,P>T #e1 ,*APT] #b 
,H]R ,MO/ ON ,LIB]TAS 

#ahigahig 

,PEOPLE 3 

,AU?OR 3 ,B5JAM9 ,R4 ,TUCK] 

,TEXT 3 

,H]R ,MO/ ON ,LIB]TAS4 

.<,LIB]TY1 ,APRIL #a#d1 #a#h#h#h4.> 

,IT IS DUE TO ,JOHN ,MO/ TO SAY ?AT1 9 HIS PAP] ,FREIHEIT1 HE HAS GREET$ ! APPE>ANCE ( ,LIB]TAS 9 A SPIRIT ( 5TIRE FAIRNESS & LIB]ALITY1 AT ! SAME TIME ?AT HE HAS NOT HESITAT$ TO PO9T \T ?OSE ( ITS FEATURES TO :I* HE CANNOT AW>D APPROVAL4 ,BESIDES GIV+ LIB]AL EXTRACTS FROM ! FIR/ NUMB]1 DULY CR$IT$1 HE DEVOTES NE>LY A COLUMN & A HALF TO A REVIEW ( ITS M]ITS & DEM]ITS1 :I* IS HE>TY 9 ITS COMM5DATION & FRANK 9 ITS CRITICISM4 ,B>R+ ! USE 9 ONE S5T5CE ( ! WORD HYPOCRITICAL1 HIS >TICLE IS FREE FROM ?OSE ABUSIVE EPI!TS ( :I* HE HAS H]ET(ORE MADE ME A T>GET4 ,) ?IS PREFACE ( ?ANKS = BO? HIS PRAISE & HIS C5SURE1 ,I PROPOSE TO BRIEFLY EXAM9E ! LATT] 9 ! SAME SPIRIT 9 :I* IT IS (F]$47#a#b#h 8 #a7  

,H]R ,MO/'S OP9ION ( ,LIB]TAS MAY BE ?US SUMM$ UP1--?AT IT IS ?OR\<LY S\ND 9 ITS ANTAGONISM TO ! ,/ATE & UTT]LY UNS\ND 9 ITS *AMPION%IP ( PRIVATE PROP]TY4 ,:E!R ,LIB]TAS *AMPIONS PRIVATE PROP]TY DEP5DS 5TIRELY ON ! DEF9ITION GIV5 TO ?AT T]M4 ,DEF9+ IT ) ,PR\DHON AS ! SUM TOTAL ( LEGAL PRIVILEGES BE/[$ UPON ! HOLD]S ( WEAL?1 ,LIB]TAS AGREES ) ,PR\DHON ?AT PROP]TY IS ROBB]Y4 ,BUT US+ ! WORD 9 ! COMMON] ACCEPTATION1 AS D5OT+ ! LABOR]'S 9DIVIDUAL POSSESSION ( HIS PRODUCT OR ( HIS PROPORTIONAL %>E ( ! JO9T PRODUCT ( HIMSELF & O!RS1 ,LIB]TAS HOLDS ?AT PROP]TY IS LIB]TY4 ,& :5EV] ,PR\DHON1 = ! TIME BE+1 USES ! WORD 9 ! LATT] S5SE1 HE TOO UPHOLDS PROP]TY4 ,BUT IT IS PRECISELY 9 ?IS S5SE ( 9DIVIDUAL AS OPPOS$ TO COMMUNI/IC POSSESSION ?AT ,H]R ,MO/ OPPOSES PROP]TY4 ,H5CE1 :5 HE PR9TS AS A MOTTO 7AS HE (T5 DOES7 ,PR\DHON'S PHRASE ,PROP]TY IS ROBB]Y1 HE VIRTUALLY MISREPRES5TS ?AT AU?OR BY US+ HIS WORDS AS IF !Y W]E 9T5D$ TO MEAN DIAMETRICALLY ! OPPOSITE ( :AT ! AU?OR HIMSELF DECL>$ !M TO MEAN4 ,IF PROP]TY1 9 ! S5SE ( 9DIVIDUAL POSSESSION1 IS LIB]TY1 !N HE :O OPPOSES PROP]TY NECESS>ILY UPHOLDS AU?ORITY--?AT IS1 ! ,/ATE--9 SOME =M OR O!R1 & HE :O W\LD D5Y BO? ! ,/ATE & PROP]TY AT ONCE BECOMES !REBY 9CONSI/5T & GUILTY ( ATTEMPT+ ! IMPOSSIBLE47#a#b#h 8 #b7  

