,AN>*ISM3 ,>GUM5TS ,= & ,AGA9/ 

,PEOPLE 3 

,AU?OR 3 ,ALB]T ,MELTZ] 

,TAGS 3 WAGE & MONET>Y SY/EMS1 M>XI/ CRITICISM ( AN>*ISM1 CRITICISM ( ! AN>*I/S1 FASCI/ OBJECTION TO AN>*ISM1 MANK9D IS BORN FREE1 ABOLITION ( ! WAGE1 OBJECTION TO AN>*ISM1 CRITICISM ( AN>*ISM1 >GUM5TS AGA9/ AN>*ISM1 MOD]N AN>*I/ MOVEM5T4 

,TEXT 3 

  

,PHOTO BY ,GL5N ,HALOG1,C,C ,B,Y-,N,C ,LIC5SE ,TABLE ( ,CONT5TS 

,9TRODUCTION 
,9ALI5ABLE ,T5ETS ( ,AN>*ISM 
,! ,CLASS ,/RUGGLE 
,ORGANIZATION & ,AN>*ISM 
,! ,ROLE ( AN ,AN>*I/ 9 AN ,AU?ORIT>IAN ,SOCIETY 
,BR++ ,AB\T ! ,NEW ,SOCIETY 
,! ,M>XI/ ,CRITICISM ( ,AN>*ISM 
,! ,SOCIAL-,DEMOCRATIC ,CRITIQUE ( ,AN>*ISM 
,! ,LIB]AL-,DEMOCRATIC ,OBJECTION TO ,AN>*ISM 
,! ,FASCI/ ,OBJECTION TO ,AN>*ISM 
,! ,AV]AGE ,P]SON'S ,OBJECTION TO ,AN>*ISM 

,9TRODUCTION 

,! ,HI/ORICAL ,BACKGR\ND TO ,AN>*ISM 

,IT IS NOT )\T 9T]E/ ?AT :AT MI<T BE CALL$ ! AN>*I/ 

APPROA* GOES BACK 9TO ANTIQUITY2 NOR ?AT !RE IS AN AN>*ISM ( 

SORTS 9 ! PEASANT MOVEM5TS ?AT /RUGGL$ AGA9/ ,/ATE 

OPPRESSION OV] ! C5TURIES4 ,BUT ! MOD]N AN>*I/ MOVEM5T 

C\LD NOT CLAIM SU* PRECURSORS ( REVOLT AS ITS [N MORE ?AN ! 

O!R MOD]N WORK+ CLASS !ORIES4 ,TO TRACE ! MOD]N ,AN>*I/ 

MOVEM5T WE MU/ LOOK CLOS] TO \R [N TIMES4 ,:ILE !RE EXI/$ 

LIB]T>IAN & NON-,/ATI/ & F$]ALI/ GR\PS1 :I* W]E LAT] 

T]M$ AN>*I/IC 9 RETROSPECT1 BE=E ! MIDDLE ( ! N9ETE5? 

C5TURY1 IT WAS ONLY AB\T !N ?AT !Y BECAME :AT WE N[ CALL 

,AN>*I/S4 

,9 P>TICUL>1 WE MAY CITE ?REE PHILOSOPHICAL PRECURSORS ( 

,AN>*ISM1 ,GODW91 ,PR\DHON1 & P]HAPS ,HEGEL4 ,NONE ( !SE WAS 9 

FACT AN ,AN>*I/1 ?\< ,PR\DHON FIR/ US$ ! WORD 9 ITS MOD]N 

S5SE 7TAK+ IT FROM ! ,FR5* ,REVOLUTION1 :5 IT WAS FIR/ US$ 

POLITICALLY & NOT 5TIRELY PEJORATIVELY74 ,NONE ( !M 5GAG$ 9 

,AN>*I/ ACTIVITY OR /RUGGLE1 & ,PR\DHON 5GAG$ 9 

P>LIAM5T>Y ACTIVITY4 ,ONE ( ! POORE/1 ?\< O/5SIBLY 

OBJECTIVE1 BOOKS ON ,AN>*ISM1 ,JUDGE ,ELTZBA*]'S ,AN>*ISM1 

DESCRIBES ,AN>*ISM AS A SORT ( HYDRA-HEAD$ !ORY SOME ( :I* 

COMES FROM ,GODW9 OR ,PR\DHON OR ,/IRN] 7ANO!R :O NEV] M5TIONS 

AN>*ISM71 OR ,KROPOTK91 EA* A DIFF]5T V>IATION ON A !ME4 ,! 

BOOK MAY BE TOSS$ ASIDE AS VALUELESS EXCEPT 9 ITS DESCRIPTION ( 

:AT !SE P>TICUL> M5 ?\<T4 ,PR\DHON DID NOT WRITE A 

PROGRAM = ALL TIME1 NOR DID ,KROPOTK9 9 HIS TIME WRITE = A 

SECT ( ,AN>*I/S4 ,BUT MANY O!R BOOKS WRITT5 BY ACADEMICS >E 

EQUALLY VALUELESS3 MANY PR(ESSORS HAVE A VIEW ( AN>*ISM BAS$ ON 

! POPUL> PRESS4 ,AN>*ISM IS NEI!R A M9DLESS !ORY ( 

DE/RUCTION NOR1 DESPITE SOME LIB]AL-M9D$ LIT]>Y CONCEPTIONS1 IS 

IT H]O-WOR%IP ( PEOPLE OR 9/ITUTIONS1 H[EV] LIB]AT$ !Y 

MI<T BE4 

,GODW9 IS ! FA!R ( ! ,/ATELESS ,SOCIETY MOVEM5T1 :I* 

DIV]G$ 9TO ?REE L9ES4 ,ONE1 ?AT ( ! ,AN>*I/S 7) :I* WE 

WILL DEAL74 ,TWO1 ?AT ( CLASSIC ,AM]ICAN ,9DIVIDUALISM1 :I* 

9CLUD$ ,?OREAU & HIS S*OOL1 SOMETIMES ?\<T ( AS 

AN>*I/IC1 BUT :I* EQUALLY GIVES RISE TO ! 'RUGG$ 

9DIVIDUALISM' ( MOD]N 'LIB]T>IAN' CAPITALISM & TO ! PACIFI/ 

CULTS ( ,TOL/OY & ,G&HI :I* HAVE 9FLU5C$ ! 5TIRE HIPPIE 

CULT4 ,9DIVIDUALISM 7APPLY+ TO ! CAPITALI/ & NOT ! WORK]7 

HAS BECOME A RI<T-W+ DOCTR9E4 

,! SECOND L9E ( DESC5T FROM ,GODW9 IS RESPONSIBLE = ! 

',PACIFI/ ,AN>*I/' APPROA* OR ! ',9DIVIDUALI/ ,AN>*I/' 

APPROA* ?AT DIFF]S RADICALLY FROM REVOLUTION>Y AN>*ISM 9 ! 

FIR/ L9E ( DESC5T4 ,IT IS SOMETIMES TOO READILY CONC$$ ?AT 

'?IS IS1 AFT] ALL1 AN>*ISM'4 ,PACIFI/ MOVEM5TS1 & ! ,G&HIAN 

9 P>TICUL>1 >E USUALLY TOTALIT>IAN & IMPOSE AU?ORITY 7EV5 IF 

ONLY BY MORAL MEANS72 ! S*OOL ( ,B5JAM9 ,TUCK] -- BY VIRTUE ( 

!IR 9DIVIDUALISM -- ACCEPT$ ! NE$ = POLICE TO BREAK /RIKES 

SO AS TO GU>ANTEE ! EMPLOY]'S 'FRE$OM'4 ,ALL ?IS S*OOL ( 

SO-CALL$ ,9DIVIDUALI/S ACCEPT1 AT ONE TIME OR ANO!R1 ! 

NECESSITY ( ! POLICE =CE1 H5CE = ,GOV]NM5T1 & ! 

DEF9ITION ( AN>*ISM IS NO ,GOV]NM5T4 

,! ?IRD S*OOL ( DESC5T FROM ,GODW9 IS SIMPLE LIB]ALISM1 OR 

CONS]VATIVE 9DIVIDUALISM4 

,DEAL+ H]E ) ! 'FIR/ L9E ( DESC5T' FROM ,GODW91 HIS IDEA 

( ,/ATELESS ,SOCIETY WAS 9TRODUC$ 9TO ! WORK+ CLASS MOVEM5T 

BY ,AMBROSE ,CUDDON 7JUN74 ,HIS REVOLUTION>Y 9T]NATIONALI/ & 

NON-,/ATI/ SOCIALISM CAME ALONG ! LATE DAYS ( ,5GLI% ,*>TISM4 

,IT WAS 9 SYMPA?Y ) ! ,FR5* ,PR\DHONIANS4 ,?OSE :O 9 ,P>IS 

ACCEPT$ ,PR\DHON'S !ORY DID NOT CONSID] !MSELVES ,AN>*I/S1 

BUT ,REPUBLICANS4 ,!Y W]E = ! MO/ P>T SELF-EMPLOY$ >TISANS 

RUNN+ !IR [N PRODUCTIVE BUS9ESSES4 ,! :OLE ( ,FR5* ECONOMY 

WAS GE>$ BO? TO ! PEASANTRY & TO ! >TISAN -- ?IS1 ! 

ONE-P]SON BUS9ESS ( PR9T]1 BOOKB9D]1 WAGON & C>T MAK]1 

BLACKSMI?1 DRESSMAK]1 GOLDSMI?1 DIAMOND POLI%]1 HAT MAK] AS 

DI/9CT FROM ! FACTORY OR F>M WORK] ( ! TIME1 :O WORK$ = 

AN EMPLOY]4 ,9DEP5D5T1 9DIVIDUALI/IC & RECEIV+ NO B5EFIT 

FROM ! ,/ATE BUT ! DUBI\S PRIVILEGE ( PAY+ TAXES & 

FI<T+1 !Y W]E AT ?AT TIME CONC]N$ TO F9D \T AN ECONOMIC 

ME?OD ( SURVIVAL & TO )/& 5CROA*+ CAPITALISM4 

,M>X DESCRIB$ !M AS 'PETTY B\RGEOIS'1 :I* HAD A DIFF]5T 

MEAN+ 9 ! N9ETE5? C5TURY4 ,HE JU/IFIABLY CLAIM$ ?AT !SE 

'PETTY B\RGEOIS' W]E NOT AS DISCIPL9$ AS ! !N FACTORY WORK]S 

7HE DESPIS$ F>M WORK]S7 & SAID ?AT :5 !Y W]E =C$ 9TO 

9DU/RY !Y DID NOT FAI?FULLY FOLL[ ! L9E LAID D[N BY A 

DISCIPL9$ P>TY FROM \TSIDE ! CLASS1 BUT W]E 9DEP5D5T ( 

M9D & TR\BLESOME TO ORGANIZATION IMPOS$ FROM ABOVE1 !IR 

FRU/RATION (T5 LEAD+ TO VIOL5CE4 ,!Y MOV$ TO AN>*ISM & 

?R\< SYNDICALISM SPREAD IT ?R\< ! WORK+ CLASS4 7,?IS CLAIM 

IS E*O$ BY ,M>XI/S N[ADAYS1 :5 ! T]M 'PETTY B\RGEOIS' MEANS 

SOME?+ UTT]LY DIFF]5T -- SOLICITORS & *>T]$ ACC\NTANTS -- 

& ?US MAKES ,M>X'S QUITE S5SIBLE ANALYSIS S\ND UTT]LY 

RIDICUL\S47 

,!SE ,FR5* & ,5GLI% MOVEM5TS CAME TOGE!R 9 ! ,FIR/ 

,9T]NATIONAL4 ,! ,9T]NATIONAL ,WORK+M5'S ,ASSOCIATION [$ ITS 

EXI/5CE TO ,M>X1 9DIRECTLY TO ,HEGELIAN PHILOSOPHY4 ,BUT )9 ! 

,9T]NATIONAL1 !RE WAS NOT ONLY ! 'SCI5TIFIC SOCIALISM' ( ,M>X1 

BUT ALSO ,UTOPIAN ,SOCIALISM1 ,BLANQUISM 7WORK+-CLASS REPUBLICANISM71 

,5GLI% ,TRADE ,UNIONISM1 ,G]MAN-AU?ORIT>IAN & OPPORTUNI/IC 

SOCIALISM1 & ,SPANI%1 ,SWISS1 & ,ITALIAN /ATELESS SOCIALISM1 AS 

WELL AS NATIONAL ,REPUBLICANISM & ! V>I\S F$]ALI/IC TR5DS4 

,BAKUN9 WAS NOT ! 'FA!R' ( AN>*ISM1 AS (T5 DESCRIB$4 ,HE WAS 

NOT AN AN>*I/ UNTIL LAT] 9 LIFE4 ,HE LE>N$ HIS F$]ALISM & 

SOCIALISM FROM ! ,SWISS WORK]S ( ! ,JURA1 & GAVE EXPRESSION TO 

! IDEAS ( ! ,GODW9IAN & ,PR\DHONIAN 'F$]ALI/S'1 OR 

NON-,/ATE SOCIALI/S4 ,9 MANY C\NTRIES1 ,SPA9 & ,ITALY 9 

P>TICUL>1 IT WAS ,BAKUN9'S CRITICISM ( ! IDEAS ( ,M>X ?AT GAVE 

! F$]ALI/ MOVEM5T ITS DEF9ITION4 7,:ILE TO ,AN>*I/S1 ,M>X IS 

( C\RSE 0! VILLA9 ( ! PIECE0 9 ! ,9T]NATIONAL1 IT MU/ BE 

GRANT$ ?AT )\T ,M>X DEF9+ ONE =M ( SOCIALISM !RE W\LD 

HAVE BE5 NO CLA%1 NO ,BAKUN9 DEF9+ ! OPPOSITE47 

,!RE HAD GR[N UP BY #ahfi A V]Y NOTICEABLE TR5D )9 ! 

,9T]NATIONAL ?AT WAS CALL$ ',BAKUN9I/' :I* WAS 9 ONE L9E FROM 

,GODW9 & ANO!R FROM ,PR\DHON4 ,:5 ! ,P>IS ,COMMUNE EXPLOD$ 9 

! FACE ( ! ,9T]NATIONAL1 IT WAS ! P>T+ ( ! WAYS 7?\< 

?IS WAS DEF]R$ A LITTLE LONG] & SEEM$ TO FOLL[ P]SONAL 

L9ES74 ,FROM ! NON-,AN>*I/S & ,M>XI/S KNEW BY !IR DIFF]5T 

ANALYZES & 9T]PRETATIONS & ACTIONS DUR+ ! ,P>IS ,COMMUNE1 

?AT !Y W]E SEP>ATE4 

,ALL ! SAME1 = MANY YE>S ,AN>*I/S CONT9U$ TO =M P>T ( ! 

,SOCIALI/ ,MOVEM5T ?AT 9CLUD$ ,M>XI/S & ,SOCIAL-,DEMOCRATS4 ,M>X 

HAD NOT SUCCE$$ 9 BUILD+ A MASS MOVEM5T4 ,! ,G]MAN SOCIALI/ 

MOVEM5T WAS MORE 9FLU5C$ BY ,LASSALLE2 ,5GLI% SOCIALISM BY 

RE=MI/ & ,*RI/IAN TRADITIONS ( RADICAL NONCON=MITY4 ,ONLY 

AFT] ,M>X'S DEA?1 :5 ,M>XISM WAS ! (FICIAL DOCTR9E ( ,G]MAN 

SOCIAL-DEMOCRACY1 W]E ,AN>*I/S F9ALLY EXCLUD$ FROM ,SOCIALI/ 

,9T]NATIONALS2 SOCIAL-DEMOCRACY M>*$ ON TO ITS [N S*ISM1 ?AT 

BETWE5 ,5GLI% ,LIB]ALISM ON ! ONE H&1 & SOCIAL-DEMOCRACY ON 

! O!R2 & ?AT BETWE5 'MAJORITY' ,SOCIAL-,DEMOCRATS 7,BOL%EVIKS1 

ACTUALLY NEV] MORE ?AN A M9ORITY7 & RE=MISM4 

,!RE W]E NO SU* S*ISMS AT ?AT TIME 9 ! AN>*I/ MOVEM5T AS 

SU*4 ,POPUL> OP9ION MADE SU* FIGURES AS ,TOL/OY 9TO 7:AT HE 

NEV] CLAIM$ TO BE7 AN AN>*I/ 7HE WAS NOT2 NEI!R 9 ! NORMAL 

S5SE ( ! WORDS WAS HE A ,*RI/IAN OR A ,PACIFI/1 AS POPUL>LY 

SUPPOS$1 BUT HIS IDOLATORS ALWAYS KN[ BETT] ?AN HE71 BUT D]IV$ 

FROM ! 'SECOND L9E' ( ,GODW9ISM LIKE MANY O!R 

C>ICATURE-,AN>*I/S4 ,:AT WE MAY CALL 'MA9/REAM' AN>*ISM WAS 

COH]5T & UNIT$1 & WAS GIV5 BODY BY ! WRIT+S ( A NUMB] 

( !ORETICIANS1 SU* AS ,PET] ,KROPOTK94 

,AFT] ! BLOODY SUPPRESSION ( ! ,P>IS ,COMMUNE1 & REPRESSION 9 

MANY P>TS ( ! WORLD -- NOTABLY ,CZ>I/ ,RUSSIA1 ,AN>*ISM PASS$ 

9TO ITS WELL-KN[N /AGE ( 9DIVIDUAL T]RORISM4 ,IT F\<T BACK & 

SURVIV$ & GAVE BIR? TO 7OR WAS C>RI$ =W>D 97 ! 

REVOLUTION>Y SYNDICALI/ MOVEM5T :I* BEGAN 9 ,FRANCE4 ,IT LO/ 

GR\ND AFT] ! ,FIR/ ,WORLD ,W>1 BECAUSE ( ! REVIVAL ( PATRIOTIC 

FEEL+1 ! GR[? ( RE=MI/ SOCIALISM1 & ! RISE ( FASCISM2 

& :ILE IT MADE A CONTRIBUTION TO ! ,RUSSIAN ,REVOLUTION1 IT WAS 

DEFEAT$ BY ! ,BOL%EVIK C\NT]REVOLUTION4 ,IT WAS SE5 9 BO? 

RESI/ANCE & 9 A CON/RUCTIVE ROLE 9 ! ,SPANI% ,REVOLUTION ( 

#a#i#c#f4 

,BY ! TIME ( ! ,SECOND ,WORLD ,W>1 ,AN>*ISM HAD BE5 TRI$ & 

TE/$ 9 MANY REVOLUTION>Y SITUATIONS & LABOR /RUGGLES4 

,ALT]NATIVE =MS HAD BE5 TRI$ & DISC>D$2 ! ,G]MAN ,REVOLUTION 

HAD 9TRODUC$ ! IDEA ( ,WORK]S ,C\NCILS4 ,! EXP]I5CE ( ! 

,AM]ICAN ,I,W,W HAD %[N ! POSSIBILITIES ( 9DU/RIAL UNIONISM & 

'H[ ONE CAN BUILD ! NEW SOCIETY 9 ! %ELL ( ! OLD'4 ,9 ! 

'FL9T AGA9/ FL9T' >GUM5T AGA9/ ,M>XI/ ,COMMUNISM1 ! LESSON 

( :AT SOCIALISM )\T FRE$OM MEANT 9 ,RUSSIA1 & ! FAILURE ( 

RE=MI/ SOCIALISM EV]Y:]E1 ! AN>*I/ DOCTR9E WAS %AP$4 

,!RE W]E NEV] !ORETICIANS ( ,AN>*ISM AS SU*1 ?\< IT 

PRODUC$ A NUMB] ( !ORETICIANS :O DISCUSS$ ASPECTS ( ! 

PHILOSOPHY4 ,AN>*ISM HAS REMA9$ A CRE$ ?AT HAS BE5 WORK$ \T 

9 PRACTICE RA!R ?AN FROM A PHILOSOPHY4 ,V]Y (T51 A B\RGEOIS 

WRIT] COMES ALONG & WRITES D[N :AT HAS ALREADY BE5 WORK$ \T 

9 PRACTICE BY WORK]S & PEASANTS2 HE IS ATTRIBUT$ BY B\RGEOIS 

HI/ORIANS AS BE+ A LEAD]1 & BY SUCCESSIVE B\RGEOIS WRIT]S 

7CIT+ ! B\RGEOIS HI/ORIANS7 AS BE+ ONE MORE CASE ?AT PROVES 

! WORK+ CLASS RELIES ON B\RGEOIS LEAD]%IP4 

,MORE (T51 B\RGEOIS ACADEMICS BORR[ ! NAME ',AN>*ISM' TO GIVE 

EXPRESSION TO !IR [N LIB]AL PHILOSOPHIES OR1 ALT]NATIVELY1 

PICK+ UP !IR CUE FROM J\RNALI/S1 ASSORT$ OBJECTS ( !IR 

DISLIKE4 ,= SOME PR(ESSORS & TEA*]S1 ',AN>*ISM' IS ANY?+ 

FROM ,TOL/OYISM TO ! ,I,R,A1 FROM DRUG-TAK+ TO MILITANT-TRADE 

UNIONISM1 FROM NATIONALISM TO BOL%EVISM1 FROM ! HIPPIE CULT TO 

,ISLAMIC FUNDAM5TALISM1 FROM ! PUNK SC5E TO VIOL5T RESI/ANCE TO 

ALMO/ ANY?+6 ,?IS IS BY NO MEANS AN EXAGG]ATION BUT A SIGN ( 

ACADEMIC ILLIT]ACY1 TO BE DI/+UI%$ FROM J\RNALI/S :O 9 ! 

