,*APT] #c1 ,SECTION #c4#a ,ANTAGONI/IC ,EFFECTS ( ! ,PR9CIPLE ( ,DIVISION #ahdfahdf ,PEOPLE 3 ,AU?OR 3 ,PI]RE-,JOSEPH ,PR\DHON ,TEXT 3 ,PR\DHON1 ,PI]RE ,JOSEPH4 ,SY/EM ( ,ECONOMICAL ,CONTRADICTIONS3 OR1 ! ,PHILOSOPHY ( ,MIS]Y ,ELECTRONIC ,TEXT ,C5T]1 ,UNIV]SITY ( ,VIRG9IA ,LIBR>Y #a4 -- ,ANTAGONI/IC EFFECTS ( ! PR9CIPLE ( DIVISION4 ,ALL M5 >E EQUAL 9 ! /ATE ( PRIMITIVE COMMUNISM1 EQUAL 9 !IR NAK$NESS & IGNORANCE1 EQUAL 9 ! 9DEF9ITE P[] ( !IR FACULTIES4 ,! ECONOMI/S G5]ALLY LOOK AT ONLY ! FIR/ ( !SE ASPECTS2 !Y NEGLECT OR OV]LOOK ! SECOND4 ,NEV]!LESS1 ACCORD+ TO ! PR(\NDE/ PHILOSOPH]S ( MOD]N TIMES1 ,LA ,RO*EF\CAULT1 ,HELVETIUS1 ,KANT1 ,FI*TE1 ,HEGEL1 ,JACOTOT1 9TELLIG5CE DIFF]S 9 9DIVIDUALS ONLY QUALITATIVELY1 EA* HAV+ !REBY HIS [N SPECIALTY OR G5IUS2 9 ITS ESS5CE1 -- NAMELY1 JUDGM5T1 -- IT IS QUANTITATIVELY EQUAL 9 ALL4 ,H5CE IT FOLL[S ?AT1 A LITTLE SOON] OR A LITTLE LAT]1 ACCORD+ AS CIRCUM/ANCES %ALL BE MORE OR LESS FAVORABLE1 G5]AL PROGRESS MU/ LEAD ALL M5 FROM ORIG9AL & NEGATIVE EQUALITY TO A POSITIVE EQUIVAL5CE ( TAL5TS & ACQUIREM5TS4 ,I 9SI/ UPON ?IS PRECI\S DATUM ( PSY*OLOGY1 ! NECESS>Y CONSEQU5CE ( :I* IS ?AT ! HI]>*Y ( CAPACITIES H5CE=? CANNOT BE ALL[$ AS A PR9CIPLE & LAW ( ORGANIZATION3 EQUALITY ALONE IS \R RULE1 AS IT IS ALSO \R IDEAL4 ,!N1 JU/ AS ! EQUALITY ( MIS]Y MU/ *ANGE GRADUALLY 9TO EQUALITY ( WELL-BE+1 AS WE HAVE PROV$ BY ! !ORY ( VALUE1 SO ! EQUALITY ( M9DS1 NEGATIVE 9 ! BEG9N+1 S9CE IT REPRES5TS ONLY EMPT9ESS1 MU/ REAPPE> 9 A POSITIVE =M AT ! COMPLETION ( HUMANITY'S $UCATION4 ,! 9TELLECTUAL MOVEM5T PROCE$S P>ALLELLY ) ! ECONOMIC MOVEM5T2 !Y >E ! EXPRESSION1 ! TRANSLATION1 ( EA* O!R2 PSY*OLOGY & SOCIAL ECONOMY >E 9 ACCORD1 OR RA!R1 !Y BUT UNROLL ! SAME HI/ORY1 EA* FROM A DIFF]5T PO9T ( VIEW4 ,?IS APPE>S ESPECIALLY 9 ,SMI?'S GREAT LAW1 ! DIVISION ( LABOR4 ,CONSID]$ 9 ITS ESS5CE1 ! DIVISION ( LABOR IS ! WAY 9 :I* EQUALITY ( CONDITION & 9TELLIG5CE IS REALIZ$4 ,?R\< DIV]SITY ( FUNCTION1 IT GIVES RISE TO PROPORTIONALITY ( PRODUCTS & EQUILIBRIUM 9 EX*ANGE1 & CONSEQU5TLY OP5S = US ! ROAD TO WEAL?2 AS ALSO1 9 %[+ US 9F9ITY EV]Y:]E 9 >T & ,NATURE1 IT LEADS US TO IDEALIZE \R ACTS1 & MAKES ! CREATIVE M9D -- ?AT IS1 DIV9ITY ITSELF1 M5TEM DIV9IOREM -- IMMAN5T & P]CEPTIBLE 9 ALL LABOR]S4 ,DIVISION ( LABOR1 !N1 IS ! FIR/ PHASE ( ECONOMIC EVOLUTION AS WELL AS ( 9TELLECTUAL DEVELOPM5T3 \R PO9T ( DEP>TURE IS TRUE AS REG>DS BO? MAN & ?