,AN>*Y AFT] ,LEFTISM #aiig ,PEOPLE 3 ,AU?OR 3 ,BOB ,BLACK ,SECTIONS 7,T,O,C7 3 O ,PREFACE #ia ,WORDS2 #e1#g#g#g ,*>ACT]S O ,9TRODUCTION #a1#c#b#h ,WORDS2 #h1#a#f ,*>ACT]S O ,*APT] #a 3 ,MURRAY ,BOOK*91 ,GRUMPY ,OLD ,MAN #c1#i#f#b ,WORDS2 #b#f1#a#e#i ,*>ACT]S O ,*APT] #b 3 ,:AT IS ,9DIVIDUALI/ ,AN>*ISM8 #e1#a#g#h ,WORDS2 #c#e1#a#b#i ,*>ACT]S O ,*APT] #c 3 ,LIFE/YLE ,AN>*ISM #b1#f#d#d ,WORDS2 #a#g1#i#e#a ,*>ACT]S O ,*APT] #d 3 ,ON ,ORGANIZATION #d1#c#e#g ,WORDS2 #b#i1#f#g#a ,*>ACT]S O ,*APT] #e 3 ,MURRAY ,BOOK*91 ,MUNICIPAL ,/ATI/ #c1#c#e#e ,WORDS2 #b#b1#a#i#f ,*>ACT]S O ,*APT] #f 3 ,REASON & ,REVOLUTION #d1#d#f#b ,WORDS2 #b#i1#h#i#h ,*>ACT]S O ,*APT] #g 3 ,9 ,SE>* ( ! ,PRIMITIVI/S ,P>T ,I3 ,PRI/9E ,ANGLES #e1#e#g#f ,WORDS2 #c#g1#f#i ,*>ACT]S O ,*APT] #h 3 ,9 ,SE>* ( ! ,PRIMITIVI/S ,P>T ,I,I3 ,PRIMITIVE ,AFFLU5CE #b1#a#g ,WORDS2 #a#d1#b#e ,*>ACT]S O ,*APT] #i 3 ,FROM ,PRIMITIVE ,AFFLU5CE TO ,LABOR-,5SLAV+ ,TE*NOLOGY #b1#c#c#h ,WORDS2 #a#e1#c#c#d ,*>ACT]S O ,*APT] #a 3 ,%UT ,UP1 ,M>XI/6 #eac ,WORDS2 #c1#c#i ,*>ACT]S O ,*APT] #aa 3 ,AN>*Y ,AFT] ,LEFTISM #c1#a#e#d ,WORDS2 #b1#d#c#c ,*>ACT]S O ,REF]5CES #c1#d#b ,WORDS2 #b#h1#c#f#b ,*>ACT]S ,SECTIONS 7,CONT5T7 3 O ,PREFACE ,PREFACE ,LEAV+ ! TW5TIE? C5TURY1 LEFTISM ( EV]Y /RIPE IS 9 DIS>RAY & DEFEAT -- AN>*O-LEFTISM 9CLUD$4 ,& ,MURRAY ,BOOK*9'S ,SOCIAL ,ECOLOGY IS C]TA9LY NO EXCEPTION TO ?IS TR5D4 ,BOOK*91 ONE ( ! BE/ KN[N ( CONTEMPOR>Y ,NOR? ,AM]ICAN AN>*I/S1 HAS SP5T MU* ( HIS LIFE /AK+ \T HIS [N P]SONAL ECO-AN>*I/ IDEOLOGICAL T]RITORY UND] ! BANN]S ( ,SOCIAL ,ECOLOGY & ,LIB]T>IAN ,MUNICIPALISM4 ,HE IS ! AU?OR ( A /EADY /REAM ( BOOKS FROM ! SIXTIES TO ! PRES5T1 9CLUD+ HIS CLASSIC COLLECTION ( ESSAYS TITL$ ,PO/-,SC>CITY ,AN>*ISM PUBLI%$ 9 #a#i#g#a1 HIS EXCELL5T VOLUME ON ! HI/ORY ( ! ,SPANI% AN>*I/ MOVEM5T WRITT5 9 ! SEV5TIES1 & HIS FAIL$ ATTEMPT 9 ! EI*OS J\RNAL GR\P 9 ! ,NEW ,YORK ( ! SIXTIES TO ! REC5T ,LEFT ,GRE5 ,NETWORK )9 ! ,GRE5S MILIEU7 HAVE NEV] MET ) MU* SUCCESS4 ,9 HIS LATE/ BOOK1 ,SOCIAL ,AN>*ISM OR ,LIFE/YLE ,AN>*ISM1 ,BOOK*9 AIMS TO P9 ! BLAME = HIS LIFETIME ( FRU/RATION 7DESPITE HIS DECADES ( VALIANT EF=T67 ON AN EVIL ANTI-SOCIALI/ CONSPIRACY :I* HAS SUBV]T$ HIS DREAMS AT EV]Y TURN3 ! DREAD$ SPECT] ( 0,LIFE/YLE ,AN>*ISM40 ,= ,BOOK*91 LIFE/YLE AN>*ISM IS A CONTEMPOR>Y MANIFE/ATION ( ! 9DIVIDUALI/ AN>*I/ CURR5TS :I* HAVE ALWAYS B$EVIL$ ! WORLD AN>*I/ MOVEM5T PROP]4 ,! FACT ?AT ! AN>*I/ 0MOVEM5T0 ITSELF HAS ALWAYS BE5 MORE ( A POLYMORPH\S 9SURRECTION>Y MILIEU 5COMPASS+ EV]Y?+ FROM AN>*O-SYNDICALI/S1 AN>*O-COMMUNI/S & AN>*O-FUTURI/S TO AN>*I/ FEM9I/S1 AN>*I/ PRIMITIVI/S & AN>*O-SITUATIONI/S DOESN'T REALLY MATT] TO HIM4 ,! IMPORTANT ?+ IS ?AT HE HAS F9ALLY BE5 ABLE TO NAME ! ANTI-ORGANIZATIONAL CABAL :I* OPPOSES HIM & TO EXPLA9 ! ESOT]IC L9KS BETWE5 ITS (T5 SEEM+LY UNRELAT$ OR EV5 MUTUALLY CONTRADICTORY EF=TS6 ,5T] ,BOB ,BLACK4 ,N[ A LOT ( PEOPLE DON'T LIKE ,BOB ,BLACK4 ,MANY AN>*I/S W\LD BE AL>M$ IF HE MOV$ 9 NEXT DOOR4 ,ANYONE ) GOOD S5SE W\LD PROBABLY BE UPSET IF HE />T$ DAT+ H] Y\NG] SI/]4 ,MO/ EV]YONE IS LOA! TO PROVOKE HIS ANG] OR FACE IT HEAD ON4 ,& NOT )\T REASON4 ,BOB MAY BE A BRILLIANT CRITIC & HIL>I\S WIT1 BUT HE'S NOT A NICE GUY4 ,HIS 9FAM\S REPUTATION ISN'T BUILT ON FAIR PLAY OR GOOD SPORTSMAN%IP4 ,MAYBE ?IS IS :Y ,MURRAY ,BOOK*9'S LATE/ RANT1 ,SOCIAL ,AN>*ISM OR ,LIFE/YLE ,AN>*ISM3 ,AN ,UNBRIDGEABLE ,*ASM1 NEV] CRITICIZES ,BOB ,BLACK DIRECTLY4 ,9 FACT IT NEV] SO MU* AS M5TIONS ,BOB'S NAME4 ,EV5 ?\< IT'S OBVI\S FROM ! BOOK'S CONT5TS ?AT BY ALL RIACT]I/ICALLY G5]\S SPIRIT1 FROM GIV+ ,BOOK*9 HIS DUE ANYWAY4 ,BOB'S DEF5SE ( AN>*Y 9 ,AN>*Y AFT] ,LEFTISM ISN'T MEANT TO EXPRESS SOLID>ITY ) ?OSE T>GET$ 9 ! LATE/ ATTACKS FRAM$ BY ,BOOK*9'S PIDG9 DIALECTICS4 ,NOR IS ,BOB REALLY 9T]E/$ 9 RESCU+ AN>*I/ IDEOLOGY FROM ITSELF4 ,HE JU/ WANTS TO SET ! RECORD /RAI+ AWAY WORSE ?AN USELESS POLEMICS4 ,DEF5D+ ! POT5TIAL = AN>*Y IS M]ELY AN UNPLEASANT TASK ( M5IAL ANTI-IDEOLOGICAL LABOR ?AT ,BOB HAS P]=M$ BECAUSE NO ONE ELSE VOLUNTE]$ TO WA% !SE P>TICUL> DIRTY DI%ES1 .<#a.> :ILE HE WANTS TO GET ON ) COOK+ ANO!R MEAL4 ,BUT ?AT'S BY NO MEANS ALL ?AT'S GO+ ON H]E4 ,DISPOS+ ( ,MURRAY ,BOOK*9'S IDEOLOGICAL & RHETORICAL RUBBI% GIVES ,BOB ! *ANCE TO DEVELOP ! GR\NDS = A MORE G5]AL ATTACK ON ! REMA9+ VE/IGES ( LEFTISM :ILE HE'S AT IT4 ,CLEAN+ H\SE ( LEFTISM IS A MU* BIGG] TASK ?AN DEAL+ ) ONE MAN'S LEFTI/ C>E]4 ,SO 9 ONE S5SE1 BY DRAW+ ATT5TION TO HIS 9EFFECTUAL POLEMIC1 ,BOOK*9 HAS MADE HIMSELF AN EXCUSE = ! BEG9N+ ( A MU* L>G] PROCESS ( CRITIQUE1 A PROCESS ?AT WILL UND\BT$LY CONT9UE TO UNFOLD ) 9CREAS+ MILITANCE 9TO ! COM+ C5TURY4 ,IT WILL REQUIRE AW>5ESS & EF=T FROM ALL ( US TO F9I% ?IS TASK1 BUT IT WILL BE DONE4 ,BOB'S D\BLE CRITIQUE 9 ,AN>*Y AFT] ,LEFTISM ONLY GA9S 9CISIV5ESS FROM ! ATTITUDE ( LUMP5 NOBLESSE OBLIGE HE HAS ADOPT$ = HIS TASK4 ,RA!R ?AN LETT+ HIS [N SORDID PA/ 7& PRES5T7 GET 9 ! WAY1 ! LACK ( ANY REV5GE MOTIVE 7SEEM+LY ,BOB'S FAVORITE MUSE7 ALL[S HIM TO UNLEA% HIS P5 ) JU/ AS MU* WIT1 BUT ) FEW] R$ H]R+S1 OBSCURE PUT-D[NS & TORTUR$ SELF-JU/IFICATIONS ?AN EV]4 ,! RESULT IS A MODE/ FEA/ MADE UP ( CONSI/5TLY 5T]TA9+ PROSE1 AN IMMAN5T CRITIQUE ( A W\LD-BE EM95T SOCIAL CRITIC1 & ONE MORE NAIL 9 ! C(F9 ( OBSOLETE LEFTISM1 AN>*I/-/YLE4 ,Y\ MI*Y3 ,A ,J\RNAL ( ,DESIRE ,>M$ ,ALT]NATIVE ,PRESS ,REVIEW ,9TRODUCTION ,?IS SMALL BOOK IS NO?+ MORE ?AN A CRITIQUE ( ANO!R SMALL BOOK1 ,MURRAY ,BOOK*9'S ,SOCIAL ,AN>*ISM OR ,LIFE/YLE ,AN>*ISM3 ,AN ,UNBRIDGEABLE ,*ASM4 .<#b.> ,HIS CONSI/S ( ! TITLE ESSAY PLUS 0,! ,LEFT ,?AT ,WAS3 ,A ,P]SONAL ,REFLECTION40 ,PUBLI%$ 9 #a#i#i#e1 IT WAS AN UNEXPECT$ 9T]V5TION 9 AN 9TRAMURAL DEBATE :I* HAD BE5 GO+ ON = AT LEA/ TW5TY YE>S BETWE5 TRADITIONALI/IC AN>*I/S -- LEFTI/1 WORK]I/1 ORGANIZATIONAL1 & MORALI/ -- & AN EV] MORE DIV]SE 7& AN EV] MORE NUM]\S7 CONT+5T ( AN>*I/S :O HAVE 9 ONE WAY OR ANO!R DEP>T$ FROM OR?ODOXY1 AT LEA/ 9 ,BOOK*9'S EYES4 ,BOOK*9 CAU*I/S BY SURPRISE4 ,MO/ ( US HAVE READ SOME ( ,BOOK*9'S BOOKS & MANY ( US1 MYSELF 9CLUD$1 HAVE LE>N$ FROM !M1 ESPECIALLY ! E>LI] BOOKS FROM ! #a#i#gS4 ,BOOK*9'S SUBSEQU5T & EV]-9T5SIFY+ PREOCCUPATION ) MUNICIPAL POLITICS WE W]E MO/LY 9CL9$ TO IGNORE AS AN IDIOSYNCRASY4 ,HE SEEM$ TO TAKE NO NOTICE ( :AT WE W]E UP TO4 ,HE WAS ABS5T FROM PUBLICATIONS LIKE ! ,FIF? ,E/ATE1 ,POPUL> ,REALITY1 ,FRONT ,L9E1 ,! ,MAT*61 & ,AN>*Y3 ,A ,J\RNAL ( ,DESIRE ,>M$4 ,IT WAS AS IF HE TOOK ! AN>*I/S = GRANT$4 ,!Y DIDN'T KN[ ?AT ,BOOK*9 ?\M ALMO/ EV]Y NEW T5D5CY 9 AN>*ISM EXCEPT HIS [N SPECIALTY1 ECOLOGY4 ,:AT'S MORE1 ! NEF>I\S NOVELTIES EXHIBIT MALIGN !MATIC AFF9ITIES4 ,NOT ONLY >E !Y P]NICI\S1 !Y >E P]NICI\S 9 ESS5TIALLY ! SAME WAY4 ,!Y REPRES5T A RECRUDESC5CE ( AN OLD H]ESY1 09DIVIDUALISM10 DECK$ \T 9 TR5DY PO/-MOD]NI/ FA%IONS 9 A CONFIGURATION ,BOOK*9 CALLS 0LIFE/YLE AN>*ISM40 ,MU* WORSE ?AN A FALL+-AWAY FROM SOME ASPECTS ( CLASSICAL LEFT-W+ AN>*ISM1 LIFE/YLE AN>*ISM IS 7HE 9SI/S7 FUNDAM5TALLY OPPOS$ TO ! DEF9+ T5ETS ( AN>*ISM4 7,H[ ?IS C\LD HAVE HAPP5$ ON HIS WAT* HE DOES NOT EXPLA947 ,= ,BOOK*91 !N1 LIFE/YLE AN>*I/S >E NOT JU/ ]RANT COMRADES1 !Y >E TRAITORS4 ,AS SU* !Y >E EV5 WORSE ?AN AV[$ OPPON5TS ( AN>*ISM4 ,HE MI/REATS !M ACCORD+LY4 ,HIS J]EMIAD IS D[NRI5'T MANY EPI!TS HE DOESN'T WORK 9 SOME:]E OR ANO!R1 & NEV] M9D IF !Y SOMETIMES CONTRADICT EA* O!R 7= 9/ANCE1 09DIVIDUALISM0 & 0FASCISM0 APPLI$ TO ! SAME PEOPLE74 ,!Y DON'T HAVE TO BE TRUE TO BE EFFECTIVE4 ,BOOK*9 />T$ \T AS A ,/AL9I/1 & IT SURE %[S 9 ! ABUSIVE /YLE & UNSCRUPUL\S CONT5T ( HIS POLEMIC4 ,HE WANTS NO DIALOGUE ) HIS SELF-APPO9T$ 5EMIES1 ONLY !IR IRREP>ABLE DISCR$IT4 ,I GET ! DI/9CT IMPRESSION ?AT ,BOOK*91 AN ELD]LY MAN SAID TO BE 9 ILL HEAL?1 IS CA%+ 9 HIS *IPS AS A PROM95T AN>*I/ !ORI/ & /AK+ ALL HIS 9FLU5CE & REPUTATION ON DEMOLI%+ ALL POSSIBLE ALT]NATIVES TO HIS [N CRE$1 :AT HE CALLS 0SOCIAL AN>*ISM40 ,A P>T+ %OT4 ,HE MISS$ ! T>GET4 ,HE HAD TO MISS ! T>GET1 S9CE !RE IS NONE4 ,!RE'S NO SU* ?+ AS 0LIFE/YLE AN>*ISM40 ,!RE >E ONLY A LOT ( AN>*I/S EXPLOR+ A LOT ( IDEAS -- A LOT ( DIFF]5T IDEAS -- ?AT ,BOOK*9 DISAPPROVES (4 ,IT FOLL[S ?AT ?IS BOOK IS NOT A DEF5SE ( 0LIFE/YLE AN>*ISM40 ,!RE'S NO SU* UNICORN1 SO ,I C\LDN'T DEF5D IT EV5 IF ,I WANT$ TO4 ,! V]Y PHRASE IS ,BOOK*9'S 9V5TION1 MU* AS ,/AL9 9V5T$ A NONS5SE CATEGORY1 ! 0BLOC ( ,RITY TOLD HIM TO BELIEVE4 ,HE HASN'T *ANG$ MU*2 OR1 IF HE DID1 HE'S *ANG$ BACK4 ,IF ,I W]E ONLY TAK+ ,BOOK*9 TO TASK = HIS 9CIVILITY1 ,I'D BE A HYPOCRITE1 = ,I'VE P5N$ PL5TY ( BLUNT CRITIQUES ( V>I\S AN>*I/S & ANTI-AU?ORIT>IANS4 ,A ,DUT* AN>*I/1 ,SIEBE ,?ISS51 HAS DESCRIB$ ME -- NOT AS A CRITICISM -- AS ! SEV]E/ CRITIC ( CONTEMPOR>Y AN>*ISM 7#a#i#i#f3 #f74 ,MAYBE ,I AM1 AL?\< CRITICISM ( AN>*I/S TAKES UP ONLY A FRACTION ( ! CONT5T ( MY PREVI\S ?REE BOOKS4 ,BUT ,I'VE (T5 BE5 T\< ON AN>*I/S ,I CONSID]$ AU?ORIT>IAN1 DI%ONE/ OR /UPID4 ,(T5 H>% BUT1 ,I LIKE TO ?9K1 R>ELY UNFAIR4 ,SOME PEOPLE1 ESPECIALLY ?OSE ,I'VE CRITICIZ$1 MI/AKE MY BE+ >TICULATE = MY BE+ RUDE1 OR MI/AKE MY NOTIC+ !M = BE+ OBSESS$ ) !M4 ,BE ?AT AS IT MAY1 = ME TO SET MYSELF UP AS ! ,MISS ,MANN]S ( AN>*ISM W\LD NOT BE APPROPRIATE4 ,I DO ?9K ,MURRAY ,BOOK*9 NE$S A LESSON 9 MANN]S1 & ,I'M GO+ TO GIVE HIM ONE1 BUT 9CIVILITY IS ! LEA/ ( :AT'S WRONG ) HIS DYSPEPTIC DIATRIBE4 ,IT'S :AT HE SAYS1 F> MORE ?AN H[ HE SAYS IT1 ?AT ,I MEAN TO HAVE DONE )4 ,I AM NOT1 EXCEPT 9CID5TALLY1 DEF5D+ ?OSE :OM ,BOOK*9 T>GETS AS 0LIFE/YLE AN>*I/S40 7,= ! RECORD1 ,I'M NOT ONE ( HIS ID5TIFI$ T>GETS47 ,I AM DEBUNK+ ! V]Y CATEGORY ( LIFE/YLE AN>*ISM AS A CON/RUCT AS MEAN+LESS AS IT IS MALICI\S4 ,& ,I AM COM+ D[N ) CRU%+ =CE ON 0AN UGLY1 /UPID /YLE & SUB/ANCE ( DOCTR9AL H>ANGUE0 7,BLACK #a#i#i#b3 #a#h#i71 ! WOR/ SURVIVAL ( ,BOOK*9'S ORIG9AL ,M>XISM4 ,I'VE DONE IT BE=E &1 FRANKLY1 ,I RA!R RES5T HAV+ TO DO IT AGA94 ,BOOK*9 HAS MADE ! C>D9AL AU?OR'S MI/AKE ( FALL+ = HIS [N JACKET BLURBS4 ,O!RWISE HE C\LD NEV] WRITE SU* A WRET*$ SCRE$ & HOPE TO GET AWAY ) IT4 ,HIS PREVI\S CONTRIBUTIONS TO AN>*ISM1 EV5 IF !Y W]E AS EPO*AL AS HE LIKES TO ?9K1 >E NO EXCUSE = ?IS K9D ( GUTT]-GABBLE4 ,HIS SWAN-SONG S\NDS NO?+ BUT S\R NOTES4 ,& S\R GRAPES4 ,:I* IS :Y ,I ?9K !RE'S A PLACE = MY POLEMIC4 ,IF EV5 ! GREAT ,BOOK*9 CAN'T GET AWAY ) TALK+ TRA%1 MAYBE LESS EM95T AN>*I/S WILL BE LESS TEMPT$ TO TALK TRA%4 ,IF EV5 ! QUASI-ACADEMIC ,BOOK*9'S QUASI-S*OL>%IP DOESN'T HOLD UP UND] EV5 MODE/ SCRUT9Y1 MAYBE SOME UNDULY IMPRESSIONABLE AN>*I/S WILL LE>N TO QUE/ION ! AU?ORITY ( FOOTNOTES & JACKET BLURBS4 ,BETT] S*OL>S ?AN ,BOOK*9 LIVE 9 DREAD ( SOMEBODY SOM$AY LOOK+ UP !IR FOOTNOTES4 ,I'LL BE GETT+ >\ND TO SEV]AL ( !M1 TOO4 ,BUT1 WOR/ ?+S FIR/4 ,MO/ PEOPLE WILL TAKE NO 9T]E/ 9 :AT ,BOOK*9 & ,I HAVE TO SAY AB\T AN>*ISM4 ,!SE BOOKS >5'T DE/9$ = ! BE/-SELL] LI/S4 ,EV5 SOME FEEL-GOOD AN>*I/S WILL DISMISS ! RUCKUS AS 09-FIT4 ,! FI*ISM IS1 OR MI*I/0 TO CALL HIM \T = A %[D[N AT HI< NOON \T AT ! ,CIRCLE-,A ,RAN*4 ,A ?R[BACK TO VULG> ,M>XISM 9 MORE ?AN ONE S5SE1 ,SOCIAL ,AN>*ISM OR ,LIFE/YLE ,AN>*ISM MAY TURN \T TO BE ! LA/ TRACT ( ITS K9D1 AT LEA/ ! LA/ ONE ) AN>*I/ PRET5SIONS4 ,SOON !RE WILL BE NOBODY LEFT 9 ,NOR? ,AM]ICA ) ! REQUISITE ,L59I/ BACKGR\ND TO PRACTICE ?IS HI*I/S 9 LETT+ GO ( ! LEFTISM !Y HAVE \TGR[N1 SOME ( !M )\T REALIZ+ IT4 ,CLEANS$ ( ITS LEFTI/ RESIDUES1 AN>*Y -- AN>*ISM M9US ,M>XISM -- WILL BE FREE TO GET BETT] AT BE+ :AT IT IS4 O ,*APT] #a 3 ,MURRAY ,BOOK*91 ,GRUMPY ,OLD ,MAN ,*APT] #a3 ,MURRAY ,BOOK*91 ,GRUMPY ,OLD ,MAN ,SOCIAL ,AN>*ISM OR ,LIFE/YLE ,AN>*ISM MAY WELL BE ! WOR/ BOOK AB\T AN>*I/S ?AT ANY ( !M HAS EV] WRITT54 ,ACCORD+ TO ! COV] BLURB1 ,MURRAY ,BOOK*91 BORN 9 #a#i#b#a1 HAS BE5 0A LIFELONG RADICAL S9CE ! E>LY #a#i#cS40 0,RADICAL0 IS H]E A EUPHEMISM = 0,/AL9I/02 ,BOOK*9 WAS ORIG9ALLY 0A MILITANT 9 ! ,Y\NG ,PIONE]S & ! ,Y\NG ,COMMUNI/ ,LEAGUE0 7,CL>K #a#i#i3#a#b2 CF4 ,BOOK*9 #a#i#g#g3#c74 ,LAT] HE BECAME A ,TROTSKYI/4 ,AT ONE TIME ,BOOK*9 HIMSELF1 0AS ONE :O P>TICIPAT$ ACTIVELY 9 ! 'RADICAL' MOVEM5TS ( ! ?IRTIES0 7#a#i#g3 #e#f71 PUT ! WORD 0RADICAL10 CONSID]+ ! CONTEXT1 9 QUOTATION M>KS1 BUT N[ HE IS NO/ALGIC AB\T ?AT MILIEU1 :AT HE CALLS ! ,LEFT ,?AT ,WAS 7#f#f-#h#f74 ,AB\T #be YE>S AGO1 ,MURRAY ,BOOK*9 PE]$ 9TO ! MIRROR & MI/OOK IT = A W9D[ ( OPPORTUNITY4 ,9 #aifc HE WROTE1 UND] A PSEUDONYM1 ,\R ,SYN!TIC ,SOCIETY 7,H]B] #a#i#f#c71 :I* ANTICIPAT$ 7AL?\< IT SEEMS NOT TO HAVE 9FLU5C$7 ! 5VIRONM5TALI/ MOVEM5T4 ,9 #a#i#g1 BY :I* TIME HE WAS PU%+ #e & CALL+ HIMSELF AN AN>*I/1 ,BOOK*9 WROTE 0,LI/51 ,M>XI/60 -- A MOD]ATELY EFFECTIVE ANTI-AU?ORIT>IAN POLEMIC AGA9/ SU* ,M>XI/ MY?S AS ! REVOLUTION>Y VANGU>D ORGANIZATION & ! PROLET>IAT AS REVOLUTION>Y SUBJECT 7,BOOK*9 #a#i#g#a3#a#g#a-#b#b#b74 ,9 ?IS & 9 O!R ESSAYS COLLECT$ 9 ,PO/-,SC>CITY ,AN>*ISM 7#a#i#g#a71 ,BOOK*9 DISDA9$ TO CONCEAL HIS DELIRAY ( HIS ,M>XI/ COMRADES-TURN$-COMPETITORS4 ,HE ?\*ISM W\LD F9ALLY DISPLACE ,M>XISM1 & ,BOOK*9 W\LD PLACE ! /AMP ( HIS SPECIALTY1 0SOCIAL ECOLOGY10 ON AN>*ISM4 ,NOT ONLY W\LD HE BE BETT+ ON ! W9N+ HORSE1 HE W\LD BE ! JOCKEY4 ,AS ONE ( HIS FOLL[]S HAS WRITT51 0IF Y\R EF=TS AT CREAT+ Y\R [N MASS MOVEM5T HAVE BE5 PA!TIC FAILURES1 F9D SOMEONE ELSE'S MOVEM5T & TRY TO LEAD IT0 7,CL>K #a#i#h#d3 #a#h74 ,BOOK*9 !REUPON SET \T TO CONQU] ! AN>*I/S = ! ECO-RADICALS 7! ,GRE5S71 ! ,GRE5S = ! AN>*I/S1 & ALL = ONE -- ! GREAT ONE -- ,MURRAY ,BOOK*9 HIMSELF4 ,HE W\LD SUPPLY ! 0MUSCUL>ITY ( ?\S10 IF HE DOES SAY SO HIMSELF 7,9/ITUTE = ,SOCIAL ,ECOLOGY #a#i#i#f3 #a#c7 7,BOOK*9 CO-F\ND$ ! ,I,S,E74 ,HE CRANK$ \T SEV]AL WELL-PADD$1 L>GELY REPETITI\S BOOKS4 ,! ,ECOLOGY ( ,FRE$OM 7#a#i#h#b2 REV4 $4 #a#i#i#a7 IS ! ONE HE APP>5TLY REG>DS AS HIS MAGNUM OPUS4 ,AT ANY RATE1 ONE ( HIS JACKET BLURBS 7,BOOK*9 #a#i#h#gA7 QUOTES A REVOLUTION>Y AN>*I/ WEEKLY1 ! ,VILLAGE ,VOICE1 TO ?AT EFFECT 7CF4 ,CL>K .<#a#i#h#d.>3 #b#a#e74 ,! MAT]IAL BASE = !SE SUP]/RUCTURAL EFFUSIONS WAS ,BOOK*9'S PROVID5TIAL APPO9TM5T AS A ,DEAN AT ,GODD>D ,COLLEGE NE> ,BURL+TON1 ,V]MONT1 A CUDDLE-COLLEGE = HIPPIES &1 MORE REC5TLY1 PUNKS1 ) WEAL?Y P>5TS 7CF4 ,GODD>D ,COLLEGE #a#i#i#e74 ,HE ALSO HELD AN APPO9TM5T AT ,RAMAPO ,COLLEGE4 ,BOOK*91 :O SNE]S AT LEFTI/S :O HAVE EMB>K$ UPON 0ALLUR+ UNIV]SITY C>E]S0 7#f#g71 IS ONE ( !M4 ,SOME?+ W5T AWRY4 ,AL?\< ,DEAN ,BOOK*9 WAS 9DE$ WIDELY READ BY ,NOR? ,AM]ICAN AN>*I/S -- ONE ( HIS ACKN[L$G$ SYCOPHANTS 7,CL>K #a#i#h#d3 #a#a7 CALLS HIM 0! =EMO/ CONTEMPOR>Y AN>*I/ !ORI/0 7,CL>K #a#i#i3 #a#b2 CF4 ,CL>K #a#i#h#b3 #e#i7 -- 9 FACT1 NOT MANY AN>*I/S ACKN[L$G$ HIM AS !IR DEAN4 ,!Y APPRECIAT$ HIS ECOLOGICAL ORI5TATION1 TO BE SURE1 BUT SOME DREW !IR [N1 MORE F>-REA*+ CONCLUSIONS FROM IT4 ,! ,DEAN CAME UP AGA9/ AN UNEXPECT$ OB/ACLE4 ,! MA/]-PLAN CALL$ = AN>*I/S TO 9CREASE 9 NUMB]S & TO READ HIS BOOKS1 & ?OSE P>TS CAME (F TOL]ABLY WELL4 ,IT WAS OKAY IF !Y ALSO READ A FEW AN>*I/ CLASSICS1 ,BAKUN9 & ,KROPOTK9 = 9/ANCE 7#h71 VETT$ BY ! ,DEAN1 ) ! UND]/&+ ?AT EV5 ! BE/ ( !M AF=D 0M]E GLIMPSES0 ( ! =MS ( A FREE SOCIETY 7,BOOK*9 #a#i#g#a3 #g#i7 SUBSEQU5TLY BUILT UPON1 BUT TRANSC5D$ BY1 ! ,DEAN'S [N EPO*AL DISCOV]Y1 SOCIAL ECOLOGY_/SOCIAL AN>*ISM4 ,BOOK*9 DOES NOT M9D /&+ ON ! %\LD]S ( GIANTS -- HE RA!R 5JOYS ! FEEL ( !M UND] HIS HEEL -- SO LONG AS HE /&S TALLE/ ( ALL4 ,HE MU/ HAVE HAD NO D\BT ?AT HE W\LD4 ,HE SEEM$ TO HAVE NO COMPETITION 9TRAMURALLY4 ,PAUL ,GOODMAN1 0! MO/ WIDELY KN[N AN>*I/0 7,DE ,LEON #a#i#g#h3#a#c#b71 UNTIMELY DI$4 ,TWE$Y ,BRITI% & ,CANADIAN AN>*I/ 9TELLECTUALS LIKE ,H]B]T ,READ1 ,ALEX ,COM=T & ,GEORGE ,WOODCOCK %UFFL$ (F 9TO ! LIT]>Y WORLD4 ,AG+ CLASS-/RUGGLE FUNDAM5TALI/S LIKE ,SAM ,DOLG(F & ,ALB]T ,MELTZ] C\LD BE C\NT$ ON TO JU/ KEEP DO+ :AT !Y W]E DO+1 :ATEV] ?AT WAS1 & ) !IR USUAL SUCCESS4 0,WE ALL /& ON ! %\LD]S ( O!RS10 AS ! ,DEAN G5]\SLY ALL[S 7#a#i#h#b3 ,ACKN[L$GM5TS74 ,DEAN ,BOOK*9 C\LD /& ON ! %\LD]S ( MIDGETS TOO4 ,! FOOT+ WAS EV5 SUR] !RE4 ,:AT ! ,DEAN DID NOT EXPECT WAS ?AT AN>*I/S W\LD />T READ+ \TSIDE HIS CURRICULUM &1 WORSE YET1 OCCASIONALLY ?9K = !MSELVES1 SOME?+ ?AT -- 9 ALL FAIRNESS -- NOBODY C\LD HAVE ANTICIPAT$4 ,!Y READ1 = 9/ANCE1 AB\T ! E?NOGRAPHY ( ! ONLY SOCIETIES -- C]TA9 ( ! SO-CALL$ PRIMITIVE SOCIETIES -- :I* HAVE ACTUALLY BE5 OP]ATIVE AN>*I/ SOCIETIES ON A LONG-T]M BASIS4 ,!Y ALSO READ AB\T PLEBEIAN MOVEM5TS1 COMMUNITIES1 & 9SURRECTIONS -- ,ADAMITES1 ,RANT]S1 ,DIGG]S1 ,LUDDITES1 ,%AYSITES1 ,5RAGES1 ,C>BON>I1 EV5 PIRATES 7TO M5TION1 TO BE BRIEF1 ONLY ,EURO-,AM]ICAN1 & ONLY A FEW ,EURO-,AM]ICAN EXAMPLES7 -- SEEM+LY \TSIDE ( ! ,M>XI/-,BOOK*9I/ PROGRESSIVE S*EMA4 ,!Y SCOP$ \T ,DADA & ,SURREALISM4 ,!Y READ ! ,SITUATIONI/S & ! PRO-SITUS4 ,&1 YES1 LIKE E>LI] G5]ATIONS ( AN>*I/S1 !Y W]E RECEPTIVE TO CURR5TS ( CULTURAL RADICALISM4 ,9DE$1 9/EAD ( LI/5+ TO 0DEC5T MUSIC0 7#f#d N4 #c#g71 !Y (T5 PREF]R$ PUNK ROCK TO ,PETE ,SEEG] & ,UTAH ,PHILIPS 70! FOLK SONG10 HE HAS EXPLA9$1 0CON/ITUTES ! EMOTIONAL1 ES!TIC1 & SPIRITUAL EXPRESSION ( A PEOPLE0 .<,BOOK*9 #a#i#i#f3 #a#i.>74 ,& USUALLY !IR HAIR WAS EI!R TOO LONG OR TOO %ORT4 ,:O S5T !M D[N ?IS TWI/$ PA?8 ,9 SOME CASES IT WAS ! 0SELF-/YL$ AN>*I/0 7#a1 #b1#i7 -- ?IS IS A FAVORITE ,BOOK*9 SLUR -- :O WROTE3 ,! GRAFFITI ON ! WALLS ( ,P>IS -- 0,P[] TO ! ,IMAG9ATION10 0,IT IS =BIDD5 TO =BID10 0,LIFE )\T DEAD TIMES0 .1 0,NEV] WORK0 -- REPRES5T A MORE PROB+ ANALYSIS ( !SE S\RCES .<( REVOLUTION>Y UNRE/ 9 MOD]N SOCIETY.> ?AN ALL ! !ORETICAL TOMES 9H]IT$ FROM ! PA/4 ,! UPRIS+ REVEAL$ ?AT WE >E AT ! 5D ( AN OLD ]A & WELL 9TO ! BEG9N+ ( A NEW ONE4 ,! MOTIVE =CES ( REVOLUTION TODAY1 AT LEA/ 9 ! 9DU/RIALIZ$ WORLD1 >E NOT SIMPLY SC>CITY & MAT]IAL NE$1 BUT ALSO ! QUALITY ( EV]YDAY LIFE1 ! DEM& = ! LIB]ATION ( EXP]I5CE1 ! ATTEMPT TO GA9 CONTROL OV] ONE'S DE/9Y .4 ,?IS WAS NOT A SOLEMN REVOLT1 A C\P D'ETAT BUREAUCRATICALLY PLOTT$ & MANIPULAT$ BY A 0VANGU>D0 P>TY2 IT WAS WITTY1 SATIRICAL1 9V5TIVE & CREATIVE -- & !RE9 LAY ITS /R5G?1 ITS CAPACITY = IMM5SE SELF-MOBILIZATION1 ITS 9FECTI\SNESS4 ,! LUMP5-BOHEMIAN CRAZY :O P5N$ ?IS PEAN TO 0NEO-,SITUATIONI/ 'EC/ASY'0 7#b#f7 IS ! PRELAPS>IAN ,MURRAY ,BOOK*9 7#a#i#g#a3 #b#d#i-#b#e1 #b#e#a71 ,!SE >E ALL1 9 FACT1 SITUATIONI/ SLOGANS4 ,SOME ( US BELIEV$ HIM !N4 ,N[ HE TELLS US WE W]E WRONG1 AL?\< HE NEV] TELLS US HE EV] WAS4 ,:Y %\LD WE BELIEVE HIM N[8 ,! ,H>D ,RIXI/S FROM ,NEW ,YORK ,CITY :O 5D$ UP AS J\RNALI/S &_/OR ACADEMICS7 BLAME ! DECL9E ( ,WE/]N CIVILIZATION ON ! '#fS4 ,BOOK*9 CAN'T CR$IBLY DO ?AT1 S9CE IT WAS 9 ! '#fS ?AT HE CAME \T AS AN AN>*I/1 & BUILT UP ! BEG9N+S ( HIS REPUTATION AS A !ORI/4 ,9 HIS GOLD5 YE>S1 HE HAS TO TREAD V]Y C>EFULLY ON ?IS D>K & BLOODY GR\ND3 ,= ALL ITS %ORTCOM+S1 ! AN>*IC C\NT]CULTURE DUR+ ! E>LY P>T ( ! HECTIC #a#i#fS WAS (T5 9T5SELY POLITICAL & CA/ EXPRESSIONS LIKE DESIRE & EC/ASY 9 EM95TLY SOCIAL T]MS1 (T5 D]ID+ ! P]SONALI/IC T5D5CIES ( ! LAT] ,WOOD/OCK G5]ATION 7#i74 ,BY DEF9ITION 0! E>LY P>T ( ! HECTIC #a#i#fS0 IS PRESUMABLY ! YE>S #a#i#f-#a#i#f#d4 ,?IS IS ! FIR/ TIME ,I'VE HE>D TELL ( AN 0AN>*IC C\NT]CULTURE0 DUR+ ! ,K5N$Y ,ADM9I/RATION4 ,AS MANIFE/$ 9 -- :AT8 ! ,PEACE ,CORPS8 ! ,GRE5 ,B]ETS8 ,& :ILE !RE W]E P]SONALI/IC T5D5CIES 9 ! E>LY #a#i#fS1 NO ONE !N ANTICIPAT$1 & SO NO ONE D]ID$1 ! SPECIFIC 0P]SONALI/IC T5D5CIES ( ! LAT] ,WOOD/OCK G5]ATION40 ,NOT ,BOOK*91 C]TA9LY1 :O CONCLUD$ PREMATURELY ?AT 0,M>XIAN PR$ICTIONS ?AT ,Y\? ,CULTURE W\LD FADE 9TO A COM=TABLE ACCOMMODATION ) ! SY/EM HAVE PROV5 TO BE FALSE0 7#a#i#g3 #f74 ,:AT DID ! ALL-SEE+ ,DEAN DO TO COMBAT !SE NEF>I\S TR5DS 9 ! #b-ODD YE>S !Y HAVE BE5 9FECT+ AN>*ISM8 ,NO?+4 ,HE HAD BETT] ?+S TO DO ?AN COME TO ! RESCUE ( ! AN>*I/ IDEOLOGY HE CONSID]S ! LA/ BE/ HOPE ( HUMANK9D4 ,ON ! ONE H&1 HE WAS CONSOLIDAT+ HIS ALLUR+ ACADEMIC C>E]2 ON ! O!R1 HE WAS MAK+ A PLAY = IDEOLOGICAL HEGEMONY OV] ! ,GRE5 MOVEM5T4 ,W]E WE ALL SUPPOS$ TO WAIT UP = HIM8 ,!RE W]E ?OSE :O ACTUALLY TRI$ TO IMPLEM5T ! ,DEAN'S DIRECTIVE TO =MULATE 0A COH]5T PROGRAM0 & 0A REVOLUTION>Y ORGANIZATION TO PROVIDE A DIRECTION = ! MASS DISCONT5T ?AT CONTEMPOR>Y SOCIETY IS CREAT+0 7#a74 ,NOTE ?AT ,BOOK*9 DEM&S ONE ORGANIZATION1 AL?\< HE DOES NOT SAY IF HE WANTS AN ,AM]ICAN ,C,N,T1 AN ,AM]ICAN ,F,A,I1 OR AN ,AM]ICAN SYMBIOTE ( BO? SU* AS =M$ 9 ,SPA91 ) LESS ?AN 5TIRELY POSITIVE CONSEQU5CES 7,BOOK*9 #a#i#i#d3 #b-#b#e2 CF4 ,BRADEMAS #a#i#e#c74 ,DUR+ ! REC5T DECADES ( DECAD5CE1 !RE W]E SEV]AL OPPORTUNITIES = ! ,DEAN TO P>TICIPATE 9 ?IS IMPORTANT WORK4 ,HE CLAIMS ?AT HIS P>5TS W]E ,WOBBLIES 7#b-#c7 -- ,I WOND] :AT !Y ?\*I/S =M$ ! ,AN>*I/ ,COMMUNI/ ,F$]ATION1 :I* COLLAPS$ 9 ACRIMONY AFT] A FEW YE>S4 ,! ,DEAN DID NOT JO94 ,ONE ,A,C,F FACTION SET UP ! SYNDICALI/ ,WORK]S ,SOLID>ITY ,ALLIANCE2 ,BOOK*9 DIDN'T JO9 ?AT ONE EI!R4 ,& F9ALLY1 9 ! LA/ FEW YE>S ! DIRECT-ACTIONI/ NEWSPAP] ,LOVE @& ,RAGE HAS TRI$ TO TURN ITS SUPPORT GR\PS 9TO ! NUCLEI ( A NATIONAL AN>*I/ ORGANIZATION4 ,ONCE AGA91 ,BOOK*9 HELD HIMSELF ALO(4 ,:Y8 ,NO D\BT ALL !SE ORGANIZATIONS FELL SOME:AT %ORT ( HIS REQUIREM5TS1 BUT AS MY MO!R SAYS1 0:AT DO Y\ WANT1 AN EGG 9 Y\R BE]80 ,! ,C,N,T & ! ,F,A,I W]E ALSO IMP]FECT4 ,EV]Y?+ IS IMP]FECT4 ,IF Y\R FUNDAM5TAL CRITIQUE ( CONTEMPOR>Y ,NOR? ,AM]ICAN AN>*I/S IS ?AT !Y HAVE FAIL$ TO ASSEMBLE 9 A CONT95TAL F$]ATION1 SURELY Y\ %\LD HAVE TOLD !M :AT IS TO BE DONE1 & H[1 A LONG TIME AGO4 ,! 9VOLVEM5T ( SO DI/+UI%$ A MILITANT AS ,BOOK*9 MI TO BE A SECT ( SQUABBL+1 DRON+ DULL>DS1 P]HAPS BECAUSE1 9 EA* & EV]Y 9/ANCE1 IT IS A SECT ( SQUABBL+1 DRON+ DULL>DS4 ,! ONLY POSSIBLE JU/IFICATION IS ?AT -- TO DO JU/ICE TO ! ,DEAN 7& DO ,I EV] WANT TO DO EXACTLY ?AT67 -- HE LAID D[N TWO REQUIREM5TS1 NOT JU/ ONE4 ,A DIRECTIVE ORGANIZATION1 YES -- BUT ) 0A COH]5T PROGRAM40 ,SU* TIME AS REMA9$ AFT] ! P]=MANCE ( HIS ADM9I/RATIVE & ACADEMIC RESPONSIBILITIES 7& ! LECTURE CIRCUIT7 ! ,DEAN HAS DEVOT$ TO PROVID+ ! COH]5T PROGRAM4 ,NO D\BT ,BOOK*9 CAN ORGANIZE ! MASSES 7HE MU/ HAVE HAD A LOT ( PRACTICE1 & SURELY GREAT SUCCESS1 9 HIS ,M>XI/-,L59I/ DAYS74 ,SO CAN MANY O!R COMRADES -- BUT NO O!R COMRADE CAN CONCOCT A COH]5T PROGRAM ! WAY ,BOOK*9 CAN4 ,IT IS1 !RE=E1 ONLY RATIONAL = A DIVISION ( LABOR TO PREVAIL4 ,LESS TAL5T$ COMRADES %\LD DO ! ORGANIZATIONAL DRUDGE-WORK1 FREE+ UP ,DEAN ,BOOK*9 -- AFT] H\RS -- TO !ORIZE4 ,IT'S AN EXAMPLE ( :AT CAPITALI/ ECONOMI/S CALL ! ,LAW ( ,COMP>ATIVE ,ADVANTAGE4 ,ALL ( ?AT ,KROPOTK9I/-,BOOK*9I/ TALK AB\T ROTATION ( TASKS1 AB\T SUP]S$+ ! SEP>ATION ( H&-WORK & BRA9-WORK -- TIME 5\< = ?AT AFT] ! ,REVOLUTION4 ,! ,DEAN'S BOOKLET ?UND]S 79 A QU]UL\S SORT ( A WAY7 ?AT 0AN>*ISM /&S AT A TURN+ PO9T 9 ITS LONG & TURBUL5T HI/ORY0 7#a74 ,:5 DIDN'T IT8 ,9 ! TIME-HONOR$ SOPHI/ MANN]1 ! ,DEAN (F]S AN ANSW] TO A NONS5SE QUE/ION ( HIS [N CONCOCTION4 0,AT A TIME :5 POPUL> DI/RU/ ( ! /ATE HAS REA*$ EXTRAORD9>Y PROPORTIONS 9 MANY C\NTRIES10 ETC41 ETC41 0! FAILURE ( AN>*I/S -- OR1 AT LEA/1 MANY SELF-/YL$ AN>*I/S -- TO REA* A POT5TIALLY HUGE BODY ( SUPPORT]S0 IS DUE1 NOT 5TIRELY ( C\RSE1 BUT 09 NO SMALL MEASURE TO ! *ANGES ?AT HAVE OCCURR$ 9 MANY AN>*I/S OV] ! PA/ TWO DECADES444 . HAVE SL[LY SURR5D]$ ! SOCIAL CORE ( AN>*I/ IDEAS TO ! ALL-P]VASIVE ,YUPPIE & ,NEW ,AGE P]SONALISM ?AT M>KS ?IS DECAD5T1 B\RGEOISIFI$ ]A0 7#a74 ,N[ ?IS IS A CURI\S CLAIM4 ,AN>*ISM IS UNPOPUL>1 NOT BECAUSE IT OPPOSES POPUL> IDEOLOGICAL FA%IONS1 BUT BECAUSE IT EMBRACES !M8 ,IT'S UNPOPUL> BECAUSE IT'S POPUL>8 ,?IS ISN'T ! FIR/ TIME ,I'VE ID5TIFI$ ?IS OBVI\S IDIOCY 7,BLACK @& ,GUND]LOY #a#i#i#b74 ,SIMPLE LOGIC ASIDE 7:]E ,DEAN ,BOOK*9 CA/ IT71 ! ,DEAN'S EMPIRICAL ASSUMPTIONS >E RIDICUL\S4 ,NOR? ,AM]ICAN AN>*ISM IS NOT 09 RETREAT0 7#e#i71 IT HAS GR[N DRAMATICALLY 9 ! LA/ TW5TY YE>S4 ,! ,DEAN MI*ISM HAS CO9CID$ ) ! ECLIPSE ( OR?ODOX AN>*O-LEFTISM BY MORE 9T]E/+ V>IETIES ( AN>*Y DOESN'T CONCLUSIVELY PROVE ?AT ! HET]ODOX AN>*IES >E ! GR[? SECTOR1 BUT IT SURE LOOKS ?AT WAY4 ,= 9/ANCE1 ! ,NOR? ,AM]ICAN AN>*I/ PUBLICATION ) ! HI*Y3 ,A ,J\RNAL ( ,DESIRE ,>M$1 IS ON ,BOOK*9'S 5EMIES LI/ 7#c#i1 #e74 ,AS = ! SUPPOSITION ?AT 0,YUPPIE & ,NEW ,AGE P]SONALISM0 >E 0ALL-P]VASIVE0 9 \R 0DECAD5T1 B\RGEOISIFI$ ]A10 ?IS SAYS MORE AB\T ,DEAN ,BOOK*9 & ! COMPANY HE KEEPS ?AN IT DOES AB\T CONTEMPOR>Y SOCIETY4 ,IF Y\ >E AN UPP] MIDDLE CLASS ACADEMIC 9 AN AFFLU5T LEFTI/ 5CLAVE LIKE ,BURL+TON OR ,B]KELEY1 Y\ MIRANT$ & N>CISSI/IC 70P]SONALI/IC10 AS IT W]E74 ,AM]ICA 7OR ,CANADA7 IS /ILL MU* MORE LIKE ,MA9 ,/REET ?AN ,M>9 ,C\NTY4 ,IF ! ,DEAN REALLY ?9KS ! BRAT-PACK COLLEGIANS 9 HIS ,BURL+TON A%RAM >E REPRES5TATIVE ,NOR? ,AM]ICAN Y\?1 HE DOESN'T GET \T 5\<4 ,B]AT+ 0,YUPPIES0 = !IR SELF-9DULG5CE1 SOME?+ ,BOOK*9 C>RIES TO ! PO9T ( OBSESSION 7#a @& PASSIM71 DOESN'T DEFY M$IA-MANAG$ POPUL> OP9ION1 IT P&]S TO IT4 ,AS IS TYPICAL ( PROGRESSIVES1 ,BOOK*9 IS BEH9D ! TIMES4 ,NOT ONLY >E ! '#fS OV]1 AS HE HAS F9ALLY FIGUR$ \T1 SO >E ! '#gS & ! '#hS4 ,! ,OLD ,LEFT ?AT HE NO/ALGICALLY RECALLS1 :AT HE CALLS ! ,LEFT ,?AT ,WAS 7#f#f-#h#f71 EXTOLL$ DISCIPL9E1 SACRIFICE1 H>D WORK1 MONOGAMY1 TE*NOLOGICAL PROGRESS1 HET]OSEXUALITY1 MORALISM1 A SOB] & ORD]LY IF NOT D[NRITY1 ! UNION OR ! AFF9ITY GR\P73 ,! PURITANISM & WORK E?IC ( ! TRADITIONAL LEFT /EM FROM ONE ( ! MO/ P[]FUL =CES OPPOS+ REVOLUTION TODAY -- ! CAPACITY ( ! B\RGEOIS 5VIRONM5T TO 9FILTRATE ! REVOLUTION>Y FRAMEWORK4 ,! ORIG9S ( ?IS P[] LIE 9 ! COMMODITY NATURE ( MAN UND] CAPITALISM1 A QUALITY ?AT IS ALMO/ AUTOMATICALLY TRANSLAT$ TO ! ORGANIZ$ GR\P -- & :I* ! GR\P1 9 TURN1 RE9=CES 9 ITS MEMB]S4 ,?IS PASSAGE MI*I/S0 7,CAMATTE #a#i#i#e3 #a#i-#c#b74 ,BY N[ ! READ] WILL BE ON TO MY GAME 7ONE ( !M1 ANYWAY73 ! ABOVE-QUOT$ AU?OR IS ONCE AGA9 ,BOOK*9 ! ,Y\NG] 7#a#i#g#a3 #d#g2 CF4 ,BOOK*9 #a#i#g#g3 *4 #a#a74 ,AGA93 ,9 ITS DEM&S = TRIBALISM1 FREE SEXUALITY1 COMMUNITY1 MUTUAL AID1 EC/ATIC EXP]I5CE1 & A BALANC$ ECOLOGY1 ! ,Y\? ,CULTURE PREFIGURES1 H[EV] 9*OATELY1 A JOY\S COMMUNI/ & CLASSLESS SOCIETY1 FRE$ ( ! TRAMMELS ( HI]>*Y & DOM9ATION1 A SOCIETY ?AT W\LD TRANSC5D ! HI/ORIC SPLITS BETWE5 T[N & C\NTRY1 9DIVIDUAL & SOCIETY1 & M9D & BODY 7,BOOK*9 #a#i#g3 #e#i74 ,BOOK*9 ! ,ELD]'S VALUES1 9 CONTRA/1 >E PRECISELY ?OSE ( ! ,NEW ,RICITY AN>*ISM 7#a#i#g#a3 #h#c-#a#c#e2 #a#i#h#i3 #a#i#f7 IS ! 9V5TION ( PR(ESSIONALS & ! FEV]-DREAM ( TE*NO-YUPPIES4 ,SO IF ,DEAN ,BOOK*91 AN OLD URBAN PR(ESSIONAL1 DISP>AGES Y\NG URBAN PR(ESSIONALS1 :AT IS IT AB\T !M ?AT HE HATES SO MU*8 ,BY A PROCESS ( ELIM9ATION1 IT CANNOT BE ?AT !Y >E URBAN & IT CANNOT BE ?AT !Y >E PR(ESSIONAL4 ,IT MU/ BE ?AT !Y >E Y\NG1 AS ! ,DEAN IS NOT4 ,ACTUALLY1 A LOT ( !M >5'T ALL ?AT Y\NG -- MO/ >E BABY BOOM]S 5T]+ MIDDLE AGE -- BUT TO A ,GRUMPY ,OLD ,MAN ( #ge LIKE ,DEAN ,BOOK*91 ?AT'S Y\NG 5\< TO RES5T4 ,BUT IT'S NOT !IR FAULT1 AFT] ALL1 ?AT MO/ ( !M WILL LIVE ON LONG AFT] ,MURRAY ,BOOK*9 IS DEAD & =GOTT54 ,& ONE MORE ?+3 ,N[ ?AT WE KN[ :Y ! H]ETICAL AN>*I/S HAVE 0FAIL$ TO REA* A POT5TIALLY HUGE BODY ( SUPPORT]S10 :AT'S HIS EXCUSE8 ,ONE ( HIS $ITORS CALLS HIM 0>GUABLY ! MO/ PROLIFIC AN>*I/ WRIT]0 7,EHRLI* #a#i#i#f3 #c#h#d74 7,AL?\< HE HAS YET TO \TPRODUCE ! LATE ,PAUL ,GOODMAN1 :O 0PRODUC$ A /REAM ( BOOKS CONTA9+ SOME ( HIS 5ORM\S \TPUT ( >TICLES & SPEE*ES0 7,WALT] #a#i#g#b3 #a#e#g7 & HE IS LIKELY TO BE SOON SURPASS$ BY ,HAKIM ,BEY -- A F> BETT] WRIT] -- :I* MAY ACC\NT = SOME ( ! 9S5SATE HATR$ ! ,DEAN DISPLAYS = ,BEY47 ,SO ! TRU? IS \T !RE4 ,:]E1 AFT] ALL !SE YE>S1 >E ! ,BOOK*9I/ MASSES8 ,! ,DEAN'S VOCABUL>Y ( ABUSE EVOKES :AT HE CALLS ! ,LEFT ,?AT ,WAS 7#f#f7 BUT H>DLY ! FONDNESS HE FEELS = IT4 ,HIS EPI!TS = UNOR?ODOX AN>*I/S >E ! /&>D ,/AL9I/ EPI!TS = ALL AN>*I/S4 ,HE B]ATES AN>*I/ 0DECAD5CE0 OV] & OV]1 TO :I* HE (T5 APP5DS AB/RACT D5UNCIATIONS ( 0B\RGEOIS0 OR 0PETTY B\RGEOIS0 T5D5CIES4 0,DECAD5CE0 IS AN EPI!T SO 9DISCRIM9ATELY APPLI$ ?AT A SPIRIT$ CASE HAS BE5 MADE = RETIR+ IT FROM RESPONSIBLE DISC\RSE 7,GILMAN #a#i#g#e74 ,EV5 )\T GO+ QUITE SO F>1 UND5IABLY 0'DECAD5T' AS A T]M ( POLITICAL & SOCIAL ABUSE HAS A G5]\S RANGE ( APPLICATIONS10 ESPECIALLY AS DEPLOY$ BY ,M>XI/S & ,FASCI/S 7,ADAMS #a#i#h#c3 #a74 ,TO SPEAK ( ! ,DEAN'S D5UNCIATIONS ( LE B\RGEOIS AS 0AB/RACT0 IS MY *>ACT]I/ICALLY C\RTE\S WAY ( H9T+ ?AT HE ( ALL PEOPLE HAD BETT] PICK HIS WORDS MORE C>EFULLY4 ,I SAY 0AB/RACT0 BECAUSE A COLLEGE DEAN IS A MEMB] ( ! B\RGEOISIE IF1 9 ANY OBJECTIVE S5SE1 ANYBODY IS4 ,BOOK*9 SURELY HAS A HI<] 9COME ?AN ANYBODY HE'S T>GET$4 ,DEAN ,BOOK*9 HAS TO BE DEPLOY+ ! WORD 9 A SUBJECTIVE1 MORALI/IC1 JUDGM5TAL S5SE :I*1 H[EV]1 HE ISN'T DEF9+4 ,IT NEV] US$ TO BO!R ! ,DEAN ?AT 0MANY MILITANT RADICALS T5D TO COME FROM ! RELATIVELY AFFLU5T /RATA0 7,BOOK*9 #a#i#g#a3 #b#e7 -- AS HIS /UD5T DISCIPLES /ILL DO4 ,:O ELSE CAN AF=D TO SIT AT HIS FEET8 ,= #a#i#i#f-#a#i#i#g1 ! TWO-SEME/] MA/]S' PROGRAM 9 ,SOCIAL ,ECOLOGY CO/S @s#a1#e#g#h 7,GODD>D ,COLLEGE #a#i#i#f74 ,BACK !N HE CONSID]$ IT A 0HI/ORIC BREA*0 ?AT IT WAS 0RELATIVELY AFFLU5T MIDDLE CLASS :ITE Y\?0 :O CREAT$ ! IMPLICITLY REVOLUTION>Y ,Y\? ,CULTURE 7,BOOK*9 #a#i#g3 #e#d-#e#e74 ,NO ONE CAN POSSIBLY PRON\NCE ) ANY CONFID5CE UPON ! CLASS POSITION ( PRES5T-DAY ,NOR? ,AM]ICAN AN>*I/S 9 G5]AL1 MU* LESS ! CLASS POSITIONS ( 09DIVIDUALI/S10 ,BOOK*9I/S1 ETC4 7,AL?