,LIB]TY ,VOL4 ,I4 ,NO4 #i ,NOT ! ,DAUE WILL+ TO HAZ>D ! JUDGM5T ?AT COM+ HI/ORY WILL YET PLACE HIM 9 ! V]Y FRONT RANKS ( ! WORLD'S GREAT SOCIAL SAVIORS4 ,! GR& HEAD & FACE SPEAK = !MSELVES REG>D+ ! IMM5SE 5]GY1 L(TY *>ACT]1 & 9NATE NOBILITY ( ! MAN4 ,WE %\LD HAVE E/EEM$ IT AMONG ! *IEF HONORS ( \R LIFE TO HAVE KN[N HIM P]SONALLY1 & %\LD ACC\NT IT A GREAT PIECE ( GOOD =TUNE TO TALK ) ONE :O WAS P]SONALLY 9TIMATE ) HIM & ! ESS5CE & FULL MEAN+ ( HIS ?\E]1 GA!R$ FROM V>I\S ,G]MAN & ,FR5* WRIT+S1 ) SU* 9F]5CES AS APPE> TO US JU/ & NATURAL4 ,MI*AEL ,BAKUN9 WAS BORN 9 #ahad ( AN ANCI5T >I/OCRATIC ,RUSSIAN FAMILY4 ,HIS FA!R WAS A WEAL?Y PROPRIETOR ( ,TOR*OK 9 ! GOV]NM5TAL DEP>TM5T ( ,TW]4 ,HE WAS AT AN E>LY AGE S5T TO ! CADET S*OOL ( ,/4 ,PET]SBURG1 & 5T]$ AS 5SIGN 9 ! >TILL]Y4 ,9 ?AT DAY ! >TILL]Y BRAN* ( MILIT>Y S]VICE WAS ONE 9 :I* ! MO/ FAVOR$ >I/OCRACY W]E 5ROLL$1 & IT HAD ALWAYS BE5 ! TRADITIONAL POLICY ( ! CZ>S TO P]MIT GREAT] FRE$OM ( ?\* 9 ?AT BRAN* ( ! S]VICE ?AN 9 ANY O!R4 ,! IMMUNITIES & PRIVILEGES !RE 5JOY$ CORRESPOND$ ) ?AT LIC5SE :I* ! ,G]MAN MON>*S HAVE ALWAYS SUFF]$ 9 ! UNIV]SITIES1 & IT WAS !RE ?AT ,BAKUN9 FIR/ NURTUR$ ! G]MS ( ?OSE GREAT REVOLUTION>Y IDEAS :I* W]E DE/9$ TO MAKE HIS LIFE SO EV5TFUL1 SO H]OIC1 & SO SIGNIFICANT 9 ! EVOLUTION ( SOCIOLOGICAL DRIFTS4 ,) A DEEP YE>N+ TO ?OR\ACT]IZ$ AS ! 0,ALGEBRA ( ,REVOLUTION10 & VISIT$ ,DRESD51 ,LEIPZIG1 & EV]Y O!R LOCALITY :]E HE MID4 ,9 #ahdc HE VISIT$ ,P>IS4 ,H]E HE BECAME AN 5?USIA/IC ADMIR] ( ,PR\DHON1 :O PROBABLY SEASON$ HIS ?\*I/IC T5D5CIES ?AT 9 LAT] DAYS DEVELOP$ HIS LOGIC 9TO :AT CON/ITUTES ! PHILOSOPHICAL ME?OD ( ,NIHILISM1 :I* N[ APPALLS & CONF\NDS DESPOTISM & *ALL5GES ! ATT5TION ( ! :OLE WORLD4 ,FROM ,P>IS HE NEXT W5T TO ,SWITZ]L&1 :]E HE REMA9$ FROM #ahdc TO #a#h#d#g4 ,H]E HE 5T]$ 9TO ! NEW SOCIAL MOVEM5T1 BE+ 5 RAPPORT ) ! ,POLI% EXILES4 ,BUT ALREADY HE HAD EXCIT$ ! GRAVE/ SUSPICIONS ON ! P>T ( ! ,RUSSIAN GOV]NM5T1 & HIS P]MIS TO SOJ\RN ABROAD WAS RESC9D$4 ,9/EAD ( OBEY+1 HE RETURN$ TO ,P>IS1 & !RE DELIV]$ A PUBLIC APPEAL TO ! ,POLES & ,RUSSIANS TO UNITE 9 A GR& ,PAN-,SLAVONIC REVOLUTION>Y CONF$]ATION4 ,AT ! DEM& ( ! CZ> HE WAS EXPELL$ 9 #ahdh FROM ,FRANCE1 & T5 ?\S& RUBLES W]E (F]$ = HIS >RE/ & RETURN TO ,RUSSIA4 ,BUT ! REVOLUTION ( ,FEBRU>Y SOON BR\IS1 :I* HE QUITT$ AGA91 H[EV]1 = ,PRAGUE TO ATT5D ! ,CONGRESS ( ,SLAVS4 ,! FOLL[+ YE> HE W5T TO ,DRESD51 & BECAME ONE ( ! *IEFS ( ! ,MAY REVOLUTION & A MEMB] ( ! 9SURRECTION>Y GOV]NM5T4 ,=C$ TO FLY FROM ,DRESD51 HE WAS CAPTUR$1 S5T TO PRISON1 & CONDEMN$ TO BE EXECUT$ 9 ,MAY1 #a#h#e4 ,HIS S5T5CE1 H[EV]1 WAS COMMUT$ TO IMPRISONM5T = LIFE4 ,ESCAP+ 9TO ,AU/RIA1 HE WAS AGA9 CAPTUR$ & AGA9 S5T5C$ TO DEA?1-- ?IS TIME = HI< TREASON4 ,BUT AGA9 HIS S5T5CE WAS COMMUT$ TO P]PETUAL IMPRISONM5T4 ,UPON REPEAT$ ?REATS & 5TREATIES ! ,AU/RIAN GOV]NM5T WAS CON/RA9$ TO DELIV] HIM UP TO ,RUSSIA4 ,AS IF H>DLY KN[+ H[ TO DISPOSE ( SO DE> A PRIZE1 HE WAS KEPT = SEV]AL YE>S 9 A DUNGEON 9 ! =TRESS ( ,NEVA1 & F9ALLY DEPORT$ TO ,SIB]IA4 ,HE SP5T SEV]AL YE>S 9 A P5AL COLONY1 SUFF]+ ! MO/ CRUEL H>D%IPS1 BUT F9ALLY SUCCE$$ 9 ESCAP+ FROM ,SIB]IA1 A FEAT :I* HE ALONE1 IT IS SAID1 EV] ACCOMPLI%$4 ,AFT] A J\RNEY ( ONE ?\S& MILES1 UND] H>D%IPS :I* APPROA* ! MIRACUL\S1 HE REA*$ ! SEA1 & OBTA9$ PASSAGE TO ,JAPAN4 ,FROM !RE HE SAIL$ TO ,CALI=NIA1 !NCE TO ,NEW ,YORK1 & 9 #a#h#f1 AS IF DESC5D+ FROM ! CL\DS1 ,MI*AEL ,BAKUN9 ALIDOR ( MO/ M51 BUT H>DLY HAD ,BAKUN9 /EPP$ FOOT 9 ,LONDON :5 HE TOOK UP HIS REVOLUTION>Y S*EMES ) R$\BL$ 5?USIASM4 ,HE ISSU$ NUM]\S ADDRESSES TO ! ,POLES & ,RUSSIANS TO JO9 9 A GR& REVOLUTION>Y CONF$]ATION ( ,SLAVS4 ,ASSOCIAT$ ) ,H]Z5 & ,OG>EFF HE PUBLI%$ A REVOLUTION>Y %EET CALL$ 0,! ,KOLOKOL0 7,! ,BELL74 ,BUT SO GR& & DEEP & SE>*+ WAS HIS PHILOSOPHY ?AT HE L$ ALL HIS CO-LABOR]S BEYOND !IR DEP?4 ,! AN>*I/IC PHILOSOPHY :I* HE HAD IMBIB$ FROM ,PR\DHON P]MEAT$ ALL HIS S*EMES4 ,HE WAS N[ PRECIPITAT$ 9TO AN EV]-DEEP5+ CONFLICT ) ! REVOLUTION>Y SOCIALI/S ( ! ,K>L ,M>X S*OOL4 ,AT ! GREAT SOCIALI/ CONGRESS 9 ,G5EVA 9 #ahg HE TOOK DIRECT & POSITIVE ISSUE ) ! GOV]NM5TAL W+ ( ! P>TY4 ,HE DEM&$ ! ABOLITION ( ! ,/ATE & ALL ORGANIZ$ 0MA*9ES0 ( SOCIAL & RELIGI\S ADM9I/RATION4 ,AT ! CONGRESS ( ! ,9T]NATIONAL AT ,HAGUE 9 #ahgb HE WAS EXPELL$1 BUT SUCCE$$ 9 C>RY+ ?IRTY DELEGATES ) HIM1 :I* BODY ( AN>*I/IC RADICALS F9ALLY WAX$ /RONG 5\< TO OV]?R[ ! ,9T]NATIONAL ,ASSOCIATION1 ONLY TO REORGANIZE IT LAT] 7AS !Y DID ?IS LA/ SUMM]7 UND] !IR [N DIRECTION4 ,MI*AEL ,BAKUN9 N[ =MULAT$ HIS SY/EM ( SCI5TIFIC AN>*Y AS FULLY AS HIS RES\RCES W\LD P]MIT4 ,HIS HOPE WAS TO CR[N HIS LIFE-WORK BY SETT+ 9 MOTION A REVOLUTION ?R\<\T ! WORLD1 LOOK+ TO ! ABOLITION ( ! ,/ATE & ! SUB/ITUTION ( ?AT NATURAL ORD] :I* COMES ( JU/ICE1 SELECTION1 & LIB]TY4 ,HIS RUL+ IDEA WAS3 ,GIV5 EQUALITY ( CONDITIONS1 & ORGANIZ$ ,/ATE & ,*UR* BECOME UNNECESS>Y4 ,! ABS5CE ( EQUALITY ( CONDITIONS IS DUE TO ! EXI/5CE ( ! ,/ATE1 & ! ,/ATE ALONE4 ,ABOLI% ! ,/ATE6 WAS ! BANN] :I* HE SET UP TO CONQU] DESPOTISM1 & ]ECT UPON ITS RU9S A REIGN ( TRUE ORD] & NATURAL GOV]NM5T4 ,HIS PHILOSOPHY & PURPOSES HE ELABORAT$ 9 SEV]AL PAMPHLETS1 N[ V]Y R>E1 PR9CIPAL AMONG :I* WAS ONE 5TITL$1 0,DIEU ET L',ETAT0 7,GOD & ! ,/ATE74 ,RUSSIA1 HIS NATIVE C\NTRY1 WAS ! L& 9 :I* HE S\Y1 !RE IS ONE MAN :O SEES ME?OD 9 HIS MADNESS1 IF NOT A WISDOM AK9 TO HIS SUBLIME H]OISM4 ,?AT MAN IS ! CZ>4 ,MI*AEL ,BAKUN9 HAS DOOM$ ! CZ>DOM1 IF NOT IMP]IALISM ?R\<\T ,EUROPE4 ,HIS S\L IS M>*+ ON1 & HIS IDEAS1 BAPTIZ$ 9 LIV+ M>TYRDOM1 >E A T]ROR TO ALL DESPOTS1 ?\< !Y MAY FEIGN IGUORANCE ( HIM4 ,) H&S & HE>T & BRA9 FULL ( REVOLUTION>Y MAT]IAL1 \R H]O DI$ AT ,B]NE1 ,SWITZ]L&1 9 #a#h#g#f4 ,EV5 A TAME SKET* ( HIS SUFF]+S & ADV5TURES 9 ! CAUSE ( LIB]TY W\LD MAKE A TALE ALIKE T\*+ & SUBLIME4 ,= SEV]AL YE>S ( HIS LIFE HE WAS PRACTICALLY \TLAW$ 9 EV]Y L& ON ! PLANET HE S\$ TO ASK = ONE4 ,HE WAS A REFUGEE & AN EXILE FROM EV]Y L&4 ,DESPOTISM HAD /&+ REW>DS = HIS BODY4 ,HE WAS E>LY DIS[N$ BY HIS FAMILY1 AL?\< HIS NAME FIGURES AMONG SOME ( ! *IEF (FIC]S NE> ! ,RUSSIAN C\RT TO-DAY4 ,! EXECUTION] /OOD WAIT+ = HIM 9 SEV]AL C\NTRIES4 ,HE WAS EV]Y:]E TRACK$ BY SPIES & DETECTIVES4 ,HE D>$ NOT EXPOSE HIS NAME ON ! CONT95T \TSIDE ( ,SWITZ]L&4 ,HE HAS NO BIOGRAPH]1 NO AU?ORITATIVE DEF5D]1 & POSSIBLY NO AU!NTICAT$ GRAVE4 ,BUT HIS ?\* \T HIS LONELY RE/+-PLACE & BE> HIM FROM IT AL(T AMONG ! GREAT F\ND]S ( ! NEW HEAV5S & ! NEW E>?4 0,A FREE MAN IS ONE :O 5JOYS ! USE ( HIS REASON & HIS FACULTIES2 :O IS NEI!R BL9D$ BY PASSION1 NOT H9D]$ OR DRIV5 BY OPPRESSION1 NOT DECEIV$ BY ]RONE\S OP9IONS40 -- ,PR\DHON4 ,PLAY-,H\SE ,PHILAN?ROPY4 ,AMONG ! ABLE/ & MO/ 9T]E/+ CONTRIBUTIONS TO ! COLUMNS ( ! 0,IRI% ,WORLD0 >E ! SKET*ES ( ONE ( ITS /AFF CORRESPOND5TS1 0,HONORIUS10 9 :I* ?AT WRIT]1 WEEK AFT] WEEK1 ) ALL ! SKILL & /RATEGY ( A BORN G5]AL1 M>%ALS ANECDOTE1 ILLU/RATION1 HI/ORY1 BIOGRAPHY1 FACT1 LOGIC1 & ! EXP]I5CES ( EV]YDAY LIFE 9 IMPREGNABLE L9E ( BATTLE1 & PRECIPITATES !M UPON ! COHORTS ( ORGANIZ$ TYRANNY & !FT1 MAK+ IRREP>ABLE BREA*ES 9 !IR =TIFICATIONS1 & SPREAD+ HAVOC ?R\<\T !IR RANKS4 ,! +5UITY :I* HE DISPLAYS 9 UTILIZ+ HIS MAT]IAL & TURN+ EV]Y?+ TO ! ACC\NT ( HIS CAUSE IS M>VEL\S4 ,\T ( EA* NEW FACT ?AT FALLS UND] HIS NOTICE1 \T ( EA* NEW *>ACT] ) :OM HE COMES 9 CONTACT1 HE DEVELOPS SOME FRE% >GUM5T AGA9/ ! SY/EM ( !FT ?AT UND]LIES \R SO-CALL$ 0CIVILIZATION10 SOME NOVEL APPLICATION ( ! PR9CIPLES ?AT MU/ UND]LIE ! COM+ TRUE SOCIETY4 ,UNLESS WE >E GREATLY MI/AK51 ! LATE/ ( HIS ASSAULTS WILL NOT PROVE ! LEA/ EFFECTIVE1 S9CE 9 IT HE HAS IMPROV$ AN EXCELL5T OPPORTUNITY TO TURN HIS GUNS UPON 5EMIES NE>] HOME1 5EMIES 9 ! GUISE ( FRI5DS4 ,HE BRIEFLY TELLS ! /ORY ( ! C>E] ( A ,YORK%IRE FACTORY-LORD1 ONE ,SIR ,TITUS ,SALT1 :O1 ?R\< HIS =TUNATE DISCOV]Y ( ! PROCESS ( MANUFACTUR+ ALPACA CLO?1 ACCUMULAT$ AN 5ORM\S =TUNE1 :I* HE EXP5D$ 9 ! E/ABLI%M5T ( 9/ITUTIONS = ! B5EFIT ( HIS EMPLOYES & 9 DE$S ( G5]AL PHILAN?ROPY4 ,TO ?IS MAN HE PAYS A TRIBUTE ( PRAISE = V>I\S VIRTUES1 :I*1 = AUT1 IT WAS EX]CIS$ 9 ! DI/RIBUTION ( O!R PEOPLE'S E>N+S2 & ?AT HIS TITLE TO EXEMPTION FROM ! CONDEMNATION ( HONE/ M5 WAS NO BETT] ?AN ?AT ( ! MORE M]CIFUL ( ! ,S\!RN SLAVE-[N]S4 ,! IMPORTANCE ( ?IS LESSON IT IS IMPOSSIBLE TO OV]E/IMATE4 ,GA9S >E NO LESS ILL-GOTT5 BECAUSE WELL-GIV54 ,PHILAN?ROPY CANNOT PALLIATE PLUND]4 ,ROBB]Y1 ?