,BOOK #b1 ,*APT] #ba 
,! ,APPEAL ,DISMISS$ 

#ahiiahii 

,PEOPLE 3 

,AU?OR 3 ,LEO ,TOL/OY 

,TRANSLATOR 3 ,L\ISE ,MAUDE 

,TEXT 3 

,AS SOON AS ! ,S5ATORS W]E SEAT$ R\ND ! TABLE 9 ! DEBAT+-ROOM1 ,WOLF BEGAN TO BR+ =W>D ) GREAT ANIMATION ALL ! MOTIVES 9 FAVOR ( A REPEAL4 ,! *AIRMAN1 AN ILL-NATUR$ MAN AT BE/1 WAS 9 A P>TICUL>LY BAD HUMOR ?AT DAY4 ,HIS ?\<TS W]E CONC5TRAT$ ON ! WORDS HE HAD WRITT5 D[N 9 HIS MEMOR&A ON ! OCCASION :5 NOT HE BUT ,VIGLAN(F WAS APPO9T$ TO ! IMPORTANT PO/ HE HAD LONG COVET$4 ,IT WAS ! *AIRMAN1 ,NIKIT9'S1 HONE/ CONVICTION ?AT HIS OP9IONS ( ! (FICIALS ( ! TWO UPP] CLASSES ) :I* HE WAS 9 CONNECTION W\LD FURNI% VALUABLE MAT]IAL = ! HI/ORIANS4 ,HE HAD WRITT5 A *APT] ! DAY BE=E 9 :I* ! (FICIALS ( ! UPP] CLASSES GOT IT HOT = PREV5T+ HIM1 AS HE EXPRESS$ IT1 FROM AV]T+ ! RU9 T[>DS :I* ! PRES5T RUL]S ( ,RUSSIA W]E DRIV+ IT1 :I* SIMPLY MEANT ?AT !Y HAD PREV5T$ HIS GETT+ A BETT] SAL>Y4 ,& N[ HE WAS CONSID]+ :AT A NEW LI<T TO PO/]ITY ?IS *APT] W\LD %$ ON EV5TS4 

0,YES1 C]TA9LY10 HE SAID1 9 REPLY TO ! WORDS ADDRESS$ TO HIM BY ,WOLF1 )\T LI/5+ TO !M4 

,BAY WAS LI/5+ TO ,WOLF ) A SAD FACE & DRAW+ A G>L& ON ! PAP] ?AT LAY BE=E HIM4 ,BAY WAS A ,LIB]AL ( ! V]Y FIR/ WAT]4 ,HE HELD SACR$ ! ,LIB]AL TRADITIONS ( ! SIX? DECADE ( ?IS C5TURY1 & IF HE EV] OV]/EPP$ ! LIMITS ( /RICT NEUTRALITY IT WAS ALWAYS 9 ! DIRECTION ( ,LIB]ALISM4 ,SO 9 ?IS CASE2 BESIDE ! FACT ?AT ! SW9DL+ DIRECTOR1 :O WAS PROSECUT+ = LIBEL1 WAS A BAD LOT1 ! PROSECUTION ( A J\RNALI/ = LIBEL 9 ITSELF T5D+1 AS IT DID1 TO RE/RICT ! FRE$OM ( ! PRESS1 9CL9$ ,BAY TO REJECT ! APPEAL4 

,:5 ,WOLF CONCLUD$ HIS >GUM5TS ,BAY /OPP$ DRAW+ HIS G>L& & BEGAN 9 A SAD & G5TLE VOICE 7HE WAS SAD BECAUSE HE WAS OBLIG$ TO DEMON/RATE SU* TRUISMS7 CONCISELY1 SIMPLY & CONV9C+LY TO %[ H[ UNF\ND$ ! ACCUSATION WAS1 & !N1 B5D+ HIS :ITE HEAD1 HE CONT9U$ DRAW+ HIS G>L&4 

,SKOVORODNIK(F1 :O SAT OPPOSITE ,WOLF1 &1 ) HIS FAT F+]S1 KEPT %OV+ HIS BE>D & MU/A*ES 9TO HIS M\?1 /OPP$ *EW+ HIS BE>D AS SOON AS ,BAY WAS SIL5T1 & SAID ) A L\D1 GRAT+ VOICE1 ?AT1 NOT)/&+ ! FACT ( ! DIRECTOR BE+ A T]RIBLE SC\NDREL1 HE W\LD HAVE BE5 = ! REPEAL ( ! S5T5CE IF !RE W]E ANY LEGAL REASONS = IT2 BUT1 AS !RE W]E NONE1 HE WAS ( ,BAY'S OP9ION4 ,HE WAS GLAD TO PUT ?IS SPOKE 9 ,WOLF'S :EEL4 

