,LIB]TY ,VOL4 ,I4 ,NO4 #f ,NOT ! ,DAUE ! WOR/ ( BLASPHEM]S4 ,?OSE :O W\LD HAVE ! USUR] REW>D$ = R5D]+ A S]VICE ALWAYS F9D IT CONV5I5T TO =GET ?AT ! USUR]'S VICTIMS W\LD NOT NE$ HIS S]VICE W]E IT NOT ?AT ! LAWS MADE AT HIS BIDD+ PREV5T !M FROM S]V+ !MSELVES4 0,! DEA? ( ,PRESID5T ,G>FIELD HAS DONE MORE TO KILL ! 9CIPI5T POISON ?AT ,COL4 ,BOB ,+]SOLL 9OCULAT$ 9 ! M9DS ( ! ,AM]ICAN PEOPLE ?AN ! PREA*+ ( ALL M9I/]S C\LD DO10 WRITES A CORRESPOND5T ( ! ,BO/ON 0,H]ALD40 ,PRESUMABLY BY ITS E/ABLI%M5T ( ! EFFICACY ( PRAY]4 ,PR9CE ,NAPOLEON1 ! ONLY ONE ( ! ,BONAP>TES EV] SUSPECT$ ( LIB]AL T5D5CIES1 WAS ONE DAY DISCUSS+ ) ,PR\DHON ! LATT]'S !ORIES4 ,A/ONI%$ AT !IR AUDACITY1 ! PR9CE EXCLAIM$3 0,:AT K9D ( SOCIETY1 !N1 DO Y\ DREAM (1 ,MONSIEUR ,PR\DHON80 0,PR9CE10 ANSW]$ ! BRAVE RADICAL1 9 NO WISE ABA%$1 0,I DREAM ( A SOCIETY :I* ,I %\LD BE GUILLOT9$ AS A CONS]VATIVE40 ,:AT PLACE SO HONOR$ AS ! LITTLE CITY ( ,BESANCON 9 ,FRANCE6 ,IT HAS GIV5 BIR? TO ?REE M5 P]HAPS ! GREATE/ ( MOD]N TIMES4 ,*>LES ,F\RI]1 ,VICTOR ,HUGO1 ,PI]RE ,JOSEPH ,PR\DHON1 P>5T1 POET1 & PHILOSOPH] ( ! SOCIALISM TO-DAY4 ,A TR9ITY ( />S =M+ AN UNP>ALLEL$ CON/ELLATION4 ,HAPPILY ,BESANCON IS A CITY ?AT HONORS ITS [N PROPHETS1 BE+ A /RONABLE FROM ,LIB]TY1 ABS5T FROM HIS /ATEM5T8 ,LIB]TY KN[S BUT ONE DEF9ITION = ITSELF3 ,L,I,B,],T,Y ,I,S ,L,I,B,],T,Y4 ,AS ,JOSIAH ,W>R5 REM>K$1 0,LIB]TY DEF9$ & LIMIT$ BY O!RS IS SLAV]Y40 ,A ,NATIONAL ,SOCIALI/IC-,REVOLUTION>Y ,CONGRESS IS TO BE HELD 9 ,*ICAGO1 BEG9N+ ,OCTOB] #b#a1 = ! PURPOSE ( =M+ AN ,AM]ICAN F$]ATION ( ! ,9T]NATIONAL ,WORK+-,PEOPLE'S ,ASSOCIATION REC5TLY REORGANIZ$ 9 ,LONDON4 ,! 9ITIATIVE 9 CALL+ CONGRESS IS TAK5 BY ?OSE GR\PS :I* S5T DELEGATES FROM ?IS C\NTRY TO ! REC5T ,LONDON CONGRESS4 ,SOCIALI/IC GR\PS & SECTIONS ( ALL %ADES1 PROVID$ !Y >E WE>Y ( COMPROMISE & DESIRE TO ACCOMPLI% ! SOCIAL REVOLUTION BY MEANS O!R ?AN POLITICAL ACTION1 >E 9VIT$ TO S5D DELEGATES TO ,*ICAGO4 ,APPLICATIONS %\LD BE S5T AS SOON AS POSSIBLE TO ,A4 ,SPIES1 #hg ,FIF? ,AV5UE1 ,*ICAGO1 ,ILL9OIS4 ,WE TRU/ ?AT NO PA9S WILL BE SP>$ TO MAKE ! CONGRESS A SUCCESS 9 EV]Y S5SE ( ! WORD4 ,NO?+ IS MORE ESS5TIAL TO ! A*IEVEM5T ( \R 5DS ?AN ! MUTUAL UND]/&+ & 9T]COMMUNICATION ( SOCIALI/S 9 ALL P>TS ( ! WORLD1 & NO 9/RUM5TALITY WAS EV] SO EFFECTIVE 9 E/ABLI%+ ?IS AS ! ,9T]NATIONAL ,WORK+ ,PEOPLE'S ,ASSOCIATION4 ,! FIF? ANNUAL CONGRESS ( ! ,NATIONAL ,LIB]AL ,LEAGUE HELD AT ,*ICAGO LA/ WEEK IS SAID TO HAVE BE5 MORE SUCCESSFUL ?AN ANY ( ITS PR$ECESSORS4 ,T4 ,B4 ,WAKEMAN WAS *OS5 PRESID5T1 9 PLACE ( ,ELIZUR ,WRIMONY )\T ANY SACRIFICE ( PR9CIPLE4 ,WE AWAIT ) 9T]E/ A /ATEM5T ( ! BASIS ON :I* !SE M>VEL\S RESULTS HAVE BE5 EFFECT$4 ,A V]Y ACUTE ?9K] & ONE ( ,LIB]TY'S MO/ DEVOT$ FRI5DS WRITES US1 AS IF 9 CRITICISM ( SOME?+ ?AT WE HAVE SAID1 ?AT 0! RIS W]E WA/$4 ,!RE HAS BE5 NO DECL9E ( SOCIALISM 9 ! C\NTRY4 ,!RE WILL BE NONE4 ,IT IS TRUE ?AT ! P>T ( ,/ATE SOCIALI/S :OM HE REPRES5TS IS FA/ DW9DL+ 9TO 9SIGNIFICANCE2 BUT TRUE SOCIALISM ?AT MEANS A FUR!R DEVELOPM5T ( ! IDEA ( SELF-GOV]NM5T1 ! SOCIALISM ?AT IS BUT ANO!R /EP 9 ?AT PA? ( PROGRESS :OSE FRE%E/ TRACKS >E ?OSE ( ,JEFF]SON & ,PA9E1 IS GR[+ EV]Y DAY4 ,ALL O!R SOCIALISM IS REACTION>Y1 & DES]VES ITS 9EVITABLE DEA?4 ,! ,DETROIT 0,NATIONAL0 ,GRE5BACK ORGAN1 :I* WI%ES ! GOV]NM5T TO RUN ! RAILROADS1 MANAGE ! TELEGRAPH1 & TRANSACT PRETTY MU* ALL BUS9ESS ( LIFE1 SAYS ?AT 0C]TA9LY NO PRIVATE COMPANY C\LD CONDUCT ! PO/AL S]VICE SO *EAPLY & SATISFACTORILY AS IS N[ DONE40 ,EVID5TLY ! $ITOR HAS NEV] SE5 ! REPORT ( ! SPECIAL COMMISSION] DETAIL$ BY ! DEP>TM5T TO EXAM9E ! PO/AL S]VICE ( ! ,PACIFIC COA/4 ,!RE HE W\LD F9D ! /ATEM5T ?AT ,WELLS1 ,F>GO @& ,CO4 SUPPLY ! 9HABITANTS ( ?AT LOCALITY ) MAIL FACILITIES SUP]IOR TO GOV]NM5T'S 9 PROMPTNESS1 SECURITY1 & UNIV]SALITY1 & AT RATES ?AT W\LD BE L[] ?AN ! GOV]NM5T'S EXCEPT = ! 5ORM\S TAX 7JU/ EQUAL TO ! GOV]NM5T'S RATES7 IMPOS$ UPON ! BUS9ESS4 ,HE W\LD F9D1 TOO1 ! FUR!R /ATEM5T ?AT1 EV5 ) SO TREM5D\S AN ADVANTAGE AS ?IS TAX GIVES IT1 ! GOV]NM5T CANNOT SUCCESSFULLY COMPETE ) ?IS PRIVATE FIRM4 ,& YET IT IS TO ?IS BRAN* ( ! GOV]NM5T'S WORK ?AT ! BELIEV]S 9 ,/ATE ADM9I/RATION PO9T ) PRIDE4 ,WE %\LD LIKE FEW ?