\< IT BE NOT BORN ( RAPACITY1 IS ROBB]Y /ILL4 ,?IS ,SIR ,TITUS ,SALT BUT S]VES AS A TYPE ( A L>GE CLASS ( 9DIVIDUALS :O >E EV] W9N+ ! APPLAUSE & ADMIRATION ( A WORLD TOO PRONE TO ACCEPT B5EVOL5CE & *>ITY 9 ! /EAD ( JU/ICE & RIISON ) ,SIR ,TITUS1-- ,GOD9 ( ,GUISE1 ! FAM\S F\ND] ( ! ,FAMILI/]RE4 0,! GREAT ,GOD9 ( ,GUISE10 0,HONORIUS0 /YLES HIM2 & IT IS PRECISELY BECAUSE ?IS CLE>HEAD$ WRIT]1 MIS9=M$ AS TO ! REAL FACTS1 MAKES HIM ! OBJECT ( EXAGG]AT$ & MISPLAC$ ADULATION ?AT ! PRES5T >TICLE IS WRITT54 ,( ,SIR ,TITUS ,SALT WE C\LD NOT SPEAK1 BUT ( ! ,FAMILI/]RE & ITS F\ND] WE CAN SAY SOME:AT ?AT MAY 9T]E/ & 5LIACT] AS ! R5[N$ ,FR5*MAN4 ,TITUS ,SALT WAS A SECT>IAN4 ,HIS @s#h1 *UR* WAS = ! 0ACCOMMODATION0 ( HIS [N SECT1 & ?OSE :O HELD TO O!R CRE$S F\ND NO PLACE ( WOR%IP FROM HIS MONEY4 ,GOD9 WAS A GR&1 LIB]AL S\L4 ,?\< $UCAT$ A ,CA?OLIC1 HE MADE ! MO/ LIB]AL PROVISION = EV]Y %ADE ( BELIEF AMONG HIS WORK+ PEOPLE1 & HE DESPIS$ EV]Y =M ( N>R[NESS & BIGOTRY4 ,GOD91 TOO1 WAS TOO NOBLE A S\L TO DESC5D TO ! >TS ( ! POLITICIAN1 & W\LD HAVE DESPIS$ HIMSELF HAD HE SOLICIT$ A VOTE FROM ANY ( HIS PEOPLE4 ,SO WOND]FUL WAS ! SUCCESS ( HIS 9DU/RIAL EXP]IM5T AT ,GUISE ?AT ,L\IS ,NAPOLEON BECAME JEAL\S ( ! POSSIBILITIES = LABOR :I* HE HAD DEMON/RAT$1 & ?AT DESPICABLE FRAUD & ROYAL SC\NDREL1 0,L\IS ! ,LITTLE10 REPEAT$LY W5T \T ( HIS WAY TO HAMP] HIS BUS9ESS1 & EV5 S\T ( A WEEK1 & OCCURR$ AT A V]Y FAVORABLE TIME1 9CLUD+ ONE ( ! TWO ANNUAL FETE DAYS 7CELEBRAT+ ,$UCATION & ,LABOR7 PECULI> TO ! 9/ITUTION4 ,BUT ! IMPRESSION LEFT ON \R M9D WAS BY NO MEANS FAVORABLE4 ,! E/ABLI%M5T SEEM$ P]VAD$ ?R\<\T BY AN ATMOSPH]E ( SUP]VISION & R\T9E1 TEMP]$ H]E & !RE BY AWKW>D ATTEMPTS AT ! PICTURESQUE4 ,! AIR ( BUOYANT CONT5TM5T :I* ! GL[+ ACC\NTS GIV5 ( ! ,SOCIAL ,PALACE W\LD LEAD ONE TO EXPECT DID NOT *>ACT]IZE ! MEMB]S ( ! L>GE H\SEHOLD TO ANY GREAT EXT5T4 ,! WORKM5 SEEM$ TO FEEL !MSELVES & !IR CLASS /ILL ! VICTIMS ( OPPRESSION4 ,A V]Y SLI AN GODLIKE 9 !IR EYES AS 9 ?OSE ?AT VIEW HIM AT A DI/ANCE4 ,9 ! PRES5CE ( ! 9QUIR+ OBS]V] !IR FACES ASSUM$ AN EXPRESSION ?AT SEEM$ TO SAY3 0,OH1 Y\ ?9K IT'S ALL V]Y PRETTY1 NO D\BT2 NO RAGS H]E1 NO DIRT2 EV]Y?+ CLEAN & ORD]LY1 & A MOD]ATE DEGREE ( EXT]NAL COM=T AMONG US ALL4 ,BUT ALL ?IS HAS TO BE PAID = BY SOMEBODY1 & IT IS ! \TSIDE WORLD ?AT FOOTS ! BILLS4 ,\R MA/] HAS ! REPUTATION ( BE+ V]Y K9D & G5]\S1 BUT HE IS \R MA/]4 ,WE 5JOY ?IS MAT]IAL WELF>E AT ! EXP5SE ( SOME?+ ( \R 9DEP5D5CE4 ,BESIDES1 HE'S GOT A S(T ?+ ( IT1-- ROLL+ UP HIS MILLIONS YE> BY YE> & EXCUS+ HIMSELF BY DI/RIBUT+ A C]TA9 PROPORTION ( HIS /EAL+S AMONG US2 BUT HE & ! RE/ ( US >E LIV+ V]Y L>GELY ON \R FELL[-LABOR]S ELSE:]E1 \T ( :OSE POCKETS !SE IMM5SE PR(ITS COME40 ,& ACTUAL QUE/ION+ PROV$ ?AT !IR FACES TOLD ! TRU?4 ,9ABILITY TO CONV]SE FLU5TLY 9 ,FR5* PREV5T$ US FROM 9QUIR+ CLOSELY 9TO DETAILS1 BUT FROM AN 9TELLIG5T Y\NG ,RUSSIAN VISIT+ ! PLACE AT ! SAME TIME & ON MU* ! SAME MISSION AS \RSELVES1 :OSE KN[L$GE ( ,FR5* & ,5GLI% WAS EXCELL5T1 WE ELICIT$ 9=MATION QUITE SUFFICI5T4 ,! MORE 9TELLIG5T ( ! WORKM5 HAD TOLD HIM CONFID5TIALLY JU/ :AT WE HAD READ 9 !IR FACES AS /AT$ ABOVE1 NOT A FEW ( !M CONFESS+ ?AT ,M4 ,GOD91 :O AT ?AT TIME WAS A MEMB] ( ! ,NATIONAL ,*AMB] ( ,DEPUTIES1 HELD HIS SEAT BY A ME?OD /RIK+LY SIMIL> TO ?AT :I* 9 ,MASSA*USETTS ! ,BO/ON 0,H]ALD0 IS WONT TO APOLOGIZE = AS 0CIVILIZ$ BULLDOZ+10-- ?AT IS1 PRIOR TO ELECTION DAY HE CONTRIV$ TO HAVE IT UND]/OOD AMONG HIS EMPLOYES ?AT A CONV5I5T OPPORTUNITY W\LD BE F\ND = ! DIS*>GE ( SU* ( !M AS %\LD FAIL TO VOTE = HIM1 NO MATT] :AT !IR PREVI\S POLITICAL AFFILIATIONS OR PRES5T POLITICAL BELIEFS4 ,& YET 0,HONORIUS0 SAYS 7OR SEEMS TO H9T7 ?AT HE IS NOT AMBITI\S1 & 0,HONORIUS0 IS AN HONORABLE MAN4 ,HUNDR$S & ?\S&S ( HONORABLE M5 %>E ! SAME DELUSION1-- = A DELUSION IT C]TA9LY IS4 ,A /RANGE SORT ( 0PHILAN?ROPI/10 ?IS6 ,A S+UL> 0NOBILITY ( S\L0 IS ,M4 ,GOD9'S6 ,HIS RELIGI\S LIB]ALITY REF]R$ TO BY 0,HONORIUS0 EVID5TLY DOES NOT EXT5D 9TO HIS BUS9ESS & POLITICS4 ,H]E IS A MAN1 +5I\S1 %REWD1 CALCULAT+1 ) L>GE EXECUTIVE CAPACITY & SOME?