+S1 & ! PROGRESS ( \R EXPOSITION IS 9 NO WISE >BITR>Y4 ,BUT1 AT ?IS SOLEMN H\R ( ! DIVISION ( LABOR1 TEMPE/U\S W9DS BEG9 TO BL[ UPON HUMANITY4 ,PROGRESS DOES NOT IMPROVE ! CONDITION ( ALL EQUALLY & UNI=MLY1 AL?\< 9 ! 5D IT MU/ 9CLUDE & TRANSFIGURE EV]Y 9TELLIG5T & 9DU/RI\S BE+4 ,IT COMM5CES BY TAK+ POSSESSION ( A SMALL NUMB] ( PRIVILEG$ P]SONS1 :O ?US COMPOSE ! ELITE ( NATIONS1 :ILE ! MASS CONT9UES1 OR EV5 BURIES ITSELF DEEP]1 9 B>B>ISM4 ,IT IS ?IS EXCEPTION ( P]SONS ON ! P>T ( PROGRESS :I* HAS P]PETUAT$ ! BELIEF 9 ! NATURAL & PROVID5TIAL 9EQUALITY ( CONDITIONS1 5G5D]$ CA/E1 & GIV5 AN HI]>*ICAL =M TO ALL SOCIETIES4 ,IT HAS NOT BE5 UND]/OOD ?AT ALL 9EQUALITY1 NEV] BE+ MORE ?AN A NEGATION1 C>RIES 9 ITSELF ! PRO( ( ITS ILLEGITIMACY & ! ANN\NCEM5T ( ITS D[NFALL3 MU* LESS /ILL HAS IT BE5 IMAG9$ ?AT ?IS SAME 9EQUALITY PROCE$S ACCID5TALLY FROM A CAUSE ! ULT]IOR EFFECT ( :I* MU/ BE ITS 5TIRE DISAPPE>ANCE4 ,?US1 ! ANT9OMY ( VALUE REAPPE>+ 9 ! LAW ( DIVISION1 IT IS F\ND ?AT ! FIR/ & MO/ POT5T 9/RUM5T ( KN[L$GE & WEAL? :I* ,PROVID5CE HAS PLAC$ 9 \R H&S HAS BECOME = US AN 9/RUM5T ( MIS]Y & IMBECILITY4 ,H]E IS ! =MULA ( ?IS NEW LAW ( ANTAGONISM1 TO :I* WE [E ! TWO OLDE/ MALADIES ( CIVILIZATION1 >I/OCRACY & ! PROLET>IAT3 ,LABOR1 9 DIVID+ ITSELF ACCORD+ TO ! LAW :I* IS PECULI> TO IT1 & :I* IS ! PRIM>Y CONDITION ( ITS PRODUCTIVITY1 5DS 9 ! FRU/RATION ( ITS [N OBJECTS1 & DE/ROYS ITSELF1 9 O!R WORDS3 ,DIVISION1 9 ! ABS5CE ( :I* !RE IS NO PROGRESS1 NO WEAL?1 NO EQUALITY1 SUBORD9ATES ! WORK+MAN1 & R5D]S 9TELLIG5CE USELESS1 WEAL? H>MFUL1 & EQUALITY IMPOSSIBLE4 ,ALL ! ECONOMI/S1 S9CE ,ADAM ,SMI?1 HAVE PO9T$ \T ! ADVANTAGES & ! 9CONV5I5CES ( ! LAW ( DIVISION1 BUT AT ! SAME TIME 9SI/+ MU* MORE /R5U\SLY UPON ! FIR/ ?AN ! SECOND1 BECAUSE SU* A C\RSE WAS MORE 9 H>MONY ) !IR OPTIMI/IC VIEWS1 & NOT ONE ( !M EV] ASK+ H[ A LAW CAN HAVE 9CONV5I5CES4 ,?IS IS ! WAY 9 :I* ,J4 ,B4 ,SAY SUMM$ UP ! QUE/ION3 -- 0,A MAN :O DUR+ HIS :OLE LIFE P]=MS BUT ONE OP]ATION1 C]TA9LY ACQUIRES ! P[] TO EXECUTE IT BETT] & MORE READILY ?AN ANO!R2 BUT AT ! SAME TIME HE BECOMES LESS CAPABLE ( ANY O!R OCCUPATION1 :E!R PHYSICAL OR MORAL2 HIS O!R FACULTIES BECOME EXT9CT1 & !RE RESULTS A DEG5]ACY 9 ! 