,*APT] #e 
,FIVE 

#aibbaibb 

,PEOPLE 3 

,AU?OR 3 ,]RICO ,MALATE/A 

,TEXT 3 

,G,I,O,R,G,I,O3 ,WELL !N1 MY DE> MAGI/RATE1 IF ,I AM NOT MI/AK51 WE W]E TALK+ AB\T ! RI<T TO PROP]TY4 

,A,M,B,R,O,G,I,O3 ,9DE$4 ,I AM REALLY CURI\S TO HE> H[ Y\ W\LD DEF5D1 9 ! NAME ( JU/ICE & MORALS1 Y\R PROPOSALS = DESPOLIATION & ROBB]Y4 

,A SOCIETY 9 :I* NO-ONE IS SECURE 9 !IR POSSESSIONS W\LD NO LONG] BE A SOCIETY1 BUT A HORDE ( WILD BEA/S READY TO DEV\R EA* O!R4 

,G,I,O,R,G,I,O3 ,DOESN'T IT SEEM TO Y\ ?AT ?IS IS PRECISELY ! CASE ) TODAY'S SOCIETY8 

,Y\ >E ACCUS+ US ( DESPOLIATION & ROBB]Y2 BUT ON ! CONTR>Y1 ISN'T IT ! PROPRIETORS :O CONT9UALLY DESPOIL ! WORK]S & ROB !M ( ! FRUITS ( !IR LABOR8 

,A,M,B,R,O,G,I,O3 ,PROPRIETORS USE !IR GOODS 9 WAYS !Y BELIEVE = ! BE/1 & !Y HAVE ! RI<T TO DO SO1 9 ! SAME WAY ! WORK]S FREELY DISPOSE ( !IR LABOR4 ,[N]S & WORK]S CONTRACT FREELY = ! PRICE ( WORK1 & :5 ! CONTRACT IS RESPECT$ NO ONE CAN COMPLA94 

,*>ITY CAN RELIEVE ACUTE TR\BLES1 UNM]IT$ TR\BLES1 BUT RI<TS MU/ REMA9 UNT\*ABLE4 

,G,I,O,R,G,I,O3 ,BUT Y\ >E SPEAK+ ( A FREE CONTRACT6 ,! WORK] :O DOES NOT WORK CANNOT EAT1 & HIS LIB]TY RESEMBLES ?AT ( A TRAVEL]1 ASSAULT$ BY ?IEVES1 :O GIVES UP HIS PURSE = FE> ( LOS+ HIS LIFE4 

,A,M,B,R,O,G,I,O3 ,ALL RI<T2 BUT Y\ CANNOT USE ?IS TO NEGATE ! RI<T ( EA* P]SON TO DISPOSE ( !IR PROP]TY AS !Y SEE FIT4 

,G,I,O,R,G,I,O3 ,!IR PROP]TY1 !IR PROP]TY6 ,BUT DOESN'T ?IS COME AB\T BECAUSE ! L&[N]S >E ABLE TO CLAIM ?AT ! L& & ITS PRODUCE AS !IRS & ! CAPITALI/S >E ABLE TO CLAIM AS !IRS ! 9/RUM5TS ( LABOR & O!R CAPITAL CREAT$ BY HUMAN ACTIVITY8 

,A,M,B,R,O,G,I,O3 ,! LAW RECOGNIZES !IR RI<T TO IT4 

,G,I,O,R,G,I,O3 ,AH6 ,IF IT IS ONLY ! LAW1 !N EV5 A /REET ASSASS9 C\LD CLAIM ! RI<T TO ASSASS9ATE & TO ROB3 HE W\LD ONLY HAVE TO =MULATE A FEW >TICLES ( LAW ?AT RECOGNIZ$ !SE RI<TS4 ,ON ! O!R H&1 ?IS IS PRECISELY :AT ! DOM9ANT CLASS HAS ACCOMPLI%$3 IT HAS CREAT$ LAWS TO LEGITIMIZE ! USURPATIONS ?AT IT HAS ALREADY P]PETRAT$1 & HAS MADE !M A MEANS ( NEW APPROPRIATIONS4 

,IF ALL Y\R 0SUPREME PR9CIPLES0 >E BAS$ ON ! CODES ( LAW1 IT WILL BE 5\< IF TOMORR[ !RE IS A LAW DECREE+ ! ABOLITION ( PRIVATE PROP]TY1 & ?AT :I* TODAY Y\ CALL ROBB]Y & DESPOLIATION W\LD 9/ANTLY BECOME 0SUPREME PR9CIPLE04 

