,P>T #b1 ,9TRODUCTION ,PEOPLE 3 ,AU?OR 3 ,AUFHEB5 ,TEXT 3 ,! ,>CANE ( ,REPRODUCTIVE ,PRODUCTION ,9TRODUCTION ,ONE ( ! MA9 CONT5TIONS AT ! CORE ( ,AUTONOMI/ ,M>XISM IS ?AT ALL HUMAN ACTIVITY 9 EI!R ! SPH]E ( PRODUCTION OR 9 CIRCULATION & REPRODUCTION IS POT5TIALLY PRODUCTIVE1 ?AT IS1 CAN CONTRIBUTE TO ! VALORIZATION ( CAPITAL4 ,! WORK ( REPRODUCTION1 :I* IS ! WORK DONE ON \RSELVES & ON \R FAMILIES TO REPRODUCE \RSELVES1 REPRODUCES \R LABOR P[]1 I4E4 \R CAPACITY TO WORK = CAPITAL -- 9 ?IS S5SE1 ,AUTONOMI/ ,M>XI/ !ORI/S >GUE ?AT ! WORK ( REPRODUCTION IS PRODUCTION = CAPITAL4 ,LEOPOLD9A ,=TUNATI'S ,! ,>CANE ( ,REPRODUCTION1 PUBLI%$ 9 ,ITALY 9 #aiha & 9 ! ,U,S 9 #a#i#i#e1.<#f#b.> SEEMS TO BE ! MO/ SOPHI/ICAT$ CONTRIBUTION TO ?IS !ME SO F>4 ,:ILE REPRODUCTIVE LABOR MAY COV] ANY?+ FROM PLAY+ VIDEO GAMES1 ATT5D+ C\RSES1 GO+ TO A GYM1 WAT*+ TELEVISION1 LOOK+ = A JOB1 ETC41 9 H] PAMPHLET ,=TUNATI DEALS ) CULTURALLY SPECIFIC FEMALE ACTIVITIES \TSIDE ! SPH]E ( PRODUCTION3 H\SEWORK & PRO/ITUTION4.<#f#c.> ,=TUNATI COMES FROM A TRADITION ( ,M>XI/ FEM9ISM CONNECT$ TO ! ,AUTONOMI/ >EA4 ,ONE CAN TRACE A /UDY ( ! CONNECTION BETWE5 FEMALE WORK & CAPITAL TO #gS' ,ITALY = EXAMPLE 9 ,M>I>OSA ,DALLA ,CO/A4 ,9 H] SEM9AL WORK ,WOM5 & ! ,SUBV]SION ( ! ,COMMUNITY1 WRITT5 9 #a#i#g#a1 ,DALLA ,CO/A 'AFFIRMS444 . ! FAMILY UND] CAPITALISM IS444 A C5T] ESS5TIALLY ( SOCIAL PRODUCTION'2 & ?AT H\SEWORK IS NOT JU/ PRIVATE WORK DONE = A HUSB& & *ILDR54.<#f#d.> ,H\SEWORK IS !N AN IMPORTANT SOCIAL ACTIVITY ON :I* CAPITALI/ PRODUCTION ?RIVES4 ,H[EV]1 :ILE ,DALLA ,CO/A SAYS ?AT ACTIVITIES DONE )9 REPRODUCTION >E 'IF NOT IMM$IATELY1 !N ULTIMATELY PR(ITABLE TO ! EXPANSION444 ( ! RULE ( CAPITAL'1 ,=TUNATI ATTEMPTS ! !ORETICAL LEAP ( DEMON/RAT+ ?AT H\SEWORK DOES PRODUCE VALUE )9 A ',M>XIAN' APPROA* & TRIES TO EXPRESS ?IS VALUE-CREATION MA!MATICALLY4.<#f#e.> ,?IS IS BRAVE 9DE$1 AS ,M>X'S ANALYSIS ( CAPITAL W\LD APPE> TO %[ ?AT ?IS IS NOT ! CASE -- ?US 9 ORD] TO A*IEVE H] AIM ,=TUNATI HAS TO REVISE ,M>X'S CATEGORIES -- OR1 9 H] WORDS1 'COMB9E !M ) FEM9I/ CRITICISM' 7P4 #a7 SO ?AT !Y CAN BECOMES SUITABLE TOOLS = ?IS AIM4 ,=TUNATI'S CLAIM ?AT REPRODUCTION PRODUCES VALUE IS A *ALL5GE TO ! ,M>XI/ 'OR?ODOXY' ?AT AGREES ?AT ! WORK ( REPRODUCTION