9DIVIDUAL MAN4 ,?AT ONE HAS MADE ONLY ! EIT ( A P9 IS A SAD ACC\NT TO GIVE ( ONE'S SELF3 BUT LET NO ONE IMAG9E ?AT IT IS ! WORK+MAN :O SP5DS HIS LIFE 9 H&L+ A FILE OR A HAMM] ?AT ALONE DEG5]ATES 9 ?IS WAY FROM ! DIGNITY ( HIS NATURE2 IT IS ! SAME ) ! MAN :OSE POSITION LEADS HIM TO EX]CISE ! MO/ SUBTLE FACULTIES ( HIS M9D4 4 4 ,ON ! :OLE1 IT MAY BE SAID ?AT ! SEP>ATION ( TASKS IS AN ADVANTAGE\S USE ( HUMAN =CES2 ?AT IT 9CREASES 5ORM\SLY ! PRODUCTS ( SOCIETY2 BUT ?AT IT TAKES SOME?+ FROM ! CAPACITY ( EA* MAN TAK5 9DIVIDUALLY40.<#a.> ,:AT1 !N1 AFT] LABOR1 IS ! PRIM>Y CAUSE ( ! MULTIPLICATION ( WEAL? & ! SKILL ( LABOR]S8 ,DIVISION4 ,:AT IS ! PRIM>Y CAUSE ( 9TELLECTUAL DEG5]ACY &1 AS WE %ALL %[ CONT9UALLY1 CIVILIZ$ MIS]Y8 ,DIVISION4 ,H[ DOES ! SAME PR9CIPLE1 RIGOR\SLY FOLL[$ TO ITS CONCLUSIONS1 LEAD TO EFFECTS DIAMETRICALLY OPPOSITE8 ,!RE IS NOT AN ECONOMI/1 EI!R BE=E OR S9CE ,ADAM ,SMI?1 :O HAS EV5 P]CEIV$ ?AT H]E IS A PROBLEM TO BE SOLV$4 ,SAY GOES SO F> AS TO RECOGNIZE ?AT 9 ! DIVISION ( LABOR ! SAME CAUSE :I* PRODUCES ! GOOD 5G5D]S ! EVIL2 !N1 AFT] A FEW WORDS ( PITY = ! VICTIMS ( ! SEP>ATION ( 9DU/RIES1 CONT5T ) HAV+ GIV5 AN IMP>TIAL & FAI?FUL EXHIBITION ( ! FACTS1 HE LEAVES ! MATT] !RE4 0,Y\ KN[10 HE SEEMS TO SAY1 0?AT ! MORE WE DIVIDE ! WORKM5'S TASKS1 ! MORE WE 9CREASE ! PRODUCTIVE P[] ( LABOR2 BUT AT ! SAME TIME ! MORE DOES LABOR1 GRADUALLY R$UC+ ITSELF TO A ME*ANICAL OP]ATION1 /UPEFY 9TELLIG5CE40 ,9 VA9 DO WE EXPRESS \R 9DIGNATION AGA9/ A !ORY :I*1 CREAT+ BY LABOR ITSELF AN >I/OCRACY ( CAPACITIES1 LEADS 9EVITABLY TO POLITICAL 9EQUALITY2 9 VA9 DO WE PROTE/ ,NOTE3 .<#a.> 0,TREATISE ON ,POLITICAL ,ECONOMY40 9 ! NAME ( DEMOCRACY & PROGRESS ?AT 9 ! FUTURE !RE WILL BE NO NOBILITY1 NO B\RGEOISIE NO P>IAHS4 ,! ECONOMI/ REPLIES1 ) ! IMPASSIBILITY ( DE/9Y3 ,Y\ >E CONDEMN$ TO PRODUCE MU*1 & TO PRODUCE *EAPLY2 O!RWISE Y\R 9DU/RY WILL BE ALWAYS 9SIGNIFICANT1 Y\R COMM]CE WILL AM\NT TO NO?+1 & Y\ WILL DRAG 9 ! RE> ( CIVILIZATION 9/EAD ( TAK+ ! LEAD4 -- ,:AT6 AMONG US1 G5]\S M51 !RE >E SOME PR$E/9$ TO BRUTI%NESS2 & ! MORE P]FECT \R 9DU/RY BECOMES1 ! L>G] WILL GR[ ! NUMB] ( \R ACCURS$ BRO!RS6 4 4 4 4 4 -- ,ALAS6 4 4 4 4 4 ,?AT IS ! LA/ WORD ( ! ECONOMI/4 ,WE CANNOT FAIL TO RECOGNIZE 9 ! DIVISION ( LABOR1 AS A G5]AL FACT & AS A CAUSE1 ALL ! *>ACT]I/ICS ( A ,L,A,W2 BUT AS ?IS LAW GOV]NS TWO ORD]S ( PH5OM5A RADICALLY OPPOSITE & DE/RUCTIVE ( EA* O!R1 IT MU/ BE CONFESS$ ALSO ?AT ?IS LAW IS ( A SORT UNKN[N 9 ! EXACT SCI5CES1 -- ?AT IT IS1 /RANGE TO SAY1 A CONTRADICTORY LAW1 A C\NT]-LAW AN ANT9OMY4 ,LET US ADD1 9 ANTICIPATION1 ?AT SU* APPE>S TO BE ! ID5TIFY+ FEATURE ( SOCIAL ECONOMY1 & CONSEQU5TLY ( PHILOSOPHY4 ,N[1 )\T A ,R,E,C,O,M,P,O,S,I,T,I,O,N ( LABOR :I* %ALL OBVIATE ! 