,P>T #e1 ,*APT] #d 
,LIB]TY1 ,L& & ,LABOR 

#aihaih 

,PEOPLE 3 

,AU?OR 3 ,B5JAM9 ,R4 ,TUCK] 

,TEXT 3 

,LIB]TY1 ,L&1 & ,LABOR 

,EXC]PT$ FROM ! BOOK2  

 ,9DIVIDUAL ,LIB]TY3 ,SELECTIONS ,FROM ! ,WRIT+S ( ,B5JAM9 ,R4 ,TUCK]  

 ,VANGU>D ,PRESS1 ,NEW ,YORK1 #aibf  

 ,KRAUS ,REPR9T ,CO41 ,MILLWOOD1 ,N,Y1 #a#i#g#c4 

 ,:ILE ! ,S+LE ,TAX IS N[ R>ELY SPOK5 (1 AT ONE TIME1 DUR+ ,H5RY ,GEORGE'S ACTIVITY1 IT WAS V]Y MU* 9 ! PUBLIC EYE4 ,BUT ,GEORGE WAS 9CL9$ TO BELITTLE OR IGNORE ALL O!R FACTORS ( ! ECONOMIC PROBLEM1 SO HE FREQU5TLY RECEIV$ CAU/IC CRITICISM FROM ! $ITOR (  
,LIB]TY3  

,H]E IS A DELICI\S BIT ( LOGIC FROM ,MR4 ,GEORGE3 0,IF CAPITAL1 A M]E CREATURE ( LABOR1 IS SU* AN OPPRESSIVE ?+1 ITS CREATOR1 :5 FREE1 CAN /RANGLE IT BY REFUS+ TO REPRODUCE IT40 ,! ITALICS >E M9E4 ,IF CAPITAL IS OPPRESSIVE1 IT MU/ BE OPPRESSIVE ( LABOR4 ,:AT DIFF]5CE DOES IT MAKE1 !N1 :AT LABOR CAN DO :5 FREE8 ,! QUE/ION IS :AT IT CAN DO :5 OPPRESS$ BY CAPITAL4 ,MR4 ,GEORGE'S NEXT S5T5CE1 TO BE SURE1 9DICATES ?AT ! FRE$OM HE REF]S TO IS FRE$OM FROM L& MONOPOLY4 ,BUT ?IS DOES NOT IMPROVE HIS SITUATION4 ,HE IS 5\< ( AN ECONOMI/ TO BE V]Y WELL AW>E ?AT1 :E!R IT HAS L& OR NOT1 LABOR :I* CAN GET NO CAPITAL - ?AT IS1 :I* IS OPPRESS$ BY CAPITAL - CANNOT1 )\T ACCEPT+ ! ALT]NATIVE ( />VATION1 REFUSE TO REPRODUCE CAPITAL = ! CAPITALI/S4 

,IT IS ONE ?+ = ,MR4 ,GEORGE TO SIT 9 HIS SANCTUM & WRITE ( ! EASE ) :I* A MAN :OSE SOLE POSSESSION IS A BIT ( L& CAN BUILD A HOME & SCRAT* A LIV+2 = ! MAN TO DO IT IS :OLLY ANO!R ?+4 ,! TRU? IS ?AT ?IS MAN CAN DO NO?+ ( ! SORT UNTIL Y\ DEVISE SOME MEANS ( RAIS+ HIS WAGES ABOVE ! CO/ ( LIV+4 ,& Y\ CAN ONLY DO ?IS BY 9CREAS+ ! DEM& = HIS LABOR BY 5ABL+ MORE M5 TO GO 9TO BUS9ESS4 ,& Y\ CAN ONLY 5ABLE MORE M5 TO GO 9TO BUS9ESS BY 5ABL+ !M TO GET CAPITAL )\T 9T]E/1 :I*1 9 ,MR4 ,GEORGE'S OP9ION1 W\LD BE V]Y WRONG4 ,& Y\ CAN ONLY 5ABLE !M TO GET CAPITAL )\T 9T]E/ BY ABOLI%+ ! MONEY MONOPOLY1 :I*1 BY LIMIT+ ! SUPPLY ( MONEY1 5ABLES ITS HOLD]S TO EXACT 9T]E/4 ,& :5 Y\ HAVE ABOLI%$ ! MONEY MONOPOLY1 & :51 9 CONSEQU5CE1 ! WAGES ( ! MAN ) ! BIT QUE/ION WILL BE N9E-T5?S SOLV$4 ,= !N EI!R ?IS MAN WILL LIVE BETT] & BETT]1 OR HE WILL /EADILY LAY UP MONEY1 ) :I* HE CAN BUY TOOLS TO COMPETE ) HIS EMPLOY] OR TO TILL HIS BIT ( L& ) COM=T & ADVANTAGE4 ,9 %ORT1 HE WILL BE AN 9DEP5D5T MAN1 RECEIV+ ALL ?AT HE PRODUCES OR AN EQUIVAL5T !RE(4 ,H[ TO MAKE ?IS ! LOT ( ALL M5 IS ! LABOR QUE/ION4 ,FREE L& WILL NOT SOLVE IT4 ,FREE MONEY1 SUPPLEM5T$ BY FREE L&1 WILL4 

,9 TRY+ TO ANSW] ! >GUM5T ?AT L& IS PRACTICALLY USELESS TO LABOR UNPROVID$ ) CAPITAL1 ,H5RY ,GEORGE DECL>ES ?AT 0LABOR & L&1 EV5 9 ! ABS5CE ( SECOND>Y FACTORS OBTA9$ FROM !IR PRODUCE1 HAVE 9 !IR UNION TODAY1 AS !Y HAD 9 ! BEG9N+1 ! POT5TIALITY ( ALL ?AT MAN EV] HAS BR\<T1 OR EV] CAN BR+1 9TO BE+40 

,?IS IS P]FECTLY TRUE2 9 FACT1 NONE KN[ IT BETT] ?AN ! M5 :OM ,MR4 ,GEORGE ?US ATTEMPTS TO MEET4 

,BUT1 AS ,CAP'N ,CUTTLE WAS 9 ! HABIT ( REM>K+1 0! 'BE>9' O' ?IS ']E HOBS]WATION LIES 9 ! APPLICATION ON'T10 & 9 ITS APPLICATION IT HAS NO =CE :ATEV]4 ,MR4 ,GEORGE USES IT TO PROVE ?AT1 IF L& W]E FREE1 LABOR W\LD SETTLE ON IT1 ?US RAIS+ WAGES BY RELIEV+ ! LABOR M>KET4 

,BUT LABOR W\LD DO NO SU* ?+4 

,! FACT ?AT A LABOR]1 GIV5 A PIECE ( L&1 CAN BUILD A HUT ( MUD1 /RIKE FIRE ) FL9T & /EEL1 SCRAT* A LOG ) HIS F+]NAILS1 & ?US BEG9 LIFE AS A B>B>IAN1 EV5 ) ! HOPE ?AT 9 ! C\RSE ( A LIFETIME HE MAY SLI<TLY IMPROVE HIS CONDITION 9 CONSEQU5CE ( HAV+ FA%ION$ A FEW ( ! RUD] ( ?OSE IMPLEM5TS :I* ,MR4 ,GEORGE /YLES 0SECOND>Y FACTORS0 7& HE C\LD DO NO MORE ?AN ?IS )\T PRODUC+ = EX*ANGE1 :I* IMPLIES1 NOT ONLY BETT] MA*9]Y1 BUT AN 5TRANCE 9TO ?AT CAPITALI/IC MAEL/ROM :I* W\LD SOON] OR LAT] SWALL[ HIM UP71 - ?IS FACT1 ,I SAY1 WILL NEV] PROVE A TEMPTATION TO ! OP]ATIVE ( ! CITY1 :O1 DESPITE HIS WRET*$NESS1 KN[S SOME?+ ( ! ADVANTAGES ( CIVILIZATION & TO SOME EXT5T 9EVITABLY %>ES1 !M4 

,MAN DOES NOT LIVE BY BREAD ALONE4 

,! CITY LABOR] MAY LIVE 9 A CR[D$ T5EM5T & BREA! A TA9T$ AIR2 HE MAY SLEEP COLD1 DRESS 9 RAGS1 & FE$ ON CRUMBS2 BUT N[ & !N HE GETS A GLIMPSE AT ! MORN+ PAP]1 OR IF NOT ?AT1 !N AT ! BULLET9-BO>D2 HE MEETS HIS FELL[-M5 FACE TO FACE2 HE KN[S BY CONTACT ) ! WORLD MORE OR LESS ( :AT IS GO+ ON 9 IT2 HE SP5DS A FEW P5NIES OCCASIONALLY = A GALL]Y-TICKET TO ! !AT] OR = SOME O!R LUXURY1 EV5 ?\< HE KN[S HE 0CAN'T AF=D IT02 HE HE>S ! MUSIC ( ! /REET B&S2 HE SEES ! PICTURES 9 ! %OP W9D[S2 HE GOES TO *UR* IF HE IS PI\S1 OR IF NOT1 P]HAPS ATT5DS ! MEET+S ( ! ,ANTI-,POV]TY ,SOCIETY & LI/5S TO /UMP SPEE*ES BY ,H5RY ,GEORGE2 &1 :5 ALL !SE FAIL HIM1 HE IS 9DE$ UN=TUNATE IF SOME FELL[-LABOR] DOES NOT 9VITE HIM TO JO9 HIM 9 A SOCIAL GLASS OV] ! NE>E/ B>4 

,NOT AN IDEAL LIFE1 SURELY2 BUT HE WILL %IV] 9 HIS G>RET & SL[LY WA/E AWAY FROM 9ANITION ]E HE WILL EX*ANGE IT = ! SEMI-B>B>\S CONDITION ( ! BACKWOODSMAN )\T AN AX4 ,&1 W]E HE TO DO O!RWISE1 ,I W\LD BE ! FIR/ TO CRY3 ,! MORE FOOL HE6 

,MR4 ,GEORGE'S REM$Y IS SIMIL> - AT LEA/ = A P>T ( MANK9D - TO ?AT :I* IS ATTRIBUT$ TO ! ,NIHILI/S1 BUT :I* FEW ( !M EV] BELIEV$ 9 - NAMELY1 ! TOTAL DE/RUCTION ( ! EXI/+ SOCIAL ORD] & ! CREATION ( A NEW ONE ON ITS RU9S4 