IS A PRECONDITION ( A FUTURE CREATION ( VALUE & S]VES TO KEEP ! CO/ ( LABOR P[] L[1 BUT DOES NOT ACTUALLY CREATE VALUE ITSELF4 ,9 ?IS 'OR?ODOX' VIEW ! WORK ( REPRODUCTION IS JU/ CONCRETE LABOR1 NOT AB/RACT LABOR4 ,S9CE IT IS ONLY CONCRETE & NOT AB/RACT LABOR1 ?IS LABOR DOES NOT ADD ANY FRE% VALUE BUT PRES]VES ! VALUES ( ! MEANS ( SUBSI/5CE CONSUM$ BY ! FAMILY AS ! VALUE ( LABOR P[]4 ,?IS VALUE MANIFE/S ITSELF AS ! EX*ANGE VALUE ( LABOR P[]4 ,=TUNATI'S MA9 >GUM5TS AGA9/ ?IS VIEW >E C5T]$ ON H] CONCEPT ( LABOR P[]1 :I* IS ! SPECIFIC PRODUCT ( ! WOMAN'S WORK AS A H\SEWIFE OR PRO/ITUTE3 9 FACT1 ,=TUNATI CLAIMS ?AT LABOR P[] IS1 )\T O!R SPECIFICATIONS1 'A COMMODITY LIKE ALL O!RS'1 :I* IS 'CONTA9$ )9' ! P]SON ( ! HUSB&4 ,IT IS TRUE ?AT :5 WE HIRE \RSELVES TO ! CAPITALI/1 \R SUBMISSION TAKES ! =M ( A SALE1 ! SALE ( LABOR P[]4 ,BUT1 AS WE WILL >GUE 9 DETAIL LAT]1 IT IS ALSO TRUE ?AT PRODUC+ & SELL+ LABOR P[] IS NOT LIKE PRODUC+ & SELL+ O!R COMMODITIES1 & ?IS DIFF]5CE EMBODIES ! ESS5CE ( \R CONDITION AS PROLET>IAT & DISPOSSESS$4 ,) H] ASSUMPTION ( LABOR P[] AS 'A COMMODITY LIKE ALL O!RS' ,=TUNATI ELIM9ATES ?IS IMPORTANT DIFF]5CE ON ! ONE H&1 & ON ! O!R H& %E IS ABLE TO CONCLUDE /RAI ,IF ACCORD+ TO ?IS D$UCTION H\SEWORK PRODUCES VALUE1 H[ CAN ,=TUNATI EXPLA9 ! FACT ?AT NO VALUE APPE>S AS A RESULT ( H\SEWORK8.<#f#g.> ,?IS IS BECAUSE1 %E SAYS1 9 CAPITALISM ! 9DIVIDUAL HAS BE5 'DISVE/$ ( ALL VALUE'1 DEVALU$1 I4E4 D5I$ ! PROP]TY ( BE+ A C>RI] ( VALUE AS A P]SON4 ,?IS IS A DEVALUATION 9 T]MS ( MONET>Y VALUE3 ':ILE A SLAVE OR S]F1 I4E4 AS ! PROP]TY ( ! MA/] OR ! FEUDAL LORD1 ! 9DIVIDUAL HAS A C]TA9 VALUE444 ! 9DIVIDUAL HAS NO VALUE' TODAY 7P4 #a74 ,IF ! 9DIVIDUAL CANNOT 'C>RY' ! VALUE PRODUC$ BY HIS WIFE1 ?IS VALUE DOES NOT APPE> 9 ! EX*ANGE BETWE5 LABOR P[] & CAPITAL1 & SLIPS ?R\< ! WORK] /RAI ,& ONLY :5 ! HUSB&'S LABOR P[] IS 9 ! H&S ( ! CAPITALI/1 :5 ! WORK] ACTUALLY WORKS1 DOES ?IS VALUE MANIFE/S ITSELF AS VALUE CREAT$ DUR+ PRODUCTION4 ,H\SEWORK ACCORD+ TO ?IS !ORY IS !N P>T ( ! AGGREGATE LABOR 9 SOCIETY ?AT VALORIZES CAPITAL1 BUT S9CE ! '9DIVIDUAL' IS 'DEVALU$'1 ITS CONTRIBUTION TO CAPITAL IS NOT RECOGNIZ$4 ,9 ! SAME WAY AS ,=TUNATI CLAIMS ?AT REPRODUCTION REALLY CREATES VALUE1 'BUT APPE>S O!RWISE'1 %E ASS]TS ?AT ! REAL /ATUS ( ! H\SEWIFE IS ?AT ( A WAG$ WORK]1 BUT 'APPE>S O!RWISE'4 ,9 FACT1 ,=TUNATI SAYS1 ! DIRECT RELATION BETWE5 ! WIFE & ! HUSB& HIDES A REAL RELATION ( WAGE-WORK EX*ANGE BETWE5 ! WIFE & CAPITAL1 :I* IS M$IAT$ BY ! HUSB& AS ! WOMAN'S WORK 'SUP]VISOR'4.