\< MY IMPRESSION IS ?AT MO/ AN>*O-SYNDICALI/S >E CAMPUS-BAS$ & NONE ( !M >E FACTORY WORK]S4 ,WORK IS MU* EASI] TO GLORIFY ?AN IT IS TO P]=M47 ,NOR DOES IT BO!R ! ,DEAN ?AT ALMO/ ! ONLY LUM9>IES UNCONDITIONALLY ADMITT$ TO HIS AN>*I/ PAN!ON1 ,BAKUN9 & ,KROPOTK91 W]E H]$IT>Y >I/OCRATS4 ,CLASS-BAIT+ IS EVID5TLY A WEAPON TO BE DEPLOY$ ) F9E DISCRIM9ATION4 ,= ,BOOK*91 AS = ,/AL9I/S1 CLASS IS NOT A CATEGORY ( ANALYSIS1 ONLY AN >GOT ( ABUSE4 ,LONG AGO HE DISMISS$ 0WORK]ITIS0 AS 0REACTION>Y TO ! CORE0 R5D]$ MEAN+LESS BY ! TRANS-CLASS DECOMPOSITION ( CONTEMPOR>Y SOCIETY 7#a#i#g#a3 #a#h#f-#a#h#g74 ,SO COMPLETELY DID CLASS DISAPPE> FROM ,BOOK*9'S IDEOLOGY ?AT A REVIEW ( ONE ( HIS GO(I] BOOKS 7,BOOK*9 #a#i#h#g7 EXCLAIM$ ?AT 0IT IS :AT IS MISS+ ALTOGE!R ?AT R5D]S HIS BOOK T]M9ALLY PA!TIC4 ,NO:]E DOES HE F9D FAULT ) ! MO/ FUNDAM5TAL DIM5SION ( MOD]N LIV+1 ?AT ( WAGE-LABOR & ! COMMODITY0 7,Z]ZAN #a#i#i#d3 #a#f#f74 ,HE N[ REV]TS TO ! HO>Y ,M>XI/ EPI!TS -- 0B\RGEOIS10 0PETIT-B\RGEOIS0 & 0LUMP50 -- BUT ) NO PRET5SE ?AT !Y HAVE1 = HIM1 REAL SOCIAL CONT5T4 ,O!RWISE1 H[ C\LD HE APPLY ALL !SE WORDS TO ! SAME PEOPLE8 ,9 !IR RELATIONS TO ! MEANS ( PRODUCTION 7OR LACK !RE(71 LIFE/YLE AN>*I/S CANNOT BE BO? B\RGEOIS & LUMP5S4 ,& H[ LIKELY IS IT ?AT \T ( !SE 0?\S&S ( SELF-/YL$ AN>*I/S0 7#a71 NOT ONE IS A PROLET>IAN8 ,:]E ,BOOK*9 ACCUSES RIVAL AN>*I/S ( 9DIVIDUALISM & LIB]ALISM1 ,/AL9I/S ACCUSE ALL AN>*I/S ( ! SAME4 ,= EXAMPLE1 !RE WAS ?AT ,MON?LY ,REVIEW CONTRIBUTOR :O REF]R$ TO ,BOOK*9ISM AS 0A CRUDE K9D ( 9DIVIDUALI/IC AN>*ISM0 7,BOOK*9 #a#i#g#a3 #b#b#e76 ,9 O!R WORDS1 444CAPITALISM PROMOTES EGOTISM1 NOT 9DIVIDUALITY OR 09DIVIDUALISM40444,! T]M 0B\RGEOIS 9DIVIDUALISM10 AN EPI!T WIDELY US$ TODAY AGA9/ LIB]T>IAN ELEM5TS1 REFLECTS ! EXT5T TO :I* B\RGEOIS IDEOLOGY P]MEATES ! SOCIALI/ PROJECT -- -- !SE WORDS BE+1 ( C\RSE1 ?OSE ( ,BOOK*9 ! ,Y\NG] 7#a#i#g#a3 #b#h#d74 ,?AT ! ,DEAN REV]TS TO !SE ,/AL9I/ SLURS 9 HIS DOTAGE REFLECTS ! EXT5T TO :I* B\RGEOIS IDEOLOGY P]MEATES HIS PROJECT4 ,FANATICALLY DEVOT$ TO URBANISM1 ! ,DEAN WAS BE+ COMPLIM5T>Y1 NOT CRITICAL1 :5 HE WROTE ?AT 0! FULFILLM5T ( 9DIVIDUALITY & 9TELLECT WAS ! HI/ORIC PRIVILEGE ( ! URBAN DWELL] OR ( 9DIVIDUALS 9FLU5C$ BY URBAN LIFE0 7#a#i#g#d3 #a74 ,9DIVIDUALITY'S NOT SO BAD AFT] ALL1 PROVID$ IT'S ON HIS T]MS4 ,AS = 0DECAD5CE10 ?AT IS AN EM95TLY B\RGEOIS SWE>-WORD = PEOPLE P]CEIV$ TO BE HAV+ MORE FUN ?AN Y\ >E4 ,BY N[ ! WORD HAS LO/ :ATEV] CONCRETE MEAN+ IT EV] HAD4 ,CALL+ PO/-LEFTI/ AN>*I/S 0DECAD5T0 IS JU/ ,DEAN ,BOOK*9'S WAY ( V5T+ HIS 5VY &1 AS ,NIETZS*E W\LD SAY1 RESS5TIM5T ?AT !Y >E NOT AFFLICT$ ) ! HEMORRHOIDS1 TAX AUDITS1 OR :ATEV] IT IS ?AT'S RA9+ ON HIS ,MAYDAY P>ADE4 O ,*APT] #b 3 ,:AT IS ,9DIVIDUALI/ ,AN>*ISM8 ,*APT] #b3 ,:AT IS ,9DIVIDUALI/ ,AN>*ISM8 ,DEAN ,BOOK*9 POSITS AN ET]NALLY RECURR+ 0T5SION0 )9 AN>*ISM BETWE5 ! 9DIVIDUAL & ! SOCIAL 7#d74 ,AS ?IS IS NONE O!R ?AN ! C5TRAL CONUNDRUM ( ,WE/]N POLITICAL PHILOSOPHY1 ! ,DEAN IS NEI!R ORIG9AL NOR -- MORE IMPORTANT -- HAS HE ID5TIFI$ A SPECIFICALLY AN>*I/ T5SION4 ,HE GOES ON TO ID5TIFY ! ANTI!SES )9 AN>*ISM AS 0TWO BASICALLY CONTRADICTORY T5D5CIES3 A P]SONALI/IC COMMITM5T TO 9DIVIDUAL AUTONOMY & A COLLECTIVI/ COMMITM5T TO SOCIAL FRE$OM0 7#d74 ,?IS IS ! 0UNBRIDGEABLE *ASM0 HIS BOOK TITLE REF]S TO4 ,IF ! ,DEAN IS RIE NOT JU/ 9 T5SION BUT BASICALLY CONTRADICTORY -- !N AN>*Y IS IMPOSSIBLE1 AS ANTI-AN>*I/S HAVE ALWAYS MA9TA9$4 ,BOOK*9 H]E REJECTS \T ( H& :AT HE US$ TO ESP\SE1 0A SOCIETY ?AT W\LD TRANSC5D ! HI/ORIC SPLITS BETWE54449DIVIDUAL & SOCIETY0 7#a#i#g3 #e#i74 ,NOT ALL ( US %>E HIS CONS]VATIVE FATALISM4 ,WE TOO HAVE \R APPREH5SIONS & \R TIMES ( DESPAIR4 ,BUT TO SURR5D] TO !M 5TIRELY 7:I* ,I CONDEMN NOBODY = DO+1 IF HE'S HONE/ AB\T IT7 IS TO R5\NCE ANY AFFILIATION ) AN>*ISM4 ,! ,DEAN WON'T FI%1 NEI!R WILL HE CUT BAIT4 ,HE WON'T %IT1 NEI!R WILL HE GET (F ! POT4 ,SOME ( ?OSE ) IMPECCABLE1 ,BOOK*9-APPROV$ CR$5TIALS1 SU* AS ,KROPOTK91 HAD A MORE TOL]ANT TAKE ON ?IS G5U9ELY TRAGIC DILEMMA3 ,AN>*I/ ,COMMUNISM MA9TA9S ?AT MO/ VALUABLE ( ALL CONQUE/S -- 9DIVIDUAL LIB]TY -- & MOREOV] EXT5DS IT & GIVES IT A SOLID BASIS -- ECONOMIC LIB]TY -- )\T :I* POLITICAL LIB]TY IS DELUSIVE2 IT DOES NOT ASK ! 9DIVIDUAL :O HAS REJECT$ GOD1 ! UNIV]SAL TYRANT1 GOD ! K+1 & GOD ! P>LIAM5T1 TO GIVE UNTO HIMSELF A GOD MORE T]RIBLE ?AN ANY ( ! PREC$+ -- GOD ! ,COMMUNITY1 OR TO ABDICATE UPON ITS ALT> HIS 9DEP5D5CE1 HIS WILL1 HIS TA/ES1 & TO R5EW ! V[ ( ASCETICISM :I* HE =M]LY MADE BE=E ! CRUCIFI$ GOD4 ,IT SAYS TO HIM1 ON ! CONTR>Y1 0,NO SOCIETY IS FREE SO LONG AS ! 9DIVIDUAL IS NOT SO60 7,KROPOTK9 #a#h#i3 #a#d-#a#e7 ,BOOK*9 IS ! V]ITABLE HI< PRIE/ ( :AT ,KROPOTK9 CALLS 0GOD ! ,COMMUNITY10 0MORE T]RIBLE ?AN ANY ( ! PREC$+10 ! MO/ VICI\S & OPPRESSIVE GOD ( ALL4 0,SOCIAL FRE$OM0 IS LIKE ! 0FREE M>KET0 9 ! S5SE ?AT ! FRE$OM REF]R$ TO HAS TO BE METAPHORICAL4 ,IT MAKES NO LIT]AL S5SE TO ATTRIBUTE FRE$OM TO BEHAVIORAL 9T]ACTION SY/EMS1 EV5 FE$BACK SY/EMS1 LACK+ ! NECESS>ILY 9DIVIDUAL QUALITIES ( CONSCI\SNESS & 9T5TION4 ,IT'S LIKE SAY+ AN AN?ILL OR ! SOL> SY/EM OR A !RMO/AT IS FREE4 ,FREE FROM1 & =1 :AT8 ,:AT ELSE C\LD A SOCIETY OR A M>KET POSSIBLY BE FREE ( IF NOT AUTONOM\S 9DIVIDUALS8 ,IF ONE ASSIGNS ANY VALUE TO 9DIVIDUAL AUTONOMY1 LOGICALLY !RE >E ONLY TWO POSSIBILITIES = IT TO EV5 EXI/1 MU* LESS FL\RI%1 9 SOCIETY4 7,CONTR>Y TO :AT ! ,DEAN IMPLIES .<#e#h.>1 NOT EV5 ,MAX ,/IRN] ?\47 ,! FIR/ IS A COMPROMISE3 LIB]ALISM4 ,! 9DIVIDUAL EX*ANGES P>T ( HIS PREC>I\S NATURAL LIB]TY = SOCIETY'S PROTECTION ( ! RE/ ( IT1 & ALSO = ! PRACTICAL OPPORTUNITIES = ADVANC+ HIS 9T]E/S ONLY OP5$ UP 9 A SOCIAL /ATE4 ,?IS WAS ! POSITION ( ,?OMAS ,HOBBES1 ,JOHN ,LOCKE1 ,ADAM ,SMI? & ,WILLIAM ,BLACK/ONE4 ,9 ! PUBLIC SPH]E1 FRE$OM MEANS DEMOCRACY2 ,9 ! PRIVATE SPH]E1 IT MEANS 9DIVIDUAL RIY1 ! RADICAL ONE1 IS AN>*ISM4 ,AN>*ISM REJECTS ! DI*OTOMY AS FALSE -- MAYBE NOT FALSE AS EXI/+ SOCIETY IS CON/ITUT$1 BUT FALSE 9 ITS SUPPOS$ FATALITY4 ,9 AN AN>*I/ SOCIETY ! 9DIVIDUAL GA9S FRE$OM1 NOT AT ! EXP5SE ( O!RS1 BUT 9 COOP]ATION ) !M4 ,A P]SON :O BELIEVES ?AT ?IS CONDITION -- AN>*Y -- IS POSSIBLE & DESIRABLE IS CALL$ AN AN>*I/4 ,A P]SON :O ?9KS IT IS NOT POSSIBLE OR NOT DESIRABLE IS A /ATI/4 ,AS ,I %ALL HAVE NO DIFFICULTY DEMON/RAT+ LAT] ON1 IT SO HAPP5S ?AT ! ,DEAN HIMSELF IS NOT AN AN>*I/1 M]ELY1 9 HIS [N T]M9OLOGY1 A 0SELF-/YL$ AN>*I/40 ,BUT ?AT'S NO REASON = ?OSE ( US :O 7ALBEIT UN5?USIA/ICALLY1 IF ,I MAY SPEAK = MYSELF7 >E AN>*I/S NOT TO HE$ HIS CRITIQUE4 ,FROM ,GEORGE ,B]N>D ,%AW TO ,GUY ,DEBORD1 ANTI-AN>*I/S :O TOOK AN>*ISM S]I\SLY HAVE (T5 SUPPLI$ CRUCIAL CRITIQUES ! AN>*I/S W]E UNABLE OR UNWILL+ TO CON/RUCT !MSELVES4 ,UN=TUNATELY1 ,BOOK*9'S ISN'T ONE ( !M4 ,:AT IS REM>KABLE AB\T ,DEAN ,BOOK*9'S PO/UR+ AS ! ,DEF5D] ( ! ,FAI?1 ASIDE FROM ! FACT ?AT HE DOESN'T %>E IT1 IS H[ MANY ( ! ,*UR* ,FA!RS 7& ,MO!RS7 HE HAS EXCOMMUNICAT$ AS 09DIVIDUALI/S40 ,PR$ICTABLY1 ,WILLIAM ,GODW9 7#e71 ,MAX ,/IRN] 7#g1 #a#a7 & ,B5JAM9 ,TUCK] 7#h7 ,BOOK*9 SUMM>ILY DISMISSES AS 9DIVIDUALI/S1 AL?\< ?AT H>DLY DOES JU/ICE TO ! RI*NESS ( !IR 9SI*ISM4 7,AL?\< EV5 ,KROPOTK9 ACKN[L$G$ ?AT ,GODW9 ESP\S$ COMMUNISM 9 ! FIR/ $ITION ( ,POLITICAL ,JU/ICE1 ONLY 0MITIGAT+0 ?AT VIEW 9 LAT] $ITIONS .<,KROPOTK9 #a#i#i#e2 #b#c#h.>1 & ! AN>*O-SYNDICALI/ ,RUDOLF ,ROCK] ACKN[L$G$ ?AT ,GODW9 0WAS REALLY ! F\ND] ( ! LAT] COMMUNI/ ,AN>*ISM0 .<#a#i#d#g3 #g.>47 #a ,BUT ?AT'S ONLY ! BEG9N+ ( ! PURGE4 ,! ,DEAN CONDEMNS EV5 ,PR\DHON AS AN 9DIVIDUALI/ 7#e71 AL?\< HE ELSE:]E PAYS TRIBUTE TO 0,PR\DHON'S EMPHASIS ON F$]AL-ISM .<:I*.> /ILL 5JOYS CONSID]ABLE VALIDITY0 7,BOOK*97 #a#i#i#f3 #b#d74 ,:5 ,BOOK*9 SAYS ?AT SOME?+ FROM A CLASSICAL AN>*I/ /ILL 5JOYS CONSID]ABLE VALIDITY1 ?IS IS HIS WAY ( SAY+ ?AT'S :OM HE FIL*$ IT FROM4 ,! F$]ALISM ( ,PR\DHON'S LAT] YE>S 7#a#i#g#i7 IS VIRTUALLY ID5TICAL TO ,BOOK*9'S CALL = A 0CONF$]ATION ( DEC5TRALIZ$ MUNICIPALITIES0 7#f74 ,:I* IS TANTAM\NT TO SAY+ ?AT 9 ! 5D ,PR\DHON WAS NOT AN AN>*I/1 AS ,I AM NOT ! ONLY ONE TO HAVE NOTIC$ 7,/EV5 #a#i#h#d74 ,9DE$1 ! ,DEAN HAS COME CLOSE TO ADMITT+ IT HIMSELF 7,BOOK*9 #a#i#g#g3 #b#a74 ,! ,DEAN N[ CLAIMS ?AT ! PROM95T ,SPANI% AN>*I/ ,F$]ICA ,MONTS5EY WAS A 0,/IRN]ITE0 . 9 !ORY IF NOT 9 PRACTICE 7#h74 ,9 HIS ,! ,SPANI% ,AN>*I/S %E IS 0ONE ( ! ,F,A,I'S LUM9>IES0 7,BOOK*9 #a#i#g#g3 #b#d#c74 ,! ,F,A,I WAS A 0VANGU>D0 7! WORD IS ,BOOK*9'S7 AN>*O-COMMUNI/ SECRET SOCIETY 7,BOOK*9 #a#i#i#d3 #b#a-#b#b2 CF4 ,BRADEMAS #a#i#e#c74 ,EV5 ,EMMA ,GOLDMAN IS UND] A CL\D4 ,AL?\< %E WAS AN AV[$ AN>*O-COMMUNI/1 %E ALSO DISPLAY$ A DISQUALIFY+ AFF9ITY ) ,NIETZS*E 7#h71 & %E WAS1 AFT] ALL1 0BY NO MEANS ! ABLE/ ?9K] 9 ! LIB]T>IAN PAN!ON0 7#a#c74 ,BOOK*9 HAS A MUSCUL>1 MASCUL9E DISDA9 = AN>*I/ WOM5 SU* AS ,EMMA ,GOLDMAN1 ,F$]ICA ,MONTS5EY & ,L4 ,SUSAN ,BR[N4 ,ONLY HIS 9NATE MODE/Y KEPT ! ,DEAN FROM NAM+ :O IS ! ABLE/ ?9K] 9 ! LIB]T>IAN PAN!ON1 BUT !N AGA91 :O1 HAV+ READ HIM1 NE$S TO BE TOLD8 ,PAUL ,GOODMAN1 A 0COMMUNIT>IAN AN>*I/0 7,/AF=D #a#i#g#b3 #a#a#b71 ,BOOK*9 CALLS 0AN ESS5TIALLY 9DIVIDUALI/IC AN>*I/0 7#a#b71 AL?\< ,GOODMAN WAS ESS5TIALLY AN URBAN-ORI5T$1 HUMANI/IC AN>*O-COLLECTIVI/ 7,GOODMAN @& ,GOODMAN #a#i#f#a3 *4 #f @& #b#b2 CF4 ,/AF=D #a#i#g#b3 #a#a#b-#a#a#c7 FROM :OM ,BOOK*9 HAS CRIBB$ MANY IDEAS )\T ADMITT+ IT4 ,NOTICE1 = 9/ANCE1 ! REM>KABLE ABS5CE ( ANY 9F]5CES TO ! BY !N DECEAS$ ,GOODMAN 9 ,BOOK*9'S ,! ,LIMITS ( ! ,CITY 7#a#i#g#d7 OR ,! ,RISE ( ,URBANIZATION & ! ,DECL9E ( ,CITIZ5%IP 7#a#i#h#g71 AL?\< HE DID LET SLIP ! NAME 9 ,CRISIS 9 ,\R ,CITIES 7,H]B] #a#i#f#e3 #a#g#g7 AT A TIME :5 ,GOODMAN WAS 9 HIS PRIME :]EAS ! FUTURE ,DEAN WAS SO F> FROM =ESEE+ HIS [N CELEBRITY ?AT HE WROTE UND] A PSEUDONYM4 ,HE'LL SOON WI% HE'D WRITT5 ?IS TRA%Y HAD UND] A PSEUDONYM4 0,9DIVIDUALI/0 AN>*I/S 9 ! ORIG9AL S5SE -- PEOPLE LIKE ,MAX ,/IRN] 7#a#i#i#e7 & ,JOHN ,H5RY ,MACKAY -- W]E NEV] NUM]\S1 AS ,BOOK*9 OBS]VES ) TOO MU* SATISFACTION 7#f-#h74 ,& !Y W]E ALWAYS FEW & F> BETWE51 /RANGE TO SAY1 9 DECAD5T1 B\RGEOIS ,NOR? ,AM]ICA1 SUPPOS$LY !IR NATURAL BRE$+-GR\ND4 ,/IRN] DID NOT ID5TIFY HIMSELF AS AN AN>*I/1 PROBABLY BECAUSE ! ONLY 79DE$1 ! V]Y FIR/7 0SELF-/YL$0 AN>*I/ 9 ! #a#h#dS :5 HE WAS WRIT+ WAS ,PR\DHON1 = :OM MORALISM1 AS ,/IRN] NOTIC$1 S]V$ AS A SURROGATE = RELIGION 7IBID43 #d#f7 -- AS IT DOES = ! ,DEAN4 ,! RA!R FEW 9DIVIDUALS :O AT LAT] TIMES CONSID]$ !MSELVES ,/IRN]I/S HAVE1 H[EV]1 USUALLY CONSID]$ !MSELVES AN>*I/S AS WELL1 SU* AS ! ,ITALIAN PEASANT GU]RILLA ,R5ZO ,NOVATORE 7,BLACK @& ,P>FREY #a#i#h#i3 #i#b-#i#c7 ,IT IS WOR? M5TION+ -- BECAUSE SO MANY PEOPLE :O TOSS HIS NAME >\ND HAVE NEV] READ HIM -- ?AT ,/IRN] HAD NO SOCIAL OR ECONOMIC PROGRAM :ATSOEV]4 ,HE WAS NO MORE PRO-CAPITALI/ ?AN HE WAS PRO-COMMUNI/1 AL?\< ,M>XI/S LIKE ,M>X1 ,5GELS & ,BOOK*9 HAVE R\T9ELY & M9DLESSLY CA/IGAT$ HIM AS AN APOLOGI/ = CAPITALISM4 ,/IRN] WAS JU/ NOT OP]AT+ AT ?AT LEVEL4 ,HE WAS /AK+ A CLAIM1 ! MO/ RADICAL CLAIM POSSIBLE1 = ! 9DIVIDUAL AS AGA9/ ALL ! IDEOLOGIES & AB/RACTIONS :I*1 PURPORT+ TO LIB]ATES HIM 9 G5]AL & 9 ! AB/RACT1 LEFT ! 9DIVIDUAL AS P]SONALLY1 PRACTICALLY SUBORD9ATE AS EV]3 0,9 PR9CIPLE444 ,/IRN] CREAT$ A UTOPI/IC VISION ( 9DIVIDUALITY ?AT M>K$ A NEW PO9T ( DEP>TURE = ! AFFIRMATION ( P]SONALITY 9 AN 9CREAS+LY IMP]SONAL WORLD0 7,BOOK*9 #a#i#h#b3 #a#e#i74 ,FROM ,/IRN]'S P]SPECTIVE -- :I* ON ?IS PO9T IS ALSO M9E -- IDEOLOGIES LIKE LIB]ALISM1 HUMANISM1 ,M>XISM1 SYNDICALISM1 & ,BOOK*9ISM HAVE ALL TOO MU* 9 COMMON 7CF4 ,BLACK #a#i#i#d3 #b#b#a-#b#b#b74 ,NOBODY ! ,DEAN D5\NCES AS A 0,/IRN]ITE10 NOT ,MI*AEL ,WILLIAM 7#e71 NOT ,HAKIM ,BEY 7#b#c7 IS A ,/IRN]I/ IF ?IS IMPLIES ?AT HE AFFIRMS AMORAL EGOISM & IS 9DIFF]5T TO OR 5TIRELY AGNO/IC AB\T SOCIAL & ECONOMIC =MATIONS4 ,BO? OBVI\SLY ASSUME AS AXIOMATIC ! NE$ = A SOCIAL MATRIX = 9DIVIDUAL EFFLORESC5CE4 ,:AT DI/+UI%ES !M1 9 MORE ?AN ONE S5SE1 FROM ! ,DEAN IS !IR APPRECIATION ( ! EPI/EMIC BREAK 9 B\RGEOIS ?\D1 ,S*OP5HAU]1 ,/IRN]1 ,NIETZS*E1 ! SURREALI/S & ! CONTEMPOR>Y EXI/5TIALI/S4 ,= ! ,M>XIANS M]ELY TO DISMISS ?IS PO/-,HEGELIAN DEVELOPM5T AS 0B\RGEOIS IDEOLOGY0 IS TO DISMISS ! PROBLEM ITSELF4 ,Y\ GUESS$ IT3 ,BOOK*9 ! ,Y\NG] AGA9 7#a#i#g#a3 #b#g#f74 ,= ,BOOK*9 TO DISMISS ?IS PO/-,HEGELIAN DEVELOPM5T AS 0B\RGEOIS IDEOLOGY0 IS TO DISMISS ! PROBLEM ITSELF4 ,9 A MORE REC5T1 /ILL N>R[] S5SE1 09DIVIDUALISM0 DESIGNATES ?OSE :O COMB9E REJECTION ( GOV]NM5T ) ESP\SAL ( AN ABSOLUTELY UNLIMIT$ LAISSEZ-FAIRE M>KET SY/EM4 ,SU* IDEOLOGUES DO EXI/1 BUT ,BOOK*9 NEV] EV5 M5TIONS A CONTEMPOR>Y EXAMPLE1 AL?\< HE CANNOT BE UNAW>E ( !IR EXI/5CE1 S9CE HE MADE USE ( ONE ( !IR PUBLI%]S1 ,FREE ,LIFE ,BOOKS 7,BOOK*9 #a#i#g#g74 ,CONSID]ABLE CONTACT ) SOME ( !M OV] ! YE>S HAS P]SUAD$ ME ?AT MO/ AN>*O-CAPITALI/S >E S9C]E 9 !IR AN>*ISM1 AL?\< ,I AM AS C]TA9 ?AT AN>*O-CAPITALISM IS SELF-CONTRADICTORY AS ,I AM ?AT AN>*O-SYNDICALISM IS4 ,UNLIKE ! ,DEAN1 ,I'VE ON OCCASION TAK5 ! TR\BLE TO CONFUTE !SE LIB]T>IANS 7,BLACK #a#i#h#f3#a#d#a-#a#d#h2 ,BLACK #a#i#i#b3 #d#c-#f#b74 ,BUT ! PO9T IS1 NOBODY ! ,DEAN T>GETS 9 ?IS SCRE$ IS BY ANY /RET* ( ! IMAG9ATION 7NOT ?AT HE HAS ONE7 AN 09DIVIDUALI/0 AN>*I/ 9 ! USUAL CONTEMPOR>Y S5SE ( ! T]M4 ,HE NEV] EV5 CLAIMS ?AT ANY ( !M >E4 ,! ,DEAN MAKES ! BIZ>RE ALLEGATION ?AT ?OSE HE CALLS LIFE/YLE AN>*I/S1 DECAD5T SUCCESSORS TO ! 9DIVIDUALI/ AN>*I/S1 CLAIM 7! QUOTATION M>KS >E HIS7 !IR 0SOV]EIGN RIE VALIDAT$ BY AXIOMATIC 0NATURAL RIKS IS 9 ORD] H]E4 0,QUOTATION M>KS10 WROTE ,!ODOR ,ADORNO1 444>E TO BE REJECT$ AS AN IRONIC DEVICE4 ,= !Y EXEMPT ! WRIT] FROM ! SPIRIT :OSE CLAIM IS 9H]5T 9 IRONY1 & !Y VIOLATE ! V]Y CONCEPT ( IRONY BY SEP>AT+ IT FROM ! MATT] AT H& & PRES5T+ A PR$ET]M9$ JUDGM5T ON ! SUBJECT4 ,! ABUNDANT IRONIC QUOTATION M>KS 9 ,M>X & ,5GELS >E ! %AD[S ?AT TOTALIT>IAN ME?ODS CA/ 9 ADVANCE UPON !IR WRIT+S1 :OSE 9T5TION WAS ! OPPOSITE3 ! SE$ FROM :I* EV5TUALLY CAME :AT ,K>L ,KRAUS CALL$ ,MOSKAUD]WELS* .<,MOSC[ D\BLE-TALK1 FROM ,MOSKAU1 ,MOSC[1 & ,KAUD]WELS*1 GIBB]I% OR D\BLE-TALK.>4 ,! 9DIFF]5CE TO L+UI/IC EXPRESSION %[N 9 ! ME*ANICAL DELEGATION ( 9T5TION TO A TYPOGRAPHIC CLI*E >\SES ! SUSPICION ?AT ! V]Y DIALECTIC ?AT CON/ITUTES ! !ORY'S CONT5T HAS BE5 BR\Y =M ALMO/ ALWAYS 9DICATES DOGMATIZATION ( ! CONT5T4 ,! BL9D V]DICT ( QUOTATION M>KS IS ITS GRAPHIC GE/URE 7,ADORNO #a#i#i3 #c#c74 ,AS A T5UR$ ACADEMIC1 ! ,DEAN IS PRESUMABLY AW>E ?AT 9 S*OL>LY DISC\RSE -- & SURELY HIS MAGI/]IAL ESSAY IS SU* -- QUOTATION M>KS ID5TIFY QUOTATIONS1 YET HIS #de FOOTNOTES FAIL TO REF]5CE ANY USE ( !SE EXPRESSIONS BY ANYBODY4 ,?AT IS BECAUSE NO SU* QUOTATIONS EXI/4 ,SO-CALL$ LIFE/YLE AN>*I/S 7MEAN+3 NON-,BOOK*9I/S7 DON'T USUALLY ?9K OR WRITE ?AT WAY4 ,!Y T5D NOT TO GO 9 = RI*I/S4 ,MAX ,/IRN] WAS AN AMORAL EGOI/ OR 9DIVIDUALI/4 ,GODW9 & ,PR\DHON W]E1 IF !Y W]E 9DIVIDUALI/S AT ALL1 MORALI/IC 9DIVIDUALI/S PREOCCUPI$ ) :AT !Y CALL$ JU/ICE4 ,LYS&] ,SPOON] WAS AN EXAMPLE ( A CLE>LY MORALI/IC1 NATURAL-RI*I/4 ,BUT :5 ! PROM95T 9DIVIDUALI/ PUBLI%] ,B5JAM9 ,TUCK] W5T OV] TO ,/IRN]I/ EGOISM 9 ! LATE N9ETE5? C5TURY1 HE SPLIT ! ,AM]ICAN 9DIVIDUALI/S4 7,?IS1 AS MU* AS ! COMPETITION FROM COLLECTIVI/S CR$IT$ BY ,BOOK*9 .<#f- #g.>1 BR\KET CAPITALISM4 ,?OSE ATTRACT$ TO ! AMORALI/1 EGOI/ OR 7IF Y\ PLEASE7 0,/IRN]I/0 POSITION NECESS>ILY %>$ ) ,/IRN] A :OLE-SALE REJECTION ( MORALISM1 ?AT BE+ :AT ,/IRN]1 & ,NIETZS*E AFT] HIM1 ABSOLUTELY EXPLOD$ AS A T5ABLE PO9T ( VIEW4 ,BUT NO MORE ?AN ,/IRN] DID !Y EXHIBIT ANY 9T]E/ 9 LAISSEZ-FAIRE 7OR ANY7 ECONOMICS4 ,CAPITALISM1 AS ,MAX ,WEB] NOTIC$1 HAS ITS [N MORALISM1 (T5 IF NOT ALWAYS EXPRESS$ AS ! 0,PROTE/ANT E?IC40 ,! EGOI/S_/AMORALI/S & ! FREE-M>KET NATURAL-RIT$ OV] PRECISELY ?IS PO9T4 ,! EGOI/_/AMORALI/S HAVE CONTRIBUT$ SOME?+ TO ! 0LIFE/YLE AN>*I/S10 ! NATURAL-RITICULATE & ELABORATE A BASICALLY 9DIVIDUALI/ AN>*ISM1 YET RETA9 SOME FILIATIONS ) AN>*O-COMMUNISM0 7#a#c71 ,9 A FOOTNOTE HE'S MORE C&ID3 0,BR[N'S HAZY COMMITM5T TO AN>*O-COMMUNISM SEEMS TO D]IVE MORE FROM H] [N PREF]5CE ?AN FROM H] ANALYSIS0 7#f#b74 ,9 O!R WORDS1 MAYBE %E MEANS WELL BUT %E'S JU/ A DITSY DAME1 LIKE ,EMMA ,GOLDMAN4 ,JU/ BELIEV+ 9 AN>*O-COMMUNISM ISN'T GOOD 5\< TO ACQUIT Y\ ( ! *>GE ( 9DIVIDUALISM4 ,Y\ HAVE TO EMOTE A POLITICALLY CORRECT1 ANTI-9DIVIDUALI/ 0ANALYSIS0 TOO4 ,I WOND] H[ MANY ,MAKHNOVI/S1 & H[ MANY ,SPANI% RANK-&-FILE 9SURRECTION>IES FIIO W\LD HAVE PASS$ :ATEV] F9AL EXAM \R P$ANT MI FROM SURE ?AT 0! REVOLUTION WILL NOT BE TELEVIS$10 BUT ,I AM QUITE SURE IT WILL NOT BE ON ! F9AL EXAM1 NOT IF TEA*] KN[S :AT'S GOOD = HIM4 ,AS ,M>X SO TRULY SAID1 ! $UCATOR HIMSELF NE$S $UCAT+4 ,& AS ,DIOG5ES SAID1 :Y NOT :IP ! TEA*] :5 ! /UD5T MISBEHAVES8 ,! ,DEAN HAS BR\K ,TWA9 W\LD SAY7 ! ,NEW ,5GL& ,PURITAN EX]CISE KN[N AS ! 0RELATION ( FAI?40 ,9 ORD] TO JO9 ! ,CONGREGATIONAL ,*UR*1 ! APPLICANT NOT ONLY HAD TO AFFIRM EA* & EV]Y T5ET ( ,CALV9ISM1 HE HAD TO DEMON/RATE ?AT HE HAD GONE ?R\< A /&>DIZ$ SEQU5CE ( SPIRITUAL EXP]I5CES4 7,ALCOHOLICS ,ANONYM\S IS ! ONLY ,PROTE/ANT CULT :I* /ILL IMPOSES ?IS REQUIREM5T47 ,MO/ BELIEV]S NEV] MADE IT ?AT F>4 ,:AT ! ,DEAN MEANS BY AN 9ADEQUATE 0ANALYSIS0 IS OBVI\S 5\<3 ANY ANALYSIS O!R ?AN ,BOOK*9ISM IS NO ANALYSIS AT ALL4 ,! 0DISDA9 = !ORY0 HE ASCRIBES TO 09DIVIDUALI/0 AN>*ISM 7#a#a7 IS REALLY DISDA9 =1 OR RA!R 9DIFF]5CE TO1 HIS !ORY4 ,N[ADAYS1 AN>*O-COMMUNISM IS ,BOOK*9ISM OR IT IS NO?+ -- ACCORD+ TO ,BOOK*9 7#f74 ,LIKE IT OR NOT -- P]SONALLY 7& 0P]SONALI/ICALLY071 ,I LIKE IT -- !RE'S AN IRR$UCIBLE 9DIVIDUALI/IC DIM5SION TO AN>*ISM1 EV5 SOCIAL AN>*ISM1 AS ,L4 ,SUSAN ,BR[N IS H>DLY H]ETICAL 9 PO9T+ \T 7#a#i#i#c3 *4 #a74 ,ACCORD+ TO ,KROPOTK91 ,AN>*O-,COMMUNISM SAYS ?AT 0,NO SOCIETY IS FREE SO LONG AS ! 9DIVIDUAL IS NOT60 7#a#h#i3 #a#e74 ,IF IT S\NDS AS IF AN>*ISM HAS1 AS ! ,DEAN MI*ISM DOES HAVE FILIATIONS ) LIB]ALISM4 ,:AT ELSE C\LD ! ,DEAN POSSIBLY MEAN :5 HE WRITES ?AT SOCIAL AN>*ISM IS 0MADE ( FUNDAM5TALLY DIFF]5T /UFF0 ?AN LIFE/YLE AN>*ISM1 IT IS 0HEIR TO ! ,5LI*O-SYNDICALI/ ,RUDOLF ,ROCK] WROTE 7& HE WAS ONLY SUMM>IZ+ ! OBVI\S73 ,9 MOD]N ,AN>*ISM WE HAVE ! CONFLU5CE ( ! TWO GREAT CURR5TS :I* DUR+ & S9CE ! ,FR5* ,REVOLUTION HAVE F\ND SU* *>ACT]I/IC EXPRESSION 9 ! 9TELLECTUAL LIFE ( ,EUROPE3 ,SOCIALISM & ,LIB]ALISM4444 ,AN>*ISM HAS 9 COMMON ) ,LIB]ALISM ! IDEA ?AT ! HAPP9ESS & ! PROSP]ITY ( ! 9DIVIDUAL MU/ BE ! /&>D 9 ALL SOCIAL MATT]S4 ,&1 9 COMMON ) ! GREAT REPRES5TATIVES ( ,LIB]AL ?\T ( !SE PASSAGES AS QUOT$ BY ,BR[N 7#a#i#i#c3#a#a74 ,NATURALLY HE'D RA!R DEBUNK ,BR[N1 AN OBSCURE Y\NG ACADEMIC 7,J>A* #a#i#i#f71 ?AN ! ILLU/RI\S AN>*I/ ELD] ,ROCK]4 ,BOOK*9'S A PLAYGR\ND BULLY :O DOESN'T M9D HITT+ A GIRL ) GLASSES1 BUT HE'D BE (F HIS ,ROCK] TO MESS ) ,RUDOLF4 ,NOBODY *OOSES HIS ANCE/ORS4 ,RATIONALLY1 NO ONE %\LD BE A%AM$ ( !M4 ,VISIT+ ! S9S ( ! FA!RS ON ! *ILDR51 EV5 UNTO ! F\R? G5]ATION 7,EXODUS #c#d3#g7 -- AS ! ,DEAN IS DO+1 PRETTY MU* ON S*$ULE -- H>DLY COMPORTS ) ! ,5LIXISM-,L59ISM1 ALSO SUPPLI$ HIM ) A MUSCUL> POLEMICAL PRAXIS & A V]SATILE VOCABUL>Y ( ABUSE4 ,I'VE ALREADY DRAWN ATT5TION TO ONE ( !SE GAMBITS1 D5IGRATION-BY-QUOTATION-M>KS4 ,ITS 0FILIATIONS0 9CLUDE ,L59'S 0,LEFT-,W+0 ,COMMUNISM1 AN ,9FANTILE ,DISORD] 7#a#i#d7 & C\NTLESS TEXTS BY ,M>X & ,5GELS1 AS ,ADORNO 7#a#i#i7 NOTIC$4 ,JOHN ,Z]ZAN1 REVIEW+ ,BOOK*9 7#a#i#h#g71 NOT$ A RELAT$ WAY ?AT ! ,DEAN ABUS$ QUOTATION M>KS3 0,ANO!R DEVICE IS TO IGNORE ! REAL HI/ORY ( URBAN LIFE1 AS IF ILLUSORY2 HE RESORTS AT TIMES TO PUTT+ SU* T]MS AS 'ELECT$' REPRES5TATIVES1 'VOT]S' & 'TAXPAY]S' 9 QUOTES AS ?\< ! T]MS REALLY DON'T1 SOMEH[1 CORRESPOND TO REALITY0 7,Z]ZAN #a#i#i#d3 #a#f#e74 ,AS IF TO CONFIRM ?AT HE'S 9CORRIGIBLE1 ,BOOK*9 REF]S TO ?IS REVIEW1 NOT AS A REVIEW1 BUT AS A 0REVIEW0 7#e#i74 ,BOOK*9 WAS DO+ ! SAME ?+ ALMO/ #d YE>S AGO :5 ! FIR/ *APT] ( ,! ,LIMITS ( ! ,CITY 7#a#i#g#d3 IX7 WAS WRITT53 ,T5O*TITLAN WAS ! 0CAPITAL10 NOT ! CAPITAL1 ( ! URBAN1 IMP]IALI/IC1 CANNIBALI/IC ,AZTEC EMPIRE 7IBID43 #g1 #i74 ,BOOK*9 JU/ DOESN'T KN[ :5 TO %UT UP4 ,HAV+ LAMBA/$ 9DIVIDUALI/S AS LIB]ALS1 HE TURNS >\ND & 9S9UATES ?AT !Y >E FASCI/S6 ,CRITICS ( 9DU/RIAL TE*NOLOGY 7SPECIFICALLY1 ,GEORGE ,BRAD=D ( ! ,FIF? ,E/ATE7 :O >GUE ?AT IT DET]M9ES1 AS WELL AS BE+ DET]M9$ BY1 SOCIAL ORGANIZATION >E1 OP9ES ! ,DEAN1 0DEEPLY ROOT$ 9 ! CONS]VATIVE ,G]MAN ROMANTICISM ( ! N9ETE5? C5TURY0 :I* 0F$ 9TO ,NATIONAL ,SOCIALI/ IDEOLOGY1 H[EV] MU* ! ,NAZIS HONOR$ !IR ANTITE*NOLOGICAL IDEOLOGY 9 ! BREA*0 7#b#i74 ,?IS W\LD BE A SOPHI/ICAT$ V]SION ( GUILT-BY-ASSOCIATION IF IT W]E SOPHI/ICAT$4 ,! ,DEAN DOESN'T BO!R TO EV5 ID5TIFY !SE 0CONS]VATIVE ,G]MAN0 ROMANTICS -- HE HASN'T READ !M1 PROBABLY C\LDN'T EV5 NAME !M -- MU* LESS SUB/ANTIATE !IR UNLIKELY 9FLU5CE ON CONTEMPOR>Y 0LIFE/YLE0 AN>*I/S4 ,RETRO-LEFTI/ ?AT HE IS1 ,BOOK*9 MU/ SUPPOSE ?AT BRACKET+ ! HATE-WORDS 0CONS]VATIVE0 & 0,G]MAN0 IS A ONE-TWO PUN* NOBODY RECOV]S FROM4 ,ONE PAGE LAT] 7#c71 HE ADMITS ?AT 0!RE IS NO EVID5CE ?AT ,BRAD=D IS FAMILI> ) ,HEIDEGG] OR ,JUNG]10 ! TW5TIE?-C5TURY ,G]MAN 9TELLECTUALS HE J'ACCUSES AS C>RI]S ( N9ETE5?-C5TURY CONS]VATIVE ,G]MAN ROMANTIC IDEOLOGY4 ,MC,C>?YISM IS ! POLITICAL /RATEGY ( GUILT BY ASSOCIATION4 ,IF Y\ KN[ A ,COMMUNI/1 OR IF Y\ KN[ SOMEONE :O KN[S SOMEONE :O IS A ,COMMUNI/1 PRESUMPTIVELY Y\ >E A ,COMMUNI/ & Y\'LL HAVE TO TALK Y\R WAY \T ( IT1 PREF]ABLY BY RATT+ SOMEBODY \T4 ,! EX-,COMMUNI/ ,BOOK*9 HAS \TDONE ,S5ATOR ,MC,C>?Y4 ,! ,S5ATOR S\?Y IS QUITE AN ACCOMPLI%M5T1 :AT ,NIETZS*E US$ TO CALL A 0D[NGO+40 ,& ANO!R ?+1 N9ETE5?-C5TURY ROMANTICISM WAS NEI!R EXCLUSIVELY CONS]VATIVE NOR EXCLUSIVELY ,G]MAN4 ,:AT AB\T ! LIB]AL OR RADICAL ,G]MAN ROMANTICISM ( ,BEE?OV5 & ,BU*N] & ,S*ILL] & ,HE9E8 ,& :AT AB\T ! NON-,G]MAN RADICAL ROMANTICISM ( ,BLAKE & ,BURNS & ,BYRON & ,%ELLEY8 ,! ,DEAN RELATES ?AT ! ,NAZIS HONOR$ !IR ROMANTIC1 ANTI-TE*NOLOGICAL IDEOLOGY 09 ! BREA*40 0,HONOR$ 9 ! BREA*0 IS ,BOOK*9'S POOR TRY AT HEAD+ (F ! OBVI\S1 & DECISIVE1 OBJECTION ?AT ! ,NAZIS DIDN'T HAVE AN ANTI-TE*NOLOGICAL IDEOLOGY4 ,! ,AUTOBAHN WAS AS MU* A MONUM5T TO TE*NOLOGY AS W]E ITS CONTEMPOR>IES ! ,MOSC[ SUBWAY & ! ,NEW ,YORK ,WORLD'S ,FAIR 7:I*1 ,I SUSPECT1 ?RILL$ ! #a#h-YE>-OLD ,MURRAY ,BOOK*974 ,SO WAS ! ,V-#b4 ,ALMO/ OP5LY ]OTIC REF]5CES TO IRON & /EEL RECUR ) MONOTON\S & PA?OLOGICAL FREQU5CY 9 ,NAZI RHETORIC4 ,AS ,JOHN ,Z]ZAN REM>K$ 9 A BOOK ! ,DEAN CLAIMS TO HAVE READ 7#c#i-#d#b1 #fb N4 #a#i72 ,BEH9D ! RHETORIC ( ,NATIONAL ,SOCIALISM1 UN=TUNATELY1 WAS ONLY AN ACCEL]ATION ( TE*NIQUE1 EV5 9TO ! SPH]E ( G5OCIDE AS A PROBLEM ( 9DU/RIAL PRODUCTION4 ,= ! ,NAZIS & ! GULLIBLE1 IT WAS1 AGA9 A QUE/ION ( H[ TE*NOLOGY IS UND]/OOD IDEALLY1 NOT AS IT REALLY IS4 ,9 #aid ! ,G5]AL ,9SPECTOR = ! ,G]MAN ,ROAD ,SY/EM PUT IT ?IS WAY3 0,CONCRETE & /ONE >E MAT]IAL ?+S4 ,MAN GIVES !M =M & SPIRIT4 ,NATIONAL ,SOCIALI/ TE*NOLOGY POSSESSES 9 ALL MAT]IAL A*IEVEM5T IDEAL CONT5T0 7,Z]ZAN #a#i#i#d3 #a#d74 ,I'M NOT ONE ( ?OSE :O CRIES \T 9 HORROR AT ! SLIY ROMANTICISM1 MO/ REC5TLY 9 ! PHILOSOPHY ( ,M>T9 ,HEIDEGG]1 :OSE VOLKIS* 'SPIRITUALISM1' LAT5T 9 ,BE+ & ,TIME1 LAT] EM]G$ 9 HIS EXPLICITLY FASCI/ WORKS0 7#e74 ,SO LET'S CONSID] :E!R ,BOOK*9-VETT$ CLASSICAL AN>*I/S >E IDEOLOGICALLY KO%]4 ,PR\DHON WAS NOTORI\SLY ANTI- ,SEMITIC 7,SILB5] #a#i#d#h71 BUT S9CE ,BOOK*9 DISMISSES HIM1 H[EV] IMPLAUSIBLY1 AS TOO MU* ! 9DIVIDUALI/ 7#d-#e71 LET'S SET ,PR\DHON ASIDE4 ,BAKUN91 ! ,RUSSIAN >I/OCRAT :O 0EMPHATICALLY PRIORITIZ$ ! SOCIAL OV] ! 9DIVIDUAL0 7#e7 HAD A NOTION :AT WAS WRONG ) HIS AU?ORIT>IAN RIVAL1 ,K>L ,M>X4 ,BAKUN9 CONSID]$ ,M>X1 0! ,G]MAN S*OL>1 9 HIS ?REEFOLD CAPACITY AS AN ,HEGELIAN1 A ,JEW1 & A ,G]MAN10 TO BE A 0HOPELESS /ATI/0 7#a#i#i#e3#a#d#b74 ,A ,HEGELIAN1 A ,JEW1 A SORT-( S*OL>1 A ,M>XI/1 A HOPELESS 7CITY-7 /ATI/ -- DOES ?IS S\ND LIKE ANYBODY FAMILI>8 ,! ,DEAN APPROV+LY QUOTES ,LEWIS ,MUM=D ON 0! ES!TIC EXCELL5CE ( ! MA*9E =M0 7#c#b71 A PHRASE :I* MI9ETTI OR ,MUSSOL9I OR ANYONE ELSE ON ! ILL-DEF9$ FRONTI] BETWE5 ,FUTURISM & ,FASCISM 7CF4 ,MOORE #a#i#i#f3 #a#h74 ,9 ,W>1 ! ,WORLDS ,ONLY ,HYGI5E1 ,M>9ETTI ELABORAT$ ON ! ,BOOK*9_/,MUM=D ES!TIC3 ,WE >E DEVELOP+ & PROCLAIM+ A GREAT NEW IDEA ?AT RUNS ?R\< MOD]N LIFE3 ! IDEA ( ME*ANICAL BEAUTY4 ,WE !RE=E EXALT LOVE = ! MA*9E1 ! LOVE WE NOTICE FLAM+ ON ! *EEKS ( ME*ANICS SCOR*$ & SME>$ ) COAL4 ,HAVE Y\ NEV] SE5 A ME*ANIC LOV+LY AT WORK ON ! GREAT P[]FUL BODY ( HIS LOCOMOTIVE8 ,HIS IS ! M9UTE1 LOV+ T5D]NESS ( A LOV] C>ESS+ HIS ADOR$ WOMAN 7,FL9T #a#i#g#b3 #i74 ,! ,G]MANS CONQU]$ ,EUROPE ) ,PANZ]S & ,/UKAS NOT BY BLOOD-&-SOIL HOCUS-POCUS4 ,NAZI IDEOLOGY IS F> TOOL 9COH]5T TO BE *>ACT]IZ$ AS EI!R PRO- OR ANTI-TE*NOLOGICAL4 ,! ,DEAN 9 BEWAIL+ \R 0DECAD5T1 B\RGEOISIFI$ ]A0 7#a7 & \R 0DECAD5T P]SONALISM0 7#b7 IS HIMSELF E*O+ ,NAZI & ,/AL9I/ RHETORIC1 AS HE SURELY REMEMB]S1 & IT'S AS EMPTY AS EV]4 ,! PO9T IS ?AT ! IDEOLOGY DIDN'T HAVE TO MAKE S5SE TO MATT]4 ,IT WAS VAGUE & 9CONSI/5T SO AS TO APPEAL TO AS MANY PEOPLE AS POSSIBLE :O DESP]ATELY NE$$ SOME?+ TO BELIEVE 91 SOME?+ TO FREE !M FROM FRE$OM1 SOME?+ TO COMM& !IR LOYALTY4 ,IT DIDN'T HAVE TO BE ! SAME COME-ON = EV]YONE4 ,! ,NAZIS1 FI%]S ( ,M5S*51 UND]/OOD ?AT Y\ NE$ DIFF]5T BAIT TO HOOK DIFF]5T FI%1 ?AT'S ALL4 ,& F9ALLY1 9DIVIDUALI/ AN>*I/S >E T]RORI/S -- OR RA!R1 AN>*I/ T]RORI/S >E 9DIVIDUALI/S4 ,! 9SEP>ABLE ASSOCIATION ( AN>*ISM ) T]RORISM COMM5C$ = ,AM]ICANS ) A SPECIFIC EV5T3 ! ,HAYM>KET TRAG$Y 9 ,*ICAGO 9 #a#h#h#f4 ,AS ! POLICE W]E BREAK+ UP A PEACEABLE WORK]S' RALLY1 SOMEONE ?REW A BOMB 9TO !IR MID/1 KILL+ OR W\ND+ SEV]AL ( !M4 ,EI*I/S 9VOLV$ 9 ! UNION MOVEM5T1 BUT 9DISPUTABLY 9NOC5T ( ! BOMB+1 W]E CONVICT$ ( MURD] & F\R ( !M HANG$ 7ONE COMMITT$ SUICIDE7 ON ! BASIS ( !IR AN>*I/ AGITATION & BELIEFS4 ,IF !RE IS ONE FACT AB\T ! HI/ORY ( AN>*ISM KN[N TO EV]YONE :O KN[S AT LEA/ ONE FACT AB\T ! HI/ORY ( AN>*ISM1 IT IS ?IS3 0,!REAFT]1 AN>*ISM1 9 ! PUBLIC M9D1 WAS 9SEP>ABLY L9K$ ) T]RORISM & DE/RUCTION0 7,AVRI* #a#i#h#d3 #d#b#h2 CF4 ,S*U/] #a#i#c#b3 #a#f#f2 ,WOODCOCK #a#i#f#b3 #d#f#d74 ,& ! AN>*ISM ) :I* ! L9K WAS =G$ WAS ! COLLECTIVI/ AN>*ISM ( ! ,HAYM>KET DEF5DANTS4 ,?AT !Y W]E1 AS 9DIVIDUALS1 9NOC5T IS IRRELEVANT TO ! G5ESIS ( ! MAD-BOMB] LEG5D4 ,9NOC5T 9 ACT BUT NOT NECESS>ILY 9 9T5TION3 0,ONE ( !M1 .<,L\IS.> ,L+G1 HAD ! BE/ ALIBI3 HE WASN'T !RE444 HE WAS HOME1 MAK+ BOMBS4 ,HE WAS ?US CONVICT$ ( A CRIME HE W\LD HAVE LIK$ TO COMMIT0 7,BLACK @& ,P>FREY #a#i#h#i3 #f#g74 ,9 CONTRA/1 ONE HI/ORIAN REF]S TO 0! PEACEFUL PHILOSOPHY ( ,9DIVIDUALI/ ,AN>*ISM0 7,S*U/] #a#i#c#b3 #a#e#i74 ,! AN>*I/S' T]RORI/ REPUTATION WAS NOT1 H[EV]1 5TIRELY FABRICAT$ BY !IR 5EMIES 7,BLACK #a#i#i#d3 #e-#e#e74 ,9 ! #a#h#hS1 LEFT-W+ ,EUROPEAN AN>*I/S HAD ALREADY BEGUN TO PREA*1 & PRACTICE1 0PROPAG&A BY ! DE$10 SU* AS BOMB+S -- 0*EMI/RY10 AS !Y SOMETIMES PUT IT -- & ASSASS9ATIONS4 ,EV5 ! BEATIFIC ,KROPOTK9 WAS ORIG9ALLY A SUPPORT] ( 0! NEW TACTIC0 7,BOOK*9 #a#i#g#g3 #a#a#e74 ,SOME ?\*ISM & DISSEM9ATE IT TO ! MASSES4 ,ACCORD+ TO :AT ! ,DEAN CALLS 0! BE/ ACC\NT ( ,SPANI% ,AN>*ISM FROM #aica TO #a#i#c#f0 7,BOOK*9 #a#i#g#g3 #c#b#e71 0! LA/ DECADE ( ! . C5TURY WAS ONE 9 :I* ! AN>*I/S REALLY W]E 5GAG$ 9 ! BOMB-?R[+ :I* IS POPUL>LY ?\*I/ T]RORI/S W]E1 TO APPLY ,BOOK*9'S T]M9OLOGY ANA*RONI/ICALLY1 USUALLY SOCIAL AN>*I/S1 R>ELY 9DIVIDUALI/ AN>*I/S4 ,AUGU/ ,VAILLANT1 :O BOMB$ ! ,FR5* ,*AMB] ( ,DEPUTIES1 WAS A LEFTI/ 7,TU*MAN #a#i#f#f3 #i#a7 & A MEMB] ( AN AN>*I/ GR\P 7,BOOK*9 #a#i#g#g3 #a#a#d74 ,( ! ,FR5* BOMB]S ( ! #a#h#iS1 ,RAVA*OL ALONE1 SO F> AS ANYBODY KN[S1 WAS 0ALMO/ BUT NOT QUITE0 A ,/IRN]I/ 7,TU*MAN #a#i#f#d3 #g#i74 ,! ,SPANI% AN>*I/S :OM ! ,DEAN E/EEMS ABOVE ALL O!RS 7#a#i#g#g1 #a#i#i#d7 HAD P]HAPS ! LONGE/ T]RORI/ TRADITION ( ALL4 ,! 