,BOOK #d1 ,*APT] #a ,( ,RESI/ANCE #agicagic ,PEOPLE 3 ,AU?OR 3 ,WILLIAM ,GODW9 ,TEXT 3 ,B,O,O,K ,I,V ,( ,! ,O,P,],A,T,I,O,N ,( ,O,P,9,I,O,N ,9 ,S,O,C,I,E,T,I,E,S ,& ,9,D,I,V,I,D,U,A,L,S ,*,A,P,T,] ,I ,( ,R,E,S,I,/,A,N,C,E ,SUBJECT ( ! F\R? BOOK4 - ,FIR/ BRAN* ( ! SUBJECT4 - ,QUE/ION ( RESI/ANCE /AT$4 - ,RESI/ANCE ( A NATION4 - ,AMBIGUITY ( ! T]M NATION4 - ,CASE ( A MILIT>Y SUBJECTION CONSID]$4 - ,RESI/ANCE ( A MAJORITY - ( A M9ORITY4 - ,FUR!R AMBIGUITY ( ! T]M NATION4 ,NATURE ( LIB]TY4 - ,REM>K4 - ,RESI/ANCE ( ! 9DIVIDUAL4 ,H,A,V,+ N[ MADE SOME PROGRESS 9 ! 9QUIRY ORIG9ALLY 9/ITUT$1 IT MAY BE PROP] TO LOOK BACK1 & CONSID] ! PO9T AT :I* WE >E >RIV$4 ,WE HAVE EXAM9$1 9 ! FIR/ PLACE1 ! P[]S ( MAN AS !Y RELATE TO ! SUBJECT ( :I* WE TREAT2 SECONDLY1 WE HAVE DEL9EAT$ ! PR9CIPLES ( SOCIETY1 AS F\ND$ 9 JU/ICE & G5]AL 9T]E/1 9DEP5D5TLY (1 & ANTEC$5T TO1 EV]Y SPECIES ( POLITICAL GOV]NM5T2 &1 LA/LY1 HAVE 5DEAVOR$ TO ASC]TA9 ! FUNDAM5TAL CONDITIONS :I* MU/ BELONG TO ! MO/ RATIONAL SY/EM ( GOV]NM5T4 ,WE MIE PO9T$ \T TO US BY ! PREC$+ REASON+S4 ,BUT !RE >E V>I\S MISCELLANE\S CONSID]ATIONS :I*1 ?\< !Y HAVE NOT FALL5 UND] ! =M] HEADS1 >E ( CONSID]ABLE IMPORTANCE TO \R DISQUISITION1 & MAY USEFULLY OCCUPY ! REMA9D] ( ! PRES5T VOLUME4 ,!Y >E ( DIFF]5T CLASSES1 & 9 A C]TA9 DEGREE DETA*$ FROM EA* O!R2 BUT MAY P]HAPS )\T IMPROPRIETY BE RANG$ UND] TWO BRAN*ES3 ! MODE 9 :I* ! SPECULATIVE OP9IONS ( 9DIVIDUALS >E TO BE R5D]$ EFFECTUAL = ! MELIORATION ( SOCIETY2 & ! MODE 9 :I* OP9ION IS F\ND TO OP]ATE 9 MODIFY+ ! CONDUCT ( 9DIVIDUALS4 ,! /RONG HOLD ( GOV]NM5T HAS APPE>$ HI!RTO TO HAVE CONSI/$ 9 S$UCTION4 ,H[EV] IMP]FECT MIILY BE5 P]SUAD$ TO REG>D IT ) A SORT ( REV]5TIAL & IMPLICIT RESPECT4 ,! PRIVILEGES ( ,5GLI%M51 & ! LIB]TIES ( ,G]MANY1 ! SPL5DOR ( ! MO/ ,*RI/IAN1 & ! SOLEMN GRAVITY ( ! ,CA?OLIC K+1 HAVE EA* AF=D$ A SUBJECT ( EXULTATION TO ! 9DIVIDUALS :O %>$1 OR ?\$1 9 ! ADVANTAGES !SE T]MS W]E CONCEIV$ TO DESCRIBE4 ,EA* MAN WAS ACCU/OM$ TO DEEM IT A M>K ( ! PECULI> K9DNESS ( PROVID5CE ?AT HE WAS BORN 9 ! C\NTRY1 :ATEV] IT WAS1 TO :I* HE HAPP5$ TO BE LONG4 ,! TIME MAY COME :I* %ALL SUBV]T !SE PREJUDICES4 ,! TIME MAY COME :5 M5 %ALL EX]CISE ! PI]C+ SE>* ( TRU? UPON ! MY/]IES ( GOV]NM5T1 & VIEW )\T PREPOSSESSION ! DEFECTS & ABUSES ( ! CON/ITUTION ( !IR C\NTRY4 ,\T ( ?IS NEW ORD] ( ?