R [N LIVES -- BEG9S TO H>D5 9TO A P]MAN5T ORD]1 A P]MAN5T ORGANIZATION1 ONCE IMP]SONAL 9/ITUTIONS =M )9 \R MID/1 WE LOSE ! P[] TO ATTACK ! /ATE & CAPITALISM EFFECTIVELY4 ,VALUE1 MEASURE1 & SOCIAL ORGANIZATION ,! MOVEM5T ( ! EXPLOIT$1 ! EXCLUD$1 ( ! SOCIETY AGA9/ ! /ATE1 IS A MOVEM5T TO DE/ROY ! SEP>ATION BETWE5 HUMANS & !IR CONDITIONS ( EXI/5CE4 ,IT IS A MOVEM5T TO BUILD NEW SOCIAL RELATIONS )\T MEASURE4 ,IT IS A REVOLT AGA9/ ! IMPOSITION ( A S+LE REGIME ( VALUE4 ,LOOK+ AT ! MANY /RUGGLES ?AT >E BE+ CALL$ 0! ANTI-GLOBALIZATION MOVEM5T10 WE CAN SEE 9 !IR DIV]SITY A COMPLEX PATT]N ( ATTACK ON & DEF5SE FROM CAPITALI/ VALORIZATION4 ,!SE /RUGGLES >E HET]OG5E\S 9 ?AT NO S+LE SOLUTION OR SY/EM ( VALORIZATION IS BE+ (F]$ TO REPLACE CAPITALISM 7?US !SE /RUGGLES CAN NOT BE CONTA9$ BY A S+LE ORGANIZATION74 ,YET1 :ILE !Y >E HET]OG5E\S1 !RE IS A PATT]N1 & ?AT PATT]N IS PRODUC$ BY ! FACT ?AT !Y >E ALL FI & HEGEMONIC REGIME ( VALORIZATION1 CAPITALISM1 ?AT IS 9VAD+ EV]Y HUMAN PRACTICE & RELATION%IP4 ,ALI5ATION IS ! GAP BETWE5 DESIRE & :AT IS SOCIALLY VALU$1 BETWE5 \R POT5TIAL TO TRANS=M ! WORLD & ! !FT & P>ASITIC USE ( ?AT P[] BY CAPITAL & ! /ATE4 ,AS ?AT P[] COMES TO BE ALI5AT$ 9 ! /ATE =M1 SOCIETY COMES TO BE 9CREAS+LY RUL$ BY NUMB]S TO ! EXT5T ?AT HUMANS !MSELVES >E EV5 R$UC$ TO 9T]*ANGEABLE NUMB]S4 ,ONE ( ! /ATE'S MO/ IMPORTANT ROLES IS TO BE ! GU>ANTOR ( MEASURE3 ! /ATE MA9TA9S ! VALUE ( MONEY1 ! G5]AL EQUIVAL5T1 IT SETS ! L[ PO9T = WAGES1 TAXES1 & GU>ANTEES ! MEASURE & PROTECTION ( PROP]TY4 ,! /ATE USES NUMB]S TO R$UCE SOCIAL PROBLEMS TO SIMPLE MA? PROBLEMS ) SOLUTIONS4 ,BUT SOCIETY ISN'T SO EASILY QUANTIFI$ & R$UC$2 SOCIETY ISN'T JU/ A PROBLEM ?AT CAN BE SOLV$ ) A RUL]4 ,?US1 EV]Y SOLUTION IS 9 REALITY A REPRESSION ( ! PROBLEM OR A %IFT+ ( ! PROBLEM TO A NEW LEVEL OR DIFF]5T SECTOR ( SOCIETY4 ,SOLUTION & REPRESSION >E A TW9$ PAIR4 ,! L>GE/ ( SU* SOCIAL PROBLEMS ?AT /ATES HAVE TO CONT5D ) >E ! DI/RIBUTION ( WEAL?1 ! M$IATION ( SOCIAL CONFLICTS ?AT ]UPT FROM ITS UNEQUAL DI/RIBUTION1 & ! REPRODUCTION ( SOCIETY ITSELF4 ,OV] ?IS C5TURY1 TWO SOLUTIONS TO ! PROBLEM ( ! DI/RIBUTION ( WEAL?1 ! SETT+ ( VALUE1 HAVE DOM9AT$ ! WORLD3 ,WE/]N CAPITALISM & ,SOVIET COMMUNISM4 ,BO? SY/EMS SEP>ATE HUMANS FROM !IR CONDITIONS ( EXI/5CE1 FROM :AT !Y NE$ TO LIVE & FOLL[ !IR DESIRES4 ,BO? SY/EMS ALSO RELY ON TRANSC5D5T 9/ITUTIONS ( P[] TO MA9TA9 !IR SY/EMS ( VALORIZATION4 ,9 ! ,WE/1 CAPITALI/ VALORIZATION RELIES ON ! /ATE TO GU>ANTEE ! G5]AL EQUIVAL5T & TO MA9TA9 ! PRIVATE PROP]TY /RUCTURE ?AT SEP>ATES US FROM :AT WE NE$ TO LIVE4 ,! HUMAN IS ?US SPLIT 9TO A PRODUC] ( GOODS = SALE & A CONSUM] ( O!R GOODS4 ,?IS SPLIT ALL[S ! EXTRACTION ( SURPLUS VALUE1 & IT IS ! PRODUCTION ( SURPLUS VALUE ?AT DEF9ES ONE AS PRODUCTIVE1 PRODUC+ &1 ?US1 HAV+ VALUE 9 SOCIETY4 ,! ,SOVIET SY/EM WAS A DIFF]5T SOLUTION TO ! SAME PROBLEM4 ,ONE'S VALUE )9 ! ,SOVIET SY/EM WAS SET BY A DIFF]5T MEASURE4 ,)9 ! ,SOVIET SY/EM1 VALUE OP]AT$ AS A QUANTIFI$1 MEASUR$ NE$ AS SET BY ! TRANSC5D5T 9TUITION ( ! /ATE4 ,! /ATE1 AS AN ALI5 9/ITUTION1 A =M ( ALI5AT$ P[]1 DECID$ :AT WAS NE$$ ?R\< ITS GREAT1 CALCULAT+ BUREAUCRATIC APP>ATUS4 ,BY TREAT+ SOCIETY AS A MA!MATICAL PROBLEM1 ! ,SOVIET SY/EM GU>ANTE$ AN EQUALITY & HOMOG5EITY ( EXI/5CE4 ,IT FLATT5$ DESIRE & 9DIVIDUALS4 ,DESIRES W]E JUDG$ TO BE ( SOCIAL VALUE OR NOT BY COMMITTEE4 ,USE VALUE CAME TO BE SET BY A MORAL SY/EM ?AT /OOD \TSIDE ( SOCIETY4 ,9 ! ,SOVIET SY/EM HUMANS W]E NO LESS SEP>AT$ FROM !IR CONDITIONS ( EXI/5CE1 = A TRANSC5D5T SY/EM ( PROP]TY /ILL EXI/$ AS ! /ATE ITSELF DIRECTLY CONTROLL$ PROP]TY4 ,!RE IS1 H[EV]1 A DIFF]5T TYPE ( COMMUNISM1 ONE 9 :I* ! 9/ITUTIONS ( PRIVATE PROP]TY BACK$ UP BY /ATE P[] >E ABS5T2 ?IS COMMUNISM CAN BE DEF9$ BY ! EQUALITY ( ACCESS TO ! CONDITIONS ( EXI/5CE4 ,?IS E?IC IS AT ! HE>T ( ! MOVEM5T ( ! EXCLUD$1 ( ! SOCIETY AGA9/ ! /ATE1 ?AT ALWAYS REMA9S ANTAGONI/IC1 H[EV] 9COH]5T1 TO ! SEP>ATIONS ?AT CAPITAL & ! /ATE IMPOSE UPON IT4 ,?IS COMMUNISM (F]S NO MA!MATICAL SOLUTION1 IMPOS$ FROM ABOVE1 TO SOCIAL PROBLEMS4 ,!RE IS NO GU>ANTEE ( :AT 9DIVIDUALS & GR\PS WILL DO ) ! CONDITIONS ( EXI/5CE ONCE !Y HAVE ACCESS TO !M1 ?AT IS UP TO !IR DESIRES & ABILITIES4 ,RA!R1 9 ! ABS5CE ( TRANSC5D5T SOLUTIONS & 9/ITUTIONS1 SOCIAL RELATIONS & PROBLEMS REMA9 AS T5SIONS )9 SOCIETY1 T5SIONS ?AT >E WORK$ ?R\< IMMAN5TLY 9 PRACTICE4 ,VALUE COMES TO BE PRODUC$ IMMAN5TLY 9 E?ICAL PRACTICE1 AS A SELF-VALORIZATION ACTIVITY BY ?OSE 9VOLV$ 9 A C]TA9 SITUATION4 ,A S+LE REGIME ( VALUE NO LONG] COV]S & ORGANIZES ! SOCIAL T]RA94 ,?IS E?IC ( DESIRE1 :I* REMA9S FUNDAM5TAL TO ! MOVEM5T ( ! EXCLUD$1 IS ANTAGONI/IC TO ! CON/ITUT$ SOCIAL ORD] ?AT SEP>ATES ! MULTITUDE FROM ITS CONDITIONS ( EXI/5CE2 &1 IT IS \T ( ?IS ANTAGONISM ?AT AN>*I/ PRACTICE -- AS IMMAN5T TO ! MOVEM5T ( ! EXCLUD$ MULTITUDES -- GR[S4 ,JU/ AS SELF-VALORIZATION BECOMES AN E?ICAL PRACTICE = ! EXCLUD$1 9=MAL ORGANIZATION1 9 /RUGGLE AGA9/ CAPITAL & ! /ATE1 BECOMES AN E?ICAL PRACTICE = AN>*I/S3 BO? CREATE SOCIAL RELATIONS BEYOND MEASURE4 ,P>T ,I,I3 ,! ,AN>*I/ E?IC & ! ORGANIZATION ( ATTACK ,! />T+ PO9T = UND]/&+ ! RELATION%IP BETWE5 AN>*I/S & ! NEW SOCIAL MOVEM5TS IS TO RECOGNIZE ?AT WE >E A M9ORITY )9 ! MOVEM5T4 ,?IS IS1 ( C\RSE1 ! NORMAL POSITION = AN>*I/S1 BUT IT DOES CALL = A SPECIFIC !ORETICAL ?9K+ & PRACTICE 9 ORD] = US TO EFFECTIVELY OP]ATE 9 SU* A CONTEXT4 ,AN>*I/S >E HOPEFULLY AT AN 9SURRECTIONAL LEVEL ( /RUGGLE1 !Y >E1 = ! MO/ P>T1 WORK+ T[>DS 9SURRECTION1 :ILE ! MOVEM5T 9 G5]AL /RUGGLES AT AN 9T]M$IATE LEVEL4 ,:AT DOES ?IS MEAN8 ,AN>*I/S1 EXCEPT ?OSE :O HOLD A DET]M9I/ & EVOLUTION>Y VIEW ( HI/ORY1 UND]/& ?AT 9SURRECTION1 :I* DE/ROYS ! TRANSC5D5T 9/ITUTIONS ( /ATE & CAPITAL & ALL[S ! REALIZATION SOCIAL RELATIONS ?AT >E IMMAN5TLY ORGANIZ$1 IS ALWAYS POSSIBLE AS AN \TCOME ( /RUGGLE4 ,?US AN>*I/S %\LD ALWAYS BE WORK+ T[>DS ! GOAL ( 9SURRECTION4 ,! /RUGGLE ( ! NEW SOCIAL MOVEM5TS ?AT HAVE DEVELOP$ OV] ! #a#i#i'S1 H[EV]1 >E MO/LY AT AN 9T]M$IATE LEVEL1 A LEVEL 9 :I* SPECIFIC 9/ITUTIONS MAY BE ATTACK$ )\T A CLE> GOAL ( 9SURRECTION AGA9/ CAPITAL & ! /ATE4 ,DIRECT ACTION AGA9/ ! ,W,T,O1 ! ,I,M,F1 & ! ,WORLD ,BANK1 ! MOVEM5T TO DE/ROY G5ETICALLY MODIFI$ CROPS1 ! MOVEM5T ( ! L&LESS TO DIRECTLY APPROPRIATE ! CONDITIONS ( !IR EXI/5CE1 & ! DIRECT ACTION 5VIRONM5TAL MOVEM5T ALL CONTA9 ! POT5TIAL ( MOV+ T[>DS 9SURRECTION4 ,AN>*I/S MU/ OP5 & DEVELOP ?AT POT5TIAL4 ,!RE >E O!RS )9 !SE SOCIAL MOVEM5TS ?AT1 :E!R CONSCI\SLY OR NOT1 WORK TO CLOSE ! POSSIBILITY ( 9SURRECTION4 ,?IS (T5 HAPP5S AS A RESULT ( C]TA9 =MS ( ORGANIZATION & ORGANIZ+ ACTIVITY4 ,P]MAN5T ORGANIZATIONS1 ORGANIZATIONS ?AT ATTEMPT TO SYN!SIZE ! MULTITUDE ( ?OSE /RUGGL+ 9TO A S+LE1 UNIFI$ ORGANIZATION1 & ORGANIZATIONS ?AT ATTEMPT TO M$IATE /RUGGLE >E ALL =MS ( ORGANIZATION ?AT T5D TO CLOSE ! POT5TIAL ( 9SURRECTION4 ,BE=E DISCUSS+ ! QUE/ION ( ORGANIZATION FUR!R1 WE NE$ TO CL>IFY H[ WE WILL USE ! T]MS '! MULTITUDE' & '! MASS4' ,! MULTITUDE IS :AT WE WILL CALL ALL ?OSE :O >E EXCLUD$ & EXPLOIT$ BY CAPITALISM2 IT IS ! MULTITUDE ?AT /RUGGLES AGA9/ ! /ATE & CAPITALISM1 IT IS ! MULTITUDE ?AT MAKES UP ! SOCIETY AGA9/ ! /ATE4 ,! MASS IS ! MULTITUDE AS IT HAS BE5 SYN!SIZ$ 9TO A S+UL> BLOCK & DISCIPL9$ TO ACT 9 A UNIFI$ MANN]4 ,JU/ AS A NATION-/ATE MU/ TRANS=M A MULTITUDE ( PEOPLE 9TO '! ,PEOPLE' OR CITIZ5S 9 ORD] TO CREATE A DISCIPL9$ NATION1 & ! *UR* MU/ MORALLY DISCIPL9E ITS MEMB]S TO PRODUCE A FLOCK1 ORGANIZATIONS ( SYN!SIS1 SU* AS '! ,P>TY1' MU/ %APE ! MULTITUDE 9TO A MASS 9 ORD] TO CONTROL ITS MOVEM5T4 ,! NATION-/ATE1 ! *UR*1 & ! ,P>TY >E ALL TRANSC5D5T 9/ITUTIONS 9 RELATION TO A MULTITUDE 9 ?AT !Y ALL /& ABOVE & \TSIDE ! MULTITUDE & YET ATTEMPT TO ORGANIZE ITS SOCIAL RELATIONS4 ,!Y SWOOP D[N UPON ! MULTITUDE ) A GRID ( ID5TITY 9TO :I* ALL MU/ FIT -- ALL RELATION%IPS >E ORGANIZ$ FROM ! \TSIDE ) SU* A GRID4 ,= AN>*I/S1 ! QUE/ION ( ORGANIZATION1 H[EV]1 IS AN E?ICAL 7IMMAN5T7 9/EAD ( MORAL 7TRANSC5D5T7 QUE/ION3 9 A GIV5 SITUATION1 H[ DO WE COMB9E 9 A WAY ?AT PROMOTES \R ACTIVE P[]S8 ,H[ DO WE BR+ A MULTITUDE TOGE!R 9 A WAY ?AT DOESN'T LIMIT \R POT5TIAL1 \R P[] TO ACT1 & \R DIFF]5T DESIRES8 ,9 ! WAKE ( ,SEATTLE & ,PRAGUE MANY ORGANIZ]S >E DISCUSS+ H[ TO BUILD & CONTROL ! MOVEM5T4 ,!Y TALK AS IF !Y >E >TI/S /&+ OV] A LUMP ( CLAY -- ! MULTITUDE -- ?AT NE$S TO BE %AP$1 DISCIPL9$4 ,! DISCUSSION USUALLY LEADS TO TALK ( ! NE$ TO LIMIT ! ACTIONS ( ! MO/ CONFRONTATIONAL & TO BE BETT] 'ORGANIZ$4' ,CONC]N+ ! ,PRAGUE DEMON/RATIONS1 ONE 0,AM]ICAN ORGANIZ]0 /AT$1 0,IF WE >E REALLY S]I\S AB\T DO+ AN ACTION1 !N WE NE$ TO MAKE C]TA9 !RE >E DE-ESCALATION TEAMS1 PEOPLE :O >E RESPONSIBLE = BREAK+ UP ! VIOL5CE40 ,! GOAL ( ! TYPE ( ORGANIZATION ?AT !Y PROMOTE1 H[EV]1 IS TO LIMIT DIRECT CONFRONTATIONAL ACTION & TO 5C\RAGE DIALOGUE & M$IATION4 ,NAIVELY1 !Y WANT TO H>NESS ! P[] ( A MASS ( BODIES 9 ORD] TO GET A SEAT AT ! TABLE ( P[]4 ,= AN>*I/S1 ( C\RSE1 BE+ AGA9/ CAPITALISM & ! /ATE 9 !IR 5TIRETY1 !RE CAN BE NO DIALOGUE ) CON/ITUT$ P[]1 ) ! TRANSC5D5T 9/ITUTIONS ( ! /ATE & CAPITAL4 ,! WILL+NESS ( ?OSE TRANSC5D5T 9/ITUTIONS TO 9ITIATE A DIALOGUE MAY BE A SIGN ( !IR FE> & WEAKNESS1 BUT IT IS ALSO ! BEG9N+ ( \R DEFEAT :5 WE LIMIT \R ACTIVE P[] TO JO9 !M 9 DISCUSSION4 ,\R ACTIVE P[]1 \R P[] TO CREATE & TRANS=M1 IS \R ONLY WEAPON1 & ?AT :I* LIMITS SU* P[] FROM )9 ! MOVEM5T IS \R GREATE/ WEAKNESS4 ,?IS DOES NOT MEAN ?AT WE %\LD REMA9 UNORGANIZ$2 9 FACT1 IT POSES ! V]Y QUE/ION ( ORGANIZATION3 H[ DO WE COMB9E 9 A WAY ?AT PROMOTES \R ACTIVE P[]S8 ,! AN>*I/ E?IC IS ALWAYS A CRITICAL E?IC1 & ?US IT D5\NCES EV]Y?