#a#i#fS OBEY$ A DIRECTIVE TO CALL ANY?+ ,M>XI/-,L59I/ ?AT 

9VOLV$ ACTION AS ',AN>*I/' & ANY?+ ,AN>*I/ AS 

'NATIONALI/'4 

,9ALI5ABLE ,T5ETS ( ,AN>*ISM 

,?AT ,MANK9D IS ,BORN ,FREE 

,\R RI<TS >E 9ALI5ABLE4 ,EA* P]SON BORN ON ! WORLD IS HEIR TO 

ALL ! PREC$+ G5]ATIONS4 ,! :OLE WORLD IS \RS BY RI<T ( 

BIR? ALONE4 ,DUTIES IMPOS$ AS OBLIGATIONS OR IDEALS1 SU* AS 

PATRIOTISM1 DUTY TO ! ,/ATE1 WOR%IP ( ,GOD1 SUBMISSION TO HI<] 

CLASSES OR AU?ORITIES1 RESPECT = 9H]IT$ PRIVILEGES1 >E LIES4 

,IF ,MANK9D IS ,BORN ,FREE1 ,SLAV]Y IS ,MURD] 

,NOBODY IS FIT TO RULE ANYBODY ELSE4 ,IT IS NOT ALLEG$ ?AT ,MANK9D IS 

P]FECT1 OR ?AT M]ELY ?R\< HIS_/H] NATURAL GOODNESS 7OR LACK ( 

SAME7 HE_/%E %\LD 7OR %\LD NOT7 BE P]MITT$ TO RULE4 ,RULE AS 

SU* CAUSES ABUSE4 ,!RE >E NO SUP]PEOPLE NOR PRIVILEG$ CLASSES 

:O >E ABOVE 'IMP]FECT ,MANK9D' & >E CAPABLE OR 5TITL$ TO RULE 

! RE/ ( US4 ,SUBMISSION TO SLAV]Y MEANS SURR5D] ( LIFE4 

,AS ,SLAV]Y IS ,MURD]1 SO ,PROP]TY IS ,!FT 

,! FACT ?AT ,MANK9D CANNOT 5T] 9TO HIS_/H] NATURAL 9H]ITANCE 

MEANS ?AT P>T ( IT HAS BE5 TAK5 FROM HIM OR H]1 EI!R BY MEANS 

( =CE 7OLD1 LEGALIZ$ CONQUE/ OR ROBB]Y7 OR FRAUD 7P]SUASION 

?AT ! ,/ATE OR ITS S]VANTS OR AN 9H]IT$ PROP]TY-[N+ CLASS 

IS 5TITL$ TO PRIVILEGE74 ,ALL PRES5T SY/EMS ( [N]%IP MEAN ?AT 

SOME >E DEPRIV$ ( ! FRUITS ( !IR LABOR4 ,IT IS TRUE ?AT1 9 A 

COMPETITIVE SOCIETY1 ONLY ! POSSESSION ( 9DEP5D5T MEANS 5ABLES 

ONE TO BE FREE ( ! ECONOMY 7?AT IS :AT ,PR\DHON MEANT :51 

ADDRESS+ HIMSELF TO ! SELF-EMPLOY$ >TISAN1 HE SAID 0PROP]TY IS 

LIB]TY01 :I* SEEMS AT FIR/ SI<T A CONTRADICTION ) HIS DICTUM 

?AT IT WAS !FT74 ,BUT ! PR9CIPLE ( [N]%IP1 9 ?AT :I* 

CONC]NS ! COMMUNITY1 IS AT ! BOTTOM ( 9EQUITY4 

,IF ,PROP]TY IS ,!FT1 ,GOV]NM5T IS ,TYRANNY 

,IF WE ACCEPT ! PR9CIPLE ( A SOCIALIZ$ SOCIETY1 & ABOLI% 

H]$IT>Y PRIVILEGE & DOM9ANT CLASSES1 ! ,/ATE BECOMES 

UNNECESS>Y4 ,IF ! ,/ATE IS RETA9$1 UNNECESS>Y ,GOV]NM5T BECOMES 

TYRANNY S9CE ! GOV]N+ BODY HAS NO O!R WAY TO MA9TA9 ITS 

HOLD4 0,LIB]TY )\T SOCIALISM IS EXPLOITATION3 SOCIALISM )\T 

LIB]TY IS TYRANNY0 7,BAKUN974 

,IF ,GOV]NM5T IS ,TYRANNY1 ,AN>*Y IS ,LIB]TY 

,?OSE :O USE ! WORD 0,AN>*Y0 TO MEAN DISORD] OR MISRULE >E NOT 

9CORRECT4 ,IF !Y REG>D ,GOV]NM5T AS NECESS>Y1 IF !Y ?9K WE 

C\LD NOT LIVE )\T ,:ITEHALL DIRECT+ \R AFFAIRS1 IF !Y ?9K 

POLITICIANS >E ESS5TIAL TO \R WELL-BE+ & ?AT WE C\LD NOT 

BEHAVE SOCIALLY )\T POLICE1 !Y >E RI<T 9 ASSUM+ ?AT 

,AN>*Y MEANS ! OPPOSITE TO :AT ,GOV]NM5T GU>ANTEES4 ,BUT ?OSE 

:O HAVE ! REV]SE OP9ION1 & CONSID] ,GOV]NM5T TO BE TYRANNY1 

>E RI<T TOO 9 CONSID]+ ,AN>*Y1 NO ,GOV]NM5T1 TO BE LIB]TY4 

,IF ,GOV]NM5T IS ! MA9T5ANCE ( PRIVILEGE & EXPLOITATION & 

9EFFICI5CY ( DI/RIBUTION1 !N ,AN>*Y IS ORD]4 

,! ,CLASS ,/RUGGLE 

,REVOLUTION>Y ,AN>*ISM IS BAS$ ON ! CLASS /RUGGLE1 ?\< IT IS 

TRUE ?AT EV5 ! BE/ ( ,AN>*I/ WRIT]S1 TO AVOID ,M>XI/ 

PHRASEOLOGY1 MAY EXPRESS IT DIFF]5TLY4 ,IT DOES NOT TAKE ! 

ME*ANI/IC VIEW ( ! CLASS /RUGGLE TAK5 BY ,M>X & ,5GELS ?AT 

ONLY ! 9DU/RIAL PROLET>IAT CAN A*IEVE SOCIALISM1 & ?AT ! 

9EVITABLE & SCI5TIFICALLY-PR$ICTABLE VICTORY ( ?IS CLASS 

REPRES5TS ! F9AL VICTORY4 ,ON ! CONTR>Y3 HAD AN>*ISM BE5 

VICTORI\S 9 ANY P]IOD BE=E #a#i#a#d1 IT W\LD HAVE BE5 A TRIUMPH 

= ! POOR] PEASANTS & >TISANS1 RA!R ?AN AMONG ! 

9DU/RIAL PROLET>IAT AMONG :OM ! CONCEPT ( AN>*Y WAS NOT 

WIDESPREAD4 

,AS WE HAVE SAID1 ,M>XI/S ACCUSE ! ,AN>*I/S ( BE+ PETTY 

B\RGEOIS4 ,US+ ! T]M 9 ITS MOD]N S5SE1 IT MAKES ,M>X LOOK 

RIDICUL\S4 ,M>X WAS DI/+UI%+ BETWE5 ! B\RGEOIS 7) FULL 

RI<TS ( CITIZ5S AS EMPLOY]S & M]*ANTS7 & ! M9OR CITIZ5S 

-- I4E4 SELF-EMPLOY$ WORK]S74 ,:5 ,M>X REF]R$ TO ! ,AN>*I/S 

BE+ 'PETTY B\RGEOIS' :O :5 !Y W]E =C$ BY MONOPOLY 

CAPITALISM & ! BREAKD[N ( A PEASANT-TYPE SOCIETY 9TO 9DU/RY1 

& BE+ !RE=E 'FRU/RAT$' & TURN+ TO VIOL5CE1 BECAUSE !Y 

DID NOT ACCEPT ! DISCIPL9E TAK5 = GRANT$ BY ! 9DU/RIAL 

PROLET>IAT1 HE WAS EXPRESS+ SOME?+ ?AT WAS HAPP5+1 

ESPECIALLY AFT] ! BREAK+ UP ( ! 9DEP5D5T ,COMMUNES ( ,P>IS 

& ,B>CELONA1 & ! BREAKD[N ( ! CAPITALI/ ECONOMY1 9 HIS 

DAY4 ,BUT1 ) ! *ANGE ( MEAN+1 TO ?9K ( TODAY'S ,AN>*I/S 

AS FRU/RAT$ B[L]-HATT$ BANK MANAG]S TURN+ TO VIOL5CE BECAUSE 

!Y HAVE BE5 =C$ 9TO 9DU/RY IS /RA9+ ONE'S S5SE ( ! 

RIDICUL\S4 

,M>X ?\<T ! 9DU/RIAL PROLET>IAT WAS NOT US$ TO ?9K+ = 

ITSELF -- NOT HAV+ ! LEISURE OR 9DEP5D5CE ( ! SELF-EMPLOY$ 

-- & WAS !RE=E CAPABLE '( ITSELF' ( A 'TRADE UNION M5TALITY1 

NE$+ ! LEAD]%IP ( AN '$UCAT$ CLASS' COM+ FROM \TSIDE1 

& PRESUMABLY NOT BE+ FRU/RAT$4 ,?IS 9 HIS DAY WAS ?\<T ( 

AS ! S*OL>S AS AN ELITE1 9 LAT] TIMES ! /UD5TS4 

,M>X C]TA9LY DID NOT =ESEE ! PRES5T DAY1 :5 ! /UD5TS AS 

A FRU/RAT$ CLASS1 HAV+ ABSORB$ ! ,M>XI/ TEA*+S1 >E BE+ 

=C$ 9TO MONOTON\S JOBS OR UNEMPLOYM5T & CREATE ! ,NEW ,LEFT 

) ITS [N ASSUMPTIONS & PREOCCUPATIONS1 BUT >E CLE>LY NOT A 

PRODUCTIVE CLASS4 

,ANY CLASS MAY BE REVOLUTION>Y 9 ITS DAY & TIME2 ONLY A PRODUCTIVE 

CLASS MAY BE LIB]T>IAN 9 NATURE1 BECAUSE IT DOES NOT NE$ TO 

EXPLOIT4 ,! 9DU/RIALIZATION ( MO/ ,WE/]N C\NTRIES MEANT ?AT 

! 9DU/RIAL PROLET>IAT REPLAC$ ! OLD 'PETTY B\RGEOIS' CLASS 

& :AT IS LEFT ( !M BECAME CAPITALI/ 9/EAD ( WORK+ CLASS1 

BECAUSE IT HAD TO EXP& & !RE=E EMPLOY 9 ORD] TO SURVIVE4 

,BUT REC5T T5D5CIES 9 SOME ,WE/]N C\NTRIES >E T5D+ TO ! 

DISPLACEM5T ( ! WORK+ CLASS & C]TA9LY ! DIVORC+ ( !M 

FROM !IR PRODUCTIVE ROLE4 ,M9+1 %IPBUILD+1 SP9N+1 

MANUFACTUR+ 9DU/RIES1 & :OLE T[NS >E CLOS$ D[N & PEOPLE 

>E =C$ TO 9TO S]VICE JOBS LIKE C>-P>K ATT5DANTS OR 

SUP]M>KET ASSI/ANTS :I* >E NOT PRODUCTIVE & SO C>RY NO 

9DU/RIAL MUSCLE4 

,:5 ! 9DU/RIAL PROLET>IAT DEVELOP$1 ! ,AN>*I/ MOVEM5T 

DEVELOP$ 9TO AN>*O-SYNDICALISM1 SOME?+ COM+ FROM ! WORK]S 

!MSELVES1 CONTR>Y TO ! IDEA ?AT !Y NE$$ A LEAD]%IP FROM 

\TSIDE ! CLASS OR C\LD NOT ?9K BEYOND ! WAGE /RUGGLE4 

,AN>*O-SYNDICALISM IS ! ORGANIZATION AT PLACES ( WORK BO? TO 

C>RY ON ! PRES5T /RUGGLE & EV5TUALLY TO TAKE OV] ! PLACES 

( WORK4 ,IT W\LD ?US BE MORE EFFECTIVE ?AN ! OR?ODOX 

TRADE-UNION MOVEM5T & AT ! SAME TIME BE ABLE TO BYPASS A 

,/ATE-RUN ECONOMY 9 PLACE ( CAPITALISM4 

,NEI!R ,AN>*ISM NOR ,M>XISM HAS EV] IDEALIZ$ ! WORK+ CLASS 

7EXCEPT SOMETIMES BY WAY ( POETIC LIC5SE 9 PROPAG&A67 -- ?IS 

WAS A FEATURE ( ! ,*RI/IAN ,SOCIALI/S4 ,NOR WAS IT EV] SUGGE/$ 

?AT !Y C\LD NOT BE REACTION>Y1 ,9 FACT1 DEPRIVATION ( $UCATION 

MAKES ! POOR] CLASS ON ! :OLE ! MORE RESI/ANT TO *ANGE4 ,IT 

W\LD BE TRY+ ! READ]'S PATI5CE TOO MU* TO REIT]ATE ALL ! 

'WORK+ CLASS >E NOT ANGELS' /ATEM5TS PURPORT+ TO REFUTE ?AT 

! WORK+ CLASS C\LD NOT RUN !IR [N PLACES ( WORK4 ,ONLY 9 

HEAV51 SO ,I AM 9=M$1 WILL IT BE NECESS>Y = ANGELS TO TAKE 

OV] ! FUNCTIONS ( MANAGEM5T6 

,ORGANIZATION & ,AN>*ISM 

,?OSE BELONG+ TO OR COM+ FROM AU?ORIT>IAN P>TIES F9D IT H>D 

TO ACCEPT ?AT ONE CAN ORGANIZE )\T 'SOME =M' ( ,GOV]NM5T4 

,!RE=E !Y CONCLUDE1 & IT IS A G5]AL >GUM5T AGA9/ 

,AN>*ISM1 ?AT 

',AN>*I/S DO NOT BELIEVE 9 ORGANIZATION'4 ,BUT ,GOV]NM5T IS ( 

PEOPLE1 ORGANIZATION IS ( ?+S4 

,!RE IS A BELIEF ?AT ,AN>*I/S 'BREAK UP O!R PEOPLE'S 

ORGANIZATIONS BUT >E UNABLE TO BUILD !IR [N'1 (T5 EXPRESS$ 

:]E DANG]\S1 HI]>*ICAL1 OR USELESS ORGANIZATIONS DOM9ATE & 

PREV5T LIB]T>IAN ONES BE+ CREAT$4 ,IT CAN WELL BE ADMITT$ ?AT 

P>TICUL> PEOPLE 9 P>TICUL> PLACES HAVE FAIL$ 9 ! TASK ( 

BUILD+ ,AN>*I/ ORGANIZATIONS BUT 9 MANY P>TS ( ! WORLD !Y 

DO EXI/ 

,AN ORGANIZATION MAY BE DEMOCRATIC OR DICTATORIAL1 IT MAY BE 

AU?ORIT>IAN OR LIB]T>IAN1 & !RE >E MANY LIB]T>IAN 

ORGANIZATIONS1 NOT NECESS>ILY AN>*I/1 :I* PROVE ?AT ALL 

ORGANIZATION NE$ NOT BE RUN FROM ! TOP D[NW>D4 

,MANY TRADE UNIONS1 P>TICUL>LY IF SUCCESSFUL1 9 ORD] TO KEEP !IR 

MOVEM5T DISCIPL9$ & AN 9TEGRAL P>T ( CAPITALI/ SOCIETY1 

BECOME 7IF !Y DO NOT />T SO7 AU?ORIT>IAN2 BUT H[ MANY 

EMPLOY]S' ORGANIZATIONS IMPOSE SIMIL> DISCIPL9E8 ,IF !Y DO1 !IR 

AFFILIATES W\LD WALK \T IF IT DID NOT SUIT !IR 9T]E/S4 ,!Y 

MU/ COME TO FREE AGREEM5T BECAUSE SOME HAVE ! MEANS TO RESI/ 

9TIMIDATION4 ,EV5 :5 !Y RESORT TO FASCISM TO KEEP ! WORK]S 

D[N1 ! EMPLOY]S RETA9 !IR [N 9DEP5D5CE & F9ANCIAL 

P[]2 ,NAZISM GOES TOO F> = SMALL] CAPITALI/S 9 ?AT AFT] 

HAV+ CRU%$ ! WORK]S IT ALSO LIMITS1 OR EV5 NEGATES1 ! 

9DEP5D5CE ( ! CLASS ?AT PUT IT 9 P[]4 

,ONLY ! MO/ REVOLUTION>Y UNIONS ( ! WORLD HAVE EV] LE>N$ H[ 

TO KEEP ! =M ( ORGANIZATION ( MASS LABOR MOVEM5TS ON AN 

9=MAL BASIS1 ) A M9IMUM ( C5TRAL ADM9I/RATION1 & ) 

EV]Y DECISION REF]R$ BACK TO ! WORK]S ON ! %OP FLOOR4 

,! ,ROLE ( AN ,AN>*I/ 

9 AN ,AU?ORIT>IAN ,SOCIETY 

0,! ONLY PLACE = A FREE MAN 9 A SLAVE SOCIETY IS 9 PRISON10 SAID 

,?OREAU 7BUT HE ONLY SP5T A NI<T !RE74 ,IT IS A /IRR+ 

AFFIRMATION BUT NOT ONE TO LIVE BY1 H[EV] TRUE IT IS4 ,! 

REVOLUTION>Y MU/ BE PREP>$ = P]SECUTION & PROSECUTION1 BUT 

ONLY ! MASO*I/ W\LD WELCOME IT4 ,IT MU/ ALWAYS REMA9 AN 

9DIVIDUAL ACTION & DECISION AS TO H[ F> ONE CAN BE CONSI/5T 9 

ONE'S REBELLION3 IT IS NOT SOME?+ ?AT CAN BE LAID D[N4 ,AN>*I/S 

HAVE PIONE]$ OR P>TICIPAT$ 9 MANY =MS ( SOCIAL REBELLION & 

RECON/RUCTION1 SU* AS LIB]T>IAN $UCATION1 ! =MATION ( 

LABOR MOVEM5TS1 COLLECTIVIZATION1 9DIVIDUAL DIRECT ACTION 9 ITS 

MANY =MS & SO ON4 

,:5 ADVOCAT+ AN>*O-SYNDICALI/ TACTICS1 IT IS BECAUSE SOCIAL 

*ANGES = ! :OLE ( SOCIETY CAN ONLY COME AB\T ?R\< A *ANGE 

( ! ECONOMY4 ,9DIVIDUAL ACTION MAY S]VE SOME LIB]ATORY PROCESS1 

IT'S TRUE4 ,9DIVIDUALS1 = EXAMPLE1 MAY RETIRE TO A C\NTRY COMMUNE1 

SURR\ND !MSELVES ) LIKE-M9D$ PEOPLE & IGNORE ! WORLD SO 

LONG AS IT OV]LOOKS !M4 ,!Y MI<T C]TA9LY MEAN:ILE LIVE 9 A 

FREE ECONOMY IF !Y C\LD OV]COME C]TA9 BASIC PROBLEMS1 BUT IT 

W\LD NOT BR+ AB\T SOCIAL *ANGE4 

,?IS IS NOT TO DECRY 9DIVIDUAL ACTION1 F> FROM IT4 ,:OLE NATIONS 

CAN LIVE UND] DICTATOR%IP & SACRIFICE :OLE PEOPLES ONE BY ONE1 

& NOBODY WILL DO ANY?+ AB\T IT UNTIL ONE 9DIVIDUAL COMES ALONG 

& CUTS (F ! HEAD ( ! HYDRA1 9 O!R WORDS1 KILLS ! TYRANT4 

,BUT G5OCIDE CAN TAKE PLACE BE=E ! 9DIVIDUAL ) ! C\RAGE1 

ABILITY1 & LUCK REQUIR$ COMES ALONG4 

,9 SU* CASES1 WE SEE WAIT+ = MASS ACTION AS QUEU+ UP = ! 

GAS *AMB] 7IT CAN BE LIT]ALLY SO74 ,WE DO NOT ?9K 0! 

PROLET>IAT CAN DO NO WRONG0 & MO/ ( ALL2 BY SUBMISSION1 IT CAN4 

,BUT ORGANIZATION IS /R5G?4 ,WE ADVOCATE MASS ACTION BECAUSE IT IS 

EFFECTIVE & BECAUSE ! PROLET>IAT HAS 9 ITS H&S ! MEANS TO 

DE/ROY ! OLD ECONOMY & BUILD ANEW4 ,! ,FREE ,SOCIETY WILL COME 

AB\T ?R\< WORK]S' CONTROL C\NCILS TAK+ OV] ! PLACES ( 

WORK & BY CONSCI\S DE/RUCTION ( ! AU?ORIT>IAN /RUCTURE4 

,!Y CAN BE BUILT )9 UNIONIZATION ( ! WORK-=CES ( ! 

PRES5T TIME4 

,WORK]S ,CONTROL 

,:5 ADVOCAT+ WORK]S' CONTROL = ! PLACES ( WORK1 WE DIFF] 

FROM ?OSE :O >E ONLY ADVOCAT+ A %>E ( MANAGEM5T OR IMAG9E 

!RE CAN BE AN 5CROA*M5T UPON MANAG]IAL FUNCTION BY ! WORK]S 

)9 CAPITALISM4 ,SELF-MANAGEM5T )9 A CAPITALI/ SOCIETY IS A 

SIZABLE RE=M1 & IS OCCASIONALLY ATTA9ABLE :5 ! WORK-=CE 

IS 9 A P>TICUL>LY /RONG POSITION1 OR MORE (T5 :5 ! WORK IS 

SUFFICI5TLY HAZ>D\S TO DEFY \TSIDE 9SPECTION4 ,?AT IS ALL IT IS1 

H[EV]1 & IS NOT TO BE CONFUS$ ) SYNDICALISM1 EXCEPT 9 ! 

S5SE ?AT ! SYNDICALI/ ?9KS ! FUTURE SOCIETY %\LD BE 

SELF-CONTROLL$4 ,WE WANT NO AU?ORITY SUPREME TO ?AT ( ! 

WORK]S1 NOT EV5 ONE ( !IR DELEGATES4 

,?IS PROBABLY MEANS BREAK+ 9DU/RY D[N 9TO SMALL UNITS1 & WE 

ACCEPT ?IS4 ,WE REJECT 'NATIONALIZATION' "7 ,/ATE CONTROL4 

,IT %\LD NOT BE 7BUT UN=TUNATELY IS7 NECESS>Y TO EXPLA9 ?AT 

!RE >E1 ( C\RSE1 WAYS ( P]SONAL LIB]ATION O!R ?AN CLASS 

ACTION1 & 9 SOME CASES !SE MAY BE NECESS>Y LE/ ONE />VE4 ,BUT 

NONE ( !SE CAN AT PRES5T HELP TO *ANGE SOCIETY4 ,! SELF-EMPLOY$ 

>TISAN NO LONG] PLAYS AN IMPORTANT P>T AS 9 ,PR\DHON'S DAY 7& 

P]HAPS ?IS WILL BE REVIV$ ) A NEW SOCIETY74 ,ONE CAN GET 

SATISFACTION WORK+ ON ONE'S [N1 ONE MAY HAVE TO DO SO BY ECONOMIC 

NECESSITY1 BUT ! MEANS ( *ANG+ SOCIETY RE/ ) ?OSE :O >E 

WORK+ 9 ! BASIC ECONOMY4 

,TR5DS OV] REC5T YE>S %[ ! IMPORTANCE ( ! SELF-EMPLOY$ 

>TISAN4 ,AS MAJOR 9DU/RIES >E DECIMAT$ BY ! RUL+ CLASS 

BECAUSE NO LONG] NECESS>Y TO CAPITALISM1 A MEANS ( 9TEGRAT+ 

?OSE WORK+ \TSIDE MA9/REAM CAPITALISM WILL 9CREAS+LY NE$ TO 

BE F\ND IF WE >E TO A*IEVE *ANGE4 ,IT WAS ! NECESSITY ( F9D+ 

?IS 9 A PREVI\S REV]SAL ( CAPITALI/ TR5DS ?AT L$ TO ! 