+S A NEW S]IES ( DUTIES WILL >ISE4 ,:5 A SPIRIT ( IMP>TIALITY %ALL PREVAIL1 & LOYALTY %ALL DECAY1 IT WILL BECOME US TO 9QUIRE 9TO ! CONDUCT :I* SU* A /ATE ( ?9K+ %ALL MAKE NECESS>Y4 ,WE %ALL !N BE CALL$ UPON TO MA9TA9 A TRUE M$IUM BETWE5 BL9DNESS TO 9JU/ICE & CALAMITY ON ! ONE H&1 & AN ACRIMONI\S SPIRIT ( VIOL5CE & RES5TM5T ON ! O!R4 ,IT WILL BE ! DUTY ( SU* AS %ALL SEE !SE SUBJECTS 9 ! PURE LI & CONFUSION1 & WILL 5DEAVOR TO DISCOV] ! MODE 9 :I* HIS FACULTIES MAY BE LAID \T TO ! GREATE/ & MO/ P]MAN5T ADVANTAGE4 ,! :OLE ( ?IS QUE/ION IS 9TIMATELY CONNECT$ ) ! 9QUIRY :I* HAS NECESS>ILY OCCUPI$ A %>E ,9 ! DISQUISITIONS ( ALL WRIT]S ON ! SUBJECT ( GOV]NM5T1 CONC]N+ ! PROPRIETY & MEASURES ( RESI/ANCE4 0,>E ! WOR/ GOV]NM5T & BE/ EQUALLY 5TITL$ TO ! TOL]ATION & =BE>ANCE ( !IR SUBJECTS8 ,IS !RE NO CASE ( POLITICAL OPPRESSION ?AT WILL AU?ORIZE ! P]SONS :O SUFF] IT TO TAKE UP >MS AGA9/ !IR OPPRESSORS8 ,OR1 IF !RE BE1 :AT IS ! QUANTITY ( OPPRESSION AT ! MEASURE ( :I* 9SURRECTIONS BEG9 TO BE JU/IFIABLE8 ,ABUSES WILL ALWAYS EXI/1 = MAN WILL ALWAYS BE IMP]FECT2 :AT IS ! NATURE ( ! ABUSE :I* IT W\LD BE PUSILLANIM\S TO OPPOSE BY WORDS ONLY1 & :I* TRUE C\RAGE W\LD 9/RUCT US WAS TO BE 5DUR$ NO LONG]80 ,NO QUE/ION CAN BE CONCEIV$ MORE IMPORTANT ?AN ?IS4 ,9 ! EXAM9ATION ( IT PHILOSOPHY ALMO/ =GETS ITS NATURE2 IT CEASES TO BE SPECULATION1 & BECOMES AN ACTOR4 ,UPON ! DECISION1 ACCORD+ AS IT %ALL BE DECID$ 9 ! M9DS ( A BOLD & RESOLUTE P>TY1 ! EXI/5CE ( ?\S&S MAY BE SUSP5D$4 ,! SPECULATIVE 5QUIR]1 IF HE LIVE 9 A /ATE :]E ABUSE IS NOTORI\S & GRIEVANCES FREQU5T1 KN[S NOT1 :ILE HE WEI ?AT :I* HE ATTEMPTS TO DESCRIBE IS ALREADY REALIZ$ 9 ! APPREH5SION ( NUMB]S ( HIS C\NTRYM54 ,LET US 5T] UPON ! QUE/ION ) ! S]I\SNESS :I* SO CRITICAL AN 9QUIRY DEM&S4 ,RESI/ANCE MAY HAVE ITS S\RCE 9 ! EM]G5CIES EI!R ( ! PUBLIC OR ! 9DIVIDUAL4 0,A NATION10 IT HAS COMMONLY BE5 SAID1 0HAS A RI MORE PLAUSIBLE4 ,BUT1 IF WE EXAM9E IT M9UTELY1 WE %ALL F9D ?AT IT IS ATT5D$ ) EQUIVOCAL CIRCUM/ANCES4 ,:AT DO WE MEAN BY A NATION8 ,IS ! :OLE PEOPLE CONC]N$ 9 ?IS RESI/ANCE1 OR ONLY A P>T8 ,IF ! :OLE BE PREP>$ TO RESI/1 ! :OLE IS P]SUAD$ ( ! 