,LIB]TY ,VOL4 ,I4 ,NO4 #ag 
,NOT ! ,DAU<T] ,BUT ! ,MO!R ( ,ORD] 

,PEOPLE 3 

,AU?OR 3 ,B5JAM9 ,R4 ,TUCK] 

,TEXT 3 

0,= ALWAYS 9 ?9E EYES1 ,O ,LIB]TY6 

,%9ES ?AT HI< LI<T :]EBY ! WORLD IS SAV$2 

,& ?\< ?\ SLAY US1 WE WILL TRU/ 9 !E40 

-- ,JOHN ,HAY4 

,ON ,PICKET ,DUTY4 

,WE >E N[ PREP>$ TO FURNI% ! PORTRAIT ( ,MI*AEL ,BAKUN9 7PUBLI%$ 9 ,LIB]TY SEV]AL WEEKS AGO7 SEP>ATELY & ON L>GE1 HEAVY PAP]4 ,IT \<T TO ADORN ! LIBR>Y WALLS ( EV]Y TRUE RADICAL4 ,CONSULT \R ADV]TIS+ COLUMN = FUR!R 9=MATION4 

,! ,PHILADELPHIA 0,PRESS0 REF]S TO ! ,BRITI% H\SE ( COMMONS AS A 0B& ( *UCKLE-HEAD$ DULL>DS40 ,SO EXACT AN APPRECIATION ( ! TOOLS ( ! GOV]N+ CLASSES IS WOR?Y ( ,LIB]TY1 :O HA/5S TO ACKN[L$GE H] 5C\RAGEM5T AT HE>+ H] OP9IONS E*O$ BY H] 9FLU5TIAL CONTEMPOR>IES4 

,ON ANO!R PAGE WILL BE F\ND ALONG EXTRACT FROM A NEWLY PUBLI%$ PAMPHLET ON 0,NATURAL ,LAW10 WRITT5 BY ?AT VET]AN BUT EV] Y\NG RE=M] & PHILOSOPH]1 ,LYS&] ,SPOON]4 ,! :OLE PAMPHLET IS A P[]FUL & CLOSELY >GU$ /ATEM5T ( ! PHILOSOPHY ( ,LIB]TY1 %[+ ! UNRI<TE\SNESS ( ! GOV]NM5T ( MAN BY MAN4 ,IT IS1 H[EV]1 BUT AN1 9TRODUCTION TO A L>GE VOLUME 9T5D$ TO BE EXHAU/IVE ( ! SUBJECT4 ,NEV]!LESS IT IS AN 9TEGRAL1 & NOT A FRAGM5T>Y PORTION ( ! WORK1 & MAYBE READ ) SATISFACTION & PR(IT BY ALL4 ,LIB]TY TRU/S ?AT EA* ( H] READ]S & FRI5DS WILL PAY IMM$IATE HE$ TO ! ADV]TISEM5T 9 ANO!R COLUMN1 & ORD] A COPY =?)4 

,ELSE:]E MAY BE F\ND RESOLUTIONS ADOPT$ BY ACTIVE & E>NE/ C[ORK]S 9 ,J]SEY ,CITY 9 SUPPORT ( ! ACT ( ,GEORGE ,H5DRIX 9 DEFAC+ ! MONUM5T ]ECT$ BY ,CYRUS ,W4 ,FIELD 9 HONOR ( ,MAJOR ,&RE4 ,AGA9/ !SE RESOLUTIONS ,LIB]TY FEELS B\ND TO PROTE/4 ,WE FULLY AGREE ?AT ,MR4 ,CYRUS ,W4 ,FIELD IS A ?OR\<LY CONTEMPTIBLE BE+1 :OSE S\LS1 IF HE HAS ONE1 WILL %RIVEL 9 HELL1 IF !RE IS ONE4 ,BUT1 AS LONG AS HE %ALL REMA9 ON E>?1 HE WILL HAVE RI<TS1 ! SAME RI<TS ?AT EV]Y O!R MAN HAS1 & 9 HIS EX]CISE !RE( ,LIB]TY WILL EV] DEF5D HIM EV5 AGA9/ H] [N FRI5DS4 ,AMONG !SE RI<TS IS ! RI<T TO WOR%IP ANY GOOD OR MAN HE PLEASES & 9 HIS [N WAY4 ,:OEV] DI/URBS OR 9T]F]ES ) HIM 9 SU* WOR%IP /RIKES AN UNW>RANTABLE BL[ AT FRE$OM ( EXPRESSION1 & 9 SO F> IS FALSE TO ,LIB]TY4 ,WE HE>TILY JO9 9 CONDEMNATION ( ! ILLEGAL >RE/ ( ,MR4 ,H5DRIX1 NOT ONLY AS ! ACT ( A COMPULSORY GOV]NM5T :I* IS NOT 5TITL$ TO >RE/ ANYBODY1 BUT AS A D5IAL ( ONE ( ! PR]OGATIVES :I* SAID GOV]NM5T ITSELF PRET5DS TO GU>ANTEE TO ITS CITIZ5S4 ,/ILL WE REMEMB] ?AT1 IF ,MR4 ,H5DRIX IS GUILTY1 HIS >RE/ IS SIMPLY ONE \TRAGE ( ,LIB]TY 9 RETURN = ANO!R4 ,! MONUM5T ]ECT$ AT ,TAPPAUT[N %\LD BE ALL[$ TO /& 9VIOLATE UNTIL TAK5 D[N BY ,MR4 ,FIELD IMPELL$ BY A S5SE ( HIS [N %AME4 ,?IS1 FIR/1 = A PR9CIPLE'S SAKE1 BECAUSE ,MR4 ,FIELD HAD A RI<T TO ]ECT IT1 &1 SECOND1 = POLICY'S SAKE1 BECAUSE :ILE IT /&S1 IT WILL COMMEMORATE EHI5Y1 NOT ! ACT ( ,&RE1 BUT ! FOLLY & S]VILITY ( HIS SMALL-S\L$ ADMIR]4 ,REMEMB]6 ,HE IS NO FIT SOLDI] ( ,LIB]TY :O REFUSES TO ACCORD ,LIB]TY TO HIS 5EMY4 

,PATRICK ,=D HAS ISSU$ ?R\< HIS J\RNAL1 ! 0,IRI% ,WORLD10 A /RONG P]SONAL DECL>ATION ON ! ,IRI% L& QUE/ION4 ,AS A :OLE IT IS MANLY & HAS ! RI<T R+4 ,TO BE SURE1 IT CONTA9S ONE RHETORICALLY RESONANT PASSAGE GLORIFY+ ! 0,HOLY ,CA?OLIC ,*UR*0 & H] 9FALLIBILITY & PL$G+ ! WRIT] TO A TOTAL *ANGE ( HIS OP9IONS ! 9/ANT ! 0,MO!R ( ! ,LIV+0 %ALL ANN\NCE H] ANTAGONISM !RETO1 P]HAPS ! MO/ ELOQU5T PIECE ( SELF-/ULTIFICATION TO UTT] :I* ANY MAN EV] SO>$ TO ! SKIES ) HIS VOICE OR GROVEL$ 9 ! MIRE ) HIS 9TELLECT4 ,BUT SU* ?+S >E TO BE EXPECT$ FROM ,PATRICK ,=D1 ! ,CA?OLIC & SLAVE ( SUP]/ITION4 ,PATRICK ,=D1 ! RE=M] & LI<T-SPREAD]1 9 :OM ALONE ,LIB]TY TAKES 9T]E/1 IS QUITE ANO!R P]SON4 ,HE DECL>ES AFRE% & 9 UNMI/AKABLE T]MS HIS ADH]5CE TO ! 0,NO ,R5T0 /&>D1 & REBUKES1 9 WORDS ?AT W\LD %AME ANY BUT %AMELESS M51 ?OSE :O W\LD NULLIFY ! GR& WORK ALREADY A*IEV$ = ,IREL& BY AB&ON+ ! ,L& ,LEAGUE ) VICTORY ALMO/ )9 ITS GRASP TO 5GAGE 9 A HOPELESS /RUGGLE = 0HOME RULE0 & ,IRI% 9DEP5D5CE4 ,HOME RULE1 =SOO?6 ,AS IF ?AT W]E NOT AS BAD AS ANY RULE6 ,AS IF ,IREL& HAD NOT SUFF]$ TOO MU* FROM ! RULE ALREADY6 ,:AT %E NE$S N[ IS NO RULE1 AN>*Y1 ) :I* WILL COME PEACE4 ,= :]E !RE IS NO RULE !RE WILL BE NO MONOPOLY2 & :]E !RE IS NO MONOPOLY !RE WILL BE NO R5T2 & :]E !RE IS NO R5T !RE WILL BE NO DI/URB+ L& QUE/ION1 & EV]Y O!R QUE/ION ( HUMAN WELF>E WILL BE />T$ ON ! ROAD TO ITS SPE$Y SOLUTION4 

,( ! ABSOLUTE CORRECTNESS ( ! PR9CIPLE1 & ADVISABILITY ( ! POLICY1 ( FREE TRADE !RE CAN BE NO REASONABLE D\BT1 BUT IT MU/ BE ?OR\<-GO+ FREE TRADE1-- NO SU* HALF-WAY >RANGEM5T AS ?AT :I* ! SO-CALL$ 0FREE TRAD]S0 W\LD HAVE ADOPT$4 ,DAVID ,A4 ,WELLS1 ,PR(ESSOR ,P]RY1 & ALL ! ECONOMI/S ( ! ,MAN*E/] S*OOL >E FOND ( CLAMOR+ = 0FREE TRADE10 BUT AN EXAM9ATION ( !IR POSITION ALWAYS %[S !M ! MO/ >D5T ADVOCATES ( MONOPOLY 9 ! MANUFACTURE ( MONEY2 ! BITT]E/ OPPON5TS ( FREE TRADE 9 CR$IT4 ,!Y AGREE & 9SI/ ?AT IT IS NO?+ LESS ?AN TYRANNY = ! GOV]NM5T TO CLIP A L>GE SLICE \T ( ! =EIGN PRODUCT :I* ANY ONE *OOSES TO IMPORT1 BUT >E UNABLE TO DETECT ANY VIOLATION ( FRE$OM 9 ! EXCLUSIVE LIC5SE GIV5 ! GOV]NM5T TO A CONSPIRACY ( NOTE-%>+ CORPORATIONS CALL$ NATIONAL BANKS1 :I* >E 5ABL$ BY ?IS MONOPOLY TO CLIP ANY:]E FROM ?REE TO FIFTE5 P] C5T \T ( ! CR$IT :I* ! PEOPLE >E COMPELL$ TO BUY ( !M4 ,SU* 0FREE TRADE0 AS ?IS IS ! MO/ PALPABLE %AM TO ANY ONE :O REALLY LOOKS 9TO IT4 ,IT MAKES GOLD A PRIVILEG$ PRODUCT1 ! K+ ( COMMODITIES4 ,& AS LONG AS ?IS ROYALTY ( GOLD EXI/S1 ! PROTECTIONI/S :O MAKE SO MU* ( ! !ORY ( ! 0BALANCE ( TRADE0 WILL OCCUPY AN 9VULN]ABLE POSITION4 ,:ILE GOLD IS K+1 ! NATION :I* ABSORBS IT -- ?AT IS1 ! NATION :OSE EXPORTS L>GELY EXCE$ ITS IMPORTS -- WILL SURELY GOV]N ! WORLD4 ,BUT DE?RONE ?IS WOR/ ( DESPOTS1 & ?AT C\NTRY WILL BE ! MO/ P[]FUL :I* SUCCE$S TO ! L>GE/ EXT5T 9 GETT+ RID ( ITS GOLD 9 EX*ANGE = PRODUCTS MORE USEFUL4 ,9 O!R WORD1 ! REPUBLICANIZATION ( SPECIO MU/ PREC$E ! FRE$OM ( TRADE4 