ORIG9AL =MATION ( AN>*O-SYNDICALISM4 

,! ,AN>*I/ AS ,REBEL 

,IT IS NOT UNKN[N = ! 9DIVIDUAL ,AN>*I/ TO FI<T ON ALONE1 

PUTT+ =W>D HIS OR H] IDEAS 9 A HO/ILE 5VIRONM5T4 ,!RE W]E 

MANY EXAMPLES 9 ! PA/ ( ,AN>*I/S /RUGGL+ ON ALONE1 SOMETIMES 

ONLY ONE 9 ! C\NTRY4 ,IT IS LESS ! CASE AT ! PRES5T TIME :5 

!RE >E USUALLY MANY PEOPLE CALL+ !MSELVES ,AN>*I/S1 ?\< 

P]HAPS ONLY ONE OR TWO 9 A LOCALITY :O REALLY >E SO1 & NOT JU/ 

ADOPT+ ! LABEL TO DESCRIBE REBELLION :5 Y\NG4 

,AN>*I/S 9 SU* CIRCUM/ANCES MAY FI<T ALONE = ! PR9CIPLE ( 

,AN>*ISM1 BUT USUALLY P>TICIPATE 9 O!R /RUGGLES1 SU* AS 

ANTI-MILIT>ISM1 ANTI-IMP]IALISM1 ANTI-NATIONALISM OR SOLELY )9 

! CONT5T ( ! CLASS /RUGGLE OR !Y MAY =M ORGANIZATIONS ( 

!IR [N4 

,IT IS NO P>T ( ! CASE = ,AN>*ISM TO SAY ?AT ! PR(ESSION ( 

ITS IDEAS *ANGES PEOPLES' *>ACT]2 OR ?AT ! MOVEM5T 9VITES 

ITSELF TO BE JUDG$ ON ANYONE :O HAPP5$ TO BE >\ND AT ANY ONE 

TIME4 ,ORGANIZATIONS !Y CREATE MAY BECOME RE=MI/ OR 

AU?ORIT>IAN2 PEOPLE !MSELVES MAY BECOME CORRUPT$ BY MONEY OR 

P[]4 ,ALL WE CAN SAY IS ?AT ULTIMATELY SU* CORRUPTION NORMALLY 

LEADS !M TO DROP ! NAME ',AN>*I/'1 AS /&+ 9 !IR WAY4 ,IF 

EV] ! T]M BECAME 'RESPECTABLE'1 NO D\BT WE W\LD HAVE TO *OOSE A 

FRE% ONE1 EQUALLY CONNOTATIVE ( LIB]T>IAN REBELLION -- AT PRES5T 

IT CAN /ILL /& AS DESCRIPTIVE ?\< 9CREAS+LY MISUS$4 

,9 ALL ORGANIZATIONS1 P]SONALITIES PLAY A P>T & IT MAY BE ?AT 9 

DIFF]5T C\NTRIES DIFF]5T S*ISMS MAY OCCUR4 ,SOME SAY ?AT !RE 

>E DIFF]5T TYPES ( ,AN>*ISM4 ,SYNDICALISM1 ,COMMUNISM1 

9DIVIDUALISM1 PACIFISM1 HAVE ALL BE5 CIT$ AS SU*4 ,?IS IS NOT SO4 

,IF ONE WI%ES TO CAUSE A S*ISM1 PURELY ON P]SONAL REASONS OR BECAUSE 

ONE WI%ES TO BECOME MORE QUIETI/ OR RE=MI/1 IT IS NO D\BT 

CONV5I5T TO PICK A NAME AS A 'BANN]'4 ,BUT 9 REALITY !RE >E NOT 

DIFF]5T =MS ( ,AN>*ISM4 ,AN>*I/-,COMMUNISM1 9 ANY DEF9ITION 

7USUALLY ?AT ( ,KROPOTK971 MEANS A ME?OD ( SOCIALISM )\T 

,GOV]NM5T1 NOT A DIFF]5T /YLE ( AN>*ISM4 ,AN ALT]NATIVE IDEA1 

CALL$ ,AN>*I/-,COLLECTIVISM1 ONCE FAVOR$ BY ,SPANI% ,AN>*I/S1 

WAS F\ND 9 PRACTICE TO BE EXACTLY ! SAME4 ,IF ONE IS GO+ TO HAVE 

NO RULE FROM ABOVE1 ONE CANNOT LAY D[N A PRECISE ECONOMIC PLAN = 

! FUTURE1 & ,COMMUNISM & COLLECTIVIZATION CONTROLL$ FROM BEL[ 

UPW>DS PROV$ TO BE NO DIFF]5T FROM EA* O!R1 OR FROM 

SYNDICALISM1 A P]MAN5T MEANS ( /RUGGLE T[>D ! SAME GOAL4 

,COMMUNISM1 9 ! S5SE US$ BY ,AN>*I/S1 IS A SOCIETY BAS$ ON ! 

COMMUNITY4 ,COLLECTIVISM IS A DIVISION ( ! COMMUNE 9TO ECONOMIC 

UNITS4 ,UNLESS ! COMMUNE IS V]Y SMALL -- BAS$ UPON ! VILLAGE -- 

IT HAS TO BE DIVID$ 9TO SMALL] UNITS1 COLLECTIVES1 SO ?AT ALL CAN 

P>TICIPATE & NOT JU/ !IR ELECT$ REPRES5TATIVES4 ,O!RWISE IT 

W\LD M]ELY BE 9DU/RIAL DEMOCRACY4 ,:ILE FREE ,COMMUNISM IS AN AIM1 

SYNDICALISM IS A ME?OD ( /RUGGLE4 ,IT IS ! UNION ( WORK]S )9 

! 9DU/RIAL SY/EM ATTEMPT+ TO TRANS=M IT 9TO A FREE 

,COMMUNI/IC SOCIETY4 

,/ATE ,COMMUNISM IS NOT AN ALT]NATIVE ,COMMUNISM TO FREE ,COMMUNISM1 

BUT ITS OPPOSITE4 ,IT IS ! SUB/ITUTION ( ! ,/ATE OR ! ,P>TY 

= ! CAPITALI/ CLASS4 ,COMMUNISM IS NOT NECESS>ILY ,AN>*I/1 

EV5 IF IT IS NOT ,/ATE ,COMMUNISM BUT ! G5U9E AU?ORIT>IAN =M 

( ,COMMUNISM 7TOTAL ,/ATE CONTROL )\T HAV+ DEG5]AT$ 9TO 

ABSOLUTE P[] FROM ABOVE1 OR EV5 GOV]NM5TAL DOM9AT$ 

SOCIALIZATION74 ,SYNDICALISM IS NOT NECESS>ILY REVOLUTION>Y & EV5 

REVOLUTION>Y SYNDICALISM 7! IDEA ?AT WORK]S CAN SEIZE PLACES ( 

WORK ?R\< FACTORY ORGANIZATION7 NE$ NOT BE LIB]T>IAN1 AS IT CAN 

GO H&-9-H& ) ! IDEA ( A POLITICAL P>TY EX]CIS+ 

POLITICAL CONTROL4 ,?IS IS :Y WE USE ! M\?FUL3 

AN>*O-SYNDICALISM4 ,WORK]S CONTROL ( PRODUCTION1 COMMUNITY CONTROL 

FROM BEL[1 NO ,GOV]NM5T FROM ABOVE4 

,NONVIOL5CE 

,IS PACIFISM A TR5D )9 ,AN>*ISM8 ,?\< PHONY ,AN>*ISM 

CONTA9S A L>GE /REAK ( PACIFISM1 BE+ MILITANT LIB]ALISM & 

R5\NC+ ANY =M ( POSITIVE ACTION = ,AN>*ISM1 PACIFISM 

7IMPLY+ EXTREME NONVIOL5CE1 & NOT JU/ ANTI-MILIT>ISM7 IS 

AU?ORIT>IAN4 ,! CULT ( EXTREME NONVIOL5CE ALWAYS IMPLIES AN 

ELITE1 ! ,SATYAGRAHI ( ,G&HI1 = 9/ANCE1 :O KEEPS EV]YONE 

ELSE 9 *ECK EI!R BY =CE OR BY MORAL P]SUASION4 ,! G5]AL 

HI/ORY ( ! OR?ODOX PACIFI/ MOVEM5TS IS ?AT !Y ATTEMPT TO 

DILUTE A REVOLUTION>Y UPSURGE BUT COME D[N ON ! SIDE ( =CE 

EI!R 9 AN IMP]IALI/ W> OR BY CONDON+ AGGRESSIVE ACTIONS BY 

GOV]NM5TS !Y SUPPORT4 

,BO? ,9DIA & ,ISRAEL W]E ONCE ! REALIZATION ( ! PACIFI/ 

IDEALS2 ! ATOM BOMB WAS L>GELY DEVELOP$ & CREAT$ BY NONVIOL5T 

PACIFI/S & BY ,LEAGUE ( ,NATIONS 5?USIA/S2 ! ,QUAK]S AS 

PEACE-LOV+ CITIZ5S BUT COMM]CIAL TYRANTS & COLONIALI/S >E 

NOTORI\S4 ,9 REC5T TIMES1 MANY :O REJECT$ ,AN>*I/ ACTIONS ( 

! ,SPANI% ,RESI/ANCE 7?\< CLAIM+ TO BE 0NONVIOL5T 

,AN>*I/S07 HAD NO DIFFICULTY LATE 9 SUPPORT+ F> MORE 0VIOL5T0 

ACTIONS ( DIFF]5T NATIONALI/ MOVEM5TS4 

,IT IS TRUE TO SAY ?AT !RE >E ,AN>*I/S :O CONSID] PACIFISM 

COMPATIBLE ) ,AN>*ISM 9 ! S5SE ?AT !Y ADVOCATE ! USE ( 

NONVIOL5T ME?ODS ?\< USUALLY N[ADAYS ADVOCAT+ ?IS ON ! 

GR\NDS ( EXP$I5CY OR TACTICS RA!R ?AN PR9CIPLE4 ,BUT ?IS 

%\LD NOT BE CONFUS$ ) ! SO-CALL$ 0,TOL/OYAN ,AN>*ISM0 

7NEI!R ,TOL/OYAN OR ,AN>*I/74 ,TOL/OY CONSID]$ ! ,AN>*I/S 

W]E RI<T 9 EV]Y?+ BUT ?AT !Y BELIEV$ 9 REVOLUTION TO 

A*IEVE IT4 ,HIS IDEA ( SOCIAL *ANGE WAS 0)9 ONE0 7:I* IS TO 

SAY 9 ! SKY74 ,HE DID NOT ADVOCATE NONVIOL5T REVOLUTION1 HE URG$ 

NONRESI/ANCE AS A WAY ( LIFE COMPATIBLE ) ,*RI/IAN TEA*+ 

?\< NOT PRACTIC$ AS SU*4 

,ONE HAS TO SAY ALSO ?AT ?IS REF]S TO PACIFISM 9 ! 

,ANGLO-,AM]ICAN S5SE1 SOME:AT WORSE 9 ,GREAT ,BRITA9 :]E ! 

CONCEPT ( LEGALIZ$ CONSCI5TI\S OBJECTION L$ TO A DIALOGUE 

BETWE5 PACIFISM & ! ,/ATE4 ,9 C\NTRIES :]E OBJECTION TO 

MILIT>Y S]VICE REMA9$ A TOTALLY ILLEGAL ACT1 ! CONCEPT ( 

PACIFISM IS NOT NECESS>ILY EXTREME NONVIOL5CE4 

,IMM$IATE ,AIMS ( ! ,AN>*I/ 

,A 0RE=MI/0 IS NOT SOMEONE :O BR+S AB\T RE=MS 7USUALLY !Y 

DO NOT1 !Y DIV]T ATT5TION TO POLITICAL MANEUV]+73 IT IS 

SOMEONE :O CAN SEE NO FUR!R ?AN AMELIORATION ( C]TA9 P>TS ( 

! SY/EM4 ,IT IS NECESS>Y TO AGITATE = ! ABOLITION ( C]TA9 

LAWS OR = ! IMM$IATE RE=M ( SOME1 BUT TO IDEALIZE ! 

AGITATION = RE=MS1 OR EV5 ! 9T]E/S 9 RE=M ( M9ORITIES 

OR EV5 :OLE COMMUNITIES1 IS RE=MI/4 ,?IS RE=MISM HAS 

P]MEAT$ ! :OLE ( :AT IS N[ CALL$ ! LEFT W+4 ,IT CREATES 

NEW 9DU/RIES 9 ! 9T]E/S ( ASPIR+ BUREAUCRATS ALLEG$LY 

GU>D+ OV] M9ORITY 9T]E/S1 PREV5T+ PEOPLE 9 ?OSE 

M9ORITIES FROM ACT+ ON !IR [N BEHALF4 ,?IS IS NOTICEABLE EV5 

9 WOM5'S /RUGGLES :I* ! LEFT M>G9ALIZES AS IF IT W]E A 

M9ORITY ISSUE4 

,SOMETIMES LAWS >E MORE H>MFUL ?AN ! (F5SES !Y LEGISLATE 

AGA9/4 ,NO LAW IS WOR? PASS+ EV5 TO HOPE :I* >E SOCIALLY 

B5EFICIAL ON ! SURFACE1 S9CE !Y >E SURE TO BE 9T]PRET$ 

WRONGLY & >E (T5 US$ TO BOL/] ! PRIVATE OP9ION ( JUDGES 

:O C>RY !M \T4 ,! OLD ,BRITI% CU/OM ( S5T5C+ POOR] 

CLASSES TO DEA? = M9OR !FTS ABOVE A SMALL PECUNI>Y VALUE WAS 

NOT ABOLI%$ BY ,P>LIAM5T NOR BY ! JUDGES1 BUT BY ! F9AL 

REFUSAL ( JURIES TO ADMIT :5 =C$ TO A GUILTY V]DICT ?AT ! 

GOODS W]E ABOVE ?AT VALUE4 

,! ,AN>*I/S CAN AS 9DIVIDUALS OR 9 GR\PS PRESS = RE=MS BUT 

AS ,AN>*I/S !Y SEEK TO *ANGE M9DS & ATTITUDES1 NOT TO PASS 

LAWS4 ,:5 M9DS >E *ANG$1 LAWS BECOME OBSOLETE &1 SOON] OR 

LAT]1 LAW 5=C]S >E UNABLE TO OP]ATE !M4 ,PROHIBITION 9 

,AM]ICA1 ! ,POLL ,TAX 9 ,BRITA91 >E 9/ANCES4 ,AT ?AT PO9T ! 

LAW HAS TO ADAPT ITSELF TO PUBLIC OP9ION4 

,! ,WIT*CRAFT ,ACT REMA9$ ON ! /ATUTE BOOKS UNTIL SOME #d YE>S 

AGO & IT WAS 5=C$ RI<T UP TO ! TIME ( ITS ABOLITION ?\< 

! ,PUBLIC ,PROSECUTOR ONLY D>$ TO USE A FEW ( ITS CLAUSES = FE> 

( RIDICULE4 ,IT WAS ABOLI%$ = POLITICAL REASONS BUT ! EQUALLY 

RIDICUL\S ,BLASPHEMY ,ACT WAS RETA9$1 BE+ UNQUE/ION$ BY 

,P>LIAM5T UNTIL ! AGITATION BY ,MUSLIMS ?AT IT WAS CLE>LY UNFAIR 

?AT ONE C\LD BE F9$ = (F5D+ ,*RI/IANITY :ILE ONE C\LD 

NOT BE EXECUT$ = (F5D+ ,ISLAM4 

,! '#a#c#h#a' LAW WAS USEFUL = SQUATT]S TO P]SUADE PEOPLE !Y C\LD 

OCCUPY NEGLECT$ BUILD+S )\T (F5SE1 ! ODD ?+ BE+ ?AT 

! LAW DID NOT EXI/4 ,! MY? WAS 5\< PROVID$ PEOPLE BELIEV$ 

9 IT4 

,ONE HAS TO C>RY ON A RESI/ANCE TO ANY & EV]Y =M ( TYRANNY4 

,:5 GOV]NM5TS USE !IR PRIVILEGES ?REAT5$1 !Y DROP ! 

PRET5SE ( DEMOCRACY & B5EVOL5CE :I* MO/ POLITICIANS PREF]4 

,AN>*I/S >E =C$ TO BECOME :AT POLITICIANS DESCRIBE !M AS3 

'AG5TS ( DISORD]'1 ?\< !RE IS A LOT MORE TO ,AN>*ISM TO 

?AT1 & ALL 'AG5TS ( DISORD]' >E NOT NECESS>ILY ,AN>*I/S4 

,A ,M>XI/-,L59I/ W\LD SAY1 0,AN>*I/S >E ABLE TO BR+ AB\T 

DISORD] BUT CANNOT SEIZE P[]4 ,H5CE !Y >E UNABLE TO MAKE TAKE 

ADVANTAGE ( ! SITUATIONS !Y CREATE1 & ! B\RGEOISIE1 

REGR\P+ ITS /R5G?1 TURNS TO FASCISM04 

,A ,TORY W\LD SAY ?AT ,M>XI/-,L59I/S >E ,AN>*I/S 0BECAUSE !Y 

WI% TO CREATE ,AN>*Y TO CREATE ! CONDITIONS 9 :I* !Y W\LD 

SEIZE P[]04 ,BO? >E ABSURDITIES4 ,AN>*I/S CAN1 ( C\RSE1 0SEIZE 

P[]0 NO LESS ?AN ANYONE JU/ AS A TEETOTAL] CAN GET BL9D DRUNK1 

BUT !Y W\LD H>DLY CONT9UE TO M]IT ! NAME4 ,AN>*I/S 9 P[] 

W\LD NOT NECESS>ILY BE ANY BETT] OR WORSE ?AN ANYONE ELSE1 & 

!Y MI<T EV5 BE AS BAD AS ,COMMUNI/S OR FASCI/S4 ,!RE IS NO 

LIMIT ( DEGRADATION TO :I* P[] CANNOT BR+ ANYONE EV5 ) ! 

L(TIE/ PR9CIPLES4 ,WE W\LD HOPE ?AT BE+ UNPREP>$ = P[]1 

!Y W\LD BE 9EFFECTIVE4 ,!IR TASK IS NOT TO 0SEIZE P[]0 7?OSE 

:O USE ?IS T]M %[ ?AT !Y SEEK P]SONAL P[] = !MSELVES7 

BUT TO ABOLI% ! BASES ( P[]4 ,P[] TO ALL MEANS P[] TO NOBODY 

9 P>TICUL>4 

,IF ONE LEAVES ! WILD BEA/ ( ,/ATE P[] P>TIALLY W\ND$1 IT 

BECOMES MORE F]OCI\S ?AN EV]1 A RAG+ WILD BEA/ ?AT WILL 

DE/ROY OR BE DE/ROY$4 ,?IS IS :Y ,AN>*I/S =M ORGANIZATIONS TO 

BR+ AB\T REVOLUTION>Y *ANGE4 ,! NATURE ( ,AN>*ISM AS AN 

9DIVIDUALI/IC CRE$ 9 ! TRUE S5SE HAS (T5 CAUS$ MANY TO SAY 

SU* ORGANIZATIONS MI<T WELL BE LEFT TO 'SPONTANEITY'1 'VOLUNT>Y 

WILL' & SO ON -- 9 O!R WORDS1 !RE CAN BE NO ORGANIZATION 

7EXCEPT = PROPAG&A ONLY7 UNTIL ! 5TIRE COMMUNITY =MS ITS [N 

ORGANIZATIONS4 ,?IS IS A RECIPE = A SORT ( >M*AIR ,AN>*ISM :I* 

NEV] GETS (F ! GR\ND1 BUT AT ! SAME TIME ) A PO9T ?AT 

CANNOT BE IGNOR$ -- UNTIL ! :OLE COMMUNITY HAS CONTROL ( ITS [N 

ORGANIZATIONS1 SU* BODIES CANNOT & %\LD NOT TAKE OV] ! SOCIAL 

& ECONOMIC MEANS ( LIFE4 

,IT IS %[N BY EV5TS ?AT UNITY ( RESI/ANCE IS NE$$ AGA9/ 

REPRESSION1 ?AT !RE MU/ BE UNIT$ =MS ( ACTION4 ,EV5 :5 

WORK]S' C\NCILS >E =M$1 !RE MAY BE REPRES5TATIVES ON !M 

FROM POLITICAL FACTIONS1 UNIT$ \TSIDE ON P>TY L9ES & ABLE TO 

PUT =W>D A UNIT$ FRONT )9 SU* C\NCILS & ?US TO DOM9ATE 

& ULTIMATELY DE/ROY !M4 ,?AT IS :Y WE NE$ AN ORGANIZ$ 

MOVEM5T TO DE/ROY SU* EF=TS AT TOTALIT>IANISM4 ,9 SOME CASES 

ONE MAY NE$ ! ULTIMATE SANCTION ( ACTS ( 9DIVIDUAL T]RORISM TO 

BE US$ AGA9/ LEAD]%IP FROM )9 QUITE AS MU* AS ?AT IMPOS$ 

FROM ABOVE4 ,?IS =M ( SPECIFIC T]RORISM HAS NO?+ 9 COMMON 

) NATIONALI/ T]RORISM1 :I* BY ITS NATURE IS AS 9DISCRIM9ATE 

AS ,/ATE T]RORISM1 = ALL ?AT IT IS JUDG$ 9 A F> H>%] LI<T4 

,AN>*I/ T]RORISM IS AGA9/ 9DIVIDUAL DESPOTS1 RUL+ OR 

5DEAVOR+ TO RULE4 ,NATIONALI/ T]RORISM IS A =M ( W> AGA9/ 

PEOPLES4 ,/ATE T]RORISM IS ! ABUSE ( P[]4 

,WORK]S' ,SELF-,DEF5SE 

,! ,M>XI/-,L59I/S 9 TIME ( REVOLUTION RELY UPON ! =MATION 

( A ,R$ ,>MY4 ,UND] ! CONTROL ( ONE P>TY1 ! 0,R$0 ,>MY IS ! 

OLD >MY UND] A R$ FLAG4 ,WE HAVE SE5 MANY TIMES H[ ?IS CAN 

BECOME A MAJOR 9/RUM5T ( REPRESSION1 JU/ AS A NATIONALI/ >MY 

UND] A NEW FLAG CAN ALSO BECOME ONE1 SOMETIMES EV5 BE=E IT 

ATTA9S P[]4 

,! V]Y =MATION ( AN >MY TO SUP]S$E WORK]S' MILITIAS WILL 

DE/ROY ! ,REVOLUTION 7,SPA9 #a#i#c#f74 ,*E ,GUEV>A 9TRODUC$ A NEW 

ROMANTIC IDEAS ( ! ,R$ ,>MY AS ! ADVANCE GU>D ( A PEASANTS 

>MY -- COMB9+ ! SPONTANEITY ( A ,MAKHNOVI/A 7,UKRA9E #a#i#a#g7 & 

,ZAPATI/A_/,MAGONI/A 7,MEXICAN-,AN>*I/IC7 PEASANT >MY ) ! 

DISCIPL9$ IDEAS ( ,P>TY 9TELLECTUALS4 ,9 SU* CASES1 AFT] ! 

9ITIAL 5?USIASM C>RIES ?R\< TO VICTORY1 ! DISCIPL9$ 

LEAD]%IP TAKES OV]2 IF IT FAILS1 ! LEAD]S RUN (F ELSE:]E4 

,! SELF-DEF5SE NOTIONS ( AN>*O-SYNDICALI/S >E ?AT WORK]S USE 

>MS 9 !IR [N DEF5SE AGA9/ ! 5EMY AT H&1 & ?AT ! 

DEMOCRATIC NOTION ( WORK]S' MILITIAS PREVAILS4 ,:ILE !RE MAY BE 

TE*NICAL LEAD]%IP1 9/RUCTION & DUTIES SU* AS >E AT PRES5T 

9 ! H&S ( NONCOMMISSION$ (FIC]S UP TO ! RANK ( S]GEANT1 

!RE %\LD BE NO (FIC]S :OSE JOB IS TO COMM&1 OR L[]-RANK+ 

,N,C,OS TO TRANSMIT ! *A9 ( COMM&4 

,! IDEA ( AN >M$ PEOPLE IS D]ID$ BY MANY SO-CALL$ MILIT>Y & 

POLITICAL EXP]TS1 BUT ONLY IS US$ BY WORK]S 9 !IR [N 9T]E/S4 

,IF SMALL] NATIONS USE IT SUCCESSFULLY1 !Y ADMIT ?AT A CITIZ5S' 

>MY -- ?AT IS TO SAY1 A NONPR(ESSIONAL ONE ?AT CAN HANG UP ITS 

RIFLES & GO BACK TO WORK1 COM+ \T :5 CALL$ UPON -- IS 

POSSIBLE PROVID$ ONLY ?AT1 AS 9 ! CASE ( 7SAY7 ,ISRAEL OR ,S\? 

