,*APT] #b 
,:AT IS ,9DIVIDUALI/ ,AN>*ISM8 

#aiigaiig 

,PEOPLE 3 

,AU?OR 3 ,BOB ,BLACK 

,TEXT 3 

,*APT] #b3 ,:AT IS ,9DIVIDUALI/ ,AN>*ISM8 

  

,DEAN ,BOOK*9 POSITS AN ET]NALLY RECURR+ 0T5SION0 )9 AN>*ISM BETWE5 ! 9DIVIDUAL & ! SOCIAL 7#d74 ,AS ?IS IS NONE O!R ?AN ! C5TRAL CONUNDRUM ( ,WE/]N POLITICAL PHILOSOPHY1 ! ,DEAN IS NEI!R ORIG9AL NOR -- MORE IMPORTANT -- HAS HE ID5TIFI$ A SPECIFICALLY AN>*I/ T5SION4 ,HE GOES ON TO ID5TIFY ! ANTI!SES )9 AN>*ISM AS 0TWO BASICALLY CONTRADICTORY T5D5CIES3 A P]SONALI/IC COMMITM5T TO 9DIVIDUAL AUTONOMY & A COLLECTIVI/ COMMITM5T TO SOCIAL FRE$OM0 7#d74 ,?IS IS ! 0UNBRIDGEABLE *ASM0 HIS BOOK TITLE REF]S TO4 

,IF ! ,DEAN IS RI<T -- ?AT 9DIVIDUAL AUTONOMY & SOCIAL LIB]ATION >E NOT JU/ 9 T5SION BUT BASICALLY CONTRADICTORY -- !N AN>*Y IS IMPOSSIBLE1 AS ANTI-AN>*I/S HAVE ALWAYS MA9TA9$4 ,BOOK*9 H]E REJECTS \T ( H& :AT HE US$ TO ESP\SE1 0A SOCIETY ?AT W\LD TRANSC5D ! HI/ORIC SPLITS BETWE54449DIVIDUAL & SOCIETY0 7#a#i#g3 #e#i74 

,NOT ALL ( US %>E HIS CONS]VATIVE FATALISM4 ,WE TOO HAVE \R APPREH5SIONS & \R TIMES ( DESPAIR4 ,BUT TO SURR5D] TO !M 5TIRELY 7:I* ,I CONDEMN NOBODY = DO+1 IF HE'S HONE/ AB\T IT7 IS TO R5\NCE ANY AFFILIATION ) AN>*ISM4 ,! ,DEAN WON'T FI%1 NEI!R WILL HE CUT BAIT4 ,HE WON'T %IT1 NEI!R WILL HE GET (F ! POT4 

,SOME ( ?OSE ) IMPECCABLE1 ,BOOK*9-APPROV$ CR$5TIALS1 SU* AS ,KROPOTK91 HAD A MORE TOL]ANT TAKE ON ?IS G5U9ELY TRAGIC DILEMMA3  
  

,AN>*I/ ,COMMUNISM MA9TA9S ?AT MO/ VALUABLE ( ALL CONQUE/S -- 9DIVIDUAL LIB]TY -- & MOREOV] EXT5DS IT & GIVES IT A SOLID BASIS -- ECONOMIC LIB]TY -- )\T :I* POLITICAL LIB]TY IS DELUSIVE2 IT DOES NOT ASK ! 9DIVIDUAL :O HAS REJECT$ GOD1 ! UNIV]SAL TYRANT1 GOD ! K+1 & GOD ! P>LIAM5T1 TO GIVE UNTO HIMSELF A GOD MORE T]RIBLE ?AN ANY ( ! PREC$+ -- GOD ! ,COMMUNITY1 OR TO ABDICATE UPON ITS ALT> HIS 9DEP5D5CE1 HIS WILL1 HIS TA/ES1 & TO R5EW ! V[ ( ASCETICISM :I* HE =M]LY MADE BE=E ! CRUCIFI$ GOD4 ,IT SAYS TO HIM1 ON ! CONTR>Y1 0,NO SOCIETY IS FREE SO LONG AS ! 9DIVIDUAL IS NOT SO60 7,KROPOTK9 #a#h#i3 #a#d-#a#e7  
  

,BOOK*9 IS ! V]ITABLE HI< PRIE/ ( :AT ,KROPOTK9 CALLS 0GOD ! ,COMMUNITY10 0MORE T]RIBLE ?AN ANY ( ! PREC$+10 ! MO/ VICI\S & OPPRESSIVE GOD ( ALL4 

0,SOCIAL FRE$OM0 IS LIKE ! 0FREE M>KET0 9 ! S5SE ?AT ! FRE$OM REF]R$ TO HAS TO BE METAPHORICAL4 ,IT MAKES NO LIT]AL S5SE TO ATTRIBUTE FRE$OM TO BEHAVIORAL 9T]ACTION SY/EMS1 EV5 FE$BACK SY/EMS1 LACK+ ! NECESS>ILY 9DIVIDUAL QUALITIES ( CONSCI\SNESS & 9T5TION4 ,IT'S LIKE SAY+ AN AN?ILL OR ! SOL> SY/EM OR A !RMO/AT IS FREE4 ,FREE FROM1 & =1 :AT8 ,:AT ELSE C\LD A SOCIETY OR A M>KET POSSIBLY BE FREE ( IF NOT AUTONOM\S 9DIVIDUALS8 

,IF ONE ASSIGNS ANY VALUE TO 9DIVIDUAL AUTONOMY1 LOGICALLY !RE >E ONLY TWO POSSIBILITIES = IT TO EV5 EXI/1 MU* LESS FL\RI%1 9 SOCIETY4 7,CONTR>Y TO :AT ! ,DEAN IMPLIES .<#e#h.>1 NOT EV5 ,MAX ,/IRN] ?\<T IT WAS POSSIBLE \TSIDE ( SOCIETY .<#a#i#i#e3 #a#f#a1 #b#g#a-#b#g#g.>47 ,! FIR/ IS A COMPROMISE3 LIB]ALISM4 ,! 9DIVIDUAL EX*ANGES P>T ( HIS PREC>I\S NATURAL LIB]TY = SOCIETY'S PROTECTION ( ! RE/ ( IT1 & ALSO = ! PRACTICAL OPPORTUNITIES = ADVANC+ HIS 9T]E/S ONLY OP5$ UP 9 A SOCIAL /ATE4 ,?IS WAS ! POSITION ( ,?OMAS ,HOBBES1 ,JOHN ,LOCKE1 ,ADAM ,SMI? & ,WILLIAM ,BLACK/ONE4 ,9 ! PUBLIC SPH]E1 FRE$OM MEANS DEMOCRACY2 ,9 ! PRIVATE SPH]E1 IT MEANS 9DIVIDUAL RI<TS4 

,! SECOND RESOLUTION ( ! QU&>Y1 ! RADICAL ONE1 IS AN>*ISM4 ,AN>*ISM REJECTS ! DI*OTOMY AS FALSE -- MAYBE NOT FALSE AS EXI/+ SOCIETY IS CON/ITUT$1 BUT FALSE 9 ITS SUPPOS$ FATALITY4 ,9 AN AN>*I/ SOCIETY ! 9DIVIDUAL GA9S FRE$OM1 NOT AT ! EXP5SE ( O!RS1 BUT 9 COOP]ATION ) !M4 ,A P]SON :O BELIEVES ?AT ?IS CONDITION -- AN>*Y -- IS POSSIBLE & DESIRABLE IS CALL$ AN AN>*I/4 ,A P]SON :O ?9KS IT IS NOT POSSIBLE OR NOT DESIRABLE IS A /ATI/4 