,A,M,B,R,O,G,I,O3 ,OH6 ,BUT ! LAW MU/ BE JU/6 ,IT MU/ CON=M TO ! PR9CIPLES ( RI<TS & MORALITY1 & %\LD NOT BE ! RESULT ( UNBRIDL$ :IMS1 OR ELSE444 

,G,I,O,R,G,I,O3 ,SO1 IT'S NOT ! LAW ?AT CREATES RI<TS1 BUT RI<TS :I* JU/IFY LAW4 ,!N BY :AT RI<T DOES ALL ! EXI/+ WEAL?1 BO? NATURAL WEAL?1 & ?AT CREAT$ BY ! WORK ( HUMANITY BELONG TO A FEW 9DIVIDUALS & GIVES !M ! RI<T ( LIFE & DEA? OV] ! MASSES ( ! UND]PRIVILEG$8 

,A,M,B,R,O,G,I,O3 ,IT IS ! RI<T ?AT EV]Y P]SON HAS1 & MU/ HAVE1 TO DISPOSE FREELY ( ! PRODUCT ( !IR ACTIVITY4 ,IT IS NATURAL TO HUMANITY1 )\T IT CIVILIZATION W\LD NOT HAVE BE5 POSSIBLE4 

,G,I,O,R,G,I,O3 ,WELL1 ,I NEV]6 ,H]E WE N[ HAVE A DEF5D] ( ! RI<TS ( LABOR4 ,BRAVO1 REALLY6 ,BUT TELL ME1 H[ COME ?OSE :O WORK >E ?OSE :O HAVE NO?+1 :ILE PROP]TY ACTUALLY BELONGS TO ?OSE :O DON'T WORK8 

,DOESN'T IT OCCUR TO Y\ ?AT ! LOGICAL \TCOME ( Y\R !ORY IS ?AT ! PRES5T PROPRIETORS >E ! ?IEVES & ?AT1 9 JU/ICE1 WE NE$ TO EXPROPRIATE !M 9 ORD] TO GIVE ! WEAL? :I* !Y HAVE USURP$ TO ITS LEGITIMATE [N]S1 ! WORK]S8 

,A,M,B,R,O,G,I,O3 ,IF !RE >E SOME PROPRIETORS :O DO NOT WORK IT IS BECAUSE !Y W]E ! FIR/ TO WORK1 !Y OR !IR ANCE/ORS1 & HAD ! M]IT TO SAVE & ! G5IUS TO MAKE !IR SAV+S BE> FRUIT4 

,G,I,O,R,G,I,O3 ,9DE$1 CAN Y\ IMAG9E A WORK]1 :O AS A RULE1 E>NS SC>CELY 5\< TO KEEP HIMSELF ALIVE1 SAV+ & PUTT+ TOGE!R SOME WEAL?6 

,Y\ KN[ V]Y WELL ?AT ! ORIG9 ( PROP]TY IS VIOL5CE1 ROBB]Y & !FT1 LEGAL OR ILLEGAL4 ,BUT1 LET'S ASSUME IF Y\ LIKE ?AT SOMEONE HAS MADE SOME ECONOMIES ( PRODUCTION 9 HIS WORK1 HIS [N P]SONAL WORK3 IF HE WANTS TO 5JOY !M LAT] ON1 :5 & H[ HE WI%ES1 ?AT IS F9E4 ,BUT ?IS VIEW ( ?+S *ANGES COMPLETELY H[EV] :5 ! PROCESS BEG9S ( MAK+ HIS SAV+S1 :AT Y\ CALL1 BE> FRUIT4 ,?IS MEANS MAK+ O!RS WORK & /EAL+ FROM !M A P>T ( :AT !Y PRODUCE2 IT MEANS HO>D+ SOME GOODS & SELL+ !M AT A PRICE HI<] ?AN !IR CO/2 IT MEANS ! >TIFICIAL CREATION ( SC>CITY 9 ORD] TO SPECULATE UPON IT2 IT MEANS TAK+ AWAY FROM O!RS !IR LIVELIHOOD D]IV$ FROM WORK+ FREELY 9 ORD] TO =CE !M TO WORK = POOR WAGES2 & MANY O!R SIMIL> ?+S :I* DO NOT CORRESPOND TO A S5SE ( JU/ICE & DEMON/RATE ?AT PROP]TY1 :5 IT DOES NOT D]IVE FROM /RAI<T=W>D & OP5 ROBB]Y1 D]IVES FROM ! WORK ( O!RS1 :I* PROPRIETORS HAVE1 9 ONE WAY OR ANO!R1 TURN$ TO !IR [N ADVANTAGE4 

