,AN>*ISM3 ,PA/ & ,PRES5T #aih ,PEOPLE 3 ,AU?OR 3 ,MURRAY ,BOOK*9 ,TAGS 3 AN>*I/ !ORIES & MOVEM5TS1 UNIV]SALITY ( ! PROLET>IAT1 WAGE LABOR V]SUS CAPITAL1 !ORIES & MOVEM5TS1 !ORY & PRACTICE1 DOM9ATION ( NATURE1 DIVISION ( LABOR1 LABOR V]SUS CAPITAL1 OBJECTIFICATION ( NATURE1 G5ESIS ( HI]>*Y4 ,TEXT 3 ,PHOTO BY OP5M$IABO/ON1,C,C ,B,Y-,N,C-,S,A ,LIC5SE ,NOTE3 ,?IS PIECE APPE>$ AS ,VOL4 #a1 ,NO4 #f ( ,COMM5T3 ,NEW ,P]SPECTIVES 9 ,LIB]T>IAN ,?\*ISM3 ,PA/ & ,PRES5T ,NOTE3 ,! FOLL[+ ISSUE ( ,C,O,M,M,5,T WAS PRES5T$ AS A LECTURE TO ! ,CRITICAL ,!ORY ,SEM9> ( ! ,UNIV]SITY ( ,CALI=NIA AT ,LOS ,ANGELES ON ,MAY #b#i1 #a#i#h4 ,MY REM>KS >E 9T5D$ TO EMPHASIZE ! EXTREME IMPORTANCE TODAY ( VIEW+ ,AN>*ISM 9 T]MS ( ! *ANG+ SOCIAL CONTEXTS ( \R ]A - - NOT AS AN OSSIFI$ DOCTR9E ?AT BELONGS TO ONE OR ANO!R SET ( ,EUROPEAN ?9K]S1 VALUABLE AS !IR VIEWS MAY HAVE BE5 9 !IR V>I\S TIMES & PLACES4 ,TODAY1 MORE ?AN EV]1 ! VIABILITY ( ,AN>*ISM 9 ,AM]ICA WILL DEP5D UPON ITS ABILITY TO SPEAK DIRECTLY -- 9 ! LANGUAGE ( ! ,AM]ICAN PEOPLE & TO LIV+ PROBLEMS ( ! ,AM]ICAN PEOPLE -- RA!R ?AN TO RESURRECT IDEAS1 EXPRESSIONS1 SLOGANS & A WE>Y V]NACUL> ?AT BELONG TO ]AS PA/4 ,?IS IS NOT TO D5Y ! 9T]NATIONALI/ SPIRIT ( ,AN>*ISM OR ITS HI/ORICAL CONT9UITY1 BUT RA!R TO /RESS ! NE$ TO SOLID>IZE ) LIB]T>IAN TRADITIONS & CONCEPTS ?AT >E CLE>LY RELEVANT TO DOM9AT$ PEOPLES 9 ! >EAS -- CONCEIV$ 9 T]MS ( PLACE1 TIME1 & =MS -- 9 :I* LIB]T>IAN MOVEM5TS FUNCTION4 ,!RE IS A GRAVE DANG] ?AT ,AN>*ISM MAY BE DEALT ) SIMPLI/ICALLY1 ! WAY WE DEAL ) MO/ RADICAL 0ISMS0 TODAY -- AS A FIX$ BODY ( !ORY & PRACTICE ?AT SO (T5 R$UCES ,SOCIALISM TO ! TEXTUAL WORKS ( ,M>X & ,5GELS & !IR ACOLYTES4 ,I DO NOT MEAN TO D5Y ! G5]IC MEAN+ ( T]MS LIKE 0,SOCIALISM4 0 ,!RE >E MANY TYPES ( ,SOCIALISMS RANG+ FROM ! UTOPIAN TO ! ,L59I/1 FROM ! E?ICAL TO ! SCI5TIFIC4 ,I SIMPLY WI% TO /AKE \T ! SAME CLAIM = ,AN>*ISM4 ,WE MU/ ALWAYS REMEMB] ?AT !RE >E ALSO MANY =MS ( ,AN>*ISM1 NOTABLY AN>*O-SYNDICALISM1 AN>*O-9DIVIDUALISM1 AN>*O-COLLECTIVISM1 AN>*O-COMMUNISM1 &1 AMUS+LY 5\<1 AN>*O-,BOL%EVISM IF ,I READ ! HI/ORY ( ! ,SPANI% ,AN>*I/ MOVEM5T CORRECTLY4 ,!SE ,AN>*I/ !ORIES & MOVEM5TS HAVE BE5 BURD5$ BY ALL ! 9TRAMURAL CONFLICTS WE 5C\NT] BETWE5 ,SOCIALI/S1 ALBEIT 9 A LESS BLOODY & LE?AL =M4 ,:AT REALLY CONC]NS ME ) ! WIDE RANGE ( ,AN>*ISMS1 H[EV]1 GOES WELL BEYOND ! G5]IC *>ACT] ( ! T]M4 ,I CANNOT /RESS /RONGLY 5\< ?AT ,AN>*ISM NOT ONLY 5COMPASSES A WIDE V>IETY ( !ORIES & MOVEM5TS BUT MORE IMPORTANTLY IT HAS A V]Y RI* HI/ORICAL G5ESIS & DEVELOPM5T4 ,?IS IS CRUCIAL TO AN UND]/&+ ( :AT ,I HAVE TO SAY4 ,MORE SO ?AN ANY RADICAL MOVEM5T ) :I* WE >E FAMILI>1 ,AN>*ISM IS A PR(\NDLY SOCIAL MOVEM5T AS DI/+UI%$ FROM ! USUAL POLITICAL MOVEM5TS WE ASSOCIATE ) ,! ,LEFT4 ,ITS VITALITY1 ITS !ORETICAL =M1 9DE$ ITS V]Y RAISON D'ETRE /EM FROM ITS CAPACITY TO EXPRESS ! MILL5NIA-LONG ASPIRATIONS ( PEOPLES TO CREATE !IR [N EGALIT>IAN OR1 AT LEA/1 SELF-ADM9I/]$ SOCIAL /RUCTURES1 !IR [N =MS ( HUMAN CONSOCIATION BY :I* !Y CAN EX]CISE CONTROL OV] !IR LIVES4 ,9 ?IS S5SE1 ,AN>*ISM REALLY CON/ITUTES A FOLK OR PEOPLE'S SOCIAL PHILOSOPHY & PRACTICE 9 ! RI*E/ S5SE ( ! T]M1 JU/ AS ! FOLK SONG CON/ITUTES ! EMOTIONAL EXPRESSION ( A PEOPLE 9 !IR ES!TIC OR SPIRITUAL DEP?S4 ,! ,HELL5IC ORIG9S ( ! T]MS AN>*E OR 0NO RULE0 %\LD NOT DECEIVE US 9TO ?9K+ ?AT IT CAN BE READILY PLAC$ 9 ! ACADEMIC SPECTRUM ( SOCIAL IDEAS4 ,HI/ORICALLY1 ,AN>*ISM HAS F\ND EXPRESSION 9 NON-AU?ORIT>IAN CLANS1 TRIBES & TRIBAL F$]ATIONS1 9 ! DEMOCRATIC 9/ITUTIONS ( ! ,A!NIAN POLIS1 9 ! E>LY M$IEVAL COMMUNES1 9 ! RADICAL ,PURITAN CONGREGATIONS ( ! ,5GLI% ,REVOLUTION1 9 ! DEMOCRATIC T[N MEET+S ?AT SPREAD FROM ,BO/ON TO ,*>LE/ON AFT] #a#g#f1 9 ! ,P>IS ,COMMUNE ( #a#h#g#a1 ! SOVIETS ( #aie & #a#i#a#g1 ! ,AN>*I/ PUEBLOS1 B>RIOS1 & WORK]-CONTROLL$ %OPS ( ! ,SPANI% ,REVOLUTION ( #aicf -- 9 %ORT1 9 ! SELF-DIRECT$1 E>LY & CONTEMPOR>Y1 SOCIAL =MS ( HUMANITY ?AT HAVE 9/ITUTIONALLY 9VOLV$ PEOPLE 9 FACE-TO-FACE RELATIONS BAS$ ON DIRECT DEMOCRACY1 SELF-MANAGEM5T1 ACTIVE CITIZ5%IP1 & P]SONAL4 P>TICIPATION4#a ,IT IS )9 ?IS ELECTRIC PUBLIC SPH]E ?AT ! ,AN>*I/ CR$O ( DIRECT ACTION F9DS ITS REAL ACTUALIZATION4 ,9DE$1 DIRECT ACTION NOT ONLY MEANS ! OCCUPATION ( A NUCLE> P[] PLANT SITE BUT LESS DRAMATIC1 (T5 PROSAIC1 & T$I\S =MS ( SELF-MANAGEM5T ?AT 9VOLVE PATI5CE1 COMMITM5T TO DEMOCRATIC PROC$URES1 L5G?Y DISC\RSE1 & A DEC5T RESPECT = ! OP9IONS ( O!RS )9 ! SAME COMMUNITY4 ,?IS 9/ITUTIONAL FRAMEWORK & S5SIBILITY IS ! AU!NTIC MILIEU ( ,AN>*ISM1 ITS V]Y PROTOPLASM4 ,! !ORIES ?AT EM]GE FROM ! ACTIVITY ( ?IS PROTOPLASM >E ! =MS ( SELF-REFLEXIVE RATIONALITY ?AT GIVE IT COH]5CE & CONSCI\SNESS4 ,TO MY ?9K+1 ! 0,DIGG]0 ,W9/ANLEY1 ! ,5RAGE ,V>LAT1 ! >TISAN ,PR\DHON1 ! WORK] ,PELL\TI]1 & ! ,RUSSIAN 9TELLECTUALS ,BAKUN9 & ,KROPOTK9 VOICE AT V>I\S LEVELS ( CONSCI\SNESS DIFF]5T1 (T5 CLE>LY DEL9EABLE1 PHASES ( HUMANITY'S ORGANIC EVOLUTION T[>D FRE$OM4 ,ONE CAN (T5 ASSOCIATE !SE 9DIVIDUALS OR ! IDEAS !Y DEVELOP$ ) ! ACTUAL DEVELOPM5T ( ! POPUL> SOCIAL =MS FROM :I* !Y EM]G$ OR TO :I* !Y GAVE IDEOLOGICAL COH]5CE4 ,?US ONE CAN JU/IFIABLY ASSOCIATE ,W9/ANLEY'S IDEAS ) ! AGR>IAN ,AN>*ISM ( ! YEOMAN COMMUNITIES 9 SEV5TE5?-C5TURY ,5GL&1 ,V>LAT ) ! URBAN NEI*ISM ( ! REVOLUTION>Y SECTIONS & ,5RAGE MOVEM5T ( ,P>IS 9 #a#g#i#c1 ,PR\DHON ) ! >TISAN ,AN>*ISM ( CRAFTSPEOPLE 9 PRE-9DU/RIAL ,FRANCE1 ,BAKUN9'S AN>*O-COLLECTIVISM ) ! PEASANT VILLAGES ( ,RUSSIA & ,SPA91 ,PELL\TI]'S AN>*O-SYNDICALISM1 ) ! 9DU/RIAL PROLET>IAT & EM]G+ FACTORY SY/EM &1 P]HAPS MO/ PROPHETICALLY1 ,KROPOTK9'S AN>*O-COMMUNISM ) \R [N ]A1 A BODY ( !ORY ?AT READILY L5DS ITSELF TO ! ECOLOGICAL1 DEC5TRALI/1 TE*NOLOGICAL1 & URBAN ISSUES ?AT HAVE COME TO ! =EGR\ND ( SOCIAL LIFE TODAY4 ,! ANTI-/ATI/ & ANTI-POLITICAL VIEWS ( !SE ,AN>*I/ ?9K]S %\LD NOT OBSCURE ! POSITIVE CONT5T ( !IR VIEWS & !IR ROOTS4 ,! ,M>XIAN NOTION ?AT HUMAN 0SOCIALIZATION0 REA*ES ITS MO/ ADVANC$ HI/ORICAL =M ) B\RGEOIS SOCIETY -- A SOCIETY ?AT /RIPS HUMANITY ( ITS REMA9+ BIOSOCIAL TRAPP+S -- W\LD HAVE BE5 EMPHATICALLY REJECT$ BY !SE ,AN>*I/S IF ONLY ON ! 9TUITIVE GR\NDS ?AT SOCIETY CAN NEV] BE TOTALLY D5ATUR$4 ,AS ,I HAVE >GU$ ELSE:]E 7SEE MY 0,BEYOND ,NEO-,M>XISM0 9 ,TELOS1 ,NO4 #c#f71 SOCIETY NEV] FREES ITSELF ( ITS NATURAL MATRIX1 EV5 9 ! 9T]NAL RELATIONS BETWE5 9DIVIDUALS4 ,! ACTUAL ISSUE1 IF ONE IS TO LE>N FROM ! ECOLOGICAL PROBLEMS ( \R TIME1 IS ! NATURE ( ?AT NATURE 9 :I* SOCIETY IS ROOT$ -- ORGANIC 7AS WAS ! CASE 9 MANY PRECAPITALI/ COMMUNITIES7 OR 9ORGANIC 7AS IS ! CASE 9 M>KET SOCIETY74 ,! CLAN1 TRIBE1 POLIS1 M$IEVAL COMMUNE1 EV5 ! ,P>ISIAN SECTIONS1 ! ,COMMUNE1 C]TA9LY ! VILLAGE & DEC5TRALIZ$ T[NS ( ! PA/1 W]E ROOT$ 9 BIO-SOCIAL RELATIONS4 ,M>KET SOCIETY ) ITS ATOMIZATION1 COMPETITION1 TOTAL OBJECTIFICATION ( ! 9DIVIDUAL & H] OR HIS LABOR-P[] -- NOT TO SPEAK ( ! BUREAUCRATIC S9EWS ?AT HOLD ?IS LIFELESS /RUCTURE TOGE!R1 ! CONCRETE1 /EEL1 & GLASS CITIES & SUBURBS ?AT PROVIDE ITS 5VIRONM5TS1 & QUANTIFICATION ?AT P]MEATES EV]Y ASPECT ( ITS ACTIVITY -- ALL ( !SE NOT ONLY D5Y LIFE 9 ! BIOLOGICAL & ORGANIC S5SE BUT R$UCE IT TO ITS MOLECUL> COMPON5TS 9 ! PHYSICAL & 9ORGANIC S5SE4 ,B\RGEOIS SOCIETY DOES NOT A*IEVE SOCIETY'S DOM9ATION ( NATURE2 RA!R1 IT LIT]ALLY DESOCIALIZES SOCIETY BY MAK+ IT AN OBJECT TO BE APPROPRIAT$ BY 9ORGANIC NATURE1 BY ! B\RGEOIS 9 HIS 9N] BE+ & HIS SOCIAL BE+4 ,! BUREAUCRACY COLONIZES ! SOCIAL 9/ITUTIONS ( HUMANITY2 ! CONCRETE CITY1 ! ORGANIC RELATIONS ( NATURE2 CYB]NETICS & ! MASS M$IA1 ! 