,MR4 ,GEORGE MAY AS WELL UND]/& FIR/ AS LA/ ?AT LABOR WILL REFUSE TO BEG9 ?IS WORLD ANEW4 ,IT NEV] WILL AB&ON EV5 ITS PRES5T MEAG] 5JOYM5T ( ! WEAL? & ! MEANS ( WEAL? :I* HAVE GR[N \T ( ITS AGES ( SORR[1 SUFF]+1 & SLAV]Y4 ,IF ,MR4 ,GEORGE (F]S IT L& ALONE1 IT WILL TURN ITS BACK UPON HIM4 ,IT 9SI/S UPON BO? L& & TOOLS4 ,!SE IT WILL GET1 EI!R BY ! ,/ATE ,SOCIALI/IC ME?OD ( CONC5TRAT+ ! TITLES TO !M 9 ! H&S ( ONE VA/ MONOPOLY1 OR BY ! ,AN>*I/IC ME?OD ( ABOLI%+ ALL MONOPOLIES1 & !REBY DI/RIBUT+ !SE TITLES GRADUALLY AMONG LABOR]S ?R\< ! NATURAL *ANNELS ( FREE PRODUCTION & EX*ANGE4 

 ,MR4 ,T4 ,W4 ,CURTIS ?\<T HE DISCOV]$ 9CONSI/5CY & EXAGG]ATION 9 ! =EGO+1 & UPBRAID$ ,MR4 ,TUCK]4 ,! LATT] !N W5T 9TO ! MATT] MORE DEEPLY3  

,H5RY ,GEORGE & HIS C[ORK]S >E ( ?AT CLASS :O SPEAK 9 ! NAME ( LIB]TY1 BUT DO NOT KN[ ! MEAN+ ! WORD40 ,MR4 ,GEORGE HAS NO CONCEPTION ( LIB]TY AS A UNIV]SAL SOCIAL LAW4 ,HE HAPP5S TO SEE ?AT 9 SOME ?+S IT W\LD LEAD TO GOOD RESULTS1 & !RE=E 9 ?OSE ?+S FAVORS IT4 ,BUT IT HAS NEV] DAWN$ UPON HIS M9D ?AT DISORD] IS ! 9EVITABLE FRUIT ( EV]Y PLANT :I* HAS AU?ORITY = ITS ROOT4 ,AS ,JOHN ,F4 ,KELLY SAYS ( HIM1 0HE IS 9CL9$ TO LOOK ) FAVOR ON ! PR9CIPLE ( LAISSEZ FAIRE1 YET HE WILL AB&ON IT AT ANY MOM5T1 :5EV] REGULATION SEEMS MORE LIKELY TO PRODUCE IMM$IATE B5EFITS1 REG>DLESS ( ! EVIL !REBY PRODUC$ BY MAK+ ! PEOPLE LESS JEAL\S ( ,/ATE 9T]F]5CE40 ,! NATURE ( HIS BELIEF 9 LIB]TY IS WELL ILLU/RAT$ BY HIS ATTITUDE ON ! T>IFF QUE/ION4 ,ONE W\LD SUPPOSE FROM HIS G5]ALIZATION ?AT HE HAS ! UTMO/ FAI? 9 FRE$OM ( COMPETITION2 BUT ONE DOES NOT REALIZE H[ LITTLE ?IS FAI? AM\NTS TO UNTIL HE HE>S HIM1 AFT] MAK+ L\D FREE-TRADE PR(ESSIONS1 PROPOSE TO SUB/ITUTE A SY/EM ( B\NTIES = ! T>IFF SY/EM4 ,IF SU* POLITICAL & ECONOMIC EMPIRICISM IS NOT RUBBI% BESIDE ! COH]5T PROPOSALS ( EI!R ,AN>*ISM OR ,/ATE ,SOCIALISM1 !N ,I DON'T KN[ *AFF FROM :EAT4 

,LIB]TY1 ( C\RSE1 HAD SOME?+ TO DO ) ! WRIT+ ( 0,PROGRESS & ,POV]TY40 ,IT ALSO HAD SOME?+ TO DO ) ! FRAM+ ( DIVORCE LAWS AS RELIEF FROM 9DISSOLUBLE M>RIAGE4 ,BUT ! DIVORCE LAWS1 9/EAD ( BE+ LIB]T>IAN1 >E AN EXPRESS RECOGNITION ( ! RI<TFULNESS ( AU?ORITY OV] ! SEXUAL RELATIONS4 ,SIMIL>LY 0,PROGRESS & ,POV]TY0 EXPRESSLY RECOGNIZES ! RI<TFULNESS ( AU?ORITY OV] ! CULTIVATION & USE ( L&4 ,= SOME C5TURIES N[ EVOLUTION HAS BE5 LITTLE ELSE ?AN ! HI/ORY ( LIB]TY2 NEV]!LESS ALL ITS FACTORS HAVE NOT BE5 *ILDR5 ( LIB]TY4 

,MR4 ,CURTIS TURNS HIS ATT5TION TO ! $ITORIAL ON 0,SECOND>Y ,FACTORS40 ,HE ?9KS ?AT MY ASS]TION ?AT ,GEORGE ASKS LABOR TO 0BEG9 ?IS WORLD ANEW0 \<T TO BE BACK$ BY SOME %[ ( >GUM5T4 ,GRACI\S HEAV5S6 ,I BACK$ IT AT ! BEG9N+ ( MY >TICLE BY A QUOTATION FROM ,GEORGE HIMSELF4 ,DISLODG$ BY HIS CRITICS FROM ONE PO9T AFT] ANO!R1 ,GEORGE HAD DECL>$ ?AT 0LABOR & L&1 EV5 9 ! ABS5CE ( SECOND>Y FACTORS OBTA9$ FROM !IR PRODUCE1 HAVE 9 !IR UNION TODAY1 AS !Y HAD 9 ! BEG9N+1 ! POT5TIALITY ( ALL ?AT MAN EV] HAS BR\<T1 OR EV] CAN BR+1 9TO BE+40 ,:5 SU* WORDS AS !SE >E US$ TO PROVE ?AT1 IF L& W]E FREE1 LABOR W\LD SETTLE ON IT1 EV5 )\T SECOND>Y FACTORS1 - ?AT IS1 )\T TOOLS - :AT DO !Y MEAN EXCEPT ?AT ! LABOR] IS EXPECT$ TO 0BEG9 ?IS WORLD ANEW08 ,BUT IF ?IS IS NOT 5\< = ,MR4 ,CURTIS1 MAY ,I REF] HIM TO ! DEBATE BETWE5 ,GEORGE & ,%EWIT*1 9 :I* ! =M]1 BE+ ASK$ BY ! LATT] :AT W\LD HAVE BECOME ( ,FRIDAY IF ,CRUSOE HAD F5C$ (F HALF ! ISL& & TURN$ HIM LOOSE UPON IT )\T ANY TOOLS1 ANSW]$ ?AT ,FRIDAY W\LD HAVE MADE SOME FI%HOOKS \T ( BONES & GONE FI%+8 ,ISN'T ?AT SUFFICI5TLY PRIMITIVE TO SUB/ANTIATE MY ASS]TION1 ,MR4 ,CURTIS8 ,TELL ,MR4 ,GEORGE ?AT ! LABOR] CAN DO NO?+ )\T CAPITAL1 & HE WILL ANSW] Y\ SUB/ANTIALLY AS FOLL[S3 ,ORIG9ALLY !RE WAS NO?+ BUT A NAK$ MAN & ! NAK$ L&2 FREE ! L&1 & !N1 IF ! LABOR] HAS NO TOOLS1 HE WILL AGA9 BE A NAK$ MAN ON NAK$ L& & CAN DO ALL ?AT ,ADAM DID4 ,:5 ,I PO9T \T ?AT SU* A RETURN TO B>B>ISM IS ON A P> ) ! REM$Y ATTRIBUT$ TO ! ,NIHILI/S1 ! TOTAL DE/RUCTION ( ! EXI/+ SOCIAL ORD]1 ,MR4 ,CURTIS ASS]TS ?AT 0?IS IS WILD TALK20 BUT HIS ASS]TION1 IT SEEMS TO ME1 0\<T TO BE BACK$ BY SOME %[ ( >GUM5T40 

,HE IS SURE1 H[EV]1 ?AT !RE IS NO NE$ ( GO+ TO ! BACKWOODS4 ,!RE IS 5\< VACANT L& 9 ! NEI<BORHOOD ( CITIES1 HE ?9KS1 TO EMPLOY ! SURPLUS WORK]S1 & ?US RELIEVE ! LABOR M>KET4 ,BUT ?IS L& WILL NOT EMPLOY ANY WORK]S ?AT HAVE NO CAPITAL1 & ?OSE ?AT HAVE CAPITAL CAN GET ! L& N[4 ,?US ! OLD QUE/ION COMES BACK AGA94 ,MAKE CAPITAL FREE BY ORGANIZ+ CR$IT ON A MUTUAL PLAN1 & !N !SE VACANT L&S WILL COME TO USE1 & !N 9DU/RY WILL BE /IMULAT$1 & !N OP]ATIVES WILL BE ABLE TO BUY AXES & RAKES & HOES1 & !N !Y WILL BE 9DEP5D5T ( !IR EMPLOY]S1 & !N ! LABOR PROBLEM WILL BE SOLV$4 

,MY WOR/ (F5SE ,MR4 ,CURTIS RES]VES TILL ! LA/4 ,IT CONSI/S 9 TELL+ ! WORK+MAN ?AT HE W\LD BE A FOOL NOT TO PREF] ! /REET B&S1 ! %OP W9D[S1 ! !AT]S1 & ! *UR*ES TO A R5EWAL ( B>B>IC LIFE4 ,MR4 ,CURTIS AGA9 MISAPPREH5DS ME 9 ?9K+ ?AT ,I COMM5D ! B&S1 ! W9D[S1 ETC4 ,I SAID EXPLICITLY ?AT !RE IS NO?+ IDEAL AB\T !M4 ,BUT SOCIETY HAS COME TO BE MAN'S DE>E/ POSSESSION1 & ! ADVANTAGES & PRIVILEGES :I* ,I CIT$1 CRUDE & VULG> & BASE AS SOME ( !M >E1 REPRES5T SOCIETY TO ! OP]ATIVE4 ,HE WILL NOT GIVE !M UP1 & ,I ?9K HE IS WISE4 ,PURE AIR IS GOOD1 BUT NO ONE WANTS TO BREA! IT LONG ALONE4 ,9DEP5D5CE IS GOOD1 BUT ISOLATION IS TOO HEAVY A PRICE TO PAY = IT4 ,BO? PURE AIR & 9DEP5D5CE MU/ BE RECONCIL$ ) SOCIETY1 OR NOT MANY LABOR]S WILL EV] 5JOY !M4 ,LUCKILY !Y CAN BE & WILL BE1 ?\< NOT BY TAX+ L& VALUES4 ,AS = ! IDEA ?AT P]SONS CAN BE 9DUC$ TO BECOME B>B>IANS FROM ALTRUI/IC MOTIVES 9 SUFFICI5T NUMB]S TO AFFECT ! LABOR M>KET1 IT IS ONE ?AT ,I HAVE NO TIME TO DISCUSS4 ,9 ONE RESPECT AT LEA/ ,MR4 ,GEORGE IS PREF]ABLE TO ,MR4 ,CURTIS AS AN OPPON5T3 HE USUALLY DEALS 9 ECONOMIC >GUM5T RA!R ?AN S5TIM5TALISM4 