,AFRICA1 !Y OBEY NATIONALI/IC & AGGRESSIVE POLICIES FROM ABOVE4 

,PROVID+ !Y DON'T MA9TA9 ! =CE 9 9T]NATIONAL-CLASS 

9T]E/S1 ! 0EXP]TS0 >E PREP>$ TO ADMIT ! EFFICI5CY ( SU* 

AN >MY REMA9+ DEMOCRATICALLY CONTROLL$ )9 ITS [N RANKS4 

,H[ ,WILL A ,REVOLUTION ,COME ,AB\T8 

,WE DO NOT KN[4 ,:5 A REVOLUTION>Y SITUATION PRES5TS ITSELF -- AS 

IT DID ) ! OCCUPATION ( FACTORIES 9 ,FRANCE1 #aicf & #a#i#f#h2 AS 

IT DID 9 ,SPA91 #aicf ) ! FASCI/ UPRIS+2 OR ) ! 

BREAKD[N ( ! ,RUSSIAN ,>MIES1 #a#i#a#g2 OR 9 MANY O!R TIMES & 

PLACES2 WE >E READY = IT OR WE >E NOT 7& USUALLY NOT74 ,MANY 

TIMES ! WORK]S >E P>TIALLY READY & LEAVE ! 0W\ND$ WILD 

ANIMAL0 ( ,/ATISM FI]C] ?AN EV]4 ,IT MAY BE PURELY 9DIVIDUAL 

ACTION ?AT SETS (F ! SP>K4 ,BUT ONLY IF1 AT ?AT P]IOD1 !RE IS 

A CONSCI\S MOVEM5T T[>DS A ,FREE ,SOCIETY ?AT ?R[S (F ! 

%ACKLES ( ! PA/1 WILL ?AT SITUATION BECOME A SOCIAL REVOLUTION4 

,! PROBLEM TODAY ?AT FACES US IS ?AT HALF ! WORLD IS PREP>$ TO 

RISE ALMO/ AT ANY OPPORTUNE TIME1 BUT HAVE NO MILIT>Y P[] TO 

RESI/ REPRESSION & NO 9DU/RIAL MUSCLE TO SU/A9 IT4 ,! O!R 

HALF ( ! WORLD HAS SU* MI<T1 BUT NO REAL DESIRE TO RISE1 BE+ 

EI!R B\<T (F BY CAPITALISM OR SUCCUMB+ TO P]SUASION4 

,BR++ ,AB\T ! ,NEW ,SOCIETY 

,:AT ,CON/ITUTES AN ,AU?ORIT>IAN ,SOCIETY8 

,EXPLOITATION -- ,MANIPULATION -- ,SUPPRESSION4 ,! ORGANS ( REPRESSION 

CONSI/ ( MANY >MS ( ! ,/ATE3 

,! ,APP>ATUS ( ,GOV]NM5T3 ,! LEGISLATURE1 ! JUDICATURE1 ! 

MON>*Y1 ! ,CIVIL ,S]VICE1 ! ,>M$ ,=CES1 ! ,POLICE ETC4 

,! ,APP>ATUS ( ,P]SUASION3 ,! $UCATIONAL SY/EM1 ! M$IA1 

9CLUD+ ,T,V1 RADIO & ! PRESS1 ! ,*UR*1 & EV5 =MS ( 

APP>5T DISS5T ?AT 9 REALITY CONDITION US TO ACCEPT ! PRES5T 

SY/EM -- ! P>LIAM5T>Y ,OPPOSITION IS ! MO/ OBVI\S1 BUT MANY 

O!R ALT]NATIVES TO ! ACCEPT$ SY/EM TOO1 E4G41 REVOLUTION 

PRES5T$ AS M]ELY ONE 9 LIFE/YLE OR MUSICAL PREF]5CE1 ACADEMIC 

TEA*+ ( ,M>XI/-,L59ISM ETC4 

,! ,APP>ATUS ( ,EXPLOITATION3 ,! MONET>Y SY/EM2 F9ANCIAL 

CONTROL2 ! ,BANKS2 ! ,/OCK ,EX*ANGE2 9DIVIDUAL1 COLLECTIVE1 & 

,/ATE EMPLOY]S2 L& [N]%IP4 ,UND] CAPITALISM !RE IS NO 

ESCAP+ ?IS4 

,MO/ POLITICAL RE=M]S HAVE SOME P>T ( ! UNFREE SY/EM !Y 

WI% TO ABOLI% ,REPUBLICANS W\LD ABOLI% ! MON>*Y1 ,SECUL>I/S 

W\LD ABOLI% OR DISE/ABLI% ! ,*UR*1 ,SOCIALI/S W\LD 7OR US$ 

TO7 WI% TO ABOLI% ! APP>ATUS ( EXPLOITATION2 PACIFI/S W\LD 

ABOLI% ! ,>MY4 ,AN>*ISM IS UNIQUE 9 WI%+ TO ABOLI% ALL4 ,! 

ONLY TRUE DEF9ITION ( AN ,AN>*I/ IS ONE :O WI%ES TO BELIEVES IT 

DESIRABLE TO ABOLI% ALL2 :O BELIEVE IT POSSIBLE TO ABOLI% ALL1 ! 

SOON] ! BETT]2 & :O WORKS TO BR+ SU* ABOLITION AB\T4 

,!RE >E MANY1 USUALLY ON ! LEFT1 :O ?9K IT DESIRABLE BUT 

IMPOSSIBLE1 MANY ON ! RI<T :O ?9K IT ONLY TOO PROBABLE BUT 

UNDESIRABLE4 ,O!RS MAY BE SYMPA!TIC TO ,AN>*ISM AS BO? DESIRABLE 

& POSSIBLE BUT REFRA9 FROM ACTION 9 ITS FAVOR4 ,TO BORR[ A PHRASE 

FROM ANO!R P>T ( ! =E/1 !Y MAY BE FELL[ TRAVEL]S ( 

,AN>*ISM4 

,! ,POLICE >E ! CORN]/ONE ( ! ,/ATE 7?\< SOMETIMES1 9 

EXTREME CASES1 ! ,GOV]NM5T ( ! DAY NE$S TO USE ! >M$ 

=CES 9 LIEU (1 OR 9 ADDITION TO ! POLICE -- 9 SOME C\NTRIES 

?IS HAS L$ TO REPLACEM5T OR CONTROL ( ! ,GOV]NM5T BY ! >MY 

SO LONG AS ! (FIC]S >E TI<TLY 9 CONTROL74 

,ONLY ,AN>*ISM BELIEVES 9 ABOLITION ( ! ,POLICE1 & ?IS IS ! 

MO/ HOTLY-DISPUT$ >GUM5T ( ,AN>*ISM4 ,YET ! POLICE =CE AS 

WE KN[ IT IS A COMP>ATIVELY MOD]N PH5OM5ON1 FI]CELY RESI/$ 

:5 9TRODUC$ = REASONS :I* HAVE S9CE BE5 PROV$ UP TO ! 

HILT1 SU* AS ! ABILITY ( ! ,POLICE TO 9TRODUCE OR BOL/] UP A 

DICTATOR%IP1 KN[N 9DE$ AS A POLICE /ATE4 ,)\T CONTROL ( ! 

,POLICE1 DEBATES AT ,WE/M9/] BECOME AS /]ILE ( RESULT AS DEBATES 

9 ! ,WE/ ,K5S+TON ,DEBAT+ ,SOCIETY 7& PROBABLY LESS 

9T]E/+74 

,) ,G]MAN MONEY1 SUPPLI$ BY ,HELPH&-,P>VUS1 ,L59 WAS ABLE TO 

RETURN TO ,RUSSIA & PAY ,LETTI% M]C5>IES TO ACT AS ,POLICE4 ,HE WAS 

! ONLY POLITICIAN 9 A POSITION TO DO SO & 9 ?IS WAY ,BOL%EVIK 

SUCCESS WAS A*IEV$4 ,! ,NAZIS 9 !IR TURN CREAT$ MURD] GANGS 

?AT ROAM$ ! /REETS1 :I* W]E TACITLY TOL]AT$ BY ! 

,REPUBLICAN ,POLICE1 BUT !IR VICTORY CAME :5 !Y CONTROLL$ ! 

,POLICE BY LEGAL MEANS4 

,CAN ,ONE ,DO ,)\T ! ,/ATE8 

,IT SEEMS TO BE G5]ALLY AGRE$ ?AT WE CAN DO )\T SOME ORGANS ( 

! ,/ATE3 CAN WE DO )\T !M ALL1 ALTOGE!R8 ,SOME >E ADMITT$LY 

USELESS1 SOME DECORATIVE1 SOME HAVE IMPOSSIBLE 9T5TIONS1 O!RS >E 

NECESS>Y = CLASS RULE1 SOME MAY WELL BE USEFUL & C>RY \T 

FUNCTIONS ESS5TIAL TO ANY SOCIETY4 

,ONE CANNOT DO ! WORK ( ANO!R4 ,IF ! MON>*Y HAS NO ,>MY IT 

CANNOT SAVE Y\ FROM =EIGN 9VASION ANY MORE ?AN ! POLICE WILL 

GET Y\ 9TO HEAV5 IF Y\ DO NOT HAVE A ,*UR*6 ,ANY COMMONS5SE 

CODIFICATION ( CONDUCT W\LD BE BETT] ?AN ! F>RAGO ( LAWS WE 

HAVE AT PRES5T1 :I* OCCUPY BO? ! LAWY]S & POLITICIANS1 ! 

ONE 9T]PRET+ ! APP>5T DESIRES ( ! O!R4 

,IT IS TRUE ?AT ! ,GOV]NM5T CAN & SOMETIMES DOES TAKE OV] 

C]TA9 NECESS>Y SOCIAL FUNCTIONS1 AS DO EV]Y ORGAN ( ! ,/ATE 

H[EV] REPRESSIVE4 ,! RAILWAYS W]E NOT ALWAYS RUN BY ! ,/ATE BUT 

BELONG$ TO CAPITALI/S1 & C\LD EQUALLY 9 A FUTURE SOCIETY BELONG 

TO ! WORK]S4 ,IT W\LD BE FOOLI% TO SAY ?AT IF M9ES BELONG$ TO 

! ,/ATE1 ?AT PROVES ! ,/ATE IS NECESS>Y1 OR WE W\LD HAVE NO 

COAL )\T IT4 ,! ,>MY IS (T5 GIV5 SOCIALLY NECESS>Y JOBS1 

SU* AS FLOOD OR E>?QUAKE RELIEF2 IT IS SOMETIMES US$ AS A SCAB 

LABOR =CE1 SU* AS 9 /RIKES2 IT IS SOMETIMES US$ AS A POLICE 

=CE4 ,?IS IS BECAUSE ! ,/ATE DOES NOT WANT ! BREAKUP ( A 

SOCIETY ?AT SUPPORTS IT4 

,EV5 ! POLICE AT TIMES FULFILL SOME NECESS>Y FUNCTIONS -- ONE GOES 

TO ! POLICE /ATION TO F9D LO/ DOGS SIMPLY BECAUSE IT HAPP5S TO 

BE !RE & HAS TAK5 OV] ?AT FUNCTION4 ,IT DOES NOT FOLL[ ?AT WE 

%\LD NEV] F9D LO/ DOGS IF !RE W]E NO ,POLICE1 & ?AT WE NE$ 

TO BE CLUBB$ OV] ! HEAD 9 TIMES ( SOCIAL UNRE/ SO ?AT OLD 

LADIES CAN NE$ NOT LOSE !IR DOGS4 ,= 9SURANCE PURPOSES1 ALL C> 

[N]S REPORT !IR LO/ OR /OL5 C>S TO ! ,POLICE1 BUT IT DOES 

NOT MEAN ?AT ! POLICE =CE AS SU* IS 9DISP5SABLE4 

,JU/ AS 9SURANCE COMPANIES W\LD F9D SOME WAY ( SEE+ !Y C\LD 

NOT PAY \T ON FRAUDUL5T CLAIMS IF !RE W]E NO POLICE =CE1 

SOCIETY W\LD SEE TO IT ?AT IT C\LD PROTECT ITSELF4 ,UN=TUNATELY1 

HAV+ A POLICE =CE ATROPHIES ! ABILITY ( SOCIETY TO DEF5D 

ITSELF4 ,PEOPLE HAVE LO/ ALL S5SE ( SOCIAL ORGANIZATION & 

CONTROL4 ,!Y CAN BE PUT 9 T]ROR BY A FEW KIDS RUNN+ WILD1 

H[EV] Y\NG4 ,! ONLY REACTION IS TO RUN TO ! ,POLICE1 & ! 

,POLICE CANNOT COPE4 

,!RE WAS AN OLD SUP]/ITION ?AT IF ! ,*UR* EXCOMMUNICAT$ A 

C\NTRY1 IT WAS UND] A T]RIBLE DISA/]4 ,ONE C\LD NOT BE M>RI$1 

BURI$1 LEAVE PROP]TY1 DO BUS9ESS 9 SAFETY1 BE $UCAT$1 BE T5D$ 

:ILE SICK1 9 A C\NTRY :I* WAS EXCOMMUNICAT$4 ,! SUP]/ITION 

WAS NOT AN IDLE ONE1 SO LONG AS PEOPLE BELIEV$ 9 ! ,*UR*4 ,IF ! 

C\NTRY WAS BANN$ FROM ! COMMUNION ( BELIEV]S1 ! HOSPITALS 7RUN 

BY ! ,*UR*7 W]E CLOS$2 !RE C\LD BE NO TRU/ 9 BUS9ESS 7! 

CL]ICS ADM9I/]$ OA?S & )\T !M NO PROMISES NE$ BE 

KEPT72 NO $UCATION 7!Y RAN ! S*OOLS72 *ILDR5 C\LD 9DE$ BE 

BEGOTT5 7NO WAY ( PREV5T+ ?AT BY ! ,*UR*671 BUT NOT 

*RI/5$1 & W]E !RE=E B>R$ FROM ! COMMUNITY ( BELIEV]S 

& UND] A ?REAT1 AS !Y ?\<T1 ( ET]NAL DAMNATION1 :ILE 

UNM>RI$ P>5TS C\LD NOT LEAVE PROP]TY TO !IR 0ILLEGITIMATE0 

*ILDR54 ,! PHYSICAL REALITY ( ,HELL WAS NOT NECESS>Y TO MAKE 

EXCOMMUNICATION EFFECTIVE4 ,WE >E WIS] N[4 ,BUT ONE SUP]/ITION HAS 

BE5 REPLAC$ BY ANO!R4 ,IT HAS BE5 TRANSF]R$ TO BELIEF 9 ! 

,/ATE4 ,IF WE W]E TO REJECT ,GOV]NM5T !RE W\LD BE NO $UCATION 

7= ,GOV]NM5T1 NATIONAL OR LOCAL1 CONTROLS ! S*OOLS -- ) 

OBVI\S EXCEPTIONS71 NO HOSPITALS 7DITTO71 NOBODY C\LD C>RY ONE 

WORK+ BECAUSE ! ,GOV]NM5T REGULATES ITS CONDUCT1 & SO ON4 ,! 

TRU? ALL ! TIME HAS BE5 ?AT NOT ! ,*UR* & NOT ! ,/ATE BUT 

WE ! ,PEOPLE HAVE WORK$ = EV]Y?+ WE'VE GOT1 & IF WE HAVE NOT 

DONE SO !Y HAVE NOT PROVID$ = US4 ,EV5 ! PRIVILEG$ HAVE BE5 

MA9TA9$ BY US NOT !M4 

,! ,MONEY ,MY? 

,) ! ,/ATE MY? COMES A SECOND MY? -- ! MONEY MY?4 ,! VALUE 

( MONEY IS DEP5D5T ON ! /R5G? ( ! ,/ATE4 ,:5 ,GOV]NM5TS 

COLLAPSE1 !IR MONEY IS WOR?LESS4 ,= YE>S ,AM]ICAN CROOKS 

TRAVEL$ ,EUROPE (F]+ TO *ANGE ,CONF$]ATE DOLL>S1 WOR? 

NO?+ S9CE ! ,S\!RN ,/ATES HAD LO/ ! ,CIVIL ,W>1 PRES5T+ 

!M TO UNSUSPECT+ ,EUROPEANS AS VALID ,U4,S4 DOLL>S -- UNTIL !Y 

BECAME COLLECTORS' PIECES & W]E WOR? MORE ?AN SEV]AL ,U4,S4 

DOLL>S6 ,AT ?AT PO9T ! ,F$]AL ,GOV]NM5T UTILIZ$ ! ORIG9AL 

PR9T+ PLANTS TO PUBLI% ,CONF$]ATE DOLL>S & GAVE !M AWAY 

) BUBBLE-GUM1 LE/ !IR [N CURR5CY BECAME DEVALU$4 

,:5 ! ,KAIS]'S ,G]MANY COLLAPS$1 ,IMP]IAL M>KS W]E USELESS4 

,:5 ! ,SPANI% ,REPUBLIC WAS DEFEAT$1 ! BANKS SIMPLY CANCEL$ ! 

VALUE ( ITS MONEY4 ,! /ORY IS 5DLESS4 ,YET ACCORD+ TO A LEG5D 

MANY /ILL BELIEVE1 ! WEAL? ( ! C\NTRY IS TO BE F\ND AT 

,WAT]L['S PR9T+ WORKS4 ,AS ! NOTES ROLL (F ! PRESS1 SO \R 

WEAL? IS CREAT$1 & IF ?IS CEAS$ WE %\LD BE IMPOV]I%$6 ,! 

BANKS HAVE COME UP ) AN ALT]NATIVE 9 PR9T+ !IR [N CR$IT 

C>DS4 ,ANO!R ALT]NATIVE MY?1 N[ DAT$1 WAS ?AT ! MONEY 

PR9T$ HAD TO CORRESPOND ) A QUANTITY ( CLOSELY-GU>D$ GOLD 

BURI$ 9 A MY/]I\S VAULT1 AFT] HAV+ BE5 DUG UP UND] TI<T 

SECURITY FROM M9ES ?\S&S ( MILES AWAY4 ,H[EV]1 ,GOV]NM5TS 

HAVE LONG S9CE DEFAULT$ ON ! PREMISES BEH9D ?IS MY? 7?\< 

!Y /ILL CONT9UE ! RITUAL74 ,! NEW] GOV]NM5TAL MY? IS ?AT 

IF TOO MANY NOTES >E PR9T$ WE %ALL HAVE 9FLATION :I* WILL MAKE 

US ALL POOR1 SO TO PREV5T ?IS WE MU/ BE PREP>$ TO 5DURE 

CONDITIONS ( /R+5CY & POV]TY1 LOSE JOBS & HOMES1 OR 9 

O!R WORDS BECOME POOR4 

,DUR+ ! W>1 RATION+ ( FOOD & CLO!S MEANT ?AT :AT C\NT$ 

WAS C\PONS1 BY :I* IT WAS HOP$ TO 5SURE !RE W]E FAIR %>ES ( 

:AT WAS AVAILABLE4 ,AS ! MONEY SY/EM CONT9U$1 A BLACK M>KET 9 

COMMODITIES WAS 9EVITABLE1 BUT RATION+ GAVE AN IDEA ( :AT ,/ATE 

,SOCIALISM -- )\T MONEY -- W\LD BE LIKE4 ,IF !RE W]E TOO MANY 

C\PONS PR9T$ !RE W\LD BE NO PO9T 9 ! S*EME4 ,MONEY IS 

ANO!R =M ( RATION+1 BY :I* ONE SET ( PEOPLE GET MORE ?AN 

ANO!R4 ,WAGE /RUGGLES >E FI<TS TO GET A BIGG] SLICE ( ! CAKE4 

,! WEAL?Y >E ?OSE :O HAVE FIR/ ACCESS TO SLIC+ ! CAKE4 ,BUT 

NEI!R MONEY NOR C\PONS MAKE ANY DIFF]5CE TO ! SIZE ( ! 

CAKE1 !Y >E SIMPLY MEANS ( DEAL+ ) ITS DI/RIBUTION1 :E!R 

FAIRLY -- OR MORE LIKELY -- UNFAIRLY4 ,SO ESS5TIAL IS MONEY TO ! 

OBTA9+ ( GOODS 9 A ,/ATE SOCIETY1 IT S\NDS HUMOR\S TO SAY 

MONEY IS A MY? -- 0,I DON'T C>E IF IT'S MY?ICAL1 GIVE ME MORE0 -- 

BUT MY? IT IS4 

,MANY WOR?Y PEOPLE BELIEVE IF ,LADY ,X DID NOT SP5D H] MONEY ON A 

YA*T1 ?AT MONEY C\LD SOMEH[ BE TRANS=M$ 9TO AN X-RAY 

APP>ATUS = ! HOSPITAL4 ,!Y DO NOT UND]/&1 IT W\LD SEEM1 

?AT YA*T BUILD]S CANNOT PRODUCE X-RAY MA*9ES4 ,O!RS ?9K ?AT 

?OSE ON ,NATIONAL ,ASSI/ANCE >E SUPPORT$ BY ?OSE AT WORK -- YET 

! M>G9 ( UNEMPLOYM5T IS ESS5TIAL TO ! ,/ATE AS A PITFALL TO 

MAKE ! 9C5TIVES TO WORK /ICK4 ,O!RS BELIEVE !RE IS A RELATION 

BETWE5 !IR WAGES GO+ UP & ! WAGES RECEIV$ BY O!R PEOPLE 

GO+ D[N4 ,9 A COMPETITIVE SOCIETY1 H[EV]1 ONE GETS :AT ONE IS 

ABLE TO COMM&4 

,! ,MY? ( ,TAXATION 

,!RE IS A PAT5T ABSURDITY 9 SUPPOS+ ?AT ?OSE :O WORK & 

PRODUCE >E HELP$ BY ?OSE :O PR(IT FROM ! SY/EM & DO 

NO?+4 ,IT IS EQUALLY ABSURD TO SUPPOSE ?AT ! RI* HELP ! POOR 

BY PROVID+ WORK OR *>ITY4 ,AS ,BR5DAN ,BEHAN COMM5T$ TO SOMEONE 

:O PO9T$ \T H[ MU* ! ,GU9NESS FAMILY HAD DONE = ! POOR 

PEOPLE ( ,DUBL9 -- 0,IT'S NO?+ COMP>$ TO :AT ! POOR PEOPLE ( 

,DUBL9 HAVE DONE = ! ,GU9NESS FAMILY04 ,TAXATION P]PETUATES ! 