9DIVIDUAL'S P]SONALITY2 9 %ORT1 M>KET 0SOCIETY0 COLONIZES EV]Y ASPECT ( P]SONAL & SOCIAL LIFE4 ,I CANNOT EMPHASIZE TOO /RONGLY ! UMBILICAL CORD ?AT UNITES ORGANIC SOCIETIES1 9 ! S5SE & ) ! QUALIFICATIONS ,I HAVE DESCRIB$ !M1 ) ,AN>*I/ !ORIES & MOVEM5TS4 ,NOR CAN ,I DESI/ FROM NOT+ ! EXT5T TO :I* ,M>XISM1 BY CONTRA/1 IS L9K$ TO ! MO/ 9ORGANIC ( ALL HUMAN /RUCTURES1 ! /ATE -- & AT O!R LAY]S ( HI]>*Y1 ) ?AT MO/ 9ORGANIC ( ALL OPPRESS$ CLASSES1 ! PROLET>IAT & SU* 9/ITUTIONALIZ$ =MS ( C5TRALIZ$ P[] AS ! FACTORY1 ! P>TY1 & ! BUREAUCRACY4 ,?AT ! V]Y 0UNIV]SALITY0 ( ! PROLET>IAT ?AT ,M>X CELEBRATES 9 ! =M ( ITS DEHUMANIZATION BY CAPITAL1 ITS ASSOCIATION ) A TE*NOLOGICAL FRAMEWORK BAS$ ON C5TRALIZATION1 DOM9ATION1 & RATIONALIZATION :I* PRESUMABLY R5D] IT 9TO A REVOLUTION>Y =CE REVEALS ! EXT5T TO :I* ,M>X'S [N !ORETICAL CORPUS IS ROOT$ 9 B\RGEOIS IDEOLOGY 9 ITS LEA/ SELF-REFLEXIVE =M4 ,= ?IS 0UNIV]SALITY0 AS WE CAN N[ SEE CELEBRATES ! 0HOLL[+ \T0 ( SOCIETY ITSELF1 ITS 9CREAS+ VULN]ABILITY TO BUREAUCRATIC MANIPULATION 9 9DU/RY & POLITICS BY CAPITAL & TRADE UNIONS4 0,S*OOL$0 BY ! NUCLE> FAMILY1 BY VOCATIONAL SUP]VISORS1 BY ! HI]>*ICAL FACTORY /RUCTURE1 & BY ! DIVISION ( LABOR1 ! 0UNIV]SALITY0 ( ! PROLET>IAT TURNS \T TO BE ! FACELES5ESS ( ! PROLET>IAT -- ITS EXPRESSION NOT ( ! G5]AL 9T]E/S ( HUMANITY 9 ITS PROGRESS T[>D SOCIALISM BUT ITS P>TICUL> 9T]E/S1 9DE$1 ( 9T]E/S AS SU*1 AS ! EXPRESSION ( B\RGEOIS EGOISM4 ,! FACTORY DOES NOT UNITE ! PROLET>IAT2 IT DEF9ES IT -- & NO T5D5CY MORE CLE>LY EXPRESSES ! PROLET>IAT'S HUMAN DESIRES ?AN ITS ATTEMPT TO ESCAPE FROM ! FACTORY1 TO SEEK :AT ! ,B]L9 ,DADAI/S ( #aiah W]E TO DEM&3 0UNIV]SAL UNEMPLOYM5T40 ,I,I ,!SE F>-REA*+ DI/9CTIONS BETWE5 ,AN>*ISM AS A SOCIAL MOVEM5T & ,M>XISM AS A POLITICAL ONE REQUIRE FUR!R EM5DATIONS4 ,I HAVE NO QU>REL ) ! GREAT WEAL? ( ,M>X'S WRIT+S1 P>TICUL>LY HIS WORK ON ALI5ATION1 HIS ANALYSIS ( ! COMMODITY RELATION%IP & ! ACCUMULATION ( CAPITAL4 ,HIS HI/ORICAL !ORIES REQUIRE ! CORRECTION ( ! BE/ WORK ( ,MAX ,WEB] & ,K>L ,POLANYI4 ,BUT IT IS NOT ,M>X'S WRIT+S ?AT MU/ BE UPDAT$4 ,!IR LIMITS >E DEF9$ BY !IR FUNDAM5TALLY B\RGEOIS ORIG9S & !IR 9CR$IBLE SUSCEPTIBILITY TO POLITICAL1 ?AT IS1 /ATE-ORI5T$ IDEOLOGIES4 ,HI/ORICALLY1 IT IS NOT ACCID5TAL ?AT ,AN>*ISM 9 ,SPA91 9 ! ,UKRA9E1 &1 9 ITS ,ZAPATI/A =M 9 ,MEXICO1 C\LD BE CRU%$ ONLY BY A G5OCIDAL DE/RUCTION ( ITS SOCIAL ROOTS1 NOTABLY ! VILLAGE4 ,M>XIAN MOVEM5TS1 :]E !Y SUFF] DEFEAT1 >E CRU%$ M]ELY BY DEMOLI%+ ! P>TY4 ,! SEEM+ 0ATAVISM0 ( ,AN>*ISM -- ITS ATTEMPTS TO RETA9 >TISAN%IP1 ! MUTUAL AID ( ! COMMUNITY1 A CLOS5ESS TO NATURE & 5LIE ITS VIRTUES 9S(> AS !Y SEEK TO RETA9 ?OSE RI*LY >TICULAT$1 COOP]ATIVE1 & SELF-EXPRESSIVE =MS ( HUMAN CONSOCIATION SCAL$ TO HUMAN DIM5SIONS4 ,! SEEM+ 0EFFECTIV5ESS0 ( ,M>XISM -- ITS ATTEMPT TO REPLICATE ! /ATE 9 ! =M ( ! P>TY1 ITS EMPHASIS ON A POLITICAL APP>ATUS1 ITS SCI5TIFIC ?RU/ & ITS D5IAL ( A PROPHETIC E?ICAL VISION -- >E ITS VISES 9S(> AS !Y DO NOT DEMOLI% ! B\RGEOIS /ATE BUT 9CORPORATE IT 9TO ! V]Y SUB/ANCE ( PROTE/ & REVOLUTION4 ,NOT ACCID5TALLY1 ,M>XISM HAS BE5 MO/ %>PLY ALI5AT$ FROM ITSELF4 ,! ATTEMPT TO 0UPDATE0 ,M>XIAN !ORY1 TO GIVE IT RELEVANCE BEYOND ! ACADEMY & RE=MI/ MOVEM5TS1 HAS ADD$ AN OBFUSCAT+ ECLECTIC DIM5SION TO ITS IDEOLOGICAL CORPUS4 ,9 RESPONSE TO ! ,RUSSIAN G5]AL /RIKE ( #a#i#e1 ,ROSA ,LUXEMBURG WAS OBLIG$ TO MAKE ! 