9JU/ICE ( ! USURPATION4 ,:AT SORT ( USURPATION IS ?AT :I* CAN BE EX]CIS$ BY ONE OR A FEW P]SONS OV] A :OLE NATION UNIV]SALLY DISAPPROV+ ( IT8 ,GOV]NM5T IS F\ND$ 9 OP9ION4#a ,BAD GOV]NM5T DECEIVES US FIR/1 BE=E IT FA/5S ITSELF UPON US LIKE AN 9CUBUS1 OPPRESS+ ALL \R EF=TS4 ,A NATION 9 G5]AL MU/ HAVE LE>N$ TO RESPECT A K+ & A H\SE ( LORDS1 BE=E A K+ & A H\SE ( LORDS CAN EX]CISE ANY AU?ORITY OV] !M4 ,IF A MAN OR A SET ( M51 UNSANCTION$ BY ANY PREVI\S PREJUDICE 9 !IR FAVOR1 PRET5D TO EX]CISE SOV]EIGNTY 9 A C\NTRY1 !Y WILL BECOME OBJECTS ( D]ISION RA!R ?AN ( S]I\S RESI/ANCE4 ,DE/ROY ! EXI/+ PREJUDICE 9 FAVOR ( ANY ( \R PRES5T 9/ITUTIONS1 & !Y WILL FALL 9TO SIMIL> DISUSE & CONTEMPT4 ,IT HAS SOMETIMES BE5 SUPPOS$ 0?AT AN >MY1 =EIGN OR DOME/IC1 MAY BE SUFFICI5T TO HOLD A PEOPLE 9 SUBJECTION1 COMPLETELY AGA9/ !IR 9CL9ATION40 ,A DOME/IC >MY AT LEA/ WILL 9 SOME DEGREE P>TAKE ( ! OP9IONS & S5TIM5TS ( ! PEOPLE AT L>GE4 ,! MORE PRECAUTIONS >E EMPLOY$ TO PREV5T ! 9FECTION1 ! DOCTR9E WILL PROBABLY SPREAD ) SO MU* ! MORE C]TA9TY & RAPIDITY4 ,%[ ME ?AT Y\ >E AFRAID ( MY 5T]TA9+ C]TA9 OP9IONS OR HE>+ C]TA9 PR9CIPLES1 & Y\ WILL 9FALLIBLY1 SOON] OR LAT]1 AWAK5 MY CURIOSITY4 ,A DOME/IC >MY WILL ALWAYS BE F\ND A V]Y D\BTFUL 9/RUM5T ( TYRANNY 9 A P]IOD ( CRISIS4 - ,A =EIGN >MY AFT] A TIME WILL BECOME DOME/ICAT$4 ,IF ! QUE/ION BE ( IMPORT+ A =EIGN >MY = ! SPECIFIC PURPOSE ( SUPPORT+ TOTT]+ ABUSE1 GREAT AL>M WILL 9EVITABLY BE EXCIT$4 ,!SE M51 IT MAY BE1 >E ADAPT$ = CONT9U+ ! REIGN ( TYRANNY2 BUT :O WILL PAY !M8 ,A WEAK1 SUP]/ITI\S OR IGNORANT PEOPLE MAY BE HELD 9 ! *A9S ( =EIGN P[]2 BUT ! S*OOL ( MORAL & POLITICAL 9DEP5D5CE S5DS =? PUPILS ( A V]Y DIFF]5T *>ACT]4 ,9 ! 5C\NT] ) !IR P5ETRATION & DISC]NM5T1 TYRANNY WILL FEEL ITSELF P[]LESS & TRANSITORY4 ,9 A WORD1 EI!R ! PEOPLE >E UN5LI$ = A /ATE ( FRE$OM1 & !N ! /RUGGLE & ! CONSEQU5CES ( ! /RUGGLE WILL BE TRULY P]IL\S2 OR ! PROGRESS ( POLITICAL KN[L$GE AMONG !M IS DECISIVE1 & !N EV]YONE WILL SEE H[ FUTILE & %ORT-LIV$ WILL BE ! ATTEMPT TO HOLD !M 9 SUBJECTION1 BY MEANS ( G>RISONS & A =EIGN =CE4 ,! P>TY ATTA*$ TO LIB]TY IS1 UPON ?AT SUPPOSITION1 ! NUM]\S ONE2 !Y >E ! P]SONS ( TRUE 5]GY1 & :O HAVE AN OBJECT WOR?Y ( !IR ZEAL4 ,!IR OPPRESSORS1 FEW 9 NUMB]1 & DEGRAD$ TO ! RANK ( LIFELESS MA*9ES1 W&] ) NO C]TA9 DE/9ATION OR PROSPECT OV] ! VA/ SURFACE1 & >E OBJECTS ( PITY RA!R ?AN S]I\S AL>M4 ,EV]Y H\R DIM9I%ES !IR NUMB] & !IR RES\RCES2 :ILE1 ON ! O!R H&1 EV]Y MOM5T'S DELAY GIVES NEW /R5G? TO ! CAUSE1 & =TITUDE TO ! *AMPIONS1 ( LIB]TY4 ,M5 W\LD NOT BE 9CL9$ P]T9ACI\SLY TO OBJECT TO A %ORT DELAY1 IF !Y RECOLLECT$ ! ADVANTAGES & ! C]TA9TY ( SUCCESS ) :I* IT IS PREGNANT4 - ,MEAN:ILE !SE REASON+S TURN UPON ! PROBABILITY ?AT ! PURPOSES ( LIB]TY WILL BE FULL AS EFFECTUALLY ANSW]$ )\T ! 