,TO ,! ,AM]ICAN ,PEOPLE4 

,! PUBLIC PR9TS HAVE TOLD Y\ ( POLITICAL TRIALS 9 ,RUSSIA & ( ! MON/R\S JUDGM5TS DAILY PRON\NC$ 9 H] C\RTS4 ,BUT !Y HAVE TOLD Y\ NO?+ ( ! CRUEL SUFF]+S ( ! CONDEMN$2 & ! VICTIMS :OSE NAMES >E RECORD$ BY !M >E BUT A FRACTION ( ! CR[DS ?AT GO TO !IR DOOM 9 D>KNESS & SIL5CE4 ,BE=E ! VA/ & EV] WID5+ DISCONT5T ( ! ,RUSSIAN PEOPLE1 AU?ORITY 9 ,RUSSIA IS T]ROR-/RICK5 & AMAZ$2 & IT LAYS H&S1 BY T5S ( ?\S&S1 ON \R Y\?1 & S5DS !M1 M5 & WOM5 ALIKE1 9TO HOPELESS BANI%M5T4 ,! DES]TS 9 ! NOR? ( ! ,EMPIRE1 FROM ! DRE>Y WA/ES R\ND ! ,:ITE -- ,SEA TO ! FROZ5 %ORES ( ,EA/]N ,ASIA1 >E SCATT]$ OV] ) B&S ( EXILES1 ! FL[] ( ! ,RUSSIAN RACE4 ,!Y >E PRISON$ EV]Y:]E3 9 WRET*$ HAMLETS1 9 ! DEP?S ( TRACKLESS & 9HOSPITABLE =E/S1 9 REMOTE TRIBAL CAMPS 9 ,EA/]N ,SIB]IA1 :]E H>DLY A WORD ( !IR NATIVE TONGUE IS SPOK5 OR UND]/OOD4 ,& !Y HAVE TO 5DURE NOT ONLY ! MORAL TORTURES ( ISOLATION & 9ACTIVITY1 BUT ! PHYSICAL PANGS ( HUNG] & COLD4 ,!RE IS SC>CE A MEANS ( LIVELIHOOD ?AT IS NOT D5I$ !M2 & ?\< TO EA* ! ,/ATE ALLOTS A PITTANCE = HIS SUPPORT1-- TWELVE %ILL+S A MON? IF HE IS NOBLY BORN2 SEV5 %ILL+S A MON? IF HE IS NOT1-- !RE >E ( LATE SO MANY ( !M ?AT IT IS NEV] PAID UNTIL LONG OV]DUE4 ,MON? AFT] MON? GOES BY1 & MANY AN EXILE DIES = LACK ( BREAD BE=E HE HAS RECEIV$ A S+LE F>?+4 

,!Y >E MO/LY Y\NG & 5]GETIC2 !Y HAVE FAI? 9 ! COM+ ( BETT] TIMES2 !Y >E BRAVE & /RONG 5\< TO MAKE LITTLE ( ! TRIALS ?AT >E IMPOS$ UPON !M BY ! DESP]ATE NECESSITIES ( !IR TIME & ( ! DUTIES TO :I* !Y >E CALL$1 IF !Y HAD BUT IS HOPE ?AT !Y MI<T ONE DAY TO LIFE & WORK AMONG !IR FRI5DS4 ,BUT !IR /R5G? IS WA/$ BY MIS]Y & H>D%IP1 & !Y DIE EASILY & SOON4 

,MONEY ALONE IS NE$$3 ?AT MU* SUFF]+ MAY BE SP>$ & MANY SUFF]]S MAY BE SAV$4 ,TO RAISE IT1 & AFT]W>DS DI/RIBUTE IT AMONG \R PRISON]S1 WE HAVE =M$ A ,R$ ,CROSS ,SOCIETY ( ! ,PEOPLE'S ,WILL4 ,IT BE>S NO P>T :ATEV] 9 \R W> AGA9/ AU?ORITY4 ,ITS RELATION TO ! ,REVOLUTION>Y ,P>TY IS ?AT ( ! ,R$ ,CROSS ,SOCIETY ( ,G5EVA TO AN >MY 9 ! FIELD4 ,!RE IS ONLY ONE DIFF]5CE1-- ?AT ! ,R$ ,CROSS ,SOCIETY3 ( ! ,PEOPLE'S ,WILL %>ES 9 EA* & EV]Y ONE ( ! DANG]S ( ! =CE IT W\LD SUCCOR & RELIEVE4 

,SU* FUNDS AS IT MAY RAISE WILL BE DEVOT$ TO BUT ONE USE4 ,NOT A P5NY BUT WILL BE SP5T UPON POLITICAL EXILES & POLITICAL PRISON]S4 ,IT WILL MAKE NO DI/9CTION 9 FAVOR ( P]SONS OR OP9IONS4 ,ALL :O SUFF] & >E 9 NE$ WILL RECEIVE ( IT ALIKE4 

,! ,SOCIETY E/EEMS IT A DUTY TO APPEAL NOT ONLY TO ! M5 & WOM5 ( ,RUSSIA1 :]E TO BE *>ITABLE TO POLITICAL CONVICTS IS TO RUN ! RISK ( SUFF]+ BESIDE !M1 BUT TO ! M5 & WOM5 ( ! FRE] & HAPPI] C\NTRIES ( ,WE/]N ,EUROPE & ,AM]ICA4 

,TO ?IS 5D IT HAS APPO9T$ TWO OR ITS MEMB]S TO WORK ( ORGANIZ+ SECTIONS ABROAD1 & ( GA!R+ 9 SU* SUMS AS MAY BE BE/[$ 9 FAVOR ( ! 5DS IT HAS 9 VIEW4 ,!SE DELEGATES >E ,V]A ,ZASS\LIT* & ,PET] ,LAVR(F4 ,!IR 9/RUCTIONS >E AS FOLL[S3 -- 

7#a7 ,TO APPEAL DIRECTLY TO SUBSCRIB]S1 BY MEANS ( NUMB]$ & /AMP$ SUBSCRIPTION LI/S1 SIGN$ BY ! DELEGATES !MSELVES & CONTA9+ AN ACC\NT ( ALL SUMS RECEIV$4 

7#b7 ,TO BEG ALL J\RNALS & ORGANS ( PUBLIC OP9ION TO ASSI/ ! ,SOCIETY BY OP5+ SUBSCRIPTION LI/S & RECEIV+ & PAY+ 9 SUBSCRIPTIONS4 

7#c7 ,TO PUBLI% ACC\NTS ( ALL SUBSCRIPTIONS RECEIV$ & ( MANN] ( !IR EMPLOY4 

7#d7 ,TO APPO9T RECEIV]S 9 C\NTRIES TO :I* NO DELEGATE HAS BE5 NAM$1 :OSE SIGNATURE %ALL HAVE EQUAL AU?ORITY ) ?AT ( ! DELEGATES !MSELVES4 

,B5J4 ,R4 ,TUCK]1 ,$ITOR ( ,LIB]TY1 ,P4 ,O4 ,BOX #c#c#f#f1 ,BO/ON1 ,MASS41 IS ! DELEGATE = ,AM]ICA4 

,IT IS E>NE/LY REQUE/$ ?AT SUBSCRIPTIONS BE ONLY PAID 7#a7 TO ONE OR O!R ( ! DELEGATES2 7#b7 TO P]SONS ACCR$IT$ BY ! POSSESSION ( SUBSCRIPTION LI/S1 AS DESCRIB$ ABOVE2 OR 7#c7 TO ! $ITORS ( SU* J\RNALS AS %ALL CONS5T TO RECEIVE SUBSCRIPTIONS = ! ,SOCIETY4 

,V]A ,ZASS\LIT*4 

,PET] ,LAVR(F4 

0,A FREE MAN IS ONE :O 5JOYS ! USE ( HIS REASON & HIS FACULTIES2 :O IS NEI!R BL9D$ BY PASSION1 NOT H9D]$ OR DRIV5 BY OPPRESSION1 NOT DECEIV$ BY ]RONE\S OP9IONS40 -- ,PR\DHON4 

,AM]ICANS1 ,ATT5TION6 

,9 \R ISSUE ( ,JANU>Y #b#a1 ,NO4 #a#c1 APPE>$ AN APPEAL ( ! ,NIHILI/S = PECUNI>Y AID1 NOT 9 BEHALF ( ! MOVEM5T ITSELF1 BUT = ! MAT]IAL RELIEF ( ?OSE :O >E N[ SUFF]+ 9 CONSEQU5CE ( !IR P>TICIPATION 9 ! /RUGGLE = ,LIB]TY 9 ,RUSSIA4 ,! SPECIAL APPEAL !N PR9T$ WAS A TRANSLATION ( ?AT :I* HAD BE5 ISSU$ TO ! PEOPLE ( ,FRANCE4 ,TO-DAY1 9 ANO!R COLUMN1 WE PR9T$ ! APPEAL ?AT HAS BE5 ISSU$ DIRECTLY TO ! ,5GLI%-SPEAK+ RACE & ESPECIALLY TO ,AM]ICANS4 ,9 IT IS /AT$ ! FACT1 :I* WE N[ TAKE PLEASURE & PRIDE 9 ANN\NC+1 ?AT ! ,$ITOR ( ,LIB]TY HAS BE5 DULY APPO9T$ ! ,AM]ICAN DELEGATE ( ! ,R$ ,CROSS ,SOCIETY ( ! ,WILL ( ,PEOPLE TO ORGANIZE ! SUBSCRIPTION 9 ?IS C\NTRY1 & RECEIVE1 ACKN[L$GE1 & TRANSMIT SU* RESPONSES TO ! APPEAL AS ,AM]ICAN SYMPA?Y & ,AM]ICAN LOVE ( ,LIB]TY %ALL %[ ITS WILL+NESS TO MAKE4 ,HE ASSUMES ! TRU/ ?US PLAC$ 9 HIS KEEP+ ) CLE> S5SE ( ! HONOR CONF]R$ & FULL REALIZATION ( ITS IMPORTANCE4 ,HE ADDS HIS VOICE TO ?OSE ( ,V]A ,ZASS\LIT* & ,PI]RE ,LAVR(F1 :O 9 TURN SPEAK AU?ORITATIVELY = ! BE/ ELEM5TS ( ,RUSSIAN LIFE1 &1 ) ALL ! E>NE/NESS AT HIS COMM&1 ASKS EV]Y ONE :OM IT MAY REA* TO GIVE ! UTMO/ ?AT HE OR %E CAN SP>E TO SUCCOR ! ,SIB]IAN EXILES & !IR SUFF]+ FAMILIES4 ,! APPEAL IS TO ! HUMAN HE>T1 REG>DLESS ( 9DIVIDUAL OP9IONS4 ,LET IT NOT BE SAID ?AT ! CITIZ5S ( ! FREE/ C\NTRY 9 ! WORLD FAIL$ TO DO !IR BE/ TO HEAL ! W\NDS 9FLICT$ UPON SU* ( !IR BRE?R5 AS HAVE H]OICALLY /RUGGL$ TO CA/ (F ! *A9S PLAC$ UPON !M BY ! MO/ ABSOLUTE & CRUEL ( AUTOCRACIES4 

