,REVIEW ( ,CON/ITU5T ,IMAG9ATION 

#bh 

,PEOPLE 3 

,AU?OR 3 ,>AGORN6 

,TEXT 3 

,CON/ITU5T ,IMAG9ATION  

$4 ,/EVPH5 ,%UKAITIS @& ,DAVID ,GRAEB] W_/ ,]IKA ,BIDDLE 7,A,K ,PRESS #b#h7  

#ccf PAGES4 ,PAP]1 @s#b#a4#i#e 

,?IS IS AN ECLECTIC BOOK4 ,:ILE ! C5TRAL QUE/ION LIES 9 ! NEI<BORHOOD ( H[ TO RECONCILE ACTIVISM ) ACADEMIA1 !RE >E PL5TY ( PLOT PO9TS (F ! MEAN4 ,D,I,Y ,PUNK ,ROCK1 ANTI-RACISM1 CRO*ET+1 TREE-SITS1 & ANTI-GLOBALIZATION T\RISM >E AMONG WRIT+S ON REAL SUBSUMPTION1 PRAXIS1 E?NOGRAPHY1 & ! MULTITUDE4 

,CONSI/5T ,IMAG9ATION IS ORGANIZ$ 9TO F\R /ANZAS ?AT COMPRISE ! $ITOR'S VIEW ( ! RELATION%IP BETWE5 RADICAL !ORY & ! 0MOVEM5T ( MOVEM5TS0 ( SOCIAL *ANGE1 EA* ) AN $ITORIAL 9TRODUCTION4 ,! FIR/ IS TITL$ ,MOM5TS ( ,POSSIBILITY_/_/,G5EALOGY ( ,RESI/ANCE & ATTEMPTS TO ADDRESS ! C5TRAL QUE/ION ( ?IS BOOK3 H[ DOES ONE NEGOTIATE BETWE5 ! DESIRE = & PRACTICE ( A TOTAL RUPTURE ( ! EXI/+ ORD] :ILE WORK+ TO UND]/& ! EXI/+ ORD]8 ,9 ! P>LANCE ( ! BOOK 0,:]E >E ! FAULT L9ES BETWE5 ACADEMIA1 ACTIVISM1 & ! ORGASMS ( HI/ORY80 

,( ! FIVE >TICLES )9 ?IS SECTION1 ! >TICLE BY ,COLECTIVO ,SITUACIONES 70,SOME?+ MORE ON ,RESE>* ,MILITANCY07 IS ! MO/ IMPORTANT BO? TO ! FIR/ SECTION & TO ! BOOK'S C5TRAL !SIS4 

,9 AN ]A :5 COMMUNICATION IS ! 9DISPUTABLE MAXIM1 9 :I* EV]Y?+ IS JU/IFIABLE BY ITS COMMUNICABLE USEFULNESS1 RESE>* MILITANCY REF]S TO EXP]IM5TATION3 NOT TO ?\<TS1 BUT TO ! P[] TO ?9K2 NOT TO ! CIRCUM/ANCES1 BUT TO ! POSSIBILITY ( EXP]I5CE2 NOT TO ?IS OR ?AT CONCEPT1 BUT TO EXP]I5CES 9 :I* SU* NOTIONS ACQUIRE P[] 7POT5CIA72 NOT TO ID5TITIES BUT TO A DIFF]5T BECOM+2 9 ONE WORD3 9T5SITY DOES NOT LIE SO MU* 9 ?AT :I* IS PRODUC$ 7?AT :I* IS COMMUNICABLE7 AS 9 ! PROCESS ( PRODUCTION ITSELF 7?AT :I* IS LO/ 9 COMMUNICATION74 7#h#a7 

,COLECTIVO ,SITUACIONES IS AN ,>G5T9E GR\P ORIG9AT+ 9 ! RADICAL /UD5T MILIEU ( ! MID-#a#i#iS ?AT1 S9CE !N1 HAS PRODUC$ BOOKS ON UNEMPLOY$ WORK]S' MOVEM5TS1 ! QUE/ION ( P[] & TACTICS ( /RUGGLE1 & CONV]SATIONS AB\T H[ TO ?9K AB\T REVOLUTION TODAY4 ,9 !IR [N WORDS 0.<,WE.> 9T5D TO (F] AN 9T]NAL READ+ ( /RUGGLES1 A PH5OM5OLOGY 7A G5EALOGY71 NOT AN 'OBJECTIVE' DESCRIPTION4 ,IT IS ONLY 9 ?IS WAY ?AT ?\<T ASSUMES A CREATIVE1 AFFIRMATIVE FUNCTION1 & /OPS BE+ A M]E REPRODUCTION ( ! PRES5T4 ,& ONLY 9 ?IS FIDELITY ) ! IMMAN5CE ( ?\<T IS IT A REAL1 DYNAMIC CONTRIBUTION1 :I* IS TOTALLY CONTR>Y TO A PROJECT OR S*EME ?AT PIGEONHOLES & OV]:ELMS PRACTICE07,P]SPECTIVES ON ,AN>*I/ ,!ORY1 FALL1 #b#c7 4 