9CONV5I5CES ( DIVISION :ILE PRES]V+ ITS USEFUL EFFECTS1 ! CONTRADICTION 9H]5T 9 ! PR9CIPLE IS IRREM$IABLE4 ,IT IS NECESS>Y1 -- FOLL[+ ! /YLE ( ! ,JEWI% PRIE/S1 PLOTT+ ! DEA? ( ,*RI/1 -- IT IS NECESS>Y ?AT ! POOR %\LD P]I% TO SECURE ! PROPRIETOR HIS = TUNE1 EXP$IT UNUM HOM9EM PRO POPULO MORI4 ,I AM GO+ TO DEMON/RATE ! NECESSITY ( ?IS DECREE2 AFT] :I*1 IF ! P>CELLAIRE LABOR] /ILL RETA9S A GLIMM] ( 9TELLIG5CE1 HE WILL CONSOLE HIMSELF ) ! ?\CELLAIRE DIVISION TO PRO/RATION ( M9D1 DW>FS MAN 9 HIS NOBLE/ P>T1 M9ORAT CAPITIS1 & ?R[S HIM BACK 9TO ANIMALITY4 ,!NCE=? ! FALL5 MAN LABORS AS A BRUTE1 & CONSEQU5TLY MU/ BE TREAT$ AS A BRUTE4 ,?IS S5T5CE ( ,NATURE & NECESSITY SOCIETY WILL EXECUTE4 ,! FIR/ EFFECT ( P>CELLAIRE LABOR1 AFT] ! DEPRAVATION ( ! M9D1 IS ! L5G!N+ ( ! H\RS ( LABOR1 :I* 9CREASE 9 9V]SE PROPORTION TO ! AM\NT ( 9TELLIG5CE EXP5D$4 ,=1 ! PRODUCT 9CREAS+ 9 QUANTITY & QUALITY AT ONCE1 IF1 BY ANY 9DU/RIAL IMPROVEM5T :ATEV]1 LABOR IS LIBITR>Y1 BUT BECAUSE IT IS ESS5TIALLY DET]M9ABLE4 ,LITTLE MATT]S IT ?AT ! /RUGGLE BETWE5 SUPPLY & DEM& 5DS1 N[ TO ! ADVANTAGE ( ! EMPLOY]1 N[ TO ! B5EFIT ( ! EMPLOYEE2 SU* OSCILLATIONS MAY V>Y 9 AMPLITUDE1 ?IS DEP5D+ ON WELL-KN[N ACCESSORY CIRCUM/ANCES :I* HAVE BE5 E/IMAT$ A ?\S& TIMES4 ,! C]TA9 PO9T1 & ! ONLY ONE = US TO NOTICE N[1 IS ?AT ! UNIV]SAL CONSCI5CE DOES NOT SET ! SAME PRICE UPON ! LABOR ( AN OV]SE] & ! WORK ( A HOD-C>RI]4 ,A R$UCTION 9 ! PRICE ( ! DAY'S WORK1 !N1 IS NECESS>Y3 SO ?AT ! LABOR]1 AFT] HAV+ BE5 AFFLICT$ 9 M9D BY A DEGRAD+ FUNCTION1 CANNOT FAIL TO BE /RUCK ALSO 9 HIS BODY BY ! MEAG]NESS ( HIS REW>D4 ,?IS IS ! LIT]AL APPLICATION ( ! WORDS ( ! ,GOSPEL3 ,HE ?AT HA? NOT1 FROM HIM %ALL BE TAK5 EV5 ?AT :I* HE HA?4 ,!RE IS 9 ECONOMIC ACCID5TS A PITILESS REASON :I* LAU FROM ?AT ,*RI/IAN *>ITY ) :I* SO MANY HONORABLE WRIT]S TODAY >E 9SPIR$1 & :I*1 P5ETRAT+ TO ! HE>T ( ! B\RGEOISIE1 5DEAVORS TO TEMP] ! RIGORS ( ! LAW BY NUM]\S RELIGI\S 9/ITUTIONS4 ,POLITICAL ECONOMY KN[S ONLY JU/ICE1 JU/ICE AS 9FLEXIBLE & UNYIELD+ AS ! MIS]'S PURSE2 & IT IS BECAUSE POLITICAL ECONOMY IS ! EFFECT ( SOCIAL SPONTANEITY & ! EXPRESSION ( ! DIV9E WILL ?AT ,I HAVE BE5 ABLE TO SAY3 ,GOD IS MAN'S ADV]S>Y1 & ,PROVID5CE A MISAN?ROPE4 ,GOD MAKES US PAY1 9 