9DEX REF]5CE TO 0,T]RORISM1 AN>*I/0 9 HIS HI/ORY ( ,SPANI% AN>*ISM COV]S DOZ5S ( PAGES 7#a#i#g#g3 #c#d#b74 ,!RE W]E SPORADIC BOMB+S 9 ! #a#h#hS :I* BECAME *RONIC1 AT LEA/ 9 ! AN>*I/ /RONCELONA1 9 ! #a#h#iS 7,BOOK*9 #a#i#g#g3 *4 #f74 #a#i#a#h-#a#i#b#c1 P]IOD ( VIOL5T CLASS /RUGGLE 9 ,SPA91 WAS ! TIME ( ! PI/OL]OS -- GUNM5 -- A T]M :I* APPLIES TO BO? EMPLOY]-HIR$ GOONS & AN>*O-LEFTI/ MILITANTS4 ,AMONG HUNDR$S ( O!RS1 0A PREMI]1 TWO =M] CIVIL GOV]NORS1 AN ,>*-BI%OP1 NE>LY #c EMPLOY]S1 FACTORY DIRECTORS1 =EM51 & POLICE1 & MANY WORK]S & !IR LEAD]S 9 ! S9DICATO LIBRE .1 FELL BE=E ! BULLETS & BOMBS ( ,AN>*I/ ACTION GR\PS0 7,BOOK*9 #a#i#g#g3 #a#i#a74 ,! PI/OL]O PHASE SUBSID$ AS ! AN>*I/S1 :O W]E GETT+ ! WOR/ ( ! VIOL5CE ANYWAY1 W]E DRIV5 UND]GR\ND BY ! ,PRIMO DE ,RIV]A DICTATOR%IP AT ! SAME TIME ?AT A MEASURE ( PROSP]ITY TOOK ! $GE (F ! CLASS /RUGGLE4 ,BUT AN>*O-T]RORISM NEV] CEAS$4 ,DUR+ ! '#b,OS & '#c,OS1 0! ,F,A,I'S MO/ WELL-KN[N MILITANTS -- ,DURRUTI1 ! ,ASCASO BRO!RS1 ,G>CIA ,OLIV] -- 9CLUD$ T]RORISM 9 !IR REP]TORY ( DIRECT ACTION3 ',GUNPLAY1 ESPECIALLY 9 0EXPROPRIATIONS0 & 9 DEAL+ ) RECALCITRANT EMPLOY]S1 POLICE AG5TS1 & BLACKLEGS1 WAS NOT FR[N$ UPON'0 7,BOOK*9 #a#i#i#d3 #b#c74 ,!IR HEI/S 0SU/A9$ ,F]R]-TYPE S*OOLS1 ,AN>*I/ PR9T+ PRESSES1 & A L>GE PUBLI%+ 5T]PRISE 9 ,P>IS :I* PRODUC$ ! ,AN>*I/ ,5CYCLOP$IA1 AS WELL AS MANY BOOKS1 PAMPHLETS1 & P]IODICALS0 7,BOOK*9 #a#i#g#g3 #a#i#i74 ,I ADDUCE !SE FACTS -- & REF]5CE MO/ ( !M1 DELIB]ATELY1 TO ,BOOK*9 -- NOT TO CONDEMN OR CONDONE :AT 0SOCIAL AN>*I/S0 HAVE SOMETIMES DONE BUT TO %[ UP ! ,DEAN'S DUPLICITY4 ,T]RORISM HAS BE51 = BETT] OR = WORSE1 A RECURR5T AN>*I/ TACTIC = MORE ?AN A C5TURY4 ,& ! AN>*O-T]RORI/S HAVE ALMO/ ALWAYS BE5 0SOCIAL10 NOT 9DIVIDUALI/1 AN>*I/S4 ,I'VE HAD OCCASION TO REBUT LEFTI/ FALSIFICATIONS TO ! CONTR>Y 7,BLACK #a#i#i#d3 #e-#e#e74 ,BOOK*9 JU/IFIES ,SPANI% AN>*O-PI/OL]O T]RORISM AS LEGITIMATE SELF-DEF5SE 7#a#i#g#g3 #b#a-#b#b71 AN OP9ION ,I %>E1 BUT ! FACT REMA9S ?AT IT WAS T]RORISM -- 9 ,BOOK*9ESE1 0SOCIAL AN>*I/0 T]RORISM -- NOT ! ACTIVITY ( 9DIVIDUALI/ AN>*I/S4 O ,*APT] #c 3 ,LIFE/YLE ,AN>*ISM ,*APT] #c3 ,LIFE/YLE ,AN>*ISM ,AS FA/-&-LOOSE AS ! ,DEAN PLAYS ) ! WORD 09DIVIDUALISM10 EXTRAPOLAT+ IT TO SOME?+ HE CALLS 0LIFE/YLE AN>*ISM0 IS1 TO BORR[ A PHRASE FROM ,J]EMY ,B5?AM NOT JU/ NONS5SE1 IT IS NONS5SE ON /ILTS4 ,H]E IS H[ HE DOES ! /RET*3 ,9 ! TRADITIONALLY 9DIVIDUALI/-LIB]AL ,UNIT$ ,/ATES & ,BRITA91 ! #a#i#iS >E AWA% 9 SELF-/YL$ . AN>*I/S :O -- !IR FLAMBOYANT RADICAL RHETORIC ASIDE -- >E CULTIVAT+ A LATT]-DAY AN>*O-9DIVIDUALISM ?AT ,I WILL CALL LIFE/YLE AN>*ISM4444 ,AD HOC ADV5TURISM1 P]SONAL BRAVURA1 AN AV]SION TO !ORY ODDLY AK9 TO ! ANTIRATIONAL BIASES ( PO/MOD]NISM1 CELEBRATIONS ( !ORETICAL 9COH]5CE 7PLURALISM71 A BASICALLY APOLITICAL & ANTI-ORGANIZATIONAL COMMITM5T TO IMAG9ATION1 DESIRE1 & EC/ASY1 & AN 9T5SELY SELF-ORI5T$ 5*ANTM5T ( . EV]YDAY LIFE1 REFLECT ! TOLL ?AT SOCIAL REACTION HAS TAK5 ON ,EURO-,AM]ICAN AN>*ISM OV] ! PA/ TWO DECADES 7#i74 ,9 A CLASSIC TALE ( C]EBRAL FANTASY1 ,JORGE ,LUIS ,BORGES RELAT$ ?AT 9 ,TLON1 0! DOM9ANT NOTION IS ?AT EV]Y?+ IS ! WORK ( ONE S+LE AU?OR03 0,CRITICISM IS PRONE TO 9V5T AU?ORS4 ,A CRITIC WILL *OOSE TWO DISSIMIL> WORKS -- ! ,TAO ,TE ,*+ & ! #aa ,NI*I/S0 >E ESS5TIALLY ALIKE BECAUSE1 WELL1 HE HAS DESIGNAT$ !M AS LIFE/YLE AN>*I/S4 ,! LABEL IS SELF-V]IFY+4 ,HE'S COBBL$ TOGE!R ALL HIS SELF-SELECT$ 5EMIES :O >E ALSO 0SELF-/YL$0 AN>*I/S AS 0LIFE/YLE AN>*I/S40 ,9 AN ESSAY ONLY REC5TLY PUBLI%$1 BUT WRITT5 ,9 #a#i#h1 ! ,DEAN COG5TLY OBS]V$ ?AT 444AN>*ISM . ACQUIR$ SOME BAD HABITS ( ITS [N1 NOTABLY AN AHI/ORICAL & 5TR5*$ COMMITM5T TO ITS [N PA/4 ,! DECL9E ( ! ,NEW ,LEFT & ! TRANS=MATION ( ! SIXTIES C\NT]-CULTURE 9TO MORE 9/ITUTIONALIZ$ CULTURAL =MS COMPATIBLE ) ! /ATUS QUO CREAT$ AMONG MANY COMMITT$ AN>*I/S A LONG+ = ! IDEOLOGICAL SECURITY & P$IGREE ?AT ALSO AFFLICTS ! DW9DL+ ,M>XI/ SECTS ( \R DAY 7#a#i#i#f3 #b#c74 ,9 ! ,MIDDLE ,AGES1 :AT ! ,DEAN'S DO+ -- BUT !Y DID IT BETT] BACK !N1 & 9 GOOD FAI? -- WAS KN[N AS ,REALISM4 ,!RE CANNOT BE A NAME 7GOES ! >GUM5T7 UNLESS !RE IS SOME?+ REAL :I* ?AT NAME DESIGNATES4 ,/4 ,ANSELM'S ONTOLOGICAL >GUM5T = ! EXI/5CE ( ,GOD1 = 9/ANCE1 BY DEF9+ ,GOD AS ?AT :I* NO?+ C\LD BE GREAT] ?AN1 IMPLIES ?AT ,GOD IS ! GREATE/ POSSIBLE BE+1 & S9CE SOME?+ MU/ BE ! GREATE/ POSSIBLE BE+1 ,GOD MU/ EXI/4 ,! REFLECTIVE READ] WILL PROBABLY SPOT AT LEA/ SOME ( ! FLAWS 9 ?IS L9E ( >GUM5T :I* ALMO/ ALL PHILOSOPH]S HAVE LONG S9CE RECOGNIZ$4 ,I AM AMAZ$ TO LE>N ?AT ! PRES5T EPO* IS 0AWA% 9 SELF-/YL$ AN>*I/S40 ,MAYBE ,I %\LD AWA% MORE (T54 ,I HADN'T ?\*I/S S9CE C]TA9 P>TS ( ,SPA9 W]E 9 ! #a#i#cS4 ,MAYBE ,BURL+TON IS AWA% 9 ,BOOK*9I/S -- A V]ITABLE ,YANKEE ,B>CELONA -- BUT ?IS CONJECTURE IS AS YET UNCONFIRM$4 0,LIFE/YLE0 WASN'T ALWAYS A DIRTY WORD = ! ,DEAN4 ,RECALL+ :AT WAS WRONG ) ! ,/AL9I/ '#cS1 HE'S WRITT53 0,LIFE-/YLE80 -- ! WORD WAS SIMPLY UNKN[N4 ,IF WE W]E ASK$ BY SOME CRAZY AN>*I/S H[ WE C\LD HOPE TO *ANGE SOCIETY )\T *ANG+ \RSELVES1 \R RELATIONS TO EA* O!R1 & \R ORGANIZATIONAL /RUCTURE1 WE HAD ONE RITUALI/IC ANSW]3 0,AFT] ! REVOLUTION44440 7,BOOK*9 #a#i#g3 #e#g74 ,BACK !N ! ,DEAN WAS CALL+ = 0COMMUNI/ LIFE-/YLES0 AS 9TEGRAL TO ! REVOLUTION>Y PROJECT 7IBID43 #e#d74 ,TODAY1 ! ,DEAN ALLEGES ?AT LIFE/YLE AN>*ISM IS 0CONC]N$ ) A '/YLE' RA!R ?AN A SOCIETY0 7#c#d71 BUT ! 0CRAZY AN>*I/S0 HE =M]LY ID5TIFI$ )1 BUT N[ MALIGNS1 AGREE ) ,BOOK*9 ! ,Y\NG] ?AT SOCIAL REVOLUTION IS LIFE/YLE REVOLUTION1 ! REVOLUTION ( EV]YDAY LIFE3 0,IT IS PLA9 ?AT ! GOAL ( REVOLUTION TODAY MU/ BE ! LIB]ATION ( DAILY LIFE0 7,BOOK*9 #a#i#g#a3 #d#d74 ,MO/ ( ?IS GIBB]I% IS PEJORATIVE & CONT5T-FREE4 ,IF ! DIZZY ,DEAN IS SAY+ ANY?+ SUB/ANTIVE1 HE IS CLAIM+ ?AT ?OSE HE HAS LUMP$ 7LUMP5$87 TOGE!R AS LIFE/YLE AN>*I/S >E 7#a7 ANTI-!ORETICAL1 7#b7 APOLITICAL1 7#c7 H$ONI/IC & 7#d7 ANTI-ORGANIZATIONAL4 ,! QUE/ION ( ORGANIZATION IS SO L>GE AS TO REQUIRE A *APT] 9 ITSELF 7,*APT] #e74 ,I'LL TAKE UP ! O!R *>GES H]E4 ,ANTI-,!ORETICAL4 ,AS TO ?IS ! ,DEAN IS NO?+ LESS ?AN GROTESQUE4 ,:5 IS A !ORI/ NOT A !ORI/8 ,:5 HIS !ORY IS NOT ! !ORY ( ,DEAN ,BOOK*94 ,?AT DISQUALIFIES ,GUY ,DEBORD1 ,MI*EL ,F\CAULT1 ,JACQUES ,CAMATTE1 ,JEAN ,BAUDRILL>D &1 TO ALL 9T5TS & PURPOSES1 EV]YBODY PUBLI%$ BY ,AUTONOM$IA4 ,BOOK*9ISM IS NOT JU/ ! ONLY TRUE !ORY1 IT IS ! ONLY !ORY4 7,M>XISM1 ( C\RSE1 IS NOT !ORY1 IT IS B\RGEOIS IDEOLOGY .<,BOOK*9 #a#i#g#i.>47 ,LIKE ,HEGEL & ,M>X BE=E HIM1 ,BOOK*9 LIKES TO ?9K ?AT HE IS NOT ONLY ! F9E/ BUT ! F9AL !ORI/4 ,AS !Y W]E WRONG1 SO IS HE4 ,APOLITICAL4 ,?IS IS1 IF ANY?+1 EV5 ZANI]4 ,H[ CAN A POLITICAL PHILOSOPHY LIKE AN>*ISM -- ANY V>IETY ( AN>*ISM -- BE APOLITICAL8 ,!RE IS1 TO BE SURE1 A DIFF]5CE BETWE5 ,BOOK*9ISM & ALL AN>*ISMS4 ,AN>*ISM IS ANTI-POLITICAL BY DEF9ITION4 ,BOOK*9ISM IS POLITICAL 7SPECIFICALLY1 IT IS CITY-/ATI/1 AS %ALL %ORTLY BE %[N74 ,IT FOLL[S AS A MATT] ( C\RSE ?AT ,BOOK*9ISM IS 9COMPATIBLE ) AN>*ISM1 BUT IT DOESN'T FOLL[ ?AT LIFE/YLE AN>*ISM IS APOLITICAL1 ONLY ?AT LIFE/YLE AN>*ISM IS1 AT WOR/1 AN>*ISM1 & AT BE/1 CONTR>Y TO ,BOOK*9ISM4 ,H$ONI/IC4 ,SURE1 :Y NOT8 ,! ,DEAN IS RI*ISM CONT9UES ! ,5LIGU$ ?AT AN>*ISM WAS ! LOGICAL IMPLICATION ( UTILIT>IANISM4 ,KROPOTK9 WAS CONV9C$ ?AT 0'! GREATE/ HAPP9ESS ( ! GREATE/ NUMB]' IS NO LONG] A DREAM1 A M]E ,UTOPIA4 ,IT IS POSSIBLE0 7#a#i#b#d3 #d74 ,HIS ADOPTION ( ! UTILIT>IAN MAXIM WAS NEI!R IRONIC NOR CRITICAL4 ,H$ONISM 9 SOME S5SE ( ! WORD HAS ALWAYS BE5 COMMON GR\ND = ALMO/ ALL AN>*I/S4 ,RUDOLPH ,ROCK] ATTRIBUT$ AN>*I/ IDEAS TO ! ,H$ONI/S & ,CYNICS ( ANTIQUITY 7#a#i#d#g3 #e74 ,BACK BE=E HE LO/ HIS GROOVE1 ! ,DEAN PRAIS$ ! UTOPIAN SOCIALI/ ,*>LES ,F\RI] = 05VISION.<+.> NEW COMMUNITIES ?AT W\LD REMOVE RE/RICTIONS ON H$ONI/IC BEHAVIOR &1 ALMO/ EMB>RASS+LY TO HIS DISCIPLES1 S\MONIZE SOCIAL RELATIONS ON ! BASIS ( PLEASURE0 7#a#i#g#d3 #a#a#b74 ,AS ?AT 0MO/ UNSAVORY0 7#b7 ( LIFE/YLE AN>*I/S1 ,HAKIM ,BEY1 PUT IT1 0Y\R 9VIOLABLE FRE$OM AWAITS TO BE COMPLET$ ONLY BY ! LOVE ( O!R MON>*S0 7#b#b .7 -- 0WORDS ?AT C\LD BE 9SCRIB$ ON ! ,NEW ,YORK ,/OCK ,EX*ANGE10 GRUMPS ! ,DEAN1 0AS A CR$O = EGOTISM & SOCIAL 9DIFF]5CE0 7#b#b74 ,DECAD5T DEG5]ATES ?AT WE >E1 LIFE/YLE AN>*I/S T5D TO FAVOR 0A /ATE ( ?+S 9 :I* EA* 9DIVIDUAL WILL BE ABLE TO GIVE FREE RE9 TO HIS 9CL9ATIONS1 & EV5 TO HIS PASSIONS1 )\T ANY O!R RE/RA9T ?AN ! LOVE & RESPECT ( ?OSE :O SURR\ND HIM40 ,PRESUMABLY ?IS CR$O1 A MORE OV]TLY H$ONI/IC V]SION ( ,BEY'S SOCIALLY 9DIFF]5T EGOTISM1 IS EV5 BETT] SUIT$ TO DECORATE ! ,/OCK ,EX*ANGE -- :I* W\LD PROBABLY SURPRISE ITS AU?OR1 ! AN>*O-COMMUNI/ ,KROPOTK9 7#a#h#i3#a#e74 ,WE ?9K LOVE & RESPECT C\LD BE =CES AS P[]FUL AS !Y >E WOND]FUL4 ,EV5 ,BAKUN9 ON OCCASION S\ND$ MORE LIKE ,RA\L ,VANEIGEM ?AN ,JEAN-,JACQUES ,R\SSEAU1 AS :5 HE WROTE ?AT ! AN>*I/ IS DI/+UI%$ BY 0HIS FRANK & HUMAN SELFI%NESS1 LIV+ C&IDLY & UNS5T5TI\SLY = HIMSELF1 & KN[+ ?AT BY DO+ SO 9 ACCORDANCE ) JU/ICE HE S]VES ! :OLE ( SOCIETY0 7QUOT$ 9 ,CL>K #a#i#h#d3 #f#h74 ,! PLEBEIAN RADICAL ,WILLIAM ,B5B[ ORIG9AT$ ! IDEA ( ! ,G5]AL ,/RIKE -- ! 0,GR& ,NATIONAL ,HOLIDAY0 ( ! WORK+ CLASSES -- 9 #ahcb 7,B5B[ N4D474 7,! ,DEAN IS WRONG :5 HE WRITES ?AT AN>*O-SYNDICALISM 0CAN BE TRAC$ BACK1 9 FACT1 TO NOTIONS ( A ',GR& ,HOLIDAY' . OR G5]AL /RIKE PROPOS$ BY ! ,5GLI% ,*>TI/S0 7#g74 ,AL?\< ,B5B[ W5T ON TO BECOME A ,*>TI/1 !RE WAS NO ,*>TI/ MOVEM5T 9 #a#h#c#b1 ! ,*>TI/S NEV] ESP\S$ ! G5]AL /RIKE1 & !RE WAS NEV] ANY?+ REMOTELY SYNDICALI/ AB\T ! ,*>TI/S' PURELY POLITICAL PROGRAM C5T]$ ON UNIV]SAL MALE SUFFRAGE .<,BLACK #a#i#i#fC.>47 ,B5B[ CALL$ UPON ! DIRECT PRODUC]S 0TO E/ABLI% ! HAPP9ESS ( ! IMM5SE MAJORITY ( ! HUMAN RACE0 -- NAMELY1 !MSELVES -- TO SECURE !IR [N 0EASE1 GAIETY1 PLEASURE & HAPP9ESS40 ,IF IT'S H$ONI/IC OR DECAD5T = IMPOV]I%$1 EXPLOIT$1 OV]WORK$ PEOPLE TO /AGE A REVOLUTION = G5]ALIZ$ CASE1 GAIETY1 PLEASURE & HAPP9ESS1 LONG LIVE H$ONISM & DECAD5CE6 ,! ,DEAN'S YAPP+ AB\T 0,YUPPIE0 SELF-9DULG5CE IS1 EV5 ASIDE FROM ITS GROSS HYPOCRISY1 MISDIRECT$4 ,! PROBLEM IS NOT ?AT ,YUPPIES1 OR UNIONIZ$ FACTORY WORK]S1 OR SMALL BUS9ESSM51 OR RETIREES1 OR :OMEV]1 >E SELFI%4 ,9 AN ECONOMY OR*E/RAT$ BY SC>CITY & RISK1 :]E ALMO/ ANYBODY MIE ANYWAY3 OLD HABITS DIE H>D74 ,! PROBLEM IS ! PREVAIL+ SOCIAL ORGANIZATION ( SELFI%NESS AS A DIVISIVE =CE :I* ACTUALLY DIM9I%ES ! SELF4 ,AS SOCIETY IS N[ SET UP1 9DIVIDUAL SELFI%NESS IS COLLECTIVELY1 & LIT]ALLY1 SELF-DEFEAT+4 ,! ,DEAN RECOILS 9 HORROR FROM A CO9AGE HE ATTRIBUTES TO ,HAKIM ,BEY1 0,M>XISM-,/IRN]ISM0 7#b7 -- ACTUALLY1 AS ,BOOK*9 PROBABLY KN[S1 ,BEY BORR[$ IT FROM ME 7,BLACK #a#i#h#f3 #a#c74 ,IT COMES FROM MY ,PREFACE TO ! ,LOOMPANICS REPR9T ( A PRO-SITUATIONI/ TEXT1 ,! ,RIGU$ = 0COMMUNI/ EGOISM40 ,I MADE IT CLE> ?AT ,I DIDN'T ?9K ! ESSAY (F]$ ANY ULTIMATE RESOLUTION ( ! T5SION BETWE5 ! 9DIVIDUAL ! SOCIAL4 ,NO !ORY WILL EV] ACCOMPLI% ?AT A PRIORI1 AL?\< !ORY MIY3 0,ANY REVOLUTION>Y :O IS TO BE C\NT$ UPON CAN ONLY BE 9 IT = HIMSELF -- UNSELFI% PEOPLE CAN ALWAYS SWIT* LOYALTY FROM ONE PROJECTION TO ANO!R0 7,= ,\RSELVES #a#i#h#c7 -- = EXAMPLE1 FROM ,/AL9ISM TO ,TROTSKYISM TO ,AN>*ISM TO4444 ,WE NE$1 NOT = PEOPLE TO BE LESS SELFI%1 BUT = US TO BE BETT] AT BE+ SELFI% 9 ! MO/ EFFECTIVE WAY1 TOGE!R4 ,= ?AT1 !Y NE$ TO UND]/& !MSELVES & SOCIETY BETT] -- TO DESIRE BETT]1 TO 5L>GE !IR P]CEPTIONS ( ! G5U9ELY POSSIBLE1 & TO APPRECIATE ! REAL 9/ITUTIONAL 7& IDEOLOGICAL7 IMP$IM5TS TO REALIZ+ !IR REAL DESIRES4 ,BY 0REAL DESIRES0 ,I DON'T MEAN 0:AT ,I WANT PEOPLE TO WANT10 ,I MEAN :AT !Y REALLY WANT1 SEV]ALLY & TOGE!R1 AS >RIV$ AT -- AS ,B5B[ SO PRESCI5TLY PUT IT -- BY UNCON/RA9$1 G5]AL1 UNHURRI$ REFLECTION1 0TO GET RID ( \R IGNORANT IMPATI5CE1 & TO LE>N :AT IT IS WE DO WANT40 ,& ALSO :AT WE 0DO NOT NE$0 7,BOOK*9 #a#i#g#g3 #c#g74 ,9 TYPICAL RETRO-,M>XI/ FA%ION1 ! ,DEAN PURPORTS TO RESORT1 ON ?IS PO9T AS ON O!RS1 TO ! ULTIMATE >GUM5T FROM AU?ORITY1 ! >GUM5T FROM ,HI/ORY3 ,! ,AU/RIAN WORK]S' UPRIS+ ( ,FEBRU>Y #aicd & ! ,SPANI% ,CIVIL ,W> ( #a#i#c#f1 ,I CAN ATTE/ .1 W]E MORE ?AN ORGIA/IC 0MOM5TS ( 9SURRECTION0 BUT W]E BITT] /RUGGLES C>RI$ ON ) DESP]ATE E>NE/NESS & MAGNIFIC5T ELAN1 ALL ES!TIC EPIPHANIES NOT)/&+ 7#b#c74 ,AS A PRELIM9>Y QUIBBLE -- ,I CAN SOMETIMES BE AS PETTY AS LIT4 ,DEAN USUALLY IS -- ,I OBJECT TO ! WORD 0ATTE/0 H]E4 ,TO 0ATTE/0 TO SOME?+ -- ! SIGN+ ( A WILL1 = 9/ANCE -- MEANS TO AFFIRM IT AS A WITNESS1 FROM P]SONAL KN[L$GE4 ,BOOK*9 WAS #ac 9 #aicd & #ae 9 #a#i#c#f4 ,HE HAS NO MORE P]SONAL KN[L$GE ( EI!R ( !SE REVOLTS ?AN MY SIX YE> OLD NIECE DOES4 ,SIMIL>LY1 ! ,DEAN 0W\LD LIKE TO RECALL A ,LEFT ,?AT ,WAS10 0! ,LEFT ( ! N9ETE5? & E>LY TW5TIE? C5TURY0 7#f#f71 & RATTLES AWAY AS IF HE W]E DO+ EXACTLY ?AT -- AL?\< ?AT IS1 = SOMEONE BORN 9 #a#i#b#a1 A *RONOLOGICAL IMPOSSIBILITY4 ,ANO!R OLD MAN1 ,RONALD ,REAGAN1 REMEMB]$ ! MOV+ EXP]I5CE ( LIB]AT+ ,G]MAN CONC5TRATION CAMPS1 AL?\< HE SP5T ,WORLD ,W> ,I,I MAK+ PROPAG&A FILMS 9 ,HOLLYWOOD4 ,:AT ! UPRIS+ ( ! ,AU/RIAN WORK]S 7/ATE SOCIALI/S1 9CID5TALLY1 NOT AN>*I/S71 SAVAGELY SUPPRESS$ 9 ONLY ?REE DAYS1 HAS TO DO ) PRES5T-DAY REVOLUTION>Y AN>*I/ PROSPECTS1 ,I HAVE NO MORE IDEA ?AN ,BOOK*9 SEEMS TO4 ,AB/A9+ FROM 0ORGIA/IC0 9SURRECTION1 IF !Y DID1 MU/ NOT HAVE IMPROV$ !IR MILIT>Y SITUATION MU*4 ,SPA91 :]E AN>*I/S PLAY$ SO PROM95T A ROLE 9 ! REVOLUTION1 ESPECIALLY 9 ITS FIR/ YE>1 IS A MORE COMPLICAT$ /ORY4 ,( C\RSE IT WAS A BITT] /RUGGLE4 ,IT WAS A W>1 AFT] ALL1 & W> IS HELL4 ,HEY6 -- ?IS JU/ OCCURR$ TO ME -- DID ,BOOK*9 FI ,I,I8 ,NOT ?AT ,I'VE EV] HE>D4 ,HE W\LD HAVE BE5 DRAFT-AGE MILIT>Y MAT]IAL1 AT AGE #b#a1 9 #aidb :5 !Y W]E DRAFT+ ALMO/ EV]YBODY1 EV5 MY SP9DLY1 NE>SI-OLD FA!R4 ,WAV+ ! BLOODY %IRT AT LIFE/YLE AN>*I/S MIILY 5TAIL ?AT IT IS ONLY ?AT ONE ?+4 ,?IS IS ! SORT ( METAPHYSICAL DUALISM :I* VITIATES ALMO/ EV]Y?+ ! ,DEAN HAS TO SAY 7,J>A* #a#i#i#f74 ,!RE WAS A GREAT DEAL FE/IVITY & CELEBRATION EV5 9 ! ,SPANI% ,REVOLUTION1 DESPITE ! UNFAVORABLE CONDITIONS4 ,9 ,B>CELONA1 0!RE WAS A FE/IVE 5?USIASM 9 ! /REETS0 7,FRAS] #a#i#g#i3#a#e#b74 ,SOME C\PLES1 0'BELIEV+ ! REVOLUTION MADE EV]Y?+ POSSIBLE' BEGAN LIV+ TOGE!R & SPLITT+ UP ) TOO MU* EASE 7IBID43 #b#b#c74 ,GEORGE ,ORWELL1 :O F\AGON FRONT W]E BADLY >M$ & EV5 WAT] WAS SC>CE1 BUT 0!RE WAS PL5TY ( W9E0 7#a#i#e#b3 #c#b74 ,9DE$1 0,ORWELL'S DESCRIPTION ( ! CITY .<( ,B>CELONA.> DUR+ ?IS PHASE IS /ILL 9TOXICAT+3 ! SQU>$ & AV5UES B$ECK$ ) BLACK-&-R$ FLAGS1 ! >M$ PEOPLE1 ! SLOGANS1 ! /IRR+ REVOLUTION>Y SONGS1 ! FEV]I% 5?USIASM ( CREAT+ A NEW WORLD1 ! GLEAM+ HOPE1 & ! 9SPIR$ H]OISM0 7,BOOK*9 #a#i#g#g3 #c#f74 ,9 ,B>CELONA1 Y\NG AN>*I/S COMM&E]$ C>S -- MOTOR+ WAS A ?RILL HI!RTO BEYOND !IR MEANS -- & C>E5$ ?R\< ! /REETS ON ]R&S ( DUBI\S REVOLUTION>Y IMPORT 7,SEIDMAN #a#i#i#a3 #a1 #a#f#h2 ,BORK5AU #a#i#f#c3 #g73 MO/LY !Y W]E JU/ JOYRID+4 ,BOOK*9 REVILES ! ROMANTICISM ( ! LIFE/YLE AN>*I/S1 =GETT+ HIS [N /ATEM5T ?AT 0,SPANI% ,AN>*ISM PLAC$ A /RONG EMPHASIS ON LIFE-/YLE0 7#a#i#g#g3 #d74 ,AS ,JOSE ,PEIRATS REMEMB]$ ! ,SPANI% ,REVOLUTION1 0WE REG>D$ \RSELVES AS ! LA/ ROMANTICS0 7,BOLLOT5 #a#i#i#a3 #gfi N4 #a#g74 ,MAY !Y NOT BE ! LA/6 ,CONSID] ! ,P>IS ,COMMUNE ( #a#h#g#a1 :I* ! ,SITUATIONI/S REF]R$ TO AS ! GREATE/ RAVE-UP ( ! N9ETE5? C5TURY3 ,! ,COMMUN>DS ( ! ,BELLEVILLE DI/RICT 9 ,P>IS1 :O F\RICADES & DI$ BY ! T5S ( ?\S&S UND] ! GUNS ( ! ,V]SAILLAIS1 REFUS$ TO CONF9E !IR 9SURRECTION TO ! PRIVATE WORLD DESCRIB$ BY SYMBOLI/ POEMS OR ! PUBLIC WORLD DESCRIB$ BY ,M>XI/ ECONOMICS4 ,!Y DEM&$ ! EAT+ & ! MORAL1 ! FILL$ BELLY & ! HEIDS TURN$ !IR 9SURRECTION 9TO A FE/IVAL ( PUBLIC JOY1 PLAY & SOLID>ITY 7,BOOK*9 #a#i#g#a3 #b#g#g74 ,REVOLUTION>IES MAKE LOVE & W>4 O ,*APT] #d 3 ,ON ,ORGANIZATION ,*APT] #d3 ,ON ,ORGANIZATION ,WELL1 F9ALLY1 ! ,DEAN HAS ID5TIFI$ A CONCRETE 0PROGRAMMATIC0 DIFF]5CE BETWE5 HIM & HIS APPO9T$ 5EMIES4 ,MO/1 MAYBE ALL ( ?OSE HE CRITICIZES AS 0LIFE/YLE AN>*I/S0 9DE$ OPPOSE ! E/ABLI%M5T ( SOME SORT ( AU?ORITATIVE AN>*I/ ORGANIZATION1 AS WELL !Y %\LD 7,BLACK #a#i#i#b3#a #a#h#a-#a#i#c74 ,IT IS SOME?+ ,NOR? ,AM]ICAN AN>*I/S HAVE ALWAYS %I$ AWAY FROM1 EV5 9 ! HEYDAY ( ! ,LEFT ,?AT ,WAS4 ,! ,DEAN1 AS PREVI\SLY NOT$1 HAS SP5T HIS 5TIRE AN>*I/ LIFE GO+ \T ( HIS WAY NOT TO 9VOLVE HIMSELF ) ANY SU* ORGANIZATION -- NOT FROM PR9CIPLE1 APP>5TLY1 BUT BECAUSE HE WAS PREOCCUPI$1 P]SONALI/ICALLY1 ) HIS [N C>E]4 ,SOME ( US ?9K ! 5T]PRISE IS ILL-ADVIS$1 EV5 C\NT]PRODUCTIVE1 EV5 AP>T FROM \R SUSPICION ?AT IT W\LDN'T ADVANCE \R C>E]S4 ,A LOT ( US DON'T EV5 HAVE C>E]S4 ,JACQUES ,CAMATTE 7#a#i#i#e3 #a#i-#c#h7 &1 BE=E HIM1 ! DISILLUSION$ SOCIALI/ ,ROB]T ,MI*ELS 7#a#i#f#b7 ) :OM ! ,DEAN IS NOT 5TIRELY UNFAMILI> 7#a#i#h#g3 #b#d#e71 PROVID$ SOME !ORETICAL REASONS = US TO ?9K SO4 ,DEAN ,BOOK*9 HIMSELF 7#a#i#g#g1#a#i#i#f7 REC\NTS ! BUREAUCRATIC DEG5]ATION ( :AT HE CONSID]S ! GREATE/ AN>*O-SYNDICALI/ ORGANIZATION ( !M ALL1 ! ,SPANI% ,C,N,T-,F,A,I4 ,EV5 ,KROPOTK91 ONE ( ! FEW AN>*I/S TO 5JOY ! ,DEAN'S IMPRIMATUR1 ?\ TOO C5TRALIZ$ & AU?ORIT>IAN3 0,AS TO ITS ,CONF$]AL ,COMMITTEE1 IT BORR[S A GREAT DEAL TOO MU* FROM ! ,GOV]NM5T ?AT IT HAS JU/ OV]?R[N0 7#a#i#i3 XXXV74 ,) ORGANIZATIONS1 ESPECIALLY L>GE-SCALE ONES1 ! MEANS T5D TO DISPLACE ! 5DS2 ! DIVISION ( LABOR 5G5D]S 9EQUALITY ( P[]1 (FICIALLY OR O!RWISE2 & REPRES5TATIVES1 BY VIRTUE ( GREAT] 9T]E/1 EXP]I5CE1 & ACCESS TO EXP]TIZE1 EFFECTIVELY SUPPLANT ?OSE !Y REPRES5T4 ,WE AGREE ) ! ,DEAN ?AT 0! WORDS 'REPRES5TATIVE DEMOCRACY1' TAK5 LIT]ALLY1 >E A CONTRADICTION 9 T]MS0 7#a#i#h#g3 #b#d#e74 ,9 O!R WORDS1 0DELEGAT$ AU?ORITY 5TAILS HI]>*Y0 7,DAHL #a#i#i,O3 #g#b74 ,?US 9 ,SPA9 ! #c1 FAI/AS QUICKLY CAME TO CONTROL ONE MILLION C5ETI/AS1 :OM !Y L$ 9TO POLICIES -- SU* AS 5T]+ ! GOV]NM5T -- TO :I* ! ,F,A,I MILITANTS %\LD HAVE BE5 EV5 MORE FI]CELY OPPOS$ ?AN ! RANK-&-FILE ,C,N,T UNIONI/S4 ,9 A CRISIS -- :I* MIE IGNORANT ( ! HI/ORY ( AN>*I/ ORGANIZATIONS4 ,WE REJECT IT1 AMONG O!R REASONS1 BECAUSE WE KN[ ?AT HI/ORY ONLY TOO WELL1 & ,BOOK*9 IS ONE ( ?OSE :O HAS TAUIAN POLITICAL P>TIES >E 9 PRACTICE1 AS 9 !ORY1 9IMICAL TO LIB]TY1 EQUALITY & FRAT]NITY4 7,ALSO 9COMPET5T3 AS ,PAUL ,GOODMAN PUT IT .<#a#i#i#d3 #e#h.>1 C5TRAL ORGANIZATION 0MA!MATICALLY GU>ANTEES /UPIDITY407 ,:AT AT FIR/ SURPRISES1 & :AT CRIES \T = EXPLANATION1 IS ?AT EGALIT>IAN & LIB]T>IAN ORGANIZATIONS SOON] OR LAT] -- USUALLY SOON] -- 5D UP ! SAME WAY4 ,ROB]T ,MI*ELS 7HIMSELF A SOCIALI/7 /UDI$ ! ,G]MAN ,SOCIAL ,DEMOCRATIC ,P>TY -- A ,M>XI/ P>TY PROGRAMMATICALLY COMMITT$ TO SOCIAL EQUALITY -- A FEW YE>S BE=E ! ,FIR/ ,WORLD ,W>1 & F\ND IT TO BE ?OR\*IC & BUREAUCRATIC4 ,V9DICAT+ ,MI*ELS1 ! VA/ MAJORITY ( ,G]MAN SOCIALI/S1 CONTR>Y TO !IR (FICIAL ANTIW> POSITION1 PROMPTLY FOLL[$ !IR LEAD]S 9 SUPPORT+ ! W>4 ,AN>*I/S MIXISM1 UNLIKE AN>*ISM1 WAS A 0B\RGEOIS IDEOLOGY0 7,BOOK*9 #a#i#g#i7 -- LIKE ! ,PH>ISEES1 ?ANK+ ,GOD ?AT !Y >E NOT AS O!R M54 7,AL?\< ?AT W\LD BE 0IDEALISM10 ANO!R B\RGEOIS IDEOLOGY47 ,MI*ELS1 WRIT+ AT A TIME :5 SYNDICALISM SEEM$ TO BE AN IMPORTANT SOCIAL MOVEM5T1 NOT$3 ,H]E WE F9D A POLITICAL S*OOL1 :OSE ADH]5TS >E NUM]\S1 ABLE1 WELL-$UCAT$1 & G5]\S-M9D$1 P]SUAD$ ?AT 9 SYNDICALISM IT HAS DISCOV]$ ! ANTIDOTE TO OLIG>*Y4 ,BUT WE HAVE TO ASK :E!R ! ANTIDOTE TO ! OLIG>*ICAL T5D5CIES ( ORGANIZATION CAN POSSIBLY BE F\ND 9 A ME?OD :I* IS ITSELF ROOT$ 9 ! PR9CIPLE ( REPRES5TATION4444 ,SYNDICALISM IS444 MI/AK5 9 ATTRIBUT+ TO P>LIAM5T>Y DEMOCRACY ALONE ! 9CONV5I5CES ?AT >ISE FROM ! PR9CIPLE ( DELEGATION 9 G5]AL 7#a#i#f#b3 #c#a#h74 ,TIMES HAVE *ANG$3 ,NOR? ,AM]ICAN SYNDICALI/S >5'T NUM]\S1 >5'T ABLE1 & LEA/ ( ALL >E !Y G5]\S-M9D$1 AL?\< MO/ MAY BE 0WELL-$UCAT$0 IF Y\ EQUATE A GOOD $UCATION ) COLLEGE -- SOME?+ ?AT ,I1 HAV+ TAUGE-SCALE ORGANIZATIONS :OSE HI<] REA*ES CONSI/ ( REPRES5TATIVES1 SU* AS ! ,SPANI% ,C,N,T OR ! CONF$]AL 0,COMMUNE ( COMMUNES0 7#e#g7 ! ,DEAN DESIRES4 ,EV5 IF !SE ORGANIZATIONS >E ONLY M9IMALLY BUREAUCRATIC -- A PRECI\S1 & PREC>I\S1 ACCOMPLI%M5T -- !Y >E NONE!LESS 9H]5TLY HI]>*IC4 ,! ,C,N,T PYRAMID HAD AT LEA/ SIX LEVELS 7& SOME \TBUILD+S73 ,SECTION -@> ,SYNDICATE -@> ,LOCAL F$]ATION ( SYNDICATES -@> ,COM]CAL F$]ATION -@> ,REGIONAL CONF$]ATION -@> ,NATIONAL CONF$]ATION 7CONGRESS7 7,BRADEMAS #a#i#e#c3 #a#f-#a#g7 ,?IS LEAVES \T1 = 9/ANCE1 SEV]AL 9T]M$I>Y BODIES SU* AS ! ,REGIONAL ,PL5UM1 ! ,PL5UM ( ,REGIONALS 7NO1 ,I'M NOT JOK+7 & ! ,NATIONAL ,COMMITTEE 7,BOOK*9 #a#i#g#g3 #a#g74 ,:AT HAPP5$ WAS JU/ :AT MI*I/S BLEW IT TOO4 ,IT IS NOT ONLY ?AT ! MO/ VOCIF]\S ,F,A,I MILITANTS1 LIKE ,MONTS5EY & ,G>CIA ,OLIV]1 JO9$ ! ,LOYALI/ GOV]NM5T -- ?AT C\LD BE EXPLA9$ AWAY1 ALBEIT IMPLAUSIBLY1 AS 0P]SONALI/IC0 TREA*]Y -- BUT ?AT MO/ ( ! ,C,N,T-,F,A,I RANK-&-FILE W5T ALONG ) IT 7,BRADEMAS #a#i#e#c3 #c#e#c74 ,EV5 MORE />TL+ ?AN ! LEAD]S' SUPPORT = :AT !Y W]E SUPPOS$ TO BE AGA9/ 7! /ATE7 WAS !IR OPPOSITION TO :AT !Y W]E SUPPOS$ TO BE = -- SOCIAL REVOLUTION -- :I* SWEPT OV] MU* ( ,REPUBLICAN ,SPA9 )\T ! SUPPORT1 & 9 MO/ CASES OV] ! OBJECTIONS1 ( ! LEAD]S 7,BOLLOT5 #a#i#i#a2 ,BR\E @& ,TEMIME #a#i#g#b74 ,! LEAD]S PLAC$ ! W> AHEAD ( ! REVOLUTION & MANAG$1 AT ! CO/ ( A MILLION LIVES1 TO LOSE BO? 7,RI*>DS #a#i#h#c74 ,! ,SPANI% EXP]I5CE WAS NOT UNIQUE4 ,! ,ITALIAN SYNDICALI/S MO/LY W5T OV] TO ,FASCISM 7,ROB]TS #a#i#g#i74 ,! %AM 9DU/RIAL DEMOCRACY ( SYNDICALI/ CORPORATISM ONLY NE$$ A LITTLE F9E-TUN+ & A T\* ( COSMETICS TO BE F9ESS$ 9TO ! %AM SYNDICALISM ( ,FASCI/ CORPORATISM4 ,= ,NOR? ,AM]ICANS1 NO EXAMPLE -- NOT EV5 ! ,SPANI% EXAMPLE -- IS MORE IMPORTANT ?AN ! ,MEXICAN ,REVOLUTION4 ,HAD IT TURN$ \T DIFF]5TLY1 IT W\LD HAVE RECOIL$ UPON ! ,UNIT$ ,/ATES ) 9CALCULABLE =CE4 ,BECAUSE ! REVOLUTION WAS CONTA9$ S\? ( ! BORD]1 9 ,AM]ICA ! ,F$]AL & /ATE GOV]NM5TS 7& ! VIGILANTES !Y 5C\RAG$7 HAD A FREE H& TO CRU% ! AN>*I/S1 SYNDICALI/S & SOCIALI/S SO ?OR\*O- SYNDICALI/S SUPPORT$ ! LIB]ALS -- ! ,CON/ITUTIONALI/S -- AGA9/ ! ,ZAPATI/A & ,VILLI/A SOCIAL REVOLUTION>IES 7,H>T #a#i#g#h3 *4 #i74 ,AS URBAN RATIONALI/ PROGRESSIVES 7LIKE ,BOOK*971 !Y DESPIS$ PEASANT REVOLUTION>IES /ILL CL++ TO ,CA?OLICISM4 ,BESIDES1 !Y ?\GON -- ACT$ TOO MU* LIKE A 0P]SONALI/06 7IBID43 #a#c#a74 ,ON BEHALF ( ! ,CON/ITUTIONALI/ REGIME -- ! ONE ,PRESID5T ,WILSON S5T ! ,U4,S4 ,>MY 9 TO PROP UP -- ! AN>*O-SYNDICALI/S RAIS$ 0,R$ ,BATTALIONS10 P]HAPS #a#b1 /RONG1 0A MASSIVE AUGM5TATION ( COMM&+ G5]AL ,OBREGON'S ,CON/ITUTIONAL >MY0 7IBID43 #a#c#c1 #a#c#e74 ,!Y SOON REAP$ ! REW>D -- REPRESSION -- ?AT !Y'D E>N$4 ,BY #aica ! GOV]NM5T HAD ! ,MEXICAN WORK+ CLASS UND] CONTROL 7IBID43 #a#g#e-#a#g#g1 #a#h#c71 AS IT /ILL DOES4 ,IF REVOLUTION RESUMES IT WILL BE ! ,NEO-,ZAPATI/AS1 ! ,MAYAN PEASANTS ( ,*IAPAS1 :O SET IT (F 7,ZAPATI/AS #a#i#i#d74 ,)\T ATTEMPT+ A COMPREH5SIVE CRITIQUE ( ! ,DEAN'S MUNICIPAL-CONF$]AL SOCIALISM1 ,I'D LIKE TO RAISE A C\PLE ( PROSAIC PO9TS ( FACT :I* DO NOT DEP5D UPON1 AL?\< !Y >E CONSI/5T )1 ! ANTI-ORGANIZATIONAL CRITIQUES ( ,MI*ELS1 ,CAMATTE1 ,Z]ZAN1 MYSELF &1 BY N[1 MANY O!RS4 ,DIRECT DEMOCRACY IS NOT1 & = ALL ANYBODY KN[S1 NEV] WAS1 ALL IT'S CRACK$ UP TO BE BY ! ,DEAN4 ,MO/ ( ! EXTANT AU?ORS FROM CLASSICAL ANTIQUITY1 :O KNEW ! WORK+ SY/EM BETT] ?AN WE EV] WILL1 W]E ANTI-DEMOCRATIC 7,F9LEY #a#i#h#e3 #h-#a#a71 AS ,BOOK*9 ELSE:]E ADMITS 7#a#i#h#i3 #a#g#f74 ,! WORD 0DEMOCRACY0 WAS ALMO/ ALWAYS US$ PEJORATIVELY BE=E ! N9ETE5? C5TURY -- ?AT IS1 :5 IT REF]R$ ONLY TO DIRECT DEMOCRACY3 0,TO DISMISS ?IS UNANIMITY AS A DEBASEM5T ( ! CURR5CY1 OR TO DISMISS ! O!R SIDE ( ! DEBATE AS APOLOGI/S :O MISUSE ! T]M1 IS TO EVADE ! NE$ = EXPLANATION0 7,F9LEY #a#i#h#e3 #a#a2 CF4 ,BAILYN #a#i#i#b3 #b#h#b-#b#h#e74 ,! ,A!NIAN POLIS1 ! MO/ ADVANC$ =M ( DIRECT DEMOCRACY EV] PRACTIC$ = ANY EXT5D$ P]IOD1 WAS OLIG>*IC4 ,IT'S NOT ONLY ?AT1 AS ,BOOK*9 GRUDG+LY CONC$ES 7#e#i71 ! POLITY EXCLUD$ SLAVES1 NUM]\S O!R NONCITIZ5S 7ONE-?IRD ( FREE M5 W]E TE*NICALLY =EIGN]S .<,WALZ] #a#i#g3 #a#f.>71 & WOM51 I4E41 ! POLIS EXCLUD$ ! OV]:ELM+ MAJORITY ( ADULT ,A!NIANS4 ,EV5 ! ,DEAN ACKN[L$GES1 BUT ATTA*ES NO IMPORTANCE TO1 ! FACT ?AT MAYBE ?REE-F\R?S ( ADULT MALE ,A!NIANS W]E 0SLAVES & DIS5FRAN*IZ$ RESID5T ALI5S0 7#a#i#h#g3 #c#e74 ,IT C\LD NOT HAVE BE5 O!RWISE3 ,!SE L>GE DIS5FRAN*IZ$ POPULATIONS PROVID$ ! MAT]IAL MEANS = MANY ,A!NIAN MALE CITIZ5S TO CONV5E 9 POPUL> ASSEMBLIES1 FUNCTION AS MASS JURIES 9 TRIALS1 & COLLECTIVELY ADM9I/] ! AFFAIRS ( ! COMMUNITY 7,BOOK*9 #a#i#h#i3 #f#i74 0,A MODICUM ( FREE TIME WAS NE$$ TO P>TICIPATE 9 POLITICAL AFFAIRS1 LEISURE ?AT WAS PROBABLY .<6.> SUPPLI$ BY SLAVE LABOR1 AL?\< IT IS BY NO MEANS TRUE ?AT ALL ACTIVE ,GREEK CITIZ5S W]E SLAVE [N]S0 7,BOOK*9 #a#i#i3 #h74 ,GREEK CULTURE1 AS ,NIETZS*E OBS]V$1 FL\RI%$ AT ! EXP5SE ( ! 0OV]:ELM+ MAJORITY03 0,AT !IR EXP5SE1 ?R\< !IR EXTRA WORK1 ?AT PRIVILEG$ CLASS IS TO BE REMOV$ FROM ! /RUGGLE = EXI/5CE1 9 ORD] TO PRODUCE & SATISFY A NEW WORLD ( NECESSITIES0 7#a#i#i#d3 #a#g#h74 ,!RE >E TWO MORE PO9TS TO POND]4 ,! FIR/ IS ?AT ! VA/ MAJORITY ( ! ,A!NIAN CITIZ5 M9ORITY AB/A9$ FROM P>TICIPATION 9 DIRECT DEMOCRACY1 JU/ AS ! MAJORITY ( ,AM]ICAN CITIZ5S AB/A9 FROM \R REPRES5TATIVE DEMOCRACY4 ,UP TO #d1 ,A!NIAN M5 5JOY$ ! PRIVILEGE ( CITIZ5%IP1 LESS ?AN HALF ( :OM RESID$ 9 ! CITY ITSELF 7,WALZ] #a#i#g3 #a#g74 0,ALL ! POLICY DECISIONS ( ! POLIS10 ACCORD+ TO ,BOOK*91 0>E =MULAT$ DIRECTLY BY A POPUL> ASSEMBLY1 OR ,ECCLESIA1 :I* EV]Y MALE CITIZ5 FROM ! CITY & ITS 5VIRONS 7,ATTICA7 IS EXPECT$ TO ATT5D0 7#a#i#g#d3 #b#d74 ,9 REALITY1 ! FACILITY PROVID$ = ! ASSEMBLY ACCOMMODAT$ ONLY A FRACTION ( !M 7,DAHL #a#i#i3 #e#c-#e#d71 SO MO/ MU/ HAVE BE5 EXPECT$ NOT TO ATT5D1 & DIDN'T4 ,ATT5DANCE PROBABLY NEV] EXCE$$ #f11 & WAS USUALLY BEL[ #c14 ,! ONLY KN[N TALLY ( ! TOTAL VOTE ON A MEASURE IS #c1#d#f#a 7,ZIMM]N #a#i#c#a3 #a#f#i74 ,& ?IS DESPITE ! FACT ?AT MANY CITIZ5S W]E SLAVE[N]S :O W]E !REBY RELIEV$1 9 :OLE OR 9 P>T1 ( ! NE$ TO WORK 7,BOOK*9 #a#i#i3 #h74 ,& DESPITE ! FACT ?AT ! PREVAL5T IDEOLOGY1 :I* EV5 ,SOCRATES SUBSCRIB$ TO1 0EMPHATICALLY PRIORITIZ$ ! SOCIAL OV] ! 9DIVIDUAL10 AS ! ,DEAN APPROV+LY ASS]TS ?AT ,BAKUN9 DID 7#e73 0AS A MATT] ( C\RSE10 ! ,A!NIANS 0PUT ! CITY FIR/ & ! 9DIVIDUAL NO:]E0 7,ZIMM]N #a#i#c#a3 #a#f#i-#a#g N4 #a74 ,EV5 MO/ ,A!NIANS ) ! TIME TO SP>E = PUBLIC AFFAIRS AVOID$ POLITICAL 9VOLVEM5T4 ,9 ?IS RESPECT !Y RESEMBL$ ! REMNANTS ( DIRECT DEMOCRACY 9 ,AM]ICA1 ! ,NEW ,5GL& T[N MEET+S4 ,!SE ORIG9AT$ 9 ! ,MASSA*USETTS ,BAY COLONY :5 ! DISP]SAL ( SETTLEM5TS MADE A UNIT>Y C5TRAL GOV]NM5T IMPRACTICAL4 ,AT FIR/ 9=MALLY1 BUT SOON =MALLY1 T[NS EX]CIS$ SUB/ANTIAL P[]S ( SELF-GOV]NM5T4 ,! ORIG9AL =M ( SELF-GOV]NM5T WAS ! T[N MEET+ ( ALL FREEM51 :I* TOOK PLACE ANY:]E FROM WEEKLY TO MON?LY4 ,?IS SY/EM /ILL PREVAILS1 =MALLY1 9 SOME ,NEW ,5GL& T[NS1 9CLUD+ ?OSE 9 ,BOOK*9'S ADOPT$ /ATE ,V]MONT -- BUT AS A =M )\T CONT5T4 ,9 ,V]MONT ! T[N MEET+ TAKES PLACE ONLY ONE DAY A YE> 7SPECIAL MEET+S >E POSSIBLE1 BUT R>E74 ,ATT5DANCE IS L[1 & DECL9+3 0,9 REC5T YE>S !RE HAS BE5 A /EADY DECL9E 9 P>TICIPATION UNTIL 9 SOME T[NS !RE >E SC>CELY MORE P]SONS PRES5T ?AN ! (FICIALS :O >E REQUIR$ TO BE !RE0 7,NUQUI/ #a#i#f#d3 #d-#e74 ,! ,DEAN HAS ?R[N A LOT ( FAIRY-DU/ ON PRES5T-DAY ,V]MONT T[N MEET+S 7#a#i#h#g3#b#f#h-#b#g2 #a#i#h#i3 #a#h#a7 )\T EV] CLAIM+ ?AT !Y PLAY ANY REAL ROLE 9 GOV]NANCE4 ,9DE$1 ,BOOK*9 HAILS ! T[N MEET+'S 0CONTROL0 7SO-CALL$7 PRECISELY BECAUSE 0IT DOES NOT C>RY ! POND]\S WEIRY ! POND]\S WEIRY1 WILL+LY1 ! POND]\S WEIE NOT POLITICAL MILITANTS LIKE ! ,DEAN4 ,SEV]AL SORTS (1 SO TO SPEAK1 SPECIAL PEOPLE FLOCK TO !SE GET-TOGE!RS4 ,!SE OCCASIONS T5D TO ATTRACT A P]SON 7TYPICALLY A MAN7 :O IS AN IDEOLOGICAL FANATIC1 A CONTROL FREAK1 AN ACT+-\T VICTIM ( M5TAL ILLNESS1 OR SOMEBODY :O JU/ DOESN'T HAVE A LIFE1 & (T5 SOMEONE FAVOR$ BY SOME COMB9ATION ( ! =EGO+ CIVIC VIRTUES4 ,FACE-TO-FACE DEMOCRACY IS 9-Y\R-FACE DEMOCRACY4 ,TO ! EXT5T ?AT ! TIRELESS TYPICALS TURN UP1 !Y DISC\RAGE ?OSE NOT SO AFFLICT$ FROM P>TICIPAT+ ACTIVELY OR RETURN+ ! NEXT TIME4 ,! ,DEAN1 = 9/ANCE1 SPEAKS GL[+LY ( 0HAV+ ATT5D$ MANY T[N MEET+S OV] ! LA/ FIFTE5 YE>S0 7#a#i#h#g3 #b#f#i7 -- !Y >5'T EV5 HELD :]E HE LIVES ,BURL+TON -- :O BUT A POLITICAL P]VO-VOYEUR C\LD POSSIBLY GET (F ON !SE SOLEMN C]EMONIES8 ,SOME PEOPLE LIKE TO WAT* AUTOPSIES TOO4 ,! SAME TYPES :O'D GET !MSELVES ELECT$ 9 A REPRES5TATIVE DEMOCRACY T5D TO DOM9ATE1 BY !IR BIGM\!D BULLY+1 A DIRECT DEMOCRACY TOO 7,DAHL #a#i#i3 #e#d74 ,NORMAL NON-OBSESSIVE PEOPLE WILL (T5 RA!R APPEASE ! OBSESSIVES OR EV5 KICK !M UP/AIRS ?AN PROLONG AN UNPLEASANT 9T]ACTION ) !M4 ,IF FACE-TO-FACE DEMOCRACY MEANS HAV+ TO FACE DEMOCRATS LIKE ,BOOK*91 MO/ PEOPLE W\LD RA!R EXECUTE AN AB\T-FACE4 ,& SO ! M9ORITY ( POLITICAL OBSESSIVES1 GIV5 AN 9/ITUTIONAL OPPORTUNITY1 T5D TO HAVE !IR WAY4 ,?AT WAS H[ IT WAS 9 ,A!NS1 :]E DIRECTION CAME FROM :AT WE MI C\LD NOT FUNCTION )\T !M0 7,F9LEY #a#i#h#e3 #f#i74 ,9 0,A ,DAY 9 ! ,LIFE ( A ,SOCIALI/ ,CITIZ510 ,MI*AEL ,WALZ] 7#a#i#g3 *4 #a#a7 S5T UP MUSCUL>1 DIRECT DEMOCRACY BE=E ,BOOK*9 PUBLICIZ$ HIS V]SION ( IT4 ,WALZ]'S PO9T ( DEP>TURE WAS :AT ,M>X & ,5GELS WROTE 9 ,! ,G]MAN ,IDEOLOGY AB\T H[ ! PO/-REVOLUTION>Y COMMUNI/ CITIZ5 IS A FULLY REALIZ$1 ALL-SID$ P]SON :O 0HUNTS 9 ! MORN+1 FI%ES 9 ! AFT]NOON1 RE>S CATTLE 9 ! EV5+1 & PLAYS ! CRITIC AFT] D9N]0 )\T EV] BE+ CONF9$ TO ANY OR ALL ( !SE SOCIAL ROLES 7IBID43 #b#b#i74 ,BOOK*9 HAS 5DORS$ ?IS VISION 7#a#i#h#i3 #a#i#b1 #a#i#e74 ,S\NDS GOOD1 BUT A MUSCUL> MUNICIPAL SOCIALI/ HAS FUR!R DEM&S ON HIS TIME3 ,BE=E HUNT+ 9 ! MORN+1 ?IS UNALI5AT$ MAN ( ! FUTURE IS LIKELY TO ATT5D A MEET+ ( ! ,C\NCIL ON ,ANIMAL ,LIFE1 :]E HE WILL BE REQUIR$ TO VOTE ON IMPORTANT MATT]S RELAT+ TO ! /OCK+ ( ! =E/S4 ,! MEET+ WILL PROBABLY NOT 5D MU* BE=E NOON1 = AMONG ! MANY-SID$ CITIZ5S !RE WILL ALWAYS BE A LIVELY 9T]E/ EV5 9 HIXI/ MAN WILL P>TICIPATE EAG]LY 9 !SE DEBATES1 EV5 PO/PON+ A S*$UL$ DISCUSSION ( SOME CONTRADICTORY !SES ON CATTLE-RE>+4 ,9DE$ HE WILL PROBABLY LOVE >GUM5T F> BETT] ?AN HUNT+1 FI%+1 OR RE>+ CATTLE4 ,! DEBATES WILL GO ON SO LONG ?AT ! CITIZ5S WILL HAVE TO RU% ?R\< D9N] 9 ORD] TO ASSUME !IR ROLE AS CRITICS4 ,!N (F !Y WILL GO TO MEET+S ( /UDY GR\PS1 CLUBS1 $ITORIAL BO>DS1 & POLITICAL P>TIES :]E CRITICISM WILL BE C>RI$ ON LONG 9TO ! NIE0 7IBID43 #b#c#e74 ,WALZ] IS F> FROM BE+ MY FAVORITE ?9K] 7,BLACK #a#i#h#e71 BUT :AT HE SKET*$ H]E IS AS MU* P>ADIGM AS P>ODY4 ,IT SC>CELY EXAGG]ATES & 9 NO WAY CONTRADICTS ,R\SSEAU'S -- HIS FELL[ ,G5EVAN ,CALV9'S -- ASCETIC REPUBLICAN CIVISM1 :I* 9 TURN IS DI/URB+LY CLOSE TO ,BOOK*9'S MUSCUL>1 MORALI/IC MUNICIPALISM4 ,! ,DEAN HAS LONG 9SI/$ UPON ! POT5TIAL ( :AT HE CALLS 0LIB]ATORY TE*NOLOGY0 TO FREE ! MASSES FROM TOIL & U%] 9 A PO/-SC>CITY SOCIETY 7#a#i#g#a3 #h#c-#a#c#i74 0,)\T MAJOR TE*NOLOGICAL ADVANCES TO FREE PEOPLE FROM TOIL10 AN>*Y -- ESPECIALLY 0PRIMITIVI/IC1 PR]ATIONAL1 ANTITE*NOLOGICAL1 & ANTICIVILIZATIONAL0 AN>*Y -- IS IMPOSSIBLE 7#b#f74 ,NO P>T ( HIS ,M>XI/ H]ITAGE IS MORE VITAL TO ,BOOK*9 ?AN ITS NOTION ( HUMANITY PASS+ FROM ! REALM ( NECESSITY TO ! REALM ( FRE$OM BY WAY ( ! RATIONAL1 SOCIALLY RESPONSIBLE APPLICATION ( ! ADVANC$ TE*NOLOGY CREAT$ BY CAPITALISM4 ,! ,DEAN IS FURI\S ) 0LIFE/YLE AN>*I/S0 :O D\BT OR D5Y ?IS PO/ULATE ( POSITIVI/ PROGRESSIVISM1 BUT = PRES5T PURPOSES1 LET'S ASSUME HE'S RI*O-DEMOCRATIC1 RATIONAL CONTROL1 ADVANC$ TE*NOLOGY W\LD DRA/ICALLY R$UCE ! TIME DEVOT$ TO PRODUCTION WORK & AF=D ECONOMIC SECURITY TO ALL4 ,TE*NOLOGY W\LD ?US DO = ! UPRILY 5\<4 ,= EV5 IF TE*NOLOGY R$UC$ ! H\RS ( WORK1 IT W\LD NOT R$UCE ! H\RS 9 A DAY4 ,!RE W\LD /ILL BE #bd ( !M4 ,LET'S MAKE-BELIEVE WE C\LD AUTOMATE ALL PRODUCTION-WORK AWAY4 ,EV5 IF WE DID1 TE*NICS C\LDN'T POSSIBLY DO MORE ?AN %AVE A FEW M9UTES (F ! LONG H\RS :I* DELIB]ATIVE1 DIRECT DEMOCRACY W\LD NECESSITATE1 ! 