,P>T #b1 ,*APT] #d ,CONSEQU5CES ( ! UNDIALECTICAL CONCEPTION ( CAPITAL AS 'JU/ IMPOSITION ( WORK' ,PEOPLE 3 ,AU?OR 3 ,AUFHEB5 ,TEXT 3 #d4 ,CONSEQU5CES ( ! UNDIALECTICAL CONCEPTION ( CAPITAL AS 'JU/ IMPOSITION ( WORK' ,WE HAVE SE5 ?AT ! ,AUTONOMI/ UND]/&+ ( CAPITAL AS 'IMPOSITION ( WORK' /RESSES ONLY ONE ASPECT ( CAPITAL1 ?AT ( DISCIPL9E1 ORGANIZATION1 DESPOTISM4 ,?IS MEANS ?AT ! O!R ASPECT ( CAPITAL1 ! FRE$OM TO EX*ANGE & [N Y\R [N VALUE 9 ! SPH]E ( CIRCULATION IS NOT SPELL$ \T4 ,?IS UNDIALECTIC APPROA* ALL[S = TWO POSSIBLE !ORETICAL UND]/&+S4 ,ONE1 CLE>LY FOLL[$ BY ,CLEAV] & ,DE ,ANGELIS1 IS ?AT ( 9CORPORAT+ ! LATT] ASPECT ( CAPITAL 9 ! FIR/1 EV5 IF !Y >E OPPOSITE4 ,9 ORD] TO =CE TWO OPPOSITE DIALECTIC ASPECTS 9TO ONE 'IMPOSITION ( WORK'1 ! CONCEPTS ?AT DESCRIBE ?IS IMPOSITION 7WORK1 COMM&1 =EMAN1 ETC47 MU/ BECOME EXTREMELY AB/RACT -- AS ?IS IS ! ONLY WAY TO GIVE ! SAME NAME TO OPPOSITE SITUATIONS6 ,= EXAMPLE1 IF WE AB/RACT 5\< ! CONCEPT ( '=EMAN'1 WE MAY >GUE ) ,DE ,ANGELIS ?AT ! M>KET IS ! '=EMAN' ( ! FREELANCE LORRY DRIV]1 9 ! SAME WAY AS A =EMAN IS = ! BLUE-COLL> WORK]4 ,?IS IS TRUE1 BUT 9 SU* AN AB/RACT WAY ?AT \R !ORY BECOMES AS USEFUL AS ,HEGEL'S NOTORI\S BLACK NIE BLACK3 IF VALUE IS PRODUC$ ANYH[2 IF ANY?+ IS PRODUCTIVE WORK2 IF ANTAGONISM IS ANY:]E2 IF ANYBODY :O IS UND] ! PRESSURE ( A =EMAN EV5 :5 HE IS NOT BECAUSE ! M>KET CAN BE CALL$ A =EMAN2 :AT DOES ALL ?IS CL>IFY OR EXPLA9 BESIDES BE+ ONLY A MORALI/IC /ATEM5T ?AT WE >E ALL 'DOM9AT$' BY CAPITAL8 ,H[EV]1 ?IS APPROA* /ILL MA9TA9S A CRITICISM ( CAPITALISM AS A :OLE & A REVOLUTION>Y ATTITUDE T[>DS B\RGEOIS RELATIONS4 ,BUT !RE IS A SECOND UND]/&+ ?AT IS POSSIBLE ONCE ! OPPOS$ ASPECTS ( CAPITAL >E NOT BO? SPELL$ \T3 ONE ?AT TAKES ONLY ONE SIDE ( ! DIALECTIC1 & CONSID]S CAPITAL JU/ 9 ITS ASPECT ( DESPOTISM1 ( 'IMPOSITION ( WORK_/ CO]CION_/ DISCIPL9E'4 ,! O!R SIDE ( CAPITAL1 B\RGEOIS FRE$OM1 :OSE EXP]I5CE IS ROOT$ 9 ! FRE$OM TO EX*ANGE1 *OOSE1 CONSUME1 ETC41 IS SIMPLY P]CEIV$ AS A =CE ?AT POT5TIALLY OPPOSES ! DESPOTISM ( CAPITAL & :I* IS POT5TIALLY LIB]ATORY4 ,NEGRI & ,H>DT SEEM TO HAVE ADOPT$ SU* A VISION ( CAPITALISM AS SIMPLY ! IMPOSITION ( A 'DISPLIPL9>Y REGIME' OV] BO? ! SPH]ES ( PRODUCTION & REPRODUCTION4.