WEIS1 = EA* ( \R LESSONS2 & TO COMPLETE ! EVIL1 WE1 9 \R RELATIONS ) \R FELL[S1 ALL ACT LIKE HIM4 ,:]E1 !N1 IS ?IS LOVE ( ! CELE/IAL FA!R = HIS CREATURES8 ,:]E IS HUMAN FRAT]NITY8 ,CAN HE DO O!RWISE8 SAY ! !I/S4 ,MAN FALL+1 ! ANIMAL REMA9S3 H[ C\LD ! ,CREATOR RECOGNIZE 9 HIM HIS [N IMAGE8 ,& :AT PLA9] ?AN ?AT HE TREATS HIM !N AS A BEA/ ( BURD58 ,BUT ! TRIAL WILL NOT LA/ = EV]1 & SOON] OR LAT] LABOR1 HAV+ BE5 P>TICUL>IZ$1 WILL BE SYN!SIZ$4 ,SU* IS ! ORD9>Y >GUM5T ( ALL ?OSE :O SEEK TO JU/IFY ,PROVID5CE1 BUT G5]ALLY SUCCE$ ONLY 9 L5D+ NEW WEAPONS TO A!ISM4 ,?AT IS TO SAY1 !N1 ?AT ,GOD W\LD HAVE 5VI$ US1 = SIX ?\S& YE>S1 AN IDEA :I* W\LD HAVE SAV$ MILLIONS ( VICTIMS1 A DI/RIBUTION ( LABOR AT ONCE SPECIAL & SYN!TIC6 ,9 RETURN1 HE HAS GIV5 US1 ?R\< HIS S]VANTS ,MOSES1 ,BUDDHA1 ,ZOROA/]1 ,MAHOMET1 ETC41 ?OSE 9SIPID WRIT+S1 ! DISGRACE ( \R REASON1 :I* HAVE KILL$ MORE M5 ?AN !Y CONTA9 LETT]S6 ,FUR!R1 IF WE MU/ BELIEVE PRIMITIVE REVELATION1 SOCIAL ECONOMY WAS ! CURS$ SCI5CE1 ! FRUIT ( ! TREE RES]V$ = ,GOD1 :I* MAN WAS =BIDD5 TO T\*6 ,:Y ?IS RELIGI\S DEPRECIATION ( LABOR1 IF IT IS TRUE1 AS ECONOMIC SCI5CE ALREADY %[S1 ?AT LABOR IS ! FA!R ( LOVE & ! ORGAN ( HAPP9ESS8 ,:Y ?IS JEAL\SY ( \R ADVANCEM5T8 ,BUT IF1 AS N[ SUFFICI5TLY APPE>S1 \R PROGRESS DEP5DS UPON \RSELVES ALONE1 ( :AT USE IS IT TO ADORE ?IS PHANTOM ( DIV9ITY1 & :AT DOES HE /ILL ASK ( US ?R\< ! MULTITUDE ( 9SPIR$ P]SONS :O PURSUE US ) !IR S]MONS8 ,ALL ( Y\1 ,*RI/IANS1 PROTE/ANT & OR?ODOX1 NEO-REVELATORS1 *>LATANS & DUPES1 LI/5 TO ! FIR/ V]SE ( ! HUMANIT>IAN HYMN UPON ,GOD'S M]CY3 0,9 PROPORTION AS ! PR9CIPLE ( DIVISION ( LABOR RECEIVES COMPLETE APPLICATION1 ! WORK] BECOMES WEAK]1 N>R[]1 & MORE DEP5D5T4 ,>T ADVANCES3 ! >TISAN REC$ES60.<#a.> ,!N LET US GU>D AGA9/ ANTICIPAT+ CONCLUSIONS & PREJUDG+ ! LATE/ REVELATION ( EXP]I5CE4 ,AT PRES5T ,GOD SEEMS LESS FAVORABLE ?AN HO/ILE3 LET US CONF9E \RSELVES TO E/ABLI%+ ! FACT4 ,JU/ AS POLITICAL ECONOMY1 !N1 AT ITS PO9T ( DEP>TURE1 HAS MADE US UND]/& !SE MY/]I\S & DISMAL WORDS3 ,9 PROPORTION AS ! PRODUCTION ( UTILITY 9CREASES1 V5ALITY DECREASES2 SO >RIV$ AT ITS FIR/ /ATION1 IT W>NS US 9 A T]RIBLE VOICE3 ,9 PROPORTION AS >T ADVANCES1 ! >TISAN REC$ES4 ,TO FIX ! IDEAS BETT]1 LET US CITE A FEW EXAMPLES4 ,9 ALL ! BRAN*ES ( METAL-WORK+1 :O >E ! LEA/ 9DU/RI\S ( ! WAGE-LABOR]S8 ,PRECISELY ?OSE :O >E CALL$ MA*9I/S4 ,S9CE TOOLS HAVE BE5 SO ADMIRABLY P]FECT$1 A MA*9I/ IS SIMPLY A MAN :O KN[S H[ TO HAN ,NOTE3 .