+S BETT] ?AN TO SEE SOME COMPET5T BUS9ESS MAN GO ?OR\D ( A LATE CRITICISM ( ! ,FREE ,RELIGI\S ,ASSOCIATION1 :I* IS ?AT SAID ,ASSOCIATION 0RETA9S SO FEW ( ! SPEAK]S :OM PEOPLE W]E ACCU/OM$ & DELI AT ITS E>LY CONV5TIONS40 ,HE ?9KS ?IS WILL 0BALANCE0 ! CRITICISM ?AT WAS MADE E>LI] 9 ITS HI/ORY1 0NAMELY1 ?AT ! SAME OLD /AG]S W]E BR\40 ,BUT1 FE>+ LE/ IT WILL NOT1 HE ASKS IF ! LA/ CRITIC DOES NOT 0SET UP A /&>D ALTOGE!R TOO SEV]E40 ,HE KN[S ( 0NO SOCIETY :I* HOLDS ! SECRET ( REM$Y AGA9/ ! RAVAGES ( AGE1 DISEASE1 & DEA? AMONG ITS SPEAK]S4 ,F\RTE5 YE>S HAVE BR\E COM+ =W>D TO TAKE ! PLACE ( ! DEP>T$ & DISABL$40 ,AS ,LIB]TY HAS A SUSPICION ?AT ! 0,9DEX0 $ITOR HAS V5TUR$ TO P]USE IT COLUMNS1 & HAS !RE9 DISCOV]$ ! CRITICISM HE REF]S TO1 WE WILL SAY A WORD OR TWO ?AT WE ?9K WILL BE TO ! PO9T4 ,TRUE1 ,LIB]TY DID SPEAK ( ! ABS5CE FROM ! ,FREE ,RELIGION ,ASSOCIATION'S PLAT=M ( ! ILLU/RI\S M5 :O GAVE TO 0,FREE ,RELIGION10 AS IT WAS CALL$1 ITS E>LY & ONLY CLAIM TO RECOGNITION4 ,BUT NOT )\T A DUE UND]/&+ ( ! FACT ?AT1 9 GOOD P>T1 0AGE1 DISEASE1 & DEA?0 HAD BE5 ! CAUSES4 ,IT WAS NOT ALONE ?IS FACT ( !IR NONAPPE>ANCE 9 ,FREE ,RELIGI\S ASSEMBLAGES AT ! PRES5T TIME ?AT >\S$ \R ATT5TION2 IT WAS ! F> MORE SIGNIFICANT FACT ?AT !IR 0SUCCESSORS0 >E M5 & WOM5 ( A DIFF]5T MOLD4 ,! %ORT & ! LONG ( IT IS1-- ! ,FREE ,RELIGI\S ,ASSOCIATION HAS RUN V]Y QUICKLY ! RACE ALL ORGANIZ$ RELIGIONS RUN2 IT HAS DROPP$ D[N FROM ! HI< REGION ( IDEAS TO ! L[ :EELB>R[ PLANE ( PROPAG&ISM4 ,IT SAYS TO ITSELF TO-DAY1 0,N[1 WE HAVE GOT ,\,R ,I,D,E,A2 LET US GET MONEY & 'Y\NG] M5 & WOM5 ) FRE% ZEAL & ABILITY' TO PUT IT ?R\<40 ,?AT IS1 IT HAS ?US E>LY /RUCK ITS LIMITATION4 ,JU/ LIKE ! OLD ,UNIT>IAN MOVEM5T \T ( :OSE LO9S IT WAS BORN1 IT HAS LO/ ITS 0MOM5T ( FAI?01 & LIVES N[ ONLY TO EXEMPLIFY 0VICE10 :I* ,EM]SON SAYS IS 0HABITUAL40 ,D\BTLESS IT WILL TRUNDLE ALONG ) ITS :EELB>R[-LOAD ( 0GOOD WORKS0 = A C]TA9 SEASON1 BUT ! WORLD WILL NOT NOTE ! ACT1 :5 H]E IS ?AT ,CORLISS' ,5G9E ( A ,*UR*1 ! ,ROMAN ,CA?OLIC1 COV]+ ! E>? ) ITS VA/ >RAY ( GOD-LIKE MA*9]Y1 NOT TO M5TION ! 0VICE0 VEHICLES ( ! :OLE ,PROTE/ANT WORLD4 ,BUT ?AT E>LY MOVEM5T :5 FAI? 9 IDEAS HAD SWAY WAS ALL ! CONTRIBUTION ( HUMAN ELEVATION IT WILL EV] GET CR$IT =4 ,= \T ( IT CAME 9SPIRATION1 VISIONS1 & IDEAL /R5G?1 :I*1 TO ! S\L IS1 0MEAT & DR9K40 ,BUT TO-DAY :AT DO !SE 0Y\NG] M5 & WOM50 (F] ! UNHE$+ WORLD8 ,H[ DO !Y PROPOSE TO >RE/ ATT5TION8 ,:Y1 !Y >E AT ! OLD MIS]ABLE TRICK ( =MULAT+ 0,CATE*ISMS = ! ,Y\NG40 ,HEAV5 SAVE ! M>K6 -- IF IT CAN2 E>? CAN'T4 ,?AT1 & SIMIL>LY DEPRAV$ WORK4 ,! *ILD %ALL NO MORE ITSELF BE AN 0IDEAL VOYAG]10 BUT %ALL SIT D[N LIKE A GOOD LITTLE *ILD 9 SOME ,FREE ,RELIGION MEET+-H\SE1 & BE F$ ON !SE 0Y\NG] M5 & WOM5 ) ZEAL0 HAVE 0=MULAT$40 ,YES1 IT IS A FACT2 !Y >E BUSY 5\< PREP>+ ,FREE ,RELIGION BEANS = ! LITTLE ONES3 BEANS & BREAD2 BREAD !Y !MSELVES HAVE BR[N$1 & !RE MAY BE NO MI/AKE1 & ! LITTLE ONES BE SAV$ ,]ROR'S 9DIGE/ION4 ,AH6 ?9K ( IT4 ,?IS IS ! 0ESPECIALLY 5C\RAG+ FEATURE40 ,FROM ,JOHN ,WEISS TO ?IS6 ,FROM ,FAI? TO ,VICE4 ,FAI? W\LD BELIEVE 9 ! *ILD1 & 9SPIRE IT ) ITS [N ,LIB]TY TO RANGE 9 ! UPP] REGION ( IDEAS1 EV] LOOK+ ) ITS [N EYES 9TO ! VA/NESS ( ITS [N BE+4 ,VICE PREP>ES A DOSE1 & GIVES IT4 ,?AT IS ,FREE ,RELIGION'S MISSION TO-DAY1 AS CONFESS$ BY ITS 0ORGANIZ]S40 ,= \R P>T1 WE CONFESS ?AT ! 0OLD /AG]S ON ITS PLAT=M0 W]E F> MORE 9T]E/+4 ,IT IS ! DIFF]5CE BETWE5 SPONTANEITY & HUMDRUMS2 LIFE & A SL[-DEA?2 JOYFUL HEAL?1 & ! 05?USIASM0 ( ! RELIGI\S DISEASE2 YEA1 BETWE5 ! WORLD'S ,FAI?1 & ! WORLD'S ,VICE4 ,AU?ORITY4 ,! MO/ DEADLY 5EMY ( HUMAN PROGRESS IS AU?ORITY4 ,IT IS 9C>NAT$ 9 A MILLIONS =MS 9 EV]Y SPH]E ( SOCIAL GR[?4 ,IT >MS ITSELF ) POSITION1 ) TITLES1 ) H]ALDIC EMBLEMS1 ) SUP]/ITIONS1 LIES1 TRICKS1 & TRAPP+S ( ALL SORTS4 ,ITS S\RCE IS HUMAN IGNORANCE & CR$ULITY1 & IT IS F$ BY ! ORGANIZ$ FRAUDS :O FATT5 ON ! SPOILS4 ,& YET AU?ORITY1 9 ITSELF1 IS NOT NECESS>ILY A DANG]\S PR9CIPLE4 ,! GREAT ELEM5T ( DESPOTISM LIES 9 ?AT FALSE $UCATION :I* IGNORES ! NATURAL S\RCE ( ALL TRUE AU?ORITY4 ,! AU?ORITY 9TO :I* IT IS ! PURPOSE ( ,LIB]TY TO P\R HAVOC & DE/RUCTION IS ALWAYS AN AU?ORITY \TSIDE ( ! 