<#i#h.> ,9 ,EMPIRE !Y DESCRIBE ! PRES5T CLASS /RUGGLE AS ! ANTAGONISM BETWE5 ! SO CALL$ 'MULTITUDE'1 A MULTICULTURAL MASS ( 9DIVIDUALS1 :O WANT TO BE FREE TO 'FL['1 & A DESPOTIC P[] 7,EMPIRE1 OR 'ALL ! P[]S ( ! OLD WORLD'7 :I* TRIES TO IMPOSE 'DISCIPL9>Y' LOCAL CONDITIONS ON ! PROLET>IAT 7PP4 #b#a#b1 #b#a#c1 & #d74 ,!Y ADMIT ?AT ?IS 'FREE FL[' IS =C$ ON 'MANY' PEOPLE BY 'DIRE CIRCUM/ANCES' & ?AT ITS EFFECT 'IS H>DLY LIB]ATORY' 9 ITSELF 7P4 #b#e#c74 ,NEV]!LESS = !M IT IS ! LIB]AL SPIRIT & ! AB/RACT DESIRE = FRE$OM ?AT ?IS 'FREE FL[' REPRES5TS OR SUGGE/S ?AT :AT C\NTS3 MOBILITY 'ALWAYS EXPRESSES444 A SE>* = LIB]ATION444 ! SE>* = FRE$OM444 7P4#b#a#b2 P4 #b#e#b74 ,?US = ,NEGRI & ,H>DT MIGRATION IS 'A P[]FUL =M ( CLASS /RUGGLE' 7P4 #b#a#c74 ,YES1 PEOPLE WANT TO FL[4 ,& ! GOV]NM5TS TRY TO REGULATE !IR FL[4 ,?US FL[+ SEEMS TO BE SOME?+ 9H]5TLY SUBV]SIVE4 ,BUT PEOPLE WANT TO FL[ :]E !Y ?9K !Y CAN SELL !IR LABOR P[] DE>] OR1 SIMPLY & DESP]ATELY1 F9D ANY POSSIBILITY ( 9COME EV5 AT ! PRICE ( SELL+ !IR LABOR P[] *EAP]4.<#i#i.> ,) ! ANALYSIS ( ,DE ,ANGELIS OR ,CLEAV] PREVI\SLY DISCUSS$ 9 M9D1 WE W\LD RA!R UND]/& ?IS FL[ ( ! UNWAG$ AS IMPOSITION ( WORK \TSIDE PRODUCTION1 & NOT AS SOME?+ SUB]SIVE 9 ITSELF4 ,! FRE$OM ( ! LABOR M>KET UND]LY+ ! WORK]S' MOBILITY IS 9 FACT A CONTRADICTORY FACE ( CAPITAL1 ! O!R FACE BE+ EXPLOITATION1 X5OPHOBIC H>ASSM5T1 /ATE CONTROL1 ! DE/RUCTION ( TRADITIONAL PEASANT PRODUCTION 9 MANY >EAS ( ! WORLD BY ! M>KET ETC4 ,! SAME CONTRADICTIONS ?AT >ISE FROM ! DYNAMICS ( CAPITAL & FROM ! FRE$OM ( ! M>KET >E ?US MAT]IAL PRECONDITIONS = ! CON/ITUTION ( MOVEM5TS ( SELF-ORGANIZATION & SOLID>ITY AMONG ! DISPOSSESS$4 ,SO IT IS NOT SO MU* ! PRES5T BL9D1 R&OM1 9DIVIDUALI/ICALLY SPONTANE\S FRE$OM-TO-FL[-=-!