,AS ,I %ALL HAVE NO DIFFICULTY DEMON/RAT+ LAT] ON1 IT SO HAPP5S ?AT ! ,DEAN HIMSELF IS NOT AN AN>*I/1 M]ELY1 9 HIS [N T]M9OLOGY1 A 0SELF-/YL$ AN>*I/40 ,BUT ?AT'S NO REASON = ?OSE ( US :O 7ALBEIT UN5?USIA/ICALLY1 IF ,I MAY SPEAK = MYSELF7 >E AN>*I/S NOT TO HE$ HIS CRITIQUE4 ,FROM ,GEORGE ,B]N>D ,%AW TO ,GUY ,DEBORD1 ANTI-AN>*I/S :O TOOK AN>*ISM S]I\SLY HAVE (T5 SUPPLI$ CRUCIAL CRITIQUES ! AN>*I/S W]E UNABLE OR UNWILL+ TO CON/RUCT !MSELVES4 ,UN=TUNATELY1 ,BOOK*9'S ISN'T ONE ( !M4 

,:AT IS REM>KABLE AB\T ,DEAN ,BOOK*9'S PO/UR+ AS ! ,DEF5D] ( ! ,FAI?1 ASIDE FROM ! FACT ?AT HE DOESN'T %>E IT1 IS H[ MANY ( ! ,*UR* ,FA!RS 7& ,MO!RS7 HE HAS EXCOMMUNICAT$ AS 09DIVIDUALI/S40 ,PR$ICTABLY1 ,WILLIAM ,GODW9 7#e71 ,MAX ,/IRN] 7#g1 #a#a7 & ,B5JAM9 ,TUCK] 7#h7 ,BOOK*9 SUMM>ILY DISMISSES AS 9DIVIDUALI/S1 AL?\< ?AT H>DLY DOES JU/ICE TO ! RI*NESS ( !IR 9SI<TS & !IR RELEVANCE TO ANY AN>*ISM4 7,AL?\< EV5 ,KROPOTK9 ACKN[L$G$ ?AT ,GODW9 ESP\S$ COMMUNISM 9 ! FIR/ $ITION ( ,POLITICAL ,JU/ICE1 ONLY 0MITIGAT+0 ?AT VIEW 9 LAT] $ITIONS .<,KROPOTK9 #a#i#i#e2 #b#c#h.>1 & ! AN>*O-SYNDICALI/ ,RUDOLF ,ROCK] ACKN[L$G$ ?AT ,GODW9 0WAS REALLY ! F\ND] ( ! LAT] COMMUNI/ ,AN>*ISM0 .<#a#i#d#g3 #g.>47 #a 

,BUT ?AT'S ONLY ! BEG9N+ ( ! PURGE4 ,! ,DEAN CONDEMNS EV5 ,PR\DHON AS AN 9DIVIDUALI/ 7#e71 AL?\< HE ELSE:]E PAYS TRIBUTE TO 0,PR\DHON'S EMPHASIS ON F$]AL-ISM .<:I*.> /ILL 5JOYS CONSID]ABLE VALIDITY0 7,BOOK*97 #a#i#i#f3 #b#d74 ,:5 ,BOOK*9 SAYS ?AT SOME?+ FROM A CLASSICAL AN>*I/ /ILL 5JOYS CONSID]ABLE VALIDITY1 ?IS IS HIS WAY ( SAY+ ?AT'S :OM HE FIL*$ IT FROM4 ,! F$]ALISM ( ,PR\DHON'S LAT] YE>S 7#a#i#g#i7 IS VIRTUALLY ID5TICAL TO ,BOOK*9'S CALL = A 0CONF$]ATION ( DEC5TRALIZ$ MUNICIPALITIES0 7#f74 ,:I* IS TANTAM\NT TO SAY+ ?AT 9 ! 5D ,PR\DHON WAS NOT AN AN>*I/1 AS ,I AM NOT ! ONLY ONE TO HAVE NOTIC$ 7,/EV5 #a#i#h#d74 ,9DE$1 ! ,DEAN HAS COME CLOSE TO ADMITT+ IT HIMSELF 7,BOOK*9 #a#i#g#g3 #b#a74 

,! ,DEAN N[ CLAIMS ?AT ! PROM95T ,SPANI% AN>*I/ ,F$]ICA ,MONTS5EY WAS A 0,/IRN]ITE0 .<SIC.> 9 !ORY IF NOT 9 PRACTICE 7#h74 ,9 HIS ,! ,SPANI% ,AN>*I/S %E IS 0ONE ( ! ,F,A,I'S LUM9>IES0 7,BOOK*9 #a#i#g#g3 #b#d#c74 ,! ,F,A,I WAS A 0VANGU>D0 7! WORD IS ,BOOK*9'S7 AN>*O-COMMUNI/ SECRET SOCIETY 7,BOOK*9 #a#i#i#d3 #b#a-#b#b2 CF4 ,BRADEMAS #a#i#e#c74 

,EV5 ,EMMA ,GOLDMAN IS UND] A CL\D4 ,AL?\< %E WAS AN AV[$ AN>*O-COMMUNI/1 %E ALSO DISPLAY$ A DISQUALIFY+ AFF9ITY ) ,NIETZS*E 7#h71 & %E WAS1 AFT] ALL1 0BY NO MEANS ! ABLE/ ?9K] 9 ! LIB]T>IAN PAN!ON0 7#a#c74 ,BOOK*9 HAS A MUSCUL>1 MASCUL9E DISDA9 = AN>*I/ WOM5 SU* AS ,EMMA ,GOLDMAN1 ,F$]ICA ,MONTS5EY & ,L4 ,SUSAN ,BR[N4 ,ONLY HIS 9NATE MODE/Y KEPT ! ,DEAN FROM NAM+ :O IS ! ABLE/ ?9K] 9 ! LIB]T>IAN PAN!ON1 BUT !N AGA91 :O1 HAV+ READ HIM1 NE$S TO BE TOLD8 

,PAUL ,GOODMAN1 A 0COMMUNIT>IAN AN>*I/0 7,/AF=D #a#i#g#b3 #a#a#b71 ,BOOK*9 CALLS 0AN ESS5TIALLY 9DIVIDUALI/IC AN>*I/0 7#a#b71 AL?\< ,GOODMAN WAS ESS5TIALLY AN URBAN-ORI5T$1 HUMANI/IC AN>*O-COLLECTIVI/ 7,GOODMAN @& ,GOODMAN #a#i#f#a3 *4 #f @& #b#b2 CF4 ,/AF=D #a#i#g#b3 #a#a#b-#a#a#c7 FROM :OM ,BOOK*9 HAS CRIBB$ MANY IDEAS )\T ADMITT+ IT4 ,NOTICE1 = 9/ANCE1 ! REM>KABLE ABS5CE ( ANY 9F]5CES TO ! BY !N DECEAS$ ,GOODMAN 9 ,BOOK*9'S ,! ,LIMITS ( ! ,CITY 7#a#i#g#d7 OR ,! ,RISE ( ,URBANIZATION & ! ,DECL9E ( ,CITIZ5%IP 7#a#i#h#g71 AL?\< HE DID LET SLIP ! NAME 9 ,CRISIS 9 ,\R ,CITIES 7,H]B] #a#i#f#e3 #a#g#g7 AT A TIME :5 ,GOODMAN WAS 9 HIS PRIME :]EAS ! FUTURE ,DEAN WAS SO F> FROM =ESEE+ HIS [N CELEBRITY ?AT HE WROTE UND] A PSEUDONYM4 ,HE'LL SOON WI% HE'D WRITT5 ?IS TRA%Y HAD UND] A PSEUDONYM4 