0MASS /RIKE0 -- A TYPICAL ,AN>*I/ 0/RATEGY0 -- PALATABLE TO ! ,SECOND ,9T]NATIONAL -- ?IS1 NOT )\T GROSSLY DI/ORT+ ,5GEL'S VIEW ON ! SUBJECT & ! ,AN>*I/ VIEW AS WELL4#b ,L59 WAS TO P]=M MU* ! SAME ACROBATICS 9 ,/ATE & ,REVOLUTION 9 #aiag :5 EV5TS FAVOR$ ! ,P>IS ,COMMUNE AS A P>ADIGM1 AGA9 ASSAIL+ ! ,AN>*I/S :ILE CONCEAL+ ,M>X'S [N D5IGRAT+ JUDGM5T ( ! UPRIS+ 9 ! LAT] YE>S ( HIS LIFE4 ,SIMIL> ACROBATICS W]E P]=M$ BY ,M&EL1 ,GORZ1 ET AL 9 ,MAY-,JUNE #a#i#f#h1 :5 ALL ( ,FRANCE WAS SWEPT 9TO A NE>-REVOLUTION>Y SITUATION4 ,:AT IS SIGNIFICANT1 H]E1 IS ! EXT5T TO :I* ! !ORY FOLL[S EV5TS :I* >E ESS5TIALLY ALI5 TO ITS ANALYSIS4 ,! EM]G5CE ( ! ECOLOGY MOVEM5T 9 ! LATE #a#i#fS1 ( FEM9ISM 9 ! E>LY #a#i#gS1 & MORE BELAT$LY1 ( NEIS HAS R>ELY BE5 VIEW$ AS A WELCOME PH5OM5ON BY ,M>XI/ !ORI/S UNTIL1 BY ! %E] =CE ( EV5TS1 IT HAS BE5 ACKN[L$G$1 LAT] DI/ORT$ TO MEET ECONOMI/IC1 ,M>XI/ CRIT]IA1 & ATTEMPTS >E ULTIMATELY MADE TO ABSORB IT4 ,AT :I* PO9T1 IT IS NOT ,AN>*ISM1 TO :I* !SE ISSUES >E LIT]ALLY 9DIG5\S1 ?AT HAS BE5 P]MITT$ TO CLAIM ITS RELEVANCY & LEGITIMACY TO ! PROBLEMS ( \R ]A BUT RA!R ,M>XISM1 MU* ( :I* HAS BECOME ! IDEOLOGY ( /ATE CAPITALISM 9 HALF ( ! WORLD4 ,?IS OBFUSCAT+ DEVELOPM5T HAS IMP$$ ! EVOLUTION ( REVOLUTION>Y CONSCI\SNESS AT ITS V]Y ROOTS & GRAVELY OB/RUCTS ! EVOLUTION ( A TRULY SELF-REFLEXIVE REVOLUTION>Y MOVEM5T4 ,BY ! SAME TOK51 ,AN>*ISM HAS ACQUIR$ SOME BAD ,M>XI/ HABITS ( ITS [N1 NOTABLY AN AHI/ORICAL & L>GELY DEF5SIVE COMMITM5T TO ITS [N PA/4 ,! TRANS=MATION ( ! SIXTIES C\NT]CULTURE 9TO MORE 9/ITUTIONALIZ$ =MS & ! DECL9E ( ! ,NEW ,LEFT HAS CREAT$ AMONG MANY COMMITT$ ,AN>*I/S A LONG+ = ! IDEOLOGICAL SECURITY & P$IGREE ?AT CURR5TLY AFFLICTS MANY ,M>XI/ SECTS4 ,?IS YE>N+ TO RETURN TO A LESS +LORI\S PA/1 TOGE!R ) ! RESURG5CE ( ! ,SPANI% ,C,N,T AFT] ,FRANCO'S DEA?1 HAS FO/]$ AN ,AN>*ISM ?AT IS *ILL+LY SIMIL> 9 ITS LACK ( CREATIVITY TO SECT>IAN =MS ( PROLET>IAN SOCIALISM1 NOTABLY AN>*O-SYNDICALISM4 ,:AT IS LACK+ 9 BO? CASES IS ! PROLET>IAT & ! HI/ORICAL CON/ELLATION ( CIRCUM/ANCES ?AT M>K$ ! HUNDR$-YE>-OLD ]A ( #ahdh TO #a#i#c#h4 ,AN>*I/ COMMITM5TS TO ! FACTORY1 TO ! /RUGGLE ( WAGE LABOR V]SUS CAPITAL1 %>E ALL ! VULG>ITIES ( SECT>IAN ,M>XISM4 ,:AT R$EEMS ! AN>*O-SYNDICALI/S FROM \TRIIAN ,M>XISM IS ! =M !IR LIB]T>IAN V>IANT ( PROLET>IAN SOCIALISM ACQUIRES4 ,!IR EMPHASIS ON AN E?ICAL SOCIALISM1 ON DIRECT ACTION1 ON CONTROL FROM BEL[1 & !IR APOLITICAL /ANCE MAY S]VE TO KEEP !M AFLOAT1 BUT :AT T5DS TO VITIATE !IR EF=TS -- ?IS QUITE ASIDE FROM ! HI/ORICAL DECL9E ( ! WORK]S MOVEM5T AS A REVOLUTION>Y =CE -- IS ! AU?ORIT>IAN NATURE ( ! FACTORY1 ! PYRAMIDAL /RUCTURE FO/]$ BY SYNDICALI/ !ORY1 & ! RELIANCE AN>*O-SYNDICALI/S PLACE ON ! UNIQUE ROLE ( ! PROLET>IAT & ! SOCIAL NATURE ( ITS CONFLICT ) CAPITAL4 ,VIEW$ BROADLY1 AN>*O-SYNDICALISM1 ,PR\DHONIANISM1 & ,BAKUN9ISM BELONG TO AN IRRETRIEVABLE PA/4 ,I SAY ?IS NOT BECAUSE !Y LACK IDEOLOGICAL COH]5CE & MEAN+ -- 9DE$1 ,PR\DHON'S EMPHASIS ON F$]ALISM /ILL 5JOYS ITS ORIG9AL VALIDITY -- BUT SIMPLY BECAUSE !Y SPEAK TO EPO*S :I* HAVE FAD$ 9TO HI/ORY4 ,!RE IS MU* !Y CAN TEA* US1 BUT !Y HAVE LONG BE5 TRANSC5D$ BY HI/ORICALLY NEW ISSUES -- 9 MY VIEW1 MORE FUNDAM5TAL 9 !IR LIB]T>IAN IMPLICATIONS -- TO :I* ! 5TIRE ,LEFT MU/ N[ ADDRESS ITSELF4 ,?IS DOES NOT MEAN ! 0DEA?0 OR EV5 ! 