-SAKE-(-AN-9COME ?AT HAS TO BE CELEBRAT$ AS A 'P[]FUL' EXAMPLE ( CLASS /RUGGLE4 ,RA!R WE HAVE TO CELEBRATE ! OPPOSITE3 ! R$ISCOV]Y ( A HUMAN REALITY ( DIRECT RELATIONS ?AT COMES \T NOT FROM ! FL[ 9 ITSELF BUT FROM ! /RUGGLES ( ! MIGRANTS4.<#a.> ,COH]5TLY ) !IR UNCRITICAL VIEW1 ! POLITICAL ACTION ( ! 'MULTITUDE' = ,NEGRI & ,H>DT MU/ PIVOT >\ND ! DEM& = ! RECOGNITION ( CIVIL RIANTE$ 9COME 7P4 #d#c74 ,CRUCIALLY1 = ,NEGRI ! MORAL 5TITLEM5T TO CITIZ5%IP & GU>ANTE$ 9COME LIES 9 ! FACT ?AT EA* ( US 'PRODUCES' & CONTRIBUTES ) WAG$ OR UNWAG$ 'WORK' TO ! P[] ( CAPITAL4 ,A SIMIL> DIRECTION IS TAK5 BY ,=TUNATI4 ,ON P4 #bd %E EXPLA9S ?AT B\RGEOIS FRE$OM IS ILLUSORY4 ,& %E ALWAYS USES APO/ROPHES >\ND ! WORDS 'FREE' & 'FRE$OM'4 ,WE AGREE ) ?IS1 DO WE8 ,WE AGREE BECAUSE WE KN[ ?AT \R B\RGEOIS FRE$OM IS ONE ) B\RGEOIS RELATIONS M$IAT$ BY EX*ANGE1 ?US ) \R FRAGM5TATION & ) ! OBJECTIFICATION ( \R SOCIAL RELATIONS AS VALUE & CAPITAL & ! CONSEQU5T P[] ( CAPITAL OV] US444 ,WELL1 =GET IT4 ,?IS IS NOT ! ISSUE = ,LEOPOLD9A ,=TUNATI4 ,9 FACT1 = ,=TUNATI EX*ANGE IS APP>5TLY AN EXI/5TIAL1 UNIV]SAL & AHI/ORICAL CONDITION ( HUMANITY S9CE ! PRE-CAPITALI/ PA/3 ! RELATION BETWE5 PEOPLE 9 ! PA/ WAS 9 FACT A =M ( EX*ANGE1 IF NOT ( MONEY = COMMODITIES1 ( 'WORK = WORK' 7E4G4 P4 #b#g72 & VALUE WAS ! FUNDAM5TAL MEASURE 9 HUMAN RELATIONS & A MEASURE ( HUMAN PRIORITIES 9 EV]Y =M ( SOCIETY1 S9CE AS %E SAID1 9 ! PA/ WE 'HAD VALUE' 9S(> WE W]E SLAVES1 ?US EX*ANGE VALUE4 ,VALUE AS MEASURE ( WOR?9ESS WAS A UNIV]SAL & AHI/ORICAL FEATURE ( HUMANITY6 ,ALSO1 ,=TUNATI CALLS ALL 9T]P]SONAL RELATIONS 'EX*ANGES' & CLAIMS ?AT 'EQUAL OPPORTUNITIES = EX*ANGE' 'SEEM TO (F] POT5TIALLY MORE EQUAL OPPORTUNITIES' 7:I* APPE> AS SOME?+ DESIRABLE74 ,BUT1 %E ADDS1 ?IS FRE$OM ( EX*ANGE IS OB/RUCT$ & FETT]$ BY CAPITAL AS PRODUCTION4 ,LET US LOOK AT ?IS 9 DETAIL4 ,= ,=TUNATI IT IS CAPITAL-AS-PRODUCTION ?AT %APES ! =M ( ! FAMILY & OB/RUCTS ! FREE RELATION ( EX*ANGE AMONG 9DIVIDUALS -- & IT IS ?IS 7NOT EX*ANGE67 ?AT IS ! V]Y REASON = ! FRAGM5TATION ( 9DIVIDUALS )9 CAPITALISM3 ,IT IS ?IS R$UCTION ( 9T]P]SONAL RELATION%IPS TO RELATIONS ( PRODUCTION 7I4E4 ! FAMILY7 ?AT UND]LIES ! GR[+ ISOLATION ( 9DIVIDUALS )9 CAPITALISM4 ,! 