9DIVIDUAL1 NEV] SUBJECT TO HIS UNCONDITIONAL VETO4,TO COME TO ! PO9T AT ONCE1 ! 9DIVIDUAL1 & ! 9DIVIDUAL ALONE1 IS ! ONLY TRUE & 9ALI5ABLE S\RCE ( AU?ORITY1 BUT CAN NEV] ASSUME TO BE AU?ORITY TO ANY ONE BUT HIMSELF )\T BECOM+ A DESPOT4 ,! FIR/ & =EMO/ GREAT FRAUD SET UP = PURPOSES ( PLUND] & SLAV]Y IS ,GOD4 ,G5]ALLY SPEAK+1 ,GOD IS ALL ?+S TO ALL M51 BUT LOCALLY SPEAK+1 HE IS ! P>TICUL> ?+ = ! P>TICUL> FIELD :]E ! MASSES >E TO BE GULL$1 ROBB$1 & 5SLAV$4 ,ONCE SETTL$ ?AT HE IS AU?ORITY1-- ?AT HIS WORD IS FROM ! BEG9N+ & 9FALLIBLE1-- & ! !OLOGICAL PUTTY-WORK]S EASILY MOLD HIM TO SUIT ! V>I\S NATIVES4 ,N[1 NO?+ P]MAN5T CAN EV] BE ACCOMPLI%$ 9 RE=M UNTIL ?IS C5TRAL FIGUREHEAD1 POSIT$ BEYOND ! VETO P[] ( ! 9DIVIDUAL1 IS DEMOLI%$4 ,IF ANY MAN WANTS A COMPANION ,GOD = HIS 5T]TA9M5T & 9/RUCTION1 LET HIM HAVE ONE4 ,IT W\LD BE A D5IAL ( ,LIB]TY TO 9T]F]E ) HIM4 ,BUT ! MOM5T HE ATTEMPTS TO SET ?AT ,GOD UP AS UNQUE/ION$ AU?ORITY = O!RS1 HE BECOMES A PUBLIC 5EMY & A SPIRITUAL PIRATE4 ,GOD HIMSELF1 BE+ A PURE FICTION1 IS ( C\RSE H>MLESS 9 HIMSELF4 ,BUT ! PRACTICAL P[] = DESPOTISM LIES 9 ! !OLOGICAL PUTTY-WORK]S :O LOBBY >\ND ! ?RONE = (FICE4 ,!SE FELL[S >E SOME?+ TANGIBLE4 ,!Y CAN KICK1 BITE1 SCRAT*1 H&LE A RACK1 PLAY SLEIKS 7SPIRITUAL RACK-R5T]S71 & DESPOTIC FOE-FRI5DS 7SPIRITUAL 0GOMBE5 M5074 ,! SUCCESS ( ! GREAT SPIRITUAL /EAL IS DUE L>GELY TO ! DECORATION ( !IR NAMES ) TITLES4 ,IT IS ,FA!R ,A41 ,REV4 ,MR4 ,B41 ,RT4 ,REV4 ,MR4 ,C41 HIS ,REV]5CE ,MR4 ,D41 ! ,REV4 ,DR4 ,E41 ,REV4 ,MR4 ,F41 ,D4,D41 ETC41 ETC4 ,*IEFLY FROM ! FACT ?AT ! C5TRAL FIGURE1 ,GOD1 OV]%AD[S !IR ECCLESIA/ICAL PETTICOATS1 BUT L>GELY FROM ! MY/]I\S TRAPP+S & TITLES ) :I* !Y 5D[ !MSELVES1 ! FELL[S BECOME RECOGNIZ$ AS ,GOD'S CAB9ET4 ,! POPE IS ! ,ALMIY ( /ATE4 ,HE IS PRIME M9I/] ( ! SPIRITUAL K+DOM4 ,! ,CA?OLIC CL]GY MAY BE SAID TO BE RELIGI\S /ALW>TS1 & ! ,PROTE/ANT PA/ORS ! HALF-BRE$S4 ,5\<1 !SE ECCLESIA/ICAL (FICE-HOLD]S BECOME AU?ORITY1 BUT1 NEV]!LESS1 A K9D ( AU?ORITY ?AT CAN BE REA*$ & MADE TO E>N AN HONE/ LIV+1 IF !IR VICTIMS CAN BE 9DUC$ TO ABOLI% ! BOGUS FICTION1 ,GOD1 BEH9D !M4 ,BUT IT IS BY NO MEANS 9 ! !OLOGICAL FIELD ALONE ?AT AU?ORITY SUPPRESSES PROGRESS4 ,WE HAVE M5TAL HI]>*Y 9 SOCIETY SC>CELY LESS DANG]\S ?AN ! SPIRITUAL1 & G5]ALLY 9 ALLIANCE ) IT4 ,?IS 9TELLECTUAL POP]Y HAS ITS HEADQU>T]S 9 ! COLLEGES1 & ILLUM9ATES ITS TRICKS TO /ULTIFY ) ?AT PR(ESSIONAL :ITEWA% KN[N AS S*OL>%IP4 ,BY A SKILLFUL USE ( TITLES1 S*OL>LY UNI=M+1 & LE>N$ POS+1 M$IOCRITY1 N>R[NESS1 & HYPOCRISY MANAGE TO USURP ! PLACES ( ! WORLD'S TRULY GREAT ?9K]S & BROADLY-$UCAT$ M54 ,! COLLEGES1 & ! TITLES NUMSKULLS :O RUN !M1 BECOMES AU?ORITY1 & ! AV]AGE MAN OR WOMAN :O VISITS ?OSE PUBLIC IGNORANCE-NURS]IES CALL$ LIBR>IES MU/ NE$S FIR/ CONSULT ! TITLE-PAGE ( A BOOK 9 ORD] TO GAUGE ! DEP? ( ?\RY AS MANY TITLES TO HIS NAME AS HE *OOSES2 BUT NO MAN :O ATTA*ES ,REV41 ,D4,D41 ,L,L4,D41 ,M4,D41 OR ANY O!R HEADS & TAILS TO HIS SOCIAL KITE HAS ! RILY TRICKS BECOME EVID5T 9 ! LI M9D )\T PAY+ ,NATURE'S REQUIR$ ADMISSION FEE ( M]IT4 ,EV5 \TSIDE ( RECOGNIZ$ OR?ODOXY 9 RELIGION & $UCATION !RE IS A NUM]\S SET ( QUASI LIB]ALS1 :O ATTEMPT TO /EAL ! LIV]Y ( AU?ORITY ?R\< :AT !Y *OOSE TO CALL 0CULTURE40 ,ABBOT ( ! 0,9DEX0 BECAME SO PUFF$ UP ) CULTURE ?AT HE F9ALLY W5T UP & DRIFT$ AWAY4 ,MANY ( ! P>TICIPANTS 9 ! SO-CALL$ ,FREE ,RELIGI\S MOVEM5T HAVE CULTURE ON ! BRA91 TO AN EXT5T ?AT R5D]S !M QUITE AS WOR?LESS AS1 & VA/LY MORE CONTEMPTIBLE ?AN ! LE>N$ DOLTS :OM ,W5DEL ,PHILLIPS CALL$ TO ORD] LA/ SUMM] AT ,H>V>D ,COLLEGE4 ,! SPIRIT ( POP]Y AMONG PR(ESS+ LIB]ALS IS MORE 9SULT+ ?AN 9 ANY O!R PLACE4 ,?IS ET]NAL H>P+ ON CULTURE :I* AS BE5 ! KEY NOTE ( ! 