0TRANSC5D5CE0 ( ,AN>*ISM AS SU* ONCE WE VIEW ! T]M 9 ITS G5]IC & HI/ORICAL MEAN+1 = ! ISSUES ?AT CONFRONT US >E MORE DI/9CTLY SOCIAL ?AN !Y HAVE EV] BE5 AT ANY TIME 9 ! PA/4 ,!Y LIT]ALLY 9VOLVE ! RECREATION ( A NEW PUBLIC SPH]E AS DI/+UI%$ FROM ! /ATE ) ! =MS1 9/ITUTIONS1 RELATIONS1 S5SIBILITIES1 & CULTURE APPROPRIATE TO A WORLD ?AT IS FAC$ ) DESOCIALIZATION AT EV]Y LEVEL ( LIFE4 ,= ,M>XISM1 !SE ISSUES >E FATAL &1 9 FACT1 R5D] ,M>XISM ITSELF 9TO IDEOLOGY 9 A SOCIALLY DE/RUCTIVE S5SE4 ,I,I,I ,WE >E NO LONG] LIV+ 9 A WORLD :]E REVOLUTION>Y CONSCI\SNESS CAN BE DEVELOP$ PRIM>ILY OR EV5 SIGNIFICANTLY >\ND ! ISSUE ( WAGE LABOR V]SUS CAPITAL4 ,I DO NOT WI% TO D5IGRATE ! SIGNIFICANCE ( ?IS C5TURY-OLD CONFLICT4 ,?AT A CLASS /RUGGLE EXI/S BETWE5 ! PROLET>IAT & ! B\RGEOISIE 7H[EV] BROADLY WE *OOSE TO DEF9E ! T]M 0PROLET>IAT07 H>DLY REQUIRES DISCUSSION1 ANYMORE ?AN ! FACT ?AT WE LIVE 9 A CAPITALI/ SOCIETY ?AT IS RUL$ BY A CAPITALI/ CLASS 7AGA91 H[EV] BROADLY WE *OOSE TO DEF9E ! T]M 0CAPITALI/074 ,:AT IS REALLY AT ISSUE IS ?AT A CLASS /RUGGLE DOES NOT MEAN A CLASS W> 9 ! REVOLUTION>Y S5SE ( ! T]M4 ,IF ! PA/ C5TURY HAS TAUIAT & ! B\RGEOISIE HAS BE5 NEI!R MORE NOR LESS REVOLUTION>Y ?AN ! CONFLICT BETWE5 ! PLEBIANS & PATRICIANS 9 ! ANCI5T WORLD OR ! S]FS & ! NOBILITY 9 ! FEUDAL WORLD4 ,BO? CONFLICTS DID NOT SIMPLY 5D 9 AN IMPASSE2 !Y NEV] CONTA9$ ! AU!NTIC POSSIBILITIES ( TRANSC5D+ ! SOCIAL1 ECONOMIC1 & CULTURAL =MS )9 :I* !Y OCCURR$4 ,9DE$1 ! VIEW ( HI/ORY AS A HI/ORY ( CLASS /RUGGLE IS A HIIAN SOCIALISM -- ,SOCIALI/ OR ,AN>*I/4 ,! MONUM5TAL CRISIS B\RGEOIS SOCIETY HAS CREAT$ 9 ! =M ( A DISEQUILIBRIUM4 BETWE5 HUMANITY & NATURE1 A CRISIS ?AT HAS TELESCOP$ AN 5TIRE GEOLOGICAL EPO* 9TO A M]E C5TURY2 ! EXPANSIVE NOTION ( HUMAN FRE$OM ?AT HAS GIV5 RISE ( FEM9ISM 9 ALL ITS V>I\S =MS2 ! HOLL[+ \T ( ! HUMAN COMMUNITY & CITIZ5%IP ?AT ?REAT5S ! V]Y CLAIMS ( 9DIVIDUALITY1 SUBJECTIVITY1 & DEMOCRATIC CONSCI\SNESS1 P]HAPS ! GREATE/ CLAIM ! B\RGEOIS EPO* HAS MADE = ITSELF AS A =CE = PROGRESS2 ! T]RIFY+ S5SE ( P[]LESSNESS 9 ! FACE ( EV]-GREAT] URBAN1 CORPORATE1 & POLITICAL GIGANTISM2 ! /EADY DEMOBILIZATION ( ! POLITICAL ELECTORATE 9 A WAN+ ]A ( 9/ITUTIONAL REPUBLICANISM --ALL ( !SE SWEEP+ REGRESSIONS HAVE R5D]$ AN ECONOMI/IC 9T]PRETATION ( SOCIAL PH5OM5A1 A TRADITIONAL 0CLASS ANALYSIS1 0 & L>GELY CONV5TIONAL POLITICAL /RATEGIES 9 ! =MS ( ELECTORAL POLITICS & P>TY /RUCTURES GROSSLY 9ADEQUATE4 ,ONE MU/ TRULY TORTURE !SE ISSUES & GROSSLY W>P !M 9TO UTT]LY DI/ORT$ =MS TO FIT !M 9TO ,M>XIAN CATEGORIES4 ,P]HAPS NO LESS SIGNIFICANTLY1 ! F>-REA*+ POLITICIZATION ( ! ECONOMY ITSELF 9 ! =M ( /ATE CAPITALISM OR ITS V>I\S APPROXIMATIONS & ! EM]G5CE ( A HI BEYOND ITS E>LI] ROLE AS A SO-CALL$ 0EXECUTIVE COMMITTEE ( ! RUL+ CLASS40 ,9DE$1 TO AN APPALL+ EXT5T1 !Y HAVE TURN$ ! /ATE 9TO A SUB/ITUTION = SOCIETY ITSELF4 ,ONE MU/ REALIZE ! 5TIRELY NEW CONDITIONS ?IS CON/ELLATION ( CIRCUM/ANCES HAS PRODUC$ = RADICALISM1 ! EXT5T TO :I* !Y R$EF9E ! REVOLUTION>Y PROJECT !ORETICALLY & PRACTICALLY4 ,! TE*NICAL PROGRESS ?AT ,SOCIALISM ONCE REG>D$ AS DECISIVE TO HUMANITY'S DOM9ATION ( NATURE & AS PRECONDITIONS = HUMAN FRE$OM HAVE N[ BECOME ESS5TIAL 9 SOPHI/ICAT+ ! DOM9ATION ( HUMAN BY HUMAN4 ,TE*NOLOGY N[ SAVAGELY RE9=CES CLASS & HI]>*ICAL RULE BY ADD+ UNPREC5D5T$ 9/RUM5TALITIES ( CONTROL & DE/RUCTION TO ! =CES ( DOM9ATION4 ,! W$D+ ( ! ECONOMY TO ! /ATE1 F> FROM SIMPLIFY+ ! REVOLUTION>Y PROJECT AS ,5GELS SO NAIVELY BELIEV$ 9 ,ANTI-,DUHR+1 HAS RE9=C$ ! P[]S ( ! /ATE ) RES\RCES ?AT ! MO/ DESPOTIC REGIMES ( ! PA/ NEV] HAD AT !IR COMM&4 ,! GR[+ RECOGNITION ?AT ! PROLET>IAT HAS BECOME - & PROBABLY HAS ALWAYS BE5 -- AN ORGAN ( CAPITALI/ SOCIETY1 NOT A REVOLUTION>Y AG5T GE/AT+ )9 ITS WOMB1 HAS RAIS$ ANEW ! PROBLEM ( ! 