9DIVIDUAL BECOMES ISOLAT$ NOT ONLY FROM \TSIDE SOCIETY BUT ALSO FROM O!R FAMILY MEMB]S ) :OM HE_/%E HAS A RELATION BAS$ ON PRODUCTION & NOT ON ! 9DIVIDUAL HIM_/H]SELF4 7P4 #b#e7 ,CAPITALI/ PRODUCTION1 :I* IS SAID TO BE ONE ) ! MALE-WOMAN RELATION%IP 9 ! FAMILY1 NEGATIVELY AFFECTS O!R 'EX*ANGES'1 LIKE ?OSE BETWE5 GAYS1 & MAKE !IR POT5TIAL = LIB]ATION1 = AN 'ESCAPE'1 DIFFICULT OR 9 VA93 ,! DEVELOPM5T ( V>I\S ALT]NATIVE EX*ANGES 7LESBIAN1 GAY MALE1 COMMUNAL1 ETC47 SEEMS TO (F] POT5TIALLY MORE EQUAL OPPORTUNITIES = EX*ANGE1 BUT AT ! SOCIAL LEVEL ! MALE_/FEMALE RELATION%IP IS SO 9FLU5TIAL ?AT 9 PRACTICE IT IS DIFFICULT TO MODIFY OR ESCAPE FROM IT1 TO CREATE A MORE EQUAL RELATION%IP BETWE5 ?OSE EX*ANG+ 7P4 #c#d74 ,FRE$OM ( *OICE & EX*ANGE1 :I* IS ! GOOD ?+ ?AT CAPITALISM (F]S TO 'EA* 9DIVIDUAL'1 IS ILLUSORY ONLY BECAUSE ! FAMILY AS A NUCLEUS ( CAPITALI/IC PRODUCTION B9DS ! 9DIVIDUALS & LIMITS \R 'REAL OPPORTUNITY = 9DIVIDUAL RELATION%IPS' -- I4E41 LIMITS ! P]FECT$ B\RGEOIS FRE$OM BAS$ ON EX*ANGE AMONG 9DIVIDUALS3 ,?US :ILE CAPITALISM444 (F]S EA* 9DIVIDUAL GREAT FRE$OM ( *OICE ) :OM TO EX*ANGE )9 ! RELATIONS ( REPRODUCTION1 IT IS ILLUSORY1 BECAUSE . ?IS 'FRE$OM' IS MAT*$ BY M9IMAL REAL OPPORTUNITY = 9DIVIDUAL RELATIONS 7P4 #b#e74.<#a#a.> ,= ,=TUNATI !N1 'CAPITAL' AS PRODUCTION IS AN EVIL 5TITY ?AT FACES US - FAC+ CAPITAL'S & ! FAMILY'S DESPOTISM1 WE1 AS 9DIVIDUALS1 /RIVE TO DEVELOP 'ALT]NATIVE EX*ANGES' & LOOK = 'OPPORTUNT9TIES' = EX*ANGE4 ,CAPITAL WANTS TO CONTROL \R 'FREE' MOVEM5TS1 *OICES & EX*ANGES 9 ORD] TO COMPEL US TO WORK )9 AU?ORIT>IAN RELATIONS & ONE ( ! WAYS TO DO ?IS IS ?R\< ! FAMILY4 ,?IS IS :Y 'FRE$OM' 9 \R SY/EM IS ILLUSORY6 ,& ?IS IS :Y %E PUTS QUOTE M>KS R\ND ! WORD6 ,WE MAY AGREE ON ! ONE H& ?AT ! 