0,9DIVIDUALI/0 AN>*I/S 9 ! ORIG9AL S5SE -- PEOPLE LIKE ,MAX ,/IRN] 7#a#i#i#e7 & ,JOHN ,H5RY ,MACKAY -- W]E NEV] NUM]\S1 AS ,BOOK*9 OBS]VES ) TOO MU* SATISFACTION 7#f-#h74 ,& !Y W]E ALWAYS FEW & F> BETWE51 /RANGE TO SAY1 9 DECAD5T1 B\RGEOIS ,NOR? ,AM]ICA1 SUPPOS$LY !IR NATURAL BRE$+-GR\ND4 ,/IRN] DID NOT ID5TIFY HIMSELF AS AN AN>*I/1 PROBABLY BECAUSE ! ONLY 79DE$1 ! V]Y FIR/7 0SELF-/YL$0 AN>*I/ 9 ! #a#h#dS :5 HE WAS WRIT+ WAS ,PR\DHON1 = :OM MORALISM1 AS ,/IRN] NOTIC$1 S]V$ AS A SURROGATE = RELIGION 7IBID43 #d#f7 -- AS IT DOES = ! ,DEAN4 ,! RA!R FEW 9DIVIDUALS :O AT LAT] TIMES CONSID]$ !MSELVES ,/IRN]I/S HAVE1 H[EV]1 USUALLY CONSID]$ !MSELVES AN>*I/S AS WELL1 SU* AS ! ,ITALIAN PEASANT GU]RILLA ,R5ZO ,NOVATORE 7,BLACK @& ,P>FREY #a#i#h#i3 #i#b-#i#c7 

,IT IS WOR? M5TION+ -- BECAUSE SO MANY PEOPLE :O TOSS HIS NAME >\ND HAVE NEV] READ HIM -- ?AT ,/IRN] HAD NO SOCIAL OR ECONOMIC PROGRAM :ATSOEV]4 ,HE WAS NO MORE PRO-CAPITALI/ ?AN HE WAS PRO-COMMUNI/1 AL?\< ,M>XI/S LIKE ,M>X1 ,5GELS & ,BOOK*9 HAVE R\T9ELY & M9DLESSLY CA/IGAT$ HIM AS AN APOLOGI/ = CAPITALISM4 ,/IRN] WAS JU/ NOT OP]AT+ AT ?AT LEVEL4 ,HE WAS /AK+ A CLAIM1 ! MO/ RADICAL CLAIM POSSIBLE1 = ! 9DIVIDUAL AS AGA9/ ALL ! IDEOLOGIES & AB/RACTIONS :I*1 PURPORT+ TO LIB]ATES HIM 9 G5]AL & 9 ! AB/RACT1 LEFT ! 9DIVIDUAL AS P]SONALLY1 PRACTICALLY SUBORD9ATE AS EV]3 0,9 PR9CIPLE444 ,/IRN] CREAT$ A UTOPI/IC VISION ( 9DIVIDUALITY ?AT M>K$ A NEW PO9T ( DEP>TURE = ! AFFIRMATION ( P]SONALITY 9 AN 9CREAS+LY IMP]SONAL WORLD0 7,BOOK*9 #a#i#h#b3 #a#e#i74 ,FROM ,/IRN]'S P]SPECTIVE -- :I* ON ?IS PO9T IS ALSO M9E -- IDEOLOGIES LIKE LIB]ALISM1 HUMANISM1 ,M>XISM1 SYNDICALISM1 & ,BOOK*9ISM HAVE ALL TOO MU* 9 COMMON 7CF4 ,BLACK #a#i#i#d3 #b#b#a-#b#b#b74 

,NOBODY ! ,DEAN D5\NCES AS A 0,/IRN]ITE10 NOT ,MI*AEL ,WILLIAM 7#e71 NOT ,HAKIM ,BEY 7#b#c7 IS A ,/IRN]I/ IF ?IS IMPLIES ?AT HE AFFIRMS AMORAL EGOISM & IS 9DIFF]5T TO OR 5TIRELY AGNO/IC AB\T SOCIAL & ECONOMIC =MATIONS4 ,BO? OBVI\SLY ASSUME AS AXIOMATIC ! NE$ = A SOCIAL MATRIX = 9DIVIDUAL EFFLORESC5CE4 ,:AT DI/+UI%ES !M1 9 MORE ?AN ONE S5SE1 FROM ! ,DEAN IS !IR APPRECIATION ( ! EPI/EMIC BREAK 9 B\RGEOIS ?\<T WR\<T BY ! LIKES ( ,/IRN] & ,NIETZS*E3  
  

,A S5SE ( 9COMPLET5ESS HAUNTS ,WE/]N PHILOSOPHY AFT] ,HEGEL'S DEA? & EXPLA9S MU* ( ! WORK ( ,KI]KEGA>D1 ,S*OP5HAU]1 ,/IRN]1 ,NIETZS*E1 ! SURREALI/S & ! CONTEMPOR>Y EXI/5TIALI/S4 ,= ! ,M>XIANS M]ELY TO DISMISS ?IS PO/-,HEGELIAN DEVELOPM5T AS 0B\RGEOIS IDEOLOGY0 IS TO DISMISS ! PROBLEM ITSELF4  
  

,Y\ GUESS$ IT3 ,BOOK*9 ! ,Y\NG] AGA9 7#a#i#g#a3 #b#g#f74 ,= ,BOOK*9 TO DISMISS ?IS PO/-,HEGELIAN DEVELOPM5T AS 0B\RGEOIS IDEOLOGY0 IS TO DISMISS ! PROBLEM ITSELF4 

,9 A MORE REC5T1 /ILL N>R[] S5SE1 09DIVIDUALISM0 DESIGNATES ?OSE :O COMB9E REJECTION ( GOV]NM5T ) ESP\SAL ( AN ABSOLUTELY UNLIMIT$ LAISSEZ-FAIRE M>KET SY/EM4 ,SU* IDEOLOGUES DO EXI/1 BUT ,BOOK*9 NEV] EV5 M5TIONS A CONTEMPOR>Y EXAMPLE1 AL?\< HE CANNOT BE UNAW>E ( !IR EXI/5CE1 S9CE HE MADE USE ( ONE ( !IR PUBLI%]S1 ,FREE ,LIFE ,BOOKS 7,BOOK*9 #a#i#g#g74 ,CONSID]ABLE CONTACT ) SOME ( !M OV] ! YE>S HAS P]SUAD$ ME ?AT MO/ AN>*O-CAPITALI/S >E S9C]E 9 !IR AN>*ISM1 AL?\< ,I AM AS C]TA9 ?AT AN>*O-CAPITALISM IS SELF-CONTRADICTORY AS ,I AM ?AT AN>*O-SYNDICALISM IS4 ,UNLIKE ! ,DEAN1 ,I'VE ON OCCASION TAK5 ! TR\BLE TO CONFUTE !SE LIB]T>IANS 7,BLACK #a#i#h#f3#a#d#a-#a#d#h2 ,BLACK #a#i#i#b3 #d#c-#f#b74 ,BUT ! PO9T IS1 NOBODY ! ,DEAN T>GETS 9 ?IS SCRE$ IS BY ANY /RET* ( ! IMAG9ATION 7NOT ?AT HE HAS ONE7 AN 09DIVIDUALI/0 AN>*I/ 9 ! USUAL CONTEMPOR>Y S5SE ( ! T]M4 ,HE NEV] EV5 CLAIMS ?AT ANY ( !M >E4 

,! ,DEAN MAKES ! BIZ>RE ALLEGATION ?AT ?OSE HE CALLS LIFE/YLE AN>*I/S1 DECAD5T SUCCESSORS TO ! 9DIVIDUALI/ AN>*I/S1 CLAIM 7! QUOTATION M>KS >E HIS7 !IR 0SOV]EIGN RI<TS0 7#a#b73  
  

,!IR IDEOLOGICAL P$IGREE IS BASICALLY LIB]AL1 GR\ND$ 9 ! MY? ( ! FULLY AUTONOM\S 9DIVIDUAL :OSE CLAIMS TO SELF-SOV]EIGNTY >E VALIDAT$ BY AXIOMATIC 0NATURAL RI<TS10 09TR9SIC WOR?10 OR1 ON A MORE SOPHI/ICAT$ LEVEL1 AN 9TUIT$ ,KANTIAN TRANSC5D5TAL EGO ?AT IS G5]ATIVE ( ALL KN[ABLE REALITY 7#a#a74  
  