 ,NEXT CAME 0,EGOI/10 :O WAS PA9$ AT ! FREQU5T ATTACKS ON ,H5RY ,GEORGE1 & IT REQUIR$ A DISCUSSION ?AT CONT9U$ ?R\< SEV]AL NUMB]S (  
,LIB]TY TO ?RE% \T ALL ! PO9TS AT ISSUE3  

,MY CORRESPOND5T1 :O1 BY ! WAY1 IS A HI<LY 9TELLIG5T MAN1 & HAS A MO/ CLE> UND]/&+ ( ! MONEY QUE/ION1 %\LD PO9T \T ! TRU?S ?AT ,I HAVE D]ID$ BE=E ACCUS+ ME ( D]ID+ ANY4 ,I C]TA9LY NEV] HAVE D]ID$ ! TRU? CONTA9$ 9 ,RIC>DO'S !ORY ( R5T4 ,:AT ,I HAVE D]ID$ IS ,H5RY ,GEORGE'S PROPOSAL ?AT A MAJORITY ( ! PEOPLE %ALL SEIZE ?IS R5T BY =CE & EXP5D IT = !IR [N B5EFIT1 OR P]HAPS = :AT !Y >E PLEAS$ TO CONSID] ! B5EFIT ( ! M9ORITY4 ,I HAVE ALSO D]ID$ MANY ( ! >GUM5TS BY :I* ,MR4 ,GEORGE HAS ATTEMPT$ TO JU/IFY ?IS PROPOSAL1 MANY ( :I* HE HAS US$ 9 FAVOR ( 9T]E/ & O!R =MS ( ROBB]Y1 & HIS RIDICUL\S PRET5SE ?AT HE IS A *AMPION ( LIB]TY4 ,BUT ,I HAVE NEV] DISPUT$ ?AT1 UND] ! SY/EM ( L& MONOPOLY1 C]TA9 9DIVIDUALS GET1 9 ! =M ( R5T1 A GREAT DEAL ?AT !Y NEV] E>N$ BY !IR LABOR1 OR ?AT IT W\LD BE A GREAT BLESS+ IF SOME PLAN %\LD BE DEVIS$ & ADOPT$ :]EBY ?IS C\LD BE PREV5T$ )\T VIOLAT+ ! LIB]TY ( ! 9DIVIDUAL4 ,I AM CONV9C$1 H[EV]1 ?AT ! ABOLITION ( ! MONEY MONOPOLY1 & ! REFUSAL ( PROTECTION TO ALL L& TITLES EXCEPT ?OSE ( OCCUPI]S1 W\LD1 BY ! EMANCIPATION ( ! WORK+MAN FROM HIS PRES5T SLAV]Y TO CAPITAL1 R$UCE ?IS EVIL TO A V]Y SMALL FRACTION ( ITS PRES5T PROPORTIONS1 ESPECIALLY 9 CITIES1 & ?AT ! REMA9+ FRACTION W\LD BE ! CAUSE ( NO MORE 9EQUALITY ?AN >ISES FROM ! UNE>N$ 9CREM5T D]IV$ BY ALMO/ EV]Y 9DU/RY FROM ! AGGREGATION ( PEOPLE OR FROM ?AT UNE>N$ 9CREM5T ( SUP]IOR NATURAL ABILITY :I*1 EV5 UND] ! OP]ATION ( ! CO/ PR9CIPLE1 WILL PROBABLY ALWAYS 5ABLE SOME 9DIVIDUALS TO GET HI<] WAGES ?AN ! AV]AGE RATE4 ,9 ALL !SE CASES ! M>G9 ( DIFF]5CE WILL T5D /EADILY TO DECREASE1 BUT IT IS NOT LIKELY 9 ANY ( !M TO DISAPPE> ALTOGE!R4 ,:E!R1 AFT] ! ABOLITION ( ! ,/ATE1 VOLUNT>Y COOP]ATORS WILL RESORT TO COMMUNI/IC ME?ODS 9 ! HOPE ( BANI%+ EV5 !SE VE/IGES ( 9EQUALITY IS A QUE/ION = !IR [N FUTURE CONSID]ATION1 & HAS NO?+ :ATEV] TO DO ) ! S*EME ( ,H5RY ,GEORGE4 ,= MY P>T1 ,I %\LD BE 9CL9$ TO REG>D SU* A C\RSE AS A LEAP NOT FROM ! FRY+ PAN TO ! FIRE1 BUT FROM A ,TURKI% BA? 9TO ! NE!RMO/ HELL4 ,I TAKE NO PLEASURE 9 ATTACK+ ,MR4 ,GEORGE1 BUT %ALL PROBABLY PURSUE MY PRES5T POLICY UNTIL HE CONDESC5DS TO ANSW] & REFUTE MY >GUM5TS1 IF HE CAN1 OR GIVES SOME SATISFACTORY REASON = DECL9+ TO DO SO4 

,EGOI/'S ACQUA9TANCE ) ,LIB]TY IS ( COMP>ATIVELY REC5T DATE1 BUT IT IS H>D TO UND]/& H[ HE C\LD HAVE FAIL$ TO F9D \T FROM IT ?AT1 9 OPPOS+ ALL GOV]NM5T1 IT SO DEF9ES ! WORD AS TO EXCLUDE ! V]Y ?+ :I* ,EGOI/ CONSID]S IDEAL GOV]NM5T4 ,IT HAS BE5 /AT$ 9 !SE COLUMNS ,I KN[ NOT H[ MANY TIMES ?AT GOV]NM5T1 ,>*ISM1 9VASION1 >E US$ H]E AS EQUIVAL5T T]MS2 ?AT :OEV] 9VADES1 9DIVIDUAL OR ,/ATE1 GOV]NS & IS AN ,>*I/2 & ?AT :OEV] DEF5DS AGA9/ 9VASION1 9DIVIDUAL OR VOLUNT>Y ASSOCIATION1 OPPOSES GOV]NM5T & IS AN ,AN>*I/4 ,N[1 A VOLUNT>Y ASSOCIATION DO+ EQUITY W\LD NOT BE AN 9VAD]1 BUT A DEF5D] AGA9/ 9VASION1 & MI<T 9CLUDE 9 ITS DEF5SIVE OP]ATIONS ! PROTECTION ( ! OCCUPI]S ( L&4 ,) ?IS EXPLANATION1 DOES ,EGOI/ P]CEIVE ANY LACK ( H>MONY 9 MY /ATEM5TS8 ,ASSUM+1 !N1 PROTECTION BY SU* A ME?OD1 OCCUPI]S W\LD BE SURE1 NO MATT] H[ COVET\S O!RS MI<T BE4 ,BUT N[ ! QUE/ION RECURS3 ,:AT IS EQUITY 9 ! MATT] ( L& OCCUPANCY8 ,I ADMIT AT ONCE ?AT ! 5JOYM5T BY 9DIVIDUALS ( 9CREM5T :I* !Y DO NOT E>N IS NOT EQUITY4 ,ON ! O!R H&1 ,I 9SI/ ?AT ! CONFISCATION ( SU* 9CREM5T BY ! ,/ATE 7NOT A VOLUNT>Y ASSOCIATION7 & ITS EXP5DITURE = PUBLIC PURPOSES1 :ILE IT MI<T BE A LITTLE NE>] EQUITY PRACTICALLY 9 ?AT ! B5EFITS W\LD BE 5JOY$ 7AFT] A FA%ION7 BY A L>G] NUMB] ( P]SONS1 W\LD BE EXACTLY AS F> FROM IT !ORETICALLY1 9ASMU* AS ! 9CREM5T NO MORE BELONGS EQUALLY TO ! PUBLIC AT L>GE ?AN TO ! 9DIVIDUAL L&-HOLD]1 & W\LD /ILL BE A LONG WAY FROM IT EV5 PRACTICALLY1 = ! M9ORITY1 NOT BE+ ALL[$ TO SP5D ITS %>E ( ! 9CREM5T 9 ITS [N WAY1 W\LD BE JU/ AS TRULY ROBB$ AS IF NOT ALL[$ TO SP5D IT AT ALL4 ,A VOLUNT>Y ASSOCIATION 9 :I* ! L&-HOLD]S %\LD CONS5T TO CONTRIBUTE ! 9CREM5T TO ! ASSOCIATION'S TREASURY1 & 9 :I* ALL ! MEMB]S %\LD AGREE TO SETTLE ! ME?OD ( ITS DISPOSITION BY BALLOT1 W\LD BE EQUITABLE 5\<1 BUT W\LD BE A %ORT-SI<T$1 WA/EFUL1 & USELESS COMPLICATION4 ,A SY/EM ( OCCUPY+ [N]%IP1 H[EV]1 ACCOMPANI$ BY NO LEGAL P[] TO COLLECT R5T1 BUT C\PL$ ) ! ABOLITION ( ! ,/ATE-GU>ANTE$ MONOPOLY ( MONEY1 ?US MAK+ CAPITAL READILY AVAILABLE1 W\LD DI/RIBUTE ! 9CREM5T NATURALLY & QUIETLY AMONG ITS RI<TFUL [N]S4 ,IF IT %\LD NOT WORK P]FECT EQUITY1 IT W\LD AT LEA/ EFFECT A SUFFICI5TLY CLOSE APPROXIMATION TO IT1 & )\T TRESPASS+ AT ALL UPON ! 9DIVIDUALITIES ( ANY4 ,SPOTS >E 0*OICE0 N[ V]Y L>GELY BECAUSE ( MONOPOLY1 & ?OSE :I*1 UND] A SY/EM ( FREE L& & FREE MONEY1 %\LD /ILL REMA9 *OICE = O!R REASONS W\LD %$ !IR B5EFITS UPON ALL1 JU/ 9 ! SAME WAY ?AT *OICE C\NTRIES UND] FREE TRADE WILL1 AS ,H5RY ,GEORGE %[S1 MAKE O!R C\NTRIES MORE PROSP]\S4 ,:5 PEOPLE SEE ?AT SU* W\LD BE ! RESULT ( ?IS SY/EM1 IT IS H>DLY LIKELY ?AT MANY ( !M WILL HAVE TO BE CO]C$ 9TO AGREE+ TO IT4 ,I SEE NO PO9T TO ,EGOI/'S ANALOGY 9 ! FIR/ S5T5CE ( HIS LA/ P>AGRAPH1 UNLESS HE MEANS TO D5Y ! RI<T ( ! 9DIVIDUAL TO BECOME A BANK]4 ,A MORE P]T95T ANALOGY W\LD BE A COMP>ISON ( ! ,GEORGE S*EME = ! CONFISCATION ( R5T ) A SY/EM ( 9DIVIDUAL BANK+ ( :I* ! ,/ATE %\LD CONFISCATE ! PR(ITS4 