,IMMAN5CE IS A CONCEPT ?AT HAS GA9$ A K9D ( TR5DY TRACTION AMONG AN>*I/S 9SPIR$ BY ! POLITICAL WRIT+S ( ,DELUEZE1 ALONG ) ! ,NEGRI-I/S ( ! ,AUTONOM\S ,M>XI/ T5D5CY4 ,! IDEA IS RA!R SIMPLE3 RA!R ?AN SEE+ HI/ORY AS A S]IES ( PROGRESSIVE *ANGES LEAD+ TO AN IDEALIZ$ FUTURE 7AS 9 DIALECTICS71 IMMAN5CE SEES NO TRANSC5D5T FUTURE4 ,LIFE IS TO BE LIV$ N[1 NOT AFT] ! REVOLUTION1 & NOT 9 ! S]VICE ( ! HI/ORICAL ACTIVE AG5T4 

,H]E WE SEE ! GREAT POT5TIAL ( PO/-/RUCTURALI/ & AUTONOMI/ IDEAS = CURR5T AN>*I/ ?\<T4 ,IMMAN5CE PROVIDES A CONCEPTUAL FRAMEWORK AS P[]FUL 7IF NOT AS HI/ORICALLY RI*7 AS DIALECTICS1 = UND]/&+ \R P>TICIPATION 9 ?IS HI/ORICAL MOM5T1 & FRAMES ! CONV]SATION ON AN APPROPRIATE SCALE4 ,WE >E NO LONG] = ,GREAT ,M5 & ! 9EVITABILITY ( ,HI/ORY4 ,AS ,DELUEZE PUTS IT 9 HIS READ+ ( ,NIETZS*E 7QUOT$ 9 ,WILL ,WEIK>T1 0,ALL ,GODS1 ,ALL ,MA/]S3 ,IMMAN5CE & ,AN>*Y_/,ONTOLOGY0 9FO49T]ACTIVI/4NET71 0,*OOSE ?OSE ?+S :I* Y\ W\LD HAVE CONT9U+ =EV]1 & EMBRACE !M ) Y\R LIFE4 ,AS A PR9CIPLE1 ?IS APPROA* AVOIDS ! DIRECT NEGATIVITY ( OPPOSITION2 & AS SU* IT ALL[S = A V]Y POSITIVE AFFIRMATION ( ! WORLD40 

,! SECOND SECTION ( ! BOOK1 ,CIRCUITS ( ,/RUGGLE1 SETS UP A S]IES ( METAPHORS AB\T HUMAN 5]GY & ACTIVISM LIKE T5-P5NY NAILS & P\NDS AWAY AT !M LIKE A TE*NOPHILIC C>P5T] BUILD+ A CASKET = ,JOHN ,Z]ZAN4 ,AS A MATT] ( FACT1 ?IS SECTION IS HAUNT$ BY ,Z]ZAN1 ) ITS DEF5SIVE RHETORIC AB\T CIRCUITS1 0TURN+ CYCLES ( /RUGGLES 9TO SPIRALS & OP5+ UP NEW PLANES ( RESI/ANCE0 7#a#a#a71 & ! PROCESS ( COMPOSITION & DECOMPOSITION ( KN[L$GE4 