,WE >E 9 POSSESSION ( /AMP$ & NUMB]$ SUBSCRIPTION LI/S ISSU$ BY ! ,C5TRAL ,COMMITTEE ( ! ,R$ ,CROSS4 ,TO ANY RESPONSIBLE P]SON 9 ANY P>T ( ,AM]ICA :O %ALL SIGNIFY HIS WILL+NESS TO DEVOTE A PORTION ( HIS TIME TO WORK+ UP ! SUBSCRIPTION1 ONE ( !SE LI/S1 TOGE!R ) COPIES ( ! PR9T$ APPEAL1 WILL BE =W>D$4 ,ESPECIALLY DO WE URGE \R READ]S TO TAKE A H&1 & AN ACTIVE ONE4 9 ! GLORI\S WORK4 ,9DIVIDUAL SUBSCRIPTIONS MAY BE S5T DIRECTLY TO ,B5J4 ,R4 ,TUCK]1 ,BOX #c#c#f#f1 ,BO/ON1 ,MASS42 ALSO ANY REQUE/S = FUR!R 9=MATION4 ,ALL AM\NTS RECEIV$1 ) ! NAMES ( ! DONORS1 WILL BE ACKN[L$G$ 9 !SE COLUMNS1 & PROMPTLY TRANSMITT$1 AT LEA/ POSSIBLE CO/1 TO ! ,C5TRAL ,COMMITTEE4 

,LET US ADD ?AT ! APPEAL :I* WE =M]LY PUBLI%$ OCCASION$1 BY ITS ISSUANCE 9 ,FRANCE1 ! EXPULSION ( ,PI]RE ,LAVR(F1 ONE ( ITS SIGN]S1 FROM ,FR5* T]RITORY BY ! NEW M9I/RY1 :I* PR(ESSES TO BE GOV]N$ 9 ITS POLICY BY ! PR9CIPLE ( ,LIB]TY4 ,LAVR(F HAS LONG LIV$ ! LIFE ( QUIET /UD5T 9 ,P>IS1 SP5D+ MO/ ( HIS TIME 9 ! LIBR>IES1 & HIS EXPULSION IS ANO!R EVID5CE ( ! HYPOCRISY ( ! PRET5SE ?AT ANY O!R PR9CIPLE ?AT AU?ORITY CAN LIE AT ! F\NDATION ( ANY =M ( GOV]NM5T :ATSOEV]4 ,BE=E LEAV+ ,FRANCE1 HE ADDRESS$ A LETT] TO ,CLEMECEAU1 FROM :I* WE QUOTE ! FOLL[+ PASSAGES1 LEAV+ TILL ANO!R TIME ! BURN+ COMM5TS ( ! RADICAL PRESS ( ,P>IS UPON ?IS LATE/ \TRAGE3 

,I HAVE JU/ BE5 NOTIFI$ ( ! DECREE EXPELL+ ME FROM ,FR5* T]RITORY4 

,HAV+ SC>CELY BUSI$ MYSELF AT SEV]AL YE>S ) ! AFFAIRS ( ,FRANCE1 ,I DID NOT CONSID] MYSELF SO DANG]\S TO 0PUBLIC SAFETY0 ( ! REPUBLICAN C\NTRY 9 :I* ,I TOOK UP MY RESID5CE SOME FIVE YE>S AGO4 ,BUT ,I DO NOT COMPLA94 ,A REVOLUTION>Y SOCIALI/1 IT IS ) ME AXIOM ?AT EXI/+ SOCIETY CANNOT BE SOCIETY ( JU/ICE & LIB]TY2 IF IT PLEASES ! GOV]NM5T ( ,FR5* REPUBLIC TO FURNI% NEW PRO(S 9 SUPPORT ( MY !ORY1 IT W\LD ILL BECOME ME TO EXHIBIT A/ONI%M5T4 ,IT ACTS ACCORD+ TO ! LOGIC ( ITS SITUATION AS A GOV]NM5T44444 

,IT 9T5DS1 9 EXPELL+ ME TO-DAY1 TO %[ A M>K ( FRI5D%IP = ! GOV]NM5T ( ! ,RUSSIAN EMPIRE2 BUT1 9 VIEW ( ! WEAKNESS & 9F]IOR 9TELLIG5CE ( ! LATT]1 ?IS ACT ( COMPLIANCE IS NOT UNLIKELY TO BE F\ND MORE DIS9T]E/$ ?AN WE C\LD HAVE DESIR$4 ,:O KN[S H[ MANY O!R CONCESSIONS TO POLITICAL COMB9ATIONS WILL FOLL[ TO-MORR[8 ,IT IS 9EVITABLE44444 

,DRIV5 RUDELY FROM A C\NTRY :I* ,I LOV$ & :]E ,I HAVE MADE FRI5DS1 ,I HAVE ONLY TO SUBMIT TO ! DECREE1 /ILL DEEM+ IT ?\<TFUL ON ! P>T ( A M9I/] NOT TO HAVE RELEGAT$ ME TO SOME 9T]IOR /RON<OLD1 OR NOT TO HAVE CONDUCT$ ME TO ! FRONTI]1 MANACLES ON WRI/S & 9 PRISON WAGON1 AS HAPP5$ A YE> & HALF AGO TO SEV]AL ( MY FRI5DS1 :O HAD M+L$ AS LITTLE AS ,I 9 ! /RUGGLES ( ,FR5* POLITICAL P>TIES4 

,I SUBMIT1 !N1 TO ! DECREE ( ! M9I/RY1 & %ALL PROBABLY HAVE LEFT ,FRANCE :5 Y\ READ ?IS LETT]4 ,BUT IT IS = Y\ & Y\R FRI5DS1 REPRES5TATIVES ( ! ,FR5* PEOPLE & MANAG]S ( !IR J\RNALS2 = Y\1 :O1 BY TAL5T & POLITICAL 9FLU5CE1 >E ! NATURAL GU>DIANS ( ! 9T]E/S & HONOR ( Y\R C\NTRY1-- IT IS Y\ TI TAKE HE$ :E!R ! GOV]NM5T ( ! ,FR5* REPUBLIC IS NOT ALL[+ ITSELF TO GLIDE TOO QUICKLY 9TO A PA? FATAL TO ! PR9CIPLES ( LIB]TY & DEMOCRACY1 :E!R ! DANG]1 FROM ! MORAL & POLITICAL PO9T ( VIEW1 DOES NOT BECOME MORE IMM95T ) EV]Y H\R4 

,9 QUITT+ ,FRANCE1 PROBABLY =EV]1 ,I %ALL ALWAYS PRES]VE ! MEMORY ( ?OSE :O /RUGGLE )9 H] B\ND>IES = ! TRIUMPH ( ! PR9CIPLES ( REPUBLICAN RADICALISM4 

,SAMUEL ,JOHNSON4 

,LIB]TY HE>S ) REGRET ( ! DEA? ( ,SAMUEL ,JOHNSON4 ,( ! RELIGI\S RADICAL :O1 S9CE ! DEA? ( ,P>K]1 HAVE COME 9TO NOTICE AS APO/LES ( ,REASON 9 ,RELIGION1 ,MR4 ,JOHNSON1 LESS WIDELY KN[N ?AN MANY O!RS1 EASILY /OOD =EMO/4 ,9 BREAD? ( VIEW1 CLE>NESS ( ?\<T1 HE HAD AMONG ! RADICAL WRIT]S NO SUP]IOR4 ,HIS MANY & C>EFULLY PREP>$ CONTRIBUTIONS TO ! 0,RADICAL0 %[ ! VIGOR & TEMP] ( HIS M9D4 ,A TRANSC5D5TALI/ ( MO/ CONSI/5T P>TS1 HE KNEW ALWAYS :]E HE /OOD1 & WAS NEV] F\ND LAPS+ 9TO UNC]TA9TY & COMPROMISE4 ,! MAT]IALI/ F\ND 9 HIM A MAN ) BO? ! C\RAGE ( HIS CONVICTIONS & ! 0PREP>$NESS0 TO /ATE !M4 ,HE KNEW HIS [N GR\ND ?OR\<LY4 ,PROBABLY NO WRIT] HAS PRES5T$ ! TRANSC5D5TAL PHILOSOPHY ) MORE SATISFACTION TO TRANSC5D5TAL BELIEV]S ?AN DID ,MR4 ,JOHNSON 9 AN ELABORATE PAP] PUBLI%$ 9 ! 0,RADICAL ,REVIEW10 NE>LY FIVE YE>S AGO4 ,= N9ETE5 YE>S HE WAS ! PREA*] TO A ,FREE ,SOCIETY 9 ,LYNN4 ,HE WAS A FIRM BELIEV] 9 9DIVIDUAL1 P]SONAL 9FLU5CE & P[]1 & 9/9CTIVELY AVOID$ ! ORGANIZ+1 SECT>IAN PURPOSES & PLANS SO BEGUIL+ TO O!RS4 ,! BOND ( ORGANIZ$ RELIGI\S PROPAG&ISM1 H[EV] LIB]AL 9 PROTE/ATIONS1 WAS TO HIS M9D /ILL A FETT]4 ,TO SWAP ! 0,LORD%IP ( ,*RI/0 = ! MA/]%IP ( EV5 A TACIT UND]/&+ AMONG RADICALS AS TO MATT]S ( BELIEF WAS TO MAKE NO SIGNAL ADVANCE4 ,! M9D1 TO BE FREE1 MU/ FOLL[ ITS [N LAWS ) NOT EV5 ! IMPLI$ DUTY ( SOCIAL >GUM5T4 ,EA* MAN MU/ DO HIS [N WORK 9 HIS [N WAY ON HIS [N GR\ND1 & )\T FE> OR FAVOR4 ,= ?IS DUTY ( FRE$OM1 ?IS ABSOLUTE NECESSITY = 9DEP5D5T ACTIVITY1 HE EV] DID VALIANT & SUCCESSFUL BATTLE4 ,& H]E91 MORE ?AN 9 ANY O!R FACT ( HIS LIFE1 DOES ,LIB]TY REJOICE4 ,9 SPIRIT ,MR4 ,JOHNSON WAS EV] A ,LIB]TY'S SIDE4 ,BUT NOT ALWAYS C\LD HE SEE O'] :AT SEEM+LY DANG]\S PASSES ! ASPIR+ DAME L$4 ,IF HE DID NOT FOLL[ H] TO ! L5G? ( H] LEAD+1 IT WAS NOT ?AT HE LACK$ ! C\RAGE1 BUT ?AT1 TO HIS >D5T VISION1 ! GOAL HAD BE5 T\*$4 ,NEV]!LESS1 9 HIS PHILOSOPHY ! F\NDATIONS ( ,LIB]TY W]E LAID DEEP & /RONG4 ,S9C]ITY1 HONE/Y ( ?\<T & EXPRESSION 5NOBL$ & /R5G!N$ HIS :OLE LIFE4 ,NOT %R9K+ FROM ! WORLD1 AS SOME MI/AK5LY HAVE SAID1 BUT RETIR+ TO HIS APPO9T$ TASKS ?AT HE MI<T WELL & FAI?FULLY DO !M1 HE TOIL$ HAPPILY & UNREMITT+LY4 ,TW5TY YE>S & MORE HE HAD WORK$ UPON ! ?REE L>GE VOLUMES DEVOT$ TO ! 0,ORI5TAL ,RELIGIONS10 TWO ( :I*1 PUBLI%$ BY ,J4 ,R4 ,OSGOOD @& ,CO41 >E BE=E ! PUBLIC1-- 0,9DIA0 & 0,*9A40 ,?IS LA/-NAM$ VOLUME IS WELL WOR?Y ! WIDE/ CIRCULATION4 ,IT TREATS ( ! ,*9ESE PEOPLE1 !IR RELIGION1 PHILOSOPHY1 GOV]NM5T1 !IR :OLE SOCIAL LIFE & HI/ORY1 9 ! MO/ LE>N$ & 9TELLIG5T MANN]1 & HAS ! MO/ PRACTICAL ( BE>+ UPON ?IS N[ EXCIT+ QUE/ION 9 ,AM]ICAN POLITICS4 ,FROM ITS PAGES ONE LE>NS ?AT ! MU* HAT$ 0HEA!N ,*9EE0 IS1 9 NE>LY ALL ! ESS5TIALS ( REAL MANL9ESS1 QUITE BEYOND ! IMITATION EV5 ( HIS ,*RI/IAN DETRACTORS4 