0(T5 PROSAIC1 EV5 T$I\S BUT MO/ IMPORTANT =MS ( SELF-MANAGEM5T ?AT REQUIR$ PATI5CE1 COMMITM5T TO DEMOCRATIC PROC$URES1 L5G?Y DEBATES1 & A DEC5T RESPECT = ! OP9IONS ( O!RS )9 ONE'S COMMUNITY0 7,BOOK*9 #a#i#i#f3 #b2 CF4 ,DAHL #a#i#i3 #c#b-#c#f1 #e#b74 7,I PASS OV] AS B5EA? COMM5T ,BOOK*9'S AV[AL ( 0A DEC5T RESPECT = ! OP9IONS ( O!RS407 ,HAV+ TO RACE FROM MEET+ TO MEET+ TO TRY TO KEEP ! MILITANTS FROM TAK+ OV] W\LD BE EV5 WORSE ?AN WORK+1 BUT )\T ! PAY4 ,?AT WAS ! FIR/ PRACTICAL OBJECTION4 ,! SECOND IS ?AT !RE IS NO REASON TO BELIEVE ?AT !RE HAS EV] BE5 AN URBAN1 PURELY DIRECT DEMOCRACY OR EV5 A REASONABLE APPROXIMATION ( ONE4 ,EV]Y KN[N 9/ANCE HAS 9VOLV$ A CONSID]ABLE ADMIXTURE ( REPRES5TATIVE DEMOCRACY :I* SOON] OR LAT] USUALLY SUBORD9AT$ DIRECT DEMOCRACY :]E IT DIDN'T ELIM9ATE IT ALTOGE!R4 ,9 ,A!NS1 = 9/ANCE1 A ,C\NCIL ( #e1 *OS5 MON?LY BY LOT1 SET ! AG5DA = ! MEET+S ( ! EKKLESIA 7!RE WAS NO PROVISION = NEW BUS9ESS TO BE BR\7 & :I*1 9 TURN1 ELECT$ AN 9N] C\NCIL ( #e = GOV]N+ BETWE5 ASSEMBLIES1 :I* 9 TURN ELECT$ A DAILY *AIRMAN4 ,SIR ,ALFR$ ,ZIMM]N1 :OSE SYMPA!TIC BUT DAT$ ACC\NT ( ,A!NIAN DEMOCRACY ! ,DEAN HAS REF]R$ TO APPROV+LY 7#a#i#g#a3 #a#e#i1 #bhh N4 #b#g71 OBS]V$ ?AT ! ,C\NCIL CONSI/$ ( PAID (FICIALS 7,ZIMM]N #a#i#c#a3 #a#f#e71 A DETAIL ! ,DEAN OMITS4 ,9 G5]AL1 0! SOV]EIGN PEOPLE JUDG$ & ADM9I/]$ BY DELEGAT+ P[] TO REPRES5TATIVES0 7IBID13 #a#f#f74 ,G5]ALS1 = 9/ANCE -- V]Y IMPORTANT (FICIALS 9 AN IMP]IALI/ /ATE FREQU5TLY AT W> -- W]E ELECT$ ANNUALLY 7,DAHL #a#i#i3 #c2 CF4 ,BOOK*9 #a#i#g#a3 #a#e#g74 ,!SE W]E REM>KABLY RADICAL DEMOCRATIC 9/ITUTIONS = !IR DAY1 & EV5 = \RS1 BUT !Y >E ALSO SUB/ANTIAL DEP>TURES FROM ,BOOK*9I/ DIRECT DEMOCRACY4 ,NONE!LESS ! ,DEAN ONLY GRUDG+LY ADMITS ?AT ,A!NS WAS EV5 A 0QUASI-/ATE0 7,BOOK*9 #a#i#h#i3 #f#i71 :ATEV] ! HELL A 0QUASI-/ATE10 IS4 ,UNBELIEVABLY1 ! ,DEAN CLAIMS ?AT 0,A!NS HAD A '/ATE' 9 A V]Y LIMIT$ & PIECEMEAL S5SE444 ! '/ATE' AS WE KN[ IT 9 MOD]N TIMES C\LD H>DLY BE SAID TO EXI/ AMONG ! ,GREEKS0 7#a#i#h#g3 #c#d74 ,JU/ ASK ,SOCRATES4 ,:AT'LL Y\ BE HAV+8 ,HEMLOCK1 /RAIDS1 COMMISSIONS1 OR COLLECTIVES ( QUALIFI$1 EV5 ELECT$ (FICIALS0 7,BOOK*9 #a#i#h#i3 #a#g#e7 -- ! EXP]TS & ! POLITICIANS4 ,AGA93 0,GIV5 A MODE/ BUT BY NO MEANS SMALL SIZE1 ! POLIS C\LD BE >RANG$ 9/ITUTIONALLY SO ?AT IT C\LD HAVE ITS AFFAIRS CONDUCT$ BY WELL-R\ND$1 PUBLICLY-5GAG$ M5 ) A M9IMAL1 C>EFULLY GU>D$ DEGREE ( REPRES5TATION0 7,BOOK*9 #a#i#i3 #h74 ,MEET ! NEW BOSS1 SAME AS ! OLD BOSS6 ,CONSID] ,SWITZ]L&1 A HI /ATECRAFT & ! NATION-/ATE UTT]LY SUP]FLU\S0 7#a#i#h#g3 #b#b#i74 ,ALEXIS DE ,TOCQUEVILLE1 AS A/UTE A /UD5T ( DEMOCRACY AS EV] WAS1 WROTE 9 #a#h#d#h3 ,IT IS NOT SUFFICI5TLY REALIZ$ ?AT1 EV5 9 ?OSE ,SWISS CANTONS :]E ! PEOPLE HAVE MO/ PRES]V$ ! EX]CISE ( !IR P[]1 !RE DOES EXI/ A REPRES5TATIVE BODY 5TRU/$ ) SOME ( ! C>ES ( GOV]NM5T4 ,N[1 IT IS EASY TO SEE1 :5 /UDY+ REC5T ,SWISS HI/ORY1 ?AT GRADUALLY ?OSE MATT]S ) :I* ! PEOPLE CONC]N !MSELVES >E BECOM+ FEW]1 :]EAS ?OSE ) :I* !IR REPRES5TATIVES DEAL >E DAILY BECOM+ MORE NUM]\S & MORE IMPORTANT4 ,?US ! PR9CIPLE ( PURE DEMOCRACY IS LOS+ GR\ND GA9$ BY ! OPPOS+ PR9CIPLE4 ,! =M] IS 9S5SIBLY BECOM+ ! EXCEPTION & ! LATT] ! RULE 7#a#i#f#iB3 #g#d74 ,EV5 9 ! ,SWISS CANTONS !RE W]E REPRES5TATIVE BODIES 7LEGISLATURES7 TO :I* ! EXECUTIVE & ! JUDICI>Y W]E /RICTLY SUBORD9ATE 7IBID43 #g#d#a74 ,CIVIL LIB]TIES W]E VIRTUALLY UNKN[N & CIVIL RI*IES AT ! TIME 7IBID43 #g#c#h74 ,DE ,TOCQUEVILLE CONSID]$ ! ,SWISS ,CONF$]ATION ( HIS DAY 0! MO/ IMP]FECT ( ALL ! CON/ITUTIONS ( ?IS K9D YET SE5 9 ! WORLD0 7IBID43 #g#d#d74 ,E>LI]1 ,JOHN ,ADAMS HAD ALSO MADE ! PO9T ?AT ! ,SWISS CANTONS W]E >I/OCRATIC REPUBLICS AS WELL AS OBS]V+ ?AT !IR HI/ORICAL T5D5CY WAS = H]$IT>Y ELITES TO 5TR5* !MSELVES 9 (FICE 7,C\LBORN #a#i#f#e3 #a#a-#a#b74 ,AS = ! 0ECONOMIC & POLITICAL COORD9ATION0 :I* R5D]S ! ,SWISS 0NATION-/ATE UTT]LY SUP]FLU\S0 7,BOOK*9 #a#i#h#g3 #b#b#i71 IF ! ,SWISS NATION-/ATE IS UTT]LY SUP]FLU\S1 :Y DOES IT EXI/ AT ALL8 ,AS IT DOES1 AS SURELY AS EXI/ ! ,SWISS BANKS :OSE NUMB]$ ACC\NTS SAFEGU>D SO MU* ( ! LOOT ( ! WORLD'S DICTATORS & GANG/]S 7,RUW>T #a#i#i#f3 #d74 ,IS !RE POSSIBLY A CONNECTION8 ,MIK+ & MONEY-LAUND]+ UND]WRITE ITS DIRECT DEMOCRACY 7SU* AS IT IS7 JU/ AS SLAV]Y & IMP]IALISM UND]WROTE ! DIRECT DEMOCRACY ( ,A!NS8 ,A ,SWISS P>LIAM5T>IAN ONCE REF]R$ TO HIS C\NTRY AS A NATION ( RECEIV]S ( /OL5 GOODS4 ,?OSE ( US :O >E SOME:AT OLD] ?AN MO/ ,NOR? ,AM]ICAN AN>*I/S1 AL?\< MU* Y\NG] ?AN ! ,DEAN1 ALSO RECALL ! HI/ORY ( EF=TS TO =M AN ALL-9CLUSIVE AN>*I/ ORGANIZATION H]E4 ,NEV] DID !Y COME CLOSE TO SUCCESS4 7,TO ANTICIPATE AN OBJECTION -- ! ,9DU/RIAL ,WORK]S ( ! ,WORLD IS NOT N[1 & NEV] HAS BE51 AN AV[$LY AN>*I/ ORGANIZATION4 ,IT IS SYNDICALI/1 NOT AN>*I/ .<& NOT ,BOOK*9I/.>74 ,NOT UNTIL AB\T #a#i#b#d1 :5 MO/ ( ! MEMB]%IP HAD FALL5 AWAY1 JO9$ ! ,COMMUNI/ ,P>TY1 OR 9 SOME CASES GONE TO PRISON1 WAS ! LITTLE ?AT WAS LEFT ( ! ,ONE ,BIG ,UNION ESS5TIALLY1 IF UN(FICIALLY1 AN AN>*I/ ORGANIZATION47 ,MU* LAT] ! ,AN>*I/ ,COMMUNI/ ,F$]ATION MADE AN EF=T TO UNIFY ! WORK]I/_/ORGANIZATIONAL AN>*I/S1 & MO/ REC5TLY ! EX- 7OR MAYBE NOT SO EX-7 ,M>XI/S >\ND ,LOVE @& ,RAGE1 :OSE AN>*I/ BONA FIDES >E WIDELY D\BT$1 FLOPP$ TOO4 ,AT ?IS TIME !RE SEEMS TO BE NO 9T]E/ 9 A CONT95TAL AN>*I/ F$]ATION4 ,! ONLY APP>5T PURPOSE = ONE IS TO LEGISLATE /&>DS ( AN>*I/ OR?ODOXY 7,BLACK #a#i#i#b3 #a#h#a-#a#i#c71 AN OBJECTIVE UND]/&ABLY UNWELCOME TO ! UNOR?ODOX MAJORITY ( AN>*I/S1 AL?\< ?AT N[ APPE>S TO BE ! ,DEAN'S BELAT$ GOAL4 ,:ILE ! AN>*I/ RANKS HAVE GREATLY GR[N DUR+ ! DECADES ( DECAD5CE1 WE >E F> FROM NUM]\S & UNIT$ 5\< TO ASSEMBLE 9 A FI*I/S0 T5D TO BE ANTI-ORGANIZATIONAL1 9 ! S5SE ?AT WE KN[ ?AT AN>*I/ ORGANIZATIONS HAVE A POOR TRACK RECORD & ALSO ?AT1 GIV5 \R NUMB]S1 \R RES\RCES1 & \R DIFF]5CES1 ,NOR? ,AM]ICAN AN>*I/S HAVE NO COMPELL+ REASON TO BELIEVE ?AT :AT'S NEV] WORK$ = US BE=E W\LD WORK IF WE TRI$ IT N[4 ,IT IS NOT AS IF !SE ORGANIZ+ EF=TS >E 9DISP5SABLE TO ACCOMPLI% EV5 :AT LITTLE WE >E ALREADY ACCOMPLI%+4 ,MO/LY :AT WE >E ACCOMPLI%+ IS PUBLI%+4 ,AFT] ! ,A,C,F FELL AP>T1 ! COLLECTIVE :I* HAD BE5 RESPONSIBLE = PRODUC+ ITS NEWSPAP] ,/RIKE6 CONT9U$ TO DO SO ON ITS [N = SOME YE>S4 ,AN ORGANIZATION MAY NE$ A NEWSPAP]1 BUT A NEWSPAP] MAY NOT NE$ AN ORGANIZATION 7,BLACK #a#i#i#b3 #a#i#b74 ,9 ! CASE ( ,LOVE @& ,RAGE1 ! NEWSPAP] PREC$$ :AT LITTLE !RE IS TO ITS CONT95TAL ORGANIZATION4 ,SELF-REPORTS & O!R REPORTS ( AN>*I/ BURN\T )9 LEFTI/ ANTI-AU?ORIT>IAN COLLECTIVES AB\ND 7,NO ,MIDDLE ,GR\ND1 ,PROCESS$ ,WORLD1 ,OP5 ,ROAD1 ,BLACK ,ROSE ,BOOKS1 ,SABOTAGE ,BOOK/ORE1 ETC474 ,!SE >E1 = AN>*I/S1 USUALLY IDEOLOGICAL KILL+-FIELDS4 ,IRONICALLY1 ! ALLEG$LY ANTI-ORGANIZATIONAL COLLECTIVES1 SU* AS ,AUTONOM$IA & ! ,FIF? ,E/ATE1 HAVE \TLA/$ MO/ ( ! ORGANIZATIONAL ONES4 ,C\LD IT BE ?AT ! ORGANIZ]-TYPES >E TOO 9DIVIDUALI/IC TO GET ALONG ) EA* O!R8 O ,*APT] #e 3 ,MURRAY ,BOOK*91 ,MUNICIPAL ,/ATI/ ,*APT] #e3 ,MURRAY ,BOOK*91 ,MUNICIPAL ,/ATI/ ,!RE IS NO PUTT+ (F ! 9EVITABLE ANY LONG]4 ,IT HAS TO BE SAID3 ,DEAN ,BOOK*9 IS NOT AN AN>*I/4 ,BY ?IS ,I DO NOT MEAN ?AT HE IS NOT MY K9D ( AN>*I/1 AL?\< ?AT TOO IS TRUE4 ,I MEAN HE IS NOT ANY K9D ( AN>*I/4 ,! WORD MEANS SOME?+1 AFT] ALL1 & :AT IT MEANS IS D5IAL ( ! NECESSITY & DESIRABILITY ( GOV]NM5T4 ,?AT'S A B>E- BONES1 PRE-ADJECTIVAL DEF9ITION ANT]IOR TO ANY SQUABBL+ AB\T 9DIVIDUALI/1 COLLECTIVI/1 COMMUNI/1 MUTUALI/1 SOCIAL1 LIFE/YLE1 ECOLOGICAL1 MY/ICAL1 RATIONAL1 PRIMITIVI/1 ,WATSONIAN1 ONTOLOGICAL1 ETC4 AN>*ISMS4 ,AN AN>*I/ AS SU* IS OPPOS$ TO GOV]NM5T -- FULL /OP4 ,DEAN ,BOOK*9 IS NOT OPPOS$ TO GOV]NM5T4 ,CONSEQU5TLY1 HE IS NOT AN AN>*I/4 ,:AT6 0,! =EMO/ CONTEMPOR>Y AN>*I/ !ORI/0 7,CL>K #a#i#i3 #a#b7 IS NOT AN AN>*I/8 ,Y\ HE>D ME4 ,HE'S NOT -- REALLY & TRULY1 HE'S NOT4 ,& NOT BECAUSE HE FLUNKS SOME AB/RUSE IDEOLOGICAL TE/ ( MY [N CONCOCTION4 ,HE'S NOT AN AN>*I/ BECAUSE HE BELIEVES 9 GOV]NM5T4 ,AN AN>*I/ CAN BELIEVE 9 MANY ?+S1 & ALL TOO (T5 DOES1 BUT GOV]NM5T IS NOT ONE ( !M4 ,!RE'S NO?+ HE9\S AB\T NOT BE+ AN AN>*I/4 ,SOME ( MY BE/ FRI5DS >E NOT AN>*I/S4 ,!Y DO NOT1 H[EV]1 CLAIM TO BE AN>*I/S1 AS ! ,DEAN DOES4 ,I C\LD TAKE SOME *EAP %OTS AT ! ,DEAN -- COME TO ?9K ( IT1 ,I ?9K ,I WILL6 ,H[ MANY ( HIS ,R$-&-,GRE5 DISCIPLES KN[ ?AT HE WAS =M]LY 9 FAVOR ( A MODE/ MEASURE ( NUCLE> P[]8 ,SOL>1 W9D1 & TIDAL P[] %\LD BE EXPLOIT$ TO ! MAX1 BUT 0IT W\LD BE IMPOSSIBLE TO E/ABLI% AN ADVANC$ 9DU/RIAL ECONOMY BAS$ EXCLUSIVELY ON SOL> 5]GY1 W9D P[]1 OR EV5 TIDAL P[]0 7,H]B] #a#i#f#e3 #a#i#c71 & WE MU/ HAVE AN ADVANC$ 9DU/RIAL ECONOMY1 ?AT GOES )\T SAY+4 ,SO1 ?\< WE %\LDN'T 0OV]COMMIT \RSELVES TO ! USE ( NUCLE> FUELS10 ! CLEAN 5]GY S\RCES WILL NOT SUFFICE3 0,!SE GAPS WILL BE FILL$ BY NUCLE> & FOSSIL FUELS1 BUT WE WILL EMPLOY !M JUDICI\SLY1 ALWAYS TAK+ C>E TO LIMIT !IR USE AS MU* AS POSSIBLE0 7IBID474 ,?AT'S A COM=T4 ,& IT W\LD BE SCURRIL\S ( ME TO REPORT ?AT ?IS SAME ,BOOK*9 BOOK 7,H]B] #a#i#f#e3 IX7 9CLUDES -- ?IS MU/ BE AN AN>*I/ FIR/ -- A PLUG FROM A ,CAB9ET MEMB]1 !N-,SECRET>Y ( ! ,9T]IOR ,/EW>T ,L4 ,UDALL3 0,CRISIS 9 ,\R ,CITIES SETS =? 9 ONE VOLUME VIVID EVID5CE ?AT ! MO/ DEBILITAT+ DISEASES ( \R TIME >E A RESULT ( \R P]SI/5T & >ROGANT ABUSE ( \R %>$ 5VIRONM5T4444 ,WE CANNOT M9IMIZE ! 9VE/M5TS NECESS>Y TO POLLUTION CONTROL1 BUT AS ,MR4 ,H]B] .<,BOOK*9.> DOCUM5TS1 ! P5ALTIES = NOT DO+ SO HAVE BECOME UN?9KABLE40 ,?IS IS1 BE IT NOT$1 A CALL = LEGISLATION & TAXATION :I* A CLOSET AN>*I/ ALL[$ TO ADORN ONE ( HIS BOOKS4 ,!RE'S ALSO AN AFT]WORD FROM ! ,SURGEON ,G5]AL ( ! ,UNIT$ ,/ATES4 ,AS EMB>RASS+ TO ! ,DEAN AS !SE REM9D]S MU/ BE1 !Y >E NOT CONCLUSIVE AGA9/ HIM4 ,IT IS HIS [N EXPLICIT 5DORSEM5TS ( ! /ATE :I* >E DECISIVE4 ,NOT1 TO BE SURE1 ! NATION-/ATE ( MOD]N ,EUROPEAN PROV5ANCE4 ,HE DOESN'T LIKE ?AT SORT ( /ATE V]Y MU*4 ,IT ALL[S = TOO MU* 9DIVIDUAL AUTONOMY4 ,BUT HE IS 5AMOR$ ( ! CITY-/ATE ( CLASSICAL ANTIQUITY & ! OCCASIONALLY1 SEMI-SELF- GOV]N+ 0COMMUNE0 ( PRE-9DU/RIAL WE/]N ,EUROPE4 ,9 ?IS HE IS REM9ISC5T ( ,KROPOTK91 :O PROP\ND$ ! ABSURD OP9ION ?AT ! /ATE DID NOT EXI/ 9 WE/]N ,EUROPE PRIOR TO ! SIXTE5? C5TURY 7CF4 ,BOOK*9 #a#i#h#g3 #c#c-#c#d74 ,?AT W\LD HAVE SURPRIS$ & AMUS$ ,WILLIAM ! ,CONQU]OR & HIS SUCCESSORS1 NOT TO M5TION ! ,FR5* & ,SPANI% MON>*S & ! ,ITALIAN CITY-/ATES FAMILI> TO ,MA*IAVELLI -- :OSE ,IL ,PR9CIPE WAS CLE>LY NOT DIRECT$ TO A M&AT$ & REVOCABLE DELEGATE RESPONSIBLE TO ! BASE1 BUT RA!R TO A MAN ON HORSEBACK1 SOMEBODY LIKE ,CAES>E ,BORGIA4 ,AL?\< IT IS ! MO/ UNREM>KABLE ( OBS]VATIONS1 ! ,DEAN C>RIES ON AS IF HE'S G5U9ELY 9C5S$ ?AT ,JOHN ,Z]ZAN1 REVIEW+ HIS ,! ,RISE ( ,URBANIZATION & ! ,DECL9E ( ,CITIZ5%IP 7#a#i#h#g71 PO9T$ \T ?AT ! ROMANTICIZ$ CLASSICAL ,A!NIAN POLIS HAS 0LONG BE5 ,BOOK*9'S MODEL = A REVITALIZATION ( URBAN POLITICS10 A 0CAN>D0 TO :I* ! ,DEAN 9DIGNANTLY RETORTS1 0,9 FACT1 ,I TOOK GREAT PA9S TO 9DICATE ! FAIL+S ( ! ,A!NIAN POLIS 7SLAV]Y1 PATRI>*Y1 CLASS ANTAGONISMS1 & W>70 7#e#i74 ,HE MAY HAVE FELT GREAT PA9S AT GETT+ CAUD SLAV]Y 7#a#i#h#g3 #h#c1 #h#g71 AS IF ! FACT ?AT CLASSICAL CITIES HAD MO/LY SUBJECT POPULATIONS 7,DAHL #a#i#i3 #a7 WAS ! ACCID5TAL RESULT ( SOME COLLECTIVE PSY*IC QUIRK1 SOME /RANGE ?\S&-YE> HEAD-TRIP4 ,:AT ,Z]ZAN SAID IS ONLY :AT ONE ( ! ,DEAN'S ADMIR]S PUT 9 /RONG] T]MS3 0,BOOK*9 CONT9UALLY EXHORTS US TO HE>K5 BACK TO ! ,GREEKS1 SEEK+ TO RECAPTURE ! PROMISE ( CLASSICAL ?\K #a#i#h#b3 #e#b2 ,CL>K #a#i#h#d3 #b#b-#b#c74 ,EV]Y HI/ORIAN KN[S ?AT L>GE-SCALE SLAV]Y WAS A NECESSITY = ! CLASSICAL CITY 7,F9LEY #a#i#e#i71 AL?\< ! ,DEAN HAS ISSU$ ! FIAT ?AT 0! IMAGE ( ,A!NS AS A SLAVE ECONOMY :I* BUILT ITS CIVILIZATION & G5]\S HUMANI/IC \TLOOK ON ! BACKS ( HUMAN *ATTELS IS FALSE0 7#a#i#g#b3 #a#e#i74 7,M4,I4 ,F9LEY -- LIKE ! ,DEAN1 AN EX-,COMMUNI/ .<,NOVICK #a#i#h#h3 #c#b#h.> -- IS A ,BOOK*9-APPROV$ HI/ORIAN .<#a#i#h#i3 #a#g#h.>47 ,SOME ( :AT ,Z]ZAN WRITES AB\T PALEOLI?IC SOCIETY MAY BE CONJECTURAL & CRITICIZABLE1 BUT :AT HE WRITES AB\T ,BOOK*9 IS PURE REPORTAGE4 ,! ,DEAN PLA9LY SAYS ?AT 0LAT] IDEALS ( CITIZ5%IP1 EV5 9S(> AS !Y W]E MODEL$ ON ! ,A!NIAN1 SEEM MORE UNF9I%$ & IMMATURE ?AN ! ORIG9AL -- H5CE ! V]Y CONSID]ABLE DISCUSSION ,I HAVE GIV5 TO ! ,A!NIAN CITIZ5 & HIS CONTEXT0 7#a#i#h#g3 #h#c74 ,?AT IS P]HAPS BECAUSE ! EV5 MORE UNF9I%$ & IMMATURE REALIZATIONS ( 0LAT] IDEALS0 LACK$ ! COMB9ATION ( ! IMM5SE SLAVE 9FRA/RUCTURE & ! TRIBUT>Y EMPIRE POSSESS$ BY CLASSICAL ,A!NS4 ,SIMIL> PEANS TO ,A!NIAN CITIZ5%IP PEPP] ! ,DEAN'S E>LY BOOKS TOO 7#a#i#g#b3 #a#e#e-#a#e#i2 #a#i#g#d3 *4 #a74 ,MANIFE/LY :AT'S PUT A BEE 9 ,BOOK*9'S B]ET IS ?AT ,Z]ZAN HAS HAD ! TEM]ITY TO READ ,BOOK*9'S BOOKS1 NOT JU/ REV]E !IR DI/+UI%$ AU?OR1 & ,Z]ZAN HAS ACTUALLY KEPT TRACK ( :AT ! ,DEAN'S BE5 REIT]AT+ ALL !SE YE>S4 ,! D[N SIDE ( BE+ 0>GUABLY ! MO/ PROLIFIC AN>*I/ WRIT]0 7,EHRLI* #a#i#i#f3 #c#h#d7 IS ?AT Y\ LEAVE A LONG PAP] TRAIL4 ,BOOK*9 IS A /ATI/3 A CITY-/ATI/4 ,A CITY-/ATE IS NOT AN ANTI-/ATE4 ,CONTEMPOR>Y ,S+APORE1 = 9/ANCE1 IS A HIIAN CITY-/ATE4 ,! E>LIE/ /ATES1 9 ,SUM]1 W]E CITY-/ATES4 ,! CITY IS :]E ! /ATE ORIG9AT$4 ,! ANCI5T ,GREEK CITIES W]E ALL /ATES1 MO/ ( !M NOT EV5 DEMOCRATIC /ATES 9 EV5 ! LIMIT$ ,A!NIAN S5SE ( ! WORD4 ,ROME W5T FROM BE+ A CITY-/ATE TO AN EMPIRE )\T EV] BE+ A NATION-/ATE4 ,! CITY-/ATES ( ,R5AISSANCE ,ITALY W]E /ATES1 & ONLY A FEW ( !M1 & NOT = LONG1 W]E 9 ANY S5SE DEMOCRACIES4 ,9DE$ REPUBLICAN ,V5ICE1 :OSE 9DEP5D5CE LA/$ ! LONGE/1 />TL+LY ANTICIPAT$ ! MOD]N POLICE-/ATE 7,&RIEUX #a#i#g#b3 #d#e-#e#e74 ,TAK+ A WORLDWIDE COMP>ATIVE-HI/ORICAL P]SPECTIVE1 ! PRE-9DU/RIAL CITY1 UNLESS IT WAS ! CAPITAL ( AN EMPIRE OR A NATION-/ATE 79 :I* CASE IT WAS DIRECTLY SUBJECT TO A RESID5T MON>*7 WAS ALWAYS SUBJECT TO AN OLIG>*Y4 ,!RE HAS NEV] BE5 A CITY :I* WAS NOT1 OR :I* WAS NOT P>T (1 A /ATE4 ,& !RE HAS NEV] BE5 A /ATE :I* WAS NOT A CITY OR ELSE DIDN'T 9CORPORATE ONE OR MORE CITIES4 ,! PRE-9DU/RIAL CITY 7:AT ,GIDEON ,SJOB]G CALLS -- A POOR *OICE ( WORDS -- ! 0FEUDAL CITY07 WAS ! ANTI!SIS ( DEMOCRACY1 NOT TO M5TION AN>*Y3 ,C5TRAL TO ! /RATIFICATION SY/EM ?AT P]VADES ALL ASPECTS ( ! FEUDAL CITY'S SOCIAL /RUCTURE -- ! FAMILY1 ! ECONOMY1 RELIGION1 $UCATION1 & SO ON -- IS ! PREEM95CE ( ! POLITICAL ORGANIZATION4444 ,WE REIT]ATE3 ! FEUDAL1 OR PRE9DU/RIAL CIVILIZ$1 ORD] IS DOM9AT$ BY A SMALL1 PRIVILEG$ UPP] /RATUM4 ,! LATT] COMM&S ! KEY 9/ITUTIONS ( ! SOCIETY4 ,ITS HI<] E*ELONS >E MO/ (T5 LOCAT$ 9 ! CAPITAL1 ! L[] RANKS RESID+ 9 ! SMALL] CITIES1 USUALLY ! PROV9CIAL CAPITALS 7,SJOB]G #a#i#f3 #b#b74 ,SJOB]G ANTICIPAT$ ! OBJECTION1 0,:AT AB\T ,A!NS80 ,HE WROTE1 0AL?\< ! ,GREEK CITY WAS UNIQUE = ITS TIME1 9 ITS POLITICAL /RUCTURE IT ACTUALLY APPROXIMATES ! TYPICAL PRE9DU/RIAL CITY F> MORE ?AN IT DOES ! 9DU/RIAL-URBAN ORD]0 7IBID43 #b#c#f74 ,ONLY A SMALL M9ORITY ( ,A!NIANS W]E CITIZ5S1 & MANY ( !M W]E ILLIT]ATE &_/OR TOO POOR TO BE ABLE TO P>TICIPATE EFFECTIVELY1 IF AT ALL1 9 POLITICS 7IBID43 #b#c#e74 ,!N & !RE1 AS ALWAYS 9 CITIES EV]Y:]E1 POLITICS WAS AN ELITE PR]OGATIVE4 ,! 0LAT5T0 DEMOCRACY ( ANY & EV]Y URBAN REPUBLIC 7#e#i7 IS SOME?+ ONLY ,BOOK*9 CAN SEE1 JU/ AS ONLY ,WILHELM ,REI* C\LD SEE ORGONES UND] ! MICROSCOPE4 ,! DI/9CTION ! ,DEAN TRIES TO DRAW BETWE5 0POLITICS0 MID 0/ATECRAFT0 7#a#i#h#g3 #bdc @& PASSIM7 IS ABSURD & SELF-S]V+1 NOT TO M5TION ?AT IT'S A MAJOR MUTILATION ( ORD9>Y ,5GLI%4 ,EV5 IF LOCAL POLITICS IS A K9D]1 G5TL] V]SION ( NATIONAL POLITICS1 IT IS /ILL POLITICS1 :I* HAS BE5 WELL IF CYNICALLY DEF9$ AS :O GETS :AT1 :51 :]E1 H[ 7,LASSWELL #a#i#e#h74 ,IT'S NOT JU/ ?AT ! ,DEAN USES AN IDIOSYNCRATIC T]M9OLOGY TO RECONCILE 79 A RAM%ACKLE SORT ( A WAY7 AN>*Y ) DEMOCRACY1 HE'S MORE APOPLECTIC ?AN ANYBODY C\LD HAVE EV] ?\IAN4 0,DEMOCRATIC RULE IS /ILL RULE10 .<,L4 ,SUSAN.> ,BR[N W>NS4444 ,OPPON5TS ( DEMOCRACY AS 0RULE0 TO ! CONTR>Y NOT)/&+1 IT DESCRIBES ! DEMOCRATIC DIM5SION ( AN>*ISM AS A MAJORIT>IAN ADM9I/RATION ( ! PUBLIC SPH]E4 ,ACCORD+LY1 ,COMMUNALISM SEEKS FRE$OM RA!R ?AN AUTONOMY 9 ! S5SE ?AT ,I HAVE C\NT]POIS$ !M 7#a#g1 #e#g74 ,MOV+ ALONG FROM HIS M9D-BOGGL+ D$UCTION ?AT DEMOCRACY IS DEMOCRATIC1 ,BOOK*9 FUR!R FUSSES ?AT 0PEJORATIVE WORDS LIKE DICTATE & RULE PROP]LY REF] TO ! SIL5C+ ( DISS5T]S1 NOT TO ! EX]CISE ( DEMOCRACY0 7#a#h74 ,FREE SPEE* IS A F9E ?+1 BUT IT'S NOT DEMOCRACY4 ,Y\ CAN HAVE ONE )\T ! O!R4 ,! ,A!NIAN DEMOCRACY ?AT ! ,DEAN V5]ATES1 = 9/ANCE1 DEMOCRATICALLY SIL5C$ ! DISS5T] ,SOCRATES BY PUTT+ HIM TO DEA?4 ,AN>*I/S 0JETTISON0 DEMOCRATIC DECISION-MAK+1 NOT BECAUSE IT'S AU?ORIT>IAN1 BUT BECAUSE IT'S /ATI/4 0,DEMOCRACY0 MEANS 0RULE BY ! PEOPLE40 0,AN>*Y0 MEANS 0NO RULE40 ,!RE >E TWO DIFF]5T WORDS BECAUSE !Y REF] TO 7AT LEA/7 TWO DIFF]5T ?+S4 ,I DON'T CLAIM -- & TO MAKE MY PO9T1 ,I DON'T HAVE TO CLAIM -- ?AT ! ,DEAN'S *>ACT]IZATION ( AN>*ISM AS G5]ALIZ$ DIRECT DEMOCRACY HAS NO BASIS :ATSOEV] 9 TRADITIONAL AN>*I/ ?\*ISM ( SOME ( ! MORE CONS]VATIVE CLASSICAL AN>*I/S IS 9DE$ ALONG !SE L9ES -- AL?\< ,BOOK*9'S V]SION1 RI*I/ ,HANNAH ,>5DT 7#a#i#e#h74 ,IRONICALLY1 IT IS ! AN>*I/S ,BOOK*9 DISP>AGES AS 9DIVIDUALI/S -- LIKE ,PR\DHON & ,GOODMAN -- :O BE/ REPRES5T ?IS AN>*I/ !ME4 ,IT WAS ! 9DIVIDUALI/ EGOI/ ,B5JAM9 ,TUCK] :O DEF9$ AN AN>*I/ AS AN 0UNT]RIFI$ ,JEFF]SONIAN DEMOCRAT40 ,BUT ANO!R !ME ) AS LEA/ AS RESPECTABLE AN AN>*I/ P$IGREE HOLDS ?AT DEMOCRACY IS NOT AN IMP]FECT REALIZATION ( AN>*Y BUT RA!R /ATISM'S LA/ /&4 ,MANY AN>*I/S BELIEVE1 & MANY AN>*I/S HAVE ALWAYS BELIEV$1 ?AT DEMOCRACY IS NOT JU/ A GROSSLY DEFICI5T V]SION ( AN>*Y1 IT'S NOT AN>*Y AT ALL4 ,AT ANY RATE1 NO 0DIRECT FACE-TO-FACE DEMOCRACY0 7#e#g7 ?AT ,I AM AW>E ( HAS DELEGAT$ TO COMRADE ,BOOK*9 7M&AT$1 REVOCABLE1 & RESPONSIBLE TO ! BASE7 ! AU?ORITY TO PASS OR FAIL AN>*I/S :I* HE 5JOYS TO PASS OR FAIL COLLEGE /UD5TS4 ,IT IS BY NO MEANS OBVI\S1 & ! ,DEAN NO:]E DEMON/RATES1 ?AT LOCAL IS K9D] & G5TL] -- NOT :]E LOCAL REF]S TO LOCAL GOV]NM5T4 ,IT IS EQUALLY AS PLAUSIBLE ?AT1 AS ,JAMES ,MADISON >GU$1 A L>GE & HET]OG5E\S POLITY IS MORE FAVORABLE TO LIB]TY ?AN ! 0SMALL REPUBLIC10 AS !N LOCAL M9ORITIES CAN F9D NATIONAL ALLIES TO C\NT]ACT LOCAL MAJORIT>IAN TYRANNY 7,COOKE #a#i#f#a3 #c#e#a-#c#e#c74 ,BUT AFT] ALL1 AS HE SAYS HIMSELF1 ! ,DEAN ISN'T 9T]E/$ 9 LIB]TY 79 HIS J>GON1 AUTONOMY .<#e#g.>17 BUT ONLY 9 :AT HE CALLS SOCIAL FRE$OM1 ! P>TICIPATORY1 SELF-RATIFI$ S]VITUDE ( 9DOCTR9AT$ MORALI/S TO ! PETITE POLITY 9 :I* !Y FUNCTION AS SELF-EFFAC+ CITIZ5-UNITS4 ,MY PRES5T PURPOSE IS NOT TO TAKE ! FULL MEASURE ( ,BOOK*9ISM1 ONLY TO *>ACT]IZE IT AS :AT IT MANIFE/LY IS1 AS AN IDEOLOGY ( GOV]NM5T -- DEMOCRACY -- NOT A !ORY ( AN>*Y4 ,BOOK*9'S 0M9IMAL AG5DA0 -- ?IS HO>Y ,M>XI/ WORD 0M9IMAL0 IS HIS1 NOT M9E 7#a#i#h#g3 #b#h#g7 -- IS UNAMBIGU\SLY /ATI/1 NOT AN>*I/4 ,! 0F\RFOLD T5ETS10 ! ,F\R ,COMM&M5TS HE REQUIRES ALL AN>*I/S TO AFFIRM1 AL?\< MO/ ( !M DO NOT1 & NEV] DID1 >E3 444A CONF$]ATION ( DEC5TRALIZ$ MUNICIPALITIES2 AN UNWAV]+ OPPOSITION TO /ATISM2 A BELIEF 9 DIRECT DEMOCRACY2 & A VISION ( A LIB]T>IAN COMMUNI/ SOCIETY 7#f74 ,BY SOME QUIRK ( FATE1 ,BOOK*9'S M9IMAL1 BELIEVE-IT-OR-ELSE AN>*I/ CRE$ JU/ HAPP5S TO BE HIS CRE$4 ,IT ALSO HAPP5S TO BE DELIRI\SLY 9COH]5T4 ,A 0CONF$]ATION ( DEC5TRALIZ$ MUNICIPALITIES0 CONTRADICTS 0DIRECT DEMOCRACY10 AS A CONF$]ATION IS AT BE/ A REPRES5TATIVE1 NOT A DIRECT1 DEMOCRACY4 ,IT ALSO CONTRADICTS 0AN UNWAV]+ OPPOSITION TO /ATISM0 BECAUSE A CITY-/ATE OR A F$]AL /ATE IS /ILL A /ATE4 ,& BY REQUIR+1 NOT 0A LIB]T>IAN COMMUNI/ SOCIETY10 ONLY ! VISION ( ONE1 ! ,DEAN CLE>LY IMPLIES ?AT !RE IS MORE TO SU* A SOCIETY ?AN OB$I5CE TO ! FIR/ ,?REE ,COMM&M5TS -- BUT EXACTLY :AT MORE1 HE ISN'T SAY+4 ,! ,DEAN IS RELEGAT+ HI<]-/AGE AN>*Y 7! REAL ?+7 TO SOME REMOTE FUTURE TIME1 JU/ AS ! ,M>XI/S RELEGATE :AT !Y CALL HI<]-/AGE COMMUNISM TO SOME HAZY DI/ANT FUTURE :I* SEEMS1 LIKE A MIRAGE1 =EV] TO REC$E4 ,AMAZ+LY1 ! ,DEAN CONSID]S A CITY LIKE ,NEW ,YORK 767 TO BE 0L>GELY MADE UP ( NEIGELY ORGANIC COMMUNITIES ?AT HAVE A C]TA9 MEASURE ( ID5TITY0 7#a#i#h#g3 #b#d#f74 7,HE HAS ELSE:]E & 9CONSI/5TLY WRITT5 ?AT ! MOD]N WORLD 0LACKS REAL CITIES0 .<,BOOK*9 #a#i#g#d3 VIII.>47 ,BUT COMMUNITY 0OBVI\SLY MEANS MORE ?AN1 SAY1 NEIT 9 HIS CONCEPTION ( AN ORGANIC COMMUNITY4 ,I W\LDN'T RECOMM5D HE TAKE A MIDNIE ! MO/ CONSPICU\S MANIFE/ATIONS ( COMMUNITY 9 MANY IMPOV]I%$ & O!RWISE ATOMIZ$ ,NEW ,YORK NEIE V]Y HAPPY AB\T IT4 ,:ILE ! WORD 0AN>*ISM0 APPE>S ON ALMO/ EV]Y PAGE ( ! ,DEAN'S DIATRIBE1 ! WORD 0AN>*Y0 R>ELY IF EV] DOES4 ,! IDEOLOGY1 ! ISM1 IS :AT PREOCCUPIES HIM1 NOT ! SOCIAL CONDITION1 ! WAY ( LIFE1 IT'S PRESUMABLY SUPPOS$ TO GUIDE US T[>D4 ,IT MAY NOT BE AN 9ADV]T5T *OICE ( WORDS ?AT :AT ,BOOK*9 LAYS D[N1 AS ONE ( HIS ,F\R ,COMM&M5TS ( OR?ODOX AN>*ISM1 IS 0AN UNWAV]+ OPPOSITION TO /ATISM0 7#f3 EMPHASIS ADD$71 NOT AN UNWAV]+ OPPOSITION TO ! /ATE4 ,AS A DEMOCRAT1 ! ,DEAN IS AT BE/ CAPABLE ( ONLY A WAV]+ OPPOSITION TO ! /ATE1 :]EAS AN AB/RACT REJECTION ( AN AB/RACTION1 0/ATISM10 IS EASY 5\< TO ISSUE4 ,& ,I'M SURE IT'S NO ACCID5T ?AT HIS %OT AT ! MA9/REAM M>KET+ ( ,BOOK*9ISM 7,BOOK*9 #a#i#h#gA7 NO:]E ID5TIFIES ! ,DEAN AS AN AN>*I/ OR HIS TEA*+S AS ANY K9D ( AN>*ISM4 ,A FUR!R ,BOOK*9I/ FIDDLE -- ?IS ONE A BLATANT REGRESSION TO ,M>XISM 79DE$1 TO ,/4-,SIMONIANISM7 -- IS ! DI/9CTION BETWE5 0POLICY0 & 0ADM9I/RATION0 7IBID43 #b#d#g-#b#d#h74 ,POLICY IS MADE1 HE SAYS1 BY ! OCCASIONAL FACE-TO-FACE ASSEMBLY :I* PU%Y 9TELLECTUALS LIKE ,BOOK*9 >E SO GOOD AT MANIPULAT+4 ,ADM9I/RATION IS = ! EXP]TS1 AS 9 HI<]-/AGE ,M>XI/ ,COMMUNISM1 :]E ! 0GOV]NM5T ( M50 IS O/5SIBLY REPLAC$ BY ! 0ADM9I/RATION ( ?+S40 ,UN=TUNATELY IT IS M5 7& IT USUALLY /ILL IS M57 :O GOV]N BY ADM9I/]+ ?+S1 & BY ADM9I/]+ PEOPLE AS IF !Y W]E ?+S1 AS GOV]NORS HAVE ALWAYS GOV]N$4 ,POLICY )\T ADM9I/RATION IS NO?+4 ,ADM9I/RATION ) OR )\T POLICY IS EV]Y?+4 ,/AL9 ! ,G5]AL ,SECRET>Y1 ! ADM9I/RATOR1 UND]/OOD ?AT1 :I* IS :Y HE TRIUMPH$ OV] ,TROTSKY1 ,BUKH>9 & ALL ! O!R POLICY-PREOCCUPI$ POLITICIANS :O P]HAPS POSSIBLY BELIEV$ 9 SOME?+4 0,POLICY0 IS A EUPHEMISM = LAW1 & 0ADM9I/RATION0 IS A EUPHEMISM = 5=CEM5T4 ,JU/ :AT POLITICAL PRACTICE DOES ! EXIMI\S ELD] PRESCRIBE TO AN>*I/S8 ,WE KN[ H[ HI<]-/AGE CONF$]AL MUNICIPALISM LOOKS -- MUSCUL> M5TAT+ M5 MASS$ 9 MEET+S -- BUT :AT IS TO BE DONE 9 ! H]E & N[8 ,! ,DEAN DESPISES EXI/+ AN>*I/ EF=TS3 ,! SPORADIC1 ! UNSY/EMATIC1 ! 9COH]5T1 ! DISCONT9U\S1 & ! 9TUITIVE SUPPLANT ! CONSI/5T1 PURPOSIVE1 ORGANIZ$1 & RATIONAL1 9DE$ ANY =M ( SU/A9$ OR FOCUS$ ACTIVITY AP>T FROM PUBLI%+ A 0Z9E0 OR PAMPHLET -- OR BURN+ A G>BAGE CAN 7#e#a74 ,SO WE >E NOT TO PUBLI% Z9ES & PAMPHLETS AS ,BOOK*9 US$ TO DO1 NOR >E WE TO BURN G>BAGE CANS4 ,NOR >E WE TO EXP]I5CE FRE$OM 9 ! TEMPOR>Y COLLECTIVE FRAT]NIZATIONS ,HAKIM ,BEY CALLS ,TEMPOR>Y ,AUTONOM\S ,ZONES 7#b-#b#f74 ,WE'RE SUPPOS$ TO GET ORGANIZ$1 BUT ,BOOK*9 HAS NOT 9DICAT$1 NOT EV5 BY EXAMPLE1 :AT ORGANIZATION WE'RE SUPPOS$ TO JO94 ,:AT !N8 ,I ,ON ?IS PO9T ! ,DEAN1 USUALLY SO V]BOSE1 IS ALLUSIVE & ELUSIVE4 ,I HAVE BE5 UNABLE TO LOCATE 9 ANY ( HIS WRIT+S ANY =MULATION ( ! 0PROGRAMMATIC AS WELL AS ACTIVI/ SOCIAL MOVEM5T0 HE N[ DEM&S 7#f74 ,:AT ,I ?9K HE IS H9T+ AT1 ) NODS & W9KS1 IS P>TICIPATION 9 LOCAL ELECTORAL POLITICS3 ,! MUNICIPALITY IS A POT5TIAL TIME BOMB4 ,TO CREATE LOCAL NETWORKS & TRY TO TRANS=M LOCAL 9/ITUTIONS ?AT REPLICATE ! ,/ATE . IS TO PICK UP A HI/ORIC *ALL5GE -- A TRULY POLITICAL ONE -- ?AT HAS EXI/$ = C5TURIES4444 ,= 9 !SE MUNICIPAL 9/ITUTIONS & ! *ANGES ?AT WE CAN MAKE 9 !IR /RUCTURE -- TURN+ !M MORE & MORE 9TO A NEW PUBLIC SPH]E -- LIES ! ABID+ 9/ITUTIONAL BASIS = A GRASSROOTS DUAL P[]1 A GRASSROOTS CONCEPT ( CITIZ5%IP1 & MUNICIPALIZ$ ECONOMIC SY/EMS ?AT CAN BE C\NT]POIS$ TO ! GR[+ P[] ( ! C5TRALIZ$ ,NATION-,/ATE & C5TRALIZ$ ECONOMIC CORPORATIONS 7,BOOK*9 #a#i#i3 #a#b74 ,:5 ! ,DEAN SPEAKS ( TRANS=M+ EXI/+ LOCAL 9/ITUTIONS1 :5 HE SPEAKS ( 0! *ANGES WE CAN MAKE 9 !IR /RUCTURE10 HE CAN ONLY BE REF]R+ TO P>TICIPATION 9 LOCAL POLITICS AS IT IS ACTUALLY CONDUCT$ 9 ! ,UNIT$ ,/ATES & ,CANADA -- BY GETT+ ELECT$ OR BY GETT+ APPO9T$ BY ?OSE :O'VE GOTT5 !MSELVES ELECT$4 ,?AT IS EXACTLY :AT ! WORLD'S ONLY ,BOOK*9I/ POLITICAL MOVEM5T1 ,BLACK ,ROSE BOSS ,DIMITRI ,R\SSOP\LOS' ,ECOLOGIE ,MONTREAL GR\PUSCULE 7,ANONYM\S #a#i#i#f3#b#b7 HAS ATTEMPT$1 &1 =TUNATELY1 FAIL$ AT4 ,Y\ CAN CALL ?IS ANY?+ Y\ WANT TO -- EXCEPT AN>*I/4 ,TO SUM UP3 ,DEAN ,BOOK*9 IS A /ATI/4 O ,*APT] #f 3 ,REASON & ,REVOLUTION ,*APT] #f3 ,REASON & ,REVOLUTION ,! ,DEAN D5\NCES LIFE/YLE AN>*I/S = SUCCUMB+ TO ! REACTION>Y 9TELLECTUAL CURR5TS ( ! LA/ QU>T] C5TURY1 SU* AS IRRATIONALISM 7#a-#b1 #i1 #e#e-#e#f @& PASSIM74 ,HE LAM5TS ! ,/IRN]I/ 0F>EWELL TO OBJECTIVE REALITY0 7#e#c7 AN ! DISDA9 = 0REASON AS SU*0 7#b#h74 ,) HIS USUAL SELF-ABSORPTION SANS SELF-AW>5ESS1 ,BOOK*9 FAILS TO NOTICE ?AT HE IS E*O+ ! RIT1 & MUSIC4 ,! Y\NG PEOPLE :O >ROGANTLY REFUS$ TO 0TRU/ ANYONE . OV] ?IRTY10 TO USE A POPUL> SLOGAN ( ! DAY1 SEV]$ ALL TIES ) ! BE/ TRADITIONS ( ! PA/ 7,BOOK*9 #a#i#h#i3 #a#f#b74 70,TRU/ NO ONE OV] ?IRTY0 7TO GET ! SLOGAN RILY FROM ! CONS]VATIVE DEMI-9TELLIG5TSIA1 FROM ,HILTON ,KRAM]1 ,NORMAN ,PODHORETZ1 ,MIDGE ,DE*T]1 ,JAMES ,Q4 ,WILSON1 ,IRV+ ,KRI/OL1 ,WILLIAM ,F4 ,BUCKLEY1 ,GEORGE ,WILL1 ,NEWT ,G+RI*1 ,?OMAS ,S[ELL1 ,WILLIAM ,SAFI]1 ,CL>5CE ,?OMAS1 ,PAT ,BU*ANAN & ! ,H]ITAGE ,F\NDATION CREW4 ,EV]Y G5]ATION1 ONCE IT S5SES ?AT IT'S BE+ SUPPLANT$ BY ! NEXT ONE1 =GETS ?AT IT WAS ONCE ! UP/>T 7! RI*I/S >E AFFLICT$1 *>GES ! ,DEAN1 ) MY/ICISM & IRRATIONALISM4 ,!SE >E WORDS HE DOES NOT DEF9E BUT REPEAT$LY BRACKETS AS IF !Y HAD ! SAME MEAN+ 7#b1 #a#a1 #ai @& PASSIM74 ,!Y DON'T4 ,MY/ICISM IS ! DOCTR9E ?AT IT IS POSSIBLE1 BYPASS+ ! ORD9>Y ME?ODS ( P]CEPTION & COGNITION1 TO EXP]I5CE ,GOD_/,ULTIMATE ,REALITY DIRECTLY1 UNM$IAT$LY4 ,9 ?IS S5SE1 IT IS LIKELY ?AT ,HAKIM ,BEY QUALIFIES AS A MY/IC1 BUT ,I CAN'T ?9K ( ANYBODY ELSE ON ! ,DEAN'S 5EMIES LI/ :O EV5 COMES CLOSE4 ,!RE IS NO?+ 9NATELY RATIONAL OR IRRATIONAL AB\T MY/ICISM4 ,REASON-ID5TIFI$ PHILOSOPH]S SU* AS ,KANT1 ,HEGEL & ,>I/OTLE 7! LATT] CIT$ #c TIMES 9 ! ,DEAN'S MAGNUM OPUS .<#a#i#h#b3 #c#g#f.>7 MA9TA9$ ?AT !RE IS AN ,ULTIMATE ,REALITY4 ,IF !Y'RE RIY CONSCI\SNESS 7#a#i#i#a3 #f#h74 ,! 0EPI/EMOLOGICAL AN>*I/10 AS PHILOSOPH] ( SCI5CE ,PAUL ,FEY]AB5D CALLS HIMSELF1 TAKES GREAT 9T]E/ 9 EXP]I5CES 0:I* 9DICATE ?AT P]CEPTIONS CAN BE >RANG$ 9 HITICUL> >RANGEM5T AS 'CORRESPOND+ TO REALITY' :ILE NOT >BITR>Y 7IT ALMO/ ALWAYS DEP5DS ON TRADITIONS71 IS C]TA9LY NOT MORE 'RATIONAL' OR MORE 'OBJECTIVE' ?AN ! *OICE ( ANO!R >RANGEM5T0 7#a#i#g#e3 #a#h#i-#a#i74 ,ALL ,I CAN SAY = MYSELF IS ?AT1 = BETT] OR = WORSE1 ,I HAVE NEV] HAD A MY/ICAL EXP]I5CE &1 FUR!RMORE1 ?AT ,I DO NOT CONSID] ! NOTION ( ULTIMATE OR ABSOLUTE REALITY MEAN+FUL4 ,AS ,I ONCE JIB$1 MY/ICS 0HAVE 9COMMUNICABLE 9SIATIONAL1 NOT NECESS>ILY IRRATIONAL4 ,! ,DEAN'S F]V5T FAI? 9 OBJECTIVE REALITY 7#e#c7 HAS MORE 9 COMMON ) MY/ICISM ?AN IT DOES ) SCI5CE4 ,AS MY/ICS DO1 ,BOOK*9 BELIEVES !RE IS SOME?