,A DIGRESSION ON !1 = LACK ( A BETT] WORD1 E?ICS ( PUNCTUATION M>KS IS 9 ORD] H]E4 0,QUOTATION M>KS10 WROTE ,!ODOR ,ADORNO1  
  

444>E TO BE REJECT$ AS AN IRONIC DEVICE4 ,= !Y EXEMPT ! WRIT] FROM ! SPIRIT :OSE CLAIM IS 9H]5T 9 IRONY1 & !Y VIOLATE ! V]Y CONCEPT ( IRONY BY SEP>AT+ IT FROM ! MATT] AT H& & PRES5T+ A PR$ET]M9$ JUDGM5T ON ! SUBJECT4 ,! ABUNDANT IRONIC QUOTATION M>KS 9 ,M>X & ,5GELS >E ! %AD[S ?AT TOTALIT>IAN ME?ODS CA/ 9 ADVANCE UPON !IR WRIT+S1 :OSE 9T5TION WAS ! OPPOSITE3 ! SE$ FROM :I* EV5TUALLY CAME :AT ,K>L ,KRAUS CALL$ ,MOSKAUD]WELS* .<,MOSC[ D\BLE-TALK1 FROM ,MOSKAU1 ,MOSC[1 & ,KAUD]WELS*1 GIBB]I% OR D\BLE-TALK.>4 ,! 9DIFF]5CE TO L+UI/IC EXPRESSION %[N 9 ! ME*ANICAL DELEGATION ( 9T5TION TO A TYPOGRAPHIC CLI*E >\SES ! SUSPICION ?AT ! V]Y DIALECTIC ?AT CON/ITUTES ! !ORY'S CONT5T HAS BE5 BR\<T TO A /&/ILL & ! OBJECT ASSIMILAT$ TO IT FROM ABOVE1 )\T NEGOTIATION4 ,:]E !RE IS SOME?+ :I* NE$S TO BE SAID1 9DIFF]5CE TO LIT]>Y =M ALMO/ ALWAYS 9DICATES DOGMATIZATION ( ! CONT5T4 ,! BL9D V]DICT ( QUOTATION M>KS IS ITS GRAPHIC GE/URE 7,ADORNO #a#i#i3 #c#c74  
  

,AS A T5UR$ ACADEMIC1 ! ,DEAN IS PRESUMABLY AW>E ?AT 9 S*OL>LY DISC\RSE -- & SURELY HIS MAGI/]IAL ESSAY IS SU* -- QUOTATION M>KS ID5TIFY QUOTATIONS1 YET HIS #de FOOTNOTES FAIL TO REF]5CE ANY USE ( !SE EXPRESSIONS BY ANYBODY4 ,?AT IS BECAUSE NO SU* QUOTATIONS EXI/4 ,SO-CALL$ LIFE/YLE AN>*I/S 7MEAN+3 NON-,BOOK*9I/S7 DON'T USUALLY ?9K OR WRITE ?AT WAY4 ,!Y T5D NOT TO GO 9 = RI<TS-TALK BECAUSE IT IS JU/ AN IDEOLOGICAL1 MY/IFY+ WAY ( SAY+ :AT !Y WANT1 SOME?+ BETT] SAID HONE/LY & DIRECTLY4 

,BY ?IS MALADROIT MISREPRES5TATION1 ! ,DEAN 9ADV]T5TLY EXPOSES HIS ORIG9AL MISUND]/&+ ( ! SO-CALL$ 9DIVIDUALI/ AN>*I/S4 ,MAX ,/IRN] WAS AN AMORAL EGOI/ OR 9DIVIDUALI/4 ,GODW9 & ,PR\DHON W]E1 IF !Y W]E 9DIVIDUALI/S AT ALL1 MORALI/IC 9DIVIDUALI/S PREOCCUPI$ ) :AT !Y CALL$ JU/ICE4 ,LYS&] ,SPOON] WAS AN EXAMPLE ( A CLE>LY MORALI/IC1 NATURAL-RI<TS 9DIVIDUALI/ AN>*I/4 ,BUT :5 ! PROM95T 9DIVIDUALI/ PUBLI%] ,B5JAM9 ,TUCK] W5T OV] TO ,/IRN]I/ EGOISM 9 ! LATE N9ETE5? C5TURY1 HE SPLIT ! ,AM]ICAN 9DIVIDUALI/S4 7,?IS1 AS MU* AS ! COMPETITION FROM COLLECTIVI/S CR$IT$ BY ,BOOK*9 .<#f- #g.>1 BR\<T AB\T ! DECL9E ( ! T5D5CY47 ,AL?\< !RE W]E EXCEPTIONS1 ! MORALI/IC NATURAL-RI<TS 9DIVIDUALI/S -- :I* W]E MO/ ( !M -- USUALLY 5D$ UP AS ESS5TIALLY ADVOCATES ( PURE FREE-M>KET CAPITALISM4 ,?OSE ATTRACT$ TO ! AMORALI/1 EGOI/ OR 7IF Y\ PLEASE7 0,/IRN]I/0 POSITION NECESS>ILY %>$ ) ,/IRN] A :OLE-SALE REJECTION ( MORALISM1 ?AT BE+ :AT ,/IRN]1 & ,NIETZS*E AFT] HIM1 ABSOLUTELY EXPLOD$ AS A T5ABLE PO9T ( VIEW4 ,BUT NO MORE ?AN ,/IRN] DID !Y EXHIBIT ANY 9T]E/ 9 LAISSEZ-FAIRE 7OR ANY7 ECONOMICS4 ,CAPITALISM1 AS ,MAX ,WEB] NOTIC$1 HAS ITS [N MORALISM1 (T5 IF NOT ALWAYS EXPRESS$ AS ! 0,PROTE/ANT E?IC40 ,! EGOI/S_/AMORALI/S & ! FREE-M>KET NATURAL-RI<TI/S P>T$ OV] PRECISELY ?IS PO9T4 ,! EGOI/_/AMORALI/S HAVE CONTRIBUT$ SOME?+ TO ! 0LIFE/YLE AN>*I/S10 ! NATURAL-RI<TI/S HAVE NOT4 

,= 9/ANCE1 TAKE ,L4 ,SUSAN ,BR[N 7PLEASE6 -- NO1 JU/ KIDD+71 :O'S ATTEMPT$1 SAYS ! ,DEAN1 0TO >TICULATE & ELABORATE A BASICALLY 9DIVIDUALI/ AN>*ISM1 YET RETA9 SOME FILIATIONS ) AN>*O-COMMUNISM0 7#a#c71 ,9 A FOOTNOTE HE'S MORE C&ID3 0,BR[N'S HAZY COMMITM5T TO AN>*O-COMMUNISM SEEMS TO D]IVE MORE FROM H] [N PREF]5CE ?AN FROM H] ANALYSIS0 7#f#b74 ,9 O!R WORDS1 MAYBE %E MEANS WELL BUT %E'S JU/ A DITSY DAME1 LIKE ,EMMA ,GOLDMAN4 ,JU/ BELIEV+ 9 AN>*O-COMMUNISM ISN'T GOOD 5\< TO ACQUIT Y\ ( ! *>GE ( 9DIVIDUALISM4 ,Y\ HAVE TO EMOTE A POLITICALLY CORRECT1 ANTI-9DIVIDUALI/ 0ANALYSIS0 TOO4 ,I WOND] H[ MANY ,MAKHNOVI/S1 & H[ MANY ,SPANI% RANK-&-FILE 9SURRECTION>IES FI<T+ = COMUNISMO LIB]T>IO W\LD HAVE PASS$ :ATEV] F9AL EXAM \R P$ANT MI<T ASSIGN TO !M TO TE/ !IR 0ANALYSIS40 ,I HAVE A PRETTY GOOD IDEA H[ !Y W\LD HAVE RECEIV$ SU* AN 9SOL5T 9QUISITION4 ,PO/-SITUATIONI/ ?AT ,I AM1 ,I AM F> FROM SURE ?AT 0! REVOLUTION WILL NOT BE TELEVIS$10 BUT ,I AM QUITE SURE IT WILL NOT BE ON ! F9AL EXAM1 NOT IF TEA*] KN[S :AT'S GOOD = HIM4 ,AS ,M>X SO TRULY SAID1 ! $UCATOR HIMSELF NE$S $UCAT+4 ,& AS ,DIOG5ES SAID1 :Y NOT :IP ! TEA*] :5 ! /UD5T MISBEHAVES8 