<#f#i.> ,AL?\<1 AS WE WILL SEE BEL[1 ,=TUNATI'S >GUM5TS SEEM TO DIV]GE FROM O!R !ORETICAL ,AUTONOMI/ APPROA*ES1 IT HAS 5C\NT]$ SOME APPRECIATION )9 ! ,AUTONOMI/ >EA4 ,DALLA ,CO/A M5TIONS IT = EXAMPLE2 & ,H>RY ,CLEAV] HAS IT 9 ! READ+ LI/ = HIS ',AUTONOMI/ ,M>XISM' C\RSE4.<#g.> ,\TSIDE ! >EA ( ,AUTONOMIA1 H] PAMPHLET HAS BE5 PRAIS$ BY ,A,K DI/RIBUTION AS 'AN EXCELL5T BOOK WOR? READ+ V]Y C>EFULLY & A GOOD EXAMPLE ( IMMAN5T CRITIQUE ( ,M>X'S WORK'4.<#g#a.> ,SURELY NO READ] CAN MISS ,=TUNATI'S 9 BE+ ABLE TO DEAL ) 'COMPLEXITIES'3 9 H] PAMPHLET ! WORDS 'COMPLEX' & 'COMPLEXITY' APPE> AT LEA/ #bf TIMES4.<#g#b.> ,H] 'D5SE' /YLE1 NOTIC$ BY ,A,K DI/RIBUTION1 :I* = EXAMPLE CALLS HAV+ SEX A 'WORK ( SEXUAL REPRODUCTION ( ! MALE WORK]' IS CONSI/5T ) ?IS FASC9ATION ) 'COMPLEXITY'4 ,NO D\BT ?IS HAS 9SPIR$ AWE & RESPECT 9 H] READ]S4 ,ONE REASON = ! PRES5T CRITIQUE IS FIR/ ( ALL BECAUSE ! DISP>ITY BETWE5 ! MALE & FEMALE CONDITION 9 CAPITALI/ SOCIETY IS A REAL PROBLEM4 ,IF \R REALIZATION AS 9DIVIDUALS HAV+ 'VALUE' 9 B\RGEOIS SOCIETY IS ONLY ?R\< \R ROLES AS BUY]S & SELL]S ( COMMODITIES 7OR SPECIFICALLY AS SELL]S ( LABOR P[] & E>N]S ( A WAGE71 BE>+ & RE>+ *ILDR5 IS AN OB/ACLE TO ?IS REALIZATION4 ,AL?\< P>T ( ! TOLL ( BE+ P>5TS CAN BE %>$1 BE>+ ! *ILD CANNOT -- &1 :ATEV] H] CLASS1 ! WOMAN IS DISCRIM9AT$ AGA9/ ) RESPECT TO ! MALE 9 CAPITALISM4 ,A /UDY ( ! PROBLEM CONNECT$ TO FEMALE WORK IS !N 9T]E/+ = ITS POT5TIAL CRITICISM ( B\RGEOIS RELATIONS ( EX*ANGE -- SPECIFICALLY ( ! FRAGM5TATION ( SOCIETY 9TO B\RGEOIS 9DIVIDUALS :O RECOGNIZE EA* O!R ONLY AS BUY]S & SELL]S ( COMMODITIES4 ,=TUNATI'S WORK IS ! PRODUCT ( H] 9VOLVEM5T ) ! ',WAGES = ,H\SEWORK' MOVEM5T 9 ,ITALY 9 ! #a#i#gS4 ,?IS MOVEM5T PRODUC$ PL5TY ( RADICAL !ORY CLOSE TO ,AUTONOMIA 7SU* AS ,DALLA ,CO/A'S WORK7 & RECEIV$ ATT5TION & RESPECT FROM ,U,S ,AUTONOMI/ ,M>XISM1 ESPECIALLY ,H>RY ,CLEAV]4.<#g#c.