MY? ?AT ?OSE ) MORE MONEY HELP ?OSE ) LESS4 ,TAXATION GRABS 

MONEY \T ( ! POCKETS ( ! LESS WELL-(F EV5 BE=E !Y HAVE A 

*ANCE TO LOOK AT IT4 ,! RI* DRESS UP !IR ACC\NTS BY MEANS ( 

PR(ESSIONAL ADVIS]S4 ,BUT ASIDE FROM ?AT1 MONEY DOES NOT CREATE 

WEAL?1 IT IS MUSCLE1 BRA91 & NATURAL RES\RCES ?AT DO4 ,MONEY IS 

US$ TO RE/RICT ! APPLICATION ( HUMAN 5DEAVOR4 ,IT IS POSSIBLE 

TO PR9T MONEY1 OR >RANGE CR$IT1 :5 IT IS 9 ! 9T]E/S ( 

MONEY MANIPULATORS TO DO SO4 ,:5 !Y WI% TO GO 9TO RECESSION1 

!Y DO SO BY )DRAW+ MONEY & CR$IT4 ,RECESSION IS NOT A 

NATURAL DISA/] LIKE FAM9E1 DR\<T1 FLOODS1 OR E>?QUAKES ?\< 

IT IS PRES5T$ AS SU*4 

,! ,EFFECT ( ,IMMIGRATION 

,! L>GE SCALE EMPLOY] LOOK+ AT GREAT] PR(ITABILITY OR ! WAY 

TO CUT CO/S HAS SEV]AL OPTIONS OP51 ! EASIE/ & LAZIE/ BE+ 

TO CUT WAGES4 ,IF ! WORK]S >E WELL-ORGANIZ$ !Y CAN RESI/ ?IS 

SO !RE >E TWO OPTIONS OP5 TO ! MAJOR CAPITALI/4 ,EI!R TAKE 

! FACTORIES TO :]E ! *EAP LABOR IS OR TAKE ! *EAP LABOR 

TO :]E ! FACTORIES >E4 ,! FIR/ OPTION 5TAILS GREAT POLLUTION1 

AS A RULE -- NOT ?AT !Y EV] C>E AB\T ?AT -- & 9 SOME CASES 

!Y HAVE TO GO 9TO >EAS ( POLITICAL 9/ABILITY4 ,IT IS *EAP] TO 

MOVE ! *EAP LABOR4 

,HAV+ ?US 5C\RAG$ IMMIGRATION1 WE>+ ! F9ANCIAL HAT AS IT 

W]E1 ! CAPITALI/ 9 ! CAPACITY ( A RI<T-W+ POLITICIAN1 DONS 

! POLITICAL HAT & D5\NCES IMMIGRATION4 ,?IS HAS ! ADVANTAGE ( 

SETT+ WORK] AGA9/ WORK]1 FUEL$ BY RELIGI\S &_/OR RACIAL 

ANTIPA?IES :I* CAN P]SI/ = G5]ATIONS1 & HAVE ! ADD$ 

BONUS ( 9DUC+ ! WORK] TO SUPPORT ! RI<T W+ ELECTORALLY4 

,IT DOES ! CAPITALI/ NO H>M TO HAVE A WORK =CE HAT$ BY ?OSE 

:O SURR\ND !M1 OR 9 FE> ( DEPORTATION IF !Y /EP \T ( 

L9E4 ,NOR DOES IT H>M ! CAPITALI/1 9 A POLITICAL CONTEXT1 TO 

HAVE ISSUES SU* AS IMMIGRATION REPLACE ! BASIC ISSUE ( ! WAGE 

& MONET>Y SY/EM4 ,IT ONLY BECOMES H>MFUL FROM ?AT PO9T ( VIEW 

:5 A FASCI/ =CE SU* AS ,HITL]'S GA9S SU* >M$ MI<T ?AT IT 

CAN IGNORE ! WI%ES ( ! CAPITALI/S :I* GAVE !M ?AT P[] 

& /RIVES = ITS [N SUP]IORITY4 

,! ,ABOLITION ( ! ,WAGE & ,MONET>Y ,SY/EMS 

0,SOCIALISM0 HAS BECOME SO DIFFUS$ A T]M TODAY ?AT IT IS US$ ( 

ALMO/ ANY RE=MI/ OR 9DE$ POSITIVELY C\NT]-REVOLUTION>Y 

MOVEM5T ?AT WI%ES TO USE ! T]M & COV]S A MULTITUDE ( IDEAS 

FROM LIB]ALISM TO TYRANNY1 BUT 9 REALITY ! ESS5TIALS ( ANY 

SOCIALI/IC !ORY >E ! ABOLITION ( ! WAGE & MONET>Y 

SY/EMS4 ,?IS IS BECAUSE A G5U9E SOCIALI/IC MOVEM5T %\LD BE ( 

! WORK+ CLASS & 9T5D$ = ITS [N EMANCIPATION FROM WAGE 

SLAV]Y4 ,! WAGE & MONET>Y SY/EMS >E ! *A9S ( ?AT SLAV]Y 

?AT NE$ TO BE BROK54 

,SOME MODIFI$ =M ( WAGE OR SOME MEANS ( EX*ANGE MI<T BE 

CONSI/5T ) A FREE COMMUNI/IC SOCIETY1 ESPECIALLY AMONG A 

PO/-REVOLUTION>Y SOCIETY ACCU/OM$ TO SOME =M ( 

LABOR-REW>D+ ASSESSM5T1 BUT ! PRES5T =M ( MONET>Y SY/EM 

IS ONE 9 :I* MONEY IS NOT A S]VANT 7A MEANS ( EX*ANGE7 BUT A 

BOSS 9 ITS [N RI<T4 ,WAGES >E A MEANS ( D5OT+ ! POSITION 9 

SOCIETY'S PECK+ ORD] :I* A P]SON IS DEEM$ TO HOLD4 ,IT IS NOT 

EV5 FAIR AS REG>DS ! ASSESSM5T IT MAKES4 ,SU* SY/EMS MU/ BE 

SWEPT ASIDE4 

,AT PRES5T1 AS 9DICAT$ ABOVE1 ! ,GOV]NM5T1 OR ! EFFECTIVE 

CONTROLL] :I* MAY 9 SOME CASES BE OV] ! ,GOV]NM5T 7! BANKS1 

= 9/ANCE7 ASSESS ! NATIONAL WEAL?4 ,A CORRESPOND+ NUMB] ( 

BANK NOTES >E PR9T$1 CO9 IS /RUCK1 CR$ITS >E GRANT$ TO 

F9ANCIAL H\SES4 ,ACCORD+ TO ! DEGREE ( EFFICI5CY OR 

9EFFICI5CY ( A CURR5T ,GOV]NM5T 7:I* IS ! /UFF ( 

DAY-TO-DAY PRESS POLITICAL SLOGANE]+ & NE$ NOT CONC]N US7 ! 

ASSESSM5T1 OR BUDGET MAY BE CORRECT OR 9CORRECT4 ,ACCORD+ TO HIS 

OR H] ASSESSM5T1 ! ,*ANCELLOR ( ! ,EX*EQU] MAY BE 0G5]\S0 

OR 0NIGG>DLY0 9 %>+ \T ! NATIONAL 0CAKE0 & APPORTION+ 

\R SLICES4 ,BUT 9 REALITY SAL>IES & WAGES >E DET]M9$ BY 

SOCIAL CONV5TION1 TRADITION1 ,GOV]NM5T PATRONAGE1 ECONOMIC 

COMPETITION1 H]$IT>Y P[]1 TRADE UNION B>GA9+1 9DIVIDUAL 

5T]PRISE & WILDCAT /RIKES4 ,ACCORD+ TO !IR EFFECTIV5ESS1 SO 

IS ! 0SLICE ( CAKE0 EA* RECEIVES4 ,?OSE UNABLE TO USE ANY ( ! 

PRESSURES >E SIMPLY LEFT \T ( ! RECKON+ & MU/ BE CONT5T 

) :AT IS GIV5 !M 9 ORD] SOLELY TO SURVIVE4 ,! 0CAKE0 IS ! 

SAME :ATEV] ! ,GOV]NM5T DOES AB\T IT4 

,IS ,AN>*ISM ,COMPATIBLE ) ,CAPITALISM8 

,IT IS ONLY POSSIBLE TO CONCEIVE ( ,AN>*ISM 9 A =M 9 :I* IT IS 

FREE1 COMMUNI/IC1 & (F]+ NO ECONOMIC NECESSITY = REPRESSION 

OR C\NT]+ IT4 ,COMMON S5SE %[S ?AT ANY CAPITALI/ SOCIETY 

MI<T DISP5SE ) A 0,/ATE0 79 ! ,AM]ICAN S5SE ( ! WORD7 BUT 

IT C\LD NOT DISP5SE ) ORGANIZ$ ,GOV]NM5T1 OR A PRIVATIZ$ =M 

( IT1 IF !RE W]E PEOPLE AMASS+ MONEY & O!RS WORK+ TO 

AMASS IT = !M4 ,! PHILOSOPHY ( 0AN>*O-CAPITALISM0 DREAM$ UP 

BY ! 0LIB]T>IAN0 ,NEW ,RI<T1 HAS NO?+ TO DO ) ,AN>*ISM AS 

KN[N BY ! ,AN>*I/ MOVEM5T PROP]4 ,IT IS A LIE ?AT COV]S AN 

UNPLEASANT REALITY 9 ITS WAY -- SU* AS ,NATIONAL ,SOCIALISM DOES 9 

ANO!R4 ,PAT5TLY UNBRIDL$ CAPITALISM1 NOT EV5 HAMP]$ BY A 

RE=MI/ ,/ATE1 :I* HAS TO PUT SOME LIMITS ON EXPLOITATION TO 

PREV5T VIOL5T CLA%ES 9 SOCIETY1 NE$S SOME =CE AT ITS DISPOSAL 

TO MA9TA9 CLASS PRIVILEGES1 EI!R FROM ! ,/ATE ITSELF OR FROM 

PRIVATE ,>MIES4 ,:AT !Y BELIEVE 9 IS 9 FACT A LIMIT$ ,/ATE -- 

?AT IS1 ONE 9 :I* ! ,/ATE HAS ONE FUNCTION1 TO PROTECT ! 

RUL+ CLASS1 DOES NOT 9T]F]E ) EXPLOITATION1 & COMES AS 

*EAP AS POSSIBLE = ! RUL+ CLASS4 ,! IDEA ALSO S]VES ANO!R 

PURPOSE BEYOND ITS FULFILLM5T -- A MORAL JU/IFICATION = B\RGEOIS 

CONSCI5CES 9 AVOID+ TAXES )\T FEEL+ GUILTY AB\T IT -- JU/ 

AS PACIFISM SOMETIMES S]VES AS AN EXCUSE = B\RGEOIS CONSCI5CES 

9 AVOID+ DANG] )\T FEEL+ GUILTY4 

,COMMUNITY ,CONTROL 

,! HI/ORY ( COLLECTIVE CONTROL 9 A CAPITALI/ SOCIETY IS A PRETTY 

DISMAL ONE4 ,!RE HAVE BE5 MANY ATTEMPTS TO BYPASS ! SY/EM BY 

=M+ 0COMMUNITIES0 :I* BECAUSE !Y >E LESS ?AN ! :OLE1 

REAL COMMUNITY1 >E B\ND 9 ! 5D NOT TO PROSP]4 ,COOP]ATIVE 

SOCIETIES NO LESS ?AN SMALL BUS9ESSES R>ELY )/& ! PRESSURE 

( MONOPOLY CAPITALISM4 ,COLLECTIVE F>MS -- COLLECTIVE 5T]PRISES AT 

:I* ONE WORKS AT LESS ?AN ! NORMAL WAGE TO = ! SAKE ( 

9DEP5D5CE -- LIKE CRAFT BUS9ESSES1 NEV] QUITE GET (F ! GR\ND 

& IT ALWAYS COMES D[N TO ! MONOPOLY M>KET4 ,ALL C\LD FL\RI% IF 

! SY/EM W]E FREE1 BUT IT IS NOT4 

,NEV]!LESS1 ONE CAN NOTE ?AT MANY COMMUNAL PRODUCTS >E EQUALLY 

AVAILABLE TO ALL1 EI!R ON PAYM5T ( A FIX$ SUM1 OR FREE4 ,! 

HI<WAYS >E FREE -- NEI!R ,/ATE NOR CAPITALISM HAS GOT R\ND 7YET7 

TO MAK+ ALL ROADS TOLL ROADS TO 5T] :I* ONE MU/ PAY 7BUT 

!Y'VE GOT R\ND TO IT ON MA9 MOTORWAYS ON ! ,CONT95T74 ,IT W\LD 

PROBABLY MAKE NO ECONOMIC DIFF]5CE IF ! UND]GR\ND RAILWAY WAS 

ALSO FREE1 BE>+ 9 M9D ! CO/ ( TICKET COLLECT+4 ,WAT] US$ 

TO BE FREE -- EV5 :5 WAT] RATES CAME 9 ONE C\LD DRAW AS MU* AS 

ONE LIK$ FROM ! TAP4 ,N[ !RE >E WAT] MET]S1 AS IF WE W]E 

LIV+ 9 ! ,SAH>A :]E WAT] HAS LONG BE5 RATION$4 ,SO F> !Y 

HAVE NOT GOT R\ND TO MAK+ US PAY = AIR4 

,AN>*ISM PRESUPPOSES ?AT ALL !SE >GUM5TS BAS$ ON ECONOMICS >E 

BUNKUM4 ,S]VICES :I* COME NATURALLY OR >E PRODUC$ BY ! PEOPLE 

%\LD BELONG TO ! PEOPLE4 

,NE$ ,!RE BE A ,TRANSITIONAL ,SOCIETY8 

,A TRANSITIONAL SOCIETY TO ,AN>*ISM ISN'T NECESS>Y4 ,! IDEA T\T$ 

BY ,L59I/S WAS ?AT ! ,/ATE W\LD FADE AWAY AFT] YE>S ( ! 

H>%E/ DICTATOR%IP -- ORIG9ALLY CLAIM$ TO BE ONLY AS MU* AS WAS 

NECESS>Y TO SAVE ! 9FANT ,SOVIET ,REPUBLIC BUT :I* LA/$ = 

SEV5TY YE>S UNTIL ! PEOPLE GOT F$ UP ) IT4 ,ALL ?AT FAD$ 

AWAY WAS PEOPLE RA% 5\< TO WANT TO GO =W>D TO FREE SOCIALISM4 

,! PROSPECT ( 'WI!R+ AWAY ( ! ,/ATE' AFT] YE>S ( 

/R5G!N+ IT IS ILLOGICAL4 ,L59I/S JU/IFY ?IS BY SAY+ ! 

,/ATE IS ONLY ?AT P>T ( ! ,/ATE APP>ATUS :I* FAVORS ! 

CAPITALI/ CLASS BY SUPPRESS+ ! WORK+ CLASS4 ,?IS MI<T FADE 

AWAY 7?\< IT DID NOT DO SO 9 ! YE>S ( ,/ATE ,COMMUNISM74 ,:AT 

CANNOT FADE AWAY IS ! RE/ ( ! ,/ATE APP>ATUS1 UNLESS ! ,/ATE 

IS DE/ROY$ ROOT & BRAN*4 

,! FACT ?AT A TRANSITIONAL SOCIETY TO ,AN>*ISM ISN'T NECESS>Y 

DOES NOT NECESS>ILY MEAN !RE WILL NOT BE ONE4 ,:O CAN SAY8 ,AFT] 

ALL1 *ANG+ ATTITUDES TO SU* MATT]S AS RACIAL DOM9ATION1 SEXUAL 

DISCRIM9ATION1 RELIGI\S ORI5TATION1 CON=MITY1 & SO ON MI<T BE 

P>T ( A TRANSITION TO A ,FREE ,SOCIETY ALREADY EXI/+4 ,!RE MI<T 

BE AN OCCUPATION ( ! PLACES ( WORK )\T A CONSCI\S 

REVOLUTION1 :I* 9 ITSELF W\LD BE A TRANSITIONAL P]IOD4 

,ONE C\LD EV5 VISUALIZE A CURI\S TRANSITIONAL P]IOD 9 :I* P>T 

( SOCIETY WAS EVOLV+ TO A NEW SY/EM & P>T WAS /ICK+ TO ! 

OLD -- ) WORK]S' CONTROL COEXI/+ ) PRIVATE CAPITALISM 9 ! 

M>KET ! WAY RIGID OLD-TIME FAMILY /YLES COEXI/ ) FREE 

RELATION%IPS 9 ! SAME /REET4 ,BUT CLE>LY 9 ! LONG RUN ONE OR 

! O!R SY/EM W\LD HAVE TO GO4 ,CAPITALISM C\LD NOT EXI/ IF 

PEOPLE C\LD BE FREE TO *OOSE ! WAY !Y WORK )\T BE+ 

COMPELL$ BY CONSCRIPTION OR NECESSITY -- !RE=E IT W\LD EI!R 

NE$ TO RE9=CE ITS AU?ORITY 7POSSIBLY BY FASCI/ GANGS1 AS DUR+ 

! OCCUPATION ( ! FACTORIES 9 ,ITALY7 OR GO UND] 7:I* IS ! 

*OICE ! ,ITALIAN CAPITALI/S AS A :ILE1 EV5 ?\< MANY HAD 

DEMOCRATIC VIEWPO9TS1 W]E =C$ TO TAKE74 

,A ,FREE ,SOCIETY 

,A SOCIETY CANNOT BE FREE UNLESS NOT ONLY >E !RE NO GOV]NM5TAL 

RE/RA9TS1 BUT ! ESS5TIALS ( LIFE >E FREE 9 ?AT S5SE TOO4 

,IT IS TRUE ?AT IF SOME PRODUCTS W]E 9 %ORT SUPPLY1 H[EV] FREE 

! SOCIETY1 ACCESS TO !M W\LD HAVE TO BE RATION$ BY SOME MEANS4 

,IT C\LD BE BY 'LABOR-VALUE' C>DS1 BY ORD9>Y 'FAIR RATION+'1 IT 

MI<T IMPLY RET5TION ( A DIFF]5T MONET>Y SY/EM 7BUT NOT MONEY AS 

AN 5DS 9 ITSELF1 9 :I* MONEY HAS A VALUE BEYOND ?AT ( 

EX*ANG+ GOODS74 

,WE CANNOT LAY D[N ! ECONOMICS = A ,FREE ,SOCIETY :I* BY ITS 

NATURE IS FREE TO REJECT OR ACCEPT ANY?+ IT FANCIES4 ,! 

AU?ORIT>IAN ECONOMI/ CAN DO SO 70SO LONG AS ,I1 OR MY P>TY1 IS 9 

P[]1 WE WILL DO ?IS OR ?AT074 

,AN AN>*I/ SOCIETY IS BY DEF9ITION A ,FREE ,SOCIETY1 BUT A ,FREE 

,SOCIETY IS NOT NECESS>ILY ,AN>*I/4 ,IT MI<T FALL %ORT 9 SEV]AL 

RESPECTS4 ,SOME FAIL+S MI<T S]I\SLY LIMIT ITS DESIRABILITY4 ,= 

9/ANCE1 A ,REVOLUTION C>RI$ \T BY M5 9 A MALE-DOM9AT$ 

SOCIETY1 MI<T P]PETUATE SEX DISCRIM9ATION1 :I* W\LD LIMIT 

FRE$OM & UND]M9E ! ,REVOLUTION BY LEAV+ IT POSSIBLE = 

AGGRESSIVE ATTITUDES TO BE FO/]$4 ,! LIB]AL ILLUSION ?AT 

REPRESSIVE =CES MU/ BE TOL]AT$ :I* WILL ULTIMATELY WIPE \T 

ALL FRE$OM -- LE/ ! RI<T TO DISS5T BE IMP]IL$ -- C\LD WELL 

DE/ROY ! REVOLUTION4 

,A ,FREE ,SOCIETY HEAD TO RID ITSELF OR REPRESSIVE 9/ITUTIONS & SOME 

MI<T LONG LA/ LONG] ?AN O!RS4 ,! ,*UR* IS ONE 9/ANCE -- YET 

RELIGI\S BELIEFS1 :I* CONT9UE UND] ! MO/ REPRESSIVE & 

BRUTAL DICTATOR%IPS1 C\LD SURELY CONT9UE UND] ,NO ,GOV]NM5T4 ,ONLY 

?OSE CRE$S :I* HAVE NOT HAD !IR CLAWS CUT & DEM& SUPPRESSION 

( O!R RELIGIONS OR UNBELIEF1 =C$ CONV]SIONS OR M>RIAGES1 

C5SOR%IP BY !MSELVES & OB$I5CE TO !IR [N LAWS FROM ?OSE 

NOT WI%+ TO DO SO1 HAVE ANY?+ TO FE> FROM AN ,AN>*I/ 

,REVOLUTION4 

,! ,EMPLOY]S ,DO ,NOT ,GIVE ,WORK 

,IT IS ,PRIMITIVE BASIC SOCIALI/ ?9K+1 TO :I* ,AN>*ISM 

SUBSCRIBES1 ?AT WORK IS NOT SOME?+ ?AT IS GIV5 BY ! EMPLOY]4 

,! EMPLOY] MAY HAVE ! LEGAL RI<T TO DI/RIBUTE WORK1 BUT ! 

WEAL? ( A C\NTRY IS DUE TO ! WORK]S & TO NATURAL RES\RCES1 

NOT TO AN EMPLOY] OR A ,/ATE4 ,!Y HAVE ! *ANCE ( PREV5T+ 

WEAL? BE+ CREAT$4 

,IT IS ! ,AN>*I/ CASE ?AT FLUCTUATIONS ( ! MONEY M>KET1 

9FLATION1 RECESSSION1 UNEMPLOYM5T1 AS WELL AS W>1 >E >TIFICIALLY 

CREAT$ & >E NOT NATURAL DISA/]S LIKE FLOOD1 FAM9E1 E>?QUAKE1 

DR\<T -- & AS ONE KN[S N[ADAYS1 EV5 SOME ( !SE >E CREAT$ 

BY ABUSE ( NATURAL RES\RCES4 

,IT MAY BE ?AT 9 SOME TE*NOLOGICAL SOCIETY ( ! FUTURE1 RUN BY 

! ,/ATE1 9 A SORT ( BOSS UTOPIA1 ! WORK+ CLASS WILL BE 

DISPLAC$ AS A PRODUCTIVE CLASS4 ,WE SEE SIGNS ( ?AT EV5 TODAY AS 

L>GE P>T ( ! ECONOMY >E CLOS$ D[N AS UNPR(ITABLE & PEOPLE 

UPROOT$4 ,!RE IS A TE*NOLOGY1 /ILL 9 ITS 9FANCY BUT MAK+ 

GREAT /RIDES1 :I* WILL R$UCE US1 AS A PRODUCTIVE CLASS1 TO 

TURN]S ( SWIT*ES & OP5]S ( ! SCI5TI/S' DOORS2 TO 

SECRET>IES & RECEPTIONI/S2 TO JANITORS & CL]KS2 TO DOME/IC 

S]VANTS ( ! RI*4 ,AN>*O-SYNDICAL/S ?9K SU* A SOCIETY MU/ 

BE RESI/$4 ,!Y DO NOT WOR%IP WORK AS A FETI% 9 ITSELF BUT FI<T 

DEHUMANIZATION & ALI5ATION4 ,9 ?IS !Y DIFF] FROM SOME O!R 

,AN>*I/S :O ?9K WORK HAS NO PURPOSE & :O BECOME 

/ATE-DEP5D5T BY CONVICTION4 

,OBJECTIONS TO ,AN>*ISM 

,:5EV] ,AN>*I/S ATTACK PRES5T-DAY SOCIETY1 !Y T\* ON ! 