,! ,DEAN HAS BR\<T 0D[N TO DATE0 7AS ,M>K ,TWA9 W\LD SAY7 ! ,NEW ,5GL& ,PURITAN EX]CISE KN[N AS ! 0RELATION ( FAI?40 ,9 ORD] TO JO9 ! ,CONGREGATIONAL ,*UR*1 ! APPLICANT NOT ONLY HAD TO AFFIRM EA* & EV]Y T5ET ( ,CALV9ISM1 HE HAD TO DEMON/RATE ?AT HE HAD GONE ?R\< A /&>DIZ$ SEQU5CE ( SPIRITUAL EXP]I5CES4 7,ALCOHOLICS ,ANONYM\S IS ! ONLY ,PROTE/ANT CULT :I* /ILL IMPOSES ?IS REQUIREM5T47 ,MO/ BELIEV]S NEV] MADE IT ?AT F>4 ,:AT ! ,DEAN MEANS BY AN 9ADEQUATE 0ANALYSIS0 IS OBVI\S 5\<3 ANY ANALYSIS O!R ?AN ,BOOK*9ISM IS NO ANALYSIS AT ALL4 ,! 0DISDA9 = !ORY0 HE ASCRIBES TO 09DIVIDUALI/0 AN>*ISM 7#a#a7 IS REALLY DISDA9 =1 OR RA!R 9DIFF]5CE TO1 HIS !ORY4 ,N[ADAYS1 AN>*O-COMMUNISM IS ,BOOK*9ISM OR IT IS NO?+ -- ACCORD+ TO ,BOOK*9 7#f74 

,LIKE IT OR NOT -- P]SONALLY 7& 0P]SONALI/ICALLY071 ,I LIKE IT -- !RE'S AN IRR$UCIBLE 9DIVIDUALI/IC DIM5SION TO AN>*ISM1 EV5 SOCIAL AN>*ISM1 AS ,L4 ,SUSAN ,BR[N IS H>DLY H]ETICAL 9 PO9T+ \T 7#a#i#i#c3 *4 #a74 ,ACCORD+ TO ,KROPOTK91 ,AN>*O-,COMMUNISM SAYS ?AT 0,NO SOCIETY IS FREE SO LONG AS ! 9DIVIDUAL IS NOT60 7#a#h#i3 #a#e74 ,IF IT S\NDS AS IF AN>*ISM HAS1 AS ! ,DEAN MI<T SAY1 0FILIATIONS0 ) LIB]ALISM1 ?AT'S BECAUSE AN>*ISM DOES HAVE FILIATIONS ) LIB]ALISM4 ,:AT ELSE C\LD ! ,DEAN POSSIBLY MEAN :5 HE WRITES ?AT SOCIAL AN>*ISM IS 0MADE ( FUNDAM5TALLY DIFF]5T /UFF0 ?AN LIFE/YLE AN>*ISM1 IT IS 0HEIR TO ! ,5LI<T5M5T TRADITION0 7#e#f78 ,AS AN>*O-SYNDICALI/ ,RUDOLF ,ROCK] WROTE 7& HE WAS ONLY SUMM>IZ+ ! OBVI\S73  
  

,9 MOD]N ,AN>*ISM WE HAVE ! CONFLU5CE ( ! TWO GREAT CURR5TS :I* DUR+ & S9CE ! ,FR5* ,REVOLUTION HAVE F\ND SU* *>ACT]I/IC EXPRESSION 9 ! 9TELLECTUAL LIFE ( ,EUROPE3 ,SOCIALISM & ,LIB]ALISM4444 

,AN>*ISM HAS 9 COMMON ) ,LIB]ALISM ! IDEA ?AT ! HAPP9ESS & ! PROSP]ITY ( ! 9DIVIDUAL MU/ BE ! /&>D 9 ALL SOCIAL MATT]S4 ,&1 9 COMMON ) ! GREAT REPRES5TATIVES ( ,LIB]AL ?\<T1 IT HAS ALSO ! IDEA ( LIMIT+ ! FUNCTIONS ( GOV]NM5T TO A M9IMUM4 ,ITS SUPPORT]S HAVE FOLL[$ ?IS ?\<T TO ITS ULTIMATE LOGICAL CONSEQU5CES1 & WI% TO ELIM9ATE EV]Y 9/ITUTION ( POLITICAL P[] FROM ! LIFE ( SOCIETY 7#a#i#d#g3 #a#f1 #a#h-#a#i74  
  

,IF HE HADN'T SE5 !SE WORDS BE=E1 ! ,DEAN W\LD HAVE COME ACROSS P>T ( !SE PASSAGES AS QUOT$ BY ,BR[N 7#a#i#i#c3#a#a74 ,NATURALLY HE'D RA!R DEBUNK ,BR[N1 AN OBSCURE Y\NG ACADEMIC 7,J>A* #a#i#i#f71 ?AN ! ILLU/RI\S AN>*I/ ELD] ,ROCK]4 ,BOOK*9'S A PLAYGR\ND BULLY :O DOESN'T M9D HITT+ A GIRL ) GLASSES1 BUT HE'D BE (F HIS ,ROCK] TO MESS ) ,RUDOLF4 

,NOBODY *OOSES HIS ANCE/ORS4 ,RATIONALLY1 NO ONE %\LD BE A%AM$ ( !M4 ,VISIT+ ! S9S ( ! FA!RS ON ! *ILDR51 EV5 UNTO ! F\R? G5]ATION 7,EXODUS #c#d3#g7 -- AS ! ,DEAN IS DO+1 PRETTY MU* ON S*$ULE -- H>DLY COMPORTS ) ! ,5LI<T5M5T RATIONALISM HE CLAIMS AS HIS ANCE/RY 7#b#a1 #e#f74 

,! ,LEFT ,?AT ,WAS :I* PROVID$ ,BOOK*9'S ORIG9AL POLITICS1 ,M>XISM-,L59ISM1 ALSO SUPPLI$ HIM ) A MUSCUL> POLEMICAL PRAXIS & A V]SATILE VOCABUL>Y ( ABUSE4 ,I'VE ALREADY DRAWN ATT5TION TO ONE ( !SE GAMBITS1 D5IGRATION-BY-QUOTATION-M>KS4 ,ITS 0FILIATIONS0 9CLUDE ,L59'S 0,LEFT-,W+0 ,COMMUNISM1 AN ,9FANTILE ,DISORD] 7#a#i#d7 & C\NTLESS TEXTS BY ,M>X & ,5GELS1 AS ,ADORNO 7#a#i#i7 NOTIC$4 ,JOHN ,Z]ZAN1 REVIEW+ ,BOOK*9 7#a#i#h#g71 NOT$ A RELAT$ WAY ?AT ! ,DEAN ABUS$ QUOTATION M>KS3 0,ANO!R DEVICE IS TO IGNORE ! REAL HI/ORY ( URBAN LIFE1 AS IF ILLUSORY2 HE RESORTS AT TIMES TO PUTT+ SU* T]MS AS 'ELECT$' REPRES5TATIVES1 'VOT]S' & 'TAXPAY]S' 9 QUOTES AS ?\< ! T]MS REALLY DON'T1 SOMEH[1 CORRESPOND TO REALITY0 7,Z]ZAN #a#i#i#d3 #a#f#e74 ,AS IF TO CONFIRM ?AT HE'S 9CORRIGIBLE1 ,BOOK*9 REF]S TO ?IS REVIEW1 NOT AS A REVIEW1 BUT AS A 0REVIEW0 7#e#i74 ,BOOK*9 WAS DO+ ! SAME ?+ ALMO/ #d YE>S AGO :5 ! FIR/ *APT] ( ,! ,LIMITS ( ! ,CITY 7#a#i#g#d3 IX7 WAS WRITT53 ,T5O*TITLAN WAS ! 0CAPITAL10 NOT ! CAPITAL1 ( ! URBAN1 IMP]IALI/IC1 CANNIBALI/IC ,AZTEC EMPIRE 7IBID43 #g1 #i74 