,MR4 ,JOHNSON'S DEA? OCCURR$ SUDD5LY1 & GAVE A SAD SURPRISE TO HIS MANY P]SONAL FRI5DS4 ,A BRAVE1 TRUE MAN1 :OSE MEMORY ,LIB]TY WILL EV] *]I%6 ,HAD HE BEGUN LIFE TO-DAY ) ! SAME F]V5T ZEAL & CLE>-SI<T$NESS ?AT *>ACT]IZ$ HIS ANTI-SLAV]Y C>E] ?IRTY YE>S AGO1 !RE IS NO D\BT :]E HE W\LD HAVE TAK5 HIS /& & :AT NEW BATTLES HE W\LD HAVE HELP$ ,LIB]TY FI<T4 ,BUT AGE & DEA?1 FOES & DE/ROY]S ( US ALL1 *A9$ & CLAIM$ HIM4 ,MU* HE DID1 YET MU* REMA9S BEH9D4 ,9 HIS DAY & G5]ATION HE DID ,LIB]TY NOBLE S]VICE4 ,BUT NOBL]1 HI<]1 PR(\ND] MEAN+S ! AGES UNVEIL1 & WE :O /ILL LIVE MU/ NE$S PRESS =W>D 9TO !IR NEW] & /RONG] LI<T4 

0,FRE$OM ALL-W+$ EXP&S1 

,NOR P]*ES 9 N>R[ PLACE1 

,H] BROAD VAN SEEKS UNPLANT$ L&S40 

,!SE L9ES ( ,EM]SON HE LOV$ TO QUOTE1 & N[ ?AT HIS LIPS >E /ILL1 HIS VOICE SIL5T1 ,LIB]TY TO HIS MEMORY REPEATS !M1 & ADOPTS !M AS H] [N4 

,CON/RUCTION & ,DE/RUCTION4 

,ALMO/ )\T EXCEPTION EV]Y NEW SUBSCRIB] TO ,LIB]TY TO :OM ITS PURPOSES >E DISCLOS$ & :O HAS GR[N UP UND] PREVAIL+ SY/EMS EXCLAIMS3 0,AH6 ,I SEE Y\ >E WOND]FULLY EXP]T AS TE>+ D[N1 BUT Y\ DON'T SAY :AT Y\ PROPOSE TO SUB/ITUTE4 ,I AM FULLY AW>E ?AT \R PRES5T GOV]NM5TS >E T]RIBLY ROTT51 BUT Y\ DON'T PROPOSE ANY?+ BETT]40 

,DE> FRI5DS3 SUPPOSE ! NATURAL ROAD-B$ FROM ,BO/ON TO ,L[ELL W]E ( ! V]Y BE/ QUALITY4 ,NATURE HAD MADE IT MO/ ADMIRABLY ADAPT$ = TRAVEL & TRANSPORTATION4 ,BUT1 SEE+ A *ANCE TO PUT UP A JOB & ROB ! PUBLIC1 C]TA9 DESIGN+ ROGUES1 HIR$ BY A FEW ?IEV+ CONTRACTORS1 HAVE SUCCE$$1 ?R\< ! VILE >TS ( POLITICS1 9 COV]+ ?IS NATURAL PAVEM5T ) A C]TA9 PAT5T 9V5TION1 GOTT5 UP BY ! POLITICAL ROAD-BUILD]S4 ,Y\ & WE >E LOCAT$ ON ?IS PAT5T ROAD4 ,EV]Y TIME ?AT WE PUT A SPADE 9TO \R GR\ND WE F9D ?AT ! NATURAL B$ IS ALMO/ P]FECT4 ,IT IS H>D1 YET ELA/IC & ABSORPTIVE1 & 9 EV]Y WAY ADAPT$ = COMM]CE & TRANSPORTATION1 IF IT HAD ONLY BE5 LEFT TO ! C>E ( ?OSE :O USE IT1 & :O HAVE MO/ AT /AKE 9 ITS S]VICEABILITY4 

,BUT ! PAT5T ROAD WE F9D TO BE A P]FECT NUISANCE4 ,WE >E CON/ANTLY BE+ LEVI$ UPON BY =CE TO SUPPORT IT & REPAIR IT4 ,EV]Y DAY WE1 OR SOME ( \R NEI<BORS1 0GET /UCK0 UPON IT & \R PROP]TY IS RU9$ & DISABL$4 ,IT IS H>D TO WALK & RIDE UPON4 ,IT IS UNEV54 ,IT IS FULL ( GULLIES & HOLES1 & IS 9 EV]Y WAY A CON/ANT S\RCE ( DAMAGE TO \R LIVES & POSSESSIONS4 

,BUT1 :5EV] WE COMPLA9 & APPEAL TO ! POLITICAL ROAD-BUILD]S1 !Y >E V]Y POLITE & SYMPA!TIC4 ,!Y HE> \R GRIEVANCES1 & /RAI<TWAY ! JOBB+ CONTRACTORS BEH9D !M SET AB\T TO REPAIR ! ROAD AT \R EXP5SE 9 !IR [N WAY4 ,! TAXES 9CREASE1 BUT ! ROAD GR[S WORSE4 ,SOME ( US BEG9 TO SUSPECT ?AT ! :OLE S*EME IS A PUT-UP JOB TO ROB US1 BUT !N ! ?\<T ?AT IT IS ! WORK ( \R LEGISLATIVE GOV]NORS RE/RA9S US FROM WICK$1 AN>*I/IC DESIGNS4 ,& YET ! ?\<T ?AT UND]NEA? !IR >TIFICIAL PAT5T ROAD !RE IS A P]FECT NATURAL BOD CON/ANTLY HAUNTS US4 0IF !Y HAD ONLY LET US ALONE10 SOME ( US CRY1 0& NOT BUILT UP !IR >TIFICIAL SW9DLE OV] ! NATURAL B$ 9 ! FIR/ PLACE1 ALL W\LD HAVE BE5 WELL40 

,BUT BY & BY TWO OR ?REE RESOLUTE DWELL]S ALONG ! ROAD BEG9 TO ASK !MSELVES3 0,BY :AT RI<T DO !SE SW9DL+ POLITICAL PAT5T-ROAD-BUILD]S M$DLE ) ! NATURAL B$8 ,BY :AT SACR$ RI<T >E !SE ROBB]S PRIVILEG$ TO ET]NALLY IMPOSE UPON US8 ,:Y %\LD !Y HAVE ANY AU?ORITY ABOVE US 9 !SE MATT]S80 ETC42 &1 UPON LOOK+ 9TO ! MATT] DEEPLY1 !Y F9D ?AT ! ROBB]S HAVE NO SOLID CLAIM TO AU?ORITY 9 NATURAL JU/ICE4 

,N[1 !N1 = RADICAL1 H]OIC TREATM5T6 ,ON SOME F9E MORN+ !Y />T \T ) PL[ & PICK & DYNAMITE TO 0TE> D[N0 ! USELESS & CO/LY SUP]/RUCTURE4 ,BUT SC>CELY HAVE !IR PL[S P5ETRAT$ ! PAT5T ROAD & T\*$ H>D-PAN :5 ! O!R PLUND]$ NEI<BORS >RIVE UPON ! SC5E4 0,HOLD ON60 !Y CRY ) ONE ACCORD2 0Y\ >E WOND]FULLY EXP]T AT TE>+ D[N1 BUT Y\ DON'T SAY :AT Y\ PROPOSE TO SUB/ITUTE4 ,WE >E AW>E ?AT ! PAT5T-ROAD-BUILD]S & !IR ROAD >E T]RIBLY ROTT51 BUT Y\ DON'T PROPOSE ANY?+ BETT]40 ,! FACT IS ?AT !Y HAVE BECOME SO IMBU$ ) ! IDEA ?AT NO?+ CAN BE PROP]LY DONE )\T RESOLUTIONS1 BILLS1 COMMITTEES1 VOTES1 & ALL ! R$-TAPE HOCUS-POCUS ( ! ,/ATE ?AT !SE SUP]/ITI\S FALSELY $UCAT$1 /ATECRAFT-RIDD5 NEI<BORS >E READY TO P\NCE UPON !IR ONLY TRUE FRI5DS1 :O DESIRE TO GO /RAI<T D[N TO H>D-PAN & ABOLI% ! ROBB+ SW9DL]S4 