+ ?AT CUTS US (F FROM & DIM9I%ES \R P[] TO ACT4 ,AS NOT$ ABOVE1 ONE ( ! GREATE/ DANG]S TO ! DEVELOPM5T ( ! NEW SOCIAL MOVEM5TS 9 A POSITIVE DIRECTION IS ?AT =MS ( ORGANIZATION ?AT CUT US (F FROM \R ACTIVE P[] & CLOSE (F ! POT5TIAL ( 9SURRECTION 9 ! PRES5T MOM5T BECOME DOM9ANT3 !SE >E P]MAN5T1 SYN!SIZ+1 & M$IAT+ ORGANIZATIONS4 ,P]MAN5T ORGANIZATIONS T5D TO DEVELOP 9TO TRANSC5D5T 9/ITUTIONS 9 RELATION TO ! /RUGGL+ MULTITUDE4 ,!Y T5D TO DEVELOP A =MAL OR 9=MAL HI]>*Y & TO DISEMP[] ! MULTITUDE3 P[] IS ALI5AT$ FROM ITS ACTIVE =M )9 ! MULTITUDE & 9/ITUT$ )9 ! ORGANIZATION4 ,?IS TRANS=MS ! ACTIVE MULTITUDE 9TO A PASSIVE MASS4 ,! HI]>*ICAL CON/ITUTION ( P[]-RELATIONS REMOVES DECISION FROM ! MOM5T -- ! IMMAN5CE -- ( ITS NECESSITY4 ,! PRACTICAL CONSEQU5CES ( SU* AN ORGANIZATION IS ?AT ! ACTIVE P[]S ( ?OSE 9VOLV$ 9 ! /RUGGLE >E /IFL$ BY ! ORGANIZATION4 ,DECISIONS ?AT %\LD BE MADE BY ?OSE 9VOLV$ 9 AN ACTION >E DEF]R$ TO ! ORGANIZATION2 &1 P]MAN5T ORGANIZATIONS T5D TO MAKE DECISIONS BAS$ NOT ON ! NECESSITY ( A SPECIFIC GOAL OR ACTION1 BUT ON ! NE$S ( ?AT ORGANIZATION1 ESPECIALLY ITS PRES]VATION4 ,! ORGANIZATION BECOMES AN 5D 9 ITSELF4 ,AS AN ORGANIZATION MOVES T[>DS P]MAN5CE & COMES TO /& ABOVE ! MULTITUDE1 ! ORGANIZ] APPE>S1 (T5 CLAIM+ TO HAVE CREAT$ ! /RUGGLE1 & BEG9S TO SPEAK = ! MASS4 ,IT IS ! JOB ( ! ORGANIZ] TO TRANS=M ! MULTITUDE 9TO A CONTROLLABLE MASS & TO REPRES5T ?AT MASS TO ! M$IA4 ,ORGANIZ]S R>ELY VIEWS !MSELVES AS P>T ( ! MULTITUDE2 !Y /& \TSIDE ( IT1 TRANSC5D5T TO IT1 & TALK ( 'REA*+ \T TO ! COMMUNITY1' 'AWAK5+ ! MASSES1' & 'BUILD+ ! ORGANIZATION & MOVEM5T' AS IF 9SURRECTION WAS A GAME ( NUMB]S4 ,?US1 AS \TSID]S1 !Y DON'T SEE IT AS !IR TASK TO ACT1 TO DO ACTIONS1 BUT TO PROPAG&IZE & ORGANIZE1 = IT IS ! MASSES ?AT ACT4 ,!IR WOR/ FE> IS ALI5AT+ ! 'REAL MASSES' ?US IMAGE BECOMES ALL-IMPORTANT4 ,AFT] ,SEATTLE MANY ORGANIZ]S W]E WORRI$ AB\T ! EFFECT ?AT PROP]TY DE/RUCTION W\LD HAVE ON ! IMAGE ( ! MOVEM5T1 & W5T TO GREAT L5G?S TO DI/ANCE !MSELVES FROM ! P]PETRATORS ( SU* ACTS4 ,DIRECT ,ACTION ,NETWORK W5T TO ! EXTREME ( NOT (F]+ LEGAL AID TO ?OSE *>G$ ) FELONIES DUR+ ! ,SEATTLE PROTE/S4 ,SEEM+LY1 !Y SUBSCRIBE TO ,NAPOLEONIC LAW 9 :I* ! ACCUS$ >E PRESUM$ GUILTY1 NOT 9NOC5T4 ,AGA91 !IR IMAGE WAS AT /AKE4 ,LAT]1 9 ,L4,A41 ! ,AUGU/ COLLECTIVE ASK$ ,D4,A4,N4 IF !Y C\LD USE ITS SPACE = ! ,L4,A4 AN>*I/ CONF]5CE4 ,D4,A4,N4 DECL9$ EXPLA9+ ?AT AN>*I/S 9 G5]AL W]E TOO :ITE & TOO MALE1 & ?IS W\LD AFFECT ,D4,A4,N4'S ABILITY TO REA* \T TO ! COMMUNITY4 ,9 O!R WORDS1 !Y WANT$ TO APPE> TO BE 9 T\* ) ! COMMUNITY1 & AN>*I/S W\LD HURT !IR IMAGE4 ,= ! ORGANIZ]1 :O TAKES AS HIS_/H] MOTTO 'ONLY ?AT :I* APPE>S 9 ! M$IA EXI/S1' CONCRETE ACTION ALWAYS TAKES A BACK SEAT TO ! MA9T5ANCE ( M$IA IMAGE4 ,! GOAL ( SU* IMAGE MA9T5ANCE IS NEV] TO ATTACK A SPECIFIC TRANSC5D5T 9/ITUTION1 BUT TO AFFECT PUBLIC OP9ION1 =EV] BUILD ! MOVEM5T OR1 EV5 WORSE1 ! ORGANIZATION4 ,! ORGANIZ] MU/ ALWAYS WORRY AB\T H[ ! ACTIONS ( O!RS WILL REFLECT ON ! MOVEM5T2 !Y MU/1 !RE=E1 BO? ATTEMPT TO DISCIPL9E ! /RUGGL+ MULTITUDE & TRY TO CONTROL H[ ! MOVEM5T IS REPRES5T$ 9 ! M$IA4 ,IMAGE REPLACES ACTION = ! P]MAN5T ORGANIZATION & ! ORGANIZ] :O OP]ATES )9 ! SOCIETY ( ! SPECTACLE4 ,! ATTEMPT TO CONTROL ! VA/ IMAGE & OP9ION-MAK+ FACTORIES ( \R SOCIETY IS A LOS+ BATTLE1 AS IF WE C\LD EV] TRY TO MAT* ! QUANTITY ( IMAGES PUT =W>D BY ! M$IA OR GET !M TO 'TELL ! TRU?4' ,TO COME TO A BETT] UND]/&+ ( ! PROBLEMS 9VOLV$ 9 SU* A BATTLE & H[ ! 'ORGANIZ]' OP]ATES1 WE NE$ TO FIR/ BETT] COMPREH5D H[ 'OP9ION' FUNCTIONS 9 SOCIETY4 ,ON A BASIC LEVEL1 WE NE$ TO ASK1 :AT IS OP9ION8 ,AN OP9ION IS NOT SOME?+ FIR/ F\ND AMONG ! PUBLIC 9 G5]AL & !N1 AFT]W>DS1 REPLAY$ ?R\< ! M$IA1 AS A SIMPLE REPORT+ ( ! PUBLIC OP9ION4 ,AN OP9ION EXI/S 9 ! M$IA FIR/2 IT IS PRODUC$ BY ! M$IA NOT ! MULTITUDE4 ,SECONDLY1 ! M$IA !N REPRODUCES ! OP9ION A MILLION TIMES OV] L9K+ ! OP9ION UP TO A C]TA9 TYPE ( P]SON 7CONS]VATIVES ?9K X1 LIB]ALS ?9K Y74 ,?IRDLY1 AS ,ALFR$O ,BONANNO PO9TS \T1 0.<,AN OP9ION.> IS A FLATT5$ IDEA1 AN IDEA ?AT HAS BE5 UNI=M$ 9 ORD] TO MAKE IT ACCEPTABLE TO ! L>GE/ NUMB] ( PEOPLE4 ,OP9IONS >E MASSIFI$ IDEAS40 ,PUBLIC OP9ION IS PRODUC$ AS A S]IES ( SIMPLE *OICES OR SOLUTIONS 7',I'M = GLOBALIZATION & FREE TRADE1' OR ',I'M = MORE NATIONAL CONTROL & PROTECTIONISM'74 ,WE >E ALL SUPPOS$ TO *OOSE -- AS WE *OOSE \R LEAD]S OR \R BURG]S -- 9/EAD ( ?9K = \RSELVES4 ,IT IS OBVI\S1 !RE=E1 ?AT AN>*I/S CANNOT USE ! OP9ION-MAK+ FACTORY TO CREATE C\NT]-OP9IONS1 & HOPEFULLY AN>*I/S W\LD NEV] WANT TO OP]ATE ON ! LEVEL ( OP9ION EV5 IF WE C\LD SOMEH[ EX]T CONTROL OV] ! CONT5T SPEW$ \T ( ! FACTORY GATES4 ,ANYH[1 ! AN>*I/ E?IC C\LD NEV] BE COMMUNICAT$ 9 ! =M ( OP9ION1 IT W\LD DIE ONCE MASSIFI$4 ,H[EV]1 IT IS EXACTLY ON ! LEVEL ( OP9ION ?AT ! ORGANIZ] WORKS1 = OP9ION & IMAGE-MA9T5ANCE >E ! V]Y TOOLS ( P[]1 TOOLS US$ TO %APE & DISCIPL9E A MULTITUDE 9TO A CONTROLLABLE MASS4 ',! ,P>TY' IS A P]MAN5T ORGANIZATION ?AT ATTEMPTS TO SYN!SIZE ALL /RUGGLE 9TO ONE CONTROLLABLE ORGANIZATION2 9 DO+ SO1 IT CUTS ! MULTITUDE (F FROM ITS ACTIVE P[] & CLOSES ! DOOR TO 9SURRECTION4 ,= ! ,P>TY1 ! /RUGGLE IS ALWAYS 9 ! FUTURE1 AT SOME MY?ICAL TIME2 ! PRES5T IS = POLITICAL WORK1 = RECRUIT+ & DISCIPL9+ P>TY MEMB]S4 ,COMM5T+ ON ,PRAGUE1 ! ,COMMUNI/ ,P>TY ( ,GREAT ,BRITA9 NOT$ ?AT ! MO/ POSITIVE EV5T 9 ! LATE/ ,GLOBAL ,DAY ( ,ACTION WASN'T ! ACTION1 BUT ! FACT ?AT !Y SOLD OR DI/RIBUT$ #b1#a ISSUES ( ! ,WEEKLY ,WORK] & PASS$ \T #e1 LEAFLETS 7:AT !Y CALL POLITICAL WORK74 ,MEAN:ILE ! ,9T]NATIONAL ,SOCIALI/ ,ORGANIZATION 7! ,S,W,P7 CONC5TRAT$ ON IMAGE AT ! EXP5SE ( ACTION3 !Y CLAIM$ !Y W\LD BR+ #be PEOPLE BUT BR\*I/S1 :O C\LD MAKE DECISIONS )9 ! MOM5T ITSELF1 COV]$ ! 