9DIVIDUAL FRE$OM (F]$ BY CAPITALISM1 :I* IS LIB]ATORY FROM ! CON/RA9S ( ! PA/1 IS ! C>ROT ( ?IS SY/EM :OSE /ICK IS PRODUCTION -- & NONE ( US W\LD SACRIFICE \R B\RGEOIS FRE$OM TO GO BACK TO A SUFFOCAT+ ,M$IEVAL SOCIAL RELATION4 ,BUT ON ! O!R H& IF WE WANT TO MAKE A COH]5T CRITICISM ( CAPITAL AS PRODUCTION1 WE CANNOT & MU/ NOT AVOID CONSID]+ ITS ASPECT ( B\RGEOIS FRE$OM1 ! FRE$OM ( EX*ANGE1 AS AN 9TEGRAL P>T ( CAPITAL & ( ITS P[] OV] US4 ,IT IS WRONG TO SEP>ATE ! TWO ASPECTS & OPPOSE PRODUCTION TO B\RGEOIS FRE$OM1 OR ASSUME EX*ANGE AS AN AHI/ORICAL CONDITION ( LIFE4 ,=TUNATI'S /RESS ON EQUAL OPPORTUNITY = WOM5 & LACK ( EQUALITY BETWE5 M5 & WOM5 IS AMBIGU\S TOO1 S9CE H] >GUM5TS SEEM TO PIVOT ON ! RECOGNITION ( US AS 'VALUE' 9 A MORAL S5SE 9 RELATION TO \R ROLE AS VALUE OR NON-VALUE-CREAT+ = CAPITAL4.<#a#b.> ,AL?\< ADMITT+ ?AT EV]YBODY1 BO? M5 & WOM51 >E EXPLOIT$ 9 CAPITALISM1 ,=TUNATI COMPLA9S ?AT 'UND] CAPITALISM M5 & WOM5 >E NOT EXPLOIT$ EQUALLY' 7P4 #c#i71 & ?AT ! H\SEWIFE IS NOT A 'VALUE' )9 CAPITALISM3 ' UNLIKE ! MALE WORK]444 . IS POSIT$ AS NON-VALUE2 %E CANNOT OBTA9 MONEY = H] WORK1 %E RECEIVES NO WAGE 9 EX*ANGE444 %E CANNOT HOLD MONEY444' 7P4 #c#g7 ,& ?AT1 )9 ! FAMILY1 ! H\SEWIFE & H] HUSB& '5T] 9TO RELATION444 )\T EQUAL RI ,! ONE-SID$ VISION ( CAPITALISM AS PRODUCTION1 AS OPPOS$ TO ! POT5TIAL REAL OPPORTUNITY = EQUALITY & FRE$OM ( EX*ANGE1 HAS CONSEQU5CES :5 IT COMES TO ANALYZ+ 'CLASS /RUGGLE'1 AS A 'REFUSAL ( 7ANY7 WORK'1 A REFUSAL TO HAVE ANY?+ TO DO ) CAPITAL AS PRODUCTION & DESPOTISM1 BUT /ILL )9 CAPITALISM AS F> AS EX*ANGE & CONSUMPTION ( COMMODITIES >E CONC]N$4 ,9 FACT = ,=TUNATI A MAJOR DEM& AGA9/ CAPITAL IS ?AT H\SEWIVES %\LD 'BE ALL[$ TO CONSUME' 7P4 #g#f7 -- SO MAJOR ?AT1 9 ,=TUNATI'S P]CEPTION1 SU* A DEM& 'W\LD FREE EV]YONE1 NOT JU/ WOM51 FROM ! IRON LAWS ( ! PRODUCTION ( SURPLUS VALUE' 7P4 #g#f74 ,:ILE PRODUCTION IS CAPITAL1 CONSUMPTION IS SOME?