,BOOK*9 JU/ DOESN'T KN[ :5 TO %UT UP4 ,HAV+ LAMBA/$ 9DIVIDUALI/S AS LIB]ALS1 HE TURNS >\ND & 9S9UATES ?AT !Y >E FASCI/S6 ,CRITICS ( 9DU/RIAL TE*NOLOGY 7SPECIFICALLY1 ,GEORGE ,BRAD=D ( ! ,FIF? ,E/ATE7 :O >GUE ?AT IT DET]M9ES1 AS WELL AS BE+ DET]M9$ BY1 SOCIAL ORGANIZATION >E1 OP9ES ! ,DEAN1 0DEEPLY ROOT$ 9 ! CONS]VATIVE ,G]MAN ROMANTICISM ( ! N9ETE5? C5TURY0 :I* 0F$ 9TO ,NATIONAL ,SOCIALI/ IDEOLOGY1 H[EV] MU* ! ,NAZIS HONOR$ !IR ANTITE*NOLOGICAL IDEOLOGY 9 ! BREA*0 7#b#i74 ,?IS W\LD BE A SOPHI/ICAT$ V]SION ( GUILT-BY-ASSOCIATION IF IT W]E SOPHI/ICAT$4 ,! ,DEAN DOESN'T BO!R TO EV5 ID5TIFY !SE 0CONS]VATIVE ,G]MAN0 ROMANTICS -- HE HASN'T READ !M1 PROBABLY C\LDN'T EV5 NAME !M -- MU* LESS SUB/ANTIATE !IR UNLIKELY 9FLU5CE ON CONTEMPOR>Y 0LIFE/YLE0 AN>*I/S4 ,RETRO-LEFTI/ ?AT HE IS1 ,BOOK*9 MU/ SUPPOSE ?AT BRACKET+ ! HATE-WORDS 0CONS]VATIVE0 & 0,G]MAN0 IS A ONE-TWO PUN* NOBODY RECOV]S FROM4 ,ONE PAGE LAT] 7#c71 HE ADMITS ?AT 0!RE IS NO EVID5CE ?AT ,BRAD=D IS FAMILI> ) ,HEIDEGG] OR ,JUNG]10 ! TW5TIE?-C5TURY ,G]MAN 9TELLECTUALS HE J'ACCUSES AS C>RI]S ( N9ETE5?-C5TURY CONS]VATIVE ,G]MAN ROMANTIC IDEOLOGY4 

,MC,C>?YISM IS ! POLITICAL /RATEGY ( GUILT BY ASSOCIATION4 ,IF Y\ KN[ A ,COMMUNI/1 OR IF Y\ KN[ SOMEONE :O KN[S SOMEONE :O IS A ,COMMUNI/1 PRESUMPTIVELY Y\ >E A ,COMMUNI/ & Y\'LL HAVE TO TALK Y\R WAY \T ( IT1 PREF]ABLY BY RATT+ SOMEBODY \T4 ,! EX-,COMMUNI/ ,BOOK*9 HAS \TDONE ,S5ATOR ,MC,C>?Y4 ,! ,S5ATOR S\<T TO UNCOV] ASSOCIATION AS EVID5CE ( GUILT4 ,! ,DEAN AFFIRMS GUILT AS EVID5CE ( ASSOCIATION4 ,?AT'S REALLY ALL !RE IS TO HIS DIRTY LITTLE DIATRIBE4 ,TO BE EV5 LESS FAIR ?AN ,JOE ,MC,C>?Y IS QUITE AN ACCOMPLI%M5T1 :AT ,NIETZS*E US$ TO CALL A 0D[NGO+40 

,& ANO!R ?+1 N9ETE5?-C5TURY ROMANTICISM WAS NEI!R EXCLUSIVELY CONS]VATIVE NOR EXCLUSIVELY ,G]MAN4 ,:AT AB\T ! LIB]AL OR RADICAL ,G]MAN ROMANTICISM ( ,BEE?OV5 & ,BU*N] & ,S*ILL] & ,HE9E8 ,& :AT AB\T ! NON-,G]MAN RADICAL ROMANTICISM ( ,BLAKE & ,BURNS & ,BYRON & ,%ELLEY8 

,! ,DEAN RELATES ?AT ! ,NAZIS HONOR$ !IR ROMANTIC1 ANTI-TE*NOLOGICAL IDEOLOGY 09 ! BREA*40 0,HONOR$ 9 ! BREA*0 IS ,BOOK*9'S POOR TRY AT HEAD+ (F ! OBVI\S1 & DECISIVE1 OBJECTION ?AT ! ,NAZIS DIDN'T HAVE AN ANTI-TE*NOLOGICAL IDEOLOGY4 ,! ,AUTOBAHN WAS AS MU* A MONUM5T TO TE*NOLOGY AS W]E ITS CONTEMPOR>IES ! ,MOSC[ SUBWAY & ! ,NEW ,YORK ,WORLD'S ,FAIR 7:I*1 ,I SUSPECT1 ?RILL$ ! #a#h-YE>-OLD ,MURRAY ,BOOK*974 ,SO WAS ! ,V-#b4 ,ALMO/ OP5LY ]OTIC REF]5CES TO IRON & /EEL RECUR ) MONOTON\S & PA?OLOGICAL FREQU5CY 9 ,NAZI RHETORIC4 ,AS ,JOHN ,Z]ZAN REM>K$ 9 A BOOK ! ,DEAN CLAIMS TO HAVE READ 7#c#i-#d#b1 #fb N4 #a#i72  
  

,BEH9D ! RHETORIC ( ,NATIONAL ,SOCIALISM1 UN=TUNATELY1 WAS ONLY AN ACCEL]ATION ( TE*NIQUE1 EV5 9TO ! SPH]E ( G5OCIDE AS A PROBLEM ( 9DU/RIAL PRODUCTION4 ,= ! ,NAZIS & ! GULLIBLE1 IT WAS1 AGA9 A QUE/ION ( H[ TE*NOLOGY IS UND]/OOD IDEALLY1 NOT AS IT REALLY IS4 ,9 #aid ! ,G5]AL ,9SPECTOR = ! ,G]MAN ,ROAD ,SY/EM PUT IT ?IS WAY3 0,CONCRETE & /ONE >E MAT]IAL ?+S4 ,MAN GIVES !M =M & SPIRIT4 ,NATIONAL ,SOCIALI/ TE*NOLOGY POSSESSES 9 ALL MAT]IAL A*IEVEM5T IDEAL CONT5T0 7,Z]ZAN #a#i#i#d3 #a#d74  
  