9T]SECTION AS BE/ !Y C\LD4 ,TRANSC5D5T ORGANIZATIONS1 SU* AS P]MAN5T ORGANIZATIONS & M$IAT+ ORGANIZATIONS1 BY !IR V]Y LOGIC1 WILL ALWAYS =GO ACTION & CLOSE ! POT5TIAL = 9SURRECTION4 ,BUT TRANSC5D5T ORGANIZATIONS1 SU* AS '! ,P>TY1' :ILE !Y CAN /IFLE ACTION1 CAN NEV] CONTA9 ! DESIRES & P[] ( ! MULTITUDE2 !Y >E ALWAYS DOOM$ TO FAILURE4 ,BUT1 AS AN>*I/S1 :O REFUSE SU* A VANGU>D1 TRANSC5D5T POSITION1 WE >E P>T ( ! MULTITUDE1 WE >E )9 IT1 WE >E IMMAN5T TO IT4 ,WE >E EXPLOIT$ AS ! MULTITUDE IS2 WE >E EXCLUD$ AS ! MULTITUDE IS4 ,:ILE ON ! ONE H& ! AN>*I/ E?IC IS ALWAYS A CRITICAL E?IC ?AT D5\NCES TRANSC5D5T 9/ITUTIONS & MORALITY1 IT IS ALSO ALWAYS A CON/RUCTIVE E?IC ?AT LEADS T[>DS ! BUILD+ ( NEW SOCIAL RELATIONS & NEW =MS ( ACTIVE P[]4 ,AS A M9ORITY )9 ! /RUGGL+ MULTITUDE1 WE *OOSE A =M ( ORGANIZATION ?AT FOLL[S BO? ! LOGIC ( \R POSITION )9 ! MOVEM5T ( ! EXPLOIT$ & ! AN>*I/ E?IC ( IMMAN5TLY ORGANIZ$ SOCIAL RELATIONS -- RELATIONS ?AT >E SELF-ORGANIZ$ 9/EAD ( ORGANIZ$ BY A TRANSC5D5T 9/ITUTION 7SU* AS ! /ATE1 ! *UR*1 OR ! P>TY7 :I* /&S \TSIDE ! MULTITUDE4 ,WE MU/ ORGANIZE \RSELVES 9 A MANN] ?AT WON'T T5D T[>DS P]MAN5CE & HI]>*Y1 :I* WON'T COME TO /& ABOVE ! MULTITUDE1 & *OOSES SELF-ACTIVITY OV] IMAGE & REPRES5TATION4 ,WE MU/ DEVELOP =MS ( ORGANIZATION ?AT OP5 TO ! POT5TIAL = 9SURRECTION & MOVE ! /RUGGLE 9 ?AT DIRECTION1 9/EAD ( ALWAYS %IFT+ ?AT POT5TIAL FUR!R 9TO ! FUTURE4 ,9=MAL ORGANIZATION ,:AT TYPE ( ORGANIZATION ALL[S DECISION TO OCCUR 9 ! MOM5T ( ITS NECESSITY8 ,WE CALL ORGANIZATION ?AT LACKS ! =MALITY & AU?ORITY :I* SEP>ATE ORGANIZ]S & ORGANIZ$1 9=MAL ORGANIZATION4 ,9 ?IS SECTION1 WE >E SPECIFICALLY DISCUSS+ ! ORGANIZATION ( SOCIAL /RUGGLE4 ,WE WILL DISCUSS SOME G5]AL PR9CIPLES ?AT HAVE GR[N \T ( PRACTICE4 ,JU/ AS SOME SMALL-SCALE SOCIETIES LACK =MAL IMP]SONAL 9/ITUTIONS1 9=MAL ORGANIZATION LACKS (FICES & HI]>*ICAL POSITIONS4 ,BECAUSE ! ORGANIZ]'S NATURE IS TO PLAN & CONTROL S_/HE (T5 PRIVILEGES ! P]PETUATION ( ! ORGANIZATION OV] O!R GOALS4 ,9=MAL ORGANIZATIONS DISSOLVE :5 !IR GOAL IS A*IEV$ OR AB&ON$1 !Y DO NOT P]PETUATE !MSELVES M]ELY = ! SAKE ( ! ORGANIZATION IF ! GOALS ?AT CAUS$ PEOPLE TO ORGANIZE HAVE CEAS$ TO EXI/4 ,! PASSAGE FROM 9=MAL TO =MAL OR P]MAN5T ORGANIZATION IS ANALOG\S TO ! MOM5T :5 A SMALL-SCALE SOCIETY CREATES IMP]SONAL 9/ITUTIONS2 IT IS A MOM5T 9 :I* ! GR\P'S P[] IS ALI5AT$ & PLAC$ \TSIDE ( IT4 ,9=MAL ORGANIZATION IS A MEANS = AFF9ITY GR\PS TO COORD9ATE EF=TS :5 NECESS>Y4 ,WE MU/ ALWAYS REMEMB] ?AT MANY ?+S CAN BE DONE EASI] ) AN AFF9ITY GR\P OR 9DIVIDUAL1 9 !SE CASES HI<] LEVELS ( ORGANIZATION JU/ MAKES ! DECISION MAK+ PROCESS CUMB]SOME1 IT /IFLES US4 ,! SMALLE/ AM\NT ( ORGANIZATION NECESS>Y TO A*IEVE ONES AIMS IS ALWAYS ! BE/ TO MAXIMIZE \R ACTIVE P[]S4 ,9=MAL ORGANIZATION MU/ BE BAS$ ON AN E?IC ( AUTONOM\S ACTION2 AUTONOMY IS NECESS>Y TO PREV5T \R ACTIVE P[]S FROM BECOM+ ALI5AT$1 TO PREV5T ! =MATION ( RELATIONS ( AU?ORITY4 ,AUTONOMY IS REFUS+ TO OBEY OR GIVE ORD]S1 :I* >E ALWAYS %\T$ FROM ABOVE OR BEYOND ! SITUATION4 ,AUTONOMY ALL[S DECISION TO OCCUR 9 & DUR+ ! SITUATION ( ITS NECESSITY1 9/EAD ( BE+ PR$ET]M9$ OR DELAY$ BY ! DECISION ( A COMMITTEE OR MEET+4 ,ORGANIZATIONAL PLAT=MS IMPOSE A =MALITY 9 ! DECISION MAK+ PROCESS ?AT 9HIBITS AUTONOMY4 ,?IS DOES NOT MEAN TO SAY H[EV] ?AT WE %\LDN'T ?9K /RATEGICALLY AB\T ! FUTURE & MAKE AGREEM5TS OR PLANS4 ,ON ! CONTR>Y1 PLANS & AGREEM5TS >E USEFUL & IMPORTANT4 ,:AT WE >E EMPHASIZ+ IS A FLEXIBILITY ?AT ALL[S PEOPLE TO DISC>D PLANS :5 !Y BECOME USELESS4 ,PLANS %\LD BE ADAPTABLE TO EV5TS AS !Y UNFOLD4 ,IT CAN BE DANG]\S DUR+ A DEMON/RATION OR ACTION TO HESITATE TO *ANGE PLANS :5 EV5TS TAKE AN UNEXPECT$ TURN1 BECAUSE ONE'S GR\P HAD ORIG9ALLY PLANN$ O!RWISE4 ,S9CE AUTONOMY IS BORN \T ( AN E?IC ?AT REJECTS ! BLOCK+ ( ACTIVE P[]S1 IT !RE=E IMPLIES A REFUSAL TO BLOCK ! ACTIONS ( O!RS ) AN IMPORTANT EXCEPTION4 ,:5 O!RS TRY TO IMP$E \R ACTION1 WE WILL NOT JU/ SIT BY & LET !M4 ,EXAMPLES ( ?IS 9CLUDE1 ?OSE :O TRI$ TO PHYSICALLY /OP PROTE/]S FROM BREAK+ W9D[S 9 ,SEATTLE1 ?OSE :O TAKE PHOTOS ( ILLEGAL ACTIONS1 ?OSE :O UNMASK PEOPLE :O *OOSE TO BE MASK$ = SECURITY REASONS1 & ?OSE :O M>K PROTE/]S ) PA9T TO BE ID5TIFI$ LAT] BY ! POLICE4 ,!SE PEOPLE NOT ONLY REFUSE TO RESPECT ! AUTONOMY ( O!RS' ACTION1 BUT TAKE ?IS TO AN EXTREME BY TRY+ TO PLACE ?OSE !Y DISAGREE ) 9 ! H&S ( ! POLICE1 5EMIES :O HAVE ! P[] TO TAKE AWAY YE>S ( \R LIVES4 ,WE HAVE NO *OICE BUT TO DEF5D \RSELVES4 ,! PO9T :]E AUTONOMY 5DS IS ! PO9T :]E ALI5AT$ P[] IS =M$1 :]E \R ONLY WEAPON1 \R P[] TO ACT IS TAK5 FROM US4 ,JU/ AS AN 9=MAL ORGANIZATION MU/ HAVE AN E?IC ( AUTONOMY OR IT WILL BE TRANS=M$ 9TO AN AU?ORIT>IAN ORGANIZATION1 9 ORD] TO AVOID ! ALI5ATION ( \R ACTIVE P[]S1 IT MU/ ALSO HAVE AN E?IC ( NO COMPROMISE ) RESPECT ! ORGANIZATION'S AGRE$ GOAL4 ,! ORGANIZATION'S GOAL %\LD BE EI!R A*IEV$ OR AB&ON$4 ,COMPROMIS+ ) ?OSE :O WE OPPOSE 7E4G42 SU* AS ! ,/ATE OR A CORPORATION7 DEFEATS ALL TRUE OPPOSITION1 IT REPLACES \R P[] TO ACT ) ?AT ( \R 5EMIES4 ,S9CE ,SEATTLE1 GLOBAL F9ANCIAL & TRADE ORGANIZATIONS HAVE BE5 CALL+ = DIALOGUE4 ,TO GET US TO B>GA9 ) !M !Y HAVE TRI$ TO LOOK SYMPA!TIC & CONC]N$4 ,DUR+ ! PROTE/S 9 ,PRAGUE 9 ,SEPTEMB]1 A ,WORLD ,BANK REPRES5TATIVE SAID3 0,WE SYMPA?IZE ) ! QUE/IONS ! PROTE/]S >E PROPOS+ BUT WE DISAGREE ) !IR ME?ODS4 ,WE ?9K !Y'RE GO+ AB\T ?IS 9 ! WRONG WAY4 ,WE WANT DIALOGUE NOT =CE40 ,ANO!R ,WORLD ,BANK REPRES5TATIVE SAID3 0,!SE >E IMPORTANT MEET+S1 AB\T 5D+ ,A,I,D,S & POV]TY2 :AT WE WANT IS DIALOGUE NOT DIATRIBES40 ,! FACT ?AT ! ,WORLD ,BANK WANTS DIALOGUE IS A MEASURE ( \R SUCCESS 9 ! /REETS4 ,!Y HOPE WE WILL *OOSE DIALOGUE OV] DIRECT ACTION1 BECAUSE !Y KN[ ?AT DIALOGUE ) !M W\LD BE 9EFFECTIVE1 ?AT !Y W\LD NEV] REALLY CONC$E TO \R DEM&S4 ,!Y CAN LI/5 TO US1 POLITELY RESPOND1 EV5 MAKE M9OR ADJU/M5TS1 BUT !Y ALL EV5TUALLY GO HOME TO A GAT$ COMMUNITY ( OBLIVION & HAVE A M>T9I4 ,?IS IS :Y !Y WANT TO *ANNEL ! =CE ( \R DIRECT ACTION 9TO APPEALS1 PETITIONS & ATTEMPTS TO MANIPULATE ! MA9/REAM M$IA4 ,! ,WORLD ,BANK RECOGNIZES ! P[] ( \R DIRECT ACTION & IS TAK+ C\NT] MEASURES2 IT IS TRY+ TO CONV9CE US TO USE 9EFFECTIVE ME?ODS4 ,! SCRAPS H&$ D[N TO APPEASE & DIV]T US BY ?OSE WE OPPOSE MU/ BE REFUS$4 ,COMPROMISE ) ANY TRANSC5D5T 9/ITUTION 7! ,/ATE1 ,W,T,O1 ,W,B1 ,I,M,F1 ! ,P>TY ETC47 IS ALWAYS ! ALI5ATION ( \R P[] TO ! V]Y 9/ITUTIONS WE SUPPOS$LY WI% TO DE/ROY2 ?IS SORT ( COMPROMISE RESULTS 9 ! =FEITURE ( \R P[] TO ACT DECISIVELY1 TO MAKE DECISIONS & ACTIONS 9 ! TIME WE *OOSE4 ,AS SU*1 COMPROMISE ONLY MAKES ! /ATE & CAPITAL /RONG]4 ,= ?OSE :O WI% TO OP5 ! POSSIBILITY ( 9SURRECTION1 ?OSE :O DON'T WI% TO WAIT = ! SUPPOS$LY APPROPRIATE MAT]IAL CONDITIONS = REVOLUTION1 = ?OSE :O DON'T WANT A REVOLUTION :I* IS M]ELY ! CREATION ( A NEW P[] /RUCTURE BUT WANT ! DE/RUCTION ( ALL /RUCTURES :I* ALI5ATE \T P[] FROM US1 SU* COMPROMISE IS CONTR>Y TO !IR AIMS4 ,TO CONT9UALLY REFUSE TO COMPROMISE IS TO BE 9 P]PETUAL CONFLICT ) ! E/ABLI%$ ORD] & ITS /RUCTURES ( DOM9ATION & DEPRIVATION4 ,P]MAN5T CONFLICTUALITY MEANS ?AT WE WILL NOT WAIT = ORD]S FROM LEAD]S OR ORGANIZ]S :O1 BY NATURE ( !IR ROLE1 AIM TO CONTROL \R REBELLION & ?US ALI5ATE \R ACTIVE P[]S4 ,P]MAN5T CONFLICTUALITY IS UNCONTROLLABLE AUTONOM\S ACTION4 ,9=MAL ORGANIZATIONS MAY BE COMPOS$ ( AFF9ITY GR\PS ) QUITE DIFF]5T POLITICAL P]SPECTIVES FROM EA* O!R4 ,! DISP>ATE P]SPECTIVES ?AT MAY BE F\ND 9 AN 9=MAL ORGANIZATION W\LD NOT T5D TO BE F\ND )9 ! AFF9ITY GR\P4 ,! AFF9ITY GR\P W\LD BE BAS$ ON A COMMONALITY ( P]SPECTIVE ?AT W\LDN'T NECESS>ILY EXI/ 9 A L>G] GR\P4 ,SOME PEOPLE WI% TO OP5 ! POSSIBILITY = 9SURRECTION1 :ILE O!RS >E ONLY CONC]N$ ) AN IMM$IATE GOAL4 ,!RE IS NO REASON :Y ?OSE :O %>E AN IMM$IATE PRACTICAL AIM BUT DIV]GE 9 !IR LONG-T]M GOALS MI+ UP TE/ CROPS IF !RE >E MANY PLOTS 9 AN >EA & TO CIRCULATE ANTI-,G,E LEAFLETS4 7,9 CASES ( SABOTAGE1 ! FEW] ! PEOPLE :O KN[ ! BETT]1 9=MATION %\LD ONLY BE %>$ BETWE5 AFF9ITY GR\PS :5 !RE IS A REASON TO COORD9ATE EF=TS1 = EXAMPLE1 :5 IT IS DESIRABLE = SEV]AL AFF9ITY GR\PS TO HIT SEV]AL T>GETS 9 ONE NIY RUPTURE ) ?IS SOCIAL ORD] & ?OSE :O M]ELY HATE G5ETIC 5G9E]+ C\LD EASILY WORK TOGE!R T[>DS ?IS IMM$IATE GOAL4 ,= ?OSE :O WI% TO OP5 ! POSSIBILITY ( 9SURRECTION1 SU* COOP]ATION WILL NOT CLOSE ! DOOR ON !IR DREAMS4 ,9=MAL ORGANIZATION1 ) ITS E?ICS ( AUTONOMY & NO COMPROMISE1 DOES NOT CONTROL /RUGGLE2 &1 UNCONTROLLABILITY OP5S ! POSSIBILITY = AN 9SURRECTION>Y RUPTURE ) ?IS NECROPHILIC SOCIAL ORD]4 ,9 ! ABOVE CASE1 WE'RE ASSUM+ ?AT ALL 9VOLV$ UPHOLD AN ANTI-AU?ORIT>IAN E?IC ?AT RESPECTS AUTONOMY ( ACTION4 ,BECAUSE AU?ORITY CAN >ISE 9 ANY GR\P1 SOME AN>*I/S FEEL SAF] IF !Y ONLY 9T]ACT ) O!R AN>*I/S1 ?US AVOID+ AU?ORIT>IANS4 ,BUT IT IS NOT ! LABEL AN>*I/ ?AT ANNIHILATES AU?ORITY BUT AN ONGO+ /RUGGLE ) ALL ?OSE ONE 9T]ACTS )4 ,EV]Y NEW SITUATION & RELATION WE 5T] POSES ! POSSIBILITY = ! RISE ( AU?ORITY4 ,JU/ AS ,CLA/RES NOT$ A ',SOCIETY AGA9/ ! ,/ATE' O!R AN?ROPOLOGI/S :O HAVE LIV$ 9 SMALL-SCALE SOCIETIES HAVE NOT$ A PROCESS ( ASS]TIVE EGALIT>IANISM1 AN ACTIVE T5D5CY TO SQUEL* ATTEMPTS AT CREAT+ ROLES ( AU?ORITY1 OR ECONOMIC 9EQUALITY4 ,9 AN 9=MAL ORGANIZATION1 WE NE$ TO ASS]TIVELY C\NT] ! =MATION ( AU?ORIT>IAN RELATIONS4 ,! DIFFICULTY ( ?IS PROBLEM CANNOT BE AVOID$ BY /AY+ 9 AN AN>*I/ *I/S C\LD BE A =CE ?AT HELPS ! ANTI-CAPITALI/ & ANTI-AU?ORIT>IAN CURR5TS )9 ! ANTI-GLOBALIZATION MOVEM5T SPREAD FUR!R4 ,?IS C\LD BE A*IEV$ BY OP5+ UP DISCUSSION BETWE5 AN>*I/S & O!R ANTI-CAPITALI/ GR\PS1 & BETWE5 ANTI-CAPITALI/S & ANTI-CORPORATE_/ANTI-GLOBALIZATION GR\PS4 ,?IS DISCUSSION W\LD 9 SOME CASES LEAD TO L9KS ( COOP]ATION & SOLID>ITY4 ,:5 WE DISCUSS ! IMPORTANCE ( L9KS BETWE5 /RUGGLES OR ! SPREAD ( /RUGGLE WE >E NOT TALK+ AB\T A GR[? 