,DOES IT SEEM JU/ TO Y\ ?AT A P]SON :O HAS1 7LET US CONC$E71 BY !IR WORK & !IR G5IUS PUT TOGE!R A LITTLE CAPITAL1 CAN BECAUSE ( ?IS ROB O!RS ( ! PRODUCTS ( !IR WORK1 & FUR!RMORE BEQUEA? TO ALL ! G5]ATIONS ( HIS DESC5DANTS ! RI<T TO LIVE 9 IDL5ESS ON ! BACK ( WORK]S8 

,DOES IT SEEM JU/ TO Y\ ?AT1 BECAUSE !RE HAVE BE5 A FEW LABORI\S & ?RIFTY M5 - ,I SAY ?IS TO BR+ \T Y\R POSITION - ?AT HAVE ACCUMULAT$ SOME CAPITAL1 ! GREAT MASS ( HUMANITY MU/ BE CONDEMN$ TO P]PETUAL POV]TY & BRUTALIZATION8 

,&1 ON ! O!R H&1 EV5 IF SOMEONE HAD WORK$ = !MSELVES1 ) !IR MUSCLES & !IR BRA9S )\T EXPLOIT+ ANYBODY2 EV5 IF1 AGA9/ ALL ! ODDS1 SU* A ONE HAD BE5 ABLE TO PRODUCE MU* MORE ?AN !Y NE$$ )\T ! DIRECT OR 9DIRECT COOP]ATION ( ! SOCIETY AS A :OLE1 IT DOES NOT MEAN BECAUSE ( ?IS ?AT !Y %\LD BE AU?ORIZ$ TO DO H>M TO O!RS1 TO TAKE AWAY FROM O!RS ! MEANS ( EXI/5CE4 ,IF SOMEONE BUILT A ROAD ALONG ! %ORE !Y C\LD NOT1 BECAUSE ( ?IS1 >GUE = A RI<T TO D5Y ! ACCESS ( O!RS TO ! SEA4 ,IF SOMEONE C\LD TILL & CULTIVATE ON !IR [N ALL ! SOIL ( A PROV9CE1 !Y C\LD NOT PRESUME BECAUSE ( ?IS TO />VE ALL ! 9HABITANTS ( ?AT PROV9CE4 ,IF SOMEONE HAD CREAT$ SOME NEW & P[]FUL MEANS ( PRODUCTION1 !Y W\LD NOT HAVE ! RI<T TO USE !IR 9V5TION 9 SU* A WAY AS TO SUBJECT PEOPLE TO !IR RULE & EV5 LESS ( BEQUEA?+ TO ! C\NTLESS SUCCESSIONS ( !IR DESC5DANTS ! RI<T TO DOM9ATE & EXPLOIT FUTURE G5]ATIONS4 

,BUT ,I AM LOS+ MY WAY TO SUPPOSE = A MOM5T ?AT PROPRIETORS >E WORK]S OR ! DESC5DANTS ( WORK]S6 ,W\LD Y\ LIKE ME TO TELL Y\ ! ORIG9 ( ! WEAL? ( ALL ! G5TLEM5 9 \R COMMUNITY1 BO? ( NOBLEM5 ( ANCI5T /OCK AS WELL AS ! N\VEAUX RI*ES8 

,A,M,B,R,O,G,I,O3 ,NO1 NO1 9 *>ITY1 LET'S LEAVE ASIDE P]SONAL MATT]S4 

,IF !RE >E SOME RI*ES ACQUIR$ BY D\BTFUL MEANS ?IS DOES NOT PROVIDE A REASON TO D5Y ! RI<T TO PROP]TY4 ,! PA/ IS ! PA/1 & IT'S NOT USEFUL TO DIG UP OLD PROBLEMS AGA94 