,! /RA9$ METAPHORS REA* !IR NADIR ) ! >TICLE 0,RE9V5T+ ,TE*NOLOGY3 ,>TIFICIAL ,9TELLIG5CE FROM ! ,TOP ( A ,SYCAMORE ,TREE0 BY ,H>RY ,HALP94 ,SET AS A RANT WRITT5 FROM ! TOP ( A NAMELESS TREE-SIT1 & DECL>+ ?AT 0! RE-5*ANTM5T ( EV]YDAY LIFE0 WILL COME ?R\< TE*NOLOGY -- IT TURNS \T TO BE A NEW =M ( ! OLD >GUM5T AB\T ! NEUTRALITY ( MEANS4 ,IF Y\ >E A GLOBAL JU/ICE ACTIVI/ !N COMMUNICATIONS TE*NOLOGY IS A NEW K9D ( AL*EMY4 ,AS A TE*NOLOGI/ 9 ! MOVEM5T Y\ HAVE TO 0PROVIDE SOLUTIONS ?AT RESPECT ! V]Y HUMAN & ECOLOGICAL ORIG9S ( !SE NETWORKS444 TO TE> D[N >TIFICIAL DIVISIONS BETWE5 TE*NOLOGY1 ACTION1 & !ORY0 7#a#f#b74 ,S\NDS LIKE ! TOP %EET TO A V5TURE CAPITALI/ PROPOSAL4 

,! ?IRD SECTION1 ,COMMUNITIES (_/9 ,RESI/ANCE1 CONTA9S ! DREAMY-EY$ /ORIES ( H[ CURR5T ACTIVISM1 SPECIFICALLY >\ND FOOD POLITICS1 SOCIAL S]VICES1 HOMELESS ORGANIZ+1 & KNITT+1 P]TA9S TO 0CIRCULAT+ MOM5TS ( RUPTURE1 ?R\< CIRCUITS & CYCLES ( /RUGGLE1 WE F9D ! PROCESSES ?R\< :I* COMMUNITIES >E =M$ 9 RESI/ANCE40 7#a#g#i7 

,! MO/ 5GAG+ ( !SE ESSAYS IS 0,! ,REVOLUTION ,WILL ,WE> A ,SWEAT]3 ,KNITT+ & ,GLOBAL ,JU/ICE ,ACTIVISM0 BY ,KIR/Y ,ROB]TSON4 ,?IS >TICLE DOESN'T QUE/ION ! OV]>*+ LOGIC ( ACTIVISM BUT DOES DISCUSS A PRACTICE ?AT IS F> MORE 9T]E/+ ?AN TRADITIONAL GRASSROOTS ACTIVISM OR PROTE/+4 ,AL?\< IT DOESN'T USE ! J>GON ( IMMAN5CE1 KNITT+ IS PRES5T$ AS AN IMMAN5T PRACTICE1 :I* IS A CORRECTION MANY ( ! !ORETICAL >TICLES C\LD HAVE US$4 

,F9ALLY ! LA/ SECTION1 ,$UCATION @& ,E?ICS1 SUMM>IZES ! DEF5SE ( ! BOOK'S C5TRAL !SIS -- ?AT USABLE KN[L$GE = ! SOCIAL JU/ICE MOVEM5T HAS SOME?+ TO DO ) ! 9/ITUTION ( ! UNIV]SITY4 ,EA* ( !SE AU?ORS ASS]TS ?AT KN[L$GE IS A SUP]SET ( ! UNIV]SITY $UCATION PRODUCTION 5VIRONM5T1 BUT SOMEH[ ?AT 5VIRONM5T IS /ILL !RE HAUNT+ US 9 ! BACKGR\ND1 LIKE AN EMPLOY] :OSE PAY*ECKS >E TOO SMALL1 OR A DREAM ( A GOAL NEV] ACCOMPLI%$4 ,SOMETIMES ?IS LOOKS LIKE KN[L$GE IS SOME?+ ?AT CAN1 %\LD1 & MU/ BE 9=M$ BY O!R S\RCES1 LIKE ! ,SITUATIONI/S3 0H[ WE LIVE \R EV]YDAY LIVES HAS EV]Y?+ TO DO ) ! PROJECTS WE ASPIRE TO CREATE & 5ACT4 ,!ORY1 ANALYSIS1 & N>RATION >E A C5TRAL P>T ( \R DAILY ACTIONS1 & !SE DAILY ACTIONS >E1 BY DEF9ITION ! MAT]IALITY ( POLITICS0 7#b#e#d72 OR SCI5CE FICTION10! FIGURE ( ! REVOLT+ KN[L$GE-WORK] HAS NOT YET TRULY MADE ITS PRES5CE KN[N4 ,CYP]-PUNK SEEMS TO HAVE BE5 OV]LY OPTIMI/IC0 7#b#g#b72 OR ANTI-RACI/ P$AGOGY1 0! DEFAULT P$AGOGIC & EPI/EMIC MODES ( ! ACADEMY >E1 BY VIRTUE ( BE+ ! HI/ORICALLY DEVELOP$ & PROMULGAT$ MODES ( A ,EUROC5TRIC & AU?ORIT>IAN 9/ITUTION1 ANTAGONI/IC TO ! AIMS ( ANTI-RACI/ $UCATION0 7#b#i#e74 