,UND] ! 9FLU5CE ( COMPETITION ! BE/ & *EAPE/ PROTECTOR1 LIKE ! BE/ & *EAPE/ TAILOR1 W\LD D\BTLESS GET ! GREAT] P>T ( ! BUS9ESS4 ,IT IS CONCEIVABLE EV5 ?AT HE MI<T GET ! :OLE ( IT4 ,BUT IF HE %\LD1 IT W\LD BE BY HIS VIRTUE AS A PROTECTOR1 NOT BY HIS P[] AS A TYRANT4 ,HE W\LD BE KEPT AT HIS BE/ BY ! POSSIBILITY ( COMPETITION & ! FE> ( IT2 & ! S\RCE ( P[] W\LD ALWAYS REMA91 NOT ) HIM1 BUT ) HIS PATRONS1 :O W\LD EX]CISE IT1 NOT BY VOT+ HIM D[N OR BY =CIBLY PUTT+ ANO!R 9 HIS PLACE1 BUT BY )DRAW+ !IR PATRONAGE4 ,SU* A /ATE ( ?+S1 F> FROM %[+ ! IMPOSSIBILITY ( ,AN>*Y1 W\LD BE ,AN>*Y ITSELF1 & W\LD HAVE LITTLE OR NO?+ 9 COMMON ) :AT N[ GOES BY ! NAME 0EQUITABLE DEMOCRATIC GOV]NM5T40 

,IF 0IT CAN BE %[N ?AT ! VALUE ( ! PROTECTION TO ! POSSESSION ( L& EQUALS ITS ECONOMIC R5T10 ! DEMON/RATION WILL BE 9T]E/+4 ,TO ME IT SEEMS ?AT ! MEASURE ( SU* VALUE MU/ (T5 9CLUDE MANY O!R FACTORS ?AN ECONOMIC R5T4 ,A MAN MAY [N A HOME ! ECONOMIC R5T ( :I* IS Z]O1 BUT TO :I* HE IS DEEPLY ATTA*$ BY MANY T5D] MEMORIES4 ,IS ! VALUE ( PROTECTION 9 HIS POSSESSION ( ?AT HOME Z]O8 ,BUT P]HAPS ,EGOI/ MEANS ! EX*ANGE VALUE ( PROTECTION4 ,IF SO1 ,I ANSW] ?AT1 UND] FREE COMPETITION1 ! EX*ANGE VALUE ( PROTECTION1 LIKE ! EX*ANGE VALUE ( EV]Y?+ ELSE1 W\LD BE ITS CO/1 :I* MI<T 9 ANY GIV5 CASE BE MORE OR LESS ?AN ! ECONOMIC R5T4 ,! CONDITION ( RECEIV+ PROTECTION W\LD BE ! SAME AS ! CONDITION ( RECEIV+ BEEF/EAK - NAMELY1 ABILITY & WILL+NESS TO PAY ! CO/ !RE(4 

,IF ,I AM RI<T1 ! PAYM5T ( R5T1 !N1 W\LD NOT BE AN ESS5TIAL FEATURE 9 ! CONTRACT BETWE5 ! L&-HOLD] & ! PROTECTOR4 ,IT IS CONCEIVABLE1 H[EV]1 ?\< 9 MY JUDGM5T UNLIKELY1 ?AT IT MI<T BE F\ND AN  
ADVANTAGE\S FEATURE4 ,IF SO1 PROTECTORS ADOPT+ ?AT =M ( CONTRACT W\LD DI/ANCE !IR COMPETITORS4 ,BUT IF ONE ( !SE PROTECTORS %\LD EV] SAY TO L&-HOLD]S 0,SIGN ?IS CONTRACT2 IF Y\ DO NOT1 ,I NOT ONLY WILL REFUSE Y\ PROTECTION1 BUT ,I WILL MYSELF 9VADE Y\ & ANNUALLY CONFISCATE A PORTION ( Y\R E>N+S EQUAL TO ! ECONOMIC R5T ( Y\R L&10 ,I 9CL9E TO ! OP9ION ?AT 09TELLIG5T PEOPLE0 W\LD SOON] OR LAT]1 0BY ! PROCESS ( NATURAL SELECTION10 EVOLVE 9TO ,AN>*Y BY RALLY+ >\ND !SE L&-HOLD]S = ! =MATION@& ( A NEW SOCIAL & PROTECTIVE SY/EM1 :I* W\LD SUBORD9ATE ! POOL+ ( ECONOMIC R5TS TO ! SECURITY ( EA* 9DIVIDUAL 9 ! POSSESSION ( ! RAW MAT]IALS :I* HE USES & ! DISPOSITION ( ! WEAL? :I* HE !REBY PRODUCES4 

,IF GOV]NM5T %\LD BE ABRUPTLY & 5TIRELY ABOLI%$ TOMORR[1 !RE W\LD PROBABLY 5SUE A S]IES ( PHYSICAL CONFLICTS AB\T L& & MANY O!R ?+S1 5D+ 9 REACTION & A REVIVAL ( ! OLD TYRANNY4 ,BUT IF ! ABOLITION ( GOV]NM5T %ALL TAKE PLACE GRADUALLY1 BEG9N+ ) ! D[NFALL ( ! MONEY & L& MONOPOLIES & EXT5D+ !NCE 9TO ONE FIELD AFT] ANO!R1 IT WILL BE ACCOMPANI$ BY SU* A CON/ANT ACQUISITION & /EADY SPREAD+ ( SOCIAL TRU? ?AT1 :5 ! TIME %ALL COME TO APPLY ! VOLUNT>Y PR9CIPLE 9 ! SUPPLY ( POLICE PROTECTION1 ! PEOPLE WILL RALLY AS PROMPTLY & UNIV]SALLY TO ! SUPPORT ( ! PROTECTOR :O ACTS MO/ NE>LY 9 ACCORDANCE ) ! PR9CIPLES ( SOCIAL SCI5CE AS !Y N[ RALLY TO ! SIDE ( ! ASSAULT$ MAN AGA9/ HIS W\LD-BE MURD]]4 ,9 ?AT CASE NO S]I\S CONFLICT CAN >ISE4 

,EGOI/ NEGLECTS TO CONSID] MY /ATEM5T 9 REPLY TO HIM 9 ! LA/ ISSUE ( ,LIB]TY1 TO ! EFFECT ?AT ! S\RCE ( ! PROTECTORS P[] LIES PRECISELY 9 ! PATRONAGE4 ,! PROTECTOR :O IS MO/ PATRONIZ$ WILL1 !RE=E1 BE ! /RONGE/2 & ! PEOPLE WILL 5D[ ) !IR P[] ! PROTECTOR :O IS BE/ FITT$ TO USE IT 9 ! ADM9I/RATION ( JU/ICE4 

,IF ! MASSES1 OR ANY L>GE SECTION ( !M1 AFT] HAV+ COME TO AN UND]/&+ & ACCEPTANCE ( ,AN>*ISM1 %\LD !N BE 9DUC$ BY ! SOPHI/RY ( TYRANTS TO REJECT IT AGA91 DESPOTISM W\LD RESULT4 ,?IS IS P]FECTLY TRUE4 ,NO ,AN>*I/ EV] DREAM$ ( D5Y+ IT4 ,9DE$1 ! ,AN>*I/'S ONLY HOPE LIES 9 HIS CONFID5CE ?AT PEOPLE :O HAVE ONCE 9TELLIG5TLY ACCEPT$ HIS PR9CIPLE WILL 0/AY PUT40 

,! PRES5T ,/ATE CANNOT BE AN \TGR[? ( ,AN>*Y1 BECAUSE ,AN>*Y1 9 ! PHILOSOPHIC S5SE ( ! WORD1 HAS NEV] EXI/$4 ,= ,AN>*Y1 AFT] ALL1 MEANS SOME?+ MORE ?AN ! POSSESSION ( LIB]TY4 ,JU/ AS ,RUSK9 DEF9ES WEAL? AS 0! POSSESSION ( ! VALUABLE BY ! VALIANT10 SO ,AN>*Y MAY BE DEF9$ AS ! POSSESSION ( LIB]TY BY LIB]T>IANS - ?AT IS BY ?OSE :O KN[ :AT LIB]TY MEANS4 ,! B>B>IC LIB]TY \T ( :I* ! PRES5T ,/ATE DEVELOP$ WAS NOT ,AN>*Y 9 ?IS S5SE AT ALL1 = ?OSE :O POSSESS$ IT HAD NOT ! SLI<TE/ CONCEPTION ( ITS BLESS+S OR ( ! L9E ?AT DIVIDES IT FROM TYRANNY4 

,NO?+ CAN HAVE VALUE 9 ! ABS5CE ( DEM& = IT4 ,!RE=E ! BASIS ( ! DEM& CANNOT BE IRRELEVANT 9 CONSID]+ VALUE4 ,N[1 IT IS MANIFE/ ?AT ! DEM& = PROTECTION 9 ! POSSESSION ( L& DOES NOT RE/ SOLELY UPON EXCESS ( F]TILITY OR COMM]CIAL ADVANTAGE ( SITUATION4 ,ON ! CONTR>Y1 IT RE/S1 9 AN EV]-RIS+ DEGREE & AMONG AN EV]-9CREAS+ PROPORTION ( ! PEOPLE1 UPON ! LOVE ( SECURITY & PEACE1 ! LOVE ( HOME1 ! LOVE ( BEAUTIFUL SC5]Y1 & MANY O!R :OLLY S5TIM5TAL MOTIVES4 ,9ASMU*1 !N1 AS ! /R5G? ( SOME ( ! MOTIVES = ! DEM& ( PROTECTION BE>S (T5 NO RELATION TO ECONOMIC R5T1 ! VALUE ( SU* PROTECTION IS NOT NECESS>ILY EQUAL TO ECONOMIC R5T4 ,:I* IS ! CONTR>Y ( ,EGOI/'S PROPOSITION4 