9TRODUCTION ( =CE3 !RE CAN BE LITTLE D\BT ( ! JU/IFIABL5ESS ( A :OLE NATION HAV+ REC\RSE TO >MS1 IF A CASE CAN BE MADE \T 9 :I* IT %ALL BE IMPOSSIBLE = !M TO PREV5T ! 9TRODUCTION ( SLAV]Y 9 ANY O!R WAY4 ,! SAME REASON+S1 ) LITTLE V>IATION1 WILL APPLY TO ! CASE ( AN UNQUE/IONABLE MAJORITY ( A NATION1 AS TO ?AT ( ! :OLE4 ,! MAJORITY ( A NATION IS IRRESI/IBLE2 IT AS LITTLE NE$S TO HAVE REC\RSE TO VIOL5CE2 !RE IS AS LITTLE REASON TO EXPECT ?AT ANY USURP] WILL BE SO MAD AS TO CONT5D ) IT4 ,IF EV] IT APPE> TO BE O!R WISE1 IT IS BECAUSE1 9 ONE ( TWO WAYS1 WE DECEIVE \RSELVES ) ! T]M MAJORITY4 ,FIR/1 NO?+ IS MORE OBVI\S ?AN ! DANG] 9CID5T TO A MAN ( A SANGU9E TEMP] ( OV]E/IMAT+ ! /R5G? ( HIS P>TY4 ,HE ASSOCIATES P]HAPS ONLY ) P]SONS ( HIS [N WAY ( ?9K+1 & A V]Y SMALL NUMB] APPE>S TO HIM AS IF IT W]E ! :OLE WORLD4 ,ASK P]SONS ( DIFF]5T TEMP]S & HABITS ( LIFE H[ MANY REPUBLICANS !RE >E AT ?IS H\R 9 ,5GL& OR ,SCOTL&1 & Y\ WILL IMM$IATELY BE /RUCK ) ! V]Y OPPOSITE ANSW]S Y\ WILL RECEIVE4 ,!RE >E MANY ]RORS ( A SANGU9E TEMP] ?AT APPE>1 AT FIR/ SIT ( /RANGE COMPOSITION :O1 = ! PREC>I\S 9F]5CES HE DRAWS 9 MORAL OR POLITICAL CALCULATION1 W\LD VOLUNTE] A M&ATE ( DEA?1 OR BE ! FIR/ TO UN%EA? ! SWORD ( SUMM>Y EXECUTION4 ,A SECOND DECEPTION ?AT LURKS UND] ! WORD MAJORITY LIES1 NOT 9 ! QUE/ION ( NUMB]1 BUT ( QUALITY & DEGREE ( ILLUM9ATION4 ,A MAJORITY1 WE SAY P]HAPS1 IS DISSATISFI$ ) ! PRES5T /ATE ( ?+S1 & WI%ES = SU* A SPECIFIC ALT]ATION4 ,ALAS1 IT IS TO BE FE>$ ?AT ! GREAT] P>T ( ?IS MAJORITY >E (T5 M]E P>ROTS :O HAVE BE5 TAUY GRIEVANCE4 ,DO !Y DISLIKE ! VISE & MEANNESS ?AT GR[ \T ( TYRANNY1 & PANT = ! LIB]AL & +5U\S VIRTUE ?AT W\LD BE FO/]$ 9 !IR [N M9DS 9 A DIFF]5T CONDITION8 ,NO4 ,!Y >E V]Y ANGRY1 & FANCY !MSELVES V]Y JUDICI\S4 ,:AT IS IT !Y DESIRE8 ,!Y KN[ NOT4 ,IT W\LD PROBABLY BE EASY TO %[ ?AT :AT !Y PR(ESS TO DESIRE IS LITTLE BETT] ?AN :AT !Y HATE4 ,:AT !Y HATE IS NOT ! G5]AL DEPRAVATION ( ! HUMAN *>ACT]2 & :AT !Y DESIRE IS NOT ITS IMPROVEM5T4 ,IT IS AN 9SULT UPON HUMAN UND]/&+1 :5 WE SPEAK ( P]SONS 9 ?IS /ATE ( 9FANT9E IGNORANCE1 TO SAY ?AT ! MAJORITY ( ! NATION IS ON ! SIDE ( POLITICAL R5OVATION4 ,FEW GREAT] MIS=TUNES CAN BEFALL ANY C\NTRY ?AN = SU* P]SONS TO BE 9/IGAT$ TO SUBV]T EXI/+ 9/ITUTIONS1 & VIOL5TLY TO TAKE ! WORK ( POLITICAL RE=MATION 9TO !IR [N H&S4 ,!RE IS AN OBVI\S REM$Y TO EA* ( ! DECEPTIONS H]E 5UM]AT$3 ,TIME3 ,IS IT D\BTFUL :E!R ! RE=M]S BE A REAL MAJORITY ( ! 9HABITANTS ( ANY C\NTRY8 ,IS IT D\BTFUL :E!R ! MAJORITY TRULY UND]/& ! OBJECT ( !IR PR(ESS$ WI%ES1 & !RE=E :E!R !Y BE RIPE = ITS RECEPTION1 & COMPET5T TO ITS ASS]TION8 ,WAIT BUT A LITTLE :ILE1 & ! D\BT WILL PROBABLY BE SOLV$ 9 ! MANN] ?AT ! W>ME/ FRI5D ( HUMAN HAPP9ESS & IMPROVEM5T W\LD DESIRE4 ,IF ! SY/EM ( 9DEP5D5CE & EQUALITY BE ! TRU?1 IT MAY BE EXPECT$ H\RLY TO GA9 CONV]TS4 ,! MORE IT IS DISCUSS$1 ! MORE WILL IT BE UND]/OOD1 & ITS VALUE *]I%$ & FELT4 ,IF ! /ATE ( ! MAJORITY BE D\BTFUL1 A V]Y FEW YE>S1 P]HAPS A %ORT] TIME1 WILL T5D TO PLACE IT BEYOND ! REA* ( CONTROV]SY4 ,! GREAT CAUSE ( HUMANITY1 :I* IS N[ PLEAD+ 9 ! FACE ( ! UNIV]SE1 HAS BUT TWO 5EMIES2 ?OSE FRI5DS ( ANTIQUITY1 & ?OSE FRI5DS ( 9NOVATION1 :O1 IMPATI5T ( SUSP5SE1 >E 9CL9$ VIOL5TLY TO 9T]RUPT ! CALM1 ! 9CESSANT1 ! RAPID & AUSPICI\S PROGRESS :I* ?\ TO BE MAK+ 9 ! WORLD4 ,HAPPY W\LD IT BE = MANK9D IF ?OSE P]SONS :O 9T]E/ !MSELVES MO/ ZEAL\SLY 9 !SE GREAT QUE/IONS W\LD CONF9E !IR EX]TIONS TO ! DIFFUS+1 9 EV]Y POSSIBLE MODE1 A SPIRIT ( 9QUIRY1 & ! EMBRAC+ EV]Y OPPORTUNITY ( 9CREAS+ ! /OCK1 & G5]ALIZ+ ! COMMUNICATION1 ( POLITICAL KN[L$GE6 ,A ?IRD SITUATION1 :I* MAY BE CONCEIV$ TO EXI/ 9 A C\NTRY :]E POLITICAL RE=M HAS BE5 MADE A TOPIC ( CONSID]ABLE ATT5TION1 IS ?AT :]E NEI!R ! :OLE1 NOR ! MAJORITY1 ( ! NATION IS DESIR\S ( ! RE=M 9 QUE/ION1 BUT :]E ! 9NOVATORS >E AN UNQUE/IONABLE M9ORITY4 ,9 ?IS CASE NO?+ CAN BE MORE 9DEF5SIBLE ?AN A PROJECT = 9TRODUC+ BY VIOL5CE ?AT /ATE ( SOCIETY :I* \R JUDGM5TS MAY HAPP5 TO APPROVE4 ,9 ! FIR/ PLACE1 NO P]SONS >E RIPE = ! P>TICIPATION ( A B5EFIT ! ADVANTAGE ( :I* !Y DO NOT UND]/&4 ,NO PEOPLE >E COMPET5T TO 5JOY A /ATE ( FRE$OM :O >E NOT ALREADY IMBU$ ) A LOVE ( FRE$OM4 ,! MO/ DREADFUL TRAG$IES WILL 9FALLIBLY RESULT FROM AN ATTEMPT TO GOAD MANK9D PREMATURELY 9TO A POSITION1 H[EV] AB/RACT$LY EXCELL5T1 = :I* !Y >E 9 NO DEGREE PREP>$4 ,SECONDLY1 TO 5DEAVOR TO IMPOSE \R S5TIM5TS BY =CE IS ! MO/ DETE/ABLE SPECIES ( P]SECUTION4 ,O!RS >E AS MU* 5TITL$ TO DEEM !MSELVES 9 ! RIE4 ,! MO/ SACR$ ( ALL PRIVILEGES IS ?AT BY :I* EA* MAN HAS A C]TA9 SPH]E1 RELATIVE TO ! GOV]NM5T ( HIS [N ACTIONS1 & ! EX]CISE ( HIS DISCRETION1 NOT LIABLE TO BE TR5*$ UPON BY ! 