0REVOLUTION>Y AG5T0 9 AN 5TIRELY NEW & NON-,M>XIAN =M4 ,F9ALLY1 ! NE$ = ! REVOLUTION>Y PROJECT TO VIEW ITSELF AS A CULTURAL PROJECT 7OR C\NT]CULTURE1 IF Y\ WILL7 ?AT 5COMPASSES ! NE$S ( HUMAN SUBJECTIVITY1 ! EMP[]M5T ( ! 9DIVIDUAL1 ! AS!TICIZATION ( ! REVOLUTION>Y IDEAL HAS L$1 9 TURN1 TO A NE$ TO CONSID] ! /RUCTURAL NATURE1 9T]NAL RELATIONS1 & 9/ITUTIONAL =MS ( A REVOLUTION>Y MOVEM5T ?AT WILL COMP5SATE1 IF ONLY 9 P>T1 = ! CULTURAL1 SUBJECTIVE1 & SOCIAL NEGATION ( ! PUBLIC & ! PRIVATE SPH]E4 ,9DE$1 WE MU/ R$EF9E ! V]Y MEAN+ ( ! WORD 0,LEFT0 TODAY4 ,WE MU/ ASK IF RADICALISM CAN BE R$UC$ TO A CRUDE =M ( SOCIAL DEMOCRACY ?AT OP]ATES )9 ! E/ABLI%$ ORD] TO ACQUIRE MASS1 M9DLESS CON/ITU5CIES OR IF IT MU/ ADVANCE A F>-REA*+ REVOLUTION>Y *ALL5GE TO DESOCIALIZATION & TO EV]Y ASPECT ( DOM9ATION1 BE IT 9 EV]YDAY LIFE OR 9 ! BROAD] SOCIAL >5A ( ! COM+ HI/ORIC EPO*4 ,I,V ,:ATEV] ELSE ,AN>*ISM MEANT 9 ! PA/ -- BE IT ! MILL5>IAN MOVEM5TS ( ,*RI/IANITY1 ! PEASANT MOVEM5TS ( ! ,ANABAPTI/S1 -! ,MAKHNOVITE & ,ZAPATI/A MILITIAS1 ! ,P>ISIAN ,5RAGES & ,COMMUN>DS1 ! ,PR\DHONIAN >TISANS1 OR ! E>LY 9DU/RIAL WORK]S :O 5T]$ ! ,C,G,T 9 ,FRANCE & ! ,C,N,T 9 ,SPA9 -- IT IS CLE> TO ME ?AT CONTEMPOR>Y ,AN>*ISM MU/ ADDRESS ITSELF 9 ! MO/ SOPHI/ICAT$ & RADICAL T]MS TO CAPITALI/1 9DE$ TO HI]>*ICAL SOCIETY1 9 ITS ADVANC$ &1 ,I G5U9ELY BELIEVE1 ITS T]M9AL =MS4 ,TO RELEGATE ,AN>*ISM TO AN AHI/ORICAL MORAL MOVEM5T BAS$ ON ! VIRTUES ( 0NATURAL MAN0 & HIS PROCLIVITIES = MUTUAL AID1 TO DEF9E IT M]ELY 9 T]MS ( ITS OPPOSITION TO ! /ATE AS ! S\RCE ( ALL EVIL1 WORSE1 TO DESCRIBE ,AN>*ISM M]ELY 9 T]MS ( ONE ( ITS V>IANTS -- ! ,AN>*ISM ( ,/IRN]1 ,PR\DHON1 ,BAKUN91 OR ,KROPOTK91 -- IS TO GROSSLY MISREAD ,AN>*ISM AS A HI/ORICAL MOVEM5T1 TO IGNORE ITS EXI/5CE AS A SOCIAL MOVEM5T 9 A SPECIFIC SOCIAL CONTEXT4 ,AN>*ISM DOES NOT HAVE ! PROPRIET>Y *>ACT] ( ,M>XISM ) ITS BODY ( DEF9ABLE TEXTS1 COMM5TATORS1 & !IR (F%OOTS4 ,CONCEIV$ AS A SOCIAL MOVEM5T RA!R ?AN A POLITICAL ONE1 IT IS NOT ONLY DEEPLY WOV5 9TO ! DEVELOPM5T ( HUMANITY BUT DEM&S HI/ORICAL TREATM5T4 ,DO ,I MEAN TO SAY1 !N1 ?AT ,AN>*ISM DISSOLVES 9TO HI/ORY & HAS NO !ORETICAL ID5TITY8 ,MY REPLY W\LD BE AN EMPHATIC 0,NO40 ,:AT UNITES ALL ,AN>*I/ !ORIES & MOVEM5TS >E NOT ONLY !IR DEF5SE ( SOCIETY AGA9/ ! /ATE1 ( DIRECT ACTION AGA9/ POLITICAL ACTION2 MORE FUNDAM5TALLY1 ,I BELIEVE1 ,AN>*ISM BY DEF9ITION GOES BEYOND CLASS EXPLOITATION 7:OSE SIGNIFICANCE IT NEV] D5IES7 9TO HI]>*ICAL DOM9ATION1 :OSE HI/ORICAL SIGNIFICANCE IT 9CREAS+LY ANALYZES AS ! S\RCE ( AU?ORITY AS SU*4 ,! DOM9ATION ( ! Y\NG BY ! OLD 9 TRIBAL G]ONTACRACIES1 ( WOM5 BY M5 9 PATRI>*AL FAMILIES1 ! CRUDE OBJECTIFICATION ( NATURE -- ALL PREC$E CLASS SOCIETY & ECONOMIC EXPLOITATION4 ,9 FACT1 !Y REMA9 ! CRUCIAL RESIDUAL SPH]E ( AU?ORITY ?AT ,M>XISM & ,SOCIALISM RETA9 ALL TOO COM=TABLY 9 !IR NOTIONS ( A CLASSLESS SOCIETY4 ,AN>*ISM1 9 EFFECT1 PROVIDES ! MAT]IALS = AN ANALYSIS ( ! NATURE ( FRE$OM & ! NATURE ( OPPRESSION ?AT GO BEYOND ! CONV5TIONAL ECONOMI/IC1 NEXUS ( CAPITALI/ SOCIETY 9TO ! V]Y S5SIBILITY1 /RUCTURE1 & NATURE ( HUMAN CONSOCIATION AS SU*4 ,! G5ESIS ( HI]>*Y1 :I* = ,M>X WAS AN 9EVITABLE EXT5SION ( BIOLOGY 9TO SOCIETY1 IS SE5 AS A SOCIAL PH5OM5ON )9 ! ,AN>*I/ FRAMEWORK1 ONE :I* HAS ITS MO/ CONSOLIDAT+ S\RCE 9 PATRI>*Y & ! SUPREMACY ( ! MALE'S CIVIL DOMA9 OV] ! WOMAN'S DOME/IC DOMA94 ,I KN[ ( NO MORE BRILLIANT /ATEM5T ( ?IS F>-REA*+ %IFT ?AN ,HORKHEIM]'S & ,ADORNO'S PASSAGE ON 0ANIMALS0 AT ! 