,I'M NOT ONE ( ?OSE :O CRIES \T 9 HORROR AT ! SLI<TE/ :IFF ( ANTI-,SEMITISM4 ,BUT ! ,DEAN SEES FIT TO 9S9UATE ?AT EV5 ! PROMISCU\SLY PLURALI/IC ,HAKIM ,BEY IS IDEOLOGICALLY AK9 TO ,HITL] 7#b#b71 & ?AT ! PRIMITIVI/ QUE/ TO RECOV] AU!NTICITY 0HAS ITS ROOTS 9 REACTION>Y ROMANTICISM1 MO/ REC5TLY 9 ! PHILOSOPHY ( ,M>T9 ,HEIDEGG]1 :OSE VOLKIS* 'SPIRITUALISM1' LAT5T 9 ,BE+ & ,TIME1 LAT] EM]G$ 9 HIS EXPLICITLY FASCI/ WORKS0 7#e74 ,SO LET'S CONSID] :E!R ,BOOK*9-VETT$ CLASSICAL AN>*I/S >E IDEOLOGICALLY KO%]4 ,PR\DHON WAS NOTORI\SLY ANTI- ,SEMITIC 7,SILB5] #a#i#d#h71 BUT S9CE ,BOOK*9 DISMISSES HIM1 H[EV] IMPLAUSIBLY1 AS TOO MU* ! 9DIVIDUALI/ 7#d-#e71 LET'S SET ,PR\DHON ASIDE4 ,BAKUN91 ! ,RUSSIAN >I/OCRAT :O 0EMPHATICALLY PRIORITIZ$ ! SOCIAL OV] ! 9DIVIDUAL0 7#e7 HAD A NOTION :AT WAS WRONG ) HIS AU?ORIT>IAN RIVAL1 ,K>L ,M>X4 ,BAKUN9 CONSID]$ ,M>X1 0! ,G]MAN S*OL>1 9 HIS ?REEFOLD CAPACITY AS AN ,HEGELIAN1 A ,JEW1 & A ,G]MAN10 TO BE A 0HOPELESS /ATI/0 7#a#i#i#e3#a#d#b74 ,A ,HEGELIAN1 A ,JEW1 A SORT-( S*OL>1 A ,M>XI/1 A HOPELESS 7CITY-7 /ATI/ -- DOES ?IS S\ND LIKE ANYBODY FAMILI>8 

,! ,DEAN APPROV+LY QUOTES ,LEWIS ,MUM=D ON 0! ES!TIC EXCELL5CE ( ! MA*9E =M0 7#c#b71 A PHRASE :I* MI<T HAVE BE5 TURN$ BY ,M>9ETTI OR ,MUSSOL9I OR ANYONE ELSE ON ! ILL-DEF9$ FRONTI] BETWE5 ,FUTURISM & ,FASCISM 7CF4 ,MOORE #a#i#i#f3 #a#h74 ,9 ,W>1 ! ,WORLDS ,ONLY ,HYGI5E1 ,M>9ETTI ELABORAT$ ON ! ,BOOK*9_/,MUM=D ES!TIC3  
  

,WE >E DEVELOP+ & PROCLAIM+ A GREAT NEW IDEA ?AT RUNS ?R\< MOD]N LIFE3 ! IDEA ( ME*ANICAL BEAUTY4 ,WE !RE=E EXALT LOVE = ! MA*9E1 ! LOVE WE NOTICE FLAM+ ON ! *EEKS ( ME*ANICS SCOR*$ & SME>$ ) COAL4 ,HAVE Y\ NEV] SE5 A ME*ANIC LOV+LY AT WORK ON ! GREAT P[]FUL BODY ( HIS LOCOMOTIVE8 ,HIS IS ! M9UTE1 LOV+ T5D]NESS ( A LOV] C>ESS+ HIS ADOR$ WOMAN 7,FL9T #a#i#g#b3 #i74  
  

,! ,G]MANS CONQU]$ ,EUROPE ) ,PANZ]S & ,/UKAS NOT BY BLOOD-&-SOIL HOCUS-POCUS4 ,NAZI IDEOLOGY IS F> TOOL 9COH]5T TO BE *>ACT]IZ$ AS EI!R PRO- OR ANTI-TE*NOLOGICAL4 ,! ,DEAN 9 BEWAIL+ \R 0DECAD5T1 B\RGEOISIFI$ ]A0 7#a7 & \R 0DECAD5T P]SONALISM0 7#b7 IS HIMSELF E*O+ ,NAZI & ,/AL9I/ RHETORIC1 AS HE SURELY REMEMB]S1 & IT'S AS EMPTY AS EV]4 ,! PO9T IS ?AT ! IDEOLOGY DIDN'T HAVE TO MAKE S5SE TO MATT]4 ,IT WAS VAGUE & 9CONSI/5T SO AS TO APPEAL TO AS MANY PEOPLE AS POSSIBLE :O DESP]ATELY NE$$ SOME?+ TO BELIEVE 91 SOME?+ TO FREE !M FROM FRE$OM1 SOME?+ TO COMM& !IR LOYALTY4 ,IT DIDN'T HAVE TO BE ! SAME COME-ON = EV]YONE4 ,! ,NAZIS1 FI%]S ( ,M5S*51 UND]/OOD ?AT Y\ NE$ DIFF]5T BAIT TO HOOK DIFF]5T FI%1 ?AT'S ALL4 

,& F9ALLY1 9DIVIDUALI/ AN>*I/S >E T]RORI/S -- OR RA!R1 AN>*I/ T]RORI/S >E 9DIVIDUALI/S4 

,! 9SEP>ABLE ASSOCIATION ( AN>*ISM ) T]RORISM COMM5C$ = ,AM]ICANS ) A SPECIFIC EV5T3 ! ,HAYM>KET TRAG$Y 9 ,*ICAGO 9 #a#h#h#f4 ,AS ! POLICE W]E BREAK+ UP A PEACEABLE WORK]S' RALLY1 SOMEONE ?REW A BOMB 9TO !IR MID/1 KILL+ OR W\ND+ SEV]AL ( !M4 ,EI<T PROM95T AN>*I/S 9VOLV$ 9 ! UNION MOVEM5T1 BUT 9DISPUTABLY 9NOC5T ( ! BOMB+1 W]E CONVICT$ ( MURD] & F\R ( !M HANG$ 7ONE COMMITT$ SUICIDE7 ON ! BASIS ( !IR AN>*I/ AGITATION & BELIEFS4 ,IF !RE IS ONE FACT AB\T ! HI/ORY ( AN>*ISM KN[N TO EV]YONE :O KN[S AT LEA/ ONE FACT AB\T ! HI/ORY ( AN>*ISM1 IT IS ?IS3 0,!REAFT]1 AN>*ISM1 9 ! PUBLIC M9D1 WAS 9SEP>ABLY L9K$ ) T]RORISM & DE/RUCTION0 7,AVRI* #a#i#h#d3 #d#b#h2 CF4 ,S*U/] #a#i#c#b3 #a#f#f2 ,WOODCOCK #a#i#f#b3 #d#f#d74 ,& ! AN>*ISM ) :I* ! L9K WAS =G$ WAS ! COLLECTIVI/ AN>*ISM ( ! ,HAYM>KET DEF5DANTS4 ,?AT !Y W]E1 AS 9DIVIDUALS1 9NOC5T IS IRRELEVANT TO ! G5ESIS ( ! MAD-BOMB] LEG5D4 ,9NOC5T 9 ACT BUT NOT NECESS>ILY 9 9T5TION3 0,ONE ( !M1 .<,L\IS.> ,L+G1 HAD ! BE/ ALIBI3 HE WASN'T !RE444 HE WAS HOME1 MAK+ BOMBS4 ,HE WAS ?US CONVICT$ ( A CRIME HE W\LD HAVE LIK$ TO COMMIT0 7,BLACK @& ,P>FREY #a#i#h#i3 #f#g74 ,9 CONTRA/1 ONE HI/ORIAN REF]S TO 0! PEACEFUL PHILOSOPHY ( ,9DIVIDUALI/ ,AN>*ISM0 7,S*U/] #a#i#c#b3 #a#e#i74 