0,FREE ,RELIGI\S ,9DEX0 S9CE ITS RISE IS SIMPLY A SURREPTITI\S ATTEMPT TO MAKE CULTURE AN AU?ORITY 9 ! PLACE ( ! ,D4,D4S1 & ,L,L4,D4S1 & O!R DEVICES ( OR?ODOX4 ,ABBOT'S ATTEMPT TO ORGANIZE HIS CULTURE 9TO A 0CONS5SUS ( ! COMPET5T0 WAS PRO( PLA9 & PALPABLE ?AT HE SIMPLY S]V$ ! PAPAL SY/EM ( AU?ORITY 9 ! LIV]Y ( A LIB]AL4 ,LIB]TY 9SI/S ?AT ! 9DIVIDUAL IS AN AU?ORITY GREAT] ?AN GODS1 HI]>*S1 PR(ESSIONALS1 CULTURI/S1 PURI/S1 & ALL ! O!R PRET5D]S :O1 UND] ONE GUISE OR ANO!R1 ATTEMPT TO /EAL 9TO ! HUMAN M9D & S\L ?R\< SOME S*EME 9DEP5D5T ( !IR TRUE M]IT4 ,:OEV] ATTEMPTS TO MAKE A PETTY ,GOD1 EV5 \T ( SO GREAT A %AM AS ,ABBOT'S 0CULTURE10 IS AN ALLY ( ! POPE & A FOLL[] ( HIS ME?ODS4 ,HE :O SETS UP A 0CONS5SUS ( ! COMPET5T10 DEFIES PURITY1 VIRTUE1 YEA1 ,LIB]TY ITSELF1 TO ! EXT5T ( MAK+ AN AU?ORITY ( IT1 IS AN 5EMY ( HIS K9D4 ,PURITY1 VIRTUE1 CULTURE1 -- ALL !SE HALF-BRE$ PETTY GODS ( ! ,FREE ,RELIGIONI/S1 -- :AT >E !Y MORE ?AN SOMEBODY'S UNDEF9$ IDEALS1 B9D+ ONLY UPON !MSELVES AS 9DIVIDUALS8 ,?IS HUMBUGG]Y ( SETT+ UP IDEALS AS AU?ORITY WAS DISPOS$ ( BY ,PLATO OV] TWO ?\S& YE>S AGO1 & IT IS A POOR COMM5T ON ! 0CULTURE0 ( !SE !ORETICAL PURI/S ?AT !Y HAVE PR(IT$ SO LITTLE BY HIS IMMORTAL DIALOG]S4 ,NO1 !RE IS BUT ONE WAY TO ,LIB]TY1 & ALL ! O!R %IFTS ( 0ADVANC$ CULTURE0 >E SURE TO LEAD DESPOTISM 9 ! 5D4 ,?AT WAY IS TO ACCORD TO ! 9DIVIDUAL FULL DISCRETION>Y P[] 9 ALL MATT]S ( OP9ION1 CONSCI5CE1 & ! CONDUCT ( LIFE4 ,& ?AT P[] IS NOT ACCORD$ TO HIM1 :51 BY ANY MEANS1 FAIR OR FOOL1 HE IS ASK$ TO SUBSCRIBE TO ANY GOD1 S*EME1 IDEAL1 OR FICTION1 ) ! IMPLICATION ?AT ! GIV5 MA*9E IS 9 ANY S5SE AU?ORITY4 ,ALL WE ASK ( ,GOD & ALL HIS HANG]S-ON IS TO GET \T ( \R SUNLIFIELD WAS SO %OT ?AT ! W\ND WAS FATAL FROM ! BEG9N+4 ,H5CE1 ! SKILL ( SURGEONS WAS UNAVAIL+4 ,H5CE1 NO E>?LY VISIBLE P[] C\LD SAVE HIM4 ,*RI/IANS ALL OV] ! C\NTRY PRAY TO AN 9VISIBLE P[] ASK+ = 0DIV9E M]CY10 ?AT ! C\RSE ( NATURE MAY BE /AY$ & A MIRACLE BE WR\FIELD DI$4 ,!N1 !Y ASSEMBLE 9 HUMILIATION1 & OBS]VE A DAY ( 0FA/+40 ,!Y SAY3 0,IT HAS PLEAS$ ,ALMIFIELD DI$ BECAUSE ,GUITEAU %OT HIM4 ,& ,GUITEAU IS TO BE HANG$ AS A MURD] ( ,G>FIELD4 ,IF ,GOD 0REMOV$ HIM10 :Y HANG ,GUITEAU8 ,WAS ,GUITEAU AN 9/RUM5T 9 ,GOD'S H&S8 ,HE SAYS ?AT HE DID ! 0WILL ( ,GOD40 ,*RI/IANS CONFESS AS MU*3 0,?\<1 ,GOD1 HAS HUMBL$ US = \R S9S1 & TAK5 HIM TO ?YSELF40 ,BUT IT WAS ,GUITEAU'S BULLET ?AT S5T HIM HI!R4 ,& ,GUITEAU WILL BE HANG$4 ,& GOD WILL BE PRAIS$1 BECAUSE1 9 HIS 09SCRUTABLE WISDOM1 HE DOE? ALL ?+S RITS40 ,& YET !Y KN[ ( NO FATE TOO H>% = ! WRET* :OM !IR ,GOD EMPLOY$4 ,SU* IS ! MUDDLE 9TO :I* ! WORLD IS EV] GETT+ BECAUSE ( ITS BELIEF 9 ! EXI/5CE ( P]SONAL GODS1 9 :OSE H&S >E ALL ! EV5TS ( LIFE4 ,PREA*+ ,PLAY$ ,\T4 ,PREA*]S >E PREA*]S1-- ?AT IS1 !Y MU/ PREA* ONCE EV]Y ,SUNDAY1 AT LEA/4 ,& :AT %ALL IT BE AB\T8 ,:AT >E !Y HIR$ =8 ,:AT IS !IR MA9 & /APLE TOPIC8 ,:Y1 WE ALL KN[ FULL WELL ?AT !IR S]MONS MU/ BE AB\T 0S940 ,S91 9 SOME =M OR O!R1 !Y MU/ BEWAIL1 OR BE FALSE TO !IR MISSION4 ,WE ONCE HE>D A PREA*] DECL>E1 ) ALL ! E>NE/NESS IMAG9ABLE1 0,:AT1 MY BRE?R51 IS ! ONE SUBJECT ( \R LIVES8 ,IT IS ! EXCE$+ S9FULNESS ( S940 ,ON ORD9>Y OCCASIONS1 IT IS ! 9DIVIDUAL S9N] :OM !Y HOLD OV] ! COALS4 ,ON EXTRAORD9>Y ONES1 ! NATION IS BR\ ! PREA*] WAS ! DEADLIE/ ( S9S4 ,IT WAS AN (F5SE TO ,GOD4 ,= WAS NOT ! M9I/] ! ANO9T$ ( ,GOD8 ,DID HE NOT1 9 AN ESPECIAL & WELL-NI< 9FALLIBLE MANN]1 KN[ ! WILL ( ,GOD8 ,WAS IT NOT HIS BUS9ESS TO READ ,GOD'S WORD1 & !N 0EXP\ND0 IT8 ,IF ! ORIG9AL TEXT WAS OBSCURE1 HE C\LD MAKE IT CLE>1 LIKE ! NOON-DAY4 ,& ! BURD5 ( ALL WAS1 0,S91 S91 S940 ,S9 & ! 