<#a.> ,TOCQUEVILLE1 0,DEMOCRACY 9 ,AM]ICA40 ,IDLE A FILE OR A PLANE3 AS = ME*ANICS1 ?AT IS ! BUS9ESS ( 5G9E]S & =EM54 ,A C\NTRY BLACKSMI? (T5 UNITES 9 HIS [N P]SON1 BY ! V]Y NECESSITY ( HIS POSITION1 ! V>I\S TAL5TS ( ! LOCKSMI?1 ! $GE-TOOL MAK]1 ! GUNSMI?1 ! MA*9I/1 ! :EEL-WRIS HAS SE5 ! GR&E/ & F9E/ ?AT HIS PR(ESSION CAN (F]1 ON LEAV+ HIS %OP1 F9DS HIMSELF UNABLE TO R5D] ! SLIN HIS LIV+4 ,! 9CAPACITY ( ! SUBJECT IS DIRECTLY PROPORTIONAL TO ! P]FECTION ( ! >T2 & ?IS IS AS TRUE ( ALL ! TRADES AS ( METAL-WORK+4 ,! WAGES ( MA*9I/S >E MA9TA9$ AS YET AT A HI< RATE3 SOON] OR LAT] !IR PAY MU/ DECREASE1 ! POOR QUALITY ( ! LABOR BE+ UNABLE TO MA9TA9 IT4 ,I HAVE JU/ CIT$ A ME*ANICAL >T2 LET US N[ CITE A LIB]AL 9DU/RY4 ,W\LD ,GUT5BURG & HIS 9DU/RI\S COMPANIONS1 ,FAU/ & ,S*(F]1 EV] HAVE BELIEV$ ?AT1 BY ! DIVISION ( LABOR1 !IR SUBLIME 9V5TION W\LD FALL 9TO ! DOMA9 ( IGNORANCE -- ,I HAD ALMO/ SAID IDIOCY8 ,!RE >E FEW M5 SO WEAK-M9D$1 SO UNLETT]$1 AS ! MASS ( WORK]S :O FOLL[ ! V>I\S BRAN*ES ( ! TYPOGRAPHIC 9DU/RY1 -- COMPOSITORS1 PRESSM51 TYPE-F\ND]S1 BOOK-B9D]S1 & PAP]-MAK]S4 ,! PR9T]1 AS HE EXI/$ EV5 9 ! DAYS ( ! ,E/I5NES1 HAS BECOME ALMO/ AN AB/RACTION4 ,! EMPLOYM5T ( WOM5 9 TYPE-SETT+ HAS /RUCK ?IS NOBLE 9DU/RY TO ! HE>T1 & CONSUMMAT$ ITS DEGRADATION4 ,I HAVE SE5 A FEMALE COMPOSITOR -- & %E WAS ONE ( ! BE/ -- :O DID NOT KN[ H[ TO READ1 & WAS ACQUA9T$ ONLY ) ! =MS ( ! LETT]S4 ,! :OLE >T HAS BE5 )DRAWN 9TO ! H&S ( =EM5 & PRO(-READ]S1 MODE/ M5 ( LE>N+ :OM ! IMP]T95CE ( AU?ORS & PATRONS /ILL HUMILIATES1 & A FEW WORKM5 :O >E REAL >TI/S4 ,! PRESS1 9 A WORD1 FALL5 9TO M]E ME*ANISM1 IS NO LONG]1 9 ITS P]SONNEL1 AT ! LEVEL ( CIVILIZATION3 SOON !RE WILL BE LEFT ( IT BUT A FEW S\V5IRS4 ,I AM TOLD ?AT ! PR9T]S ( ,P>IS >E 5DEAVOR+ BY ASSOCIATION TO RISE AGA9 FROM !IR DEGRADATION3 MAY !IR EF=TS NOT BE EXHAU/$ 9 VA9 EMPIRICISM OR MISL$ 9TO B>R5 UTOPIAS6 ,AFT] PRIVATE 9DU/RIES1 LET US LOOK AT PUBLIC ADM9I/RATION4 ,9 ! PUBLIC S]VICE1 ! EFFECTS ( P>CELLAIRE LABOR >E NO LESS FRITM5TS ( ADM9I/RATION1 9 PROPORTION AS ! >T DEVELOPS1 MO/ ( ! EMPLOYES SEE !IR SAL>IES DIM9I%4 ,A LETT]-C>RI] RECEIVES FROM F\R HUNDR$ TO SIX HUNDR$ FRANCS P] ANNUM1 ( :I* ! ADM9I/RATION RETA9S AB\T A T5? = ! RETIR+ P5SION4 ,AFT] ?IRTY YE>S ( LABOR1 ! P5SION1 OR RA!R ! RE/ITUTION1 IS ?REE HUNDR$ FRANCS P] ANNUM1 :I*1 :5 