,EGOI/'S DEF9ITION ( ! RI<T ( POSSESSION ( L& RE/S ON AN ASSUMPTION :I* ,AN>*I/S D5Y1 - NAMELY1 ?AT !RE IS AN 5TITY KN[N AS ! COMMUNITY :I* IS ! RI<TFUL [N] ( ALL L&4 ,H]E WE T\* ! C5TRAL PO9T ( ! DISCUSSION4 ,H]E ,I TAKE ISSUE ) ,EGOI/1 & MA9TA9 ?AT 0! COMMUNITY0 IS A NON5TITY1 ?AT IT HAS NO EXI/5CE1 & ?AT :AT IS CALL$ ! COMMUNITY IS SIMPLY A COMB9ATION ( 9DIVIDUALS HAV+ NO PR]OGATIVES BEYOND ?OSE ( ! 9DIVIDUALS !MSELVES4 ,?IS COMB9ATION ( 9DIVIDUALS HAS NO BETT] TITLE TO ! L& ?AN ANY S+LE 9DIVIDUAL \TSIDE ( IT2 & ! >GUM5T :I* ,EGOI/ USES 9 BEHALF ( ! COMMUNITY ?IS \TSIDE 9DIVIDUAL1 IF HE BUT HAD ! /R5G? TO BACK IT UP1 MI<T CITE ) EQUAL PROPRIETY 9 HIS [N BEHALF4 ,HE MI<T SAY3 0,! RI<T ( POSSESSION ( L& CONSI/S 9 AN AGREEM5T ON MY P>T TO =EGO ! SPECIAL ADVANTAGES :I* ! USE ( SU* L& AF=DS TO AN UNDI/URB$ POSSESSOR4 ,IT REPRES5TS A GIV+-UP1 BY ME1 ( ?AT :I* ,I C\LD OBTA9 = MYSELF1 - ! CO/ TO ME BE+ C]TA9LY ?AT :I* ,I HAVE REL9QUI%$1 & EQUALS 9 VALUE ! SPECIAL ADVANTAGE :I* IS ! CAUSE ( R5T4 ,9 VIEW ( ?IS1 IT SEEMS TO ME ?AT AF=D+ ?IS PROTECTION IS TO ME AN EXP5SE EQUAL TO ! R5T40 ,& !REUPON HE MI<T PROCE$ TO COLLECT ?IS R5T FROM ! COMMUNITY AS COMP5SATION = ! PROTECTION :I* HE AF=D$ IT 9 ALL[+ IT TO OCCUPY ! L&4 ,BUT 9 HIS CASE ! SUPPOS$ CONDITION IS LACK+2 HE HAS NOT ! /R5G? NECESS>Y TO 5=CE SU* AN >GUM5T AS ?IS4 ,! COMMUNITY1 OR COMB9ATION ( 9DIVIDUALS1 HAS ?IS /R5G?4 ,ITS ONLY SUP]IORITY TO ! S+LE 9DIVIDUAL1 !N1 9 RELATION TO ! L&1 CONSI/S 9 ! RI<T ( ! /RONGE/1 - A P]FECTLY VALID RI<T1 ,I ADMIT1 BUT ONE :I*1 IF EX]CIS$1 LEADS TO S]I\S RESULTS4 ,IF ! COMMUNITY PROPOSES TO EX]CISE ITS RI<T ( ! /RONGE/1 :Y /OP ) ! COLLECTION ( ECONOMIC R5T8 ,:Y NOT MAKE ! 9DIVIDUAL ITS SLAVE \TRI<T8 ,:Y NOT /RIP HIM ( EV]Y?+ BUT ! B>E NECESSITIES ( LIFE8 ,:Y RECOGNIZE HIM AT ALL1 9 ANY WAY1 EXCEPT AS A TOOL TO BE US$ 9 ! 9T]E/ ( ! COMMUNITY8 ,9 A WORD1 :Y NOT DO PRECISELY :AT CAPITALISM IS DO+ N[1 OR ELSE :AT ,/ATE ,SOCIALISM PROPOSES TO DO :5 IT GETS CONTROL ( AFFAIRS8 ,BUT IF ! COMMUNITY DOES NOT PROPOSE TO GO TO ?IS EXTREME2 IF IT PROPOSES TO RECOGNIZE ! 9DIVIDUAL & TREAT ) HIM@a!N IT MU/ =EGO 5TIRELY ITS RI<T ( ! /RONGE/1 & BE READY TO CONTRACT ON A BASIS ( EQUALITY ( RI<TS1 BY :I* ! 9DIVIDUAL'S TITLE TO ! L& HE USES & TO :AT HE GETS \T ( IT %ALL BE HELD VALID AS AGA9/ ! WORLD4 ,!N1 IF ! 9DIVIDUAL CONS5TS TO POOL HIS R5T ) O!RS1 WELL & GOOD2 BUT1 IF NOT - :Y1 !N1 HE MU/ BE LEFT ALONE4 ,& IT WILL NOT DO = ! COMMUNITY TO TURN UPON HIM & DEM& ! ECONOMIC R5T ( HIS L& AS COMP5SATION = ! 0PROTECTION0 :I* IT AF=DS HIM 9 ?US LETT+ HIM ALONE4 ,AS WELL MI<T ! BURGL> SAY TO ! H\SEHOLD]3 0,H]E1 ,I CAN1 IF ,I *OOSE1 5T] Y\R H\SE ONE ( !SE F9E NI<TS & C>RY (F Y\R VALUABLES2 ,I !RE=E DEM& ?AT Y\ IMM$IATELY H& !M OV] TO ME AS COMP5SATION = ! SACRIFICE :I* ,I MAKE & ! PROTECTION :I* ,I AF=D Y\ 9 NOT DO+ SO40 

 ,EGOI/ ASS]T$ ?AT IT W\LD BE DIFFICULT TO %[ ?AT ! OCCUPI] ( SUP]IOR L& W\LD BE 5TITL$ TO ?AT P>T ( ! PRODUCTION FROM HIS L& ?AT W\LD BE 9 EXCESS ( :AT1 ) AN EQUAL APPLICATION ( LABOR1 C\LD BE PRODUC$ FROM 9F]IOR L&4 ,MR4 ,TUCK] REPLI$3  

,PRECISELY AS DIFFICULT AS IT W\LD BE TO %[ ?AT ! MAN ( SUP]IOR SKILL 7NATIVE1 NOT ACQUIR$7 :O PRODUCES 9 ! RATIO ( FIVE HUNDR$ TO ANO!R'S ?REE HUNDR$ IS EQUITABLY 5TITL$ TO ?IS SURPLUS EX*ANGE VALUE4 ,!RE IS NO MORE REASON :Y WE %\LD POOL ! RESULTS ( \R L&S ?AN ! RESULTS ( \R H&S4 ,& TO COMPEL SU* POOL+ IS AS M$DLESOME & TYRANNICAL 9 ONE CASE AS 9 ! O!R4 ,?AT S*OOL ( ,SOCIALI/IC ECONOMI/S :I* C>RIES ,H5RY ,GEORGE'S IDEA TO ITS CONCLUSIONS1 CONFISCAT+ NOT ONLY R5T BUT 9T]E/ & PR(IT & EQUALIZ+ WAGES1 - A S*OOL ( :I* ,G4 ,B]N>D ,%AW MAY BE TAK5 AS A TYPICAL REPRES5TATIVE1 - IS MORE LOGICAL ?AN ! S*OOL TO :I* ,MR4 ,GEORGE & ,EGOI/ BELONG1 BECAUSE IT COMPLETES ! APPLICATION ( ! TYRANNICAL PR9CIPLE4 

,! CULTIVATOR ( L& :O DOES NOT ASK PROTECTION DOES NOT EXPECT ! COMMUNITY TO SECURE HIM ! OPPORTUNITY REF]R$ TO4 ,HE SIMPLY EXPECTS ! COMMUNITY NOT TO DEPRIVE HIM ( ?IS OPPORTUNITY4 ,HE DOES NOT SAY TO ! COMMUNITY3 0,H]E6 AN 9VAD] IS TRY+ TO \/ ME FROM MY L&2 COME & HELP ME TO DRIVE HIM (F40 ,HE SAYS TO ! COMMUNITY3 0,MY RI<T TO ?IS L& IS AS GOOD AS Y\RS4 ,9 FACT IT IS BETT]1 = ,I AM ALREADY OCCUPY+ & CULTIVAT+ IT4 ,I DEM& ( Y\ SIMPLY ?AT Y\ %ALL NOT DI/URB ME4 ,IF Y\ IMPOSE C]TA9 BURD5S UPON ME BY ?REAT5+ ME ) DISPOSSESSION1 ,I1 BE+ WEAK] ?AN Y\1 MU/ ( C\RSE SUBMIT TEMPOR>ILY4 ,BUT 9 ! MEAN TIME ,I %ALL TEA* ! PR9CIPLE ( LIB]TY TO ! 9DIVIDUALS ( :I* Y\ >E COMPOS$1 & BY & BY1 :5 !Y SEE ?AT Y\ >E OPPRESS+ ME1 !Y WILL ESP\SE MY CAUSE1 & Y\R TYRANNICAL YOKE WILL SPE$ILY BE LIFT$ FROM MY NECK40 