0WRA? ( ,GOD10 FROM :I* S9N]S MU/ FLEE4 ,! PRES5T TIME IS UNLIKE ! PA/ 9 ?IS RESPECT4 ,IT LI/5S TO ! PREA*]1 -- :5 !RE IS NOT A GREAT] ATTRACTION ELSE:]E1 -- BUT LITTLE HE$S HIMS1 UNLESS HE REALLY HAS SOME:AT TO SAY2 & ?AT SOME:AT IS TAK5 = :AT IT IS WOR?1 & NOT BECAUSE ! PREA*] SAYS IT4 ,N[ & !N ! MANRISES ABOVE ! PREA*]1 &1 :5 ?IS OCCURS1 ! PROBLEM ( LIFE MAY GET TREAT$ ) SOME BREAD?1 & HIS WORDS REVIVE SOME E>?LY VITAL 9T]E/4 ,BUT1 = ! MO/ P>T1 ! PREA*] IS ALL[$ TO MAKE ! BURD5 ( HIS DISC\RSE /ILL ( S9 AGA9/ DEITY1 & GO HIS WAY1 SO LONG AS HE KEEPS UP ! *UR* E/ABLI%M5T1 & MAKES ! REQUISITE RESPECTABLE %[+4 ,BUT1 AS A 0MAN ( ,GOD10 HE IS NO MORE KN[N4 ,AN ORNAM5T N[1 A FIGURE-HEAD1 LIKE ,VICTORIA2 NOT A NECESSITY1 :OSE DEMISE IS UN?9KABLE4 ,\R SPACE IS LIMIT$1 SO ?AT WE CAN ONLY 9 A FREE WAY1 VOICE ! REAL S5TIM5T ( ! S5SIBLE WORLD4 ,BUT ?IS APPE>S TO BE ! NOBLE FACT3 ,! WORLD IS WE>Y ( BE+ PREA*$ AT4 ,IT DESIRES 9/RUCTION1 KN[L$GE AS TO ?IS PRES5T LIFE4 ,:AT IS BEYOND IT WILL WAIT =4 ,ITS S9S IT WILL SL\< (F AS IT GOES ALONG1 ONLY LET IT HAVE ! HI<] AIMS ( LIV+ CLE>LY SET F\R?4 ,:AT IS TRUE & BEAUTIFUL & JU/ IT DESIRES TO HE> AB\T4 ,BUT ! ET]NAL D+-DONG ( 0S91 S9 S910 & ?AT BY A FELL[-S9N] *ANT$1 0WE>IES IT10 AS ,GOE! WROTE1 0\T & \T40 ,ALL ( :I* IS SUBMITT$ ) ! UTMO/ P]SONAL GOOD-WILL = ! PREA*]S1 = :OM WE HAVE NO PRAY] = ! WORLD'S E>S BUT ?IS1 -- ?AT !Y1 ONE & ALL1 MAY BE SPE$ILY DELIV]$ 9TO ! UNSANCTIMONI\S GOOD S5SE :I* IS ! SALVATION ( ALL HUMAN S\LS1 ?AT !Y MAY HAVE A :OLESOME WRA? = WRONG-DO+1 & RISE ABOVE ! FE> ( ! RI* & ! MIGE4 ,MY ,DE> ,MR4 ,TUCK]1-- ,IT IS 5TIRELY IMMAT]IAL 9 ?IS DISCUSSION :E!R MY POSITION IS 0ODD0 OR O!RWISE4 ,! QUE/ION AT ISSUE MU/ BE SETTL$1 IF SETTL$ AT ALL1 ON ITS [N M]ITS2 & NO PREJUDICE EI!R = OR AGA9/ CAPITAL CAN AFFECT ! >GUM5T4 ,LET US BURD5 IT ) NO IRRELEVANT MATT]4 ,MY QUE/ION WAS SIMPLY ?IS3 ,IS A MAN :O LOANS A PL[ 5TITL$ 9 EQUITY TO COMP5SATION = ITS USE2 & IF NOT1 :Y NOT8 ,?IS QUE/ION 7,I SAY IT ) ALL RESPECT7 Y\ EVADE4 ,BUT1 UNTIL IT IS ANSW]$1 NO PROGRESS CAN BE MADE 9 ?IS 9QUIRY4 ,IT IS NO ANSW] TO SAY1 0,LET HIM SELL HIS PL[40 ,HE DOES NOT SELL IT2 HE LOANS IT1 AS HE HAS A NATURAL RI AN APPLICATION TO ! EXAMPLE ,I /AT$1 :AT IS IT GOOD =8 ,I HAVE NEV] SE5 A GOOD REASON :Y ! PL[-MAK] IS NOT 5TITL$ TO PAY = ! USE ( HIS PL[4 ,Y\ REF] ME TO C]TA9 0AU?ORITIES10 -- ,BR[N & ,RUSK94 ,I DO NOT B[ TO AU?ORITIES ON QUE/IONS ( ?IS NATURE2 & ,I SUPPOS$ Y\ DID NOT4 ,I ASK = A REASON1 NOT A NAME4 ,BR[N'S PROPOSITION1 :I* ,I AFFIRM AS /\TLY AS HE DOES1 DOES NOT ANSW] MY QUE/ION4 ,RUSK9 IS EQUALLY REMOTE4 ,HE CONCLUDES ?AT ! CASE HE EXAM9ES IS ONE ( SALE & PUR*ASE4 ,?AT IS NOT ! CASE ,I /AT$ AT ALL4 ,IF !RE BE AN ANSW] TO MY QUE/ION1 ,I AM SURE Y\ >E CAPABLE ( /AT+ IT4 ,Y\RS CORDIALLY1 ,J4 ,M4 ,L4 ,BABCOCK ,WE HAVE NO WI% TO WA/E !SE COLUMNS 9 REPETITION2 BUT ?IS *>GE ( EVASION IS A S]I\S ONE1 :I* CAN BE ?OR\E UNFITT$ = \R TASK1 & \GU$ ?AT ! MAN :O MAKES A PL[ & L5D IT IS 5TITL$ TO A PORTION ( ! LOAF SUBSEQU5TLY PRODUC$ 9 ADDITION TO ! RETURN ( HIS PL[ 9TACT4 ,HE N[ ASS]TS ?AT WE ANSW]$ ?IS BY SAY+1 0,LET HIM SELL HIS PL[40 ,NO1 WE DID NOT4 ,ON ! PR9CIPLE ?AT ONLY LABOR CAN BE AN EQUITABLE BASIS ( PRICE1 WE >GU$ 9 REPLY AS FOLL[S3 0,! MAK] ( ! PL[ C]TA9LY IS 5TITL$ TO PAY = HIS WORK4 ,FULL PAY1 PAID ONCE2 NO MORE4 ,?AT PAY IS ! PL[ ITSELF1 OR ITS EQUIVAL5T 9 O!R M>KETABLE PRODUCTS1 SAID EQUIVAL5T BE+ MEASUR$ BY ! AM\NT ( LABOR EMPLOY$ 9 !IR PRODUCTION40 ,TRUE OR FALSE1 ?IS ANSW] IS DIRECT & TANGIBLE2 9 NO S5SE IS IT EVASIVE4 ,!N ,MR4 ,BABCOCK ASK$ ?IS O!R & DI/9CT QUE/ION3 0,IF HE FURNI%ES HIS PL[S ONLY ON CONDITION ?AT !Y BE RETURN$ TO HIM 9 AS GOOD A /ATE AS :5 TAK5 AWAY1 H[ IS HE TO GET HIS BREAD80 ,WE REPLI$ ?AT WE DID NOT KN[1 & ?AT1 IF HE WAS SU* A FOOL AS TO DO SO1 WE DID NOT C>E4 ,NO?+ EVASIVE H]E1 EI!R2 ON ! CONTR>Y1 UTT] FRANKNESS4 ,T\*$ A LITTLE1 H[EV]1 BY ,MR4 ,BABCOCK'S SYMPA?Y ) ! USUR] ?US ?REAT5$ ) />VATION1 WE V5TUR$ ! SUGGE/ION ?AT1 9/EAD ( L5D+ HIS PL[ TO ! F>M]1 HE MIMONY ) \RS ON ! PO9T N[ 9 DISPUTE1 ,A4 ,B4 ,BR[N & ,JOHN ,RUSK94 ,BUT NOT AS AU?ORITIES1 9 ,MR4 ,BABCOCK'S S5SE ( ! WORD4 ,/ILL1 ,MR4 ,BR[N BE+ ,MR4 ,BABCOCK'S C&IDATE = ,SECRET>Y ( ,/ATE1 & P>TY C&IDATES BE+ SUPPOS$LY REPRES5TATIVE9 ?