+ ( A TA/E = PHILOSOPHY1 :O DISCOV]S AN 9DU/RIAL PROCESS :I*1 ?R\< A MONOPOLY GU>ANTE$ BY ! PAT5T LAWS1 HE IS 5ABL$ TO C>RY ON AT AN 5ORM\S PR(IT2 HE EMPLOYS HUNDR$S ( OP]ATIVES2 = !M & !IR FAMILIES HE BUILDS A GIGANTIC HOME1 :I* HE DIGNIFIES BY ! NAME ( A PALACE1 ?\< IT NE$S BUT A FEW BOLTS & B>S TO MAKE IT SEEM MORE LIKE A PRISON1 SO *E]LESS1 =MAL1 & =BIDD+ IS ITS GLOOMY ASPECT2 HE DI/RIBUTES AMONG !M A PORTION ( ! PR(ITS1 P]HAPS TO QUIET HIS CONSCI5CE1 P]HAPS TO BECOME NOT$ = FAIR DEAL+ & PHILAN?ROPY2 ! BALANCE -- MORE ?AN SUFFICI5T TO SATISFY ! ORD9>Y MANUFACTUR] SUBJECT TO COMPETITION -- HE COMPLAC5TLY POCKETS1 PUTT+ =?1 MEAN:ILE1 ! RIDICUL\S PRET5SE ?AT HE HOLDS ?IS FUND AS A TRU/EE2 F9ALLY1 KN[+ NO?+ ( ,LIB]TY & ,EQUITY & SNE]+ AT !IR DEF5D]S1 HE PR(ESSES TO ?9K ?AT HE CAN REG5]ATE ! WORLD BY ! FANCIFUL & UNS\ND S*EMES ( $UCATION ?AT HE SP5DS HIS LEISURE H\RS 9 DEVIS+ & REALIZ+1 SUPPORT+ !M ) WEAL? GA9$ BY !FT1 P[] GA9$ BY 9DIRECT BRIB]Y & BULLDOZ+1 & POPUL>ITY GA9$ BY PRET5SE & HUMBUGG]Y4 ,NEV]!LESS1 = DO+ ?IS ! :OLE HUMANIT>IAN WORLD & NOT A FEW H>D-HEAD$ RE=M]S B[ D[N & WOR%IP HIM4 ,EV5 CLE>-SIY71 IS NECESS>ILY C>RI$ ON 9 VIOLATION ( ?AT PR9CIPLE2 & ?AT :OEV] PROSECUTES IT AS 9 ACCORDANCE ) ?AT PR9CIPLE !REBY PROVES HIMSELF EI!R TOO IGNORANT OR TOO 9S9C]E TO BE ALL[$ TO S]VE1 MU* LESS TO LEAD1 9 ! REVOLUTION>Y MOVEM5T4 ,SU* A MAN IS ( ! PLUND]]S1 & %\LD BE ) !M4 ,IDOL-SMA%+ IS NO 5VIABLE TASK2 BUT TO UNMASK ! PRET5SIONS ( P9EY-H\SE PHILAN?ROPI/S :OSE HI+ ) A =TUNATE FEW ( GOODS /OL5 FROM ! MANY IS A S]VICE ?AT1 H[EV] DISAGREEABLE1 IS ( PRIME NECESSITY 9 ! REALIZATION ( ?AT ,EQUITY :I* DI/RIBUTES TO EA* ! PRODUCT ( HIS LABOR & ?AT ,LIB]TY :I* R5D]S IT IMPOSSIBLE = ONE TO REAP ! PR(IT ( ANO!R'S TOIL4 ,LIB]TY HAD 9 TYPE1 & 9T5D$ TO PUBLI% 9 ?IS ISSUE1 A COMMUNICATION FROM ! C5TRAL BUREAU ( 9=MATION AT ,LONDON REPORT+ ! PROGRESS & GR[? ( ! REORGANIZ$ ,9T]NATIONAL ,WORK+- PEOPLE'S ,ASSOCIATION1 & CONTA9+ A COMPLETE LI/ ( ! GR\PS & SECTIONS ?AT HAVE =W>D$ !IR ADHESIONS & ACCEPT$ ! PLAT=M2 BUT FACTS HAVE REC5TLY TRANSPIR$ ?AT MAKE IT DANG]\S TO REVEAL ! EXI/5CE & LOCATION ( ! ,FR5*1 ,ITALIAN1 & ,SPANI% GR\PS4 ,!RE=E1 RA!R ?AN PR9T AN 9COMPLETE LI/1 WE OMIT IT ALTOGE!R1 SIMPLY /AT+ ?AT1 AP>T FROM ! NUM]\S SECTIONS ?AT PREF] TO CORRESPOND DIRECTLY ) EA* O!R1 =TY-SIX >E 9 DIRECT COMMUNICATION ) ! C5TRAL BUREAU1 WORK+ TOGE!R = ! SOCIAL REVOLUTION ! WORLD OV] 9 H>MONY SUB/ANTIALLY COMPLETE4 ,! ,UNIT$ ,/ATES IS REPRES5T$ BY GR\PS LOCAT$ 9 ,NEW ,YORK1 ,J]SEY ,CITY1 & ,MILWAUKEE4 ,NEW SECTIONS >E =M+ EV]Y:]E ) GREAT RAPIDITY4 ,! PROGRESS ( AN>*I/IC SOCIALISM 9 ,EUROPE IS REALLY WOND]FUL4 ,9 ,SPA91 :]E ! WORK+-PEOPLE >E BEG9N+ TO SEE ! FUTILITY ( POLITICAL ME?ODS1 A REC5T WORK+M5'S CONGRESS DECL>$1 BY ! VOICE ( ONE HUNDR$ & TW5TY-EIELY 9 FAVOR ( AN>*Y4 ,A VALU$ CONTRIBUTOR /RONGLY DEF5DS 9 ANO!R COLUMN ! ATTITUDE REC5TLY TAK5 BY ,O4 ,B4 ,FRO?+HAM1 VIEW+ IT FROM A TRANSC5D5TAL /&PO9T4 ,WE >E MAT]IALI/S ( ! MO/ EXTREME SORT1 BUT DO NOT F9D IT NECESS>Y TO DISCUSS ,MR4 ,FRO?+HAM'S ATTITUDE T[>D REVEAL$ RELIGION AS IF IT W]E AN ISSUE BETWE5 ! EXP]I5TIAL & 9TUITIONAL PHILOSOPHIES4 ,! POSITION ( ,MR4 ,FRO?+HAM SEEMS TO US SOME?+ LIKE ?IS4 ,YE>S AGO HE DISCOV]$ ?AT ! ,*RI/IAN $IFICE1 COM=TABLE AS IT WAS1 /OOD ON A ROTT5 F\NDATION1 & ?AT ITS DECAY+ WALLS W]E LIABLE AT ANY MOM5T TO TUMBLE AB\T HIS E>S4 ,HE WISELY HA/5$ TO AB&ON IT1 & PROCE$$1 9 COMPANY ) O!RS 7WE DO NOT REF] ESPECIALLY TO ! ,FREE ,RELIGI\S ,ASSOCIATION71 TO LAY ! F\NDATIONS = A MORE SOLID /RUCTURE4 ,!Y DID !IR WORK WELL1 & IT IS N[ GO+ BRAVELY ON4 ,BUT1 AS W9T] APPROA*ES1 ! COLD NOR? W9DS :I/LE ?R\< ! B>E FRAMEWORK ( ! ,FREE?