,! REPLY ( ! H>D-PAN M5 TO !IR DELUD$ NEI<BORS IS V]Y SIMPLE4 ,!Y >E CON/RUCT+ SOME?+ BETT] 9 ! V]Y FACT & ACT ( TE>+ D[N4 ,REMOV+ ! ROTT5 SUP]/RUCTURE IS 9 & ( ITSELF BUILD+ SOME?+ BETT]4 ,:ILE !Y >E PUTT+ ! PL[ D[N TO H>D-PAN1 !Y DO NOT =BID !SE :O *OOSE FROM US+ ! OLD SUP]/RUCTURE TILL !IR WORK IS DONE4 ,!Y SIMPLY ASK !IR NEI<BORS TO TAKE HOLD & HA/5 ITS REMOVAL1 9/EAD ( /&+ IDLE & F9D+ FAULT1 IF NOT D5\NC+ !M 9 !IR RI<TE\S WORK4 ,:5 ! OLD ROTT5 SW9DLE IS \T ( ! WAY1 !N :ATEV] NEW >RANGEM5TS >E NECESS>Y TO COMPLETE ! USEFULNESS ( ! NATURAL ROAD CAN BE EASILY FIX$ UPON & EXECUT$ BY MUTUAL CONS5T4 

,BUT ! OLD SUP]/RUCTURE MU/ COME D[N BE=E ANY CON/RUCTION IS POSSIBLE4 ,! ROAD ( EQUITABLE COMM]CE IS ALREADY !RE1 IF ! PAT5T 9NOVATION CAN ONLY BE GOTT5 \T ( ! WAY4 ,!SE POLITICAL PAT5T-ROAD-BUILD]S >E SIMPLY USURP]S1 :O P]SI/5TLY BLOCK ! WAY & TAX !IR FELL[ M5 TO SU/A9 !IR NUISANCES4 ,9 WAG+ W> AGA9/ NATURAL EQUITY & TRUE GOV]NM5T IT IS !Y :O >E ! REAL DE/RUCTIONI/S4 ,IF \R FRI5DS WILL ONLY WEAN !MSELVES FROM ! OLD DELUSION ( CONF\ND+ ! C>T ) ! HORSE1 !Y WILL !N EASILY SEE ?AT ! FRI5DS ( ,LIB]TY >E ! ONLY REAL CON/RUCTIONI/S4 ,WE HOPE WE HAVE MADE \R PO9T PLA94 

,9 CONSEQU5CE ( A DEM& ?AT HAS >IS5 = PICTURES ( ,LAURA ,K5DRICK1 H] FRI5DS CONTEMPLATE ! PRODUCTION ( A F9E PHOTO-LI?OGRAPH ( H] FEATURES4 ,! PROJECT WILL BE C>RI$ \T1 IF IT RECEIVES SUFFICI5T 5C\RAGEM5T4 ,SU* P]SONS AS W\LD1 9 ?AT CASE ORD] ONE OR MORE COPIES AT TW5TY-FIVE C5TS EA* WILL CONF] A FAVOR BY S5D+ !IR NAMES & ADDRESSES )\T DELAY TO ,LIB]TY = TRANSMISSION TO ?OSE HAV+ ! MATT] 9 *>GE1 9 ORD] ?AT ! LATT] MAY KN[ :E!R OR NOT TO PROCE$ ) ! WORK PROPOS$4 

,A ,H]O9E ( ! ,COMMUNE4 

,TODAY IS ! ,EI<TE5? ( ,M>*1 ! ANNIV]S>Y ( ! ,P>IS ,COMMUNE1 A GLORI\S DATE 9 ! CAL5D> ( ,LIB]TY4 ,IT IS ! DAY WE CELEBRATE4 ,BUT ?IS YE> IT IS ,=TUNE'S WILL ?AT WE %\LD CELEBRATE IT AT ! GRAVE :I!R ONE ( ! ,COMMUNE'S MANY H]O9ES HAS LATELY GONE4 ,M>IE ,F]RE1 SI/] ( ! BRAVE ,!OPHILE ,F]RE :O WAS %OT AT ,SATORY BY ! 9FAM\S ,?I]S1 WAS BURI$ AT ,P>IS 9 ! CEMET]Y ( ,LEVALLOIS-,P]RET ON ,FEBRU>Y #b#g4 ,FROM V>I\S ,P>IS PAP]S WE GLEAN ! FOLL[+ FACTS CONC]N+ ! SAD EV5T3 

,M>IE ,F]RE SUCCUMB$ TO A DISEASE ( ! HE>T COMPLICAT$ ) RHEUMATISM4 ,%E DI$ AT ! H\SE ( A FRI5D1 ,MME4 ,CAMILLE ,BIAS1 ,NO4 #bg ,RUE ,C5DORCET4 ,FROM ?IS H\SE AT N9E O'CLOCK 9 ! MORN+ ! PROCESSION />T$4 ,A CIVIL BURIAL1 IT IS NE$LESS TO SAY4 ,V]Y SIMPLE OBSEQUIES4 ,! HE>SE1 ONE ( ! MO/ MODE/1 BORE ?REE L>GE CR[NS ( R$ & :ITE ROSES1 TO SAY NO?+ ( IMMORTELLES4 ,FOLL[+ ! HE>SE1 TO ! NUMB] ( AB\T FIFTE5 HUNDR$1 W]E ! PR9CIPAL SURVIVORS ( ! ,COMMUNE3 ,H5RI ,RO*E=T1 ,CLOVIS ,HUGUES1 ,G5]AL ,EUDES1 ,ALPHONSE ,HUMB]T1 ,L\ISE ,MI*EL1 ,EMILE ,GAUTI]1 & MANY O!RS4 ,IT WAS A LONG WAY TO ! CEMET]Y1 :]E ! DECEAS$ WAS TO BE BURI$ BESIDE H] BRO!R1 & IT TOOK AN H\R & A QU>T] TO MAKE ! J\RNEY1 :I* WAS EFFECT$ 9 ! MO/ TRANQUIL MANN]4 ,AT ! HEAD ( ! PROCESSION WALK$ ?REE CITIZ5S C>RY+ L>GE CR[NS ( R$ IMMORTELLES4 ,AT ! GRAVE !RE W]E SEV]AL ADDRESSES1 AMONG :I* WAS ONE BY ,L\ISE ,MI*EL1 :O SAID3 

0,CITIZ5S1 SOON ?IS OP5 TOMB WILL CLOSE =EV] ON ! DE>E/ POSSESSION ( ! DEMOCRATIC & SOCIAL REVOLUTION4 ,M>IE ,F]RE1 :OM WE ALL ADMIR$1 MANIFE/$ ALL ! VIRTUES ( WOMAN1 ALL ! 5]GY ( MAN1 :5EV] !RE WAS OCCASION TO /RUGGLE = ! 5D :I* WE ALL PURSUE4 ,H] MEMORY WILL LIVE ALWAYS 9 ! HE>TS ( ?OSE :O KNEW H]4 ,9 H] :OSE BODY IS N[ TO JO9 ! BODY ( H] ASSASS9AT$ BRO!R WE BEHOLD ANO!R CONQU]$ VICTIM1 & WE %ALL NOT =GET IT4 ,BUT1 ?\< DEAD1 %E WILL EV] LIVE1 = %E WILL S]VE AS MODEL & EXEMPL> = ! WOM5 ( ! REVOLUTION4 ,%E WILL RECALL TO ALL ! TASK :I* IT REMA9S = US TO F9I%1 ! LEVEL+ ( ALL SOCIAL 9IQUITIES BY JU/ICE & EQUALITY4 ,M>IE ,F]RE1 ADIEU1 & SUCCESS TO ! REVOLUTION60 

,H5RI ,RO*E=T P5N$ ! FOLL[+ T\*+ TRIBUTE TO ?IS NOBLE WOMAN'S MEMORY 9 ! COLUMNS ( 0,L',9TRANSIGEANT10 UND] ! HEAD1 ,LA ,SOEUR DU ,FUSILLE 7,! ,SI/] ( ! ,%OT73 

,%E IS CALL$1 OR RA!R1 S9CE !Y BURY H] ?IS MORN+ %E WAS CALL$ ,M>IE ,F]RE4 ,SE>* ! VOLUMES ( ,%AKSP]E1 RE-READ ,VICTOR ,HUGO1 TRAV]SE ! RANGE ( BLOODY TRAG$IES FROM ,CORNEILLE TO ,A,ES*YLUS1 WE DEFY Y\ TO F9D ANY?+ AS D>K AS ! /ORY ( ?IS POOR FL[]-GIRL1 :O DI$ YE/]DAY ALMO/ UNEXPECT$LY1 WE MI<T SAY 9 ! ODOR ( SANCTITY3 HAD ?AT PHRASE NOT BE5 DAMAG$ 9 ! JUGGL]IES ( ! ,CA?OLIC ,*UR*4 

,9 ,MAY1 #a#h#g#a1 ,M>IE ,F]RE LAY SICK ( TYPHOID FEV] 9 A SMALL ROOM ON ! ,RUE ,FRASILLEAU1 :]E %E LIV$ ) H] MO!R & BRO!R4 ,A POLICE COMMISSION]1 FOLL[$ BY POLICE AG5TS & SOLDI]S1 BUR/ 9TO H] ROOM3 

0,:]E IS ,!OPHILE ,F]RE1 MEMB] ( ! ,COMMUNE80 

0,I DO NOT KN[40 

0,P]HAPS Y\R MO!R WILL KN[40 

,!Y SPR+ UPON ,MME4 ,F]RE1 ! MO!R1 & W>N H]1 ) ?AT DELICACY :I* *>ACT]IZ$ ! ,V]SAILLI/S 9 ALL !IR EXPLOITS1 ?AT %E MU/ MAKE KN[N ! RETREAT ( H] SON OR BE IMM$IATELY %OT4 

,M>IE ,F]RE SPRANG FROM H] B$1 & BEGG$ TO BE EXECUT$ 9/EAD ( H] MO!R4 

0,IT IS VEIL2 DRESS Y\RSELF1 = WE >E GO+ TO TAKE Y\ AWAY10 SAID ! *IEF ( ! SQUAD4 

,AT SEE+ H] DAU<T] %IV]+ ) FEV] :ILE DONN+ H] G>B ( DEA?1 ,MME4 ,F]RE C\LD HOLD \T NO LONG]2 H] BRA9 GAVE WAY4 ,( H] TWO SONS ONE1 ! Y\NG]1 WAS ALREADY A PRISON] 9 ! H&S ( ! V]SAILLI/S2 ! O!R PROBABLY C\LD NOT LONG ELUDE !M4 ,TO TOP ALL1 !Y W]E AB\T TO SLAY ! SI/] UND] H] V]Y EYES4 ,! UNHAPPY WOMAN FELL S5SELESS1 & ( ! 9COH]5T WORDS ?AT PASS$ H] LIPS ! POLICE C>EFULLY RETA9$ ?IS ADDRESS3 ,RUE ,SA9T-,SAUVEUR4 

,?I!R !Y RAN1 RANSACK$ ! /REET UNTIL !Y F\ND ,!OPHILE ,F]RE1 &1 BE+ UNABLE TO TAKE ! MO!R1 :O WAS /RUCK ) A SORT ( CONGE/ION1 DRAGG$ (F H] DAU<T] ,M>IE1 :O SP5T A WEEK 9 A FETID PRISON AMID ! PRISON]S HUDDL$ !RE BY HUNDR$S4 