GIV5 TO AN ALMS-H\SE BY ! P5SION]1 5TITLES HIM TO A B$1 S\P1 & WA%+4 ,MY HE>T BLE$S TO SAY IT1 BUT ,I ?9K1 NEV]!LESS1 ?AT ! ADM9I/RATION IS G5]\S3 :AT REW>D W\LD Y\ GIVE TO A MAN :OSE :OLE FUNCTION CONSI/S 9 WALK+8 ,! LEG5D GIVES BUT FIVE S\S TO ! ,W&]+ ,JEW2 ! LETT]-C>RI]S RECEIVE TW5TY OR ?IRTY2 TRUE1 ! GREAT] P>T ( !M HAVE A FAMILY4 ,?AT P>T ( ! S]VICE :I* CALLS 9TO EX]CISE ! 9TELLECTUAL FACULTIES IS RES]V$ = ! PO/MA/]S & CL]KS3 !SE >E BETT] PAID2 !Y DO ! WORK ( M54 ,EV]Y:]E1 !N1 9 PUBLIC S]VICE AS WELL AS FREE 9DU/RY1 ?+S >E SO ORD]$ ?AT N9E-T5?S ( ! LABOR]S S]VE AS BEA/S ( BURD5 = ! O!R T5?3 SU* IS ! 9EVITABLE EFFECT ( 9DU/RIAL PROGRESS & ! 9DISP5SABLE CONDITION ( ALL WEAL?4 ,IT IS IMPORTANT TO LOOK WELL AT ?IS ELEM5T>Y TRU? BE=E TALK+ TO ! PEOPLE ( EQUALITY1 LIB]TY1 DEMOCRATIC 9/ITUTIONS1 & O!R UTOPIAS1 ! REALIZATION ( :I* 9VOLVES A PREVI\S COMPLETE REVOLUTION 9 ! RELATIONS ( LABOR]S4 ,! MO/ REM>KABLE EFFECT ( ! DIVISION ( LABOR IS ! DECAY ( LIT]ATURE4 ,9 ! ,MIDDLE ,AGES & 9 ANTIQUITY ! MAN ( LETT]S1 A SORT ( 5CYCLOPA$IC DOCTOR1 A SUCCESSOR ( ! TR\BAD\R & ! POET1 ALL-KN[+1 WAS ALMIY SOV]EIGNTY4 ,TODAY WE HAVE MANUFACTUR]S1 LAWY]S1 DOCTORS1 BANK]S1 M]*ANTS1 PR(ESSORS1 5G9E]S1 LIBR>IANS1 ETC42 WE HAVE NO M5 ( LETT]S4 ,OR RA!R1 :OEV] HAS RIS5 TO A REM>KABLE HEIY P>T ( EV]Y PR(ESSION4 ,! MAN ( LETT]S1 R$UC$ TO HIS SIMPLE/ EXPRESSION1 IS ! PUBLIC WRIT]1 A SORT ( WRIT+ COMMISSION] 9 ! PAY ( EV]YBODY1 :OSE BE/-KN[N V>IETY IS ! J\RNALI/4 ,IT WAS A /RANGE IDEA ?AT OCCURR$ TO ! ,*AMB]S F\R YE>S AGO1 -- ?AT ( MAK+ A LAW ON LIT]>Y PROP]TY6 ,AS IF H5CE=? ! IDEA WAS NOT TO BECOME MORE & MORE ! ALL-IMPORTANT PO9T1 ! /YLE NO?+4 ,?ANKS TO ,GOD1 !RE IS AN 5D ( P>LIAM5T>Y ELOQU5CE AS ( EPIC POETRY & MY?OLOGY2 ! !AT] R>ELY ATTRACTS BUS9ESS M5 & SAVANTS2 & :ILE ! CONNOISSEURS >E A/ONI%$ AT ! DECL9E ( >T1 ! PHILOSOPHIC OBS]V] SEES ONLY ! PROGRESS ( MANLY REASON1 TR\BL$ RA!R ?AN REJOIC$ AT !SE DA9TY TRIFLES4 ,! 9T]E/ 9 ROMANCE IS SU/A9$ ONLY AS LONG AS IT RESEMBLES REALITY2 HI/ORY IS R$UC+ ITSELF TO AN?ROPOLOGICAL EXEGESIS2 EV]Y:]E1 9DE$1 ! >T ( TALK+ WELL APPE>S AS A SUBORD9ATE AUXILI>Y ( ! IDEA1 ! FACT4 ,! WOR%IP ( SPEE*1 TOO MAZY & SL[ = IMPATI5T M9DS1 IS NEGLECT$1 & ITS >TIFICES >E LOS+ DAILY !IR P[] ( S$UCTION4 ,! LANGUAGE ( ! N9ETE5? C5TURY IS MADE UP ( FACTS & FIGURES1 & HE IS ! MO/ ELOQU5T AMONG US :O1 ) ! FEWE/ WORDS1 CAN SAY ! MO/ ?