\E1 TO TOIL ON 9 ! COLD1 & GOES (F BL[+ HIS DELICATE F+]S ) ! BREA? FROM HIS BLUE NOSE4 ,HE N[ SITS HESITAT+LY 9 ! SUNNIE/ SPOT ?AT HE CAN F9D 9 ! OP5 AIR1 WOND]+ :E!R HE W\LD NOT DO BETT] TO RETURN TO ! $IFICE :I* HE ORIG9ALLY AB&ON$4 0,I KN[ IT IS CRUMBL+10 WE CAN HE> HIM MURMUR1 0BUT !RE IS A FURNACE !RE AT LEA/4 ,%ALL ,I NOT TAKE ! RISK80 ,IF HE SUCCE$S 9 )/&+ ! TEMPTATION1 !RE IS A B>E POSSIBILITY ?AT1 :5 ! ,LIB]AL /RUCTURE IS COMPLET$1 HE WILL AGA9 SEEK ADMISSION TO 5JOY ITS COM=TS1 OR EV51 :5 SUMM] COMES1 ASK P]MISSION TO TAKE A B& 9 F9I%+ ! WORK4 ,O!RS MAY LOOK UPON SU* A C\RSE ) :AT FAVOR !Y CAN2 BUT TO US IT SEEMS WEAK1 *ILDI%1 PETULANT1 C[>DLY1 IGNOBLE1 & FAI?LESS4 ,A WELL-DRESS$1 WELL-BEHAV$ WOMAN 9 ,PROVID5CE WAS RETURN+ TO H] HOME AT #c O'CLOCK A4M4 ,! /REETS BE+ EMPTY1 %E LI1 &1 AS %E SP$ ALONG1 WAT*$ ! CURL+ SMOKE DISSOLVE 9 ! MOONBEAMS1 V]Y MU* AFT] ! MANN] ( A FREE & 9DEP5D5T CITIZ5 ( ! /RONG] SEX4 ,%E WAS QUIET & ORD]LY1 & W5T /RAI*$ H] RUDELY TO ! /ATION4 ,!RE %E RECEIV$ A SECOND DOSE ( BLUE-COAT$ RUD5ESS1 &1 AFT] MANY 9SULTS1 WAS SUFF]$ TO GO1 ) (FICI\S REPRIM&S4 ,! ,WOMAN ,SUFFRAGE ,ASSOCIATION WAS SITT+ 9 ,PROVID5CE AT ?AT TIME4 ,ITS LEAD]S MU/ HAVE SE5 ! ITEM 9 ! PAP]S1 & WE HUMBLY SUGGE/ TO ,LUCY ,/ONE1 ,MRS4 ,E4 ,B4 ,*ACE1 & ! O!R DISCIPLES ( WOMAN'S RI4 ,! VOT+ SW9DLE CREAT$ !SE POLICE RUFFIANS & !IR SUP]IORS4 ,! ,/ATE IS ! REAL LOAF]1 & TRUE WOMAN WILL YET LE>N NOT TO COVET ITS COMPANY OR KEEP IT ALIVE ) VOTES4 ,MR4 ,W4 ,G4 ,H4 ,SM>T IS AB\T TO ISSUE 9 PAMPHLET =M AN ADDRESS DELIV]$ BY HIM1 ,OCTOB] #b1 BE=E ! ,TRANSATLANTIC ,L& & ,LABOR ,LEAGUE ( ,S\? ,BO/ON1 5TITL$ 0,! ,SOCIAL ,ECONOMIC ,SY/EM ,?AT ,IS1 & ,?AT ,IS ,TO ,BE40 ,IT WILL BE PR9T$ ON GOOD PAP] & >RANG$ 9 TWO P>TS4 ,DEAL]S & LABOR ORGANIZATIONS1 FROM :OM ,MR4 ,SM>T REQUE/S E>LY ORD]S1 CAN OBTA9 ! WORK1 AT ! RATE ( TW5TY-FIVE COPIES = ONE DOLL>1 OR ONE COPY = T5 C5TS1 FROM ,E4 ,M4 ,*AMB]L91 0,E*O0 ,PRIM+ ,(FICE1 ,WA%+TON ,/REET1 ,BO/ON1 TO :OM PO/-(FICE MONEY ORD]S %\LD BE MADE PAYABLE4 ,LIB]TY HAS LITTLE 9 COMMON ) ,MR4 ,SM>T'S FUNDAM5TAL ?\ES1 AS H]ET(ORE1 ?AT HE IS NOT 9SANE1 AXCEPT 9 ! 0LEGAL S5SE10-- ?AT IS1 9 ! S5SE ?AT ! PLEA IS SIMPLY A LAWY]'S TRICK = PR(ESSIONAL PURPOSES4 ,N[1 IF TWELVE ,*RI/IANS CAN CONVICT ,GUITEAU1 !Y MU/ BE FRAUDS4 ,HE SAYS ?AT ,GOD TOLD HIM TO DO ! DE$1 JU/ AS ,HE TOLD ,ABRAHAM TO (F] UP ,ISAAC4 ,! DIV9E COMM& WAS TO HIM UNMI/AKABLE4 ,HE OBEY$ IT4 ,IF HE DIES AT ! H&S ( TWELVE ,*RI/IAN JURORS1 HE WILL DIE A M>TYR TO HIS FAI?1 :ILE !Y WILL GO BACK ON !IRS4 ,! 0GOSPEL TRA910 H[EV]1 PROBABLY WILL IGNORE ?IS RELIGI\S HOT BOX1 BUT ! MORE ?\E BEG9N+ TO FE> ! CONSEQU5CES & MAY HA/5 TO GET (F AT ! NEXT /ATION4 ,9 ! CRITICAL COMM5TS ?AT APPE>$ 9 \R LA/ NUMB] UPON SOME REC5T UTT]ANCES ( ,GEORGE ,*A9EY WE W]E GUILTY ( A MISQUOTATION 9 ATTRIBUT+ ! PHRASE 0FREE & EQUAL0 TO ! ,DECL>ATION ( ,9DEP5D5CE4 ,IT OCCURS 9/EAD1 AS A K9D FRI5D HAS PO9T$ \T TO US1 9 ! ,MASSA*USETTS ,BILL ( ,RIELESSNESS CONC]N+ FACTS4 ,N[ WE 0KN[ H[ IT IS \RSELVES10 & MAKE PUBLIC APOLOGY = \R [N C>ELESSNESS CONC]N+ QUOTATIONS4 0,LEAVES ( ,GRASS40 ,LIB]TY HAS RECEIV$ FROM ! PUBLI%]S 7,JAMES ,R4 ,OSGOOD @& ,CO41 ,BO/ON71 & JOYFULLY WELCOMES 0,LEAVES ( ,GRASS10 ! COLLECTIVE TITLE ( ,WALT ,:ITMAN'S POEMS4 ,IT IS A CONV5I5T1 COMPACT1 & TA/EFULLY 0GOT UP0 VOLUME ( #*b PAGES1 & CONTA9S A NUMB] ( HI!RTO UNPUBLI%$ POEMS1 BESIDES ?OSE ( ! E>LI] $ITIONS4 0,LEAVES ( ,GRASS0 HAVE LO/ NO?+ ( !IR ORIG9AL NATIVE SIMPLICITY1 FRE%NESS1 & VIGOR FROM BE+ MORE C>EFULLY >RANG$ & PLAC$ 9 A MORE >TI/IC1 ?\< IT MAY BE A MORE CONV5TIONAL VASE4 ,! BOOK WILL BE MORE READILY PUR*AS$ & READ1 AT ANY RATE2 & ?AT IS ! MA9 PO9T4 ,! TITLES ( SOME ( ! POEMS HAVE BE5 *ANG$1 & ! TABLE ( CONT5TS NEWLY >RANG$ & MADE MU* MORE CONV5I5T = REF]5CE TO SPECIAL PASSAGES4 ,WE HAVE NOT DISCOV]$ ?AT ! BOOK HAS LO/ ANY?