,P>T #a1 ,*APT] #f 
,MR4 ,LEVY'S ,MAXIMUM 

#ahigahig 

,PEOPLE 3 

,AU?OR 3 ,B5JAM9 ,R4 ,TUCK] 

,TEXT 3 

,MR4 ,LEVY'S ,MAXIMUM 

.<,LIB]TY1 ,NOVEMB] #a1 #a#h#i4.> 

,:ATEV] ELSE ,AN>*ISM MAY MEAN1 IT MEANS ?AT ,/ATE CO]CION ( PEACEABLE CITIZ5S1 9TO COOP]ATION 9 RE/RA9+ ! ACTIVITY ( ,BILL ,SIKES1 IS TO BE CONDEMN$ & \<T TO BE ABOLI%$4 ,AN>*ISM IMPLIES ! RI<T ( AN 9DIVIDUAL TO /& ASIDE & SEE A MAN MURD]$ OR A WOMAN RAP$4 ,IT IMPLIES ! RI<T ( ! W\LD-BE PASSIVE ACCOMPLICE ( AGGRESSION TO ESCAPE ALL CO]CION4 ,IT IS TRUE ! ,AN>*I/ MAY VOLUNT>ILY COOP]ATE TO *ECK AGGRESSION2 BUT ALSO HE MAY NOT4 ,QUA ,AN>*I/1 HE IS )9 HIS RI<T 9 )HOLD+ SU* COOP]ATION1 9 LEAV+ O!RS TO BE> ! BURD5 ( RESI/ANCE TO AGGRESSION1 OR 9 LEAV+ ! AGGRESSOR TO TRIUMPH UN*ECK$4 ,9DIVIDUALISM1 ON ! O!R H&1 W\LD NOT ONLY RE/RA9 ! ACTIVE 9VAD] UP TO ! PO9T NECESS>Y TO RE/ORE FRE$OM TO O!RS1 BUT W\LD ALSO CO]CE ! MAN :O W\LD O!RWISE BE A PASSIVE WITNESS (1 OR CONNIV] AT1 AGGRESSION 9TO COOP]ATION AGA9/ HIS MORE ACTIVE COLLEAGUE47#g 8 #a7  

,! FOLL[+ P>AGRAPH OCCURS 9 AN ABLY-WRITT5 >TICLE BY ,MR4 ,J4 ,H4 ,LEVY 9 ! ,P]SONAL ,RI<TS ,J\RNAL4 ,! WRIT]'S EVID5T 9T5TION WAS TO PUT ,AN>*ISM 9 AN UNFAVORABLE LI<T BY /AT+ ITS PR9CIPLES1 OR ONE ( !M1 9 A V]Y (F5SIVE WAY4 ,AT ! SAME TIME IT WAS HIS 9T5TION ALSO TO BE FAIR1--?AT IS1 NOT TO DI/ORT ! DOCTR9E ( ,AN>*ISM1--& HE HAS NOT DI/ORT$ IT4 ,I REPR9T ! P>AGRAPH 9 $ITORIAL TYPE = ! PURPOSE ( GIV+ IT1 AS AN ,AN>*I/1 MY 5TIRE APPROVAL1 B>R+ ! /IGMA S\<T TO BE CONVEY$ BY ! WORDS ACCOMPLICE & CONNIV]4 ,IF A MAN WILL BUT /ATE ! TRU? AS ,I SEE IT1 HE MAY /ATE IT AS BALDLY AS HE PLEASES3 ,I WILL ACCEPT IT /ILL4 ,! ,AN>*I/S >E NOT AFRAID ( !IR PR9CIPLES4 ,IT IS F> MORE SATISFACTORY TO HAVE ONE'S POSITION /AT$ BALDLY & ACCURATELY BY AN OPPON5T :O UND]/&S IT ?AN 9 A G5IAL1 MILK-&-WAT]1 & 9ACCURATE FA%ION BY AN IGNORAMUS47#g 8 #b7  