,ON RE/OR+ H] H] LIB]TY ! TURNKEYS TOLD H] ?AT H] FA!R & H] TWO BRO!RS HAD BE5 >RE/$1 & ?AT H] MO!R1 :OM ! LA/ %OCK HAD DRIV5 MAD1 HAD BE5 REMOV$ TO ! ,SA9T-,ANNE ASYLUM1 :]E1 = ! RE/1 %E DI$ %ORTLY AFT]4 ,M]LE ALONE REMA9$1 ) H] C\RAGE & H] 9DU/RY1 TO SUPPLY H] RELATIVES ) ! FOOD ?AT ! JAIL]S REFUS$ !M1 = 9 ! PRISONS ( ,V]SAILLES )\T MONEY !RE WAS NO EAT+1 & ,I HAVE P]SONALLY HAD ! PLEASURE ( SAV+ FROM DEA? BY />VATION TWO OR ?REE FELL[-PRISON]S1 ) :OM ,I %>$ ! MEALS1 MU* TOO ABUNDANT = MYSELF1 :I* W]E BR\<T TO ME FROM )\T4 

,BUT AFT] ! WEEK ( ,MAY & ! /ORIES :I* ! V5OM\S NEWSPAP]S HAD FABRICAT$ CONC]N+ ! M5 ( ! ,COMMUNE1 AT :AT DOOR C\LD ONE KNOCK TO OBTA9 WORK :O BORE ! NAME ( ,F]RE8 ,MOREOV]1 AT :AT H\R ( ! DAY C\LD WE ORPHAN LABOR1 :5 %E CONT9UALLY HAD TO BE ON ! ROAD FROM ,LEVALLOIS TO ,V]SAILLES 9 ORD] TO TRY TO SEE H] BRO!RS1 TO :OM %E BR\<T ! MEAG] EXTRAS ?AT CON/ITUT$ ! MAJOR PORTION ( !IR DAILY F>E8 

,! NI<T FOLL[+ ,F]RE'S DEA? S5T5CE ,I WAS AWAK5$ BY PI]C+ CRIES & A NOISE ( BROK5 FURNITURE4 ,AT FIR/ ,I ?\<T SOME PRISON] HAD COMMITT$ SUICIDE4 ,IT WAS ! BRO!R ( ! CONDEMN$1 :O1 OCCUPY+ ! CELL ABOVE M9E1 HAD BE5 PLUNG$ BY ! NEWS ( ! FATE 9 /ORE = HIS ELD] BRO!R 9TO A SORT ( N]V\S ATTACK COMPLICAT$ ) WILD DELIRIUM4 

,!Y CALL$ ,F]RE1 :O SLEPT /OICALLY1 & = SOME H\RS ! K9DNESS ( ! DIRECTOR ALL[$ TO REMA9 TOGE!R 9 ONE CELL !SE TWO MEMB]S ( ! SAME FAMILY1 ( :OM ONE HAD LO/ HIS HEAD & ! O!R WAS AB\T TO LOSE HIS LIFE4 ,IT WAS ! LATT] :O CONSOL$ & SUCCE$$ 9 CALM+ ! =M]4 ,ONLY MY GU>D1 A MAN :O1 ?\< V]Y ?OR\<LY H>D5$ TO HUMAN SUFF]+1 HAD1 ! PR(\NDE/ RESPECT = ! ADMIRABLE BRAV]Y ( ! CONDEMN$ MAN ( ! ,COMMUNE1 TOLD ME ?AT ON RE5T]+ HIS CELL ,F]RE1 :O HAD CONTA9$ HIMSELF FROM FE> ( ADD+ FUEL TO HIS BRO!R'S EXCITEM5T1 SEAT$ HIMSELF ON HIS B5* &1 PLAC+ HIS TWO ELB[S ON ! OAK5 TABLE FA/5$ TO ! WALL1 BUR/ 9TO TE>S4 

,M>IE1 :O REFRA9$ FROM SLEEP 9 ORD] TO PROCURE = H] RELATIVES A FEW ( ! EXTRAS SO NECESS>Y TO !M1 LE>N$1 ON >RIV+ AT ! PRISON1 ?AT ! ELD] ( H] TWO BRO!RS HAD BE5 CONDEMN$ TO DEA? & ?AT ! Y\NG] HAD JU/ BE5 SEIZ$ ) A FIT ( BURN+ FEV]4 ,AS = H] FA!R1 !RE WAS NO?+ AGA9/ HIM4 ,CONSEQU5TLY !Y DID NOT RELEASE HIM4 ,!Y KEPT ON WAIT+ = SOME?+ TO TURN UP4 

,M>IE ,F]RE'S TORTURE LA/$ FIVE MON?S4 ,:5 ,I LATELY SAW H] AGA9 ON MY RETURN FROM EXILE1 ,I /ILL RETA9$ ALL 9DELIBLE REMEMBRANCE ( ! Y\NG GIRL :I* H] UNEXPECT$ DEA? HAS JU/ REVIV$4 ,I /ILL SEE H] GLID+ LIKE A %AD[1 9 H] BLACK G>M5TS1 ALONG ! CORRIDOR :I* L$ TO ! P>LOR4 ,?REE ( US1 ,ROSSEL1 ,F]RE1 & MYSELF1 G5]ALLY MET 9 !SE BOX-LIKE 5CLOSURES :I* CON/ITUTE AN 5TIRE ROOM1 A SORT ( CELLUL> OMNIBUS4 ,BE+ ALL ?REE M>K$ = DEA?1 WE HAD BE5 PLAC$ SIDE BY SIDE ON ! GR\ND FLOOR ( ! PRISON1 ) TWO OV]SE]S1 :O1 ?R\< \R OP5 GRATES1 KEPT !IR RE/LESS EYES /EADILY UPON US4 

,9 ! P>LOR ,MLLE4 ,ROSSEL1 ,MLLE4 ,F]RE1 & MY *ILDR5 GA!R$ ) A COMMON FEEL+ ( ANXIETY4 ,I %ALL NEV] =GET1 :5 !Y LE>N$ ?AT ,I WAS S5T5C$ ONLY TO P]PETUAL EXILE 9 A =TIFI$ DI/RICT1 ! LOOK ( SYMPA!TIC 5VY :I* ! TWO Y\NG GIRLS \T UPON MY DAU<T]S1 SEEM+ TO SAY3 

0,Y\R FA!R IS SIMPLY DE/9$ TO 5D HIS DAYS SIX ?\S& FIVE HUNDR$ LEAGUES AWAY AMONG CANNIBALS2 >E Y\ NOT HAPPY 5\<80 

,! SI/] ( ,F]RE1 LIKE ! SI/] ( ,DELESCLUZE1 /RUGGL$ BRAVELY AGA9/ ! BITT]NESS ( H] SORR[S1 & !N FELL CONQU]$4 ,! DAY :5 ! CL]ICAL CAL5D>1 :I* ! PO/MAN BR+S US EV]Y YE>1 %ALL BE REPLAC$ BY ! REPUBLICAN CAL5D>1 ! NAME ( ?IS M>TYR WILL %9E AMONG ! MO/ MEMORABLE2 & IF EV] CIVIL BAPTISM SUCCE$S RELIGI\S BAPTISM1 HONE/ WOM5 WILL PLACE !IR 9FANTS UND] ! %IELD ( H] MEMORY & H] VIRTUE4 

,! ,&RE ,MONUM5T4 

,! FOLL[+ RESOLUTIONS W]E PASS$ AT A REC5T MEET+ ( ! ,J]SEY ,CITY GR\P ( ! ,9T]NATIONAL ,WORK+ ,PEOPLE'S ,ASSOCIATION3 

,WE RESOLVE ?AT WE PROTECT AGA9/ ! ILLEGAL >RE/ & IMPRISONM5T ( CITIZ5 ,H5DRIX ON A *>GE ( DEF9+ A MONUM5T ]ECT$ BY TRAITOR ,FIELD 9 MEMORY ( SPY ,&RE4 

,WE FUR!R RESOLVE ?AT IT IS A BL[ AIM$ AT ! RI<TS ( FREEM5 MORE DEADLY ?AN ! CANNON BALLS ( ,GEORGE ! ,?IRD4 

,WE FUR!R RESOLVE ?AT ?IS DA/>DLY \TRAGE 9 >RE/+ CITIZ5 ,H5DRIX ON SU* *>GE IS AN 9SULT TO ! ,REBELS ( #aggf & TO ! FREEM5 ( TO-DAY4 

,WE FUR!R RESOLVE1 9 ! NAME ( ,JU/ICE & ,SOLID>ITY1 TO GIVE \R MORAL & MAT]IAL SUPPORT TO CITIZ5 ,H5DRIX OR ANY O!R P]SON :OMSOEV] :O MAY BE IMBU$ ) SU* A SPIRIT ( PATRIOTISM4 

,*UR* & ,/ATE4 

,LIB]ALS COMPLA9 ( ! OPPRESSIONS ( ! *UR*2 !Y SAY1 & TRULY1 ?AT ! *UR* IS ! FAVORITE OR ! ,/ATE4 ,BUT !Y =GET ?AT1 W]E IT NOT = ! ,/ATE1 ! *UR* W\LD BE P[]LESS = EVIL 9 ?IS DIRECTION4 ,BEH9D ! EXEMPTION ( *UR* PROP]TY1 ! ,SUNDAY LAWS1 ,BIBLE 9 ! S*OOLS1 ETC4 /&S ! ,/ATE1 5=C+ BY ! P[] ( EV]Y BAYONET !SE UNJU/ DISCRIM9ATION4 ,! ,/ATE HAS EV] BE5 ! EXECUTIVE >M ( ! *UR*4 ,H]JUDGES1 H] %]IFFS1 H] JAIL]S HAVE S5T5C$1 HAVE HUNG1 RACK$1 BURN$1 EXIL$1 & IMPRISON$ ! S5T5C$ H]ETICS 9 ALL AGES4 ,TO-DAY %E =CES UPON US ! MORALITY ( ! *UR*1 & \R REFUSAL TO CON=M TO ! /&>D ECCLESIA/IC IS TANTAM\NT TO REBELLION AGA9/ ! ,/ATE4 ,! LATT] P[] /&S PL$G$ TO COMPEL US TO SPEAK & ACT 9 *UR* *ANNELS4 ,LET US OP5 \R EYES & TAKE A SQU>E LOOK AT ! WORK BE=E US4 

-- ,WALK]4 

,LEGISLATION3 ,ITS ,ORIG9 & ,PURPOSE4 

.<,FROM ,LYS&] ,SPOON]'S 0,NATURAL ,LAW40.> 

,?R\< ALL HI/ORIC TIMES1 :]EV] ANY PEOPLE HAVE ADVANC$ BEYOND ! SAVAGE /ATE & HAVE LE>N$ TO 9CREASE !IR MEANS ( SUBSI/5CE BY ! CULTIVATION ( ! SOIL1 A GREAT] OR LESS NUMB] ( !M HAVE ASSOCIAT$ & ORGANIZ$ !MSELVES AS ROBB]S TO PLUND] & 5?RALL$ ALL O!RS :O HAD EI!R ACCUMULAT$ ANY PROP]TY ?AT C\LD BE SEIZ$1 OR HAD %[N BY !IR LABOR ?AT !Y C\LD BE MADE TO CONTRIBUTE TO ! SUPPORT OR PLEASURE ( ?OSE :O %\LD 5?RALL$ !M4 