,IF ! CO/ PR9CIPLE ( VALUE CANNOT BE REALIZ$ O!RWISE ?AN BY COMPULSION1 !N IT HAD BETT] NOT BE REALIZ$4 ,= MY P>T1 ,I DO NOT BELIEVE ?AT IT IS POSSIBLE OR HI<LY IMPORTANT TO REALIZE IT ABSOLUTELY & COMPLETELY4 ,BUT IT IS BO? POSSIBLE & HI<LY IMPORTANT TO EFFECT ITS APPROXIMATE REALIZATION4 ,SO MU* CAN BE EFFECT$ )\T COMPULSION1 - 9 FACT1 CAN ONLY BE EFFECT$ BY AT LEA/ P>TIAL ABOLITION ( COMPULSION1 - & SO MU* WILL BE SUFFICI5T4 ,BY F> ! L>G] P>T ( ! VIOLATIONS ( ! CO/ PR9CIPLE - PROBABLY N9E-T5?S - RESULT FROM >TIFICIAL1 LAW-MADE 9EQUALITIES2 ONLY A SMALL PORTION >ISE FROM NATURAL 9EQUALITIES4 ,ABOLI% ! >TIFICIAL MONOPOLIES ( MONEY & L&1 & 9T]E/1 PR(IT1 & ! R5T ( BUILD+S WILL ALMO/ 5TIRELY DISAPPE>2 GR\ND R5TS WILL NO LONG] FL[ 9TO A FEW H&S2 & PRACTICALLY ! ONLY 9EQUALITY REMA9+ WILL BE ! SLI<T DISP>ITY ( PRODUCTS DUE TO SUP]IORITY ( SOIL & SKILL4 ,EV5 ?IS DISP>ITY WILL SOON DEVELOP A T5D5CY TO DECREASE4 ,UND] ! NEW ECONOMIC CONDITIONS & 5L>G$ OPPORTUNITIES RESULT+ FROM FRE$OM ( CR$IT & L& CLASSES WILL T5D TO DISAPPE>2 GREAT CAPACITIES WILL NOT BE DEVELOP$ 9 A FEW AT ! EXP5SE ( /UNT+ ?OSE ( ! MANY2 TAL5TS WILL APPROXIMATE T[>DS EQUALITY1 ?\< !IR V>IETY WILL BE GREAT] ?AN EV]2 FRE$OM ( LOCOMOTION WILL BE VA/LY 9CREAS$2 ! TOIL]S WILL NO LONG] BE AN*OR$ 9 SU* L>GE NUMB]S 9 ! PRES5T COMM]CIAL C5T]S1 & ?US MADE SUBS]VI5T TO ! CITY L&LORDS2 T]RITORIES & RES\RCES NEV] BE=E UTILIZ$ WILL BECOME EASY ( ACCESS & DEVELOPM5T2 & UND] ALL !SE 9FLU5CES ! DISP>ITY ABOVE M5TION$ WILL DECREASE TO A M9IMUM4 ,PROBABLY IT WILL NEV] DISAPPE> 5TIRELY2 ON ! O!R H&1 IT CAN NEV] BECOME 9TOL]ABLE4 ,IT MU/ ALWAYS REMA9 A COMP>ATIVELY TRIVIAL CONSID]ATION1 C]TA9LY NEV] TO BE WEI<$ = A MOM5T 9 ! SAME SCALE ) LIB]TY4 

,IT WAS ONLY BECAUSE ,I CONCEIV$ IT \T ( ! QUE/ION ?AT ,EGOI/1 9 MA9TA9+ ?AT 0! VALUE ( PROTECTION 9 ! POSSESSION ( L& IS EQUAL TO ITS ECONOMIC R5T10 C\LD BE DISCUSS+ VALUE )\T REG>D TO ! LAW ( EQUAL LIB]TY AS A PRIOR CONDITION1 OR SOB]LY ADVOCAT+ ! EX]CISE ( ! RI<T ( MI<T REG>DLESS ( EQUITY1 ?AT ,I 9T]PRET$ HIS WORDS AS IMPLY+ A SUP]IORITY 9 EQUITY 9 ! COMMUNITY'S TITLE TO L& OV] ?AT ( ! 9DIVIDUALS SUP]IORITY O!R ?AN ?AT ( MI<T2 A SUP]IORITY1 9 %ORT1 O!R ?AN ?AT BY :I* ! HI<WAYMAN RELIEVES ! TRAVEL] ( HIS GOODS4 ,I WAS B\ND TO SUPPOSE 7& LAT] /ATEM5TS 9 HIS PRES5T LETT] SEEM TO /R5G!N ! SUPPOSITION7 ?AT HE LOOK$ UPON ! 0GIV+ UP1 BY ! COMMUNITY10 ( ITS RI<T TO L& AS ! GIV+ UP ( A SUP]IOR  
EQUITABLE RI<T2 = O!RWISE1 9 DEM&+ VALUE 9 RETURN = ?IS SACRIFICE1 HE W\LD BE COMPELL$ 9 LOGIC TO DEM&1 ON BEHALF ( A BURGL>1 VALUE 9 RETURN = ! SACRIFICE MADE 9 DECL9+ TO C>RY (F A H\SEHOLD]'S WEAL? BY /EAL?4 ,BUT ,EGOI/ REPUDIATES ?IS SUPPOSITION 7?\< HE DOES NOT FOLL[ ! LOGIC ( HIS REPUDIATION71 & ,I MU/ TAKE HIM AT HIS WORD4 ,HE ?US LAYS HIMSELF OP5 TO A RETORT :I* ,I C\LD NOT O!RWISE HAVE MADE4 ,9 HIS PREVI\S LETT] HE CRITICIZ$ ME = MAK+ S5TIM5T A FACTOR 9 ! E/IMATION ( VALUE4 ,:E!R OR NOT ?IS WAS A TRANSGRESSION1 ON MY P>T1 ( ! LIMITS ( ECONOMIC DISCUSSION1 HE C]TA9LY HAS TRANSGRESS$ !M MU* MORE S]I\SLY 9 MAK+ =CE SU* A FACTOR4 ,EX*ANGE IMPLIES LIB]TY2 :]E !RE IS NO LIB]TY !RE IS NO EX*ANGE1 BUT ONLY ROBB]Y2 & ROBB]Y IS =EIGN TO POLITICAL ECONOMY4 ,AT LEA/ ONE PO9T1 H[EV]1 IS GA9$4 ,BETWE5 ,EGOI/ & MYSELF ALL QUE/ION ( ANY SUP]IOR EQUITABLE RI<T ( ! COMMUNITY IS PUT ASIDE =EV]4 ,EQUITY NOT CONSID]$1 WE AGREE ?AT ! L& BELONGS TO ! MAN OR BODY ( M5 /RONG 5\< TO HOLD IT4 ,& = ALL PRACTICAL PURPOSES HIS DEF9ITION ( 0[N]%IP0 SUITS ME1 ?\< ,I VIEW [N]%IP LESS AS ! 0RESULT ( ! ABILITY ( ! COMMUNITY TO MA9TA9 POSSESSION0 & AN APPLICATION ( ?IS RESULT 0= ! B5EFIT ( 9DIVIDUALS10 ?AN AS A RESULT ( ! 9ABILITY ( ! COMMUNITY TO MA9TA9 ITSELF 9 PEACE & SECURITY O!RWISE ?AN BY ! RECOGNITION ( ONLY SU* RELATIONS BETWE5 MAN & WEAL? AS >E 9 H>MONY ) ! LAW ( EQUAL LIB]TY4 ,9 O!R WORDS1 [N]%IP >ISES NOT FROM SUP]IORITY ( ! COMMUNITY TO ! 9DIVIDUAL1 BUT FROM ! 9F]IORITY ( ! COMMUNITY TO ! FACTS & P[]S ( NATURE4 

 ,EGOI/ H]E /AT$ ?AT HE W\LD NOT AGREE ?AT ! RI<T ( ! /RONGE/ WILL LEAD TO S]I\S RESULTS1 EXCEPT :5 APPLI$ TO CREATE AN 9EQUITABLE RELATION BETWE5 9DIVIDUALS02 SO ,MR4 ,TUCK] REJO9$3  

,H]E WE HAVE AN ACKN[L$GM5T ( A PR9CIPLE ( EQUITY & A CONTEMPLATION ( ITS OBS]VANCE BY ! MI<TY1 :I* GOES TO SU/A9 MY ORIG9AL SUPPOSITION1 DESPITE ,EGOI/'S PROTE/4 ,IT IMPLIES AN AB&ONM5T BY ! MI<TY ( !IR RI<T ( DOM9ATION & A WILL+NESS TO CONTRACT ) ! WEAK4 ,N[1 ,I AGREE ?AT ! CONTRACTS ?US 5T]$ 9TO WILL NOT LEAD TO S]I\S RESULTS1 UNLESS !Y CREATE 9EQUITABLE RELATIONS BETWE5 9DIVIDUALS4 ,BUT ! FIR/ ( ALL EQUITIES IS NOT EQUALITY ( MAT]IAL WELL-BE+1 BUT EQUALITY ( LIB]TY2 & IF ! CONTRACT PLACES ! =M] EQUALITY BE=E ! LATT]1 IT WILL LEAD TO S]I\S RESULTS1 = IT LOGICALLY NECESSITATES ! >BITR>Y LEVEL+ ( ALL MAT]IAL 9EQUALITIES1 :E!R !SE >ISE FROM DIFF]5CES ( SOIL OR DIFF]5CES ( SKILL4 ,TO DIRECTLY 5=CE EQUALITY ( MAT]IAL WELL-BE+ IS M$DLESOME1 9VASIVE1 & (F5SIVE1 BUT TO DIRECTLY 5=CE EQUALITY ( LIB]TY IS SIMPLY PROTECTIVE & DEF5SIVE4 ,! LATT] IS NEGATIVE1 & AIMS ONLY TO PREV5T ! E/ABLI%M5T ( >TIFICIAL 9EQUALITIES2 ! =M] IS POSITIVE1 & AIMS AT DIRECT & ACTIVE ABOLITION ( NATURAL 9EQUALITIES4 ,IF ! =M] IS ! TRUE POLICY1 !N IT IS AS EQUITABLE TO 5=CE ! POOL+ ( 9T]E/1 PR(IT1 & WAGES AS ! POOL+ ( R5T4 ,IF ! LATT] IS ! TRUE POLICY1 WE HAVE ONLY TO SEE TO IT ?AT NO >TIFICIAL B>RI]S AGA9/ 9DIVIDUAL 9ITIATIVE >E CON/RUCT$4 ,UND] SU* CONDITIONS1 IF ! NATURAL 9EQUALITIES T5D TO DISAPPE>1 AS !Y SURELY WILL1 !N SO MU* ! BETT]4 