,! PR9CIPAL >GUM5T US$ BY ,H]R ,MO/ AGA9/ ,LIB]TAS IS ?AT IT IGNORES ! NECESSITY ( PRODUCTION ON ! L>GE SCALE N[ & H]EAFT]1--A NECESSITY :I*1 9 ,H]R ,MO/'S VIEW1 9VOLVES ! EXPLOITATION ( LABOR BY CAPITAL :]EV] PRIVATE PROP]TY PREVAILS4 ,!RE IS NO F\NDATION = ?IS /ATEM5T4 ,LIB]TAS DOES NOT = A MOM5T D5Y OR IGNORE ! NECESSITY ( PRODUCTION ON ! L>GE SCALE4 ,IT DOES1 H[EV]1 S]I\SLY QUE/ION ! CLAIM ?AT SU* PRODUCTION MU/ ALWAYS 9VOLVE L>GE CONC5TRATION ( CAPITAL1 & EMPHATICALLY D5IES ?AT IT NECESS>ILY 9VOLVES LABOR'S EXPLOITATION UNLESS PRIVATE PROP]TY IS ABOLI%$4 ,AS ,I HAD ALREADY SAID 9 !SE COLUMNS1 ! MA9 /R5G? ( ! >GUM5T = ,/ATE ,SOCIALISM & ,COMMUNISM HAS ALWAYS RESID$ 9 ! CLAIM1 TILL LATELY UNDISPUT$1 ?AT ! P]MAN5T T5D5CY ( PROGRESS 9 ! PRODUCTION & DI/RIBUTION ( WEAL? IS 9 ! DIRECTION ( MORE & MORE COMPLICAT$ & CO/LY PROCESSES1 REQUIR+ GREAT] & GREAT] CONC5TRATION ( CAPITAL & LABOR4 ,BUT ! IDEA IS BEG9N+ TO DAWN UPON M9DS--!RE >E SCI5TI/S :O EV5 PR(ESS TO DEMON/RATE IT BY FACTS--?AT ! T5D5CY REF]R$ TO IS BUT A PHASE ( PROGRESS1 & ONE :I* WILL NOT 5DURE4 ,ON ! CONTR>Y1 A REV]SAL ( IT IS CONFID5TLY LOOK$ =4 ,PROCESSES >E EXPECT$ TO BECOME *EAP]1 MORE COMPACT1 & MORE EASILY MANAGEABLE1 UNTIL !Y %ALL COME AGA9 )9 ! CAPACITY ( 9DIVIDUALS & SMALL COMB9ATIONS4 ,SU* A REV]SAL HAS ALREADY BE5 EXP]I5C$ 9 ! C\RSE TAK5 BY IMPROVEM5TS 9 IMPLEM5TS & MAT]IALS ( DE/RUCTION4 ,MILIT>Y PROGRESS WAS = A LONG TIME T[>D ! COMPLEX1 REQUIR+ IMM5SE >MIES & VA/ \TLAYS4 ,BUT ! T5D5CY ( MORE REC5T DISCOV]IES & DEVICES HAS BE5 T[>DS PLAC+ 9DIVIDUALS ON A P> ) >MIES BY 5ABL+ !M TO WIELD P[]S :I* NO AGGREGATION ( TROOPS CAN )/&4 ,ALREADY1 IT IS BELIEV$1 ,LIEUT5ANT ,ZAL9SKI ) HIS DYNAMITE GUN C\LD %IELD ANY SEAPORT AGA9/ ! 5TIRE ,BRITI% NAVY4 ,) ! SUPPLANT+ ( /EAM BY ELECTRICITY & O!R ADVANCES ( :I* WE KN[ NOT1 IT SEEMS MORE ?AN LIKELY ?AT ! CON/RUCTIVE CAPACITY ( ! 9DIVIDUAL WILL KEEP PACE ) HIS DE/RUCTIVE4 ,9 ?AT CASE :AT WILL BECOME ( ,/ATE ,SOCIALISM & ,COMMUNISM8 ,IT BEHOOVES !IR ADVOCATES NOT TO BE SO COCK-SURE AS !Y HAVE BE5 H]ET(ORE ( ! CORRECTNESS ( ?IS MAJOR PREMISE ( ALL !IR >GUM5TS47#a#b#h 8 #c7  