,!SE B&S ( ROBB]S1 SMALL 9 NUMB] AT FIR/1 HAVE 9CREAS$ !IR P[] BY UNIT+ ) EA* O!R1 9V5T+ W>LIKE WEAPONS1 DISCIPL9+ !MSELVES1 & P]FECT+ !IR ORGANIZATIONS AS MILIT>Y =CES1 & DIVID+ !IR PLUND] 79CLUD+ !IR CAPTIVES7 AMONG !MSELVES1 EI!R 9 SU* PROPORTIONS AS HAVE BE5 PREVI\SLY AGRE$ ON1 OR 9 SU* IT !IR LEAD]S 7ALWAYS DESIR\S TO 9CREASE ! NUMB] ( !IR FOLL[]S7 %\LD PRESCRIBE4 

,! SUCCESS ( !SE B&S ( ROBB]S WAS AN EASY ?+1 = ! REASON ?AT ?OSE :OM !Y PLUND]$ & 5SLAV$ W]E COMP>ATIVELY DEF5SELESS2 BE+ SCATT]$ ?9LY OV] ! C\NTRY2 5GAG$ :OLLY 9 TRY+1 BY RUDE IMPLEM5TS & HEAVY LABOR1 TO EXTORT A SUBSI/5CE FROM ! SOIL2 HAV+ NO WEAPONS ( W>1 O!R ?AN /ICKS & /ONES2 HAV+ NO MILIT>Y DISCIPL9E OR ORGANIZATION1 & NO MEANS ( CONC5TRAT+ !IR =CES1 OR ACT+ 9 CONC]T1 :5 SUDD5LY ATTACK$4 ,UND] !SE CIRCUM/ANCES ! ONLY ALT]NATIVE LEFT !M = SAV+ EV5 !IR LIVES1 OR ! LIVES ( !IR FAMILIES1 WAS TO YIELD UP NOT ONLY ! CROPS !Y HAD GA!R$ & ! L&S !Y HAD CULTIVAT$1 BUT !MSELVES & !IR FAMILIES ALSO AS SLAVES4 

,!NCE=? !IR FATE WAS1 AS SLAVES1 TO CULTIVATE = O!RS ! L&S !Y HAD BE=E CULTIVAT$ = !MSELVES4 ,BE+ DRIV5 CON/ANTLY TO !IR LABOR1 WEAL? SL[LY 9CREAS$2 BUT ALL W5T 9TO ! H&S ( !IR TYRANTS4 

,!SE TYRANTS1 LIV+ SOLELY ON PLUND] & ON ! LABOR ( !IR SLAVES1 & APPLY+ ALL !IR 5]GIES TO ! SEIZURE ( /ILL MORE PLUND] & ! 5SLAVEM5T ( /ILL O!R DEF5SELESS P]SONS2 9CREAS+1 TOO1 !IR NUMB]S1 P]FECT+ !IR ORGANIZATIONS1 & MULTIPLY+ !IR WEAPONS ( W>1 !Y EXT5D !IR CONQUE/S UNTIL1 9 ORD] TO HOLD :AT !Y HAVE ALREADY GOT1 IT BECOMES NECESS>Y = !M TO ACT SY/EMATICALLY1 & CO-OP]ATE ) EA* O!R 9 HOLD+ !IR SLAVES 9 SUBJECTION4 

,BUT ALL ?IS !Y CAN DO ONLY BY E/ABLI%+ :AT !Y CALL A GOV]NM5T1 & MAK+ :AT !Y CALL LAWS4 

,ALL ! GREAT GOV]NM5TS ( ! WORLD -- ?OSE N[ EXI/+ AS WELL AS ?OSE ?AT HAVE PASS$ AWAY -- HAVE BE5 ( ?IS *>ACT]4 ,!Y HAVE BE5 M]E B&S ( ROBB]S1 :O HAVE ASSOCIAT$ = PURPOSES ( PLUND]1 CONQUE/1 & ! 5SLAVEM5T ( !IR FELL[ M54 ,& !IR LAWS1 AS !Y HAVE CALL$ !M1 HAVE BE5 ONLY SU* AGREEM5TS AS !Y HAVE F\ND IT NECESS>Y TO 5T] 9TO 9 ORD] TO MA9TA9 !IR ORGANIZATIONS & ACT TOGE!R 9 PLUND]+ & 5SLAV+ O!RS & 9 SECUR+ TO EA* HIS AGRE$ %>E ( ! SPOILS4 

,ALL !SE LAWS HAVE HAD NO MORE REAL OBLIGATION ?AN HAVE ! AGREEM5TS :I* BRIG&S1 B&ITS1 & PIRATES F9D IT NECESS>Y TO 5T] 9TO ) EA* O!R = ! MORE SUCCESSFUL ACCOMPLI%M5T ( !IR CRIMES & ! MORE PEACEABLE DIVISION ( !IR SPOILS4 

,?US SUB/ANTIALLY ALL ! LEGISLATION ( ! WORLD HAS HAD ITS ORIG9 9 ! DESIRES ( ONE CLASS ( P]SONS TO PLUND] & 5?RALL$ O!RS1 & HOLD !M AS PROP]TY4 

,9 PROCESS ( TIME1 ! ROBB]1 OR SLAVE-HOLD+1 CLASS -- :O HAD SEIZ$ ALL ! L&S & HELD ALL ! MEANS ( CREAT+ WEAL? -- BEGAN TO DISCOV] ?AT ! EASIE/ MODE ( MANAG+ !IR SLAVES & MAK+ !M PR(ITABLE WAS NOT = EA* SLAVEHOLD] TO HOLD HIS SPECIFI$ NUMB] ( SLAVES1 AS HE HAD DONE BE=E1 & AS HE W\LD HOLD SO MANY CATTLE1 BUT TO GIVE !M SO MU* LIB]TY AS W\LD ?R[ UPON !MSELVES 7! SLAVES7 ! RESPONSIBILITY ( !IR [N SUBSI/5CE1 & YET COMPEL !M TO SELL !IR LABOR TO ! L&HOLD+ CLOSE -- !IR =M] [N]S -- = JU/ :AT ! LATT]-MI<T *OOSE TO GIVE !M4 

,( C\RSE1 !SE LIB]AT$ SLAVES1 AS SOME HAVE ]RONE\SLY CALL$ !M1 HAV+ NO L&S OR O!R PROP]TY & NO MEANS ( OBTA9+ AN 9DEP5D5T SUBSI/5CE1 HAD NO ALT]NATIVE -- TO SAVE !MSELVES FROM />VATION -- BUT TO SELL !IR LABOR TO ! L&HOLD]S 9 EX*ANGE ONLY = ! CO>SE/ NECESS>IES ( LIFE2 NOT ALWAYS = SO MU* EV5 AS ?AT4 

,!SE LIB]AT$ SLAVES1 AS !Y W]E CALL$1 W]E N[ SC>CELY LESS SLAVES ?AN !Y W]E BE=E4 ,!IR MEANS ( SUBSI/5CE W]E P]HAPS EV5 MORE PREC>I\S ?AN :5 EA* HAD HIS [N [N]1 :O HAD AN 9T]E/ TO PRES]VE HIS LIFE4 ,!Y W]E LIABLE1 AT ! CAPRICE OR 9T]E/ ( ! L&-HOLD]S1 TO BE ?R[N \T ( HOME1 EMPLOYM5T1 & ! OPPORTUNITY ( EV5 E>N+ A SUBSI/5CE BY !IR LABOR4 ,!Y W]E1 !RE=E1 9 L>GE NUMB]S1 DRIV5 TO ! NECESSITY ( BEGG+1 /EAL+1 OR />V+1 & BECAME1 ( C\RSE1 DANG]\S TO ! PROP]TY & QUITE ( !IR MA/]S4 

,! CONSEQU5CE WAS ?AT !SE LATE [N]S F\ND IT NECESS>Y1 = !IR [N SAFETY & ! SAFETY ( !IR PROP]TY1 TO ORGANIZE !MSELVES MORE P]FECTLY1 AS A GOV]NM5T & MAKE LAWS KEEP+ !SE DANG]\S PEOPLE 9 SUBJECTION2 ?AT IS1 LAWS FIX+ ! PRICES AT-:I* !Y %\LD BE1 COMPELL$ TO LABOR1 & ALSO PRESCRIB+ FE>FUL PUNI%M5TS1 EV5 DEA? ITSELF1 = SU* !FTS & TRESPASSES AS !Y W]E DRIV5 TO COMMIT AS !IR ONLY MEANS ( SAV+ !MSELVES FROM />VATION4 

,!SE LAWS HAVE CONT9U$ 9 =CE = HUNDR$S1 &1 9 SOME C\NTRIES1 = ?\S&S ( YE>S2 & >E 9 =CE TO-DAY1 9 GREAT] OR WAS SEV]ITY1 9 NE>LY ALL ! C\NTRIES ON ! GLOBE4 

,! PURPOSE & EFFECT ( !SE LAWS HAVE BE5 TO MA9TA91 9 ! H&S ( ! ROBB]1 OR SLAVE-HOLD+ CLASS1 A MONOPOLY ( ALL L&S &1 AS F> AS POSSIBLE1 ( ALL O!R MEANS ( CREAT+ WEAL?2 & ?US TO KEEP ! GREAT BODY ( LABOR]S 9 SU* A /ATE ( POV]TY & DEP5D5CE AS W\LD COMPEL !M TO SELL !IR LABOR TO !IR TYRANTS = ! L[E/ PRICES AT :I* LIFE C\LD BE SU/A9$4 

,! RESULT ( ALL ?IS IS ?AT ! LITTLE WEAL? !RE IS 9 ! WORLD IS ALL 9 ! H&S ( A FEW1-- ?AT IS1 9 ! H&S ( ! LAW-MAK+1 SLAVE-HOLD+ CLASS1 :O >E N[ AS MU* SLAVE-HOLD]S 9 SPIRIT AS !Y EV] W]E1 BUT :O ACCOMPLI% !IR PURPOSES BY MEANS ( ! LAWS !Y MAKE = KEEP+ ! LABOR]S 9 SUBJECTION & DEP5D5CE1 9/EAD ( EA* ONE'S [N+ HIS 9DIVIDUAL SLAVES AS SO MANY *ATTELS4 

,?US ! :OLE BUS9ESS ( LEGISLATION1 :I* HAS N[ GR[N TO SU* GIGANTIC PROPORTIONS1 HAD ITS ORIG9 9 ! CONSPIRACIES :I* HAVE ALWAYS EXI/$ AMONG ! FEW = ! PURPOSE ( HOLD+ ! MANY 9 SUBJECTION & EXTORT+ FROM !M !IR LABOR & ALL ! PR(ITS ( !IR LABOR4 