,9 SPEAK+ ( SKILL AS 09SEP>ABLY ATTA*$ TO ! 9DIVIDUAL10 ,EGOI/ SURELY DOES NOT MEAN TO >GUE ! IMPOSSIBILITY ( SEIZ+ & DI/RIBUT+ ! RESULTS ( SKILL1 = ?AT W\LD BE A RIDICUL\S CONT5TION4 ,!N HE CAN ONLY MEAN ?AT !RE IS SOME?+ SACR$ AB\T ! 9DIVIDUAL :I* ! MI<TY >E B\ND TO RESPECT4 ,BUT ?IS AGA9 IS 9CONSI/5T ) HIS !ORY ( ! RI<T ( MI<T4 ,IF ! /RONGE/ IS TO EX]CISE HIS MI<T1 !N HE NE$ /OP AT NO?+ BUT ! IMPOSSIBLE2 IF1 ON ! O!R H&1 HE CONTRACTS ) ! WEAK] ON A BASIS ( EQUAL LIB]TY1 !N BO? /RONG & WEAK MU/ BE LEFT SECURE 9 !IR POSSESSION ( ! PRODUCTS ( !IR LABOR1 :E!R AID$ BY SUP]IOR SKILL OR SUP]IOR SOIL4 

,IF ,MAL?USIANISM IS TRUE1 IT IS AS TRUE AFT] ! POOL+ ( R5T AS BE=E4 ,IF ! 5CROA*M5T ( POPULATION OV] ! LIMIT ( ! E>?'S CAPACITY IS 9EVITABLE1 !N !RE IS NO SOLUTION ( ! SOCIAL PROBLEM4 ,POOL+ ! R5T OR ORGANIZ+ CR$IT W\LD ONLY PO/PONE ! CATA/ROPHE4 ,SOON] OR LAT] ! MASSES W\LD F9D NO?+ TO %>E BUT ! CURSES ( W> RA!R ?AN ! 0BLESS+S ( PEACE10 & AT ?AT /AGE IT W\LD MATT] BUT LITTLE TO !M :E!R !Y %>$ EQUALLY OR UNEQUALLY4 

,I HOLD ?AT1 9 CASE R5T W]E TO BE NATIONALIZ$ BY =CE1 LIB]TY W\LD BE 9COMPLETE2 & LIB]TY MU/ BE COMPLETE1 :ATEV] HAPP5S4 

,I HOLD ?AT SUP]IORITY WILL ALWAYS RULE2 & IT IS ONLY :5 REAL SUP]IORITY IS KN[N & RECOGNIZ$ AS SU*1 & !RE=E ALL[$ TO HAVE ITS P]FECT WORK UNRESI/$ & UNIMP$$1 ?AT ! M9IMUM ( EVIL WILL RESULT4 ,! REALLY S]I\S RESULTS >E ?OSE ?AT FOLL[ ! ATTEMPTS ( 9F]IORITY1 MI/AK+ ITSELF = SUP]IORITY1 TO FLY 9 ! FACE ( ! REAL >TICLE4 ,9 O!R WORDS1 :5 9DIVIDUALS OR MAJORITIES1 SEE+ ?AT !Y >E /RONG] = ! TIME BE+ ?AN O!R 9DIVIDUALS OR M9ORITIES1 SUPPOSE ?AT !Y >E !RE=E /RONG] ?AN NATURAL SOCIAL LAWS & ACT 9 VIOLATION ( !M1 DISA/] IS SURE TO FOLL[4 ,!SE LAWS >E ! REALLY MI<TY1 & !Y WILL ALWAYS PREVAIL4 ,! FIR/ ( !M IS ! LAW ( EQUAL LIB]TY4 ,IT IS BY ! OBS]VANCE ( ?IS LAW1 ,I AM P]SUAD$1 RA!R ?AN BY 0AN EQUAL %>E 9 ! TRANSF]ABLE OPPORTUNITIES10 ?AT ! ULTIMATE 09TELLIG5CE ( ! PEOPLE0 WILL REMOVE 0EV]Y REASONABLE CAUSE ( COMPLA9T40 

,I F9D SO LITTLE ATTEMPT TO MEET ! V>I\S CONSID]ATIONS :I* ,I HAVE ADVANC$ ?AT ,I HAVE NOT MU* TO ADD BY WAY ( COMM5T4 ,! MONOPOLY ( M9+ GOLD AT A P>TICUL> PO9T EXI/S 9 ! PHYSICAL CON/ITUTION ( ?+S1 & A POOL+ ( ! RESULTS !RE( 7:I* W\LD BE A VIRTUAL DE/RUCTION ( ! MONOPOLY7 CAN ONLY BE DIRECTLY A*IEV$ 9 ONE ( TWO WAYS1 - MUTUAL AGREEM5T OR AN 9VASION ( LIB]TY4 ,! MONOPOLY ( 9V5TORS & AU?ORS1 ON ! CONTR>Y1 HAS NO EXI/5CE AT ALL EXCEPT BY MUTUAL AGREEM5T OR AN 9VASION ( LIB]TY4 ,IT SEEMS TO ME ! DIFF]5CE BETWE5 ! TWO IS SUFFICI5TLY CLE>4 ,EGOI/'S /ATEM5T ( ! LAW ( EQUAL LIB]TY IS SATISFACTORY4 ,/&+ UPON IT1 ,I W\LD REPEL1 BY =CE IF NECESS>Y1 ! CONFISCATOR ( R5T ON ! GR\ND ?AT HE 0TAKES A LIB]TY AT ! EXP5SE ( O!RS40 ,I HAVE NO OBJECTION TO =CIBLE MEASURES AGA9/ TRANSGRESSORS1 BUT ! QUE/ION RECURS AS TO :O >E ! TRANSGRESSORS4 ,IF ! PIECE ( L& :I* ,I AM US+ HAPP5S TO BE BETT] ?AN MY NEI<BOR'S1 ,I DO NOT CONSID] MYSELF A TRANSGRESSOR ON ?AT ACC\NT2 BUT IF MY NEI<BOR DIGS SOME ( MY POTATOES & C>RIES !M (F1 ,I C]TA9LY CONSID] HIM A TRANSGRESSOR1 EV5 ?\< HE MAY NAME HIS PLUND] ECONOMIC R5T4 ,BUT ,EGOI/1 VIEW+ ?IS CASE1 CONSID]S ME ! TRANSGRESSOR & MY NEI<BOR ! HONE/ MAN4 ,I BELIEVE ?AT $UCATION 9 LIB]TY WILL BR+ PEOPLE TO MY VIEW RA!R ?AN HIS4 ,IF IT DOESN'T1 ,I %ALL HAVE TO SUCCUMB4 ,IT IS TO BE NOT$ ?AT ,EGOI/ MAKES NO FUR!R REF]5CE TO MY >GUM5T REG>D+ SKILL4 ,I URG$ ?AT ! LEVEL+ ( 9EQUALITIES 9 L& LOGICALLY LEADS TO ! LEVEL+ ( 9EQUALITIES 9 SKILL4 ,EGOI/ REPLI$ ?AT SKILL IS 9SEP>ABLY ATTA*$ TO ! 9DIVIDUAL1 :ILE L& IS NOT4 ,I REJO9$ ?AT ! RESULTS ( SKILL >E NOT 9SEP>ABLY ATTA*$ TO ! 9DIVIDUAL1 & ?AT ! RI<T ( MI<T RECOGNIZES NO?+ SACR$ AB\T ! 9DIVIDUAL4 ,TO ?IS ,EGOI/ MAKES NO REPLY4 ,H5CE MY >GUM5T ?AT ! NATIONALIZATION ( R5T LOGICALLY 9VOLVES ! MO/ COMPLETE ,/ATE ,SOCIALISM & M9UTE REGULATION ( ! 9DIVIDUAL /&S UNASSAIL$4 

,IT HAS BE5 /AT$ & RE/AT$ 9 !SE COLUMNS1 UNTIL ,I HAVE GR[N WE>Y ( ! REIT]ATION1 ?AT VOLUNT>Y ASSOCIATION = ! PURPOSE ( PREV5T+ TRANSGRESSION ( EQUAL LIB]TY WILL BE P]FECTLY 9 KEEP+ ) ,AN>*ISM1 & WILL PROBABLY EXI/ UND] ,AN>*ISM UNTIL IT 0CO/S MORE ?AN IT COMES TO02 ?AT ! PROVISIONS ( SU* ASSOCIATIONS WILL BE EXECUT$ BY SU* AG5TS AS IT MAY SELECT 9 ACCORDANCE ) SU* ME?ODS AS IT MAY PRESCRIBE1 PROVID$ SU* ME?ODS DO NOT !MSELVES 9VOLVE A TRANSGRESSION ( ! LIB]TY ( ! 9NOC5T2 ?AT SU* ASSOCIATION WILL RE/RA9 ONLY ! CRIM9AL 7MEAN+ BY CRIM9AL ! TRANSGRESSOR ( EQUAL LIB]TY72 ?AT NON-MEMB]%IP & NONSUPPORT ( IT IS NOT A CRIM9AL ACT2 BUT ?AT SU* A C\RSE NEV]!LESS DEPRIVES ! NONMEMB] ( ANY TITLE TO ! B5EFITS ( ! ASSOCIATION1 EXCEPT SU* AS COME TO HIM 9CID5TALLY & UNAVOIDABLY4 ,IT HAS ALSO BE5 REPEAT$LY AFFIRM$ ?AT1 9 PROPOS+ TO ABOLI% ! ,/ATE1 ! ,AN>*I/S EXPRESSLY EXCLUDE FROM !IR DEF9ITION ( ! ,/ATE SU* ASSOCIATIONS AS ?AT JU/ REF]R$ TO1 & ?AT :OEV] EXCLUDES FROM HIS DEF9ITION & *AMPION%IP ( ! ,/ATE EV]Y?+ EXCEPT SU* ASSOCIATIONS HAS NO QU>REL ) ! ,AN>*I/S BEYOND A V]BAL ONE4 ,I %\LD TRU/ ?AT ! 0UND]/&+ ON !SE PO9TS0 IS N[ CLE>1 W]E IT NOT ?AT EXP]I5CE HAS CONV9C$ ME ?AT MY COMM& ( ! ,5GLI% LANGUAGE IS NOT ADEQUATE TO ! CON/RUCTION ( A F\NDATION = SU* TRU/4 

