,P>T #a1 ,*APT] #ca 
,P9NEY ,/RUGGL+ ) ,PROCRU/ES 

#ahigahig 

,PEOPLE 3 

,AU?OR 3 ,B5JAM9 ,R4 ,TUCK] 

,TEXT 3 

,P9NEY ,/RUGGL+ ) ,PROCRU/ES4 

.<,LIB]TY1 ,M>* #a#b1 #a#h#h#g4.> 

,IT IS ! HABIT ( ! WILD ,WE/]N]1 :5EV] HE CANNOT ANSW] A ,BO/ONIAN'S >GUM5TS1 TO /R+ LONG WORDS 9TO LONG S5T5CES 9 MOCK]Y ( C]TA9 FANCI$ PECULI>ITIES ( ! ,BO/ON M9D4 ,$ITOR ,P9NEY ( ! ,W9/$ ,PRESS IS NOT EXACTLY A WILD ,WE/]N]1 BUT HE LIVES JU/ F> 5\< BEYOND ! CONF9ES ( ,MASSA*USETTS TO 5ABLE HIM TO RESORT TO ?IS DEVICE 9 ORD] TO OBSCURE ! O!RWISE OBVI\S NECESSITY ( MEET+ ME ON REASON'S GR\ND4 ,HIS LA/ REPLY TO ME FRUITLESSLY FILLS TWO-?IRDS ( ONE ( HIS LONG COLUMNS ) ! SORT ( BUNKUM REF]R$ TO1 :]EAS ?AT AM\NT ( SPACE1 DULY APPLI$ TO SOLID >GUM5T1 MI<T HAVE SUFFIC$ TO %[ ONE ( US 9 ]ROR4 ,:ATEV] ! *>ACT]I/ICS ( ,BO/ON 9TELLECT1 G5]ICALLY SPEAK+1 9 ! P>TICUL> ,BO/ONIAN ) :OM HE IS N[ CONFRONT$ ,MR4 ,P9NEY W\LD SEE1 W]E HE A /UD5T ( HUMAN NATURE1 AN EXTREMELY H>D-HEAD$ 9DIVIDUAL1 AB\T :OSE M9D !RE IS NO?+ CELE/IAL OR SUP]MUNDANE OR AES!TIC OR AB]RANT1 & :OSE ONLY DIALECTICS CONSI/S 9 SE>*+ FAI?FULLY = ! FUNDAM5TAL WEAKNESS ( HIS ADV]S>Y'S POSITION & /RIK+ AT IT ) SWIFT PRECISION1 OR ELSE1 F9D+ NONE SU*1 ACKN[L$G+ DEFEAT4 ,BUT HUMAN NATURE--AT LEA/1 ,BO/ON HUMAN NATURE--BE+ A PUZZLE TO ,MR4 ,P9NEY1 HE MI/AKES ME = A QUIBBL]1 A DISPUTATI\S ADVOCATE1 & A LOV] ( LOGOMA*Y4 ,LET US SEE1 !N1 BY :OM LOGOMA*Y WAS FIR/ EMPLOY$ 9 ?IS DISCUSSION47#c#b 8 #a7  