,! *AIRMAN AGRE$ ) ,SKOVORODNIK(F1 & ! APPEAL WAS REJECT$4 

,WOLF WAS DISSATISFI$1 ESPECIALLY BECAUSE IT WAS LIKE BE+ CAU<T ACT+ ) DI%ONE/ P>TIALITY2 SO HE PRET5D$ TO BE 9DIFF]5T1 &1 UNFOLD+ ! DOCUM5T :I* CONTA9$ ,MASLOVA'S CASE1 HE BECAME 5GROSS$ 9 IT4 ,MEAN:ILE ! ,S5ATORS RANG & ORD]$ TEA1 & BEGAN TALK+ AB\T ! EV5T ?AT1 TOGE!R ) ! DUEL1 WAS OCCUPY+ ! ,PET]SBURG]S4 

,IT WAS ! CASE ( ! *IEF ( A ,GOV]NM5T DEP>TM5T1 :O WAS ACCUS$ ( ! CRIME PROVID$ = 9 ,/ATUTE #i#i#e4 

0,:AT NA/9ESS10 SAID ,BAY1 ) DISGU/4 

0,:Y2 :]E IS ! H>M ( IT8 ,I CAN %[ Y\ A ,RUSSIAN BOOK CONTA9+ ! PROJECT ( A ,G]MAN WRIT]1 :O OP5LY PROPOSES ?AT IT %\LD NOT BE CONSID]$ A CRIME10 SAID ,SKOVORODNIK(F1 DRAW+ 9 GRE$ILY ! FUMES ( ! CRUMPL$ CIG>ETTE1 :I* HE HELD BETWE5 HIS F+]S CLOSE TO ! PALM1 & HE LAU<$ BOI/]\SLY4 

0,IMPOSSIBLE60 SAID ,BAY4 

0,I %ALL %[ IT Y\10 SAID ,SKOVORODNIK(F1 GIV+ ! FULL TITLE ( ! BOOK1 & EV5 ITS DATE & ! NAME ( ITS $ITOR4 

0,I HE> HE HAS BE5 APPO9T$ GOV]NOR TO SOME T[N 9 ,SIB]IA40 

0,?AT'S F9E4 ,! >*DEACON WILL MEET HIM ) A CRUCIFIX4 ,!Y \<T TO APPO9T AN >*DEACON ( ! SAME SORT10 SAID ,SKOVORODNIK(F4 0,I C\LD RECOMM5D !M ONE10 & HE ?REW ! 5D ( HIS CIG>ETTE 9TO HIS SAUC]1 & AGA9 %OV$ AS MU* ( HIS BE>D & MU/A*ES AS HE C\LD 9TO HIS M\? & BEGAN *EW+ !M4 

,! U%] CAME 9 & REPORT$ ! ADVOCATE'S & ,NEKHLUD(F'S DESIRE TO BE PRES5T AT ! EXAM9ATION ( ,MASLOVA'S CASE4 

0,?IS CASE10 ,WOLF SAID1 0IS QUITE ROMANTIC10 & HE TOLD !M :AT HE KNEW AB\T ,NEKHLUD(F'S RELATIONS ) ,MASLOVA4 ,:5 !Y HAD SPOK5 A LITTLE AB\T IT & F9I%$ !IR TEA & CIG>ETTES1 ! ,S5ATORS RETURN$ 9TO ! ,S5ATE ,*AMB] & PROCLAIM$ !IR DECISION 9 ! LIBEL CASE1 & BEGAN TO HE> ,MASLOVA'S CASE4 

,WOLF1 9 HIS ?9 VOICE1 REPORT$ ,MASLOVA'S APPEAL V]Y FULLY1 BUT AGA9 NOT )\T SOME BIAS & AN EVID5T WI% = ! REPEAL ( ! S5T5CE4 

0,HAVE Y\ ANY?+ TO ADD80 ! *AIRMAN SAID1 TURN+ TO ,FAN>94 ,FAN>9 ROSE1 & /&+ ) HIS BROAD :ITE *E/ EXP&$1 PROV$ PO9T BY PO9T1 ) WOND]FUL EXACTNESS & P]SUASIV5ESS1 H[ ! ,C\RT HAD 9 SIX PO9TS /RAY$ FROM ! EXACT MEAN+ ( ! LAW2 & BESIDES ?IS HE T\*$1 ?\< BRIEFLY1 ON ! M]ITS ( ! CASE1 & ON ! CRY+ 9JU/ICE ( ! S5T5CE4 ,! TONE ( HIS SPEE* WAS ONE ( APOLOGY TO ! ,S5ATORS1 :O1 ) !IR P5ETRATION & JUDICIAL WISDOM1 C\LD NOT HELP SEE+ & UND]/&+ IT ALL BETT] ?AN HE C\LD4 ,HE WAS OBLIG$ TO SPEAK ONLY BECAUSE ! DUTY HE HAD UND]TAK5 =C$ HIM TO DO SO4 