9TEMP]ATE ZEAL OR DICTATORIAL TEMP] ( HIS NEIGUM5T1 BUT ( /R5G?1 PRESUMPTION OR 9TRIGUE4 ,!RE IS A FUR!R AMBIGUITY 9 ! T]M NATION1 AS EMPLOY$ 9 ! PROPOSITION ABOVE /AT$1 0?AT A NATION HAS A RIBITR>Y T]M4 ,:I* IS MO/ PROP]LY T]M$ A NATION1 ! ,RUSSIAN EMPIRE1 OR ! CANTON ( ,B]NE8 ,OR IS EV]Y?+ A NATION UPON :I* ACCID5T %ALL BE/[ ?AT APPELLATION8 ,IT SEEMS MO/ ACCURATE TO SAY ?AT ANY NUMB] ( P]SONS :O >E ABLE TO E/ABLI% & MA9TA9 A SY/EM ( MUTUAL REGULATION = !MSELVES CON=MABLE TO !IR [N OP9IONS1 )\T IMPOS+ A SY/EM ( REGULATION UPON A CONSID]ABLE NUMB] ( O!RS 9CONSI/5T ) ! OP9ION ( !SE O!RS1 HAVE A RIY TO 9CUR1 = ! SAKE ( A PREPOND]AT+ GOOD4 ,ALL GOV]NM5T 9CLUDES 9 IT ?IS EVIL1 AS ONE ( ITS FUNDAM5TAL *>ACT]I/ICS4 ,!RE IS ONE CIRCUM/ANCE ( MU* IMPORTANCE TO BE ATT5D$ TO 9 ?IS DISQUISITION4 ,SUP]FICIAL ?9K]S LAY GREAT /RESS UPON ! EXT]NAL SITUATION ( M51 & LITTLE UPON !IR 9T]NAL S5TIM5TS4 ,P]SEV]+ 9QUIRY WILL PROBABLY LEAD TO A MODE ( ?9K+ ! REV]SE ( ?IS4 ,TO BE FREE IS A CIRCUM/ANCE ( LITTLE VALUE1 IF WE C\LD SUPPOSE M5 9 A /ATE ( EXT]NAL FRE$OM1 )\T ! MAGNANIMITY1 5]GY & FIRMNESS ?AT CON/ITUTE ALMO/ ALL ?AT IS VALUABLE 9 A /ATE ( FRE$OM4 ,ON ! O!R H&1 IF A MAN HAVE !SE QUALITIES1 !RE IS LITTLE LEFT = HIM TO DESIRE4 ,HE CANNOT BE DEGRAD$2 HE CANNOT READILY BECOME EI!R USELESS OR UNHAPPY4 ,HE SMILES AT ! IMPOT5CE ( DESPOTISM2 HE FILLS UP HIS EXI/5CE ) S]5E 5JOYM5T & 9DU/RI\S B5EVOL5CE4 ,CIVIL LIB]TY IS *IEFLY DESIRABLE AS A MEANS TO PROCURE & P]PETUATE ?IS TEMP] ( M9D4 ,!Y !RE=E BEG9 AT ! WRONG 5D1 :O MAKE HA/E TO OV]TURN & CONF\ND ! USURP$ P[]S ( ! WORLD4 ,MAKE M5 WISE1 & BY ?AT V]Y OP]ATION Y\ MAKE !M FREE4 ,CIVIL LIB]TY FOLL[S AS A CONSEQU5CE ( ?IS2 NO USURP$ P[] CAN /& AGA9/ ! >TILL]Y ( OP9ION4 ,EV]Y?+ !N IS 9 ORD]1 & SUCCE$S AT ITS APPO9T$ TIME4 ,H[ UN=TUNATE IS IT ?AT M5 >E SO EAG] TO /RIKE & HAVE SO LITTLE CON/ANCY TO REASON6 ,IT IS PROBABLE ?AT ?IS QUE/ION ( RESI/ANCE W\LD NEV] HAVE ADMITT$ ( SO LONG A CONTROV]SY1 IF ! ADVOCATES ( ! SY/EM ( LIB]TY PROMULGAT$ 9 ! LA/ C5TURY HAD NOT1 UNOBS]V$ TO !MSELVES1 9TRODUC$ A CONFUSION 9TO ! QUE/ION4 ,RESI/ANCE MAY BE EMPLOY$1 EI!R TO REPEL ! 