+ ABSOLUTE 0\T !RE0 :I* IS ACCESSIBLE TO DIRECT APPREH5SION -- BY 0REASON AS SU*0 7#b#h7 ON HIS ACC\NT1 BY O!R MEANS ACCORD+ TO !IRS4 ,SCI5TI/S HAVE BE5 DISABUS+ !MSELVES ( SU* SIMPLISM = AB\T A C5TURY4 ,! H>D SCI5CES -- />T+ ) PHYSICS1 ! H>DE/ ( !M ALL -- W]E ! FIR/ TO AB&ON A METAPHYSICAL POSITIVISM :I* NO LONG] CORRESPOND$ TO :AT SCI5TI/S W]E REALLY ?9K+ & DO+4 ,! ,DEAN WAS AT ONE TIME VAGUELY ,I AW>E ( ?IS 7#a#i#h#b3 #b#h#a74 ,! NOT-QUITE-SO-SCI5TIFIC S(T SCI5CES ) L[] SELF-E/EEM W]E SL[] TO R5\NCE SCI5TISM1 BUT BY N[1 !Y HAVE1 TOO -- !Y HAVE TOO1 BECAUSE !Y HAVE TO4 ,! REJECTION ( POSITIVISM 9 SOCIAL ?\Y TO A CLASSIC CONTEMPOR>Y TEXTBOOK ON SOCIAL SCI5CE RESE>* ME?ODS C\LD NOT BE MORE BLUNT3 0OBJECTIVITY4 ,DOESN'T EXI/4 ,SEE 9T]SUBJECTIVITY0 7,BABBIE #a#i#i#b3 ,G#f74 ,SETTL+ = 9T]SUBJECTIVE V]IFIABILITY )9 A COMMUNITY ( PRACTIC+ SCI5TI/S IS ACTUALLY ! MO/ CONS]VATIVE PO/-OBJECTIVI/ POSITION CURR5TLY )9 ! RANGE ( SCI5TIFIC RESPECTABILITY 7E4G41 ,KUHN #a#i#g74 ,HI/ORY1 ! MAYBE-SCI5CE :I* HAS ALWAYS HAD ! MO/ AMBIGU\S & DUBI\S CLAIM TO OBJECTIVITY1 HELD \T ! LONGE/1 BUT NO LONG] 7,NOVICK #a#i#h#h3 *4 #a#c74 ,OBJECTIVITY 9 ANY ABSOLUTE S5SE IS ILLUSORY1 A CULT FETI%1 A *ILDI% CRAV+ = AN UNATTA9ABLE C]TITUDE4 ,9TELLECTUALS1 NEUROTICS -- I4E41 9 A POLITICAL CONTEXT1 IDEOLOGUES -- 0HAVE TO DO ) ! 9VISIBLE & BELIEVE 9 IT10 !Y HAVE 0ALWAYS KEPT BE=E !IR EYES AGA9 AN 9TR9SICALLY VALID IMPORTANCE ( ! OBJECT1 AN ABSOLUTE VALUE ( IT1 AS IF ! DOLL W]E NOT ! MO/ IMPORTANT ?+ TO ! *ILD1 ! ,KORAN TO ! ,TURK0 7,/IRN] #a#i#i#e3 #b#i#e74 ,9 CONTRA/1 ! AN>*I/ 0DOES NOT BELIEVE 9 ANY ABSOLUTE TRU?0 7,ROCK] #a#i#d#g3 #b#g74 ,NOR DOES ! SCI5TI/4 ,NOR DOES ! MATURE ADULT4 ,9 ! NOVEL ,SEV5 ,R$ ,SUNDAYS1 ! AN>*I/ ,SAM> SAYS1 0,?IS EF=T TO /OP ?9K+ IS AT BASE RELIGI\S4 ,IT REPRES5TS A FAI? 9 SOME?+ ABSOLUTE0 7,S5D] #a#i#i3 #b#e#c74 ,IF ,/IRN] BID 0F>EWELL TO OBJECTIVE REALITY10 IF ,NIETZS*E HELD 0?AT FACTS >E SIMPLY 9T]PRETATIONS0 7#e#c71 !Y W]E F> AHEAD ( !IR TIMES4 ,IT IS BY N[ ALMO/ TRITE TO REM>K ?AT !RE IS 0NO !ORY-9DEP5D5T WAY TO RECON/RUCT PHRASES LIKE 'REALLY !RE'0 7,KUHN #a#i#g3 #b#f2 CF4 ,BRAD=D #a#i#i#f3 #b#e#i-#b#f74 ,SCI5TI/S DISP5SE ) OBJECTIVE REALITY = ! SAME REASON ! MA!MATICIAN ,LAPLACE1 AS HE TOLD ,NAPOLEON1 DISP5S$ ) ,GOD3 !RE'S NO NE$ = ! HYPO!SIS 7CF4 ,BOOK*9 #a#i#g#i3 #b#c74 ,REVIEW+ TWO REC5T AN?OLOGIES1 ,RE?9K+ ,OBJECTIVITY 7,MEGILL #a#i#i#d7 & ,SOCIAL ,EXP]I5CE & ,AN?ROPOLOGICAL ,KN[L$GE 7,HA/RUP @& ,H]VIK #a#i#i#d71 AN?ROPOLOGI/ ,JAY ,RUBY RELATES ?AT NO CONTRIBUTOR TO EI!R VOLUME >GUES ?AT 0AN OBJECTIVE REALITY EXI/S \TSIDE ( HUMAN CONSCI\SNESS ?AT IS UNIV]SAL0 7#a#i#i#f3 #c#i#i74 ,9T5D+ NO HUMOR1 BUT UNWITT+LY PROVID+ SOME AT ,BOOK*9'S EXP5SE1 HE CONT9UES3 0,IT IS UN=TUNATE ?AT ,MEGILL DID NOT SEEK \T PROPON5TS ( ?IS POSITION1 = !Y CAN EASILY BE F\ND AMONG J\RNALI/S -- PR9T & BROADCA/1 DOCUM5T>Y FILMMAK]S1 ,M>XI/S1 & ! POLITICAL & RELIGI\S RI RATIONALISM BY :AT ONE ,M>XI/ LAWY] CALL$ 0FIDEISM40 ,BUT ?IS POLEMICAL PR$ECESSOR ( ,BOOK*9'S -- A C]TA9 ,L59 -- HAD AT LEA/ A NODD+ ACQUA9TANCE ) ! CONT5T ( ! !N-NEW PHYSICS :I* WAS UNDO+ FUNDAM5TALI/ MAT]IALISM 7,L59 #a#i#e74 ,!RE IS NO 9DICATION ?AT ,BOOK*9 HAS ANY REAL GR\ND+ 9 SCI5CE1 AL?\< ?IRTY YE>S AGO HE DID AN ADEQUATE JOB ( POPUL>IZ+ 9=MATION AB\T POLLUTION 7,H]B] #a#i#f#c1 #a#i#f#e74 ,! TRUE BELIEV]S 9 OBJECTIVI/1 MATT]-9-MOTION RATIONALISM >E USUALLY1 LIKE ,L59 & ,BOOK*91 WORDMONG]S -- LAWY]S1 J\RNALI/S 7,RUBY #a#i#i#f3 #c#i#i71 OR IDEOLOGUES 7,BLACK #a#i#i#fA7 -- NOT SCI5TI/S4 ,!Y BELIEVE ! MORE F]V5TLY BECAUSE !Y DO NOT UND]/&4 ,!Y CL+ TO OBJECTIVE REALITY 0) ! SAME FE> A *ILD CLUT*ES HIS MO!R'S H&0 7IBID43 #a#e74 ,AS ,CLIF=D ,GE]TZ SAYS1 ! OBJECTIVI/S >E 0AFRAID REALITY IS GO+ TO GO AWAY UNLESS WE BELIEVE V]Y H>D 9 IT0 7QUOT$ 9 ,NOVICK #a#i#h#h3 #e#e#b74 ,L59 C\LD H>DLY BE MORE 9DIGNANT3 0,BUT ?IS IS ALL %E] OBSCURANTISM1 \T-&-\T REACTION4 ,TO REG>D ATOMS1 MOLECULES1 ELECTRONS1 ETC41 AS AN APPROXIMATELY TRUE REFLECTION 9 \R M9D ( ! OBJECTIVELY REAL MOVEM5T ( MATT] IS EQUIVAL5T TO BELIEV+ 9 AN ELEPHANT UPON :I* ! WORLD RE/S60 7#a#i#e3 #c#f#a74 ,EI!R !SE IMP5ETRABLE P>TICLES >E B\NC+ >\ND (F EA* O!R D[N !RE LIKE BILLI>D BALLS ON A POOL TABLE 7:AT A CURI\S MODEL ( OBJECTIVE REALITY .<,BLACK #a#i#i#fA.>7 OR !Y >E FANTASY BE+S LIKE UNICORNS1 LEPRE*AUNS & LIFE/YLE AN>*I/S4 ,IT'S APPROPRIATE ?AT ! LAWY] ,L59'S CRITIQUE ( ! PHYSICS ( SCI5TI/S LIKE ,MA* 7,L59 #a#i#e7 WAS ANSW]$ BY A SCI5TI/1 A PROM95T A/RONOM] :O WAS ALSO A PROM95T LIB]T>IAN COMMUNI/3 ,ANTON ,PANNEKOEK 7#a#i#d#h74 ,ECOLOGY IS A SCI5CE1 BUT ,SOCIAL ,ECOLOGY IS TO ECOLOGY :AT ,*RI/IAN ,SCI5CE IS TO SCI5CE4 ,BOOK*9'S ACADEMIC AFFILIATIONS1 UNDI/+UI%$ AS !Y >E1 & HIS S*OL>LY PRET5SIONS HAVE MADE SOME IMPRESSION ON SOME AN>*I/S1 BUT !N AGA91 SOME AN>*I/S >E ALL TOO EASY TO IMPRESS4 ,ACCORD+ TO ! 7,BOOK*9I/7 ,9/ITUTE = ,SOCIAL ,ECOLOGY1 ITS CO-F\ND] IS AN 09T]NATIONALLY ACCLAIM$ AU?OR & SOCIAL PHILOSOPH]0 7#a#i#i#e3 #f74 ,! ,ECOLOGY ( ,FRE$OM 7,BOOK*9 #a#i#h#b71 ACCORD+ TO A ,BOOK*9I/1 IS 0A WORK ( SWEEP+ SCOPE & /RIK+ ORIG9ALITY0 :I* IS 0DE/9$ TO BECOME A CLASSIC ( CONTEMPOR>Y SOCIAL ?\K #a#i#h#d3 #b#a#e74 ,H[ IS ,BOOK*9'S S*OL>%IP REG>D$ BY ACTUAL S*OL>S8 ,I DECID$ TO F9D \T4 ,I LOOK$ UP ALL REVIEWS ( ! ,DEAN'S BOOKS LI/$ 9 ! ,SOCIAL ,SCI5CES ,9DEX FROM ,APRIL #aiha TO DATE 7,JUNE #a#i#i#f74 ,I APPRECIATE ?AT ?IS IS A CRUDE & 9COMPLETE MEASURE ( HIS RECEPTION -- IT FAILS TO PICK UP1 = 9/ANCE1 TWO NOTICES 9 ! ACADEMICALLY M>G9AL J\RNAL ,5VIRONM5TAL ,E?ICS 7,WATSON #a#i#i#e2 ,ECK]SLEY #a#i#h#i7 -- BUT IT CANVASSES EV]Y IMPORTANT J\RNAL & MO/ ( ! LESS IMPORTANT ONES4 ,!RE W]E ALL ( TWO REVIEWS ( ! FIR/ $ITION ( ,! ,ECOLOGY ( ,FRE$OM1 HIS ,DAS ,KAPITAL1 0! MO/ IMPORTANT BOOK TO APPE> SO F> 9 ! HI/ORY ( AN>*I/ ?\K #a#i#h#d3#a#h#h N4 #b74 ,! ONE-PAGE REVIEW 9 ! ,AM]ICAN ,POLITICAL ,SCI5CE ,REVIEW1 AFT] SUMM>IZ+ ,BOOK*9'S CONT5TIONS1 ASK$3 0,CAN HUMANITY SIMPLY BE 9TEGRAT$ 9TO ! :OLE . )\T LOS+ ITS DI/9CTIV5ESS1 & CAN SOLUTIONS TO ! PROBLEMS ( ! MOD]N WORLD EM]GE 9 ! RELATIVELY SPONTANE\S FA%ION ,BOOK*9 ANTICIPATES 7PP4 #c#a#f-#c#a#g71 MU* AS PROBLEMS >E DEALT ) BY ANTS1 BEES1 & BEAV]S80 7,SMI? #a#i#h#c3 #e#d74 ,!RE'S NO?+ ON ! PAGES CIT$ :I* HAS ANY?+ TO DO ) ! RELATIVELY SPONTANE\S SOLUTION ( SOCIAL PROBLEMS :I* ,SMI? CLAIMS ?AT ,BOOK*9 ESP\SES4 ,! REVIEW] C\LD H>DLY HAVE MISUND]/OOD ,BOOK*9 MORE PR(\NDLY4 ,! ,DEAN IS FRANTICALLY 9SI/5T ON DI/+UI%+ HUMANS FROM ANIMALS & 0ANIMALITY0 7#d#g-#d#h1 #e1 #e#c1 #e#f71 ESPECIALLY 0F\R-LEGG$ ANIMALITY0 7#c#i7 -- F\R LEGS BAD1 TWO LEGS GOOD6 ,SMI? -- :OEV] HE IS -- CLE>LY HAD NO CLUE ?AT HE WAS REVIEW+ A GIANT WORK ( POLITICAL !ORY4 ,! SEV5-P>AGRAPH REVIEW 9 ! ,AM]ICAN ,AN?ROPOLOGI/ WAS SURPRIS+LY FAVORABLE4 ,REVIEW] ,K>5 ,L4 ,FIELD WROTE3 ,! ,ECOLOGY ( ,FRE$OM UNITES MAT]IALS FROM MANY DISCIPL9ES1 & NO D\BT SPECIALI/S FROM EA* ONE WILL TAKE ,BOOK*9 TO TASK = OCCASIONAL LAPSES ( RIGOR4 ,BUT DESPITE ITS %ORTCOM+S1 ! WORK REMA9S ! K9D ( WIDE-RANG+ & IMPASSION$ SYN!SIS ?AT IS ALL TOO R>E 9 ?IS AGE ( S*OL>LY SPECIALIZATION 7#a#i#h#d3 #a#f#b74 ,9 O!R WORDS1 ! BE/ ?+ AB\T ! BOOK -- & ,I AGREE -- IS ?AT IT ?9KS BIG4 ,ON ! O!R H&1 0! SC5>IO HE CON/RUCTS IS NOT :OLLY P]SUASIVE03 ,! DESCRIPTION ( 0ORGANIC0 SOCIETY DRAWS L>GELY ON MAT]IALS BY ,PAUL ,RAD9 & ,DORO?Y ,LEE1 & PA9TS AN OV]LY HOMOG5IZ$ -- EV5 SANITIZ$ -- PICTURE ( PRELIT]ATE PEACEFULNESS & EGALIT>IANISM2 IT EVOKES 6,KUNG & ,TASADAY1 BUT NOT ,YANOMAMO & ,KWAKIUTL4 ,ATTEMPT+ TO DI/ANCE HIMSELF FROM TRADITIONAL ,M>XIAN V]SIONS ( ! EM]G5CE ( CLASS SOCIETY1 ,BOOK*9 D[NPLAYS ! IMPORTANCE ( TE*NOECONOMIC FACTORS1 BUT ! CORRESPOND+ EMPHASIS HE PLACES ON AGE /RATIFICATION AS ! KEY TO DOM9ATION IS UNCONV9C+ & SUFF]S FROM SU* A PAUCITY ( EMPIRICAL EVID5CE ?AT IT READS AT TIMES LIKE A 0,JU/-,SO0 /ORY 7IBID43 #a#f#a74 ,?AT ! ,DEAN IS TAK5 TO TASK = ROMANTICIZ+ ! PRIMITIVES BY AN AN?ROPOLOGI/ IS TRULY MATT] = MIR?4 ,N[ADAYS HE TAKES ! AN?ROPOLOGI/S TO TASK = ROMANTICIZ+ ! PRIMITIVES 7,*APT]S #h @& #i74 ,EI!R ! ,DEAN HAS REV]S$ HIMSELF )\T ADMITT+ IT1 OR ELSE ! MO/ FAVORABLE REVIEW HE'S EV] RECEIV$ FROM A NON-AN>*I/1 BONA FIDE S*OL> RE/$ ON A S]I\S MISREAD+ ( ,BOOK*9'S MAGNUM OPUS4 ,& IT WAS ALL D[NHILL FROM !RE4 ,! ONE SPECIFIC PO9T BR\*Y 7& /ILL ! BE/67 -- WAS CONTE/$1 NOT ONLY BY ,FIELD1 BUT SUBSEQU5TLY BY AN>*I/ ,L4 ,SUSAN ,BR[N4 ,AS A FEM9I/1 %E ?9KS IT'S MORE PLAUSIBLE ?AT ! SEXUAL DIVISION ( LABOR1 :E!R OR NOT IT WAS NECESS>ILY HI]>*ICAL1 EV5TUALLY TURN$ \T TO BE ! ORIG9 ( HI]>*Y 7#a#i#i#c3 #a#f-#a#f#a74 ,I T5D TO ?9K SO TOO4 ,?AT %E D>$ TO CRITICIZE ! ,DEAN1 & 9 A BOOK FROM HIS [N MA9 PUBLI%] ,BLACK ,ROSE ,BOOKS1 PROBABLY EXPLA9S :Y %E GOT R\ND$ UP ) ! UNUSUAL SUSPECTS 7#a#c-#a#i7 AL?\< %E DOESN'T SEEM TO HAVE MU* ELSE 9 COMMON ) !M4 ,IF ! ACADEMIC RECEPTION ( ,! ,ECOLOGY ( ,FRE$OM WAS LESS ?AN TRIUMPHAL1 ! ,DEAN'S O!R BOOKS HAVE F>$ WORSE4 ,!RE W]E NO REVIEWS 9 SOCIAL SCI5CE J\RNALS ( ,PO/-,SC>CITY ,AN>*ISM & ,! ,LIMITS ( ! ,CITY :5 !Y W]E REPR9T$ BY ,BLACK ,ROSE ,BOOKS 9 #a#i#h#f4 ,!RE W]E NO REVIEWS ( ,! ,MOD]N ,CRISIS 7#a#i#h#g71 OR ,REMAK+ ,SOCIETY 7#a#i#h#i71 OR ,! ,PHILOSOPHY ( ,SOCIAL ,ECOLOGY 7#a#i#i71 OR ! REVIS$ $ITION ( ,! ,ECOLOGY ( ,FRE$OM 7#a#i#i#a71 OR ,:I* ,WAY = ! ,ECOLOGY ,MOVEM5T8 7#a#i#i#c71 OR ,TO ,REMEMB] ,SPA9 7#a#i#i#e71 OR1 = ?AT MATT]1 ,SOCIAL ,AN>*ISM OR ,LIFE/YLE ,AN>*ISM 7#a#i#i#e74 ,!RE WAS EXACTLY ONE NOTICE ( ,! ,RISE ( ,URBANIZATION & ! ,DECL9E ( ,CITIZ5%IP 7#a#i#h#gA7 9 AN SOCIAL SCI5CE J\RNAL1 & EV]Y?+ AB\T IT IS ODD4 ,IT APPE>$ -- ALL TWO P>AGRAPHS ( IT -- 9 ,ORBIS3 ,A ,J\RNAL ( ,WORLD ,AFFAIRS1 A RI%IP1 0S*OL>%IP1 ?\<1 IS NOT HIS PO9T1 OR HIS A*IEVEM5T40 7,?AT'S = SURE47 ,! REVIEW] -- AS HAD ,K>5 ,FIELD -- EXPRESSES SATISFACTION AT READ+ A BOOK ) 0A REAL IDEA0 = A *ANGE1 EV5 IF ! IDEA IS A 0SLIGU+ ?AT ! T5D5CY ( URBANISM IS TO DIM9I% HUMAN FRE$OM1 AL?\< H]E & !RE COMMUNITIES HAVE MANAG$ TO BUCK ! TR5D = A:ILE4 ,BUT :AT ,BOOK*9 REALLY CONT5DS IS ! OPPOSITE3 ?AT ! T5D5CY ( URBANISM IS LIB]ATORY1 AL?\< H]E & !RE ! ELITES HAVE MANAG$ TO BUCK ! TR5D = A:ILE4 ,! REVIEW] IS RIXISM TO :I* HE HAS ALWAYS CLUNG /UBBORNLY4 ,! LATE ,K>L ,POPP]1 AT ONE TIME ! MO/ PROM95T PHILOSOPH] ( SCI5CE ( ?IS C5TURY1 D5\NC$ DIALECTICAL REASON+1 NOT ONLY AS MY/ICAL GIBB]I%1 BUT AS POLITICALLY TOTALIT>IAN 9 T5D5CY 7#a#i#f#b74 ,HE D5\NC$ 0,HEGELIAN DIALECTICS2 ! MY/]Y ME?OD ?AT REPLAC$ 'B>R5 =MAL LOGIC'0 7IBID3 #a3 #b#h74 ,I BR+ ?IS UP1 NOT BECAUSE ,I 5DORSE ,POPP]'S POSITIVISM -- ,I DON'T 7,BLACK #a#i#i#fA7 -- BUT AS A REM9D] ?AT PEOPLE :O LIVE 9 ! ,CRY/AL ,PALACE %\LDN'T ?R[ /ONES4 ,I MYSELF VETO NO MODE ( REASON+ OR EXPRESSION1 AL?\< ,I ?9K SOME >E MORE EFFECTIVE ?AN O!RS1 ESPECIALLY 9 SPECIFIC CONTEXTS4 ,!RE'S NO SU* ?+1 = 9/ANCE1 AS ! SCI5TIFIC ME?OD2 IMPORTANT SCI5TIFIC DISCOV]Y R>ELY IF EV] RESULTS FROM FOLL[+ RULES 7,FEY]AB5D #a#i#g#e74 ,RELIGI\S =MS ( EXPRESSION1 = 9/ANCE1 ,I'VE LONG CONSID]$ ESPECIALLY DI/ORT+ 7,BLACK #a#i#h#f3 #g#a-#g#e71 BUT ,I'VE ALSO 9SI/$1 AS OPPOS$ TO FREE?9K] SIMPLETONS1 ?AT IMPORTANT TRU?S HAVE BE5 EXPRESS$ 9 RELIGI\S T]MS3 0,GOD IS UNREAL1 BUT .<,HE.> HAS REAL BUT MUDDL$ REF]5TS 9 LIV$ EXP]I5CE0 7,BLACK #a#i#i#b3#b#b#b74 ,BOOK*9 WAS =M]LY AW>E ( ?IS 7#a#i#h#b3 #a#i#e-#b#a#d74 ,! ,DEAN'S DIALECTIC IS MORE ?AN A MODE ( REASON+3 HE HAS A 0DIALECTICAL NOTION ( CAUSALITY0 7,BOOK*9 #a#i#h#i3 #b#c74 ,! ,UNIV]SE ITSELF EXHIBITS 0AN OV]ALL T5D5CY ( ACTIVE1 TURBUL5T SUB/ANCE TO DEVELOP FROM ! SIMPLE TO ! COMPLEX1 FROM ! RELATIVELY HOMOG5E\S TO ! RELATIVELY HET]OG5E\S1 FROM ! SIMPLE TO ! V>IEGAT$ & DIFF]5TIAT$0 7IBID43 #a#i#i74 ,TO EVOLVE1 ?AT IS1 FROM PRIMAL GLOP TO US3 0,HUMANITY1 9 EFFECT1 BECOMES ! POT5TIAL VOICE ( A NATURE R5D]$ SELF-CONSCI\S & SELF-CREATIVE0 7IBID43 #b#a2 CF4 #a#i#h#gB3 #c74 ,WE >E ONE ) NATURE -- PROVID$ WE FOLL[ HIS PACKAGE DIRECTIONS -- & AT ! SAME TIME WE >E MORE NATURAL ?AN NATURE HAS HI!RTO BE54 ,\T ( ! EVOLUTION ( CONSCI\SNESS EM]G$ ! CONSCI\SNESS ( EVOLUTION & N[1 RATIONAL SELF-DIRECTION4 ,BY & ?R\< ?IS SOCIAL 0SECOND NATURE0 -- CONSCI\S HUMANITY -- ! DIALECTIC ACTUALIZES ! 0IMMAN5T SELF-DIRECT$NESS0 7#a#i#h#gB3 #b#h7 ( ! COSMOS4 ,AN 0IMMAN5T WORLD REASON0 IS ! 09H]5T =CE10 0! LOGOS -- ?AT IMP>T. MEAN+ & COH]5CE TO REALITY AT ALL LEVELS ( EXI/5CE0 7,BOOK*9 #a#i#h#b3 #a74 ,HUMANITY'S DUTY & DE/9Y IS TO 9SCRIBE ! ,WORD ON ! FABRIC ( REALITY4 ,! ,DEANLY DIALECTIC REPRES5TS ! MO/ ADVANC$ ?\ANCE1 IT'S ! SAME OLD /ORY ( MAN'S ,GOD-GIV5 MISSION TO DOM9ATE NATURE 7,G5ESIS #i3 #a-#c73 ! DIRECT$ EVOLUTION ( AN OBJECTIVE 0ECOLOGICAL E?ICS 9VOLVES HUMAN /EW>D%IP ( ! PLANET0 7,BOOK*9 #a#i#h#gB3 #c#b74 ,BUT 9 ESS5CE1 SECOND NATURE IS A MOM5T 9 ! DEVELOPM5T ( 444A RADICALLY NEW 0FREE NATURE0 9 :I* AN EMANCIPAT$ HUMANITY WILL BECOME ! VOICE1 9DE$ ! EXPRESSION1 ( A NATURAL EVOLUTION R5D]$ SELF-CONSCI\S1 C>+1 & SYMPA!TIC TO ! PA91 SUFF]+1 & 9COH]5T ASPECTS ( AN EVOLUTION LEFT TO ITS [N1 (T5 WAYW>D1 UNFOLD+4 ,NATURE1 DUE TO HUMAN RATIONAL 9T]V5TION1 WILL !NCE ACQUIRE ! 9T5TIONALITY1 P[] ( DEVELOP+ MORE COMPLEX LIFE-=MS1 & CAPACITY TO DIFF]5TIATE ITSELF 7,BOOK*9 #a#i#h#i3 #b#b-#b#c74 7,QU]Y3 ,:Y IS IT A MORAL IMP]ATIVE TO MAKE ! WORLD MORE COMPLICAT$ ?AN IT ALREADY IS87 ,EV5 TODAY1 :5 AN UNEMANCIPAT$ HUMANITY 0IS /ILL LESS ?AN HUMAN0 7IBID43 #b#b71 WE >E WELL ON \R WAY TO RATIONALIZ+ ! 0(T5 WAYW>D0 C\RSE ( EVOLUTION4 ,?ANKS TO BIOTE*NOLOGY1 0?\S&S ( MICROORGANISMS & PLANTS HAVE BE5 PAT5T$ AS WELL AS SIX ANIMALS4 ,MORE ?AN #b G5ETICALLY 5G9E]$ ANIMALS >E AWAIT+ PAT5T APPROVAL AT ! ,PAT5T & ,TRADEM>K ,(FICE0 7,RIFK9 #a#i#i#e3 #a#a#i74 ,?IS W\LD SEEM TO HE FULLY 9 KEEP+ ) ,BOOK*9'S PROGRAM 7,ECK]SLEY #a#i#h#i3 #a#a#a-#a#a#b74 ,NATURE F9DS FRE$OM AT LONG LA/ 9 SUBMISSION TO ITS HIAPHRASE ,NIETZS*E1 NOT-QUITE-MAN IS SOME?+ TO BE SURPASS$3 A ROPE /RET*$ OV] ! ABYSS BETWE5 ALL ! RE/ ( US & ,MURRAY ,BOOK*94 ,IS EV]YBODY ) ME8 ,BOOK*9 IS SAY+ ?AT NATURE ISN'T ACTUALLY FREE :5 IT'S REALLY FREE 7:]E REALLY MEANS 0:AT IT IS071 :5 IT'S \T ( CONTROL4 ,?AT'S JU/ 0NEGATIVE FRE$OM0 -- 0A =MAL 'FRE$OM FROM' -- RA!R ?AN . A SUB/ANTIVE FRE$OM TO0 7#d74 ,WE >E NO LONG] TO LET ,NATURE TAKE ITS C\RSE4 ,NATURE IS ACTUALLY FREE :5 IT'S REALLY CONTROLL$ BY ITS HI5'T ACTUALLY FREE :5 !Y'RE REALLY FREE1 I4E41 UNCONTROLL$4 ,! WORK+ CLASS 9-ITSELF IS ACTUALLY FREE :5 IT'S REALLY CONTROLL$ BY ! CLASS =-ITSELF1 ! CLASS-CONSCI\S VANGU>D -- WORK]S LIKE ,BOOK*9 WAS1 BACK :5 HE WAS A WORK]4 ,:5 HE TELLS IT ! WAY IT IS1 ! WAY IT 0ACTUALLY0 IS1 ,BOOK*9 IS IRREFUTABLE4 ,9S(> AS ! EVID5CE SUPPORTS HIM1 HE IS 0REALLY0 RI AS IT DOES NOT1 ?AT IS BECAUSE HE IS1 TO ?AT EXT5T1 0POT5TIALLY0 RIK #a#i#h#b3 #e#b2 #a#i#h#d3 #b#b-#b#c74 ,! FACT ?AT ! POT5TIAL WAS NEV] REALIZ$ :5 ,A!NS WAS REAL DOESN'T MATT]4 0,AN OAK TREE OBJECTIVELY 9H]ES 9 AN ACORN0 7,BOOK*9 #a#i#h#gB3 #ce N4 #b#b7 -- ?US ! ACORN IS ACTUALLY AN OAK -- EV5 IF A SQUIRREL EATS IT4 ,TO CALL ?IS AN 0IDIOSYNCRATIC USE ( ! WORD ,I OBJECTIVE0 7,ECK]SLEY #a#i#h#i3 #a#a7 IS PUTT+ IT MILDLY4 ,Y\ CAN MAKE ?IS SAME TRICK WORK = ! CITY 9 ! ,I AB/RACT1 & ?US = ANY CITY3 0,CIVILIZATION1 EMBODI$ 9 ! CITY AS A CULTURAL C5T]1 IS DIVE/$ ( ITS RATIONAL DIM5SIONS .1 AS IF ! CITY W]E AN UNABAT$ CANC] RA!R ?AN ! POT5TIAL SPH]E = UNIV]SALIZ+ HUMAN 9T]C\RSE1 9 M>K$ CONTRA/ TO ! P>O*IAL LIMITATIONS ( TRIBAL & VILLAGE LIFE0 7#c#d74 ,NO MATT] H[ DEVA/AT+ A CASE IS MADE AGA9/ CIVILIZATION1 0TO MALIGN CIVILIZATION )\T DUE RECOGNITION ( ITS 5ORM\S POT5TIALITIES = SELF-CONSCI\S FRE$OM0 IS 0TO RETREAT BACK 9TO ! %AD[Y WORLD ( BRUTI%NESS1 :5 ?\ WAS ONLY AN EVOLUTION>Y PROMISE0 7#e#f74 7,AT LEA/ ! BRUTES DIDN'T USE BIG WORDS ?AT DON'T EXI/47 ,DEMOCRACY 0LIES LAT5T 9 ! REPUBLIC0 7#e#i71 ANY URBAN REPUBLIC1 AS IT HAS = ?\S&S ( YE>S 7& = H[ MANY ?\S&S MORE874 ,) *>ACT]I/IC UND]/ATEM5T1 ! ,DEAN CONC$ES ?AT HIS IS 0A FAIRLY UNOR?ODOX NOTION ( REASON0 7#a#i#h#b3 #a74 ,IT'S ,HEGEL'S PHILOSOPHY ( HI/ORY ) AN AB/RACT ,HUMANITY REPLAC+ ! ,WORLD-,SPIRIT1 R\XI/ PHILOSOPHY IS DEVELOP+-HUMANITY-AS-SUPRANATURAL4 ,! DIFF]5CE IS ONLY T]M9OLOGICAL4 ,:5EV] ,/IRN] SAYS 0,I0 HE REF]S TO HIMSELF1 ,MAX ,/IRN]1 BUT ONLY AS AN EXAMPLE4 ,:5EV] HE REF]S TO ! UNIQUE ONE OR TO ! EGO HE REF]S1 NOT TO AN AB/RACT 9DIVIDUAL1 BUT TO EA* & EV]Y 9DIVIDUAL1 TO HIMSELF1 C]TA9LY1 BUT ALSO TO EV]Y ,TOM1 ,DICK & ,MURRAY4 ,?IS IS :Y ACCUS+ ,/IRN] ( ELITISM 7#g7 IS BOGUS4 ,BOOK*9 ?9KS ?AT REAL ,HUMANITY IS /ILL LESS ?AN ACTUALLY HUMAN 7#a#i#h#i3 #b#b74 ,/IRN] ?9KS ?AT EV]Y REAL HUMAN IS MORE ?AN HUMAN7ITY73 0',MAN' AS A CONCEPT OR PR$ICATE DOES NOT EXHAU/ :AT Y\ >E BECAUSE IT HAS A CONCEPTUAL CONT5T ( ITS [N & BECAUSE IT LETS ITSELF /IPULATE :AT IS HUMAN1 :AT IS A 'MAN1' BECAUSE IT CAN BE DEF9$444 ,BUT CAN Y\ DEF9E Y\RSELF8 ,>E Y\ A CONCEPT80 7#a#i#g#h3 #f#g74 ,POSIT+ A HUMAN ESS5CE IS UNNECESS>Y = ! PRACTICE ( ANY >T OR SCI5CE4 ,! 9DWELL+ ESS5CE IS NOT DISCOV]ABLE BY OBS]VATION1 EXP]IM5TATION1 OR ANY RATIONAL MODE ( 9QUIRY4 ,TO BE SURE1 !RE >E ?OSE :O CLAIM TO HAVE APPREH5D$ ESS5CE DIRECTLY1 BY NON-ORD9>Y CONSCI\SNESS4 ,!Y'RE CALL$ MY/ICS1 & ,PR(ESSOR ,BOOK*9 PR(ESSES TO DESPISE !M4 ,MORE LIKELY HE 5VIES ! QUALITATIVE SUP]IORITY ( !IR VISIONS4 ,MUNICIPAL SOCIALISM HAS GOT TO BE AS MUNDANE AS MY/ICISM GETS4 ,AS ,HAKIM ,BEY WRITES3 0,9 SLEEP WE DREAM ( ONLY TWO =MS ( GOV]NM5T -- AN>*Y @& MON>*Y4444 ,A DEMOCRATIC DREAM8 A SOCIALI/ DREAM8 ,IMPOSSIBLE0 7#a#i#i#a3 #f#d74 ,! ,DEAN IS 9DIGNANT AT ?IS SUPPOS$ D5IGRATION ( 0! DREAMS ( C5TURIES ( IDEALI/S0 7#b#a7 BUT NEGLECTS TO 9DICATE BY :AT MUSCUL> RATIONALI/ FACULTY HE IS PRIVY TO ! DREAMS ( ! DREAM]S ( PREVI\S C5TURIES -- A \IJA BO>D P]HAPS8 ,BUT HE MAY BE RI ! COLONIZATION ( ! UNCONSCI\S MAY HAVE PROCE$$ 9 ! CASE ( A LIFELONG1 ELD]LY POLITICAL MILITANT4 ,BOOK*9 MAY WELL BE A C\NT]EXAMPLE TO ! CLAIM BY A ,NIETZS*E COMM5TATOR ?AT 0!RE IS NO SU* ?+ AS A DULL UNCONSCI\S0 7,ANSELL-,PE>SON #a#i#i#d3 #a#f#h74 ,DO &ROIDS DREAM ( ELECTRIC %EEP8 ,OR AS ,NIETZS*E PUT IT3 EV]Y 0?+ 9 ITSELF' IS /UPID 7#a#i#i#d3 #h#a74 ,:E!R MY/ICAL OR M]ELY MY/IFY+1 ,BOOK*9'S CONCEPTION ( REASON IS AS UNREASONABLE AS SO MANY ( ITS RESULTS4 ,HIS LATE/ POLEMIC IS SO FOOLI% ?AT IT 9VITES REEXAM9ATION ( HIS PREVI\S BOOKS :I* MO/LY ESCAP$ CRITICAL ATT5TION FROM RADICALS4 ,! ACCOLADES ( LIB]AL J\RNALI/S 7& !Y'LL =GET HIM SOON 5\<7 WON'T AV]T ! S]I\S DEVALUATION HE'S CALL$ D[N UPON HIMSELF4 ,I ONCE DEF9$ DIALECTICS1 UNFAIRLY1 AS 0A ,M>XI/'S EXCUSE :5 Y\ CAT* HIM LY+0 7#a#i#i#b3 #a#d#i74 ,9 ?IS S5SE ALONE IS ,BOOK*9'S REASON+ DIALECTICAL4 ,AFT] DECADES ( TALK+ D[N TO ECO- HIPPIES :O DISDA9 0ALL MUSCUL>ITY ( ?\* ( ! ,PRIMITIVI/S ,P>T ,I3 ,PRI/9E ,ANGLES ,*APT] #g3 ,9 ,SE>* ( ! ,PRIMITIVI/S ,P>T ,I3 ,PRI/9E ,ANGLES ,BA%+ ! PRIMITIVI/ AN>*I/S IS PROBABLY ,DEAN ,BOOK*9'S HIE ! EXCOMMUNICATE AN>*I/S :OSE VIEWS >E MO/ LIKELY TO BE CONFUS$ )1 & TO COMPETE SUCCESSFULLY )1 HIS [N4 ,HE REVELS 9 HIS SELF-IMAGE AS ECOLOGY'S APO/LE TO ! AN>*I/S1 & = ONCE1 !RE'S SOME TRU? TO HIS MESSIANIC MA*ISMO4 ,IT WAS ! ,DEAN1 AFT] ALL1 :O HAS = SO LONG & 9 SO MANY BOOKS CLAMOR$ = ! RE/ORATION ( 0ORGANIC COMMUNITY10 AS HE N[ %AMEFAC$LY ADMITS 7#d#a2 CF4 ,BOOK*9 #a#i#g#d1 #a#i#h#b1 #a#i#h#gA1 #a#i#h#i1 #a#i#i#a74 ,ONCE AGA9 HIS EMB>RASSM5T IS ?AT HIS READ]S TOOK HIM AT HIS WORD -- AN ]ROR ?AT ?IS READ]1 = ONE1 WILL NOT REPEAT4 ,!SE 9NOC5TS NEV] SUSPECT$ ?AT !Y W]E NOT SUPPOS$ TO LE>N ANY?+ AB\T PRIMITIVE SOCIETIES OR PRE-9DU/RIAL COMMUNITIES EXCEPT :AT CLE>$ ,BOOK*9I/ C5SOR%IP4 ,! ,DEAN IS SO MU* ! 0IRATE PETTY B\RGEOIS0 7#e#b7 ON ?IS SUBJECT ?AT HE LA%ES \T AT ! PRIMITIVI/S 9 PETTY1 PEEVI% WAYS -- EV5 = HIM4 ,SEV]AL S\RCES ,JOHN ,Z]ZAN CITES 9 ,FUTURE ,PRIMITIVE 7#a#i#i#d71 HE HUFFS1 >E 05TIRELY ABS5T0 FROM ITS BIBLIOGRAPHY1 SU* AS 0',COH5 7#a#i#g#d7' & ',CL>K 7#a#i#g#i7'0 7#f#b N4 #a#i74 ,Z]ZAN CITES 0,COH5 7#a#i#g#d710 NOT ON ANY CONTROV]SIAL PO9T1 BUT = ! PLATITUDE ?AT SYMBOLS >E 0ESS5TIAL = ! DEVELOPM5T & MA9T5ANCE ( SOCIAL ORD]0 7#a#i#i#d3 #b#d7 -- DOES ! ,DEAN DISAGREE8 ,HE NEV] SAYS SO4 0,CL>K 7#a#i#g#i70 MAY BE A MISPR9T = 0,CL>K 7#a#i#g#g710 :I* DOES APPE> 9 ,Z]ZAN'S BIBLIOGRAPHY 7#a#i#i#d3 #a#g#c74 ,AS ! AU?OR ( A BOOK FROM ! SAME PUBLI%]1 ,AUTONOM$IA1 9 ! SAME S]IES1 ,I KN[ H[ SLOPPY ! PRODUCTION VALUES ( ?IS AMATEUR1 ALL-VOLUNTE] NONPR(IT COLLECTIVE CAN BE4 ,ADDITIONALLY1 ,Z]ZAN 7#a#i#i#f3 #a7 9 A LETT] TO ME ADMITS TO 0FAULTY RECORD-KEEP+0 & EXPLA9S ?AT ! ABS5CE ( ! TWO REF]5CES ! ,DEAN C>PS AB\T 0GOES BACK TO SWIT*+ TO SOCIAL SCI5CE-TYPE NOTES -- AFT] ,F,E . REFUS$ TO RUN FOOTNOTES TO MY >TICLES1 9 ! '#hS40 ,! ,DEAN REF]S TO P>T #b1 *4 #d1 SEC4 #d ( ,MAX ,/IRN]'S ,! ,EGO & ,HIS ,[N 7#f#d-#f#e7 AL?\< ! BOOK 5DS ) P>T #b1 *4 #c 7,/IRN] #a#i#i#e3 VIII1 #c#b-#c#b#d74 ,MY LIBR>Y COPY ( ,PO/-,SC>CITY ,AN>*ISM 7,BOOK*9 #a#i#g#a7 FROM ,RAMP>TS ,PRESS HAS A LI/ ( FIFTE5 ]RATA TAP$ 9TO IT :I* PRESUMABLY \ RESE>*0 7#f#b N4 #a#i71 & IT IS F> FROM COMPLETE3 ?AT %\LD BE ,JACQUES ,ELLUL1 = 9/ANCE1 NOT ,JACQUES ,ELUL 7IBID43 #h#f74 ,& ?AT %\LD BE ,ALFR$ ,ZIMM]N1 NOT ,$W>D ,ZIMM]MAN 7IBID43 #a#e#i1 #bhh N4 #b#g2 CF4 ,ZIMM]N #a#i#c#a74 ,BOOK*9 WAS P]HAPS ?9K+ ( A S+]-SONGWRIT] :O HAS 9T]E/$ HIM = DECADES1 ,BOB ,DYLAN 7#i71 ! ,>TI/ ,=M]LY ,KN[N AS ,ZIMM]MAN4 ,9 AN ESPECIALLY MALADROIT MOVE1 ! ,DEAN CITES A FAVORABLE REVIEW ( ,HAKIM ,BEY'S ,T4,A4,Z4 7#a#i#i#a7 9 ! ,:OLE ,E>? ,REVIEW AS V]IFY+ ?AT ,BEY'S AN>*ISM IS A DECAD5T1 0UNSAVORY0 7#b7 0B\RGEOIS =M ( AN>*ISM0 7#b#b73 ! ,:OLE ,E>? ,REVIEW HAS1 AFT] ALL1 A 0YUPPIE CLI5TELE0 7#b#c74 ,! BACK JACKET BLURBS = JU/ ONE ( ! ,DEAN'S BOOKS 7#a#i#h#g7 COME FROM SU* >*-YUPPIE PUBLICATIONS AS ! ,VILLAGE ,VOICE & ,! ,NATION4 ,! 9SIDE BACK JACKET BLURB BOA/S ?AT HE HAS CONTRIBUT$ TO 0MANY J\RNALS0 9CLUD+ ,CO,EVOLUTION ,QU>T]LY4 ,CO,EVOLUTION ,QU>T]LY WAS ! ORIG9AL NAME ( ! ,:OLE ,E>? ,REVIEW4 ,! ,DEAN'S DEVOTION TO URBANISM IS AN IMPORTANT P>T ( HIS HATR$ ( ! PRIMITIVE4 ,CITY-/ATISM & PRIMITIVE SOCIETY >E MUTUALLY EXCLUSIVE4 ,:AT AMAZES IS ?AT ! ,DEAN ASSUMES ?AT IT'S ! PRIMITIVI/S1 NOT ! CITY-/ATI/S1 :O >E ! PRESUMPTIVE H]ETICS FROM AN>*ISM -- ?AT !Y1 NOT HE1 HAVE SOME EXPLA9+ TO DO4 ,!RE HAS NEV] BE5 AN AN>*I/ CITY1 NOT = MORE ?AN A FEW MON?S AT ! MO/1 BUT !RE HAVE BE5 MANY LONGLA/+ AN>*I/ PRIMITIVE SOCIETIES4 ,MANY AN>*I/S HAVE CONSID]$ AN>*Y POSSIBLE 9 URBAN CONDITIONS -- AMONG !M ! ,DEAN'S BETE NOIR ,HAKIM ,BEY 7,BLACK #a#i#i#d3 #a#f7 -- BUT ,BOOK*9 IS ! FIR/ AN>*I/ :O EV] POSIT$ ?AT AN>*Y IS NECESS>ILY URBAN4 ,?AT W\LD HAVE COME AS QUITE A SURPRISE TO ! ,MAKHNOVI/ PEASANT GU]RILLAS 9 ! ,UKRA9E OR ! 9SURRECTION>Y AN>*I/ VILLAG]S 9 ! PUEBLOS ( ,&ALUSIA 7,BOOK*9 #a#i#g#g3 *4 #e74 ,MY PO9T IS NOT ?AT ! EF=TS & EXP]I5CES ( URBAN AN>*I/S >E IRRELEVANT OR UNWOR?Y ( ATT5TION -- AFT] ALL1 ,I'M AN URBAN AN>*I/ MYSELF -- ONLY ?AT !Y >E NOT ! ONLY AN>*I/ EXP]I5CES WOR?Y ( ATT5TION4 ,I FAIL TO UND]/& :Y AN>*I/S %\LD ATT5D ONLY TO !IR FAILURES & IGNORE !IR ONLY SUCCESSES4 ,I DON'T CONSID] MYSELF A PRIMITIVI/4 ,G5U9E AN>*O- PRIMITIVI/S SU* AS ,JOHN ,Z]ZAN1 ,GEORGE ,BRAD=D & ,F]AL ,FAUN PROBABLY DON'T ?9K ,I'M ONE ( !M EI!R1 ANY MORE ?AN ,HAKIM ,BEY IS1 AL?\< ! ,DEAN CAN'T QUITE FIGURE \T 0IS HE IS OR IS HE A9'T0 7#f#b N4 #h74 ,SO IT'S NOT MY PURPOSE TO DEF5D ! VIEWS ( ,JOHN ,Z]ZAN OR ,GEORGE ,BRAD=D AGA9/ ,BOOK*9 7AL?\<1 9CID5TALLY1 ,I'LL DO SOME ( ?AT73 !Y >E QUITE CAPABLE ( DEF5D+ !MSELVES & ,I'M SURE !Y WILL4 ,BRAD=D1 9 FACT1 HAS WRITT5 A L5G?Y REJO9D] TO BE CO-PUBLI%$ BY ,AUTONOM$IA & ,BLACK @& ,R$4 ,BUT IT IS MY PURPOSE TO %[ ?AT 9 ! WAY HE D5\NCES ! PRIMITIVI/S1 ! ,DEAN IS1 AS USUAL1 UNSCRUPUL\S & MALICI\S4 ,:5 HE ISN'T FLAT-\T WRONG HE'S USUALLY IRRELEVANT4 ,9 REBUTT+ A RIIAN CRITIC1 ,I MADE CLE> TWO ( ! ASPECTS ( PRIMITIVE SOCIETIES 7!RE >E O!RS7 :I* \*I/S3 ,HUNT]-GA!R]S 9=M \R UND]/&+ & EMB>RASS LIB]T>IANS .<& ,BOOK*9I/S.> 9 AT LEA/ TWO WAYS4 ,!Y OP]ATE ! ONLY KN[N VIABLE /ATELESS SOCIETIES4 ,& !Y DON'T1 EXCEPT 9 OCCASIONAL EM]G5CIES1 WORK 9 ANY S5SE ,I'VE US$ ! WORD 7,BLACK #a#i#i#b3 #e#d74 ,EV5 ! ,DEAN E>LI] ADMITT$ ! FIR/ PO9T3 0,?IS ORGANIC1 BASICALLY PRELIT]ATE OR 'TRIBAL1' SOCIETY WAS /RIK+LY NONDOM9E]+0 7#a#i#h#i3 #d#g74 ,AFT] ALL1 ,CULTURAL ,MAN IS AT LEA/ TWO MILLION YE>S OLD4 ,HE WAS ORIG9ALLY A HUNT]-GA!R4 ,HE WAS AN ANATOMICALLY MOD]N HUMAN AT LEA/ #e1 YE>S BE=E HE ADOPT$ ANY O!R MODE ( SUBSI/5CE4 ,AS REC5TLY AS #a1 YE>S AGO HE WAS /ILL ONLY A =AG] 7,LEE @& ,DE,VORE #a#i#f#hC3 #c74 ,& HE WAS /ILL AN AN>*I/4 ,N[ IT MAY WELL BE ?AT ! LIFE-WAYS ( HUNT]-GA!R]S 7ALSO KN[N AS =AG]S7 >E NOT1 AS A PRACTICAL MATT]1 AVAILABLE = IMM$IATE ADOPTION BY DISGRUNTL$ URBANITES1 AS ! ,DEAN DECLAIMS 7#c#f74 ,SOME PRIMITIVI/S HAVE SAID AS MU*2 ,JOHN ,MOORE1 = ONE1 IS EXASP]AT$ TO HAVE TO KEEP SAY+ SO 7#a#i#i#f3 #a#h74 ,O!RS1 9 MY OP9ION1 HAVE EQUIVOCAT$4 ,BUT ?AT'S NOT ! PO9T1 OR NOT ! ONLY PO9T4 ,A WAY ( LIFE IS MU* MORE ?AN A 0LIFE-/YLE40 ,HUNT]-GA!R]S GR[ UP 9 A HABITAT & LE>N ITS SECRETS1 !Y HAVE 0A M>VEL\S UND]/&+ ( ! HABITAT 9 :I* !Y LIV$2 !Y W]E1 AFT] ALL1 HI*I/S %\LD PROBABLY S5D = A LOT ( ,LOOMPANICS BOOKS & PRACTICE UP ON A LOT ( SURVIVAL SKILLS BE=E !Y EV5 ?9K ( V5TUR+ 9TO ! WILD]NESS ON A LONG-T]M BASIS4 ,H>DLY ANY AN>*O-PRIMITIVI/S PROPOSE TO DO SO 7TO MY KN[L$GE1 ONLY ONE74 ,BUT ! PO9T IS TO LE>N FROM ! PRIMITIVES1 NOT NECESS>ILY TO APE !M4 ,DEAN ,BOOK*91 9 CONTRA/1 DOESN'T KN[ & DOESN'T WANT TO KN[ ANY?+ AB\T PRIMITIVES :I* MI*Y IS EV5 POSSIBLE -- AL?\< IT'S ! ONLY K9D ( AN>*Y EMPIRICALLY PROV5 TO BE POSSIBLE4 ,S9CE ! :OLE PO9T ( ! ,DEAN'S POLEMIC IS TO PASS JUDGM5T UPON :AT C\NTS AS AN>*ISM1 Y\'D ?9K HE'D TRY TO 9DICT PRIMITIVES AS /ATI/S4 ,AS ?AT IS IMPOSSIBLE1 HE *ANGES ! SUBJECT4 ,REPEAT$LY1 ! ,DEAN ?R[S :AT HE APP>5TLY CONSID]S R\NDH\SE PUN*ES AT PRIMITIVI/ MY?S1 BUT HE NEV] CONNECTS1 EI!R BECAUSE !Y >E NOT T5ETS ( PRIMITIVISM OR ELSE BECAUSE !Y >E NOT MY?S4 ,= 9/ANCE1 ! ,DEAN >GUES AT L5G? ?AT HUNT]- GA!R]S HAVE BE5 KN[N TO MODIFY1 & NOT M]ELY ADAPT TO1 !IR HABITATS1 NOTABLY BY ! USE ( FIRE 7#d#b-#d#c74 ,AN?ROPOLOGI/S1 & NOT ONLY ! ONES ! ,DEAN CITES1 HAVE KN[N ?AT = A LONG TIME4 ,! ,AU/RALIAN ABORIG9ES1 ! QU9TESS5TIAL =AG]S1 SET FIRES = V>I\S PURPOSES :I* TRANS=M$ !IR L&SCAPE1 USUALLY TO !IR ADVANTAGE 7,BLA9EY #a#i#g#f3 *4 #e .<0,A ,BURN+ ,CONT95T0.>74 ,%IFT+ CULTIVATORS1 SU* AS MO/ ( ! ,9DIANS ( EA/]N ,NOR? ,AM]ICA1 ALSO FIR$ ! BRU% ) IMPORTANT ECOLOGICAL CONSEQU5CES1 AS EV5 HI/ORIANS KN[ 7,MORGAN #a#i#g#e3 *4 #c74 ,IF ANY PRIMITIVI/ EV] CLAIM$ O!RWISE1 HE IS WRONG1 BUT ! ,DEAN DOES NOT CITE :5 & :]E HE DID4 ,JOHN ,Z]ZAN1 0! ANTICIVILIZATIONAL PRIMITIVI/ P> EXCELL5CE0 7#c#i71 OBS]VES1 )\T APP>5T DISAPPROVAL1 ?AT HUMANS HAVE BE5 US+ FIRE = ALMO/ TWO MILLION YE>S 7#a#i#i#d3 #b#b74 ,TO TAKE AN ECOLOGICAL P]SPECTIVE MEANS TO HYPO!SIZE G5]AL 9T]ACTION AMONG ALL SPECIES & BETWE5 EA* & ALL SPECIES & ! 9ANIMATE 5VIRONM5T4 ,IT IMPLIES DE?RON+ HUMANS AS ! LORDS ( NATURE APPO9T$ BY A ,JUDEO-,*RI/IAN DIV9ITY1 C]TA9LY1 BUT IT DOESN'T IMPLY OR PRESUPPOSE ?AT !RE WAS EV] A TIME OR A CONDITION ( SOCIETY 9 :I* HUMANS NEV] ACT$ UPON ! RE/ ( NATURE BUT W]E ONLY ACT$ UPON4 ,NOT EV5 AMOEBAS >E ?AT PASSIVE & QUIESC5T 7,BOOK*9 #a#i#h#i3 #b74 ,AMAZ+LY1 ,BOOK*9 EXPLICITLY EMBRACES ! ,HOBBESIAN MY? ?AT ! LIVES ( PRIMITIVE1 PRE-POLITICAL PEOPLE W]E NA/Y1 BRUTI% & %ORT 7#d#f74 ,= HIM AS = ,HOBBES 7,BLACK #a#i#h#f3 #b#d71 ! PURPOSE ( ! MY? IS TO FUR!R A /ATI/ AG5DA4 0,\R E>LY ANCE/ORS10 HE REM>KS ) SATISFACTION1 0W]E MORE LIKELY SCAV5G]S ?AN HUNT]-GA!R]S0 7#d#f74 ,H[ DISGU/+6 ,!Y ATE ANIMALS :I* W]E ALREADY DEAD6 ,JU/ AS WE DO :5 WE %OP ! MEAT SECTION ( A SUP]M>KET4 7,P]HAPS !RE >E NO MEAT SECTIONS 9 ,BURL+TON SUP]M>KETS4 ,P]HAPS !RE >E NO SUP]M>KETS !RE1 JU/ FOOD CO-OPS4 ,:Y DO ,I F9D IT H>D TO SUMMON UP AN IMAGE ( ,BOOK*9 PUTT+ 9 HIS F\R H\RS A MON? BAGG+ GROC]IES87 ,BOOK*9 PROBABLY PICK$ UP ?IS TIDBIT FROM ,Z]ZAN 7#a#i#i#d3 #a#i74 ,REG>DLESS1 \R /ILL-PREHI/ORIC1 /ILL-AN>*IC ANCE/ORS MU/ HAVE =M$ O!R TA/ES 9 FOOD 9 BECOM+ BIG GAME HUNT]S 7#d#b74 ,& !SE \R ANIMALI/IC ANCE/ORS W]E UNHEAL?Y TOO1 CLAIMS ! ,DEAN4 ,! ,NE&]?ALS SUFF]$ HI< RATES ( DEG5]ATIVE BONE DISEASE & S]I\S 9JURY 7#d#f74 ,!RE IS CONSID]ABLE CONTROV]SY :E!R ! ,NE&]?ALS W]E AMONG \R ANCE/ORS4 ,IF Y\R ANCE/ORS >E FROM ,EUROPE OR ! ,LEVANT1 POSSIBLY2 O!RWISE1 ALMO/ C]TA9LY NOT4 ,ADMITT$LY1 \R E>LY ANCE/ORS W]E MORE LIKELY TO BE EAT5 BY LEOP>DS & HY5AS ?AN WE >E 7#d#f71 BUT = CONTEMPOR>Y =AG]S1 PR$ATION IS A M9OR CAUSE ( DEA? 7,DUNN #a#i#f#h3 #b#b#d-#b#b#e74 ,ON ! O!R H&1 \R LEAD+ KILL]S1 CANC] & HE>T DISEASE1 APPE> 9FREQU5TLY AMONG !M 7IBID43 #b#b#d71 & \R ?