+S4 ,:OEV] CANNOT SPEAK ?IS LANGUAGE IS M]CILESSLY RELEGAT$ TO ! RANKS ( ! RHETORICIANS2 HE IS SAID TO HAVE NO IDEAS4 ,9 A Y\NG SOCIETY ! PROGRESS ( LETT]S NECESS>ILY \T/RIPS PHILOSOPHICAL & 9DU/RIAL PROGRESS1 & = A LONG TIME S]VES = ! EXPRESSION ( BO?4 ,BUT !RE COMES A DAY :5 ?\1 & :51 CONSEQU5TLY1 ! CONT9U$ PREEM95CE ( LIT]ATURE 9 A SOCIETY BECOMES A SURE SYMPTOM ( DECL9E4 ,LANGUAGE1 9 FACT1 IS TO EV]Y PEOPLE ! COLLECTION ( ITS NATIVE IDEAS1 ! 5CYCLOPA$IA :I* ,PROVID5CE FIR/ REVEALS TO IT2 IT IS ! FIELD :I* ITS REASON MU/ CULTIVATE BE=E DIRECTLY ATTACK+ ,NATURE ?R\< OBS]VATION & EXP]I5CE4 ,N[1 AS SOON AS A NATION1 AFT] HAV+ EXHAU/$ ! KN[L$GE CONTA9$ 9 ITS VOCABUL>Y1 9/EAD ( PURSU+ ITS $UCATION BY A SUP]IOR PHILOSOPHY1 WRAPS ITSELF 9 ITS POETIC MANTLE1 & BEG9S TO PLAY ) ITS P]IODS & ITS HEMI/I*S1 WE MAY SAFELY SAY ?AT SU* A SOCIETY IS LO/4 ,EV]Y?+ 9 IT WILL BECOME SUBTLE1 N>R[1 & FALSE2 IT WILL NOT HAVE EV5 ! ADVANTAGE ( MA9TA9+ 9 ITS SPL5DOR ! LANGUAGE ( :I* IT IS FOOLI%LY 5AMOR$2 9/EAD ( GO+ =W>D 9 ! PA? ( ! G5IUSES ( TRANSITION1 ! ,TACITUSES1 ! ,?UCYDIDES1 ! ,MA*IAVELS1 & ! ,MONTESQUIEUS1 IT WILL BE SE5 TO FALL1 ) IRRESI/IBLE =CE1 FROM ! MAJE/Y ( ,CIC]O TO ! SUBTLETIES ( ,S5ECA1 ! ANTI!SES ( ,/4 ,AUGU/9E1 & ! PUNS ( ,/4 ,B]N>D4 ,LET NO ONE1 !N1 BE DECEIV$3 FROM ! MOM5T ?AT ! M9D1 AT FIR/ 5TIRELY OCCUPI$ ) SPEE*1 PASSES TO EXP]I5CE & LABOR1 ! MAN ( LETT]S1 PROP]LY SPEAK+1 IS SIMPLY ! PUNY P]SONIFICATION ( ! LEA/ ( \R FACULTIES2 & LIT]ATURE1 ! REFUSE ( 9TELLIG5T 9DU/RY1 F9DS A M>KET ONLY ) ! IDL]S :OM IT AMUSES & ! PROLETAIRES :OM IT FASC9ATES1 ! JUGGL]S :O BESIEGE P[] & ! *>LATANS :O %ELT] !MSELVES BEH9D IT1 ! HI]OPHANTS ( DIV9E RIODIES ( ,GRAC*US & ,DEMOS!NES4 ,ALL ! P[]S ( SOCIETY1 !N1 AGREE 9 9DEF9ITELY DET]IORAT+ ! CONDITION ( ! P>CELLAIRE LABOR]2 & EXP]I5CE1 UNIV]SALLY CONFIRM+ ! !ORY1 PROVES ?AT ?IS WORK] IS CONDEMN$ TO MIS=TUNE FROM HIS MO!R'S WOMB1 NO POLITICAL RE=M1 NO ASSOCIATION ( 9T]E/S1 NO EF=T EI!R ( PUBLIC *>ITY OR ( 9/RUCTION1 HAV+ ! P[] TO AID HIM4 ,! V>I\S SPECIFICS PROPOS$ 9 !SE LATT] DAYS1 F> FROM BE+ ABLE TO CURE ! EVIL1 W\LD T5D RA!R TO 9FLAME IT BY IRRITATION2 & ALL ?AT HAS BE5 WRITT5 ON ?IS PO9T HAS ONLY EXHIBIT$ 9 A CLE> LIY4 ,*RONOLOGY 3 ,NOVEMB] #c1 #ahde 3 ,*APT] #c1 ,SECTION #c4#a -- ,PUBLICATION4 ,JANU>Y #b#i1 #bag 3 ,*APT] #c1 ,SECTION #c4#a -- ,ADD$4 FILE G5]AT$ FROM 3 HTTP3_/_/REVOLTLIB4COM_/