FE>S & PREJUDICES ( AV]AGE PEOPLE :O KN[ ?AT SOCIETY IS A 

JUNGLE TODAY & CANNOT VISUALIZE LIFE )\T ! SAFEGU>DS NE$$ 

9 ! JUNGLE4 ,:5 !Y HE> ( ,AN>*ISM !Y BR+ =W>D 

OBJECTIONS :I* >E1 9 FACT1 CRITICISMS ( ! PRES5T SY/EM !Y 

DO NOT O!RWISE ADMIT BUT ?9K ( AS OBJECTIONS TO A ,FREE ,SOCIETY 

( ! FUTURE4 

,!Y FE> :AT IS KN[N 9 ! ,/ATI/ LANGUAGE AS A 0/ATE ( 

,AN>*Y0 -- !Y ?9K MURD]1 RAPE1 ROBB]Y1 VIOL5T ATTACK W\LD 

5SUE IF !RE W]E NO ,GOV]NM5T TO PREV5T IT4 ,& YET WE ALL KN[ 

?AT ,GOV]NM5T CANNOT1 C]TA9LY DOES NOT41 PREV5T IT4 ,ONE HAS ONLY 

TO PICK UP ! PAP]S TO LE>N ?AT IT FL\RI%ES ?\< ,GOV]NM5T IS 

/RONG1 & ALSO :]E ,GOV]NM5T IS WEAK1 & MORE SO P]HAPS :]E 

!RE >E NUM]\S BODIES COMPET+ AS TO :I* IS ! ,GOV]NM5T & 

,GOV]NM5T IS SAID TO HAVE BROK5 D[N4 0,A /ATE ( ,AN>*Y0 NO:]E 

EXI/S -- 9 ! S5SE !RE A SOCIETY :]E !RE IS NO ,GOV]NM5T 

& NOT JU/ A WEAK OR DIVID$ ,GOV]NM5T4 

,! MO/ A FUNCTION+ ,GOV]NM5T CAN DO IS NOT PREV5TION BUT 

PUNI%M5T -- :5 IT F9DS \T1 SOMETIMES WRONGLY OR NOT AT ALL -- 

:O ! CULPRITS >E1 ITS [N ME?ODS ( REPRESSIVE ACTION CAN CAUSE 

F> MORE DAMAGE ?AN ! ORIG9AL CRIMES -- ! 0CURE0 IS WORSE ?AN 

! DISEASE4 

0,:AT W\LD Y\ DO )\T A POLICE =CE80 ,SOCIETY W\LD NEV] 

TOL]ATE MURD]1 :E!R IT HAD A POLICE =CE OR NOT4 ,! 

9/ITUTIONALIZATION ( A BODY TO LOOK AFT] CRIME MEANS ?AT IT NOT 

ONLY 0LOOKS AFT]0 CRIME & N\RI%ES CRIME1 BUT ?AT ! RE/ ( 

SOCIETY IS ABSOLV$ FROM DO+ SO4 ,! REASON+ IS ?AT A MURD] 

NEXT DOOR IS ! ,/ATE'S BUS9ESS1 NOT M9E6 ,RESPONSIBILITY = ONE'S 

NEI<BOR IS R$UC$ 9 AN AU?ORIT>IAN SOCIETY1 9 :I* ! ,/ATE 

IS SOLELY RESPONSIBLE = \R BEHAVIOR4 

0,:O WILL DO ! DIRTY WORK804 ,?IS IS A QUE/ION SOCIETY1 NOT JU/ 

! APOLOGI/ = ,AN>*ISM1 HAS TO ASK ITSELF4 ,!RE >E DIRTY JOBS 

:I* >E SOCIALLY UNACCEPTABLE & POORLY PAID1 SO ?AT NOBODY WANTS 

TO DO !M4 ,PEOPLE HAVE !RE=E BE5 5SLAV$ TO DO !M1 OR !RE 

IS COMPETITION 9 A M>KET ECONOMY & ! JOBS BECOME BETT] PAID 

7& !RE=E SOCIALLY ACCEPTABLE71 OR !RE IS CONSCRIPTION = 

SU* JOBS1 :E!R BY POLITICAL DIRECTION OR ! PRESSURES ( 

UNEMPLOYM5T4 ,SOMETIMES ! CAPITALI/ 9TRODUCES IMMIGRATION 9 ! 

HOPE ( *EAP LABOR1 ?US PUTT+ (F ! PROBLEM = A G5]ATION 

OR TWO4 ,OR IT CAN BE ?AT JOBS DON'T GET DONE &1 SAY1 ! /REETS 

>5'T SWEPT ANYMORE & SO WE GET DELUG$ ) WAT] %OOT+ \T 

FROM C>S DRIV5 BY GRADUATE PSY*OLOGI/S & /EP G+]LY PA/ 

REFUSE1 CLUT*+ \R !SES ON SOCIOLOGY4 

,:AT ! ,/ATE DOES 9 SU* CIRCUM/ANCES SEEMS TO DEP5D ON 

POLITICAL FACTORS4 ,:AT AN ,AN>*I/ SOCIETY W\LD DO C\LD ONLY BE 

=ETOLD BY A CLAIRVOYANT4 ,IT IS PLA9 :AT IT C\LD NOT DO -- USE 

=CE1 S9CE IT W\LD LACK REPRESSIVE MA*9]Y OR ! MEANS ( 

ECONOMIC CO]CION4 ,! QUE/ION IMPLIES A CRITICISM ( PROSP]ITY & 

FRE$OM1 :I* BR+ PROBLEMS 9 !IR TRA94 ,>E WE TO REJECT 

PROSP]ITY & FRE$OM = ?AT REASON8 

0,IF ! ,AN>*I/S DO NOT SEIZE P[]1 & HAVE SUP]S$$ O!R 

=MS ( SOCIALISM ?AT W\LD1 !Y OBJECTIVELY MAKE WAY = 

FASCISM04 ,?IS ALLEGATION PRESUPPOSES ! DILUTION ( AN>*ISM ) 

PACIFISM1 = !RE IS ALWAYS1 9 ANY CIRCUM/ANCES1 ONE SURE WAY ( 

AVOID+ DICTATOR%IP1 :E!R FROM ! RI<T1 LEFT1 C5T] OR )9 

ONE'S [N RANKS1 & ?AT IS BY P]SONAL REMOVAL ( ! DICTATOR4 ,?IS 

ONLY BECOMES A SYMBOLIC GE/URE :5 ! DICTATOR IS 9 P[] ) ALL 

! MA*9]Y ( COMM&-&-OBEY AT ! DISPOSAL ( ! HEAD ( 

,/ATE4 

,ANYONE WILL SEIZE P[] IF GIV5 ! OPPORTUNITY4 ,AN>*I/S DO NOT 

CLAIM TO BE A PRIVILEG$ ELITE & CANNOT TRU?FULLY ASS]T !Y 

W\LD BE BETT] ABLE TO RESI/ ! TEMPTATIONS ( P[]1 OR TO WIELD 

IT MORE SUCCESSFULLY1 ?AN ANYONE ELSE4 

,LEAD]%IP 

  

,DO ,AN>*I/S BELIEVE 9 LEAD]%IP8 ,!Y ALWAYS D5Y !Y DO1 BUT 

UND\BT$LY MANY ,AN>*I/S HAVE EM]G$ AS LEAD]S1 SOMETIMES EV5 

( >MIES 7LIKE ,BU5AV5TURA ,DURRUTI & ,NE/OR ,MAKHNO7 OR ( IDEAS1 

OR ( ORGANIZATIONS4 ,9 ANY GR\P+ SOME PEOPLE DO NATURALLY 0GIVE A 

LEAD01 BUT ?IS %\LD NOT MEAN !Y >E A CLASS AP>T4 ,:AT !Y 

ALWAYS REJECT IS RESPONSIBILITY = LEAD]%IP4 ,?AT MEANS !IR 

SUPPORT]S BECOME BL9D FOLL[]S & ! LEAD]%IP NOT ONE ( 

EXAMPLE OR ORIG9ALITY BUT ( UN?9K+ ACCEPTANCE4 

,MUSICAL G5IUSES1 >TI/S1 SCI5TI/S CAN BE ( AN 0ELITE0 )\T 

BE+ ELITI/ -- !RE IS NO REASON :Y EXCELL+ 9 C]TA9 SPH]ES 

%\LD MAKE ONE BETT] 5TITL$ TO ! WORLD'S GOODS OR MORE WOR?Y 

( CONSID]ATION 9 MATT]S 9 :I* ONE DOES NOT HAVE SPECIALIZ$ 

CONSID]ATION 7! CORRESPOND5CE BETWE5 ,FREUD & ,E9/E9 9 :I* 

!Y DISCUSS :E!R W> CAN BE PREV5T$ IS A CLASSIC EXAMPLE ( 

FUTILITY -- ,E9/E9 LOOK+ TO ,FREUD = A PSY*OLOGICAL LEAD 9 

PACIFISM & ,FREUD EXPLA9+ IT IS 9 ! NATURE ( ,MAN4 ,9 ! 5D1 

SCI5TI/S :O W]E PACIFI/S1 OR BELIEV]S 9 ! ,LEAGUE ( ,NATIONS 

5?USIA/S1 OR -- LIKE ,E9/E9 -- BO?1 9V5T$ ! ATOM BOMB74 

,9 ! SAME WAY1 PEOPLE CAN WORK 9 AN (FICE )\T BE+ 

BUREAUCRATS3 A BUREAUCRAT IS A P]SON :OSE P[] IS D]IV$ FROM ! 

(FICE !Y HOLD4 ,HOLD+ AN (FICE 9 AN ORGANIZATION CAN BR+ 

SUPREME P[] BY BE+ AT ! HEAD ( A *A9 ( COMM&-&-OBEY 7AS 

IT DID 9 ! CASE ( ,JOSEPH ,/AL974 ,9 SLANG IT IS A T]M FLUNG AT 

ANYONE :O HAPP5S TO BE EFFICI5T1 :I* IS F> FROM BE+ ! SAME 

?+4 

V ,9 ! SAME WAY1 NO REAL ,AN>*I/ --  AS DI/9CT FROM SOMEONE 

PRET5D+ TO BE OR REMA9 ONE -- W\LD AGREE TO BE P>T ( AN 

9/ITUTIONALIZ$ LEAD]%IP4 ,NEI!R W\LD AN ,AN>*I/ WAIT = A 

LEAD1 BUT GIVE ONE4 ,?AT IS ! M>K ( BE+ AN ,AN>*I/1 NOT A 

=MAL DECL>ATION ( BE+ ONE4 ,:AT ABOVE ALL IS ! CURSE ( 

LEAD]%IP IS NOT ! CURSE ( LEAD]%IP1 BUT AGREEM5T TO BE+ L$ 

BL9DLY -- NOT ! FAULTS ( ! %EPH]D BUT ! MEEKNESS ( ! 

%EEP4 ,:AT W\LD ! CRIMES ( ,HITL] HAVE AM\NT$ TO1 HAD HE HAD 

TO C>RY !M \T BY HIMSELF8 

,CAN ,PUBLIC ,OP9ION ,ITSELF BE ,AU?ORIT>IAN8 

,YES4 ,EV5 9 A ,FREE ,SOCIETY8 ,C]TA9LY4 ,BUT ?IS IS NOT AN >GUM5T 

AGA9/ A ,FREE ,SOCIETY1 IT IS A REASON :Y PUBLIC OP9ION %\LD NOT 

BE MOLD$ BY AN \TSIDE =CE4 ,!RE MI<T WELL BE A SOCIETY 

CONTROLL$ ECONOMICALLY BY ! WORK]S :]E PREJUDICE AGA9/ SOME 

M9ORITIES1 OR TRADITIONAL FAMILY ATTITUDES1 OR RULES LAID D[N BY 

RELIGIONS ROOT$ 9 ! PA/1 MI<T /ILL EXI/4 ,! SOCIETY W\LD 

BE FREE 9 ONE RESPECT ONLY -- ECONOMICALLY4 

,BUT )\T ANY MEANS ( CODIFY+ PREJUDICES2 NO REPRESSIVE 

MA*9]Y AGA9/ NONCON=MI/S2 ABOVE ALL1 NO MEANS ( REPRESSION 

BY P]SUASION :5 ! M$IA IS CONTROLL$ FROM ABOVE2 PUBLIC OP9ION 

CAN BECOME SUP]IOR TO ITS PREJUDICES4 ,! MAJORITY IS NOT 

AUTOMATICALLY RI<T4 ,! MANIPULATION ( ! IDEA ( A MAJORITY IS 

P>T ( ! ,GOV]NM5T TE*NIQUE4 

,UNITY 

,ONE LA/ OBJECTION IS MADE AGA9/ ,AN>*ISM1 USUALLY BY ?OSE AB\T 

TO 0COME OV]0 -- ,:Y DISUNITY 9 ! RANKS ( ?OSE :O TAKE UP A 

SIMIL> POSITION ON MANY /&S8 ,:Y CANNOT WE BE ALL ONE LIB]T>IAN 

LEFT8 ,:Y ANY DIVISIONS AT ALL8 

,IF WE CREATE C\NCILS ( ACTION -- WORK]S' 9DU/RIAL PROTO-UNIONS 

-- AS WE 9T5D TO DO GIV5 ! *ANCE & AGREEM5T ( WORK]S1 EV5 

IF AS A FIR/ /EP WE =M SOCIAL GR\PS BAS$ UPON 9DU/RIAL 

ACTIVITY OR SUPPORT1 OBVI\SLY WE >E GO+ TO BE UNIT$ TO O!RS 

NOT ONLY ( ! LIB]T>IAN LEFT1 OR 9DE$ 79 ! CASE ( WORK]S' 

C\NCILS7 ) PEOPLE ( RE=MI/1 REACTION>Y1 OR AU?ORIT>IAN 

PO9TS ( VIEW4 ,WE MIX ) !M 9 EV]YDAY LIFE ANYWAY4 ,! 

EXPRESSION ( ,AN>*I/ VIEWS & ATTITUDES DOES NOT MAKE US H]MITS4 

,AN>*I/ GR\PS NE$ TO KEEP ALIVE !IR ID5TITY1 BUT ONLY A P>TY 

MA*9E W\LD MAKE !M 9TO WALLS AGA9/ MEET+ O!RS \TSIDE4 

,IT IS C]TA9LY ! CURSE ( ! PRES5T DAY ?AT PSEUDO-,AN>*I/S1 

:E!R LIB]AL OR 0LIFE/YLI/01 CREATE !IR [N 0<ETTOS0 )9 A 

0LEFT01 :I* HAS BECOME ITSELF A <ETTO1 9 :I* ACCEPTANCE ( A 

PACKAGE DEAL ( IDEAS IS OBLIGATORY4 ,?IS 5DEMIC ISOLATION1 9 ! 

NAME ( Y\?1 SEX1 RACE1 NATIONALITY1 ALT]NATIVE CULTURE1 OR 

:ATEV]1 HAS NO?+ TO DO ) ,AN>*ISM ?\< IT HAS BE5 WI%$ 

ON IT BY J\RNALI/IC PROPAG&A PRESSURE4 

,! ,M>XI/ ,CRITICISM ( ,AN>*ISM 

,! ,M>XI/ CRITICISM ( ,AN>*ISM IS ! FIR/ ) :I* MO/ 

PEOPLE ) A S]I\S 9T]E/ 9 POLITICS COME 9 CONTACT4 ,!RE 

FOLL[S FROM IT ! ,M>XI/-,L59I/ CRITIQUE & ! 

,SOCIAL-,DEMOCRATIC OBJECTIONS4 

V,M>XI/-,L59I/S1 FAC$ ) ,AN>*ISM1 F9D ?AT BY ITS NATURE IT 

UND]M9ES ALL ! SUPPOSITIONS BASIC TO ,M>XISM4 ,M>XISM WAS HELD 

\T TO BE ! BASIC WORK+-CLASS PHILOSOPHY 7A BELIEF :I* HAS 

UTT]LY RU9$ ! WORK+-CLASS MOVEM5T EV]Y:]E74 ,IT HOLDS 9 

!ORY ?AT ! 9DU/RIAL PROLET>IAT CANNOT [E ITS EMANCIPATION TO 

ANYONE BUT !MSELVES ALONE1 ,IT IS H>D TO GO BACK ON ?AT & SAY 

?AT ! WORK+ CLASS IS NOT YET READY TO DISP5SE ) AU?ORITY 

PLAC$ OV] IT BY SOMEONE \TSIDE ! CLASS4 

,M>XISM NORMALLY TRIES TO REFRA9 FROM CRITICIZ+ ,AN>*ISM AS SU* 

-- UNLESS DRIV5 TO DO+ SO1 :5 IT EXPOSES ITS [N 

AU?ORIT>IANISM 7 0H[ CAN ! WORK]S RUN ! RAILWAYS1 = 

9/ANCE1 )\T DIRECTION -- ?AT IS TO SAY1 )\T AU?ORITY807 

& CONC5TRATES ITS ATTACK NOT ON ,AN>*ISM1 BUT ON ,AN>*I/S4 ,?IS 

IS BAS$ ON A D\BLE /&>D3 ,AN>*I/S >E HELD RESPONSIBLE = ! 

?\<T & ACTIONS ( ALL P]SONS1 LIVE OR DEAD1 CALL+ !MSELVES 

,AN>*I/S1 EV5 ONLY TEMPOR>ILY1 OR P]SONS REF]R$ TO AS 

,AN>*I/S BY O!RS1 EV5 IF !Y DISAGREE1 OR :OSE ACTIONS C\LD 

BE HELD TO BE ,AN>*I/IC BY NON-,AN>*I/S4 EV5 ON A FAULTY 

PREMISE1 OR >E REF]R$ TO BY O!RS AS ,AN>*I/S4 ,M>XI/S TAKE 

RESPONSIBILITY = ,M>XI/S HOLD+ !IR P>TICUL> P>TY C>D AT 

! TIME4 

,M>XISM HAS -- :E!R ONE AGREES ) IT OR NOT -- A VALID CRITICISM 

( ! ,AN>*I/S 9 ASK+ H[ ONE CAN 7N[7 DISP5SE ) POLITICAL 

ACTION -- OR :E!R ONE %\LD ?R[ AWAY SO VITAL A WEAPON4 ,BUT 

?IS CRITICISM V>IES BETWE5 ! S*OOLS ( ,M>XISM1 S9CE SOME HAVE 

US$ IT TO JU/IFY COMPLETE P>TICIPATION 9 ! :OLE CAPITALI/ 

P[] /RUCTURE1 :ILE O!RS TALK VAGUELY ONLY ( 0US+ ,P>LIAM5T 

AS A PLAT=M04 ,L59 RECOGNIZ$ ! %ORTCOM+S ( ,M>XISM 9 ?IS 

RESPECT & 9SI/$ ?AT ! AN>*I/ WORK]S C\LD NOT BE 

CRITICIZ$ = REJECT+ SO ,PHILI/9E A ,M>XISM ?AT IT US$ 

POLITICAL P>TICIPATION = ITS [N SAKE & EXPECT$ ! CAPITALI/ 

/ATE TO LET ITSELF BE VOT$ \T ( EXI/5CE PEACEFULLY4 ,HE 

!RE=E CONC5TRAT$ ON ANO!R ASPECT1 :I* ,M>X PIONE]$1 VIZ4 

CRITICISM ( P>TICUL> ,AN>*I/S1 & ?IS HAS DOM9AT$ ALL 

,L59I/ ?9K+ EV] S9CE4 

,BECAUSE ( ! LACK ( ANY O!R CRITICISM ( ! ,AN>*I/S1 

,L59I/S -- ESPECIALLY ,TROTSKYI/S -- TO ?IS DAY USE ! P]SONAL 

CRITICISM ME?OD4 ,BUT AS ,L59 SELECT$ ONLY A FEW WELL-KN[N 

P]SONALITIES :O = A FEW YE>S FELL %ORT ( ! IDEAS !Y 

PREA*$1 ! LATT]-DAY ,L59I/S HAVE TO HOLD ?AT ALL ,AN>*I/S 

>E RESPONSIBLE = EV]YONE :O CALLS HIMSELF OR H]SELF AN 

,AN>*I/ -- OR EV51 SU* AS ! ,RUSSIAN ,SOCIALI/-,REVOLUTION>IES 

9 ,RUSSIA1 W]E ONLY CALL$ SU* 7IF 9DE$ SO7 BY O!RS4 

,?IS WR9KLE 9 ,L59ISM HAS PRODUC$ ANO!R CRITICISM ( ,AN>*ISM 

7USUALLY CONF9$ TO ,TROTS & ,MAOI/S72 ,AN>*I/S >E RESPONSIBLE 

NOT ONLY = ALL REF]R$ TO AS ,AN>*I/S1 BUT = ALL WORK]S 

9FLU5C$ BY ,AN>*I/ IDEAS4 ,! ,C4,N4,T4 IS ALWAYS QUOT$ H]E1 BUT 

SIGNIFICANTLY ITS :OLE HI/ORY BE=E & AFT] ! CIVIL W> IS 

NEV] M5TION$1 SOLELY ! P]IOD ( P>TICIPATION 9 ! 

,GOV]NM5T4 ,= ?IS1 ! ,AN>*I/S MU/ = EV] ACCEPT 

RESPONSIBILITY6 ,BUT ! ,TROTS MAY BACK ! RE=MI/ UNION ,U4,G4,T4 

)\T ACCEPT+ ANY P]IOD 9 ITS 5TIRE HI/ORY4 ,9 ALL C\NTRIES 

7IF WORK]S71 !Y PRESUMABLY JO9 OR 7IF /UD5TS7 ACCEPT ! 

RE=MI/ TRADE UNIONS4 ,?AT IS ALL RI<T4 ,BUT A REVOLUTION>Y TRADE 

UNION MU/ = EV] BE CONDEMN$ = ANY ONE DEVIATION4 ,MOREOV]1 IF 

BROK5 IT MU/ NEV] BE REBUILT2 ! RE=MI/ UNION MU/ BE REBUILT 

9 PREF]5CE4 ,?IS IS ! LOGICAL CONSEQU5CE ( ALL ,TROT ?9K+ 

ON ,SPA9 OR O!R C\NTRIES :]E SU* UNIONS EXI/1 PROV+ !IR 

PREF]5CE = RE=MI/ UNIONS' NEGATIVE *>ACT]1 :I* L5DS 

ITSELF TO A LEAD]%IP !Y MAY CAPTURE2 AS AGA9/ A DEC5TRALIZ$ 

UNION :I* A LEAD]%IP CANNOT CAPTURE4 

,PETTY ,B\RGEOIS 

,NOT)/&+ ?IS PREF]5CE = NON-REVOLUTION>Y UNIONS1 & 

CONDEMNATION ( ,AN>*I/S = UNIONS BUILT FROM ! BOTTOM UP1 ALL 

,M>XI/-,L59I/S HAVE A SEEM+LY CONTRADICTORY CRITICISM ( 

,AN>*I/S1 NAMELY 0!Y >E PETTY B\RGEOIS04 

,?IS LEADS !M 9TO ANO!R DIFFICULTY -- H[ CAN ONE RECONCILE ! 