5D ( ! ,DIALECTIC ( ,5LI*Y & DOM9ATION YIELDS ! OBJECTIFICATION ( NATURE AS M]E NATURAL RES\RCES1 ( HUMAN BE+S AS M]E HUMAN RES\RCES1 ( COMMUNITY AS M]E URBAN RES\RCES 9 %ORT1 ! R$UCTION ( ! WORLD ITSELF TO 9ORGANIC TE*NICS & A TE*NOCRATIC S5SIBILITY ?AT SEES HUMANK9D AS A M]E 9/RUM5T ( PRODUCTION4 ,I HAVE TRI$ TO %[ ELSE:]E ?AT ,M>X SOPHI/ICATES & EXT5DS ?IS TR5D 9TO SOCIALISM &1 UNWITT+LY1 R$UCES SOCIALISM TO IDEOLOGY4 7,SEE MY 0,M>XISM AS ,B\REGOIS ,SOCIOLOGY10 ,\R ,G5]ATION1 ,VOL4 #a#c1 ,NO4 #c7 ,:AT CONC]NS ME = ! PRES5T IS ?AT ,AN>*ISM1 (T5 9TUITIVELY1 ASSEMBLES ! MAT]IALS = A DEEP]1 RI*]1 & MORE SIGNIFICANTLY1 A BROADS 9SIKETPLACE 9TO HI]>*ICAL RELATIONS ?AT PREVAIL 9 ! FAMILY1 ! $UCATIONAL SY/EM1 ! COMMUNITY1 & 9 FACT1 ! DIVISION ( LABOR1 ! FACTORY1 ! RELATION%IP ( HUMANITY TO NATURE1 NOT TO SPEAK ( ! /ATE1 BUREAUCRACY1 & ! P>TY4 ,ACCORD+LY1 ! ISSUES ( ECOLOGY1 FEM9ISM1 & COMMUNITY >E 9DIG5\S CONC]NS ( ,AN>*ISM1 PROBLEMS :I* IT (T5 ADVANCES EV5 BE=E !Y ACQUIRE SOCIAL IMM$IACY -- NOT PROBLEMS :I* MU/ BE TACK$ ON TO ITS !ORETICAL CORPUS & DI/ORT$ TO MEET ! CRIT]IA ( AN ECONOMI/IC1 CLASS-ORI5T$ VIEWPO9T4 ,H5CE1 ,AN>*ISM1 BY MAK+ !SE ISSUES C5TRAL TO ITS SOCIAL ANALYZES & PRACTICE HAS ACQUIR$ A RELEVANCE ?AT1 BY F>1 OV]%AD[S MO/ TR5DS 9 PRES5T-DAY SOCIALISM4 ,9DE$1 ,AN>*ISM HAS BECOME ! TR\< 9 :I* ,SOCIALISM ECLECTICALLY N\RI%ES ITSELF ON AN ALI5 DIET ( 0SOCIALI/ FEM9ISM10 ! 0ECONOMICS ( POLLUTION10 & ! 0POLITICAL ECONOMY ( URBANISM40 ,SECONDLY1 ,AN>*ISM HAS FAC$ ! URG5T PROBLEM ( /RUCTUR+ ITSELF AS A REVOLUTION>Y MOVEM5T 9 ! =M ( ! V]Y SOCIETY IT SEEKS TO CREATE4 ,IT %\LD H>DLY BE NECESS>Y TO DEMOLI% ! PREPO/]\S NOTION ?AT HI]>*ICAL =MS ( ORGANIZATION >E SYNONYM\S ) ORGANIZATION AS SU*1 ANYMORE ?AN IT %\LD BE NECESS>Y TO DEMOLI% ! NOTION ?AT ! /ATE HAS ALWAYS BE5 SYNONYM\S ) SOCIETY4 ,:AT UNIQUELY DI/+UI%ES ,AN>*ISM FROM O!R SOCIALISMS IS IT COMMITM5T TO A LIB]T>IAN CONF$]AL MOVEM5T & CULTURE1 BAS$ ON ! COORD9ATION ( HUMAN-SCAL$ GR\PS1 UNIT$ BY P]SONAL AFF9ITY AS WELL AS IDEOLOGICAL AGREEM5T1 CONTROLL$ FROM BEL[ RA!R ?AN FROM 0ABOVE10 & COMMITT$ TO SPONTANE\S DIRECT ACTION4 ,H]E1 IT FO/]S EMBRYONIC GR[?1 CELL BY CELL AS IT W]E1 AS DI/+UI%$ FROM BUREAUCRATIC GR[? BY FIAT & 9ORGANIC ACCRETION4 ,AT A TIME :5 CONSOCIATION IS FAC$ ) ! DEADLY PROSPECT ( DISSOCIATION1 ,AN>*ISM OPPOSES SOCIAL =M TO POLITICAL =M1 9DIVIDUAL EMP[]M5T ?R\< DIRECT ACTION TO POLITICAL P[]LESSNESS ?R\< BUREAUCRATIC REPRES5TATION4 ,?US ,AN>*ISM IS NOT ONLY ! PRACTICE ( CITIZ5%IP )9 A NEW PUBLIC SPH]E1 BUT ! SELF-ADM9I/RATION ( ! REVOLUTION>Y MOVEM5T ITSELF4 ,! V]Y PROCESS ( BUILD+ AN ,AN>*I/ MOVEM5T FROM BEL[ IS VIEW$ AS ! PROCESS ( CONSOCIATION1 SELF-ACTIVITY & SELF-MANAGEM5T ?AT MU/ ULTIMATELY YIELD ?AT REVOLUTION>Y SELF ?AT CAN ACT UPON1 *ANGE & MANAGE AN AU!NTIC SOCIETY4 ,I HAVE M]ELY SCRAT*$ ! WAILS ( A CONSID]ABLE !ORETICAL CORPUS & CRITIQUE ?AT W\LD REQUIRE VOLUMES TO DEVELOP 9 DETAIL4 ,LET ME EMPHASIZE ?AT ! MO/ ADVANC$ ,AN>*I/ !ORIES1 TODAY1 DO NOT 9VOLVE A MY/ICAL RETURN TO A 0NATURAL MAN10 A CRUDE ANTI-/ATISM1 A D5IAL ( ! NE$ = ORGANIZATION1 A VISION ( DIRECT ACTION AS VIOL5CE & T]RORISM1 A M9DLESS REJECTION ( SOPHI/ICAT$ !ORY1 AN OPAQU5ESS TO :AT IS LIV+ 9 ! WORK ( ALL ,SOCIALI/ !ORIES4 ,AN>*I/ CRITIQUE & RECON/RUCTION REA* F> & DEEP 9TO ! ,SOCIALI/ & B\RGEOIS TRADITIONS4 ,IF ,AN>*ISM IS ! 0RETURN ( A TICUL>LY 9 ITS ,M>XIAN =M1 LIES 9 ITS +LORI\S CELEBRATION ( ! MASSIFICATION ( ! CITIZ5 9TO ! PROLET>IAN1 ( ! FACTORY AS ! PUBLIC SPH]E1 ( CULTURAL IMPOV]I%M5T AS 0CLASS CONSCI\SNESS10 ( ! RETREAT FROM ! SOCIAL TO ! ECONOMIC1 ( ! TRIUMPH ( TE*NICS OV] NATURE & ( SCI5CE OV] E?ICS4 ,IF ,AN>*ISM IS A 0XISM IS A 0LIV+ PRES5CE10 IT IS BECAUSE ! M>KET ?REAT5S TO DEV\R SOCIAL LIFE4 ,ADORNO'S METAPHORS BECOME CONFUS$ 9 ! NAME ( A FALSE 0HI/ORICISM0 :]E EV5 ! PA/ ACTUALLY 5JOYS MORE VITALITY ?AN ! PRES5T1 A VITALITY ?AT CAN NEV] BE RECOV]$ )\T GIV+ LIFE TO ! 