,URI ,GORDON'S >TICLE 9 ! LA/ SECTION IS ! /RONGE/ ( ! BOOK 9 DEF5SE ( ! $ITORS' C5TRAL !SIS4 0,PRACTIC+ ,AN>*I/ ,!ORY3 ,T[>DS A ,P>TICIPATORY ,POLITICAL ,PHILOSOPHY0 ELOQU5TLY DRAWS TOGE!R ! ACADEMIC TEXTS ?AT HAVE TAK5 AN>*I/ ?\<T S]I\SLY ) A PROPOSAL = AN>*I/ RESE>*4 ,?IS >TICLE HAS A FASC9AT+ CONTRADICTION AT ITS C5T] BECAUSE IT BO? >GUES FROM ! MO/ CLE>LY ACADEMIC POSITION 7BE+ A S]IES ( PROPOSALS1 LI/S1 & EXPLANATIONS7 & CONCLUDES1 AT ODDS ) ITSELF1 ?AT 

.<T.>HE LACK ( RATIONAL DISCUSSION IS F> FROM ! NORM 9 ! MOVEM5T IF WE ALSO C\NT ! EV]YDAY ORAL COMMUNICATION AMONG AN>*I/S1 :]E ! BULK ( DISCUSSION ) ! MOVEM5T TAKES PLACE4 ,!SE ORAL DISCUSSIONS1 MO/ (T5 9 ! =M ( CAUSAL CONV]SATIONS AMONG ACTIVI/S1 T5D TO BE ( A F> HI<] QUALITY ?AT :AT ,MC,QU9N IS SEE+ 9 ! N>R[ DISPLAY BOX ( AN>*I/ PR9T & ,WEB-BAS$ M$IA444 ,= ?IS REASON IT IS EXTREMELY IMPORTANT = :OEV] WANTS TO WRITE AB\T AN>*ISM TO BE ATT5TIVE TO !SE ORAL DISCUSSIONS & FOLL[ !M 9 A CONSI/5T WAY4 7#b#h#e7 

,MILITANT ,9VE/IGATIONS1 ,COLLECTIVE ,!ORIZATION IS ! SUBTITLE TO ?IS COLLECTION ( 
AUTONOM\S M>XI/1 AN>*I/1 & UNSPECIFI$ RADICAL TRACTS4 ,! SUBTITLE IS ! HI<- H&$ WAY ?AT ! !SIS IS COMMUNICAT$ TO ! READ] -- & BEGS ! QUE/ION ( :AT EXACTLY IS MILITANT AB\T ! 9VE/IGATIONS & :AT IS COLLECTIVE AB\T ! !ORIZATION 9 ?IS BOOK4 

,!IR [N DEF9ITION ( MILITANT 9VE/IGATION IS A %ORT ONE4 ,IT IS AN 09T5SIFICATION & DEEP5+ ( ! POLITICAL444 ,MILITANT ,RESE>* />TS FROM ! UND]/&+S1 EXP]I5CES1 & RELATIONS G5]AT$ ?R\< ORGANIZ+1 AS BO? A ME?OD ( POLITICAL ACTION & A =M ( KN[L$GE0 ,:ILE ?IS DEF9ITION CLE>LY DRAWS A L9E 9 ! S&1 ,I AM NOT SURE IT IS :]E ! $ITORS 9T5D = IT TO BE4 ,= MANY ( ! PEOPLE 9T]E/$ 9 ! QUE/ION 7OR PRACTICE7 ( H[ TO *ANGE ! WORLD1 ! V]Y WORD POLITICAL HAS BECOME SUSPECT4 ,9 ! SAME WAY1 ORGANIZ+ IS A T]M ( ! SAME G5RE1 EXPRESS+ A C]TA9 VIEW ( MANAG+ PEOPLE -- ) ME?OD & GOAL ALREADY DET]M9$4 