,9 AN UNGU>D$ MOM5T ( RI<TE\S IMPATI5CE ) ! FOLLY ( ! PROHIBITIONI/S ,MR4 ,P9NEY HAD GIV5 UTT]ANCE TO SOME V]Y EXTREME & ,AN>*I/IC DOCTR9E4 ,I APPLAUD$ HIM1 & V5TUR$ TO CALL HIS ATT5TION TO ONE OR TWO =MS ( PROHIBITION O!R ?AN ?AT ( ! LIQUOR TRAFFIC1 EQUALLY REPUGNANT TO HIS !ORY ( LIB]TY & YET *AMPION$ BY HIM4 ,ONE ( !SE WAS ! T>IFF4 ,HE ANSW]$ ME ?AT !RE IS NO ANALOGY BETWE5 PROHIBITION & ! T>IFF2 ! T>IFF PROHIBITS NO MAN FROM 9DULG+ HIS DESIRE TO TRADE :]E HE PLEASES4 ,RI<T H]E LOGOMA*Y MADE ITS FIR/ APPE>ANCE1 OV] ! WORD PROHIBIT4 ,I HAD CIT$ TWO =MS ( ,/ATE 9T]F]5CE ) TRADE1 EA* ( :I* 9 PRACTICE EI!R ANNOYS IT OR HAMP]S IT OR EFFECTIVELY PREV5TS IT1 ACCORD+ TO CIRCUM/ANCES4 ,?IS ANALOGY 9 SUB/ANTIAL RESULTS PRES5T$ A DIFFICULTY1 :I* ,MR4 ,P9NEY TRI$ TO OV]COME BY BEG9N+ A DISPUTE OV] ! MEAN+ ( ! WORD PROHIBIT1--A MATT] ( ONLY =MAL MOM5T SO F> AS ! PRES5T DISCUSSION IS CONC]N$4 ,HE DECL>$ ?AT ! T>IFF IS NOT LIKE ! PROHIBITORY LIQUOR LAW1 9ASMU* AS IT PROHIBITS NOBODY FROM TRAD+ :]E HE PLEASES4 ,A PURELY NOM9AL DI/9CTION1 IF EV5 ?AT2 CONSEQU5TLY ,MR4 ,P9NEY1 9 PASS+ IT (F AS A REAL ONE1 WAS GUILTY ( QUIBBL+47#c#b 8 #b7  

,BUT ,I MET ,MR4 ,P9NEY ON HIS [N GR\ND1 ALL[+ ?AT1 SPEAK+ EXACTLY1 ! T>IFF DOES NOT PROHIBIT1 BUT ADD+1 ON ! O!R H&1 ?AT NEI!R DOES ! SO-CALL$ PROHIBITORY LIQUOR LAW2 ?AT BO? SIMPLY IMPOSE P5ALTIES ON TRAD]S1 9 ! ONE CASE AS A CONDITION1 9 ! O!R AS A CONSEQU5CE1 ( C>RY+ ON !IR TRADES4 ,H5CE MY ANALOGY /ILL /OOD1 & ,I EXPECT$ IT TO BE GRAPPL$ )4 ,BUT NO4 ,MR4 ,P9NEY1 9 ! V]Y BREA? ?AT HE PROTE/S AGA9/ QUIBBL+1 9SI/S ON HIS QUIBBLE BY ASK+ IF PRISON DISCIPL9E IS1 !N1 SO LAX ?AT CONVICT$ LIQUOR SELL]S CAN C>RY ON !IR BUS9ESS )9 ! WALLS1 & BY SUPPOS+ ?AT ,I W\LD /ILL ?9K PROHIBITION DID NOT PROHIBIT1 IF ! EXTREME P5ALTY = LIQUOR SELL+ W]E DECAPITATION4 ,I DO NOT DISPUTE ! FACT ?AT A MAN CANNOT C>RY ON ! LIQUOR BUS9ESS AS LONG AS HE IS 9 PRISON1 NOR CAN ,MR4 ,P9NEY DISPUTE ! FACT ?AT A MAN CANNOT SELL C]TA9 =EIGN GOODS 9 ?IS C\NTRY AS LONG AS HE CANNOT RAISE ! MONEY TO PAY ! T>IFF2 & :ILE ,I AM CONFID5T ?AT DECAPITATION1 IF RIGOR\SLY 5=C$1 W\LD /OP ! LIQUOR TRAFFIC1 ,I AM NO LESS SURE ?AT ! EFFECT ON =EIGN TRAFFIC W\LD BE EQUALLY DISA/R\S W]E DECAPITATION TO BE 5=C$ AS A TAX UPON IMPORT]S4 ,ON ,MR4 ,P9NEY'S !ORY ! PROHIBITORY LIQUOR LAW C\LD BE MADE NON-PROHIBITORY SIMPLY BY *ANG+ ! P5ALTIES FROM IMPRISONM5T TO F9ES4 ,! ABSURDITY ( ?IS IS EVID5T47#c#b 8 #c7  