,IT IS AGRE$1 !N1 ?AT1 9 ,AN>*ISM'S VIEW1 AN 9DIVIDUAL HAS A RI<T TO /& ASIDE & SEE A MAN MURD]$4 ,& PRAY1 :Y NOT8 ,IF IT IS JU/IFIABLE TO COLL> A MAN :O IS M9D+ HIS [N BUS9ESS & =CE HIM 9TO A FI<T1 :Y MAY WE NOT ALSO COLL> HIM = ! PURPOSE ( =C+ HIM TO HELP US TO CO]CE A P>5T 9TO $UCAT+ HIS *ILD1 OR TO COMMIT ANY O!R ACT ( 9VASION ?AT MAY SEEM TO US = ! G5]AL GOOD8 ,I CAN SEE NO E?ICAL DI/9CTION H]E :ATEV]4 ,IT IS TRUE ?AT ,MR4 ,LEVY1 9 ! SUCCE$+ P>AGRAPH1 JU/IFIES ! COLL>+ ( ! NON-COOP]ATIVE 9DIVIDUAL ON ! GR\ND ( NECESSITY4 7,I NOTE H]E ?AT ?IS IS ! SAME GR\ND ON :I* ,CITIZ5 ,MO/ PROPOSES TO COLL> ! NON-COOP]ATOR 9 HIS COMMUNI/IC 5T]PRISES & MAKE HIM WORK = LOVE 9/EAD ( WAGES47 ,BUT SOME O!R MOTIVE ?AN NECESSITY MU/ HAVE BE5 9 ,MR4 ,LEVY'S M9D1 UNCONSCI\SLY1 :5 HE WROTE ! P>AGRAPH :I* ,I HAVE QUOT$4 ,ELSE :Y DOES HE D5Y ?AT ! NON-COOP]ATOR IS )9 HIS RI<T8 ,I CAN UND]/& ! MAN :O 9 A CRISIS JU/IFIES NO MATT] :AT =M ( COMPULSION ON ! GR\ND ( %E] NECESSITY1 BUT ,I CANNOT UND]/& ! MAN :O D5IES ! RI<T ( ! 9DIVIDUAL ?US CO]C$ TO RESI/ SU* COMPULSION & 9SI/ ON PURSU+ HIS [N 9DEP5D5T C\RSE4 ,IT IS PRECISELY ?IS D5IAL1 H[EV]1 ?AT ,MR4 ,LEVY MAKES2 O!RWISE HIS PHRASE )9 HIS RI<T IS MEAN+LESS47#g 8 #c7  

