St Mark's, Venice I
--------------------------------------------------------------------

People :
----------------------------------

Author : William Morris

Text :
----------------------------------



      I have just received information, on the accuracy of which I can rely, that the
      restoration of the west front of St. Mark's at Venice, which has long been vaguely
      threatened, is to be taken in hand at once. A commission is called for next month,
      to examine its state and to determine whether it is to be pulled down immediately
      or to be allowed to stand till next year. The fate of such a building seems to me a
      subject important enough to warrant me in asking you to grant me space to make an
      appeal to your readers to consider what a disaster is threatened hereby to art and
      culture in general. Though this marvel of art and treasure of history has suffered
      some disgraces, chiefly in the base mosaics that have supplanted the earlier ones,
      it is in the main in a genuine and untouched state, and to the eye of anyone not an
      expert in building looks safe enough from anything but malice or ignorance. But
      anyhow, if it be in any way unstable, it is impossible to believe that a very
      moderate exercise of engineering skill would not make it as sound as any building
      of its age can be. Whatever pretexts may be put forward, therefore, the proposal to
      rebuild it can only come from those that suppose that they can renew and better (by
      imitation) the workmanship of its details, hitherto supposed to be unrivaled; by
      those that think that there is nothing distinctive between the thoughts, and
      expression of the thoughts, of the men of the twelfth and of the nineteenth
      century; by those that prefer gilding, glitter, and blankness, to the solemnity of
      tone, and the incident that hundreds of years of wind and weather have given to the
      marble, always beautiful, but from the first meant to grow more beautiful by the
      lapse of time; in short, those only can think the `restoration' of St. Mark's
      possible who neither know nor care that it has now become a work of art, a monument
      of history, and a piece of nature. Surely I need not enlarge on the preeminence of
      St. Mark's in all these characters, for no one who even pretends to care about art,
      history, or nature, would call it in question; but I will assert that, strongly as
      I may have seemed to express myself, mywords but feebly represent the feelings of a
      large body of cultivated men who will feel real grief at the loss that seems
      imminent - a loss which may be slurred over, but which will not be forgotten, and
      which will be felt ever deeper as cultivation spreads. That the outward aspect of
      the work should grow uglier day by day in spite of the aspirations of civilization,
      nay, partly because of its triumphs, is a grievous puzzle to some of us who are not
      lacking in sympathy for those aspirations and triumphs, artists and craftsmen as we
      are. So grievous it is that sometimes we are tempted to say, `Let them make a clean
      sweep of it all then: let us forget it all, and muddle on as best we may,
      unencumbered with either history or hope!' But such despair is, we well know, a
      treason to the cause of civilization and the arts, and we do our best to overcome
      it, and to strengthen ourselves in the belief that even a small minority will at
      last be listened to, and its reasonable opinions be accepted. In this belief I have
      troubled you with this letter, and I call on all those who share it to join
      earnestly in any attempt that may be made to save us from an irreparable loss - a
      loss which only headlong rashness could make possible. Surely it can never be too
      late to pull down St Mark's at Venice, the wonder of the civilized world?
    
    
      Letter to the Daily News, 1 November 1879.  
    


     From : Marxists.org

Events :
----------------------------------

     St Mark's, Venice I -- Added : February 20, 2021

     St Mark's, Venice I -- Updated : January 07, 2022

About This Textfile :
----------------------------------

     Text file generated from : 
http://revoltlib.com/