EXI/5CE ( AN>*O-SYNDICALI/ UNIONS ) 0PETTY-B\RGEOIS0 

ORIG9S -- & H[ DOES ONE GET OV] ! FACT ?AT MO/ 

,M>XI/-,L59I/S ( TODAY >E PR(ESSIONAL LADIES & G5TLEM5 

/UDY+ = OR BELONG+ TO ! CONS]VATIVE PR(ESSIONS8 ,! ANSW] 

IS USUALLY GIV5 ?AT BECAUSE AN>*ISM IS 0PETTY B\RGEOIS0 ?OSE 

EMBRAC+ IT 0:ATEV] !IR OCCUPATION OR SOCIAL ORIG9S0 MU/ ALSO 

BE 0PETTY B\RGEOIS02 & BECAUSE ,M>XISM IS WORK+ CLASS1 ITS 

ADH]5TS MU/ BE WORK+ CLASS 0AT LEA/ SUBJECTIVELY04 ,?IS IS A 

SOCIOLOGICAL ABSURDITY1 AS IF 0WORK+ CLASS0 MEANT AN IDEOLOGICAL 

VIEWPO9T4 ,IT IS ALSO A BUILT-9 ESCAPE CLAUSE4 

,YET ,M>X WAS NOT SU* A FOOL AS HIS FOLL[]S4 0,PETTY B\RGEOIS0 9 

HIS DAY DID NOT MEAN A SOLICITOR OR AN ACC\NTANT1 A FACTORY MANAG]1 

SOCIOLOGI/ 1OR ANY?+ ( ?AT SORT 7!Y W]E 0B\RGEOIS0 -- ! 

T]M WAS 0PETIT0  OR SMALL NOT 0PETTY0 ?AT QUALIFI$ ! ADJECTIVE 

-- & MEANT PRECISELY ?AT !SE W]E NOT ! SAME AS B\RGEOISIE74 

,! SMALL BUR<] WAS ONE :O HAD LESS PRIVILEGES1 ECONOMICALLY1 ?AN 

! WEAL?Y BUT HAD SOME PRIVILEGES BY VIRTUE ( HIS CRAFT4 ,AN>*ISM1 

SAID ,M>X1 WAS ! MOVEM5T ( ! >TISAN WORK] -- ?AT IS TO SAY1 

! SELF-EMPLOY$ CRAFTSMAN ) SOME LEISURE TO ?9K & TALK1 NOT 

SUBJECT TO FACTORY H\RS & DISCIPL9E1 9DEP5D5TLY-M9D$ & 

DIFFICULT TO ?REAT51 NOT BACKW>D LIKE ! PEASANTRY4 ,9 ,5GL&1 

!SE PEOPLE T5D$ TO BECOME ,RADICALS1 P]HAPS BECAUSE ! ,/ATE WAS 

LESS OPPRESSIVE & LESS OBVI\SLY UNNECESS>Y4 ,9 MANY C\NTRIES1 

H[EV]1 !Y W]E MU* MORE EXTREME 9 !IR ,RADICALISM & 9 ! 

,SWISS ,JURA ! CLOCKMAK]S' ,AN>*ISM PROSP]$4 ,IT SPREAD TO ,P>IS 

-- & ! ,P>IS ,COMMUNE WAS1 ABOVE ALL1 A RIS+ ( ! >TISANS :O 

HAD BE5 R$UC$ TO P5URY BY ,NAPOLEON ,I,I,I & HIS W>4 ,AS ! 

CAPITALI/ TE*NIQUE SPREAD ?R\<\T ! WORLD1 ! >TISANS W]E 

RU9$ & DRIV5 9TO ! FACTORIES4 ,IT IS !SE 9DIVIDUAL 

CRAFTSM5 5T]+ 9DU/RIALIZATION :O BECAME ,AN>*I/S1 PO9T$ 

\T SUCCESSIVE ,M>XI/S4 ,!Y >E NOT CONDITION$ TO FACTORY 

DISCIPL9E :I* PRODUCES GOOD ORD]1 UNLIKE A PROLET>IAT PREP>$ 

TO ACCEPT A LEAD]%IP & A P>TY1 & TO WORK = EV] 9 ! 

FACTORY PROVID$ IT COMES UND] ,/ATE CONTROL4 

,?AT ?IS OBS]VATION WAS TRUE IS SE5 BY ! CRU%+ ( ! COMMUNE 

9 ,P>IS & 9 ,SPA9 & ?R\<\T ! WORLD1 ESPECIALLY 9 PLACES 

LIKE ,ITALY1 ,BULG>IA1 9 ! ,JEWI% PALE ( SETTLEM5T 9 ,RUSSIA1 & 

SO ON4 ,IT %\LD BE ! TASK ( AN ,AN>*I/ UNION MOVEM5T TO SEIZE 

! FACTORIES1 BUT ONLY 9 ORD] TO BREAK D[N MASS PRODUCTION & 

GET BACK TO CRAFTSMAN%IP4 ,?IS IS :AT ,M>X MEANT BY A 0PETIT 

B\RGEOIS0 \TLOOK & ! T]M HAV+ *ANG$ ITS MEAN+ TOTALLY1 

! ,M>XI/S -- LIKE BELIEV]S ACCEPT+ ,HOLY ,WRIT --MISUND]/OOD 

HIM TOTALLY4 

,VANGU>DS 

,! RELUCTANCE ( ,M>XI/-,L59I/S TO ACCEPT *ANGE IS1 H[EV]1 

ABOVE ALL SE5 9 ! ACCEPTANCE ( ,L59'S CONCEPTION ( ! ,P>TY4 

7,IT IS NOT ?AT ( ,M>X47 ,L59 SAW ?AT ,RUSSIA WAS A HUGE MASS ( 

9]TIA1 ) A PEASANTRY ?AT W\LD NOT BUDGE BUT TOOK ALL ITS 

SUFF]+ ) 0,ASIATIC0 PATI5CE4 ,HE LOOK$ TO ! 0PROLET>IAT0 TO 

PU% IT4 ,BUT ! 0PROLET>IAT0 WAS ONLY A SMALL P>T ( ! ,RUSSIA ( 

HIS DAY4 ,/ILL HE RECOGNIZ$ IT AS ! ONE CLASS ) AN 9T]E/ 9 

PROGRESS -- PROVID$1 HE FELT1 IT WAS L$ BY %REWD1 CALCULAT+1 

RU?LESS1 & HI<LY-$UCAT$ PEOPLE 7:O C\LD ONLY COME FROM ! 

UPP] CLASSES 9 ! ,RUSSIA ( ! TIME74 ,! P>TY !Y CREAT$ 

%\LD BECOME1 AS MU* AS POSSIBLE1 ! P>TY ( ! PROLET>IAT 9 

:I* ?AT CLASS C\LD ORGANIZE & SEIZE P[]4 ,IT HAD !N ! 

RI<T & ! DUTY TO WIPE \T ALL O!R P>TIES4 

,! IDIOCY ( APPLY+ ?IS TODAY 91 SAY1 A C\NTRY LIKE ,BRITA9 IS 

9CR$IBLE4 ,ONE HAS ONLY TO LOOK AT ! P>TIES :I* (F] 

!MSELVES AS ! V>I\S P>TIES ( ! PROLET>IAT ( :I*1 

9CID5TALLY1 !RE C\LD BE ONLY ONE4 ,COMP>E !M ) ! PEOPLE 

>\ND4 ,! P>TIES' MEMB]%IPS >E F> BEH9D 9 POLITICAL 

9TELLIG5CE & UND]/&+4 ,!Y >E L>GELY COMPOS$ ( %ALL[ 

& 9EXP]I5C$ 5?USIA/S :O UND]/& F> LESS AB\T CLASS 

/RUGGLE ?AN ! AV]AGE WORK]4 

,HAV+ TRANSLAT$ ! ,RUSSIAN ,REVOLUTION 9TO A MY?OLOGY :I* 

PLACES GREAT /RESS ON ! QUALITIES POSSESS$ BY ITS LEAD]%IP1 

!Y !N PRET5D TO POSSESS ?AT LEAD]%IP *>ISMA4 ,BUT AS !Y 

DON'T HAVE IT1 !RE IS A TOTAL DIVORCE BETWE5 ! WORK+ CLASS & 

! SO-CALL$ ,NEW ,LEFT :I* HAS1 !RE=E1 TO COV] ITSELF UP ) 

LONG-W9D$ PHRASES 9 ! HOPE ?AT ?IS WILL PASS = LE>N+4 ,9 

! WID] 0,MOVEM5T0 ) ! DEF9ITIONS AT SECOND H& FROM 

,M>XI/-,L59ISM1 !Y SCRAT* >\ND TO F9D SOMEONE REALLY AS 

BACKW>D & DISPOSSESS$ AS ! M\JIK1 & FALL BACK ON ! 0,?IRD 

,WORLD0 MY?OLOGY4 

,! ONE CRITICISM1 APPLI$ BY ,M>XI/-,L59I/S1 ( ,AN>*ISM ) 

ANY S]I\S CLAIM TO BE CONSID]$ IS1 !RE=E1 SOLELY ?AT ( 

:E!R POLITICAL ACTION %\LD BE CONSID]$ OR NOT4 ,:5EV] IT HAS 

BE5 UND]TAK5 \TSIDE ! CLASS IT HAS PROV$ ( B5EFIT ONLY TO 

LEAD]S FROM \TSIDE ! CLASS4 

,! ,SOCIAL-,DEMOCRATIC ,CRITIQUE 

( ,AN>*ISM 

,! E>LY ,SOCIALI/S DID NOT UND]/& ?AT !RE W\LD BE 

NECESS>ILY A DIFF]5CE BETWE5 ,AN>*ISM & ,SOCIALISM4 ,BO? W]E 

SOCIALI/1 BUT :]EAS ! LATT] HOP$ TO A*IEVE SOCIALISM BY 

,P>LIAM5T>Y MEANS1 ! LATT] FELT ?AT REVOLUTION>Y MEANS W]E 

NECESS>Y4 ,AS A RESULT MANY E>LY ,AN>*I/ & SOCIALI/ GR\PS 

7ESPECIALLY 9 ,BRITA97 W]E 9T]*ANGEABLE 9 WORK+-CLASS 

MEMB]%IP4 ,SOME?+ MI<T COME FROM POLITICAL ACTION2 SOME?+ BY 

9DU/RIAL ME?ODS2 ! ,REVOLUTION HAD TO BE F\<T AS SOON AS 

POSSIBLE2 ! ONE !RE=E WAS COMPLEM5T>Y TO ! O!R ?\< IT 

WAS RECOGNIZ$ ?AT !Y MI<T HAVE TO FOLL[ SEP>ATE PA?S4 ,AT 

LEA/4 SO IT WAS ?\<T4 

,?IS1 H[EV]1 *ANG$ BECAUSE ! FACE ( SOCIALISM *ANG$4 ,IT 

DROPP$ ITS LIB]T>IAN IDEAS = ,/ATISM4 0,SOCIALISM0 GRADUALLY CAME 

TO MEAN ,/ATE ,CONTROL ( EV]Y?+ &1 !RE=E1 SO F> FROM BE+ 

ANO!R FACE ( ,AN>*ISM1 WAS ITS DIRECT OPPOSITE4 ,FROM SAY+ 

ORIG9ALLY ?AT 0! ,AN>*I/S W]E TOO IMPATI5T01 !RE=E1 ! 

P>LIAM5T>Y ,SOCIALI/S TURN$ TO A CRITICISM ( ! ,AN>*I/S 

LEVEL$ AT !M BY PEOPLE :O HAD NO DESIRE TO *ANGE SOCIETY AT ALL1 

:E!R SOON] OR LAT]4 ,!Y PICK$ UP :AT IS ESS5TIALLY ! 

CONS]VATIVE CRITICISM ( ,AN>*ISM :I* IS ESS5TIALLY ?AT ! 

,/ATE IS ! >BIT] ( ALL LEGALITY & ! PRES5T ECONOMIC ORD] 

IS ! ONLY E/ABLI%$ LEGAL ORD]4 ,A ,/ATELESS SOCIETY -- OR EV5 

ITS ADVOCACY -- IS ?US REG>D$ AS CRIM9AL 9 ITSELF6 ,IT IS NOT1 AS 

A LAW1 BUT TO ?IS DAY A POLICE CON/ABLE 9 C\RT -- OR A J\RNALI/ 

-- WILL = ?IS REASON REF] TO ,AN>*ISM AS IF IT W]E 

SELF-EVID5TLY CRIM9AL4 

,MO/ UPHOLD]S ( ANY P>LIAM5T>Y SY/EM DELIB]ATELY CONFUSE 

P>LIAM5T>ISM ) DEMOCRACY AS AN IDEAL SY/EM ( EQUAL 

REPRES5TATION1 AS IF IT ALREADY EXI/$4 ,?US ULTRA-P>LIAM5T>ISM 

IS 0UNDEMOCRATIC1 SUGGE/+ ?AT A FEW HUNDR$ M5 & A FEW DOZ5 

WOM5 SELECT$ AT R&OM & ALONE HAD ! RI<T ( EX]CIS+ 

CONTROL OV] ! RE/ ( ! C\NTRY4 

,S9CE ! ,RUSSIANIZATION ( 0,COMMUNISM01 TURN+ AWAY FROM BO? 

P>LIAM5T>ISM & DEMOCRACY1 IT HAS SUIT$ ! ,SOCIAL-,DEMOCRAT TO 

SPEAK ( CRITICISM FROM ! REVOLUTION>Y SIDE AS BE+ NECESS>ILY 

FROM ?OSE WANT+ DICTATOR%IP4 ,! ,AN>*I/S1 :O CAN H>DLY BE 

ACCUS$ ( DICTATOR%IP -- EXCEPT BY POLITICALLY ILLIT]ATE 

J\RNALI/S :O DO NOT UND]/& ! DIFF]5CES BETWE5 P>TIES -- 

MU/ !RE=E BE 0CRIM9AL0 & :OLE LABOR MOVEM5TS HAVE BE5 SO 

/IGMATIZ$ BY ! ,SECOND ,9T]NATIONAL4 ,?IS WAS PICK$ UP BY ! 

,U4,S4 ,GOV]NM5T ) ITS 0CRIM9AL-SYNDICALISM0 LEGISLATION :I* WAS 

SIMIL> TO ?AT 9 MORE OP5LY FASCI/ C\NTRIES4 

,NO MORE ?AN ! ,M>XI/-,L59I/S1 ! ,SOCIAL-,DEMOCRATS 79 ! 

S5SE ( OR?ODOX ,LABORITES7 >E UNABLE TO /ATE ?AT !IR REAL 

OBJECTION TO ,AN>*ISM IS ?AT FACT ?AT IT IS AGA9/ P[] & 

PRIVILEGE & SO UND]M9ES !IR :OLE CASE4 ,!Y BR+ UP1 IF 

*ALL5G$1 ! OBJECTION ?AT IT IS 0IMPOSSIBLE04 ,IF 0IMPOSSIBLE01 

:AT HAVE !Y TO FE> FROM IT8 ,:Y1 9 C\NTRIES LIKE ,SPA9 & 

,PORTUGAL1 :]E ! ONLY *ANCE ( RESI/+ TYRANNY WAS ! 

,AN>*I/ ,MOVEM5T1 DID ,SOCIAL-,DEMOCRATS PREF] TO HELP ! ,COMMUNI/ 

,P>TY8 ,9 ,SPA91 UP TO ! APPE>ANCE ( ! ,SOCIALI/ ,P>TY :5 IT 

WAS POLITICALLY PR(ITABLE TO SWIT*1 ! ,BRITI% ,LABOR ,P>TY HELP$ 

! ,COMMUNI/-L$ FACTIONS BUT DID NO?+ = ! ,AN>*I/ 

RESI/ANCE4 

,DICTATOR%IP ( ! PROLET>IAT IS 0POSSIBLE01 ONLY TOO MU* SO4 ,:5 

IT COMES IT WILL SWEEP ! SOCIALI/S AWAY4 ,BUT IF ! ,AN>*I/S 

RESI/1 ! ,SOCIALI/S WILL AT LEA/ SURVIVE TO PUT =W>D !IR 

ALT]NATIVE4 ,!Y FE> ONLY ! CONSEQU5CES ( ?AT ALT]NATIVE 

BE+ DECISIVELY REJECT$ -- = :O W\LD *OOSE ,/ATE ,SOCIALISM \T 

( ! A%CAN = NO?+ IF !Y C\LD HAVE ,/ATELESS ,SOCIALISM 

9/EAD8 

,9 ! CAPITALI/ WORLD1 ! ,SOCIAL ,DEMOCRAT OBJECTS TO REVOLUTION>Y 

ME?ODS1 ! 0IMPATI5T0 & ALLEG$ 0CRIM9ALITY0 ( ! ,AN>*I/S4 

,BUT 9 ! ,COMMUNI/ WORLD1 SOCIAL-DEMOCRACY WAS BY ! SAME 

CONS]VATIVE TOK5 EQUALLY 0CRIM9AL0 79DE$ MORE SO7 S9CE IT 

PRESUMABLY PO/ULAT$ CONNECTION ) 5EMY P[]S1 AS IS N[ PROV$4 

,! *>GE ( 0IMPATI5CE0 C\LD H>DLY BE LEVEL$ :5 !RE WAS NO 

WAY ( EFFECT+ A *ANGE LEGALLY & ! :OLE IDEA ( *ANGE BY 

P>LIAM5T>Y ME?ODS WAS A DREAM4 ,SOCIAL-DEMOCRACY1 9 ! S5SE ( 

,LABORISM1 GIVES UP ! FI<T )\T HOPE :5 TYRANNY TRIUMPHS 

7UNLESS IT CAN CALL ON =EIGN 9T]V5TION1 AS 9 OCCUPI$ W>-TIME 

,EUROPE74 ,IT HAS NO?+ TO (F]4 ,!RE IS NO /RUGGLE AGA9/ 

FASCISM OR ,L59ISM FROM SOCIAL-DEMOCRACY BECAUSE NO CON/ITUTIONAL 

ME?ODS (F] !MSELVES4 ,9 ! =M] ,SOVIET ,UNION & ITS 

SATELLITES1 !Y HAD NO IDEAS ON H[ TO *ANGE & HOP$ ?AT 

NATIONALI/S & RELIGI\S DISSID5TS W\LD PUT ?R\< A BIT ( 

LIB]ALISM TO EASE ! PRESSURE4 ,WE KN[ N[ H[ DISA/R\S ?AT 

POLICY HAS BE54 ,YET AN>*ISM (F]S A REVOLUTION>Y ATTACK UPON ! 

COMMUNI/ C\NTRIES ?AT IS NOT ONLY REJECT$ BY ! ,SOCIAL-,DEMOCRATS2 

P[]FUL1 !Y UNITE ) O!R CAPITALI/ P[]S TO H>ASS & 

SUPPRESS ?AT ATTACK4 

,! ,LIB]AL-,DEMOCRATIC ,OBJECTION 

TO ,AN>*ISM 

,LIB]AL-,DEMOCRACY1 OR NON-FASCI/ CONS]VATISM1 IS AFRAID TO MAKE 

DIRECT CRITICISMS ( ,AN>*ISM BECAUSE TO DO SO UND]M9ES ! :OLE 

REASON+ ( ,LIB]AL-,DEMOCRACY4 ,IT !RE=E RESORTS TO 

FALSIFICATION3 ,AN>*I/S >E EQUAT$ ) ,M>XI/S 7& !REBY ! 

:OLE ,M>XI/ CRITICISM ( AN>*ISM IGNOR$74 ,! MO/ FREQU5T 

T>GET ( ATTACK IS TO SUGGE/ ?AT ,AN>*ISM IS SOME =M ( ,M>XISM 

PLUS VIOL5CE1 OR SOME EXTREME =M ( ,M>XISM4 

,! REASON ,LIB]AL-,DEMOCRACY HAS NO DEF5SE TO (F] AGA9/ REAL 

,AN>*I/ >GUM5T IS BECAUSE ,LIB]AL-,DEMOCRACY IS US+ IT AS ITS 

APOLOGIA1 9 ! DEF5SE ( 0FRE$OM01 YET PLAC+ CIRCUMSCRIB+ 

WALLS >\ND IT4 ,IT PRET5DS ?AT P>LIAM5T>ISM IS SOME =M ( 

DEMOCRACY1 BUT ?\< SOMETIMES PREP>$ TO ADMIT 7UND] PRESSURE7 

?AT P>LIAM5T>ISM IS NO =M ( DEMOCRACY AT ALL1 OCCASIONALLY 

SEEKS TO F9D WAYS ( FUR!R DEMOCRATIZ+ IT4 ,! UND\BT$LY 

DICTATORIAL PROCESS ?AT A FEW PEOPLE1 ONCE ELECT$ BY FAIR MEANS OR 

F\L1 HAVE A RI<T TO MAKE DECISIONS = A MAJORITY1 IS COV]$ UP BY 

A DEF5SE ( ! CON/ITUTIONAL RI<TS OR EV5 ! 9DIVIDUAL LIB]TY 

( MEMB]S ( ,P>LIAM5T ONLY4 ,BURKE'S DICTUM ?AT !Y >E 

REPRES5TATIVES1 NOT DELEGATES1 IS QUOT$ AD NAUSEAM 7AS IF ?IS 

REACTION>Y POLITICIAN HAD B\ND ! ,BRITI% PEOPLE = EV]1 ?\< 

HE AS HIMSELF ADMITT$1 DID NOT SEEK TO ASK !IR OP9IONS ( ! 

MATT] ONCE74 

,LIB]AL ECONOMICS >E ALMO/ AS DEAD AS ! DODO4 ,:AT RULES IS 

EI!R ! MONOPOLY ( ! BIG FIRMS1 OR ( ! ,/ATE4 ,YET 

LAISSEZ-FAIRE ECONOMICS REMA9 EMBODI$ ASPIRATIONS ( ! ,TORY ,P>TY 

:I* !Y NEV] IMPLEM5T4 ,!Y OBJECT TO ! 9T]V5TION ( ! 

,/ATE 9 BUS9ESS1 BUT !Y NEV] C>E TO C>RY ! SPIRIT ( 

COMPETITION TOO F>4 ,!RE IS NO LOGICAL REASON :Y !RE %\LD BE 

ANY RE/RICTION ON ! MOVEM5T ( CURR5CY -- & ?IS IS GOOD ,TORY 

POLICY 7?\< NEV] IMPLEM5T$6 ,NOT UNTIL ! CRISIS1 ANY CRISIS1 

IS OV]674 ,FROM ?IS PO9T ( VIEW1 :Y %\LD WE NOT BE ABLE TO DEAL 

9 GOLD PIECES OR ,U4,S4 DOLL>S1 OR ,M>IA ,!RESA TALES1 OR ,FRANCS1 OR 

,DEUTS*M>KS1 OR EV5 DEVALU$ ,DEUTS*M>KS8 ,! P\ND /]L+ 

W\LD SOON F9D ITS [N LEVEL1 & IF IT W]E DEVALU$1 SO MU* ! 

WORSE = IT4 ,BUT :Y /OP !RE8 ,IF WE CAN *OOSE ANY CURR5CY WE 

LIKE1 FREE SOCIALISM C\LD COEXI/ ) CAPITALISM & IT W\LD DRIVE 

CAPITALISM \T4 

,ONCE FREE SOCIALISM COMPETES ) CAPITALISM -- AS IT W\LD IF WE 

W\LD *OOSE TO IGNORE ! ,/ATE'S SYMBOLIC MONEY & DEAL 9 ONE ( 

\R [N *OOS+1 :I* REFLECT$ REAL WORK VALUES -- :O W\LD 

*OOSE TO BE EXPLOIT$8 ,QUITE CLE>LY NO LAISSEZ-FAIRE ECONOMI/ :O 

HAD TO COMB9E HIS ROLE ) ?AT ( P>TY POLITICIAN W\LD ALL[ 

?+S TO GO ?AT F>4 

,LIB]AL-,DEMOCRACY PICKS UP ONE ( ! NORMAL >GUM5TS AGA9/ 

,AN>*ISM :I* BEG9 ON ! RI<T W+3 NAMELY1 IT BEG9S ) ! 