+S FUNDAM5TAL1 WE DEEM$ IT NOT \T ( PLACE TO CITE A PROPOSITION FROM ,MR4 ,BR[N ?AT SEEM$ TO US1 ON ITS FACE1 DIRECTLY CONTRADICTORY ( ,MR4 ,BABCOCK4 ,TO \R A/ONI%M5T ,MR4 ,BABCOCK ACCEPTS IT AS NOT 9CONSI/5T ) HIS POSITION1 AT ! SAME TIME DECL>+ IT IRRELEVANT4 ,>GUM5T 5DS H]E4 ,IF WE HOLD UP TWO OBJECTS1 ONE IF :I*1 TO \R EYES1 IS R$ & ! O!R BLUE1 & ,MR4 ,BABCOCK DECL>ES ?AT BO? >E R$1 IT IS USELESS TO DISCUSS ! MATT]4 ,ONE ( US IS COLORBL9D4 ,! ULTIMATE V]DICT ( MANK9D WILL DECIDE :I*4 ,9 QUOT+ FROM ,MR4 ,RUSK91 H[EV]1 WE DID NOT ASK ,MR4 ,BABCOCK TO ACCEPT HIM AS AN AU?ORITY1 BUT TO PO9T \T ! WEAKNESS ( AN >GUM5T DRAWN FROM AN ILLU/RATION SIMIL> TO ,MR4 ,BABCOCK'S4 ,MR4 ,BABCOCK REPLIES BY D5Y+ ! SIMIL>ITY1 SAY+ ?AT ,RUSK9 0CONCLUDES ?AT ! CASE HE EXAM9ES IS ONE ( SALE & PUR*ASE40 ,LET US SEE4 ,RUSK9 IS EXAM9+ A /ORY TOLD BY ,BA/IAT 9 ILLU/RATION & DEF5SE ( USURY4 ,AFT] PR9T+ ,BA/IAT'S V]SION ( IT1 HE ABRIDGES IT ?US1 /RIPP+ AWAY ALL MY/IFY+ CLAUSES3 ,JAMES MAKES A PLANE1 L5DS IT TO ,WILLIAM ON #a/ ( ,JANU>Y = A YE>4 ,WILLIAM GIVES HIM A PLANK = ! LOAN ( IT1 WE>S IT \T1 & MAKES ANO!R = ,JAMES1 :I* HE GIVES HIM ON #c#a/ ,DECEMB]4 ,ON #a/ ,JANU>Y HE AGA9 BORR[S ! NEW ONE2 & ! >RANGEM5T IS REPEAT$ CONT9U\SLY4 ,! POSITION ( ,WILLIAM1 !RE=E1 IS ?AT HE MAKES A PLANE EV]Y #c#a/ ( ,DECEMB]2 L5DS IT TO ,JAMES TILL ! NEXT DAY1 & PAYS ,JAMES A PLANK ANNUALLY = ! PRIVILEGE ( L5D+ IT TO HIM ON ?AT EV5+4 ,SUB/ITUTE1 9 ! =EGO+ 0PL[0 = 0PLANE10 & 0LOAF0 OR 0SLICE0 = 0PLANK10 & ! /ORY DIFF]S 9 NO ESS5TIAL PO9T FROM ,MR4 ,BABCOCK'S4 ,H[ MON/R\SLY UNJU/ ! TRANSACTION IS CAN BE PLA9LY SE54 ,RUSK9 NEXT %[S H[ ?IS UNJU/ TRANSACTION MAY BE *ANG$ 9TO A JU/ ONE3 ,IF ,JAMES DID NOT L5D ! PLANE TO ,WILLIAM1 HE C\LD ONLY GET HIS GA9 ( A PLANK BY WORK+ ) IT HIMSELF & WE>+ IT \T HIMSELF4 ,:5 HE HAD WORN IT \T AT ! 5D ( ! YE>1 HE W\LD1 !RE=E1 HAVE TO MAKE ANO!R = HIMSELF4 ,WILLIAM1 WORK+ ) IT 9/EAD1 GETS ! ADVANTAGE 9/EAD1 :I* HE MU/1 !RE=E1 PAY ,JAMES HIS PLANK =2 & RETURN TO ,JAMES :AT ,JAMES W\LD1 IF HE HAD NOT L5T HIS PLANE1 !N HAVE HAD -- NOT A NEW PLANE1 BUT ! WORN-\T ONE4 ,JAMES MU/ MAKE A NEW ONE = HIMSELF1 AS HE W\LD HAVE HAD TO DO IF NO ,WILLIAM HAD EXI/$2 & IF ,WILLIAM LIKES TO BORR[ IT AGA9 = ANO!R PLANK1 ALL IS FAIR4 ,?AT IS TO SAY1 CLE>+ ! /ORY ( ITS NONS5SE1 ?AT ,JAMES MAKES A PLANE ANNUALLY & SELLS IT TO ,WILLIAM = ITS PROP] PRICE1 :I*1 9 K9D1 IS A NEW PLANK4 ,IT IS ?IS LATT] TRANSACTION1 :OLLY DIFF]5T FROM ! =M]1 ?AT ,RUSK9 PRON\NCES A 0SALE10 HAVE 0NO?+ :ATEV] TO DO ) PR9CIPAL OR ) 9T]E/40 ,& YET1 ACCORD+ TO ,MR4 ,BABCOCK1 0! CASE HE EXAM9ES .<,BA/IAT'S1 ( C\RSE.> IS ONE ( SALE & PUR*ASE40 ,WE UND]/& N[ H[ IT IS ?AT ,MR4 ,BABCOCK CAN *>GE US ) EVASION4 ,HE EVID5TLY CONSID]S HIS ME?OD ( MEET+ A PO9T TO BE /RAID4 ,IF IT BE SO1 C]TA9LY \RS IS EVASIVE4 ,IF1 ON ! O!R H&1 \R C\RSE HAS BE5 /RAID1 EVASION IS TOO MILD A T]M = HIS4 ,IT IS BETT] DESCRIB$ AS FLAT MIS/ATEM5T2 PURELY C>ELESS1 ( C\RSE1 BUT SC>CELY LESS EXCUSABLE ?AN IF WILLFUL4 ,AGA9 WE 9VITE \R FRI5D TO A C>EFULEXAM9ATION 7& REFUTATION1 IF POSSIBLE7 ( ! >GUM5TS ADVANC$1 TO :I* ADD ANO!R 9 PR9T+ A TRANSLATION FROM ! WRIT+S ( ! HONOR$ ,AUGU/E ,BLANQUI1 ! SCI5TI/ & REVOLUTIONI/4 ,:OSE LIFE WAS ONE LONG SACRIFICE & M>TYRDOM = ,LIB]TY4 ,BA/IAT'S ,FABLE4 .<,FROM ,AUGU/E ,BLANQUI'S 0,CAPITAL & ,LABOR0.> ,ALL ! OLD ECONOMI/S NEGLECT$ ! QUE/ION ( ! LEGITIMACY ( USURY4 ,?IS QUE/ION IS REC5T1 DAT+ 9 ! PUBLIC M9D SC>CELY F>!R BACK ?AN #a#h#d#h4 ,BA/IAT SEIZ$ UPON IT & MADE IT ! TEXT ( HIS DISCUSSIONS ) ,PR\DHON1 ! SOCIALI/IC *AMPION ( ?AT P]IOD4 ,! >GUM5TS ( HIS FELL[-WRIT]S1 :ATEV] !IR =M1 DO NOT DIFF] FROM HIS [N4 ,ON ?IS QUE/ION ( 9T]E/1 !N1 MAY BE REFUT$1 9 ,BA/IAT'S P]SON1 ALL POLITICAL ECONOMY4 ,= ! RE/1 ! =M ( ! FABLE ?AT HE DEVISES TO DEMON/RATE ! LEGITIMACY ( USURY HAS BE5 EMPLOY$ ALSO BY O!RS4 ,!Y USE IT ) ASSURANCE1-- ONE MIIES AFT] ! MANN] ( GR& LORDS T[>DS ! COMMON PEOPLE4 ,BA/IAT NOTABLY ASSUMES AN AIR OR OV]WE5+ CONCEIT ?OR\1 9 HIS >GUM5T1 LE/ SOME ONE MAY ACCUSE HIM ( /ORM+ GATES ALREADY OP51 SO ,JOVE-LIKE IS HIS /YLE4 ,JAMES FIR/ EX*ANGES HIS PLANE = MONEY4 ,HE L5DS ! MONEY TO ,WILLIAM1 & ,WILLIAM EX*ANGES ! MONEY = A SAW4 ,! TRANSACTION IS DIVID$ 9TO TWO FACTORS4 ,BUT !REBY ITS NATURE IS NOT *ANG$4 ,IT NONE ! LESS CONTA9S ALL ! ELEM5TS ( A DIRECT LOAN4 ,!RE LIES ! SOPHI/RY & ! DELUSION4 ,! MONEY CEASES TO BE :AT IT %\LD BE1 A SIMPLE 9/RUM5T ( EX*ANGE4 ,IT AB&ONS ?IS B5EFIC5T RULE TO ASSUME A H>MFUL ONE4 ,FROM A FRI5D IT BECOMES AN 5EMY2 FROM A B5EFIT1 A SC\RGE4 ,FROM AN AUXILI>Y IT BECOMES AN OB/ACLE2 FROM AN AID1 A B>RI]4 ,?IS METAMORPHOSIS IS EFFECT$ DUR+ ITS PASSAGE ?R\< ! H&S ( ,JAMES1 :O USES ! CO9 ?AT BE HOLDS TO FLEECE HIS NEI = A PRODUCT ( EQUAL VALUE1 AS WAS DONE = HIM 9 ! SUB/ITUTION ( ! CO9 = HIS PRODUCT4 ,= BE OBTA9S AT ! 