,BUT ,H]R ,MO/ MAY CLAIM ?AT 9 ?IS REASON+ ! ELEM5T ( SPECULATION & UNC]TA9TY IS TOO L>GE TO W>RANT ! PLAC+ ( ANY WEI<T UPON IT4 ,V]Y WELL1 !N2 SIMPLY REAFFIRM+ MY [N CONFID5CE 9 IT1 ,I WILL LET IT GO = :AT IT IS WOR?1 & CONSID] AT ONCE ! QUE/ION :E!R L>GE CONC5TRATION ( CAPITAL = PRODUCTION ON ! L>GE SCALE CONFRONTS US ) ! DISAGREEABLE ALT]NATIVE ( EI!R ABOLI%+ PRIVATE PROP]TY OR CONT9U+ TO HOLD LABOR UND] ! CAPITALI/IC YOKE4 ,H]R ,MO/ PROMISES ?AT1 IF ,I WILL %[ HIM ?AT ! PRIVATE PROP]TY REGIME IS COMPATIBLE ) PRODUCTION ON ! L>GE SCALE )\T ! EXPLOITATION ( LABOR1 HE WILL /& BY ! SIDE ( ,LIB]TAS 9 ITS FAVOR4 ,?IS PROMISE CONTA9S A MO/ SIGNIFICANT ADMISSION4 ,IF ,COMMUNISM IS REALLY1 AS ,H]R ,MO/ G5]ALLY CLAIMS1 NO 9FR+EM5T ( LIB]TY1 & IF 9 ITSELF IT IS SU* A GOOD & P]FECT ?+1 :Y AB&ON IT = PRIVATE PROP]TY SIMPLY BECAUSE ! POSSIBILITY ( ! LATT]'S EXI/5CE )\T ! EXPLOITATION ( LABOR HAS BE5 DEMON/RAT$8 ,TO DECL>E ONE'S WILL+NESS TO DO SO IS PLA9LY TO AFFIRM ?AT1 EXPLOITATION ASIDE1 PRIVATE PROP]TY IS SUP]IOR TO ,COMMUNISM1 & ?AT1 EXPLOITATION ADMITT$1 ,COMMUNISM IS *OS5 ONLY AS ! LESS] EVIL4 ,I TAKE NOTE ( ?IS ADMISSION1 & PASS ON47#a#b#h 8 #d7  

,RI<T H]E1 H[EV]1 ,H]R ,MO/ QUALIFIES HIS PROMISE BY PLAC+ ANO!R CONDITION UPON ITS FULFILLM5T4 ,I MU/ NOT ONLY DEMON/RATE ! PROPOSITION /IPULAT$1 BUT ,I MU/ ALSO DO SO O!RWISE ?AN BY PO9T+ TO ,PR\DHON'S BANK+ SY/EM4 ,?IS COMPLICATES ! PROBLEM4 ,%[ ME ?AT ,A IS EQUAL TO ,B1 SAYS ,H]R ,MO/1 & ,I WILL UPHOLD ,A2 ONLY Y\ MU/ NOT %[ IT BY E/ABLI%+ ?AT ,A & ,B >E EQUAL TO ,C4 ,BUT P]HAPS ! EQUALITY ( BO? ,A & ,B TO ,C IS ! ONLY PRO( ,I HAVE ( ! EQUALITY ( ,A TO ,B4 ,AM ,I TO BE DEB>R$1 !N1 FROM MAK+ ! DEMON/RATION SIMPLY BECAUSE ?IS =M ( LOGIC IS NOT AGREEABLE TO ,H]R ,MO/8 ,NOT AT ALL2 HE IS B\ND TO %[ ! FLAW 9 ! LOGIC1 OR ELSE ACCEPT ITS CONCLUSION4 ,HIS /IPULATION1 !N1 ?AT ,I MU/ NOT PO9T TO ,PR\DHON'S BANK+ SY/EM IS RIDICUL\S1 9ASMU* AS ?IS BANK+ SY/EM1 OR AT LEA/ ITS C5TRAL PR9CIPLE1 IS ESS5TIAL TO ! DEMON/RATION ( MY POSITION4 ,I (F] HIM ?IS PR9CIPLE AS CONCLUSIVE PRO(2 HE MU/ %[ ITS ]ROR1 OR ADMIT ! CLAIM4 ,IT CANNOT BE BRU%$ ASIDE ) A CONTEMPTU\S WAVE ( ! H&47#a#b#h 8 #e7  

,N[1 :AT IS ?IS PR9CIPLE8 ,SIMPLY ! FRE$OM ( CR$IT & ! RESULTANT ORGANIZATION !RE( 9 SU* A WAY AS TO ELIM9ATE ! ELEM5T ( ! REW>D ( CAPITAL FROM ! PRODUCTION & DI/RIBUTION ( WEAL?4 ,H]R ,MO/ WILL NOT DISPUTE1 ,I ?9K1 ?AT FRE$OM ( CR$IT LEAVES PRIVATE PROP]TY 9TACT & EV5 9CREASES ! PRACTICABILITY ( PRODUCTION ON ! L>GE SCALE4 ,! ONLY QUE/ION1 !N1 IS :E!R IT WILL ABOLI% USURY2 =1 IF IT WILL ABOLI% USURY1 MY POSITION IS E/ABLI%$1 USURY BE+ BUT ANO!R NAME = ! EXPLOITATION ( LABOR4 ,! >GUM5T ?AT IT WILL EFFECT SU* ABOLITION1 & ! >GUM5T !RE=E :I* ,H]R ,MO/ IS B\ND TO DE/ROY1 HE WILL F9D SET =? 9 ! LATT] HALF ( MY PAP] ON ,/ATE ,SOCIALISM & ,AN>*ISM1 PR9T$ 9 ! FIR/ ISSUE ( ,LIB]TAS4 ,IF HE MAKES NO ANSW]1 ! PRIVATE PROP]TY PLANK 9 ! PLAT=M ( ,LIB]TAS REMA9S UNIMPAIR$ BY HIS CRITICISM2 IF1 ON ! O!R H&1 HE ATTEMPTS AN ANSW]1 !N WE %ALL SEE :AT !RE IS FUR!R TO BE SAID47#a#b#h 8 #f7  