,& ! REAL MOTIVES & SPIRIT :I* LIE AT ! F\NDATION ( ALL LEGISLATION -- NOT)/&+ ALL ! PRET5SES & DISGUISES BY :I* !Y ATTEMPT TO HIDE !MSELVES -- >E ! SAME TO-DAY AS !Y ALWAYS HAVE BE54 ,! :OLE PURPOSE ( ?IS LEGISLATION IS SIMPLY TO KEEP ONE CLASS ( M5 9 SUBORD9ATION & S]VITUDE TO ANO!R4 

,:AT1 !N1 IS LEGISLATION8 ,IT IS AN ASSUMPTION BY ONE MAN1 OR BODY ( M51 ( ABSOLUTE1 IRRESPONSIBLE DOM9ION OV] ALL O!R M5 :OM !Y CAN SUBJECT TO !IR P[]4 ,IT IS ! ASSUMPTION BY ONE MAN1 OR BODY ( M51 ( A RI<T TO SUBJECT ALL O!R M5 TO !IR WILL & !IR S]VICE4 ,IT IS ! ASSUMPTION BY ONE MAN1 OR BODY ( M51 ( A RI<T TO ABOLI% \TRI<T ALL ! NATURAL RI<TS1 ALL ! NATURAL LIB]TY ( ALL O!R M52 TO MAKE ALL O!R M5 !IR SLAVES2 TO >BITR>ILY DICTATE TO ALL O!R M5 :AT !Y MAY & MAY NOT DO1 :AT !Y MAY & MAY NOT HAVE1 :AT !Y MAY & MAY NOT BE4 ,IT IS1 9 %ORT1 ! ASSUMPTION ( A RI<T TO BANI% ! PR9CIPLE ( HUMAN RI<TS1 ! PR9CIPLE ( JU/ICE ITSELF1 FROM (F ! E>?1 & SET UP !IR [N P]SONAL WILL1 PLEASURE1 & 9T]E/ 9 ITS PLACE4 ,ALL ?IS1 & NO?+ LESS1 IS 9VOLV$ 9 ! V]Y IDEA ?AT !RE CAN BE ANY SU* ?+ AS HUMAN LEGISLATION ?AT IS OBLIGATORY UPON ?OSE UPON :OM IT IS IMPOS$4 

,ANO!R ,+]SOLL 9 ! ,FIELD4 

,! ,TALMAGE-,+]SOLL CONTROV]SY HAS CALL$ \T ! FOLL[+ LETT] FROM ! COLONEL'S BRO!R 9 DEF5SE ( HIS FA!R & ! COLONEL HIMSELF3 

,REV4 ,T4 ,D4 ,TALMAGE1 ,D4,D4 

,SIR3 -- ,I HAVE BE=E ME A COPY ( ! ,C9C9NATI 0,5QUIR]0 CONTA9+ ! REPORT ( A S]MON DELIV]$ BY Y\ ON ! #e? 9/ANT1 UPON ! 0,MEANNESS ( ,9FIDELITY40 ,9 ! C\RSE ( Y\R REM>KS Y\ SAY ?AT Y\ HAD JU/ RECEIV$ A LETT] FROM SOME ONE 9=M+ Y\ ?AT ! ,REV4 ,JOHN ,+]SOLL1 FA!R ( ,R4 ,G4 ,+]SOLL & MYSELF1 0WAS AB/EMI\S TO A FAULT1 & ! FAMILY SUFF]$ ACCORD+LY4 ,! *ILDR5 W]E COMM&$ TO EAT1 DR9K1 & DRESS SP>+LY4 ,HE NEV] SPOK5 K9D WORD ( HIS WIFE1 :O WAS A NOBLE ,*RI/IAN WOMAN1 NOR ( HIS *ILDR51 )9 ! KN[L$GE ( P]SONS N[ LIV+ H]E1 :O W]E FAMILI> ) ! FAMILY4 ,AT LA/ ! MO!R DI$4 ,%E WAS C>$ = BY FRI5DS 9 H] SICKNESS1 & ON ! DAY ( H] 9T]M5T G5TLE H&S C>RI$ H] =M1 & RE/$ IT = A TIME ON ! CATAFALQUE4 ,MR4 ,+]SOLL1 TO ! A/ONI%M5T ( ALL PRES5T1 DELIB]ATELY REMOV$ HIS CRAVAT & GLOVES1 /EPP$ ON ! RO/RUM1 & DELIV]$ A EULOGY OV] ! BODY4 ,HE ATTEMPT$ TO EXTOLL H] VIRTUES & PANEGYRIZE H] CONDUCT4 ,IT WAS ! FIR/ TIME HE HAD EV] BE5 KN[N TO SPEAK WELL ( H] 9 PUBLIC40 

,N[1 REV]5D SIR1 0WILL Y\ BE K9D 5\< TO TELL Y\R 9=MANT1 = ME1 ?AT HE OR %E IS A MALIGNANTLY CRUEL1 HE>TLESS1 & 9FAM\S LI>8 ,\R FA!R WAS POOR2 ,I WILL NOT D5Y IT4 ,9 !1 DAYS ( MY *ILDHOOD A M9I/] WAS =C$ TO PRACTICE /RICT ECONOMY TO SUPPORT A FAMILY & $UCATE HIS *ILDR5 UPON A SAL>Y ( @s#e A YE>4 ,WE HAD ABUNDANCE TO EAT & W]E WELL CLO!D1 & C]TA9LY NO MAN EV] BETT] 5JOY$ M9I/]+ TO ! WANTS ( HIS FAMILY ?AN DID \R LOV$ & HONOR$ FA!R4 ,I BELIEVE HIM TO HAVE BE5 AN EM95TLY GOOD & CONSCI5TI\S MAN -- ,I DO NOT SAY FAULTLESS4 ,AS = ,ROB]T1 ,I WILL SAY HE WAS AS GOOD & OB$I5T A BOY AS ,I EV] KNEW1 BUT ALL ?IS IS NEI!R H]E NOR !RE4 ,HE D5IES ?AT ! ,BIBLE IS ! 9SPIR$ WORD ( ,GOD1 & GIVES HIS REASONS4 ,H]E Y\ TAKE ISSUE ) HIM4 ,N[1 IS IT NOT POSSIBLE TO SUCCESSFULLY COMBAT HIS ]RORS )\T OP5+ ! TOMB & SPATT]+ ) CALUMNY \R LOV$ & HONOR$ DEAD8 ,SPEAK+ ( Y\R FA!R & MO!R Y\ SAY3 0,W\LD IT NOT HAVE BE5 DEBAS+ 9 ME TO HOOK ! HORSES TO ! PL[%>E ( CONTEMPT TO TURN UP ! MOLD ( !IR GRAVES80 ,TRUE4 ,N[ LET ME ASK Y\ IF Y\ DON'T ?9K ?AT ! ,GOLD5 ,RULE REQUIRES Y\ TO UNHOOK Y\R HORSES BE=E Y\ RU?LESSLY TURN UP ! SACR$ DU/ ?AT HIDES FROM ! LI<T ( DAY \R FA!R'S SN[-:ITE HAIR4 ,BUT 0,+]SOL ASSAILS ! BELIEF ( ! FA!R40 ,WELL1 SIR1 HAD Y\R FA!R BE5 AN 9FIDEL1 W\LD Y\ KN[1 5T]TA9+ ! VIEWS Y\ DO1 COMBAT HIS OP9IONS8 ,?AT W\LD PROBABLY BE A V]Y DIFF]5T ?+4 ,+]SOLL SAYS HE CAN NOT BELIEVE ?AT ,GOD1 ! FA!R ( US ALL1 EV] COMM&$ ! ,JEWS TO WAGE W>S ( EXT]M9ATION AGA9/ !IR NEI<BORS1 & WAS DELI<T$ AT ! SI<T ( A BABE'S BLOOD TRICKL+ D[N ! H&LE ( A ,JEWI% SPE>4 ,MOSES SAID :5 A WOMAN GAVE BIR? TO A SON ?IRTY-?REE DAYS W]E NECESS>Y TO PURIFY H]1 BUT1 IF %E GAVE BIR? TO A DAU<T]1 SIXTY-SIX DAYS W]E NECESS>Y4 ,+]SOLL SAYS ?AT LOOKS TO HIM LIKE NONS5SE1 & HE REALLY CAN NOT BELIEVE ?AT ,GOD EV] ORD]$ ANY SU* ?+4 ,HE SAYS HE CANNOT BELIEVE ?AT ,GOD1 :O W9K$ AT POLYGAMY & E/ABLI%$ SLAV]Y1 EV] ORD]$ A MAN TO BE P\ND$ TO DEA? ) /ONES SIMPLY = PICK+ UP /ICKS ON ! ,SABBA? DAY4 ,HE SAYS HE CAN NOT BELIEVE ?AT ,GOD EV] GAVE EXPRESS P]MISSION TO ONE P>T ( HIS FAMILY TO SELL DISEAS$ MEAT TO ! O!R4 

,:5 ,DAVID SAYS ( SOMEBODY1 0,LET !RE BE NONE TO EXT5D M]CY UNTO HIM1 NEI!R LET !RE BE ANY TO FAVOR HIS FA!RLESS *ILDR510 HE SAYS IT IS IMPOSSIBLE = HIM TO BELIEVE ?AT EI!R ! WORDS OR ?\<T W]E 9SPIR$ BY ! GOOD ,GOD4 ,N[1 IF Y\ WILL DRAW Y\R !OLOGIC BELT ONE HOLE TI<T] & ANSW] !SE ?+S1 Y\ WILL DO EV]YBODY A FAVOR4 ,Y\ ASK ,+]SOLL TO RETIRE TO HIS *AMB]1 LOCK HIS DOOR1 & READ ! F\RTE5? *APT] ( ,JOHN4 ,IT IS GOOD READ+4 ,LET ME ASK Y\ TO READ ! FIFTE5? ,PSALM3 0,LORD1 :O %ALL ABIDE BE ,?Y TAB]NACLE8 :O %ALL DWELL 9 ,?Y HOLY HILL80 0,HE ?AT BACKBITE? NOT ) HIS TONGUE1 NOR DEA? EVIL TO HIS NEI<BOR1 NOR TAKE? UPS REPROA* AGA9/ HIS NEI<BOR40 ,) ALL DUE RESPECT1 ,I AM Y\RS1 

,JOHN ,L4 ,+]SOL4 

,PROSPECT ,HILL1 ,WAUKE%A ,CO41 ,WIS4 

,FROM 3 ,!,AN>*I/,LIBR>Y4ORG4 

,*RONOLOGY 3 
,JANU>Y #a#c1 #bba 3 ,LIB]TY ,VOL4 ,I4 ,NO4 #ag -- ,ADD$4 
,JANU>Y #f1 #bbb 3 ,LIB]TY ,VOL4 ,I4 ,NO4 #ag -- ,UPDAT$4 

 FILE G5]AT$ FROM 3  
HTTP3_/_/REVOLTLIB4COM_/