\S&S ( OCCUPATIONAL DISEASES NEV] DO4 ,HUNT]-GA!R]S HAVE NEV] BE5 AFFLICT$ BY ASBE/OSIS1 BLACK LUNG DISEASE1 ,GULF ,W> SYNDROME 7AS ,I WRITE !SE WORDS1 ! ,P5TAGON IS F9ALLY ADMITT+ !RE MIPAL TUNNEL SYNDROME4 ,B& SOCIETIES HAVE V]Y L[ POPULATION D5SITIES1 & 0VIRAL & BACT]IAL 9FECTIONS CANNOT G5]ALLY P]SI/ AMONG SMALL HUMAN POPULATIONS0 7,KNAUFT #a#i#h#g3 #i#h74 ,PALEOLI?IC =AG]S MIS4 ,ACCORD+ TO ! ,DEAN1 PREHI/ORIC MORTALITY /ATI/ICS >E 0APPALL+03 0AB\T HALF DI$ 9 *ILDHOOD OR BE=E ! AGE ( TW5TY1 & FEW LIV$ BEYOND !IR FIFTIE? YE>0 7#d#f74 ,EV5 TAK+ !SE CLAIMS TO BE TRUE1 ! AGGREGATE FIGURES1 !IR VAGU5ESS ASIDE1 >E HIRY+ CAPACITIES ( !IR HABITATS ?AN TE*NO-URBANITES DO4 ,! ONES :O DIDN'T HAVE PAID ! PRICE4 ,! ONES :O DID1 & DO1 ADJU/ !IR POPULATIONS BY ! MEANS AT !IR DISPOSAL4 ,DELAY$ M>RIAGE1 ABORTION1 PROLONG$ LACTATION1 SEXUAL TABOOS1 EV5 G5ITAL SURG]Y >E AMONG ! CULTURAL PRACTICES BY :I* =AG]S HOLD D[N !IR BIR?RATES 7,Y5GOYAN #a#i#f#h3#a#i#d#a74 ,L[-TE* DOES HAVE ITS LIMITATIONS4 ,! CONDOM1 ! DIAPHRAGM1 ! ,I,U,D & ! ,PILL HAVE NOT BE5 AVAILABLE TO HUNT]-GA!R]S4 ,=AG]S HAVE (T5 RESORT$ TO PO/-P>TUM POPULATION CONTROL AS WELL3 9 O!R WORDS1 TO 9FANTICIDE & S5ILICIDE 7,DUNN #a#i#f#h3 #b#b#e74 ,ESPECIALLY 9FANTICIDE 7AL?\< ,I SUSPECT ! ,DEAN FEELS A LOT MORE ?REAT5$ BY S5ILICIDE74 ,9FANTICIDE WAS PROBABLY PREVAL5T AMONG ,PLEI/OC5E HUNT]-GA!R]S 7,BIRDSELL #a#i#f#h3 #b#c#f71 SO IT'S RIDICUL\S TO CALCULATE AN 0AV]AGE0 LIFESPAN 9 :I* ! FEW M9UTES OR H\RS SOME NEONATES W]E ALL[$ TO LIVE C\NT = AS MU* AS ALL ! YE>S LIV$ BY ?OSE :O ACTUALLY GO ON TO HAVE LIVES4 ,IT'S AS IF 9 MEASUR+ ! PRES5T-DAY ,AM]ICAN LIFESPAN WE 9CLUD$ 9 ! NUM]ATOR1 AS 1 EV]Y CONCEPTION AV]T$ BY CONTRACEPTION & EV]Y ABORT$ FETUS1 :ILE ADD+ EA* ( !M1 SCOR$ AS #a1 TO ! D5OM9ATOR C\NT+ ! 5TIRE POPULATION4 ,WE'D COME UP ) A />TL+LY L[ 0AV]AGE0 LIFESPAN = ! CONTEMPOR>Y ,UNIT$ ,/ATES -- #a YE>S8 #b YE>S8 -- :I* W\LD BE UTT]LY MEAN+LESS4 ,:5 CONTRACEPTIVE DEVICES BECAME AVAILABLE TO ,NUNAMIUT ,ESKIMO WOM5 9 #a#i#f#d1 !RE WAS 0MASSIVE ADOPTION0 ( !M 7,B9=D @& ,*ASKO #a#i#g#f3 #g#g74 ,AT ?IS PO9T SOMEBODY MIS 7#d#e7 IS UNREF]5C$ & MISLEAD+1 ,LEE'S C5SUSES %[$ 444A SUB/ANTIAL PROPORTION ( PEOPLE OV] ! AGE ( #f4 ,?IS HI< PROPORTION 7#h4#g TO #a4#g P]C5T7 BY ,?IRD ,WORLD /&>DS CONTRADICTS ! WIDELY HELD NOTION ?AT LIFE 9 HUNT+ & GA!R+ SOCIETIES IS 0NA/Y1 BRUTI%1 & %ORT40 ,! >GUM5T HAS BE5 MADE ?AT LIFE 9 !SE SOCIETIES IS SO H>D ?AT PEOPLE DIE AT AN E>LY AGE4 ,! ,DOBE >EA .<( ,BOTSWANA.>1 BY CONTRA/1 HAD DOZ5S ( ACTIVE OLD] P]SONS 9 ! POPULATION 7,LEE #a#i#g#i3 #d#d74 ,! POPULATION /RUCTURE 0LOOKS LIKE ?AT ( A DEVELOP$ C\NTRY1 = EXAMPLE1 LIKE ?AT ( ! ,UNIT$ ,/ATES >\ND #a#i0 7IBID42 #d#g74 ,?IS IS H[ TWO O!R AN?ROPOLOGI/S SUMM>IZE ! 6,KUNG SITUATION3 ,AL?\< 9DIVIDUALS :O HAVE REA*$ MATURITY CAN EXPECT TO LIVE 9TO !IR MIDDLE #eS1 LIFE EXPECTANCY AT BIR? IS APPROXIMATELY #cb YE>S1 DET]M9$ MA9LY BY HI< 9FANT MORTALITY -- BETWE5 #a & #b.0 9 ! FIR/ YE>1 ALMO/ ALL DUE TO 9FECTI\S DISEASE4 ,9 ! TRADITIONAL SITUATION1 9FANTICIDE MADE A SMALL ADDITIONAL CONTRIBUTION TO MORTALITY 7,KONN] @& ,%O/ACK #a#i#h#g3 #a#b74 ,IT IS TRUE ?AT =AG]S HAVE ALWAYS LACK$ ! TE*NOLOGY TO P]PETUATE ! AGONY ( !IR 9CAPACITAT$ ELD]S AS \R 9SURANCE-DRIV5 SY/EM >RANGES = SOME ( \RS4 ,:5 ,I VISIT MY FA!R 9 ! NURS+ HOME -- A /ROKE VICTIM1 A M5TALLY CONFUS$ CRIPPLE USUALLY COMPLA9+ ( PA91 #he YE>S OLD -- ,I F9D IT H>D TO CONSID] LONGEVITY AN ABSOLUTE VALUE4 ,ACCORD+ TO ! ,ILIAD1 NEI!R DID ,A*ILLES3 ,= MY MO!R ,!TIS1 ! GODDESS ( ! SILV] FEET TELLS ME ,I C>RY TWO SORTS ( DE/9Y T[>DS ! DAY ( MY DEA?4 ,EI!R IF ,I /AY H]E & FIISONS %\LD BE DIFF]5T4 ,PRIMITIVI/S LIKE ,Z]ZAN & ,BRAD=D COMP>E ! ROBU/ LIVES ( ,PALEOLI?IC =AG]S ) ! /UNT$ LIVES ( ?OSE CAU*AEOLOGICAL RECORD SUGGE/S ?AT ! TRANSITION TO ! ,NEOLI?IC WAS ACCOMPANI$ BY A FAIRLY G5]AL DECL9E 9 DIET>Y QUALITY1 EVID5C$ 9 /ATURE & DECREAS$ LONGEVITY0 7,ROSS #a#i#h#g3 #a#b74 ,& ALSO A RELAT$ DECL9E 9 HEAL?4 ,ALMO/ ALL >*AEOLOGICAL /UDIES 0CONCLUDE ?AT 9FECTION WAS A MORE S]I\S PROBLEM = F>M]S ?AN = !IR HUNT+ & GA!R+ =EBE>S1 & MO/ SUGGE/ ?AT ?IS RESULT$ FROM 9CREAS$ S$5TISM1 L>G] POPULATION AGGREGATES1 &_/OR ! WELL-E/ABLI%$ SYN]GISM BETWE5 9FECTION & MALNUTRITION0 7,COH5 #a#i#h#g3 #b#f#i-#b#g74 ,= ONE ?+1 WORK -- & :5 WE >RIVE AT AGRICULTURE WE >RIVE1 UNAMBIGU\SLY1 AT WORK -- IS HAZ>D\S TO Y\R HEAL?4 ,! FACT ?AT !SE >E ! F9D+S ( >*AEOLOGICAL /UDIES ( PREHI/ORIC SOCIETIES R5D]S IRRELEVANT1 = PRES5T PURPOSES1 ! REC5T >GUM5T ?AT ! MU*-/UDI$ ,SAN >E REALLY JU/ AN IMPOV]I%$ UND]CLASS )9 CAPITALISM 7,WILMS5 #a#i#h#i74 ,?IS IS A CONTROV]SIAL CLAIM 7,PET]S #a#i#i7 -- VIGOR\SLY REBUTT$ BY ,RI*>D ,B4 ,LEE & LIKE-M9D$ AN?ROPOLOGI/S 7,SOLWAY @& ,LEE #a#i#i7 -- :I*1 PR$ICTABLY1 ,BOOK*9 :OOPS UP ) UNCRITICAL AB&ON 7#d#d-#d#e74 ,BUT BY DEF9ITION1 PREHI/ORIC PEOPLES CANNOT HAVE BE5 M>G9AL TO1 OR RELICS (1 OR DEVOLV$ FROM HI/ORICAL SOCIETIES4 ,:AT DID !Y DEVOLVE FROM8 ,ATLANTIS8 ,LEMURIA8 ,MU8 ,>E !Y ! LOVE-*ILDR5 ( EXTRAT]RE/RIALS 70,E>? GIRLS >E EASY07 :O1 HAV+ HAD !IR EXOTIC FUN1 REVV$ UP ! ,*>IOTS ( ! ,GODS & ROCKET$ (F TO ! NEXT (F-PLANET PICK-UP SC5E8 ,! >TI/ ,GOYA1 AS QUOT$ BY ! ,DEAN1 ONCE SAID ?AT 0! SLEEP ( REASON BEGETS MON/]S0 7#b#h74 ,DOES ,BOOK*9 ?9K ?AT ! SLEEP+->\ND ( MON/]S BEGETS REASONABLES8 ,& :5 WE PROGRESS FROM M]E AGRICULTURE TO URBANISM -- ONE ?+ LEADS TO ANO!R -- HEAL? DET]IORATES EV5 MORE DRAMATICALLY4 ,?R\<\T HI/ORY1 PRE-9DU/RIAL URBAN POPULATIONS HAVE USUALLY REPRODUC$ AT LESS ?AN REPLACEM5T LEVELS3 0,ANCI5T CITIES W]E LIKE T> PITS1 DRAW+ C\NTRY FOLK 9TO !IR ALLUR+ BUT DISEASE-RIDD5 PREC9CTS0 7,BOYD @& ,RI*]SON #a#i#i#c3 #a#b#g74 ,! ,DEAN IS FOND ( ! SLOGAN ?AT 0CITY AIR MAKES Y\ FREE0 7#a#i#g#d3 #a71 BUT !RE IS CONSID]ABLY MORE TRU? TO SAY+ ?AT CITY AIR MAKES Y\ SICK 7IBID43 #f#f74 ,URBAN 09T]NAL NONVIABILITY0 HAS ?REE S\RCES3 7#a7 HI< POPULATION D5SITY 0FACILITATES ! G5ESIS & COMMUNICATION ( 9FECTI\S DISEASES02 7#b7 SU* CITIES 0HAVE ALMO/ 9V>IABLY HAD POOR SANITATION & HYGI5E1 P>TICUL>LY ) RESPECT TO WAT] & SEWAGE02 & 7#c7 URBANITES DEP5D ON \TSIDE S\RCES ( FOOD1 ON MONOCULTURAL FOOD PRODUCTION SUBJECT TO CROP FAILURES & DIFFICULTIES ( TRANSPORTATION1 /ORAGE & DI/RIBUTION 7,KNAUFT #a#i#h#g3 #i#h74 ,9DU/RIAL CITIES HAVE ONLY IMP]FECTLY COP$ ) !SE UNHEAL?Y 9FLU5CES4 ,!Y >E MORE OV]CR[D$ ?AN EV]1 )1 ! ,DEAN HAS %[N1 ADV]SE HEAL? CONSEQU5CES 7,H]B] #a#i#f#e74 0,URBAN AIR IS S]I\SLY POLLUT$ & URBAN WA/ES >E REA*+ UNMANAGEABLE PROPORTIONS0 -- FUR!RMORE3 ,NO?+ MORE VISIBLY REVEALS ! OV]ALL DECAY ( ! MOD]N CITY ?AN ! UBIQUIT\S FIL? & G>BAGE ?AT GA!RS 9 ITS /REETS1 ! NOISE & MASSIVE CONGE/ION ?AT FILLS ITS ?OR\ES1 ! APA?Y ( ITS POPULATION T[>D CIVIC ISSUES1 & ! D ! PHYSICAL VIOL5CE ?AT IS PUBLICLY 9FLICT$ ON O!R MEMB]S ( ! COMMUNITY 7,BOOK*9 #a#i#g#d3#f#f1#f#g74 ,EV5 ! MO/ CONSPICU\S HEAL? ACCOMPLI%M5T ( 9DU/RIALISM1 ! CONTROL ( DISEASE BY ANTIBIOTICS1 IS BE+ ROLL$ BACK1 AS RESI/ANT /RA9S ( DISEASE VECTORS EVOLVE4 ,EV5 ! FOOD SITUATION IS UNSATISFACTORY1 IF NOT = PRECISELY ! TRADITIONAL REASONS4 ,MO/ ,AM]ICAN URBANITES HAVE UNHEAL?Y DIETS1 & MORE ?AN A FEW >E MALN\RI%$4 ,! ,DEAN MO/LY OBSESSES AB\T DETAILS -- :Y NOT OBLIGE HIM8 -- SU* AS :E!R CONTEMPOR>Y HUNT]-GA!R] SOCIETIES >E 0PRI/9E0 & :E!R HUNT]-GA!R]S HAVE 9V>IABLY BE5 ! B5IGN /EW>DS ( !IR HABITATS4 ,AL?\< !SE PROPOSITIONS >E L>GELY IRRELEVANT TO ! SPECIES 0PRIMITIVISM0 & 5TIRELY IRRELEVANT TO ITS SUPPOS$ G5US1 0LIFE/YLE AN>*ISM10 ! WAYS ! ,DEAN DEPLOYS !M >E RELEVANT TO HIS ULT]IOR AIMS & EXEMPL>Y ( HIS UNSAVORY ME?ODS4 ,BY 0PRI/9E0 7#d#d1 #d#e7 ! ,DEAN SEEMS TO MEAN ! SUPPOSITION ?AT ALL CONTEMPOR>Y HUNT]-GA!R]S >E LIV+ FOSSILS :O HAVE ALWAYS LIV$ ! WAY !Y DO N[4 ,AS USUAL1 :5 ! ,DEAN PUTS A LOAD$ WORD 9 QUOTATION M>KS IT'S A DEAD GIVEAWAY ?AT HE'S NOT QUOT+ ANYBODY1 JU/ TALK+ TO HIS FAVORITE P]SON1 HIMSELF4 7,JU/ AS HIS MOCK]Y ( PRIMITIVE 0REV]5CE = LIFE0 7#d#b7 MI*O-PRIMITIVI/S A PHRASE EMPLOY$1 NOT BY !M1 BUT BY ?AT CELEBRAT$ RACI/ PAT]NALI/1 ! LATE ,B'WANA1 ,DR4 ,ALB]T ,S*WEITZ]47 ,HE MIN$ ?AT -- HE PROBABLY DID -- FROM ,JOHN ,Z]ZAN3 0SURVIV+ HUNT]-GA!R]S1 :O HAVE SOMEH[ MANAG$ TO EVADE CIVILIZATION'S TREM5D\S PRESSURES TO TURN !M 9TO SLAVES 7I4E4 F>M]S1 POLITICAL SUBJECTS1 WAGE LABOR]S71 HAVE ALL BE5 9FLU5C$ BY CONTACT ) \TSIDE PEOPLES0 7#a#i#i#d3 #b#i-#c74 ,! CALL = PAP]S = ! #aiff 0,MAN ! ,HUNT]0 CONF]5CE -- :I* ! ,DEAN BLAMES = ROMANTICIZ+ =AG]S 7#c#g7 -- /AT$ 0?AT !RE IS NO ASSUMPTION ?AT LIV+ HUNT]-GA!R]S >E SOMEH[ LIV+ RELICTS ( ! ,PLEI/OC5E0 7QUOT$ 9 ,B9=D #a#i#f#h3 #b#g#d74 ,BOOK*9 IS BEAT+ A DEAD HORSE OR1 BETT] YET1 AN EXT9CT EOHIPPUS3 0,IT IS WIDELY RECOGNIZ$ ?AT MOD]N HUNT]S >E NOT PRI/9E LIV+ RELICS ( ! ,PLEI/OC5E0 7,HAWKES #a#i#h#g3 #c#e74 ,! ,DEAN CITES ) SOME SATISFACTION A FAIRLY REC5T >TICLE BY ,WILLIAM ,M4 ,D5EVAN1 0,! ,PRI/9E ,MY?3 ,! ,L&SCAPE ( ! ,AM]ICAS 9 #a#d#i#b0 7#a#i#i#b71 BUT = SEV]AL REASONS1 ,I D\BT ! ,DEAN HAS EV5 READ IT4 ,9 ! FIR/ PLACE1 ! ,DEAN ONLY ADV]TS TO IT AS 0CIT$ 9 ,WILLIAM ,K4 ,/EV5S1 ',AN ,$5 9 ,ANCI5T ,AM]ICA8 ,NOT ,REALLY1' ,! ,NEW ,YORK ,TIMES 7,M>* #c1 #a#i#i#c1 P4 ,C,I0 7#f#c N4 #b#b74 ,! NEWSPAP] /ORY MAY WELL HAVE BE5 H[ ! ,DEAN GOT W9D ( ! >TICLE -- NO?+ WRONG ) ?AT1 ,I (T5 FOLL[ UP ON TIPS ?AT WAY -- BUT HAV+ S]V$ ?AT PURPOSE1 !RE'S NO REASON TO REF] TO A NEWSPAP] /ORY :I*1 AT BE/1 MU/ HAVE OV]SIMPLIFI$ ! >TICLE4 ,SECOND1 ! ,DEAN MISQUOTES ! NAME ( ! J\RNAL4 ,& F9ALLY1 ! TITLE ( ! NEWSPAP] /ORY1 SUGGE/+ A DEBUNK+ ( ! MY? ( 0AN ,$5 9 ANCI5T ,AM]ICA10 HAS ABSOLUTELY NO?+ TO DO ) :AT ,D5EVAN WAS REALLY WRIT+ AB\T1 AL?\< IT HAS EV]Y?+ TO DO ) ! ,DEAN'S ANTI-PRIMITIVI/ IDEOLOGICAL AG5DA4 ,D5EVAN'S >GUM5T1 :I* RELATES ONLY TO ! ,WE/]N ,HEMISPH]E1 IS ?AT :5 ,EUROPEANS >RIV$ 9 ! ,NEW ,WORLD1 & = SOME TIME AFT]W>DS1 ! L&SCAPE !Y 5C\NT]$ -- ,D5EVAN IS A CULTURAL GEOGRAPH] -- WAS NOT 0PRI/9E0 IF ?IS MEANS IT HAD BE5 B>ELY AFFECT$ BY T5S ( ?\S&S ( YE>S ( 9DIG5\S HUMAN PRES5CE4 ,9DIAN HUNT+1 HORTICULTURE1 & ESPECIALLY ! USE ( FIRE HAD WR\K-LIKE WOODL&S ( EA/]N ,NOR? ,AM]ICA 7,MORGAN #a#i#g#e3 *4 #c2 ,SALISBURY #a#i#h#b3 *4 #a74 ,BUT BY ! TIME ! ,EURO-,AM]ICANS MOV$ WE/ ON A L>GE SCALE1 ! ONCE-NUM]\S ,9DIANS HAD BE5 DECIMAT$ & MU* ( ! L&SCAPE HAD REV]T$ TO A TANGL$1 PRE-HUMANIZ$ 0WILD]NESS0 ! SETTL]S MI/OOK = PRI/9E CONDITIONS4 ,D5EVAN PLAUSIBLY >GUES = ?IS CONCLUSION BUT DOES NOT1 AS ! ,DEAN DOES1 CONSID] IT CAUSE = CELEBRATION4 ,BUT :AT DOES ?IS HAVE TO DO ) ANY?+8 ,A HUMANIZ$ L&SCAPE IS NOT NECESS>ILY A RAVAG$1 DEPLET$1 D5ATURALIZ$ L&SCAPE BECAUSE !RE WAS A TIME :5 HUMANS W]E NATURAL4 ,! ,DEAN1 ,PR(ESSOR ( ,SOCIAL ,ECOLOGY1 ALSO SUPPOSES HE IS SAY+ SOME?+ IMPORTANT :5 HE AV]S ?AT PRIMITIVES MAY HAVE CONTRIBUT$ TO ! EXT9CTION ( SOME SPECIES ( ! ANIMALS !Y HUNT$ & ?AT !Y MAY HAVE SOMETIMES DEGRAD$ !IR 5VIRONM5TS 7#d#b-#d#c74 ,AS ! ALLEGATIONS >E 9DEP5D5T1 LET US ADDRESS EA* C\NT ( ! 9DICTM5T SEP>ATELY4 ,EV5 ! ,DEAN ADMITS ?AT ! BE/-KN[N CLAIM = 9DUC$ EXT9CTION1 SO-CALL$ ,PLEI/OC5E OV]KILL1 IS 0HOTLY DEBAT$0 7#f#c N4 #b#c74 ,RAPID CLIMATIC *ANGE WAS 9DISPUTABLY P>T ( ! CAUSE1 & POSSIBLY A SUFFICI5T CAUSE1 = ! EXT9CTION ( OV]SPECIALIZ$ SPECIES LIKE ! MA/ODON4 ,BUT SUPPOS+ ?AT PREHI/ORIC HUNT]S W]E RESPONSIBLE = SOME EXT9CTIONS -- SO :AT8 ,EXT9CTION HAS SO F> BE5 ! FATE ( ALMO/ EV]Y SPECIES TO APPE> ON ?IS PLANET1 & MAY 9 TIME BE ! FATE ( ALL ( !M4 ,! CONT9UATION ( NATURAL LIFE DOES NOT DEP5D UPON ! CONT9UATION ( ANY P>TICUL> SPECIES1 9CLUD+ \RS4 ,:AT DIFF]5CE DOES IT MAKE8 ,ANYWAY1 TO SAY ?AT SOME PREHI/ORIC PRIMITIVES C\LD & DID KILL GAME ANIMALS ON A L>GE SCALE 7#d#b1 #f#b-#f#c N4 #b71 AS ALL AN?ROPOLOGI/S >E WELL AW>E1 DOES NOT 5TAIL ?AT !SE PRIMITIVES BR\TICLE :I* ! ,DEAN CITES 7,LEGGE @& ,R[LEY-,CONWY #a#i#h#g71 BUT MU/ NOT HAVE READ V]Y C>EFULLY -- EV5 IF WE DISREG>D HIS MI/AKE AS TO ONE COAU?OR'S NAME 7#f#b-#f#c N4 #b .<0,R[LY0.>7 -- ACTUALLY TELLS AGA9/ HIS 9DICTM5T ( ! =AG]S4 ,BOOK*9 CITES IT = ! CONCLUSION 0?AT MIGRAT+ ANIMALS C\LD HAVE BE5 SLAUTICLE TELLS A MORE 9T]E/+ /ORY4 ,! AU?ORS1 >*AEOLOGI/S1 >E REPORT+ ON A SITE !Y EXCAVAT$ 9 ,SYRIA4 ,IT WAS FIR/ OCCUPI$ BY HUNT]-GA!R]S 9 APPROXIMATELY #i ,B4,C4 & REMA9$ OCCUPI$1 ) ONE BREAK1 WELL 9TO ! ,NEOLI?IC 7AGRICULTURAL7 P]IOD4 ,! AU?ORS EMPHASIZE ?AT ?IS WAS A YE>-R\ND COMMUNITY1 NOT A SEASONAL CAMPSITE4 ,= AB\T A ?\S& YE>S AFT] ! VILLAG]S DOME/ICAT$ PLANTS1 HUNT+ -- MA9LY GAZELLE HUNT+ -- CONT9U$ TO SUPPLY !M ) ANIMAL PROTE94 ,BY !N1 ! AU?ORS BELIEVE1 ! F>M]S HAD HUNT$ ! GAZELLES 9TO EXT9CTION1 & ONLY !N DID !Y TAKE UP ANIMAL HUSB&RY TO REPLACE ! MEAT =M]LY SUPPLI$ BY WILD GAME4 ,!RE >E TWO PO9TS ( 9T]E/ H]E1 & EA* IS ADV]SE TO ! ,DEAN4 ,HUNT]-GA!R]S W]E NOT RESPONSIBLE = ! EXT9CTION ( ! GAZELLES3 !IR AGRICULTURAL DESC5DANTS W]E4 ,!SE VILLAG]S HAD LONG S9CE CEAS$ TO BE =AG]S BY ! TIME !Y F9I%$ (F ! GAZELLES 7LOCALLY1 ?AT IS3 ! ANIMALS SURVIV$ ELSE:]E74 ,MORE IMPORTANT1 !Y'D NEV] REALLY BE5 HUNT]-GA!R]S 9 ! S5SE 9 :I* HUNT]- GA!R]S 9T]E/ PRIMITIVI/S & \*I/S4 ,AN?ROPOLOGI/S HAVE REC5TLY RESOLV$ AN AMBIGUITY 9 ! EXPRESSION 0HUNT]-GA!R]S0 7CF4 ,MURDOCK #a#i#f#h3 #a#c-#a#e74 ,IT REF]S TO TWO K9DS ( SOCIETY1 NOT ONE3 NONS$5T>Y & S$5T>Y4 ,:AT !Y HAVE 9 COMMON IS ?AT !Y HUNT &_/OR GA!R RA!R ?AN PLANT_/& OR H]D4 ,!Y DO NOT DOME/ICATE EI!R PLANTS OR ANIMALS 79 A FEW SU* SOCIETIES1 DOGS >E DOME/ICAT$1 BUT NOT AS A FOOD S\RCE74 ,:AT SEP>ATES !M IS :E!R !Y OCCUPY LOCATIONS ON A LONG-T]M OR %ORT-T]M BASIS4 ,! OCCUPANTS ( ! ,SYRIAN SITE W]E ALWAYS 0HUNT]S0 9 ! OBVI\S RESPECT ?AT1 LIKE MANY MEMB]S ( ! ,NATIONAL ,RIFLE ,ASSOCIATION1 !Y HUNT$ ANIMALS4 ,BUT !Y MORE CLOSELY RESEMBL$ SU* ,NOR?WE/ ,COA/ ,9DIANS AS ! ,KWAKIUTL 9 ?AT !Y W]E ! P]MAN5T1 YE>-R\ND OCCUPANTS ( FAVOR$1 RE/RICT$ LOCATIONS :I* AF=D$ !M SU/5ANCE4 ,!Y W]E NOT ! SAME SORT ( 0HUNT]-GA!R]S0 AS ! ,AU/RALIAN ABORIG9ES1 ! ,SAN_/,BU%M51 ! ,PYGMIES1 ! ,GREAT ,BAS9 ,%O%ONE & MANY O!RS = :OM FREQU5T RELOCATION WAS ! CONDITION ( SUCCESSFUL ADAPTATION TO !IR HABITATS4 ,S$5T>Y HUNT]-GA!R]S >E SOCIALLY MU* MORE LIKE S$5T>Y AGRICULTURI/S & URBANITES ?AN !Y >E LIKE =AG]S :O >E R\T9ELY ON ! MOVE4 ,!IR SOCIETIES EXHIBIT CLASS /RATIFICATION1 H]$IT>Y *IEFS1 SOMETIMES EV5 SLAV]Y 7,KELLY #a#i#i#a2 ,R5\F #a#i#i#a3 #i-#i#a1 #i#h1 #aa N4 #a2 CF4 ,R5\F #aihi = A PREHI/ORIC ,EUROPEAN EXAMPLE74 ,IT IS FROM !SE SOCIETIES ?AT ! CITY & ! /ATE EM]G$ -- TOGE!R4 ,POSSIBLY MORE RELEVANT IS ! CLAIM ?AT PRIMITIVES >E NOT NECESS>ILY 0ECOLOGICALLY B5IGN0 7#d#b71 & !RE'S NO REASON TO SUPPOSE !Y ALWAYS >E4 ,AS ,D5EVAN SAYS1 SOMETIMES 0,9DIANS LIV$ 9 H>MONY ) NATURE ) SU/A9ABLE SY/EMS ( RES\RCE MANAGEM5T0 & SOMETIMES !Y DIDN'T 7#a#i#i#b3 #c#g74 ,BUT ,DEVEVAN WAS NOT G5]ALIZ+ AB\T PRIMITIVES1 HE WAS G5]ALIZ+ AB\T ,9DIANS4 ,HE NO:]E ADDUCES A S+LE EXAMPLE ( ,AM]9DIAN HUNT]-GA!R]S :O DEGRAD$ !IR 5VIRONM5T1 & NEI!R DOES ,BOOK*91 AL?\< ,I W\LDN'T LOSE A LOT ( SLEEP IF IT TURN$ \T ?AT !RE WAS ONE1 OR EV5 MORE ?AN ONE GR\P LIKE ?AT4 ,A SMALL-SCALE SOCIETY :I* F\L$ ITS [N NE/ W\LD PROBABLY NOT SURVIVE1 BUT ! 5VIRONM5TAL DAMAGE IT DID W\LD BE LOCALIZ$4 ,A SMALL-SCALE SOCIETY :I* BY SOME COMB9ATION ( 9SI\ND = MILL5NIA1 BUT !Y'VE 5DUR$ AT LEA/ = C5TURIES4 0,PRIMITIVISM0 IS NOT 09DIG5ISM10 I4E41 PAN-,9DIAN RACIAL NATIONALISM ) A LEFT-W+ SP9 SU* AS ,W>D ,*UR*ILL S]VES UP4 0,PRIMITIVE0 & 0,9DIAN0 >E NOT SYNONYMS4 ,MO/ PRIMITIVES W]E NEV] ,9DIANS & MANY PRE-,COLUMBIAN ,9DIANS W]5'T PRIMITIVES4 ,! ,DEAN REPORTS ?AT 0=E/ OV]CLE>+ & ! FAILURE ( SUBSI/5CE AGRICULTURE UND]M9$ ,MAYAN SOCIETY & CONTRIBUT$ TO ITS COLLAPSE0 7#d#c74 ,ONE ONLY HAS TO REF] TO HIS [N FOOTNOTE TO ID5TIFY HIS REF]5CES 7#f#d N4 #b#e7 FROM 0,! ,COLLAPSE ( ,CLASSIC ,MAYA ,CIVILIZATION0 9 ,! ,COLLAPSE ( ,ANCI5T ,/ATES & ,CIVILIZATIONS TO ,! ,COLLAPSE ( ,COMPLEX ,SOCIETIES 9 ORD] TO NOTICE ?AT HE'S NOT REF]R+ TO =AG]S OR PRIMITIVES1 HE'S REF]R+ TO A CIVILIZATION1 ! /ATE-ORGANIZ$1 URBAN-BAS$1 AGRICULTURAL1 PRIE/-RIDD51 CLASS-/RATIFI$ ,MAYAN CIVILIZATION4 ,CIVILIZATIONS HAVE A LONG HI/ORY ( OCCASION+ 5VIRONM5TAL DE/RUCTION :E!R ! CIVILIZ$ BE R$1 :ITE1 BLACK OR YELL[3 !Y HAVE BELONG$ TO ALL ( !SE RACES4 ,IS ?IS NEWS TO ,PR(ESSOR ,SOCIAL ,ECOLOGY8 ,PROBABLY ! MO/ AMUS+ ASPECT ( ! ,DEAN'S CAMPAIGN AGA9/ ! PRIMITIVI/S IS H[ BLATANTLY SELF-CONTRADICTORY IT IS 7,J>A* #a#i#i#f74 ,:ILE HE WANTS TO REPRES5T PRIMITIVE LIFE-WAYS AS UNDESIRABLE1 ! DECISIVE PO9T IS ?AT !Y >E1 = US1 SIMPLY IMPOSSIBLE3 0,ANYONE :O ADVISES US TO SIGNIFICANTLY1 EV5 DRA/ICALLY1 R$UCE \R TE*NOLOGY IS ALSO ADVIS+ US1 9 ALL LOGIC1 TO GO BACK TO ! '/ONE AGE' -- AT LEA/ TO ! ,NEOLI?IC OR ,PALEOLI?IC 7E>LY1 MIDDLE1 OR LATE70 7#c#f74 ,TO DIGRESS = JU/ A BIT1 CONSID] H[ IDIOTIC ?IS ASS]TION IS4 ,! ,DEAN SAYS ?AT ANY SIGNIFICANT ROLLBACK ( TE*NOLOGY W\LD R$UCE US TO1 AT BE/1 ! ,NEOLI?IC1 ! ,NEW ,/ONE ,AGE4 ,BUT OBVI\SLY !RE WAS A LOT ( TE*NOLOGICAL PROGRESS1 IF ?AT'S :AT IT WAS1 BETWE5 ! ,NEOLI?IC ,REVOLUTION 7AGRICULTURE7 :I* COMM5C$ A FEW ?\S& YE>S AGO & ! ,MEGAMA*9E :I* DOM9ATES US N[4 ,! ,DEAN'S BELOV$ ,A!NIAN POLIS1 = 9/ANCE1 EXPLOIT$ A TE*NOLOGY MU* 9F]IOR TO :AT WE MOD]NS COMM& BUT F> BEYOND :AT ! ,NEOLI?IC F>M]S1 ! E>LIE/ F>M]S1 HAD TO WORK )4 ,E>LY M$IEVAL ,EUROPE1 AN ALMO/ 5TIRELY RURAL SOCIETY1 QUICKLY DEVELOP$ NEW TE*NOLOGY 7SU* AS ! MOLD-BO>D PL[7 BEYOND ANY?+ ?AT URBAN-ORI5T$ ,GRECO-,ROMAN CIVILIZATION EV] DID4 ,JOHN ,Z]ZAN'S UNSPEAKABLE H]ESY1 AS ! ,DEAN SEES IT1 IS ?AT ,Z]ZAN ?9KS ?AT PREHI/ORIC HUNT]-GA!R]S DID NOT JU/ FAIL TO 09NOVATE TE*NOLOGICAL *ANGE0 7#c#h71 !Y REFUS$ DOME/ICATION & ! DIVISION ( LABOR4 ,= ! ,DEAN1 PROGRESS IS AN (F] Y\ CAN'T REFUSE4 ,BUT !N1 SUBLIMELY OBLIVI\S TO ! 9CONSI/5CY1 HE GOES ON TO SAY ?AT SOME PRIMITIVE SOCIETIES HAVE1 9 HIS VALUE-LAD5 WORD1 0DEVOLV$0 FROM MORE COMPLEX SOCIETIES 7#d#d74 ,! ,MAYANS DEVOLV$ FROM CIVILIZATION 7#d#c74 ,! ,YUQUI =AG]S ( ! ,BOLIVIAN =E/ DEVOLV$ FROM 0A SLAVE-HOLD+ PRE-,COLUMBIAN SOCIETY0 :I* WAS HORTICULTURAL 7#d#e74 ,EV5 ! ,SAN HAVE 0LIT]ALLY DEVOLV$ -- PROBABLY V]Y MU* AGA9/ !IR DESIRES -- FROM HORTICULTURAL SOCIAL SY/EMS0 7#d#d2 CF4 ,WILMS5 #a#i#h#i74 ,WE MAY 0NEV] HAVE ANY WAY ( KN[+ :E!R ! LIFEWAYS ( TODAY'S =AG+ CULTURES ACCURATELY MIRROR ?OSE ( \R ANCE/RAL PA/0 7#d#c7 -- ACTUALLY1 >*AEOLOGY & PALEOECOLOGY HAVE COME UP ) SOME WAYS -- BUT WE HAVE AN EASY WAY TO F9D \T IF ! ,SAN W\LD RA!R BE G>D5]S ?AN =AG]S4 ,WE CAN ASK !M4 ,?IS W\LD NEV] OCCUR TO ! ,DEAN1 = :OM CONTEMPOR>Y =AG]S >E LITTLE MORE ?AN TALK+ DOGS1 BUT IT OCCURR$ TO ,RI*>D ,B4 ,LEE :5 HE LIV$ ) & /UDI$ ! ,SAN 9 ! '#fS3 0:5 A ,BU%MAN WAS ASK$ :Y HE HADN'T TAK5 TO AGRICULTURE HE REPLI$3 ',:Y %\LD WE PLANT1 :5 !RE >E SO MANY MONGONGO NUTS 9 ! WORLD80' 7,LEE #a#i#f#h3 #c#c74 ,!RE >E MANY EXAMPLES ( VOLUNT>Y 0DEVOLUTION40 ,! ANCE/ORS ( MO/ ,PLA9S ,9DIAN TRIBES W]E AGRICULTURI/S4 ,!RE IS ABSOLUTELY NO REASON TO SUPPOSE !Y W]E =C$ (F !IR F>ML&S & ONTO ! PLA9S BY 5VIRONM5TAL PRESSURES OR AGGRESSION FROM O!R TRIBES4 ,:5 ! HORSE1 9TRODUC$ BY ! ,SPANI%1 F\ND ITS WAY NOR?1 !SE ,9DIANS SEIZ$ UPON ?IS NEW TE*NOLOGY TO 0DEVOLVE0 FROM S$5T>Y AGRICULTURE TO NOMADIC BUFFALO HUNT+4 ,WE'LL NEV] KN[ = SURE :Y !Y MADE ?IS *OICE4 ,WAS BUFFALO MEAT TA/I] ?AN CORN8 ,WAS HUNT+ MORE FUN ?AN F>M+8 ,WAS A FREQU5T *ANGE ( SC5]Y MORE 9T]E/+ ?AN BE+ /UCK =EV] 9 ,MUDVILLE-ON-!-,MISS\RI8 ,:ATEV] IT WAS1 IT WAS A *OICE4 ,MAYBE WE HAVE A *OICE TOO4 O ,*APT] #h 3 ,9 ,SE>* ( ! ,PRIMITIVI/S ,P>T ,I,I3 ,PRIMITIVE ,AFFLU5CE ,*APT] #h3 ,9 ,SE>* ( ! ,PRIMITIVI/S ,P>T ,I,I3 ,PRIMITIVE ,AFFLU5CE ,ACCORD+ TO ! ,DEAN1 ! NOTION ( PRIMITIVE AFFLU5CE IS SOME SILL9ESS ! HIPPIES SMOK$ UP & PUT OV] ON ! AN?ROPOLOGI/S 9 ! '#fS3 ,MU* ( .<,GEORGE ,BRAD=D'S.> 0CRITICAL AN?ROPOLOGY0 APPE>S TO D]IVE FROM IDEAS PROP\ND$ AT ! 0,MAN ! ,HUNT]0 SYMPOSIUM1 CONV5$ 9 ,APRIL #aiff AT ! ,UNIV]SITY ( ,*ICAGO4 ,AL?\< MO/ ( ! PAP]S CONTRIBUT$ TO ?IS SYMPOSIUM W]E IMM5SELY VALUABLE1 A NUMB] ( !M CON=M$ TO ! NAIVE MY/IFICATION ( 0PRIMITIVITY0 ?AT WAS P]COLAT+ ?R\< ! #a#i#fS C\NT]-CULTURE -- & ?AT L+]S ON TO ?IS DAY4 ,! HIPPIE CULTURE1 :I* 9FLU5C$ QUITE A FEW AN?ROPOLOGI/S ( ! TIME1 AV]R$ ?AT HUNT+-GA!R+ PEOPLES TODAY HAD BE5 BYPASS$ BY ! SOCIAL & ECONOMIC =CES AT WORK 9 ! RE/ ( ! WORLD & /ILL LIV$ 9 A PRI/9E /ATE1 AS ISOLAT$ REMNANTS ( ,NEOLI?IC & ,PALEOLI?IC LIFEWAYS4 ,FUR!R1 AS HUNT]-GA!R]S1 !IR LIVES W]E NOTABLY HEAL?Y & PEACEFUL1 LIV+ !N AS N[ ON AN AMPLE NATURAL L>GESS 7#c#g74 ,! *IEF VILLA9 ( ! PIECE WAS AN?ROPOLOGI/ ,RI*>D ,B4 ,LEE1 :O HAD 0E/IMAT$ ?AT ! CALORIC 9TAKE ( 'PRIMITIVE' PEOPLES WAS QUITE HI< & !IR FOOD SUPPLY ABUNDANT1 MAK+ = A K9D ( VIRG9AL 'AFFLU5CE' 9 :I* PEOPLE NE$$ TO =AGE ONLY A FEW H\RS EA* DAY0 7#c#g-#c#h74 ,9 ! ABOVE-QUOT$ PASSAGE1 0IT W\LD TAKE A FULL-SIZ$ ESSAY 9 ITSELF TO UNSCRAMBLE1 LET ALONE REFUTE1 ?IS ABSURD BALD]DA%1 9 :I* A FEW TRU?S >E EI!R MIX$ ) OR COAT$ 9 %E] FANTASY0 7#c#g74 ,! ,DEAN REF]S TO A PASSAGE HE QUOTES FROM ,BRAD=D1 BUT MI5'T EV5 A FEW TRU?S 9 HIS PASSAGE1 NOT EV5 MIX$ OR COAT$ ) FANTASY4 ,! REVISION ( ! ,HOBBESIAN PO/ULATE ?AT PRIMITIVE LIFE IS NA/Y1 BRUTI% & %ORT COMM5C$1 NOT AT ! 0,MAN ! ,HUNT]0 SYMPOSIUM 9 #aiff 7,LEE @& ,DE,VORE #a#i#f#h71 BUT AT ! SYMPOSIUM ON B& SOCIETIES 9 ,OTTAWA 9 #aife 7,DAMAS #a#i#f#i74 ,! ,*ICAGO SYMPOSIUM ONLY EXT5D$ ! !SES ( ! PIONE]+ ,OTTAWA GA!R+ 7,R5\F #a#i#i#a3 #h#i-#i74 ,APRIL #aife & EV5 ,APRIL #aiff 7,LEE @& ,DE,VORE #a#i#f#h3 VII7 >E IMPLAUSIBLY E>LY DATES TO ASSUME MU* HIPPIE 9FLU5CE ON ACADEMIC S*OL>%IP1 & ! ,DEAN ADDUCES NO EVID5CE 9 SUPPORT ( HIS SELF-S]V+ CONJECTURE4 ,!RE'S NO TRACE ( C\NT]CULTURE 9FLU5CE1 = 9/ANCE1 9 ,BOOK*9'S #aife BOOK ,CRISIS 9 ,\R ,CITIES 7,H]B] #a#i#f#e7 OR HIS #aife ESSAY 0,ECOLOGY & ,REVOLUTION>Y ,?\Y ,?\GE 9 HIS #aig ESSAY OPPORTUNI/ICALLY LAUD+ Y\? CULTURE 7,BOOK*9 #a#i#g3 #e#a-#f#c74 ,! TIMES !Y W]E A-*ANG9'4 ,TO ,BOOK*9'S ANNOYANCE1 !Y /ILL >E4 ,IF !RE IS ANY RELATION%IP BETWE5 '#fS HIPPIE CULTURE & ! ANTI-,HOBBESIAN TURN 9 AN?ROPOLOGY1 IT IS ( ! SORT ! /ATI/ICIANS CALL A SPURI\S RELATION%IP4 ,?AT IS1 ! V>IABLES >E ASSOCIAT$ ) EA* O!R1 NOT AS CAUSE & EFFECT1 BUT AS CONSEQU5CES ( A COMMON CAUSE 7,BABBIE #a#i#i#b3 #d#a#f74 ,! COMMON CAUSE W\LD HAVE BE5 ! G5]AL CLIMATE ( DI/RU/ ( AU?ORITY & OR?ODOXY4 ,IF Y\ READ ! ,DEAN'S PASSAGE ) MORE C>E ?AN IT WAS WRITT5 )1 IT'S NOTICEABLE ?AT HE ATTRIBUTES MO/ ( ! MALIGN 9FLU5CE ON ! PRIMITIVI/S1 NOT TO ! AN?ROPOLOGI/S1 BUT TO ! HIPPIES4 ,I AM DRAW+ ON MY [N DI/ANT MEMORIES H]E1 BUT MY RECOLLECTION IS ?AT :AT ! HIPPIES ROMANTICIZ$ WAS TRIBAL SOCIETY ON ! MODEL1 USUALLY ILL-UND]/OOD1 ( C]TA9 PACIFIC ,NATIVE ,AM]ICAN TRIBES LIKE ! ,HOPI & ! ,NAVAJO4 ,AT ! TIME1 ,BOOK*9 APP>5TLY ?\P0 7#c#i71 :I* WAS EXPRESSLY & ONLY AB\T REVIS+ ! ,HOBBESIAN VIEW ( HUNT]-GA!R]S4 ,= ! MO/ P>T1 HUNT]-GA!R]S DON'T EV5 LIVE 9 TRIBES1 !Y LIVE 9 B&S 7,LEE @& ,DE,VORE #a#i#f#hB3 #g-#h74 ,9 CONTRA/1 TRIBAL PEOPLES -- HORTICULTURALI/S OR H]D]S -- OCCUPY A SOCIAL SPACE 0BETWE5 B&S & /ATES0 7,GREGG #a#i#i#a74 ,MANY ( !IR SOCIETIES >E ALSO AN>*I/ & AS SU* >E ALSO 9T]E/+1 AS WELL AS 9T]E/+ 9 !IR [N RIILY !RE >E NOT AS MANY VALID G5]ALIZATIONS AB\T PRIMITIVES AS !RE >E AB\T =AG]S4 ,ALL =AG]S >E PRIMITIVES1 BUT NOT ALL PRIMITIVES >E =AG]S4 ,9 A WAY1 IT'S ,BRAD=D'S FAULT = 9VIT+ ! ,DEAN TO FOM5T CONFUSION4 ,IF ! ,DEAN QUOTES HIM CORRECTLY -- ALWAYS A BIG IF :]E ! ,DEAN IS CONC]N$ -- ,BRAD=D WROTE 9 #aiia ?AT ! 0(FICIAL0 AN?ROPOLOGICAL VIEW ( =AG]S IS ! ,HOBBESIAN ONE4 ,?AT WAS ALREADY *ANG+ EV5 :5 ,M>%ALL ,SAHL9S MADE ! SAME PO9T 9 HIS #aifh ESSAY 0,! ,ORIG9AL ,AFFLU5T ,SOCIETY0 7,SAHL9S #a#i#g#a3 *4 #a74 ,TODAY ! 0CURR5T MODEL0 7,R5\F #a#i#i#a3 #h#i-#i7 IS ! ONE ADVANC$ AT ! ,OTTAWA & ,*ICAGO CONF]5CES3 0AL?\< ! MORE IDEALIZ$ ASPECTS ( ! ,LEE & ,DE,VORE MODEL >E COMMONLY ACKN[L$G$1 ,I ?9K IT IS FAIR TO SAY ?AT NO FUNDAM5TAL REVISION ( IT HAS BE5 MADE0 7IBID43 #i74 ,SIMIL>LY1 ANO!R AN?ROPOLOGI/ REF]S TO ! CONT9U+ PREVAL5CE ( 0! REVIS$ G5]AL V]SION ( HUNT]-GA!R]S ( ! MID- #a#i#fS0 7,CONKEY #a#i#h#d3 #b#e#g74 ,JOHN ,Z]ZAN1 NOT ,GEORGE ,BRAD=D1 IS CORRECT 9 SAY+ ?AT 0A NE>LY COMPLETE REV]SAL 9 AN?ROPOLOGICAL OR?ODOXY HAS COME AB\T1 ) IMPORTANT IMPLICATIONS0 7#a#i#i#d3 #a#f74 ,BRAD=D'S FAILURE TO UPDATE ! OP9IONS HE'S EXPRESS$ S9CE ! #a#i#gS -- :I* IS TYPICAL ( ! ,FIF? ,E/ATE -- AF=D$ ! ,DEAN AN UNDES]V$ OPPORTUNITY TO CLAIM SCI5TIFIC RESPECTABILITY = A VIEWPO9T LONG S9CE DISCR$IT$4 ,BRAD=D'S O!R MI/AKE1 EAG]LY EXPLOIT$ BY ! ,DEAN1 IS ?AT HE ALLEG$LY WROTE ?AT ! REVISIONI/ VIEW IS BAS$ ON 0GREAT] ACCESS TO ! VIEWS ( PRIMAL PEOPLE & !IR NATIVE DESC5DANTS0 7#c#g74 ,?AT GAVE ! ,DEAN HIS *ANCE TO DISMISS PRIMITIVE AFFLU5CE AS ! 0$5IC0 MY? ( NO/ALGIC NATIVES 7#c#f7 FE$+ !IR FANTASIES1 & P]HAPS !IR PEYOTE1 TO CR$UL\S :ITE HIPPIES4 ,?IS IS ALL WRONG4 ,IT WAS ! E>LIE/ /UDIES ( HUNT]-GA!R]S1 9CLUD+ CLASSIC ACC\NTS BY ,KROEB]1 ,BOAS & ,RADCLIFFE-,BR[N1 :I* RELI$ ON OLD] 9=MANTS' MEMORIES ( CONDITIONS #b#e-#e YE>S BE=E1 ON 0E?NOGRAPHIC RECON/RUCTIONS ( SITUATIONS :I* W]E NO LONG] 9TACT0 7,LEE @& ,DE,VORE #a#i#f#hC3 #e-#f74 ,! ,MAN ! ,HUNT] SYMPOSIUM1 F> FROM OV]LOOK+ ?IS ME?OD'S %ORTCOM+S1 MADE ?AT A 0C5TRAL !ME0 7IBID43 #f74 ,CONTEMPOR>Y AN?ROPOLOGI/S HAVE LESS]1 NOT GREAT] ACCESS TO ! VIEWS ( SO-CALL$ PRIMAL PEOPLE4 ,9 ! FIR/ PLACE1 PRIMAL PEOPLE >E DISAPPE>+ ALMO/ AS RAPIDLY AS LEFTI/S >E4 ,& SECONDLY1 ,WE/]N AN?ROPOLOGI/S NO LONG] 5JOY AS MU* 0ACCESS0 AS !Y DID :5 ! PEOPLE !Y /UDI$ W]E SUBJECT TO ,WE/]N COLONIAL RULE4 ,MO/ 9DIG5\S PEOPLES N[ HAVE MORE P[] TO DET]M9E :E!R & ON :AT T]MS !Y WILL RECEIVE RESID5T & EV5 VISIT+ E?NOGRAPH]S4 ,SOME EXCLUDE !M 5TIRELY4 ,& ! NATIONAL GOV]NM5TS ( SOME =M] COLONIAL POSSESSIONS :I* >E N[ 9DEP5D5T /ATES RE/RICT OR EXCLUDE =EIGN AN?ROPOLOGI/S = A V>IETY ( REASONS 7,BEALS #a#i#f#i3 #b-#b#g74 ,MORE IMPORTANT1 ! AFFLU5CE !SIS IS BAS$ ON OBS]VATION & MEASUREM5T1 NOT MY? & MEMORY4 ,RI*>D ,B4 ,LEE CONCLUD$ ?AT ! 6,KUNG ,SAN_/,BU%M5 DID REM>KABLY LITTLE WORK COMP>$ TO US -- NOT BY SITT+ AT ! FEET ( ! ,OLD ,WISE ,MAN LIKE !Y DO AT ,GODD>D ,COLLEGE -- BUT BY FOLL[+ ! ,SAN >\ND TO SEE :AT !Y W]E DO+ & = H[ LONG4 ,HE BAS$ HIS CONCLUSIONS AS TO ! SUFFICI5CY ( !IR DIET ON MEASUR+ ! CALORIES !Y +E/$ & EXP5D$ 7,LEE #a#i#f#i1 #a#i#g#i71 SOME?+ R>ELY DONE PREVI\SLY4 ,ONE ( ! RESULT+ >TICLES WAS TITL$ 06,KUNG ,BU%M5 ,SUBSI/5CE3 ,AN ,9PUT-,\TPUT ,ANALYSIS0 7,LEE #a#i#f#i74 ,?IS IS SCI5CE AT ITS MO/ MUSCUL>1 NOT FREE-=M FANTASY4 ,IT DOESN'T NECESS>ILY FOLL[1 ( C\RSE1 ?AT IF ,SAN SOCIETY IS 9 A V]Y TANGIBLE1 MEASURABLE S5SE LEISURELY & AFFLU5T1 !N SO >E ALL OR MO/ O!R =AG+ SOCIETIES4 ,BUT ON ! ,HOBBESIAN NEW1 ! ,SAN AS !Y LIV$ 9 ! #a#i#fS W]E IMPOSSIBLE1 SO ! ,HOBBESIAN VIEW 9 ! MUSCUL> =M ESP\S$ BY ! ,DEAN HAS TO BE QUALIFI$ OR1 AS ! SOCIAL SCI5TI/S SAY1 0SPECIFI$0 7! SCOPE ( ITS VALIDITY N>R[$7 7,BABBIE #a#i#i#b3 #d#b#a-#d#b#b7 OR ELSE REJECT$ ALTOGE!R4 ,& :AT'S SO 9TRIGU+ IS ?AT ! ,SAN LIVE !IR AFFLU5CE 9 ! >ID ,KALAH>I ,DES]T1 NOT SOMEPLACE APPROXIMAT+ ! ,G>D5 ( ,$5 7,Z]ZAN #a#i#i#d3 #b#i74 ,IF =AG+ LIFE C\LD BE AFFLU5T !RE1 IT MI74 ,!SE IMPLICATIONS HAVE NOT ONLY REORI5T$ FIELDWORK1 !Y HAVE ALSO OCCASION$ ! RE9T]PRETATION ( ALREADY AVAILABLE ACC\NTS ( HUNT]-GA!R]S1 BO? HI/ORICAL S\RCES & =MAL E?NOGRAPHIES4 ,SAHL9S 7#a#i#g#a3 *4 #a7 DID SOME ( BO? 9 0,! ,ORIG9AL ,AFFLU5T ,SOCIETY10 :OSE CONCLUSIONS HE'D PREVIEW$ AS A DISCUSSANT AT ! ,MAN ! ,HUNT] SYMPOSIUM 7,LEE @& ,DE,VORE #a#i#f#h3 #h#e-#h#i74 ,! ABUNDANT HI/ORICAL ACC\NTS ( ! ,AU/RALIAN ABORIG9ES1 = ALL !IR MISP]CEPTIONS1 IF C>EFULLY READ1 CONFIRM ! AFFLU5CE !SIS4 ,& ! E>LI] E?NOGRAPH]S ( HUNT]-GA!R]S1 AL?\< !Y HAD (T5 ANN\NC$ AS !IR CONCLUSIONS ! ,HOBBESIAN P>TY L9E1 REPORT AMPLE DATA :I* CONTRADICT ?OSE CONCLUSIONS4 ,AN?ROPOLOGI/S :O ONCE SLIE N[ COMB+ !M V]Y C>EFULLY 7E4G41 ,P>K+TON #a#i#h#d74 ,UNLIKE ,BRAD=D1 ! ,MAN ! ,HUNT] AN?ROPOLOGI/S W]E NOT 9T]E/$ 9 PRIMITIVE ANIMISM1 H>MONY ) NATURE1 OR 0EC/ATIC TE*NIQUES10 A PHRASE ! ,DEAN ATTRIBUTES TO ,BRAD=D 7#c#f74 ,AN?ROPOLOGI/S HAD LONG S9CE DOCUM5T$ BEYOND ANY REASONABLE POSSIBILITY ( REFUTATION ALL !SE ASPECTS ( MANY PRIMITIVE CULTURES4 ,:AT ! ,MAN-!-,HUNT] REVISIONI/S ADD$ WAS PRECISELY :AT ! ,DEAN CLAIMS IS MISS+1 ! SOCIAL DIM5SION3 0,EGALIT>IANISM1 %>+1 & L[ WORK EF=T W]E /RESS$1 AS WAS ! IMPORTANCE ( GA!R+ FOODS &1 BY EXT5SION1 WOM5'S DIRECT ROLE 9 ! ECONOMY0 7,R5\F #a#i#i#a3 #h#i74 ,! ,DEAN'S 5TIRE RHETORICAL /RATEGY IS AS MISDIRECT$ AS IT IS MALICI\S4 ,PRIMITIVI/S CONTRA/ ! ORD]LY AN>*Y & ! G5]\S EGALIT>IANISM ( =AG]S ) ! *AOTIC /ATISM & CLASS HI]>*Y ( URBAN CIVILIZATION4 ,! ,DEAN DR$GES UP ONE =AG+ SOCIETY1 ! ,YUQUI ( ,BOLIVIA1 :I*1 HE CLAIMS1 9CLUDES ! 9/ITUTION ( H]$IT>Y SLAV]Y -- AL?