,BUT1 IF ,I W]E TO GRANT ?AT ,MR4 ,P9NEY'S QUIBBLE %[S ?AT !RE IS NO ANALOGY BETWE5 A PROHIBITORY LIQUOR LAW & A REV5UE T>IFF 7:I* ,I DO NOT GRANT1 BUT D5Y71 IT W\LD /ILL REMA9 = HIM TO %[ ?AT !RE IS NO ANALOGY BETWE5 A PROHIBITORY LIQUOR LAW & SU* A T>IFF AS HE FAVORS1--ONE SO HI< AS TO BE ABSOLUTELY PROHIBITORY & YIELD NO REV5UE AT ALL1--OR ELSE ADMIT HIS 9CONSI/5CY 9 OPPOS+ ! =M] & NOT ! LATT]4 ,HE HAS NOT ATTEMPT$ TO MEET ?IS PO9T1 EV5 ) A QUIBBLE47#c#b 8 #d7  

,ONE O!R PO9T1 H[EV]1 HE DOES TRY TO MEET4 ,TO MY /ATEM5T ?AT HIS POSITION ON ! AB/RACT QUE/ION ( LIB]TY 9VOLVES LOGICALLY OPPOSITION TO GOV]NM5T 9 ALL ITS FUNCTIONS HE MAKES ?IS ANSW]37#c#b 8 #e7 

,BETWE5 PURITAN M$DL+ ) A MAN'S DOME/IC AFFAIRS1 & NECESS>Y GOV]NM5T REGULATION ( MATT]S :I* ! 9DIVIDUAL IS 9COMPET5T TO DIRECT1 YET :I* MU/ BE DIRECT$ 9 ORD] TO SECURE TO ! 9DIVIDUAL HIS RI<TFUL LIB]TY1 !RE IS A DI/ANCE SUFFICI5TLY L>GE TO GIVE FULL PLAY TO \R LIMIT$ FACULTIES47#c#b 8 #f7 
  

,BUT :O IS TO JUDGE :AT GOV]NM5T REGULATION IS NECESS>Y & DECIDE :AT MATT]S ! 9DIVIDUAL IS 9COMPET5T TO DIRECT8 ,! MAJORITY8 ,BUT ! MAJORITY >E JU/ AS LIKELY TO DECIDE ?AT PROHIBITION IS NECESS>Y & ?AT ! 9DIVIDUAL IS 9COMPET5T TO DIRECT HIS APPETITE AS ?AT A T>IFF IS NECESS>Y & ?AT ! 9DIVIDUAL IS 9COMPET5T TO MAKE HIS [N CONTRACTS4 ,MR4 ,P9NEY1 !N1 MU/ SUBMIT TO ! WILL ( ! MAJORITY4 ,HIS ORIG9AL DECL>ATION1 H[EV]1 WAS ?AT DESPOTISM WAS DESPOTISM1 :E!R EX]CIS$ BY A MON>* OR A MAJORITY4 ,?IS DRIVES HIM BACK UPON LIB]TY 9 ALL ?+S4 ,= JU/ AS HE W\LD OBJECT TO ! REIGN ( A MON>* DISPOS$ TO ADM9I/] AFFAIRS RATIONALLY & EQUITABLY SIMPLY BECAUSE HE WAS A MON>*1 SO HE MU/ OBJECT TO ! REIGN ( A MAJORITY1 EV5 ?\< ITS ADM9I/RATION W]E HIS IDEAL1 SIMPLY BECAUSE IT IS A MAJORITY4 ,MR4 ,P9NEY IS TRY+ TO S]VE BO? LIB]TY & AU?ORITY1 & IS MAK+ HIMSELF RIDICUL\S 9 ! ATTEMPT47#c#b 8 #g7 

,FROM 3 FAIR-USE4ORG4 

,*RONOLOGY 3 
,NOVEMB] #c1 #ahif 3 ,P>T #a1 ,*APT] #ca -- ,PUBLICATION4 
,FEBRU>Y #a#i1 #bag 3 ,P>T #a1 ,*APT] #ca -- ,ADD$4 

 FILE G5]AT$ FROM 3  
HTTP3_/_/REVOLTLIB4COM_/