5D ( A YE> EI!R A PORTION ( ,WILLIAM'S PRODUCT EQUAL 9 VALUE TO HIS [N ) A BONUS 9 ADDITION1 OR HIS MONEY 9CREAS$ BY ONE-TW5TIE?4 ,HIS DUTY WAS TO BUY ) HIS CO9 A PRODUCT EQUAL 9 VALUE TO ?AT :I* HE HAD SOLD = ! CO94 ,HE HAS WICK$LY RETA9$ ! MONEY :I* HE %\LD HAVE RE/OR$ TO CIRCULATION BY ! COMPLEM5T>Y OP]ATION ( ! EX*ANGE1-- NAMELY1 ! B>T] ( ! CO9 = A PRODUCT EQUAL 9 VALUE TO ! FIR/4 ,IF HE DID NOT WI% TO PROCE$ IMM$IATELY TO ?IS B>T]1 IT WAS FREE TO HIM TO *OOSE HIS H\R1 PROVID$ HE %\LD ULTIMATELY FULFILL ! FAIR & JU/ CONDITION ( EX*ANGE1-- AN EQUALITY ( ! TWO VALUES EX*ANG$ ?R\< ! M$IATION ( ! CO94 ,AS = ! PRET5D$ S]VICE ( ! LOAN1 S]VICE DES]V+ REW>D1 ?AT IS A %AM4 ,IF ,JAMES HAD NE$$ HIS TOOL1 HE W\LD HAVE US$ IT4 ,APP>5TLY HE DID NOT REMA9 IDLE DUR+ ! YE> ?AT ,WILLIAM HAD POSSESSION ( HIS PLANE4 ,IF HE L5T HIS PLANE1 HE DID SO BECAUSE HE C\LD GET ALONG )\T IT4 ,TO SAY ?AT HE HAS MADE A SACRIFICE1 ?AT HE HAS DEPRIV$ HIMSELF ( A USEFUL OBJECT = ! B5EFIT ( HIS NEI ( ! LOAN1 & RECEIV$ ! PRICE ( HIS PRODUCT4 ,HE HAS NO CLAIM ON ! PRODUCT ( ,WILLIAM4 ,:E!R ,WILLIAM US$ ! PLANE OR NOT1 IT IS SUFFICI5T = HIM TO RETURN IT TO ,JAMES 9 ! CONDITION ?AT HE RECEIV$ IT4 ,HE [ES HIM NO?+ FUR!R4 0,BUT :Y %\LD ,I L5D10 SAYS ,JAMES1 0IF NO?+ IS TO COME BACK TO ME0 = ! S]VICE ?AT ,I R5D]8 0,I WILL REFUSE1 !N40 ,REFUSE1 IF Y\ LIKE4 ,BUT Y\ CANNOT ESCAPE ?IS DILEMMA4 ,EI!R Y\ NE$ Y\R PLANE1 OR Y\ DO NOT4 ,IF IT IS DETRIM5TAL TO Y\R 9T]E/S TO P>T ) IT1 KEEP IT & USE IT4 ,IF Y\ CAN DISP5SE ) IT1 IF1 )\T LOSS TO Y\RSELF1 Y\ CAN DO SOME?+ ELSE1 TO DEM&1 AS REW>D = A S]VICE ?AT CO/S Y\ NO?+1 ONE-TW5TIE? ( ! PRICE ( Y\R PLANE1 BESIDES A NEW PLANE1 IS SIMPLY A SW9DLE4 ,TO PROHIBITIONI/ LEGISLATORS3 ,:Y W\LD Y\ MAKE USE COOLLY ?9K8 ,IF Y\ MU/ GOV]N1 WE MU/ DR9K4 ,A JU/ PUBLI%$ ANECDOTE ( ,*IEF ,JU/ICE ,JOHN ,M>%ALL & ,JOHN ,C4 ,CALH\N SAYS ?AT ,M>%ALL1 ONCE MEET+ ,CALH\N ON ! /REET ( ,WA%+1 SAID1 0,Y\ SEEMS TO BE 9 PR(\ND ?\E Y\ ?9K+80 ,CALH\N1 REPLI$1 0,I AM ?9K+ ( ! ORIG9 ( GOV]NM5T40 0,& ON :AT DOES GOV]NM5T DEP5D80 0,ON ! PRODUCTION & DI/RIBUTION ( WEAL?40 0,& ON :AT DOES ! PRODUCTION & DI/RIBUTION ( WEAL? DEP5D80 0,?AT IS :AT ,I HAVE NOT DISCOV]$10 SAID ,CALH\N4 ,O,H ,F,I,R,E6 ,OH6 ,FIRE NO EYES BEHOLDE?1 ,]E PLANETS W]E BEGUN ,K9DL$ )9 ! ,9MO/- ,FI]CE1 FLAM+1 BLAZ+ SUN6 ,OH1 ,FIRE :O/ HEAT PRES]VE? ,! ,TRU? ( TRU? ALIVE6 ,!N GIVE/ TO ,BE+ BEAUTY2 ,ALL S\LS BY !E SURVIVE4 ,OH1 ,FIRE AYE MELT+ HEAV51 ,& BURN+ UP ! E>? -- ',TIS BY ?Y FI]CE 5DEAVOR ,N[1 ,LIB]TY HA? BIR?4 #a4 ,\R ,EUROPEAN ,LETT]4 .<,FROM ,LIB]TY'S ,SPECIAL ,CORRESPOND5T4.> ,L,O,N,D,O,N1 ,SEPTEMB] #a#i4 -- ,LA/ WEEK TWO M5 DESIR$ TO MEET1 P]HAPS 9 ORD] TO HAT* SOME NEW S*EME ( :OLESALE SLAUY BUT = ! FACT ?AT1 9 !IR :OLE VA/ EMPIRES1 ,MR4 ,WILLIAM & ,MR4 ,ALEX&] C\LD NOT F9D A S+LE SPOT1 9 SPITE ( ALL !IR ,MAMELUKES1 SOLDI]S1 POLICE AG5TS1 & SPIES1 :]E TO ,PRUSSIA1 9 ALL ,RUSSIA1 !RE WAS NOT A S+LE T[N1 NOT A S+LE VILLAGE1 NOT A S+LE HAMLET1 :]E !SE TWO B&ITS CONSID]$ !MSELVES SAFE6 ,!Y HAD TO GO ON BO>D ( W> %IPS1 F> AWAY FROM L&1 ON ! ,EA/]N SEA1 9 ! MID/ ( WAVES ?AT MU/ HAVE LA%$ !IR VESSELS' SIDES ) FURY AT HAV+ TO LI/5 TO ! SC\NDRELS' PLOTS4 ,?IS1 AT LEA/1 IS ONE GOOD RESULT ( ! POLICY ( ,T]RORISM2 & ! DAY IS NOT F> (F :5 NO MAN WILL BE F\ND TO PREF] SU* A CONDITION ( P]PETUAL FRI ,AFT] HAV+ APPEAL$ 9 TONES MO/ PITIFUL TO ALL EXI/+ & NON-EXI/+ AU?ORITIES 9 ,SWITZ]L&1 AFT] HAV+ GIV5 SOLEMN ASSURANCE ?AT ONLY 0RESPECTABLE10 ORD]LY1 & LAWFUL SUBJECTS %ALL BE DISCUSS$ ON ?AT OCCASION1 & AFT] PROMIS+ ?AT1 IF ANY BLACK %EEP %ALL F9D !IR WAY AMONG ! IMMACULATE FLOCK & HAVE ! IMP]T95CE TO SAY ANY?