+ AGA9/ PRODUCTION & AGA9/ CAPITAL68 ,PROLET>IAN %OPP+1 AS ! RECLAIM+ ( \R 'RIY 9DE$ -- BUT ONLY )9 A MOVEM5T ?AT HAS CONSCI\SLY PUT ! SAME CONCEPT ( B\RGEOIS EX*ANGE 9TO ! DU/B9 ( HI/ORY1 NOT ONE ?AT UNCRITICALLY RETA9S IT6 ,9 ,=TUNATI'S UNDIALECTIC VISION1 CAPITAL BECOMES A SUBJECT ?AT IMPOSES PRODUCTION & REPRESSION ON US1 :O >E FREE FROM CAPITAL IF WE 'REFUSE' ?IS DISCIPL9E1 IF WE /EP '\TSIDE PRODUCTION'4 ,CAPITAL TOTALLY 9CORPORATES US 9S(> AS WE >E LABOR P[] & WORK = IT1 OR WE >E TOTALLY ,AUTONOM\S FROM IT IF WE REFUSE ITS DISCIPL9E4 ,)9 A VIEW ?AT FOCUSES ON ! ASPECT ( PRODUCTION & NEGLECTS ! CONTRADICTION ( CAPITAL AS DESPOTISM & FRE$OM ( EX*ANGE1 !RE IS A RISK ( DEVELOP+ AN UNCRITICAL ATTITUDE TO :AT IS '\TSIDE' PRODUCTION & IMPOSITION ( DISCIPL9E4 ,?IS ALSO APPE>S TO BE TRUE = ,NEGRI4 ,9 ,PIPEL9E ,LETT]E DA ,REBIBBIA ,NEGRI PRAISES ! REBELLI\S ATTITUDE ( ?OSE :O 9 ! '#gS AVOID$ A JOB 9 9DU/RY TO F9D A NI*E 9 PETTY B\RGEOIS SEMI-LEGAL ACTIVITY2 & ( ?OSE :O GOT A SECOND JOB \TSIDE !IR MA9 JOB 9 9DU/RY4 ,NEGRI CALL$ ?IS A 'RE9V5TION ( DAILY LIFE' 7P4 #c#b74.<#a#d.> ,CONSI/5T ) ?IS1 9 ,EMPIRE ,NEGRI CELEBRATES 'DROPP+ \TS' & REFUSALS ( WORK DONE '9 EV]Y WAY POSSIBLE' 7P4 #b#g#d71 )\T ANY CRITICISM ( CONTEXT1 AIM1 MEAN+S OR \TCOMES ( !SE DROPP+-\TS4 ,=TUNATI TOO PRAISES EXAMPLES ( 'REFUSAL ( WORK' )\T ANY CRITICAL 9SIT A DIRECT EXPRESSION ( ! REFUSAL ( ! FEMALE H\SEWIFE TO TAKE ON ! EXTRA H\SEWORK ?AT *ILDR5 REQUIRE'4 ,A REFUSAL ( HAV+ *ILDR5 CAN HAVE MANY MEAN+S 9CLUD+ BE+ P>T ( AN ANTI-CAPITALI/ /RUGGLE1 BUT IT CAN ALSO BE ! RESULT ( ! NATURALIZATION ( B\RGEOIS RELATIONS ( EX*ANGE1 & ( ! DOM9ATION ( VALUE OV] \R LIVES3 MILLIONS ( WOM5 HAVE REFUS$ TO HAVE *ILDR5 9 ORD] TO BECOME FULL-TIME WAGE SLAVES4.<#a#e.> ,:AT IS 9T]E/+ IS ACTUALLY TO CONSID] H[ ?IS FACT IS CONTRADICTORY = CAPITAL1 & H[ !SE CONTRADICTIONS ACT )9 IT4 ,! MO/ NOTICEABLE EXAMPLE ( ,=TUNATI'S COMP>TM5TALIZ$ VISION ( 'REFUSAL ( WORK' AS /RUGGLE-AGA9/-CAPITAL-BY-DEFAULT IS ! FOLL[+3 = H] ! WAVE ( AB&ONM5T ( *ILDR5 ?AT WAS CAUS$ BY ! EMPLOYM5T ( WOM5 9 L>GE SCALE 9DU/RY IS AS AN EXAMPLE ( 'WOM5'S' 9DISCIPL9E' & !IR 'REFUSAL444 TO TAKE ON ! EXTRA H\SEWORK ?AT *ILDR5 BR+' 7P4 #a#g#a74 ,AGA9/ ,M>X :O CALL$ ?IS PH5OM5ON AN 'UNNATURAL E/RANGEM5T BETWE5 MO!R & *ILD' 7P4 #a#g#b7 %E LAUN*ES A FEM9I/ ATTACK1 S9CE IS IT NOT EGALIT>IAN TO ATTRIBUTE P>5TAL AFFECTION TO WOM5 AS 'NATURAL'3 'H]E'1 %E SAYS1 ',M>X HIMSELF IS BL9D$ BY CAPITALI/ IDEOLOGY' 7P4 #a#g#b74 ,BUT 9 H] FEM9I/ PASSION1 ,=TUNATI DOES NOT UND]/& ?AT H]E ,M>X SPEAKS AB\T A FUNDAM5TAL FEATURE ( CAPITAL AS ALI5ATION3 ! ONTOLOGICAL 9V]SION ?AT MAKES MONEY EV]Y?+ = ! B\RGEOIS 9DIVIDUAL & ! 9DIVIDUAL AS P]SON NO?+4 ,:5 ! REAL NE$ TO E>N A WAGE BECOMES MORE IMPORTANT = Y\R SURVIVAL ?AN Y\R [N *ILD1 CAPITAL HAS COMPLET$ ! ULTIMATE DIS9TEGRATION ( SOCIETY 9TO ALI5 9DIVIDUALS1 OB/ACLES TO EA* O!R'S HAPP9ESS1 SUBMITT$ TO CAPITAL AS WAGE E>N]S = ALL \R NE$S & DESIRES4 ,AGA9/ CAPITAL AS ! UNITY & OPPOSITION ( DESPOTISM & B\RGEOIS FRE$OM1 A REVOLUTION>Y MOVEM5T CAN ONLY *ALL5GE BO? PRODUCTION TOGE!R ) ! RELATIONS ( FREE EX*ANGE1 PRIVATE PROP]TY1 & ! :OLE CON/RUCTION ( \R DISPOSSESSION4 ,! PROCESS ( DEFETI%ISATION ( VALUE & CAPITAL IS ! REAL ABOLITION ( A MAT]IAL SOCIAL RELATION1 ( EX*ANGE2 & ?US ! REAL REPOSSESSION ( ! CONTROL OV] \R LIVES1 '! COMPLETE RE/ORATION ( MAN TO HIMSELF AS SOCIAL -- I4E4 HUMAN -- BE+1 A RE/ORATION :I* HAS BECOME CONSCI\S'4.<#a#f.> ,9 ! /RUGGLE DIRECT SOCIAL RELATIONS WILL NECESS>ILY ABOLI% ! M$IATION ( SOCIAL RELATIONS ?R\< M>KET RELATIONS4 ,ONLY )9 DIRECT SOCIAL RELATIONS WILL VALUE BE ABOLI%$ & ! REAL 9DIVIDUAL1 :O IS HIMSELF BECAUSE ( :O HE IS & :AT HE DOES ) ! O!RS1 & NOT BECAUSE ( :AT HE HAS 9 HIS POCKETS1 WILL BE CONFIRM$4 ,ONLY )9 DIRECT SOCIAL RELATIONS :AT ! 9DIVIDUAL WORKS T[>DS1 I4E4 ! :OLE ( HIS CONSCI\S ACTIVITY1 WILL BE ONE ) HIS RESULT4 ,& ?IS IS REAL FRE$OM1 BECAUSE IF WE DESIRE OR DISLIKE SOME?+ WE >E REALLY ABLE TO CONSCI\SLY WORK T[>DS A*IEV+ IT OR *ANG+ IT1 S9CE NO?+ WILL RULE OV] US DESPITE US & BEH9D \R BACKS4.<#a#g.> ,FROM 3 ,!,AN>*I/,LIBR>Y4ORG4 ,*RONOLOGY 3 ,FEBRU>Y #a1 #bba 3 ,P>T #b1 ,*APT] #d -- ,ADD$4 FILE G5]AT$ FROM 3 HTTP3_/_/REVOLTLIB4COM_/