,BUT H[EV] ?IS MAY BE1 LET US LOOK AT ! PLEA ( NECESSITY4 ,MR4 ,LEVY CLAIMS ?AT ! CO]CION ( ! PEACEFUL NON-COOP]ATOR IS NECESS>Y4 ,NECESS>Y TO :AT8 ,NECESS>Y1 ANSW]S ,MR4 ,LEVY1 9 ORD] ?AT FRE$OM MAY BE AT ! MAXIMUM4 ,SUPPOS+ = ! MOM5T ?AT ?IS IS TRUE1 ANO!R 9QUIRY SUGGE/S ITSELF3 ,IS ! ABSOLUTE MAXIMUM ( FRE$OM AN 5D TO BE ATTA9$ AT ANY CO/8 ,I REG>D LIB]TY AS ! *IEF ESS5TIAL TO MAN'S HAPP9ESS1 & !RE=E AS ! MO/ IMPORTANT ?+ 9 ! WORLD1 & ,I C]TA9LY WANT AS MU* ( IT AS ,I CAN GET4 ,BUT ,I CANNOT SEE ?AT IT CONC]NS ME MU* :E!R ! AGGREGATE AM\NT ( LIB]TY 5JOY$ BY ALL 9DIVIDUALS ADD$ TOGE!R IS AT ITS MAXIMUM OR A LITTLE BEL[ IT1 IF ,I1 AS ONE 9DIVIDUAL1 AM TO HAVE LITTLE OR NONE ( ?IS AGGREGATE4 ,IF1 H[EV]1 ,I AM TO HAVE AS MU* LIB]TY AS O!RS1 & IF O!RS >E TO HAVE AS MU* AS ,I1 !N1 FEEL+ SECURE 9 :AT WE HAVE1 IT WILL BEHOOVE US ALL UND\BT$LY TO TRY TO ATTA9 ! MAXIMUM ( LIB]TY COMPATIBLE ) ?IS CONDITION ( EQUALITY4 ,:I* BR+S US BACK TO ! FAMILI> LAW ( EQUAL LIB]TY1--! GREATE/ AM\NT ( 9DIVIDUAL LIB]TY COMPATIBLE ) ! EQUALITY ( LIB]TY4 ,BUT ?IS MAXIMUM ( LIB]TY IS A V]Y DIFF]5T ?+ FROM ?AT :I* IS TO BE ATTA9$1 ACCORD+ TO ! HYPO!SIS1 ONLY BY VIOLAT+ EQUALITY ( LIB]TY4 ,=1 C]TA9LY1 TO CO]CE ! PEACEFUL NON-COOP]ATOR IS TO VIOLATE EQUALITY ( LIB]TY4 ,IF MY NEI<BOR BELIEVES 9 COOP]ATION & ,I DO NOT1 & IF HE HAS LIB]TY TO *OOSE TO COOP]ATE :ILE ,I HAVE NO LIB]TY TO *OOSE NOT TO COOP]ATE1 !N !RE IS NO EQUALITY ( LIB]TY BETWE5 US4 ,MR4 ,LEVY'S POSITION IS ANALOG\S TO ?AT ( A MAN %\LD PROPOSE TO DESPOIL C]TA9 9DIVIDUALS ( PEACEFULLY & HONE/LY ACQUIR$ WEAL? ON ! GR\ND ?AT SU* SPOLIATION IS NECESS>Y 9 ORD] ?AT WEAL? MAY BE AT ! MAXIMUM4 ,( C\RSE ,MR4 ,LEVY W\LD ANSW] TO ?IS ?AT ! HYPO!SIS IS ABSURD1 & ?AT ! MAXIMUM C\LD NOT BE SO ATTA9$2 BUT HE CLE>LY W\LD HAVE TO ADMIT1 IF PRESS$1 ?AT1 EV5 IF IT C\LD1 ! 5D IS NOT IMPORTANT 5\< TO JU/IFY SU* MEANS4 ,TO BE LOGICAL HE MU/ MAKE ! SAME ADMISSION REG>D+ HIS [N PROPOSITION47#g 8 #d7  