,?IS WAY ( FRAM+ ! QUE/ION -- ( ASK+ ! QUE/IONS MANY ( US CONSID] C5TRAL -- BY ALREADY HAV+ DET]M9$ ! ME?OD & ! HI/ORICAL TRAJECTORY BY :I* ! QUE/IONS WILL BE ANSW]$ -- SEV]ELY LIMIT$ ! POT5TIAL ( ?IS BOOK4 ,?IS SAID1 SOME ( ! QUE/IONS >E GOOD ONES & MANY ( ! AU?ORS >E ATTEMPT+ TO ANSW] !M TO ! BE/ ( !IR ABILITIES4 

,AMONG ! AU?ORS !RE IS A COMMON NOM5CLATURE & SET ( POLITICAL M>K]S & B\ND>IES1 BUT !Y >E NOT EXPRESS$ CLE>LY BY ! $ITORS !MSELVES2 9/EAD !Y MU/ BE GLEAN$ BY A CLOSE READ+ ( EA* ( ! TEXTS 7& BY KN[+ A BIT AB\T ! $ITORS74 ,:ILE ?IS BOOK WAS PUBLI%$ BY ! O/5SIBLY AN>*I/ BOOK PUBLI%] ,A,K ,PRESS1 ! $ITORS CLE>LY DRAW MORE 9SPIRATION FROM ! EV5TS 9 ,FRANCE 9 ! #fS1 ,ITALY 9 ! #gS1 & ,C5TRAL & ,S\? ,AM]ICA 9 ! #iS ?AN !Y DO ,SPA9 9 ! #cS4 ,?IS ISN'T A PROBLEM P] SE BUT CONVEY+ ! PO9T ?AT ?IS VOLUME L>GELY COMES \T ( ! ,AUTONOM\S ,M>XI/ TRADITION1 7:ILE ! $ITORS REF] TO !MSELVES AS AN>*I/S 7#a#f771 & :AT EXACTLY ?AT 5TAILS1 IS A C5TRAL PO9T TO ?IS COLLECTION ?AT IS NEV] ADDRESS$1 MU* LESS EXPLA9$4 ,9QUIR+ AN>*I/S W\LD LIKE TO KN[4 

,AS A RESULT1 ! LANGUAGE US$ ?R\<\T ! VOLUME ASSUMES A POLITICAL $UCATION & A SET ( MOTIVATIONS ?AT WILL NOT APPLY TO ALL1 OR EV5 MO/1 READ]S :O >E ACTUALLY 9T]E/$ 9 ! RELATION%IP BETWE5 RADICAL !ORY & SOCIAL *ANGE4 ,AN $UCATION 9 #a#i? C5TURY ,HEGELIAN ?\<T OR #b? C5TURY PO/-/RUCTURALI/ POLITICAL ?\<T TURNS \T TO BE NOT AS RELEVANT AS IS 9=MATION AB\T ! LYRICAL POLEMICS ( ,SUBCOMMADANTE ,M>COS OR KN[L$GE ( ! CONTEXT ( COLLECTIVE FACTORY RECOV]Y MOVEM5TS 9 ,>G5T9A4 

,WE CAN MAP ! RESONANCE & CONNECTIONS OV] PHYSICAL SPACE & 5C\NT]S ?R\< M$IAT$ MA*9ATIONS & COMMUNICATIONS1 ?R\< & >\ND ! DISP>ATE SPACES ?AT COMPOSE ! UNIV]SITY1 ! HOSPITAL1 ! CITY SQU>E1 & ?R\< ALL SPACES ( LIFE4 ,BY LOOK+ AT ! DIFF]5T CIRCUITS & *ANNELS ?R\< :I* 9=MATION FL[S1 WE CAN SEE ?AT C>TOGRAPHIES ( RESI/ANCE TRACE ! MULTIPLE & OV]LAPP+ SPACES & =MS ( /RUGGLE ?AT EXI/1 EXT5D+ & EXP&+ !M4 7#a#a#a7 