0E TO BE EXORCIZ$1 IT IS NOT ,AN>*ISM ?AT WILL BE REMOV$ FROM ! /AGE ( HI/ORY BUT ,M>XISM1 ) ITS C5TRALIZ$ P>TIES1 HI]>*IES1 ECONOMI/IC S5SIBILITIES1 POLITICAL /RATEGIES1 & CLASS MY?OLOGIES4 ,V ,!RE IS MU* ,I HAVE BE5 OBLIG$ TO OMIT4 ,MY LIMIT$ TIME MAKES IT IMPOSSIBLE = ME TO DEAL ) SU* DELECTABLE QUE/IONS AS ! NATURE ( ! 0REVOLUTION>Y AG5T0 TODAY1 ! RELATION%IP ( ,AN>*I/ PRACTICE TO ! POLITICAL SPH]E 7A4 MORE COMPLEX ISSUE ?AN IS G5]ALLY SUPPOS$ :5 ONE RECALLS ?AT ,AN>*I/S PLAY$ A SIGNIFICANT ROLE 9 ! ELECTORAL ACTIVITIES ( ! ,MONTREAL ,CITIZ5S ,MOVEM5T71 ! DETAILS ( ,AN>*I/ ORGANIZATIONAL /RUCTURES1 ! RELATION%IP ( ,AN>*ISM TO ! C\NT]CULTURE1 TO FEM9ISM1 TO ! ECOLOGY MOVEM5T1 TO NEO-,M>XI/ T5D5CIES1 & ! LIKE4 ,BUT ALL[ ME TO CONCLUDE ) ?IS V]Y IMPORTANT CONSID]ATION4 ,AT A TIME :5 ! PROLET>IAT IS QUIESC5T -- HI/ORICALLY1 ,I BELIEVE -- AS A REVOLUTION>Y CLASS & ! TRADITIONAL FACTORY FACES TE*NOLOGICAL EXT9CTION1 ,AN>*ISM HAS RAIS$ ALMO/ ALONE ?OSE ECOLOGICAL ISSUES1 FEM9I/ ISSUES1 COMMUNITY ISSUES1 PROBLEMS ( SELF-EMP[]M5T1 =MS ( DEC5TRALIZATION1 & CONCEPTS ( SELF-ADM9I/RATION ?AT >E N[ AT ! =EGR\ND ( ! FAM\S 0SOCIAL QUE/ION40 ,& IT HAS RAIS$ !SE ISSUES FROM )9 ITS V]Y SUB/ANCE AS A !ORY & PRACTICE DIRECT$ AGA9/ HI]>*Y & DOM9ATION1 NOT AS EXOG5\S PROBLEMS ?AT MU/ BE 0COP$0 ) OR W>P$ 9TO AN ECONOMI/IC 9T]PRETATION SUBJECT ( CLASS ANALYSIS & PROBLEMS ( MAT]IAL EXPLOITATION4 .-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.- ,F,O,O,T,N,O,T,E,S 7#a7 ,IT W\LD BE WELL1 AT ?IS PO9T1 TO /RESS ?AT ,I AM DISCUSS+ ! 9/ITUTIONAL /RUCTURE ( ! SOCIAL =MS CIT$ ABOVE4 ,?AT !Y ALL V>I\SLY MAY HAVE EXCLUD$ WOM51 /RANG]S1 (T5 NON-CON=MI/S ( V>I\S RELIGI\S & E?NIC BACKGR\NDS1 NOT TO SPEAK ( SLAVES & PEOPLE LACK+ PROP]TY1 DOES NOT DIM9I% HUMANITY'S CAPACITY TO RECREATE !M ON MORE ADVANC$ LEVELS4 ,RA!R1 IT 9DICATES ?AT DESPITE !IR HI/ORICAL LIMITATIONS1 SU* /RUCTURES W]E BO? POSSIBLE & FUNCTIONAL1 (T5 ) REM>KABLE SUCCESS4 ,A FREE SOCIETY WILL HAVE TO DRAW ITS CONT5T FROM ! HI<] CANONS ( REASON & MORALITY1 NOT FROM - 0MODELS0 ?AT EXI/$ 9 ! PA/4 ,:AT ! PA/ RECOV]S & VALIDATES IS ! HUMAN ABILITY TO APPROXIMATE FRE$OM1 NOT ! ACTUALIZATION ( FRE$OM 9 ! FULLNESS ( ITS POSSIBILITIES4 7#b7 ,A DI/ORTION ALL ! MORE ODI\S BECAUSE ! ,SOCIAL ,DEMOCRATIC RANK-&-FILE HAD BE5 DEEPLY MOV$1 IDEOLOGICALLY AS WELL AS EMOTIONALLY1 BY ! #aie EV5TS4 0,! AN>*I/S & SYNDICALI/S :O HAD PREVI\SLY BE5 DRIV5 UND]GR\ND BY OR?ODOX ,SOCIAL ,DEMOCRACY N[ ROSE TO ! SURFACE LIKE MU%ROOMS ON ! P]IPH]Y ( ! ,S,P,D10 OBS]VES ,PET] ,NETTL RA!R DISDA9FULLY 9 HIS BIOGRAPHY ( ,LUXEMBURG2 0:5 IT CAME TO SOME?+ RESEMBL+ '!IR' G5]AL /RIKE !Y FELT !Y W]E CLOSE TO LEGITIMACY ONCE MORE40 ,&1 9DE$1 ) GOOD REASON3 0,= ! FIR/ TIME = YE>S AN>*I/ SPEAK]S APPE>$ ON PROV9CIAL ,SOCIALI/ PLAT=MS BY 9VITATION4 ,! OR?ODOX P>TY PRESS L$ BY ,VORW>TS WAS MU* MORE CAUTI\S2 BUT IT1 TOO1 GAVE PRIDE ( PLACE . TO ,RUSSIAN EV5TS & = ! FIR/ FEW MON?S AB/A9$ FROM WAGG+ BLUNT & CAUTI\S F+]S OV] ! DIFF]5CES BETWE5 ,RUSSIAN *AOS & ,G]MAN ORD]40 7,PET] ,NETTL1 ,ROSA ,LUXEMBURG1 ,OX=D ,UNIV]SITY ,PRESS1 #a#i#f#i1 ABRIDG$ V]SION1 PP4 #b#c-#d74 ,CONTRIBUT$ TO ,AN>*Y ,>*IVES BY ,*UCK ,MORSE ( ! ,9/ITUTE = ,AN>*I/ ,/UDIES ) ! P]MISSION ( ! AU?OR4 ,FROM 3 ,AN>*Y ,>*IVES4 ,*RONOLOGY 3 ,MAY #b#i1 #aih 3 ,AN>*ISM3 ,PA/ & ,PRES5T -- ,PUBLICATION4 ,FEBRU>Y #a1 #bag 3 ,AN>*ISM3 ,PA/ & ,PRES5T -- ,ADD$4 ,DECEMB] #c1 #bba 3 ,AN>*ISM3 ,PA/ & ,PRES5T -- ,UPDAT$4 FILE G5]AT$ FROM 3 HTTP3_/_/REVOLTLIB4COM_/