,AFT] ,FAN>9'S SPEE* ONE MI<T HAVE ?\<T ?AT !RE C\LD NOT REMA9 ! LEA/ D\BT ?AT ! ,S5ATE \<T TO REPEAL ! DECISION ( ! ,C\RT4 ,:5 HE HAD F9I%$ HIS SPEE*1 ,FAN>9 LOOK$ R\ND ) A SMILE ( TRIUMPH1 SEE+ :I* ,NEKHLUD(F FELT C]TA9 ?AT ! CASE WAS WON4 ,BUT :5 HE LOOK$ AT ! ,S5ATORS HE SAW ?AT ,FAN>9 SMIL$ & TRIUMPH$ ALL ALONE4 ,! ,S5ATORS & ! ,PUBLIC ,PROSECUTOR DID NOT SMILE NOR TRIUMPH1 BUT LOOK$ LIKE PEOPLE WE>I$1 & :O W]E ?9K+ 0,WE HAVE (T5 HE>D ! LIKE ( Y\2 IT IS ALL 9 VA910 & W]E ONLY TOO GLAD :5 HE /OPP$ & CEAS$ USELESSLY DETA9+ !M !RE4 ,IMM$IATELY AFT] ! 5D ( ! ADVOCATE'S SPEE* ! *AIRMAN TURN$ TO ! ,PUBLIC ,PROSECUTOR4 ,SEL59 BRIEFLY & CLE>LY EXPRESS$ HIMSELF 9 FAVOR ( LEAV+ ! DECISION ( ! ,C\RT UNALT]$1 AS HE CONSID]$ ALL ! REASONS = APPEAL+ 9ADEQUATE4 ,AFT] ?IS ! ,S5ATORS W5T \T 9TO ! DEBAT+-ROOM4 ,!Y W]E DIVID$ 9 !IR OP9IONS4 ,WOLF WAS 9 FAVOR ( ALT]+ ! DECISION4 ,BAY1 :5 HE HAD UND]/OOD ! CASE1 TOOK UP ! SAME SIDE ) F]VOR1 VIVIDLY PRES5T+ ! SC5E AT ! C\RT TO HIS COMPANIONS AS HE CLE>LY SAW IT HIMSELF4 ,NIKIT91 :O ALWAYS WAS ON ! SIDE ( SEV]ITY & =MALITY1 TOOK UP ! O!R SIDE4 ,ALL DEP5D$ ON ,SKOVORODNIK(F'S VOTE1 & HE VOT$ = REJECT+ ! APPEAL1 BECAUSE ,NEKHLUD(F'S DET]M9ATION TO M>RY ! WOMAN ON MORAL GR\NDS WAS EXTREMELY REPUGNANT TO HIM4 

,SKOVORODNIK(F WAS A MAT]IALI/1 A ,D>W9IAN1 & C\NT$ EV]Y MANIFE/ATION ( AB/RACT MORALITY1 OR1 WORSE /ILL1 RELIGION1 NOT ONLY AS A DESPICABLE FOLLY1 BUT AS A P]SONAL AFFRONT TO HIMSELF4 ,ALL ?IS BO!R AB\T A PRO/ITUTE1 & ! PRES5CE ( A CELEBRAT$ ADVOCATE & ,NEKHLUD(F 9 ! ,S5ATE W]E 9 ! HI<E/ DEGREE REPUGNANT TO HIM4 ,SO HE %OV$ HIS BE>D 9TO HIS M\? & MADE FACES1 & V]Y SKILLFULLY PRET5D$ TO KN[ NO?+ ( ?IS CASE1 EXCEPT+ ?AT ! REASONS = AN APPEAL W]E 9SUFFICI5T1 & ?AT HE1 !RE=E1 AGRE$ ) ! *AIRMAN TO LEAVE ! DECISION ( ! ,C\RT UNALT]$4 

,SO ! S5T5CE REMA9$ UNREPEAL$4 

,FROM 3 ,!,AN>*I/,LIBR>Y4ORG4 

,*RONOLOGY 3 
,NOVEMB] #c1 #ahih 3 ,BOOK #b1 ,*APT] #ba -- ,PUBLICATION4 
,JANU>Y #a#c1 #bba 3 ,BOOK #b1 ,*APT] #ba -- ,ADD$4 

 FILE G5]AT$ FROM 3  
HTTP3_/_/REVOLTLIB4COM_/