,P>T #a1 ,*APT] #de 
,AN ,UN=TUNATE ,ANALOGY 

#ahigahig 

,PEOPLE 3 

,AU?OR 3 ,B5JAM9 ,R4 ,TUCK] 

,TEXT 3 

,AN ,UN=TUNATE ,ANALOGY4 

.<,LIB]TY1 ,NOVEMB] #e1 #a#h#h#g4.> 

,A QUE/ION HAS >IS5 9 ,5GL& :E!R ! PUBLIC HAVE A RI<T ( ACCESS TO ! TOP ( ,LATRIGG 9 ,KESWICK ,VALE1 ! PUBLIC CLAIM+ SU* RI<T & C]TA9 L&[N]S D5Y+ IT4 ,IT IS PROBABLE ?AT ! CLAIM ( ! PUBLIC IS GOOD1 BUT1 AS ,I AM NOT 9=M$ REG>D+ ! BASIS ( ! L&HOLD]S' TITLE 9 ?IS P>TICUL> CASE1 IT IS NOT MY PURPOSE TO DISCUSS ! MATT]4 ,! ,LONDON ,JUS1 H[EV]1 HAS DISCUSS$ ! MATT]1 & ,I REF] TO IT ONLY TO EXPOSE AN 9CONSI/5CY 9TO :I* ?AT J\RNAL HAS FALL54 ,IT SEEMS ?AT ,MR4 ,PLIMSOLL1 :O *AMPIONS ! CLAIM ( ! PUBLIC1 HAS MADE ?IS DECL>ATION37#d#f 8 #a7  

,:AT ,P>LIAM5T HAS GIV5 ,P>LIAM5T CAN TAKE AWAY4 ,NOT RI<TLY1 DECL>ES ,JUS2 & IT IMAG9ES A CASE47#d#f 8 #b7 

,SUPPOSE ,P>LIAM5T GRANTS A LIFE-P5SION TO A DI/+UI%$ G5]AL2 SUPPOSE ?AT ! NEXT ,P>LIAM5T1 BE+ ( ANO!R COLOR1 REJECTS ! GRANT1 WILL ,MR4 ,PLIMSOLL PRET5D ?AT 9 SU* A CASE ,P>LIAM5T W\LD HAVE ! RI<T TO TAKE IT AWAY8 ,NOT HE2 NO HONE/ MAN C\LD ?9K SO = A MOM5T4 ,PRIVATE P]SONS DO NOT CONSID] !MSELVES 5TITL$ TO TAKE BACK ?AT :I* !Y HAVE GIV5 TO O!RS1 EV5 )\T ANY CONSID]ATION :ATEV]47#d#f 8 #c7 
  

,TRUE1 SO F> AS PRIVATE P]SONS >E CONC]N$4 ,BUT PRIVATE P]SONS DO CONSID] !MSELVES 5TITL$ TO TAKE BACK ?AT :I* HAS BE5 TAK5 FROM !M & GIV5 TO O!RS4 ,IF ! BODY POLITIC1 OR ,/ATE1 :I* COMPELS ,A TO BELONG TO IT & AID 9 SUPPORT+ IT1 PL$GES A C]TA9 SUM ANNUALLY TO ,B1 &1 TO MEET ?IS PL$GE1 =CIBLY COLLECTS ANNUALLY FROM ,A'S PROPORTIONAL P>T ( ! SUM1 !N ,A1 :5 HE BECOMES /RONG 5\<1 MAY NOT ONLY DECL9E TO MAKE ANY FUR!R ANNUAL PAYM5TS TO ,B1 BUT MAY TAKE FROM ,B ALL ?AT HE HAS BE5 COMPELL$ TO PAY TO HIM 9 ! PA/4 ,TO-DAY1 TO BE SURE1 ,A1 AS SOON AS HE ACQUIRES P[]1 G5]ALLY VITIATES HIS CLAIM UPON ,B BY PROCE$+ TO PL$GE O!RS 9 ! SAME MANN] 9 :I* O!RS1 :5 !Y W]E 9 P[]1 HAD PL$G$ HIM4 ,BUT ?IS FACT1 BE+ ACCID5TAL RA!R ?AN ESS5TIAL1 HAS NO LOGICAL BE>+ UPON ! QUE/ION ( ,A'S RI<T TO RECOV] FROM ,B4 ,IT FOLL[S1 !N1 ?AT PRIVATE P]SONS CANNOT BE HELD TO ! PL$GES ( AN ASSOCIATION :I* =CES !M 9TO ITS MEMB]%IP1 & ?AT ,P>LIAM5T1 :I* REPRES5TS ! WILL ( A MAJORITY ( ! MEMB]S ( SU* AN ASSOCIATION1 & ( A MAJORITY :I* NECESS>ILY V>IES CONT9UALLY 9 ITS MAKE-UP1 /&S ON A V]Y DIFF]5T FOOT+ FROM ?AT ( PRIVATE P]SONS 9 ! MATT] ( OBS]V+ OR VIOLAT+ CONTRACTS47#d#f 8 #d7  