9JURIES COMMITT$ AGA9/ ! NATION G5]ALLY1 OR SU* AS1 9 !IR IMM$IATE APPLICATION1 RELATE TO ! 9DIVIDUAL4 ,TO ! FIR/ ( !SE ! PREC$+ REASON+S PR9CIPALLY APPLY4 ,! 9JURIES TO A NATION DEP5D = !IR NATURE1 = ! MO/ P>T1 UPON !IR P]MANAN5CY1 & !RE=E ADMIT ( ! UTMO/ SOBRIETY & DELIB]ATION AS TO ! MODE 9 :I* !Y >E TO BE REM$I$4 ,9DIVIDUALS MAY BE 9JUR$ OR DE/ROY$ BY A SPECIFIC ACT ( TYRANNY1 BUT NATIONS CANNOT2 ! PR9CIPAL MIS*IEF TO ! NATION LIES 9 ! PRESAGE CONTA9$ 9 ! S+LE ACT1 ( ! 9JU/ICE ?AT IS TO CONT9UE TO BE EX]CIS$4 ,RESI/ANCE1 BY ! V]Y MEAN+ ( ! T]M1 AS IT IS US$ 9 POLITICAL 9QUIRY1 SIGNIFIES A SPECIES ( CONDUCT ?AT IS TO BE ADOPT$ 9 RELATION TO AN E/ABLI%$ AU?ORITY3 BUT AN OLD GRIEVANCE SEEMS OBVI\SLY TO LEAD1 AS ITS C\NT]P>T1 TO A GRADUAL & TEMP]ATE REM$Y4 ,! CONSID]ATION :I*1 BY BE+ CONF\ND$ ) ?IS1 HAS S]V$ TO MISLEAD C]TA9 5QUIR]S IS ?AT ( :AT IS COMMONLY KN[N BY ! NAME ( SELF-DEF5SE1 OR1 MORE PROP]LY1 ! DUTY OBLIG+ EA* 9DIVIDUAL TO REPEL1 AS F> AS LIES 9 HIS P[]1 ANY VIOL5T ATTACK MADE EI!R UPON HIMSELF OR ANO!R4 ,?IS1 BY ! T]MS ( ! QUE/ION1 IS A CIRCUM/ANCE ?AT DOES NOT ADMIT ( DELAY2 ! B5EFIT ( ! REM$Y 5TIRELY4DEP5DS UPON ! TIME ( ! APPLICATION4 ,! PR9CIPLE 9 ?IS CASE IS ( EASY DEVELOPM5T4 ,=CE IS AN EXP$I5T ! USE ( :I* IS MU* TO BE DEPLOR$4 ,IT IS CONTR>Y TO ! NATURE ( 9TELLECT1 :I* CANNOT BE IMPROV$ BUT BY CONVICTION & P]SUASION4 ,IT CORRUPTS ! MAN ?AT EMPLOYS IT1 & ! MAN UPON :OM IT IS EMPLOY$4 ,BUT IT SEEMS ?AT !RE >E C]TA9 CASES SO URG5T AS TO OBLIGE US TO HAVE REC\RSE TO ?IS 9JURI\S EXP$I5T3 9 O!R WORDS1 !RE >E CASES :]E ! MIS*IEF TO ACCRUE FROM NOT VIOL5TLY C\NT]ACT+ ! P]V]S5ESS ( ! 9DIVIDUAL IS GREAT] ?AN ! MIS*IEF :I* ! VIOL5CE NECESS>ILY DRAWS ALONG ) IT4 ,H5CE IT APPE>S ?AT ! GR\ND JU/IFY+ RESI/ANCE1 9 EV]Y CASE :]E IT CAN BE JU/IFI$1 IS ?AT ( ! GOOD LIKELY TO RESULT FROM SU* 9T]F]5CE BE+ GREAT] ?AN ! GOOD TO RESULT FROM OMITT+ IT4 ,!RE >E PROBABLY CASES :]E1 AS 9 A MURD] = EXAMPLE AB\T TO BE COMMITT$ ON A USEFUL & VALUABLE MEMB] ( SOCIETY1 ! *ANCE ( PREV5T+ IT BY ANY O!R MEANS ?AN 9/ANTANE\S RESI/ANCE IS SO SMALL AS BY NO MEANS TO V9DICATE US 9 9CURR+ ! DANG] ( SO MIS*IEV\S A CATA/ROPHE4 ,BUT WILL ?IS