> ,H[EV] 9 ! PRES5T CRITIQUE WE HAVE *OS5 TO DEAL ONLY ) ! P>TICUL> !ORETICAL DEVELOPM5T BY ,LEOPOLD9A ,=TUNATI & NOT ) ! WID] ISSUE ( ,WAGES = ,H\SEWORK -- A TREATM5T ?AT W\LD HAVE TO TAKE ON ! RA!R CULT-LIKE BEHAVIOR ( ! MOVEM5T ESP\S+ ?IS DEM&4 ,9 FACT1 BESIDES ! 9T]E/+ ISSUES RELAT$ TO WOM5'S CONDITION 9 \R SOCIETY1 ! PR9CIPAL FOCUS = ?IS CRITIQUE ( ,=TUNATI'S WORK IS ! SPECIFIC ISSUE ( REPRODUCTION AS 'PRODUCTIVE WORK'1 :I* ,=TUNATI %>ES ) ! BROAD] >EA ( ,AUTONOMI/ ,M>XISM4 ,9 P>TICUL>1 WE WANT TO ADDRESS ! ,AUTONOMI/ ELABORATION ( ! CONCEPT ( VALUE 9 ! PRES5T MODE ( PRODUCTION4 ,9 ?IS DISCUSSION WE WILL /RESS NOT ONLY ! SIMIL>ITIES AMONG V>I\S AU?ORS1 BUT ALSO !IR1 SOMETIMES IMPORTANT1 DIFF]5CES 9 !IR !ORETICAL POSITIONS4 ,WE WILL DISCUSS 9 P>TICUL> ! FOLL[+ ?REE PO9TS3 ! IMPORTANCE1 )9 ,AUTONOMI/ ,M>XISM1 ( DEMON/RAT+1 AT EV]Y CO/1 EV5 ) ! AID ( '=MULAS'1 ?AT ! WORK ( REPRODUCTION IS PRODUCTIVE & A CREATOR ( VALUE ! ,AUTONOMI/ CONCEPT ( ! WORK ( REPRODUCTION AS WORK :I* IS1 AS ,=TUNATI W\LD PUT IT1 'CAPITALI/ICALLY ORGANIZ$'2 I4E41 9DIRECTLY CONTROLL$ BY CAPITAL & HAV+ ! *>ACT] ( WAG$ WORK4 ! CONCEPT ( CAPITAL AS IMPOSITION ( WORK1 DISCIPL9E & REPRESSION1 & ! P>ALLEL CONCEPTION ( ! WORK+ CLASS AS ANTAGONISM AGA9/ CAPITAL4 ,9 DISCUSS+ !SE PO9TS1 WE WILL MAKE P>ALLELS & REF]5CE TO SOME ( ! MA9 AU?ORS :O WRITE1 OR WROTE1 )9 ,AUTONOMIA OR ,AUTONOMI/ ,M>XISM1 & 9 P>TICUL> ,H>RY ,CLEAV] 7,READ+ ,CAPITAL ,POLITICALLY.<#g#d.>71 ,MASSIMO ,DE ,ANGELIS 7,BEYOND ! ,TE*NOLOGICAL & ! ,SOCIAL ,P>ADIGMS3 ,A ,POLITICAL ,READ+ ( ,AB/RACT ,LABOR AS ! ,SUB/ANCE ( ,VALUE.<#g#e.>71 & ,ANTONIO ,NEGRI 7,PIPEL9E1 ,LETT]E DA ,REBIBBIA.<#g#f.>7 & ,ANTONIO ,NEGRI & ,MI*AEL ,H>DT 7,EMPIRE.<#g#g.>74 ,WE WILL MAKE CLE> ! DIFF]5CE BETWE5 !SE AU?ORS1 :O ON ! ONE SIDE %>E SOME BASIC T5ETS ( ! ,AUTONOMI/ TRADITION1 BUT ON ! O!R SIDE MAY DIV]GE ON FUNDAM5TAL PO9TS & 9 !IR UND]/&+ ( CAPITALISM4 ,9 ! FOLL[+ SECTIONS WE WILL ANALYZE ! DETAILS ( ,=TUNATI'S [N TREATM5T ( REPRODUCTION AS PRODUCTIVE WORK & H] 9ITIAL ASSUMPTIONS4 ,= SIMPLICITY'S SAKE WE ONLY DEAL ) ,=TUNATI'S APPROA* TO H\SEWORK1 & AVOID ! ISSUE ( PRO/ITUTION4.<#g#h.> ,FROM 3 ,!,AN>*I/,LIBR>Y4ORG4 ,*RONOLOGY 3 ,FEBRU>Y #a1 #bba 3 ,P>T #b1 ,9TRODUCTION -- ,ADD$4 ,FEBRU>Y #a1 #bba 3 ,P>T #b1 ,9TRODUCTION -- ,UPDAT$4 FILE G5]AT$ FROM 3 HTTP3_/_/REVOLTLIB4COM_/