+ ( ITS *>ACT]I/IC \TSPOK5 9DEP5D5CE1 NOR ?AT ANY CONCESSION HAS BE5 MADE TO ,MRS4 ,GRUNDY4 ,IT /ILL RETA9S ALL ITS NAK$ TRU?FULNESS & PURITY1 LIKE ITS PROTOTYPE 9 M>BLE1 ! ,GREEK ,SLAVE4 ,WALT ,:ITMAN IS PREEM95TLY1 ABOVE ALL & BE=E ALL1 ! POET ( 9NOVATION1 ! POET ( *ANGE1 ! POET ( GR[?1 ! POET ( EVOLUTION4 ,!RE IS NOT A DROP ( /AGNANT BLOOD 9 HIS VE9S4 ,EV]Y FIB] ( HIM QUIV]S ) LIFE1 5]GY1 & FIRE4 ,HIS SPIRIT IS AT ! SAME TIME ! SPIRIT ( CONT5T & DISCONT5T4 ,HE IS SATISFI$ ) :ATEV] IS & AS IT IS -- = TO-DAY1 BUT NOT = TO-MORR[1 NOR ?AT = ANY FUTURE TO-MORR[4 ,URGE & URGE & URGE1 ,ALWAYS ! PROCREANT URGE ( ! WORLD4 ,?AT SEEMS TO HIM TO BE ! KEY-NOTE ( ! UNIV]SE4 ,A /UDY1 0,BY ,BLUE ,ONT>IO'S ,%ORE10 AF=DS A GOOD IDEA ( :AT HE HIMSELF CONSID]S HIS MISSION1 & %[S H[ ?OR\IO'S %ORE1 ,AS ,I MUS$ ( !SE W>LIKE DAYS & ( PEACE RETURN'D1 & ! DEAD ?AT RETURN NO MORE1 ,A ,PHANTOM GIGANTIC SUP]B1 ) /]N VISAGE ACCO/$ ME1 ,*ANT ME ! POEM1 IT SAID1 ?AT COMES FROM ! S\L ( ,AM]ICA1 ,*ANT ME ! C>OL ( VICTORY1 & /RIKE UP ! M>*ES ( ,LIB]TAD1 M>*ES MORE P[]FUL YET1 ,& S+ ME BE=E Y\ GO ! SONG ( ! ?ROES ( ,DEMOCRACY4 ,! POET1 9 RESPOND+1 COMM5CES ) A /RIK+ BIT ( 9DIVIDUAL SELF-ASS]TION1 ( :I* WE CAN QUOTE BUT A FEW L9ES3 ,A ,NATION ANN\NC+ ITSELF1 ,I MYSELF MAKE ! ONLY GR[? BY :I* ,I CAN BE APPRECIAT$1 ,I REJECT NONE1 ACCEPT ALL1 !N REPRODUCE ALL 9 MY [N =MS4 ,WE >E P[]FUL & TREM5D\S 9 \RSELVES1 ,WE >E EXECUTIVE 9 \RSELVES1 ,WE >E SUFFICI5T 9 ! V>IETY ( \RSELVES1 ,WE >E ! MO/ BEAUTIFUL TO \RSELVES & 9 ON \RSELVES1 ,NO?+ IS S9FUL TO US \TSIDE ( \RSELVES1 ,:ATEV] APPE>S1 :ATEV] DOES NOT APPE>1 WE >E BEAUTIFUL OR S9FUL 9 \RSELVES ONLY4 7,O MO!R -- ,O SI/]S DE>6 ,IF WE >E LO/1 NO VICTORY ELSE HAS DE/ROY'D US1 ,IT IS BY \RSELVES WE GO D[N TO ET]NAL NIB'D TONGUE1 QUE/ION+ EV]Y ONE ,I MEET1 ,:O >E Y\ ?AT WANT$ ONLY TO BE TOLD :AT Y\ KNEW BE=E8 ,SOME:AT *ANG+ ! !ME3 ,I LI/5$ TO ! ,PHANTOM BY ,ONT>IO'S %ORE1 ,I HE>T ! VOICE >IS+ DEM&+ B>DS1 ,BY !M ALL NATIVE & GR&1 BY !M ALONE CAN !SE ,/ATES BE FUZ$ 9TO ! COMPACT ORGANISM ( A ,NATION4 ,TO HOLD M5 TOGE!R BY PAP] & SEAL OR BY COMPULSION IS NO ACC\NT1 ,?AT ONLY HOLDS M5 TOGE!R :I* AGGREGATES ALL 9 A LIV+ PR9CIPLE1 AS ! HOLD ( ! LIMBS ( ! BODY OR ! FIB]S ( PLANTS4 ,( !SE ,/ATES ! ,POET ,IS ! EQUABLE MAN1 ,= ! GREAT ,IDEA1 ! IDEA ( P]FECT & FREE 9DIVIDUALS1 ,= ?AT ! B>D WALKS 9 ADVANCE1 LEAD] ( LEAD]S4 ,! ATTITUDE ( HIM *E]S UP SLAVES & HORRIFIES =EIGN DESPOTS4 ,)\T EXT9CTION IS ,LIB]TY1 )\T RETROGRADE IS ,EQUALITY1 ,!Y LIVE 9 ! FEEL+S ( Y\NG M5 & ! BE/ WOM51 7,NOT = NO?+ HAVE ! 9DOMITABLE HEADS ( ! E>? BE5 ALWAYS READY TO FALL = ,LIB]TY47 ,= ! GREAT ,IDEA1 ,?AT1 ,O MY BRE?R51 ?AT IS ! MISSION ( POETS4 ,A FEW L9ES TO %[ :AT HE CLAIMS = HIMSELF3 ,GIVE ME ! PAY ,I HAVE S]V$ =1 ,GIVE ME TO S+ ! SONGS ( ! GREAT ,IDEA1 TAKE ALL ! RE/4 ,I HAVE LOV$ ! E>?1 SUN1 ANIMALS1 ,I HAVE DESPIS$ RI*ES1 ,CLAIM'D NO?+ TO MYSELF :I* ,I HAVE NOT C>EFULLY CLAIM'D = O!RS ON ! SAME T]MS1 ,I AM WILL+ TO WAIT TO BE UND]/OOD BY ! GR[? ( ! TA/E O MYSELF1 ,REJECT+ NONE1 P]MITT+ ALL4 ,WE MU/ F9D ROOM = \R POET'S CRE$ ( ,9DIVIDUALISM1 & CLOSE !RE) \R QUOTATIONS TROM ?IS REM>KABLE BOOK3 ,I SWE> ,I BEG9 TO SEE ! MEAN+ ( !SE ?+S1 ,IT IS NOT ! E>?1 IT IS NOT ,AM]ICA :O IS SO GREAT1 ,IT IS ,I :O AM GREAT OR TO BE GREAT1 IT IS Y\ UP !RE1 OR ANY ONE1 ,IT IS TO WALK RAPIDLY ?R\< CIVILIZATIONS1 GOV]NM5TS1 !ORIES1 ,?R\< POEMS1 PAGEANTS1 %[S1 TO =M 9DIVIDUALS1 ,UND]NEA? ALL1 9DIVIDUALS1 ,I SWE> NO?+ IS GOOD TO MO ?AT IGNORES 9DIVIDUALS1 ,! ONLY GOV]NM5T IS ?AT :I* MAKES M9UTE ( 9DIVIDUALS1 ,! :OLE !ORY ( ! UNIV]SE IS DIRECT$ UN]R+LY TO ONE S+LE 9DIVIDUAL -- NAMELY TO Y\1 7,TALK AS Y\ LIKE1 HE ONLY SUITS !SE ,/ATES :OSE MANN]S FAVOR ! AUDACITY & SUBLIME TURBUL5CE ( ! ,/ATES17 ,UND]NEA? ! LESSONS ( ?+S1 SPIRITS1 ,NATURE1 GOV]NM5TS1 [N]%IPS1 ,I SWE> ,I P]CEIVE O!R LESSONS1 ,UND]NEA? ALL TO ME 9 MYSELF1 TO Y\ Y\RSELF1 7! SAME MONOTON\S OLD SONG47 ,I AM = ?OSE :O HAVE NEV] BE5 MA/]'D1 ,= M5 & WOM5 :OSE TEMP]S HAVE NEV] BE5 MA/]'D1 ,= ?OSE :OM LAWS1 !ORIES1 CONV5TIONS1 CAN NEV] MA/]4 ,I AM = ?OSE :O WALK ABREA/ ! :OLE E>?1 ,:O 9NAGURATE ONE TO 9AUGURATE ALL4 ,I WILL NOT BE \T-FAC$ BY IRRATIONAL ?