,BUT SUPPOSE ?AT ! POSITION ( ,JUS ?AT !Y /& ON ! SAME FOOT+ TO BE GRANT$4 ,:AT HAS ,JUS TO SAY !N8 ,?IS1--NAMELY ?AT IT F9DS ITSELF 9 SYMPA?Y ) ,MR4 ,PLIMSOLL & ! PEOPLE ( ,KESWICK 9 !IR DESIRE TO 5JOY ! BEAUTIFUL SC5]Y ( ,LATRIGG2 ?AT IT BELIEVES ! RI<T ( WAY TO SU* 5JOYM5T WAS ORIG9ALLY !IRS2 & ?AT ! SOON] !Y RECOV] IT1 ! BETT]4 ,BUT H[8 ,IT HAS ALREADY D5I$ ?AT :AT ,P>LIAM5T HAS GIV5 ,P>LIAM5T CAN TAKE AWAY2 SO IT F9DS ITSELF OBLIG$ TO PICK ITS WAY >\ND ?IS DIFFICULTY BY ! FOLL[+ DEVI\S PA?37#d#f 8 #e7 

,IF ,P>LIAM5T HAS GIV5 AWAY TO PRIVATE P]SONS ?AT :I* \<T TO HAVE BE5 RETA9$ 9 PUBLIC H&S = ! PUBLIC USE & B5EFIT1 ) OR )\T SUFFICI5T 7OR ANY7 CONSID]ATION1 !N LET ! ,NATION KEEP FAI? & BUY IT BACK47#d#f 8 #f7 
  

,! ITALICS >E M9E4 ,BE>+ !M 9 M9D1 LET US RETURN TO ! ANALOGY BETWE5 ,P>LIAM5T & PRIVATE P]SONS4 ,DO PRIVATE P]SONS1 !N1 CONSID] !MSELVES 5TITL$ TO BUY BACK ?AT :I* !Y HAVE GIV5 TO O!RS1 ON T]MS FIX$ BY !MSELVES1 & :E!R ! O!RS DESIRE TO SELL OR NOT8 ,?AT ! PRIVATE P]SON :O GIVES A ?+ TO ANO!R & AFT]W>DS COMPELS ! LATT] TO SELL IT BACK TO HIM IS LESS A ?IEF ?AN HE W\LD HAVE BE5 IF HE HAD TAK5 IT BACK )\T COMP5SATION IS A PR9CIPLE UNRECOGNIZ$1 SO F> AS ,I KN[1 EI!R 9 LAW OR 9 POLITICAL ECONOMY4 ,NO MORE CAN BE SAID ( SU* A ROBB] ?AN ?AT HE %[S SOME CONSID]ATION = HIS VICTIM4 ,!N1 IF ,P>LIAM5T & PRIVATE P]SONS /& ON ! SAME FOOT+1 :5CE DOES ,JUS D]IVE ! RI<T ( ,P>LIAM5T TO =CIBLY BUY BACK :AT IT HAS GIV5 AWAY87#d#f 8 #g7  

,JUS IS A F9E PAP]4 ,IT MA9TA9S C]TA9 PHASES ( ,9DIVIDUALISM ) SPL5DID =CE & VIGOR4 ,BUT IT CONT9UALLY PUTS ITSELF 9TO AWKW>D SITUATIONS SIMPLY BY FAIL+ TO BE ?OR\< 9 ITS ,9DIVIDUALISM4 ,H]E1 = 9/ANCE1 IT D5IES ! RI<T ( ! ,/ATE TO TAKE FROM ! 9DIVIDUAL )\T COMP5SATION :AT IT HAS GIV5 HIM1 BUT AFFIRMS ! RI<T ( ! ,/ATE TO COMPEL ! 9DIVIDUAL TO SELL TO IT :AT IT HAS GIV5 HIM4 ,9 A WORD1 ,JUS IS NOT ,AN>*I/IC4 ,IT DOES NOT FAVOR 9DIVIDUAL LIB]TY 9 ALL ?+S4 ,IT W\LD CONF9E 9T]F]5CE ) IT )9 MU* N>R[] LIMITS ?AN ?OSE G5]ALLY SET BY GOV]NM5TALI/S1 BUT1 AFT] ALL1 LIKE ALL O!R GOV]NM5TALI/S1 IT FIXES ! LIMITS 9 ACCORDANCE ) >BITR>Y /&>DS PRESCRIB+ ?AT 9T]F]5CE MU/ BE C>RI$ ON ONLY BY ME?ODS & = PURPOSES :I* IT APPROVES ON GR\NDS =EIGN TO ! BELIEF 9 LIB]TY AS ! NECESS>Y CONDITION ( SOCIAL H>MONY47#d#f 8 #h7 

,FROM 3 FAIR-USE4ORG4 

,*RONOLOGY 3 
,NOVEMB] #c1 #ahif 3 ,P>T #a1 ,*APT] #de -- ,PUBLICATION4 
,FEBRU>Y #b1 #bag 3 ,P>T #a1 ,*APT] #de -- ,ADD$4 

 FILE G5]AT$ FROM 3  
HTTP3_/_/REVOLTLIB4COM_/