,BUT1 AFT] ALL1 IS ! HYPO!SIS ANY MORE ABSURD 9 ! ONE CASE ?AN 9 ! O!R8 ,I ?9K NOT4 ,IT SEEMS TO ME JU/ AS IMPOSSIBLE TO ATTA9 ! MAXIMUM ( LIB]TY BY DEPRIV+ PEOPLE ( !IR LIB]TY AS TO ATTA9 ! MAXIMUM ( WEAL? BY DEPRIV+ PEOPLE ( !IR WEAL?4 ,9 FACT1 IT SEEMS TO ME ?AT 9 BO? CASES ! MEANS IS ABSOLUTELY DE/RUCTIVE ( ! 5D4 ,MR4 ,LEVY WI%ES TO RE/RICT ! FUNCTIONS ( GOV]NM5T2 N[1 ! COMPULSORY COOP]ATION ?AT HE ADVOCATES IS ! *IEF OB/ACLE 9 ! WAY ( SU* RE/RICTION4 ,TO BE SURE1 GOV]NM5T RE/RICT$ BY ! REMOVAL ( ?IS OB/ACLE W\LD NO LONG] BE GOV]NM5T1 AS ,MR4 ,LEVY IS QUICK-WITT$ 5\< TO SEE 7TO RETURN ! COMPLIM5T :I* HE PAYS ! ,AN>*I/S74 ,BUT :AT ( ?AT8 ,IT W\LD /ILL BE A P[] = PREV5T+ ?OSE 9VASIVE ACTS :I* ! PEOPLE >E PRACTICALLY AGRE$ 9 WANT+ TO PREV5T4 ,IF IT %\LD ATTEMPT TO GO BEYOND ?IS1 IT W\LD BE PROMPTLY *ECK$ BY A DIM9UTION ( ! SUPPLIES4 ,! P[] TO CUT (F ! SUPPLIES IS ! MO/ EFFECTIVE WEAPON AGA9/ TYRANNY4 ,TO SAY1 AS ,MR4 ,LEVY DOES1 ?AT TAXATION MU/ BE COEXT5SIVE ) GOV]NM5T IS NOT ! PROP] WAY TO PUT IT4 ,IT IS GOV]NM5T 7OR1 RA!R1 ! ,/ATE7 ?AT MU/ & WILL BE COEXT5SIVE ) TAXATION4 ,:5 COMPULSORY TAXATION IS ABOLI%$1 !RE WILL BE NO ,/ATE1 & ! DEF5SIVE 9/ITUTION ?AT WILL SUCCE$ IT WILL BE /EADILY DET]R$ FROM BECOM+ AN 9VASIVE 9/ITUTION ?R\< FE> ?AT ! VOLUNT>Y CONTRIBUTIONS WILL FALL (F4 ,?IS CON/ANT MOTIVE = A VOLUNT>Y DEF5SIVE 9/ITUTION TO KEEP ITSELF TRIMM$ D[N TO ! POPUL> DEM& IS ITSELF ! BE/ POSSIBLE SAFEGU>D AGA9/ ! BUGBE> ( MULTITUD9\S RIVAL POLITICAL AG5CIES :I* SEEMS TO HAUNT ,MR4 ,LEVY4 ,HE SAYS ?AT ! VOLUNT>Y TAXATIONI/S >E VICTIMS ( AN ILLUSION4 ,! *>GE MI<T BE MADE AGA9/ HIMSELF ) MU* MORE REASON47#g 8 #e7  

,MY *IEF 9T]E/ 9 ,MR4 ,LEVY'S >TICLE1 H[EV]1 IS EXCIT$ BY HIS VALID CRITICISM ( ?OSE ,9DIVIDUALI/S :O ACCEPT VOLUNT>Y TAXATION1 BUT /OP %ORT1 OR ?9K !Y /OP %ORT1 ( ,AN>*ISM1 & ,I %ALL WAIT ) MU* CURIOSITY TO SEE :AT ,MR4 ,GREEVZ ,FI%]1 & ESPECIALLY ,MR4 ,AUB]ON ,H]B]T1 WILL HAVE TO SAY 9 REPLY47#g 8 #f7  

,ON ! :OLE1 ,AN>*I/S HAVE MORE REASON TO BE GRATEFUL TO ,MR4 ,LEVY = HIS >TICLE ?AN TO COMPLA9 ( IT4 ,IT IS AT LEA/ AN APPEAL = 9TELLECTUAL CONSI/5CY ON ?IS SUBJECT1 & AS SU* IT R5D]S UNQUE/IONABLE S]VICE TO ! CAUSE ( PLUMB-L9E ,AN>*ISM47#g 8 #g7 

,FROM 3 FAIR-USE4ORG4 

,*RONOLOGY 3 
,NOVEMB] #c1 #ahif 3 ,P>T #a1 ,*APT] #f -- ,PUBLICATION4 
,FEBRU>Y #a#i1 #bag 3 ,P>T #a1 ,*APT] #f -- ,ADD$4 

 FILE G5]AT$ FROM 3  
HTTP3_/_/REVOLTLIB4COM_/