+S1 ,I WILL P5ETRATE :AT IT IS 9 !M ?AT IS S>CA/IC UPON ME1 ,I WILL MAKE CITIES & CIVILIZATIONS DEF] TO ME1 ,?IS IS :AT ,I HAVE LE>N'T FROM ,AM]ICA -- IT IS ! AM\NT1 & IT ,I TEA* AGA94 7,DEMOCRACY1 :ILE WEAPONS W]E EV]Y:]E AIM'D AT Y\R BREA/1 ,I SAW Y\ S]5ELY GIVE BIR? TO IMMORTAL *ILDR51 SAW 9 DREAMS Y\R DILAT+ =M1 ,SAW Y\ ) SPREAD+ MANTLE COV]+ ! WORLD47 ,I WILL CONFRONT !SE %[S ( ! DAY & NIE TO BE 5\< = !MSELVES1 & ,I AM NOT TO BE 5\< = MYSELF4 ,ATT5TION1 0,APEX06 ,MY DE> ,MR1 ,TUCK]1-- ,ALL[ ME JU/ TO SAY ?AT 0,APEX0 IS 9 ]ROR 9 SUPPOS+ HE HAS ANSW]$ MY QUE/ION4 ,IT APPE>S BY HIS [N COMM5T ?AT HIS 0,YES0 MEANS ?AT ! PL[-L5D] IS 5TITL$ TO PAY = ! WE> & TE> ( ! PL[4 ,I ASK$3 ,IS HE 5TITL$ TO PAY = ITS USE8 ,I M>VEL ?AT HE %\LD OV]LOOK ! DI/9CTION1 = ,I BAD BE5 C>EFUL TO M>K IT 9 MY FIR/ /ATEM5T4 ,:5 ! QUE/ION AS ,I PUT IT IS ANSW]$ 9 ! AFFIRMATIVE1 ,I %ALL BE READY TO ANSW] ! O!R1 0,:AT ( IT80 ,BUT ,I AM /ILL LEFT TO ! M\RNFUL IMPRESSION ?AT MY QUE/ION IS NOT ANSW]$4 ,Y\RS CORDIALLY1 ,J4 ,M4 ,L4 ,BABCOCK4 ,!RE IS MORE SAV+ GRACE 9 ONE SOT %\T+ 0,FREE RUM60 FROM ! GUTT]1 ?AN 9 ACRES ( PROHIBITORY PRIE/S1 S*OL>S1 & SCI5TI/S4 -- ,PR9CETON ,WORD4 ,USURY4 ,PAY+ MONEY = ! USE ( MONEY IS A GREAT & B>B>\S WRONG4 ,IT IS ALSO A /UP5D\S ABSURDITY4 ,NO ONE MAN CAN USE MONEY4 ,! USE ( MONEY 9VOLVES ITS TRANSF] FROM ONE TO ANO!R4 ,!RE=E1 AS NO ONE MAN CAN USE MONEY1 IT CANNOT BE RIILY A ?+ :I* BELONGS TO SOCIETY4 ,?IS IS ONE ( ! GREAT TRU?S ( CIVILIZATION :I* HAS BE5 G5]ALLY OV]LOOK$4 ,= ?IS :OLE QUE/ION ( ! RI \T1 IT IS & EV] MU/ TO A GREAT WRONG & AN UTT] ABSURDITY TO GIVE WEAL? = ! USE ( AN IDEA4 ,9 EQUITY COMP5SATION IMPLIES S]VICE OR LABOR1 & AS MONEY DOES NOT CO/ LABOR1 :Y1 LABOR CANNOT1 JU/LY BE DEM&$ = ITS USE4 ,BUT LET US LOOK AT IT PRACTICALLY4 ,! PEOPLE USE MONEY2 ! PEOPLE FURNI% ! MONEY2 &1 IF ! CO/ ( ISSUE IS PAID1 !RE CAN BE NO O!R EXP5SE4 ,! GREAT DIFFICULTY T\*+ ?IS :OLE MATT] IS A B>B>\S MISCONCEPTION ( ! NATURE ( MONOY & A MORE B>B>\S DISPOSITION TO MONOPOLIZE P[] & ROB ! WEAK4 ,= -- LET US ASK -- :O PAYS ! GREAT TAX ( 9T]E/8 ,NOT ?OSE :O HAVE & H&LE ! MONEY2 NOT ?OSE :O USE ! MONEY2 BUT ! POOR1 ! WEAK1 ! IGNORANT1 ! DUPES ( ! RUL+ CLASS4 ,WE CAN ILLU/RATE ?IS BY A FACT ( TO-DAY4 ,IF FIVE OR MORE M5 HAV+ ONE HUNDR$ ?\S& DOL>S1 & NO MORE1 ORGANIZE & E/ABLI% A NATIONAL BANK1 JU/ SO SOON AS !IR BANK IS 9 OP]ATION !Y HAVE ! USE & 9COME ( ONE HUNDR$ & N9ETY ?\S& DOLL>S4 ,N[1 IS IT NOT CLE> ?AT1 ?IS COMPANY HAV+ GOT N9ETY ?\S& DOLL>S = NO?+1 SOMEBODY HAS LO/ ?AT AM\NT8 ,=1 IF ONE MAN GETS A DOLL> ?AT HE HAS NOT E>N$1 SOME O!R MAN HAS E>N$ A DOLL> ?AT HE HAS NOT GOT4 ,?AT IS AS C]TA9 AS ?AT TWO & TWO MAKE F\R4 ,IF ALL M5 C\LD USE !IR [N CR$IT 9 ! =M ( MONEY1 !RE C\LD BE NO SU* ?+ AS 9T]E/4 ,YET1 TO PUT ?IS IDEA 9TO PRACTICE1 !RE MU/ BE ORGANIZATION & CONSOLIDATION ( CR$IT4 ,COMM]CIAL CR$IT1 TO BE GOOD1 MU/ BE KN[N TO BE GOOD4 ,A MAN'S CR$IT MAY BE GOOD TO ! EXT5T ( A ?\S& DOLL>S1 BUT1 ?AT FACT NOT BE+ G5]ALLY KN[N1 HE MU/1 AS ?+S >E1 EX*ANGE HIS CR$IT = ?AT :I* IS KN[N TO BE GOOD1 & PAY A MONOPOLY PRICE = ! PRIVILEGE ( US+ HIS [N CR$IT 9 ! =M ( MONEY4 ,LET US REMEMB] ?AT NO MAN CAN BORR[ MONEY1 AS A GOOD BUS9ESS TRANSACTION1 UND] ANY SY/EM1 UNLESS HE HAS ! REQUIR$ SECURITY TO MAKE ! L5D] :OLE 9 CASE HE %\LD LOSE ! MONEY4 ,:AT A /UP5D\S WRONG IS ?IS1-- ?AT A MAN HAV+ CR$IT CANNOT USE IT1 BUT MU/ EX*ANGE IT & PAY A MONOPOLY PRICE1 :I* IS REALLY = ! PRIVILEGE ( US+ HIS [N CR$IT6 ,& AGA91 HE CANNOT PAY ?IS HIMSELF1 BUT MU/ COMPEL ! POOR MAN TO WORK \T ?IS TAX2 ! LATT] MU/ PAY ?IS 9T]E/ 9 ! 5HANC$ PRICE ( GOODS4 ,I WOND] IF ! PEOPLE WILL ALWAYS BE ?IS BL9D & /UPID6 ,SO LONG AS BUS9ESS M51 AS SU*1 & LABOR]S %ALL CONT9UE TO P]MIT ! FEW %REWD MONEY$ M5 TO MONOPOLIZE COMM]CIAL CR$IT1-- ?AT IS1 MONEY1-- JU/ SO LONG WILL IT BE H>D TIMES = BUS9ESS & LABOR4 ,:AT WE WANT N[ IS ! ORGANIZATION ( CR$IT ON A JU/ & EQUAL PLAN4 ,WILLIAM ,B4 ,GRE5E SOLV$ ?IS :OLE MATT] & SUMM$ IT UP 9 TWO WORDS3 0,MUTUAL ,BANK+40 ,?AT IS :AT WE WANT4 ,APEX4 ,MR4 ,FRO?+HAM'S ,DEFECTION4 .<,= ,LIB]TY4.> ,FREE ,RELIGION MAY PUT ON M\RN+ N[4 ,ITS EX-*EF1 IF HE HAS NOT FALL51 HAS HAD HIS M9D GREATLY %AK51 & KN[S NOT BUT HE MU/ BEAT A RETREAT TO ! %ADES :5CE TW5TY YE>S AGO 9TELLECTUALLY HE EM]G$4 0,I DO NOT WANT TO GIVE ! IMPRESSION10 HE IS REPORT$ AS SAY+1 0TAHT ,I RECANT ANY?