,:AT IS A 0C>TOGRAPHY ( RESI/ANCE08 ,IF Y\ >E FAMILI> ) GR\PS LIKE BUREAU D'ETUDES & ,MULTIPLICITY1 Y\ KN[ ?AT ?IS T]M REF]S TO A SUBSET ( ! =MAL DISCIPL9E ( GEOGRAPHY -- A RADICAL CRITIQUE ( MOD]NI/ C>TOGRAPHY A LA ! ,M]CATOR PROJECTION4 ,9/EAD ( SIMPLE TWEAKS TO ,M]CATOR TO CREATE A WORLD MAP REFLECT+ ! ACTUAL SIZE ( ! CONT95TS 7LIKE ! ,GALL-,PET]S PROJECTION71 !SE RADICAL C>TOGRAPH]S MAP ! MICRO 7LIKE ,MULTIPLICITY'S MAP ( TWO R\TES BETWE5 ! SAME TWO PO9TS 9 ,ISRAEL -- ONE = AN ,ISRAELI1 ! O!R = A ,PALE/9IAN7 & ! MACRO 7AS 9 ! P[] MAP BUREAU D'ETUDES CREAT$ ( ! ,U,S POLITICAL SY/EM74 

,A C>TOGRAPHY ( RESI/ANCE MOVES FROM ! WORK ( RADICAL C>TOGRAPH]S 9TO A PRACTICE ?AT IS TE*NICALLY CAPABLE ( EVALUAT+ RELATION%IPS ( PROBABLY DISP>ATE ACTORS ONTO A /AGE :]E !IR ACTIONS CAN BE UND]/OOD1 CLE>LY CONVEY$ TO O!RS1 & PROLIF]AT$4 ,NE>LY EV]Y >TICLE 9 ?IS BOOK HAS A FEW NEW TURNS ( PHRASE ALONG !SE L9ES1 DEM&+ FUR!R RESE>* TO UND]/& ! CONTEXT ?AT !Y COME \T ( & MORE ?AN A LITTLE PATI5CE TO UND]/& :]E ! REF]5CE 5DS & ! /YLI/IC FL\RI% BEG9S4 

,?IS D5SE 0DISCURSIVE REGIME0 DOM9ATES ESPECIALLY ! $ITORIAL VOICE1 BUT ALSO ! BOOK AS A :OLE4 ,! RESULT IS A BOOK ( & = SPECIALI/S 9 ?IS K9D ( LANGUAGE4 ,:O >E !SE PEOPLE8 ,:]E DID !Y GO TO LE>N ?IS J>GON8 ,HAV+ TRA9$ !MSELVES 9 ?IS K9D ( LANGUAGE1 :AT DO !Y DO ) IT & ! M>G9AL K9D ( P[] !Y GA9 AS A RESULT8 

,H[ CAN WE OP5 ! UNIV]SITY TO USE ITS RES\RCES = ! B5EFIT ( MOVEM5TS & ORGANIZ+8 ,H[ CAN WE USE IT TO CREATE A =UM = COLLECTIVE REFLECTION1 TO RE-IMAG9E ! WORLD FROM :]E WE F9D \RSELVES8 ,IT IS ?R\< ?IS CON/ITU5T PROCESS ( COLLECTIVELY %>$ & EMBODI$ IMAG9ATION ?AT ! B\ND>IES ( ! CLASSROOM1 ( :]E KN[L$GE IS CREAT$ & /RUGGLES OCCUR1 />T TO BREAK D[N4 7#b#e#a7 

,DAVID ,GRAEB] IS A WELL-KN[N FIGURE 9 AN>*I/ CIRCLES4 ,HE WAS ONE ( ! M$IA SPOKESPEOPLE DUR+ ! ,N,Y,C ,R,N,C 9 #bd & !N MADE HEADL9ES 7AT LEA/ 9 ! AN>*I/ PRESS7 = HIS RELEASE FROM HIS JOB AT ,YALE4 ,AN 0\T0 AN>*I/ :O WAS ALSO A R5[N$ COLLEGE PR(ESSOR 9 AN?ROPOLOGY MADE HIS EXPULSION DRAMATIC = MANY AN>*I/S4 ,GRAEB] RECOV]$ HIS PR(ESSIONAL /&+ & IS CURR5TLY TEA*+ 9 ! ,U,K4 ,%UKAITIS IS A GRADUATE /UD5T ALSO 9 ! ,U,K4 ,CLE>LY !SE TWO >E NOT EVALUAT+ ! UNIV]SITY FROM A DI/ANCE OR FROM A TOTAL REJECTION ( IT1 BUT AS P>TICIPANTS :O >E TRY+ TO RECONCILE !IR A PRIORI DECISIONS4 