9 NUMB]S ( AN ORGANIZATION OR MOVEM5T4 ,! TYPE ( ORGANIZATION ?AT WE HAVE BE5 DISCUSS+ IS NOT COMPOS$ ( PEOPLE :O AIM TO 9CREASE ITS NUMB]S AT ! SACRIFICE ( ! QUALITY ( ! RELATION%IPS ( ?OSE :O COME TOGE!R2 ! SP>K ( REBELLION CANNOT BE QUANTIFI$4 ,9=MAL ORGANIZATION IS A MEANS = DISCUSSION BETWE5 DIV]SE 9DIVIDUALS & GR\PS TO BECOME FOCUS$ ACTION4 ,9=MAL ORGANIZATIONS1 AFF9ITY GR\PS & 9DIVIDUALS HAVE ALREADY GIV5 BIR? TO MANY PROJECTS1 SOME ( :I* AIM TO 9CREASE COMMUNICATION & %>+ SU* AS GA!R+S1 ! CREATION ( SOCIAL SPACES LIKE 9FO-%OPS1 & PUBLICATIONS1 !SE PROJECTS >E CRUCIAL :5 CAPITALISM CON/ANTLY PUTS UP WALLS TO SEP>ATE US4 ,O!RS HAVE FOCUS$ ON ! URG5T TASK ( DIRECTLY ATTACK+ ! EXI/5T SOCIAL ORD]4 0,MAKE \R /RUGGLE AS TRANSNATIONAL AS CAPITAL40 ,?IS SLOGAN IS V]Y COMPELL+ & HAS BECOME ! MO/ COMMON SLOGAN HE>D )9 ! ANTI-GLOBALIZATION MOVEM5T4 ,BUT H[ DO WE MAKE \R /RUGGLE AS TRANSNATIONAL AS CAPITAL8 ,?IS BR+S UP SOME DIFFICULT PROBLEMS = ANTI-AU?ORIT>IANS4 ,H[ CAN A TRANSNATIONAL /RUGGLE AGA9/ CAPITAL & ! /ATE OCCUR )\T CREAT+ AN OV]>*+ MASSIVE AU?ORIT>IAN /RUCTURE8 ,H[ CAN /RUGGLE AGA9/ A COMMON 5EMY1 CAPITAL1 REMA9 FOCUS$ YET DISP>ATE1 LOCAL & GLOBAL8 ,TRANSNATIONAL /RUGGLE1 9 REALITY1 MEANS /RUGGLE ON MANY SCAL> LEVELS4 ,IT ALSO DEM&S ! DEVELOPM5T ( MANY PRACTICES ?AT ALL[ US TO WORK TOGE!R &1 AT ! SAME TIME1 W>D (F ! GR[? ( TRANSC5D5T 9/ITUTIONS 9 \R MID/4 ,OP]AT+ ON MANY SCAL> LEVELS WILL CREATE T5SIONS )9 ! MOVEM5T1 & !RE IS NO SIMPLE SOLUTION ?AT RESOLVES SU* T5SIONS4 ,YET1 ATTEMPT+ TO OP]ATE ON A S+LE SCAL> LEVEL1 SU* AS ! NATIONAL SCALE OR ! BUILD+ ( A MASSIVE 9T]NATIONAL ORGANIZATION1 DOOMS \R MOVEM5T TO FAILURE2 NOR CAN WE BUILD A LOCAL COCOON TO HIB]NATE 94 ,WAIT+ ONLY BR+S US DEFEAT4 ,CAPITALISM IS A V]Y ADAPTABLE =CE2 IT HAS MANAG$ TO EMB$ ITSELF 9 9NUM]ABLE SOCIAL & CULTURAL REALITIES4 ,CAPITALISM OP]ATES FROM ABOVE & BEL[2 IT IMPOSES ITSELF ?R\< ! CO]CION ( DEPRIVATION & !N EMB$S ITSELF 9 SOCIAL RELATIONS4 ,!RE IS ONE CAPITALISM1 IT OP]ATES AS A SY/EM1 YET IT FUNCTIONS 9 MILLIONS ( P>TICUL> LOCAL WAYS4 ,ANY FILY EV]Y FACET ( \R DAILY LIVES >E TO BE DE/ROY$1 ?IS DE/RUCTION MU/ SPR+ FROM ! DESIRE ( ! MULTITUDE4 ,! DESIRE TO DE/ROY CAPITALISM IS ! SP>K :I* MU/ >ISE 9 MANY LOCALITIES & SPREAD ?R\<\T ! GLOBE1 9 ORD] = \R /RUGGLE TO BECOME AS TRANSNATIONAL AS CAPITAL4 ,!RE IS NO LONG] ANY:]E TO HIDE4 ,IF WE DE/ROY ! /ATE & CAPITAL 9 ONE PLACE1 LEAV+ ! 9DU/RIAL MILIT>Y REGIME 9 ! H&S ( \R 5EMIES1 \R LITTLE UTOPIA WILL SOON BE CRU%$4 ,LIKEWISE IF WE TRY TO ISOLATE \RSELVES1 AS ,HAKIM ,BEY SO POETICALLY SUGGE/S 9 ,T4,A4,Z41 TO CREATE A SELF-SUFFICI5T AUTONOM\S ZONE FREE FROM CAPITAL1 WE CANNOT SUCCE$4 ,IT IS ( C\RSE V]Y IMPORTANT TO CREATE SPACES = \RSELVES :]E WE CAN BREA! FREELY2 :]E WE CAN ACT & ?9K )\T ! IMM$IATE /RAIT JACKET ( CAPITALI/ RELATIONS & ROLES1 )\T ! #i-#e PRODUCTION-CONSUMPTION GR9D4 ,BUT IF WE /OP !RE WE RUN 9TO A PROBLEM1 CAPITALISM SURR\NDS US4 ,! SQUAT IS EVICT$1 ! SELF-SUFFICI5T RURAL COMMUNITY IS SURR\ND$ BY T[NS1 OR LOGG+ MOVES 9 UNTIL ! ONLY TREES LEFT >E ON ONES L&4 ,ONE CAN NO LONG] BE COMPLETELY \TSIDE ( CAPITALISM2 IT IS A SOCIAL DISEASE ?AT HAS T\*$ ALL SOCIETIES4 ,?IS IS NOT TO SAY ?AT IT HAS FULLY P5ETRAT$ !M ALL1 ! FEW ,P5AN ( ,BORNEO ?AT REMA9 9 ! =E/ DO /ILL %>E A SOCIAL LIFE ?AT IS 9 />K CONTRA/ TO CAPITALI/ RELATIONS4 ,BUT !Y >E FIBY FIELDS1 CAPITALISM IS A PE/ :I* SEEKS TO TAKE OV] EV]Y?+ IT T\*ES2 IT CANNOT BE CONTA9$ )\T BE+ DE/ROY$ AS A :OLE4 ,MANY AN>*I/S 9 ! ANTI-GLOBALIZATION MOVEM5T OP]ATE ON ! SCALE ( ! NATION-/ATE1 IMAG9+ ?AT ,CLA/RES' 0,SOCIETY ,AGA9/ ! ,/ATE0 C\LD BE RE>TICULAT$ AS ! 0,/ATE ,AGA9/ ,CAPITAL02 !Y SEEM TO UND]/& CAPITAL AS BECOM+ PURE & SEP>AT+ ITSELF FROM ! /ATE4 ,& AS AN 9DEX ( CURR5T PESSIMISM ! /ATE IS IMAG9$ AS PROTECT+ CULTURE AGA9/ GLOBAL CAPITALISM4 ,AS WE >GU$ 9 \R SECTION ON VALUE1 H[EV]1 !RE CAN BE NO CAPITALISM )\T TRANSC5D5T 9/ITUTIONS1 SU* AS ! /ATE1 TO BACK UP ITS PRIVATE PROP]TY SY/EM4 ,! /ATE1 9 SOME =M1 IS ! CONDITION ( POSSIBILITY ( CAPITALISM1 ?AT :I* IS NECESS>Y = CAPITALISM TO GO ON EXI/+4 ,?US CAPITALISM CAN NEV] FREE ITSELF FROM ! /ATE & CONT9UE TO REPRODUCE ITSELF4 ,( C\RSE1 ! TRANSC5D5T 9/ITUTIONS ?AT ALL[ = ! REPRODUCTION ( CAPITALISM >E CON/ANTLY TRANS=M+ !MSELVES2 !Y >E NOT /ATIC4 ,AS ! SCALE ( ! /ATE-CAPITAL RELATION *ANGES SO TOO MU/ ! ORGANIZATION ( RESI/ANCE & ATTACK2 YET1 ANY >GUM5T ?AT WE NE$ TO COMPROMISE & EV5 ALLY \RSELVES ) OLD] TRANSC5D5T 9/ITUTIONS SU* AS ! NATION-/ATE >E SORELY MISGUID$4 ,ANY COMPROMISE ) ALI5AT$ P[] CAN ONLY CUT US (F FROM \R P[] TO TRANS=M SOCIETY & \R P[] TO CREATE ! LIFE ( \R DESIRES TO ! BE/ ( \R ABILITIES4 ,?9K+ AB\T ! ISSUE ( ! SCALE ( RESI/ANCE1 AB\T H[ TO BR+ ! CONCEPT ( A TRANSNATIONAL RESI/ANCE TO & ATTACK ON CAPITAL 9TO PRACTICE1 DEM&S A MU* MORE C>EFUL ANALYSIS4 ,:5 PEOPLE />T ?9K+ ON GLOBAL T]MS !RE IS SOMETIMES A T5D5CY TO ASSUME ?AT ! ONLY WAY = A /RUGGLE TO BE GLOBAL IS TO FUNCTION LIKE A /ATE OR CORPORATION1 TO TRY TO SYN!SIZE ALL /RUGGLE )9 ONE 9T]NATIONAL ORGANIZATION1 & ?US UNIFY PRACTICE ?R\< ?IS ORGANIZATION4 ,?IS IS UNDESIRABLE FROM AN ANTI-AU?ORIT>IAN PO9T ( VIEW1 YET IT IS ALSO IMPRACTICAL4 ,H[ C\LD ONE POSSIBLY BR+ ALL /RUGGLE UND] ONE ORGANIZATION1 )\T FIR/ SUPPRESS+ MANY LOCAL /RUGGLES4 ,A L>GE ORGANIZATION ( ?IS SORT BY NATURE SEP>ATES DECISION FROM ! NE$S ( ! EXPLOIT$1 IT MAKES !M WAIT TO ACT UNTIL ! MOM5T :I* IS MO/ ADVANTAGE\S TO ! ORGANIZATION4 ,L>GE ORGANIZATIONS ?AT BR+ TOGE!R MANY SOCIAL /RUGGLES (T5 ?9K ONLY 9 AB/RACT T]MS AB\T CAPITAL4 ,IT ?US BECOMES NECESS>Y TO WAIT TO ACT UNTIL ! APPROPRIATE MAT]IAL CONDITIONS >ISE1 = A CRISIS TO >ISE 9 CAPITALISM AS A :OLE4 ,SU* ?9K+ IS BL9D TO ! MULTIF>I\S LOCAL MOTIVATIONS = REVOLT4 ,TRANSC5D5T ORGANIZATIONS CAN ONLY COMM& REVOLT2 9 DO+ SO !Y TRY TO DEPRIVE REVOLT ( ITS IMPETUS1 ! IMMAN5T DESIRE ( ! MULTITUDE4 ,IT IS ?IS DESIRE ?AT IS ! SP>K ( 9SURRECTION2 ONLY IT CAN TRANS=M ! :OLE ( SOCIAL LIFE4 ,NO 9DIVIDUAL1 AFF9ITY GR\P1 OR ORGANIZATION CAN COMM& 9SURRECTION2 9SURRECTION IS BY NATURE UNCONTROLLABLE4 ,?OSE :O DREAM ( AN 9SURRECTION CANNOT JU/ WILL IT 9TO EXI/5CE1 !Y CAN ONLY OP5 UP ! POSSIBILITY = ITS UNFOLD+ ?R\< DIRECT ATTACKS ON ?IS SOCIAL ORD]1 ACTIONS :I* CAN COMMUNICATE & SPREAD ?R\<\T ! SOCIAL BODY4 ,CAPITAL CAN NEV] BE ATTACK$ 9 ! AB/RACT1 IT CAN ONLY BE ATTACK$ 9 ITS CONCRETE MANIFE/ATIONS2 ATTACK IS ALWAYS LOCAL BUT IT CAN COMMUNICATE GLOBALLY4 ,LOCAL ATTACKS CAN 9SPIRE PEOPLE ELSE:]E -- :O HAVE A COMMON 5EMY -- TO TAKE ACTION4 ,! PO9TS AT :I* PEOPLE P]CEIVE ! COMMONALITY ( AN 5EMY V>Y WIDELY1 FROM A SPECIFIC COMPANY1 SPECIFIC LAW OR POLITICIAN1 TO CAPITALISM OR ! /ATE AS A :OLE4 ,ACTIONS & ! PUBLICIZ+ ( ACTIONS VIA COMMUNIQUES & \R M$IA >E OPPORTUNITIES = PEOPLE TO SEE ! COMMONALITY BETWE5 ! OPPRESS$ 9 A F>AWAY PLACE & !MSELVES4 ,9 ?IS LIES AN OPPORTUNITY = PEOPLE TO TAKE !IR ANALYSIS ONE /EP FUR!R1 & BECOME CRITICAL ( CAPITALISM AS A TOTALITY4 ,REC5TLY 9 ,NOR? ,AM]ICA1 5VIRONM5TALI/S HAVE BE5 MORE SUCCESSFUL ?AN WORK]S 9 LETT+ LOCAL /RUGGLE COMMUNICATE ! GLOBAL SCALE ( CAPITAL4 ,! 5VIRONM5TAL DIRECT ACTION MOVEM5T IS SPREAD+ QUICKLY ALL OV] ! CONT95T1 ) V]Y LITTLE ORGANIZATION AT ALL4 ,! ,E,L,F IS NOT AN ORGANIZATION1 ANYONE CAN SIGN ! NAME ,E,L,F 7?\< ?OSE :O />T$ IT REQUE/ ?AT ?OSE :O SIGN ! NAME MEET C]TA9 CRIT]IA ( P]SPECTIVE & GOAL74 ,YET1 ,E,L,F ACTIONS HAVE SPREAD WIDELY )\T ! SUPPORT ( AN ORGANIZATION1 ,E,L,F ACTIONS OCCUR BECAUSE PEOPLE >E ANGRY ?AT ! E>? IS BE+ TRA%$1 ?IS IRE SPREADS MORE EFFECTIVELY ?AN W\LD A P]MAN5T ORGANIZATION ) ITS COMMITTEES & PAP] SELL+4 ,NOT ALL PEOPLE :O 5GAGE 9 SU* ACTS ( SABOTAGE USE ! NAME ,E,L,F1 !RE >E 9NUM]ABLE O!R EXAMPLES1 ! TE>+ UP ( G5ETICALLY 5G9E]$ TE/ CROPS :I* HAS SPREAD OV] SEV]AL CONT95TS IS ! MO/ WELL KN[N EXAMPLE4 ,9 !SE CASES1 ! LOCAL ACT ( SABOTAGE COMMUNICATES A GLOBAL 5EMY ! CAPITALI/ 9DU/RIAL MA*9E ?AT IS POLLUT+ \R PLANET4 ,! REC5T UPSURGE ( ! GLOBAL DAYS ( ACTION (F]S AN OPPORTUNITY = SPECIFIC ACTIONS TO COMMUNICATE & BUILD L9KS GLOBALLY4 ,BUT WE NE$ TO ASK :AT EXACTLY IS ! NATURE ( ! OPPORTUNITY ?AT ! GLOBAL DAYS ( ACTION (F] AN>*I/S8 ,:ILE ! T>GETS *OS51 ! 9T]NATIONAL 9/ITUTIONS ( CAPITALISM1 DO HELP TO COMMUNICATE AN OPPOSITION TO CAPITALISM 9 G5]AL1 P]HAPS ! GREATE/ OPPORTUNITY !SE GLOBAL DAYS ( ACTION (F] IS ! POT5TIAL TO L9K-UP P>TICUL>1 LOCAL ACTIONS ?AT ATTACK SPECIFIC T>GETS ) A G5]AL OPPOSITION TO CAPITALISM4 ,9 O!R WORDS1 ! FACT ( ! SIMULTANEITY ( ACTIONS ON A P>TICUL> DATE MAY BE MORE IMPORTANT ?AN ! SPECTACUL> %UTT+ D[N ( A HUGE MEET+4 ,BY SKIPP+ ! BIG EV5T & 9/EAD DO+ SMALL]1 LOCAL ACTIONS1 AN>*I/S CAN COMMUNICATE ! LOCAL CONSEQU5CES ( ! EV] EXP&+ CAPITALI/ DEA?-MA*9E4 ,BY ! V]Y SIMULTANEITY ( MANY ACTIONS CONNECTIONS BETWE5 REGIONS & /RUGGLES >E BUILT4 ,WE >E NOT SAY+ ?AT \R ACTIONS %\LD BE DET]M9$ BY ! DATES SET BY ! 9/ITUTIONS ( GLOBAL CAPITALISM NOR %\LD ONE ONLY CONDUCT ACTIONS ON SU* DATES1 BUT WE ALSO %\LD NOT IGNORE ! HI/ORICAL OPPORTUNITIES (F]$ BY ! GR[? ( ! GLOBAL DAYS ( ACTION4 ,TO BE EFFECTIVE SU* ACTIONS %\LD BE P>T ( AN ONGO+ /RUGGLE4 ,DO+ ACTIONS LOCALLY ALSO HAS ! POT5TIAL TO 9VOLVE O!RS :O MAY NOT UND]/& H[ ! BIG EV5TS ( ! GLOBAL DAYS ( ACTION -- ! ATTACKS ON 9/ITUTIONS SU* AS ! ,W,T,O1 ! ,W,B1 & ! ,I,M,F -- >E CONNECT$ TO !IR LIVES4 ,DO+ LOCAL ACTIONS ON ! DATES ( ! GLOBAL DAYS ( ACTION IS ONE IMPORTANT WAY TO 9T5SIFY SU* /RUGGLES4 ,! F9AL -- & POSSIBLY MO/ IMPORTANT -- KEY TO AN ACTIVE1 TRANSNATIONAL ATTACK ON CAPITAL & ! /ATE IS DEVELOP+ ! PRACTICE ( A CRITICAL & REVOLUTION>Y SOLID>ITY4 ,:5 WE >E CRITICAL ( ?OSE :O %>E \R AIMS1 CRITICAL SOLID>ITY IS A WAY = DISAGREEM5TS OV] /RATEGY1 TACTICS & ORGANIZATION TO BE AIR$ & DISCUSS$ )\T TRY+ TO BLOCK EA* O!R'S ACTIONS4 ,IF WE CONT9UALLY BLOCK ! ACTIONS ( O!RS NO ACTION WILL TAKE PLACE4 ,NOTABLY1 S9CE ,SEATTLE PREVI\SLY FI]CE !ORETICAL DIVISIONS HAVE TAK5 ON LESS IMPORTANCE4 ,?IS WAS P>TICUL>LY CLE> 9 ! CALL = A ,REVOLUTION>Y ,ANTI-,CAPITALI/ ,BLOCK AT ! ,A#a#f ,WA%+TON PROTE/1 :I* WAS A SIGNIFICANT CALL = SOLID>ITY & JO9T ACTION BY ALL :O CONSID] !MSELVES TO BE ANTI-CAPITALI/ REVOLUTION>IES4 ,!RE HAS BE5 A LOT MORE ACTIVITY ON MANY LEVELS S9CE ,SEATTLE1 PEOPLE :O DIDN'T GO HAVE BE5 9SPIR$ BY ! /ORIES ( ?OSE :O DID1 SUDD5LY N[ ?AT !RE IS PL5TY TO DO1 !ORETICAL DIVISIONS GIVE WAY TO CONC]NS ( PRACTICAL IMPORTANCE4 ,AS A M9ORITY )9 ! MOVEM5T ( ! EXPLOIT$1 AN>*I/S MU/ F9D WAYS TO WORK & 9T]ACT ) ?OSE ) :OM !Y DISAGREE4 ,AT ! SAME TIME ?IS DOESN'T