+4 ,I SIMPLY /OP D5Y+1 & WAIT = MORE LIGUM5T3 AN 9TELLECTUAL /AT+1 A LAWY]-LIKE PRES5T+ ( HIS CASE1-- HIS CASE AGA9/ ! OLD SUP]NATURAL FAI?4 ,ALWAYS WELL DONE2 /RONG1 CLASSICAL1 RHETORICAL1 ELEGANT2 BUT NOT /IRR+ ONE ) MORE ?AN A KE5 9TELLECTUAL APPRECIATION4 0,I ALWAYS FEEL COLD *ILLS RUN D[N MY BACK :5 ------------ SPEAKS10 ONCE SAID AN ACQUA9TANCE ( M9E20 & :5 ?AT HAPP5S1 ,I KN[ MY S\L IS COM+ UP TO FEV] HEAT40 ,BUT IT WAS NOT ,MR4 ,FRO?LN] /ATEM5TS ( :AT HAS BE5 T]M$ ! ,RADICAL1 OR ,LIB]AL1 POSITION ?AN HAS ,MR4 ,FRO?+HAM4 ,HE HAS DONE GREAT S]VICE1 & !RE >E HUNDR$S1 IF NOT ?\S&S1 :O W\LD E>NE/LY CONFESS ?AT HE HAD BE5 A REAL HELP] TO !M4 ,HE HELP$1 AS WE HAVE 9DICAT$1 9 RESOLV+ !IR D\BTS1-- PLAC+ ! WEIGUM5T TO ! D\BT]'S SIDE4 ,BUT TO QUICK5 ! BELIEV] 9 HIS BELIEF1 CLE>+ AWAY ! CONT5TI\S 9TELLECTUALISM ?AT 9T]V5E BETWE5 ! UNIV]SE ( SPIRITUALITIES & ! S\L'S VISION BY SPONTANE\S SPIRITUAL AFFIRMATIONS :I* NO S\L C\LD OR W\LD GA9SAY1-- ?AT FUNCTION ( ! GREAT TEA*]1 OR QUICK5]1 HE DID NOT1 9 ANY M>K$ DEGREE1 POSSESS4 ,HE WAS NOT1 H[EV]1 )\T ?AT SIDE ( HUMAN NATURE4 ,ESPECIALLY 9 HIS PRIVATE CONV]SATION1 :5 CONTROV]SY OR ADVOCACY DID NOT COME TO ! FRONT1 HE W\LD MANIFE/ A RES]VE TRANSC5D5TAL P[] :I* NOT ALONE SURPRIS$ ! LI/5]1 BUT SUGGE/$ ?AT ,MR4 ,FRO?+HAM WAS PROBABLY ! 0COM+ MAN40 ,BUT ?IS SUGGE/ION WAS NOT TO BE REALIZ$4 ,! VIEW ( ! 9TELLECTUAL D\BT] WAS TOO HABITUAL ) HIM4 ,HE MU/ LEAVE HIS [N DIRECT VISION = ! RECON/RUCTION ( OLD VISIONS OR OLD BELIEFS4 ,NOT CONT5T$ ) :AT HE HIMSELF C\LD BELIEVE1 HE MU/ 5T] ! >5A ( DEBATE1 & RID ! WORLD1 BY =CE ( NEW >GUM5TS & PR(\ND] /ATEM5TS1 ( ITS ]RORS4 ,! 0SITUATION0 HAD A *>M HE C\LD NOT RESI/4 ,H[ ,FREE ,RELIGION /OOD2 H[ MU* HEADWAY IT MADE FROM YE> TO YE>2 H[ ! OLD FAI? WAS AFFECT$ BY IT1 & :AT MID !MSELVES AS A P>T ( A MOVEM5T 9 HI/ORY1 & W]E EV] BUSY AB\T ! 0LOGIC0 ( IT2 UNRE/FUL ) !IR IDEAS1 UNLESS !Y C\LD ALSO BE MAK+ !MSELVES FELT AS A P[] 9 ! ,REPUBLIC1 %AP+ EV5TS4 ,F9ALLY1 SOME TWO YE>S AGO1 IT CAME TO PASS ?AT ,MR4 ,FRO?+HAM FELT ! /RESS ( A NEW DEP>TURE SO /RONGLY ?AT HE RETIR$ FROM HIS OLD ASSOCIATIONS & S\LY SEES IS ! FACT ?AT !RE IS SOME?+ 9 HUMAN EXP]I5CE CORRESPOND+ TO :AT ! ,*RI/IAN WORLD HAS PROCLAIM$ AS 0REVEAL$ RELIGION40 ,HE SEES OR FEELS ?AT ! MAT]IALI/IC RELIGION COM+ TO ! FRONT HAS ONLY ! 9TELLECTUAL BASIS :I* CLOSES UP ! *ANNELS ( ! SPIRIT :OSE 9-COM+ 9TO HUMAN EXP]I5CE IS ALL ?AT KEEPS HUMAN LIFE FRE%1 PROGRESSIVE1 &1 9 ANY TRUE S5SE1 ALIVE4 ,:5 HE LEFT ,NEW ,YORK TWO YE>S AGO1 HE ANN\NC$ ?AT HIS M9I/RATIONS FROM ! TRANSC5D5TAL1 OR 9DIVIDUALI/IC1 /&PO9T W]E AT AN 5D4 ,HE LOOK$ = NO F>!R PROGRESS1 SAVE 9 ! B5EFIC5T AIDS ( SOCIAL1 SCI5TIFIC ORGANIZATION4 ,IT WAS HIS LAPSE 9TO ?OSE MAT]IALI/IC MOODS :I* HAVE MORE OR LESS OV]TAK5 NE>LY ALL ! LIB]AL LEAD]S4 ,TO-DAY HE TURNS HIS FACE T[>D 0REVELATION10 :I* IS SIMPLY A WORD ?AT /&S = ! SO-CALL$ OR?ODOX 9T]PRETATION ( ! S\L'S PROCLAMATION4 ,AS ! ,*RI/IAN WORLD HAS UND]/OOD 7OR MISUND]/OOD7 ! GREAT FACT ( ! S\L'S REVELATION ( ITSELF1 ! WORLD IS LIMIT$ TO AN 9DIVIDUALISM ( A PA/ AGE4 ,PET]1 ,PAUL1 & ,JESUS HAD REVELATIONS FROM ! S\L1 BUT NO 9DIVIDUAL TO-DAY MAY ASSUME ANY SU* IMPORTANCE4 ,?IS LIMITATION IS ! ,*RI/IAN'S MISAPPREH5SION1 ! TRU? BE+ ?AT ALL AGES & ALL 9DIVIDUALS MAY LEAVE ?IS OP5 DOOR = ! S\L'S 5TRANCE4 ,UND\BT$LY ,MR4 ,FRO?+HAM SAW 9 ! ,CA?OLIC CL]GY A C]TA9 0P[] BEH9D !M :I* MU/ MY/IFY ! PHILOSOPH]S10 ESPECIALLY ?OSE :OSE LIFE IS L$ BY SPECULATIONS ( ! MAT]IALI/IC BRA94 ,!SE ,CA?OLICS HAVE AT LEA/ SOME PORTIONS ( ! S\L'S REVELATION BY 9H]ITANCE4 ,HAD !Y ?AT :I* MIATELY AS 9DIVIDUALS W]E !Y DISCONNECT$ FROM ORGANIZ$ TYRANNY1 ! MY/]I\S P[] ,MR4 ,FRO?+HAM SPEAKS ( W\LD NOT LESS51 BUT 9CREASE4 ,MR4 ,FRO?+HAM'S PURPOSE TO /OP D5Y+ & WAIT = MORE LI !IR DISS]TATIONS ( 0REVEAL$ RELIGION10 HE WILL CEASE TO BE LOYAL TO HIS PURPOSE4 ,!RE IS A DIFF]5CE BETWE5 WAIT+ & GO+ AFT] LIY ( HIS M9I/RY WAS HIS UN/EADY RELIANCE ON ! REVELATIONS ( HIS [N S\L4 ,HIS WAIT+ MAY RE/ORE HIS FAI? !RE91 & CLO! HIM ) P[] AS FROM ON ,HI<4 ,FROM 3 ,!,AN>*I/,LIBR>Y4ORG4 ,*RONOLOGY 3 ,JANU>Y #a#c1 #bba 3 ,LIB]TY ,VOL4 ,I4 ,NO4 #i -- ,ADD$4 ,JANU>Y #f1 #bbb 3 ,LIB]TY ,VOL4 ,I4 ,NO4 #i -- ,UPDAT$4 FILE G5]AT$ FROM 3 HTTP3_/_/REVOLTLIB4COM_/