,! USUAL >GUM5T MADE BY RADICALS :O BECOME PR(ESSORS IS ?AT EV]Y P]SON 9 ?IS SOCIETY MU/ WORK1 & ?AT !Y >E JU/ MAK+ A *OICE2 IT IS ONE ?AT CAN BE CRITICIZ$1 BUT IT IS H>DLY ! WOR/ *OICE TO BE MADE )9 CAPITALISM4 ,ADDITIONALLY1 SEV]AL ( ! AU?ORS )9 ?IS COLLECTION >GUE1 RESE>* MILITANCY IS A PROJECT ?AT IS DEF9$ BY ! T5SION ( ITS RELATION%IP ) ACADEMIC KN[L$GE4 ,:O BETT] TO HAVE ?IS T5SION ?AN SELF-DEF9$ RADICALS 9 ! UNIV]SITY8 

,BUT !RE IS SOME?+ AB\T ! ASSUMPTION ?AT ! CLASSROOM IS A LOCUS = /RUGGLE1 = ! CREATION ( KN[L$GE1 ?AT FRAMES ! PRES5T]7S74 ,IS IT REALLY POSSIBLE TO RECLAIM SOME?+ -- ANY?+ -- FROM ! HI]>*ICAL ATMOSPH]E ( ! ,EURO-,AM]ICAN UNIV]SITY /RUCTURE8 ,IS ?IS QUE/ION ANSW]$ DIFF]5TLY IF Y\ >E ON ! CUSP ( BE+ A PR(ESSOR Y\RSELF8 ,A CONC]N ( ?IS BOOK IS ON ! RELEVANCE ( ! UNIV]SITY & ! 9T]- & 9TRA-/RUGGLES !RE94 
,AN >TICLE ?AT DES]VES SPECIAL M5TION AS A CONTRA/ TO ! RE/ ( ! BOOK IS BY ,CRIME?,9C4 CALL$ 0,NO ,GODS1 ,NO ,MA/]S ,DEGREES40 ,BESIDES ! WITTY TITLE1 ?IS >TICLE ASKS MANY ( ! QUE/IONS ?AT ! RE/ ( ! AU?ORS SEEM EI!R OBLIVI\S TO OR ANTAGONI/IC T[>DS4 ,SPECIALIZATION1 TRADITION1 & ! CONFLICT BETWE5 AN>*I/-AS-RESE>*] & AN>*I/-AS-REVOLUTION>Y >E TOPICS GIV5 ONLY %ORT %RIFT 9 ?IS >TICLE BUT >E GL>+ 9 !IR COMPLETE ABS5CE 9 ! RE/ ( ! BOOK4 ,LIKE MO/ ,CRIME?,9C4 WRIT+1 ?IS S]VES AS A POLEMIC 0TO LIFE0 RA!R ?AN ! K9D ( SOB] YET OBVI\SLY 5GAG$ ANALYSIS ( MO/ ( ! O!R >TICLES1 BUT AGA9 ?IS CONTRA/ IS REFRE%+4 ,:5 Y\ HAVE TRAVEL$ ?R\< #c PAGES ( >TICLES ?AT Y\ SUSPECT >E C5TRAL TO A T]M PAP] OR A DOCTORAL !SIS1 READ+ A CRY = ACTION RA!R ?AN A DESCRIPTION ( A NE>-ACTION IS WELCOME RELIEF4 

,CON/ITU5T ,IMAG9ATION SUCCE$S4 ,IT DEMON/RATES ?AT !RE IS A RELATION%IP BETWE5 RADICAL !ORY & :AT REMA9S ( ! MOVEM5TS = SOCIAL *ANGE4 ,SOME GOOD NEWS RESULTS FROM ?IS SUCCESS3 !RE WILL CONT9UE TO BE 9T]E/+ ?9K+ DONE AB\T ! POLITICAL CONSEQU5CES ( SOME ( ! MORE AB/RACT NOTIONS ( PO/-/RUCTURALI/1 AUTONOM\S1 & AN>*I/ IDEAS 9TO ! NEXT FEW DECADES1 BY !SE ?9K]S IF NO ONE ELSE4 ,:ILE MANY READ]S1 & P]HAPS ! AU?ORS !MSELVES1 MAY DISAGREE1 ! BAD NEWS ( ?IS BOOK IS ! \TLOOK = ! 0MOVEM5T ( MOVEM5TS40 ,! GA9S ?AT >E /RUGGL$ = 9 !SE N>RATIVES >E SMALL1 IF NOT M9USCULE4 ,! VISION ( ! CON/ITU5T MOVEM5TS IS MYOPIC TO ! PO9T ( SEV]ITY4 