\< HE HAS TO ADMIT ?AT 0?IS FEATURE IS N[ REG>D$ AS A FEATURE ( =M] HORTICULTURAL LIFEWAYS0 7#d#e74 ,Y\ C\LD H>DLY ASK = A BETT] EXAMPLE ( ! EXCEPTION ?AT PROVES ! RULE4 ,!RE W]E ONLY #dc ,YUQUI AT CONTACT 9 ! #a#i#eS1 F> BEL[ ! M9IMUM -- USUALLY PUT AT AB\T #e -- = SOCIAL VIABILITY4 ,!Y >E PROBABLY DESC5D$ FROM A ,GU>ANI RAID+ P>TY ( ! LATE PRE-,COLUMBIAN P]IOD :I* WAS UNABLE TO F9D ITS WAY BACK TO ,P>AGUAY4 ,REM>KABLY1 !Y MA9TA9$ VE/IGES ( SLAV]Y1 SOME?+ 0DIFFICULT TO IMAG9E1 BUT IT DID EXI/40 ,! ,DEAN NEGLECTS TO M5TION ?AT UPON FALL+ 9TO ! CLUT*ES ( ! MISSION>IES1 ?IS SOCIAL SPL9T] AB&ON$ BO? =AG+ & SLAV]Y 7,/E>MAN #a#i#h#i74 ,?IS EXAMPLE PROVES1 AT ! MO/1 ?AT =AG+ SOCIETIES >E NOT ALWAYS AN>*I/ & EGALIT>IAN1 LEAV+ UNT\*$ ! CONCLUSION1 :I* EV5 ! ,DEAN DOESN'T D5Y1 ?AT !Y >E ALMO/ ALWAYS AN>*I/ & EGALIT>IAN4 ,ON ! O!R H&1 9 ?IRTY YE>S ( CELEBRAT+ URBANISM1 ! ,DEAN HAS YET TO ID5TIFY A /ABLE1 AN>*IC1 EGALIT>IAN URBAN SOCIETY4 ,P]HAPS REVOLUTION>Y ,B>CELONA APPROXIMAT$ ONE = A FEW MON?S 9 #a#i#c#f-#a#i#c#g1 & ,P>IS 9 #aifh = SEV]AL WEEKS4 ,BUT AT BE/ !SE >E ONLY BLIPS ON A SOCIAL SCRE5 ( ALMO/ UNRELIEV$ URBAN /ATISM & CLASS /RATIFICATION4 ,!SE 0\TLI]S10 AS ! /ATI/ICIANS REF] TO R>E VALUES ( V>IABLES1 F> \TSIDE ! RANGE ( ALL O!RS1 DO REM9D US -- AS DO ! ,YUQUI -- ( ! HUMAN CAPACITY = EXTREME SOCIAL PLA/ICITY4 ,AS SU*1 !Y HE>T5 ME1 BUT !Y FAIL TO P]SUADE ME ?AT 0SOME K9D ( URBAN COMMUNITY IS NOT ONLY ! 5VIRONM5T ( HUMANITY3 IT IS ITS DE/9Y0 7,BOOK*9 #a#i#g#d3 #b74 ,I DON'T ?9K ANATOMY IS DE/9Y & ,I DON'T ?9K URBANITY IS DE/9Y EI!R4 O ,*APT] #i 3 ,FROM ,PRIMITIVE ,AFFLU5CE TO ,LABOR-,5SLAV+ ,TE*NOLOGY ,*APT] #i3 ,FROM ,PRIMITIVE ,AFFLU5CE TO ,LABOR-,5SLAV+ ,TE*NOLOGY ,ONE T5D5CY :I* SURELY BELONGS ON ! ,DEAN'S 5EMIES %ORT LI/ IS Z]O-WORK1 ! CRITIQUE ( WORK AS SU*1 0! NOTION ?AT ! ABOLITION ( WORK IS POSSIBLE & DESIRABLE3 ?AT G5U9E1 UNCONDITION$ NE$S CAN BE MET BY VOLUNT>Y PLAYLIKE ACTIVITY 5JOY$ = ITS [N SAKE0 7,BLACK #a#i#i#fD3 #b#b74 ,Z]O-WORK MAY WELL BE ! ONLY PROGRAMMATIC POSITION %>$ BY EV]YBODY ! ,DEAN T>GETS1 EV5 ,L4 ,SUSAN ,BR[N 7#a#i#i#e74 ,! ,LEFT ,?AT ,WAS NOT ONLY POSIT$ WORK AS A NECESSITY1 IT REG>D$ IT AS ALMO/ A SACRAM5T4 ,& :ILE Z]O-WORK IS NOT ! SAME ?+ AS SU* ,BOOK*9 BUGBE>S AS H$ONISM & PRIMITIVISM1 IT COMPLEM5TS !M NICELY4 ,IT IS AN IMPORTANT ,BOOK*9 T>GET1 BUT HE ATTACKS IT ) POT%OTS1 NOT ! USUAL SCATT]%OT4 ,!RE MAY BE SEV]AL REASONS = HIS UN*>ACT]I/IC CIRCUMSPECTION4 ,9 HIS Y\NG] DAYS 70Y\NG]0 BE+1 ( C\RSE1 A RELATIVE T]M71 ,BOOK*9 UND]/OOD ?AT DEAL+ RADICALLY ) :AT HE CALL$ 0TOIL0 WAS A CRUCIAL DIM5SION ( PO/-SC>CITY AN>*ISM3 0,! DI/9CTION BETWE5 PLEASURABLE WORK & ON]\S TOIL %\LD ALWAYS BE KEPT 9 M9D0 7#a#i#g#a3 #i#b74 ,EV5 #be YE>S AGO1 ! PRODUCTIVE =CES HAD DEVELOP$ 0TO A PO9T :]E EV5 TOIL1 NOT ONLY MAT]IAL SC>CITY1 IS BE+ BR\*O-SYNDICALI/S1 ADD$ WORK]S' CONTROL ( PRODUCTION ACCORD+ TO ONE =MULA OR ANO!R4 ,!SE RE=MS1 EV5 IF COMPLETELY SUCCESSFUL ON !IR [N T]MS1 FALL %ORT ( ANY QUALITATIVE TRANS=MATION ( ! EXP]I5CE ( PRODUCTIVE ACTIVITY4 ,:Y DOESN'T ! ,DEAN JU/ CONTRADICT HIS =M] OP9ION )\T ADMITT+ IT1 AS HE DOES ) SO MANY O!RS8 ,IT MAY BE BECAUSE Z]O-WORK IS ONE DIM5SION ( AVANT-G>DE AN>*ISM :I* ON ,BOOK*9'S T]MS LOOKS PROGRESSIVE NOT REGRESSIVE -- A D\BLE IRONY1 AS HET]ODOX AN>*I/S T5D TO DISBELIEVE 9 PROGRESS4 ,R$UC$ H\RS ( WORK IS AN ANCI5T DEM& ( ! LEFT 7& ( ! LABOR MOVEM5T .<,HUNNICUTT #a#i#h#h.>74 ,M>X CONSID]$ IT ! PRECONDITION ( PASSAGE FROM ! REALM ( NECESSITY TO ! REALM ( FRE$OM 7#a#i#f#g3 #h#b71 JU/ LIKE ,BOOK*9 7,CL>K #a#i#h#d3 #e#e74 ,AN>*I/S AGRE$3 0,! EIKET AN>*I/S ( #ahhf PAID ) !IR LIVES0 7,BLACK #a#i#i#b3 #b#i74 ,OV] A C5TURY AGO1 ,KROPOTK9 >GU$ ?AT IT WAS !N ALREADY POSSIBLE TO R$UCE ! WORK+ DAY TO F\R OR FIVE H\RS1 ) RETIREM5T BY AGE #de OR #e 7#a#i#i#e3 #i#f74 ,:AT W\LD HIS E/IMATE BE TODAY3 #d OR #e M9UTES8 ,S9CE ! ,DEAN BELIEVES 7H[EV] ]RONE\SLY7 ?AT TE*NOLOGICAL PROGRESS R$UCES 0TOIL10 AT LEA/ POT5TIALLY 7#b#f71 HE HAS TO BELIEVE ?AT ! ABOLITION ( WORK IS AN EV]- 9CREAS+LY PRACTICAL POSSIBILITY4 ,HE CAN ONLY CRITICIZE Z]O-WORK]S1 NOT AS REACTION>IES1 BUT AS AHEAD ( !IR TIME4 ,& ?AT DEBUNKS ! :OLE NOTION ( LIFE/YLE AN>*ISM AS A SURR5D] TO ! PREVAIL+ CLIMATE ( REACTION4 ,! ,DEAN MI*I/S HAVE SUPPOS$LY )DRAWN 0FROM ! SOCIAL DOMA9 ?AT =M$ ! PR9CIPAL >5A ( E>LI] AN>*I/S0 7#b7 BECAUSE LIFE/YLE AN>*ISM 0IS CONC]N$ ) A '/YLE' RA!R ?AN A SOCIETY0 7#c#d74 ,BUT = AN OLD ,M>XI/ LIKE ,BOOK*91 LABOR IS ! V]Y ESS5CE ( ! SOCIAL3 0,LABOR1 P]HAPS MORE ?AN ANY S+LE HUMAN ACTIVITY1 UND]P9S CONTEMPOR>Y RELATION%IPS AMONG PEOPLE ON EV]Y LEVEL ( EXP]I5CE0 7#a#i#h#b3 #b#b#d74 ,9 ! IMPORTANCE !Y ATTA* TO ! LABOR PROCESS1 Z]O-WORK]S RESEMBLE TRADITIONAL SOCIALI/S1 NOT 0! GR[+ '9W>DNESS' & N>CISSISM ( ! YUPPIE G5]ATION0 7#i74 ,WORK IS AB\T REAL LIFE1 NOT LIFE/YLE OR HAIR/YLE4 ,F9ALLY1 !RE MI*ISM4 ,W]E HE TO DEAL ) Z]O-WORK ?AT WAY HE W\LD PROBABLY HAVE TO DEAL ) ME4 ,AS ! AU?OR ( 0,! ,ABOLITION ( ,WORK0 7,BLACK #a#i#h#f3 #a#g-#c#c71 A WIDELY READ ESSAY :I* HAS BE5 PUBLI%$ 9 SEV5 LANGUAGES1 & O!R Z]O-WORK WRIT+S 7,BLACK #a#i#i#b3 *4 #a2 #a#i#i#fB71 ,I W\LD BE ! S+LE MO/ CONV5I5T :IPP+-BOY4 ,BUT ,BOOK*9 NEV] REF]S TO ME ) RESPECT TO Z]O-WORK OR ANY?+ ELSE4 ,:AT AM ,I1 *OPP$ LIV]8 ,I CAN ONLY SPECULATE :Y ,I WAS SP>$1 EXCEPT BY IMPLICATION1 ! ,DEAN'S WRA?4 ,! FLATT]+ SUGGE/ION HAS BE5 MADE ?AT HE FE>$ MY POLEMIC P[]S & HOP$ ,I'D IGNORE HIS DIATRIBE UNLESS P]SONALLY PROVOK$ BY IT 7,J>A* #a#i#i#f3 #c74 ,IF SO1 HE MISCALCULAT$4 ,I'M A BETT] FRI5D TO MY FRI5DS ?AN ?AT1 & BESIDES1 ,I LIKE A GOOD FI*O-LIB]AL 9DIVIDUALI/S1 BUT ,I SAID NO?+1 = ,I WAS NOT AN AN>*O-LIB]AL 9DIVIDUALI/2 NEXT !Y CAME = ! MY/ICS1 BUT ,I SAID NO?+1 = ,I WAS NOT A MY/IC2 NEXT !Y CAME = ! PRIMITIVI/S1 BUT ,I SAID NO?+1 = ,I WAS NOT A PRIMITIVI/10 ETC4 ,IF ANY?+1 ,I AM PEEV$ TO BE OV]LOOK$4 ,BOOK*9'S 5EMIES LI/ LOOKS TO BE = ! AN>*I/S ( ! '#iS :AT ,NIXON'S 5EMIES LI/ WAS = ! LIB]ALS ( ! '#gS1 AN HONOR ROLL4 ,I'VE PREVI\SLY FLATT5$ A NOBODY -- HIS NAME DOESN'T MATT] -- :O PU%$ ! SAME L9E AS ,BOOK*9 7,BLACK #a#i#i#b3 #a#h#a-#a#i#c2 ,BLACK @& ,GUND]LOY #a#i#i#b7 AL?\< ?AT ONE ALSO HAPP5$ NOT TO M5TION MY NAME4 ,= ME1 ! POLITICAL IS ! P]SONAL4 ,AN ATTACK UPON ALL IS AN ATTACK UPON ONE4 ,SOLID>ITY =EV] -- OR MAKE MY DAY6 6,NO PAS]AN -- BABY6 ,WE HAVE ALREADY SE5 7,*APT] #i7 H[ ! ,DEAN BLI!LY MISREPRES5TS ! BE/ CURR5T UND]/&+ ( H[1 & H[ LONG1 =AG]S WORK -- IF ?AT IS EV5 ! WORD = :AT !Y DO = A LIV+1 OR RA!R1 = ! LIV+ ?AT !Y DO4 ,AS ,I'VE SUMM>IZ$ ! SITUATION 9 MY BOOK ,FRI5DLY ,FIRE3 ,9 ADDITION TO %ORT] H\RS1 0FLEXTIME0 & ! MORE RELIABLE 0SAFETY NET0 AF=D$ BY FOOD %>+1 =AG]S' WORK IS MORE SATISFY+ ?AN MO/ MOD]N WORK4 ,WE AWAK5 TO ! AL>M CLOCK2 !Y SLEEP A LOT1 NIE S$5T>Y 9 \R BUILD+S 9 \R POLLUT$ CITIES2 !Y MOVE AB\T BREA?+ ! FRE% AIR ( ! OP5 C\NTRY4 ,WE HAVE BOSSES2 !Y HAVE COMPANIONS4 ,\R WORK TYPICALLY IMPLICATES ONE1 OR AT MO/ A FEW HYP]-SPECIALIZ$ SKILLS1 IF ANY2 !IRS COMB9ES H&WORK & BRA9WORK 9 A V]SATILE V>IETY ( ACTIVITIES1 EXACTLY AS ! GREAT ,UTOPIANS CALL$ = 7,BLACK #a#i#i#b3 #c#c74 ,I'VE CIT$ AMPLE SUPPORT+ REF]5CES 9 ?AT BOOK 7:I* ! ,DEAN IS SURELY FAMILI> )1 IF LESS ?AN HAPPY )7 AS ALSO 9 ?IS ONE 7CF4 ,Z]ZAN #a#i#i#d3 #a#g#a-#a#h#e .<,BIBLIOGRAPHY.>74 ,ALL ,BOOK*9 CAN DO IS FULM9ATE ?AT ! PRIMITIVE AFFLU5CE !SIS IS HIPPIE HOKUM1 AN AD HOM9EM 9SULT :I* IS IRRELEVANT AS WELL AS UNTRUE4 ,! ,DEAN IS EQUALLY WRONG AB\T WORK -- & ! RELATION%IP ( TE*NOLOGY TO WORK -- 9 O!R =MS ( SOCIETY4 ,9 ,FRI5DLY ,FIRE ,I SUMM>IZ$ SOME ( ! EVID5CE 7!RE'S LOTS MORE7 ?AT AS TE*NOLOGY ADVANCES1 ! QUANTITY ( WORK 9CREASES & ! QUALITY ( ! WORK EXP]I5CE DECL9ES 7,BLACK #a#i#i#b3 #a#i-#d#a74 ,9 G5]AL1 !RE'S NO SU* ?+ AS LABOR-SAV+ TE*NOLOGY4 ,!RE'S USUALLY1 AT BE/1 ONLY LABOR- RE>RANG+ TE*NOLOGY1 :I* FROM ! WORK]'S P]SPECTIVE IS SORT ( LIKE 0EMIGRAT+ FROM ,ROMANIA TO ,E?IOPIA 9 SE>* ( A BETT] LIFE0 7IBID43 #a#c74 ,CAPITALI/S DEVELOP & DEPLOY NEW TE*NOLOGY1 NOT TO R$UCE LABOR1 BUT TO R$UCE ! PRICE ( LABOR4 ,! HI<] ! TE*1 ! L[] ! WAGES & ! SMALL] ! WORK-=CE4 ,:5 HE DESC5DS FROM DECLAMATION TO DETAIL1 ! ,DEAN EXPOSES HIS IGNORANCE ( ! REAL HI/ORY ( WORK & TE*NOLOGY4 ,! TWO EXAMPLES HE ADDUCES >E EVID5CE 5\<4 ,H]E'S HIS C>TOON HI/ORY ( ,S\!RN AGRICULTURE3 ,9 ! ,S\?1 PLANTATION [N]S NE$$ SLAVE 0H&S0 9 GREAT P>T BECAUSE ! MA*9]Y TO PLANT & PICK COTTON DID NOT EXI/2 9DE$1 ,AM]ICAN T5ANT F>M+ HAS DISAPPE>$ OV] ! PA/ TWO G5]ATIONS BECAUSE NEW MA*9]Y WAS 9TRODUC$ TO REPLACE ! LABOR ( 0FRE$0 BLACK %>E-CROPP]S 7#c#e74 ,9 O!R WORDS1 ,BOOK*9 BLAMES SLAV]Y ON TE*NOLOGICAL BACKW>DNESS1 NOT ON A CAPITALI/ WORLD-SY/EM :I* ASSIGN$ TO ! ,S\? ! FUNCTION ( EXPORT MONOCULTURE4 ,BUT COTTON WAS ( M9OR IMPORTANCE 9 ! L[-TE* COLONIAL ECONOMY ( ! SEV5TE5? & EID #a#i#h#e74 ,AS EV]Y S*OOL*ILD KN[S1 TE*NICAL PROGRESS /R5G!N$ SLAV]Y1 :I* HAD BE5 LANGUI%+1 ) ! CONJUNCTION ( ! COTTON G9 ) ! TEXTILES-BAS$ ,9DU/RIAL ,REVOLUTION 9 ,BRITA9 7,S*EIB]1 ,VATT] @& ,FAULKN] #a#i#g#f3 #a#c-#a#c#d74 ,IF :AT ,BOOK*9 SAYS AB\T SLAVEHOLD]S MAKES S5SE1 !NEV]Y RUL+ CLASS IS (F ! HOOK4 ,! PLANTATION [N]S 0NE$$0 SLAVES 09 GREAT P>T0 BECAUSE !Y LACK$ MA*9ES TO DO !IR WORK = !M4 ,PRESUMABLY 9DU/RIALI/S 0NE$$0 *ILD LABOR = ! SAME REASON4 ,A!NIAN CITIZ5S 0NE$$0 SLAVES BECAUSE !IR TE*NOLOGY WAS 9ADEQUATE TO PEEL !IR GRAPES1 GIVE !M BL[JOBS1 & SATISFY ! MANY O!R NE$S ( A CIVIC-M9D$ CITIZ5RY ) AIMS SO L(TY ?AT !Y C\LD NOT BE TR\BL$ ) E>N+ !IR [N KEEP4 0,NE$0 IS SOCIALLY & ECONOMICALLY RELATIVE4 ,NO D\BT ! ,S\!RN PLANT]S & ! ,A!NIAN CITIZ5S NE$$ SLAVES1 BUT DID ! SLAVES NE$ ! ,S\!RN PLANT]S OR ! ,A!NIAN CITIZ5S8 ,! ,DEANS'S O!R EXAMPLE IS ALSO MALADROIT4 ,IT'S ?AT CLASSIC 9/RUM5T ( WOM5'S LIB]ATION1 ! WA%+ MA*9E3 0,MOD]N WORK+ WOM5 ) *ILDR5 C\LD H>DLY DO )\T WA%+ MA*9ES TO RELIEVE !M1 H[EV] M9IMALLY1 FROM !IR DAILY DOME/IC LABORS -- BE=E GO+ TO WORK TO E>N :AT IS (T5 ! GREAT] P>T ( !IR H\SEHOLDS' 9COME0 7#d#i74 ,9 O!R WORDS1 ! WA%+ MA*9E RE9=CES ! DOME/IC SEXUAL DIVISION ( LABOR & 5ABLES WOM5 TO BE PROLET>IANIZ$ -- TO 5T] ! PAID LABOR =CE AT ! BOTTOM 7,BLACK #a#i#i#b3 #b#i-#c74 ,?ANKS TO TE*NOLOGY1 MOD]N WORK+ WOM5 GET TO DO ! UNPAID DRUDGE-WORK1 ! 0%AD[ WORK0 7,ILLI* #a#i#h#a7 ( ! PATRI>*AL H\SEHOLD1 PLUS ! UND]PAID CAPITALI/ DRUDGE-WORK ( ! (FICE1 ! RE/AURANT & EV5 ! FACTORY4 ,! WA%+ MA*9E1 & H\SEHOLD TE*NOLOGY 9 G5]AL1 NEV] SAV$ WOM5 ANY LABOR-TIME4 ,IT JU/ RAIS$ P]=MANCE /&>DS 7) A ,MAYTAG1 NO EXCUSE ANY MORE IF Y\R LAUNDRY'S NOT BRIE 7,C[AN #a#i#g#d1 #a#i#h#c74 ,I D\BT ,BOOK*9 DOES HIS [N LAUNDRY1 & NOT ONLY BECAUSE HE'S ALWAYS AIR+ HIS DIRTY L95 9 PUBLIC4 ,9 ,BOOK*9'S CIVIC ,UTOPIA1 0A HI< PREMIUM W\LD BE PLAC$ ON LABOR-SAV+ DEVICES -- BE !Y COMPUT]S OR AUTOMATIC MA*9]Y -- ?AT W\LD FREE HUMAN BE+S FROM NE$LESS TOIL & GIVE !M UN/RUCTUR$ LEISURE TIME = !IR SELF-CULTIVATION AS 9DIVIDUALS & CITIZ5S0 7#a#i#h#i3 #a#i#g74 ,TO BELIEVE 9 ?AT IS1 = SOMEONE AS IGNORANT AS ,BOOK*91 AN ACT ( FAI?4 ,9 REC5T DECADES PRODUCTIVITY1 DRIV5 BY HI< TE*NOLOGY F> BEYOND ANY?+ ! ,DEAN ANTICIPAT$1 HAS 9CREAS$ PRODIGI\SLY -- MORE ?AN D\BL+ S9CE #aidh 7,S*OR #a#i#i#a3 #a-#b1 #e1 #b#i74 ,ODDLY 5\<1 NOT EV5 0MAT]IAL SC>CITY10 MU* LESS 0TOIL10 HAS DIM9I%$4 ,REAL 9COME HAS FALL5 AT ! SAME TIME H\RS ( WORK HAVE 9CREAS$ 7,BLACK #a#i#i#d3 #c#a-#c#b2 ,BLACK #a#i#i#fB3 #d#e74 ,EV5 ! ,DEAN HAS NOTIC$1 LIT]ALLY ON PAGE ONE1 0! GR[+ IMPOV]I%M5T ( MILLIONS ( PEOPLE0 AT ! SAME TIME ?AT 0! 9T5SITY ( EXPLOITATION HAS =C$ PEOPLE 9 GR[+ NUMB]S TO ACCEPT A WORK WEEK TYPICAL ( ! LA/ C5TURY0 7#a74 ,:AT HE HASN'T NOTIC$ IS ?AT ! P>ADOX ( MORE PROGRESS1 MORE PRODUCTIVITY1 MORE POV]TY & MORE WORK CALLS HIS ESS5TIALLY ,M>XI/ CELEBRATION ( ! DEVELOPM5T ( ! PRODUCTIVE =CES1 AS HE MIE 9H]5TLY DOM9E]+ & ECOLOGICALLY DANG]\S0 7#c#d71 BUT HE CANNOT IMAG9E ?AT !Y 9CREASE & WORS5 WORK4 ,REALLY HE JU/ DOESN'T C>E4 ,HE HASN'T DEVOT$ ANY SU/A9$ ATT5TION TO WORK S9CE ,PO/-,SC>CITY ,AN>*ISM 7#a#i#g#a74 ,AFT] #be YE>S AS A COLLEGE BUREAUCRAT1 ! FACTORY IS A DI/ANT MEMORY4 ,HIS #aihi PRIM] SUMM>IZ+ HIS VIEWS ON REMAK+ SOCIETY DEVOT$ ALL ( TWO S5T5CES TO WORK ) BUT A P]FUNCTORY AFFIRMATION ( ROTATION ( TASKS 7#a#i#h#i3 #a#i#e74 ,ALL ,BOOK*9 C>ES AB\T ANY MORE IS POLITICS & ECOLOGY1 9 ?AT ORD]4 ,PROVID$ A TE*NOLOGY IS NEI!R 0DOM9E]+0 NOR 0DANG]\S10 ITS IMPACT ON WORK MEANS NO?+ TO HIM4 ,NO?+ BETT] DRAMATIZES ! ,DEAN'S SELF-DECEPTION & IRRELEVANCE ?AN ! CONTRA/ BETWE5 HIS F]VOR = POLITICS & HIS 9DIFF]5CE TO WORK4 ,HE BELIEVES1 BECAUSE HE WANTS TO BELIEVE1 ?AT 0SELDOM 9 REC5T MEMORY HAS !RE BE5 A MORE COMPELL+ POPUL> S5TIM5T = A NEW POLITICS0 7#e#i74 ,?AT CONTRADICTS HIS *>ACT]IZATION ( ! EPO* AS PRIVATI/IC1 P]SONALI/IC & APOLITICAL4 ,! TRU? IS ?AT SELDOM 9 REC5T MEMORY HAS !RE BE5 A MORE COMPELL+ S5TIM5T = NO POLITICS4 ,ON ! O!R H&1 WORK IS IF ANY?+ MORE SALI5T1 IF LESS LIK$1 9 ! LIVES ( ORD9>Y PEOPLE ?AN IT'S BE5 9 DECADES4 ,LONG] H\RS1 L[] REAL 9COMES1 & EMPLOYM5T 9SECURITY HAVE DONE NO?+ TO COMP5SATE = ! JOYLESS & (T5 HUMILIAT+ EXP]I5CE ( ! WORK ITSELF4 ,9 ! #a#i#fS ,BOOK*91 EV] AL]T TO SNIFF+ \T POT5TIALLY REVOLUTION>Y S\RCES ( SOCIAL MALAISE1 EXPRESS$ APPROVAL ( ! Y\NG] G5]ATION'S CONTEMPT = ! WORK TRAP 7,BOOK*9 #a#i#g3 #e#d1 #f#a2 #a#i#g#a3 #a#g#e-#a#g#f2 CF4 #a#i#i#d3 #c74 ,BUT :ILE O!R ,BOOK*9-APPROV$ T5D5CIES1 LIKE Y\? CULTURE1 W]E RECUP]AT$1 A WID5+ REVOLT AGA9/ WORK BECAME A P]SI/5T FEATURE ( ! ,AM]ICAN WORKPLACE 7,DE,LEON #a#i#i#f3 #a#i#f-#a#i#g2 ,Z]ZAN #a#i#h#h3 #a#g-#a#h#c74 ,SPONTANE\S & ACEPHAL\S1 IT C\LD NEI!R BE B\Y =CE 7,BLACK #a#i#i#fA74 O ,*APT] #a 3 ,%UT ,UP1 ,M>XI/6 ,*APT] #a3 ,%UT ,UP1 ,M>XI/6 ,AS A MATT] ( C\RSE1 UNLESS IDEOLOGY WI!RS AWAY1 IT EV5TUALLY H>D5S 9TO DOGMA4 ,AFT] ,JESUS COMES ,PAUL1 & EV5TUALLY SOME ,POPE1 ,9NOC5T 9 NAME ONLY4 ,?AT ,BOOK*9ISM W\LD CALCIFY 9TO A CRE$ AFT] NO V]Y LONG TIME IS NO SURPRISE4 ,EV5 9 ITS PRIME IT WAS >?RITIC ) ,R\SSEAU1 ,/4-,SIMON1 ,M>X & ,>5DT4 ,IT WAS ALWAYS AMBIGU\S AB\T TE*NOLOGY & SC>CITY4 ,ITS ECOLOGICAL CONT5T WAS ALWAYS AT ODDS ) ITS CIVISM1 TO :I*1 9 RETROSPECT1 ECOLOGY SEEMS TO HAVE ALWAYS BE5 AN ACCESSORY1 AN ADD-ON4 ,IT'S M>R$ BY ECC5TRICITIES AS V>I\S AS PRIMITIVE G]ONTOCRACY & ,SWISS AN>*Y4 ,IT'S UNR$EEM$ BY IRONY1 MU* LESS HUMOR4 ,:AT'S AMAZ+ IS ?AT ,BOOK*9 ISN'T LEAV+ ,BOOK*9ISM TO ITS ,PLEKHANOVS1 ,KAUTSKYS & ,L59S4 ,HE'S VULG>IZ+ HIS IDEOLOGY HIMSELF4 ,AS ! ,GRE5 ,AN>*I/ REVIEW] OBS]VES1 ! ,DEAN N[ 0GOES ON TO CRUDELY R$UCE OR REJECT ALL ?AT'S BE/ 9 HIS ,ECOLOGY ( ,FRE$OM10 =SAK+ DIALECTICS = DUALISM 7,ANONYM\S #a#i#i#f3 #b#b74 ,9 FACT HE'S GONE BACK ON ! BE/ ( EV]Y?+ HE'S WRITT54 ,?IS LATE/ TRACT BY ! AU?OR ( 0,LI/51 ,M>XI/60 MIXI/60 ,! AU?OR ( 0,DESIRE & ,NE$0 7#b7 D5\NCES DESIRE AS GRE$4 ,! B5IGN1 0CONCILIATORY0 ANIMISM ( ORGANIC SOCIETY 7,BOOK*9 #a#i#h#b3 #i#h7 HAS BECOME 0AN 9EXPLICABLE1 (T5 FRI TOOK = REALITY0 7#d#b74 ,! AU?OR :O ACCLAIM$ ! DROP-\T CULTURE 7,BOOK*9 #a#i#g3 #fc N4 #a7 N[ VILIFIES 0LUMP5 LIFEWAYS0 7#e#f74 ,! AU?OR :O CANNOT SPIT \T ! WORD 0Z9E0 )\T CONTEMPTU\S QUOTATION M>KS 7#e#a7 US$ TO PUBLI% A Z9E1 ,COMM5T1 HIMSELF 7,BOOK*9 #a#i#g#i3 #b#h74 ,!RE MU/ BE HUNDR$S ( !SE CONTRADICTIONS4 ,! ,DEAN IS OBLIVI\S TO ALL ( !M4 0,C]TA9LY10 DECREES ! ,DEAN1 0IT IS ALREADY NO LONG] POSSIBLE1 9 MY VIEW1 TO CALL ONESELF AN AN>*I/ )\T ADD+ A QUALIFY+ ADJECTIVE TO DI/+UI% ONESELF FROM LIFE/YLE AN>*I/S0 7#f#a74 ,?AT'S ! MO/ REASONABLE PROPOSAL 9 ! 5TIRE ESSAY4 ,I SUGGE/ HE CALL HIMSELF A 0,BOOK*9I/ AN>*I/0 OR1 IF HIS OV]WE5+ MODE/Y =BIDS1 AN 0ANTI-LIFE/YLE AN>*I/40 ,NOBODY WILL KN[ :AT HE'S TALK+ AB\T1 SO 9TRODUC+ HIMSELF ?AT WAY MIDIZE ! T]M9OLOGY ON ,BOOK*9'S T5D5TI\S T]MS4 ,MO/ AN>*I/S W\LD ALREADY RA!R ANSW] TO 0SOCIAL AN>*I/0 ?AN 0LIFE/YLE AN>*I/40 ,READ+ ! ,DEAN'S TRACT WON'T TURN ANY LIFE/YLE AN>*I/S -- :O NUMB] 9 ! 0?\S&S0 7#a7 -- 9TO SOCIAL AN>*I/S1 BUT IT MI*I/S1 EV5 IF1 LIKE ,BOOK*91 WE >5'T AN>*I/S AT ALL4 ,BOOK*9I/S MI*I/S10 BUT Y\ SEE :]E ?AT W\LD LEAD4 ,!Y NE$ A NAME NOBODY ELSE WANTS4 ,H[ AB\T 0,M>XI/08 O ,*APT] #aa 3 ,AN>*Y ,AFT] ,LEFTISM ,*APT] #a#a3 ,AN>*Y AFT] ,LEFTISM ,9 ONE RESPECT1 ,MURRAY ,BOOK*9 IS RI*I/S >E AT A TURN+ PO9T4 ,= ! FIR/ TIME 9 HI/ORY1 !Y >E ! ONLY REVOLUTION>Y CURR5T4 ,TO BE SURE1 NOT ALL AN>*I/S >E REVOLUTION>IES1 BUT IT IS NO LONG] POSSIBLE TO BE A REVOLUTION>Y )\T BE+ AN AN>*I/1 9 FACT IF NOT 9 NAME4 ,?R\<\T ITS EXI/5CE AS A CONSCI\S CURR5T1 AN>*ISM HAS BE5 %AD[$ & USUALLY OV]%AD[$ BY LEFTISM 9 G5]AL1 & ,M>XISM 9 P>TICUL>4 ,ESPECIALLY S9CE ! =MATION ( ! ,SOVIET ,UNION1 AN>*ISM HAS EFFECTIVELY 7& !RE=E 9EFFECTIVELY7 DEF9$ ITSELF ) REF]5CE TO ,M>XISM4 ,! R$UCTION ( AN>*I/S TO SATELLITES ( ! ,COMMUNI/S1 ESPECIALLY 9 REVOLUTION>Y SITUATIONS1 IS SO REGUL> A FEATURE ( !IR MOD]N HI/ORY ?AT IT CAN'T BE AN ACCID5T4 ,FIXAT$ ON !IR GREAT RIVAL1 ! AN>*I/S HAVE COMPET$ ) ,M>XI/S ON !IR [N LEFTI/ T]MS & SO ! AN>*I/S HAVE ALWAYS LO/4 ,M>XISM WAS ALREADY IDEOLOGICALLY BANKRUPT BY ! TIME ,EUROPEAN ,COMMUNISM COLLAPS$4 ,AS IDEOLOGY1 ,M>XISM IS N[ M]ELY A CAMPUS -- & MO/LY A FACULTY -- PH5OM5ON1 & EV5 AS SU* ITS P]SI/5CE IS MO/LY P>ASITIC UPON FEM9ISM & ! RACIAL NATIONALISMS4 ,AS A /ATE SY/EM1 :AT REMA9S ( ,M>XISM IS M]ELY ,ORI5TAL DESPOTISM1 UN?9KABLE AS A MODEL = ! ,WE/4 ,SUDD5LY1 SEV5TY YE>S ( AN>*I/ EXCUSES BECAME IRRELEVANT4 ,AL?\< !SE DEVELOPM5TS CAU*I/S1 LIKE EV]YBODY ELSE1 BY SURPRISE1 !Y W]E NOT AS UNPREP>$ AS !Y W\LD HAVE BE5 TW5TY YE>S E>LI]4 ,MANY ( !M HAD1 IF NOT BY DESIGN1 !N BY DRIFT & DEFAULT1 /RAY$ FROM !IR TRADITIONAL POSITION AS 0! 'LEFT W+' ( 'ALL SOCIALISMS'0 7#f7 -- BUT NOT BY MOV+ TO ! RIE = ONE OR ! O!R4 ,AS ! LEFTI/ V5E] -- OR T>NI% -- !Y TYPICALLY ACQUIR$ 9 COLLEGE WORE (F1 AN 9DIG5\S ANTI-AU?ORIT>IANISM %[$ ?R\<4 ,! ,M>XI/S !Y 5C\NT]$ ON CAMPUS W]E TOO RIDICUL\S TO BE TAK5 S]I\SLY AS RIVALS OR REF]5CE PO9TS4 7,?AT SOME ( !M W]E PR(ESSORS MADE !M ?AT MU* MORE RIDICUL\S47 ,MORE ?AN EV] BE=E1 SOME AN>*I/S 9SI/$ ON A 0P]SONALI/IC0 GR\ND+ ( POLITICS 9 ! EXP]I5CE ( EV]YDAY LIFE1 & !Y CORRESPOND+LY OP5$ UP TO !ORI/S LIKE ! SITUATIONI/S = :OM ! CRITIQUE ( EV]YDAY LIFE WAS A FIR/ PR9CIPLE4 ,!Y TOOK TO DUMP/]-DIV+ AMONG ! DISC>DS ( DOCTR9ES & CULTURES TO FA%ION1 LIKE A COLLAGE1 RECOMB9ANT WORLD-PICTURES ( !IR [N4 ,& IF ,NIETZS*E'S DEF9ITION IS RI*I/S1 MO/LY SYNDICALI/S1 REMA9 \T-&-\T LEFTI/S4 ,AS SU*1 !Y %>E ! DECL9E ( ! RE/ ( ! LEFT4 ,!Y NO LONG] 9CLUDE ANY FIR/-RATE OR EV5 SECOND-RATE ?9K]S4 ,O!R POCKETS ( AN>*I/S ACT AS AUXILI>IES ( SUB-LEFTI/1 P>TICUL>I/ IDEOLOGIES LIKE FEM9ISM & ,?IRD ,WORLD NATIONALISM 79CLUD+ 9DIG5ISM7 -- ! L>G] HUNKS ( WRECKAGE FROM ! ,NEW ,LEFT4 ,!SE TOO HAVE PRODUC$ !IR LOGORRHEICS BUT NOBODY ) ANY?+ TO SAY4 ,MANY O!R AN>*I/S RETA9 VE/IGES ( LEFTISM 7NOT ALWAYS A BAD ?+74 ,:AT'S IMPORTANT IS H[ MANY ( !M1 :ATEV] !IR L+]+ 9FLU5CES1 SIMPLY >5'T LEFTI/S ANY MORE4 ,! ,DEAN'S J]EMIAD EXPRESSES HIS %OCK ( RECOGNITION AT ?IS UNPREC$5T$ /ATE ( AFFAIRS4 ,! PRECONDITION = ANY SUB/ANTIAL 9CREASE 9 AN>*I/ 9FLU5CE IS = AN>*I/S TO MAKE EXPLICIT & EMPHATIC !IR BREAK ) ! LEFT4 ,?IS DOES NOT MEAN PLAC+ ! CRITIQUE ( ! LEFT AT ! C5T] ( ANALYSIS & AGITATION4 ,ON ! CONTR>Y1 ?AT'S ALWAYS BE5 A SYMPTOM ( AN>*ISM'S SATELLITE /ATUS4 ,IT IS 5\< TO ID5TIFY LEFTISM1 AS ! OCCASION >ISES1 AS ALL IT REALLY IS1 A V>IANT ( HEGEMONIC IDEOLOGY -- A LOYAL OPPOSITION -- :I* WAS =M]LY EFFECTIVE 9 RECUP]AT+ REVOLUTION>Y T5D5CIES4 ,!RE'S NO REASON = AN>*I/S TO 9H]IT AN ACCURS$ %>E ( ! LEFT'S UNPOPUL>ITY4 ,LET'S MAKE \R [N 5EMIES4 ,& \R [N FRI5DS4 ,S9CE !RE REALLY IS SOME?+ AN>*I/ AB\T SOME POPUL> T5D5CIES1 WE %\LD TRY TO MAKE SOME AN>*I/ T5D5CIES POPUL>4 ,C]TA9 AN>*I/ !MES BO? OLD & NEW RESONATE ) C]TA9 WIDESPREAD ATTITUDES4 ,IT ISN'T NECESS>ILY ELITI/ OR MANIPULATIVE TO CIRCULATE ! PROPOSITION ?AT AN>*ISM EXPLICATES & ELABORATES V>I\S 9*OATE ANTI-AU?ORIT>IAN T5D5CIES4 ,?IS CAN BE DONE 9 AN IMP]IALI/IC & OPPORTUNI/IC FA%ION1 BUT ,I BELIEVE IT CAN ALSO BE DONE1 JUDICI\SLY1 9 GOOD FAI?4 ,IF WE'RE MI/AK51 NO H>M DONE1 WE JU/ WON'T GO OV] V]Y WELL1 SOME?+ WE'RE US$ TO4 ,MANY PEOPLE WILL SURELY %R9K1 AT LEA/ 9ITIALLY1 FROM DRAW+ ! AN>*I/ CONCLUSIONS WE SUGGE/ !IR [N ATTITUDES & VALUES T5D T[>D4 ,!N AGA91 SOME O!RS MAY NOT1 NOT EV5 9ITIALLY -- ESPECIALLY ! Y\NG4 ,BESIDES1 MAK+ CONV]TS IS NOT ! ONLY PURPOSE ( AN>*I/ AGITPROP4 ,IT MAY ALSO 5L>GE ! *OK+LY CON/RICT$ RANGE ( ,NOR? ,AM]ICAN POLITICAL DISC\RSE4 ,WE MAY NEV] BR+ MO/ ( ! 9TELLIG5TSIA OV]1 BUT WE CAN S(T5 !M UP4 ,WE CAN R$UCE SOME ( !M TO SYMPA?IZ]S1 TO :AT ! ,/AL9I/S CALL$ FELL[ TRAVEL]S1 TO :AT ,L59 CALL$ USEFUL IDIOTS4 ,!Y WILL TRADUCE \R IDEAS BUT ALSO1 9 SOME MUTILAT$ =M1 S5D !M >\ND & LEGITIMATE !M 9 ! S5SE ?AT !Y >E TO BE TAK5 S]I\SLY4 ,& 9 SO DO+ !Y WILL WEAK5 !IR [N P[] TO C\NT] !M IF & :5 !SE IDEAS >E TAK5 S]I\SLY 5\< TO BE ACT$ UPON BY ?OSE :O UND]/& !M4 ,AM]ICANS 7& UND\BT$LY O!RS1 BUT ,I'LL /ICK ) ! ,AM]ICAN CONTEXT ,BOOK*9 ADDRESSES7 REALLY >E 9 A C]TA9 S5SE 0AN>*I/IC40 ,I'M NOT GO+ TO PRET5D1 LIKE ,DAVID ,DE ,LEON 7#a#i#g#h71 ?AT !RE IS SOME?+ 9NATELY & IMMEMORIALLY AN>*I/ AB\T ,AM]ICANS4 ,\R BELIEFS & BEHAVIOR HAVE LONG BE5 O!RWISE 9 IMPORTANT RESPECTS4 ,MO/ CONTEMPOR>Y ,AM]ICAN AN>*I/S & O!R RADICALS -- & ,I 9CLUDE MYSELF H]E -- HAVE BE5 CONSCI\SLY & CONSPICU\SLY ANTI-,AM]ICAN4 ,9 COLLEGE1 ,I MAJOR$ 9 HI/ORY1 BUT ,I TOOK C\RSES ONLY 9 ,EUROPEAN HI/ORY1 BECAUSE ,EUROPEANS HAD A REVOLUTION>Y H]ITAGE :I* WE ,AM]ICANS 7,I ASSUM$7 DID NOT4 ,MU* LAT] ,I LE>N$ ?AT ,AM]ICANS HAVE AT TIMES BE5 MU* MORE REVOLUTION>Y 7& SO1 TO ME1 MORE 9T]E/+7 ?AN ,I ORIG9ALLY SUPPOS$4 ,:ILE ?IS DISCOV]Y DIDN'T TRANS=M ME 9TO A PATRIOT1 AS MY ANTI-,GULF ,W> ACTIVITIES DEMON/RATE 7,BLACK #a#i#i#b3 *4 #i71 IT DID K9DLE A SYMPA!TIC 9T]E/ 9 ,AM]ICAN HI/ORY :I* ,I AM /ILL PURSU+4 ,AN>*Y IS AT ONCE V]Y MU* AN ELABORATION ( C]TA9 ,AM]ICAN VALUES & AT ! SAME TIME ANTI!TICAL TO C]TA9 O!RS4 ,SO IT MAKES NO S5SE = ,AM]ICAN AN>*I/S TO BE PRO-,AM]ICAN OR ANTI-,AM]ICAN4 ,!Y %\LD BE !MSELVES -- !IR ONE 9DISPUTABLE >EA ( EXP]TIZE -- & SEE :AT ?AT LEADS TO4 ,PO/-LEFTI/ AN>*Y IS POSITION$ TO >TICULATE -- NOT A PROGRAM -- BUT A NUMB] ( REVOLUTION>Y !MES ) CONTEMPOR>Y RELEVANCE & RESONANCE4 ,IT IS1 UNLIKE ,BOOK*9ISM1 UNAMBIGU\SLY ANTI-POLITICAL1 & MANY PEOPLE >E ANTI-POLITICAL4 ,IT IS1 UNLIKE ,BOOK*9ISM1 H$ONI/IC1 & MANY PEOPLE FAIL TO SEE :Y LIFE IS NOT TO BE LIV$ 5JOYABLY IF IT IS TO BE LIV$ AT ALL4 ,IT IS1 UNLIKE ,BOOK*9ISM1 09DIVIDUALI/IC0 9 ! S5SE ?AT IF ! FRE$OM & HAPP9ESS ( ! 9DIVIDUAL -- I4E41 EA* & EV]Y REALLY EXI/+ P]SON1 EV]Y ,TOM1 ,DICK & ,MURRAY -- IS NOT ! MEASURE ( ! GOOD SOCIETY1 :AT IS8 ,MANY PEOPLE WOND] :AT'S WRONG ) WANT+ TO BE HAPPY4 ,PO/-LEFTI/ AN>*Y IS1 UNLIKE ,BOOK*9ISM1 IF NOT NECESS>ILY REJECTIVE1 !N AT LEA/ SUSPICI\S ( ! *RONICALLY UNFULFILL$ LIB]ATORY PROMISE ( HI< TE*NOLOGY4 ,& MAYBE MO/ IMPORTANT ( ALL IS ! MASSIVE REVULSION AGA9/ WORK1 AN 9/ITUTION :I* HAS BECOME LESS & LESS IMPORTANT TO ,BOOK*9 AT ! SAME TIME IT'S BECOME MORE & MORE IMPORTANT1 & OPPRESSIVE1 TO PEOPLE \TSIDE ACADEMIA :O ACTUALLY HAVE TO WORK4 ,MO/ PEOPLE W\LD RA!R DO LESS WORK ?AN ATT5D MORE MEET+S4 ,:I* IS TO SAY1 MO/ PEOPLE >E SM>T]1 & SAN]1 ?AN ,MURRAY ,BOOK*9 IS4 ,PO/-LEFTI/ AN>*I/S MO/LY DON'T REG>D \R TIMES ONE-DIM5SIONALLY1 AS EI!R A 0DECAD5T1 B\RGEOISIFI$ ]A0 7#a7 ( 0SOCIAL REACTION0 7#i7 OR AS ! DAWN+ ( ! ,AGE ( ,AQU>IUS4 ,!Y T5D T[>D PESSIMISM1 BUT NOT USUALLY AS MU* AS ! ,DEAN DOES4 ,! SY/EM1 UN/ABLE AS EV]1 NEV] CEASES TO CREATE CONDITIONS :I* UND]M9E IT4 ,ITS SELF-9FLICT$ W\NDS AWAIT \R SALT4 ,IF Y\ DON'T BELIEVE 9 PROGRESS1 IT'LL NEV] DISAPPO9T Y\ & Y\ MITICUL>S1 -- AS ,I'VE COME TO APPRECIATE1 SOME:AT TO MY SURPRISE1 9 WRIT+ ?IS ESSAY1 -- TRADITIONAL AN>*I/ !MES & PRACTICES >E MORE ATTUN$ TO POPUL> PR$ILECTIONS ?AN EV] BE=E4 ,MO/ ,AM]ICANS HAVE JO9$ !M1 = 9/ANCE1 9 AB/5TION FROM ELECTIONS1 & !Y JU/ MI*I/S' REASONS4 ,CLASS CONFLICT AT ! PO9T ( PRODUCTION HOLDS LITTLE 9T]E/ = CAMPUS-BAS$ ,BOOK*9I/-,>5DTI/ CIVILOGUES1 BUT MEANS MU* TO PO/-COLLEGE WORK]S R$UC$1 = ! DURATION1 TO ! DEGRADATION !Y BRIEFLY ?\Y ,AUTONOM\S ,ZONE1 AS IT W]E7 SU* AS !Y MAY NEV] 5JOY AGA91 NO MATT] H[ MU* !Y E>N4 ,!Y MAY HAVE LE>N$ JU/ 5\< ALONG ! WAY TO QUE/ION :E!R LIFE HAS TO BE ?IS WAY4 ,BUT ! NEW !MES ( ! ,NEW ,AN>*ISM1 OR1 BETT] YET1 ! ,NEW ,AN>*ISMS ALSO HAVE POPUL> APPEAL -- NOT BECAUSE !Y P&] TO PREVAL5T ILLUSIONS BUT BECAUSE !Y P&] 7& :Y NOT87 TO PREVAL5T DISILLUSIONS4 ,) TE*NOLOGY1 = 9/ANCE4 ,A POLITICAL CRITIQUE ( TE*NOLOGY MAY MAKE A LOT ( S5SE TO ! T5D]S ( HI< TE*NOLOGY :O HAVE NOT EXP]I5C$ ANY?+ ( ITS LIB]ATORY POT5TIAL AS SO (T5 PROMIS$ BUT NEV] DELIV]$ BY ! PROGRESSIVES1 BY ! ,M>XI/S1 SYNDICALI/S1 ,BOOK*9I/S & O!R TE*NOCRATS4 ,AT ! V]Y LEA/1 TRICKLE-D[N TE*NO-LIB]ATION IS AS FRAUDUL5T AS TRICKLE-D[N 5RI*M5T ?R\< SUPPLY-SIDE ECONOMICS 7MAKE ! ALREADY RI* SO MU* RI*] ?AT SOME CRUMBS >E B\ND TO FALL FROM !IR TABLE74 ,COMPUT] PROGRAMM+ IS1 IF MORE 9T]E/+1 LITTLE MORE LIB]ATORY ?AN DATA 5TRY1 & ! H\RS >E LONG]4 ,!RE'S NO LIPAL TUNNEL4 ,) :ATEV] ELEM5TS ! ,NEW ,AN>*ISMS >E COMP\ND$ & :ATEV] !IR =TUNES WILL BE1 ! OLD AN>*ISM -- ! LIB]T>IAN FR+E ( ! ,LEFT ,?AT ,WAS -- IS F9I%$4 ,! ,BOOK*9I/ BLIP WAS A CONJUNCTURAL QUIRK1 AN ANOMAL\S AMALGAM ( ! OLD AN>*ISM & ! ,NEW ,LEFT TO :I* ! ,DEAN-TO-BE =TUIT\SLY ADD$ A LITTLE POP ECOLOGY & 7?IS P>T PASS$ UNNOTIC$ = F> TOO LONG7 HIS WEIRD CITY-/ATI/ FETI%4 ,N[ ,BOOK*9 BELAT$LY BUMBLES =? AS ! DEF5D] ( ! FAI?1 ?AT OLD-TIME RELIGION4 ,AN>*ISM-AS-,BOOK*9ISM WAS A CONFUSIONI/ EPISODE EV5 HE1 ITS FABRICATOR1 SEEMS TO BE 9 HA/E TO CONCLUDE4 ,IF ! WORD 0DECAD5CE0 MEANS ANY?+1 ,SOCIAL ,AN>*ISM OR ,LIFE/YLE ,AN>*ISM IS AN EX]CISE 9 DECAD5CE1 NOT TO M5TION AN EX]CISE 9 FUTILITY4 ,IF ! WORD MEANS ANY?+1 IT MEANS A DET]IORATION FROM A PREVI\S HI<] LEVEL ( ACCOMPLI%M5T -- IT MEANS DO+ WORSE :AT WAS =M]LY DONE BETT]4 ,9 ?AT S5SE1 ! ,NEW ,AN>*ISMS ( ! 0LIFE/YLE AN>*I/S0 CANNOT BE DECAD5T1 = :AT !Y >E DO+ IS AT BE/1 SOME?+ BETT]1 & AT WOR/1 SOME?+ DIFF]5T FROM :AT ! OLD-/YLE LEFT-W+ AN>*I/S DID4 ,BOOK*9 IS NOT EV5 DO+ :AT ,BOOK*9 ONCE DID1 IF NEV] V]Y WELL1 !N AT LEA/ A LOT BETT]4 ,)9 AN>*ISM1 :AT IS TAK+ PLACE RESEMBLES :AT1 9 SCI5CE1 IS KN[N AS A P>ADIGM %IFT 7,KUHN #a#i#g74 ,A P>ADIGM IS AN OV]>*+ FRAME ( REF]5CE1 SOME?+ BROAD] ?AN A !ORY 7OR IDEOLOGY71 :I* DIRECTS ! DEVELOPM5T ( ?\ADIGM4 ,?AT ?IS IS A SOME:AT CIRCUL> =MULATION ITS ORIG9ATOR ADMITS 7IBID43 #a#g#f71 BUT TRU? IS CIRCUL>1 AN 9ESCAPABLE H]M5EUTIC CIRCLE BUT ONE :OSE DIAMET] WE CAN WID5 ALONG ) \R P]SPECTIVES4 ,! DETAILS &1 = ?AT MATT]1 ! DEFICI5CIES ( ,KUHN'S MU*-DISCUSS$ MODEL ( SCI5TIFIC !ORY & PRACTICE NE$ NOT DETA9 US H]E 7AL?\< ,I COMM5D !M TO AN>*I/S CAPABLE ( MORE MUSCUL> ?9K+ ?AN ,BOOK*9 & MO/ O!R AN>*O-EGE UP =74 ,H]E ,I'M DRAW+ ATT5TION TO JU/ TWO ASPECTS ( ?IS HI/ORICAL APPROA* TO EXPLA9+ !ORETICAL ?9K+ :I* ,I F9D SUGGE/IVE4 ,! FIR/ IS ! NOTION ( 0NORMAL SCI5CE10 :I* REF]S TO ! EV]YDAY PRACTICE ( WORKADAY SCI5TI/S3 ! WORK+-\T ( ! IMPLICATIONS ( ! PREVAIL+ P>ADIGM4 ,NEWTON'S PHYSICS1 = 9/ANCE1 KEPT OBS]VATIONAL A/RONOM]S & EXP]IM5TAL PHYSICI/S HAPPY1 OR AT LEA/ BUSY1 = OV] TWO HUNDR$ YE>S3 IT ASSIGN$ !M PROBLEMS TO SOLVE & CRIT]IA = :AT C\NT$ AS SOLUTIONS TO ?OSE PROBLEMS4 ,! CLASSICAL AN>*ISM ( ,GODW91 ,PR\DHON1 ,BAKUN9 & ESPECIALLY ,KROPOTK9 MAY BE ?\*I/ POLITICAL P>ADIGM4 ,= ALL !IR DIFF]5CES1 TOGE!R !Y FURNI%$ MANY ANSW]S & A CONTEXT = DEVELOP+ MANY MORE4 ,LAT] FIGURES LIKE ,MALATE/A1 ,GOLDMAN1 ,B]KMAN1 ! AN>*O-SYNDICALI/S1 & ! 9TELLECTUALS WRIT+ = ,FRE$OM 9 EFFECT 5GAG$ 9 0NORMAL AN>*ISM0 -- 9 RE/AT+1 ELABORAT+1 UPDAT+ & 9 DETAILS AM5D+ ! P>ADIGM4 ,M5 LIKE ,H]B]T ,READ1 ,GEORGE ,WOODCOCK1 ,ALEX ,COM=T & ,PAUL ,GOODMAN WORK$ )9 ?IS TRADITION 9 ! 9CLEM5T CLIMATE ( ! '#dS & '#eS4 ,9 *>ACT]IZ+ !IR ACTIVITY AS D]IVATIVE ,I AM BY NO MEANS D5IGRAT+ IT1 OR !M4 ,PRECISELY BECAUSE ! CLASSICAL P>ADIGM WAS RI* 9 POT5TIAL1 9TELLIG5T AN>*I/S HAVE DRAWN FRE% 9SIADIGM4 ,TOO MANY 0ANOMALIES10 AS ,KUHN CALLS !M1 HAVE APPE>$ TO BE RECONCIL$ ) ! P>ADIGM )\T 9CREAS+ /RA9 & A DEEP5+ S5SE ( >TIFICIALITY4 ,CLASSICAL AN>*ISM1 LIKE LEFTISM 9 G5]AL1 IS PLAY$ \T4 ,MURRAY ,BOOK*91 :OM SOME AN>*I/S ONCE MI/OOK = ! FIR/ !ORI/ ( A NEW AN>*I/ P>ADIGM1 HAS N[ COME =? EXPLICITLY AS ! LA/ *AMPION ( ! OLD ONE1 ! AN>*I/ TAIL ( :AT HE CALLS ! ,LEFT ,?AT ,WAS4 ,ONE O!R SUGGE/IVE FEATURE ( ,KUHN'S >GUM5T IS HIS ACC\NT ( H[1 ON ! GR\ND1 ! SUPPLANT+ ( ONE P>ADIGM BY ANO!R ACTUALLY TAKES PLACE3 ,:51 9 ! DEVELOPM5T ( A NATURAL SCI5CE1 AN 9DIVIDUAL OR GR\P FIR/ PRODUCES A SYN!SIS ABLE TO ATTRACT MO/ ( ! NEXT G5]ATION'S PRACTITION]S .1 ! OLD] S*OOLS GRADUALLY DISAPPE>4 ,9 P>T !IR DISAPPE>ANCE IS CAUS$ BY !IR MEMB]S' CONV]SION TO ! NEW P>ADIGM4 ,BUT !RE >E ALWAYS SOME M5 :O CL+ TO ONE OR ANO!R ( ! OLD] VIEWS1 & !Y >E SIMPLY READ \T ( ! PR(ESSION1 :I* !REAFT] IGNORES !IR WORK 7,KUHN #a#i#g3 #a#h-#a#i74 ,KUHN GOES ON TO EXPLA9 ?AT ?IS MAY 9VOLVE 9TRANSIG5T 9DIVIDUALS1 0MORE 9T]E/+1 H[EV]1 IS ! 