OBJECTIONS AGA9/ SOCIALISM -- ?AT IS ,/ATISM -- BUT IF !RE IS AN 

ANTI-,/ATI/ SOCIALISM ?AT IS 9 FACT MORE LIB]AL ?AN ITSELF1 !N 

IT IS 0CRIM9AL04 ,IF IT IS NOT1 !N IT SEEKS LAW TO MAKE IT SO4 

,?IS >GUM5T IS 9 FACT B5EA? CONTEMPT1 YET IT IS ONE ?AT 

9FLU5CES ! PRESS1 POLICE1 & JUDICI>Y TO A SURPRIS+ EXT5T4 

,9 FACT ,AN>*ISM AS SU* 7AS DI/9CT FROM SPECIFIC ,AN>*I/ 

ORGANIZATIONS7 C\LD NEV] BE ILLEGAL1 BECAUSE NO LAWS CAN MAKE 

PEOPLE LOVE ! ,/ATE4 ,IT IS ONLY DONE BY FALSE IDEALS SU* AS 

DESCRIB+ ! ,/ATE AS 0C\NTRY04 

,! FACT IS ?AT ,LIB]AL-,DEMOCRACY SELDOM VOICES ANY >GUM5TS 

AGA9/ ,AN>*ISM AS SU* -- O!R ?AN RELY+ ON PREJUDICE -- 

BECAUSE ITS OBJECTIONS >E PURELY AU?ORIT>IAN & UNMASK ! 9NATE 

,/ATISM & AU?ORIT>IANISM ( LIB]ALISM4 ,N[ADAYS CONS]VATIVES 

LIKE TO APPROPRIATE ! NAME 0LIB]ALISM0 TO DESCRIBE !MSELVES AS 

IF !Y W]E MORE RECEPTIVE TO FRE$OM ?AN SOCIALI/S4 ,BUT !IR 

LIB]ALISM IS CONF9$ TO KEEP+ ! ,/ATE \T ( 9T]F]+ 9 

!IR BUS9ESS AFFAIRS4 ,ONCE AN>*ISM MAKES IT PLA9 ?AT IT IS 

POSSIBLE TO HAVE BO? SOCIAL JU/ICE & TO DISP5SE ) ! ,/ATE!Y >E %[N 9 !IR TRUE COLORS4 ,!IR >GUM5TS AGA9/ ,/ATE 

SOCIALISM & ,COMMUNISM MAY S\ND 0LIB]T>IAN01 BUT !IR >GUM5TS 

AGA9/ ,AN>*ISM REVEAL ?AT !Y >E ESS5TIALLY AU?ORIT>IAN4 

,?AT IS :Y !Y PREF] TO RELY UPON 9NU5DO1 SL&]S4 & FALSE 

REPORT+1 :I* IS P>T ( ! E/ABLI%M5T ANTI-AN>*ISM1 

FAI?FULLY SUPPORT$ BY ! M$IA4 

,! ,FASCI/ ,OBJECTION TO ,AN>*ISM 

,! FASCI/ OBJECTION TO ,AN>*ISM IS1 CURI\SLY 5\<1 MORE HONE/ 

?AN ?AT ( ! ,M>XI/1 ! LIB]AL OR ! ,SOCIAL-,DEMOCRAT4 ,MO/ ( 

!SE WILL SAY1 IF PRESS$1 ?AT ,AN>*ISM IS AN IDEAL1 P]HAPS 

IMP]FECTLY UND]/OOD1 BUT EI!R IMPOSSIBLE ( A*IEVEM5T OR 

POSSIBLE ONLY 9 ! DI/ANT FUTURE4 ,! FASCI/1 ON ! CONTR>Y1 

ADMITS ITS POSSIBILITY2 ,:AT IS D5I$ IS ITS DESIRABILITY4 

,! RI<T-W+ AU?ORIT>IAN 7:I* T]M 9CLUDES MANY BEYOND ?OSE 

NAM+ !MSELVES FASCI/S7 WOR%IPS ! V]Y ?+S :I* >E 

ANA!MA TO ,AN>*I/S1 ESPECIALLY ! ,/ATE4 ,?\< ! CONCEPTION 

( ! ,/ATE IS IDEALIZ$ 9 FASCI/ !ORY1 IT IS NOT D5I$ ?AT 

ONE C\LD DO )\T IT4 ,BUT ! 0FIR/ DUTY ( ! CITIZ5 IS TO 

DEF5D ! ,/ATE0 & IT IS HI< TREASON TO OPPOSE IT OR ADVOCATE 

ITS ABOLITION4 

,SOMETIMES ! ,/ATE IS DISGUIS$ AS ! 0CORPORATE PEOPLE0 OR ! 

0NATION10 GIV+ A MY/ICAL IDEA ( ! ,/ATE BEYOND ! M]E 

BUREAUCRATIC APP>ATUS ( RULE4 ,! =CES ( MILIT>ISM & 

OPPRESSION >E IDEALIZ$ 7AFT] ! ,G]MAN EMP]OR :O SAID ?AT 

UNIV]SAL PEACE WAS 0ONLY A DREAM & NOT EV5 A GOOD DREAM074 

,RUNN+ ?R\<\T RI<T-W+ PATRIOTISM IS A MY/ICAL FEEL+ AB\T 

! 0C\NTRY01 BUT ?\< ,NAZIS 9 P>TICUL> SOMETIMES HAVE 

REC\RSE TO AN IDEALIZATION ( ! 0PEOPLE0 7?IS HAS MORE ( A 

RACIAL ?AN POPUL> CONNOTATION 9 ,G]MAN71 IT IS REALLY ! ACTUAL 

SOIL ?AT IS HELD SACR$1 ?US TAK+ ! ,/ATE MY? TO ITS LOGICAL 

CONCLUSION4 ,= ! ,AN>*I/ ?IS1 ( C\RSE1 IS NONS5SE4 ,! 

NONS5SE CAN BE SE5 9 ITS />KE/ =M ) ! FOLL[]S ( 

,FRANCO :O KILL$ (F SO MANY ,SPANI>DS EV5 AFT] ! ,CIVIL ,W> WAS 

5D$1 :ILE HANK]+ = ! B>R5 ROCK ( ,GIBRALT>3 ESPECIALLY 

9 ,G5]AL ,MILAN DE ,A/RRAY1 :O WANT$ TO KILL (F 0BAD ,SPANI>DS0 

& ]ADICATE ,CATALANS & ,BASQUES 9 ! NAME ( UNIT>Y ,SPA91 ?US 

7AS ,UNAMUNO PO9T$ \T7 MAK+ ,SPA9 AS 0ONE->M$ & ONE-EY$1 AS 

! ,G5]AL WAS HIMSELF04 

,AN>*ISM IS CLE>LY SE5 BY FASCI/S AS A DIRECT M5ACE & NOT A 

PURELY PHILOSOPHICAL ONE4 ,IT IS NOT M]ELY ! DIRECT ACTION ( 

,AN>*I/S BUT ! ?+ ITSELF :I* REPRES5TS ! EVIL4 ,! 

0DEMOCRATIC0 M$IA F9ALLY GOT >\ND TO PICK+ UP !SE /R&S 9 

FASCI/ ?9K+1 IRON+ !M \T NICELY1 & PRES5T+ !M 9 ! 

0NEWS0 /ORIES4 ,HITL] REG>D$ ! ,AU?ORIT>IAN ,/ATE HE HAD BUILT 

AS MILL5NIAL 7! ?\S&-YE> /ATE7 BUT HE KNEW IT C\LD BE 

DISMEMB]$ & REJECT$4 ,HIS CON/ANT !ME WAS ! DANG] ( ?IS 

& :ILE HE CONC5TRAT$ 7= POLITICAL REASONS7 ATTACKS ON A 

TOTALIT>IAN RIVAL1 ,/ATE ,COMMUNISM 7S9CE ,RUSSIA PRES5T$ A 

MILIT>Y M5ACE71 HIS ATTACKS ON 0COSMOPOLITANISM0 HAVE ! 

REIT]AT$ !ME ( ANTI-,AN>*ISM4 

0,COSMOPOLITANISM0 & 0,/ATELESSNESS0 >E ! 0CRIMES0 ,NAZISM 

ASSOCIAT$ ) ,JEWS1 ?\< S9CE ,HITL]'S DAY L>GE NUMB]S ( !M 

HAVE REV]T$ TO NATIONALISM & A /RONG /ATE4 ,! !ME ( 0,JEWI% 

DOM9ATION0 GOES H& 9 H& ) 0AN>*I/ DE/RUCTION ( 

AU?ORITY1 MORALS1 & DISCIPL9E01 S9CE FASCISM REG>DS P]SONAL 

FRE$OM AS BAD 9 ITSELF & ONLY NATIONAL FRE$OM P]MISSIBLE4 

,9S(> AS ONE CAN MAKE ANY S5SE ( ,HITL]'S SPEE*ES 7:I* >E 

SOMETIMES DECEPTIVE S9CE HE FOLL[$ DIFF]5T /R&S ( ?\<T 

ACCORD+ TO ! WAY HE C\LD SWAY AN AUDI5CE71 HE BELIEV$ 

0PLUNG+ 9TO ,AN>*Y0 ( A C\NTRY 7ABOLITION ( ,/ATE RE/RA9TS7 

WILL LEAD TO *AOS1 :I* WILL MAKE IT POSSIBLE = A DICTATOR%IP 

O!R ?AN ! ONE 9 ! PEOPLE'S 9T]E/S TO SUCCE$4 

,HITL] DID NOT CONFUSE ,/ATE ,COMMUNISM ) ,AN>*ISM 7AS ,FRANCO DID 

DELIB]ATELY7 = PROPAG&A PURPOSES1 TO TRY TO ]ADICATE ,AN>*ISM 

FROM HI/ORY4 ,HE EQUAT$ ,COMMUNISM ) 0,JEWI% DOM9ATION01 & ! 

CASE AGA9/ ! ,JEWS 79 ORIG9AL ,NAZI ?9K+7 ?AT !Y >E A 

RACIALLY-PURE PEOPLE :O WILL GA9 CONQUE/ OV] HELOTS LIKE ! 

,G]MANS4 

,A 0,MA/] ,RACE0 MU/ CONTROL ! ,G]MANS TO KEEP ! RIVAL ,/ATE \T4 

,9 A CONDITION ( FRE$OM ! ,G]MAN 0HELOTS0 W\LD REV]T TO ,AN>*Y1 

JU/ AS ! RACIALLY 09F]IOR0 ,CELTS ( ,FRANCE ?REW \T ! ,NORMAN 

,NORDIC OV]LORDS 7! ,H\/ON ,*AMB]LA9 V]SION ( ! ,FR5* 

,REVOLUTION74 ,LAT]1 ( C\RSE1 :5 ,NAZISM BECAME A MASS ,P>TY IT WAS 

EXP$I5T TO AM5D ?IS TO SAY+ ! ,G]MANS W]E ! ,MA/] ,RACE1 

BUT ?IS WAS NOT ! ORIG9AL ,NAZI PHILOSOPHY1 NOR WAS IT PRIVATELY 

ACCEPT$ BY ! ,NAZI LEAD]S 70! ,G]MAN PEOPLE W]E NOT WOR?Y ( 

ME074 ,BUT !Y C\LD H>DLY TELL MASS MEET+S ?AT !Y W]E ALL 

0HELOTS04 ,AT LEA/ NOT UNTIL !IR P[] WAS COMPLETE4 ,?IS IDEA ?AT 

A :OLE PEOPLE 7:I*EV] IT WAS7 CAN BE BORN 0HELOTS0 C\LD NOT BE 

BETT] EXPRESS$ AS ! CONTR>Y OPPOSITE ( ,AN>*ISM1 S9CE 9 ?IS 

CASE IT W\LD 9DE$ BE IMPOSSIBLE4 

,?IS ,NAZI PROPAG&A IS E*O$ BY ! M$IA TODAY2 0PLUNG+ ! 

C\NTRY 9TO ,AN>*Y W\LD BE FOLL[$ BY A ,COMMUNI/ OR EXTREME 

RI<T-W+ DICTATOR%IP0 IS CURR5T NEWSPAP] J>GON4 

,TO SUM UP ! FASCI/ OBJECTION TO ,AN>*ISM3 ,IT IS NOT D5I$ ! 

ABOLITION ( ! ,/ATE CAN COME AB\T1 BUT IF SO1 GIV5 ECONOMIC1 

SOCIAL1 & POLITICAL FRE$OM1 ! 0HELOTS0 -- :O >E 0NATURALLY 

9CL9$0 TO ACCEPT SUBJECTION FROM SUP]IOR RACES -- WILL SEEK = 

MA/]S4 ,!Y WILL HAVE A NO/ALGIA = 0/RONG RULE04 

,9 ,NAZI ?9K+1 /RONG RULE CAN ONLY COME FROM 79 !ORY7 

RACIALLY-PURE MEMB]S ( ! 0,MA/] ,RACE0 7SOME?+ A LITTLE MORE 

?AN A CLASS & LESS ?AN A PEOPLE71 :I* CAN BE CON/RUCTIVE 

MA/]S 7I4E41 ! 0,>YANS071 OR A RACE :I* HAS HAD NO CONTACT 

) ! 0SOIL0 & WILL BE ?US DE/RUCTIVE4 

,9 O!R TYPES ( FASCI/ ?9K+1 GIV5 FRE$OM1 ! PEOPLE WILL 

?R[ (F ALL PATRIOTIC & NATIONALI/IC ALLEGIANCES & SO ! 

0C\NTRY0 WILL CEASE TO BE GREAT4 ,?IS IS ! BASIS ( ,MUSSOL9I'S 

FASCISM1 &1 ( C\RSE1 IT IS P]FECTLY TRUE1 BE>+ 9 M9D ?AT 

0! C\NTRY0 IS HIS SYNONYM = ! ,/ATE & HIS ONLY CONCEPTION ( 

GREATNESS IS MILIT>I/IC4 ,! FRANKE/ ( ALL IS ! ,SPANI% TYPE ( 

FASCISM :I* S\<T TO IMPOSE CLASS DOM9ATION ( ! MO/ BRUTAL 

K9D & MAKE IT PLA9 ?AT ITS OPPOSITION TO ,AN>*ISM WAS SIMPLY 9 

ORD] TO KEEP ! WORK+ CLASS D[N4 ,IF NECESS>Y1 ! WORK+ CLASS 

MAY BE1 & WAS1 DECIMAT$ 9 ORD] TO CRU% ,AN>*ISM4 

,IT IS TRUE ( ALL POLITICAL PHILOSOPHIES & BLATANT ) ! FASCI/ 

ONE1 ?AT ITS RELATION%IP TO ,AN>*ISM ?R[S AS CLE> LI<T UPON 

ITSELF6 

,! ,AV]AGE ,P]SON'S ,OBJECTION TO ,AN>*ISM 

,G5]ALLY SPEAK+1 ! ORD9>Y PEOPLE PICK UP !IR OBJECTION TO 

,AN>*ISM FROM ! PRESS1 :I* 9 TURN IS 9FLU5C$ BY :AT ! 

E/ABLI%M5T WANTS4 ,= MANY YE>S !RE WAS A PRESS CONSPIRACY ( 

SIL5CE AGA9/ ,AN>*ISM1 FOLL[$ 9 ! #aif BY A RUL+ ON 

TRANSCRIB+ ,AN>*ISM & ,M>XISM1 OR ,AN>*ISM & NATIONALISM1 SO 

?AT ! ONE MU/ BE REF]R$ TO ! O!R1 9 ORD] TO CONFUSE4 ,?IS 

WAS B\RN \T 9 MANY EXPOSURES 9 ,BLACK ,FLAG %[+ :]E AV[$ 

,M>XI/S W]E 9 ! TURBUL5T ,SIXTIES DESCRIB$ 9 ! PRESS AS 

0,AN>*I/S0 :ILE AV[$ ,AN>*I/S W]E DESCRIB$ AS 0,M>XI/S0 OR 

0NATIONALI/S04 ,ON SOME OCCASIONS NATIONALI/S W]E CALL$ 

0,AN>*I/S10 BUT USUALLY :5 ! WORD 0,AN>*I/0 WAS BE+ US$ AS 

IF TO DESCRIBE ONESELF AS AN ,AN>*I/1 IT WAS TO MAKE A CONFESSION ( 

GUILT4 ,?IS1 AS WE HAVE SE51 IS PICK$ UP FROM ! ,LIB]AL-,DEMOCRATIC 

ATTITUDE TO ,AN>*ISM4 ,BUT IT IS FLAVOR$ /RONGLY ) ! FASCI/ 

ATTITUDE1 TOO4 ,BECAUSE ( IT1 ! PHRASE 0SELF-CONFESS$ ,AN>*I/0 

CAME TO BE US$ BY ! ,PRESS TO DESCRIBE A P]SON :O IS AN ,AN>*I/ 

AS OPPOS$ TO SOMEONE :O !Y HAVE M]ELY LABEL$ ,AN>*I/ 9 ORD] 

TO CONFUSE4 

,?IS HAS ALT]$ SOME:AT ) ! COMM]CIAL EXPLOITATION ( 

,AN>*ISM BY COMM]CIAL EXPLOITATION ( MUSIC & ACADEMIC 

EXPLOITATION ( PHILOSOPHY1 GIV+ RISE TO A MIDDLE-CLASS LIB]AL 

V]SION ( AN ,AN>*I/ AS A LIB]AL-M9D$ PHILOSOPH]1 A H>MLESS 

ECC5TRIC1 A DROP \T1 OR A P]SON WE>+ FA%IONABLY UNFA%IONABLE 

CLO!S4 

,AS OPPOS$ TO ?IS 9CREAS+LY POPUL> MISCONCEPTION1 ! AV]AGE 

P]SON TAKES ! FASCI/ VIEW ( AN>*ISM -- AS PICK$ UP 9 ITS 

5TIRETY BY POLICE (FIC]S & O!RS -- AS G5U9E1 BUT TEMP]$ 

) ! FACT ?AT !Y DO NOT TAKE IT QUITE S]I\SLY4 ,SOMETIMES 

!Y CONFUSE ! WORD 0REVOLUTION>Y01 & ASSUME ALL :O PROTE/ >E 

!REBY ,AN>*I/4 ,?IS IGNORANCE1 H[EV]1 IS MORE (T5 DISPLAY$ BY 

J\RNALI/S ?AN IT IS BY ! G5]AL PUBLIC4 

,:5 IT COMES D[N TO AN OBJECTION TO ,AN>*ISM AS IT IS1 AS DI/9CT 

FROM OBJECTIONS TO A MY?OLOGICAL ,AN>*ISM AS IMAG9$ OR 

C>ICATUR$ BY ! AU?ORIT>IAN ,P>TIES OR E/ABLI%M5T1 OR 

PRACTIC$ BY ! ALT]NATIVE E/ABLI%M5T1 !RE >E NOT MANY 

S]I\S OBJECTIONS FROM ! G5]AL PUBLIC4 ,!Y MAY NOT ?9K IT 

PRACTICAL ( REALIZATION IF PRES5T$ 9 A POSITIVE WAY TO !M1 BUT 

!Y USUALLY DO SO IF PRES5T$ 9 A NEGATIVE WAY -- I4E4 DESCRIB+ 

! TYRANNY ( ! ,/ATE4 ,! FACT ?AT WE C\LD DISP5SE ) 

AU?ORIT>IAN P>TIES1 ! WOR?LESSNESS ( POLITICIANS1 & SO ON IS 

G5]ALLY AGRE$4 ,! SOLE MA9 OBJECTION IS P]HAPS ! FEEL+ ?AT 

!Y WANT TO MAKE ! BE/ \T ( LIFE AS IT IS3 & !Y DO NOT FEEL 

/RONG 5\< TO *ALL5GE ! ,/ATE OR TO FACE ! /RUGGLE 9VOLV$ 

9 BR++ AB\T A ,FREE ,SOCIETY1 OR PUT UP ) ! MANY 

VICISSITUDES 7MAJOR & M9OR7 ?AT MAKE UP ! LIFE ( A MILITANT OR 

SOMEONE REASONABLY COMMITT$ TO AN IDEAL4 ,! TEMPTATIONS  >E GREATTO 

CON=M & TO ACCEPT ! BRIBES :I* ! CAPITALI/ CLASS CAN N[ 

HOLD \T4 ,ONLY :5 ! ,/ATE WANTS ITS LA/ \NCE ( BLOOD DO PEOPLE 

WAKE UP TO ! NE$ = RESI/ANCE1 BUT !N IT IS TOO LATE & ALSO1 

( C\RSE1 ! ,/ATE !N TAKES ON ! PRET5SE ( BE+ 0! 

C\NTRY01 9 ORD] TO BE LOV$ 9/EAD ( HAT$ OR DISLIK$4 

,! ,R$UCTION ( ,AN>*ISM TO ,M>G9ALIZATION 

,BY CRAFTY ME?ODS1 NOT US$ AGA9/ O!R POLITICAL !ORIES1 IT IS 

5DEAVOR$ BY ,/ATI/ PROPAG&A TO M>G9ALIZE ,AN>*ISM TO 

NO?+4 ,IT IS CONFUS$ BY J\RNALI/S1 PR(ESSORS1 & SUBSIDIZ$ 

0RESE>*]S0 TO %[ ?AT ,AN>*I/S >E ID5TICAL TO DROP\TS1 

DRUG-TAK]S1 NATIONALI/ ASSASS9S1 ,NEW-,AGE TRAVEL]S1 POLITICAL 

DISSID5TS1 MILITANT TRADE UNIONI/S1 Y\NG REBELS1 MIDDLE-CLASS 

!ORI/S1 DREAM]S1 PLOTT]S1 COM$IANS1 FRU/RAT$ RE=M]S1 

EXTREME PACIFI/S1 MURD]]S1 S*OOLBOY REBELS1 & CRIM9ALS4 ,SOME 

,AN>*I/S1 ONE SUPPOSES1 C\LD BE ANY BUT H>DLY ALL ( !SE -- AS 

C\LD MEMB]S ( ALL POLITICAL P]SUASIONS -- BUT NONE C\LD BE 

DESCRIPTIVE ( ! CAUSE4 ,BY MISUSE ( ! WORD 0,AN>*I/01 OR BY 

ADD$ 0ALLEG$0 OR 0SELF-CONFESS$0 ,AN>*I/2 OR BY CONJO9+ ! 

WORD ) AN OBVI\S CONTRADICTION1 ,AN>*ISM CAN BE M>G9ALIZ$ 

&1 BY IMPLICATION1 ,/ATI/ !ORIES MADE TO SEEM ! NORM4 

-- ,ALB]T ,MELTZ] 

,M>K$ UP BY ,*UCK ON #e-#a#e-#i#f 

,BR\<T TO Y\ BY3 ,MID-,ATLANTIC ,9FO%OP 

& 

,A,K ,PRESS 

,FROM 3 ,HACK4ORG4 

,*RONOLOGY 3 
,FEBRU>Y #g1 #bag 3 ,AN>*ISM3 ,>GUM5TS ,= & ,AGA9/ -- ,ADD$4 
,DECEMB] #c1 #bba 3 ,AN>*ISM3 ,>GUM5TS ,= & ,AGA9/ -- ,UPDAT$4 

 FILE G5]AT$ FROM 3  
HTTP3_/_/REVOLTLIB4COM_/