,! FACT ?AT ,EGOI/ PO9TS \T A SIMIL>ITY BETWE5 ! MONOPOLY ( A GOLD M9E & ?AT ( AN 9V5TION BY NO MEANS DE/ROYS ! DIFF]5CE BETWE5 !M :I* ,I PO9T$ \T1 - ?IS DIFF]5CE BE+ ?AT1 :]EAS 9 ! =M] CASE IT IS IMPOSSIBLE TO PREV5T OR NULLIFY ! MONOPOLY )\T RE/RICT+ ! LIB]TY ( ! MONOPOLI/1 9 ! LATT] IT IS IMPOSSIBLE TO SU/A9 IT )\T RE/RICT+ ! LIB]TY ( ! W\LD-BE COMPETITORS4 ,TO ! ,AN>*I/1 :O BELIEVES 9 ! M9IMUM ( RE/RICTION UPON LIB]TY1 ?IS DIFF]5CE IS A VITAL ONE1 - QUITE SUFFICI5T TO W>RANT HIM 9 REFUS+ TO PREV5T ! ONE :ILE REFUS+ TO SU/A9 ! O!R4 

,EGOI/ SAYS ?AT 0AN OCCUPI] IS NOT A TRANSGRESSOR ( EQUAL LIB]TY UNLESS HE CLAIMS & RECEIVES ! RI<T ( UNDI/URB$ POSSESSION )\T GIV+ AN EQUIVAL5T 9 RETURN40 ,AN>*ISM HOLDS1 ON ! CONTR>Y1 9 ACCORDANCE ) ! PR9CIPLES /AT$ AT ! \TSET ( ?IS REJO9D]1 ?AT AN OCCUPI] IS NOT A TRANSGRESSOR EV5 IF1 NOT CLAIM+ IT OR PAY+ = IT1 HE DOES RECEIVE ?IS RI<T4 

,! ASS]TION ?AT 0! DI/RIBUTION ( SKILL IS ABSOLUTELY 9DEP5D5T ( SOCIAL AGREEM5T0 IS ABSOLUTELY ]RONE\S4 ,9 PRO( ( ?IS ,I NE$ ONLY CALL ATT5TION TO ! APPR5TICE%IP REGULATIONS ( ! TRADE UNIONS & ! V>I\S $UCATIONAL SY/EMS ?AT >E OR HAVE BE5 9 VOGUE1 NOT ONLY AS EVID5CE ( :AT HAS ALREADY BE5 DONE 9 ! DIRECTION ( CONTROLL+ ! DI/RIBUTION ( SKILL1 BUT ALSO AS AN 9DICATION ( :AT MORE MAY BE DONE IF ,/ATE ,SOCIALISM EV] GETS A *ANCE TO TRY UPON HUMANITY ! 9T]E/+ EXP]IM5TS :I* IT PROPOSES4 ,ON ! O!R H&1 ! COLLECTION ( R5T BY ! COLLECTIVITY DOES NOT NECESS>ILY AFFECT ! DI/RIBUTION ( L&4 ,L& TITLES WILL REMA9 UN*ANG$ AS LONG AS ! TAX 7OR R5T7 %ALL BE PAID4 ,BUT IT DOES DI/RIBUTE ! PRODUCTS RESULT+ FROM DIFF]5CES ( L&1 & IT IS LIKEWISE POSSIBLE TO DI/RIBUTE ! PRODUCTS RESULT+ FROM DIFF]5CES ( SKILL4 ,N[ UNTIL ?IS POSITION IS OV]?R[N 7& ,I DEFY ANY ONE TO SUCCESSFULLY DISPUTE IT71 IT IS S5SELESS TO LIK5 0DISSATISFACTION ) ! DI/RIBUTION ( SKILL0 TO 0! CRY+ ( A *ILD BECAUSE IT CANNOT FLY40 ,! ABSURDITY ( ?IS ANALOGY1 9 :I* ! POSSIBILITY ( DI/RIBUT+ PRODUCTS IS IGNOR$1 W\LD HAVE BE5 APP>5T IF IT HAD BE5 IMM$IATELY FOLL[$ BY ! ADMISSION ( ?IS POSSIBILITY :I* ,EGOI/ PLACES SEV]AL P>AGRAPHS FUR!R D[N4 ,TO BE SURE1 HE DECL>ES EV5 !RE ?AT IT IS IMPOSSIBLE1 BUT ONLY 9 ! S5SE 9 :I* ,PR\DHON DECL>ES 9T]E/-BE>+ PROP]TY IMPOSSIBLE1 - ?AT ( PRODUC+ ANTI-SOCIAL RESULTS :I* EV5TUALLY KILL IT OR COMPEL ITS AB&ONM5T4 ,I CONT5D ?AT SIMIL>LY ANTI-SOCIAL RESULTS WILL FOLL[ ANY ATTEMPT TO DI/RIBUTE BY LAW ! PRODUCTS >IS+ FROM DIFF]5CES ( L&2 & ,I ASK1 AS ,I HAVE ASK$ BE=E )\T OBTA9+ AN ANSW]1 :Y ! COLLECTIVITY1 IF 9 ITS RI<T ( MI<T IT MAY SEE FIT TO DI/RIBUTE ! R5T ( L&1 MAY NOT F9D IT EQUALLY EXP$I5T TO DI/RIBUTE ! R5T ( SKILL2 :Y IT MAY NOT R$UCE ALL DIFF]5CES ( WEAL? TO AN ABSOLUTE LEVEL2 9 %ORT1 :Y IT MAY NOT CREATE ! WOR/ & MO/ COMPLETE TYRANNY ! WORLD HAS EV] KN[N8 

,9 REG>D TO ! ATTITUDE ( ,AN>*I/IC ASSOCIATIONS T[>DS R5T & ITS COLLECTION1 ,I W\LD SAY ?AT !Y MI<T1 CONSI/5TLY ) ! LAW ( EQUAL FRE$OM1 EXCEPT FROM !IR JURISDICTION :ATEV] CASES OR =MS ( TRANSGRESSION !Y %\LD NOT ?9K IT EXP$I5T TO ATTEMPT TO PREV5T4 ,!SE EXCEPTIONS W\LD PROBABLY BE DEF9$ 9 !IR CON/ITUTIONS4 ,! MEMB]S C\LD1 IF !Y SAW FIT1 EXEMPT ! ASSOCIATION FROM 5=C+ GAMBL+ DEBTS OR R5T CONTRACTS4 ,ON ! O!R H&1 AN ASSOCIATION ORGANIZ$ ON A DIFF]5T BASIS :I* %\LD 5=CE SU* DEBTS OR CONTRACTS W\LD NOT !REBY BECOME ITSELF A TRANSGRESSOR4 ,BUT ANY ASSOCIATION W\LD BE A TRANSGRESSOR :I* %\LD ATTEMPT TO PREV5T ! FULFILLM5T ( R5T CONTRACTS OR TO CONFISCATE R5T & DI/RIBUTE IT4 ,( ! ?REE POSSIBILITIES SPECIFI$ BY ,EGOI/ ! ?IRD IS ! ONLY ONE ?AT T5DS TO E/ABLI% AN >TIFICIAL 9EQUALITY2 & ?AT ! WOR/ ( ALL 9EQUALITIES1 - ! 9EQUALITY ( LIB]TY1 OR P]HAPS IT W\LD BE MORE ACCURATE TO CALL IT ! EQUALITY ( SLAV]Y4 ,! FIR/ OR SECOND W\LD AT ! WOR/ FAIL TO 5TIRELY ABOLI% NATURAL 9EQUALITIES4 

,! POSSIBILITY ( VALUABLE L& BECOM+ VACANT IS H>DLY WOR? CONSID]ATION4 ,/ILL1 IF ANY OCCUPANT ( VALUABLE L& %\LD BE FOOLI% 5\< TO QUIT IT )\T FIR/ SELL+ IT1 ! E/ATE W\LD BE LIABLE TO SEIZURE BY ! FIR/ COM]1 :O W\LD IMM$IATELY HAVE A FOOT+ SIMIL> TO ?AT ( O!R L&HOLD]S4 ,IF ?IS BE FAVORITISM1 ,I CAN ONLY SAY ?AT ! WORLD IS NOT DE/9$ TO SEE ! TIME :5 SOME ?+S WILL NOT GO BY FAVOR4 

,EGOI/'S >GUM5T ?AT FREE COMPETITION WILL T5D TO DI/RIBUTE R5T BY A READJU/M5T ( WAGES IS EXACTLY TO MY PURPOSE4 ,HAVE ,I NOT TOLD HIM FROM ! />T ?AT ,AN>*I/S WILL GLADLY WELCOME ANY T5D5CY TO EQUALITY ?R\< LIB]TY8 ,BUT ,EGOI/ SEEMS TO OBJECT TO REA*+ EQUALITY BY ?IS ROAD4 ,IT MU/ BE REA*$ BY LAW OR NOT AT ALL4 ,IF REA*$ BY COMPETITION1 0COMPETITION W\LD BE H>ASS$40 ,9 O!R WORDS1 COMPETITION W\LD H>ASS COMPETITION4 ,?IS WE>S ! ASPECT ( ANO!R ABSURDITY4 ,IT IS V]Y LIKELY ?AT COMPETITORS W\LD H>ASS COMPETITORS1 BUT COMPETITION )\T H>ASS$ COMPETITORS IS SC>CELY ?9KABLE4 ,IT IS EV5 NOT IMPROBABLE ?AT 0CLASS DI/9CTIONS0 W\LD BE DEVELOP$1 AS ,EGOI/ SAYS4 ,WORK]S W\LD F9D ! PLACES :I* !IR CAPACITIES1 CONDITIONS1 & 9CL9ATIONS QUALIFY !M TO FILL1 & W\LD ?US BE CLASSIFI$1 OR DIVID$ 9TO DI/9CT CLASSES4 ,DOES ,EGOI/ ?9K ?AT 9 SU* AN EV5T LIFE W\LD NOT BE WOR? LIV+8 ,( C\RSE ! WORDS 0H>ASS0 & 0CLASS DI/9CTION0 HAVE AN UGLY S\ND1 & COMPETITION IS DECID$LY MORE ATTRACTIVE :5 ASSOCIAT$ 9/EAD ) 0EXCEL0 & 0ORGANIZATION40 ,BUT ,AN>*I/S NEV] RECOIL FROM DISAGREEABLE T]MS4 ,ONLY !IR OPPON5TS >E TO BE FRI<T5$ BY WORDS & PHRASES4 

,FROM 3 ,FLAG4,BLACK5$4NET4 

,*RONOLOGY 3 
,NOVEMB] #c1 #aig 3 ,P>T #e1 ,*APT] #d -- ,PUBLICATION4 
,FEBRU>Y #b#b1 #bag 3 ,P>T #e1 ,*APT] #d -- ,ADD$4 

 FILE G5]AT$ FROM 3  
HTTP3_/_/REVOLTLIB4COM_/