,! MO/ P>ADIGMATIC MOVEM5TS -- TO ! EXT5T ?AT !Y >E EV5 TREAT$ 9 ?IS TEXT -- >E ! S]IES ( /RUGGLES 9 ,>G5T9A 9 ! FIR/ P>T ( ?IS DECADE4 ,!Y >E LITTLE KN[N1 & W]E IMM$IATELY CLAIM$ BY LIB]ALS & DEFEAT$ BY GLOBALIZATION4 ,?IS S]IES ( EV5TS1 POPUL>IZ$ BY ! ,NAOMI ,KLE9 DOCUM5T>Y 0,! ,TAKE10 DO 9DE$ HE>K5 BACK TO A TIME :]E WORK]S' P[]1 CONSCI\S HUMAN SUBJECTS1 & HOPE-ABOVE-ALL W]E ELEM5TS ( \R POLITICAL EXP]I5CE4 ,WE %\LD NOT EV5 FEEL NO/ALGIA = ! 9CONGRUITY ( ?IS 9COMPLETE VIEW ( ?IS MOM5T4 ,WE %\LD FEEL A CULTURAL DISCONNECT4 

,AS IS (T5 ! CASE :5 IDEAS FROM ONE P>T ( ! WORLD >E %>$ 7(T5 BY EXUB]ANT FANS ( ?OSE IDEAS7 ) ANO!R CULTURE1 SOME?+ IS LO/ 9 TRANSLATION4 ,9 ! CASE ( ,COLECTIVO ,SITUACIONES1 :O >E IMPRESSIVE 9 !IR >TICULATION AB\T PRACTICE & ?\<T & HAVE V]Y LITTLE EXPOSURE 9 ,NOR? ,AM]ICAN RADICAL CIRCLES1 !IR IDEAS AB\T AFFECTIVE EXP]IM5TS1 RESE>* MILITANCY1 & ! 0SAD MILITANT0 >E EXCIT+ BUT ODD4 ,CAN EV5 ! ,NOR? ,AM]ICAN RADICAL ACADEMIC GET MU* \T ( BECOM+ 0MILITANT0 :5 EXPRESS+ VAGUE ANTI-W> BELIEFS IS 5\< TO GET !M ON A RI<T-W+ RADICAL WAT* LI/8 ,>E ! IDEAS ( ,COLECTIVO ,SITUACIONES BE+ PROP]LY UND]/OOD :5 !Y >E EVOK$ AS 9 ! >TICLE 0,DRIFT+ ,?R\< ! ,KN[L$GE ,MA*9E80 ,! >TICLE CITES ,COLECTIVO ,SITUACIONES AS AN 9SPIRATION 9 ITS DESCRIPTION ( A ,LABOR ,DAY PROTE/ :]E C]TA9 ,UNIV]SITY EMPLOYES :]E NOT GIV5 ! DAY (F WORK 7BECAUSE !Y W]5'T PROP]LY DEF9$ AS WORK]S74 ,!IR PROTE/ 9VOLV$ CREAT+ AN 0AD HOC 9T]V5TION GR\P0 VIS A VIS A GR\P ( EMPLOYES 7A4K4A4 KN[L$GE WORK]S7 PROTE/+ !IR EXCLUSION BY DO+ 0MILITANT RESE>*40 ,?IS 5TAIL$ HAV+ /UD5TS & PASS]SBY FILL \T QUE/IONNAIRES & WALK+ >\ND CAMPUS 9 A 0/ATION>Y-DRIFT40 ,NOR? ,AM]ICANS' LACK ( A SOCIAL MOVEM5T ( !IR [N TRANSLATES AS A HUNG] = ! SOCIAL MOVEM5TS ( O!R PEOPLES & PLACES4 

,FROM 3 ,!,AN>*I/,LIBR>Y4ORG4 

,*RONOLOGY 3 
,NOVEMB] #c1 #bg 3 ,REVIEW ( ,CON/ITU5T ,IMAG9ATION -- ,PUBLICATION4 
,APRIL #b#h1 #bb 3 ,REVIEW ( ,CON/ITU5T ,IMAG9ATION -- ,ADD$4 
,JANU>Y #d1 #bbb 3 ,REVIEW ( ,CON/ITU5T ,IMAG9ATION -- ,UPDAT$4 

 FILE G5]AT$ FROM 3  
HTTP3_/_/REVOLTLIB4COM_/