,! AN>*I/S' T]RORI/ REPUTATION WAS NOT1 H[EV]1 5TIRELY FABRICAT$ BY !IR 5EMIES 7,BLACK #a#i#i#d3 #e-#e#e74 ,9 ! #a#h#hS1 LEFT-W+ ,EUROPEAN AN>*I/S HAD ALREADY BEGUN TO PREA*1 & PRACTICE1 0PROPAG&A BY ! DE$10 SU* AS BOMB+S -- 0*EMI/RY10 AS !Y SOMETIMES PUT IT -- & ASSASS9ATIONS4 ,EV5 ! BEATIFIC ,KROPOTK9 WAS ORIG9ALLY A SUPPORT] ( 0! NEW TACTIC0 7,BOOK*9 #a#i#g#g3 #a#a#e74 ,SOME ?\<T IT ! MO/ EFFECTIVE WAY TO DRAMATIZE AN>*ISM & DISSEM9ATE IT TO ! MASSES4 ,ACCORD+ TO :AT ! ,DEAN CALLS 0! BE/ ACC\NT ( ,SPANI% ,AN>*ISM FROM #aica TO #a#i#c#f0 7,BOOK*9 #a#i#g#g3 #c#b#e71 0! LA/ DECADE ( ! .<N9ETE5?.> C5TURY WAS ONE 9 :I* ! AN>*I/S REALLY W]E 5GAG$ 9 ! BOMB-?R[+ :I* IS POPUL>LY ?\<T TO EXHAU/ !IR RANGE ( ACTIVITIES0 7,BRADEMAS #a#i#e#c3 #i74 

,!SE AN>*I/ T]RORI/S W]E1 TO APPLY ,BOOK*9'S T]M9OLOGY ANA*RONI/ICALLY1 USUALLY SOCIAL AN>*I/S1 R>ELY 9DIVIDUALI/ AN>*I/S4 ,AUGU/ ,VAILLANT1 :O BOMB$ ! ,FR5* ,*AMB] ( ,DEPUTIES1 WAS A LEFTI/ 7,TU*MAN #a#i#f#f3 #i#a7 & A MEMB] ( AN AN>*I/ GR\P 7,BOOK*9 #a#i#g#g3 #a#a#d74 ,( ! ,FR5* BOMB]S ( ! #a#h#iS1 ,RAVA*OL ALONE1 SO F> AS ANYBODY KN[S1 WAS 0ALMO/ BUT NOT QUITE0 A ,/IRN]I/ 7,TU*MAN #a#i#f#d3 #g#i74 

,! ,SPANI% AN>*I/S :OM ! ,DEAN E/EEMS ABOVE ALL O!RS 7#a#i#g#g1 #a#i#i#d7 HAD P]HAPS ! LONGE/ T]RORI/ TRADITION ( ALL4 ,! 9DEX REF]5CE TO 0,T]RORISM1 AN>*I/0 9 HIS HI/ORY ( ,SPANI% AN>*ISM COV]S DOZ5S ( PAGES 7#a#i#g#g3 #c#d#b74 ,!RE W]E SPORADIC BOMB+S 9 ! #a#h#hS :I* BECAME *RONIC1 AT LEA/ 9 ! AN>*I/ /RON<OLD ( ,B>CELONA1 9 ! #a#h#iS 7,BOOK*9 #a#i#g#g3 *4 #f74 #a#i#a#h-#a#i#b#c1 P]IOD ( VIOL5T CLASS /RUGGLE 9 ,SPA91 WAS ! TIME ( ! PI/OL]OS -- GUNM5 -- A T]M :I* APPLIES TO BO? EMPLOY]-HIR$ GOONS & AN>*O-LEFTI/ MILITANTS4 ,AMONG HUNDR$S ( O!RS1 0A PREMI]1 TWO =M] CIVIL GOV]NORS1 AN ,>*-BI%OP1 NE>LY #c EMPLOY]S1 FACTORY DIRECTORS1 =EM51 & POLICE1 & MANY WORK]S & !IR LEAD]S 9 ! S9DICATO LIBRE .<A COMPANY UNION.>1 FELL BE=E ! BULLETS & BOMBS ( ,AN>*I/ ACTION GR\PS0 7,BOOK*9 #a#i#g#g3 #a#i#a74 

,! PI/OL]O PHASE SUBSID$ AS ! AN>*I/S1 :O W]E GETT+ ! WOR/ ( ! VIOL5CE ANYWAY1 W]E DRIV5 UND]GR\ND BY ! ,PRIMO DE ,RIV]A DICTATOR%IP AT ! SAME TIME ?AT A MEASURE ( PROSP]ITY TOOK ! $GE (F ! CLASS /RUGGLE4 ,BUT AN>*O-T]RORISM NEV] CEAS$4 ,DUR+ ! '#b,OS & '#c,OS1 0! ,F,A,I'S MO/ WELL-KN[N MILITANTS -- ,DURRUTI1 ! ,ASCASO BRO!RS1 ,G>CIA ,OLIV] -- 9CLUD$ T]RORISM 9 !IR REP]TORY ( DIRECT ACTION3 ',GUNPLAY1 ESPECIALLY 9 0EXPROPRIATIONS0 & 9 DEAL+ ) RECALCITRANT EMPLOY]S1 POLICE AG5TS1 & BLACKLEGS1 WAS NOT FR[N$ UPON'0 7,BOOK*9 #a#i#i#d3 #b#c74 ,!IR HEI/S 0SU/A9$ ,F]R]-TYPE S*OOLS1 ,AN>*I/ PR9T+ PRESSES1 & A L>GE PUBLI%+ 5T]PRISE 9 ,P>IS :I* PRODUC$ ! ,AN>*I/ ,5CYCLOP$IA1 AS WELL AS MANY BOOKS1 PAMPHLETS1 & P]IODICALS0 7,BOOK*9 #a#i#g#g3 #a#i#i74 

,I ADDUCE !SE FACTS -- & REF]5CE MO/ ( !M1 DELIB]ATELY1 TO ,BOOK*9 -- NOT TO CONDEMN OR CONDONE :AT 0SOCIAL AN>*I/S0 HAVE SOMETIMES DONE BUT TO %[ UP ! ,DEAN'S DUPLICITY4 ,T]RORISM HAS BE51 = BETT] OR = WORSE1 A RECURR5T AN>*I/ TACTIC = MORE ?AN A C5TURY4 ,& ! AN>*O-T]RORI/S HAVE ALMO/ ALWAYS BE5 0SOCIAL10 NOT 9DIVIDUALI/1 AN>*I/S4 ,I'VE HAD OCCASION TO REBUT LEFTI/ FALSIFICATIONS TO ! CONTR>Y 7,BLACK #a#i#i#d3 #e-#e#e74 ,BOOK*9 JU/IFIES ,SPANI% AN>*O-PI/OL]O T]RORISM AS LEGITIMATE SELF-DEF5SE 7#a#i#g#g3 #b#a-#b#b71 AN OP9ION ,I %>E1 BUT ! FACT REMA9S ?AT IT WAS T]RORISM -- 9 ,BOOK*9ESE1 0SOCIAL AN>*I/0 T]RORISM -- NOT ! ACTIVITY ( 9DIVIDUALI/ AN>*I/S4 

,FROM 3 ,!,AN>*I/,LIBR>Y4ORG4 

,*RONOLOGY 3 
,NOVEMB] #c1 #aiif 3 ,*APT] #b -- ,PUBLICATION4 
,NOVEMB] #b#i1 #bb 3 ,*APT] #b -- ,ADD$4 

 FILE G5]AT$ FROM 3  
HTTP3_/_/REVOLTLIB4COM_/