+ AB\T MATT]S NOT ON ! S*$ULE ( 0LAWFUL0 SUBJECTS1 !Y WILL BE SUMM>ILY EJECT$ 9TO ! FRE% AIR1 ?IS CONGLOM]ATION ( EI NUMB] ( ,SOCIALI/S & ! SO-CALL$ ,SOCIAL ,DEMOCRATS %[] DAILY ON ! GOV]NM5T FRE% ACCLAMATION AS ( ! NEW 0IMP]IAL SOCIALI/S0 POLICY ( ! IRON *ANCELLOR4 ,ALL ?IS WILL BE *ANG$ 9 A FEW WEEKS1 & ! N[ =M$ ,EXECUTIVE ,COMMITTEE ( ! ,G]MAN ,REVOLUTIONI/S WILL V]Y SOON GIVE TO ?IS GLORI\S EMPIRE AS MU* TR\BLE AS ITS ,RUSSIAN NAMESAKE GIVES TO ! CZ>4 ,! IMITATORS 9 ,FRANCE ( ! /RATEGY ( ! ,G]MAN ,SOCIALI/S MADE1 AT ! LA/ ELECTIONS1 A COMPLETE FIASCO4 ,9 ALL ,FRANCE !IR :OLE P>TY C\LD MA/] SC>CELY MORE ?AN T5 ?\S& VOTES4 ,! 0RESPECTABLE0 NEWSPAP]S >E SAY+ ?AT ?+S 9 ,SPA9 LOOK V]Y 0GLOOMY40 ,K+ ,ALFONSO IS SUFF]+ FROM A V]Y SEV]E 0DI>RHEA10 & HAS ALREADY PACK$ HIS TRUNKS4 ,HE CONSID]S IT A V]Y DISAGREEABLE PH5OM5ON ?AT 9 ! LA/ FEW MON?S OV] A HUNDR$ MANUFACTORIES HAVE BE5 BURN$ D[N4 ,9 ,ITALY DISSATISFACTION IS MAK+ ITS WAY 9 ! GUISE ( RELIGI\S ANTIPA?IES2 = ! KE5 OBS]V] ! TRUE CAUSE ( ALL ! REC5T DI/URBANCES IS EASILY F\ND4 ,DUR+ ! LA/ FEW MON?S ,I HAVE MADE 9QUIRIES CONC]N+ AN 9DIVIDUAL /YL+ HIMSELF 0,JOHN ,BAK]10 :O FROM TIME TO TIME CUTS A RA!R PRET5TI\S FIGURE 9 A FEW ,AM]ICAN PAP]S4 ,I AM AU?ORIZ$ BY ! ,POLI% & ,RUSSIAN ORGANIZATIONS AT ,G5EVA TO DECL>E ?AT 0,JOHN ,BAK]0 NEV] WAS1 & IS NOT N[1 A MEMB] ( ANY SOCIALI/IC OR REVOLUTION>Y ORGANIZATION )9 !IR COGNIZANCE2 ?AT 0,JOHN ,BAK]0 IS 5TIRELY UNKN[N TO ANY ( \R P>TISANS AT ,LEMB]G1 ,W>S*AN1 ,/4 ,PET]SBURG1 ,G5EVA1 OR ,LONDON2 ?AT 0,JOHN ,BAK]0 HAS NEV] RECEIV$ 9=MATION FROM ANY ( \R ORGANIZATIONS OR FROM ANY MEMB] !RE(2 ?AT 0,JOHN ,BAK]10 ?\< !RE IS NO POSITIVE PRO( %[+ HIM TO BE A SPY 9 ! S]VICE ( ! ,RUSSIAN GOV]NM5T1 IS AN 9DIVIDUAL AGA9/ :OM EV]Y REVOLUTIONI/ HAS REASON TO BE ON GU>D2 & ?AT1 9 %ORT1 0,JOHN ,BAK]0 IS A P]FECT HUMBUG4 ,SO MU* = ! 0SPECIAL0 CORRESPOND5T ( ?AT 0NEWSY10 0HIS PRISON G>B1 & 9 ALL RESPECTS IS TREAT$ AS A COMMON ?IEF4 ,HE HAS TO REPAIR OLD CLO!S1 & IS ALL[$ TO NEI!R WRITE NOR READ ANY?+ BUT ! PI\S TRACTS %[]$ UPON HIM DAILY 9 HIS SELL BY SOME K9D S\L :O DOES NOT YET DESPAIR ( SAV+ HIM FROM ! DEVIL'S CLAWS4 ,ALL 9T]C\RSE ) ! \T] WORLD IS CUT (F1 EXCEPT ?AT HE HAS P]MISSION1 ONCE 9 ?REE MON?S1 TO SEE ONE ( HIS FRI5DS = FIVE M9UTES BEH9D IRON B>S & 9 ! PRES5CE ( A JAIL]4 ,I WILL MAKE NO FUTILE ATTEMPT TO EMPHASIZE !SE FACTS BY ANY COMM5TS ( MY [N4 ,=TUNATELY HIS HEAL? IS GOOD1 & HE HOPES TO BE ABLE ]E LONG TO REPAY ) 9T]E/ HIS DEBT TO ?OSE :O HAVE DEPRIV$ HIM ( HIS LIB]TY4 ,KROPOTK9 IS /AY+1 = ! PRES5T AT ,?\ON1 A SMALL VILLAGE ON ,FR5* T]RITORY1 FIVE MILES FROM ,G5EVA4 ,HIS WIFE WILL PASS H] EXAM9ATION 9 M$IC9E SOMETIME 9 ,OCTOB]1 AFT] :I* HE WILL PROCE$ TO ,LONDON1 :]E HE WILL GIVE A S]IES ( LECTURES ON ,RUSSIA & TAKE UP1 PROBABLY1 HIS P]MAN5T RESID5CE4 ,CRUMBS FROM ,LIB]TY'S ,TABLE4 ,AN >BITR>Y 9CREASE ( WAGES OR AN >BITR>Y DECREASE ( ! H\RS ( LABOR1 IF ANY 9EQUITABLE DI/RIBUTION ( ! PRODUCT CONT9UES1 IS ONLY A MITIGATION ( ! RIGORS ( S]VITUDE1 NOT A DE/RUCTION ( SLAV]Y 9 :I* ! MASSES >E HELD TO ?OSE :OM ! ,NEW ,YORK 0,TIMES0 APTLY DESCRIBES AS 0! SMALL CLASS :OSE OCCUPATION IS ! DIFFICULT ONE ( 5T]TA9+ !MSELVES40 -- ,NEW ,YORK ,TRU?4 ,! OLD TRU? ?AT TO SUPPRESS FRE$OM ( SPEE* IS TO CAUSE1 /IMULATE1 & PROTECT RECKLESSNESS ( ACTION IS AN OLD TRU?1 BUT IT IS ONE :I* NE$S REPETITION 9 EV]Y CRISIS ( ! WORLD'S HI/ORY4 ,TO CREATE SECRECY IS TO PROTECT CONSPIRATORS2 ! PUBLICITY ( CRIME IS ! PROTECTION ( HONE/ M54 -- ,PALL ,MALL ,GAZETTE4 ,! SPOILS SY/EM WILL NOT BE DE/ROY$ BY *ANG+ ! ME?ODS ( DIVID+ ! SPOILS4 -- ,BULLION4 ,FROM 3 ,!,AN>*I/,LIBR>Y4ORG4 ,*RONOLOGY 3 ,JANU>Y #a#c1 #bba 3 ,LIB]TY ,VOL4 ,I4 ,NO4 #f -- ,ADD$4 ,JANU>Y #f1 #bbb 3 ,LIB]TY ,VOL4 ,I4 ,NO4 #f -- ,UPDAT$4 FILE G5]AT$ FROM 3 HTTP3_/_/REVOLTLIB4COM_/