MEAN ?AT DISAGREEM5TS >E HIDD54 ,IT IS IMPORTANT ?AT ! CONCEPT ( CRITICAL SOLID>ITY BE UND]/OOD WIDELY1 = ALL TOO (T5 A CRITICAL ATTITUDE IS TAK5 TO MEAN A LACK ( SUPPORT4 ,WE CAN BE CRITICAL ( ! ,ZAPATI/AS :ILE WE ACT 9 SOLID>ITY ) ! /RUGGLE ( ! EXCLUD$ 9 ,*IAPAS AGA9/ ! ,MEXICAN ,/ATE & ! IMPOSITION ( NEO-LIB]AL ECONOMICS4 ,IT IS ALWAYS MORE IMPORTANT TO ACT 9 SOLID>ITY ) PEOPLE'S DECISION TO CREATE !IR [N LIVES1 ?AN TO AGREE ) !IR !ORETICAL P]SPECTIVE OR ! TACTICS !Y *OOSE4 ,IT IS ! SOLID>ITY ) ! BECOM+-ACTIVE & ! REFUSAL ( ! ALI5ATION ( P[] ?AT IS MO/ VITAL4 ,AS ,NIKOS ,MAZOTIS SAID AT HIS TRIAL1 0,= ME1 SOLID>ITY MEANS ! UNRES]V$ ACCEPTANCE & SUPPORT ) EV]Y MEANS ( ! RIITY ?AT IS ALWAYS OP5 TO ! AUTONOM\S ACTION ( O!RS1 WE NE$ TO BUILD REVOLUTION>Y SOLID>ITY4 ,REVOLUTION>Y SOLID>ITY %\LD BE ACTIVE & 9 CONFLICT ) ! /RUCTURES ( DOM9ATION4 ,REVOLUTION>Y SOLID>ITY ALL[S US TO MOVE F> BEYOND ! 0S5D-A-*ECK0 /YLE ( SOLID>ITY ?AT SO P]VADES ! LEFT AS WELL AS SOLID>ITY ?AT RELIES ON PETITION+ ! /ATE = RELIEF OR M]CY4 ,ONE EXAMPLE ( REVOLUTION>Y SOLID>ITY WAS ,NIKOS ,MAZOTIS' ACTION AGA9/ ,T,V,X ,GOLD 9 ,DECEMB] #a#i#i#g4 ,MANY PEOPLE 9 ! VILLAGES >\ND ,/RYMONIKOS 9 ,NOR!RN ,GREECE W]E /RUGGL+ AGA9/ ! 9/ALLATION ( A GOLD METALLURGY PLANT 9 !IR >EA4 ,9 SOLID>ITY ) ! VILLAG]S1 ,NIKOS PLAC$ A BOMB 9 ! ,M9I/RY ( ,9DU/RY ( ,DEVELOPM5T ?AT WAS 9T5D$ TO EXPLODE :5 NO ONE WAS 9 ! BUILD+2 UN=TUNATELY1 IT NEV] W5T (F AT ALL4 ,NIKOS IS N[ S]V+ A #a#e-YE> PRISON S5T5CE 7R$UC$ TO FIVE & A HALF YE>S2 HE IS DUE \T ?IS YE>74 ,T,V,X ,GOLD IS A MULT9ATIONAL COMPANY :OSE HEADQU>T]S IS 9 ,CANADA1 !RE >E ?US MANY PO9TS AT :I* REVOLUTION>Y SOLID>ITY ) ! VILLAG]S ( ,/RYM9IKOS C\LD HAVE BE5 5ACT$4 ,FUNDRAIS+ ON BEHALF ( ONE'S COMRADES IS NECESS>Y & SURELY APPRECIAT$1 BUT ?IS C\LD BE COMB9$ ) MORE ACTIVE =MS ( SOLID>ITY ) ?OSE :O /RUGGLE AGA9/ \R COMMON 5EMIES4 ,REVOLUTION>Y SOLID>ITY COMMUNICATES ! L9K BETWE5 ! EXPLOITATION & REPRESSION ( O!RS & \R [N FATE2 &1 IT %[S PEOPLE ! PO9TS AT :I* CAPITALISM OR ! /ATE OP]ATE 9 SIMIL> WAYS 9 V]Y DIFF]5T PLACES4 ,BY CREAT+ L9KS BETWE5 ! /RUGGLES AGA9/ ! TRANSC5D5T P[] /RUCTURES ?AT =M ! ,/ATE & ,CAPITAL1 REVOLUTION>Y SOLID>ITY HAS ! POT5TIAL TO TAKE \R LOCAL /RUGGLES TO A GLOBAL LEVEL4 ,SOLID>ITY IS :5 Y\ RECOGNIZE Y\R [N /RUGGLE 9 ! /RUGGLE ( O!RS4 ,REVOLUTION>Y SOLID>ITY IS SOLID>ITY ) ! BECOM+-ACTIVE ( O!RS & !RE=E ) !IR REFUSAL TO ACCEPT ! ALI5ATION ( !IR [N P[]4 ,MOREOV]1 REVOLUTION>Y SOLID>ITY IS ALWAYS AN ACTIVE ATTACK2 IT ALWAYS 9VOLVES ! RECOV]Y ( \R [N ACTIVE P[]S ?AT MULTIPLY 9 COMB9ATION -- 9 SOLID>ITY -- ) ! ACTIVE P[]S ( O!RS4 ,CONCLUSION ,9 ?IS >TICLE WE HAVE >GU$ ?AT AN>*ISM IS A PRACTICE ?AT IS ALWAYS 9 T5SION ) ! CON/ITUT$ ORD]4 ,! COMMON ?READ ( AN>*I/ PRACTICE IS ! REFUSAL ( A TRANSC5D5T1 CON/ITUT$ ORD]1 ! DEM& ?AT DECISIONS BE MADE BY ?OSE 9VOLV$ 9 A SITUATION4 ,AN>*ISM IS AN ATTACK ON ALL ?AT SEP>ATES US FROM \R ACTIVE P[]S2 AN>*ISM IS ! DESIRE ?AT ANIMATES \R REFUSAL TO ALL[ ! ALI5ATION ( \R P[]4 ,?US ! PRACTICE ( AN>*ISM IS AN E?IC4 ,! PRACTICES ?AT WE HAVE SKET*$ 9 ! ABOVE ESSAY HAVE BE5 DEVELOP$ BY AN>*I/S )9 ! /RUGGLE ( ! EXCLUD$1 &1 AS SU*1 !Y CON/ITUTE A CONT9UATION ( ! SOCIETY AGA9/ ! /ATE4 ,9 ORD] TO REMA9 VITAL1 H[EV]1 AN>*ISM MU/ AVOID ! CON/ITUTION ( TRANSC5D5T P[]-RELATIONS )9 ITS MID/4 ,= SU* RELATIONS W\LD BO? VOID ! EFFECTIV5ESS ( \R ATTACK & LEAD TO ! DEFEAT ( SELF-CON/ITUT$ SOCIAL RELATIONS4 ,9=MAL ORGANIZATION IS A MEANS = AN>*I/S TO COMB9E ) O!RS ( ! EXPLOIT$ MULTITUDE )\T =M+ TRANSC5D5T 9/ITUTIONS4 ,! PRACTICE ( ! AN>*I/ E?IC )9 ! WID] /RUGGLE WILL BO? ALL[ PEOPLE TO REMA9 ACTIVE 9 !IR ATTACK & BR+ 9TO EXI/5CE NEW1 IMMAN5TLY CREAT$ WAYS ( LIV+ & RELAT+4 ,?R\< ! V]Y PRACTICE ( 9=MAL ORGANIZATION1 ! AN>*I/ E?IC CAN SPREAD FUR!R )9 ! ANTI-GLOBALIZATION MOVEM5T4 ,)9 ! WID] MOVEM5T ( ! EXPLOIT$ & EXCLUD$1 ! MOVEM5T -- H[EV] COH]5T -- TO RECLAIM ! P[] TO CREATE \R [N SOCIAL RELATIONS BEYOND MEASURE1 AN>*I/S >E ?US 9 A POSITION TO DEEP5 ! /RUGGLE AGA9/ CAPITAL & ! /ATE4 ,REF]5CES ,HAKIM ,BEY1 ,T,A,Z4 ,NEW ,YORK3 ,AUTONOM$IA4 ,ALFR$O ,BONANNO1 ,! ,AN>*I/ ,T5SION4 ,LONDON3 ,ELEPHANT ,$ITIONS1 #aiih 7WWW4GEOCITIES4COM74 ,PI]RE ,CLA/RES1 ,SOCIETY ,AGA9/ ! ,/ATE4 ,NEW ,YORK3 ,URIZ51 #a#i#g#g4 ,GILLES ,DELUEZE & ,FELIX ,GUATT>I1 ,NOMADOLOGY3 ,! ,W> ,MA*9E4 ,NEW ,YORK3 ,SEMIOTEXT7E71 #a#i#h#f4 ,MI*AEL ,H>DT & ,ANTONIO ,NEGRI1 ,EMPIRE4 ,CAMBRIDGE3 ,H>V>D ,UNIV]SITY ,PRESS1 #b4 ,DAVID ,H>VEY1 ,! ,CONDITIONS ( ,PO/MOD]NITY4 ,OX=D1 #a#i#h#i4 ,9SURRECTION1 0,AUTONOM\S ,BASE ,NUCLEUS10 7WWW4GEOCITIES4COM7 ,9SURRECTION1 0,BEYOND ! ,/RUCTURES ( ,SYN!SIS10 7WWW4GEOCITIES4COM7 ,PET] ,KROPOTK91 ,! ,CONQUE/ ( ,BREAD4 ,LONDON3 ,ELEPHANT ,$ITIONS1 #a#i#i#f4 ,NIKOS ,MAZOTIS1 0,/ATEM5T TO ! ,A!NS ,CRIM9AL ,C\RT40 7WWW4GEOCITIES4COM7 ,FROM 3 ,!,AN>*I/,LIBR>Y4ORG4 ,*RONOLOGY 3 ,JANU>Y #b#h1 #bba 3 ,! ,AN>*I/ ,E?IC 9 ! ,AGE ( ! ,ANTI-,GLOBALIZATION ,MOVEM5T -- ,ADD$4 ,JANU>Y #g1 #bbb 3 ,! ,AN>*I/ ,E?IC 9 ! ,AGE ( ! ,ANTI-,GLOBALIZATION ,MOVEM5T -- ,UPDAT$4 FILE G5]AT$ FROM 3 HTTP3_/_/REVOLTLIB4COM_/