,G,I,O,R,G,I,O3 ,WE'LL LEAVE !M BURI$ IF ?AT'S :AT Y\ WANT4 ,AS F> AS ,I AM CONC]N$ IT IS NOT IMPORTANT4 ,9DIVIDUAL PROP]TY %\LD BE ABOLI%$1 NOT SO MU* BECAUSE IT HAS BE5 ACQUIR$ BY MORE OR LESS QUE/IONABLE MEANS1 AS MU* AS BECAUSE IT GRANTS ! RI<T & MEANS TO EXPLOIT ! WORK ( O!RS1 & ITS DEVELOPM5T WILL ALWAYS 5D UP MAK+ ! GREAT MASS ( PEOPLE DEP5D5T ON A FEW4 

,BUT1 BY ! WAY1 H[ CAN Y\ JU/IFY 9DIVIDUAL L&$ PROP]TY ) Y\R !ORY ( SAV+S8 ,Y\ CAN'T TELL ME ?AT ?IS WAS PRODUC$ FROM ! WORK ( ! PROPRIETORS OR ( !IR ANCE/ORS8 

,A,M,B,R,O,G,I,O3 ,Y\ SEE4 ,UNCULTIVAT$1 /]ILE L& HAS NO VALUE4 ,PEOPLE OCCUPY IT1 RECLAIM IT1 MAKE IT YIELD1 & NATURALLY HAVE A RI<T TO ITS CROPS1 :I* W\LDN'T HAVE BE5 PRODUC$ )\T !IR WORK ON ! L&4 

,G,I,O,R,G,I,O3 ,ALL RI<T3 ?IS IS ! RI<T ( ! WORK] TO ! FRUITS ( HIS [N LABOR2 BUT ?IS RI<T CEASES :5 HE CEASES TO CULTIVATE ! L&4 ,DON'T Y\ ?9K SO8 

,N[1 H[ IS IT ?AT ! PRES5T PROPRIETORS POSSESS T]RITORIES1 (T5 IMM5SE1 ?AT !Y DO NOT WORK1 HAVE NEV] WORK$ & MO/ FREQU5TLY DO NOT ALL[ O!RS TO WORK8 

,H[ IS IT ?AT L&S ?AT HAVE NEV] BE5 CULTIVAT$ >E PRIVATELY [N$8 ,:AT IS ! WORK1 :AT IS ! IMPROVEM5T :I* MAY HAVE GIV5 A DATE ( ORIG91 9 ?IS CASE1 TO PROP]TY RI<TS8 

,! TRU? IS ?AT = ! L&1 EV5 MORE = ! RE/1 ! ORIG9 ( PRIVATE PROP]TY1 IS VIOL5CE4 ,& Y\ CANNOT SUCCESSFULLY JU/IFY IT1 IF Y\ DON'T ACCEPT ! PR9CIPLE ?AT RI<T EQUALS =CE1 & 9 ?AT CASE444 HEAV5 HELP Y\ IF ONE DAY Y\ BECOME ! MO/ 5FEEBL$4 

,A,M,B,R,O,G,I,O3 ,BUT 9 %ORT1 Y\ LOSE SI<T ( SOCIAL UTILITY1 ! 9H]5T NECESSITY ( CIVIL SOCIETY4 ,)\T ! RI<T TO PROP]TY !RE W\LD BE NO SECURITY1 NO MORE ORD]LY WORK & SOCIETY W\LD DISSOLVE 9 *AOS4 

,G,I,O,R,G,I,O3 ,:AT6 ,N[ Y\ TALK ( SOCIAL UTILITY8 ,BUT :51 9 \R E>LI] CONV]SATIONS ,I ONLY CONC]N$ MYSELF ) ! DAMAGE PRODUC$ BY PRIVATE PROP]TY1 Y\ CALL$ ME BACK TO >GUM5TS AB\T AB/RACT RI<TS6 

,5\< = ?IS EV5+4 ,EXCUSE ME BUT ,I HAVE TO GO4 ,WE'LL GO 9TO IT ANO!R TIME4 

,FROM 3 ,!,AN>*I/,LIBR>Y4ORG4 

,*RONOLOGY 3 
,NOVEMB] #c1 #aiba 3 ,*APT] #e -- ,PUBLICATION4 
,M>* #a#g1 #bba 3 ,*APT] #e -- ,ADD$4 

 FILE G5]AT$ FROM 3  
HTTP3_/_/REVOLTLIB4COM_/