,BUT ,H]R ,MO/'S CRITICISM IS NOT AIM$ AT ! PLAT=M ALONE2 HE IS ESPECIALLY SEV]E UPON ! TACTICS ( ,LIB]TAS4 ,IT IS H]E ?AT HE CROSSES ! L9E ( C\RTE\S CRITICISM1 & BECOMES ABUSIVE BY *>ACT]IZ+ AS HYPOCRITICAL ! DECL>ATION ( ,LIB]TAS ?AT1 AS LONG AS FRE$OM ( SPEE* & ( ! PRESS IS NOT /RUCK D[N1 !RE %\LD BE NO RESORT TO PHYSICAL =CE 9 ! /RUGGLE AGA9/ OPPRESSION4 ,?AT ,LIB]TAS IS HYPOCRITICAL 9 ?IS POSITION HE 9F]S FROM ! FACT ?AT IT N[ DISC\NT5ANCES PHYSICAL =CE1 AL?\< FIVE M5 HAVE BE5 MURD]$1 O!RS >E 9 PRISON1 & /ILL O!RS >E 9 DANG] ( IMPRISONM5T1 = HAV+ EX]CIS$ ! RI<T ( FREE SPEE*4 ,H]R ,MO/ APP>5TLY =GETS ?AT ,FREIHEIT IS /ILL PUBLI%$ 9 ,NEW ,YORK1 ! ,AL>M 9 ,*ICAGO1 & ,LIB]TY & ,LIB]TAS 9 ,BO/ON1 & ?AT ALL !SE PAP]S1 IF NOT ALL[$ TO SAY EV]Y?+ !Y W\LD LIKE TO1 >E ABLE TO SAY ALL ?AT IT IS ABSOLUTELY NECESS>Y TO SAY 9 ORD] TO F9ALLY A*IEVE !IR 5D1 ! TRIUMPH ( LIB]TY4 ,IT MU/ NOT BE 9F]R$ ?AT1 BECAUSE ,LIB]TAS ?9KS IT MAY BECOME ADVISABLE TO USE =CE TO SECURE FREE SPEE*1 IT W\LD !RE=E SANCTION A BLOODY DELUGE AS SOON AS FREE SPEE* HAD BE5 /RUCK D[N 9 ONE1 A DOZ51 OR A HUNDR$ 9/ANCES4 ,NOT UNTIL ! GAG HAD BECOME COMPLETELY EFFICACI\S W\LD ,LIB]TAS ADVISE ?AT LA/ RESORT1 ! USE ( =CE4 ,& ?IS1 F> FROM %[+ HYPOCRISY1 IS ! BE/ EVID5CE ( ! S9C]ITY ( ?IS J\RNAL'S UTT] DISBELIEF 9 =CE AS A SOLUTION ( ECONOMIC EVILS4 ,IF !RE IS HYPOCRISY ANY:]E1 IT IS ON ! SIDE ( ?OSE :O1 AFFECT+ TO ?9K =CE A DEPLORABLE ?+ ONLY TO BE RESORT$ TO = PURPOSES ( DEF5SE1 >E EAG]LY WAT*+ = ! COMMISSION ( (F5SES 9 ! HOPE ( F9D+ A PRETEXT = ! 9AUGURATION ( AN ]A ( T]ROR & SLAU<T] HI!RTO UNP>ALLEL$ 9 HI/ORY47#a#b#h 8 #g7 

,FROM 3 FAIR-USE4ORG4 

,*RONOLOGY 3 
,NOVEMB] #c1 #ahif 3 ,P>T #e1 ,*APT] #b -- ,PUBLICATION4 
,FEBRU>Y #b#a1 #bag 3 ,P>T #e1 ,*APT] #b -- ,ADD$4 

 FILE G5]AT$ FROM 3  
HTTP3_/_/REVOLTLIB4COM_/