JU/IFY US1 9 ! CASE ( AN 9DIVIDUAL OPPRESS$ BY ! AU?ORITY ( A COMMUNITY8 ,LET US SUPPOSE ?AT !RE IS A C\NTRY 9 :I* SOME ( ITS BE/ CITIZ5S >E SELECT$ AS OBJECTS ( V5GEANCE BY AN AL>M$ & JEAL\S TYRANNY4 ,IT CANNOT REASONABLY BE D\BT$ ?AT EV]Y MAN1 A CONDEMN$ FELON OR MURD]]1 IS TO BE COMM5D$ = QUIETLY )DRAW+ HIMSELF FROM ! EXECUTION ( ! LAW2 MU* MORE SU* P]SONS AS HAVE N[ BE5 DESCRIB$4 ,BUT \E /ILL AT L>GE TO RISE 9 BEHALF ( !IR BRE?R5 UND] P]SECUTION8 ,EV]Y MAN ?AT IS DISPOS$ TO 5T] 9TO SU* A PROJECT1 & :O IS ANXI\S AB\T ! MORAL RECTITUDE ( HIS CONDUCT1 MU/ RE/ ITS JU/IFICATION UPON ONE ( ! TWO GR\NDS ABOVE /AT$3 EI!R ! IMM$IATE PURPOSE ( HIS RIS+ IS ! MELIORATION ( PUBLIC 9/ITUTIONS1 OR IT IS TO BE E/IMAT$ ) REF]5CE TO ! M]ITORI\SNESS ( ! 9DIVIDUALS 9 QUE/ION4 ,! FIR/ ( !SE HAS BE5 SUFFICI5TLY DISCUSS$2 WE WILL SUPPOSE !RE=E ?AT HE CONF9ES HIMSELF TO ! LA/4 ,H]E1 AS HAS BE5 ALREADY OBS]V$1 ! :OLE1 AS A MORAL QUE/ION1 WILL TURN UPON ! COMP>ATIVE B5EFIT OR MIS*IEF TO RESULT FROM ! RESI/ANCE TO BE EMPLOY$4 ,! DISP>ITY IS GREAT 9DE$ BETWE5 ! RESI/ANCE ORD9>ILY SUGGE/$ BY ! T]M SELF-DEF5SE1 & ! RESI/ANCE :I* MU/ EXPECT TO 5C\NT] 9 ITS PROGRESS ! CIVIL P[] ( ! C\NTRY4 ,9 ! FIR/1 ! QUE/ION IS ( A MOM5T2 IF Y\ SUCCE$ 9 ! 9/ANT ( Y\R EX]TION1 Y\ MAY EXPECT ! APPLAUSE1 RA!R ?AN ! PROSECUTION1 ( EXECUTIVE AU?ORITY4 ,BUT1 9 ! LATT]1 ! 5D WILL SC>CELY BE ACCOMPLI%$ BUT BY ! OV]?R[ ( ! GOV]NM5T ITSELF4 ,LET ! LIVES ( ! 9DIVIDUALS 9 SUPPOSITION BE AS VALUABLE AS Y\ PLEASE1 ! VALUE WILL NECESS>ILY BE SWALL[$ UP 9 ! GREAT] QUE/IONS ?AT OCCUR 9 ! SEQUEL4 ,?OSE QUE/IONS !RE=E >E ! PROP] TOPICS ( ATT5TION2 & WE %ALL BE TO BLAME IF WE SUFF] \RSELVES TO BE L$ UNAW>ES 9TO A CONDUCT ! DIRECT T5D5CY ( :I* IS ! PRODUCTION ( ONE SORT ( EV5T1 :ILE ALL WE 9T5D$ WAS ! PRODUCTION ( ANO!R4 ,! VALUE ( 9DIVIDUALS \E M5 :OSE SAFETY %\LD BE *]I%$ BY US ) ANXI\S ATT5TION2 BUT IT IS DIFFICULT TO IMAG9E A CASE 9 :I*1 = !IR SAKE1 ! LIVES ( ?\S&S1 & ! FATE ( MILLIONS1 %\LD BE COMMITT$ TO RISK4 ,FOOTNOTES #a,BOOK #a1 ,*AP4 ,V,I1 P4 #a#d#h2 ,BOOK ,I,I1 ,*AP4 L,I,I1 PP4 #a#h#a-#b4 #b,BOOK ,I,I1 ,*AP4 ,V1 ,V,I4 ,FROM 3 ,AN>*Y ,>*IVES4 ,*RONOLOGY 3 ,NOVEMB] #c1 #agib 3 ,BOOK #d1 ,*APT] #a -- ,PUBLICATION4 ,JANU>Y #b#f1 #bag 3 ,BOOK #d1 ,*APT] #a -- ,ADD$4 FILE G5]AT$ FROM 3 HTTP3_/_/REVOLTLIB4COM_/