5DURANCE ( :OLE S*OOLS 9 9CREAS+ ISOLATION FROM PR(ESSIONAL SCI5CE4 ,CONSID]1 = EXAMPLE1 ! CASE ( A/ROLOGY1 :I* WAS ONCE AN 9TEGRAL P>T ( A/RONOMY0 7IBID43 #ai N4 #a#a74 ,NOT TO PRET5D ?AT AN>*ISM IS A SCI5CE -- SU* A PRET5SE IS ITSELF A P>T ( ! OBSOLETE P>ADIGM -- BUT ! ANALOGY IS ILLUM9AT+4 ,AS ,BOOK*9 ADMITS1 & DEPLORES1 0?\S&S0 ( AN>*I/S1 0! NEXT G5]ATION'S PRACTITION]S0 ( AN>*ISM1 >E 9CREAS+LY AB&ON+ SOCIAL AN>*ISM = LIFE/YLE AN>*ISM4 ,SOME ( ! OLD] S*OOL'S PRACTITION]S CONV]T1 AS HAS 9DE$ HAPP5$4 ,O!R ONCE-PROM95T FIGURES1 AS ,KUHN NOTIC$ 7IBID471 M>G9ALIZE !MSELVES AS ! ,DEAN HAS N[ DONE4 ,& TO CL9* ! COMP>ISON1 :AT W]E ONCE 09TEGRAL P>TS0 ( AN>*ISM >E ON ! V]GE ( SPLITT+ (F ON !IR [N AS DID A/ROLOGY FROM A/RONOMY SO AS TO HAVE ANY HOPE ( SURVIV+ AT ALL4 ,BOOK*9ISM1 0SOCIAL ECOLOGY10 WAS NEV] AN 9TEGRAL P>T ( AN>*ISM1 = ALL ! ,DEAN'S EF=TS TO MAKE IT SO4 ,IF IT P]SI/S A:ILE AFT] ! ,DEAN'S DEMISE1 SOCIAL ECOLOGY_/AN>*ISM WILL BE> AB\T ! SAME RELATION%IP TO ! NEW AN>*ISM AS A/ROLOGY TO A/RONOMY4 ,AS WILL1 ,I EXPECT1 ! DW9DL+ AN>*O-LEFTI/ FUNDAM5TALISMS4 ,( !SE !RE W\LD SEEM TO BE ONLY ?REE4 ,! FIR/ IS ! SUPPOS$ PURE-&-SIMPLE AN>*ISM (1 SAY1 ,F]D ,WOODWOR? ( ,! ,MAT*6 OR ! LATE UNLAM5T$ ,BOB ,%EA4 ,! 9H]5T IMPROBABILITY ( A SOCIALLY & ECONOMICALLY AGNO/IC AN>*ISM -- LET'S ABOLI% ! /ATE & LAT] SORT \T ! TRIFL+ DETAILS1 SU* AS \R WAY ( LIFE -- AS WELL AS ! %E] CRACKPOTK9ISM ( ITS VE/IGIAL DEVOTEES 7,BLACK #a#i#i#d3 #d#b-#d#d7 RELEGATE ?IS FUNDAM5TALISM TO IMM95T OBLIVION4 ,EV5 ,BOOK*9 W\LD BE EMB>RASS$ TO BE ASSOCIAT$ ) IT4 ,A ,M>XI/ IS CAPABLE ( MANY ]RORS & MANY HORRORS1 & USUALLY COMMITS SOME1 BUT ONE ?+ A ,M>XI/ CANNOT BE 9DIFF]5T TO IS POLITICAL ECONOMY & ! SOCIAL RELATIONS ( PRODUCTION4 ,! SECOND OBSOLETE AN>*O-LEFTISM IS AN>*O- SYNDICALISM4 ,AL?\< IT IS A WORK]I/ IDEOLOGY1 ITS FEW WORK+-CLASS ADH]5TS >E ELD]LY4 ,AL?\< IT IS BY DEF9ITION A UNION-ORI5T$ IDEOLOGY1 !RE IS NO P]CEPTIBLE SYNDICALI/ PRES5CE 9 ANY UNION4 ,A SYNDICALI/ IS MORE LIKELY TO BE A PR(ESSOR ?AN A PROLET>IAN1 MORE LIKELY TO BE A FOLK S+] ?AN A FACTORY WORK]4 ,ORGANIZ]S ON PR9CIPLE1 SYNDICALI/S >E DISUNIT$ & FACTIONALIZ$4 ,REM>KABLY1 ?IS DULLE/ ( ALL AN>*ISMS ATTRACTS SOME ( ! MO/ IRRATIONAL & HY/]ICAL ADH]5TS4 ,ONLY A RA!R SMALL M9ORITY ( ,NOR? ,AM]ICAN AN>*I/S >E SYNDICALI/S4 ,SYNDICALISM WILL P]SI/1 IF AT ALL1 AS A CAMPUS-BAS$ CULT 9 9CREAS+ ISOLATION FROM ! MA9 CURR5TS ( AN>*ISM4 ,! ?IRD AN>*O-LEFTISM IS AN>*O-FEM9ISM4 ,! CATEGORY IS1 ,I ADMIT1 QUE/IONABLE4 ,SO-CALL$ RADICAL FEM9ISM IS LEFTI/ 9 ORIG9 BUT EXTREME RIATI/ 9 T5D5CY & SOMETIMES 9 PR9CIPLE1 AN>*O-FEM9ISM IS ORI5T$ MU* MORE T[>D /ATI/ FEM9ISM ?AN AN>*ISM4 ,IT IS ALREADY WELL ON ITS WAY T[>D 5CAPSULATION & ISOLATION FROM ! AN>*ISMS4 ,! FEM9I/ PRES5CE 9 AN>*ISM IS MORE APP>5T ?AN REAL4 ,MANY AN>*I/ WOM5 CALL !MSELVES FEM9I/S FROM =CE ( HABIT OR BECAUSE !Y ?9K ?AT BY NOT SO ID5TIFY+ !MSELVES !Y SOMEH[ UND]M9E ?OSE WOM5 :O DO4 ,BUT !RE IS LITTLE IF ANY?+ DI/9CTIVELY FEM9I/1 =TUNATELY1 9 ! AN>*ISM ( MO/ NOM9AL AN>*O-FEM9I/S4 ,FEM9ISM IS SO OBVI\SLY AN ,E/ABLI%M5T IDEOLOGY & SO REMOTE FROM ITS 7L>GELY MY?ICAL7 RADICAL ROOTS ?AT ITS AFFIRMATION BY AN>*I/S WILL BECOME EV] MORE P]FUNCTORY4 ,LIKE LEFTISM1 FEM9ISM IS A NE$LESS LIABILITY = AN>*I/S4 ,!RE IS LIFE AFT] ! LEFT4 ,& !RE IS AN>*Y AFT] AN>*ISM4 ,PO/-LEFTI/ AN>*I/S >E /RIK+ (F 9 MANY DIRECTIONS4 ,SOME MAY F9D ! WAY -- BETT] YET1 ! WAYS -- TO A FREE FUTURE4 O ,REF]5CES ,REF]5CES ,ADAMS1 ,ROB]T ,M4 7#a#i#h#c74 ,DECAD5T ,SOCIETIES4 ,SAN ,FRANCISCO1 ,C,A3 ,NOR? ,PO9T ,PRESS ,ADORNO1 ,!ODOR ,W4 7#a#i#i74 0,PUNCTUATION ,M>KS40 ,! ,ANTIO* ,REVIEW 7,SUMM]73 #c-#c#e ,&RIEUX1 ,MAURICE 7#a#i#g#b74 ,DAILY ,LIFE 9 ,V5ICE 9 ! ,TIME ( ,CASANOVA4 ,NEW ,YORK @& ,WA%+TON1 ,D,C3 ,PRAEG] ,PUBLI%] .<,ANONYM\S.> 7#a#i#h#h74 ,REVIEW ( ,! ,RISE ( ,URBANIZATION & ! ,DECL9E ( ,CITIZ5%IP1 BY ,MURRAY ,BOOK*94 ,ORBIS3 ,A ,J\RNAL ( ,WORLD ,AFFAIRS #cb 7,FALL73 #fbh .<,ANONYM\S.> 7#a#i#i#f74 ,REVIEW ( ,SOCIAL ,AN>*ISM OR ,LIFE/YLE ,AN>*ISM3 ,AN ,UNBRIDGEABLE ,*ASM1 BY ,MURRAY ,BOOK*94 ,GRE5 ,AN>*I/ #db 7,SUMM]73 #b#b-#b#c ,ANSELL-,PE>SON1 ,KEI? 7#a#i#i#d74,AN ,9TRODUCTION TO ,NIETZS*E AS ,POLITICAL ,?9K]3 ,! ,P]FECT ,NIHILI/4 ,CAMBRIDGE3 ,CAMBRIDGE ,UNIV]SITY ,PRESS ,APT]1 ,DAVID ,E41 @& ,JAMES ,JOLL1 $S4 7#a#i#g#b74 ,AN>*ISM ,TODAY4 ,G>D5 ,CITY1 ,N,Y3 ,AN*OR ,BOOKS ,>5DT1 ,HANNAH 7#a#i#e#h74 ,! ,HUMAN ,CONDITION4 ,*ICAGO1 ,I,L @& ,LONDON3 ,UNIV]SITY ( ,*ICAGO ,PRESS ,AVRI*1 ,PAUL 7#a#i#h#d74 ,! ,HAYM>KET ,TRAG$Y4 ,PR9CETON1 ,N,J3 ,PR9CETON ,UNIV]SITY ,PRESS ,BABBIE1 ,E>L 7#a#i#i#b74 ,! ,PRACTICE ( ,SOCIAL ,RESE>*4 ,SIX? ,$ITION4 ,BELMONT1 ,C,A3 ,WADSWOR? ,PUBLI%+ ,COMPANY ,BAILYN1 ,B]N>D 7#a#i#i#b74 ,! ,IDEOLOGICAL ,ORIG9S ( ! ,AM]ICAN ,REVOLUTION4 ,5L>G$ ,$ITION4 ,CAMBRIDGE3 ,H>V>D ,UNIV]SITY ,PRESS ,BAKUN91 ,MI*AEL 7#a#i#i74 ,/ATISM & ,AN>*Y4 ,$IT$ BY ,M>%ALL ,%ATZ4 ,CAMBRIDGE3 ,CAMBRIDGE ,UNIV]SITY ,PRESS ,BEALS1 ,RALPH ,L4 7#a#i#f#i74 ,POLITICS ( ,SOCIAL ,RESE>*3 ,AN ,9QUIRY 9TO ! ,E?ICS & ,RESPONSIBILITIES ( ,SOCIAL ,SCI5TI/S4 ,*ICAGO1 ,I,L3 ,ALD9E ,PUBLI%+ ,COMPANY ,B5B[1 ,WILLIAM 7N4D474 ,GR& ,NATIONAL ,HOLIDAY & ,CONGRESS ( ! ,PRODUCTIVE ,CLASSES4 ,$IT$ BY ,S,A4 ,BU%ELL4 ,LONDON3 ,PELAGIAN ,PRESS ,BEY1 ,HAKIM 7#a#i#i#a74 ,T4,A4,Z43 ,! ,TEMPOR>Y ,AUTONOM\S ,ZONE1 ,ONTOLOGICAL ,AN>*ISM1 ,POETIC ,T]RORISM4 ,BROOKLYN1 ,N,Y3 ,AUTONOM$IA ,B9=D1 ,LEWIS ,R41 @& ,W4,J4 ,*A/O1 ,JR4 7#a#i#g#f74 0,NUNAMIUT ,DEMOGRAPHIC ,HI/ORY3 ,A ,PROVOCATIVE ,CASE40 ,9 ,ZUBR[ 7#a#i#g#f71 PP4 #f#c-#a#d#c ,B9=D1 ,SALLY ,R4 7#a#i#f#h74 0,E?NOGRAPHIC ,DATA & ,UND]/&+ ! ,PLEI/OC5E40 ,9 ,LEE @& ,DE,VORE 7#a#i#f#hA71 PP4 #b#g#d-#b#g#e ,BLACK1 ,BOB 7#a#i#h#f74 ,! ,ABOLITION ( ,WORK & ,O!R ,ESSAYS4 ,PORT ,T[NS5D1 ,W,A3 ,LOOMPANICS ,UNLIMIT$ -- 7#a#i#i#b74 ,FRI5DLY ,FIRE4 ,BROOKLYN1 ,N,Y3 ,AUTONOM$IA -- 7#a#i#i#d74 ,B5EA? ! ,UND]GR\ND4 ,PORTL&1 ,O,R3 ,F]AL ,H\SE -- 7#a#i#i#fA74 0,TE*NOPHILIA1 ,AN ,9FANTILE ,DISORD]40 ,GRE5 ,AN>*I/ #db 7,SUMM]73 #a#c-#a#e -- 7#a#i#i#fB74 0,:AT'S ,WRONG ,) ,?IS ,PICTURE80 ,EXQUISITE ,CORPSE #e#g3 #d#c-#d#e -- 7#a#i#i#fC74 ,UNPUBLI%$ REVIEW ( ,GR& ,NATIONAL ,HOLIDAY & ,CONGRESS ( ! ,PRODUCTIVE ,CLASSES1 BY ,WILLIAM ,B5B[ -- 7#a#i#i#fD74 0,Z]O ,WORK40 ,SMALL ,MAGAZ9E ,REVIEW #b#h7#f7 7,JUNE73 #bb -- 1 @& ,MIKE ,GUND]LOY 7#a#i#i#b74 0,NEO-,9DIVIDUALISM ,RECONSID]$40 ,9 ,BLACK 7#a#i#i#b71 PP4 #a#i#i-#b#a -- 1 @& ,ADAM ,P>FREY1 $S4 7#a#i#h#i74 ,RANTS & ,9C5DI>Y ,TRACTS3 ,VOICES ( ,DESP]ATE ,ILLUM9ATION1 #aeeh TO ,PRES5T4 ,NEW ,YORK3 ,AMOK ,PRESS @& ,PORT ,T[NS5D1 ,W,A3 ,LOOMPANICS ,UNLIMIT$ ,BLACK1 ,ROB]T ,C4 .<,BOB ,BLACK.> 7#a#i#h#e74 0,! ,HEAV5LY ,CITY ( ! #b?-,C5TURY ,POLITICAL ,PHILOSOPH]3 ,WALZ] ON ,JUDG+40 ,LEGAL ,/UDIES ,=UM #i7#c73 #b#e#i-#b#g#i ,BLA9EY1 ,GE(FREY 7#a#i#g#f74 ,TRIUMPH ( ! ,NOMADS3 ,A ,HI/ORY ( ,ABORIG9AL ,AU/RALIA4 ,WOOD/OCK1 ,N,Y3 ,OV]LOOK ,PRESS ,BOLLOT51 ,BURNETT 7#a#i#i#a74 ,! ,SPANI% ,CIVIL ,W>4 ,*APEL ,HILL1 ,N,C3 ,UNIV]SITY ( ,NOR? ,C>OL9A ,PRESS ,BOOK*91 ,MURRAY 7#a#i#g74 0,! ,Y\? ,CULTURE3 ,AN ,AN>*O- ,COMMUNI/ ,VIEW40 ,9 ,HIP ,CULTURE3 ,SIX ,ESSAYS ON ,ITS ,REVOLUTION>Y ,POT5TIAL 7,NEW ,YORK3 ,TIMES ,*ANGE ,PRESS71 PP4 #e#a-#f#c -- 7#a#i#g#a74 ,PO/-,SC>CITY ,AN>*ISM4 ,B]KELEY1 ,C,A3 ,! ,RAMP>TS ,PRESS -- 7#a#i#g#d74 ,! ,LIMITS ( ! ,CITY4 ,NEW ,YORK3 ,H>P] @& ,R[ ,COLOPHON ,BOOKS -- 7#a#i#g#g74 ,! ,SPANI% ,AN>*I/S3 ,! ,H]OIC ,YE>S1 #a#h#f#h-#a#i#c#f4 ,NEW ,YORK3 ,FREE ,LIFE ,$ITIONS1 #aigg -- 7#a#i#g#i74 0,M>XISM AS ,B\RGEOIS ,SOCIOLOGY40 ,\R ,G5]ATION #a#c7#c7 7,SUMM]73 #b#a-#b#h -- 7#a#i#h#b74 ,! ,ECOLOGY ( ,FRE$OM3 ,! ,EM]G5CE & ,DISSOLUTION ( ,HI]>*Y4 ,PALO ,ALTO1 ,C,A3 ,*E%IRE ,BOOKS -- 7#a#i#h#gA74 ,! ,RISE ( ,URBANIZATION & ! ,DECL9E ( ,CITIZ5%IP4 ,SAN ,FRANCISCO1 ,C,A3 ,SI]RA ,CLUB ,BOOKS -- 7#a#i#h#gB74 0,?9K+ ,ECOLOGICALLY3 ,A ,DIALECTICAL ,APPROA*40 #a#h7#b7 ,\R ,G5]ATION 7,M>*73 #c-#d -- 7#a#i#h#i74 ,REMAK+ ,SOCIETY4 ,MONTREAL1 ,CANADA @& ,NEW ,YORK3 ,BLACK ,ROSE ,BOOKS -- 7#a#i#i74 0,RADICAL ,POLITICS 9 AN ,]A ( ,ADVANC$ ,CAPITALISM40 ,\R ,G5]ATION #b#a7#b7 7,JUNE73 #a-#a#b -- 7#a#i#i#a74 ,ECOLOGY ( ,FRE$OM3 ,! ,EM]G5CE & ,DISSOLUTION ( ,HI]>*Y4 ,REVIS$ ,$ITION4 ,MONTREAL1 ,CANADA3 ,BLACK ,ROSE ,BOOKS -- 7#a#i#i#d74 ,TO ,REMEMB] ,SPA93 ,! ,AN>*I/ & ,SYNDICALI/ ,REVOLUTION ( #a#i#c#f4 ,$9BUR<1 ,SCOTL& @& ,SAN ,FRANCISCO1 ,C,A3 ,A,K ,PRESS -- 7#a#i#i#f74 0,AN>*ISM3 ,PA/ & ,PRES5T40 ,9 ,EHRLI* 7#a#i#i#f71 PP4 #a#i-#c ,BOYD1 ,ROB]T1 @& ,PET] ,J4 ,RI*]SON 7#a#i#i#c74 0,CULTURE & ,HUMAN ,EVOLUTION40 ,9 ,RASMUSS5 7#a#i#i#c71 PP4 #a#a#i-#a#c#d ,BORK5AU1 ,FRANZ 7#a#i#f#c74 ,! ,SPANI% ,COCKPIT4 ,ANN ,>BOR1 ,M,I3 ,UNIV]SITY ( ,MI*IGAN ,PRESS1 ,ANN ,>BOR ,PAP]BACKS ,BRADEMAS1 ,/EPH5 ,JOHN 7#a#i#e#c74 0,REVOLUTION & ,SOCIAL ,REVOLUTION3 ,A ,CONTRIBUTION TO ! ,HI/ORY ( ! ,AN>*O-,SYNDICALI/ ,MOVEM5T 9 ,SPA93 #a#i#c-#a#i#c#g40 ,PH4,D DISS]TATION1 ,UNIV]SITY ( ,OX=D ,BRAD=D1 ,GEORGE 7#a#i#i#f74 0,M$IA3 ,CAPITAL'S ,GLOBAL ,VILLAGE40 ,9 ,EHRLI* 7#a#i#i#f71 PP4 #b#e#h-#b#g#a ,BR\E1 ,PI]RE1 @& ,EMILE ,TEMIME 7#a#i#g#b74 ,! ,REVOLUTION & ! ,CIVIL ,W> 9 ,SPA94 ,CAMBRIDGE3 ,M,I,T ,PRESS ,BR[N1 ,L4 ,SUSAN 7#a#i#i#c74 ,! ,POLITICS ( ,9DIVIDUALISM3 ,LIB]ALISM1 ,LIB]AL ,FEM9ISM & ,AN>*ISM4 ,MONTREAL1 ,CANADA3 ,BLACK ,ROSE ,BOOKS -- 7#a#i#i#e74 0,DOES ,WORK ,REALLY ,WORK80 ,KICK ,IT ,OV] #c#e3 #a#d- #ag ,CAMATTE1 ,JACQUES 7#a#i#i#e74 ,?IS ,WORLD ,WE ,MU/ ,LEAVE & ,O!R ,ESSAYS 4 ,$IT$ BY ,ALEX ,TROTT]4 ,BROOKLYN1 ,N,Y3 ,AUTONOM$IA ,CL>K1 ,JOHN 7#a#i#h#b74 ,REVIEW ( ,T[>D AN ,ECOLOGICAL ,SOCIETY1 BY ,MURRAY ,BOOK*94 ,\R ,G5]ATION #a#h7#b7 7,SUMM]73 #e#b-#e#i -- 7#a#i#h#d74 ,! ,AN>*I/ ,MOM5T3 ,REFLECTIONS ON ,CULTURE1 ,NATURE & ,P[]4 ,MONTREAL1 ,CANADA3 ,BLACK ,ROSE ,BOOKS -- 7#a#i#i74 0,BOOK*91 ,MURRAY 7B4 #a#i#b#a740 ,5CYCLOP$IA ( ! ,AM]ICAN ,LEFT1 $4 ,M>I ,JO ,BUHLE1 ,PAUL ,BUHLE @& ,DAN ,GEORGAKAS4 ,NEW ,YORK @& ,LONDON3 ,G>L& ,PUBLICATIONS ,COH51 ,M>K ,N4 7#a#i#h#g74 0,! ,SIGNIFICANCE ( ,LONG-,T]M ,*ANGES 9 ,HUMAN ,DIET & ,FOOD ,ECONOMY40 ,9 ,H>RIS @& ,ROSS 7#a#i#h#g71 PP4 #b#f#a-#b#h#c ,COH51 ,M4,N41 @& ,G4,S4 ,>MELAGOS1 $S4 7#a#i#h#d74 ,PALEOPA?OLOGY AT ! ,DAWN ( ,AGRICULTURE4 ,NEW ,YORK3 ,ACADEMIC ,PRESS ,COLB\RN1 ,H4 ,TREVOR 7#a#i#f#e74 ,! ,LAMP ( ,EXP]I5CE3 ,:IG ,HI/ORY & ! ,9TELLECTUAL ,ORIG9S ( ! ,AM]ICAN ,REVOLUTION4 ,*APEL ,HILL1 ,N,C3 ,UNIV]SITY ( ,NOR? ,C>OL9A ,PRESS ,CONKEY1 ,M>G>ET ,W4 7#a#i#h#d74 0,TO ,F9D ,\RSELVES3 ,>T & ,SOCIAL ,GEOGRAPHY ( ,PREHI/ORIC ,HUNT] ,GA!R]S40 ,9 ,S*R]E 7#a#i#h#d71 PP4 #b#e#c-#b#g#f ,COOKE1 ,JACOB ,E41 $4 7#a#i#f#a74 ,! ,F$]ALI/4 ,MIDDLET[N1 ,C,T3 ,WESLEYAN ,UNIV]SITY ,PRESS ,C[AN1 ,RU? ,S*W>TZ 7#a#i#g#d74 0,A ,CASE ,/UDY ( ,TE*NOLOGICAL ,*ANGE3 ,! ,WA%+ ,MA*9E & ! ,WORK+ ,WIFE40 ,9 ,H>TMAN @& ,BANN] 7#a#i#g#d71 PP4 #b#d#e-#b#e#c -- 7#a#i#h#c74 ,MORE ,WORK = ,MO!R3 ,! ,IRONY ( ,H\SEHOLD ,TE*NOLOGY FROM ! ,OP5 ,HE>? TO ! ,MICR[AVE4 ,NEW ,YORK3 ,BASIC ,BOOKS ,DAHL1 ,ROB]T ,A4 7#a#i#i74 ,AFT] ! ,REVOLUTION3 ,AU?ORITY 9 A ,GOOD ,SOCIETY4 ,REVIS$ ,$ITION4 ,NEW ,HAV51 ,C,T @& ,LONDON3 ,YALE ,UNIV]SITY ,PRESS ,DAMAS1 ,DAVID1 $4 7#a#i#f#i74 ,CONTRIBUTIONS TO ,AN?ROPOLOGY3 ,B& ,SOCIETIES4 ,OTTAWA1 ,CANADA3 ,NATIONAL ,MUSEUM ( ,CANADA ,DE ,LEON1 ,DAVID 7#a#i#g#h74 ,! ,AM]ICAN AS ,AN>*I/3 ,REFLECTIONS ON ,9DIG5\S ,RADICALISM4 ,BALTIMORE1 ,M,D @& ,LONDON3 ,! ,JOHNS ,HOPK9S ,UNIV]SITY ,PRESS -- 7#a#i#i#f74 0,= ,DEMOCRACY ,:]E ,WE ,WORK3 ,A ,RATIONALE = ,SELF-,MANAGEM5T0 ,9 ,EHRLI* 7#a#i#i#f71 PP4 #a#i#b-#b#a ,D5B[1 ,JAMES ,R4 7#a#i#h#d74 0,PREHI/ORIC ,H]D]S & ,=AG]S ( ! ,KALAH>I3 ,! ,EVID5CE = #ae ,YE>S ( ,9T]ACTION40 ,9 ,S*RIRE 7#a#i#h#d71 PP4 #a#g#e-#a#i#c ,D5EVAN1 ,WILLIAM 7#a#i#i#b74 0,! ,PRI/9E ,MY?3 ,! ,L&SCAPE ( ! ,AM]ICAS 9 #a#d#i#b0 ,ANNALS ( ! ,ASSOCIATION ( ,AM]ICAN ,GEOGRAPH]S #h#b3 #c#f#i-#c#h#e ,DUNN1 ,FR$]ICK ,L4 7#a#i#f#h74 0,EPIDEMOLOGICAL ,FACTORS3 ,HEAL? & ,DISEASE 9 ,HUNT]-,GA!R]S40 ,9 ,LEE @& ,DE,VORE 7#a#i#f#hA71 PP4 #b#b#a-#b#b#h ,ECK]SLEY1 ,ROBYN 7#a#i#h#i74 0,DIV9+ ,EVOLUTION3 ,! ,ECOLOGICAL ,E?ICS ( ,MURRAY ,BOOK*940 ,5VIRONM5TAL ,E?ICS #a#a7#b7 7,SUMM]73 #i#i-#a#a#f ,EHRLI*1 ,H[>D ,J41 $4 7#a#i#i#f74 ,RE9V5T+ ,AN>*Y1 ,AGA94 ,$9BUR<1 ,SCOTL& @& ,SAN ,FRANCISCO1 ,C,A3 ,A,K ,PRESS ,FEY]AB5D1 ,PAUL 7#a#i#g#e74 ,AGA9/ ,ME?OD3 ,\TL9E ( AN ,AN>*I/IC ,!ORY ( ,KN[L$GE4 ,LONDON3 ,N,L,B @& ,ATLANTIC ,HIEWELL TO ,REASON4 ,LONDON @& ,NEW ,YORK3 ,V]SO ,F9LAY1 ,M4,I4 7#a#i#e#i74 0,WAS ,GREEK ,CIVILIZATION ,BAS$ ON ,SLAVE ,LABOR80 ,HI/ORIA #h3 #a#d#e-#a#f#d -- 7#a#i#h#e74 ,DEMOCRACY ,ANCI5T & ,MOD]N4 ,SECOND ,$ITION4 ,LONDON3 ,! ,HOG>? ,PRESS ,FL9T1 ,R4,W41 $4 7#a#i#g#b74 ,M>9ETTI3 ,SELECT$ ,WRIT+S4 ,NEW ,YORK3 ,F>R]1 ,/RAUS @& ,GIR\X ,= ,\RSELVES 7#a#i#h#c74 ,! ,RI4 ,NEW ,YORK3 ,PAN!ON ,GILMAN1 ,RI*>D 7#a#i#g#e74 ,DECAD5CE4 ,NEW ,YORK3 ,F>R]1 ,/RAUS @& ,GIR\X ,GODD>D ,COLLEGE 7#a#i#i#e74 #aiie ,(F-,CAMPUS ,CATALOG4 ,PLA9FIELD1 ,V,T3 ,GODD>D ,COLLEGE -- 7#a#i#i#f74 ,ADD5DUM TO ,(F ,CAMPUS ,CATALOG4 ,PLA9FIELD1 ,V,T3 ,GODD>D ,COLLEGE ,GOODMAN1 ,PAUL 7#a#i#i#d74 ,CRAZY ,HOPE & ,F9ITE ,EXP]I5CE3 ,F9AL ,ESSAYS ( ,PAUL ,GOODMAN4 ,$IT$ BY ,TAYLOR ,/OEHR4 ,SAN ,FRANCISCO1 ,C,A3 ,JOSSEY-,BASS1 ,9C4 -- 1 @& ,P]CIVAL ,GOODMAN 7#a#i#f74 ,COMMUNITAS3 ,MEANS ( ,LIVELIHOOD & ,WAYS ( ,LIFE4 ,SECOND ,$ITION1 ,REVIS$4 ,NEW ,YORK3 ,V9TAGE ,BOOKS ,GORDON1 ,ROB]T ,J4 7#a#i#h#d74 0,! 6,KUNG 9 ! ,KALAH>I ,EX*ANGE3 ,AN ,E?NOHI/ORICAL ,P]SPECTIVE40 ,9 ,S*RIRE 7#a#i#h#d71 PP4 #a#i#e-#b#b#d ,GREGG1 ,SUSAN1 $4 7#a#i#i#a74 ,BETWE5 ,B&S & ,/ATES4 ,C>BONDALE1 ,I,L3 ,S\!RN ,UNIV]SITY ( ,ILL9OIS AT ,C>BONDALE ,H>RIS1 ,M>V91 @& ,]IC ,B4 ,ROSS1 $S4 7#a#i#h#g74 ,FOOD & ,EVOLUTION3 ,T[>D A ,!ORY ( ,HUMAN ,FOOD ,HABITS4 ,PHILADELPHIA1 ,P,A3 ,TEMPLE ,UNIV]SITY ,PRESS ,H>T1 ,JOHN ,M4 7#a#i#g#h74 ,AN>*ISM & ! ,MEXICAN ,WORK+ ,CLASS1 #a#h#f-#a#i#c#a4 ,AU/91 ,T,X @& ,LONDON3 ,U4 ( ,TEXAS ,PRESS ,H>TMAN1 ,M>Y ,S41 @& ,LOIS ,BANN]1 $S4 7#a#i#g#d74 ,CLIO'S ,CONSCI\SNESS ,RAIS$3 ,NEW ,P]SPECTIVES ON ! ,HI/ORY ( ,WOM54 ,NEW ,YORK3 ,H>P] @& ,R[ ,HA/RUP1 ,KIR/51 @& ,PET] ,H]VIK1 $S4 7#a#i#i#d74 ,SOCIAL ,EXP]I5CE & ,AN?ROPOLOGICAL ,KN[L$GE4 ,NEW ,YORK3 ,R\TL$GE ,HAWKES1 ,KRI/5 7#a#i#h#g74 0,H[ ,MU* ,FOOD ,DO ,=AG]S ,NE$80 ,9 ,H>RIS @& ,ROSS 7#a#i#h#g71 PP4 #c#d#a-#c#e#e ,H]B]1 ,LEWIS .<,MURRAY ,BOOK*9.> 7#a#i#f#c74 ,\R ,SYN!TIC ,5VIRONM5T -- .<,MURRAY ,BOOK*9.> 7#a#i#f#e74 ,CRISIS 9 ,\R ,CITIES4 ,5GLEWOOD ,CLIFFS1 ,N4,J43 ,PR5TICE-,HALL ,HOLTON1 ,G]ALD 7#a#i#i#c74 ,SCI5CE & ,ANTI-,SCI5CE4 ,CAMBRIDGE3 ,H>V>D ,UNIV]SITY ,PRESS ,HUT 7#a#i#f#a74 ,CONSCI\SNESS & ,SOCIETY3 ,! ,REORI5TATION ( ,EUROPEAN ,SOCIAL ,?\ION ,BOY>S ,9/ITUTE = ,SOCIAL ,ECOLOGY 7#a#i#i#f74 #aiif ,CATALOG4 ,PLA9FIELD1 ,V,T3 ,9/ITUTE = ,SOCIAL ,ECOLOGY ,J>A*1 ,LAWR5CE 7#a#i#i#f74 0,MANI*EAN ,AN>*ISM OR ,DI%ONE/ ,AN>*ISM2 ,JUDG+ A ,BOOK*9 BY ,HIS ,COV]-,UPS40 ,UNPUBLI%$ REVIEW ( ,SOCIAL ,AN>*ISM OR ,LIFE/YLE ,AN>*ISM =?COM+ 9 ,AN>*Y3 ,A ,J\RNAL ( ,DESIRE ,AIM$ ,KELLY1 ,ROB]T ,C4 7#a#i#i#a74 0,S$ANTISM1 ,SOCIOPOLITICAL ,9EQUALITY1 & ,RES\RCE ,FLUCTUATIONS40 ,9 ,GREGG 7#a#i#i#a71 PP4 #a#c#e-#a#e#h ,KNAUFT1 ,BRUCE ,M4 7#a#i#h#g74 0,DIV]G5CE ,BETWE5 ,CULTURAL ,SUCCESS & ,REPRODUCTIVE ,SUCCESS 9 ,PRE9DU/RIAL ,CITIES40 ,CULTURAL ,AN?ROPOLOGY #b7#a7 7,FEB473 #i#d-#a#a#d ,KONN]1 ,MELV91 @& ,M>JORIE ,%O/AK 7#a#i#h#g74 0,TIM+ & ,MANAGEM5T ( ,BIR? ,AMONG ! 6,KUNG3 ,BIOCULTURAL ,9T]ACTION 9 ,REPRODUCTIVE ,ADAPTATION40 ,CULTURAL ,AN?ROPOLOGY #b7#a7 7,FEB473 #a#a-#b#h ,KROPOTK91 ,PI]RE 7#a#h#i74 ,! ,PLACE ( ,AN>*ISM 9 ,SOCIALI/IC ,EVOLUTION4 ,LONDON3 ,WILLIAM ,REEVES ,KROPOTK91 ,PET] 7#a#i#d#g74 ,E?ICS3 ,ORIG9 & ,DEVELOPM5T4 ,NEW ,YORK3 ,! ,DIAL ,PRESS -- 7#a#i#i74 0,PREFACE0 TO ,H[ ,WE ,%ALL ,BR+ ,AB\T ! ,REVOLUTION3 ,SYNDICALISM & ! ,COOP]ATIVE ,COMMONWEAL?1 BY ,EMILE ,PATAUD & ,EMILE ,P\GET4 ,9 ,PATAUD @& ,P\GET 7#a#i#i71 PP4 XXXI-XXXVII -- 7#a#i#i#e74 ,! ,CONQUE/ ( ,BREAD & ,O!R ,WRIT+S4 ,$IT$ BY ,M>%ALL ,S4 ,%ATZ4 ,CAMBRIDGE3 ,CAMBRIDGE ,UNIV]SITY ,PRESS ,KUHN1 ,?OMAS ,S4 7#a#i#g74 ,! ,/RUCTURE ( ,SCI5TIFIC ,REVOLUTIONS4 ,SECOND ,$ITION1 ,5L>G$4 ,*ICAGO1 ,I,L3 ,UNIV]SITY ( ,*ICAGO ,PRESS ,LASSWELL1 ,H>OLD 7#a#i#e#h74 ,POLITICS3 ,:O ,GETS ,:AT1 ,:51 ,H[4 ,) ,PO/SCRIPT4 ,NEW ,YORK3 ,M]IDIAN ,BOOKS ,LEE1 ,RI*>D ,BOR%AY 7#a#i#f#h74 0,:AT ,HUNT]S ,DO = A ,LIV+1 OR1 ,H[ TO ,MAKE ,\T ON ,SC>CE ,RES\RCES40 ,9 ,LEE @& ,DEVORE 7#a#i#f#h71 PP4 #c-#d#h -- 7#a#i#f#i74 06,KUNG ,BU%M5 ,SUBSI/5CE3 ,AN ,9PUT-,\TPUT ,ANALYSIS40 ,9 ,VAYDA 7#a#i#f#i71 PP4 #d#g-#g#i -- 7#a#i#g#i74 ,! 6,KUNG ,SAN3 ,M51 ,WOM5 & ,WORK 9 A ,=AG+ ,SOCIETY4 ,CAMBRIDGE3 ,CAMBRIDGE ,UNIV]SITY ,PRESS -- 1 @& ,IRV5 ,DE,VORE1 $S4 7#a#i#f#hA74 ,MAN ! ,HUNT]4 ,*ICAGO3 ,ALD9E ,PUBLI%+ ,COMPANY -- @& ,IRV5 ,DE,VORE 7#a#i#f#hB74 0,PREFACE40 9 ,LEE @& ,DE,VORE 7#a#i#f#hA71 PP4 VII-IX -- 1 @& ,IRV5 ,DE,VORE 7#a#i#f#hC74 0,PROBLEMS 9 ! ,/UDY ( ,HUNT]S & ,GA!R]S40 ,9 ,LEE @& ,DE,VORE 7#a#i#f#hA71 PP4 #c-#a#b ,LEGGE1 ,AN?ONY ,J41 @& ,PET] ,A4 ,R[LEY-,CONWY 7#a#i#h#g74 0,GAZELLE ,KILL+ 9 ,/ONE ,AGE ,SYRIA40 ,SCI5TIFIC ,AM]ICAN #b#e#g7#b7 7,AUGU/73 #h#h-#i#e ,L591 ,V4,I4 7#a#i#d74 0,LEFT-,W+0 ,COMMUNISM1 AN ,9FANTILE ,DISORD]3 ,A ,POPUL> ,ESSAY 9 ,M>XIAN ,/RATEGY & ,TACTICS4 7,LITTLE ,L59 ,LIBR>Y1 ,VOL4 #b47 ,N4,Y43 ,9T]NATIONAL ,PUBLI%]S -- 7#a#i#e74 ,MAT]IALISM & ,EMPIRIO-,CRITICISM3 ,CRITICAL ,COMM5TS ON A ,REACTION>Y ,PHILOSOPHY4 ,LONDON3 ,LAWR5CE & ,WI%>T ,LTD4 ,LEVI-,/RAUSS1 ,CLAUDE 7#a#i#f#b74 ,! ,SAVAGE ,M9D4 ,*ICAGO1 ,I,L3 ,UNIV]SITY ( ,*ICAGO ,PRESS @& ,LONDON3 ,WEID5FELD & ,NI*OLSON ,L[IE1 ,ROB]T ,H4 7#a#i#f#c74 ,9DIANS ( ! ,PLA9S4 ,G>D5 ,CITY1 ,N,Y3 ,! ,NATURAL ,HI/ORY ,PRESS ,M>X1 ,K>L 7#a#i#f#g74 ,CAPITAL3 ,A ,CRITIQUE ( ,POLITICAL ,ECONOMY4 ,$IT$ BY ,FR$]ICK ,5GELS4 ,VOL4 ,I,I,I3 ,! ,PROCESS ( ,CAPITALI/ ,PRODUCTION AS A ,:OLE4 ,NEW ,YORK3 ,9T]NATIONAL ,PUBLI%]S ,MC,CUSK]1 ,JOHN ,J41 @& ,RUSSELL ,R4 ,M5>D 7#a#i#h#e74 ,! ,ECONOMY ( ,BRITI% ,AM]ICA1 #a#f#g-#a#g#h#i4 ,*APEL ,HILL1 ,N,C @& ,LONDON3 ,UNIV]SITY ( ,NOR? ,C>OL9A ,PRESS ,MEGILL1 ,ALLAN1 $4 7#a#i#i#d74 ,RE?9K+ ,OBJECTIVITY4 ,DURHAM1 ,N,C3 ,UNIV]SITY ( ,NOR? ,C>OL9A ,PRESS ,MI*ELS1 ,ROB]T 7#a#i#f#b74 ,POLITICAL ,P>TIES3 ,A ,SOCIOLOGICAL ,/UDY ( ! ,OLIG>*ICAL ,T5D5CIES ( ,MOD]N ,DEMOCRACY4 ,NEW ,YORK3 ,! ,FREE ,PRESS ,MONEGAL1 ,EMIR ,RODRIGUEZ1 @& ,ALA/AIR ,REID1 $S4 7#a#i#h#a74 ,BORGES3 ,A ,READ]4 ,NEW ,YORK3 ,E4,P4 ,DUTTON ,MOORE1 ,JOHN 7#a#i#i#f74 0,COMM5T>Y ON ! ,AN>*O-,FUTURI/ ,MANIFE/O40 ,GRE5 ,AN>*I/ #d_/#d#a 7,SPR+73 #a#h-#b ,MORGAN1 ,$MUND ,S4 7#a#i#g#e74 ,AM]ICAN ,SLAV]Y1 ,AM]ICAN ,FRE$OM3 ,! ,ORDEAL ( ,COLONIAL ,VIRG9IA4 ,NEW ,YORK @& ,LONDON3 ,W4,W4 ,NORTON @& ,COMPANY ,MURDOEK1 ,GEORGE ,PET] 7#a#i#f#h74 0,! ,CURR5T ,/ATUS ( ! ,WORLD'S ,HUNT+ & ,GA!R+ ,PEOPLES40 ,9 ,LEE @& ,DE,VORE 7#a#i#f#hA71 PP4 #a#c-#b ,NEWCOMB1 ,W4,W41 ,JR4 7#a#i#f#a74 ,! ,9DIANS ( ,TEXAS4 ,AU/91 ,T,X3 ,UNIV]SITY ( ,TEXAS ,PRESS ,NIETZS*E1 ,FRI$RI* 7#a#i#i#d74 ,ON ! ,G5EALOGY ( ,MORALITY4 ,$IT$ BY ,KEI? ,ANSELL-,PE>SON4 ,CAMBRIDGE3 ,CAMBRIDGE ,UNIV]SITY ,PRESS ,NOVATORE1 ,R5ZO 7#a#i#h#i74 0,ICONOCLA/S1 ,=W>D60 ,9 ,BLACK @& ,P>FREY 7#a#i#h#i71 PP4 #i#b-#i#c ,NOVICK1 ,PET] 7#a#i#h#h74 ,?AT ,NOBLE ,DREAM3 ,! 0,OBJECTIVITY ,QUE/ION0 & ! ,AM]ICAN ,HI/ORICAL ,PR(ESSION4 ,CAMBRIDGE3 ,CAMBRIDGE ,UNIV]SITY ,PRESS ,NUQUI/1 ,&REW ,E4 7#a#i#f#d74 ,T[N ,GOV]NM5T 9 ,V]MONT4 ,BURL+TON1 ,V,T3 ,UNIV]SITY ( ,V]MONT ,GOV]NM5T ,RESE>* ,C5T] ,ORWELL1 ,GEORGE 7#a#i#e#b74 ,HOMAGE TO ,CATALONIA4 ,NEW ,YORK @& ,LONDON3 ,H>C\RT ,BRACE ,JOVANOVI* ,PANNEKOEK1 ,ANTON 7#a#i#d#h74 ,L59 AS ,PHILOSOPH]3 ,A ,CRITICAL ,EXAM9ATION ( ! ,PHILOSOPHICAL ,BASIS ( ,L59ISM4 ,NEW ,YORK3 ,NEW ,ESSAYS ,P>K+TON1 ,JOHN ,E4 7#a#i#h#d74 0,SOAQUA & ,BU%M53 ,HUNT]S & ,ROBB]S40 ,9 ,S*RIRE 7#a#i#h#d71 PP4 #a#e#a-#a#g#d ,PATAUD1 ,EMILE1 @& ,EMILE ,P\GET 7#a#i#i74 ,H[ ,WE ,%ALL ,BR+ ,AB\T ! ,REVOLUTION3 ,SYNDICALISM & ! ,COOP]ATIVE ,COMMONWEAL?4 ,LONDON @& ,W9*E/]1 ,M,A3 ,PLUTO ,PRESS ,PET]S1 ,PAUL9E 7#a#i#i74 0,! ,SAN ,HI/ORICIZ$40 ,SCI5CE #bdh 7,MAY #b#h73 #i#e-#i#g ,POPP]1 ,K>L ,L4 7#a#i#f#b74 ,! ,OP5 ,SOCIETY & ,ITS ,5EMIES4 #b VOLS4 ,F\R? ,$ITION1 ,REVIS$4 ,NEW ,YORK @& ,EVAN/ON1 ,I,L3 ,H>P] ,TOR*BOOKS ,PR\DHON1 ,P4-,J4 7#a#i#g#i74 ,! ,PR9CIPLE ( ,F$]ATION4 ,$IT$ BY ,RI*>D ,V]NON4 ,TORONTO1 ,CANADA3 ,UNIV]SITY ( ,TORONTO ,PRESS ,RASMUSS51 ,D4 ,TAB1 $4 7#a#i#i#c74 ,! ,ORIG9 & ,EVOLUTION ( ,HUMANS & ,HUMANNESS4 ,BO/ON1 ,M,A @& ,LONDON3 ,JONES & ,B>TLETT ,PUBLI%] ,R5\F1 ,M,A4,P4 7#a#i#i#a74 0,S$5T>Y ,HUNT]-,GA!RS3 ,A ,CASE = ,NOR!RN ,COA/S40 ,9 ,GREGG 7#a#i#i#a71 PP4 #h#i-#a#g ,RI*>DS1 ,V]NON 7#a#i#h#c74 ,LESSONS ( ! ,SPANI% ,REVOLUTION1 #a#i#c#f-#a#i#c#i4 ,REVIS$1 ,5L>G$ ,$ITION4 ,LONDON3 ,FRE$OM ,PRESS ,RIFK91 ,J]EMY 7#a#i#i#e74 ,! ,5D ( ,WORK3 ,! ,DECL9E ( ! ,GLOBAL ,LABOR ,=CE & ! ,DAWN ( ! ,PO/-,M>KET ,]A4 ,NEW ,YORK3 ,G4,P4 ,PUTNAM'S ,SONS ,ROB]TS1 ,DAVID ,D4 7#a#i#g#i74 ,! ,SYNDICALI/ ,TRADITION & ,ITALIAN ,FASCISM4 ,*APEL ,HILL1 ,N,C3 ,UNIV]SITY ( ,NOR? ,C>OL9A ,PRESS ,ROCK]1 ,RUDOLF 7#a#i#d#g74 ,AN>*O-SYNDICALISM3 ,VIEORY & ,PRACTICE4 ,9DORE1 ,9DIA3 ,MOD]N ,PUBLI%]S ,ROSS1 ,]IC ,B4 7#a#i#h#g74 0,AN ,OV]VIEW ( ,TR5DS 9 ,DIET>Y ,V>IATION FROM ,HUNT]-,GA!R] TO ,MOD]N ,CAPITALI/ ,SOCIETIES40 ,9 ,H>RIS @& ,ROSS 7#a#i#h#g71 PP4 #g-#e#e ,RUBY1 ,JAY 7#a#i#i#f74 0,OBJECTIVITY ,REVISIT$40 ,AM]ICAN ,AN?ROPOLOGI/ #i#h7#b7 7,JUNE73 #c#i#h-#d ,RUH>T1 ,M>Y 7#a#i#i#f74 0,KEEP+ ,\R ,FRE$OM 9 AN ,UNFREE ,WORLD40 ,=MULATIONS #c7#c7 7,SPR+73 #c-#d1 #ac ,SAHL9S1 ,M>%ALL 7#a#i#g#b74 ,/ONE ,AGE ,ECONOMICS4 ,*ICAGO1 ,I,L3 ,ALD9E ,PUBLI%+ ,COMPANY ,SALISBURY1 ,NEAL 7#a#i#h#b74 ,MANIT\ & ,PROVID5CE3 ,9DIANS1 ,EUROPEANS1 & ! ,MAK+ ( ,NEW ,5GL&1 #a#e-#a#f#d#c4 ,NEW ,YORK @& ,OX=D3 ,OX=D ,UNIV]SITY ,PRESS ,S*EIB]1 ,H>RY ,N41 ,H>OLD ,G4 ,VATT] @& ,H>OLD ,UND]WOOD ,FAULKN] 7#a#i#g#f74 ,AM]ICAN ,ECONOMIC ,HI/ORY4 ,NEW ,YORK3 ,H>P] @& ,R[ ,S*OR1 ,JULIET 7#a#i#i#a74 ,! ,OV]WORK$ ,AM]ICAN3 ,! ,UNEXPECT$ ,DECL9E ( ,LEISURE4 ,NEW ,YORK3 ,BASIC ,BOOKS ,S*RIRE1 ,C>MEL1 $4 7#a#i#h#d74 ,PA/ & ,PRES5T 9 ,HUNT] ,GA!R] ,SOCIETIES4 ,ORL&O1 ,F,L3 ,ACADEMIC ,PRESS ,S*U/]1 ,EUNICE ,M9ETTE 7#a#i#c#b74 ,NATIVE ,AM]ICAN ,AN>*ISM3 ,A ,/UDY ( ,LEFT-,W+ ,AM]ICAN ,9DIVIDUALISM4 7,SMI? ,COLLEGE ,/UDIES 9 ,HI/ORY1 ,VOL4 ,X,V,I,I1 ,NOS4 #a-#d47 ,NOR?AMPTON1 ,M,A3 ,SMI? ,COLLEGE ,DEP>TM5T ( ,HI/ORY ,SEIDMAN1 ,MI*AEL 7#a#i#i#a74 ,WORK]S ,AGA9/ ,WORK3 ,LABOR 9 ,P>IS & ,B>CELONA ,DUR+ ! ,POPUL> ,FRONTS4 ,B]KELEY3 ,UNIV]SITY ( ,CALI=NIA ,PRESS ,S5D]1 ,RAMON ,J4 7#a#i#i74 ,SEV5 ,R$ ,SUNDAYS4 ,*ICAGO1 ,I,L3 ,IVAN ,R4 ,DEE1 ,PUBLI%] ,SILB5]1 ,$MUND 7#a#i#d#h74 0,PR\DHON'S ,JUDEOPHOBIA40 ,HI/ORICA ,JUDAICA #a#a7#a7 7,APRIL73 #f#a-#h ,SJOB]G1 ,GIDEON 7#a#i#f74 ,! ,PRE9DU/RIAL ,CITY3 ,PA/ & ,PRES5T4 ,GL5COE1 ,I,L3 ,! ,FREE ,PRESS ,SMI?1 ,GREGORY ,B4 7#a#i#h#c74 ,REVIEW ( ,! ,ECOLOGY ( ,FRE$OM1 BY ,MURRAY ,BOOK*94 ,AM]ICAN ,POLITICAL ,SCI5CE ,REVIEW #g#g7#a7 7,M>*73 #$ ,SOLWAY1 ,JACQUEL9E ,S41 @& ,RI*>D ,B4 ,LEE 7#a#i#i74 0,=AG]S1 ,G5U9E OR ,SPURI\S8 ,SITUAT+ ! ,KALAH>I ,SAN 9 ,HI/ORY40 ,CURR5T ,AN?ROPOLOGY #c#a7#b7 7,APRIL73 #a#i-#a#d#f ,/AF=D1 ,DAVID 7#a#i#g#b74 0,AN>*I/S 9 ,BRITA9 ,TODAY40 ,9 ,APT] @& ,JOLL 7#a#i#g#b71 PP4 #i#i-#a#b#b ,/IRN]1 ,MAX 7#a#i#g#h74 0,/IRN]'S ,CRITICS40 ,PHILOSOPHICAL ,=UM #h7#b-#d73 #f#f-#h -- 7#a#i#i#e74 ,! ,EGO & ,ITS ,[N4 ,$IT$ BY ,DAVID ,LEOPOLD4 ,CAMBRIDGE3 ,CAMBRIDGE ,UNIV]SITY ,PRESS ,TANAKA1 ,JIRI 7#a#i#h74 ,! ,SAN ,HUNT]-,GA!R]S ( ! ,KALAH>I3 ,A ,/UDY 9 ,ECOLOGICAL ,AN?ROPOLOGY4 ,TOKYO1 ,JAPAN3 ,UNIV]SITY ( ,TOKYO ,PRESS ,?ISS51 ,SIEBE 7#a#i#i#f74 ,DE ,WEG NA> ,CROATAN4 7,DE ,KUN/ VAN HET ,AFHAK547 ,ROTT]DAM1 ,NE!RL&S3 ,BAALPRODUKTIES ,SITT>D ,TOCQUEVILLE1 ,ALEXIS DE 7#a#i#f#iA74 ,DEMOCRACY 9 ,AM]ICA4 ,$IT$ BY ,J4,P4 ,MAY]4 ,G>D5 ,CITY1 ,NEW ,YORK3 ,AN*OR ,BOOKS -- 7#a#i#f#iB74 0,REPORT ,GIV5 ,BE=E ! ,ACADEMY ( ,MORAL & ,POLITICAL ,SCI5CES ON ,JANU>Y #a#e1 #a#h#d#h1 ON ! ,SUBJECT ( ,M4 ,*]BULIEZ' ,BOOK ,5TITL$ ,ON ,DEMOCRACY 9 ,SWITZ]L&40 ,9 ,TOCQUEVILLE 7#a#i#f#iA71 PP4 #g#c#f-#g#d#i 7,APP5DIX ,I,I7 ,TU*MAN1 ,B>B>A 7#a#i#f#f74 ,! ,PR\D ,T[]4 ,NEW ,YORK3 ,! ,MACMILLAN ,COMPANY ,VAYDA1 ,&REW ,P41 $4 7#a#i#f#i74 ,5VIRONM5T & ,CULTURAL ,BEHAVIOR4 ,NEW ,YORK3 ,NATURAL ,HI/ORY ,PRESS ,V9C5T1 ,K4 ,/EV5 7#a#i#h#d74 ,PI]RE-,JOSEPH ,PR\DHON & ! ,RISE ( ,FR5* ,REPUBLICAN ,SOCIALISM4 ,OX=D3 ,OX=D ,UNIV]SITY ,PRESS ,WALT]1 ,NICOLAS 7#a#i#g#b74 0,AN>*ISM 9 ,PR9T3 ,YE/]DAY & ,TODAY40 ,9 ,APT] @& ,JOLL 7#a#i#g#b71 PP4 #a#d#g-#a#f#h ,WALZ]1 ,MI*AEL 7#a#i#g74 ,OBLIGATIONS3 ,ESSAYS ON ,DISOB$I5CE1 ,W>2 & ,CITIZ5%IP4 ,CAMBRIDGE3 ,H>V>D ,UNIV]SITY ,PRESS ,WATSON1 ,RI*>D ,A4 7#a#i#i#e74 ,REVIEW ( ,:I* ,WAY = ! ,ECOLOGY ,MOVEM5T8 BY ,MURRAY ,BOOK*94 ,5VIRONM5TAL ,E?ICS #a#d7#d7 7,W9T]73 #d#c#g-#d#c#i ,WILMS51 ,$W9 ,N4 7#a#i#h#i74 ,L& ,FILL$ ) ,FLIES3 ,A ,POLITICAL ,ECONOMY ( ! ,KALAH>I4 ,*ICAGO1 ,I,L @& ,LONDON3 ,UNIV]SITY ( ,*ICAGO ,PRESS ,WOODBURN1 ,J4 7#a#i#h#b74 0,EGALIT>IAN ,SOCIETIES40 ,MAN #g3 #d#c#a-#d#e#a ,WOODCOCK1 ,GEORGE 7#a#i#f#b74 ,AN>*ISM3 ,A ,HI/ORY ( ,LIB]T>IAN ,IDEAS & ,MOVEM5TS4 ,NEW ,YORK3 ,M]IDIAN ,BOOKS ,Y5GOYAN1 ,>AM ,A4 7#a#i#f#h74 0,DEMOGRAPHIC & ,ECOLOGICAL ,9FLU5CES ON ,ABORIG9AL ,AU/RALIAN ,M>RIAGE ,SECTIONS40 ,9 ,LEE @& ,DE,VORE 7#a#i#f#h71 PP4 #a#h#e-#a#i#i ,ZAPATI/AS 7#a#i#i#d74 ,ZAPATI/AS6 ,DOCUM5TS ( ! ,NEW ,MEXICAN ,REVOLUTION4 ,BROOKLYN1 ,N,Y3 ,AUTONOM$IA ,Z]ZAN1 ,JOHN 7#a#i#h#g74 ,ELEM5TS ( ,REFUSAL4 ,SEATTLE1 ,W,A3 ,LEFT ,BANK ,BOOKS -- 7#a#i#i#d74 ,FUTURE ,PRIMITIVE & ,O!R ,ESSAYS4 ,BROOKLYN1 ,N,Y3 ,AUTONOM$IA @& ,COLUMBIA1 ,M,O3 ,AN>*Y_/,C4,A4,L4 ,PRESS -- 7#a#i#i#f74 ,LETT] TO ,BOB ,BLACK1 ,MAY #b ,ZIMM]N1 ,ALFR$ 7#a#i#c#a74 ,! ,GREEK ,COMMONWEAL?3 ,POLITICS & ,ECONOMICS 9 ,FIF?-,C5TURY ,A!NS4 ,FIF? ,$ITION1 ,REVIS$4 ,OX=D3 AT ! ,CL>5DON ,PRESS ,ZUBR[1 ,EZRA ,B4,W41 $4 7#a#i#g#f74 ,DEMOGRAPHIC ,AN?ROPOLOGY3 ,QUANTITATIVE ,APPROA*ES4 ,ALBUQU]QUE1 ,N,M3 ,UNIV]SITY ( ,NEW ,MEXICO ,PRESS .<#a.> ,! ,FIF? ,E/ATE'S ,DAVID ,WATSON 7A4K4A4 ,GEORGE ,BRAD=D7 HAS JU/ WRITT5 A VALUABLE CRITIQUE ( MAJOR !MES 9 ,BOOK*9'S WORK TITL$ ,BEYOND ,BOOK*93 ,PREFACE = A ,FUTURE ,SOCIAL ,ECOLOGY1 PUBLI%$ BY ,AUTONOM$IA 7,BROOKLYN1 ,N,Y7 & ,BLACK @& ,R$ 7,DETROIT1 ,M,I74 ,IT WAS ALSO /IMULAT$ BY ,BOOK*9'S ABYSMAL ,SOCIAL ,AN>*ISM OR ,LIFE/YLE ,AN>*ISM4 ,H[EV]1 ,WATSON'S WORK IS AIM$ MORE T[>DS DEF5D+ AN>*O-PRIMITIVISM & REHABILITAT+ A NON-,BOOK*9I/ ,SOCIAL ,ECOLOGY ?AN T[>DS ! CRITIQUE ,BOB TAKES ON 9 ?IS VOLUME ( ,BOOK*9'S LEFTOV] LEFTISM S]V$ 9 BIODEGRADABLE ECOLOGICAL & MUNICIPALI/ WRAPP+S4 .<#b.> ,$9BUR<1 ,SCOTL& @& ,SAN ,FRANCISCO1 ,C,A3 ,A,K ,PRESS1 #a#i#i#e4 ,ALL REF]5CES CONSI/+ SOLELY ( NUM]ALS 9 P>5!SES >E PAGE REF]5CES TO ?IS BOOK4 ,ALL O!R REF]5CES -- BE !Y TO ,BOOK*9'S O!R WRIT+S OR ! WRIT+S ( O!RS -- FOLL[ AN APPROXIMATION ( SOCIAL-SCI5CE CITATION /YLE4 ,?AT IS1 !Y CONSI/ ( A P>5!TICAL REF]5CE TO A S\RCE BY ! LA/ NAME ( ! AU?OR & ! YE> ( PUBLICATION FOLL[$ BY1 9 SOME 9/ANCES1 SPECIFIC PAGE REF]5CES4 ,= EXAMPLE1 7,BLACK #a#i#i#d3 #e7 REF]S TO PAGE #e ( ! BOOK LI/$ 9 ! ,BIBLIOGRAPHY AS FOLL[S3 ,BLACK1 ,BOB 7#a#i#i#d74 ,B5EA? ! ,UND]GR\ND4 ,PORTL&1 ,O,R3 ,F]AL ,H\SE @& ,PORT ,T[NS5D1 ,W,A3 ,LOOMPANICS ,UNLIMIT$ ,SOMETIMES ! AU?OR'S NAME IS OMITT$ IF1 9 CONTEXT1 IT IS PROVID$ OR IMPLI$ 9 ! TEXT1 E1G41 7#a#i#i#d3 #e7 :]E ! TEXT ITSELF HAS ID5TIFI$ ,BLACK AS ! S\RCE4 ,I REQUE/ ! =BE>ANCE ( READ]S :O ?9K ?AT 9 EXPLA9+ ! ALMO/-OBVI\S ,I AM TALK+ D[N TO !M4 ,I EXPECT ?AT NE>LY ALL ( MY READ]S >E EI!R FAMILI> ) ?IS CITATION SY/EM OR ELSE W\LD HAVE NO DIFFICULTY FIGUR+ IT \T4 ,I *OSE TO USE IT TO SUPPLY AT LEA/ ! RUDIM5TS ( REF]5CES SIMULTANE\SLY ) :AT ,I MAKE ( !M4 ,I *OOSE TO EXPLA9 ! SY/EM H]E FROM AN EXCESS ( CAUTION4 ,I EXPECT ! ,BOOK*9I/ C\NT]ATTACK TO RELY HEAVILY ON CONFUSIONI/ QUIBBL+ AB\T DETAILS1 9CLUD+ BIBLIOGRAPHIC DETAILS4 ,SOME AN>*I/S >E UNDULY IMPRESS$ BY ! TRAPP+S ( S*OL>%IP1 UNAW>E ?AT1 IF C>EFULLY SCRUT9IZ$1 !Y >E SOMETIMES ONLY CLAPTRAPP+S4 ,SOME >E EV5 SUSCEPTIBLE TO TYPESET TEXT AS SU*1 AS IF TYPESETT+ W]E SOME SORT ( GU>ANTEE ?AT ! TEXT IS PRESUMPTIVELY IMPORTANT &_/OR TRUE4 ,TO A CONSID]ABLE EXT5T1 ,BOOK*9'S SEEM+ S*OL>%IP IS %ALL[ OR %AM1 & ?AT'S ESPECIALLY TRUE ( ,SOCIAL ,AN>*ISM OR ,LIFE/YLE ,AN>*ISM4 ,TO DEMON/RATE ?AT1 AS ?IS ESSAY DOES1 MY S*OL>%IP WILL HAVE TO BE MU* BETT] & MU* MORE HONE/4 ,C>EFUL REF]5C+1 & A CLE> UND]/&+ ( MY ME?OD ( REF]5C+1 IS CRUCIAL TO ?AT DEMON/RATION4 ,= Y\1 G5TLE READ]1 ! WOR/ IS N[ BEH9D Y\4 ,LET ! GAMES BEG96 ,*RONOLOGY 3 ,NOVEMB] #c1 #aiif 3 ,AN>*Y AFT] ,LEFTISM -- ,PUBLICATION4 ,APRIL #a#h1 #bb 3 ,AN>*Y AFT] ,LEFTISM -- ,ADD$4 ,JANU>Y #c1 #bbb 3 ,AN>*Y AFT] ,LEFTISM -- ,UPDAT$4 FILE G5]AT$ FROM 3 HTTP3_/_/REVOLTLIB4COM_/